There's plenty of games with similar/better implemented versions of this combat system that are PVP centric..
#3v3 TDM Game Mode
soft lynx
torpid lintel
There's plenty of games with similar/better implemented versions of this combat ...
Like what?
Chivalry/Mordhau/Renown/Mortal 2 are point blocking systems, which are their own sub-category directional blocking systems which not everyone prefers.
Games with similar combat systems to this one are:
- War of the Roses (Axed, gone)
- Gloria Victis (Axed, gone)
- Of Kings and Men (Axed, gone)
- Mount and Blade (Does not feel tuned for multiplayer, does not feel good)
- Last Oasis (Spiderman simulator)
The current live games that use this specific War of the Roses inspired combat system don't compare for different reasons.
There is no harm in a small PvP mode you could queue in, it does not divert attention to the main game. It's a side thing. Which historically isn't uncommon for developers to add to story game. A small mode like that does no harm, is not an ambitious feat, and gives more longevity to a game. You can already duel, which is a precursor and tends to be some of the most fun moments.
soft lynx
Oh you want a complete queue/matchmaking system too? You're asking them to make a different game than what everyone else here is playing.