#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 491 of 1

shrewd meteor
#

But that is up for the writers to decide

placid fulcrum
#

That would make Roadhog look even less smart

#

Betting his head on a 50%share of a cat in a sack

#

And he doesn't even enjoy it

#

He came across to me like a smart guy in his comic

#

So I like to think that he knows something we don't

shrewd meteor
#

I hope he does

placid fulcrum
#

Tangentially related, but someone mentioned echo being used as a way to develop mccree and it just reminded me how upset I am that the devs sunk mcashe probably only so that they could pair off mccree with echo

#

She didn't make much of an impression on me. Ashe has a personality, echo doesn't (yet?)

#

She was literally turned off when they had no need of her.

#

That's not a pairing that would make me want to ship it

#

In fact, most of the canon pairings are deeply disappointing

shrewd meteor
#

Did they actually hint echo/mcree?

#

When?

placid fulcrum
#

Ana, Soldier, Widowmaker, Tracer, Reaper, Torbjorn are/were all dating some randos with no personality or importance

#

Why else would they go out of their way to tell us mcashe isn't a thing? Either he'll be dating echo, or yet another rando.

#

Honestly, I'd prefer a rando over a robot waifu that he has the key to turn on and off whenever he pleases

shrewd meteor
#

Lmao

#

Dating echo

#

You can't get it with a human woman

#

So you try your luck with an omnic

placid fulcrum
#

Idk, I feel like he could get it

shrewd meteor
#

Oh no

placid fulcrum
#

Ashe seems interested

shrewd meteor
#

Ashe I can understand

#

Being long term friends and all

placid fulcrum
#

She's kept his photo on her bike for 20 years

modern bloom
peak escarp
#

Or one panel where Dr. Winston is arguing with his colleagues about keeping those highly intelligent animals basically imprisoned?

#

But the fact of the matter is that the gorillas are members of the colony, just like you and I. I don't believe there's a magic solution to socializing them. We think of them as teenagers, but they're much more than that.

#

we don't have any examples of Moira experimenting on unwilling subjects - we only know she has done unethical work from her bio and origin trailer.

#

and on the Ashe/McCree topic . . . I think she has unrequited love for him

placid fulcrum
#

oh, nice

#

where is this message from?

#

Also, @modern bloom I don't think that fits this channel

peak escarp
#

this was the teaser for Horizon

placid fulcrum
#

awesome! thanks

peak escarp
#

regardless of the ethical implications of doing genetic therapy on great apes, Harold Winston was a good man

placid fulcrum
#

he called it off when he noticed they're not doing well, that speaks well of him

peak escarp
#

he treated the apes like members of the colony, rather than test subjects, which is appropriate considering their intelligence level

#

we dont know much about the other scientists, but Harold's note implies that they didn't treat the apes like equals

modern bloom
peak escarp
#

!!loreonly @modern bloom

twilit nacelleBOT
#

@modern bloom This channel is for serious discussion strictly related to the lore of Overwatch. Shitposting will result in a loss of access.

modern bloom
#

Ok sorry m8

#

will stick to v+videocontent from now on

valid terrace
#

I don’t know what the big deal about Moira being 100% evil is

#

All the characters have checkered pasts from at least one standpoint, not a single one is perfectly good or evil

#

It’s just that she values scientific progress over safety and protocols, which didn’t sit well with Soldier and Mercy, so as the higher ups in Overwatch’s science division, they wouldn’t let her get very far

#

You can agree or disagree with any of the characters, they can be good or evil depending on who makes the call

#

I think prior to Retribution, Moira was the most significantly maverick member of Overwatch that we know about

iron plume
#

I don't think anyon's claiming her to be 100% evil
but I'm honestly a bit tired of her whitewashing

#

she isn't just reckless in "valuing progress over safety and protocols"

#

she values it over ethics

limpid agate
#

So

iron plume
#

also

with Soldier and Mercy
there's no sign whatsoever that Mercy had anything to do with her disgrace

#

or morals

#

we have a word for that and that word is "evil"

#

she doesn't do it for the shits and giggles of "being bad"

#

but that's not a requirement

valid terrace
#

At the time wasn’t Mercy at the head of the science department? If not then that was my false assumption.

iron plume
#

she wasn't in charge of Blackwatch's

valid terrace
#

No, but that was separate from her research at Overwatch

iron plume
#

Her pre-blackwatch research wasn't for OW

valid terrace
#

Regardless, Morrison didn’t approve of her methods, and whether or not he was qualified, he certainly had a large say in her limits at Overwatch

peak escarp
#

Overwatch shut her down

#

her previous work wasn't for Overwatch

#

we weren't really discussing if Moira was evil - someone said Moira had "done nothing wrong"

placid fulcrum
#

on screen

#

she did nothing wrong on screen

#

I still stand by this, btw

peak escarp
#

which is technically true

#

but she's not a good person

#

I agree that they need to show more and tell less

placid fulcrum
#

OW2 might be a good start of that

#

let's keep our fingers crossed

#

will all missions be in the current time, or will some of them be in the past? do we know anything about this?

peak escarp
#

I would argue that her work on Reyes was Moira doing wrong

lament prawn
#

overwatch 2 is supposed to be the next chapter, the heroes have been recalled and now the story finally goes beyond

#

there may be some flashbacks here and there but in general OW2's purpose is to take the story forward

peak escarp
#

yes he volunteered, but she did more than what he volunteered for

#

he wanted her to fix his problems, not turn him into smoke

placid fulcrum
#

he continues to call her his friend, so he doesn't mind it

#

and it's not like this is the first time he was augmented

peak escarp
#

that doesn't change the fact that she did more than he consented to

placid fulcrum
#

can we be sure?

#

maybe she couldn't have fixed him in any other way? he could've gone to mercy instead

peak escarp
#

the artist said his expression in Moira's origin was one of fear

lament prawn
#

didnt she even do the similar experiments on herself only after she's had experience by testing it on him?

placid fulcrum
#

so? I feel fear every time I get shots, doens't mean they're bad for me and doens't mean I don't consent to them

peak escarp
#

maybe Mercy couldn't fix him, or he didnt want his friends to worry

placid fulcrum
#

it's normal to feel fear when you see your body turning into smoke all fo the sudden. but ultimately he was more than happy with the results

#

so saying she's a monster for doing something that the person she did it to was happy with is a bit over the top

#

I wish they'd show me the unwilling test subjects who aren't happy with the results

#

why not officially confirm that she had something to do with Widowmaker's brainwashing?

#

although that would have made her a traitor to overwatch even before the split

#

so probably not

lament prawn
#

willing or not, her work is not good because she's aware that it hasn't been tested and could make for unwanted results but continues to do so anyway

placid fulcrum
#

um, winston's work was untested and had unwanted results

#

and we agreed that he's a good person regardless

lament prawn
#

winston has shown care for the wellbeing of the subjects, moira hasnt

placid fulcrum
#

difference is, we saw winston's kinder side, we didn't see moira's. and winston was on the side of the "good guys" unlike moira. but I still wish for more showing, less telling

lament prawn
#

i agree with you in the sense that more showing is good and they should do more, but i dont think they've shown so little to the point where we don't know who's good and who isn't

placid fulcrum
#

also, moira did show care for her subjects

#

she asks them how they feel all the time

#

worries about side effects

#

she has multiple interactions like that

lament prawn
#

well of course she'd want to know how her experiments affect her subjects, thats the point of doing them

#

but just comparing the personalities of her and winston, i can see who cares (or at least who cares far more than the other) without needing to be told "he good she bad" directly

placid fulcrum
#

or you jsut let your preconceived notions do that

#

because I can totally read her concern as genuine

#

literally the only reason not to do that is because she's steretypical cartoon bad guy

#

not because there's anything we've been shown about her actual character that would support the idea of her being cruel and uncaring

#

certainly no more than multiple "good guy" characters, who have some very cruel lines

peak escarp
#

if I go in for a dental checkup and the dentist starts pulling teeth without asking or telling me, that's a breach of ethics

#

doesn't matter if I feel better about it afterwards

placid fulcrum
#

difference is - you go to a dentist asking to come up with a new and undiscovered treatment for teeth

#

you don't get to complain when the dentist starts pulling your teeth then

peak escarp
#

I sure would

placid fulcrum
#

how do you think drugs are tested in the real world?

iron plume
#

on people directly agreeing to consequences

placid fulcrum
#

unforseen consequences

peak escarp
#

the people being tested are still told what they're taking

placid fulcrum
#

that nobody told them what they could be, because nobody knows

iron plume
#

and with studies carefully monitored for adverse effects

peak escarp
#

they dont just dose people unknowingly

iron plume
#

that then stop if they start happening

placid fulcrum
#

they won't know until a subject start experiencing them

#

how do you know moira didn't carefully monitor reyes?

#

you're just making assumptions

peak escarp
#

she did monitor him

iron plume
#

<

peak escarp
#

that isnt my point

#

she did something to him that he did not consent to

placid fulcrum
#

he did consent

#

she did what he specifically hired her for

#

and he was happy with her work

#

you're making up headcanons

peak escarp
#

we know he asked her to help him with "a genetic issue"

placid fulcrum
#

and she did

peak escarp
#

we know he looked frightened when he appeared to be turning into smoke

placid fulcrum
#

as I do, when I'm getting shots

peak escarp
#

this implies that he did not agree to that

placid fulcrum
#

as do people who consent to drug tests, when they suffer side effects

#

that doesn't invalidate their consent

lean prawn
#

normally they test it on animals first to see if there are any harmful side effects

iron plume
#

she experimented on herself first

placid fulcrum
#

there is ero reason to believe moira wouldn't stop if she felt his life was in danger

iron plume
#

she knew the side effects

#

and judging by his reactions she didn't tell him

lean prawn
#

she experimented with a rabbit first

placid fulcrum
#

she doens't turn into smoke, so I doubt it

iron plume
#

you're staring with the conclusion and forcing evidence to fit it

placid fulcrum
#

no, you are making up headcanons and confusing them for canon

#

facts are as follows: reyes hired her to perform a new and untested procedure on him, she did what he wanted and he was happy with it and coninues to employe her and even consider her a frined

iron plume
#

if taking a (somewhat) nebulous situation and interpreting is "making up headcanons" then you're doing the exact same thing

placid fulcrum
#

everything else is just your own unfounded speculation

#

no, I'm stating canon facts

#

reyes got what he wanted and he's happy with it

#

there is no lack of consent, either confirmed or implied

#

in fact, wasn't it implied that it was the woman in your icon that is responsible for what's currently wrong with his body, that he definitely didn't consent to?

#

interesting double standards

peak escarp
#

no it wasn't

placid fulcrum
#

he definitely blames overwatch

peak escarp
#

it was never implied that Mercy was involved

placid fulcrum
#

"you tell me doc"

#

"they left me to suffer"

iron plume
#

oh god

lean prawn
#

maybe he's asking because mercy is a licensed medical professional and he just wants a diagnosis

#

mercy didn't turn him into a ghost or drop a building on his face

#

she just knows health

placid fulcrum
#

if he cared about mercy's diagnosis he wouldn't have gone to moira to begin with

#

and mercy's on his kill list, rememebr?

iron plume
#

he doesn't care for the diagnosis, he's just a sarcastic asshole

peak escarp
#

because she's Overwatch

lean prawn
#

Winston and tracer didn't really do much to him either and they're also on the kill list

placid fulcrum
#

anyway, it's ludicrous to blame the state of reyes' body on moira, when the man himself is blaming everyone except her

lean prawn
#

again, jack dropped the building on his face

placid fulcrum
#

how about let him decide who really did something agaisnt his consent?

iron plume
#

moira isn't evil but mercy is

#

i'm done

placid fulcrum
#

my point is: canon over fanon. also let the "victim" say who they blame for doing things to their body that they don't like, shall we?

iron plume
#

the canon is

#

mercy had fuck all to do with reaper

placid fulcrum
#

the canon is -reyes likes moira and is happy with her work on him

iron plume
#

and moira is a scientist infamous for her disregard of ethics and morals

placid fulcrum
#

that hasn't been shown to us thus far

#

would be nice to see it on screen

iron plume
#

that doesn't make denying it any more canon

placid fulcrum
#

well, so much stuff we've seen that turned out to be biased

iron plume
#

such as

placid fulcrum
#

like that news article which stated that reyes hated morrison for getting picked as the leader

#

or hanzo's bio stating that genji is dead

lean prawn
#

"Overwatch didn't agree with my tactics, and they tried to shut me down."
-Moira's origin trailer

placid fulcrum
#

who's to say that mercy's opinion about moira isn't biased or based on incomplete information?

lament prawn
placid fulcrum
#

after all, in mercy's short story, her own research was also hated

iron plume
#

how about moira working for a literal terrorist organization

#

and mercy's research isn't hated, her involvement with overwatch is

placid fulcrum
#

and her research as a result of that

lean prawn
#

mercy was sought out by overwatch because of her own revolutionary research

placid fulcrum
#

so was moira

iron plume
#

(wonder what made people hate overwatch, by the way)

#

(if only there was some kind of infamous incident we played through)

lean prawn
#

moira was shut down by overwatch

#

then recruited by blackwatch

placid fulcrum
#

I mean, according to the comics, blackwatch did a whole lot of horrible things

#

"assassination, coercion, kidnapping, torture, and worse."

lean prawn
#

like recruiting a geneticist who had no qualms about violating the regulations of the scientific community

placid fulcrum
#

idk what "and worse" is but I can imagine

#

lackwatch was a aprt of overwatch

lean prawn
#

that jack had largely no say in

placid fulcrum
#

it operated with knowledge and protection from overwatch

#

jack has all say in it

lean prawn
#

the entire venice sting was behind jack's back

placid fulcrum
#

no it wasn't

#

we see him walking them up to the jet in the comic

#

he couldn't officially allow for it, but he still unofficially gave his permission

lean prawn
#

what was this entire thing about originally

placid fulcrum
#

telling vs showing

#

and how we're told moira is evil, but she hasn't done much evil on screen

lean prawn
#

she does take active part in a terrorist organization

placid fulcrum
#

so does every memebr of overwatch

#

because it's an illegal organization that has been complicit in a number of criminal activities over the years

iron plume
#

"criminal" and "terrorist" is a pretty big fucking leap

#

it's Talon's explicit goal to start a worldwide conflict

#

which overwatch is trying to mitigate

placid fulcrum
#

well... they entered london despite having no permission from official authorities and stirred s*t there

lean prawn
#

to stop another terrorist organization

iron plume
#

Talon whataboutism
never thought I'd see the day

placid fulcrum
#

if your side does "assassination, coercion, kidnapping, torture, and worse." then "but our primary goal is to stop terrortists!" isn't an excuse

iron plume
#

who took part in that "and worse"

#

pray tell

placid fulcrum
#

wqe don't know

iron plume
#

lmao

lean prawn
#

overwatch says that overwatch is a terrorist organization, but the cinematics show us that the organization was revived upon an ideal

placid fulcrum
#

it's one of those "tell don't show" moments

#

from the comics

#

to be honest, i don't think I want that shown

#

it's one of the rare cases where telling is enough

#

anyway, how about we talk about something positive for a change?

#

who's your favourite character and do you play them?

iron plume
#

to play, Ashe, but that's not this channel
as a character, Mercy

placid fulcrum
#

I'm just curious if people typically play their lore favourites or not

#

because I do like to play my favourite characters, even though their playstyle doens't appeal to me particularly

#

i'm also curious whether playing a character makes you more interested in their lore

#

that's generally the case in wow. people are downright obsessed with their races and factions

iron plume
#

I like ashe's character

#

but her lore isn't particularly interesing

placid fulcrum
#

if overwatch were to introduce a talon/overwatch hero divide, I wonder if people would become equally tribalist

#

I hope it won't

peak escarp
#

I love Mei's character

#

and Mercy's lore

valid terrace
#

The farthest I can see them doing that is a twitter contest leading to a skin for the winning side

placid fulcrum
#

that would be interesting

valid terrace
#

Or maybe an event tdm

peak escarp
#

it would be better if some heroes stayed neutral/3rd party

#

not everyone needs to pick a side

valid terrace
#

I think they meant for the fans rather than characters

placid fulcrum
#

I love characters and their lore equally: junkers, deadlock gang, reaper, ana, sombra (shocking as it may sound). I only care about the other characters in relation to these ones (at the moment, might change in the future with more lore incoming). I play them all, more or less often. The only character I like to play whose lore I don't care for is Brigitte.

#

although, let me retract: it's not that I don't care for the lore for other characters. if there's a comic or story, or a cinematic, I will definitely watch it. just, it won't get me as excited as these characters.

valid terrace
#

I enjoy playing all the characters, and the lore just deepens my experience in the game

lean prawn
#

zarya is my favourite character

fresh tundra
#

How come?

lean prawn
#

she's a paragon of her beliefs, strong physically and emotionally

peak escarp
#

she's inspirational

lean prawn
#

she reminds me of captain america from the first and second movies

#

also she was like "oh no my gun is broken hey look there's another gun i can use" and rips a gun off of an armored vehicle and just started using that

#

her character is just so cool

placid fulcrum
#

I like how she was able to overcome her prejudice and saved the life of her omnic partner (dare i say "friend"?)

peak escarp
#

calling Lynx her friend would be generous

lean prawn
#

more like zarya swallowing her prejudices for the greater good

#

which is just as inspirational

shell jay
#

Is it possible Junkrat and Roadhog could have a romantic relationship in anyway

#

Also have you noticed that mostly everyone has had something terrible or depressing happen in their lives except for Brigette?

peak escarp
#

I think a romantic relationship between Junkrat and Roadhog is very unlikely

#

Roadhog doesn't seem to like him much

#

also Brigitte had to see her godfather essentially get fired - I'd count that as something terrible

valid terrace
#

Do you think we could get a hero that’s only in it for the fame Booster Gold style, or would that distort the message they’re trying to spread too much?

shell jay
#

I mean some of the heroes are villains so i dont think it would affect it much

valid terrace
#

I mean one that is clearly meant to be a hero, but not in the public interest

#

And Soldier doesn’t count

worthy rose
#

A hero who's only in it for the glory

#

doesn't really care about doing good?

#

Possibly

#

tho it will be hard to do without ruining that feeling that the blizzard team tries so hard to do.

valid terrace
#

That’s what I mean

worthy rose
#

The closest character would probably be maybe Junkrat?

shell jay
#

I think that would actually be a good character concept

#

A celebrity who received backlash for something so they became a hero for the fame

valid terrace
#

H&G Rein is pretty close

#

But he just likes the fight

worthy rose
#

No

#

Booster gold wasnt a celebrity; he was a time traveler from the future who wanted to get famous during the era of superman

#

What i think moscimer means is a hero that isnt morally good or evil but self serving but operates on the side of good

valid terrace
#

Right

shell jay
#

I was just coming up with a random character I didn't know booster gold

valid terrace
#

Same character as BG but not backstory obviously

worthy rose
#

Which I think junkrat is the closest to that but he doesn’t cleanly fit and I doubt they wanna touch the time travel aspect cause that’s a messy slope

#

In terms of most writing

shell jay
#

What if they made a completely new character based on that

valid terrace
#

Exactly

worthy rose
#

I would hate another character based on time travel

peak escarp
#

same

valid terrace
#

I’m just trying to get the consensus on if heroes have to be selfless in lore

#

So far all the heroes are

worthy rose
#

And while doable; I wouldnt really be a fan cause a lot overwatch’s charms come from characters personality. They are all very intriguing but having a character just be “Hi; I self inserted myself into the hero group cause fame.” Is gonna be real hard to make charming.

shell jay
#

What if the character had nothing to do w time travel

worthy rose
#

Also cause time travel characters are like the duct tape of writing in that if you meed something to occur, time travel to do whatever or get whatever to get out of a sticky scenario

#

Which enables basically no more stakes

shell jay
#

Like I said earlier, a celebrity trying to cover up backlash

#

Or something like that 🤷🏽‍♂️

valid terrace
#

I disagree, I find Overwatch’s side characters and villains have more interesting morals and goals since they can be so controversial

worthy rose
#

They can be but they all serve a character motive you more or less get behind

#

Or understand

#

It’s why a lot of ppl like Thanos

valid terrace
#

I can side with Booster Gold, despite most of the time ignoring if it’s the right thing to do

worthy rose
#

But a super self serving “I just wanna be famous” and thus butting into situations and interacting with like Tracer or Winston who are idealists would be more trouble than good

valid terrace
#

I think it would add depth to Winston’s own morals by having someone as a foil of himself

#

Doing the same things for different reasons

#

There’s so many characters now where ‘save the world’ is their only real motivation

#

Separating those ideals through contrast would be refreshing

#

Hopefully OW2 does that anyways though

peak escarp
#

Helix could fill that role

#

saving the world for the money

#

rather than saving the world because it's the right thing to do

frosty shell
#

I like the character concept of a mercenary hero good guy

#

But it seems like it's too late to add that character type now

placid fulcrum
#

I don't see why it absolutely has to be a time traveler for them to want to be famous, but I also don't think that a time traveling character would be bad. Imagine for example the scenario where they travel to the past to kill the person responsible for the first omnic crusis (ala "killing hitler"), and somehow end up taking them to the future and when that person sees the state of the world, it kickstarts their path towards the "dark side"

frosty shell
#

True time travel is too much for Overwatch

placid fulcrum
#

Tracer begs to differ

frosty shell
#

That's not time travel

#

She just rewinds herself

placid fulcrum
#

She time traveled 6 months into the future during heraccident

frosty shell
#

That's not real time travel I would say

placid fulcrum
#

How come?

frosty shell
#

By that definition Mei time traveled 9 years

placid fulcrum
#

Mei was still there, tracer wasn't

#

It was instant for her

frosty shell
#

We don't really know much about what was happening to Tracer during that time

#

All we know is that she was popping in and out of existence

placid fulcrum
#

There was no "during". She time traveled

frosty shell
#

Not really

#

She was popping in and out

placid fulcrum
#

That was 6 months later

frosty shell
#

Yes

#

But just because she disappeared doesn't mean she time traveled

#

She might've just been undetectable

#

And the effect is the same as for Mei

placid fulcrum
#

That's a reasonable assumption for a character whose powers are explicitly stated to be linked to time travel

peak escarp
#

She time traveled 6 months into the future during heraccident

#

what?

#

source?

placid fulcrum
#

Her short

frosty shell
#

But during its first flight, the aircraft's teleportation matrix malfunctioned, and it disappeared. Lena was presumed dead.

She reappeared months later, but her ordeal had greatly changed her: her molecules had been desynchronized from the flow of time. Suffering from "chronal disassociation," she was a living ghost, disappearing for hours and days at a time. Even for the brief moments she was present, she was unable to maintain physical form.[3]

peak escarp
#

"My teleportation matrix malfunctioned, and I disappeared. I was missing for months! And no-one knew where - or when - I'd gone."

#

doesn't say 6 months

placid fulcrum
#

"Or when"

peak escarp
#

still doesn't say 6 months

placid fulcrum
#

Yeah, maybe i was wrong about the passage of time

#

But it's still months

limpid agate
#

What's your point

frosty shell
#

Storywise, it's still the same effect as Mei

peak escarp
#

time still progressed forward for her and everyone else

placid fulcrum
#

My point it - she traveled to the future

frosty shell
#

Time travel into the future doesn't mean much if you can't travel back

limpid agate
#

I also traveled to the future

placid fulcrum
#

Not to her, there's nothing to imply this

frosty shell
#

Mei also traveled into the future at a faster rate

placid fulcrum
#

"No one knew when I'd gone"

frosty shell
#

Tracer herself didn't remember it

#

To be fair, the "when" line supports your points

limpid agate
#

If you've ever taken a nap, you've time traveled to the future the same way Tracer has in that chronal disassociated gap. The difference is, your body still exists in this plane of existence, while hers didnt

placid fulcrum
#

You're being deliberately obtuse

limpid agate
#

Not really.

#

Time travel forward is not that impressive.

placid fulcrum
#

"The character who has the ability that literally has the description "Tracer bounds backward in time, returning her health, ammo and position on the map to precisely where they were a few seconds before." couldn't possibly be linekd to time travel!"

frosty shell
#

She's close to time travel

placid fulcrum
#

I don't know if you're just disagreeing for the sake of disagreeing, but that's just plain silly

peak escarp
#

it's more like a fast forward/rewind, than true time travel

limpid agate
#

She can't travel across the timeline of the world

peak escarp
#

based on how it appeared in Alive

limpid agate
#

She can change her own relative time

#

Go to where she was 10 seconds earlier

#

Or will be in 10 seconds

placid fulcrum
#

not with that thing on her chest

#

but there was at least one incident where she did pop months into the future

limpid agate
#

And she aged normally

placid fulcrum
#

prove it

frosty shell
#

We don't know if Tracer aged while she was gone

limpid agate
#

1 sec

frosty shell
#

She does age normally now

#

But do we know if she aged while she was gone?

placid fulcrum
#

exactly my point

limpid agate
#

Hmm fair that was not explicitly confirmed

#

Either way

peak escarp
#

would you even notice if someone didn't age for a few months?

limpid agate
#

She cant time travel. She can adjust her own time, but not time travel

peak escarp
#

it's negligable

frosty shell
#

She still pretty much did the same thing as Mei

placid fulcrum
#

a character with time travel in her abilities, and her condition that literally has "chronal" in the name, whose backstory involved "no one knows where - or when - i'd gone" is explicitly linked to time travel

#

denying it is just being deliberately obtuse

frosty shell
#

We're not saying she isn't linked to time travel

peak escarp
#

Mei would look significantly younger than others her age - she's chronologically 40 but biologically 31

placid fulcrum
#

mei was just asleep. she didn't blink into the future in a second

frosty shell
#

We're just saying she's not a time traveler

placid fulcrum
#

she i't but the idea of time travel and a character that would be linked to it is still there

frosty shell
#

Why do you care?

#

We only disagree about one small point that doesn't matter

placid fulcrum
#

because someone said it doesn't fit overwatch universe

frosty shell
#

It doesn't

#

Time travel far into the past doesn't

placid fulcrum
#

the devs even stated that one of the original concepts for junkrat was an alien and you think time travel doens't fit the universe which already has a character linked to it?

limpid agate
#

A character with Reaper in their name, has a condition that literally has "wraith" in the name, whose backstory involved "everyone thought I died, and now I'm an immortal ghost" is explicitly linked to undeath.

#

Except

#

He isn't

frosty shell
#

Exactly

#

And once the story got fleshed out, Junkrat couldn't be an alien

peak escarp
#

what do aliens have to do with anything?

limpid agate
#

a character with supernatural healing in her abilities, and her condition that literally has "resurrect" in the name, whose has the persona of an angel is explicitly linked to bringing back the dead

#

Except

#

She isnt

frosty shell
#

Exactly

limpid agate
#

Tracer can't go 10 seconds in the past or future

frosty shell
#

And what's your source for that? Junkrat went through many changes in development but I don't remember anyone saying he was once thought of as an alien

limpid agate
#

She can reposition herself with timetravel as the excuse

#

But she cant go back in time

#

If she can go into the future, it would be more

peak escarp
#

according to the artbook, Junkrat was just a demolitions guy

frosty shell
#

Oh I found a mention

limpid agate
#

Unexisting

frosty shell
#

Nevermind

limpid agate
#

Then re-existing

#

Which is only tangically "time travel"

#

But its effectively the same as Moira or Reaper

#

Unexisting, and then re-existing.

frosty shell
#

However, it doesn't say he was an alien

#

Just "more alien than human"

#

And he certainly isn't an alien now

placid fulcrum
#

it's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard

#

twisting words just for the sake of disagreement

limpid agate
#

I agree, Tracer is a silly "time traveller"

frosty shell
#

No

limpid agate
#

She has the persona

#

But doesn't do it

frosty shell
#

It's to explain why time travelling to try and stop the Omnic Crisis wouldn't fit the universe

limpid agate
#

Because she cant

#

Its also to explain why she cant just undo a bunch of things

#

Like Mondatta

#

She has control over her personal time

#

She cant control the universal time flow, and is still a slave to it

placid fulcrum
#

she can't. another character might. this is the universe with talking gorillas and hamsters that build robots

limpid agate
#

But she can control her own

#

Lack of disproof is not proof

frosty shell
#

Talking gorillas does not imply true time travel could exist

peak escarp
#

having a time traveller go back and undo the bad things is just lazy writing

frosty shell
#

They could add it in, I guess

limpid agate
#

Tracer is a one of a kind character, as far as we were told and led to believe.

frosty shell
#

But I'd.hate it

limpid agate
#

They could add it in just as they could add in a pyromancer who lived in the Earth's core for 20 years.

placid fulcrum
#

I mean that if these characters have not yet been introduced and I brough the idea up here, you'd argue that this also "doesn't fit the unvierse"

limpid agate
#

Its something that is technically not impossible, but is <1% likely to happen

#

Disproof is not proof.

#

You want to argue that someone who can rewind the world's time exists.

frosty shell
#

Wrecking Ball and Sigma were weird, but I'd never react with "that'd never happen"

#

I didn't think a hamster would happen, but only because I thought Hammond would be a chimp

placid fulcrum
#

something tells me you would, if it was me who brought up the idea

limpid agate
#

Ill argue that someone who can create stars out of cigars would exist. Its equally unlikely

peak escarp
#

it isn't about you

placid fulcrum
#

you guys are jsut arguing because you want to disagree with me, it's pretty obvious

limpid agate
#

No

frosty shell
#

No

limpid agate
#

Its because

peak escarp
#

we don't care who you are

frosty shell
#

We really don't

limpid agate
#

Lack of disproof

#

Isnt proof

frosty shell
#

You're just not very good at understanding the lore

placid fulcrum
#

you even deny that one of the early concepts for junkrat was an alien and try to twist the word to mean anythign other than what it obviously means

peak escarp
#

do you have a source for that?

frosty shell
#

They said he would be "more alien than human"

limpid agate
#

Uhhh

#

So?

frosty shell
limpid agate
#

Early concepts for this game were a different game

#

And also not canon

#

I dont see how this is relevant to the lore?

frosty shell
#

Which, yeah, doesn't mean he's an alien

placid fulcrum
#

fair point, but still "more alien than human" doens't fit the universe, does it?

limpid agate
#

Who cares

frosty shell
#

Not really

limpid agate
#

Not canon

#

Not relevant

frosty shell
#

He could've been a horrible mutant

placid fulcrum
#

relevant in the way that the devs are obviously flexible in their idea of what would fit the universe

limpid agate
#

Were*

frosty shell
#

Like how Roadhog was originally going to have a pig snout

limpid agate
#

Not are

#

That was before the universe existed

frosty shell
#

Yes, were

limpid agate
#

It now exists

peak escarp
#

those concepts were created before they even decided what the Overwatch universe would be

limpid agate
#

Those concepts are before Doomfist was even a character

#

He's now the main antagonist

frosty shell
#

When it was still Titan, they had no rules

placid fulcrum
#

prove to me that time travel is in their rules

limpid agate
#

What

frosty shell
#

I hope you nmean isn't

limpid agate
#

The burden of proof lies in the claim.

frosty shell
#

Otherwise you just completely changed your argument

placid fulcrum
#

you're the ones who claim it's not possible

#

so prove that to me

frosty shell
#

I can't prove it

#

Because I'm not Michael freaking Chu

placid fulcrum
#

my proof is that we already have a character whose backstory involved time traveling months into the future

frosty shell
#

O can't decide what is and isn't possible

#

Time travel into the future is nothing like the past

limpid agate
#

Okay. The counter point is she can't time travel

placid fulcrum
#

anymore

#

she did that one time

peak escarp
#

she couldn't control it

limpid agate
#

She can't time travel

placid fulcrum
#

did it once, might do it in the future

frosty shell
#

But that was into the future and she couldn't control it

limpid agate
#

You're trying to argue the semantics on if that's time travel

#

But fine, lets humour you

peak escarp
#

and being able to time travel but not control when or for how long seems like a really shitty superpower

frosty shell
#

If she wanted to time travel into the future, she could pull a Mei

limpid agate
#

Lets suppose that your idea is time travel

#

And its possible to go into the future

#

So okay

#

What does the 1 directional time traveller do

frosty shell
#

That's a much easier way

placid fulcrum
#

mei was literally there. she didn't disappear from the timeline, her body was there. not comaprable to tracer who traveled instantly

frosty shell
#

Not really

limpid agate
#
Lets suppose that your idea is time travel
And its possible to go into the future
So okay
What does the 1 directional time traveller do
placid fulcrum
#

the fact that you're arguing it's in any way similar means that i'm arguing with people who are either being deliberately obtuse or genuinely not very knowleadgable about what time travel means

frosty shell
#

It accomplishes the same purpose of skipping ahead, apart from maybe cryofreese being harder to maintain

limpid agate
#

You're just going to keep dodging the question

frosty shell
#

I know what time travel means

limpid agate
#

What does your 1 directional time traveller do

#

They can go forwards in time

#

Great

#

So what?

placid fulcrum
#

if it was possible for tracer, it's not a stretch that it's possible for somebody else.

peak escarp
#

it is possible for Tracer through a very specific set of circumstances unlikely to be repeatable

placid fulcrum
#

can you prove it?

limpid agate
#

Problem with that:

  • Tracer was the first and last person to fly the Slipstream
  • Tracer's condition was because she crashed the Slipstream
  • The Slipstream was a new technology
  • The Slipstream was abandonned
  • Winston invented the Chronal Accelerator specifically for Tracer
#

With this

#

It is nigh impossible for there to be a second Tracer.

#

The odds of it happening are negligible

peak escarp
#

sure it's possible someone else could figure out time travel through a different method, but it's not probable

placid fulcrum
#

the slipstream was officially abandoned, nothing stops a character like moira or sigma from continuing work on it's concept in secret

limpid agate
#

Okay

#

So what

#

What's your point

#

What is at stake

#

What is the goal you are trying to achieve

frosty shell
#

What does your 1 directional time traveller do

placid fulcrum
#

my only point is that it's within reason for a time traveling character to exist in this universe

frosty shell
#

You still haven't answered

worthy rose
#

We'd get a copy of Tracer, which makes it pointless, so it won't happen.

frosty shell
#

Traveling into the future is way different than the past

limpid agate
#

If you define time travelling as going into the future

placid fulcrum
#

that's like saying genji is a copy of hanzo

worthy rose
#

bruh

#

do they use the same weapons?

placid fulcrum
#

both a re ninjas with dragon powers

limpid agate
#

Its more like saying Moira is a copy of Reaper.

worthy rose
#

Tracer's kit is more centered around the accelerator

limpid agate
#

The Genji/Hanzo comparison was pretty terrible.

worthy rose
#

It would be more like making another character dual wielding shotguns or something.

limpid agate
#

That's also a terrible comparison

worthy rose
#

True

limpid agate
#

Its literally like saying Moira is a copy of Reaper.

placid fulcrum
#

says the guy from tracer/mei comparison, lmao

frosty shell
#

But both of them experience a huge time.jump

placid fulcrum
#

not really no

#

mei was asleep

#

might've been in a coma

#

wouldn't be a difference

peak escarp
#

from Mei's perspective, very little time passed at all

limpid agate
#

Your point at stake is not a point.

peak escarp
#

it was like taking a nap

limpid agate
#

You have nothing to prove

placid fulcrum
#

but it did pass

peak escarp
#

and?

limpid agate
#

"Tracer means time travel exists"
With your 1 directional definition of time travel, sure.

#

So what

#

"A second tracer could exist"
Incredibly extremely infinitely unlikely

#

Its borderline impossible

#

You want to see someone adapting time travel tech?

#

Sombra

#

There's your second time traveller

placid fulcrum
#

how do you cope with sigma's powers if your brain cannot handle the idea of a two-directional time travel?

limpid agate
#

She is capable of blinking out of existence

#

And re-appearing elsewhere

#

We havent seen the feats of appearing sometime else

#

But you could argue that it may not possibly be impossible for her to appear later than when she disappeared

#

Is it likely?

#

Not really

#

But there's your closest possible comparison to Tracer 2

#

Sombra maybe possibly

placid fulcrum
#

it's more than likely, it's canon

limpid agate
#

Source

placid fulcrum
#

she isntantly traveled months into the future

limpid agate
#

Source.

peak escarp
#

it never said that

#

it said she was missing for months

frosty shell
#

Apart from that "when" thing it didn't say that

limpid agate
#

Its a grey area

#

They didnt define it either way

placid fulcrum
#

"no one knew where - or when - i'd gone"

limpid agate
#

Correct

#

And

#

You're making an assumption

peak escarp
#

it's too vague to be certain of anything

limpid agate
#

There are 2 possibilities. Probably 3, but Ill point out the two big ones.
1 - Tracer was conscious during the time skip.
2 - Tracer was unconscious during the time skip.

#

The first one defiles your idea of time travel

#

The second favours it

#

We don't know which holds true

placid fulcrum
#

tracers consciousness has nothing to do with this

#

she could be unconscious but still in some place for 6 month, maybe asleep but still physically there

#

time travel would be if she instantly moved from one point in time to another

limpid agate
#

If she was consciously unexistent for 6 months

#

Then appears 6 months later

#

Did she really time travel?

#

Or did she simply just not exist in the physical plane

#

I suppose the 3rd point is:
3 - The time skip was instant

#

So your 3 possibilities are:

  • Conscious - Not time travel
  • Unconscious - Mei time travel
  • Instant - Time travel
placid fulcrum
#

the fact that her condition has "chronal" in it and time travel is repeatedly used in the description of her powers tells me that it's time travel pwoers not nonexistence powers

limpid agate
#

So

#

Baptiste has something called an immortality field

#

I doubt you could survive swallowing a grenade in it.

placid fulcrum
#

is the immortality field canon, or jsut for gameplay purpsoes?

limpid agate
#

Yes.

#

He used it in the short story

peak escarp
#

the pseudo-science explanation for Tracer's disappearance is that she was out of phase with the timeline, making her invisible

limpid agate
#

Resurrect is also canon.

placid fulcrum
#

because canonically ana's bullets don't magically decide whether to heal or harm based on her emotions towards the target, canonically she consciously swaps the bullet

limpid agate
#

Mercy used it in Zero Hour

#

But Mercy cannot bring back the dead.

#

The names are just names

placid fulcrum
#

she did canoncially though

limpid agate
#

No

#

She didnt

#

Mercy has never revived the dead.

frosty shell
#

You really don't understand the lore

limpid agate
#

Mei was not dead.

peak escarp
#

we are well aware of what abilities are/are not canon

placid fulcrum
#

then she didn't

frosty shell
#

Sorry I was being a bit hostile

placid fulcrum
#

you're the one who told me that she did

limpid agate
#

She did use resurrect.

#

It can't bring back the dead.

frosty shell
#

Mei wasn't dead

limpid agate
#

But the ability that is called "resurrect" was used by Mercy on Mei.

placid fulcrum
#

but it doens't cnaonically work as a resurrection

#

alright.

peak escarp
#

this is resurrect

frosty shell
#

Exactly

limpid agate
#

Names don't mean shit

peak escarp
#

she even says the voice line from the game - "Let's get you back in the fight."

limpid agate
#

Reaper isn't the Grim Reaper.

#

Spirit Dragons aren't actually made from spirit

peak escarp
#

it's functionally a burst of nanobiotic healing that gets someone who is incapacitated back on their feet

placid fulcrum
#

but tracer's powers are canonically linked to time travel. we see this outside the gameplay

limpid agate
#

With whatever semantic you want to argue about time travel

placid fulcrum
#

again "no one knew where - or when - i'd gone"

peak escarp
#

she travels along her own timeline, yes

limpid agate
#

She cannot go back in time.

#

And her being able to go forward is dubious

#

That's not a concrete source.

#

There are 3 possibilities about what happened over those months

#

1 is time travel, 1 is not time travel, 1 is debatably time travel.

#

We dont know which it is

#

Theyre all equally likely

#

But we cant assume which it is

placid fulcrum
#

she can't

#

I never said tracer could

#

another character might

limpid agate
#

Based on what

placid fulcrum
#

based on the fact that we get new heroes with new previously unheard of powers and weapons, and devices

limpid agate
#

That's not proof

peak escarp
#

okay, so another character might. so what? why bother debating something that may or may not happen?

limpid agate
#

Like I said

#

I can use that same piece of proof to say

placid fulcrum
#

I wonder that as well Doctor_Six

limpid agate
#

There is a pyromancer living in the core of the Earth.

placid fulcrum
#

why are you so admaant to argue that it's impossible

peak escarp
#

you're the one who brought it up

limpid agate
#

Just meditating for the past 10 years

#

Equally likely

#

To your backwards-in-time time travelers

placid fulcrum
#

I literally just said that it's possible for there to be a time-travelling character. and then you proceeded to argue with me over it for over an hour

#

why is that, I wodner?

limpid agate
#

Because you are arguing its possible for there to be a backwards in time time traveller

placid fulcrum
#

because it is

limpid agate
#

Source

peak escarp
#

a <1% chance is still positive possibility

limpid agate
#

Tracer is not a source

placid fulcrum
#

or even not a character, but a device that could do it

limpid agate
#

Neither is Sigma

#

Lack of proof isn't proof

#

Lack of disproof isnt proof either.

#

Your source is nothing

#

Because there is nothing

#

Its not worth discussing

placid fulcrum
#

is that's you philosophy, try to prove to me the existence of literally any character, weapon or ability not yet seen in the game

#

go ahead

#

I'll be waiting

limpid agate
#

There is 0 merit in arguing the existence of supernatural powers that do not yet exist in Overwatch.

placid fulcrum
#

time travel is not a supernatural power

#

it's physically possible in our universe

limpid agate
#

Is it a natural power?

placid fulcrum
#

is gravity a natural power?

#

is turning into ash a natural power?

limpid agate
#

In the sense of Tracer/Sigma/Reaper

#

No

#

None of them are.

placid fulcrum
#

yeah, but it's still there

limpid agate
#

They're the exception

#

Not the rule.

#

They've been defined.

#

And they exist.

#

You cant just exist that there is someone who can turn the blood in someone's veins into scissors

placid fulcrum
#

and if these heroes hadn't been introduced yet, and I brought up the possibility of them existing , you'd also argue with me for an hour

#

so what's even the point of me talking to someone who's obviously jsut disagreeing for the sake of disagreeing?

limpid agate
#

Or that there is a character who smokes cigars, and then blows out meteorites.

placid fulcrum
#

i'm wasting my time here

limpid agate
#

This is a discussion channel for the lore of Overwatch

#

You're coming in with unsourced bullshit.

placid fulcrum
#

I thought I could come here for nice lore discussions, not for petty arguments

#

sad to see I was wrong

peak escarp
#

you're not discussing lore that exists

limpid agate
#

You're free to speculate stuff so long as you have a proper source.

#

You do not.

peak escarp
#

you're going on about "what ifs"

limpid agate
#

Your source for your backwards-in-time time traveler is the same source I'll use to say that Kylo Ren exists.

placid fulcrum
#

you were the ones who started the discussion on potential new characters

limpid agate
#

Or a character with equal powers to Kylo ren

peak escarp
#

I did not

limpid agate
#

Not literally

placid fulcrum
#

you have no source for any new character or ability, why did you bother starting this discussion?

limpid agate
#

Kylo Ren

peak escarp
#

I only mentioned Helix

limpid agate
#

I'm ending this and moving on to something worthwhile

#

you were the ones who started the discussion on potential new characters

#

Great, lets look at that.

#

I want to see the return of Sven.

#

Potential for another builder character, as he is part of Ironclad (formerly)

#

Also from his upgrades to the Destroyer

#

We also saw him with a stun gun in the comic.

frosty shell
#

Yeah Sven could come back

limpid agate
#

So that could be an interesting weapon or ability.

peak escarp
limpid agate
#

I've gone off enough about Sanjay too

peak escarp
#

I still want Kimiko and Mirembe to make another appearance

#

maybe not as heroes, but they can be some of the support staff that comes back

limpid agate
#

You can remove Sojourn.

#

And add the cop from Zero Hour as Face Only, maybe.

#

I thought she was pretty impressionable, and she is a unique appearing fighter.

#

Much like the guy from Binary.

peak escarp
#

I liked her

limpid agate
#

I wouldnt say add the face to the reporter or girl though

#

They're civilians.

peak escarp
#

yeah

limpid agate
#

1 more

#

!!loreComics

twilit nacelleBOT
#

Comics:
Train Hopper: https://bit.ly/2vaOY0I
Dragon Slayer: https://bit.ly/2GpRZRk
Going Legit: https://bit.ly/2InZUkm
A Better World: https://bit.ly/2DeJGpK
Mission Statement: https://bit.ly/2UFLC5o
Destroyer: https://bit.ly/2XcYZ9G
Legacy: https://bit.ly/2DgM1jQ
Old Soldiers: https://bit.ly/2KLILTV
Junkenstein: https://bit.ly/2Is3WZ4
Reflections: https://bit.ly/2IoZQkr
Binary: https://bit.ly/2IzNvJy
Uprising: https://bit.ly/2UCymhE
Masquerade: https://bit.ly/2IzNTI0
Wasted Land: https://bit.ly/2DeKB9G
Searching: https://bit.ly/2Gh3jy6
Retribution: https://bit.ly/2XePmHG

Mini-Comics:
Return of Junkenstein: https://bit.ly/2Gqp7Z8
Yeti Hunt: https://bit.ly/2VPmxRI

peak escarp
#

no point in adding Hanan either

limpid agate
#

Made their escape

#

And hasnt appeared again yet

placid fulcrum
#

I'm interested in that omnic talking with doomfist

limpid agate
#

He's the leader of Null Sector

peak escarp
#

I also didn't have Fio on that list, since she hasn't been seen in present day

limpid agate
#

We should learn more about him in Overwatch 2.

placid fulcrum
#

hard to say if he could be playable

#

maximilian doens't strike me as a fighter, but this leader might be

peak escarp
#

I'd like Predator to be playable

#

mostly because we don't have any "bad guy" omnic heroes

placid fulcrum
#

Predator? who's that? I' don't see that name on the list

#

but yes, would be interesting to have a playable villain omnic

peak escarp
#

that's just what we call the mysterious omnic

#

it's faster to type (and he kinda looks like the Predator from the movies)

placid fulcrum
#

oh yeah, he really does

peak escarp
#

other names I've heard are MOE (mysterious omnic enemy) and Null Hector

placid fulcrum
#

"null hector" 😂

#

btw, i've been wondering something

#

so mnay characters have these lines on their skin, like they've been augmented in some way. and ana used to have a cybernetic eye. is there any human character who hasn't been augmented in any part of their body?

peak escarp
#

Ashe, Baptiste, Brigitte, D.Va, Hanzo, Lucio, Mei, Mercy, Pharah, Reinhardt, Roadhog and Zarya are all non-augmented humans

#

Roadhog is questionable, since the radiation may have augmented him

#

but the rest are definitely untouched humans

shrewd meteor
#

Pretty sure hanzo summoning dragons of light screams "augmented"

#

At least to md

peak escarp
#

well

#

we don't know exactly what they are/how the dragons work

#

I'll add Hanzo as questionable too

shrewd meteor
#

Solid light?

#

Just like symm

#

Maybe?

peak escarp
#

yeah, possibly

#

but the mechanism for releasing them could be implanted into Hanzo (making him augmented) or it could be part of his weapon

#

or some other unseen device

shrewd meteor
#

Well

#

His tattoo glows when he is about to use it

#

An implant?

frosty shell
#

In our other Discord server I pointed out that they might not be able to do any damage

shrewd meteor
#

It can get a 6k

#

Pretty sure it can

#

XD

peak escarp
#

we mean in canon

#

when Genji redirects it at Hanzo, it passes through him

#

they probably toned down the damage for the short, but he didn't seem that injured afterwards

shrewd meteor
#

Maybe it doesn't affect the original user

#

Safety mechanism

#

Or something

frosty shell
#

Possible

placid fulcrum
#

there's one detail in reaper's overwier that doens't make much sense

#

"Survivors have described a black shadow ghosting unscathed through the most hellish battlefields. The few bodies recovered of those he kills are pale, empty husks drained of life, their cells showing signs of intense degradation."

#

he never showed sings of being able to do this

valid terrace
#

He does it in Bastet

placid fulcrum
#

I must've missed it. interesting

valid terrace
#

Yeah it’s bad enough to overpower Soldier’s healing ability

#

Has there been any development on the nature or progress of Mei’s ecological meltdown?

#

Or is it just global warming or something?

#

Maybe it’s a pyromancer that’s been meditating in the Earth’s core for the last 10 years 🤔

#

Also have we ever seen the moon when it wasn’t full?

placid fulcrum
#

yup

#

we have, on the lunar base mission

#

you can see the earth, but not the sun, meaning the sun doesn't hit from the direction where from earth's perspective thew moon would be fully visible

valid terrace
#

Ah, you’re right

#

Didn’t think about that

placid fulcrum
#

huh, turns out moira was actually working with talon even before overwatch was disbanded?

#

so she was a traitor and a double agent all along

shrewd meteor
#

They should delv more into that

placid fulcrum
#

speaking of double agents, reaper might be one. his mask bears a strong resemblance to blackwatch's symbol, and I've seen someone speculate that the reason legends about "reaper" date back to when blackwatch was founded is because "reaper" was then just a codename for blackwatch operations, since they were supposed to be a secret. if that's true, then reaper is essentially "blackwatch: the person" now

#

there's also that one panel where doomfist wonder whether ana and soldier are still alive because reaper still has sentiment left for them

pliant sparrow
#

So is reaper an urban legend in the overwatch universe?

#

I can easily see many people being sceptic of his abilities but then again this is a much more advanced time

placid fulcrum
#

it seems this way

#

"Some speak of a black-robed terrorist known only as the Reaper. His identity and motives are a mystery. What is known is that where he appears, death follows."

shrewd meteor
#

I think it's a hereditary title

#

Much like doomfist

#

Because the experiments on gabriel were during his active duty in blackwatch

#

Which Moira participated in

#

Speculation only

pliant sparrow
#

But then where would he have inherited it from?

placid fulcrum
#

moira's paper was described as having been published "a decade" ago, so "reaper" existed at least 10 years before she became involved with reyes. but that doesn't mean he (or "they", if it's a codename)had superpowers then. may have been just a vigilante, dressed in black robe

#

in fact, is another reaper existed before blackwatch was founded, the blackwatch symbol could've been inspired by him

#

so in this scenario reyes killed this "reaper" but found his activities inspiring (because he didn't follow the rules, which allowed him more freedom), so he formed blackwatch and stylized it after the original reaper. after blackwatch's dissolution, he decided to become a reaper himself

alpine jackal
#

i believe reyes was always reaper in disguise

#

always a talon agent working behind the scenes

worthy rose
#

See that's where I disagree

#

Cause Jack Morrison joined the army at 18 and Reyes was in it since 20.
They've been nonstop fighting the omnic crisis and then became heads of OW and BW respectively. Both have been shown to be idealistic men who would do almost anything for peace and to make the world a better place. Saying this was a major long con is too big of a stretch given that kind of history.

alpine jackal
#

Then why did reyes turn?

placid fulcrum
#

I agree with kaeore. reyes doens't strike me as a traitor. if the legendary reaper was him all along, then he probably wasn't doing this on the orders of talon, but acting as a vigilante, much like soldier is doing now

alpine jackal
#

Overwatch fell, so he chose to become some soul-sucking terrorist who joined the organization he swore to destroy?

#

Something clearly happened that made him join Talon

placid fulcrum
#

I find that surprising as well

#

hence why I hope we'll get more backstory with overwatch 2

alpine jackal
#

Yep

#

2 things going on here: His hatred at Jack for his causes in Overwatch and Blackwatch's downfall, (as well as the war taking a toll on reyes) made him join talon only for that reason, or 2: Hes long conning Talon himself, while getting revenge on those that led to OW's / BW's downfall

#

I mean SOMETHING'S happened that made him turn, I really hope OW2 expands on that

placid fulcrum
#

I hope for 2. double agent reaper would be a great twist

alpine jackal
#

Something interesting yes. He hates jack and ana still, and wants revenge, but he still hates talon too

#

Hes serving himself

placid fulcrum
#

yup

#

probably will still die at the end if there ever is an end)

alpine jackal
#

Yea, although no clue if reaper can even age

placid fulcrum
#

a heroic sacrifice is his destiny

alpine jackal
#

yeah in a way

#

hes still a bad person imo, hes killed a LOT of people, but I believe he still will turn against talon

pliant sparrow
#

Reaper might be unkillable through most means short of vaporisation

#

He might also be unable to survive in a vacuum

peak escarp
#

I've been a fan of the "Reaper is an urban legend inspired by Blackwatch/Reyes" theory for a long time

pliant sparrow
#

Do we know if oxygen deprivation affects him?

#

I'm assuming it does since he's still made of cells

placid fulcrum
#

it's possible that his unstable condition will eventually kill him

edgy path
#

anyways.... we need teh lore of zen tho :C

peak escarp
#

why?

pliant sparrow
#

Zen doesnt have much relevance to anything going on except genji

grand wedge
#

Yet.

peak escarp
#

Zen will get lore when he is important to the story, in OW2

grand wedge
#

How the omnic and the Shambali will respond to Null Sector global threat? It’ll be really interesting

peak escarp
#

personally I don't find Zenyatta that interesting, but his story will include Genji, and I'm down for that

grand wedge
#

He is the character with less lore so it’s hard to find him interesting but I played him a lot and love him so that’s why I need more lore - and I bet a lot of people who play Zen feel the same

marble wigeon
#

Zenyatta fascinates me on concept but they really don't do anything with him

#

At least so far

grand wedge
#

And what is the Iris !!!

peak escarp
#

I play Zen all the time

#

I'm curious to know what Zen's purpose was before finding enlightenment, but that's about it

grand wedge
#

How did they break there programming to become sentient beings during the first crisis and decided to create a religion intrigued me

peak escarp
#

that's not specific to Zen, that's more worldbuilding

marble wigeon
#

I'm fine with them skimming past that tbh

#

How they became sentient isn't really a big deal to the world as is

peak escarp
#

they might not have an explanation for why

#

maybe they just did and nobody knows why

#

I just like the thought of pre-enlightenment Zen being a cashier or shop-bot or something

limpid agate
#

All I'm interested in is where he is from

peak escarp
#

like, what omnium?

shut stratus
#

like owu?

pliant sparrow
#

A character I really want to see more of is orisa

limpid agate
#

Like what country would be considered his origin

#

Like, is Bastion German or Swedish?

#

Or Orisa Numbani or Nigerian?

#

Is Zen Nepali, or something European?

#

I would say German, Numbani, and Unknown for those 3.

pliant sparrow
#

Do we know where numbani is on the map?

lean prawn
#

nigeria-ish

#

i think

pliant sparrow
#

Had a feeling it was somewhere in Western Africa

#

Hopefully my geography hasn't let me down there

limpid agate
#

Its presumably within Nigeria

peak escarp
#

its usually marked near/in Nigeria

#

its probably an independent city-state

grand wedge
#

Yes it’s world building but we have more chances to have this world building through Zen lore. I’d love to see were he was « born » too

pliant sparrow
#

Wonder if we'd get a story mission telling a characters backstory

#

Such as zarya fighting for Russia

#

Or if we'll get to fight the gwishin

peak escarp
#

probably not

#

story missions need 4 playable heroes

peak escarp
#

I do think we will get a mission against the Gwishin though, where some Overwatch heroes team up with D.Va

worthy rose
#

I'd rather get the MEKA heroes tbh

peak escarp
#

I doubt we'd get all 4 of them at the same time

#

maybe one

limpid agate
#

And hopefully that one is not Yuna.

#

D.Mon is the least interesting of the pack.

peak escarp
#

I'd like Overlord or Casino

dull olive
#

Do we know who made reaper?

#

Like at all?

shell jay
#

If they put MEKA heroes into the game they wouldnt be like D.Va where shes two characters, Mech and Person, because Blizzard said that that system was extremely hard to put in the game and should not be remade

#

Moira I think if you watch her origin story @dull olive

dull olive
#

Yeah that’s what I thought when I watched the origin stories

#

But I thought I read ages ago that mercey did

#

Have the lores changed?

limpid agate
#

@shell jay Not necessarily.

dull olive
#

I stopped playing for ages

limpid agate
#

@dull olive Mercy had nothing to do with Reaper

#

Never did

#

It was a common misconception.

#

Someone made a theory using fabricated evidence to say Mercy did it.

dull olive
#

My life is a lie

shell jay
#

Even though Reaper says "you tell me doc" when she asks "what happened to you?"doesnt mean she did that to him

#

I've assumed it was Moira due to the picture of her and Reyes in her Origin video

peak escarp
#

this is all the confirmation you need

shell jay
#

thank you I was trying to send it but I dont have permissions @peak escarp

peak escarp
#

any evidence pointing to Mercy's involvement was either completely fabricated ("don't forget, you're the one responsible for this") or subject to individual interpretation ("you tell me, doc")

#

it's also a misconception that Genji, Reyes and Jack ever actually died - they were all just near death or believed to be dead, but survived

valid terrace
#

Ana too if you want one that we knew about

peak escarp
#

those were just the three I've heard people say that Mercy resurrected

dusty cairn
#

But mercy's resurrection in lore isn't canon tho

#

they probably meant that she healed them when they were in a near death state

limpid agate
#

It is canon. But not how you think

#

She used it on Mei in Zero Hour

#

Mei was very not dead.

shell jay
#

Her arm was I'm going to guess broken or hurt so she was unable to move it

#

I don't know exactly how she healed it without her staff though

#

Maybe a new ability in Ow2

limpid agate
#

Its not a new ability

#

Its an existing ability

#

Its called Resurrect.

#

She healed Mei the same way she (presumably) self-heals

#

Suggesting that the biotic tech is integrated with her suit

shell jay
#

Oh, I didn't really think of that

#

I was just playing on Oasis University and in one of the spawns there was this big black spike ball that was being inspected by the bots, it looks somewhat important, is it just there for show or do you thi k it could be important

peak escarp
#

probably just for show

limpid agate
#

A ferrofluid or ferromagnetic fluid is a liquid that becomes strongly magnetized in the presence of a magnetic field.
A process for making a ferrofluid was invented in 1963 by NASA's Steve Papell to create liquid rocket fuel that could be drawn toward a pump inlet in a weight...

#

Hmmm

#

Random half-based speculation

#
  • Ferrofluid exists in University
  • Hamid Faisal is an Archeologist (Read: Scholar) with ties to Oasis
    Magnetism could be part of his kit?
#

They worked on Magnetism before with Hammond but didnt like how he did it

frosty shell
#

It could be part of the system Moira used on Reaper

limpid agate
#

Doubt it

#

Reaper predates Oasis as well

grave talon
#

ngl but Im very curious about what they plan to do with Sombra and esp Reaper

Thinking about it, imo Sombra seems very chaotic neutral. She seems to have the right mind with Taking Down People In Power Who Are Lying but shes too sarcastic to be a 100% good guy or have a complete affiliation.

And she seems to be in Talon for more access to info (and maybe even info on members in Talon) she doesnt even really take Reaper, a inner council member, that seriously and even lied to him and Widowmaker about Volskaya

As for Reaper I've seen some theories saying that hes brainwashed and ngl but I'm lowkey leaning towards that. As Gabriel he was all against Talon and now hes a inner council member of it. (Maybe Moira did a little bit more then just turning him into Reaper) I've seen some say that hes a double agent. And part of me is like yea maybe? He seems a bit too hellbent on killing all ex Overwatch members. Almost like hes been brainwashed or reprogrammed into it 👀

However, if he does come to his senses like "Hm. Maybe I should rejoin to at least take down Talon" Talon will def come after him. But how can you take down a guy who can just turn into a shadow and regenerate? Light. And by light, Moiras coalescence. Maybe Moira will take down her own creation?

Anyways, as for Sombra: will she join Overwatch? Will she become a double agent and give over info to Overwatch from Talon? Will she stay with Talon? Will she become her own affiliation?

And what about Reaper? Can he be cured? IS there a cure? (And by cure I don't mean like. making him 100% human again because I doubt thats possible at this point. At least making it so hes not in constant pain, or knowing what his condition is) Will he die? Who will kill him or how will he die?

Anyways I see we're discussing Reaper a bit and I'm curious and tbh kinda saddened by his story, and I've been Overwatch for about a month now n just kinda. wanted to share some things I've observed and kinda hyped about! :]

shell jay
#

Damn didn't expect to read a whole news article

#

But you make a good point

#

These are really good ideas, I think Sombra wants power for herself

#

Maybe just being her own person and not having to work for anyone like Talon or Overwatch

#

@grave talon

grave talon
#

Yea I def do think she may start leaning more towards that area. With Overwatch coming back and Talon probably going under fire from them again she may bail

shell jay
#

In Infiltration she went with her own thing and blackmailed Katya Volskaya which I believe isn't what she was supposed to do

#

She also keeps 'friends' like Katya most likely for her own personal need

grave talon
#

That wasnt to the plan at all either 👀
Also in one of the comics its revealed that Reaper knew this all along. Which makes me curious if Sombra does leave, maybe Reaper will had enough and go after her since he does seem annoyed by her from in-game voice lines

shell jay
#

I feel like Reaper would turn on Sombra very quickly judging by how much she annoys her, I can imagine him attacking her or something she did, it seems like no one in the talon members we have in game like her that much judging by in game voice lines

#

When widow kills Sombra she'll say "Big mouth, big target"

#

I'm not sure on Moira, Doomfist, and Sigmas thoughts on her

pliant sparrow
#

If reaper dies it'll probably be either his own ability that kills him, incineration or suffocation

shell jay
#

But it's clear to me Reaper and Widow dislike her