Missing Appearances Content

[serene hollow]

Hello guys. While trying to get the complete set of appearances, I realized there were some missing items. I need some help to identify them. There are 96 appearances in my gameplay -- I've PS5 Deluxe digital edition. I've got them all, except 3 of the additional content.

The additional content list is:

1. Dark arts robe
2. House fanatic school robe
3. Beaked skull mask
4. Dark arts mask
5. Duelist's mask
6. Dark arts gloves
7. Dark arts hat
8. Dark arts garrison hat
9. Dark arts scarf
10. Dark arts ensemble
11. Silver dragon-eyed spectacle
12. Urchin Hat
13. Carmine Lightning Bolt Scarf
14. Lilac Ensemble
15. Merlin's cloak

And there are three missing spaces. So, can anyone help?

[kindred venture]

It’s the Shopkeeper clothing from the Haunted Hogsneade quest

That’s what you’re missing

[serene hollow]

I've made it. Got the items, but they are in a different section.

[near stone]

Do you have the one you receive from finishing the dark arts arena?

it would only be one, but it 's already one ^^

[serene hollow]

Yup, that's the Duelist's mask

[kindred venture]

For me the

Shopkeeper’s Hat
Shopkeeper’s Coat
Shopkeeper’s Ensemble

are all in my Additional Content section of my Appearance collection.

They’re the ones you’re missing

[blissful elm]

I just noticed that my shopkeeper appearances disappeared as well along with the two shop quest enemies. (They were there before because I checked when I saw some people saying that theirs didn’t show up.)

[serene hollow]

Oh dear... 🤡

[civic yoke]

I’m missing 3-4 of the additional content outfits. Was that only attainable through their twitch streams? I’m bummed out if it is because I’m going for the platinum

[near stone]

PS5?

Not sure it is, it didn't show for me until I got the twitch content

[civic yoke]

Yea ps5. I hope I can get it some other way, cause I missed their streams

[near stone]

Do you have the shopkeeper's items showing? It seems they were removed for some people?

And did you do the dark arts arena?

In practice could you send a screenshot of your collection?

[civic yoke]

I can tomorrow definitely, I don’t have access right now.

[kindred venture]

I don’t think that those items normally count as anyone who buys the game when they can’t get the Twitch drop stuff anymore would just have no way to get everything for the collection achievement.

I think they’re added on top of the amount needed for the achievement but don’t count towards it if that makes sense? Any that come under “additional content” aren’t included in the base game amount you need to collect for the achievement

Otherwise the Dark Arts arena reward,nDark Arts outfits and the Haunted Hogsmeade rewards would make it impossible for anyone not on PS or who didn’t buy the deluxe/digital deluxe wouldn’t be able to get it either. But they can

[near stone]

@kindred venture it could be that they count if you have access to them? I.E. the value isn't fixed per se?

[kindred venture]

I don’t think so as my collection achievement only popped when I got the last appearance reward from the main and side quest challenges, and before that I’d gotten all the others.

If it had counted the additional content ones then it would have popped sooner if it was fixed.

Which I think is why it only counts the base game stuff, not the additional content stuff.

[near stone]

no, what I mean is: if you are on PS5, you need PS5 exclusive contents and other things (i.e. 15ish things). If you are on PC, you need all but the 3 PS5 exclusives.

Your collection should show the max everywhere, and said max can move, depending on platform, twitch drops,...

[kindred venture]

I don’t think so because then that just creates different thresholds across platforms.

I think anything that falls under the Additional Content section just don’t count towards the achievement and only base game stuff would

[near stone]

I really think the easy implementation is to base yourself on the values shown in the collections section... which includes them

the threshold then becomes a percentage set at 100% for all

[kindred venture]

I’m talking in regards to the Collectors Edition achievement itself. Not the total in your respective collection which would change depending on what additional content you have. Like mine is x/96 but if I also had the Kelpie Robe it would be x/97

But any stuff in the Additional Content bit won’t count towards the achievement, only base game content

[near stone]

Might be, no idea how they did it on their side

[kindred venture]

Only have the base game stuff count and additional content appearance items being separate and not counting towards the achievement.

Only quest rewards, expiration rewards and challenge rewards count.

Same way that you’d only need the 9 different potions and Felix Felicis doesn’t count towards the trophy, it only adds to your personal collection but not the collection that the game is tracking for an Achievement

[near stone]

@kindred venture The only way to be sure would be to not get the potion and get everything else/not get the PS5 clothing and get everything else, and check if you get the achievment... on PS5.

[kindred venture]

Issue is stuff like the potion are in your collection from the start.

You’d have to check with the shopkeeper outfit and the Dark Arts arena mask reward etc

Whic would require me playing through the entire game again on another account just to check lol

All the guides online say the stuff you need and the numbers don’t include additional content, therefore I highly doubt it’s needed for the achievement, only base game things not any additional content

Plus changing the trophy threshold wouldn’t work,BaS it would have to be on a per player basis depending on what additional content they had which would be an absolute mess.

There’s 603 base game collection items. These are the ones you need for the achievement.

Anything else is additional content and doesn’t count towards the achievement. As it’s not base game which is the only thing the achievement tracks.

[near stone]

I'd try with the dark arts arena mask reward, but already have the achievment

[kindred venture]

But you have all the other base game collection items?

Then that proves that the additional content stuff isn’t needed for the achievement doesn’t it?

[near stone]

I would. I had the dark arts mask before getting biscuit with the patch

[kindred venture]

603 is the total for the trophy on PlayStation even with the Deluxe edition items

It only counts the base game collection stuff, not any additional content,

My trophy only popped when I got the last challenge appearance rewards from main and side quests.

It didn’t pop before that.

[near stone]

ok, good to know, not sure I can know the status easily on steam

[kindred venture]

Had to switch to my fiancé’s son’s account as it wouldn’t show me the total on mine due to the fact I’d already got it haha

[civic yoke]

I have 88 out of 91 appearances, and the 3 that are missing are in the additional content category, any idea what it could be?

[near stone]

PS5?

[civic yoke]

Yes

[near stone]

I guess those are the shop ones, then

Yes, the shop from the PS5 quest

[civic yoke]

Ohhh the dungeon one, I already completed it

[civic yoke]

Well turns out I just needed to find more Revelio pages and conjouring spells. And I finally got my first platinum trophy!

[serene hollow]

I've got them, but they won't appear in collection.

[graceful vapor]

If you want to avoid issues like these check out #1081068010908946492 theres a handy dandy spreadsheet with all the gear in the game, each with descriptions and whether its dlc or not etc etc. To support the creator me and them would appreciate an upvote on a major bug we discovered whilst testing gear #1085328697738940496