#Summary: Response Behavior Differences When Canvas is Open vs Closed

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

hard haven
#

Description: While working on updating code in the canvas, I observed a difference in response behavior depending on whether the canvas was open or closed.

Issue Encountered:
Before making any updates, I intended to discuss adding new utility functions to my code. While the canvas was open, the assistant directly proceeded to edit the code in the open canvas editor instead of discussing the changes.

When I closed the canvas and asked the same question, the response was more conversational and aligned with my intention to discuss the approach without immediate edits.

Impact:
The assistant seems to prioritize direct edits to the code when the canvas is open instead of following the intended flow of conversation. This inconsistency affects the experience, leading to unintended edits when the user is not ready.

Suggested Improvement:

  • Improve consistency between responses when the canvas is open vs closed, especially when discussing potential changes or planning next steps.
  • Ensure the assistant can differentiate between when a user wants to discuss an idea versus making direct changes, regardless of the canvas state.
nocturne schoonerBOT
#

@hard haven

Please follow the posting guidelines.

For better assistance from the community or an OpenAI team member, please follow the posting guidelines by clicking the button below.

➜ Need to contact OpenAI support? Visit https://help.openai.com
hard haven
#

Steps to reproduce:

Open a code file in the canvas for editing.
Ask a question about adding new utility functions or potential improvements without specifying that immediate changes are needed.
Observe how the assistant proceeds to update the code directly in the canvas.
Expected result:

The assistant should engage in a discussion about the suggested changes and wait for explicit confirmation before making updates to the code.

Actual result:

The assistant proceeded to directly edit the code in the canvas instead of following the conversational flow intended by the user.

Additional information

Browser: Edge Version 129.0.2792.79 (Official build) (64-bit)

OS: Windows 10, OS build: 19045.4894