Like the iron doors and trapdoors are
#gold doors and trapdoors should be opened only by redstone
last crag
Because it would be coherent if all mettalic door and trapdoor work the same
jade hemlock
Under what precedent?
Vanilla just has 1 type of metallic door
By that reasoning one could say that it would be coherent to have all doors function the same
last crag
Other mods which adds metallic doors and trapdoors tend to do it (Oreganized, Caverns and Chasms...)
jade hemlock
Too bad organized one is unique
I think my impl is more consistent than them because iron doors function different than wood doors so that is that is the precedent from where I drew my design decisin
It basically would imply that all materials of doors function differently
last crag
An alternate solution could be to make it work like copper doors from 1.21. They could be opened by both redstone and players.
jade hemlock
Which is also consistent with the pressure plate drawing a parallel there
Sure the addition of copper door makes things harder but doesn't fully get rid of that stuff since pressure plates exist too
Tho actually copper doors are unique too
They oxidate
So even in 1.21 it would be consistent
last crag
Since iron pressure plates are considered heavy, and golden pressure plate light (while in real it's the reverse, but whatever), it would make sense of gold door and trapdoor could be opened by both hands and redstone, like copper door and trapdoor do
last crag
I don't remember that they can be opened with redstone
jade hemlock
They can't be opened but interact with it
last crag
They should
jade hemlock
They act as a wooden door when unpowered and an iron door when powered
jade hemlock
They should
That would make them the same as wood doors. Pointless recolor, inconsistent for reasons above and wuld loose its unique functionality making it less useful in contraptions and such