#halfsword-chat-โ
1 messages ยท Page 584 of 1
i was invulnerable testing how much it would take
the commoner champ is the easy one, its the beggar champ you must fear
and they're like tanks
every time i've fought the commoner champion i just walk up and stab him in the throat
so i was basically just swinging like a crackhead
Bro ๐ the first one seems hard until you figure him out, now I beat him every time, but the commoner champ with his big ass sword is crazy, he just killed me with a jump shot not even lying
WALK???
he has like a giant sword
...
such cap bro
if u walk up to him its sticking in you like 50 times
the first one is hard because you dont start with a wepaon, so you have to scramble to grab one
bro
i walked up and stabbed him with my falchion
Yeah but you can just run around him
the first boss
just pick up a hammer
candlestick
anything except tongs or a paddle
it doesnt always spawn a hammer or a candle
Or the paddle thing
sometimes all it gives you is gloves and a bar stool
if u use the paddle it wont even break his bones
Anything long enough to swing works well i find
Paddle works fine tbh
unless you swing really hard
yes i've had to bludgeon him with a bar stool before
You just gotta keep battering him
Yeah but its easy to use just have to stay out of reach and hit him a few times with it
its better than tongs
The fists acc work well too sometimes
First boss is super easy as long as you don't charge in like an idiot
i saw an npc do that
i spawned a bunch of big guys
and he charged in like he was superman
with a shield and pike
I'm starting to appreciate the hoe
Do you guys use the sword against the commoner champ?
Long range like the spear but choppy like the axe
an adze drop would be ideal for the beggar boss
Playtest hoe was much better than the current hoe but it's still solid
does the game have an adze?
I do now but I had to use pitchfork for a while
it has a little hammer with an adze on it
like a tiny mattock or something
but like an actual full length mattock would be nice
yeah, hammer on one side and a little axe like blade on the other
like a more wieldy hoe
should i download halfsword again
idk, you're already in the half sword discord
Ok ill try pitchfork again, I tried it at first and it didnt work, now im usung the sword but still lose almost every time lol
yea might aswell
Just alt-stab or double-click stab. The benefit is the range, take advantage of it
oh hey congrats on level 1 lol
half way there
On the grind ๐
the hoe is so good
swing it at the right place and the enemy is decapitated
Alr ill give it another shot
I've mostly been scoring legchops
Yonny Yonson
I scored a decapitation through the head once
not sure how, but it was damn lucky
A normal decapitation or like slicing the head in 2 halfs
What
its from a jontron video
im kinda dogwater at using sword
where he stabs himself in the shin with an axe
Oh
You'll get there with practice
sword is ment to be
i wanna do those moves where I hit their face under their helmet or their neck
i have all connections with the sword
ill get there eventually
some how
oh yeah
a true warrior's swordfighting method
I remember with spear they get LAUNCHED
what is the point of being so unforgiving with porogress when defending yourself is basically impossible??
Because defending yourself isn't impossible
with how funky the weapon control is, it certainly seems to be
id say do the free mode and get good at each stage there
It's not that janky. The system is designed to make parrying easier
how would you even keep your character? after dying and getting sent to the abyss is there a way to get out?
i do agree some weapons are a bit jank
edge alignment is terrible
there should be a better free mode selector imo
Yes, you fight a couple of willies and then fight the previous boss, and you are able to start the tier over
ive not passed farmer cos i just cant defend myself, theres no tutorial, and the control isnt exactly precise
Buddy I'm sorry but this is a skill issue. You just have to practice
oh well i just died to the willies... ๐ญ hey good to know for next time tho
hit f to slow time is how ive found its a little easier, the control is very janky tho i do agree
u gotta hit their weapon out of the way before they kill you, it's pretty hard
you could just...... explain how to do it?
i can barely hit THEM let alone their hand
Break bro's ankles 
there's some yt videos where they show their mouse movements, I found that they helped with learning the controls
- Stop running face first into enemy willies.
- Hold shift to take position.
- Wait for enemy willie to make the first swing.
- Using slight lmb mouse motions, angle towards wherever the enemy willie is swinging from.
- On successful parry, swing back.
Really simply, use pitchfork.
Hold alt and pull back on the mosue while running towards him with 'W' and shift
Then push the mouse forward while still holding alt.
Get him in the leg.
Badaboom
find a yt video where they show the controls and how to swing and hit properly first imo
You just have to familiarize yourself with how you angle your weapon
Just ditz around in freemode while you learn the game @untold sentinel
this video
so often my knife just harmlessly slips over them without a cut, thats the game being ass for giving my character a a wrist more limp than a 70 year old mans nob
No, you're not using the knife properly
Knife is goated tbh
Don't make me drop da clips
british simulator lmaooo
and then someone loosely bonks me on the head and i get lobotomised
as a somewhat new player most combat ends up feeling very janky, i make sure to put alot of momentum into my swing but it slides off their clothing ๐ญ
usa has more knife crime
yeah
knife is op
it instakills in the naked phase
Ong, the SHIV NO LESS
you arent being helpful, just saying
thats your fault
isnt helpful
I gave you a guide, bud
ofc there probably methods to do it better, but like, the new player should be able to do basic swings ๐ญ
Either go practice or stop whining
This is bait fr
๐ญ how do you play on controller
I'm doing pretty well without parrying but bosses are fucking me up
You can connect your controller to your laptop/pc
It's actually shocking how well the game fits for a controller
Although you need a mouse to do some things and a keyboard
edge alignment shouldnt be so finicky
but combat basically is very well done
On top of this, knives aren't meant for swinging, they're meant for stabbing. Reclaimer's guide helps fine with that.
Only things lacking for combat is freeze time I believe
yeah like most of the time i feel id be better off just using blunt weapons
This
U can't do anything with the menu on controller tho so you will need a mouse and keyboard
I run mouse and controller together
Same
You can't just swing wildly and expect cuts to happen
Keyboard too because I do have to press G to continue
well its almost like im trying to sweing in a straight line
normalize reverse gripping knife
I have up on the d-pad mapped to g
and stabbing- dont even get me started cause aiming is so annoying ๐ญ
And outer edge on left stick to shift
You can change keybinds for controller?
You can run mega fast
Like I said, swinging with a knife is inefficient and mostly pointless
Does the freeze thing work for it too
Yeah enable steam input
HOLY SHIT, I HIT A NECK SHOT!!!
Plentiful
Freeze?
even a chest shot with the dagger is lethal tbf
I meant uhh make timer slower
is mnk a bad idea for this then? is that why im hating it
fr
playing with the armored bois
Yeah anything works as long as it has a key its bound to
When you figure out how to land a stab, you start winning a lot more
I have pickup left and right bound to left and right d-pad
what's the purpose of the ultimate challenge in free mode? how do i get weapons if knights are spawning with me??
That's perfect because in the default settings there's no controls for the d pads
even doing the stab modfe he apparently has a metal chest my iknife just slid off to the side
thats just a dog combat system
Don't know what to tell you if I can't see what you're doing, man
- Hold Alt
- CHAAAARGE
- pray to jeebus
I can only assume you're not actually hitting with your stabs
idk I'm a new player but the combat so far seems to not be very difficult so far aside from the bosses might because I'm using controller and it might be easier(?)
WHATS THE WORD ON THE BLOOD CRASHING?
the combat base is fine imo, it just needs to be more inuitive, too much of a learning curve
it literally just slid off his chest and then he got me in the neck perfectly
When u get ur stabs its normally an instant kill
I land my stabs ๐
If you're really struggling you can increase your damage to npcs and decrease the damage npcs do to you
stabs are iffy for me
It helps being on controller for movement because u can line urself up really well
most of the stabs, im looking at him, my knife looks alligned to him, and my characters arm just course redirects directly inbetween the guys torso and arm to miss, pretty sure hes experiencing the same thing
what's the purpose of the ultimate challenge in free mode? how do i get weapons if knights are spawning with me??
looks like the knife is sliding off his chest
weapons tend to have a direction they like stabbing in annoying as hell ๐
yeah my wrist just bent on its own
sure
That's why you alter your position
Yeah u gotta move to the left a little
You don't stand directly in the center
Ive master stabs through inept carnage
and then i got to the boss fight and he clobbers me before i even grab a weapon
yeah but in the first place my knife shouldnt be changing its course, it should be intuitive
what a brilliant well made fight
Trye
True
Brother, you can run
You don't have to charge straight forward
If you stab with a Pitchfork wouldn't recommend stabbing in the center because it goes to stab in the right for some reason you should go a little to the left and try stabbing ๐ฅ
if im tryna stab id assume im trying to stab forward not off to the side ๐ญ
are you actually incapable of processing a thought? we are saying "this is an issue wew are experiencing" and your re4sponse is "nuh uh"
brother, SO CAN HE
lmao
The damage you do to bosses is higher than normal so all u gotta do is land one clean hit
And I'm telling you the issue is not the game, it's you
Nah its valid to blame the game in part
having all the other content locked behind this puirely luck based cesspit of the lower tier
this isnt darksouls bro ๐ญ
Lock in
im not engaging with you any more, you are clearly incapable of higher order thinking
lmfao
nothing in this game is luck based
I clear the lower tiers easy and i have a full time job too
u have to increase your skill
when the combat isnt inuitive even after hours of playing thats a game issue (unless the goal is to be very difficult)
its just annoying, a game is meant to be fun, randomly getting bonked and my attacks just randomly being ineffective is not fun
there's free mode btw, you unlock everything
it's intuitive to me. maybe u are lacking in skill
exactly
Very true
then stop playing the game.
quit
Thats not their point
"oh you think this isnt perfect? just leave dont bother raising issues"
The only times I've lost to the first boss is when I was running and fucking fell due to my willy being a idiot although ive never really had a problem grabbing the weapons because he seems like he's gonna kill you immediately when you stop and grab a weapon but in my experience you have maybe 3 seconds before he gets close enough
do you actually have a brain brother
first boss is way too hard for peasant lvl lmao
we're giving you the solution to your issues. the solution is to get better
thought you weren't engaging with me anymore, bud
You guys are funny
dude i dont care if he doesnt run and chase you, he ran me down bruh
Unironically I've died too much by him due to tripping
i'm playing the same game as you man
the sheer levels of chimp are insane
these people seem to think this is darksouls ๐ญ
you're the chimpo
you suck and are blaming the game
it's not
When i figure out how to record my game ur cooked
how difficult is it to comprehend "yes this early access demo of a game isnt perfect, and there are things that need polishing"
rub those brain cells together
yes. that is true. it is also true that you suck at the game and need to get better
bro, the fucking spears in the same category as others is stupid, esp the one with spikes
and you're just refusing any guidance and kicking and screaming the entire time
Arguing when neither of your points clash is crazy
like if youre playing a game and its unintuitive as a new player that IS bad game design, unless its MEANT to be uninuitive
there is a learning curve. i don't believe that it's unintuitive.
how difficult is it to comprehend that your criticisms are invalid because they come from a lack of understanding
How do you do this
learning the basics shouldnt take more then an hour or two tho? ๐ญ
I keep seeing these clips
except theyre not invalid, because it is an issue
yeah a personal issue
the basics can be learned in an hour or two, but mastering them takes time
how many hours do you have in the game
Nah nah nah some games can be like that
yes, but only if the game is meant to be hard
i played from the start of the playtest, about 88 hours
have you mongs not heard the expression "repitition legitimises"
have you never heard of practice makes perfect
wrong
whataboutism doesnt combat my point
A physics based game like this will be inherently harder to learn versus other games because the market is smaller and people have less experience with it in general
do you know what the fuck whataboutism even is lmao
im not arguing that its impossible to improve from where i am
"hurr durr well what about practise makes perfect" doesnt address what ive said
you've said nothing
Why is the left fist feel so much stronger then the right fist
im arguing that there are issues with the system that cause annoyance
you are cooking absolutely nothing
Is willy left handed
you have boiled a pot of water to the point where there is no more water
the term skill issue shouldnt even be coming up cause ๐ญ someone being unexperienced shouldnt make all combat worse
get out of the kitchen brother
and yet you refuse to engage with the point
Fr it has a snapping issue as well
and why the fuck not?
I'm not engaging in this
master the bullshit and embrace the cheese, pipe down and get back to the stabbing
didnt mean to do ur message
Oh
So true
you are coming across like a monkey
lack of experience is one thing, but the combat system being an unweildy unintuitive mess, is another
you can acknowledge both
how long have you been playing the game, then?
it's not unintuitive. it worked fine for me
which is what me and schnatt are doing, and you refuse to
your opinion is not a fact
and it's not a criticism of the game
especially when i had the exact opposite experience
lmao
and nor is yours if youre going to take that route then you have no point either
because this isnt darksouls? good game design means being accessible and not locked behind hours and hours of practice
I do not think combat is bad I like it but I do believe it could improve in a couple of ways
but, it is
im not the one in here criticizing the game though
so what you're saying is you're wasting your time
Guys i have to piss can you make up and move on in that time
i'm here for a kiss whenever you're ready ๐
guys kiss
you're in here blaming the game for your personal experience
What the freaky
no what im saying is that point goes no where and isnt worth making, once again your reading comprehension fails you
saying something is unintuitive is a critisim?
zanta you are just a career idiot at this point
if you want to claim the game is unintuitive then back up your opinion with examples or an argument
you really like lobbing insults, huh
otherwise stfu nobody cares
honestly these two arent worth the time, both of them are clearly a bit too thick to understand that you can say
im just gonna say, I had a bad experience for a bit, learning curve is big
" the system has issues that need polishing" and " i still like it"
he played that game, found something he didnt like about it, and said "hey this is bad" its just feedback.
elaborate on the issues that need polishing
you can acknowlege the issues without meaning you hate the game cuh
i also had a bad experience first playing the game, but it's a system that is not as clunky and unintuitive as it's being made out to be.
waht issues are there that need polishing
like
have a discussion
dont just complain
elaborate
how can u use knight armor in abyss mode?
omg, like, get rid of spears and put them in their own category, unfun to play or play against
yeah but you gotta understand youre dealing with discord fanboys
bro
being unintuitive is a subjective thing, in our opinions it IS unintuitive, thats a simple fact. its just feedback
youre a fuckin monkey
this from the guy that started out the swearing lmao
ngl
it's not an issue if you're not immediately good at the game, that's fine. but you take the time to get better. you don't immediately say it's the game fault and give up.
ironic
you still havent elaborated
"have a discussion"
youre just in here crying
still waiting for an explanation on the issues youre crying about
some people like to act like you killed their mom after you leave some critisim on their favorite game ๐
yes because saying that the new player experience is clunky and not captivating = crying
what is your criticism
i understand that, but blop isn't so nuanced on this, calling the combat engine dogwater and immediately throwing insults at anyone who doesn't agree
yeah its childish asf, not worth it
when you stab someone, and it looks lined up, the character stabs to the left or right, missing what it looks like it should be hitting.
lmao
horizontal swings are dogwater too
still no explanation or elaboration of these issues. just crying and getting mad when people don't agree
It depends on the weapon and if your character is deciding to wield it in the left or right side
neither you or lerdzila can moan about insults when both of you were doing it just as quickly lmao
when did I insult you?
i'm not crying about insults
I also have issues with the lock on, it seems to be off
haha went captain america on his ass
look at your own messages you goldfish
he said he didnt like it, and immediately got replied with "skill issue" i dont think he started the insults ๐ญ
insutl all you want. you're a moron and i'm trying really hard to get you to explain your feelings
skill issue is not an insult bud
Yea the lock on definitely isn't very well made at the moment it could be made better
the irony is insane
lock on does suck ass
yeah but he should just stab forward to the middle.
what about the game is unintuitive
I actually agree with that ngl
for the 30x time
If im locked on to someone and im square with them, and i stab straight, it should land cleanly with their center of mass
will yall pipe down and get to the killing
its because its overly sensitive to movements you arent deliberately making
It was fucking annoying the first hour honestly but I've gotten used to it now
which throws it off massivelt
AND they could make it so by moving ur mouse left or right, you can make him stab left or right too.
so you're mad you can't control the weapon properly
im on a low end pc and i used to run half sword at 640 by 480p and had my vram set to 12000 by 13000 and it was stupid cus i knew what i was doing and changed like 30mins ago now half sword runs 1080 p
that's a skill issue
a problem AND a solution there we go
because i can control it fine
double tap
you can misrepresent a point, it doesnt make yopu right
yeah it should be hard to control ๐
I actually wouldn't mind that
again, repitition legitimises
Totally this game is unintuitive....syke lol I just threw a shield and hit him smack dab in the fac.e
we are talking ab new player experience
bro this discord needing me to make my quality so ass on the vid
it's just hard to control cause it's complex.
good luck geting throuigh to him this guy must be illiterate
new players should just be beastly the first time they play?
im thinking hes italian and we are somehow insulting his entire family tree on accident
im a master so everyone else's experience is irrelevant
no, its not just complexity, the control is overly sensitive to little movements that arent deliberate
yes yes makes sense
i can get behind that
yal want clips
upset you just started and can't immediately do sick shit lol
Change your sensitivity.
how entitled
anyone
"how entitled" stfu lmao
or like when they are on the ground, i move my mouse up to ready, and straight down, and my char either aims completely right, or completely left instead of straight down like i move my mouse to do ๐ญ
which is the reason for so much missing etc
Changing my sensitivity to stupidity rn so i can still watch the convo
the hoe really feels like a weapon taht demands good spacing and awareness
you know if you spent all this time playing instead of crying on discord you might be able to control your sword a little better lmao
I'll turn my mods off and go grab a longsword in a middle teir then go through the stances.
It is highly recommended to lower your sensitivity especially as a new player.
tier
i wouldnt call "being able to at least hit the guy" "sick shit"
i was able to do it the very first time i ever played the game
if you cant even hit people that's a you problem
you can whinge and moan about criticism all you want it doesnt make you smart or funny
I decrease mouse sensitivity the sword moves slower which is also annoying. thankfully my mouse has a sensitivity button which makes changing sensitivity easier
cope
someone with 1hr of playtime should be able to consistently hit their target with basic moves ๐
in all fairness, you don't really need to swing the sword that fast.
yeah thats what i did it made it better, but it still is an issue
let momentum do the work sometimes, it works fine
if you can;t even hit people i don't know what to tell you bro
dpi doesnt mattter if u train with what u have
blasphemy! the game is perfect and any issue you have with this
EARLY ACCESS DEMO
is clearly because you are inferior and not possibly an issue to be buffed out
Less is often more. Small swift movements. learn to control momentum.
yes
Have u played exanima
it's like, a bit too slow at my lowest mouse dpi ๐
fair enough
yes exanima is sick
I know nothing is really happening in this clip, but watch it. It's very intuitive. You can roll between stances really easily. It's basically just where your invisible mouse is at on the screen.
hey who was it that called bullshit on me walking up to the zweihander guy and just stabbing him
Have u played exanima
Indubitably! Yes I agree, the combat should also require ATLEAST 15 hours to acclimate to! This is a very low skill curve!
did we say it was a low skill curve??
practice to stab in a sword fighting game ๐
y-yes
that is something you should do
brother this is a video game i saw on tiktok not the unlanwful games act
Do we know when the fatal error will be fixed?
i would say you need to practice
so hitting a stab should require multiple hours of playtime ๐ญ
im saying it should be lower
You can easily strike places that you mean to strike, you can aim, etc.
doesnt take multiple hours lmao
So u probably havent played exanima
if it does that's a you problem
you should spend all your time training to fight in this game!!!11!!1!1!1!1
and i'm saying, no it shouldn't. especially when sword combat is literally the entire game
It really depends on the player tbh.
just playing the game is practice
like
go play the game
crying in discord doesnt make you stab more accuratelyu
yeah im saying that BASIC moves, should be easy to learn
if you were immediately good at combat then there would be no reason to play
It took me about 20-30 hours to consistently beat the enemy.
if you wanna do cool shit it should take training
cool shit, such as?
like combo stuff
i'm not trying to be rude, i'm just curious
My theory is that lerdzilla has played exanima, so he has more experience with the genre i.e. a more intuitive grasp of the mechanics but blop hasnt
like slicing people in half
It took me 200hrs to be the First abyss demo. Vanilla settings no chessing the healing system.
thgeres a difference between "good at combat" and basics of function, the argument you are making, to me and schnatt, comes off the same as if we were to tell you that you need to practice reload drills in COD. thats not being good, thats a core part of the function, thats the issue we are raising
im trying to be rude. like i can't imagine being upset that you're not immediately good at something you just started. it's a physics based game, yes just stabbing people takes practice
if you dont like it then you can always play something else
brother the onmly one acting upset is you

I think this may be the case as well. People who have never played Exanima, Human fall Flat, or Gang Beasts often struggle with the concept of the control scheme.
i have like 6 hours and its pretty janky to me
and I'm saying that, functionally, comparing this game to CoD is dishonest. CoD is a multiplayer shooter. This is a swordfighting simulator. The crux of the game is in fact to learn the basics, and the basics are meant to take time.
just recorded this first try so it's not anything super special but it's still an "advanced" thing.
Guys ur lucky i dont have work tomorrow so im gonna make the problem very simple
i feel like if the entire game was just basic stabs and slices that would get boring
I promise I'm not trying to fight you here
idk what you're talking about this is a roundhouse kick simulator.
it's not. that's not what i said.
it's still janky lmao, spears suck ass, 20+ hours
the problem is that when i started and couldnt stab anybody i practiced until i could
instead of crying about not being able to
my point is that if it takes time to learn JUST basics, then most players arent gonna get to anything cool
shouldn't the point of a game be to invest time in it?
you should be able to get the basics quickly and THEN spend time mastering cooler techniques
yet this game is still extremely viral and enjoyed by casual tiktok viewers
yeah but investing time to do basic stabs isnt fun
There are many players that do not like working for things in general and do not get to see nice things in allot of games.
and thats the disagreement we have, i think that to expect you to have to practice to even perform a basic attack, is stupid, this isnt a realistic simulation of medieval combat, its not HEMA on a screen, its clunky, and no one likes clunky, you may not think it is, but you have almost 100 hours, and you being used to a clunky system doesnt mean it isnt clunky, it means you dont feel its clunky
brother what? the point is to ENJOY it
omg the popularity fallacy i gotta check this off!
thanks for that
i got bingo
It actually is a HEMA combat sim my friend.
your arguments are actually peak year 3
I kinda like it kinda being realistic but it's so jank with some thigns
it's not a fallacy at all. you're making claims like "MOST PLAYERS ARENT GONNA GET TO ANYTHING COOL" whereas the numbers indicate the exact opposite
no, its not, just because someone has a sword doesnt make it accurate to hema
Holy fuck whatโs happening in this chat
this is like saying the new assassins creed is a kendo simulator
pair of dorks mad they just started and aren't immediately good
the point of a game is to be enjoyable, so it should be enjoyable (and not frustrating in most cases), if a mechanic is frustrating thats an issue (unles its meant to be frustrating)
the skill limit for the game is actually really low but so is the iq of most of the players and their general knowhow ๐ค
The combat system is designed completely around HEMA.
it's not frustrating
the basics are generalized and you can learn them by just knowing things about actual fencing
The more nuance you give your game the more unavoidable this issue is, although it can be helped to a significant degree with good tutorials and stuff
have you heard of subjectivity?
except the numbers dont contradict him
so you understand your personal feelings are not an objective criticism?
am i the only one that likes fpv mode
it makes using the spiked bat thing so much easier
brother, you can make whatever claim you want, im yet to see anything even remotely similar, the dexterity involved in even a beginners level of HEMA is just not available here
There is definitely something wrong with the way lock on and stabbing works
yeah? you didnt know that? your feelings are ALSO subjective
maybe i should rephrase. shouldn't a game, if it is achieving what is supposed to, make players want to invest time in it? I understand in this case that it clearly doesn't seem to work for all players, but that's fine.
FPV makes me sick sadly.
it's kinda shakey and that makes me nausious
then what is your point?
surely you want accessibility to achieve that with as many people as posible tho
the point is to have fun, the result is investing time
its cool but it makes the flop of the swords look so much more apparent and all my cool moves turn into not so much
you're in here claiming the game is frustrating and unintuitive like it's the game's fault
i said the opposite
idk i think it feels awesome
and you started arguing with me abgout it lol
that i dont like that the game feels uninuitive?
god this game in vr would be so cool
theres a reason DCS for example is so niche, everyone thinks flying a jet is cool, not as many want to sit down and learn the startup procedure for a m2000
Blade and sorcery
okay and it feels intuitive to me so
cry more i guess? idk
thats a misrepresentation, you engaged us
shit is that just blade and sorcery
yeah you feeling that doesnt make my point less valid?
You can disagree with me that's fine. As a member of the dev team I can assure the combat system is designed around HEMA techniques. The combat system is not intuitive to all and can require many hours for some to get accustomed to.
you don't have a point. you have an opinion
"i do not personally share your experience, although others do, therefore your experience is invalid
it should be inuitive to everyone is my point cant believe you hadnt caught onto that
my point is my opinion
a point would be using examples from the game to support your opinion
can u split the spears and the more closer range weapons into different tiers?
i don't know about that. i think the interest in the game is its niche. accessibility would be nice if this was meant for all audiences, but it's not.
inuitiveness IS an opinion
wow
Not my call.
๐
the militiamen champion aint shit, i killed him with the almighty but forbidden technique
you cant draw truth from wether something is inuitive cause its all subjective
you can say its designed around it but i have not seen, in any video, any more HEMA than i see in the star wars films
bro thinsk sharing his opinion is making a point ๐ญ
so
dick shot
lmao
Woah dont lose your valid point like this bro
you cant
okay
thats exactly what that is when youre talking about a subjective matter
the "i" part is subjective, try again
i saw someone play the game and stabbed people
There are many Dedicated channels to advance fighting techniques.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ddleysHN0c
This is my case for an Intention based playstyle in the Half Sword Playtest. This game has kept me interested for far longer than I initially anticipated. The depth of Half Sword is often missed, because it is laying just under the surface of a fun, wacky, medieval physics slasher.
There is TONS to learn. The beauty of this game, is that if yo...
may such cases
its not a slight against the game, but its just true, ive not seen anything to make me think this is any more hema than chivalry 2
making a point is supporting your opinion with examples
thats a statement on how other people felt ab the game, its a collection of subjective statments, not an opbjective one
try again.
btw, how do I do a straight horizontal slash? it's always like at an angle or something
go look up the scientific method buddy
we make observations and come to conclusions based on the data
But your earlier point was that it was just a demo and clearly needs work... This is the same case. They are working on it
data indicates most people don't have a problem with it
i dont think you understand what a scientific theory is
no thats just expanding on your point, if you say "the game feels unintuitive and clunky, so much so that it causes issues to even accomplish the most basic things" which is what me and schatt have said multiple times, thats still making a point
yeah which means most people subjectively think its not janky, thats not objective
What is a point
what data...
You mean like a vertical top down slash?
dont say "we" when you clearly have no idea what youre talking about
what data
no like, a sideways slash
source?
i can't believe how heated you guys are because you have to practice to be good
you are making statements about how people feel nothing objective about feelings
YOOOO I did like...a finisher.
wait... WAIT hes done with points and decided to attack us directly?
i'll make a compilation of people playing the game and hitting people just for you
Am so sorry yall just git gud that's my only input
it's like, always kinda off?
Or play smthn else
so you dont have any and youre waffling
right
nono
I threw the fucking spike into his neck.
John over here being normal love u king
Im also normal
it was very cool.
you're the only one with a problem
our point is that the game feels uninuitive, ofc practice would help, its that as a new player slashing and stabbing should feel someone natural. atleast thats how me and blop feel
I'll post some silly shit to shift the vibe
nah imma keep posting them here cause it's better than the shit yall are posting.
bickering like children.
how does this "data" show that?
Keep edge alignment while reaching the appropriate speed is the hardest part. Also when moving the mouse fast it is easy to switch into another guard. So as much as possible you have to swipe and drag your mouse at the same time. Across the horizantal axis.
lerd buddy this angle doesnt workfor you
what angle
the only angle is you suck at this game and want the game to be responsible for it
the "scientific method the data shows" and then not having anything to back it
youre just waffling
Blop has been bait this whole time bro let's talk abt something else
i find it so strange how once someones logical arguments run dry instead of accepting it they just go to insults
no, again you fail to read bud
its like
lerd hasnt had any logical argument, its always been insults
Yall need to calm down and move on now.
What is this evidence of btw
you dont know what these words mean clearly
hopw does you having a video prove that i am the only one with an issue?
I want to post clips my friends ๐ญ
i can stab people
schatt has the same issue
he did have some, when he asked what exactly makes it unintuitve, but once i gave examples and explained how inuitiveness is subjective he went straight to insults
DID SOMEONE SAY STAB
yeah
he agrees its unintuitive
skill issues
It's my favorite way to kill ppl
so your claim that its only me is immediately falsified
The real heartwarming thing is that they have true hope they can make the other see reason
spears are horrible with controls imo
Let reason rulen where rage might reign
something about spears having weird physics and momentum
i just don't agree with this, honestly. i think slashing and stabbing are basic movements that can be done fine, but applying them to combat with a live opponent is something completely different, and yes, this is something that is going to require a lot of practice. it's a simulator and the point of the game is the combat, so the combat is going to have a learning curve. it's going to take time to traverse that curve because that's the point.
so sad how reasonablility tends to fall flat, i had SOME hope in the begginging
nah but like he just paragraphed me
will i let him get the final blow...?
yes
yes i will
now
zanata
So, I recommend yall learn how to do roundhouse kicks. It's harder without slow motion, but possible. I typically use slow motion. I typically use them if I have one of my arms that are broken or hands messed up. It does work...sometimes. It's better than nothing!
time to move on collectively
Oh wrong one
no i want to have a fist fight
none of ur clips every play for me on discord ๐
i love how this game can have both the most epic fights and hte most anticlimactic fights
This is the backup roundhouse kick one.
I was literally shaking excited to see a roundhouse kick
i had some no name with a sword and shield fight like hell, but i killed the militia champion instantly by stabbing him in the balls
im not gonna lie, I got a bit nausious with that shaking
and the fights that make you cry yourself to sleep.
Holy shit
yeah
True can be. Games never made me motion sick but irl shit wrecks me
Just like my parents
first person view is so cool but damn it is not easy to play for long
I just wish they'd implement some smoothing in first person.
Did cuckold get yelled allot at home too?
the thing is youre talking from 88 hours of experience, so obviously those things are going to feel easy now, we are coming from 0, or very few, so our opinion on how intuitive that feels holds a bit more water just because you are used to the system so it feels normal either way, i dont disagree that it should be hard in a sim game, im arguing that this isnt just "difficulty" and more feeling limp and useless, thats the reason for annoyance
honestly i kinda want to get blade and sorcery, someone said its this game but with VR
I actually dont have parents but i wanted to make the joke regardless
I feel like maybe there could be some smoothing to make it less shakey but idk
is vr even werf for a swordfighting enthusiast?
the complete lack of any weight or resistance makies it feel very weird
I knew it would land better if i pretended
oh i could imagine
if you live in any city you should be able to find a HEMA plac ce
it's like 300 bucks for a mid end vr headset
Damn I don't know how to one up that one.
-# you win this round.
oh i have the money, i've been workign 40 hours as a groundskeeper and i dont really have bills, so i have like 3k saved
if you wanna do other stuff too with vr, i think it's worth
I was born with glass bones and paper skin. Every morning, I break my legs, and every afternoon, I break my arms. At night, I lie awake in agony until my heart attacks put me to sleep.
What is this from
It sounds familiar
spongebo
BS every kid in GenX has this same cousin.
omg, im getting better at kneck shots I think :DDDD
Ohh never saw that episode
it's a physics-based game. theyre all like this, you're controlling the character's arms and legs with a mouse and keyboard. it's never going to feel "intuitive" on first play because you don't move your limbs with a mouse and buttons in real life
hey john, have you had a boss fight just suddenly end in a single hit from a lucky stab
Almost had a valid point until the end
tjhis is the reason for my COD comparison earlier, to me it should be that the basic attacks and functions, or just the idea that whatever attack i make actually poses a threat (not like the feeble wristed stab that annoyed me earlier) and that the challenge should be the effective employment of thse methods not the challenge being the motion itself
I have an ungodly amount of hours. The game is not intuitive unless you have played games with similar control schemes it is very hard for beginners.
Absolutely
smary bullshit from the peanut gallery. if you're not going to say anythign worth reading don't talk to me
sword duel....
so... you admit it isnt intuitive
honestly I was assuming they didn't know the genuine definition of intuitive.
i had an epic looking boss in full plate die to one luckily placed stab to the groin, i was looking forward to that fight too
it's intuitive as it's ever going to be
late reply cause for some reason the mods timed me out AFTER i decided to move on ๐ญ
Enhancer punch strength is so fucking funny
i accidentally stabbed him though
Subjective. Worth reading also depends on your reading comprehension
Cause like....NOTHING is intuitive.
is htis some kinda mod
lol
i know starting out doesn't feel easy, it wasn't that long ago when i started playing. at the end of the day, i know there are things about the game and its combat that need to be polished. i also believe, though, that there has to be a learning curve to this, especially as a game that is almost entirely physics-based. intuitivity and accessibility, i think, are two different things. the system is not very accessible and i fully agree on that front.
thats just not true?
@little verge what do you think about having bones or something in the models so that the swords don't just go straight through?
Literally nothing is intuitive besides shit like breathing and existing.
You have to learn everything.
Anyways I don't want to get dragged into this.
i dont think you understand what intuitive means
but also, i don't expect the system to ever be as accessible as a CoD or any other game on that front.
see
Yee let's you spawn stuff and add a bunch of modifiers etc.
brother, stop it, you're just ragebaiting at this point.
oh that sounds fun, can ye link the mod in DM's?
so what
Fucking YALL. Can we throw on slowmode to end this
Literally almost nothing is intuitive for humans. We don't carry a lot of instinctual knowledge.
he always was
Sure one sec
No. However all intuition is based of some cursory knowledge. If you have never played a similar game with this control scheme it is very foreign and often frustrating.
danke
youre not understanding the term
oh wait the game has a nexus
this debate has gotten philosophical i'm going to kill myself
to stab? or not to stab?
humans dont have instinctual knowledge on how to drink from a mug, we didnt evolve around mugs, but if you see a mug of water you dont need a tutorial on how to drink from it
not to stab.
i'm only baiting because there's nothing to discuss. he's upset physics based games don't feel like putting on a skin suit and mocapping the character. what else is there to say about it other than practice or don't play the game
Finally, after so long you guys are actually defining and agreeing on a common set of terms!! (The first step in a real discussion)
chop
ye barely any updated except like the 2 main I'm pretty sure
Which is why I say this game is really quite intuitive. Sure, it's complex, but generally you could guess that moving your mouse to the left will make you swipe left, moving right, etc.
nah ill stab (and miss)
just use the woodman's axe it's like a cheat code
Anyways this is such a weird conversation.
My intuition tells me that the only solution to such a bleak reality is to remove myself from it
the core, bare control scheme is, the actual combat system, is not
this is a first in online arguments
never seen this happen before
what do y'all think of the spear weapons in the game? I feel like they are like, very clunky
they take some time to get used to
There is already a full skeleton and all the internal organs modeled and present in game. The however have not been implemented beyond a static state. Guts spilling and compound fractures are planned.
i still miss my stabs a lot tbh lol
i think it's a problem with the lock-on
omg :D
i usually have no problem hitting stabs if i turn lock-on off but then i'm stuck moving facing one direction the whole time like a bozo
when i say it feels unintuitive, what i mean isnt that i cant figure out the idea of a swiping motion or a stabbing motion, its that the reasoning behind these being unsuccessful in practice is obfuscated and difficult to resolve, i can easily tell how to perform a stabbing motion, it is not so clear why this stabbing motion isnt * working *
Another clip please chill and look at the drip
I feel like the stabs almost go out of their way to miss sometimes
literally my #1 thing
yes
inuitively i think they should go one way, but they end up going another
Probably bugged
Mostly when on the ground ironically.
Once you get the hang of it landing them in combat is satisfying and consistent af
Yes however the fact that you must click and drag the correct mouse button for the correlating limb is not intuitive. Especially if you are not accustomed to individual limb control.
It's like saying the combat is intuitive because you have played Mordhau but the game really plays like surgeon simulator.
inuitively ๐ฐ
as the alaskans do
Yeah that's true.
also, with shields, it's like, how do I move them independently
i think the other people are having trouble thinking about that because their experience makes them inuitively think it should go where it does
im gonna start spamming inuitively now
what do the Inuit have to do with this ๐
Watching these guys argue was the ego boost i needed. Really made me feel higher on the bell curve
Yeah but it feels like I won a fight with a game when I land a stab, not a fight with Willie.
hence me saying repititon legitimisess
yes
the game is intuitive for what it is. if you want to play semantics then no game is intuitive, using a computer takes learning
Two minutes of straight stabbing for anyone interested
It's been ages since I posted gameplay.
you still fail to understand the concepots being discussed, and thats ok, we accept you for what you are
Disagree there personally but it is one of the more fickle things. There's something to it tho
add a parry demon bot that (intuitively) looks weak but blocks every attack ๐
I think I don't play with any of the shield characters cause it's actually bad playing them cause I can't hit the enemy and also block somehow
definitely not easy tho
longsword ๐คค
Since we're still on the stabbing
see, doing THAT would be unintuitive
There is. Idk. Sometimes it feels better than other times. Itโs strange, but in general I donโt feel as much control as I do with slashes.
Honestly there could be a more intuitive control scheme for the game, like two mice, each with a joystick
nothing of value
not necessarily. i want a sword long enough to close the distance without me getting too close, and using a shield limits me in that respect.
ONE TIME i got a goated longsword duel where there were like 4 consequtive parries and my brain (intuitively) was very happy
It's uh, limited i will say. We only have forward and back from one stance. Wish there was more verticality and samces
unless you mean literally to fuck the shield
uhhh.. reread it a bit more literally
Correct. If you have never played a game like it before it is a foreign and less intuitive.
depends on the shield i guess
maybe to decide..
you could use
intuition
My intuition tells me that swinging my sword at this guy will make me happy
well schnatt weve just concluded (intuitively) that it is unintuitive
intuition means fucking nothing to me now
Use a gamepad mate lol.
intuitively i would have to agree
don't you mean inuitively
Ur so silly... I already do
wait now when someone say intuition you will intuitively think nothing
Gross.
narwhal boss when
think about that intuitively
it's like bad cause you'd expect the shield to stay where it's at but if you try attacking while blocking a hit from another angle, that's not gonna work out
Gamepad in my left, mouse in my right
And my 82 year old grandpa who never used a computer would find opening steam unintuitive but that's not a criticism of anything lol
cause your mouse controls both shield and weapon
i can't speak on this because I rarely play with shields so idk how blocking works lmao
Like anything you're unfamiliar with is unintuitive no shit
two mice
no
four
for legs
genuine question, did you struggle in school, i dont mean this as an insult, im genuinely curious
This is where my double mouse idea came from
I am gonna add intuitive to Automod ban list.
NO
good
intuitively?
inuitive is safe though
maybe we could have like buttons for preprogrammed shield locations??
inutively i would be sad
wha does it even mean
An intuitive solution
are you inuitive?
so we have the answer- intuitive is unintuitive
nah, i'm from New Zealand
inuitive is intuitive
My intuition says that this is unnecessary and oppressive. I should relate this to 1984.
I don't know what argument your trying to make here?
intuitively i would agree
why does it look like a misspelt word
jamais vu
hes either challenged or ragebaiting
i think
Tldr having to practice is bullshit and the game's fault ๐ก
idr what the word is
Literally stumbling head first into the point and still missing it
lmao
this isnt very inuitive can you explain
the man could not be denser if he tried
intuitively? no
No he probably goes to the gym they often do
๐ญ (inuitively)
so do i, i can still comprehend a sentence
Make CM angry before bedtime. he makes chat cool down many minutes.
no, in Inuit terms
Hes literally becoming denser through effort
intuitively, what do you guys think is the best side weapon?
the second you leave its starting again ๐
hello wonderbeast-hope youโre doing well ๐ซก
and i will be inuition baiting
dagger or mace
or maybe hes stopped trying to achieve the mythical "thought"
how does the hand axe do?
reject thought, become monky
i'd rather just have a full axe
I will set it to six hours then!
monkeys have intuition not thought...
rather unintuitive
Speaking my language- i mean ooh ooh ah ah
and this guy has neither
Hello Abom I am good. tired.
that would be most unfortunate
who is this guy tho
lerd
I have learned to master the Striesand effect.
lard
i am sorry you wandered into this dumpster fire in the chat
Does anybody else find bonking just REALLY comedic.
They're mad at me because I told them they need to practice and can't just immediately be good their first time playing lmao
well, same here really- itโs 2 am and i donโt really plan on sleeping and couldnโt if i wanted to lol
It's my job.
yo lard stop baiting its over
Sleeping is good.
lerd is just ragebaiting because he didnt understand about half of the english lexicon
i don't work in the morning so i guess i'm no-lifing
do you get paid to admin
yk how the weapon kinda wobbles after any move right? do you guys think it's a bit much?
All this time you spent crying and trying to insult me you could've landed a stab finally lol
and manage the community
it is- i know. problem being i tried for awhile and it really wasnโt working
Yeah bro i honestly feel bad. Im sorry that this is hard for you
i think lexicon is too complex for him
No, but I am paid to be the community manager.
That's pretty sick.
genuinely what is life like for someone like that
how many people are on the team rn?
maybe hes the reason they have to put "caution hot water" stickers on hot drink machines
two
Probably amazing. Intuitive even
Don't feel bad, I don't have any trouble with Half Sword lol
no thats me
true, i doubt hed be able to read it
i honestly prefer bonks over slices
hed probably warn the water
this got me dead ๐ญ
community manager, i assume, goes beyond discord right?
it feels sacrilegious given the game but a good conk is just really funny
There 12 members of the dev team and 6 members of Game Seer (marketing PR). 18 total people.
Not any harder than Hava so i agree with you somewhat
that's not a big dev team at all considering the scale
we meant basic comprehension but thats good bud
this auto-block orientation change is so annyoing. stopping me from doing a zwerch and a schielhau
how it points it to the sky
bro is too funny i hope u dont get ran over tommorow at 4:26pm ๐
well
ill be inside cooking for my gf at 4:26pm
That's uncalled for.
i dont think it was meant to be a threat
final destinationed

i think youve misinterpreted
i've been seeing a lot more lumber trucks ever since final destination started getting advertised
its like when someone invents water powered cars and you say "hope you dont go missing" i didnt mean it as a threat i swear ๐ญ
i wonder if that's on purpose.
Nah dont wish harm on people for being silly on the internet
in the 7th floor flat of my uni apartment, if anyone runs me over itll be bloody aladdin
yeah ik, it just doesnt come off as obvious over text
Yep I am the one behind all the platforms.
I just wish he asked me what Hava was so I could say hava nice night
@remote ferry whats hava
hava my balls
lmao, I sometimes run into enemies and I end up cutting their legs off
