0xdeafcafe

[upbeat wagon]

Hi there

Which test card are you using?

We have a couple test cards that require 3DS every time, regardless of being set up previously

[crystal yacht]

Authenticate unless set up and Already set up are the two I'm using

These are the error's I'm seeing in Stripe when trying to charge the customer using the payment method that has a successful SetupIntent

[upbeat wagon]

Can you give me the PaymentIntent ID that hit that requires_action?

[crystal yacht]

yep

pi_3Ng5bdAJaOWIoiCJ2GWgiEwT

Thank you so much for looking into this so quickly, I really appreciate it

[upbeat wagon]

Happy to help

Taking a look at the PI

Okay

So you used the 4000003800000446 there

Which the description is: This card is already set up for off-session use. It requires authentication for one-time and other on-session payments. However, all off-session payments succeed as if the card has been previously set up.

Your PaymentIntent looks like a one-time on-session payment

Becuase you aren't passing off_session: true

Try passing that and let me know if it still moves to requires_action

[crystal yacht]

We aren't passing off_session in the payment intent, you're right 🤦‍♂️

We've run this code on production and it has worked which is super weird. I'm going to push this change and give it a test. Thank you!

[upbeat wagon]

Yeah that card is pretty particular

But also in production you do want to be passing off_session: true if the customer is not present

That will optimize the flow

[crystal yacht]

Yeah 100%, the engineer who wrote this must have just missed it out. Oh well, mistakes happen

[crystal yacht]

That all works perfectly. Thanks again for helping me with this - have a great day!