#Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) (2025-2026)

1 messages · Page 5 of 1

misty smelt
#

Yeah it seems like cmu really emphasize whether you have the scores or not

hot seal
#

hm ok

misty smelt
#

issssssss alright

hot seal
#

aww

coarse hatch
#

yes this is good to add

#

it's definitely an acquired taste, ever for the most diehard nerds

cosmic crystal
#

I mean you self report though if you want your score to be considered

#

You don’t need to officially send in scores through college board for it to be considered

hot seal
#

yea theyre saying self report

misty smelt
#

yeah it's self report

quasi prawn
#

carnEDGEie mellon university

vague yoke
#

🙏

hot seal
sharp rover
#

is there a cmu 2030 server?

stone shore
vague yoke
hot seal
earnest jacinth
#

i am very happy with cmu

#

although i think its a lot more work than other colleges

#

based on what i hear

cedar turret
#

vs im in the studio till 2am

hot seal
#

😭

ocean garden
#

Not at all

ocean garden
thick quiver
#

how yall balancing classes with clubs/resaerch tho

astral thicket
ocean garden
#

Again I don't think the workload is a lot but this is all I've seen

#

Though art students may have different experiences LOL

thick quiver
#

im talking cs lol

ocean garden
gritty patrol
gritty patrol
#

Why are you up Spence

flat heron
#

is there no cmu bme

#

tf do i do if im bme major

hot seal
#

💀

hot seal
#

is there stats on accept vss reject

coarse hatch
#

you double it with another major in college of engineering

flat heron
#

🪦 my app is cooked then

#

i don’t got ece activities..

coarse hatch
ocean garden
ocean garden
flat heron
#

ima just do ece bro its ggs

#

carnegie mellon compouter 🥀

coarse hatch
ocean garden
#

I mean my friend is in chemE and he likes it

#

Though not interested in BME

coarse hatch
ocean garden
#

Maybe not the best authority ig

gritty patrol
#

are they on fast track?

#

like how long do they expect to grad

ocean garden
gritty patrol
#

probably haven't taken any of the chem e brutal classes then? 1st sem freshman

ocean garden
#

Yeah prob

gritty patrol
coarse hatch
gritty patrol
#

FCE

#

is capped at 25

coarse hatch
#

nono, i did 18620, 18622, 18623 + 2 geneds

coarse hatch
gritty patrol
#

Yea but you can only press up to 25

#

so 23 means most ppl pressded 25+

coarse hatch
#

:)

ocean garden
coarse hatch
ocean garden
#

What's IC

gritty patrol
#

also thats on you.

#

you took 3 phd level classes

coarse hatch
gritty patrol
#

actually that might be 700+ maybe its masters level

coarse hatch
ocean garden
ocean garden
gritty patrol
coarse hatch
gritty patrol
#

you getitng better now?

ocean garden
#

Do you actually make it

coarse hatch
#

i think im in the video somewhere

ocean garden
#

Oh okay

coarse hatch
#

came home an immediately got sick so lmfao

gritty patrol
coarse hatch
#

yeah i mean its pretty cool to learn an extremely large amount of information on how chips are produced in such an extremely short period of time

#

definitely very cool to have an understanding of how a computer is made from the base silicon

#

was not easy, and I don't recommend, but good experience to see how far i can realistically push myself

gritty patrol
#

I highly recocmend pacing your classes

coarse hatch
#

yeah i agree

earnest jacinth
#

legendary late semester lock in

gritty mirage
#

is a personal growth journey fine for the. 3rd essay

gritty mirage
#

😍😍😍

gritty mirage
#

i was gonna talk about how i lateen to the same song 30k times last year and the song profession kinda matches different points of my life

gritty mirage
#

herro

hazy bramble
#

am i cooked rd if two ppl in my school already got into ed for cs

#

😹😹😹😹

hot seal
#

uhh

#

am i cooked rd if i got deferred ed and more ppl in my school are applying rd for cs

hot seal
#

🙏

gritty patrol
#

It looks like they just plonked entire classes of bay schools in Gates

hazy bramble
#

💀💀💀😝😝😝😝

gritty mirage
#

liek growth or maybe liek a snippet of my life?

cedar turret
cedar turret
#

oh

#

i thought u meant common app

#

pick a super interesting fun fact or a topic you love to talk about and write about it

#

a lot of folks did that

gritty mirage
#

i see

#

does it gotta be about me?

#

or can it be about naything

gritty mirage
#

or should I pick like a subject or niche interest

boreal agate
# cedar turret do not add anything unless there was no space in the app to do it, for example y...

like if my website and research were a big part of my app can i put links to both or is that tacky? It said to put any "qualifications"..

Ngl I feel personally without that they dont have any real evidence I did anything (particularly for the website). but i have no clue if its a good idea or not, or if it will be interpreted wrongly 🤷‍♂️

And one paper from my research is still under review for the conference it was submitted to (So i linked the preprints on arxiv)

gritty mirage
#

icl if its a website

#

they should just be able to find the url

boreal agate
#

i mean its a personal website with my github projects and like 40 of my graphic designs

gritty mirage
#

oh

#

on me

boreal agate
#

My linkedin is the first that comes up for my name and it has the website too but im not going to bet on them searching for it

gritty mirage
#

how i see it is they will see it and either a) beleive you on the spot no questiosn asked or b) be hesitant and dig for liek 5 minutes nad find it

#

so either way youre probably good

boreal agate
#

I think it gives me more credibility (I submitted my ea apps without any of this cursedmoon )

boreal agate
#

Even if they dont click it its the fact i was confident enough to add them

#

ig

boreal agate
# gritty mirage where ea?

Umd and stanford, and I applied to UCs
My research was at one of the UCs and I worked directly with a professor. I mentioned that and im not concerned about the verification at all

#

But no evidence of my website 😭

gritty mirage
boreal agate
#

Maryland

gritty mirage
#

i se

boreal agate
#

Chudputer science cursedmoon

#

Its close to home for me

gritty mirage
#

😭

#

brutal bro

boreal agate
#

everyoe say its chopped

gritty mirage
#

would they reject you if you looked like jordan barrett

boreal agate
#

😭

#

I ain tryna get a job tho. Im tryna go to grad school and teach

#

but it still might be cooked 😔

gritty mirage
#

ngl sounds liek a dram but then i check my bank accoutn forf the crisp 200 dolla rpaycheck

boreal agate
#

its ok ill just do day trading to pay for Grad School

gritty mirage
#

aight bro

#

atp whats the point of grad school

boreal agate
#

going into research

#

More qualified for any education position

gritty mirage
#

i guess yeah

boreal agate
#

Idk what else

#

My dad got a job then left it then did grad school so idk

#

Now he teaches

#

Might be the method if im broke after college

gritty mirage
#

Consider your application as a whole. What do you personally want to emphasize about your application for the admission committee’s consideration? Highlight something that’s important to you or something you haven’t had a chance to share. Tell us, don’t show us (no websites please).

for this prompt what should I talk about

#

a specific moment in time that made me realzie something

#

a short personal growth trip?

#

or

lavish jolt
#

i just talked about one of my hobbies lol

#

i think anything will work as long as the essay lets aos know a little more about who you are

fringe badge
#

yea

gritty mirage
#

huge

gritty mirage
#

youa re wasting an entire years worth of tuition in applications

#

are youc razy

fringe badge
#

not half a year, plus it’s worth it for anyone entering the most crucial four years of their life

#

Education is priceless

lucid valve
#

Unless it’s for like design/art or somethn like that I think

#

Idk

stone shore
gritty mirage
#

is that a big thing i should bring to light in my app?

lucid valve
#

Lot of working together

#

Idk 😭

boreal agate
hot seal
#

it says no links in the 3rd essay but i put some in common app add info

boreal agate
#

Yep

lucid valve
#

Ahh valid

robust creek
#

Pls CMU let me in rd

hot seal
#

fr

coarse hatch
#

man everyone seems confused by this 3rd supp

#

personal stories or realizations probably go better in other sections (in my opinion) but you can pretty much put whatever here

#

i ended up writing about a project idea that i had, and basically walked through how I'd make an immunocompromised plant for immunocompromised patients. i never ended up doing the project (might get to it this sem since ill have time) but the point was to illustrate my thought process and even moreso my curiosity

my situation was unique as i was in the hospital at the time of writing the essays. but you should be able to take similar ideas and apply these to your supps

#

consider how your application looks, and what impression you'd like to give to anyone reading your application, and use this supp to fill that out

cosmic crystal
#

I think the last 1/3 is anything a branch of ur commapp essay didn’t is good?

#

Like if personal essay was about community, the anything supp can be about intellectual vitality

#

Idk that’s what I’m thinking

gritty mirage
#

i cant lie that doesnt make sense

coarse hatch
gritty mirage
#

ohhh

gritty patrol
#

As in at the uni? Or in chat

#

First one yes but not as much as the other way round

#

Since Pitt has better parties/ life etc (practically everything afaik except Student org funding) People generally prefer to walk to Pitt

flat heron
#

how easy is it to switch majors at cmu?

#

(i.e. bio to mechE)

hard jay
# flat heron (i.e. bio to mechE)

I'm pretty sure it depends personally I haven't been through the process, but generally it's kinda hard to switch between schools like for bio to mechE it's MCS to CIT

#

Within college it is relatively easy

flat heron
hard jay
#

that might work

#

it's easy to get an additional major in any school even if it's not urs

flat heron
hard jay
#

im not familiar with our majors but yeah if that's a second major

#

you can do that

#

Ur primary just has to be in ur college

#

then you can add wtv u want lmao

flat heron
#

dangg im torn

#

cuz i rlly wanna study engineering

#

but i know im not getting in cuz all my ecs are bme

#

technically computational bio is best but thats in the school of CS 💔 i am not getting into cmu cs

hard jay
#

oh rip

#

hey u can take a comp bio additional

#

you learn nearly just as much

#

like evidently an additional is pretty much the primary but u don't got the school's gen eds

#

yeah liek looking at the primary versus the additional ur just losing out on some electives which i mean nothing is stopping u from just taking extra electives lmao

desert agate
#

i wanna do electrical engineering but i go to a tech school so i was never able to do a physics or foreign language class

#

am i cooked?

gritty mirage
#

it seems that cmu has a focus on collaboration. Should i talk about collaboration in multipel supps, or use another supp for a different value that carngie has

coarse hatch
# flat heron (i.e. bio to mechE)

it used to be harder i believe, i know one of the first transfers from mcs (physics) into college of engineering (ece) that happened in a few years. the year after there were more and i know others have transferred from tepper business as well, it should be getting marginally easier

#

intracollege is still an order of magnitude easier, however specifically it's getting harder for other majors within college of engineering to switch into ece

coarse hatch
desert agate
#

I’m also planning on doing physics as a dual enrollment class this coming semester

#

alongside trig and stats

coarse hatch
#

yeah I'm not sure how much foreign language will matter, but if you don't have physics somewhere on the transcripts you'd likely be cooked

desert agate
#

I technically have half a year of foreign language from 9th grade

#

I think I could explain why I don’t have all the required courses tho

#

I go to my tech school half the day so I only have like 5 classes on a regular day. cause of my district having a lot of required classes I don’t really get to do any electives or extra sciences/maths at my main school

#

For my sophomore I literally have six classes on my transcript lol

tranquil jasper
#
poll_question_text

ED 1 results?

victor_answer_votes

12

total_votes

23

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

Deferred

hot seal
#

violet hatch
#

yo

sick tinsel
#

Yo twin

gritty patrol
#

👀

robust creek
#

AHHHH

hot seal
#

bro got retriggered

robust creek
hot seal
ocean garden
#

You should apply

ocean garden
#

(I am not diverse at all relative to the CMU population)

lethal pike
#

do they not admit by major in SCS

#

why is HCI in scs im so cooked

lavish jolt
#

i also applied to hci 😔

stone shore
#

At least bro is not a bay area Asian

ocean garden
#

Everyone enters as SCS Undeclared

ocean garden
#

That's just cuz I'm from Florida though 💀

stone shore
#

I'm so sorry for your unfortunate upbringing in Florida

ocean garden
robust creek
#

im from seattle my geographic diversity is cooked

lethal pike
robust creek
#

🐶

ocean garden
#

You don't declare major until sophomore year

#

I'm technically undeclared rn

stone shore
#

bro was not paying attention during FIC smh

ocean garden
stone shore
#

fair enough

#

I did not have neither

#

nope

ocean garden
#

I never did comp math and I am usaco silver

lethal pike
#

ic

stone shore
#

silver shitters unite

lethal pike
#

were ur ecs cracked

ocean garden
#

Idk

lethal pike
#

hmm

stone shore
#

eh no idea

ocean garden
#

You can't really predict college apps lol

#

There's so many factors

lethal pike
#

hmm

ocean garden
#

And many don't even depend on you

lethal pike
#

but competing with scs kids

ocean garden
#

It's just what the school wants at the moment

lethal pike
#

is everyone very cracked there

stone shore
#

for example I wrote the most dogshit essays known to man 😭

ocean garden
#

I also don't ask random people for their college application 😭 🙏

lethal pike
#

fair

ocean garden
#

People do seem very passionate though

lethal pike
ocean garden
#

And that thing varies a lot

#

But that seems consistent across CMU

lethal pike
#

ah ok

fringe badge
#

One of my essays was lowkey controversial 🗿

gritty mirage
#

does cmu admit for major?

fringe badge
#

School

ocean garden
#

And CFA?

gritty mirage
#

is ca grouped with engineering

#

cs

ocean garden
gritty mirage
#

is cmu engineering or cs more comp

ocean garden
#

Idk less popular engineering majors def less comp than cs though

lethal pike
gritty mirage
#

massive

lethal pike
#

id say cs is more competitive than the most popular engineering majors such as ece

gritty mirage
#

im applying engineering

#

😄

#

chem

#

oh

#

im applyincv he/mech

#

chem/mech

lethal pike
#

nice

gritty mirage
#

!

lethal pike
#

i mean eng is comp but not as

#

lesser than cs for sure

cedar turret
#

no one in my dept, dorm floor, or people i’ve met in general live in florida

#

except me

novel rose
#

Does CMU have any sort of maker portfolio thing for SCS applicants?

coarse hatch
#

oh wait not what you meant by comp

#

cs is definitely more competitive

coarse hatch
novel rose
gritty mirage
#

you good no worrries

ocean garden
ocean garden
#

I can count the number of people I know from Florida on one hand

violet hatch
coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

If Im usaco platinum do you think i should apply directly to SCS?

#

My friend at SCS told me i should apply to MCS for physics first if i want to maximize my odds of getting admitted

coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

It only asked me if i wanted consideration for fine arts lmao

coarse hatch
#

huh i guess they've changed it

violet hatch
#

Did u apply directly to cmu for ece

coarse hatch
#

yup

violet hatch
#

Is ece within CIT?

coarse hatch
#

for mcs -> scs transfer you do have to do basically a years worth of CS courses and maintain good grades in those courses + generally and then transfer might be ok

coarse hatch
coarse hatch
#

just don't fuck it up

violet hatch
#

Is it bad if my school has a complete different curriculum than the ap

#

And i cant get cred for csa

coarse hatch
#

thats annoying because your credits will likely not transfer

#

you'll have to either test out of stuff and take harder courses later to make up for it, or redo a bunch of beginner content

#

its really annoying, none of my credits could transfer so i had to test out of a bunch of stuff

coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

Oh

coarse hatch
#

intro courses for programming here are in python and C

violet hatch
#

So i just have to get a 4.0 in the cs courses my freshman year

#

And im basically set for the internal transfer

coarse hatch
# violet hatch So i just have to get a 4.0 in the cs courses my freshman year

Non-SCS students

CMU students in majors outside of SCS can apply for transfer into the Computer Science major or a dual degree in Computer Science. Students considering a transfer or dual degree are expected to earn at least a 3.6 QPA in 15-122, 15-150, 15-210, 15-213, 15-251 and 21-127, and have an overall 3.0 QPA.

#

from the website

violet hatch
#

But it’s much harder to get a 3.6 in college right

coarse hatch
#

usaco plat in what field?

violet hatch
#

Compared to hs

violet hatch
#

Cpp

coarse hatch
#

oh ic i am dumb

#

just seeing how much that knowledge would apply to these classes

violet hatch
#

It’s basically algorithms

#

Dp, heaps, binary tree etc etc

coarse hatch
# violet hatch But it’s much harder to get a 3.6 in college right

15-122 isn't too bad, standard intro to C with some DS and algo, 15150 is functional programming (weird inbetween of theory and fp basics), 15-213 is intro to systems (not too hard just some basic interaction with low level C and OS fundamentals), 21-127 (intro to proof based mathematics, 21-128 is also an option that is more rigorous and may be more interesting if you already have experience here), 15-251 is ideas in theoretical computation (extremely math heavy understanding of the reductions, complexity, different ideal computation models), 15-210 is basically advanced algorithms and algorithmic complexity study (this is an in a functional programming language which makes it hard to write, but easy to analyze complexity)

#

usually people find 15-251 or 15-210 the hardest, but this depends on the person

violet hatch
#

So i need the credit for all of those courses?

#

6 cs creds

coarse hatch
#

yeah 3.6 average in all of those

violet hatch
#

How long will it take for me to finish all of them?

#

A year?

coarse hatch
sick tinsel
#

im ngl if i dont get in cmu, imma apply for a transfer all 4 years

violet hatch
#

So like for freshman and sophomore year ill prob stay in MCS then junior year i can switch out to SCS

coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

What if I fail to get that GPA?

#

Do i have to stay in MCS?

coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

I like physics but im only applying as that because i fit the major very well and its less comp

#

Like cs/meche is prob the most direct alignment w my profile

#

Most of my schools im applying as a physics major and i regret applying directly to cornell engineering ed cuz i got deferred

coarse hatch
#

i know people who transferred from physics to ECE but they did that super early on. if they didn't do it as early graduating on time may not have been possible

violet hatch
coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

What about internships?

#

If I want a swe internship won’t i be at a disadvantage?

coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

Should i try to get a quant internship then?

#

Because physics aligns w quant pretty well

#

And i know cmu feeds into those quant firms pretty well

coarse hatch
#

i think quant is more selective, i've heard that they focus much more towards the CS majors, with some ECEs getting hired for fpga stuff

#

quant is weird tho

violet hatch
#

Yeah quant is def more selective

coarse hatch
#

if you're good, they'll want you

violet hatch
#

I really want uchicago because they’re super flexible w major declaration and stuff

ocean garden
coarse hatch
violet hatch
ocean garden
#

Ohh okay

#

Isn't there a giant Google doc about that lmao

#

Lemme find it

coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

Im trying to play it safe because i know that MCS is def way less competitive considering my fit+applicant pool

#

And i want to increase my odds of actually getting admitted to cmu

ocean garden
#

@coarse hatch did you apply ED?

#

Wait wrong ping

#

Mb

#

@violet hatch

violet hatch
#

I got deferred ed to cornell engineering

ocean garden
#

You haven't applied to cmu then?

violet hatch
#

No first time

#

About to submit my app tmr tho

ocean garden
#

Just apply to SCS then

violet hatch
#

But i have to re-do my why major essay and i feel like my major essay for physics is really good

ocean garden
#

I don't think it's worth it to apply mcs if you're just gonna transfer to SCS

violet hatch
#

The admit rate for scs is like 6%

ocean garden
ocean garden
violet hatch
#

My friend at SCS told me he knows hella people who did it tho

coarse hatch
#

yeah like its sucks beans to do

ocean garden
#

I think you basically have to speedrun the whole CS core and do much better than the average SCS student in it

violet hatch
#

But sansk you have to understand that im basically risking my chances of admissions to CMU by applying to SCS

ocean garden
#

And you won't have any reservations for classes or anyone to advise you

violet hatch
#

What about from CMU MCS TO CIT?

coarse hatch
violet hatch
#

But I personally feel like the only reason I would go to cmu is for their cs program like I would hate to stay as a physics major

ocean garden
#

It's really hard to transfer

violet hatch
#

As much as i like physics the job market is absolutely cooked for phys

coarse hatch
#

CIT is going through some restructuring and transfering to cit is possible but you're advisors will be as annoying as possible about it

#

also if you do it late, you're not going to grad on time

#

or take any of the actually good courses in the majors

ocean garden
#

Transferring within CIT is annoying lol

#

So many CIT people are tryna transfer to ECE

coarse hatch
ocean garden
violet hatch
coarse hatch
#

like if you want to get the most out of the degree you have to direct apply

#

bro shits expensive

violet hatch
#

That is true

ocean garden
#

That's 90k more 💔

coarse hatch
#

generally people want to get out early with transferred credits

violet hatch
#

Cant i test out of some of those courses tho?

ocean garden
#

Not really lol

coarse hatch
#

you'll have to take other classes to cover for those units if test out. and you can only test out of like 15-112

ocean garden
#

In math, there is an exam but it's usually just to get into a harder class

#

If you wanna actually skip like 15151 or smth

#

There's only like 2 or 3 people who do that

violet hatch
#

Ill probably choose a school where doing an internal transfer is the most streamline

#

Like uchicago is currently #1 on my list because they dont have specific “colleges” within the school

coarse hatch
#

like i'd only do this path if you want CMU to be more a backup

ocean garden
#

If you actually wanna go to cmu, apply SCS

violet hatch
coarse hatch
#

yeah

ocean garden
violet hatch
#

I would prob choose cmu over public flagships tho

ocean garden
#

A lot of college apps is based on fit

violet hatch
#

I have a pretty big olympiad background but at the same time SCS is just too competitive

#

I really dont wanna risk yfm

#

MCS is ~20% and SCS is ~6%

#

And the applicant pool for SCS is prob even more cracked

ocean garden
#

Going in with a major you don't want to do expecting to transfer to SCS is already a big risk

violet hatch
#

Cmu scs is way too risky

#

Mcs is the most realistic path for me

ocean garden
#

If it's a backup, what's the harm in not doing SCS

violet hatch
#

I skimmed it yeah

violet hatch
#

I wouldnt call scs a backup at all

#

Getting into cmu for scs is basically getting into an ivy rd

#

I’m applying to 25 schools

coarse hatch
ocean garden
#

I know plenty of people who didn't get into Georgia tech but got into cmu scs

violet hatch
coarse hatch
#

with usaco and olympiad stuff you already make a pretty good candidate, cmu loves yall

ocean garden
#

Also lowk physics isn't even really a cs-adjacent major

violet hatch
ocean garden
#

Most people ik who thought SCS would be too hard go into like ece, math, statml, etc

ocean garden
coarse hatch
#

your likely to have plenty of other backups, just aim high for scs ngl

violet hatch
#

After getting deferred from cornell engineering i really dont want to risk applying straight for the #1 major

#

Like i felt distraught for a week after that

coarse hatch
#

frankly its not a risk, more an opportunity

violet hatch
#

From what I have heard, the transfer process is hard but still very possible tho

ocean garden
#

I got rejected from Cornell bro and I didn't even apply engineering 😭

ocean garden
#

Though my essays showed that I hated Cornell lowk

violet hatch
#

My college counselor convinced me that I should apply as an planetary science major/ physics for alls chools

coarse hatch
#

what

#

are they actively trying to make you fail

ocean garden
violet hatch
#

Dang

violet hatch
#

There is a pretty good alignment w physics

#

Usa physics olympiad and other research that aligns w physics

ocean garden
#

I had meteorology research as my #1 ec but didn't apply to meteorology 💔

ocean garden
#

Because I wanted to do CS lol

violet hatch
#

U applied as a cs major for all schools?

ocean garden
#

Yeah

violet hatch
#

Dang

#

Balls of steel

coarse hatch
#

yeah pretty much all my ecs were random CS things, but i applied ece regardless

violet hatch
#

Unlike you guys

#

Im very scared of this entire process

ocean garden
#

I think I had like 1 or 2 cs ecs

violet hatch
#

And i have nightmares of getting rejected everywhere

ocean garden
#

Don't worry about the outcome too much

violet hatch
#

Idm being a physics major but ill never find a job lmao

coarse hatch
ocean garden
#

If you're good at olys, you'll prob be fine wherever you go too

gritty mirage
#

electrical engineering?

errant cedar
#

hi guys i was wondering if internal transfer from cmu dietrich to mcs is hard

gritty patrol
errant cedar
gritty mirage
gritty patrol
errant cedar
gritty patrol
#

Econ is in tepper?

errant cedar
gritty patrol
#

Shouldn’t be easy but also not impossible regardless

stone shore
vernal sparrow
#

i got deferred 🙃

stone shore
#

bum school bro

#

who makes you write a 650 word essay

vernal sparrow
#

they need a bunch of glaze

ocean garden
violet hatch
#

cmu has been submitted

#

🤞

lethal pike
#

why r they telling us to write a second commonapp essay

narrow gale
#

Can someone help me decide between Discrete Math and Logic (Mathematical Sciences specialization, in the College of Science) or Logic and Computation (Philosophy specialization, Dietrich)?

Pros for Discrete Math and Logic:
-More depth electives in math, as far as I can tell.
-Harder math courses, if I'm understanding correctly
-Mathematical Sciences probably looks better on a resume
-Not sure how gen-eds work but I'm only interested in very specific humanities (philosophy and linguistics) so College of Science might be a better fit?

Pros for Logic and Computation:
-I do like philosophy and linguistics a lot tho and want to minor in linguistics, so Dietrich might be a better fit?
-Admit rate higher

gritty mirage
narrow gale
gritty mirage
narrow gale
gritty mirage
narrow gale
#

aight thanks

gritty mirage
#

youlll still probably have a lot of math courses that intrue you

#

intrigue

vernal sparrow
ocean garden
#

Ohh they're asking what to apply to

#

I thought it was minor

narrow gale
#

but I need to apply to a college/department

ocean garden
#

You can take the philosophy courses as a math major too btw

#

Dietrich courses are basically open to everyone

narrow gale
# ocean garden Are you more interested in philosophy or math

so i'm operating off assumptions here but I'm more interested in the other stuff the department of philosophy has to offer (that being linguistics, formal logic stuff, category theory) and less interested in "pure" philosophy (ethics and such) but still somewhat interested.
when it comes to math i'm mostly only interested in discrete math and stuff that intersects with theoretical cs and/or philosophy (i.e. logic, automata, data structures, category theory, game theory etc) and not too interested in higher pure math beyond that (i.e. analysis).

#

my main concerns are to do with Dietrich's gen ed compared to College of Science, acceptance rates, and how the degree will look on a resume

ocean garden
narrow gale
#

thanks

ocean garden
#

And plenty of math majors take category tjeory

narrow gale
#

yea i suppose i could just apply college of science and consider a linguistics minor

lavish jolt
#

submitted my app happythumbsup

lethal pike
#

hi guys

dull meteor
#

Should you only submit 2 letters of rec to CMU

lethal pike
#

any tips for essay 3

dull meteor
#

Because they only read 2 right?

lethal pike
#

?

lethal pike
dull meteor
#

they won't read the third?

lethal pike
#

there is no harm in sending if u have one tho?

dull meteor
#

even though common app allows it?

lethal pike
#

they wont

#

they said

dull meteor
#

so yeah

lethal pike
#

they will not consider for application

#

they might read it

dull meteor
#

i dont want them to spend time

lethal pike
#

mostly not

dull meteor
#

on the other rec i guess

lethal pike
#

they wont consider ur 3rd into decision

dull meteor
#

so i won't submit 3

hazy bramble
#

submitted my app yesterday 🤧

small fog
#

hello

#

did anyone pick information systems as their major

dreamy magnet
#

hi, would anyone be willing to review my cmu essays 🙏

gritty patrol
dreamy magnet
#

i forgot to update he roll 💀... i am senior

sick tinsel
#

does the cmu portal allow u to send resumes or research abstracts chat?

hot seal
#

no

sick tinsel
#

dang it

flat heron
#

how do you answer the additional info question?

sour kelp
flat heron
#

is it okay if you structure it like a story?

#

or does it have to be straightforward more like a uc essay?

#

looking at the examples, it seems i can put my community essay here

#

but not sure

sour kelp
#

i dont think theres a "right" CMU way

#

I tell a story, but within the story there's lessons i learn, what i do ,etc.

flat heron
#

is half of the essay story and the other half about cmu?

#

or like what youve learned

sour kelp
#

UC essays at least imo are more like here's what i did, here's what i felt, here's what ill do and way less "creative" imo

sour kelp
flat heron
#

did you write a completely new essay

#

or reuse another prompt

flat heron
#

does "tell us, dont show us" mean no stories or is it chill

lavish jolt
#

stories are fine, they just don’t want links to stuff

ocean garden
#

Well my diversity essay

#

Its basically an open space for any essay you want

#

One that shows smth that the other essays haven't already showed

#

Don't overthink it

flat heron
# ocean garden Well my diversity essay

got it, but my community essay's last paragraph is like "at [college], i plan to do the same, taking advantage of ..." so do you think its chill if i still add specifics for cmu

lethal pike
#

like

#

do you write it like a normal essay

#

or say like say it directly

#

also by Tell us, don’t show us do they mean just abt the no website links etc or the writing style aw like tell,not show

ocean garden
ocean garden
lethal pike
#

idk

ocean garden
ocean garden
ocean garden
#

It's just a space to put another essay which shows another part of you

cedar turret
#

i applied the night before the deadline

hot seal
#

WHAT

cedar turret
#

i made a template essay to submit to all the schools that covered the why us part

#

and a few other templates

hot seal
#

cool

cedar turret
#

my template was kinda shit looking back at it but apparently it worked!

hot seal
#

lowkey that makes me feel like bad if ive been working on it and planning to apply for a long time and i dont get in

cedar turret
#

it’s really good to spend time on the essays

#

and produce something you’re proud of

hot seal
#

yes precisely im not, i got deferred ed

cedar turret
#

ok good

hot seal
#

and i didnt particularly produce smth i was proud of

#

looking back

#

my writing got better

ocean garden
#

I didn't really want to go to CMU when I applied

#

Then I researched more after I got in and liked it

hot seal
#

loll real

#

the more ik abt scohols like when im doing why us the more i wanna go

ocean garden
#

And I wasn't expecting to get in 💀

#

I just applied just because

cedar turret
#

but then got denied

#

so now i’m here

hot seal
#

wth

#

dang

ocean garden
cedar turret
# hot seal wth

you’ll find a good majority of the school didnt want to originally come to cmu

#

i absolutely love it here

#

but originally i didn’t want to come

hot seal
#

i didnt know much abt it then i loved it while applying then i became nonchalant when after i got deferred

cedar turret
#

fair

#

it has a lot of pros and a lot of cons

#

mostly the food

#

i fucking hate the dining halls after a semester

#

compared to pitt

hot seal
#

i like my food

cedar turret
#

@ocean garden do you like rip off panera

#

or rip off panda express

ocean garden
#

Is that abp and hunan

cedar turret
#

or my personal favorite: pizza place that raises the price for lunch vs dinner but gives the same amount of food

cedar turret
ocean garden
cedar turret
ocean garden
ocean garden
#

Is this crisp n crust or the edge

cedar turret
ocean garden
#

It's always 2 slices per block though right

cedar turret
#

10 dollars vs 13.50 dollars for 2 slices

ocean garden
#

Oh wait yeah block price changes

#

Wait they change it on the retail menu too??

cedar turret
ocean garden
#

Bro 💀

#

I'm not getting a meal plan next year 🙏

cedar turret
#

i hate chartwells

ocean garden
#

At least there's variety

#

I just keep cycling through

#

Or I just spam tahini lmao

cedar turret
ocean garden
#

Are there really any weed out courses though

#

It's a weed out university

novel rose
#

Lmao

sick tinsel
#

Cmu is like the goat of all enginnering universities

lethal pike
#
  1. Many students pursue college for a specific degree, career opportunity or personal goal. Whichever it may be, learning will be critical to achieve your ultimate goal. As you think ahead to the process of learning during your college years, how will you define a successful college experience? (300 word maximum)

this essay shouldnt connect to past stuff right?

#

or should it

sour kelp
lethal pike
#

its quite broad and step-back kind of thing

sour kelp
tepid rose
#

hello all, was wondering if SCS considers your intended major during admissions? ie would they be looking at pure cs vs comp bio the same during admissions or nah

stoic relic
cedar turret
#

3 big ones

stoic relic
#

wait @cedar turret if u know the answer u can answer too sorry for ping 🙏 deciding between major to apply as rn

cedar turret
cedar turret
ocean garden
#

I applied comp bio but I'm doing CS now (might do addl in comp bio though)

stoic relic
#

i heard some schools are mad comp for transfer which is why i was asking

cedar turret
#

like IS is hard to transfer to due to the lack of space

#

so they have very high standards

#

you do not have the right here to transfer like some schools where you can change your major on the portal

#

it’s all dependent on the space they have, supply and demand

stoic relic
#

this makes sense

#

thank you

ocean garden
#

You don't wanna be stuck

ocean garden
#

So the notion of a weed out is really different from other schools

novel rose
#

is it just me or are the CMU prompts like extremely copypastable from other schools and UCs

versed spade
#

cuz im also kinda thinking abt tha t

stoic relic
stoic relic
#

if i had to answer a legit "why major" for business admin i think i'd perish

#

bc imho business admin is a dumb major 💀

#

like idk how someone can be passionate about it

#

they can talk about like omg the impact it can have on communities through community serivce

#

but that's not a true passion for the major itself

#

if that makes sense

ocean garden
stoic relic
novel rose
#

i think what he says makes perfect sense for business admin

ocean garden
#

Wait but surely tepper has other majors

stoic relic
ocean garden
#

Idk anything about Tepper or business lmao

stoic relic
#

like

#

i love how wharton has econ

novel rose
#

if you understand the people that go into business admin, you really notice people just use it as a means to an end

stoic relic
#

its actual grounded education and application

novel rose
#

nobody cares about the major itself

stoic relic
#

i love learning itself i feel like anything is applicable to impact if you choose it ot be

ocean garden
stoic relic
#

learning about how businesses run and stuff is like stupid imo

#

😭

#

i say this as someone who will try and break into consulting

ocean garden
#

Surely you could write a application-focused essay

novel rose
#

also isn't ts due tmrw

stoic relic
#

yeah i totally could but i was thinking about writing that for my third lol i have a good story for my basis for application

stoic relic
#

ive written last minute for so long lol its bad

versed spade
#

😮‍💨

stoic relic
#

lowk i was searching i tup

#

and i heard tepper is less selective too

versed spade
#

oh really

#

its cuz like i didnt wanna rewrite my thing that i stole from econ in the other schools

#

💀

#

so i just moved some stuff around

#

🥀

ocean garden
stoic relic
#

wait

novel rose
#

why would a cs major not apply cmu 💀

stoic relic
#

does variance actually exist between schools in cmu

#

for like selectivity

#

ik cornell is decentralized so theres a LOT of vriance

ocean garden
stoic relic
#

but idk as much for cmu

versed spade
novel rose
#

also wait sansk do you do usaco

novel rose
#

I feel like i've seen the name before

ocean garden
novel rose
#

I might've talked to you on my other account

ocean garden
#

You prob have

versed spade
#

other acc lol

stoic relic
# ocean garden Yeah

i've heard both tepper and dietrich are less selective than the school overall but do you have any insight on how selective they are relative to each other

ocean garden
#

I think tepper is more selective but idk?

versed spade
#

oh shit

ocean garden
#

Dietrich is very flexible though if you want that

#

Like there's so many majors and it's really easy to switch between them

novel rose
#

my gh profile has my real name n everything

versed spade
stoic relic
ocean garden
stoic relic
novel rose
#

cmu is fairly transparent

ocean garden
#

Like they burn all the applications after admissions are over

stoic relic
#

from 2020 the data says tepper is much less selective than dietrich but that's when they stopped publishing

#

i thikn 23% vs 13%

ocean garden
#

So that no one can request their college application

novel rose
#

Oh no sorry

stoic relic
#

but recent sources have said tepper has exploded in selectivity

#

sooo

novel rose
#

you have to be able to recieve whatever they have on you

stoic relic
#

ya boi has no clue

novel rose
#

so by burning it they avoid FERPA

ocean garden
novel rose
#

yeah

versed spade
#

i mean i think id still do tepper regardless

ocean garden
#

So you can ask and they'll just say they don't have anything

versed spade
#

idek if i wanna be in dietrich

novel rose
#

they release comprehensive numbers tho

versed spade
#

🥲

stoic relic
#

lol i'd be fine with dietrich for a semester

#

or year

#

i just need to get to consulting.. eventually

versed spade
#

transfer tho is that harder

stoic relic
#

dunno

ocean garden
#

Lowk idk anyone who wants to transfer to tepper

stoic relic
#

how closed off is the tepper environment/resources from other schools

#

i'm guessing bc tepper is less selective it's also like

#

not as private

versed spade
#

but i mean doing econ is shared

stoic relic
#

compared to wharton and its resources compared to other schools within penn

stoic relic
#

yeah

#

i'd think so

ocean garden
#

There's plenty of cs majors in the entrepreneurship frat

stoic relic
#

i think im gonna go dietrich econ

ocean garden
#

And startup resources anyone can access

stoic relic
#

i'm assuming dietrich and tepper have similar first-year classes for econ at the minimum

versed spade
#

probably

stoic relic
#

so i won't be like

#

too excluded from the environemnt

#

if internal transfer does work out

novel rose
#

why are there two econ majors anyways

novel rose
#

I know nothing about cmu except SCS for forgive my ignorance

versed spade
#

no its one but its shared classes at tepper and dietrich

stoic relic
#

ok brb

ocean garden
#

But CMU has a lot of separation lol

#

Like there's different comp bio classes for bio majors and comp bio majors

#

💀

novel rose
#

what

#

just why

ocean garden
#

For stats, there's a CS version, math version, and a stats version

#

Of the same class

versed spade
#

😭😭

ocean garden
novel rose
#

I feel like that works against students though

ocean garden
#

I mean you can take any version in most cases

#

You have the choice to take the stats major version of stats as a CS major for example

stoic relic
#

???

#

this is so weird

#

like i knew this before but tis just so weird and im exclaiming it now

#

economics is housed in "tepper" for the actual CMU site

#

but you can't select it on commonapp

#

lowk can i email cmu

#

would they get back to me by tmorrow

#

lol

versed spade
#

no because they moved econ to dietrich

#

but u still share with tepper

stoic relic
#

💀

versed spade
#

idk i was like trying to figure that out earlier too

stoic relic
#

at least on reddit

versed spade
#

wat

stoic relic
#

that they moved it from dietrich to tepper

versed spade
#

🤔

#

oh maybe it was that then

#

but still sharing the classes

stoic relic
versed spade
#

its just wack imo

#

like on the tepper programs econ is there too

#

smh

stoic relic
#

yes

#

i saw

#

its just like

#

when im applying as commonapp i can't choose econ in tepper

#

which is stupid

#

im still gonna email them tbh

versed spade
#

lmk what they say 🥲

stoic relic
#

but yeah ok im gonna go w dietrich

#

wait

#

i can just call them tmr

#

im a genius

lethal flint
#

wait lemme get this straight

#

first supp is why major and i can just copy and paste

#

second is why us?

#

third i just probably copy and paste from somewhere too

versed spade
#

third u can just write whatever right

lethal flint
#

lowk might just use that first stanford prompt again

coral current
#

Can i write like literally anything in q3

#

like paste a community essay

#

or do i have to show another facet of personallity that i havent covered in Q1 & Q2

ocean garden
ocean garden
#

Otherwise the essay kinda useless

coral current
#

the first two are p much fully like that so im not sure how much more insight another 300 words would give

ocean garden
gritty mirage
lethal flint
gritty mirage
#

for

#

oih

#

i thought this was stanford

#

becuase i saw you

#

💀

#

thats on me

lethal flint
#

Stanford isn’t the only school in applying to dawg

#

imagine someone who did that tho

#

Ego

gritty mirage
#

i assumed as much but i just saw you

stone vector
#

submitteeddddddd

#

:D

sour kelp
#

For the Why Major and Why CMU essays, is it ok if they kinda build off of each other with a bit of overlap. Like my Why major is about my research in an area, and my Why CMU talks about exploring that research at CMU

willow perch
willow perch
sour kelp
#

Is that too repetitive in your opinion?

lethal flint
junior cradle
rigid linden
sour kelp
sour kelp
novel rose
#

iirc you can change majors within SCS fairly easily

#

so you get admitted to SCS as a whole

ocean garden
#

I don't have a major yet

gritty patrol
lethal pike
hushed mist
#

is CMU Tepper or econ more selective?

sick tinsel
#

For enginnering u enter with a major

#

It's on the cmu website

cosmic crystal
stoic relic
#

for anyone who is interested:

college acceptanace rates will be the same across the board apart from CS and some drama programs. they're pushing hard on that this year.

economics is initially funneled through dietrich but goes into tepper; this is simply administrative in nature to allow for BA's as well as BS's (although imho this is kinda dumb)

internal transfer is very easy at cmu; between schools also isn't extremely difficult from how she sounded

#

uhh who was asking about this

#

@hushed mist

#

im actually very surprised by how open they were with information

#

i offhandedly brought up admission rates between schools and she was the one to volunteer information, i didn't even ask

#

i'm like "oh i'v eheard and seen online that some schools have varying acceptance rates, which is why i was confused.." and she took that and elaborated on it

lethal pike
#

which schools