what is the most underrated weezer song

[flint comet]

island in the sun or beverly hills

🔥

[gilded dagger]

bro wgat

[flint comet]

joek

[storm basalt]

butterfly, thought i knew or death and destruction imo

[gilded dagger]

i log butterfly

[flint comet]

just raditude

[gilded dagger]

i dont see enough people talk about go away and lonely girl

[flint comet]

go awya is my favottirite wezir sog

[storm basalt]

i heart wesir

[gilded dagger]

foreal

[gilded dagger]

meto

[dry ore]

Love Explosion

[gilded dagger]

Cleopatra

[flint comet]

Numbers

Or here comes the rain

[spark ridge]

anonymous

and uhh

screens

[next forum]

Do you wanna get high? is one of their best songs easily

but lots say its the worst on white so I think its a bit underrated

[lean tendon]

Love explosion is the BEST maladroit song and the least streamed.

[spark ridge]

REALL

[spark ridge]

who tf is saying that bro its soo good

[next forum]

ray

😡

[fluid lake]

Girl We Got A Good Thing

Most of Hurley too.

[kindred bear]

slob

[lean tendon]

Slob sweep sounds like a command more than a username.

“Slob, sweep!”

[vague linden]

the underdogs
raditude has lots of underrated weezer songs lol, too many people are missing out on this album imo

[karmic cove]

Buddy holly

[burnt rampart]

Freak me out

And december

[hidden elbow]

Death and eestruction

Destruction

[noble ibex]

butterfly, the alternative take especially, longtime sunshine, and devotion

[south niche]

why bother?

[tropic cradle]

Idk why

Or Space Rock

[south niche]

i meant the song lmao

[tropic cradle]

No I know

It’s very underrated though

[south niche]

OH

my bad haha

[tropic cradle]

No problem

[next anvil]

Hang on or falling for you

[vague linden]

falling for you ain't underrated though

id say Put me back together/The underdogs/Run over by a truck

raditude is pretty underrated

overall

[next anvil]

Fr fr

[kindred bear]

Jacked up or Slob

[trail raptor]

both

[trail raptor]

overrated

[pearl nebula]

Pork and Beans

[next anvil]

Absolutely not

[kindred bear]

https://open.spotify.com/track/0axMVGNgZdFAUbHk9Tp1oG?si=8cf85722f7d545ac

This one also needs to be talked about more.

[next anvil]

That song taught me how to count by 5

(not rly)

[trail raptor]

how

[trail raptor]

this song is ok

[kindred bear]

NO

It's so good

[next anvil]

Bc it's rly good and less talked about that some other ones that are less deserving

[kindred bear]

Every song on EWBAITE needs to be talked about more imo

People say the album is good but no one talks about specific songs

[next anvil]

Fr

[trail raptor]

its good but tbh my least favorite on ewbaite

[kindred bear]

That's fine

[trail raptor]

thats everyone’s fav on ewbaite

[kindred bear]

Really?

my fav is either that or Go Away

[trail raptor]

the bridge on go away is heavenly

especially the “that was your last chance”

[kindred bear]

Go Away is overhated

I've seen so many people say it's their least favorite on the album

[trail raptor]

ive never seen a go away hater

[kindred bear]

I have and it's sad

[trail raptor]

damn

its a pretty good song

its also pretty crazy how there’s ewbaite haters in general

[burnt rampart]

Yeah go away is by far one of the least liked ewbaite songs

But its great

[dry ore]

Always see Cleopatra towards the bottom of EWBAITE rankings

[flint comet]

Go away is such a baller bro

Also cleopatra is a baller to

I think the least liked songs on ewbaite have the same story as blue/pink

All songs are really good, so having a “worst song” doesn’t say ALOT.

The worst songs on blue are better than 80% of weezer’s catalogue

[kindred bear]

california snow also underrated

[next anvil]

Bruh, that song suck (my opinion)

[north temple]

The Spider

[south tapir]

bird with a broken wing went hard asf

[flint quartz]

My best friend from the make believe album

🔥

[hollow cove]

agreed

beverly hills is so underrated

/j

[next anvil]

Frrr

[next forum]

i love best coast and ewbaite so its weird that i dont like go away but i dont

it by far the worst on the album

[gilded dagger]

i love baunt you wvergshay

[azure pollen]

holiday

or maybe twhtalmh

[azure pollen]

sorry

the world hath turned and left me here

[dry ore]

both are in my top 3 on that album

[burnt rampart]

Best song OAT

But I wouldnt call any song on Blue or pinkerton underrated

Maaaaybe underrated compared to other Blue songs

[noble ibex]

butterfly fr

aloo gobi isnt the best sing but it’s ALWAYS in my head

[noble ibex]

ILY NO ONE TALKS SNOUGH SBOUT THIS SONG

[muted shard]

i gotta say

pink triangle radio mix

it's like it sounds higher quality yk

It does actually

Wtf

[wispy creek]

Jamie its not a offical album song BUT IT IS IN MY WORLD

[modest badge]

teenage dirtbag

[shrewd ridge]

Heart songs
California snow
Why bother
Da vinci

[shrewd ridge]

Yeah I like california snow

The lyrics are very shit I agree but the instrumental and chorus I quite like

[vague linden]

overrated if anything

[north temple]

I just like it a lot, okay?!?!/nm

[vague linden]

i will NOT allow anyone to enjoy something i dislike!!!! 😡

[kindred bear]

California Snow is so good bruh

[flint comet]

Buddy holly

[fluid lake]

Susanne,
California Snow,
Zombie Bastards,
Everybody Needs Salvation,
Lullaby,
Unspoken,
Sandwiches Time,
Two Broken Hearts,
Wanda (You're My Only Love),
Smile,
She's Had a Girl,
What is This I Find?,
so many.....

I reject the rules.

[terse rose]

BASED

and like half of black

[kindred bear]

So real for California Snow and Zombie Bastards

[odd ember]

i’ve seen to much “Go Away” hate

too*

[tight oar]

Cali Snow

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[flint comet]

We should giiiiiive all our love

[muted shard]

Run Away

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[vague linden]

ruling me

and >half of raditude

[north echo]

I know this isn’t about demos but the demo for TISAP is insane

[lyric cosmos]

Posabilities
Pardon Me
The Other Way
Freak Me Out
Let It All Hang Out
Unspoken

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[north echo]

Freak me out? Man what are you on?? ☠️☠️☠️

TOW is based tho 💯🔥🔥

[lyric cosmos]

I like it it's chill

[timid agate]

island in the sun, buddy holly, say it aint so, beverly hills...

[flint comet]

Totally

Bro “tell me what you did” could of been weezers best of the best, up there with hyed, instead we got pity

Have you seen weezers self produced make believe versus the final, don’t get me wrong Rick making hyed and helping rivers mentally is great, but god did we miss out on something close to Pinkerton

[north echo]

Oh yeah I forgor he’s like entirely responsible for hyed

[flint comet]

He’s the sole reason rivers is happy and all, but god am I so sad we missed out on ponkerton2

[raw ridge]

Tragic girl

[next forum]

"not any b-sides/demos"

[silent kiln]

Surf Wax America

[fluid lake]

don't be a coward. don't give into their silly rules.

[raw ridge]

Fair point

[fluid lake]

yeah!! :DDD

[flint comet]

I love wax surf

[flint comet]

why bother

[azure pollen]

dude i love that song so much

[flint comet]

SAMEE

[silent kiln]

They were playing that on my local radio

[muted shard]

hash pipe

[raw ridge]

Dawg what planet are you living in

[raw ridge]

I love those obscure songs

[muted shard]

jupiter

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[north echo]

Rob cantor

[muted shard]

indeed

[trail raptor]

Feels Like Summer

[tiny quest]

true

I think dreamin' is criminally underrated

[flint comet]

Dreamin is rlly good too

[winter brook]

Burndt Jamb and Endless Bummer

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[flint comet]

Literally

[sour dawn]

can't stop partying

[north echo]

No lol

[raw ridge]

[sour dawn]

you're allowed to be wrong it's okay

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[north echo]

No in my opinion*

[tight oar]

Trueeeee

[sour dawn]

you opinion allowed to be wrong i am not in denial no shut up 😭

[flint comet]

5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100 105

[next anvil]

How long did it take you to find that?

[tiny quest]

i think hold me is also very underrated

and this is such a pity

[north echo]

Tell me what you did is better than pity

(The demo)

[brittle solstice]

buddy holly

[humble frost]

Falling for you

[tiny quest]

VALID

[tropic tundra]

if we're counting SZNZ as an album, should she stay or should she go

if not, numbers

[tiny quest]

true

[sinful meadow]

buddy holly

[silent kiln]

Good pfp

[warm marsh]

Ruling me 100%

[north echo]

Ruler of everything 💯

[vague linden]

☝️ he's right, you know

i'd also add run away and time flies while we're there

[remote monolith]

People dont talk about EWBAINE period

[north echo]

Everything will be alright in ne end

[remote monolith]

Oh

I’m stupid

[north echo]

Lol

[raw ridge]

Not true at all

[remote monolith]

Well at least i dont hear it

All i hear id people praising blue and Pinkerton

[kindred bear]

People say Everything Will be Alright in the End is great a lot but they never say specific songs

[remote monolith]

I think I’d say it is my 3rd favorite album. Blue is first then Pinkerton the EWBAITE

[kindred bear]

It's my 4th favorite maybe

[north echo]

4-5

[winter tendon]

The only answer that should be in there is Let's Sew Our Pants Together

[hollow cove]

tired of having sex

[hexed cairn]

That's a song?

[south tapir]

only correct answer

[kindred bear]

crab

[sweet hare]

the british are coming

[north echo]

Fr

[dry carbon]

smt on make believe or maladroit probably

also butterfly

ill say damage in your heart is the most underrated

actually nah hold me is

[hollow geode]

sweet mary

its a genuinely good song, held back by the fact it’s on a bad rated album (can agree with the majority of songs on that album)

genuinely one of my favorite weezer songs

[dry carbon]

i like the whole album besides that song

its not cus of the album its on its cus it just isnt very good

[hollow geode]

man that is like the only song I love on the album (qb blitz is ok but sweet mary tops that imo)

[honest lynx]

pork and beans

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[flint comet]

Yes

[raw ridge]

Not weezer but Walt Disney

[tropic cradle]

Disneygay

[north echo]

@hidden elbow

[hidden elbow]

What’s up

[tropic cradle]

Huh

He just said Walt Disney

[hidden elbow]

I am disneygay

[regal oxide]

Where’s my sex

[dry carbon]

nah thats actual ass

[regal oxide]

The guitar is so good in that song

[dry carbon]

everything abt it is awful

[lapis knot]

why bother is their best song fr

[dry carbon]

unironically yea

their second best probably

[grizzled hamlet]

Pig

[dry carbon]

not rlly underrated, i see a lotta praise for it

[tropic cradle]

Kinda right

[dry carbon]

nah nothing abt it is good

[regal lotus]

Purple Flowers? Yea, Purple Flowers.
definitely.

[dry carbon]

absolutely peak

[dull garden]

ahem
i don’t wanna let you go personally has a special place in my heart

[dry carbon]

yea its amazing

[grizzled hamlet]

fine then, The Underdogs

[dry carbon]

yea that works

[pulsar hemlock]

Yeah it's easily the best song on the album.

By a lot

[dull garden]

glad you can agree i’m super in love with the bridge demo version too

[pulsar hemlock]

Lemme give it a listen.

[flint comet]

do you wanna get high or la girlz

[grizzled hamlet]

Nothing on white is really underrated, white in general is highly praised, especially these 2 songs

[dry carbon]

yea agreed

[north echo]

I hear a ton for dywgh but not too much for la girlz

[sly orchid]

One message removed from a suspended account.

One message removed from a suspended account.

One message removed from a suspended account.

[azure pollen]

I don’t know if we are all in drugs is underrated but I never hear anyone talking about it

[dry carbon]

it is kinda underrated

[north echo]

It’s a good song for me personally

[dusky agate]

I think butterfly is underrated but one song I hear nobody talk about that is literally one of my favs is getchoo it's a super banger

[dry carbon]

butterfly is very underrated

[dusky agate]

I wish more people knew it because I'm soo obsessed with that song rn it's soo good

[dry carbon]

most ppl know it just most ppl dislike it

[dusky agate]

WHAT I was sooo not aware of this why would anybody hate it??

[dry carbon]

they think its too slow for the album i think

and that longtime sunshine would be a better closer

a notion i hate

[dusky agate]

Oh it is a bit different from the rest of the album but I think it was needed but then again I think that the good life gives off red album vibes so I don't know how valid I am lol

[dry carbon]

yea that i dont rlly get

i mean thematically its like a less silly pork and beans kinda

the music itself not at all

[flint comet]

Automatic

I Don’t Want to Let You Go

Most of the songs off Summer

[dry carbon]

summer is not underrated

[flint comet]

I’ve seen it get a lot of hate here

I definitely wouldn’t say songs like Cuomoville and Opposite of Me are very well liked

[dry carbon]

i dont

its fun and catchy

[lyric cosmos]

Posabillities, Pardon Me, TOW, Freak Me Out, Dreamin, Automatic, Hang On, Beach Boys, Screens

[flint comet]

I have no idea how anyone could dislike Dreamin

Fucking incredible song

[north echo]

Wait isn’t automatic a LTJ song?

Wait

It’s on red?

:(

[lyric cosmos]

Ltj?

Yeah its red

What is LTJ?

[north echo]

Less than Jake

Ska band

[flint comet]

https://tenor.com/view/yes-agree-nod-dog-gif-14494361

Great band

[flat venture]

Butterfly

[raw ridge]

Fair

[north echo]

For real!

[obsidian garden]

The good life

[dry carbon]

praying this is irony

[kindred bear]

In The Garage, Surf Wax America, Butterfly, California Snow, Slob, Jacked Up, This Is Such a Pity, and uhhh I guess that's all.

[dry carbon]

i hear literally NOTHING but love for surf wax america

never any critiscism for it

rest i can see

[north echo]

I think it was originally pretty disliked

But then some people came out and started to love it

Same thing that happened to mb I think

[grizzled hamlet]

nothing off blue and pinkerton are underrated

or white I think too

Slob is generally loved too

[flint comet]

People don’t really talk about Take Control, but I’ve never heard anyone disliked it so idk

I would pay money to see them play that live

[dry carbon]

its amazing

and i woooont be comin baaaack round here no more, no

[dry carbon]

yea me too

catchy as shit

[grizzled hamlet]

Rivers version or Scott’s version

[dry ore]

Love that song

[kindred bear]

yes

that one

[flint comet]

Also Dead Roses

Easily my fave lyrics,

[next forum]

getchoo gets too much hate its a great song

[raw ridge]

A lot of people talk about getchoo, but not no other one

I love no other one

[dry carbon]

me too

[hollow geode]

me too too

[rain zealot]

butterfly & thank you and good night

endless bummer is also kinda underrated

[north echo]

Real

Not the butterfly that songs 6/10 but the endless bummer yeah

[grizzled hamlet]

Endless Bummer gets so much love and appraisal

And nothing on Pinkerton or blue is underrated tbh lol

Thank you and good night maybe, however I know a lot of people love that one as well

[raw ridge]

Butterfly though, and I never hear anyone mention no other one

[grizzled hamlet]

pinkerton and blue are widely considered to be 10/10 albums tho, so i don't think any song on either of those two albums can be considered underrated lol

[woeful briar]

buddy holly literally no one has heard of it

[flint comet]

Is that the one where they go hip hip?

[lapis knot]

Why Bother? is amazing

[dry carbon]

its like my third favorite song ever

[lapis knot]

id probaby say second, with holiday or no one else in first

[dry carbon]

i dont like holiday

[flint comet]

Literally it's so underrated

[spice karma]

Wild at heart is such a banger

[north echo]

Memories is like c tier at best

[dry carbon]

d tier at best

[spice karma]

Ruling me is good

[dry carbon]

it is not

[regal oxide]

What about brave new world?

[regal oxide]

I say it’s A tier that song when played fast and heavy is so fire

[spice karma]

It is

All my friends are insects is🔥

[ancient scroll]

Mykel & Carli the deep meaning of it is super important

[regal lotus]

hot take: King

[north echo]

For real

[dry carbon]

its

ok?

i like it

one of the only hurley era songs i can confidently say i like

[north echo]

It’s a joke cuz it was on yo gabba gabba chill

https://youtu.be/0jtn3Apxwj4

[dry carbon]

thats what makes it good yea

[dry carbon]

whyre you telling me to chill 😭

[north echo]

You can’t get passionate about yo gabba gabba :(

Unless you watched it as a child

Then you 100% can

[dry carbon]

i did

its nostalgic

[north echo]

Fr

[flint comet]

(Probably because it’s the only one they didn’t write)

[dry carbon]

yea the hurley era songwriting is awful

even the listenable songs are still pretty meh lyrically

[flint comet]

Eh
I love it, but Briny is objectively far better

https://youtu.be/1Q63-FbRGlk?si=Klbt008gvW7YddkL

Yea

It’s one of the EWBAITE demos

Personally my favorite demo

[north echo]

I thought blue dream was a van weezer song

[dry carbon]

it is

but they built it off an ewbaite demo

[north echo]

Oh okay

[flat venture]

TRIE

REAL

The Spider too

[flint comet]

Pig

[dry carbon]

not rlly underrated

[flint comet]

Idc if it’s a b-side or demo lullaby for Wayne needs more recognition

[dry carbon]

it rlly does

i like it more than like 70% of the main album lmao

[north echo]

”erm it’s not a lullaby the title lied 0/10 🤓”

[green cedar]

The good life

[north echo]

Nuh uh

That might

That might be the worst take on this entire forum

@vague vapor @pulsar spoke looke this

[pulsar spoke]

at what

[pulsar spoke]

underated?

nah

[vague vapor]

true, not enough realize it's their best song

[dry carbon]

on NO planet

almost everyone puts it in like top 3 pinkerton

[green cedar]

Its so underrated

[dry carbon]

bait or naive

call it

[north echo]

Bait

[north echo]

People don’t have to realize it’s their best song, they just have to recognize it as a good song

[dry carbon]

probably

[north echo]

So would you say that not enough people recognize it as a good song?

[dry carbon]

everyone does

i dont think anyone dislikes it

ergo, not underrated

[vague vapor]

no I think they do

[north echo]

So you would say that buddy holly or something is underrated?

:(

Wait I’m taking this too seriously

Ugh

[vague vapor]

no because it's not their best song

[lost mason]

Haunt You Every Day

[dry carbon]

hold me is more underrated

hyed is usually the song ppl like on make believe

no one talks abt hold me ever

even tho its an easy 10

[vague vapor]

*9

[dry carbon]

hold me is a 10/10

[vague vapor]

the demo maybe

[dry carbon]

nah the demos a 9

[vague vapor]

you got the ratings mixed

[dry carbon]

nope

album version way better

[vague vapor]

no

[dry carbon]

yuh

[sinful meadow]

We are all on drugs

[pulsar spoke]

Sux

[solemn pond]

I say Weekend Woman

From Pacific Daydream

[regal oxide]

That’s literally “Blue Dream”

[flint comet]

No shit

[dry carbon]

no it doesnt

[dry carbon]

but better

[pulsar spoke]

Mhm

[north echo]

YES!!!

The demo just sounds off

Idk how

[dry carbon]

definitely

[north echo]

Think it’s at the chorus

Easily the most slept on song on the album

[dry carbon]

by far

[regal oxide]

Eh to soft for me

It’s the same thing lol

[north echo]

7/10

Not particularly underrated

On a silly scale it’s way underrated

15 rivers out of 10

[vague vapor]

is the christmas song underrated

idk

[flint comet]

Kinda
Not cause people dislike it, but just because many don’t know of it

[vague vapor]

exactly

[north echo]

So just unknown?

Idk

[flint comet]

photograph from the green album. it is SO FUCKING GOOD

[vague vapor]

fr

[pulsar spoke]

Agreed

[flint comet]

A lot of songs from van weezer are super underrated, like they are complete baller songs and yet I see more people talk about Hurley and ratitude than van weezer

Literally the worst song on van weezer according to a lot of people still lands like a 6-7/10

People sleep on van weezer

[spice karma]

Fr I like a lot of van weezer

[dry carbon]

well raditudes way better

hurleys totally awful

[flint comet]

Raditudes better than van weezer?

[dry carbon]

but vw is bottom 3 weezer not including sznz

[dry carbon]

by tenfold

[flint comet]

Irony or serious?

https://tenor.com/view/shocked-black-guy-shocked-gif-27437284

[dry carbon]

100% serious

raditude is great vw is incredibly mid

[spice karma]

Mb is even more mid

[dry carbon]

no its not lmfao

its like 100x better than van midzer

[flint comet]

Vw is great haha

[spice karma]

Mb is so mid

[lost mason]

more people need to talk about summer elaine and drunk dory honestly

[dry carbon]

it is not

[dry carbon]

it is not

[spice karma]

Nuh uh

[dry carbon]

10/10 album EASILY but ok

[north echo]

People don’t talk about Hurley cuz it sucks ☠️

[north echo]

You’re gonna tell me that you’d rather listen to like pd or smth than vw?

[spice karma]

It’s like a 4.5 at best

[north echo]

It’s kinda generic

Still one of my favorite white songs

[north echo]

Have you actually listened to mb or have you just listened to Beverly Hills and called it a day

[spice karma]

Yeah I have. I have the hole album on my playlist

But I can’t remember half of it it’s just so forgettable

[pulsar spoke]

Ban Weezer is so good

[spice karma]

Fr fr

[pulsar spoke]

Van Weezer*

[spice karma]

Still fr fr

[dry carbon]

definitely

[pulsar spoke]

VW = PD

[north echo]

Nuh uh :(

[dry carbon]

i mean id rather listen to blue or pinkerton or make believe over either but yea pds way better than vw lmao

WAY better

[spice karma]

Pd is the worst weezer album I’ve ever heard

[pulsar spoke]

:(

[spice karma]

Sorry

But I really don’t like it

[dry carbon]

hurley is like

so much worse

its unbelievable

i would genuinely from the bottom of my heart call it a negative ten out of ten

i have yet to hear anything thats even a fifth as bad

[lost mason]

white's kinda eh to me tbh

seadd and dywgh are the only ones that really stuck out to me

[spice karma]

I don’t think you need to say that you don’t like Harley anymore I think everyone knows you don’t like Harley

[dry carbon]

i cant even express it enough

i would need the rest of my life talking exclusively about hurley to express a quarter of my hate for it

[dry ore]

hate hurley

[dry carbon]

hell yea fuck that album

[vague vapor]

honestly true

besides hurley ofc

[dry carbon]

id say vw is worse

hurley<van weezer<teal<black<pd

imo

this isnt counting sznz spring and summer which id consider abt equal or worse than vw

[pulsar spoke]

black above Hurley

aboiver

van weezer

[dry carbon]

(this is worst to best for clarification)

[dry carbon]

hurley is 18727292873x worse than black

[pulsar spoke]

no

[north echo]

no lol

maybe like 1.5x

[regal oxide]

We are all on drugs for sure that opening guitar riff is one of the best I’ve ever heard

[rain zealot]

my best friend is fire

[pulsar spoke]

Fuck yeah dude!

[north echo]

I agree

Bit abrupt coming from peace but I still enjoy it’s harshness

[regal oxide]

I didn’t know people actually cared about that

[north echo]

I care about it idk ¯_(ツ)_/¯

[flint comet]

cant knock the hustle

so good

[north echo]

No lol

[pulsar spoke]

not at all

[flint comet]

i've never heard anyone talk about it on this discord, and with any of my weezer friends. they say they never heard of it.

[rain zealot]

it makes me cringe

not terrible tho

[vague vapor]

time flies, definitely weezer's best

[flint comet]

I remember there used to be an account on insta specifically for hating on that song

[dry carbon]

BASED

[pulsar spoke]

i hate time flies

worst production i've ever heard on a song from any artist ever in history

[dry carbon]

definitely

for some songs lo-fi adds to it, makes it better

this is not one of those times

[flint comet]

its always sunny in bikini bottom

[pulsar spoke]

State Farm Song

[fluid island]

No one else

[north echo]

1 more hit :D

[pulsar spoke]

Please daddy please daddy~

[flint comet]

Real tho

[flint comet]

no

[regal oxide]

All my friends are insects

[vague vapor]

true

[spice karma]

Fr that’s what I’ve been saying

[regal oxide]

The solo in that song is fire

[dry carbon]

its ok

for a hurley song its amazing

but for a weezer song in general its just alright

[spice karma]

You just can’t accept the truth that all my friends are insects is the best weezer song

[regal oxide]

Lmao

[flint comet]

Take Control, maladroit

[dry carbon]

peak

[azure pollen]

I feel like automatic is underrated

[pulsar spoke]

Red is underrated

[dry carbon]

no its not

its possibly the least hated weezer album, besides cdw its unoffensive and to an extent unnoteworthy in basically every way

it by all means gets the love it deserves and arguably way more

it fits the definition of overrated much better

[azure pollen]

But automatic is underrated right

[dry carbon]

never seen much discussion

and its an alright song

so ig to an extent

[pulsar spoke]

Red is way better than people give it credit

[dry carbon]

its way worse than the average fan says

it's definitely one of the biggest fan favorites

most people will tell you its the bands best aside from blue and pinkerton

its acted as if one of the greatest albums by the band yet not at all as influential, different, or unique as most of the bands other work

besides blue its by far their most overrated

[pulsar spoke]

(Ok Human, Green, White, EWBAITE are all more common answers for that)

[dry carbon]

okh and white probably

ewbaite maybe

green absolutely not

[pulsar spoke]

People say EWBAITE as one of the best… and Green is for those that says “old weezer is best”

Not saying its my opinion

Just what I hear as answers

I’ve had many tell me red is bad

[dry carbon]

oh i know its not but green is nowhere near as highly rated as red

[dry carbon]

one time i have witnessed this

in my entire life as a weezer fan

once

ive seen more hate for blue than red

way more hate for pt than red

as well as okh and white

[pulsar spoke]

Thats because blue is more popular

Underated doesnt mean its hated

[dry carbon]

ewbaite is the only one thats anywhere as close to unhated as red is

[pulsar spoke]

White

[dry carbon]

and ewbaite is way better

[pulsar spoke]

Ok Human

Are the two other juggernauts

[dry carbon]

anytime white is mentioned theres that one "erm actually its more pop than classic weezer! white is severely overrated and doesnt deserve the attention it gets" person

always

[dry carbon]

fair amount of hate here as well

its unique and different

[pulsar spoke]

Thats because it’s more popular… people are contrarian just to be different

[dry carbon]

changes up the formula

we know damn well weezer fans dont like this

[pulsar spoke]

I love OK Human

[dry carbon]

its still much more hated on than red

[pulsar spoke]

Eh

People call red mid and leave it at that

Like “only 4 good songs”

[dry carbon]

never heard it called anything but great

besides that one guy who said it was bad

tbh ive heard more ewbaite hate than red

i can think of two times its been called overrated

only once for red not including myself

no matter your feelings on red if you say its not one of their most popular releases among fans youre lying to yourself

[pulsar spoke]

Just did a list to get my opinions clear

[pulsar spoke]

I’m not lying to myself

Its popular among fans

As is EVERY weezer album really

[dry carbon]

and fans are the opinions that matter, no?

[pulsar spoke]

I guess

But

[dry carbon]

who cares what other ppl think, outside of fans theres only two albums that are enjoyed at all

[pulsar spoke]

Like i said

Every album is popular among fans

[dry carbon]

not rlly

i mean theres fans of every album definitely

but overall albums like make believe, raditude, hurley, pd, black, and vw are looked down upon by most of the fanbase

[pulsar spoke]

Yeah, (although make believe is in the same tier as red tbh, underrated)

And the hate on some of those make sense

Being in the middle rated albums (red), is too low IMO

[dry carbon]

its high tier absolutely

i will make you a tierlist rn of the opinions i see often

[pulsar spoke]

okayyy

[dry carbon]

from my time in the community these are the opinions i've picked up

and ive been here for a while

[pulsar spoke]

Red is lower from popular opinion

Summer is also too high

As well as spring

[dry carbon]

this is what i can say is one of the closest we can get to an objectively correct tierlist

[pulsar spoke]

Autumn is loved way more than spring and summer

[dry carbon]

this isnt a personal opinion list 😭

[pulsar spoke]

Also hurley andd raditude lower haha

[dry carbon]

ohh i see what you mean

[pulsar spoke]

Ik

[dry carbon]

raditude maybe

hurley no

massive resurgence recently

[pulsar spoke]

You just notice all hurley love, most still hate it

Most just hate it less than you

Because you hate it A LOT

[dry carbon]

id say its split pretty evenly

[flint comet]

Eh

[pulsar spoke]

nah

[dry carbon]

its hated more than its liked sure but not by a big enough portion to put it a tier lower

its like 55/45

[dry carbon]

youre doing the same thing with red, youre tricking yourself into thinking its underrated cus you like it so much when really its arguably the least deserving of this title

definitely top 5 most liked no question

top 3 if not for ewbaite

[pulsar spoke]

Not doing the same IMO

[dry carbon]

the same? no. something extremely similar? yes

[pulsar spoke]

red isny hated

But its not loved

[dry carbon]

you say people dont give it the credit it deserves yet they absolutely do, they just dont give it the same credit you do cus you give it significantly more credit than it deserves

thats my two cents here

[pulsar spoke]

(you like make believe)

[dry carbon]

i give it way more credit than it technically deserves sure but at least i admit that i overrate it severely

but ironic that you bring it up cus thats an actual example of an album that doesnt get the credit it deserves

i rate it higher than it probably should be but it definitely doesnt deserve to be D and C tier like it is in most rankings

[pulsar spoke]

I agree that it’s not bad.

I just think if people actually listened to red without prejudice, it’d be rated higher.

[dry carbon]

what prejudice????

[pulsar spoke]

That idea of that era of albums

Make Believe — Hurley

Even green to an extent

[dry carbon]

valid

[flint comet]

True

[dry carbon]

people dismiss that era a lot but of it red is by far the most highly rated from it

and when i see ppl hate on that era ive seen ppl even say "besides red"

[pulsar spoke]

I agree to that

Still a ‘prejudice’ against it

[north echo]

Umm no?

[north echo]

Is this from a weezer fans perspective or the general public?

[dry carbon]

kinda a combo of the two

[dry carbon]

umm yes

[pulsar spoke]

Everyone from the general public i’ve shown red has said it sucked and it’s bad, so

ONLY thing ive heard

[dry carbon]

i was looking mostly for fans opinons but i added some general public stuff

[dry carbon]

this applies to every post-pinkerton album and even pinkerton itself sometimes

[pulsar spoke]

If accounting for popular opinion, pinkerton would be a bit lower too… everyone i’ve showed pinkerton also hates pinkerton soooo

[dry carbon]

most ppl who listen to rock music rank both very highly and dont like the rest

[north echo]

Ok cuz if it was general then teal is WAY too low

Also raditude is way too high

But I guess that’s also taking general public into account idk

[dry carbon]

somewhat resurgance but i can see it being lower

[kindred bear]

Everyone alive should think The Good Life is the best song

[dry carbon]

its not tho

[mystic sluice]

Friend Of A friend

[dry carbon]

definitely

[flint comet]

In recent times I’ve been seeing IJTOTLOMD getting hate

[north echo]

Why you post it in the underrated forum :(

[dry carbon]

yea ive seen hate for it too but it ain't exactly underrated

just one of those songs ppl think is cool to hate

[flint comet]

I’d say that makes it underrated rn

Never see people talk about it when bring up B sides anymore

[north echo]

Saying that any song on Pinkerton or the dlx is insane

Mild hate?

From a few people?

[dry carbon]

butterfly receives like a shitton of hate

and i swear its true

rest yea by no means underrated in any way

generally pinkerton and like 95% of its tracks are looked upon extremely highly

[pulsar spoke]

You’re basing this off me ong!!!

I have seen no hate on I Swear Its true but me!

[dry carbon]

dude

everyone hates it

i mentioned it once in chat

i said i loved it

and like 7 ppl came outta nowhere and started telling me how ass it was

[pulsar spoke]

I’ve never seen this!!!

It’s not horrible

I just am not the biggest fan of it

I’d never call it ass tbh

[dry carbon]

#weezer message

read the convo below here

[pulsar spoke]

I see

[regal oxide]

Get me some

[mystic sluice]

tastes like pain

[dry carbon]

very underrated

[north echo]

I agree

Probably the highlight of my autumn listen

[pulsar spoke]

Tastes like pain js straight MID

[flint comet]

The British are Coming

[azure pollen]

Oh shit they are???

Ew

I’m leaving

[north echo]

It’s way better than Da Vinci in my opinion, which is my least favorite ewbaite song

[pulsar spoke]

Its so good

Its my favorite off EWBAITE

[north echo]

Personally I’m high on foolish father rn idk why

[brisk karma]

idk, buddy holly its so underground

[north echo]

I’ve never even heard of that song before it sounds interesting

[spice karma]

Which album is that song from???

[dry carbon]

idk tbh

ive never heard it before

im guessing one of those albums everyone forgets about like dtfm or pd

[brisk karma]

unreleased

[spice karma]

No way

[flint comet]

i like back to the shack and the british are coming

[kindred bear]

Da Vinky is goated

don't even

[dry carbon]

both are

[pulsar spoke]

Da Vinci sucks ngl

[kindred bear]

🤓

wait hold on

[dry carbon]

LMAO

[pulsar spoke]

I got depicted as a crying wojak, my argument has been defeated

[dry carbon]

"great argument, however i depicted you as a crying nerd and me as a chad"

[next forum]

i dont hate IJTOTLOMD i hate people who only like IJTOTLOMD

[dry carbon]

its great but there are better songs on the dlx

[worthy kindle]

Jacked Up would be peak white album except for those stupid high notes on the pre-chorus

It is however what Pacific Daydream wishes it could be

[next forum]

theyre awesome

i love jacked up

[pulsar spoke]

Agreed

[tropic cradle]

It’s ok

It’s overrated imo

[dry carbon]

i think its rated pretty perfectly

[lean tendon]

Devotion will always be underrated because there is no amount of praise that will ever properly express how good that song is.

[pulsar spoke]

it really is amazing

[lean tendon]

This guy gets it.

[dry carbon]

yes there can

watch

"its very good"

done

[lean tendon]

Not good enough.

[pulsar spoke]

@dry carbon they do love devotion

[dry carbon]

more than enough

[dry carbon]

step aside wooof someone likes a weezer song more than i do

we all know this isnt allowed

you see i own this tow-

[pulsar spoke]

I love LTS forever

[dry carbon]

excuse me did you just like a weezer song more than i do

[lean tendon]

I like EVERY weezer song more than you.

Boom.

[dry carbon]

you dont like el scorcho or the spider more than me

that i guarantee

[lean tendon]

I guarantee you are wrong. I love both of those songs more than your parents loved you.

[dry carbon]

no

words don't express how much i love the spider and el scorcho

id go as far as to say i like those songs more than you like devotion

[lean tendon]

The audacity you have to insinuate in the slightest that I only like Devotion a regular amount is astounding. Count your minutes.

[pulsar spoke]

I like Longtime Sunshine more than anyone else like any other song

[lean tendon]

My passion for the song Devotion exceeds human bounds. Even I fail to understand how much I like it. You will pay for your vile misunderstanding, you blaspheme.

[pulsar spoke]

sometimes i wanna pack it all up...

[dry carbon]

i like el scorcho this much... +1.

[lean tendon]

Here’s the question though, is the Pinkerton deluxe version better than the Alone version? I think so.

[pulsar spoke]

Alone

[dry carbon]

yea pt dlx version better

[pulsar spoke]

no

[lean tendon]

You have 3 days. Spend them wisely.

[dry carbon]

thanks i will

[lean tendon]

👍

[north echo]

Dtfm underrated probably idk I’m tired

[dry carbon]

true

[pulsar spoke]

its mid

[dry carbon]

i rlly like it

[lean tendon]

Some of the songs are masterpieces. Some of them are hot dookie. 50/50.

[dry carbon]

valid

[flint comet]

Time Flies is a good song

[dry carbon]

nope

[pulsar spoke]

It would be better if actually produced

[fluid lake]

anything on Hurley is underrated. (except for "Smart Girls" -- that song is weird.)

[pulsar spoke]

Smart Girls is good!

but you can't defend time flies...

[fluid lake]

I can and I will.

[pulsar spoke]

do so

[tropic cradle]

Nope

Wrong

[fluid lake]

shitty production was purposeful, artistic. may not be your cup of tea -- but wasn't accidental. makes the song.

[tropic cradle]

@dry carbon get in here we got a smart girls enjoyer

[pulsar spoke]

well its fucking awful

we have a time flies enhoyer, who like s hurley the most

[fluid lake]

to your ears, because it's your POV.....

[pulsar spoke]

they already know!

[tropic cradle]

How can you like that song

[pulsar spoke]

to anyone with working ears! get your ears checked pal

[dry carbon]

are these accusations true? do we truly have a smart girls enjoyer here? they will be swiftly dealt with.

[tropic cradle]

Please 🙏

[pulsar spoke]

where did all these smart girls come from?

[fluid lake]

I do gotta check my ears, tbh. as a whole. we all gotta.

watch out for our ears.

[dry carbon]

the depths of hell and it is my duty to destroy them

[pulsar spoke]

Its my duty to destroy Yuu haters

[fluid lake]

I like the composition in "Smart Girls" -- I despise the lyrics.

[dry carbon]

i was joking bro ion even know what yuu is 😭

[pulsar spoke]

whats wrong with the lyrics?

[dry carbon]

both

both is awful

[pulsar spoke]

yuu is me ong frfr

[fluid lake]

the composition is fun.

the lyrics are slimy as hell.

in a bad way.

[dry carbon]

annoying and the way he sings it is awful

[fluid lake]

unintended.

[dry carbon]

is there a good way? 😭

[pulsar spoke]

"slimy"?

[tropic cradle]

It actually makes sense

[fluid lake]

if it was parodying itself, like "No One Else."

[pulsar spoke]

how?

[tropic cradle]

They are slimy

[dry carbon]

except worse

[pulsar spoke]

are you saying its creepy?

[fluid lake]

yeah, it isn't. exactly.

[fluid lake]

yes.

[pulsar spoke]

like

[fluid lake]

implies that all girls are dumb.

[pulsar spoke]

what

[pulsar spoke]

since when?

huh?

did I miss a page?

[fluid lake]

"where did all these smart girls come from??"

???

[pulsar spoke]

thats not how i read those lyrics at all 😭

[dry carbon]

honestly

kinda

[fluid lake]

but that's how they are.

[pulsar spoke]

you like pinkerton shut up

we all like pinkerton

[dry carbon]

you.. like pinkerton

[fluid lake]

Pinkerton knows it's garbage.

[pulsar spoke]

tee hee

[pulsar spoke]

huh?

[fluid lake]

that makes it a lot easier to stomach.

it's self-aware of their flaws.

[pulsar spoke]

I think y'all are misrepresenting smart girls lyrically

i dont think its meant to be taken like that at all

[fluid lake]

what way is it supposed to be taken then?

[dry carbon]

you stupid

[feral elm]

Im not that deep into weezer, how rated is “i just threw out the love of my dreams”? Its a banger frfr

[pulsar spoke]

its great

[fluid lake]

it's great, yeah.

[pulsar spoke]

not the best on dlx tho

[dry carbon]

pretty highly

[fluid lake]

but it does.....

[dry carbon]

some ppl hate it but generally its well liked

[fluid lake]

he even said it on that letter, know your Weezer lore.

[dry carbon]

nah it's great

[pulsar spoke]

where slimy??

[feral elm]

Pinkerton? Pink a ton of what? Har har har har har har

[pulsar spoke]

ummm

[fluid lake]

it's great, but like: in an awful way?

[dry carbon]

smt just irks me abt these lyrics

[fluid lake]

slimy.

[pulsar spoke]

how 😭

[dry carbon]

theyre kinda creepy sure but mostly theyre just annoying and no doubt terribly written

[pulsar spoke]

YUMI SHERIE

[dry carbon]

this is objectification way more than anything on pinkerton is

[feral elm]

Objectification-adjacent?

[dry carbon]

definitely

[feral elm]

Oh wait you said that

[pulsar spoke]

objectification 😭

[dry carbon]

their most objectification-y song

[dry carbon]

do you not see it? have you gone blind woooof?

[pulsar spoke]

i dont!

its just a stupid song that you're reading into!!!

[dry carbon]

"i dont know if i can choose just one" as if theyre just things he can pick and choose

[feral elm]

Maybe they are the one being objectified? Maybe thats why

[dry carbon]

im not a woman

[feral elm]

Thats why wooof dont fet it

[fluid lake]

easy to say when you're in your own bubble, that's what they meant. from the opposite perspective: pretty objectifying and degrading.

[dry carbon]

but an entire song abt objectification isnt ok just cus its silly

[feral elm]

Doesnt matter

[pulsar spoke]

I mean... I guess it can be read like that

I more think... like... its just theres many great girls out there...

that are smart

idk

[feral elm]

Lots of silly songs are fine despite having an awful meaningn you bufoon

[pulsar spoke]

i dont default to objectifaction

[feral elm]

Buffoon

[fluid lake]

My Sharona is a banger, that I absolutely despise.

[dry carbon]

and hes saying that as if he can just have any one of them

who cares what they want theyre all for him he can just choose

[pulsar spoke]

thats not-

no

[feral elm]

Real

[dry carbon]

acting like hes buying them at a fucking toy store or some shit

[pulsar spoke]

NO

[feral elm]

Youre projecting /s

[pulsar spoke]

how do you get that from that

"choosing someone" doesn't imply that!

"choosing the right one for me"

is a thing

to say

[fluid lake]

oppa Gangnam style

[pulsar spoke]

that

people

say

[dry carbon]

thats not how it comes across in the slightest

[feral elm]

“I always get it up for the touch of the younger kind”

[fluid lake]

god damn those lyrics are disgusting

[pulsar spoke]

syntax... am I bad person if i like... Smart Girls?

in

youyr eyes

[fluid lake]

you're not.

[dry carbon]

bad person? no

bad taste? no doubt

[feral elm]

If britain didnt exist we wouldnt have it, such a shame

[pulsar spoke]

ohew

phew

[fluid lake]

maybe a bit aloof.

[feral elm]

We also wouldnt have radiohead, win-win

[fluid lake]

no lemons to suck. a better world.

[pulsar spoke]

:(

[feral elm]

Banana man gets a little “weird” at the fast bit as well

[dry carbon]

in this context i think he means it like unaware

[pulsar spoke]

im very friendly...

[fluid lake]

you are, that's true.

[pulsar spoke]

only 2 definitons!

[feral elm]

Two wuv is another tally hall song thats weird, objectifying and a little rapey in the music video.

[fluid lake]

absolutely.....

[feral elm]

Still the best song on that album

[dry carbon]

the music video maybe

the song itself is a little odd but it aint too bad

[pulsar spoke]

@fluid lake what'd i do to you

[dry carbon]

its more clearly ironic than a lot of these other songs i see like this

[pulsar spoke]

smart girls

[fluid lake]

didn't mean it in a harmful way, apologies. I just meant you seem a bit detached from gender politics.

[pulsar spoke]

erased

[pulsar spoke]

detached from gender politics...