#what is the most underrated weezer song

1 messages · Page 2 of 1

feral elm
#

Now i think about it a lot of tally hall songs are just ironic weird

dry carbon
#

true

pulsar spoke
#

how am i detached...

feral elm
#

I love birth song

fluid lake
#

don't take it personally!!

#

it's fine to like songs.

pulsar spoke
#

i wont!

feral elm
#

“All you pink skin babes are the same”

Talking about an unborn foetus

pulsar spoke
#

I don't consider myself politically detached though

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

not hating the lyrics is fine, liking the song itself is not fine cus this is probably the worst song ever made

#

at least worst song ive ever heard, and by a lot

feral elm
pulsar spoke
#

I feel like people disagree with my music taste more than yours syntax

feral elm
#

Are you stewpid

dry carbon
#

smart girls is awful

#

like a genuine 0/10

feral elm
#

Ok?

pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

if not negative 1/10

fluid lake
#

I hate my ungrateful son. ungrateful boy. nasty, rotten, boy.

pulsar spoke
#

-1/10

#

@dry carbon I DARE you to listen to demon dice

#

DARE

#

prepare yourseld

#

self

feral elm
#

“Daddy funk me! I say anyhoos”

dry carbon
#

later

fluid lake
#

I mean, we do like Weezer -- we're prepared.... kinda.

dry carbon
#

i should shower now

pulsar spoke
#

"jesus jesus japanesus"

#

real lyric

#

from them

#

its crazy

fluid lake
#

the human mind is a terrifying machine.

pulsar spoke
#

demon dice... is so... bad

dry carbon
#

i mean rivers wrote and recorded smart girls and thought "yea this is acceptable to release" so agreed

feral elm
#

“You see there’s leaders, and there’s followers. But id rather be a dick than a swallower”

#

Thank you MLK for those inspiring words

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
fluid lake
feral elm
pulsar spoke
feral elm
#

If you are good and listen to the entirety of madvillainy

fluid lake
#

so based

north echo
#

What have you done :(

#

The only song I can confidently say is underrated is hold me

#

The most slept on mb song

#

There’s probably some song on ok human or smth but idc

#

hold me

pulsar spoke
#

Hold me is really good

dry carbon
modest badge
#

anti hero

fluid lake
#

MB stinks balls. sweaty ones.

#

3 or 4 good songs, basically "Black" with rock production.

kindred bear
fluid lake
#

based. same here.

north echo
#

I’m just curious

fluid lake
#

wait, nevermind. hold on.

#

honestly? "Perfect Situation" and "Haunt You Everyday." I don't remember the rest.

dry carbon
#

hold me and damage in your heart are great too

kindred bear
#

But I think the old versions of Perfect Situation and Haunt You Everday are better

north echo
#

(Tell me what you did)

tawdry kettle
#

tisap?

#

today I sold all possessions

#

this is such a pity

#

I'm sorry

kindred bear
mystic sluice
#

King

mystic sluice
brazen stone
#

Nobody talks about Falling For You enough in my opinion

dry carbon
#

they talk abt it a shitton

pulsar spoke
#

Ffy is kinda overrated imo, still good song

dry carbon
#

maybe but i still love it

north echo
#

It is overrated and I don’t love it L

flint comet
#

The one that got away

pulsar spoke
flint comet
pulsar spoke
#

so

#

“Worst”

flint comet
#

I think everybody thinks winter is the best

pulsar spoke
#

But I think winter is bettwr than blue

flint comet
#

Depends on what you like

#

Both rock though

spice karma
flint comet
modest badge
#

in the garage

dry carbon
#

its looked pretty fondly on

#

its pretty mediocre

#

very forgettable

#

and worst on the album besides smile

fathom badger
#

I Just Threw Out The Love of My Dreams

pulsar spoke
#

it's beloved

fathom badger
#

yeah butt likeee more people need to like it

like even more

pulsar spoke
#

And it’s nowhere near tbe best on pink. Dlx

dry carbon
#

its prolly the most popular pink dlx track

#

actually yea id say it is besides tragic girl MAYBE

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
#

I mean

#

Those are all better

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
#

Syntax

#

Shut

dry carbon
#

and ywgwmt is the worst pt dlx track

pulsar spoke
#

Not true

#

Funnest to sing

dry carbon
#

the rest is can see being slightly better but not by a lot (besides tragic girl which is better)

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
#

Fun≠funny

#

If I have fun with a song thag can make it good

#

Wdym

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
#

It very much can?

#

Like what?

#

Sad bias strikes again

dry carbon
#

fun can ig but a fun song doesnt make it a great song

pulsar spoke
#

I know, but there’s obviously more than that

#

But it being fun to sing makes me like it

dry carbon
#

and it doesnt save one that has pretty bad lyrics for the album its on and instrumentals that are nothing to write home about

#

its the only pinkerton era song id say is under a 9/10

#

its like an 8.5 prolly or just 8

pulsar spoke
#

The lyrics are for a story, and written good for what they are

dry carbon
#

but in comparison to the rest of the album awful

pulsar spoke
#

Nothing on Pinkerton DLX is below a 9 except I Swear it’s True

dry carbon
#

i swear its true is a 10/10 easily??

pulsar spoke
#

It’s an easy 6

dry carbon
#

????

#

music good vocals good lyrics good

#

what is the problem seriously

dry ore
#

I always found it to be overhated

dry carbon
#

definitely the most underrated dlx track

pulsar spoke
#

I don’t have any enjoyment listening to it

dry carbon
#

i get a LOT

#

more than a majority of the main album and all the dlx besides tragic girl

#

the blue version doesnt do much for me but its still a 7

vague vapor
#

Susanne maybe

dry carbon
#

usually thats considered the best on blue dlx no?

#

in my time ive heard nothing but immense praise for it

vague vapor
#

no 💀💀

dry carbon
#

besides paperface

vague vapor
#

mykel and carli and paperface are way more loved

#

paperface for good reasons

#

but still

dry carbon
#

ive seen more susanne love than M&C love but yea both are looked upon very fondly

vague vapor
#

lullaby for wayne with the bigger weezer fans too

#

idk I see a lot more people say m&c is the best blue era song than susanne

dry carbon
#

lullabye for wayne is the best dlx song just in general imo besides like tragic girl and the spider

#

oh and friend of a friend

#

but its 4th or 5th definitely

vague vapor
#

I'd also say my evaline is pretty underrated because like obviously it's not the greatest song ever but I like it a lot, it's short and sweet, but I see a lot of hate for it

dry carbon
#

i dont hate it but its my least favorite deluxe track just in general besides the absolutely insufferable jacked up remix

vague vapor
#

although lullaby for wayne is still really great

dry carbon
#

prom night is more a bonus track so ion count it but its the best white era track imo besides friend of a friend

vague vapor
#

fair enough

dry carbon
#

i looooove white bonus tracks

vague vapor
#

same

#

besides jacked up remix

#

and I love the usa it's mid

dry carbon
#

the main album be so good and its like "waow no way this gets better" and then the bonus tracks and shit happen its like "waow it got better!!"

dry carbon
dry carbon
vague vapor
#

I wouldn't go THAT far

#

also ngl the blue vs pinkerton interview is one of my favorite things in a weezer release

#

not a song but still want to mention it

dry carbon
#

i like it

#

its a neat lil bonus

vague vapor
#

tripping down the freeway

vague vapor
#

piece of cake is their worst song

#

by far

pulsar spoke
vague vapor
#

lawn chair is bad but not that bad

next anvil
slender grottoBOT
#

“Beverly Hills is so ingenious. Like the lyrics….’It’s something you’re born into, and I just don’t belong’. It’s what everybody is feeling, but nobody had thought it or articulated it in a song. It’s just genius I think.

The social commentary alone is just very overlooked in rock critic intelligentsia. I don’t think they’re really operating on the same level that Rivers is in terms of art. It’s a statement.

… and it’s a kick-ass jam too.“

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

amazing? no

#

good? yea

dry carbon
#

smart girls worse

#

im the nr 1 smart girls hater like genuinely i dont think anyone hates that song more than me

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

piece of cake is bottom 15 but almost all of hurley is worse

vague vapor
#

piece of cake is bottom 1 at least

dry carbon
#

bottom 10 at MOST

vague vapor
#

you know how you are with smart girls

#

that's me with piece of cake

dry carbon
#

no one is with anything as i am with smart girls

#

maybe close

#

but never quite

vague vapor
#

okay

dry carbon
#

my hate for that song is like Pi

#

irrational and never ending

#

except its kinda rational

#

cus that song sucks

stiff dagger
#

In the mall

pulsar spoke
#

Smart Girls is aight

#

:3

dry carbon
#

no

#

it is the opposite of that

dry carbon
stiff dagger
pulsar spoke
#

Not horrible

dry carbon
#

true

#

then yea its just awful

north echo
north echo
#

Smh

#

Hurley has 10 tracks

#

Get it right

pulsar spoke
#

Beverly Hills is amazing

north echo
pulsar spoke
kindred bear
#

Beverly Hills made me not listen to Weezer for most of my life

pulsar spoke
#

Let me like it

kindred bear
#

because I heard it and thought of them as the "Beverly Hills Group"

#

Then I listened to Buddy Holly and was like

pulsar spoke
#

Beverly Hills is so fun

kindred bear
#

Beverly Hills is like

pulsar spoke
#

and kinda relatable, when you look at the lyrics and don’t take them at face value

kindred bear
#

Getting edged with a piece of sandpaper

pulsar spoke
#

sigh

kindred bear
#

sigh

dry carbon
kindred bear
#

naur

#

it's honestly overrated

#

I see too much love for it

dry carbon
#

its by far the most underrated weezer album

#

maladroit is not underrated lmfao

#

its constantly praised

#

it used to be underrated

#

now its perfectly rated

#

if not slightly overrated

#

dtfm is good and probably number 2

#

but the ratios arent quite matching up

#

dtfm is more hated than make believe but make believe is significantly better than dtfm so id say that makes it the more underrated of the two

kindred bear
#

not even a real album

dry carbon
#

riddle me this, was everything on it unique or had it been previously released

#

@kindred bear

kindred bear
#

I don't know I just said that because

dry carbon
#

LMAO

#

valid

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

i agree

sudden verge
#

surf wax america

dry carbon
#

its not underrated at all bro

#

its generally considered one of the best on blue and i have never once seen anyone hate it

#

its horribly overrated

vague vapor
#

quite the opposite

dry carbon
vague vapor
#

never bad but compared to the rest on blue

dry carbon
#

ive met like one person who doesnt have it in the top 5

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

and several who have it in the top 3

#

its extremely loved

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

yes

pulsar spoke
#

@dry carbon I say it’s my favorite all the time though… maybe you just think my opinion on blue os popular belief 🥺

dry carbon
#

not counting myself ofc

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
#

I love swa

dry carbon
#

its one of those songs that everyone calls underrated to the point that it becomes SEVERELY overrated

vague vapor
#

I see barely anyone say surf wax is top half on blue literally who are you talking to syntax 😭

dry carbon
#

top 3 most overrated weezer songs imo

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

who calls pinkerton underrated

#

ive seen that happen one time ever

pulsar spoke
#

Budd Holly, Jonas, Undone, Say it Ain’t So, and Only in Dreams consistently are ranked higher than SWA

pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

yea like 10 years ago

dry carbon
tawdry kettle
#

I quite like swa

#

I'm sorry

pulsar spoke
#

More like 25

pulsar spoke
dry carbon
tawdry kettle
#

I'm sorry

dry carbon
tawdry kettle
#

I'm sorry

pulsar spoke
#

Actually

dry carbon
#

nah

tawdry kettle
#

I'm koku

#

:koku:

pulsar spoke
#

You are koku!

tawdry kettle
#

^me!

#

as drawn by me

pulsar spoke
dry carbon
pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

two koku

#

again?

pulsar spoke
#

I’m Woooof

tawdry kettle
#

this ain't the first time people have renamed themselves to koku here

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

:o

#

no way that's impossible!

vague vapor
#

I like swa but it's like a 8.8 compared to a bunch of 9's and 10's on blue

pulsar spoke
#

@dry carbon weezer opions?

dry carbon
#

rde album

pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

:koku:

pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

hello

#

I like pd

#

and my name is woooof

pulsar spoke
#

No way

#

its Woooof

#

Haii Woooof

tawdry kettle
#

haiiii :3

pulsar spoke
#

@tawdry kettle @dry carbon @pulsar spoke

tawdry kettle
#

I like femboys

pulsar spoke
#

I like this Woooof guy

dry carbon
#

femboys and longtime sunshine..

pulsar spoke
#

Thats me!

#

Wittawy

tawdry kettle
#

longtime sunshine is my favourite song, yeah

#

and let it be as well

vague vapor
tawdry kettle
#

was it let it be?

dry carbon
#

red album and pd and white..

tawdry kettle
#

I hope it was...

pulsar spoke
#

Yess

#

I love let it be

tawdry kettle
#

I love let it be — woooof

#

(me)

pulsar spoke
#

You

vague vapor
pulsar spoke
#

I love weezer

pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

hello my name is kyrum and I'm cool

vague vapor
#

what would you guys say are my defining things

pulsar spoke
#

woah

tawdry kettle
#

I love sonic 3d blast

dry carbon
vague vapor
pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

and I love sandman mystery theatre or whatever it's called

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

oh that too

pulsar spoke
#

Kyrum I keep thinking ur like the pokemon Kyurem

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

guy with gas mask, hat, and gun

#

amirite guys

tawdry kettle
#

koku!

#

..I mean

#

kyrum!

dry carbon
#

kyrum

pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

:koku:

dry carbon
#

woooof?

pulsar spoke
vague vapor
tawdry kettle
pulsar spoke
#

Woooof

dry carbon
#

syntax??

tawdry kettle
#

I wonder where it's from..

pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
pulsar spoke
#

Its me syntax

dry carbon
#

holy shit guys

pulsar spoke
#

I hate uhhh Hurley

vague vapor
#

if I had a nickel for every time I've switch names in this server I'd have 2 yada yada

dry carbon
#

its him syntax

pulsar spoke
#

I hate Hurley

dry carbon
#

its ok

vague vapor
#

I love longtime sunshine :3

dry carbon
#

fembyos

#

fmeblys

pulsar spoke
#

koku loves LTS?

dry carbon
#

elfmeebeodgesnk

pulsar spoke
#

mmfgh..,

tawdry kettle
#

I wouldn't say love..

#

but I'm kyrum not koku

dry carbon
pulsar spoke
#

kyrum must know a lot about koku

tawdry kettle
#

we've been friends since...

pulsar spoke
tawdry kettle
#

four days ago

pulsar spoke
#

El Scorcho is Peak

dry carbon
#

me when longtime sunhsine

pulsar spoke
#

Longtime Sunshine is alright, but it’s not as good as a lot from Pinkerton Dlx tbh

dry carbon
#

Syntax...

vague vapor
pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

nah

tawdry kettle
#

kyrum

pulsar spoke
#

If you wanted a slow track, Butterfly is the better option.

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

nah butterfly is ok but not better than the masterpiece that is longtime sunshine

#

best song ever

pulsar spoke
#

I don’t think so

dry carbon
#

i do

vague vapor
#

guys what's the best beatles song

#

let it be obviously

pulsar spoke
#

I didn’t think koku thoufht that

vague vapor
#

idk I think so

#

I forgor

dry carbon
#

i think its let it be

tawdry kettle
#

my name is kyrum and I think koku's favourite beatles song is...

#

idk

#

eleanor rigby(?)

vague vapor
#

yeah

next anvil
#

Anything from Raditude other than love is the answer

pulsar spoke
next anvil
#

It's the worst song on raditude?

pulsar spoke
#

It’s lyrically the best even!

dry carbon
dry carbon
#

good? yea

kindred bear
#

Long time Sunshine is mmmrmrphphh

#

just mrrphphphpphphp

#

ughhhh

#

so fucking good

#

ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

dry carbon
#

i wasnt being serious lmao

#

i was roleplaying as woooof for a joke

#

i like butterfly way more than lts

kindred bear
#

You still said facts

kindred bear
dry carbon
#

i merely enjoy it more

rare dawn
#

cant stop partying

spice karma
#

No

north echo
#

Stop cherry-picking stories

dry carbon
#

im not

kindred bear
#

Raditudue on top

modest badge
dry carbon
#

bad lyrics and vocals and music

#

just

#

bad

kindred bear
#

it's good

north echo
#

No

#

It has the second worst lyrics ever (only beaten out by California snow)

pulsar spoke
#

Honestly the message of Memories is relatable

#

And the MV being so happy, but it being so long ago now and the theme of the song, the MV feels kinda sad almost

#

Like, look at how much fun they’re having

next anvil
kindred bear
#

It's one of the only 3 good songs bruh

next anvil
#

What are the other two, of of curiosity?

kindred bear
#

Where's My Sex and All My Friends are Insects

dry carbon
#

wheres my sex is 0/10

#

insects is a deluxe track

#

memories is awful

#

try again

kindred bear
#

Don't care

#

Deluxe is still part of the album

dry carbon
#

counterpoint: if it was there wouldn't be a seperate dlx edition

dry carbon
#

theres more than enough angel and the one love

#

ive seen multiple people say its the best post-pinkerton track

#

i disagree very strongly, imo its the worst red track but like what you like

pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

horribly boring

north echo
#

The greatest man that ever lived (isn’t boring but still is moreso than taato)

north echo
#

So do I

#

But I think that it drags on more than taato

whole pecan
#

Summer Elaine and Drunk Dori

north echo
#

Fr

#

I love that song

fluid lake
#

any songs from Hurley other than "Smart Girls."

pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

awful and unlistenable

#

as is most of the album

fluid lake
#

Hurley fucking rocks, y'all are closed minded.

pulsar spoke
#

Memories, Smart Girls, Trainwrecks, and Unspoken are great.

dry carbon
#

hang on is good run away is mediocre rest is absolutely awful

#

ive listened to it 6 times and every time it gets worse

fluid lake
#

wrong.....

dry carbon
#

i can say with 100% confidence its the worst album ive ever heard

fluid lake
#

says the MB fan....

dry carbon
#

how many times have you heard make believe

#

i asked you earlier and you dodged the question

#

if its only once you dont get an opinion cus thats not enough to truly form an opinion on smt

pulsar spoke
#

Hang on till’ i see you again

dry carbon
fluid lake
#

more than I should.

#

so more than thrice....

dry carbon
#

that is not an answer

dry carbon
#

so you just have bad taste then alr

#

should expect nothing more from hurley role person

fluid lake
#

no!!! I just hate innofensive stuff....

#

done badly -- I mean.

#

Hurley is MB done right.

#

😳

dry carbon
dry carbon
pulsar spoke
fluid lake
#

playing it safe is fine, but when you do it to the point of not feeling solid -- that becomes a problem.

#

same issue I have with "Black."

dry carbon
#

better to play it safe than make something genuinely awful (hurley)

fluid lake
#

nah, the opposite.

#

IMO -- at least.

#

and Hurley ain't awful.

#

weird cover/name, but good songs.

dry carbon
#

good song*

#

just the one

fluid lake
#

songs*

dry carbon
#

rest are pretty bad

fluid lake
#

hm...........

dry carbon
#

yes?

vague vapor
#

nah that's like bottom 5 weezer at LEAST

#

wheres my sex
love is the answer
time flies
piece of cake

#

in that order

vague vapor
#

piece of cake is their worst song

north echo
#

the black album is their worst song

vague linden
#

+1

#

death to false metal gets too much hate

#

ruling me has to win the prize of the most underappreciated weezer song

next anvil
#

Real

still pike
#

Great song

vague vapor
#

buddy holly

pulsar spoke
#

True

flint comet
#

Recommend me other songs

dry carbon
#

underrated songs
adds some of the most popular weezer songs
alright.

#

oid is arguably the most praised blue album song

#

at least top 3

#

not even arguably tbh, ive seen more ppl say its their all time favorite weezer song than any other song

#

falling for you is praised highly also

#

so is slob and love of my dreams

#

love of my dreams is like their 7th most popular song on spotify how is it underrated 💀

#

thank you and goodnight is praised

#

and dark enough to see the stars

#

ngl this feels more like a "songs i like" playlist than an "underrated songs" playlist

dry carbon
#

swa yea

#

butterfly isnt widely praised tho its pretty underrated

dry carbon
#

fym 🤨

#

thats true

vague linden
#

you probably meant to post this

flint comet
vague linden
#

now this is a playlist of real underrated songs

still pike
#

Yeah gave it a chance

#

And it was pretty good

#

Thanks Hurley Album Enjoyer

flint comet
#

I dont see you talking about them

vague linden
#

of course it's good, we need to #freeHurley

dry carbon
#

oid? not underrated
swa? not underrated
ijtotlomd? one of their most popular spotify songs (not underrated)
falling for you? not underrated
slob? no
jacked up? no
thank you and goodnight? no
dark enough? no

vague linden
#

maybe dark enough, but it's still pretty popular among the fans

flint comet
#

youd be shocked

vague linden
#

i think they can trim their playlist by just leaving in the mall and possibilities

dry carbon
#

i see tons of takes daily

#

and ive heard almost no hate for all of these

flint comet
#

You would be shocked theres more than reddit

dry carbon
#

what is this based on anyways

flint comet
dry carbon
#

underrated means "the general community dislikes it but its good" not "someone i asked thinks its bad but its good"

flint comet
#

...

dry carbon
#

theres not just weezer fans here and on reddit but these are the largest communities of weezer besides maybe twitter idk whats up there or if there even is a weezer community there or smt and i can tell you with 100% certainty that every song i named above is not underrated

dry carbon
#

at that point just add every song that isnt buddy holly and island in the sun cus weezer as a whole needs to be listened to more

flint comet
north echo
#

fr make believe yay

lost mason
north echo
#

if were going for underrated on white thats gotta go to basketball hands down

#

also its not that its underrated i just see absolutely nobody talking about it

tawdry kettle
#

I thought it was from sznz winter...

vague linden
#

uh, pretty sure it's from pinkerton?

north echo
#

my bad

#

teehee

dry carbon
north echo
#

i love the one that got away so much

#

something about that guitar solo

#

with its simplicity

#

idk

#

its just amazing

vague linden
#

same, when it released I think I played this song on loop for like a week non stop

tropic cradle
north echo
pulsar spoke
exotic pond
#

Ngl I feel like Burndt Jamb is not as popular as it should be because it just sounds so good
It is not given the attention I think it deserves

vague linden
#

yeah, definitely not underrated

pulsar spoke
kindred bear
pulsar spoke
#

It’s one of the few weezer songs i dont really like

tiny quest
#

Lullaby for Wayne is criminally underrated

#

( i think )

dry carbon
#

yes

kindred bear
#

I think it's decent but it's one of the weaker ones on the blue deluxe

dry carbon
#

its by far the best blue dlx track and better than most of the main album

vague vapor
#

it's top 3

kindred bear
dry carbon
#

susanne is mid mykel and carli is pretty good but not better

kindred bear
#

I dunno I just don't really like Lullaby For Wayne

kindred bear
#

Put Me Back Together

flint comet
lusty hare
#

Getchoo

atomic ledge
#

Thought I knew just might be the worst weezer song ever

still pike
#

Time flies tbh

kindred bear
atomic ledge
#

It’s so bad

#

Oh my gosh

kindred bear
#

nuh uh

atomic ledge
#

Just thinking about it gives me a headache

kindred bear
#

good

#

Suffer

atomic ledge
#

hey

#

You hurt my feelings

#

😭

#

Btw most underrated song is put me back together

kindred bear
atomic ledge
#

Yeah

#

I really like it

dry carbon
atomic ledge
dry carbon
#

the angel and the one is way worse than thought i knew and id say automatic is a bit worse too

atomic ledge
#

And automatic is aight

dry carbon
#

none of them are actually bad but the angel and the one is boring as fuck and automatic is nothing special

atomic ledge
#

Whatever

dry carbon
#

my man gave up 💀

atomic ledge
#

I find Brian’s vocals on the song annoying

#

And the melody sucks

#

The angel and the one is beautiful

#

One of the best weezer closers

dry carbon
#

its bottom 5 closers if im being honest

dry carbon
atomic ledge
dry carbon
#

time flies is the worst closer

#

followed by cali snow

atomic ledge
atomic ledge
#

I think I don’t want to let you go is second

#

It’s really boring

dry carbon
#

nah that ones like one of the best closers

atomic ledge
#

What?

#

It’s really boring and nothing happens

dry carbon
#

that describes angel way better than idwtlyg

#

at least idwtlyg is catchy

atomic ledge
#

Angel explodes

#

I don’t want to let you go isn’t very catchy and nothing happens

dry carbon
#

and he sings a little louder

#

thats not an explosion it just makes it go from painfully boring to just kinda boring

atomic ledge
#

I disagree

#

But I’ve got school tomorrow so I got to go to bed

#

Bye

dry carbon
#

gn

atomic ledge
#

Gn

vague vapor
#

idk about the christmas song, it's one of their best but I feel like most people who've heard it agree, I'd say it's just underknown? I guess idk what I'm trying to say

dry ore
#

Perhaps it's more overlooked rather than underrated?

flint comet
#

Yea

flint comet
#

"The Spider" is like... really good.

pulsar spoke
flint comet
#

rest of red is like a 6/10

flint comet
drifting lodge
#

december

flint comet
#

Weezer has always had good finishers excluding exceptions

drifting lodge
#

its my favorite track on maladroit

flint comet
#

That and space rock for me

#

I think more people need to go listen to Van Weezer again, seeing way to many 4/10's and Im starting to think people quit after the first track 😭

drifting lodge
#

its funny how different it is from ok human

flint comet
dry carbon
#

say what you want about other songs being better vocally or musically

#

but the spider is simply unbeatable lyrically

#

top 3 weezer for me also

#

whereas the next closest red song is like top 30 probably

sinful shore
#

Hold me is a solid out 8 of ten 10

#

But the acoustic demo is amazing it is perfect

#

Also,

#

Butterfly

dry carbon
sinful shore
#

As long as you can agree that hold me is very good

dry carbon
#

yea its amazing

north echo
#

aside from the chorus but that makes it feel harsh and fun yay

slim zinc
#

Slob

vague linden
#

smart girls

#

opening night

pulsar spoke
pulsar spoke
dry carbon
#

genuinely so fucking irritating i wish i was deaf when it comes on

vague linden
#

you're genuinely so wrong it's scary

dry carbon
#

how

#

how is it not irritating

#

vocals are literally the worst in any song ive ever heard

#

theres no good part in the instrumental whatsoever nothing of note its just boring in that regard

vague linden
#

best vocal performance since pinkerton

#

and im kin d of serious

dry carbon
#

the lyrics are just so ridiculously fucking stupid even for weezer standards that theres no way it wasnt made bad on purpose i genuinely cannot believe it was made to be a real song

vague linden
#

how is screams and all

#

the vocals are really good

#

the lyrics are dumb yeah

dry carbon
vague linden
#

nawhr

#

smart girls has dumb lyrics okay BUT the melody is amazing and vocal performances are the best on the album

#

this song is actaully addictive

dry carbon
#

smart girls lyrics arent dumb they're absolutely idiotic

#

i physically tense up whenever i think about any of the lines in this fuckin song

vague linden
#

it's weezer we talking about

dry carbon
#

theres a difference between funny cringe and just flat out fuckin stupid cringe

#

lyrically every song on hurley besides like two falls under stupid cringe

#

and especially smart girls

#

this guy can write good songs

#

he has before this and he did after

#

hell unspoken is a fine written song

#

during the same era that smart girls came out he wrote a song that was lyrically pretty good

#

he chose to make smart girls bad im 100% convinced

vague linden
#

lyrically bad

#

but aside from that, it's near perfect

dry carbon
#

💀

vague linden
#

you can enjoy a song but not the lyrics lol

dry carbon
vague linden
#

never been this serious

dry carbon
#

the vocals are like nails on a chalkboard to me idk why but it genuinely makes me wanna bash my head into a rock until i bleed out and thats barely an exaggeration

#

i dont remember a good riff i dont remember a good solo i dont remember a good drum or bass part

vague linden
#

i know i already told you this before, but you're missing out

dry carbon
#

its at best shitty

dry carbon
#

i hate it so much words cant describe it

#

im not missing out on anything

vague linden
#

you're blinded by your hate

dry carbon
#

im so much happier without it

dry carbon
#

yea i dont like it because i hate it thats how hating things works bud

vague linden
#

you're just stuck on your first impression of the album

#

there is no way

#

you can't enjoy a single song

#

especially SMART GIRLS

dry carbon
cerulean mesa
#

mondon why would you care

dry carbon
#

i enjoy hang on and to an extent run away

vague linden
#

it's hurley!!

dry carbon
#

i just think everything else on the album is stinky poopoo garbage

vague linden
#

well one day

dry carbon
vague linden
#

you'll understand

dry carbon
#

then i relistened and it went down to C

#

its actually gone down a tier every time i've listened to it

#

its now in like G or something but i just leave it at F

cerulean mesa
#

except for swifties ofc

dry carbon
#

ive heard it 4-6 times hated it more each time

#

its my least favorite album ever

#

and im never gonna listen to it again

#

ive heard it enough to know its awful

vague linden
vague linden
dry carbon
#

youre the one who needs condolences

vague linden
#

i might change my role from pinkerton to hurley soon

cerulean mesa
vague linden
#

i must show the whole world the right path

vague linden
dry carbon
#

why

#

what am i saying why to huh

#

sorry i got confused

vague linden
#

it's alright

#

your hate for hurley confuses you

#

it's normal

#

im listening to smart girls rn

#

the solo is peak

dry carbon
#

cobb is watching our conversation

vague linden
#

you just gotta wait a few years

#

took me some time too

dry carbon
#

yea no

#

if i have to listen to an album for several years for it to become good then its not good and im experiencing stockholm syndrome

#

id rather listen to like

#

honestly anything else 💀

cerulean mesa
#

Man cobb makes pretty decent music, it's kinda sad that he's just the guy that made the gary come home punk cover, or the guy who made zerwee, or the guy who made a cover of XYZ, I think he's got some potential, his last EP was good

vague linden
dry carbon
#

you are the one whos facing delusions my friend

still pike
cerulean mesa
dry carbon
#

id take dance monkey ten times over smart girls or wheres my sex once

cerulean mesa
#

I don't think it's that good..

dry carbon
#

yea thats exactly my point

dry carbon
#

if you enjoy it whatever go enjoy it

still pike
#

Blue and Pinkerton are

dry carbon
#

but if you think it is genuinely some kind of amazing masterwork of a creation the album with wheres my fucking sex on it you are the delusional one homie

vague linden
#

i'm not saying it's a perfect flawless masterpiece, but it's a great solid weezer album, and it gets too much hate it doesnt deserve

dry carbon
#

it gets not enough hate

#

sure a lotta people hate it

still pike
dry carbon
still pike
dry carbon
#

so it gets a lotta hate but for some reason the people who love it REALLY love it which means it requires more hate

vague linden
#

it literally is getting the pinkerton treatment though

#

one day people will realise

dry carbon
#

💀

#

pinkerton got hate because it was a look into his personal life and depression

#

hurley isnt that

#

hurley has one song thats even comparable to that

#

the rest of the album is possibly the least pinkerton weezers ever made besides maybe like pd or raditude

vague vapor
dry carbon
#

it will not become a cult classic loved by all fans and the day that it does is the day i leave the weezer community not even joking

vague linden
#

pack your bags then 😎

dry carbon
dry carbon
vague linden
#

we'll see

still pike
#

I’m a Green Mrider

#

But even I accept criticism from the album

#

Calm down bro

vague linden
#

hurley has some flaws and I never said it shouldnt be criticized

#

buuut some people just

#

hate to hate

dry carbon
#

i dont hate to hate you know that

#

hating to hate would be if i listened to it one time and decided that was enough to base my opinion on

#

i want to like it

#

i've listened to it tons of times hoping itll grow on me but it does the opposite

#

i am not hating to hate i hate because it is a genuinely awful record that deserves more hate than it gets

vague linden
#

people have to understand that hurley is the closest we got to the weezer sound in its purest form since pinkerton

dry carbon
#

now youre just spewing nonsense

vague linden
#

#justice for hurley

still pike
#

I get no Pinkerton vibes from Hurley

dry carbon
#

green sounds more like classic 90s weezer than fuckin hurley

still pike
#

Green mentioned

dry carbon
#

hell even reds way closer than hurley

vague linden
#

rough production, poppy melodies covered by a heavy rock sound, good vocal performances (even close to pinkerton on some tracks: unspoken, smart girls), etc..

#

they have a lot of similarities

dry carbon
#

heavy rock sound and good vocals, yea no

vague linden
#

but hurley is a lot more pop

dry carbon
#

its barely even rock bro

still pike
#

I enjoy Hurley to some extent but this is too much 😭

vague linden
#

what I mean

#

is that it is

#

if pinkerton

#

was pop

dry carbon
#

"if you ignore the difference its similar"

vague linden
#

and I think it works great

dry carbon
vague linden
#

just listen to smart girls

#

it's a pinkerton track

dry carbon
#

the vocals arent pinkerton the lyrics couldnt be less pinkerton

dry carbon
vague linden
#

exdcept for the lyrics of course lol

#

but I mean

#

the music and the melody

#

and the way he sings

#

like the solo

#

this is straight out of pinkerton

dry carbon
#

pinkerton is raw and emotional with raw emotional vocals

vague linden
#

im not kidding

#

thats why I said pinkerton, but pop

dry carbon
#

nothing emotional or raw out of that song

vague linden
#

a biut less raw

dry carbon
#

you're literally just saying "besides all the differences its the same" this applies to literally anything

#

if you ignore the differences a lamp and a fridge are the exact same thing!,

#

your argument makes literally no sense whatsoever

#

this has to be bait

#

it just has to

still pike
#

TWHTALMH

#

IS ON

#

But yeah bait

#

Even I don’t defend Green this much

#

Did you guys know Green and Pinkerton are the same

#

They both contain songs

vague linden
#

im trying to make a

#

hurley/pinkerton comparaison

#

but my computer doesnt pick up the sound

#

but the second half of smart girls KIND OF sounds like Tired Of Sex

#

especially the 'make me loose my mind' part

#

play the two songs side by side

#

and you'll see

#

you cant tell me it doesnt sound like a pinkerton track (but pop)

dry carbon
#

cannibal corpse (slam metal) and blink 182 (pop punk) are actually really similar if you just ignore the differences

#

you see

#

they both are bands

#

they both have only male members

#

they both do genres of rock

#

cannibal corpse is basically just blink 182 but slam metal

dry carbon
#

youre nitpicking, you can nitpick pretty much any two things into sounding similar

#

i could probably find a black metal riff that sounds vaguely like sweater song doesnt make them in any way similar

vague linden
#

thats one example amongst many others

#

but you have to admit

#

it kinda have

#

that same energy

dry carbon
#

lemme listen

#

no not in the slightest what the fuck are you talking about

#

im actually slightly more convinced that theyre completely different now

vague linden
#

what

#

no

#

if you cannot hear it then you are doing it on purpose

dry carbon
#

no im genuinely not

#

i have no idea how these things are even slightly similar

vague linden
#

smh my head

dry carbon
#

like i said

#

you can find any two things and nitpick them into being similar

dry carbon
dry carbon
vague linden
#

this is completely unrelated

#

these two songs

#

really sound alike

dry carbon
#

no they do not

vague linden
#

but you simply refuse to face the truth 😌

dry carbon
vague linden
#

the way he's singing

#

the melody

#

idk

dry carbon
#

im not saying its the exact same thing im using it as an example as to how you can make two completely different things seem similar by finding random small details in common

#

this is what conspiracy theorists do

#

both songs have guitar and rivers singing they must be the same

vague linden
#

two songs that have the same energy, are kind of sang the same way and I'm nitpicking?

dry carbon
#

they dont have the same energy and are not sung very similarly

#

yes nitpicking

vague linden
#

this is a lost cause

dry carbon
#

then stop trying

#

i dont get why you need to convince me to love this album

#

its not gonna happen youre wasting your time

#

i hate it and always will

vague linden
#

this is litterally

#

a real life example

#

of the Allegory of the cave

dry carbon
#

💀

#

how are these things related

#

explain how im chained to a wall looking at shadows because i dont like a shitty album

#

are you saying im not actually seeing it for what it is because im blinded by hate or something

#

tryna bring greek philosophy into an argument is not gonna make me like the album buddy

#

really just cannot let this go so hes wasting both of our times

vague linden
#

lmao

#

i know i just thought it was funny

#

but i do hope that someday you will break free of your chains and go see the truth

still pike
#

This shit is killing me

dry carbon
#

its pretty comical

#

mans out here making a fool of himself so he can convince me to like an album that ive alr told him several times he cannot convince me

vague linden
#

and I will keep on trying util the day you get enlightened by this album

dry carbon
#

you waste your own time buddy

#

but keep trying if you must

#

but its not a good idea

vague linden
#

it is my moral duty to spread awareness

pulsar spoke
#

I’m a smart girls defender but no

vague linden
#

then give me a counter-example

pulsar spoke
vague linden
#

yeah

pulsar spoke
#

LA Girlz

#

Angel and the One

#

The Other Way

#

The Spider

vague linden
#

yeah they're good but not near smart girls

still pike
#

Make believe mentioned Wtf is a bad album 🗣️🔥🗣️🔥

pulsar spoke
#

I like it

vague linden
#

listen to the mp3 i sent

pulsar spoke
#

But still

pulsar spoke
still pike
#

Jacked up > Smart Girls

dry carbon
#

pretty much all of maladroit, make believe, raditude, dtfm, ewbaite, white, and okh easily beat smart girls vocally

still pike
#

Rivers killed it in those vocals