#retired-patch-6-3-discussion
1 messages · Page 182 of 1
Yes?
Yup
She was already there before so she could theoretically teleport
The problem is that not every ship goes vroom. There's several NPC's who make the trip outside of MSQ as well.
No. She had use of the aethernet at that point.
Not everyone can teleport
Almost everyone can
they just cant travel as much as the WoL
and all three of those are specifically stated to take the boat
because some people are doing trades n shit
For normal ppl
Because almost everyone can't excessively teleport and you can't teleport somewhere you haven't attuned too and also teleporting cargo is....yikes
For the ships it requires the right to ride it
I bet you i carry more in my inventory than that one random ship in kugane can ferry
probably not al
At some point after 6.0 they'll probably be like "It's been 3 years since you showed up"
People too poor for it
Your inventory is bullshit
tell that to my 35k Coffee Bisquits
The most I can buy is each EXP spanning 3-6 months
But yeah when you look at the Othard trips...Y'shtola would have needed a boat, we needed a boat...and that's it so that's 4 months
1/3 of a year is not close to a year
Anything else theoretically can be teleported
I think, I don't think I'm forgetting anything
if you consider all of the job quests to be canon you have to add a minimum of 2 months more
Actually four
I wonder how much time has passed since ARR and ShB
Apparently there was an NPC in Idyllshire who at some point had a baby
because Jacke and Oboro make the trip to AND from by boat
Less than a year
Leveva and Martin make the trip too - but you can assume they were on the same boat as Jacke and Oboro
see thats why RP and headcanons suck 
Eh job quests sit in a weird place I kinda just want to consider them as going to the far east at the same time as MSQ or whatever other wise with how many people take the trip in job quests we'd be 1000 years into the future
I wonder how much time passes if WoL multiclass
Time is BS in this game, I hope they wont end it with "oh wol you finally woke up after 5 yr coma"
It was all a dream
When they add more story to Azem it'll even more awkward for RP
im a fast learner learning new classes in 2-3 days ez life
FFXIV: The Phantom Pain
Apparently a Doman NPC said at some point it had been a year since the liberation of Doma
Hey you, you're finally awake, you were caught trying to cross the Garlean Border right?
I only specifically mention the NIN quests because the quests implicitly must happen after your trip occurred due to how its written.
imagine the players who RP'd as Garleans now that its ASHES 
Time to copy paste my normal response to that comment
if its been 1 year or less doesnt matter cause its not long 
Imagine having to walk everywhere.
They can RP as the cleaners
i saw a chick saying
someone gotta do it
Thats the true reason for the /sweep emote
'once we go to garlemald ill look for my parents'
and im like 'stop it they never existed'
'There's some of them over there, and hey i see some of them over there too'
lulz
Garlemald basically getting nuked into oblivion
sipping choccy milk while everything burns
true that is something that was said, specifically about Kaien dying IIRC but also he died BEFORE the events of 2.0 due to the journey length mentioned later. Then you also have any potential time between the crushed rebellion and Yugiri getting everything organised and the refugee exodus taking place, then factor in the 2 month trip, probably a bit longer since they had shitty boats and would have needed rest. I think given that there is room for it to actually have been a year without moving the timeline too much, also factor in that character could have easily been rounding up.
apathy is death.
Also there is several dialogue lines later on that summarily prove it's NOT been 1 year since ARR
Time bubble has a weird effect on the story in another way too
Estinien and Nanamo stuff?
It kind of elevates the WoL's status in terms of our ability to get shit done, or it implies that the entirety of the planet is fucking incompetent.
because we've basically solved the majority of the major societies issues on the planet in less than a year, yet these problems have existed for sometimes thousands of years.
the time bubble works both ways
Like....the fuck were these people doing up until we showed up
I chalk that up more to our bullshit hero antics and less a problem on the years
Thats why wol looks like he does now.
these things probably took place over a much longer time period while at the same time, time didn't move
it's all just handwaived
WoL, how did you solve our problems so quickly?
Teleport
If you complain it took us so little time to fix these issues you should still say it's unreasonable when it took us 30 years to fix a 1000 year problem
Its just bullshit power level type stuff.
It strains credibility when they have things pretend to actually be a threat to us
Like, Ranjit vs. Thancred was a scenario that i could take seriously. Ranjit vs. WoL was not.
lol
Even across universes fate still plays it part
Hey now
Fighting the end of the world for your entire life does fucking wonders to harden you out
I slowly start to realize why the fuck it was so important for the world that we survive. Shit would go literally up in flames without us 
I can accept WoL Vs Ranjit, what I CAN'T accept is Ranjit Vs us and 6 others like he did at the start
also keep in mind that Elidibus has been manipulating warriors of light from the shadows for millennia
in our case though it didn't work
IF we can find him.
I'd comment on Lyon as well, but as proven by Godbert, old as fuck highlanders become freakishly powerful.
I bet he uses salamander oil too
The Manderville Family
because Lahabrea gave us a deep seated distrust of the paragons
Ranjit is only plausible if wol got nerfed while passing rift, which they didnt
I hope we get more Lyon
inb4 Lyon turns out to be related to the Mandervilles
I like how he knew how heroism worked and try to use against us.
Goldsmith LB when?
Dude has LITERALLY spent his entire fucking life fighting the end of the world. Idk why people make him out like he'd be a complete noodle, literally no one we know would have fought as much shit as he has, stuff that can quote literally kill you if you get touched sometimes
i mean, didn't Lyon very consciously inform us where the bozja garlean friendship gang were before Delubrum
I forget what he said before giving very obvious side-eye to where we were hiding
Yes, he did
Yeah, he side eyes us
But given how that played out, that was likely an intentional trap
Its a win-win for him either way it goes down
i'd be interested to see how it goes on, Lyon always seemed to make his own decisions so with Misilja (sp, idc) and Save the Queen captured it'd be interesting to see him consider which the winning side might be
Out of the bozja story I found Misjia boring, more lyon
Based on his lore note entry, he aint switching sides.
although given Mikoto's premonition, if Save the Queen stays captured then i'll be surprised
Oh we captured StQ?
I'd say he definitely got us to go after her, to buy time for reinforcement to get there
You havent done the new shit yet?
I haven't done anything past Cid memories frankly
yes, StQ was captured alongside Misilja and Mikoto opted to take it back with her for study after the Blades offered to hold on to it
well we know how that will turn out
And that's going to go SO WELL
It's kinda wishy washy, not only ranjit but the rest of the lore didnt follow strenght level of the mobs. Considering they're 1/14 shard
followed by Mikoto immediately having a premonition of herself falling unconscious from the Enterprise upon touching the blade
good old future visions
Nothing says 1/14th people are weaker
The game says they'd be less dense in soul
But that's it really
Realistically the only people that should be gaining any power from rejoinings are like....Ascians and probably the WoL too.
and Misilja is now just in prison somewhere with us not actually knowing if she's become a... revenant? what was the word?
fuckin echo sharingan eyes idk
No?
and the WoL is a big stretch
Actually i think ascians are saying that the whole time
I don't think anyone would get stronger with rejoinings until a point where it just clicks
Pretty sure thats just them looking down at us
Resonant
Resonant, ta
"bitch you aint whole get out noob"
Misija is 100% a Resonant now
Sha-resonence
Misilja potentially having become a full Resonant also puts her on a similar character line to Fordola, and since they're both 'in prison somewhere' if they don't end up interacting in some way I'll be surprised
Eh, i doubt it
I'd be surprised if they interact
They're very different characters despite the similarities people try to draw
the story for Bozjan will probably tie all/most loose ends before the end
I don't think ANYONE would let her go near Garlemald and across the entire world
Yeah Delubrum is us capturing STQ
Misija has no remorse whatsoever for what she's done.
i know, i'm just not discounting a 'wow i'm really like you except you realised the error of your ways' arc because sometimes shit writes itself
Unlock Fordola, Misijia doesn't definitely have have the vibes for atonement
likely she'll escape, then redeem herself by suiciding to destroy something, and that'll be the end of that story
Fordola has remorse of a peculiar flavor
i mean fordola gave no fucks until she ended up having an echo vision of us
Fordola has Krile's echo abilities
that or she escapes, and when she gets to crazy guy, he just kills her to extract her super echo or whatever, whichever
regardless pretty sure she'll be dead
I dont agree with that
No fucks about?
am i misremembering?
No you're not
i thought i recall her being absolutely unrepentant until she saw what we'd been through
She was suicidal
Okay, I am misremembering then
She lost her purpose
She was also all "my life bad, you don't know how bad I lived"
Her unrepentant act was to try and goad her captor into executing her
She purposely didn't kill herself in her cell because she wanted to be executed in front of everyone yeah, Arenvald calls her out in this and she tells him to shut the fuck up
The worst part is
I don't think she was repentant before that either
yeah, i don't remember that so moot point from me
it was a "noble suicide" she was going for
She basically thought that if she were executed in front of everyone it would at least serve the people of Ala Mhigo
side comment, whatever the fuck happened to Arenvald
Primal slaying
Also clapping Fordola's ass
understandable
Arenvald and Fordola are doing what we would normally be doing in "calmer times"
Damn right Law
Basically they took our jobs
But we've got world-ending events going on so they're picking up the slack
i imagine they have the space to pull a glorious Estinien in Endwalker
Damn Ala Mhigans taking our jobs
Which primals are Fordola and Arenvald slaying, exactly
Any that arise Snack
and wouldn't Arenveald get tempered
In the short story it's Ifrit
Arenvald has echo
He got echo
And all the Mor Dhorna adventurers taking our work
he can't
ffs snack
Safe to assume Ifrit, Lakshmi
arenvald is essentially just us without protagonist energy
He got the tragic protagonist backstory down to perfection though
true
Our echo is stronger
It seems almost certain both of them will show up in 6.0 though
or at minimum they'll be offscreen dismantling towers
since they have the capability to do so
Well
Maybe
They can resist the tempering at least
I'm not even sure what you need to destroy those towers
Well sure we have no idea what they really are yet.
Like those things look tough as fuck
But presumably at some point we win the war with Zenos
And that tempered dude at the end of cutscene
Is any role better than others or more fun to do new content with?
and someone is gonna have to shut those things down that isnt us because we have more important shit going on
Content I mean expansion
So they seem the logical choice to write that in
He will never die
like don't get me wrong, I am not advocating a redemption arc
I cant imagine a scenario where 6.0 ends with him alive.
He is our friend forever
Zenos becomes our talking weapon
I dont even understand why they brought him back
and i don't want it to end with another 'he merges with the x' because i thought that was lazy first time and fuck if it happens a second
Like bring him back okay but keep him alive for another expansion
@gaunt star because he is our friend
hes in love with the WoL
he is our ohana
Everybody keeps wondering why they would bring him back
*Nhaama
Which is why I keep saying maybe he's possibly Hythlodaeus
Or a sundered version of him
I think temulun is hyth
Since this is the ending of the 10 year long story arc
Im assuming we will have the cavalcade of all the characters being big dick heroes
Including characters such as
Fordola
Eh I hope they don't go too crazy with Fordola
my only issue with Zenos being Hythlodaeus is that likely implies we'll be expected to like him
and that smells like redemption arc
I already like Zenos
Apparently hythlo was a bit of a douche
I think he's great
Shes effectively mostly reformed and this is a Japanese story
He'll stay in the lifestream and make geostigma
So forgiveness is probably gonna be a big part
Zenos is technically emet descendant right ?
Also Hythlo humored Azems questionable choices
Yes
Kind of, yes.
He has the Ascian jucie
I myself still dont understand the whole convocation and the Ascians and who tf is Azem
Emet would propably have noticed if Zenos had Hyths soul
Emet I think made him into a soul Chimera, which he unknowingly added Resonant on top of
He helped him summon ifrita
Azem = you
For the grapes
Your best friend become your descendant is just kek
Unless he refused to recognise it like he did us
the WoL is sundered Azem
Would someone explain how Azem is WoL?
You shouldnt have skipped Cutscenes
The convocation we're effectively the leaders of the Ascian society. Azem was the fourteenth member
I didnt
Azem was ancient, sundering happened, we are reincarnated soul
if we follow ffiv lore, zenos will turn up to be azem's sibling
Wol is 8/14 azem
9/14
The WoL is the sundered Azem on the source, 8 times rejoined
9/14
Is there any wiki page or something I can read about this convocation
You and Aldbert are a piece of Azem
Did you forget that sundered ascians are fragments of the original full ascian
i think the fact Azem's not-a-soul-crystal reacted to us enough to bestow the power of a convocation member vs Elidibus was enough confirmation of that
How many pieces are there
wiki
Pfft
Wiki shmicky
cant wait till alphinaud gets sacrificed to zenos
I mean this is all shit directly explained ingame
Yeah I'm curious how you didn't get this Dan
My brain was too lazy to understand
Hes one of the most popular characters and YoshiP views him as the real protag
So no his plot armor is too thicc
So is Alisaies
@hasty viper this is the final fantasy 4 reference the twins are going to turn into stone
wait what he views him as the real protag?
just let them petrify themselves to save the WoL and stay there the whole expac
Yes
It'd be cool if all scions are presumed dead at the end
The real protag who's never been in a trailer until now.
@faint dagger Alisaie is precious
In HW
Yo, Angelo Alphinaud
So, a thought enters my mind.
Oi WoL I tuned the twins into stone ain't that wacky?
What are we saving eli's soul for?
Zodiark and Hydalyn will posses both Alphinaud and Alisae and they will fight each other
It broke down into dust
@inner kite to restore the void
What do we suppose the new "WoL outfit" is gonna be. You know there's gonna be one.
Edgy Alisaie
I mean
I’m waiting for my astronaut outfit
Oh right, 5.5 should get us a new Tataru Scion glam
The story is inspired by FF4
I wonder
lmao imagine
Doesnt mean its literally going to be FF4 again
Just like how ShB was inspired by FF3
New Scion glam gonna be all belts
It wasnt JUST FF3
They're mixing 4 and 8 this time
Why 8?
Lunar cry
Okay to be fair
There hasn’t been a lunar cry
To be fair Yoshi in an interview talking about PLD made no mention to Cecil, and implied they didnt know what to make WoL into until they were like "Idk Light?"
Lunar Cry was a thing in IV in all but name
@autumn heron whoa I didn't know Final Fantasy III had sin eaters
The moon crashing down to earth with freaky shit happening with a god inside was ffiv the after years
The plot of FF3 is a primordial light eating the world
Literally what
Even then og IV had Zeromus on the moon causing bad shit with monsters right?
In other thoughts.
So some of these references are more coincidence than direct
That's not the plot but that did happen in that world
How funny is it that they announce that belts are going away yet they put two fucking belts on PLD AF gear.
@teal geyser wasn't Darkness eating the world in Final Fantasy 3
And FF3 had the Warrior of Darkness be not inherently bad people
While he was conscious Zemus built the tower/giant of babil but not sure if he messed up the moon itself
Yes but there was a thing about back in the day there were Warriors of darkness fighting against light and it's this alternating conflict
Too much dark is bad
its even more hilarious the trailer starts zoomed in on the belts
Too much light is also bad
Yeah but that's basically what Final Fantasy XIV does isn't it? Hydaelyn and Zodiark balancing each other out
Plus we had the Crystal Tower in A Realm Reborn
With the final boss being The Cloud of Darkness
I wonder how did hydaelyn imagine balancing everything without zodiark
What do you guys think the new melee dps is gonna be?
She wouldnt
We are going to remove our belts and spank Zenos butt with them
The worlds would all be burnt
She did a pretty fucking good job so far
Immersion ruined. Game unplayable.
Belts removed
@teal geyser I don't think primals have the world's best interests at heart
I don't see anything
im uninstalling
Sure is alot of stars on the PLD gear
He's still there, it's not like he's dead, just split to shards
namura gonna be fuckin pissed
I think you're generalising and you honestly would need to provide actual proof before I stop thinking "no they can"
Look we are the warrior of light and we are going to do what we do best
Maybe Zenos figured out that belts do more damage than his sword
Belts removed
Anti-Nomura technology
Oh and eat grapes
Anima is not a primal
Primals do what they were summoned to do
@red talon and I will do what I am summoned to do which is kill the primals
Well then I'd add that she never planned to kill him so idk why you are on about how she imagined she'd balance everything without him because that was never part of the plan
Primals just in some cases is a monkeys paw
A big zipper will appear in the sky, and a giant Gakt will step through to destroy Hydaelyn on Nomura's behalf.
Hydaelyn would probably just self-dissipate if Zodiark was killed.
given Zodiark literally is the only purpose to Hydaelyn existing
What if Hydaelin and Zodiark are bound to each other and is basically anima?
Yeah she did, she said darkness must be destroyed in ARR
Alexander existing was going to inevitably drain the world's aether though
That was the issue
@unique verge watch her 180 on us and say "you upset the balance" or some shit and then tries to sunder even further
He would turn the world into the burn
Alexander is fucking nuts as far as primal goes
XIV, especially after ShB has set up thay Hydelyen is hiding things from you
I still think about his capabilities
Shes isnt as malevolent as she seems
There's a theory I read about that: Alexander could have used his time manipulation to prevent himself from being summoned in the first place, but he didn't. He let himself be summoned so that Cid could witness him and write the nescessary theories that lead to the creation of the Tycoon centuries later.
@rough kestrel he was just a machine I mean the Goblins are the ones who summoned him so of course he would be a machine
She had good intentions but fucked up
Hydaelyn be like "Oh, you thought you were 9/14? Calculate this" and proceeds to cast Order
HAHA I JUST
Ascians bad yes
PICTURED HYDAELYN DOING THAT EXACT DANCE ON ZODIARK's CORPSE AS SHE SUNDERS HE SHARDS
Hydaelin is gonna sunder us into a 8 man party 🤔
get in the whale!
We must go for the SMT neutral ending
She will come to FF14 to take revenge for every belt that is removed
Of kill them both

We'll probably find that we can escape the Sundering by going into Ascian void.
The only problem with that theory is that it's directly stated that Alex couldn't see the future that laid ahead of us so he literally couldn't have planned around that
Hydaelyn default dances so hard that zodiark dies from excessive cringe damage
@unique verge wait 9/14.... Ooooh I forgot to add his original Source fragment so 8 times rejoined would actually mean is 9/14 of the way there right
No. 9/14 is because we ate Ardbert
Yep Yayo
Yeah that “you always had the echo, you just needed a reminder of the final days” was a pretty strong case against Hydaelyn
Which is a rejoining in its own way
@unique verge Ardbert would have been number 8
Yeah just clarifying that its not from a "rejoining" like the others so to speak
There have been 7 rejoinings tho
Ardbert was like
I bet that Zodiark is not even a bad guy
G'raha and WoL are 9/14, everyone else on the source is 8/14
Zodiark just wants to keep the world together
Im 100% sure Zodiark isnt at all the bad guy
That's not a case against Hydaelyn. Just because the echo is part of us doesn't mean...she's bad because of that
Even if everyone has to die
aren't we still 8/14? Since 13th didnt get rejoined because Void world
They both just fucked up
Emet said WoL was 7 times rejoined before Ardberd joined us
No?
7 rejoinings + us + Ardbert, you don't need the void to get to 9
Future G'raha is in deed sleep, dreaming or connected to present time line G'raha crackpot theory
They're literally called soul vessels. Not "memory vessels".
She’s not bad but she’s uncool for gaslighting us into believing it’s part of her blessing
I don't recall her even saying it was part of her blessing
Everyone just assumed it was
Like Minfilia
I do wonder though, Elidibus commented that Graha in SHB was surprisingly dense.
8th calamity yo
Soooo there is 4-5 Azem pieces out there? would be cool to meet one one day
Wait wasn't it 6 completed rejoinings + us and ardbert since 13th failed?
And Hydaelyn never corrected Minfilia
Could be chilling in the lifestream though
So Graha would be 10 if the vessel really did carry his Soul to The First
I thought it was just memory though
@rough kestrel but that's what I said I forgot to add the one that was your original fragment
13th wasn't tied to a calamity
oh i see i see
13 wasn’t a rejoining
Its possible that we might find out that Cylva is also Azem shard in the future.
It was a blunder
13th was the ascians buggering it up, iirc
Yeah they effed up for 13th
Ascians failed the mechanic check with 13th and wiped it
....I'm sorry I didn't realise that was an important thing to say that MUST be said when you don't have lots of time to discuss things and clearly takes precedence over explaining the actual multiworld
Everybody on The Source by default is 8/14 yes?
Cylva works as an option for how to rejoin us further if it becomes plot-required later, basically. Unukalhai was an option for this as well - but its been all but stated that he's not due to the way the 5.4 void quests are written.
Yes Virtus
So Graha would be 10 now right?
9
Look Emet said "Seven times rejoined" then we joined with Ardbert, so that makes us 8 times rejoined. You don't count our original state
G'raha is 9, but its weird.
But you're rejoining 9 + 9?
G'raha in theory can exceed 14
Ok here is my theory. Zodiark saved the world from destruction but in the process he got weaker so he needed more sacrifices to be sustained. Then he gets corrupted by the Sound that caused the destruction of the star and when they summon Haedelyn she is forced to lock him away in the moon in order to stop the spread of this infection but in the process she splits the star into 13 shards. Releasing Zodiark means also bringing back the Sound which then will be the next chapter that we go into 6.1
I thought Graha only got his future memories
9+8
Right
Since we can only go to 13 anyway, since I think we're not really gonna be able to claim ourself from voidworld
So is he bullshitting us then when he's like "OH I'M TIRED GUYS"
No
He should be fucking magic fuel for days
There's a survivor of the void though. So its not impossible.
Mm, true, but I'd still say highly improbable
Cylva was one of the WoL's of the 13th. She could be our shard.
That's under the assumption that it works by 9+8 which isn't at all a thing that is stated and everything simply points to otherwise
I want to marry her
@unique verge Unukalhai is also a 13th survivor
THat soul density has to go somewhere
Man I forget Cylva, tbf
he's not our shard
You're duplicating a soul
Yes but the 5.4 void quests very strongly suggest that Unukhalhai is a shard of Taynor
And cramming them both into the body
We reduce the number of candidate for Unu shard to 2 right now
I wouldn't think took hard about it ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
The kid from the Magic DPS role quests
Soul density=strenght
nope
Oh yeah that kid
Nice assumption there
Black Mages friend
Nothing really says that though
The 8th calamity was The First rejoining with The Source right? The entire point of SHB
Only emet selch
So I wonder who Graha's shard on The First was
Yes
And if we ever met them
As far we know being 1/14 or 13/14 is the same, however being 14/14 could make a change
Technically we've been to the void so that means we have been to the 13th right?
Well, it was about preventing the calamity
Just because a shard exists doesn't mean it must automatically be alive
Could be in the lifestream
That's the entire thing that makes G'raha weird. He is, by all rights, rejoined with that shard already - but it also still exists.
Its why Graha was so flagrent in having WoL and Elidibus controlling Zenos NOT FIGHT at the time
Question. Is Fandaniel the last Ascian remaining? Where are the other sunderes ones?
Win or Lose
There are others
We don't know what they are doing though
Black rose will fuck everything up amd cause the 8th calamity
Showing each other their rock collection
Some might go "y'know what WoL I'll help you" some may just fuck off to other shards
@unique verge but the G'raha we met on the First was G'raha from the source in the future
Who knows
Well if we use the word as they are intended, we don't know of any ascian left
Gaius has some red masks and it's unclear he killed killed them but even if he did kill kill them I remember doing the math and there should be like, 2 other red masks at least other than Fandaniel still alive
watching events unfold.
It seems underwhelming for this to be the ending of the Ascian story when there are more out there outside of Fandaniel. Are we going to let them roam free?
He doesnt have the means to kill them
Which begs the question, how did he track them
Also G'raha Tia isn't a name that'd be used on the first...
Ascians come to you 
To Gaius though?
The G'raha we met on the First was from the Apocalypse Timeline from the Source. That G'raha got the rejoining of that timeline. Then he time travelled into Current Timeline - where the First was never rejoined. Then his soul was carried back across the rift and merged with his original body, which should mean that he is 9/14 but that the First shard is technically still out there even though he already has it.
Where there's trouble, there's ascians
Sure why not Virtus 
@unique verge but then who was his first counterpart was he already dead?
We'll never know
It could have been a whole different race for all we know
We have no idea. Could be that his First counterpart is pending reincarnation from the lifestream.
Impossible to answer
Would be fucked up if we find out later Graha time traveling automatically kills the shard he has on him
To balance things out
It's Vauthery /s
G'raha's lore is fucked up
That'd be some shit
What if its the Viis girl he took care of?
You know it's possible Vauthry was Zenos's counter part.
Valthry is Alhpinauds
That creates a level of fucked up scenario i'd rather not get into
They look the same
I'd love to find out Gaius is a shard of somebody cool
Time traveling stories always have a ton of plot holes or they stretch logic too much to fit the narrative
Daddy G'raha and daddy Graha
That hurt to write
Yeah there is not much point in trying to find logical reason
Nero's shard on the first was Lady Chai, her husband is Cid's Shard 
@teal geyser but Alphinaud did say he saw a bit of himself in Valthry
and?
I cant imagine Nero ever being that stupid.
I mean, this is Nero we're talking about
Do you know how often people can see something of one person in another?
Like no offense, people like Chai and all, but she's as dumb as a rock
Normal cid> pirate cid
She's a great accountant how dare you
inb4 Chai is Lyse shard
Valthry might be Alphinauds counterpart, and what Alphinaud could have become if he continued being who he was in 2.0
She's literally super budget balancer
The only thing we can honestly say about shards is they share some personality traits
But not everything
Vauthry is parenting gone bad
@unique verge she smarter than you think
Ardbert is a weird case because he and CG WoL are really so fucking similar.
I mean I wouldn't even say that Virtus, aside from WoL and Derp the rest are literally just "haha look at funny joke"
if Unu and Taynor turn out to be, they're pretty similar
that would be hte only other real example
I mean she pointed out that her husband used to run the stoneworks and clued you in on how to motivate him when he lacks confidence
Imagine if fucking Thancred and Ranjit were shards of eachother
So really if it wasn't for her you might have not been able to solve the problems so easily
But I think people gravitate towards her cuz she just got that Mom vibe
That doting mom vibe
I'm sorry are we all sleeping on Dulia's actual job?
Eating?
....
Wouldnt they flash light if they touched, since thancred was in similar state to ardbert (only visible)
Oh valid
Funny but no she's literally a Tataru but not an asshole
Question. Wouldn't the logical thing to be that only the first people after the sundering are related to the Ascians directly and have shards of themselves living parallel to them? How come their predecessors have shards if they are just the kids of those who got sundered?
Is there a glow on 3rd step too? Cause I've seen 2 types of law rapiers one had slight glow and the other one was extrenly glowy
You're asking how people born after sundering can still be connected to Ancients?
Yoshi-p said everyone has a shard of ancient in them
No matter beastman or regular person
I mean that's not an explanation
Yeah most existing souls are shards of ancients if I recall
But we can get there
@teal geyser that and the fact that supposedly for every human there are 13 other sundered versions of them
Never said i was explaining it
Mario this is easy, the souls get reincarnated and all the ancient souls in the lifestream also got sundered in the sundering so people are still being born with souls of ancients that were just in the lifestream
Just putting it out there that we might not have seen everybody's counterpart because maybe they were people who live in other parts of the world before it was swallowed in the light
So they might be long dead
I mean thats assumed
The 13 other versions part is super easy too because that's just "sundering splitting everything into 14"
It would be the mother of all coincidences if every single major and minor characters counterparts were on Norvrandt
Venat and Hythlodaeus are really the two big mysteries to me.
So it's just a recycling of souls
Yes that is how the lifestream has worked since ARR
Minfilia explains this in post-ARR
They literally gave us a powerpoint in-game of how this functions
@rough kestrel maybe Louisoix was Hythlodaeus
I really expect there to be a reveal about who the Scions are shards of, because it's one of the first things I wondered about upon learning about Azem
what if, hear me out
Stop making everyone important ancients
the scions were normal
The Scions are scions

Leave them as such
Diplomatic ancient one lol alphi
The only named character for there to be a shard of that would be relevant is Hythlo
There was a theory about Y'shtola being Hythlodaeus's shard as she seems to pop up after he leaves scenes with you.
not everyone needs to be a literal mary sue
It's really sad when Elidibus is probably never going to get recycled cause he is trapped in the crystal tower
Everyone else is largely irrelevant
and there's no reason for them to introduce new ancients to the lore at this time
And Emet did pick her out of the stream in particular for you
That theory is stupid. It's literally just "they existed near each other and they use the same laugh animation"
elidiibus the new crystal exarch?
That's a non point
so we might find out who Hythlo is. but thats it. thats as far as its gonna go.
It's probs someone who was born with soulsight
Emet could have done that to anyone
I mean there are far dumber theories.
Yes everything is speculation
I don't have an opinion either way
Yes but it's certainly down there nonetheless
i dont think its too far-fetched
I still think it's a possibility it could be louisoix
but its fun to think about
There's no need to shame anyone about their theory
congruent triangles are fun to think about
Like I put this above Zenos is Yda theory but below anything else


Laha returning like a literal Phoenix
Also the M looks very similar to Zodiark from FF12
It would make alot more sense to 1.x players
Than anyone current
As you dont get those scenes with Louie
But I've seen the 1.x stuff with him, I could buy it
Yeah but I believe Yoshida confirm that 1.0 is canon to the rest of the game
true but the devs aren’t gonna call back a 1.x reference all the way in 6.x
In broadstrokes it is
thats asking the viewer for far too much
Oh lmao
Time to brek it
I saw hythlo and thought of the tweet
The other one I think was people saying Graha might be Hythlo
@gaunt star I'm the one who brought up that theory but it was just a guess I'm trying to think of characters that give off the same sort of vibe as Hythlo
Anyone else kinda disappointed with Zodiark's design? He looks pretty generic demon man. They should made him more weird
Because I still think they have a part to play in the final chapter of this arc
Imagine if it was fucking Haurchefante
Oh my God
Haurche gives me the biggest Hythlo vibe
And that shard always has a long H name
He’ll probably have an additional transformation
Remember that the warring triad statues especially Sofia’s don’t 100% resemble them either
Hildibrand is Hythlo
It would make absolutely no sense if not for the fact they kept referencing Haurchefant throughout ShB
But still think it's probs gonna be Temelun since she can see our soul, with non artificial echo
@inner kite who is that again

Grandma from azim steppe, and they always give her some new dialogue
I'm looking forward to meeting the elephant bois
Hydeleyen is just Cosmos, Zodiark os just Chaos
They use the same design every time
Wonder if they will have any special dialogue for Au'ra
Really so what she had like maybe 1, 2 good scenes with you in stormblood? I'm not sure it holds up
As an au ra they better have special dialog
Hey remember that Xaela from the one part in SB... they're actually tied to a major character
Its au ra
Au'''''ra
1.0 callbacks are cool and all but the zero context for it for most people is gonna be lul

Sadu Dotharl recurring character? 🙏
They always give her new dialogue
After shb too
Worst design ever

booba
whos dat
Lady why do you have a laundry basket as a dress?
Modern fashion
Thats Cosmos 2 from Dissidia NT
Materia ala Cosmos from Dissidia NT
No one likes her
Ah NT
the fight game?
People like old cosmos
I didn't really like what they did with NT so I didn't play it much

She's a little bitch
Do this nomura back
Just emulate the old psp dissidia games
But kefka is good
Old dissidia was so nice
Is it?
Not enough belts
It's designed by Nomura
Kefka is the best villain in the history of villains
Is it?
Looks nicer in nomura's art but still pretty funny lookin
That dress is not practical
And those things behind her look like sage weapons
i wouldnt mind those appearing as sage weps
The little crown is cute
It looks like a bucket
If i could cosplay as a laundry basket
Stop being gullible
Why do people hate materia
I would look like that
Who cares
Cause her dress is bad
Tbf most armor in fantasy isnt practical
And her personality
Like boob armor
where is this from
Her design I guess would only satisfy pathetic gacha degens.
Cosmos has Nouliths?
Oh, wonder if they will scale down materia as well with the stat squish
Boob armor irl is a massive detrament

Dissida NT
Probablt leo
what character?
Practical character designs are non-existant in fantasy in general
Materia
I thought Nouliths were original
hmm....looks like minfilia
Even if they dont, the stat budget of items will scale down, so you'd be limited in how much you could insert anyway
Nouliths are original to ff
But every wacky weapon design has been done somewhere
Like a violin sniper
Sorry the things on Cosmos back looks very similar
honestly i thought they were gonna add a fan as a weapon
Nouliths are pretty cool
Yoshi P stole both the nouliths and the belts from Nomura. Nomura is pissed 
like the siren class from tactics ogre
Nouliths are cool but I’m not sure if they will look good in other weapons
Hopefully sage feels fun to play
I feel like sage could get bad weapon designs
Define fun
I also don’t know how a relic glow would look on sage
No u liths
They have to add them to lower level trials too
Satisfying gameplay loop
everyone forgets about AST's primary weapon
it's also unique to FF
Also gotta look cool
Astro weapons are terrible
I didn't forget about it it's just boring
Red mages weapon is also unique
Glowy titania weapons anyone?
Nous(intellect) liths(stones) in Greek

Titania weapons are already ugly
So they're intelligent stones
Yeah
Ruby is all shit
Titania DRK is pretty
Maybe it’s because my main jobs always have terrible weapons
The DRK weaps from trials this expac look nice tbh
Healers are all about mind they should have called them mind stones
Cuz casters are dumb 
Casters r too fucking stupid
Just wait till 6.0+ when we get the glowy versions of the ex-trial weapons
And lame
This from the monk Main
It really isn't
Depends on the week I have several Max jobs

i read the new cac job is the evolution of dragon knight 😦 and maybe the next weapon is a "faux" 😦
What’s your favorite job
Probably Paladin because you feel like an actual main character when you main tank
Instead of being a wuss and hitting people from behind
PLD is master tank class
BTN is clearly the chad's choice
BTN has a scythe
True op FSH
nah we all know GSM is the strongest class..
i basically play WAR 90% of the time because its self healing makes it so easy to carry bad groups in alot of random content.
Maybe Zenos will become a farmer
@unique verge I played Warrior Dark Knight and gun breaker to I just like Paladin more
Not to mention WAR is fucking broken in anything Bozja
@unique verge why not play paladin then
PLD self healing is dumb
Why
PLD self healing allows it to solo a bunch of dungeon bosses.
WAR self healing allows it to solo basically any dungeon boss, but at twice the speed
essence of the bloodsucker on WAR is so entertaining
clem breaks combo and if buff with requi basically means have to restart rotation since good luck with lost mp
WAR allows you to tank the floor
You never use clemency really
How so, through nascent?
BZM best class
Yes
In raid settings
You really don't use clemency it's more for those "oh shit" moments
A WAR can full heal itself from 0 in 1-2 GCD's using NF
The only good time to clem in a raid, is if all your healers are dead and you need a little extra life, while you wait for the RDM/SMN to res the healers
It's the "oh shit" heal
@humble rain do you have any balls?
I have lots of balls
Dragon ballz
You should have said you're just selling limonade
I don't want Blitzball
Neither do I honestly
I want Blitzball
Blitzball is stupid and boring it was bad in Final Fantasy 10 worst in Final Fantasy 10-2 and it's not going to be any good on 14
If you don't like it don't try it. No one is forcing you
Blitz was fun, I enjoyed it
FF7 snowboarding pog
Put sphere break into the game I'll play that over Blitzball even though I think it's kind of stupid too
I think we have enough card/board games already
Blasphemy
We need something more fleshed out that involves more people and that's Blitzball
I shall send you to the shadow Realm
Try that on my Exodia
Blitzball and fleshed-out don't belong in the same sentence
Blitzball is fun
People who really desire Blitzball on Final Fantasy XIV truly don't remember just how shity it was on 10
Animal crossing: Endwalker
the worst part is, with as awful as blitzball was, the XIV version of it would still be bad but the most fleshed out version
@real swift I know it's sad to think about
Final Fantasy 10-2 is version is more like they went backwards in development
I mean we're already getting stardew valley in XIV lol
Just don't play it. I want Blitzball in
@humble rain you sound like the CEO of EA
now we just need a romancing mechanic with the NPCs and there ya go
There still minigames that I don't enjoy but if others do then it's fine
Ser aymeric dinner party
so is blitzball like... some sort of soccer/lacrosse?
Yeah
@faint dagger yeah only completely underwater
thousand yard Lunaro stare
Underwater soccer
But its turn based with stats
And was incredibly broken and half the time your shit didn't work
You know, where the lore for it would come from in XIV...the Sahagin
don't even need that
Can't wait for it to be Shogi instead
@real swift they'll scribble in some bullshit reason
we can breathe underwater thanks to the kojin
Just get Brother in your team and learn Jecht shot
@digital forge hey shogi now that's a game I could get behind
I'm hopeful for Blitzball but I'm expecting Shogi
I'm hopeful for anything but Blitzball
But what if...
Chocobo Racing update...
It'd be like real life soccer, it was a ritualistic game the sahagin used to play using the skulls of a sacrifice, or a fallen foe to appease some under sea god but eventually it evolved into a form of entertainment.
Brought to you by a beast tribe who makes war with us
I heard somewhere ala mhigan golf but lol
Well the pirates that founded limsa were why they went to war with land dwellers but, they're all making amends
@inner kite even that would be preferable
thus the sahagin would introduce it to the land dwellers and there ya go.
Anyways ppl in general dont spend much time in golden saucer
It's going to be mini golf
Sahagin using balls
@inner kite I love going there just for the setting and ambience.
I think they should add slots
With big payouts
Nah
doesn't gold saucer teeter very carefully on the esrb rating for gambling
They haven't added that because gambling laws
surely that'd push it over
Yeah, that's why we don't have poker
But we can have a lottery?
Lottery is just another form of gambling
and that's why the mahjong mini game is bringing up legality questions
Doman Mahjong, and the cactapot stuff is the most gambly thing in all honesty.
Yes but one could argue that anything were you spend currency for a chance to gain a currency payout is some form of gambling so all the little machines there count
Just on a technical level
Yeah gatcha for example
yep...i'm honestly surprised there haven't been any laws against places like chukie cheese, or other arcade venus where you pay money to try and win tickets
Panchinko machines next patch
for a crappy little ball on a string or crappy 10 cent bracelet






