little osprey
(Repost from questions-channel)
Hi there, I've just tested the Smarter Farmers mod (Fabric 1.21.1) and realized that they don't just plant crops on farmland, they sometimes just randomly plant crops on grass blocks around the naturally generated farmlands. Which leads to randomly growing crops throughout a village.
This issue has been around since 1.20.1.
An example image of the issue has been provided (the random spots of crops around the naturally generated farmland were planted by farmers).
Testing on a minimal instance now
quaint magnet
veryfy tags of tall grass. test without other mods and or in a place where NO tall grass is around
little osprey
Alright, I tested on a minimal instance, just Fabric API, Moonlight and Smart Farmers. The farmer I've watched is still doing it (proof screenshot provided below). There is no tall grass around. I've watched the farmer and he planted on a normal grass block with nothing else on it.
Tested on 1.21.1 Fabric
quaint magnet
2 things:
this was in 1.20 no?
is it using the vesion i just released? as ive said one from yesterday had precisely that bug
little osprey
This was also in 1.20.1 and is still in 1.21.1 now.
I'm using version 2.2.0 of Smarter Farmers.
quaint magnet
which is one from yesterday
little osprey
(That is the newest version available on modrinth)
Ah, I see I do have an old version. Gimme a minute, I'll check with version 2.2.1
quaint magnet
if the issue pertains to 1.20 test on 1.20
little osprey
Alright, I have tested the newest versions of both 1.20.1 and 1.21.1.
In 1.21.1, the issue appears to be fully resolved, at least the farmers didn't do that anymore during the time I watched them.
In 1.20.1, the issue also seems to be fully resolved - I must have been referring to an older version on 1.20.1 when I mentioned the problem. The farmers do still trample farmland here, though that is a different problem.
When I saw the issue on 1.21.1 version 2.2.0, I assumed it was never fixed, since I saw the same issue back then in 1.20.1. I assume it since had already been fixed and then just returned in 1.21.1, then was fixed again in version 2.2.1 yesterday.
Thanks for your support, and apologies for the false alarm 🙂
quaint magnet
the trampling i resolved in recent 1.21
little osprey
Yes, that is correct, they don't trample in 1.21.1
quaint magnet
its because in 1.20 its a forge only feature due to lack of api on fabric
i have however found a hacky workaround on abric that will likely work in most of the cases
little osprey
Sounds great ^^ Thanks for clearing that up!
quaint magnet
i might port that but 1.21 changed a lot and so might only port that change
be warned of mods that tag grass as crops
little osprey
👍 I'll check the newest version (2.2.1) on 1.21.1 now, to see if it works with my modpack. If the farmers be wacky again, I'll report back to ask about grass tags 🙂