#retired-patch-6-3-discussion

1 messages · Page 221 of 1

teal geyser
#

shoot

#

oh

#

no

high swan
#

Honestly, i blame Wow for making me skip cutscenes

teal geyser
#

I just blame you

high swan
#

Dont 😦

#

Only 2 MMOs i played seriously are Wow and this

#

And as you know in wow its a race to max level

#

I brought that mentality to FF14 initially

teal geyser
#

The reason I blame you is because no way you didn't know this game was story focused

#

but whatever

spiral mica
#

the cool thing is, you can just go to an inn and watch all hte cutscenes again

teal geyser
#

Except like

#

so much of the plot just also isn't in cutscenes

#

sooo

spiral mica
#

true

teal geyser
#

At least you can NG+!

spiral mica
#

yep

high swan
#

No way im doing NG+

#

ill just keep asking you about stuff

spiral mica
#

thing is, how long were you skipping cutscenes?

high swan
#

Oh, i just realised you're on my server. I can even ask you in game in person too!

teal geyser
#

I don't mind

high swan
#

^^

teal geyser
#

I'd answer it whenever you ask

high swan
#

You're the best

teal geyser
#

what's your name?

high swan
#

@spiral mica I started to.....uh, stop? At Stormblood

teal geyser
spiral mica
#

so.......

high swan
#

By stop, i mean stop skipping

spiral mica
#

you know literally NOTHING about the main plot

teal geyser
#

fuck me

spiral mica
#

not one thing

high swan
#

So. From Stormblood i started following the plot closely

#

I didn't skip EVERYTHING

#

I watched voiced cutscenes and uh....

teal geyser
#

Hey Vic

#

hey

high swan
#

"Interesting" looking ones

#

hey

teal geyser
#

Who is Haurchefant?

vernal haven
teal geyser
high swan
#

Yeah ok

brisk quail
vernal haven
#

same tbh

high swan
#

He was a Knight of House.....Fortemps?

#

He ded

teal geyser
#

okay

high swan
#

I forget who killed him, probably one of the Knights of the Church

teal geyser
#

Yep

brisk quail
#

He is a bastard son of Fortemps

teal geyser
#

Ser Zephirin

brisk quail
#

That's important too

teal geyser
#

ehhh

#

I think he got close enough Ynne

high swan
#

I know alot of people love him and i never got that. But maybe now i get it. Cause i skipped loads of shit

brisk quail
#

As soon as things went to shit

#

And trusted you wholly

high swan
#

iirc he was our first contact going into Foundation

teal geyser
#

Honestly Vic if you don't get something that's probably because you skipped it

high swan
#

Yeah, but im a changed man now

teal geyser
#

He was literally the single person who allowed you into Ishgard

torpid yoke
#

we dont get any of the cool abilities because gameplay stuff

teal geyser
#

after Ul'dah wanted you captured

torpid yoke
#

like aetheryte tax and such

high swan
#

Oh, we are running away from Ul'dah because we "killed" the Sultana

teal geyser
#

we got framed for it and yeah

high swan
#

And looking for refuge in Foundation

#

lol its all coming together now

tulip geyser
#

Even Zenos is better at it and he's Zenos

teal geyser
#

But yeah anyway what's your name? @high swan

high swan
#

Ishgard is the region, right? is the city really called Foundation?

teal geyser
#

No

#

Ishgard is the city

torpid yoke
#

Thats because aulus studied the echo (inhumanely probably)

high swan
#

Yarra Dullahan

teal geyser
#

Foundation is just the name of that one part of Ishgard

high swan
teal geyser
#

Coerthas is the name of the region

high swan
#

Ah yes

torpid yoke
#

plus zenos actually thought to learn how to use it more

#

im still waiting till i can fuse with a primal/ summon >:/

vernal haven
#

coishgard

torpid yoke
#

cough cough ranjit job hack cough hack

vernal haven
#

founderthas

torpid yoke
brisk quail
#

Yeah. The scions/ysholta have a 'last stand' in the sewers of uldah. Yshtola makes the walls collapse and gets lost in the lifestream, and kinda dies. Thancred and co. all disappear and you run into the snow of Southern corthas.

Then Harchenfaunt, a friend you helped earlier, takes you in and since you're technically on Ishgardian turf, uldah/the crystal braves can't touch you. So Harchenfaunt looks into requesting house fortemps to take you into ishgard as that'd totally guarantee safety from Uldah

#

Meanwhile you stay and chat with Harchenfaunt as your whole world literally collapses around you

#

And you eventually make it into Ishgard and meet up with cool grandpa

#

At this point then you start helping Ishgard, in part to keep your standing with House Fortemps, avoid being suspicious by the church's standards so you don't get executed and stuff and other things.

high swan
#

Thanks

brisk quail
#

Most of the... affection for Harchenfaunt is like... mid 40s. 50s.

#

Where the inital quest for him starts

#

Where you meet him

#

And then he takes you in pre-HW

#

Tldr: he was the one dude who still believed you a hero when literally everything went to shit and was the only friend you know who was alive... and not imprisoned and managed to find you sanctuary in ishgard by talking with cool grandpa

high swan
#

Nice

#

Do Estinien now

vernal haven
#

do estinien now is an order im more than happy to oblige

dim sigil
#

Reverse that

teal geyser
# high swan Do Estinien now

Estinien TLDR: Edgy boy whose village and family got massacred by Nidhogg and spent his whole life on a quest of vengenance, kills Nidhogg, later becomes Nidhogg because eyes, later becomes himself and find peace and becomes weirdly fond of Nidhogg because he and the dragon have led very similar lives

high swan
#

I kinda knew already 🙂

#

I just wanted him to type loads of stuff

brisk quail
#

That's all you need to know

vernal haven
#

eggstinien

#

🥚

craggy pawn
#

Edgestinien

high swan
#

Thats pretty epic

vernal haven
#

eggpic

spiral mica
#

hopefully Estinien does some absurdly overpowered stuff as a trust

torpid yoke
#

what do you consider over powered?

high swan
#

Calling Nidhog for a carpet bomb

maiden lodge
oak pike
#

Spams stardiver

#

Nastrond spam

maiden lodge
#

bosses still run through 3 cycles to kill

torpid yoke
#

he does do more niddhogg stuff than midgardsormr stuff

oak pike
#

When I see red I just think of niddhogg stuff

gaunt star
#

my theory on how 6.0 will end.zenos kills zodiark because he wants the fight you and not have zodiark steal his glory.he probably kills them and somehow absorbs their power.then after you kick his ass you realise hydalen is not what you think and have to crush her too

paper dagger
#

I doubt you'll see Trusts in less than 30ish minutes. That's going to start pushing too much into replacing the actual duty finder too much

gaunt star
#

atleast with estenian even his single target is guranteed some aoe damage from dragoon skills

#

i also think gaius wil get killed off at some point.possibly saving wol in proccess and in dying breath ask you to destroy garlean empire or something

oak pike
#

Doesn’t g’rah aoe

#

Unless the weapons story line is require I don’t think he’s gonna die

#

Unless he dies at the end of the weapons story line

gaunt star
#

i doubt it

#

he has too much potential for garlemand story in 6.0

#

i mean who better to help you there than him and nero

#

and there's always the potential for nero to fuck us over because of his bitter rivalry with cid to get revenge

torpid yoke
#

revenge for?

oak pike
#

Nah Nero wouldn’t fuck is over tbh

teal geyser
#

^ well

#

He would but not for like, revenge when it comes at ending the world

oak pike
#

I still find it funny that gaius is not a prisoner but fordola is

torpid yoke
#

he's working out how to time travel before cid rn

gaunt star
#

ARR story.nero was always overshadowed by cid and didnt get the recognition he deserved by the empire

teal geyser
#

I mean

#

I guess Gaius kinda needs some freedom to do what he does

gaunt star
#

also gaius the most primal hating person in existance

#

i cant see us nothing helping us out

#

even if he gets an ironic death and kileld by ultimate primal zodiark

brisk quail
#

I mean gaius isn't a prisoner

#

But he has an edgy elezen blackmage prepping fire iv on him every minute

paper dagger
#

RE: Trust damage, as it was explained to me the characters AE and Single Target, but it doesn't matter. They coded it so the damage is consistent. Kinda like BLU mage 100 needles

heady shadow
#

there are plenty of times in history when some famous general or whatever helps the side they were fighting against after some awol.

paper dagger
#

So Even if they AE, it'll hit all the mobs for less damage

heady shadow
#

and usually they are left alive because mutual benifits

paper dagger
#

That was an intended mechanic to keep the Trust runs consistently less efficient than the average Duty Finder

gaunt star
#

trust damage scales up and down but it doesn't rubberband quite as hard as they imply

#

They basically have an "on-pace" rotation which is horribly slow and a "you're taking too long" rotation which is just regular slow

rain onyx
#

Yeah unless you do big pulls and do big damage Trusts generally clear dungeons right around the 25-30 minute mark.

dim sigil
#

I grinded by watching YouTube as trusts killed mobs

maiden lodge
#

I dislike that they punish you for playing better.

torpid yoke
#

how so?

maiden lodge
#

They do less damage if you do more.

dim sigil
#

Just wait until the game is dead and there's only trust

maiden lodge
#

So if you play better, you still don't accomplish anything

rain onyx
#

Yeah if you’re a DPS you could just pull mobs and then AFK until the next pull

maiden lodge
#

Now, normally, if you play better, your overall average experience in dungeons is smoother and better. But this means that the 'slow down' trusts give is higher--so they feel even worse than they would.

maiden lodge
#

It means bosses overstay their welcome--if you're used to a boss showing a given mechanic only once or twice, suddenly now you're going through it three or four times... and there's nothing you can do to speed that up.

dim sigil
#

I had a duty roulette run where the boss went through it like 5 times I don't know why i didnt leave

dim sigil
#

I feel like I was the only one that actually attacking

torpid yoke
maiden lodge
#

I don't mind Trusts being slower than with people. I mind when my personal participation is undone such that they're more slower for me than they would be for others.

oak pike
#

I just view trust as Par time for dungeons at this point

pine epoch
#

I hope 6.0 they change trust AI to function better the better you play rather than picking up the slack of a shit player

oak pike
#

Trust damage scale gonna remain the same honestly

pine epoch
#

Reason I never went back and grinded trust after finishing msq was cause I felt it was a waste of time if the trust arent going to. You know. Do better unless you suck. Cause I could use that playtime to do something else like farm a savage or ex mount

vernal haven
#

i mean the whole idea is that trusts are never competitive with players to try and keep the queues active while offering people a slower alternative that helps during periods of bad queue times, the main ballache with trusts was having to level them all for the flex but i mean

#

optional

oak pike
#

Like trusts are there and it’s gonna hit a target time range if you’re playing good or not

pine epoch
#

The optimal method when playing with trust is to afk. Hell you could automate this make a macro bot that moves you forward (which I dont advocate) and just let the trust do all the work while you go watch youtube or make a sandwich

vernal haven
#

trust are great when you're hammered as fuck and don't want to grief people haha

#

i mean you could do that sure

oak pike
#

Just like how people afk prae

vernal haven
#

i honestly don't care what people do with their trusts

pine epoch
#

I do trust for the first time through a dungeon just to see the npc dialogue then every other time I go with players

vernal haven
#

afk prae hurts my time

#

do what you want with trusts

oak pike
#

Like trusts are fine where they are at with their intentions

vernal haven
#

im fine with trusts yeah

oak pike
#

Would I like them to go faster yes

#

But I understand why trust are made like this

vernal haven
#

i mean i think i'd rather trusts were kinda shitty

#

if they were good people would only use them

oak pike
#

Yeah

#

If trusts are good why queue for dungeons

vernal haven
#

ffxiv duty finder reminds of going to the zoo

#

sometimes its fun to see chimps flinging shit

oak pike
#

🐒

vernal haven
#

i've seen a duty finder with multiple apes

#

i dont think it made them strong

#

it made them dead

#

which, to be fair, might make them stronger

oak pike
#

Man imagine squadron in SHB

#

Blow everything on the first trash you see

floral aurora
#

I would love a 8-16 bit squadrons dungeon runs

#

That be cool

high swan
#

Go all the way

#

Savage and Ultimate Squads

#

Play the whole game for me

#

I got better things to be doing anyway

floral aurora
#

I hope this new raid is awesome, because I want to beat Lahabrea Savage xD

gaunt star
#

The only reasonably complex connection I can make with the shirts that Yoshida wore were that they might reference his new weapon and/or the class. The only way I can think of deriving a name from this theory is the fact that Zenos repeatedly refers to himself hunting prey so maybe Hunter...? I am trying my best to make a connection that comes up with a solution for a name.

floral aurora
#

Long as the new dps is fun, that's all i care about xD

gaunt star
#

Yeah I just can't control myself when it comes to speculating

high swan
#

How is Zenos going to beat us anyway

#

Since we dont get echo headaches anymore

#

He's done for

gaunt star
#

Obviously it's not gonna be any basic fight

#

I wanna see what he'll pull off

floral aurora
#

Fists, Daggers, Swords, Spears, and scythes. What could be next?

somber storm
#

Bigger sword

floral aurora
#

Dark Knight

gaunt star
#

There's also a Hammer

floral aurora
#

Warrior

#

Magical Sword - RDM

gaunt star
#

I wouldn't compare them too closely because there are plenty of staff weapons

somber storm
#

Sword bigger than drk

gaunt star
#

It would be pretty cool to have heavy weapon on a dps

somber storm
#

2 big swords

gaunt star
#

chosen undead

floral aurora
#

How about.....

#

That will work

gaunt star
#

that would fit the maiming archetype better I think

#

but heavy armor 🤔

floral aurora
#

Long as I get a lightsaber like that

gaunt star
#

not that it matters because dragoons jump the size of skyscrapers

floral aurora
#

Oooooooo

#

Will we get a "Moon Jump" ????

#

I hope so xD

unique verge
#

If Manderville can jump to the moon, no reason why we cant

floral aurora
#

More jumps for Mario!

gentle wharf
#

If so that's awesome

high swan
#

Its on you bro its on you

#

You came here

#

My hands are clean

gentle wharf
#

I ain't worried about spoilers

high swan
#

I did nothing wrong bro

gentle wharf
#

You sound sus bro

high swan
#

The reason we got Echo headaches was because of the Exach

#

Exarch*

gentle wharf
#

OOOOH

#

Got it

#

Cool

teal geyser
#

well

high swan
#

Where in the game are you?

teal geyser
#

those weren't echo headaches

#

sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

gentle wharf
#

So soon enough!

brisk quail
#

Those aren't echo headaches. The sound is diffrent

teal geyser
#

also btw Vic you realise that like, the headaches and the ability to fight Zenos is kinda unrelated right? @high swan

#

Not like they stopped us when beating Zenos before

brisk quail
#

And we still get echo headaches

#

(See Bozja)

teal geyser
#

See like, literally anything

brisk quail
#

Bozja is the last one I can think of off the top of my head

#

It's not a thing we 'get over'

#

It's our power

teal geyser
#

Uhh

brisk quail
#

And our drawback for it

teal geyser
#

I can't think of an echo flashback in 5.4 to be fair so... sure

#

In MSQ anyway

brisk quail
#

Yeah

#

But we still get em

#

Bozja is just an easy one to reference

high swan
#

Didn't we get our asses saved in the first zeno fight

#

we blacked out and someone saved us?

#

Hien?

teal geyser
#

Vic

#

There is several things wrong with that

#

A) that wasn't Zenos, just his body
B) that wasn't our first fight with Zenos
C) Estinien

#

Even if you count that as a Zenos fight that'd be the 4th time we fight

#

But that's an Elidibus fight anyway tbh since that's who was in that body

brisk quail
#

WoL has the echo power of context

torpid yoke
#

of convience

brisk quail
#

When someone gets very emotional. We get to glimpse at the memory or context of that situation

torpid yoke
#

but the echo decides when its convient

brisk quail
#

Also the echo theme

#

There's only one song in our minds

rain onyx
#

Roll for psychic damage

somber storm
#

Now who is Patrick?

balmy mesa
#

Good question

#

Would WoL be SpongeBob?

orchid slate
#

I hope I'm not the only one who might think this but I feel like the ship might be our main city hub for Endwalker?

next quarry
#

I hope so

#

would be really cool

balmy mesa
#

That would mix things up a bit I think

#

Just have the ship parked in orbit of the moon

somber storm
#

We Phantasy Star now

#

Rowena and her stalls

dull lake
#

Now that no one is ocuppyng the arcanist class, is it time for Tataru to shine?

#

We need a Tataru expansion

tulip geyser
#

With how the world might be on fire a mobile hub sounds awesome for storytelling too

balmy mesa
#

she has to get back money that's owed to her after all KEKW

#

and/or shake down unsuspecting adventurers to bankroll the scions' exploits

pulsar yacht
#

tataru's signature skill: death by 1000 paper cuts sofieSmug

somber storm
balmy mesa
somber storm
#

Probably

#

Hell we know she is gonna make Cid pay for it as well

left lynx
#

if we're going to Garlemald in Endwalker, I wonder if this means we'll finally get armor like the Garleans in ARR

tulip geyser
left lynx
#

we get Allagan gear out of 5000 year old ruins just fine, I'm sure Cid can fix us up some magitek armor

somber storm
#

Well

#

Most Garlean armour is shit

#

Mass produced

gaunt star
#

Isnt the new bozja gear basically garlean armor?

pine epoch
#

It's the judge armor from FF12

#

Which inspired the garleans

#

But they aren't the same

floral aurora
#

Someone wants super badass dps job

#

Dual Wielder Ultimate badass

heady shadow
#

the dps ends up being a dual weapon job, weapons will be like gabranths from ff12

#

mwhahahaha

floral aurora
#

Lets hope SE makes all happy in May

balmy mesa
#

that's wishful thinking lul

#

there will be people who are salty

floral aurora
#

I'm sold on Sage so far but we'll see about this new dps

heady shadow
#

fuck them

floral aurora
#

😂

heady shadow
#

those salty people are alwasy salty

#

and never stop bitching

#

so fuck em

floral aurora
#

Yeah I'm on the hype train xD

balmy mesa
#

haha, shove them into the lochs

#

I'm keen for sage

floral aurora
#

Not the salt train

balmy mesa
#

but I'm hoping this means that SCH gets some fixes

tulip geyser
#

If AST is losing noct, may I please have a lot more space themed fun to make up for it

heady shadow
#

let them drown in salt?

#

i like it

floral aurora
#

I'm hoping AST gets a complete rework. AST should not be a boring job by any means

#

Its a dealer job

#

Come on SE

tulip geyser
#

Yeah play up the space and fortune teller angles to the hilt

floral aurora
#

Yeah I want them to think more outside the box with that job

boreal forge
#

Just make the ast predict who will cause a wipe looking at the stars so that person would avoid automatically that mechanic, and there would be no wipe

#

I see it

regal lantern
#

For 6.0, the maiming job would have been better if it was a dual wielding Judge job

#

Scythe is good but Judge would have been more... fitting?

#

We could even say it is an art from Ilsabard, somewhere on the Southern ends

#

I still am clueless where the Scythe job could be from

#

Thavnair? Ul'Dah/Thanalan? Golmore?

somber storm
#

Probably something Zenos whipped up

pine epoch
#

I bet the dps job unlock quest will either be ul dah or gridania

#

Surprise us

#

Its in coerthas central

#

In dragonhead

#

Or mor dhonna

regal lantern
#

Mor Dhona or Dragonhead would be nice

balmy mesa
#

you know, dual-wielding brings up an interesting thing

somber storm
#

Hingashi

unique verge
#

Not gonna be hingashi

#

and Mor Dhona or Dragonhead is a big stretch

somber storm
#

Level 70 start though

unique verge
#

Yeah but they'll never put it behind MSQ progression again

somber storm
#

Oh yeah

unique verge
#

I still remain optimistic that it isnt a scythe job

balmy mesa
#

dual-wielding, what if they let us do MH and OH like with PLD?

regal lantern
#

Since the hints are usually pretty straight forward

unique verge
#

I'm not certain what the hint is towards, but i dont believe it to be hinting at a scythe job, for a variety of reasons, such as "it'll feel too samey with DRK/DRG", "the thing in the trailer is not really able to be confirmed to be anything", "a scythe is already available as a weapon in-game via mogstation", "DRK is the closest we are likely to ever come to a 'evil aligned' job and most Scythe based job names people are throwing around are further than DRK", etc.

craggy gale
#

scythes are lame and i don't like them

#

put down the lawnmower

somber storm
#

Lawnmower man

regal lantern
# unique verge I'm not certain what the hint is towards, but i dont believe it to be hinting at...

"it'll feel too samey with DRK/DRG"
I mean that never stopped SE from making jobs.

"the thing in the trailer is not really able to be confirmed to be anything"
The trailer is not really the major hint, it is an addition but not a primary tell.

"a scythe is already available as a weapon in-game via mogstation"
We also had gunblades in Mogstation for a long time.

"DRK is the closest we are likely to ever come to a 'evil aligned' job and most Scythe based job names people are throwing around are further than DRK"
Scythe/Reaper/Necro doesn't have to be a evil-aligned job.

The reason people think it's a scythe is primarily because:

  1. The T-shirts, both at the announcement and again at the 5.5 live letter.
  2. Scythe sort of goes with a Reaper/Death themed job, however, it can also be a job that has the concept of beating death rather than enforcing it.
  3. The hints via T-shirts are always a very straight forward thing and never something players have to research deep into with theories to find out. From Scarlet Witch (Red Mage), Samu Raimi's Spiderman movie (Spiderman), 007(MCH/gun job), things are always a bit too straight forward with Yoshi P.

As for what the hint is towards, I'll let you decide

unique verge
#

You dont need to repost the pictures

#

Ive seen them

regal lantern
#

Well you said you don't know what the hint is about

unique verge
#

No i didnt

#

I said i havent decided what the new job is

regal lantern
#

"I'm not certain what the hint is towards"
?

unique verge
#

Yes, as in, i dont know what the hint is attempting to convey

#

other than i dont agree with 'scythe job'

regal lantern
#

Lol that's why I sent the picture, like what do you think a death reaper is trying to show?

#

A templer? lol

unique verge
#

We'll know soon enough anyway.

tropic frigate
#

the biggest thing to confuse us is that some shirts were pretty simple and some were more in depth

regal lantern
#

No

#

They were all pretty straight forward

#

In the past

tropic frigate
#

i recall a spider man shirt meant samurai

#

that is true right?

regal lantern
#

I knew you'd say that

tropic frigate
#

it shows that they will go that far

regal lantern
#

But he explicitly said on that Fan Fest "I really like the Spiderman movies by Samu Raimi (sam raimi)" hence Samurai

tropic frigate
#

even though the second shirt he wore in live letter has nothing else besides the front?

#

for most recent LL

regal lantern
#

It's a children of Bodom tshirt

tropic frigate
#

yea

regal lantern
#

with the follow the reaper album cover

tropic frigate
#

and probably dont even need to know the song either

#

its simply the same as the first

unique verge
#

To clarify

#

that is NOT the album cover art for Follow the Reaper

regal lantern
#

This one

unique verge
#

I looked into the image at the time and it appears to just be some art the band commissioned but never used as album art

#

they used it for a poster iirc

#

but not album art

regal lantern
#

They often used reaper as their image

#

It's a death metal band at that, so people saying "rock band tshirts" are also... wrong

#

Sex Pistol was punk, not rock

unique verge
#

smh i had to have that argument earlier

#

someone tried to say Children of Bodom was a "hardcore punk" band. I laughed hard at that one.

craggy gale
#

for what it's worth i hope it's music themed so no one has to level archer to 30 exclusively to unlock performance ever again

unique verge
#

Another reason im skeptical on the Reaper connection

#

is that it doesnt fit visually with what we know for a fact - its a Maiming job

regal lantern
#

Oh actually

#

It can

high swan
#

Define maiming job

unique verge
#

Okay, but the ones on his shirts absolutely do not

unique verge
regal lantern
#

There you go, it works

tropic frigate
#

it all depends on how big or heavy the scythe looks and it can always work

#

although sometimes things just dont fit

#

aiming sets on a dancer can look weird

regal lantern
#

True

high swan
#

Yeah, i think the class themes are losing traction

#

Samurai should probably be a maiming class. More heavily armoured

regal lantern
#

Eh... no?

tropic frigate
#

i can see that

#

doesnt it look more heavy in 11?

#

and wasnt it a tank or something

#

while drk was a dps?

high swan
regal lantern
#

There is a certain aspect of samurai to be heavily armoured but its not necessarily always heavily armoured

tropic frigate
#

i feel like the same could be with current sam

#

either way it can work

spiral wagon
#

ok random question

#

WHERE will the new dps class be unlocked at?

brisk quail
#

They haven't confirmed.

#

But... I'd say... Gridania.

#

Possibly a connection to voidsent, Edda, PotD...

spiral wagon
#

ok now what if

#

they add it in NOT one of the starter cities

brisk quail
#

No.

strange summit
#

Well hello there

brisk quail
#

They've been pretty set in their ways since HW

pulsar yacht
#

Inb4 rhgars reach for new melee since have to be lv 70 to unlock

spiral wagon
#

^

brisk quail
#

Yeah. But sage is in limsa.

#

So...

spiral wagon
#

thats cus llimsa didnt have two classes unlocked there

#

they only had the 1 and that was dancer

strange summit
#

Because they can't use Sharlayan for Sage yet

spiral wagon
#

now each city has two classes (not including BLU)

brisk quail
#

Whatever makes you happier I guess... we'll see if it happens that way

spiral wagon
#

no wait gridania doesnt have a second one does it

#

shit

teal geyser
#

Even then Oograth literally not making it a starting city is really fucking stupid

spiral wagon
#

it still be a nice change of pace

brisk quail
#

I agree with @teal geyser

teal geyser
#

There is a fucking reason nobody likes the HW job requirements

spiral wagon
#

spice things up

teal geyser
#

NO ONE

spiral wagon
#

:(

teal geyser
#

NO ONE would want to have to do the base game AND first expansion to even get access to a job

#

And even then it's 70 so you might need to level even further to get it

spiral wagon
#

inb4 its on the First

teal geyser
#

MSQ locked jobs is something they are never going to do again for really fucking obvious reasons and I'm kind of even mad you WANT this requirement locking

spiral wagon
#

well sorry i want a job questline not Start take place in the main areas

brisk quail
#

They don't.

#

Dancer takes place in a myriad of places

#

Same with like 80% of jobs

#

And even then. Being in a starting city is beneficial for the servers

#

As they allocate more load for those instances

#

If you have 1000000 people load into some random zone to get a job it'll be hell

spiral wagon
#

i dont want it to be out in the wilds

#

just a different city than the starter 3

brisk quail
#

Even then... outside places require MSQ progress

spiral wagon
#

yes as cal mentioned

brisk quail
#

Yeah and it was despised.

#

They got alot of flak for it

#

Why would they do it agai

spiral wagon
#

alright hows this.

brisk quail
#

After it was so heatedly repeated to them?

spiral wagon
#

job quest line starts in gridania

#

and

#

moves you over into gyr abania

brisk quail
#

That's how most Job quests work. Usally goes into the current expac.

#

Like RDM

#

Starts in uldah.

#

Goes to mordhona

#

Hangs out in both SB and HW

teal geyser
#

Only problem with that is uh

#

We probably aren't getting much job quests anyway

brisk quail
#

Yeah

#

They're doing role quests again

#

They'll do the inital like... 5 for lore

teal geyser
#

RDM could do it because at least they had two sections, the starting questline in the 50-60 and then they could do expansion stuff

brisk quail
#

And then the special ones at every 10 levels

teal geyser
brisk quail
#

Yeah

#

Because this job NEEDS lore

#

It has alot going on

#

That needs explaining and or mentioning

#

oh yeah this is sharlayan magic mixed with allagan and ironwork tech, fancy huh?

#

Done.

teal geyser
#

"it's a mecha ya?"

somber storm
#

Wakka

brisk quail
#

I was about to say

#

I hear it.

somber storm
#

Filthy Machina

brisk quail
#

What a great youtube video... Wakka being unhappy with Al Bhed for 11 minutes straight

balmy mesa
#

oh god that gif lul

balmy mesa
somber storm
#

Wakka's ex was more satisfied with a machina

tight horizon
#

honestly was hoping that the new class would be "throw shit at monsters" - a la wakka/yuffie. Could be a boomerang, could be a ball, doesnt matter. Just yeet at em

balmy mesa
#

would need to be ranged DPS in that case

#

it'd be cool though

#

but it's kinda like what DNC already does

#

throw shit at people while being fabulous

strange wing
#

Grand Wizard Wakka was a magical moment

gaunt star
#

Wakka as a character hasn’t aged well for me but I haven’t played X in years so idk if he got his arc completed

wary perch
#

He get to married impregnated lulu

#

I said his life is complete

gaunt star
#

Fuck you got a point there XD

viscid monolith
#

Wakka's character is perfect. Always has been always will be.

cinder badger
#

@viscid monolith Wakka is what Fozzy Bear says on the Muppet Show

#

I always found it a little funny how in Final Fantasy 10 they gave you a dialogue option to tell Lulu that she's more your type

#

And then she makes mention of adding you to her list

teal geyser
#

Racist Wakka best Wakka

forest magnet
#

did :wakkaglare: get removed?

#

huh?

viscid monolith
#

I guess people didn't use it enough?

somber storm
#

don't worry, we have gif form

craggy pawn
#

I really hope they add some kind of tutorial for class boosts in 6.0.

#

Tho thats no gonna help much

somber storm
#

The smiths

#

And you can redo class quests in ng+

teal geyser
#

you don't pay their sub @craggy pawn

ornate coral
#

anyone know when preorder will be available?

open verge
#

Around may imo

teal geyser
#

^ probably

scenic sun
#

Wait i missed the Wakka topic

gaunt star
dim sigil
#

Wakka was pretty necessary as it gave us a good window into how people generally feel about the Al Bhed having that be a party member isn't something that you could get from npcs

exotic copper
#

Hammer job

strange wing
#

Tidus: "Wakka, why is your facebook profile an iron cross?"

forest magnet
#

he's simply a wwii history buff

#

obviously

cursive hedge
#

what do we think the ilevel will be for the starter gear set? Like 500?

cursive hedge
#

endwalker

pine epoch
#

525 probably

#

I mean 515

brisk quail
#

I mean if base GNB gear is... 255

#

Wait...

#

No it'd be 5 below tome

#

385 if it starts at 70

#

So Aug scaven would still be better

cursive hedge
#

thinking about how worth it it is to get cryptlurker set for endwalker

brisk quail
#

It'd be easy and well worth it

#

Because as soon as END hits

#

It's all poetic purchaseable

#

Including augment

#

Honestly... I'd buy what you can now (like accesories) if you aren't raiding/BIS chasing

#

Then wait for END and buy the remaining pieces

cursive hedge
#

ah yeah I forgot about that

brisk quail
#

Except belt

#

Since belt is dying

cursive hedge
#

I can't really do the savage raids anymore cause I'm too far behind, but I still feel like playing

#

theyre removing belt?

brisk quail
soft gyro
#

belts are worthless

brisk quail
#

Honestly. Good change

#

It was just another thing to keep updated on

soft gyro
#

less materia slots tho

brisk quail
#

Less tokens per raid

#

Less tome stones per upgrade

#

Less coins per augment mat

cursive hedge
#

they might balance around it to make other items stronger/more expensive with tomes?

brisk quail
#

Possibly

#

But changing raid token seems unlikely

soft gyro
#

they gonna add a feature where you can accidentally loose your pants

brisk quail
#

Pants GONE

#

Gotta go pick it up

soft gyro
#

blm one handed caster

#

other hand to hold up his pants

flat merlin
#

Lmao

brisk quail
rain onyx
#

Lulu Primal incoming

dim sigil
#

Jokes on you my pants are always loose

spiral wagon
#

in 6.0 maybe we will get a cid outfit change?

mint axle
#

I'm betting the 2nd trial for endwalker will be Lunar Bahamut, and third trial will be Zodiark.

orchid slate
#

Has there been any new information for 6.0?

woven escarp
#

not until may

#

unless someone blabs to famitsu I guess

orchid slate
#

I've been passively trying to find supposed tweets from a member of the FFXIV team that apparently gave another hint to what the new melee class is but the apparent tweet has been 404'd and the source can't supply the link to said, deleted tweet to view the meta data or something or another.

woven escarp
#

anyone who leaked something out of sequence has been quietly erased from existence

#

SE killed all their NA QA team because of blufevr

orchid slate
#

Holy shit REALLY!?

woven escarp
#

"planned cutbacks" affecting support staff in NA

#

which was announced shortly after someone from inside SE leaked a ton of details about stormblood

#

and blue mage

orchid slate
#

That's funny so there's no NA relations anymore

#

Well that's one way to fix a leak, just cut it from the source.

woven escarp
#

ye

#

that's why there's been less noise around fanfest this year, only CBU3 knows anything

rough kestrel
#

NA is the 13th shard

#

"We need it to have an accident"

heady shadow
#

back then you had a bunch of mr happy fans rabidly going over blufevr

#

*after

orchid slate
#

I kinda understand why JP never wants to have any joint companies with NA but god damn it just keeps getting worse

heady shadow
#

it sucks tbh. because its really just the actions of the few that end up messing it up for everyone

#

but then you look at sony thats deliberately being shitheads but meh

pine epoch
#

Sony has a shit head in a position that gives them room to look at state of play and any press conference

#

And leak all the info

balmy mesa
#

like what happened with the ps5 open beta?

pine epoch
#

Ye

#

The person leaked all the games for the ps5 conference

#

Their still employed

#

And leaked info about 7R ps5 and yuffie dlc

woven escarp
#

HD yuffie 😌

pine epoch
#

Like I know some people really like leaks cause it gives them a look into games that are so dead quiet. But. I honestly find leaks to be such a fucking insult

#

I may be somewhat of a hypocrite

#

Since I like looking at datamine info

woven escarp
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

I don't care about leaks but it's easy to forget about a game if you don't hear anything about it for a while

#

like you want to put a little bait in the water to keep people interested

maiden lodge
#

I know it's fun to meme that 14 doesn't like to use american anything or have thme involved in anything but it's not true. People need to get their facts straight before they start being upset about things.

woven escarp
#

yeah

#

they just fired everyone in QA at the time because they didn't know who blufevr was

#

and they knew he was in the NA team

thin crypt
#

when we get to the moon

balmy mesa
#

wtf is that from

thin crypt
#

final fantasy movie

elder moth
balmy mesa
#

god damn I love the idle camera in FFXIV sometimes

#

like having the camera focus on two naked hyurs tied up with zero context whatsoever

heady shadow
#

spirits within... classic movie for those who like it.

maiden lodge
heady shadow
#

though if it dropped the FF in its name it would been better

maiden lodge
heady shadow
#

and big corpos bad?

#

and almost never trust almost all characters voiced by james woods?

balmy mesa
#

lol

maiden lodge
heady shadow
#

i think he good at it tbh

maiden lodge
#

I was entertained by it, in the theater.

#

Needed a chocobo or a black mage though

heady shadow
#

ye

woven escarp
#

zeus cannon is one of the best FF songs

dim sigil
#

It's still a bad movie even without ff name

balmy mesa
#

speaking of cinematics

#

I'm hoping we get a proper 4K cinematic for Endwalker

#

artifacting of the title movie in ShB's pretty bad

#

lol, the sineater in that video looks kind of like Zenos

#

but obviously can't be

maiden lodge
#

We kinda... should kn....

balmy mesa
#

lol

gaunt star
#

When the fuck are they going to fix Alisae's two braids!

#

3d newbie mistakes 101

regal lantern
#

Okay so here's my theory for what's up with Fandaniel, and very likely how he may have a redemption arc if SE continues the method they did throughout 5.0

So we have been gaining victories over Ascians left and right and if I remember right, Fandaniel shows up in 5.1, way after the fall of Emet Selch. What if he isn't some wannabe Kefka but rather truly someone who lost all and any hope of ever bringing back Amaurot. Maybe of the Convocation, he was the weakest (in strength) and he knows he can never fix things anymore, that WoL's victory is inevitable. No one relied on Elidibus to fix things, not even Emet, Elidibus is merely a shadow of what he is, a shade, not unlike Nidhogg's shade. Actually, the very same, albeit instead of a shade of rage, this is a shade of obsession and dutifulness.

So Fandaniel, realising there's no hope for Amaurot, decided "if I can't have my family back, this world has no purpose to continue." after all, to them we are merely micro organisms. Even the planet is fragmented, nothing is how it was. So in grief and rage, he went "I will just destroy it all just like you destroyed us!"

#

So rather than a crazy lunatic, in 6.0 we will see someone who lost all hope and lived his last days just waiting to die, hence he doesn't care if Zenos kills him or not

maiden lodge
#

Okay but

#

That Fandaniel wasn't there.

dim sigil
#

Aren't they effectively the same person

maiden lodge
#

No.

dim sigil
#

It's just he's inhabiting a different body

maiden lodge
#

No.

#

That's not what a Paragon of the Shard is.

#

A Paragon of the Shard is someone 1) native to one of the Reflections who 2) perferred to be, but not always, is a reincarnation of the original Convocation members at the summoning of Zodiark, and who 3) has Emet-selch yeet what memories he could of that original member into their brain.

gaunt star
#

I think he probably hates his superiors because all his creations are fucked up shit so they kicked him out only to revive him when they literally had no other choice

dim sigil
#

Don't they get the crystal thing and then their memories of the original person is put inside them

maiden lodge
dim sigil
#

So in a sense they're the same person

maiden lodge
#

But... that doesn't always lead to perfect loyalty.

dim sigil
#

Yeah they are just memories after all

maiden lodge
#

And no, it doesn't mean they're the same person. See Gaia.

tulip geyser
#

THere are probably little reminders to who they were

#

Like Mitron and Loghrif's draw to one another

dim sigil
#

I see gaia as the same, just this gaia had a diff life

tulip geyser
#

The PC's love of wandering

maiden lodge
#

Gaia is a different person with different beliefs and experiences to Lohgrif, and Mitron is trying to remove those experiences and beliefs from Gaia.

dim sigil
#

I mean yeah but it's still the same soul

maiden lodge
#

Same soul, but not the same person

next quarry
#

Us and azem

maiden lodge
#

Us and Ardbert.

next quarry
#

Yea

maiden lodge
#

same soul, or in the case of PotShards, fragments of the same soul != same person

#

That's the other thing--Fandaniel doesn't even have the same soul as the original, he's got a tiny fragment of it. There's someone on the Source he's more Fandaniel than Fandaniel is.

balmy mesa
#

do we know for sure that Fandaniel is an Ascian, rather than some nutjob disguising himself as one?

#

Like yeah he does his emblem thing

maiden lodge
regal lantern
gaunt star
#

ok but are we sure shadowhunter is gaius 🤔

next quarry
#

No it's ||Ranjit||

woven escarp
#

they never really did mention how gaius managed to get so many scalps

balmy mesa
#

I should rephrase, could you see a twist like that coming with him?

gaunt star
#

cuz he has STRENGTH BEFITTING A RULER

woven escarp
#

I wonder if that will become important now that we only have fandaniel left to worry about

regal lantern
#

Oh wait, Kawaiian means that this is not the same person as the whole Fandaniel. Yes true.

balmy mesa
#

walks like an Ascian, talks like an Ascian, but might not be an Ascian

maiden lodge
# regal lantern What do you mean?

This really needs to be pinned.

Paragons of the Shards can't have been pre-sundering because they'd be native to the Source. Because Fandaniel is not native to the Source he must have come after the Sundering. If he came after the Sundering, he came after Zodiark's summoning.

He cannot have been there.

maiden lodge
#

Sorry if I got a bit ruffled in my response--I've had people literally assert he's the exact same guy

woven escarp
#

he literally says he's a sundered

#

which makes him a second class citizen in the ascian hierarchy

#

nobody in the convocation gives a shit about him

regal lantern
#

But I never did say this is the same person, this is just my theory on how he will be shown to not be an actual bad person. That’s he’s actually good, and not some wannabe Kefka

maiden lodge
woven escarp
#

well, that's because we killed the last unsundered haha

balmy mesa
#

Lahabrea is a big question mark cos of the raid coming up

woven escarp
#

but my point was that fandaniel isn't an original

#

anyone who's like "but what if he wasn't" is ignoring tier 1 canon

tulip geyser
#

Only three of them were original anyhow

maiden lodge
tulip geyser
#

And this particular Fandaniel seems to have been a problem child in general

maiden lodge
#

Though, make that 'he's from the Seventh or another shard that was Rejoined'

woven escarp
#

fandaniel has been trying to die for ages and the unsundered didn't let him

#

now that he's free from their threats he's just going to kill everyone because he wants to die

maiden lodge
#

Fandaniel: "I just want to die."
Emet-selch: "Mood."

woven escarp
#

his plan is probably engineered to fail specifically so someone will come and kill him

regal lantern
#

Why can’t he just die alone then lol

woven escarp
#

because he also wants everyone else to die

balmy mesa
tulip geyser
#

I think he's lying. Sure he may want to die, but its more important to drag everyone else with him because thats what the thing-in-the-planet wanted

gaunt star
#

He's going back to the void

maiden lodge
gaunt star
#

See void quests

woven escarp
#

there's a lot of "uh... ignore that waves hand frantically" in XIV lore

woven escarp
#

what about that heart of sabik lore I was promised?

#

6 years ago?

balmy mesa
gaunt star
#

Yes

woven escarp
#

unukalhai 😔

maiden lodge
balmy mesa
#

well, looks like I'm gonna rock that thok

regal lantern
#

I’ll be honest

maiden lodge
#

And the role quests of course

dim sigil
#

To me though that makes no sense one could easily Miss family they never had they have been given many memories of it

regal lantern
#

I don’t get fandaniel

#

Just die alone

#

Please

balmy mesa
#

I've already done all the role quests, just not the ex trials

gaunt star
#

Fandaniel is just Kuja

woven escarp
#

I thought the ex primals were independent of meeting unukalhai

maiden lodge
#

You only need Rav and Bis Ex, the rest are unlocks and you're golden

woven escarp
#

only that you had to do the HM warring triad

maiden lodge
balmy mesa
#

okay, so I'm gonna have a whale of a time rocking that thok around the clock

woven escarp
#

I'm about 95% certain I never did bismarck ex

tulip geyser
#

I think since the sundered ascians arent necessarily tempered since they werent there at the summoning (though they may be devout, see Nabriales) I think whatever made the Sound has gotten to Fandaniel instead

woven escarp
#

I know I did ravana ex for the first time on blue mage two weeks ago haha

maiden lodge
#

Because unlike the Warring Triad, the two primals are required to complete the quests that are prerequisites

#

Previous quest The Diabolical Bismarck
Thok Around the Clock
A Fiendish Likeness
A Deific Simulacrum
A Demonic Duplicate
Safekeeping

woven escarp
#

🤔

#

there must be another quest then

#

I know unukalhai has been in the waking sands for ages

maiden lodge
#

Rising Stones, and yeah.

tulip geyser
#

Oh hey

maiden lodge
#

I mean, go talk to Cyella in the First and see what prereqs you're missing

tulip geyser
#

Does the end of 6.0 mean we're gonna move bases again, do you think?

balmy mesa
#

probably

#

moon base pls

woven escarp
#

I already finished the shadowkeeper quest with cyella

#

I bet the next scion base is in garlemald

maiden lodge
#

She has another one.

balmy mesa
#

I loved the role quests in ShB

gaunt star
#

Garlemald is in ruins

#

2nd city is still unknown

balmy mesa
#

not the first dumpster fire we've lived in tho

maiden lodge
gaunt star
#

There have been at least two moon settlements: the Crystal Palace and Fort Lune in the past

woven escarp
#

rhalgr's reach is pretty shit

maiden lodge
woven escarp
#

hope you like sand, my guys

gaunt star
#

Roach reach is the worst hub in the game

woven escarp
#

that's the doman base 😔

balmy mesa
#

idyllshire is kinda annoying, if only because the fucking hinterlands don't have aetherytes

maiden lodge
#

Our bases have been, respectively, The Waking Sands, the RIsing Stones, Fortemps Manor, the Ruby Bazaar, and the entire whole Crystarium

balmy mesa
#

They could do something nuts by going "alright, idyllshire is your base"

#

but that's in a bullshit location anyway

woven escarp
#

not as annoying as the sea of clouds having both aetherytes on the same side of the map

#

so there's no fuckin benefit to using one over the other

maiden lodge
woven escarp
#

"here's this huge ass fuckin map, but both teleport locations are right next to each other"

balmy mesa
maiden lodge
#

Or you're there for beast tribes as opposed to fucking around

woven escarp
#

having ok'gundu out on the east end of the map at least gives you more coverage

#

putting it right next to cloudtop is redundant

balmy mesa
#

cos they realised it was in the middle of fuck off nowhere and they shoved the beast tribe there

maiden lodge
woven escarp
#

beast tribe shit takes you all over the map

#

but you gotta fly there once you get the quests

balmy mesa
#

In terms of BT, I think what they did for qitari and dwarves in terms of distance from aetheryte was pretty good

maiden lodge
woven escarp
#

yeah, but you could have put it on the east end of the map so you could teleport between the two aetherytes instead of spending 8 minutes flying corner to corner

balmy mesa
#

HW zones were done with some... questionable design decisions which they've mercifully taken out back and shot

woven escarp
#

yeah

#

can you just fly up into neverreap and do a quest, then down into wisenbent and do a quest

maiden lodge
#

Sea of Clouds is a zone that's really awesome until you get the whole map

woven escarp
#

yeah

#

it looks really cool

#

but it's so fucking annoying to navigate

balmy mesa
#

sadly it's ruined by moogles

woven escarp
#

so many Z axis changes

balmy mesa
#

Oh wait, churning mists*

maiden lodge
#

But Sea of Clouds is still better to navigate then CWH or Azys Lla

balmy mesa
#

Could you imagine if they were in Sea of Clouds?

#

CWH is fine to navigate

#

It's just a slog

maiden lodge
#

'What you want is on the other end of the map and there's only one aetheryte in the corner go fuck yourself'

woven escarp
#

yeah

balmy mesa
#

ha, dusk vigil

woven escarp
#

they could have at least put an aetheryte on the fuckin flagship

maiden lodge
#

At least there's a back door into Sea of Clouds, right?

#

RIGHT?!

balmy mesa
#

flagship?

#

in CWH they could've put one where that little town is, in the middle of the map

#

Dravania Hinterlands, probably one near the centre

#

On the bright side at least Azys Lla let you get flying pretty early

woven escarp
#

that's because azys lla is a guided tour, you need flying so they just force it on you through an easy MSQ

#

if azys lla was like a regular zone it would be miserable

#

like tempest REEE

maiden lodge
#

It's wrecked.

balmy mesa
#

yeah lol

#

no funding

#

damn lalafells

maiden lodge
#

Also destroyed by the weather

woven escarp
#

that one was functional in 1.0

#

it's an easter egg haha

viral hawk
#

Hey all. Just curious, did they say anything about vieras/lionmen getting more hairs and hats in the new expac?

woven escarp
#

ah, I forgot this meme from 5.0, can't wait for the 6.0 patch notes to make it relevant again

tulip geyser
#

Replace that WHM with SGE and you'll be right

woven escarp
#

well, who knows if sage will be good

#

it looks cool but that doesn't mean it'll be good

tulip geyser
#

Wont play it myself but people do like the lazorshow

woven escarp
#

reminder that ast sucked shit for months in 3.0 until they super buffed it

tulip geyser
#

Yes cause I was and still am one of them lol

dim sigil
#

Ast is getting a big rework isnt it

woven escarp
#

ast is getting turned into a throughput healer like whm

#

so there will be two barrier healers and two raw healers

balmy mesa
#

I just want my boy SCH back 😭

woven escarp
#

so rip noct stance

tulip geyser
#

Yeah, and I hope without Noct- not that I disliked noct, I started healing in MMOs as a Disc priest- the job can have more of its own stuff instead of being "kinda WHM" "kinda SCH" "good ogcd tho"

woven escarp
#

I mean, the only time you used noct is if you had two asts lmao

#

or if you really felt like pissing away MP

tulip geyser
#

Especially after Neutral became a thing

balmy mesa
#

I suspect that noct stance will still exist, they'll just rework it to fit the class identity

tulip geyser
#

But I hate pets so never got into SCH

balmy mesa
#

like diurnal would favour cheaper heals that are pretty good on MP, have regen etc, noct would have the big beefy oGCD heals that can do party wide

woven escarp
#

maybe noct becomes a supercharged healing output stance

#

yeah

#

noct used to have a 20% healing buff on it to make barriers stronger

#

but it also made spells way more expensive so 🤔

gaunt star
#

I wouldn't be surprised if they kept neutral sect

#

but no shield outside that

balmy mesa
#

yeah

#

like say, you want Medica II? The equivalent would be noct

#
  • single target regen: diurnal
  • party wide regen: noct
tulip geyser
#

Will just have to wait and see I guess

woven escarp
#

yeah, especially since whm has a barrier OGCD too

balmy mesa
#

I think they might still keep that, somehow

#

like as a kind of "oh shit" button

#

the reverse could be true for the barrier healers

tulip geyser
#

Yeah probably cause theres always "Well what if barrier healer is ded, tho" moments

balmy mesa
#

yeah, especially in raids

#

dammit, accidentally let my aussie slip and ended up having a reply auto-deleted, haha

maiden lodge
#

Cause there's only two raid wide aoe shields in ogcds--Consolation, and Nocturnal Celestial Opposition

pure thorn
#

Wrong channel

#

Ignore

balmy mesa
viscid monolith
#

First few weeks of prog you use noct

maiden lodge
maiden lodge
viscid monolith
#

Then everyone has better gear and you go back to Diurnal

maiden lodge
#

And after that it doesn't heckin matter

balmy mesa
#

The heals were beefy, but I preferred SCH because you could be more proactive about keeping people alive

viscid monolith
#

They just couldn't make Noct work

maiden lodge
#

They did.

#

First few weeks of prog you use noct

The only time that shit matters.

viscid monolith
#

Not without overshadowing SCH

#

I meant besides that

woven escarp
#

especially after they shit on sch in 5.0

maiden lodge
#

Here's the thing, Noct ast is not the problem with Scholar.

#

WHM is.

viscid monolith
#

There was a stretch of time in SB where Noct was better than SCH in every way

woven escarp
#

"healer dps needs to be homogenized and nerfed because multiple buttons confused our soccer mom playtesters and all you honest healers out there"

maiden lodge
#

It was WHMatha All ALong.

woven escarp
#

sch mains crying in despair

maiden lodge
viscid monolith
#

Cheaper and stronger shields

#

Higher raid dps

maiden lodge
#

'Noct Ast is better than Sch' never mattered because WHM was shit. And honestly, still is.

gaunt star
balmy mesa
#

I liked AST because in casual raid situations you could go "oh, WHM? Noct. SCH? Diurnal. AST? Figure it out"

maiden lodge
#

If SCH were bad, AST/SCH would not be better or even competitive with AST/WHM and wouldn't have been since heckin 4.0

#

They want to believe WHM is better than SCH but the fact is, WHM/SCH is carried in healing by the SCH, and WHM ends up chadding the SCH as a result. But the total raid dps (the only number that matters) is less because the WHM has only one AoE heal.

#

Asylum.

#

Assize only gets used to heal when it's used to DPS, otherwise, WHM is forced to cast to aoe heal.

#

Cure 3 is a crutch that WHM is forced to resort to because it has nothing else, not a benefit.

#

But what's better? A Cure 3 (forcing party positioning around a healer), or Indom+Fey Blessing?

gaunt star
#

The latter

maiden lodge
#

Asylum or Sacred Soil?

#

Scholars have a deeper and more useful healing kit than White Mages.

#

So when savage happens, who has to cover more healing? Scholar. Not because Scholar's clumsy or bad, but because the Whm's out of options once they use Asylum, or Bene, DBeni, and Tetra.

gaunt star
#

Did white mages drop a tier?

#

I thought they were the healer goats of 5.0

#

whm comps never actually were the best

#

Why is that

#

actually gate does have a lot of whm rep

#

and verse does as well at the very top but sch+ast better in general 🤔

#

promise is 100% ast and 90% sch tho haha

#

this is the kind of healing distribution you see in top ast+whm logs though

dim sigil
#

I guess cuz I don't really play MMOs but I don't get the mindset of if you don't do it in the first week or month is pointless

gaunt star
#

WHM is just using lilies to move, assize on cd, and asylum here and there

#

but in general ast+sch work more efficiently together in actually healing people which means fewer gcds spent healing

#

though I guess at the extreme top end an ast solohealing with their ogcds while a glarebot goes brrr is pretty effective

#

Personally from a tank perspective I’ve always enjoyed playing with scholars more

#

Barrier style is so much more interesting

dim sigil
#

Seeing a tank buster do a zero feels nice

gaunt star
#

my proudest moment in ffxiv was taking 0 damage from a tail end

gaunt star
#

Barriers man

wary perch
#

Every tank has a self barrier except pld

woven escarp
#

that's because pld has perfect invul and a bunch of strong defensive skills

#

it's not like they need a barrier 🤔

gaunt star
#

Paladin is a walking fortress

woven escarp
#

ye

gaunt star
#

I remember paladins used to get bullied so hard for not being warrior

white rose
#

Tbf warriors live the meme of getting hurt but never dying

#

And pld lives the title of being a fortress cause they can mitigate constantly or go full invuln

#

What is even DRK

tulip geyser
#

"Local Man Too Angry To Die"

balmy mesa
#

nothing like a good holmgangbang to walk away from the scene in one piece... in the case of WAR

gaunt star
balmy mesa
#

world first

dense kite
#

Oy kids

#

Important discussion ongoing

balmy mesa
#

I voted "EW", since it makes sense with prior expansions

fallen girder
#

EW makes sense and its funnier

balmy mesa
#

ew sadge

viscid monolith
#

PLD has 3 defensives besides Halloed

gaunt star
#

Cant wait to get reported by someone in game cuz they got upset that I said EW at them

strange summit
cinder badger
#

People stil think Scythe will be the thing?

#

Friendwalker

craggy pawn
#

Yessss

gaunt star
#

I hope it isn't a scythe

#

I want something original

soft gyro
#

sad there was no ultimate for 5.5 and no ultimate for blu when they couldve.