#retired-patch-6-3-discussion
1 messages · Page 10 of 1
Azeyma makes me wish we had actual fans for weapon on Dancer
Despite that being Oschon's thing
the hoodie and her white hair and stuff
My original character was a Keeper with Menphina but I decided after RPing them that Nymeia better fit for his patron,
she sure is the spinner too with the giant wheel
Ofc that was pre Hrothgar…
first starting the game I thought goddess of fate would be the safest choice for whatever lore might happen
I was right lol
Meanwhile, I went with Rhalgr because patron of monks
I already have the theory Althyk and Nymeia are gonna have E2 + Forced March mechs now
I assume Nymeia will have one ability where she unspools a thread of fate,
Delayed time mech AoEs and gotta get yourself to the safe spot because you're "Fated to move in that direction".
Inb4 they have Relativity hourglasses
Either connecting people or marking some type of aoe
Where do I sign to give the remaining twelve a bit more melanin btw
but althyk and nymeia feel like basically a set up for time mechanics totally
Nophica kinda surprised me with what we saw, but she is the Goddess of Earth so WOOO. LYON 2.0
althyk being mr 'louisoix used me to catapult some wols out of existence' and nymeia being fatey mcfateface
The wheel is a bit on the nose 
Reaper but instead junctioned to an elemental
she has always been said to have a spinning wheel
Tbf, her brief is “depicted as a weaver with a white veil”
I wonder if Nophica will have a bow attack
Yeah, she is literally known as the Spinner
not a hoodie
but I'm not too miffed about the hood
There’s somewhere else that says her loom is from which all magicks are woven
Close to the og, but different enough
Giving major valkyrie vibes
I think it suits her
Nophica is depicted with a scythe not bow, funny enough with how her patron country is BOWS AND SPEARS AND HEALING MAGIC.
Also they gave Menphina the tic tac toe forehead and I can't unsee it
Hatsune Menphina
Speaking of Lyon, though
Menphina new best Beastmaster
Anyways, I bet I could make the majority of Ishgard pass out cold by mentioning that you fought Halone
Also it is probably to avoid duplicating oschon
So, anyone else notice Menphina arena is a CHESS BOARD?
Since oschon too seems to have a bow
Also she does have a dog
I think that’s just how that part of the palace is tiled
Could be simply the floor checker pattern TBF
But did you notice there’s markers over the four-armed statues
She has a pupper, can't wait to see if it's named Dalamud
I think a lot of the cities would be abit shocked you fought the gods they worship
see how we were talking about nald'thal by accident
and some guy was like you what now and we had to run off
Me going to ishgard and shouting I clapped Halone:
The church in shamble for the 2nd time 
that would make you look crazy to be fair
It is the wol
wol gets taken to hospital
Everyone would just take what we said for granted at this point
especially since halone's so commonly featured in ishgardian swearing lol
I think estinien would trust anything you said
man
I think estinien would find this fun
I wish he was in these raids
where is he now? radz training, right
Too busy bonding with zero
Estinien has been open minded ever since well, learning half of their religion was an entire lie
Give it time, they'll soon be the clueless duo
estinien and zero alone together would be the loudest silence you've heard in your life
alternatively estinien makes smalltalk, which sounds more horrific
Estinien teaching Zero all the wrong lessons
She's the goddess of fertility and life and thus responsible for harvests.
So it makes sense.
Whereas Halone is a goddess of war, meaning that it makes perfect sense for her to be wielding a variety of weapons.
Halone wielding a greatsword? That’s blasphemy 
Estinien starts talking about dragons
Imagine the absolute shock the Halonic Orthodox Church would be in if they learned Halone was a DRK as well as a DRG and PLD
If you did the Scholasticate and Endwalker caster role quests, this would actually be the fourth time 
I mean just wielding a greatsword doesnt mean ur drk. we see one of the holy knights wield one
Greatswords have a stigma because of the Dark Knight order and Zephirin is looked upon cautiously for wielding one, but he does because he’s a shorty who needs the reach
it's wild to think of the Dark Knights as being a black sheep order within Ishgardian society. Especially when the only ones we see are Fray and Sidurgu
Sidingo?
Sigrande?
Well remember how the order began,
sidurgu
Siddle the Middle
That guy who lost his titles for slaying a child-abusing clergyman
alaimbert of the spiked BUTT
Sid
The world isn't just black (knights) and white (paladin)
Man I have no desire to play Paladin and then bam, rewatch Endwalker trailer and I’m back to thinking I’m gonna be a Pal main
... at least thats what the fandom wiki says, but cant find any other sources <.<
If he wants to stop being called that maybe he should use a different AF set
Aye, I didn’t say Sid was the first Dark, who woulda taught him 
I mean we meet the guy
Tryphaniel sounds right
We don’t meet Tryphaniel, he became a dark knight like 80 years ago
I mean Sid’s mentor
There had to be a first though who would have taught him then
the first drk would be that disillusioned ishgardian knight who turned against the system, wasn't it?
and ompagne was sid and fray's mentor
yeah he punished a clergyman for abusing a child and got his title revoked for his deeds
honestly guessing there's other drks floating around coerthas but they're more solitary so we don't ever see them
but that's just a guess
and as far as i can tell, dark knights are not a real "order" but rather just people who have been inspired by other dark knights / have their own reasons. They're basically just vigilantes in ishgard so to speak, at least thats how i interpret it
basically that I think
there's gotta be some other customs we never hear about and some shit with jobstone passing
so there is def a real possibility of there being other dark knights in ishgard that we just dont meet
but that'll prolly forever be some mists of time stuff. maybe smth in an ee somewhere? prolly not
I mean sidurgu even mentions of that hes heard of other dark knights experiencing what the WoL did when they first picked up the stone
Yeah, order is very loose, Tryphaniel is not said to have “taught” anyone the ways but Fray taught Sid and “taught” us
which kinda implies sid has talked to other drks thats not fray and his mentor
ompagne seems to have taught both sid and fray
and yeah im p sure ompagne taught both fray and sid?
I feel like anything sid knows might be off of ompagne's heresays
Mb, I forgot about their mentor, just that Fray and he recruited Sid after what happened to the Orl
oof, an issue that might get brought up again in the future I'm expecting
Oh yeah you guys think they’re gonna do From the heavens (Orchestral) for the final phase of omega
all the phases will probably be orchestral or Primals cover, though
Cool cool
Like we got Revenge Twofold’s Orchestral arrangement for Dragon King Thordan
all of the raid ultimate musics have been cover tracks, from my observation
UWU had Primals for, well, the primals, and then orchestra for Ultima
and TEA was more Primals covers followed by Orchestra
Does anyone know if they're increasing the amount of animals we can own in Island Sanctuary?
Unless there is a dancing madness phase, ye
I wonder if it is going to be literally all omega tbf
I never watched tea, but how is it structured?
絶アレキサンダー BGM - 白視点
BGM-1 [ 00:37 ] BGM-2 [ 03:37 ] BGM-3 [ 06:56 ] BGM-4 [ 07:06 ] BGM-5 [ 11:51 ]
The Epic of Alexander (Ultimate) Theme OST - Whm Pov
構成:戦ナモ忍機黒学白
■■ 黒視点 → https://youtu.be/5bLeC6rWzVE
2週目消化 → https://youtu.be/EechtCLSXdM
初クリア時の動画です。
The Epic of Alexan...
uwu is garuda ifrit titan ultima
with primals for the primals and orchestral for ultima
Vault 1 > Thordan SR > Nidhogg 1 (+Eyes) > Vault 2 > Thordan CM > Nidhraes > Wyrmking, iirc
Oh TEA
LL > BJ/CC > A. Prime (with Formations) > Perfect
lacus litore 😟
UCoB is all base music I think, though Beyond Redemption might"ve been new, since the version in the T12 cutscene is a lot shorter
That’s CLL 
Locus > Metal -Brute Justice- > Rise > Moebius Orch, I believe
i think so
So ye
They could make a fight of only 3 omega
Base > f/m > omega weapons > omega protocol
Or could just go crazy and have omega pull from other raid bosses within that tier
With a protocol Delta, Sigma and Alpha (Midgasdaorm)
imagine if they asspull middy and then we have ucob 3
alpha as boss
Omega Weapon > F/M > Final seems like a given, final may have a follow-up or a new design itself
And that’s just the guaranteeds, god knows what’s between those points
4 boss is already enough tbf
As said, my hope is Omega runs Programs that bring about the other boss mechanics
Man, how do you even top Final's design
But also Thordan had like 6-7 phases
TOP will be “potentially near DSR’s length” but not nearly as difficult, iirc
The Blood of Storm (Ultimate) when
probably not
Yeah, because DSR has two phases with their own two Trios, and Nidhraes having its oaths
the checkpoint for DSR was to probably avoid people trying to save haurchefant the first time and wasting time doing that
would be cool if m/f fuse to become some kind of humanoid singular boss as a new boss fight for omega....
but final omega is so. uh. final
can't imagine anything beyond it
The checkpoint is because the first half of the “real” fight is “what actually happened,” yeah
Then leads into the alterations
There's much to fear from the raid series with mechanics like Pantokrator and Hello World
That's what they say to get our guards down
Y "We think of DSR as the hardest ultimate and we tried to not make it "more difficult", but the direction and design is different, so it will depend on personal feeling, but don't expect higher difficulty than DSR"
Then they kick us in the crotch straight after
DSR will likely be overthrown at some point
which i assume is msq ult for stormblood
DSR is hard because it's long and a team wipe can send you back very far
interesting at least
TOP might have something similar
I’m telling you, Program: Kefka + Pantokrator and some of the aoes are inverted
same goes for most ults tbf
isnt this all ults
Yeah but it's more pronounced in DSR
pretty sure most people's most hated part of DSR is the hp balancing on the dragons and the whole one dies everyone dies instantly nature? though I'd have to grab a second opinion
As in, Program: Kefka makes Omega start doing his fake aoes… in Pantokrator 
but that's a big thing.
Gotta do Pantokrator but watcb which aoe has ?’s to know they’re the safe spots
just dont die

I hope they don't bring back blackhole
Remember
But also dunno
yeah skill issue tbh
We'll have to fight young Midgardsomr in some capacity in TOP too
Nothing in savage 1 to 7 is really hard
My one hope is weaving in Tower of the Gods/Graven Image
Power Slide with charm/sleep tethers 
Midgardsomr 3: The Squeakuel
In before Omega Zenos /s
Final Omega's dumpy hiding a black hole
I don't think we have to fight him: or at least we have no way of knowing
Because that boss's model was huge, IIRC
I just think it would be funny if we had twisters in three ults
Oh god, Program: Exdeath and bringing on his void spells
Program: Chaos
oh man
don't forget middy
Prob
What’d be neat is if they have Exdeath, Kefka, Chaos, and Middy as new Omega chassis
As in Omega turns into quicksilver versions of them
Nah, I'd be more concerned about black holes covered up by the boss model again
those are the coolest four
Imagine M and F turning into the different bosses 
Ultimate raiders when they finally clear phase 1 of the New Omega Ultimate... #FFXIV
I'm just imagining clown make-up on omega's robot face
Kefka phase where he cycles through phantom train and chardanook
Just real everything and the kitchen sink
“Protocol: Sigmascape”
just a phase where every boss you fought in omega is lined up like when you do wormholes in tea or predation
like outside the arena all 12 of them

Can't wait for omega save state
I can definitely see M and F actually transforming into the other bosses,
And it resets the fight to an earlier phase /s
As Omega cycles through various chassis’s
easy since they can be jelly
“Nah nah, these results aren’t good enough. Starting over”
New Patch mechanic: Rollback
Another loop
Like alongside M chariot and F knock back, also watch Kefka stack and Exdeath double buster and Middy dynamo
While wol hp > 0
I hope we get a cool unique mechanic like we saw in p8s' chemistry session in part two
I guess I do expect Omega’s Trios/Formations to be “Program: [whatever]”
I just hope Nero Cid and Alpha come in to assist for bits
I hope we hear nero voiceover but granted this stuff is in alphascape where nero is KIA
Like sparing thordan
Sigma Protocol, it transforms into Kefka and lobs O5-8 mechanics
Or codex
“I’ll deal with the paint, just stay alive out there”
And also reverses them because this is Kefka we're talking about
Also Omega strongest attack: it just doxes you
I hope there’s a Psi Protocol and does Chaos’ stuff,
It’s one fight but story wise he is the victor of an entire bracket of tests we didn’t see
Also
What does omega say
in before Sephiroth cause at this point it is just the recurring joke
Overrated Protocol
But yeah I guess my dream TOP is that F/M phase they do the gender-fluid into other bosses
Ah yes, the genders: male, female, tree, clown, dragon
I'm a tree
these new genders are getting crazier and crazier. /s
How horrifying will it be when you get to the first swap of F/M and one turns into Exdeath and the other into Midgardsormir
neo exdeath and middy next to eachother
full size middy
I want both of them to entirely dwarf the arena
F turns into ex death,
The next cast,
Optimized Grand Cross Alpha
Optimized Almagest

Assumed you can even see anything with their body blocking everything
Okay if they go through with that, they have to go “executing Exodus protocol”
Trueeee
I cant believe I called how omega ultimate works
Omega would be that nerd
This will forever be something I will bring up
Like I don’t expect it to be as complex as DSR but I do hope they give each major thing of the raid series a chance to shine
I hope the final phase transition is as sexy as tea
I wonder if omega will get a new form or if Final Omega but different color like ultima and bahamut
Since from the heavens orchestral will be the final phase theme
Optimized Forsaken
Since dsr is blue
It red this time

No grey
red feels so not omega though
Dont skimp us like with alexander
Tea and dsr glows and color are to similar and is a major complaint
i'd bet: probably silver white and some effects so it doesn't look entirely like padjali weapons
that or the colour of the lilac highlights on omega raid weaps, that would be in theme
So I hope its o12s weapons with DNA structure glow.
really??? I feel like dsr is the colour of cheese
Possibly silver red and blue
eugh
Silver weapon red and blue dna structure glow
that sounds nightmarish to pair with clothing
I do think we're overdue for smth purple
Does that just kill you
we got skipped out on a lilac purple in dsr despite the lanner being purple
It’ll probably inflict a Beyond Death,
Either relic or omega weapons
One of the two
oh I care more about the glow than the model
They made it gold because ultimate end is gold
Oh you know what,
And its stupid
I did think ultimate end was cool
The glow and weapons should of been red and blue. Blue for thordan holy, red for nidhogg rage
I didn't mind the dsr glow at all when I went to solo thordan for khloe and saw ultimate end and was like OOOOHHH
Because that's the glows for thordan and nidhoggs weapons blue and red
As said, I hope the weapons’ base color is that iridescent silver they use on F/M and in O12
I think they should've gone into the timer sigil
maybe they've done it already w tea but I think it would've been cool as a weapon
red timer blue timer
Just thought of the best ultimate troll move: Omega's final move has it channelling all it's simulations and you see representations all merge into Omega and the move requires everyone to stack into one spot. Then last simulation to merge with Omega is Kefka and before he goes in he signals that the move is fake but it's blink and you miss it and then everyone wipes and doesn't know why
Ye silver base for the weapons
like thordan and niddy naturally
Although tbf
It depends on the color of last omega form
which is likely still to be silver/platinum
Unless they dip into blue/azure
1 month away, so we'll see
Yeah, iirc the silver Final has that kinda oil slick iridescence effect?
Would be fantastic as the weapon base
oh yah
I still question who looked at this and was like yeah that's good, ship it
I WILL play tic tac toe on every single person I see with that hair
too much forehead but maybe it's just that hyur... unlikely
no is gonna be ass
Viera
I know, you know, we all know
lol
is from DD
Probably gonna be on some allagan twink we see in a data recording
…maybe it’ll be Amon’s real face 
Actually legit Amon would be involved somewhere if Orthos is under Syrcus
Also reminder that the crumbling Dalamud in the trailer will be the second dalamud recreation we’ve seen,
!lsearch regeneration grid

What's with allag and making dalamuds
At the depth of 6,835 yalms, you and your companions are greeted by a breathtaking sight: a colossal replica of Dalamud, believed to be the device which regulates Bahamut's regeneration. The structure swarms with legions of the lesser moon's internal defenses, but through it you must go if you are to reach the main bridge
Oh @subtle pasture I found 1.0 dialogue from Gaius
On the Black Warden?
That might get brought back for myths
Ye
When you arrive at the gates of your Seventh Hell, let the Black Warden know it was not I, but the good Admiral who sent you there.
Later in HW Cid says a similar line
Huh, could it be a Garlean death deity?
Did we ever go to the seven hell?
First the archbishop turns up with an Ascian in tow, and now the godsdamned Emperor pays us a visit!? What is this, a procession of notable bastards? Who's next? The Keeper of the Seventh bloody Gate!?
Maybe Reaper associated
Black Warden and Keeper
…watch emo doll be The Black Warden
I assume the Keeper of the Seventh Gate is also the Black Warden, since Gaius says they’re in the Seventh Hell, but interesting it’s mentioned by Garleans
But ya in 1.0 Gaius researched eorzean culture, mythology and religion in his campaign to conquer eorzea. Which is why he went to attack mor dhona first.
That was gaius character he would research the lands he'd plan to conquer to better understand who hes dealing with
Tell me, do you think it fate that brings you here? Some threads woven by your Weaver whore? Or was it no more than the meddling of Master Garlond? Hmph, it matters not.
…dang 
Calling the weaver a whore
Nymeia looking up from her knitting, “hm. I feel like smiting someone today.”
But it is interesting only garleans have mentioned some kind of being in the seventh hell
Once in 1.0
And then Cid in HW
Cause I dont believe the lorebook mentions them
I guess I’d prefer it’s tied to Reaper stuff in Manalis than be a boss of Thaleia…?
But we’ll see 
"The fuck did that dude just call me"
I was about to mention something about bad drip, but Nymeia has whatever the hell that loom is floating behind her
Her wheel...
I will forever go "why literally give her a wheel... as decorative piece behind her."
Nymeia pauses her knitting, squints, “…someone is about to have bad luck…”
A otherwise perfect looking design
I do like how literal it is but I didn't expect an actual spindle wheel situation behind her
Her and Althyk both, how are they more gaudy than Byregot’s halo of nails
When I first saw it I thought it was a nautical thing,
Then I thought it was wheel of time?
I noticed it was a spindle really quick
Then I noticed the spool next to it, yeah
I guess it's cooler knowing hey that's nymeia's actual spindle of fate
I couldn’t see the spindle part
The Loom of Fate, from which all magicks flow
…apparently
I noticed the spokes, so
...smth like that
Halone is like the only one I have no complaints about and really love from the new 5 gods.
Yeah I thought it was a nautical ship wheel before I could rewatch and spot the spool
What’s wrong with Moon Cat Imouto?
people are pissed she has no eyebrows
Menphina is… fairly plain, all things considered
Dalamud is more decorated than she is
Dalamud is like cooler looking than her
Tic tac toe forehead
I think she looks cute but I also didn't go into any of this with expectations I guess 
The only part of menphina character design I like is the frozen moon beams coming out of her back
Oh she’s cute as heck, but she reminds me so much of Seraphine
Basic pop star fit
Can't wait to see Nophica from the front
I really dislike her metal gauntlet and I feel clashed with her design. If it was like all the way up to her elbow covering part of the dress maybe
Not just because of her rack, but to see how her face looks
I hate menphina pigtails as well
I’m glad she’s blue
And her tiara
I called that
I mostly don’t like her design because of how decorated Azeyma is in comparison,
They’re the sun and moon sisters 
Well she is the younger sister
Azeyma was the favored child
She is also oschon lover
i feel like menphina doesn’t have enough moon motifs
She gives the vibe of an ice fairy which is fine,
Can't wait for her to do the moon attack from Elden Ring
I dont get the vibe of goddess of moon and love.
She feels more like a ice fairy goddess
Halone fits the bill of goddess of war
Yeah, Halone's look is immaculate
Something something lunacy
She clearly doesn't skip laundry day
I like how her weapon shifts between spear and sword
I really hope my misgivings go away once the patch drops cause I dont wanna be negative about these raids >.<
That is the thing tho with making all the bosses this raid series the 12. Not all the designs are going to be as loved.
Your gonna have hit or misses
in before she is oschon sister
Back to the black warden. The fact there is only 3 gods left that opens up a ??? Of whose the 4th boss of 6.5 raid.
Which is why I've been bringing up the Black Warden
TBF we already saw with Rahlgar and hammer god that they don't have to forcefully follow the relationship chart
From what we know of Twelve lore, Oschon just kind of showed up one day
Second phase where she wears Dalamud (and only Dalamud) like E8s
So he just Wandered in? 
Yes 
Mostly just. Getting more annoyed about the alliance raid the longer I think about it.
My annoyance with design choice is being outweighed by Nymeia’s mere presence, Menphina song, and Nophica having seasonal shifts
Also just being in the Heaven of Ice,
And seasonal tits
Thaliak, llymlaen, oschon, ??? Is what I'm mostly thinking about now to get me excited.
The final boss will be “The Thirteenth Wonder”
The 14th god /s
The 13th unknown god who was sealed away
This better be more than them just testing us because a GrEaT EvIl is about to be unleashed
The Jailer
….
"and Bahamut stirs"
TBF I'm starting to think the twelve are actual manifestation of people hopes and dreams or some shit
So
Hades Remnant
Technically Pashtarot is the jailor of the convocation, huh
Preserver of Discipline and Order
The horny jail man
With the raid. At first I vibed hard with aglaia. But the more I've thought about it. I kind of dont care a lot to fight the twelve. I'm more interested in studying the heavens and omphalos. The more I think about it the more I get aggravated with the 12.
The black warden jailer
Tbf, we won't know the motives or what they are until probably end of this Alliance Raid.
(Apocalypse in background)
Well, we'll probably know 50-70% of the truth at the end of this tier
Also TBF the heaven story line was clearly an excuse for us to fight the twelve from the start
Whatever mistery comes with them, it comes second in the end
and AR in general have poor and short stories
I feel mostly what set me off is kind of just having the gods being all the bosses this raid series is what's kind getting me annoyed. Cause I think back on the title and pr talk yoshida did for the raid and what we have now. I feel kind of robbed. Of like traveling across eorzea researching myriad of myths. But should of been obvious given the art was just the 12s symbols.
Tbf, the Heavens being scattered across Eorzea mean we technically do 
TBF the pr was about discovering the mysteries of the twelve from the start (and of course fighting them)
But I do want more fleshed out between sections of investigating with the team
Yeah i feel like the name is misleading
The real myths were the friends we made along the way
But this circles back to AR being poor way to tell stories that would require more time
Wait
What disappointed me with Aglaia was that part only went back to the Sixth Umbral Era, when the Mhachi survivors likely witnessed Rhalgr through the destabilized veil,
TFW Nier made you explore the place at least /s
But like, how are we suppose to get 0 era lore if part 1 only goes to that latest point
We won't know
Althyk time


Also tbg
We do have the god of time this tier
We dunno when the twelve were created
Hard to call anything when we're still going through the story
So that also is part of the mystery I guess
AT LEAST give me deep War of the Magi lore in this set of quests
Part 2 has big pants to fill. Cause abyssos over in panda hit the jackpot I feel.
aside being rushed for Tartarus and the middle stage, ye
But I feel like part 2 will go over what the twelve actually are
While the reason for why we're fighting them will be left in the 3rd tier
There is Ghra device in the first place, they were analyzing the stone, and Dalamund existing at all will point the characters to ask questions
I do feel robbed. Cause I really liked nier having quest in 5.2 and 5.4 and wished myths could of had that.
What I want to bring up is Menphina is Oschon's lover
But it was only done cause Yoko taro requested it
And Deryk looks mighty similar to Oschon from the Arrow card
He wrote it
Which isn't surprising, stories change over time from the original source
And Menphina seems to be “leading” this arc,
See Midgasdaorm too
We aren't even supposed to be in the 7th Heaven cause apparently we DIE if we do
esp if she is the final boss of Euphrosyne
Oh you know what,
Nald’thal “lead” the first arc, and was made by Oschon
Menphina leads this arc, and is his lover

Ye, and Oschon is prob the opo opo
Or was Byregot the one that kinda lead the charge before Aglaia
Technically, all of them toghetor
Bryegot was the one who challenged us
Nhald Thal was just in the back
Also, that Deryk is occupied somewhere
Since G’raha is our companion for Euphrosyne
But ya, I'm just sitting around waiting for the patch to drop so I can actually determine how I like it or not.
Just right now all I can do is pick apart the character designs of the gods
Uhm, too early to say for that
For all we know he could have slipped on a banana peel
As in we saw G’raha with us in the start of the raid when Yoshi previewed the first half of the Heaven of Earth
I do feel like I'm on the money of what the twelve are.
Oh, ye, I got that
Doing scans with his backpack thingamajig
Oh I remember one of my dislikes but this is more of s dislike of how yoshida has been handling previewing the alliance raids this patch. "Spoilers" and not showing the bosses
I also still think the twelve are not Hydealyn creations at all
And only showing us sights
what did you say the twelve were xel
Recreations of hydaelyns summoners like the watcher
Fields of Abundance > aboreal platforms > The Bole > ice sculptures > Tower of War > Cathedral of Love
They haven't shown Nophica titty because of ToS
Or warriors of light from the first era
Is my theory for the raid makeup
I protend over the 2nd
i think i’m just not a huge fan of the meeting your gods thing bc it feels like saying they have to be “real” for that faith to be valid
Although the other idea is that the twelve are just actual nature born deities
Because were told Crystal's of light in earlier eras are stronger and denser than the ones of our era.
but i don’t have strong feelings abt it either way
Either way my money is on their some form servants of hydaelyn
To clarify, kinda like weapons in ff7 are made by Gaia, but they're shaped by people faith and prayers
Whether she created them like the watcher. Or they were former wols
But not primals
I dunno if they’re saying they have to be real for the faith to be valid yet. I’m gonna wait till we find out what they actually are but tbh I hope they spawned out of just sheer belief personally
they did insist they weren’t primals which was a head scratcher
So it isn't the god that shaped the faith, but the faith that shaped the god
I like the whole magic is real if you believe in it stuff
guess we’ll find out
Dalamund existing is what makes me protend towards this idea
But also no real basis aside that
i question how honest they are abt that tbh
The thing about Primals is if we did defeat them, they wouldn't have returned as fast as they did
"We're not primals."
"Are you eikons then?"
"Uh....."
We dont know this
lying bastards YARGHHHHH
We dont know anything abt the phantom realm
trust nobody
Not even yourself
We also dunno if we "killed" them
Oh right… there’s an MSQ wall for Euphrosyne, isn’t there
We've seen the souls of at least bryegot and rhalger. Taking on the forms of their servants the hawk and spriggan
Prob for Ghra to be there with us
Again
This is gonna have as many msq gates as Eden 
But we do know for Primals to come into being they have to be summoned.
when did we hear this?
idr
Live letter
yes..
And when nald thal is defeated he has the same death animation as the ancients except green instead of blue

It's the entire point of early MSQ is "Don't let Beastmen get Crystals or else we have a Primal to deal with again after you just defeated them."
hydaelyn couldve summoned them.
It’s like, what is a god in this world. We have Creation mages and Eikons/Primals/Deiforms
Ye, I think they might be playing around the idea of what is a summon and what isn't
is the msq gate to play to end of .3?
So the Q is, what are the Twelve in comparison to those two forms of “divinity”
Obviously God is whoever is hot
i couldn’t find mentions of the msq gate on the slideshow
zodiark
Debatable
if someone can link to the translation bit where they mention the msq requirement that would be cool
There’s also how Athena’s research in Pandaemonium is called “transcending into the divine,”
cuz i can’t find it for the life of me
But that’s separate bull… for now
But Zodi is Fanny/Hermes/Elidibus/Themis so technically that's them
Zodiark got robbed of a good character design in favor of letting amano design him. And I will forever not make this complaints >:l
One sec, i do believe it was a slide
i keep thinking about bloodborne parallels with this
forcing yourself to become a god

And again Senny, we watch them disappear into green energy after we beat them, and they come right back to go "It was just a ruse so you'd fight us". That goes against the laws of Primals because they have to be resummoned after having their form destabilized, as we watch them do.
Black Chaos?

we still dont know.
like, we cant say anything about their nature yet.
TL:Dr we don't know jackshit
especially not ruling out primals
Make whatever theories sounds right to you
given livingway's explanation of "proper" summoning.
if they were willing to put up a ruse that they wanted to tyrannically control the star, i dont buy them saying they arent primals, either
it gives them wiggle room besides
But ya their death animation is the same as an ancient except green. And we've seen their souls being elementally aligned.
To go back to my idea, they might be saying they're not Primals cause if faith shaped them in a natural way, it was not an irruent and actual voluntary act from someone (the summoning)
Another thing, we've never seen a Primal do what the Twelve do by using either living creatures or in Byregot's case, a golem in order to be among the world
Could there be levels to this? Maybe. But they are not the standard of Primal we know even if.
Magic is gonna be magic
inb4 a stone keeps resummoning them
Hydaelyn used Krile and Minfillia 
are we only working with the definition of primals being summoned via crystals here
like the panda stone
Oh yeah, i can’t find the line about Euphrosyne having an MSQ gate…
but the definition we know is very narrow.
like
shadowkeeper, fatebreaker and ra-la kinda count
TBF summoning by crystal is part of the Primals process
Wasn't it just a single tweet assuming so? Didn't see it in any liveletter translations
because I do doubt that they’re summoned manually via crystals if at all but I won’t admonish the very real possible they could still be born of faith
still that’s just my tuppence
Shadowkeeper was more akin to an Ancient’s transformation
Because she was something Mitron made
Then I see why they’re so determined to say they’re not primals if that’s the only definition they’re working on
Shadowkeeper is also not a primal, she just fuses/gets imbued by darkness and the ascians
it doesn’t really chuck many other possibilities out the window
She was also a memory
its a false claim being spread around
Yes, and that definition is a figure of notability or mythology summoned through a ritual by the summoner's will that requires aether, commonly in the form of crystals but will drain the land too
but we know "proper" summoning is possible.
from livingway
we dont know like
And every time we've fought a Primal, we disrupt their form and they go back to the Lifestream
if the phantom realm has unique qualities that sustain them
or something
there's no real conclusions we can make about their nature yet.
just weird inconsistencies
like, menphina having dalamud at all
Cant wait for the phantom realms to end up being mystical seals preventing a 13th god from being set free that's living in the 7th gate
that dog is fuckin dead
The Lifestream thing was disproven long ago
got a citation for that claim @teal salmon
It's never been disproven wut
In the lifestream
That’s Ysayle herself, who effectively is that Shiva; I mean like the old lore from like the 1.0 trailer
????
This was said in ARR
Though yeah genuinely
that claim isnt based on anything
When a primal dies their core goes to the lifestream. This is ARR lore that has been brought up in interviews with koji and oda
What are the inconsistencies we've noticed? Menphina has a loyal hound, Halone's moon has a Dalamud...
menphina has existed as a goddess for longer than dalamud
This lore is also why you can only have 1 primal at a time
dalamud is her "loyal hound"
Based on the Creation Magic stuff, like there can be the Ifrit we fight and the marshmallow roasting one from Meracydia
what
If amalja summon ifrit another group cant summon ifrit
huh

But if the people of the new world have a ifrit in their culture but is a nice ifrit that roast marshmallows. That ifrit would be able to be summoned at the same time as amaljaa ifrit
could also be
yknow. a different fire primal
i really dont know what you're talking about woods
what was the debate about again
primals go lifestream
they sure do
Wrong interview I think I posted
ding ding ding.
I'll summon ifrit's brother, ifroot
The debate was me stating how the Twelve can't be Primals as they go against a fundamental rule of Primals- That being when we defeat a Primal and destabilize their form, their core goes to the Lifestream.
Yeah, but we don't know if the concept of Menphina having a doggo was created to explain Dalamud OR if Dalamud was given that name because the concept already existed.
Yet when we beat the Twelve they're back as if nothing happened despite their whole green glowiness.
i mean
Menphina having dalamund is pretty much it
also possible they could’ve just tped out of there before getting actually smackered
And even then, Dalamund exist in the phantom realm
which leads to my theory that it is people who shape the faith and the realm
We dunno that
We don’t even know if the “Pure Primals” that fueled the Ragnarok were much different
We know that dalamund was named the hound, but if she had one before that is unkown
did we actually “kill” them though? or merely incapacitate?
Simply cause all twelve lore stops at allagan
chi egg…
Yesn't
i'm sure the dog came first. but we really dont know till they tell us
Dalamund is for sure an allagan creation
Tbf, the phantom realm itself is a grand mystery because how are these massive swells of elemental aether near perfectly hidden from the realm below
smadge need answers
So the red moon existing is a glaring issue if Menphina was created before that
15 days please look forward to it
I say issue, but eh
like im not arguing against the dog existing the whole time and the allagans naming the satellite after him
but
we dont know
We never killed them
they could go the other way
If the religion and the Twelve were shaped by the faithful, you'd expect they're to be more evolution and difference introduced over time, and yet we're told the gods have stayed consistent.
they seem to reappear with no real issues or seemingly obvious damage
Aye, for one thing, the dog isn’t red, but the lesser moon in the Heaven is
They talk to us after the whole raid, remember
well
if we never killed them then the primals returning to the lifestream thing is totally irrelevant
Dalamud doesn’t look like Dalamud,
honestly that could also mean nothing pash
But is it Dalamud doesn’t look like Dalamud or does Dalamud not look like Dalamud

We don't even know if the dog is called Dalamud in the myth. We're just told Dalamud is called that.
inb4 dog is the black warden
To be fair aren’t the iterations we see the gods in now very reminiscent of what they’re believed to be today
her dog is called dalagab actually /j
disappointed that dog doesnt have a sword though
Well, their depiction never changed much over time
What’s the other moon wolf in Norse myth
Red Wolf of Radagon boss fight in Elden Ring.
See all bosses here: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7bwjwx5WwdfUYIZ9qg8nKdjymqVI8E-r
BFD, Boss Fight Database.
Red Wolf of Radagon boss battle. Elden Ring boss battle.
relevant
Aside that, they're still somewhat different
shoulda been dalamud
Skoll and Hati…?

Rhalgar being 1 on 1 cause they apparently saw him
skoll and hati
Ladi dadi, we love to skadi
And Azeyma, Nophica and other 2 on the cards
skadi is a jotunn
We always cause trouble when we guzzle bacardi
Not only statues but I guess also what they’re the gods of
more than that
Yes, they faded away and even G'raha states his surprise as it looked similar to how a Primal would
llymlaen
It’s what they’re the gods of right now to the people from what we can see mainly
Ye, but those statues are quite approssimatives
We have statues of Nhald Thal, but they're not as faithful to a human shape like Halone or Rhalgar
she could end up being a mermaid, for all we know.
And we know Halone statue is different from the real deal, so
Pretty similar
KF: Yes. <thinks> … Yes! But as I mentioned with the Phoenix, depending on the culture, there’s a different perception of what it was. Was it a god? Was it a savior? Was it evil? Let’s use Ifrit as an example, though I’m not saying this is really the case with him. The Amalj’aa look at him as an angry god that wants to purify the land with his flames. When they summon him, they pray to that type of Ifrit, and it forms. Say, in the New World, thousands of miles away, there is also the legend of Ifrit, but in the thousands of years since that original seed of myth, he’s grown into a very benevolent god that… <laughs> gives flowers to children and is the fire that roasts your marshmallows… that’s a different essence, even though it’s the same Ifrit. Those two could exist simultaneously. But if Amalj’aa summon one Ifrit and some other Amalj’aa who worship the same Ifrit try to do the same thing, they could not.
Found the quote from a previous time but not the link to the interview. Back to searching for it.
Merrow No. 5
eh.
a bit
not extremely different though
do refer to this doc i made
https://www.notion.so/sensensensen/In-Game-Portrayals-of-the-Twelve-and-Their-Shrines-16d5d7a6c1684f9b809bd83ec743ac2c
Anyhow the fact that the gods stayed mostly the same isn't contrary to the concept that the faith shaped them in the end
It's not super different, she just has the visor on her helmet down when we fight her
I mean, she looked like a valkyrie on the statues and she looked just like one in the raid
Aye, which technically is her place with Althyk,
She has a cute hoodie tho now
They’re the ones said to have parleyed with Middy so please let us speak to them
either her or cybele
Inb4 she's just hiding her face
her face looks rlly pretty
like they're hiding nophica from us
she looks like ihhhhhh
A nier character lol
oh yeah iddy
did you see uh
in the clip during the ultimate
did you notice althyk is mounted
Anyway ye, twelve rapresentations stayed consistent since allagan as far as we know
he’s what now
he's riding a horse
Ye, he’s got the austere emperor vibe down pat
It's Althyk that's mounted? Hmm.
Oh SICK
Yeah, can see his stupid helm
(there is also Ramuh, which is apparently Rhalgar seen by the Pixies, but oh well)
Austere indeed, what the fuck is he wearing
gods are gods they’re allowed to look weird
Are they allowed to have more melanin too
Inb4 that's his body
He’s doing a joint spell with his wifey, yeah
just saw the PLD reworrk...where is this supposed to be putting us on the Tank role spectrum now?
Someone post the Balance sticker
on paper at least
Wait for 6.3 to know
Here’s this ten page PowerPoint
ask her to sew a pretty outfit
We just don't know
hmm nice
on why I’d be a better husband than althyk
- i'm not your brother (no incest)
That’s MERELY on the vague ass descriptions we saw in LL
we’re gonna get more later
In before tic tac toe mechanic
Exactly
- i have longer arms
to hug you with 
- performs well (in the kitchen)
Just saying Menphina has a chess board arena, and we got statues, maybe wolf moves according to the piece?
Surprised there’s no groomer memes on Althyk,
Oh god don’t manifest them
Since he raised her from a baby, too
I feel like this can only devolve
Absolutely,
it’s already weird but don’t persuade actually gross memes to show up to drive it home
Trust me soon as they mention it, it's gonna light up like wild fire
just leave it at that
So just Silly God Things 
we’re overly aware of this
Remember Erichthonios origin story
let’s not remember
Technically his mother was Gaia
zeus couldnt restrain his libido
Over half of Zeus’ children he wasn’t even in a humanoid shape when he impregnated their mothers
Gonna throw this interview in lore spoilers
dude was so horny his headache resulted in a child
Only if it's the Jojo ending Idris
Then there's athena 
looks at the Minotaur story
On a side note, Menphina face still looks kinda weird from some angles
Ignore the Nophica circle of people trying to see her
she might look better in game
Ps, that's how Athena gonna show up in Pandaemonium
honestly she looks fine
It looks weird at every angle
Indeed.
(I still don’t get why there’s ice under her skirt)
Using Scathach's model was a strange choice
I think it is a combination of the wide forehead - empty eyes and small nose
she’s FFXII core and I like it
Halone’s palace is made of frozen moonlight
Neat fact- Menphina has a skillet for a weapon
She’s definitely ringing in ice fairy vibes,
the empty eyes are good in a divinity offputting way
So I hope she has a fusion with her doggo
iddy am i wrong in getting like
chang'e vibes
Really? Did you forget we have a horny playerbase?
from menphina
She has pupils
We might get that fusion we might not
They just match her eye color 
It looks like shes the final boss of the alliance raid given what we can hear from the song
Name a game that doesn't have a horny player base
Kind of yes she’s too much of a child and not at all a Chinese xiannu vibe lol but her eyes are a good step in the Moon Goddess direction
They didn’t show any of her fight after Lunar Cry, I do believe 
She looks perfect
🥰
Chess
Nah
ig its the crown giving me that vibe
but also given the Order from the elemental list
Menphina was always going to be the final boss
Is Nymeia right after Menphina?
Honestly when I think of Chang’e I think of the traditional Chinese immortal fit and just same lady with long white hair with a. Few rabbits lol
Nymeia is the after Menphina
Nophica, Nymeia, Halone, Menphina









