#(P5R PC) Rose & Violet - Story overhaul

1 messages · Page 33 of 1

surreal ermine
#

ye

bold mortar
#

ok then the skirt is almost finalized

#

gonna need some slight edits

#

but i can do the belt in a sec

#

ok that's it then for this

#

gonna check the school uniform rq and then probably ping zylvos with these

#

hmmm

#

should i have gloves for this model?

safe pebble
#

she looks like the daughter of a super rich CEO 💅🏻

#

or part of the devil wears prada cast

#

i like it, it's cute

bold mortar
#

if the school uniform version has it then the casual one might as well too

random hinge
#

I think I would've kept the bow green in the casual version

bold mortar
#

you can change it back then if you like

random hinge
#

Well, it's your model, I'm suggesting it

bold mortar
#

it doesn't matter that much to me

random hinge
#

I'll give it a try to see what it looks like

bold mortar
#

you'll want to import a new green bow though probably, since i changed the mat so it wouldn't have a green glow

random hinge
#

I'll clean up the duplicated textures/materials as well

#

Yeah, don't worry. I also edit the material when I recolor the red bow

bold mortar
#

ok sounds good

bold mortar
surreal ermine
#

can i make a red rose version?

bold mortar
#

sure go ahead

surreal ermine
#

cool

bold mortar
#

you might want to wait for zylvos to double check it first though

surreal ermine
#

yeah

bold mortar
#

ok now that i've spent nearly 12 hours on this today

#

i'm gonna rest

#

did this in lieu of studying for two quizzes i have tomorrow naosmiley

random hinge
#

Good luck TeddieSalute

bold mortar
#

should be ok

random hinge
#

And good sleep

raw marlin
#

What do you think?

surreal ermine
#

ooo a darker blue

raw marlin
#

Sumire is black and red

#

Think it’d be cool if Kasumi was white and blue

surreal ermine
#

serpent&rose made this for sumire

raw marlin
#

When was this?

surreal ermine
#

a few weeks ago?

bold mortar
#

i'm partial to sky blue myself

raw marlin
#

I never seen this before

surreal ermine
raw marlin
#

Which blue fits Kasumi more

surreal ermine
#

for rose probably the dark blue

#

the blue for sumire was meant to match cendrillon

jade willow
jade willow
#

on my next playthrough im making Sumire wear white and Kasumi wear black

surreal ermine
#

i also will probably use this for sumire throughout my whole playthrough next time with fem jonkler

jade willow
#

Yes, the mytamagos hair is really special

#

I like that for original game, she keeps the ribbon but repurposes it. I didnt like that she kept using the ponytail 🫠

#

I wonder how hard it would be to mod a model swap like that since Atlus didnt

surreal ermine
#

i gave instructiosn for that in the description

#

it's not seperate models. it's a flag trigger

#

after her rank 10, you select the "before third semester" option in the config. i named it that to avoid spoilers

jade willow
#

I wonder how hard would it before it to be automatic though

#

Probably impossible

raw marlin
#

So that before third semester would be the “Kasumi” design and after her actual awakening it’s the Sumire one

surreal ermine
#

ehh it's possible but annyoing to do. would require scripting

#

"before third semester" replaces her ponytail models. "after third semester" replaces her long har models

jade willow
#

It would be cute to have a scene where Kasumi gives her the ribbon and then she starts wearing it in the second hairstyle

raw marlin
jade willow
#

It looks really nice! I like the dark blue

#

I remember you asking for the red part a couple of days ago

#

Im still very new to learning blender, but if you need help let me know and I will try to tell you anything I know

raw marlin
#

Thanks Serpent

raw marlin
bold mortar
raw marlin
#

Cuz I couldn’t see the red parts on GFD studios it was like cropped and you see it all when you export the thing

raw marlin
#

And the hair

jade willow
raw marlin
#

You can do that?

jade willow
#

Yeah, just need to put your cursor over the texture window

raw marlin
#

I thought that would only apply to the models and not the textures

jade willow
#

right click and drag to move, etc

#

or i guess left click as well

molten finch
buoyant arch
#

I'll be honest in saying I've been staring at my work for around 20 minutes, flipping the canvas and adjusting whatever I could to try and see if anything was wrong, but trully nothing is coming up

#

i probably stared at it for so long I started filtering out issues

#

trully catfishing my mind

bold mortar
#

self-gaslighting

jade willow
limber ember
#

Sorry for the late response, but the bangs bother me. It doesn’t look like hair at all, it’s just triangles. I recommend drawing some smaller strands of hair between the big chunks to make it look softer. The way it is now, it looks like unnaturally glued together.

buoyant arch
limber ember
#

Yeah, it can be difficult if you're not used to changing it up. But that's why you're practicing and asking for advice. 👍

I looked at the portrait again and when you redo the hair, I'd also make the shadow lines much thinner. The shadows you cast make it look like the bangs have these huge volumes which they don’t.

Before I go, I want to commend you for learning and semi-successfully replicating P5's artstyle! Despite the mistakes, you're doing great! Keep at it.

buoyant arch
#

ty for the kind words. Sure as hell am doing my best

#

I'll follow your critique and send something else soon

limber ember
#

Take your time with it!

buoyant arch
#

alr, so far I reduced the thickness of some shades, added a few extra strokes to not make them glued, gave them some more depth and added a few strands tto make them not so perfectly glued to eachother like she used some sort of hair product

limber ember
#

That looks better, although I hate to be this person but I have one last thing to nitpick, if that's alright? 😅

buoyant arch
#

by all means

#

hold nothing

#

i want to get better. Any criticism or nitpick is appreciated

bold mortar
#

I checked my steam hours for the last two weeks
60 hours on blender and 20 on p5 itself

#

I don't think I've spent very much time playing the game

limber ember
#

@buoyant arch Make the middle bang right above the nose bridge bend to the right. It's straight now. It doesn’t follow the trajectory you set out with the other bangs and makes it look off. It takes away focus from the eyes, that's disruptive it is.

If you do this, it'll be peak and I'll have nothing to say anymore.

buoyant arch
#

i had this in mind when I saw another one of my works, and the already existing portrait of hers

#

alr, I'll get this done

limber ember
#

Thank you for taking the time

buoyant arch
#

my pleasure

buoyant arch
#

adjusted the strand, added some depth and some extra highlight

#

i think I just need the back of her head and the ribbon now

bold mortar
limber ember
buoyant arch
#

this is how it is rn

#

ill do the blinking and I think it'll be it

buoyant arch
buoyant arch
#

alr I'll quickly say that this looks better in-game than I expected

random hinge
#

Oh yeah, that looks very good!

buoyant arch
#

dunno if you'll be adding like, a second config for my version to keep the first version up or not, but anyways, here it is

random hinge
#

I think keeping the first version and adding this one as a second version is the right call

buoyant arch
#

by all means then

random hinge
#

I'll rename them (Version 1) and (Version 2). The image will have to speak for itself

#

Thanks!

buoyant arch
#

my very pleasure

#

I'll get to work on the untied hair to go alongside it

#

not today, cause I'll be busy, but I'll get it done

jade willow
#

I really like her eyelashes, they feel very Kasumi

#

after fighting with this girl for like 4 hrs she is keeping her hair this strawberry blond 😭 I can just shake my head and give up for now

surreal ermine
errant zenith
#

Who the

jade willow
bold mortar
#

could be a material thing

random hinge
#

Definitely a material issue

#

I remember having that kind of issue with the front bangs when MyTamagos and I were testing it

jade willow
#

If you would like to, that would be very kind of you! So here's two different models - The first one is the one from croissant guard that works fine, but it has diff weights and I wanted to change the shadow texture. The second model is one with the weights I want, but whenever I try to adjust the .dds they break in game. I also tried using p5 gfd assets which kinda helped it from blinking different colors but now its like this weird color

bold mortar
#

which one is the one you want me to look at

jade willow
#

the second one is the one Im trying to make work nod

#

But dont overexert yourself! Im going to go make dinner for my family and will be gone for a while, but Ill try again later. If you find out anything though, please let me know!

bold mortar
#

the "p5r" mats are very shiny

#

like i used "p5r clothes" on the mitsuru summer model

#

and it made it glow

jade willow
#

ohhh

#

so are the gfd assets very specific?

bold mortar
#

idk i just know that those mats don't work

#

see now it works

#

as opposed to this

#

ngl though i kinda like the strawberry blonde

granite wren
#

It's like Sayori

bold mortar
#

who?

buoyant arch
errant zenith
errant zenith
#

Man… I miss the doki doki era

#

Game still gets modded with custom stories

jade willow
# bold mortar

omg if you got this to work ill die! I need to check in game later when I get the chance

#

what did you end up doing?

bold mortar
coral prawn
rich tree
#

ive stopped using the fast travel all togeather

#

I use the subway for everything now

bold mortar
#

except if i'm replaying a day

#

then i'll use fast travel

jade willow
#

yayy! it is working so much better now, thank you bester!

#

I thought that her hair was red because of the texture, but I guess its more so something about the shader

bold mortar
#

i feel like it should still be dark colored even at night

#

like this

#

or this

jade willow
#

Its kinda weird, I think its responding to the shade or different lights.

#

Let me show you

#

whereas when she is kinda see-through (when against a wall in its like the shaders dont apply or something?) the actaul color goes through

#

also getting this error

#

actually maybe it would be worth to remove the shadow texture now that the material is working

bold mortar
#

if you haven't done that already

jade willow
#

like this material?

bold mortar
#

yeah

#

though you'll end up with this

jade willow
#

oooh

#

wait let me try

bold mortar
#

probably need to change the shadow map

jade willow
#

yeah thats what im going to do

#

okay time to pray pray

#

IT WORKED!! HAPPY

bold mortar
#

nice

jade willow
#

omg thank you so much Bester!!

bold mortar
#

np

jade willow
#

😭 I literally struggled all day with this. Wow, I cant believe it was so simple all along. Thank you!

bold mortar
#

my 400 hours of blender coming in handy naosmiley

jade willow
#

no more weird glow femc

bold mortar
#

epic

bold mortar
#

or just another alternate models mod?

jade willow
#

I plan to make a version for red and brown

bold mortar
#

oh good

#

since i prefer the brown hair

jade willow
#

I still want to work on the hair more, it has some issues that I dont like still but the hair color was bugging me a lot

bold mortar
#

gonna be kinda tedious though doing a set of those twice

#

because for each color you'll have to change each model manually

jade willow
#

really? Its not just a texture swap like for the ponytail?

bold mortar
#

what i mean is you'll have to add the hair to each model manually

#

but since you'll have two variants, you'll have twice as much work

jade willow
#

Oh yeahhh

#

Well I think I would just do a texture swap after the mesh itself is on each model

bold mortar
#

ehhhh

#

i suppose

#

what you could do is just have both materials ready

#

and then swap them for the models

jade willow
#

Yeah! If it causes issues though I dont mind doing manually for both. I think it shouuld be fine?

bold mortar
#

it's not hard it just like

#

6 hours of work

#

hmm i wonder what that hair looks like with my models

#

not bad

jade willow
bold mortar
#

would need some work

jade willow
#

uughh yeah the front part is quite annoying

#

It clips through her shoulder during the PT idle animation and some other times, Im not sure if that is a weight issue or something like colliders

bold mortar
#

yukari outfit is pretty good with it though

jade willow
#

That looks really cute

#

Made for each other

#

The funny thing is, while I like this hair I still love the ponytail the best.

bold mortar
#

yeah and ofc R&V is made with it in mind

#

so ponytail will be my go-to

jade willow
#

100%

bold mortar
#

though i'll probably do my next run with the makoto hair i made

jade willow
#

I think the Makoto hair is so cute

#

Tbh I didnt see the vision but once you put the bow on there its very cute, especially with the modest vibes she has

#

Very sweet girl

bold mortar
#

reminds me i need to see how it looks with the fur coat model

#

that's pretty good

jade willow
#

rich girl

#

I cant wait to try out the fur coat when it comes out

bold mortar
#

yeah me too

#

i guess since that one is done theres nothing else for me to change i think

jade willow
#

Youve cranked out a lot of stuff this past week

#

Two new outfits and the makoto hair as well right?

bold mortar
#

yup naosmiley

#

the only thing i haven't really had a go at was the winter casual, summer uniform, and the PT outfit

#

but i don't really want another winter casual since I like Yukari's and there isn't much to improve on with the white shirt summer uniform

#

PT outfit I don't care about either since I'm not gonna use it anymore

#

i'm content with the masked uniforms i made

#

I suppose what I could do mess with Yusuke's winter casual

#

that looks kinda goofy

#

idk the point being I've done all that I can think of rn in terms of R&V modding

jade willow
#

Oh yeah, the masks as well!

#

tbh I dont remember what Yusuke wears for winter casual...

#

But this hair for him actually makes him really nice looking...

#

He looks more like a moody artist lol

bold mortar
#

kinda goofy looking tbh

jade willow
bold mortar
#

what I could do actually is just use his vanilla winter uniform in place of the casual outfit

#

that'd look a bit better

jade willow
#

oh!!!

#

this mod actually uses new outfits for him as well

bold mortar
#

i like Yusuke's hair design as is

jade willow
#

not the promo at the bottom 👀

bold mortar
#

hmm that looks like an interesting mod naothumbsup

#

it should get many likes and subcribes

jade willow
#

I was like one of your first likes

#

here since day 1 CH_BossThumbsUp

bold mortar
#

awesome

jade willow
#

I loaded this model and its so far surprisedpikachu

bold mortar
#

erm

#

whose model is that

jade willow
#

from the yusuke mod

bold mortar
#

oh right

#

lion uses an older version of the GMD addon

jade willow
#

I guess I could load it into blender

bold mortar
#

just shift+scroll

#

btw @cedar hornet update your gmd addon lol

cedar hornet
#

Is that why that happens?

bold mortar
#

yeah

#

i made the the alternate bangs models with that version of the addon and thats why in gfd they're really zoomed out

#

but when i updated the new models i made were normal

cedar hornet
#

Def gotta get that updated then

#

Thank you

jade willow
#

some people like older versions

#

I forget why something about the textures right? I remember seeing in a guide they recommended a specific version

bold mortar
#

could be

#

idk i haven't had any problems with the newest version

jade willow
#

🤭 He looks so handsome whaaat

#

Yusuke male romance WHEN

bold mortar
#

@surreal ermine

cedar hornet
#

Im def excited to not have to shift scroll for every model

bold mortar
#

yeah lol

jade willow
#

I didnt know shift scroll made it go faster

bold mortar
#

it got really bad on some of my models

jade willow
#

I was watching it slowly come into view 😭

bold mortar
cedar hornet
jade willow
#

Why does it do that? Is it just only gfd?

#

I notice sometimes my models do that randomly

bold mortar
#

idk could be a bug with the older versions of the gmd addon

jade willow
#

is this rose's bun? omg so innovative

cedar hornet
#

I need to update it tbh

#

Most of the hair could look so much better

jade willow
#

You really cooked with this Lion

#

I never knew I liked Yusuke until now

bold mortar
jade willow
#

Kasumi x Yusuke shippers arise

cedar hornet
#

Hes my fav thief

bold mortar
#

akechi's the goat but yusuke would be my second favorite ig

cedar hornet
bold mortar
#

wrong term actually

#

but basically here would need to be edited

#

like the vertices

#

if you haven't done that already

cedar hornet
#

Im not familiar, im still just figuring stuff out on the fly 😔

bold mortar
#

i'll explain rq

jade willow
cedar hornet
#

Lol i was a Granblue recolorer before this

#

Its all so new still

bold mortar
#

i did yakuza mods before this so it's the same principle for me

jade willow
#

Well you really ate 💯

#

I did FFXIV texture editing 💀

#

which is basically just paint and photostuff

cedar hornet
#

yeah, i'm pretty familiar with photopea

#

blender not so much

bold mortar
#

you can see its quite big

#

and it's quite large on kasumi

cedar hornet
#

right

bold mortar
#

one sec gotta load this in blender

jade willow
cedar hornet
#

i've been looking at making something for her

jade willow
#

a hairstyle or ?

bold mortar
#

so here is how it looks on kasumi

#

seems quite big

cedar hornet
bold mortar
#

you can use the scaling options, but they aren't terribly precise

#

so what you do is enter edit mode

#

and select the vertices

#

these for instance

#

click on mesh

#

transform

#

and you'll have a few options to play with

#

usually you'll want move or scale

#

move can to that for instance

#

it's only helpful for slight changes

cedar hornet
#

oh yeah i've done some editing like that

bold mortar
#

scaling works a bit better

#

not here in this instance

#

since i just deleted the bottom part of the coat

#

this works better

#

since you can make them thinner

#

requires a lot of fine tuning

#

but it's the best way to go

#

something i did on the coat model actually was delete up to here

#

but i needed it to be longer

#

but i didn't want to restart

#

moved it down

#

moved the next section down too

#

hence proportional editing

#

but anyways

#

that's all to say you can precisely fix the yusuke hair model

jade willow
#

not me just using G and S 😭

cedar hornet
#

Ok i'm seeing it

#

i'm planning on updating that mod soon so i'll try editing the bun a bit more

bold mortar
#

yusuke's hair won't need such drastic edits

#

just some smaller vertex moving

peak drift
#

Bruh I would pay someone to code in a menu in front of a store or something that allows me to freely just change my outfit and hair like dress up outside of the metaverse.

bold mortar
#

unfortunately you're talking to some modelers here naosmiley

peak drift
#

lol I know

bold mortar
#

what you could do is make it a suggestion ig

#

idk that'd be like a whole new framework in itself

jade willow
#

Isnt that already a thing tho?

#

Costume framework does that no?

bold mortar
#

ig but for like hair and stuff

#

it'd be complicated

#

you'd basically need to make it so it can support every new hair mod

#

and new costumes

jade willow
#

Hair would be like different models, but it would just look like you switched just the hair 😭

bold mortar
#

and account for the special models used in certain events

bold mortar
cedar hornet
#

maybe something like that character creator mod for p3r?

jade willow
bold mortar
#

you have different meshes which are called depending on the context

#

it's annoying to learn but would be quite helpful in Persona's case

#

and ofc the textures aren't packed into the models so it's way easier to do texture swaps lol

jade willow
#

Hmm

#

I think I would be happy with just more base game outifts

bold mortar
bold mortar
jade willow
#

hahaha

bold mortar
#

though tbh it wouldn't take that long because half the battle really was the fur coat

cedar hornet
#

making outfits lowkey the best part of this

jade willow
#

Well I mean more like

#

We have a set amount of outfits. Like it would be nice for there to be an outfit that is called specifically for a rainy day for example

#

But that would need another "slot"

bold mortar
#

you'd need a script for that lol

#

my ideal mod for P5 rn besides a total overhaul of the story would be like

#

idk

#

i guess removing most of morgana's narration

#

that'd be nice

cedar hornet
jade willow
#

Would scripting that be difficult? I imagine people would have done it already if it were

jade willow
bold mortar
cedar hornet
bold mortar
#

feels much better than the cat telling me what to do

jade willow
#

ACTUALLY

#

I agree!!

#

I like Mona as a character but not as a navi

bold mortar
#

i'm not talking about the battle lines

#

i'm talking about

#

"hey you can't go out tonight!"

#

"you don't like crepes!!"

#

i'm not talking about gameplay changes though

jade willow
#

No thats what I mean

#

I meant navi as in from zelda

bold mortar
#

it's fine

#

i just want to feel like the protagonist has more agency

cedar hornet
#

makoto narrated himself and it was way better

bold mortar
#

yeah

#

and ofc it should be second person like 3 and 4

#

"you exerted yourself today. best not to go out tonight."

#

vs.

#

"HEY HERES MY STUPID ANNOYING VOICE, YOU CAN'T GO OUT BECAUSE REASONS OK"

#

even the call kawakami option would be vastly improved

#

"call kawakami?"
vs.
"HEY ARE YOU GOING TO CALL KAWAKAMI?"

#

like maybe not everything needs you're stupid cat narration

jade willow
#

It would be nice for first person narration. "I'm so tired from going into the metaverse today, better rest"

bold mortar
#

I'm a P4 supremacist so I prefer the second-person narration

#

oh if only I new how to make these changes

jade willow
#

time to get into scripting

#

🤝

#

You could name it something like this 😭

bold mortar
#

speaking of them i really wish that the no SIU director spoilers mod worked with R&V

peak drift
#

I’d think I’d be more okay with it if it wasn’t always multiple sentences of explanation on why something is happening or why I can’t do something. Then again that’s a P5 problem. All the characters like to yap.

bold mortar
#

true

#

and on the whole I just despise the grand conspiracy

peak drift
#

It’s the worst in the Shido arc. Like everyone is constantly explaining the same things over and over

bold mortar
#

or more to the point the fact it has to share narrative room with yaldaboath

#

like just make shido the antagonist

#

it's fine

#

||and also get rid of the arrest arc and a the arrest premise too||

#

one nice thing I'll say about P5X is that the premise is one of the better ones

peak drift
#

I don’t mind it that much. Idk what else they would really do since they do need a testimony.

bold mortar
bold mortar
#

but barring that

#

don't have akechi have the super stupid death scene

peak drift
#

That pretty much changing the whole story at that point lol

bold mortar
#

yeah exactly

#

i want the story to be changed fundamentally

peak drift
#

I don’t mind it. I feel like it gives the protagonist motivators. And ties into the central themes of persona 5.

jade willow
#

for my next outfit mod im thinking of this apron... 👀

peak drift
#

Cute!

jade willow
#

I think it would be!

#

I have too many wips rn... 1disco_dead

bold mortar
peak drift
#

I guess you have something to look forward to with persona 6. It will be an entirely different game.

bold mortar
#

idk i'm scared what they'll do

#

P5 was wildly popular so I think they'll lean into it more than P3 or 4

#

like it would be horrible if they kept confidants instead of social links

peak drift
#

I don’t think they are gonna arrest their main protag again

bold mortar
#

yeah i don't think they'll sink that low again

#

i imagine they'll have the decently to have the protagonist be somewhere where people actually like him

peak drift
#

Every persona game has a different theme so they will do what matches their core concept

bold mortar
#

no more rebellion

#

rebellion is dumb!

jade willow
#

Whats the difference between confidants and social links

bold mortar
#

the function is mostly the same

#

i just dislike the idea that every relationship has to be based on a "deal"

#

like the idea that relationships are transactional is repulsive to me

peak drift
#

I mean tbh they are functionally transactional in every game. From a game play standpoint

jade willow
#

I enjoy that actually

#

It mirrors real life

peak drift
#

I think in persona 5 it comes across more as you can learn something from anyone

#

Exp and stuff for personas

bold mortar
#

S. Links in 3 and 4 don't give you any gameplay benefits like 5

#

And again I'm complaining about the presentation more than anything

jade willow
#

Also do the other persona games have you become friends with such a variety of people?

bold mortar
#

Yeah

#

Well 3 and 4

#

Since s. links were introduced in 3

bold mortar
#

Fine whatever

#

Just stop portraying making friends as a transaction

peak drift
#

Gameplay effects narrative

#

In game design we are taught that

bold mortar
#

5 is severely lacking on account of it's dumb premise

peak drift
#

Yeah though tbh Shujin students probably wouldn’t let joker join. It would be cool if we got our stats up in charm or kindness if they let us join

bold mortar
#

Yeah ik because of the premise

#

Even then you could explain it away by having clubs open up after kamoshida

#

And speaking of that, next to nobody apologizes to you for the rumors

#

It's crazy

peak drift
#

I think they could have tied it to stats. Probably ran out of development time since I know they have concepts of it.

bold mortar
#

Idk i guess I'm just hoping for more p4

peak drift
#

Yeah

bold mortar
#

P4 was so perfect

#

Good character moments, low stakes plot, nice environment...

jade willow
#

And cute family dynamic!

bold mortar
#

Yeah that too

jade willow
#

I loved Nanako

bold mortar
#

Sojiro kinda sucks

peak drift
#

That makes 4 special

jade willow
#

playing as a big brother was kinda cool

bold mortar
#

Yeah ofc

jade willow
#

I like that in R&V Sojiro isnt such a jerk

#

Like why are you so MEAN

bold mortar
#

But the difference is p4 is harder to mod so I'm stuck here

bold mortar
peak drift
#

At least the remake will probably be easier

bold mortar
#

Nope

#

UE sucks

#

I refuse to mod it

jade willow
#

loool

#

I guess youre stuck here with us

peak drift
#

It’s worse than modding original p4?

bold mortar
#

Also I dislike remakes in principle

bold mortar
#

Ever again

#

Ishin Kiwami was bad enough

peak drift
#

I guess I learned Unreal in school so I forgot how it might not be user friendly

bold mortar
#

Also I just think it sucks

#

Maybe if p3r and p4 remake were on the p5 engine

#

But I don't see a point

#

I like OG p4 and I have no reason at all to drop $70 for a remake I know will be inferior

peak drift
#

How so?

bold mortar
#

Script changes, bland graphics, mediocre ui, unreal engine, etc.

#

and btw this is from someone who prefers P3R over the original

#

well mostly

jade willow
#

@cedar hornet did you see this???

cedar hornet
#

omg no way

#

thats so cool

#

imma give this a watch

jade willow
#

hahaha thats so fun

bold mortar
cedar hornet
#

necroneos on deviantart

#

i think i linked them on the mod page

jade willow
#

@surreal ermine mentioned as well

bold mortar
#

i see

#

wonder if i should try my hand at a harder port

jade willow
#

bester honorable mention

cedar hornet
#

the amv 😂

bold mortar
raw marlin
#

He’s just like that

#

He loves FEMCs man

jade willow
#

These mods are sooo cuteee

#

omg actually its really giving odile and odette

molten finch
jade willow
#

I wonder how hard it would be to swap out sakura leotard model

molten finch
jade willow
#

Yeah!

#

It would make a bit more sense I think if it didnt switch to her in the pink leotard

#

I wonder if you'd have to mess with animations tho

molten finch
molten finch
#

aka really hard to mod there

jade willow
#

could be

molten finch
#

mmhmm

random hinge
#

"That Kasumi" looks much more difficult to edit than the regular models. It has a special pose and there's the png at the start of the animation I'm not even sure how it can be edited
#1351304235320348683 message

#

You can praise smug Kasumi here if you'd like
#1351304235320348683 message

jade willow
#

I thought surely it would be simple as dropping in a GMD

bold mortar
#

I'm getting closer to the incognito segment

#

Getting closer to being very annoyed

jade willow
#

lmao

#

Its kinda cute though

bold mortar
#

Plot aside, I also just dislike not being able to use the winter casual outfit

jade willow
#

Hmm. I feel like you use the winter outfit so much.

#

Probably the most of them all

bold mortar
#

I feel the opposite

#

Feels like you use the summer outfit the most

#

Maybe the incognito segment feels longer than it is

#

Maybe it's just annoying that the winter outfit doesn't get the full month like summer does with summer break

#

And you only get it back after shido for a few days before midwinter

jade willow
#

Idk

#

Some day we have to sit down and count the days because I swear the winter outfit is more used

#

To be fair I might be biased cause I love my summer outfits

bold mortar
#

Well summer is like early June to October I think

#

And that includes like all of August

jade willow
#

Also! I edited Sumi (for private use) so she can look prettier in the "Odile" look

jade willow
#

Or no, youre right its in October

bold mortar
#

Compsred to that, winter is april to june, then october to november 22, then like the last couple days of december

#

And you usually only get it on sundays and ig at night too

jade willow
#

I guess it is the least used outfit

#

I guess it feels more because it switches back so often

bold mortar
#

I remember Zylvos had the idea of replacing the incognito outfit with the winter one

#

I suppose the way to do that would be to swap the ponytail for long hair

#

And the glasses too probably

#

And just make that for each winter casual

bold mortar
#

@random hinge do you have any thoughts on this?

random hinge
#

That's doable as a config option

#

Making it for the next update, though... I'll have to see

#

Story wise, obviously, it's recommended to stick to the gym outfit

jade willow
bold mortar
#

Just a thought I had

random hinge
#

It's more of Blender skill issue on my part

random hinge
#

I don't mind updating even for minor things like adding a new bustup

molten finch
#

My fave Summer Casual Outfit for Kasumi/Rose, as gotta thank Lolsu for removing the hairpins & swapping the shoes+socks for Sumire's Vanilla Summer Casual Sandal as it's a very good fit~ ❤️

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/232037676759384064/1436544546635780136/Preview.png?ex=6919385d&is=6917e6dd&hm=1d4dfc3603d616c236fefd4f050411719e7839bf7d9b86e277b00a7e6a22f745&

Alternate download link ver can be found here: https://gamebanana.com/mods/628434

GameBanana

A Persona 5 Royal (PC) (P5R (PC)) Mod in the Characters category, submitted by Lolsu64

rich tree
#

Is there a way to replace this outfit that she wears from oct to Jan? with Rise's midwinter coat?

random hinge
#

Sure, you just need to rename the file for Rise midwinter model to C0001_002_00.GMD

#

And replace it in:
kasumi_as_protagonist_-alternate_models-_ponytail_variant1_3_1\Characters\Joker\1\MODEL\CHARACTER\

#

Make a backup of the old file and rename it to oldC0001_002_00.GMD

#

That way, you can go back to it

#

Just so you know, this will not replace the model in Kasumi awakening event and in the interrogations events. Those are separate models

rich tree
#

woot it worked

#

its to damn cute to only see it in January

random hinge
#

@buoyant arch I forgot to ask you yesterday, but do you have the latest portrait you made with the eyes already in place? It's for the foggy glasses portrait

jade willow
random hinge
#

The thing is, I don't really know what to replace that model with

#

It can't dynamically change to match Kasumi's appearance because it's a separate model

#

If I replace it with the PT outfit, I'll have to do it for each variant of the PT outfit

#

And with all of that, does that make sense to replace this model?

jade willow
#

uuuh no I wouldnt do that haha. It could be the PT outfit but like the black one only like in the menu art (in my opinion ofc!!)

#

It was just a thought, but if you feel its already fine then thats great!

random hinge
#

If I replaced Kasumi with her PT costume, I'd still be weird for her to disappear and reappear at the end. I kinda like the idea of Sumire feeling like she's finally performing like an equal/rival of Kasumi when she was a gymnast, while the real Kasumi is in the background

jade willow
#

Thats a cute idea actually

#

I just thought it would be cute if they were together finally performing too!

random hinge
#

Well, that's how I rationalize it as it is right now

#

Since making a new showtime altogether isn't something I can (and I don't think it's ever been done)

jade willow
#

I think before making a new showtime it would be easier (in comparison to that) to change the EPL so she stays instead of disappearing. Of course all is easier said than actually done Im aware!

#

I personally would be happy just with a model swap, so I think its worth talking to mudkip and seeing if they know anything. If I find anything out I'll post here in case anyone else is interested too nodd

buoyant arch
#

just a sec

#

here you go

#

@random hinge

random hinge
jade willow
#

Message sent now we pray pray

buoyant arch
safe pebble
#

@random hinge not sure if this is the right place to ask but i recently commissioned some alternate outfits (courtesy of @pseudo dock) for kasumi and don't really wanna go through the hassle of posting them on gamebanana, so i was wondering if you wanted to include them in your alternate models mod instead, or i can just drop them here if anybody wants them

#

alrernate summer uniform and alternate workout clothes

molten finch
#

Reminds me of her wearing Sumire's Summer Uniform there~

random hinge
safe pebble
random hinge
#

Okay, so this is going to take longer than expected

#

Or I'm going to rename it to Rayman outfit

random hinge
#

I'll make sure to credit Croissant Guard for those

jade willow
#

Those are sooo cute!

random hinge
# safe pebble alternate workout clothes:

Just to be sure with the credits and how I should name those outfits : where do they come from? I assume the pink sweater one is the from P5X, with the girl who gets subway slammed

surreal ermine
#

lmao yeah

#

the one on the right looks familiar too

safe pebble
#

LOL

#

tamayo yoshida is the NPCs name

#

for the gym outfit

random hinge
#

Alright, thanks. That should help with naming them

jade willow
#

So I edited what Mudkip made (with them showing me every step of the way lol) which is why Kotone is still there. Ill probably replace the models with the vanilla sumi png there until I figure out how to replace it

surreal ermine
#

omg both my mods! lol

jade willow
#

lol yeah!

#

I love red sumi

#

and the gmd I switched it out for what the black vers. of her outfit so I wanted contrast

molten finch
jade willow
#

in this case both

#

kaSUMI SUMIre I use both nicknames for them lol

molten finch
#

Hmmkay!

jade willow
surreal ermine
#

i usually say sumi when i'm trying not to spoiler sumire

jade willow
#

actually I forgot to mark it as a spoiler pepesweat

safe pebble
surreal ermine
#

it's fine in this thread. you're not supposed to play this mod without having played p5r anyway lmao

jade willow
jade willow
surreal ermine
#

i think if someone plays this mod without having played p5r before it's their own fault

jade willow
#

this is just toooo cute

#

But basically as Mudkip explained to me for the models specifically, you need to grab a GMD and pack in the animations and then pack those into the EPL

#

I wanted to try and swap out the .png for this pose in blender but no luck yet

molten finch
surreal ermine
molten finch
surreal ermine
#

the kotone

molten finch
molten finch
# jade willow

Also I do love how Sumire is the one with White Leotard & Long Hair Ribbon Model while Kasumi is Ponytail with Ribbon and wearing Black Sister Leotard as the best difference there~ 🥳🙌

jade willow
surreal ermine
#

it goes by super quick too. people aren't going to be looking that hard

#

(aside from us, obviously...)

jade willow
#

The only other thing is that it looks like physics are not applied to her outfit

#

but it doesnt look as bad as I thought it would tbh

#

Also in her reflection her face is blue, I think thats a personal issue in my game though because it was doing that in my untouched ST

#

Also looks like theyre missing their rapiers

random hinge
#

@bold mortar I'm sending you back the two midwinter outfits you made with the alternate bangs. I've cleaned up the textures/materials and adjusted the "collar" on the fur coat to reduce clipping with the ponytail/long hair. Also, I've fixed the feet disappearing on the midwinter casual (mesh issue, not a bone issue)

jade willow
#

lol i hate textures

bold mortar
#

debating whether to use the turtleneck uniform on my neck run

#

it does look pretty good with the makoto hair though

#

and i'll definitely use that with my next run

jade willow
#

the suspenders are cute too

#

giving her a ponytail for bedtime WhiteBear_Happy

jade willow
bold mortar
#

might be a bit much for the sleeping model yeah

jade willow
#

Like the side ponytail in general? or just too far to the left?

#

I just felt like her hair down looked like it would be super hot and messy to sleep through 😭

bold mortar
bold mortar
#

i've never heard of anyone tying their hair into a ponytail to sleep

jade willow
#

Idk I definitely dont sleep with my hair down. I let Kasumi slide with it because her hair is like pin straight and anime girls tend to do that, but in real life most girls tie their hair back from what I know

#

You wake up with your hair in your mouth all across your face like the grudge 💀

bold mortar
#

idk i'm not a woman so i wouldn't know

jade willow
#

Yeaaah 😭 or maybe its just me. To be fair I get hot very easily

bold mortar
#

idk it just seems counterintuitive to me

jade willow
#

I guess?

#

actually I should find a cute scrunchie for her

bold mortar
#

idk to me it doesn't make sense to tie up your hair like that right befor bed

#

and also ofc you gotta worry about how it'd look in game

jade willow
#

I like it! Im gonna see how it looks sleeping and stuff before going all in cause if her ponytail disappears into the bed its gonna be awkward

bold mortar
jade willow
#

not too bad I think

bold mortar
#

yeah its pretty good

jade willow
#

I really am liking the brown hair color for this style though

#

I wonder if red will look too busy

#

A part of me feels like Ill never publish this mod cause I wont be able to make it well enough t_cry

bold mortar
#

instead of red you should do the strawberry blondenaosmiley

jade willow
#

lol the strawberry blonde was not bad

#

Also sometimes her hair was black from shading issues and that also looked nice

bold mortar
#

one thing i'd give joker is that he's the single protagonist with black hair

jade willow
#

That actually really bothered me when I first played the game

#

Everyone felt very not Japanese

#

Like for example, Ann REALLY irks me

bold mortar
#

i mean ann is supposed to be part white

#

but yeah otherwise i think the need to differentiate the named NPCs can go too far sometimes

jade willow
#

She's supposed to be like a quarter american or something? Iirc Finnish?

bold mortar
#

yeah something like that

jade willow
#

But it just seems very unrealistic to me that she would have blonde hair and blue eyes being a quarter white

bold mortar
#

i don't think it's that unlikely

jade willow
#

Like, most half Japanese people look mixed. It would have been nicer if she had more Japanese features, too

#

Actually, I take back what I said

#

Apparently she is half finnish, half american, and half Japanese

bold mortar
#

takamaki is apparently a finnish surname

jade willow
#

I read that as well! Its funny because it sounds very Japanese to me

bold mortar
#

i think its a japanese surname too

#

reminds me of the 19th century belief that finns are asians

jade willow
#

Actually I think Ive heard of something like that before, too. That a long time ago a lot of asians moved to Finland for some reason? Pretty vague in my memory

#

also apparently Futaba was meant to have black hair?

#

I should make a mod where everyone's hair is returned to black ryujiman

surreal ermine
#

futaba probably just dyes her hair

bold mortar
#

and it's not really that outlandish

#

Bulgarians also come from central asia

surreal ermine
#

i don't think ann's heritage is ever confirmed. we just know she can speak english because she lived in america for a bit, and that she is only 25% white

bold mortar
#

yeah the finnish thing is just conjecture i think

surreal ermine
#

which makes no sense... she would not have blond hair and blue eyes if she was only 1/4 white

#

her being finnish came from people trying to rationalize her last name

#

bc i'm pretty sure she said her white comes from her dad's side

#

but if she's 25%, easily her grandma on her dad's side could've been the white one

#

if i were to headcanon it up, ann's dad was born in america to a japanese immigrant father. he eventually moved to japan and met ann's mother, then they moved back to america for a period after ann was born, then came back

#

the reason it's highly unlikely for a child like her to have blond hair and blue eyes is because both fo those traits are recessive and can only present if both parents are carrying the gene

#

i find it unlikely her japanese mother was carrying those recessive alleles

#

ok nerding out done

jade willow
#

Yeah Idk I wish they just made her a foreign exchange student or more clearly half white and half Japanese

#

People online seem to think she's half finnish / half american and half Japanese, but even still considering her features are recessive it would be very unlikely for her to have them

#

Idk I just head canon shes born in japan but is white because it makes the most sense for me

safe pebble
#

she's so babygirl

#

and i adore her with all my heart

jade willow
#

She is super cute

#

She can be an idol

jade willow
#

any opinions on this outfit for sleepwear? Idk I might just revert it to default

random hinge
#

@safe pebble @pseudo dock After looking at the models, there's a few changes I'd like to make to them. Since they were made as a commission, I don't want to edit them without the approval from you two. The changes I'd like to make are (so far):
Kotomo model :

  • Edit the shoes so they're removable during events that requires it. I'll just black socks with the right bones.
  • Personally, I think a red bow would match the other ribbon around her neck. Was the black color requested specifically?
  • For consistency, I think it'd better if the short under the skirt is black.
  • The model has the earrings from the Yukari models. Was this requested? I'm not a huge fan of them, but I don't mind keeping them.
    Gym outfit:
  • I'm not a huge fan of that bow (outside the Phantom Thief outfit). I'd like to replace with another existing bow or the pink hair tie that's used on the gym outfit with the red tank top. Again, was that requested specifically?
random hinge
jade willow
#

This is actually that same outfit but with the leggings removed.

#

I also made the shorts a bit longer

coral prawn
#

It's completely false

#

I swear to god no one reads confidant descriptions

#

It was only said that she lived in Finland for a brief period of time

pseudo dock
safe pebble
#

you can change the gym outfit hair tie as well, i don't mind :)

random hinge
#

For the ponytail, the red bow looks nice I think

safe pebble
random hinge
rich tree
#

any chance we could get a pink or blue option for her umbrella?

random hinge
#

@safe pebble Does that pink band work for you? It's the same as the red tank top gym outfit

random hinge
rich tree
#

fair enough disregard it

random hinge
#

Nah, don't worry. I'll consider it, but there can easily be a lot of requests for that too

#

Also, one of the umbrella is bit tricky to edit iirc

#

I think it doesn't open in GFD or Blender, I don't remember which one

random hinge
#

Alright then, I'll go with that hair tie

#

I think I'll keep the black ribbon for the long hair variant

jade willow
#

I like her yellow umbrella. It's the one she actually used in canon 🥰

raw marlin
#

Anywhere else that needs to be blue?

random hinge
#

The Kotomo model has hair/face named vertex groups in the chest mesh. This isn't working well

raw marlin
#

Kasumi I think you’re missing something

random hinge
#

Okay, so the model wasn't liking the Sumire hair chunk I'm using for all the other models. Reusing the hair chunk from the base models eve sent me makes it work again

granite wren
#

Kasumi brave enough to show off her personal hole in reality

raw marlin
#

Very brave

rich tree
gaunt juniper
#

Man, I went to work on a few personal projects and I've come back to a plethora of new Kasumi hairstyles and outfits.

granite wren
#

She's just so fun to dress up in new outfits

hollow owl
#

Kasumi out here getting love and attention

errant zenith
#

Omg Kasumi is actually my dress up darling I just realized

bold mortar
#

Yeah I've dedicated so many hours this week just to play dress up lol

errant zenith
#

From Atlus outfits to outside of Atlus outfits

#

It’s awesome

molten finch
jade willow
#

tsubasa has a laaarge bust

granite wren
#

Yeah, TMS had a late teenage cast so it tracks

#

but it CAN be scaled down

#

her pink palette just fits Rose so well though

random hinge
#

You'll just need to credit Croissant Guard (and P5X as a source for the models) in your bangs mod

granite wren
random hinge
#

I'm getting prepared to update the mods

#

If you have personal edits or custom models, make a backup of them before updating

jade willow
#

its happening!! B_yay

granite wren
raw marlin
bold mortar
#

before i update my mod

jade willow
#

well I will test it in game now

granite wren
random hinge
#

Rose and Violet updated

#

If you're curious about Sumire's rank 10, here's a spoiler:

surreal ermine
#

AWWW

granite wren
#

AAAAAAAAAAAAAA FemCYay

jade willow
#

THATS SO CUTEE

raw marlin
#

AAAAAAWWWWWWnaocheer

random hinge
#

Models mods updated

#

I hope I haven't forgotten anything. I can feel Wisteria's pain when multiple people were contributing at the same time now

rich tree
#

how do you deal with a ghost bag? i posted a photo in the other chat

#

.<

bold mortar
errant zenith
#

Huge

bold mortar
#

ok time to update my mods now

errant zenith
#

Bester got the Masumi Profile pic

bold mortar
#

who

errant zenith
#

Makoto+Kasumi=Masumi

rich tree
#

woot bag free and looking cute

bold mortar
#

hmm i gotta edit the new models too

surreal ermine
#

looks like i'm spending some time making red rose versions of these models

#

ough i gotta edit the config too

bold mortar
#

gotta make versions for the makoto hair mod too

jade willow
#

Now I can try the fur coat mod with the rise hair

#

Material girl 💅

bold mortar
#

ok i think i've changed every model

#

which means i gotta update alternate bangs and then make all the new changes for the makoto hair mod

bold mortar
#

tf

#

why isn't the mod showing the reloaded ii install button

jade willow
#

Sometimes it takes up to 5 mins

bold mortar
#

idk everything else loads fine

#

so something is up with this

#

i'll give it another couple minutes

#

ig

surreal ermine
#

that's weird

#

did you change the update stuff?

#

the api could also be down

bold mortar
surreal ermine
#

did you fuck around with the update tab again

bold mortar
#

wdym by that?

surreal ermine
#

nvm

bold mortar
#

i just published it normally and then uploaded it

bold mortar
surreal ermine
#

yeah

#

looks fine

bold mortar
#

idk then

#

i'll try publishing and uploading it again

jade willow
#

the program had an update today

#

Maybe its related?

bold mortar
#

idk zylvos' update worked just fine

surreal ermine
#

reloaded has an update?

bold mortar
#

yeah it updated today

surreal ermine
#

oh i haven't been prompted yet

jade willow
#

I ignored that prompt lol

#

manually managing files >

bold mortar
#

ok ig i'll downgrade it and see

jade willow
#

this top is giving me such a hard time I might start over

surreal ermine
#

oh right i haven't been prompted because i use 2.5

bold mortar
#

ig theres a probablem with the new R2 update

#

anyways guys

#

now alternate bangs is uploaded

#

time to make the makoto hair update now naosmiley

bold mortar
#

can't really test that

jade willow
#

is textures hard for everyone or am I just silly?

bold mortar
#

idk what problem are you having

#

also i think i've finished the update for the makoto hair models

jade willow
bold mortar
#

yeah

bold mortar
#

Epic now both are updated

errant zenith
bold mortar
#

i should probably change my GB name to match my username better lol

bold mortar
#

makes it easier than replacing the files every time i update my mod

jade willow
#

Kasumi is so cute

#

She works well with so many hairstyles, its hard to choose

bold mortar
#

dunno who'd use them though

bold mortar
jade willow
#

I think in the future Ill make sure the textures on straight before messing with the mesh

bold mortar
#

good idea

jade willow
#

omg bester

#

do you know about this mystical feature called the sculpt tool!?

#

omg no Im freaking out that was sooo much easier than moving the vertices around

bold mortar
#

i use it sometimes in conjunction with vertex editing

#

it's something that should be used in moderation though

#

sometimes you can end up with weird looking stuff because of it

jade willow
#

It seems to work fine with animations at least (in blender)

#

Very nice to adjust just a specific area like a too large bust

bold mortar
#

yeah ofc

#

just speaking from experience, don't go overboard with it

jade willow
#

omg I think the issue is this mesh didnt have a uv0 map for its texture surprisedpikachu

jade willow
bold mortar
#

the evil one

jade willow
#

her eyes look HUGE

bold mortar
#

no eyelids here

bold mortar
jade willow
#

What do you mean?

bold mortar
#

since i've been complaining incessantly about the the fact that a month's worth of time that could've had the winter casual outfit was stolen by the incognito arc

#

i could make a my own incognito outfit

jade willow
#

Like the winter outfit with glasses?

bold mortar
#

yeah something like that

#

gonna make it rq

jade willow
#

"rq" is crazy

bold mortar
#

hair swaps should take all of a minute lol

bold mortar
#

well it'll need some slight editing

surreal ermine
#

creepypasta

jade willow
#

I can see why you want the winter outfits to last longer

jade willow
#

Here is my current progress with fixing the textures

surreal ermine
bold mortar
#

now i need to fix this

jade willow
#

I have nooo idea about that. Textures are the new magical mystical thing in blender for me

#

Im gonna try onee more thing and then rest

surreal ermine
#

famous last words

jade willow
#

real

bold mortar
jade willow
#

how did you do that wow_

bold mortar
#

vertex editing

surreal ermine
#

keep in mind though that those strands of hair move

#

they'll probably still clip

bold mortar
#

oh yeah probably

#

i'll probably end up testing it more whenever i get to the incognito segment

#

just rn that's what i've done

random hinge
#

I will update the ponytail variant when I get home from work because:

  • I've mixed up the fancy fur coat casual and eiko's casual outfit in the costume folders,
  • L7M3 finished the long hair bustup for the new version of their portraits.
random hinge
bold mortar
#

though i thought that was me just copying something wrong

bold mortar