MarkoBoras

[dense rain]

What type of integration are you using now for Subscription? Subscription API or Checkout Session?

[robust timber]

checkout session

and billing portal

for subscription

[dense rain]

• failed checkout right now in checkout (user is trying to subscribe)
  For initial checkout, you can listen to checkout.session.completed event for subscribing successfully and fulfil the order. Or you can listen to customer.subscription.* events and check the payment_status. Is there any reason why you want to listen to failed payment for initial subscribing?

• payment is triggerred on renewal of subscription and it has failed because of insufficient funds
  You can listen to invoice.payment_failed event for the payment failure of a subscription

[robust timber]

invoice.payment_failed will trigger for failed renewal and for initial subscribing

right?

[dense rain]

Yup, if the payment failed for initial subscribing and in future billing cycles

[robust timber]

Is there something for grace period enabling

This is what I am using

but the problem is that payment retry is trigerring also in cases when user is trying to pay through checkout and it has failed

I only want this flow to start trigerring when renewal has failed

[dense rain]

Customer can try to pay until Checkout Session expires

By default, Checkout Session expires after 24 hours

[robust timber]

ok

Let me explain what I want to achieve then

and can you point me what to use or I am using the right thing

I want to give users who have already subscribed to plus plan grace period when their current subscription ends.
I want to send them 3 stripe mails that payment has failed and before every mail stripe automatically tries to charge them.

I am trying to achieve that through

Problem is that this is trigerred also for users who have free plan and their payment has failed on checkout because of wrong card

[dense rain]

I want to give users who have already subscribed to plus plan grace period when their current subscription ends.
If the subscription is going to end, what kind of grace period are you referring to?

I want to send them 3 stripe mails that payment has failed and before every mail stripe automatically tries to charge them.
It's not possible to set payment retry to only happen after payment method is collected again from the email

Problem is that this is trigerred also for users who have free plan and their payment has failed on checkout because of wrong card
Free plan should be with $0 and shouldn't be charged. The setting here only applies to recurring payment, not payment failure when signup the subscription via Checkout Session.

[robust timber]

Nice

didn't know this 'The setting here only applies to recurring payment, not payment failure when signup the subscription via Checkout Session.'

About your question 'If the subscription is going to end, what kind of grace period are you referring to?'

I'll implement custom logic where I'll leave him in app plus features in some period

and he'll get on his email

3 tiems like I've set there

will it work?

because your colleague has told me that these mail will not trigger in test mode

but in production on fail of recurring payment

[meager sundial]

Yes in test mode we don't send automatic emails.