#40k-lore-chat

1 messages · Page 1811 of 1

vagrant osprey
#

I dunno about the codexes, but there are female Sensei.

#

All the way back to RT they were there as something you could play.

primal tide
#

Female SM would be cool as hell

vagrant osprey
#

Anyway, Cawl has canonically spent 10,000 years researching how Geneseed works and how to make better Astartes.

#

The Minotaurs are suggested to be something he made on the leadup to the Primaris.

#

There's countless chapters of Astartes, and for most of them it's unknown what their lineage is.

storm jungle
#

Which is again a reason for people to make their own chapters, theres a reason almost every faction has an excuse for there to be multiple variants of themselves so yep

#

It just fits in perfectly with the plot so woop-woop

vagrant osprey
#

Yep.

#

So, lore-wise, there's a perfectly valid reason for female Astartes to exist.

#

I'm not sure anyone would be able to tell the difference without a medical exam, but still!

storm jungle
#

Nah im pretty sure they'd keep the female features like stormcasts for artwork and marketing

#

boobs and other stuff tho probably not

#

They would all look the same with the helmet anyway in the end regardless

buoyant crypt
#

what exactly dio you mean no boobs

primal tide
#

Yeah, it just needs to be a box of heads and gw saying "your dudes / dudettes"

storm jungle
#

As in almost flat

#

because muscle

#

and gene-seeeed nut

vagrant osprey
#

Astartes don't have much in the way of body fat.

buoyant crypt
#

what if they have unique organs in their boobs

#

uwu

storm jungle
#

honestly they perfectly could lol

buoyant crypt
#

shock absorption boobs

#

low gravity boobs

storm jungle
#

big massive wobbling bazongas

buoyant crypt
#

melta gun nipples

primal tide
#

If each male astartes doesnt need a massive fuckin codpiece, I'm pretty sure female astartes wouldn't have special battle plate requirements

storm jungle
#

Oh yeah realistically speaking they still would both wear the same armor

#

not gonna stop r34 but hey

primal tide
#

Lol

buoyant crypt
#

they dont need special plates

#

just like a door that opens so they can shoot their nipple guns effectively

primal tide
#

Cringe

buoyant crypt
#

it was dilaras idea

storm jungle
#

no it wasnt

#

:I

storm jungle
barren tapir
#

While not confirmed it is hinted that geneseed is coded to work with male genes... Why is that? No official reason other than big E never wanted females to be his war tools... I mean, it is canon that Malcador (the Hero) suggested to make half of the primarchs into females so the possibility was there

primal tide
#

Yeah, the justification is at least as handwavey as any change would be so it's not really a binding reason imho

barren tapir
#

I think that SoB are the female version of the SM... At least that is what i heard in the comunity some time ago

buoyant crypt
#

I mean kinda but they are unmodified

barren tapir
#

Something on the line that it is the same for the custodes and the sisters of silence (those gals rock!)

buoyant crypt
#

(Still peeved the SoB vr game looks so bad)

primal tide
#

Sisters of battle are cool in their own way but are kind of a poor substitute regarding lady space marines

#

Yeah that trailer was the anti hype

devout marlin
#

SoB are a perfectly fine substitute

#

They’ve been shown going toe to toe with space marines before and they have no modifications, that’s pretty badass

vagrant osprey
#

Which kinda makes Astartes look super awful, since they're literally engineered to be peak warriors.

primal tide
#

Yeah, those instances definitely seem like the exception, and again it's not about being a substitute in battle

#

It's partly about widening the range of stories, characters, and appeal for the poster boys for the game

storm jungle
#

The entire reason SoB exist at all is due to a larger female representation factor to begin with

#

They are badass i agree and its one of the bigger points people point out that if female Marines were a thing in the past the SoB would probably never exist or be as prominent as they are now

primal tide
#

That's cool and all, but it's kind of a lame reason to not have female astartes

storm jungle
#

Oh god sorry

#

I fully agree that the geneseed excuse is just as you say "handwavy"

#

In the end I'll just blame it on 80's macho flair and their first models not selling well.

primal tide
#

Haha

storm jungle
#

Because even as a chick i can agree back in the day you WANTED to see a big guy holding a bigass machinegun firing at aliens

primal tide
#

Yeah I mean, at the end of the day it's all just make believe but it would be nice to have some lore and official alternate heads/characters

storm jungle
#

Yep

#

but hey, theres still companies that sell female marine heads

#

at least thats one positive

primal tide
#

Lol yeah

#

Usually the same ones that sell half naked tau and necrons tho 🙄

storm jungle
#

Eurgh i know

#

like i get porn will exist and theres no stopping it but Tau porn gets really stale after awhile for me lol

primal tide
#

It's just cringe as hell to me

storm jungle
#

Same

#

Like yeah, okay big tits lol

primal tide
#

Same with mtg card sleeves with anime girls on them lol

storm jungle
#

lmao

vagrant osprey
#

I'm becoming increasingly convinced that humanity runs on cringe.

primal tide
#

It's not a bug, it's a feature

vagrant osprey
#

Lore-wise, thronebutt wanted all his tools to be men because he's a chauvinist, and didn't want them to have "troublesome hormones" influencing them.

primal tide
#

Also something about wanting to play up their rivalry

vagrant osprey
#

You know. The same reason why 1950s scientists kept testing medications for women on men and assuming their results were valid.

storm jungle
#

wanting to play up their rivalry
Thats really funny since its what Mal said about female-primarchs too

primal tide
#

Yeah, there's two different excerpts now which mention this, one in Valdor iirc and another in a different book

vagrant osprey
#

Yes. And the Emperor said that he didn't want female primarchs because they would be too likely to get into catfights.

primal tide
#

Amazing

vagrant osprey
#

I can't stress enough that the Emperor was an absolutely abhorrent person.

primal tide
#

As if the male primarchs and astartes are above catfights somehow

storm jungle
#

I'm the sole girl among 3 elder brothers and yes i can confirm chapin.

#

Its terrible

vagrant osprey
#

Yep.

#

The Emperor is good at a few things. "Being a person" is not on that list.

#

"Planning" is also not on the list.

#

"Doing the job he was fucking made to do" is also not on the list.

vagrant osprey
#

Wow, yeah.

#

Magnus... prrrrobably doesn't turn out too well

storm jungle
#

Yeaaah probably not lol

primal tide
#

Yeah those are legit

storm jungle
#

Sang, Robo and Curze all look disappointed at us while Dorn is still too busy thinking of fortifications

#

would still date em tbh

primal tide
#

Now I'm going to have nightmares about taking curze on a date, thanks

storm jungle
#

Np

#

Tbh Roboute and Sangy are the best bet

#

just look at those expressions

vagrant osprey
#

I wonder what Vulkan looks like.

barren tapir
#

Who know, after all primaris are an improvement over firstborn because a guy got the datas and played with them with 10k years... Maybe the reason as why two primarchs are absent is because big E, being himself, actually made two female primarchs...

#

I mean, sisters of silence must have some sources... And the fact that they were originally from a particular world isn't really a solit story... So who know...

storm jungle
#

I mean again

#

40k is inconsistent af

#

anything can exist and cannot exist

barren tapir
#

It started as something as much inconsistent as you can make something without breaking it, but it seems that GW is starting to realize the gold mine it can be and trying to make it right... Primaris are the example...

storm jungle
#

Yep

#

because money is some good shit

#

Keep pumping out those [insert-role]cessors

barren tapir
#

All that i want is some spotlight for my poor guys and gals in the Astra Militarum...

storm jungle
#

At this point the setting has turned into Every Faction VS Space Marines.

barren tapir
#

Well, that will make xeno lovers happy, now they are nearer their w... Damn, that will take a lot of effort... w-w-waaiiiffuu... Fiiiuu, that was painful

verbal nest
#

Hey

#

Heck off

#

Waifu for life

vagrant osprey
#

The best part about 40k as a setting is that all the problems are completely solvable if anybody was able to actually make use of what they have, but nobody is willing to actually do that.

verbal nest
#

Best part about 40k is that if everyone stepped back and looked at what was happening, there would be zero issues

#

Maybe irl too

vagrant osprey
#

In the end, the best humanity can reasonably hope for is becoming a client species of the Tau. Not because that's good, but because the other possibilities are far worse.

#

Yeah, IRL too.

#

I think the strongest lesson to take away from 40k is to never tie yourself to somebody else the way people have tied themselves to the Emperor.

#

There will always be demagogues, and they will always fail and betray you.

primal tide
#

Very relevant these days

barren tapir
#

Well... I'm not really an Big E supporter, but at the beginning of the GC it wasn't that bad... Sure, dickish actions were made, but it wasn't that bad... Not compared as what it is 10K years later

vagrant osprey
#

(The Imperium could have literally just absorbed the Eldar in a series of treaties and turned them into weapons against chaos.)

primal tide
#

Don't forget that servitors are literal nightmare fuel

barren tapir
#

Still i would really love to see another human civilization that isn't IoM

vagrant osprey
#

The Imperium uses servitors entirely because Emps was a biological purist and hated all forms of mechanical automation.

barren tapir
#

I mean, there are, like adrantis five, but they get nuked sadly...

#

Still it get a lot of time for macharius to destroy it, and it was just a simple system

vagrant osprey
#

Mechanicus, and the Astartes.

#

And it took AGES

#

And they basically did a Zapp Brannigan tactic

barren tapir
#

He used a comet

#

It was more an orky taktik

verbal nest
#

Rear Brigadier Zapp Brannigan
Brannigans Law

storm jungle
#

Blank brought up something really important

#

the entire setting is set in the Milky Way yet it feels so small

#

Since it makes it look like the Imperium is the only human faction around

vagrant osprey
#

That's because GW does not understand scale.

storm jungle
#

Pretty much

vagrant osprey
#

Also, we've seen the galaxy. It's named the "Milky Way", but it's definitely not.

barren tapir
#

That's because GW does not understand scale.
Pauldrons say hi

vagrant osprey
#

Not the right number of spiral arms, core shape is wrong.

storm jungle
#

Again

#

artist fault

vagrant osprey
#

Terra's position doesn't match at all.

#

Fair.

storm jungle
#

Its pretty much our universe just more over the top.

vagrant osprey
#

Artists are also to blame for Bolter barrels being 2.5 inches across.

storm jungle
#

I really doubt they would make it something completely new when characters like Pious even mention WW1-2

#

also YEP

verbal nest
#

Are Bolters meant to be smaller?

vagrant osprey
#

Yes.

barren tapir
#

I really doubt they would make it something completely new when characters like Pious even mention WW1-2
He also fought during the napoleonic wars

storm jungle
#

Guy's a chad

#

Its just that GW as Pseu says is shit at scale

#

also naming lol

#

Big E conquering Merica for example

verbal nest
#

Wut 40k emojis but not from this server

barren tapir
#

Big E conquering Merica for example
Wut?

storm jungle
#

The unification wars lmao

barren tapir
#

Ah, that

storm jungle
#

It actually is called Merica

verbal nest
#

Wasn't the unification wars galactic scale

storm jungle
#

Nope

#

Uni-Wars was set on earth

verbal nest
#

Huh

storm jungle
#

with Big E's beta-marines

barren tapir
#

The unification war is the unification of Terra by Big E

storm jungle
#

Yeah the Great Crusade was the giant war that Big E set out to unify on a galactic scale

verbal nest
#

RIP Sejanus

barren tapir
#

Big E: ok, i want to remove everything related to religions, it doesn't matter how weak the link is...
Also Big E: how i would call this great war of expasion?? AH ah! Great Crusade! I'm a genius lol

storm jungle
#

Even Uriah on the voxcast points that out

verbal nest
#

You talking mad shit for someone within unification distance

storm jungle
#

and Big E on the throne is all "NOPE THAT DOESNT MATTER"

barren tapir
#

Like, he could have called it, glorius conquest or something else, why crusade

storm jungle
#

Simple.

#

It sounds cool.

#

WOOP-WOOP

#

[cue the Horus Heresy]

verbal nest
#

"glorious conquest" ok nerd

barren tapir
#

Are you telling me that something like War of Resurgence is not cool?

storm jungle
#

OOFFF

#

Okay thats good

vagrant osprey
#

If you want to know how bad GW is at scale, check the list of events that are dated 999.999M41

barren tapir
#

They explained that it was because clerks fucked up with dates... GW blamed the in universe chars instead of recognizing their fault

storm jungle
#

LOL

#

incompetent gits an all

barren tapir
#

Like, Guillman had to use his free time fixing all that stuff, and even he isn't sure he managed to fix all

storm jungle
#

I still dont know how the 40k calendar works

#

i tried to read the wiki and it was the most confusing thing id have ever seen

barren tapir
#

He and his thousad strong historicae new departement

storm jungle
#

then again those dunces literally copy paste everything

vagrant osprey
#

Cadia falls and the cicatrix maledictum tears the galaxy in half. Then the Black Crusade travels from Cadia to lay siege to Maccrag. Then Papa Smurf rises from the dead and fends off the Black Crusade. Then Papa Smurf heads to Terra and "talks with the Emperor". Then Papa Smurf finds a path near the Eye of Terror where the cicatrix maledictum can be traversed and reestablishes contact with the Dark Imperium. Then he conquers the now-in-disarray Dark Imperium and installs a regent (After having previously said that the Second Imperium was his worst mistake). Then he returns to Terra.

#

Ok, so, it's pretty easy.

barren tapir
#

The first three numbers should give info about the sources, like it was witnessed, it was reported and how much the sources is reliable IIRC

storm jungle
#

gotcha

#

also again guys, just use the 4chan timeline

buoyant crypt
#

I guess I’m down

#

Wrong chat

barren tapir
#

Cadia falls and the cicatrix maledictum tears the galaxy in half. Then the Black Crusade travels from Cadia to lay siege to Maccrag. Then Papa Smurf rises from the dead and fends off the Black Crusade. Then Papa Smurf heads to Terra and "talks with the Emperor". Then Papa Smurf finds a path near the Eye of Terror where the cicatrix maledictum can be traversed and reestablishes contact with the Dark Imperium. Then he conquers the now-in-disarray Dark Imperium and installs a regent (After having previously said that the Second Imperium was his worst mistake). Then he returns to Terra.
That is some fucked up summary mate

storm jungle
#

aaargghgfgghfgffgh

vagrant osprey
#

The format is 999.999M41.
The first three numbers are the year, 0-999
The period is a decimal point.
The second three numbers are thousanths of a year.
The M41 just means it's in 41st Millenium.

storm jungle
#

Also thank you! ❤️

#

I only know the M(number) part since its the most self explanatory

vagrant osprey
#

There are other things that add things like "how trusted this date is" and "who witnessed it", but that

#

is the basic date format.

barren tapir
#

The format is 999.999M41.
The first three numbers are the year, 0-999
The period is a decimal point.
The second three numbers are thousanths of a year.
The M41 just means it's in 41st Millenium.
That is wrong, three digits are for the reliability of the source, and the others are the years

vagrant osprey
#

Did I get the thousandths and years backwards again?

#

Yep, I got them backwards. Sorry!

barren tapir
#

Like, the three digits near m41 are the years, the first three are the reliability index

vagrant osprey
#

No, blank.

#

That would be X.999.999.M41

primal tide
#

I remember in eisenhorn the first three are definitely fractions of a year

vagrant osprey
#

That goes from 0-9, with lower numbers being better.

#

@storm jungle Sorry, it's the fraction of a year that comes first, THEN the year itself. So 000.999M41 would be the start of the year 999 in M41

barren tapir
#

Oh crap, all my calcualtions were wrong... Damn why it must be that confusing

storm jungle
#

Thanks again!

#

ALSO SEE WHAT I MEAN

#

Can they just explain it to this in layman's terms

vagrant osprey
#

ALSO! 1/1000th of a year is 8.76 hours.

storm jungle
#

no wonder adepts go mad

primal tide
#

It's literally the opposite of regular numbers haha

#

Like saying 0.9 is exactly 9

vagrant osprey
#

So 8 hours, 45 minutes, 36 seconds.

primal tide
#

Or 5.2 is two and a half

vagrant osprey
#

So all that stuff I listed above was supposed to all happen within less than 9 hours, even though it involves more than 2 centuries of travel time.

barren tapir
#

They sure know how to complicate their date recording stuff

vagrant osprey
#

The Emperor is awful at math

primal tide
#

The Emperor is awful at math
Fixed

vagrant osprey
#

Yes.

#

I'm pretty sure Adepts go mad because the Imperium writes everything down on scrolls, and compiles it all on Terra.

#

Thronebutt HATES automation, so things like "searchable databases" terrified him.

#

Also, the Ecclesiarchy keeps picking sections of the records vaults to purge with fire.

#

And rather than evacuating them first, they'd really prefer it if the people working in those departments were at their posts at the time.

#

Basically, people keep talking about the Skaven not being in 40k, but they DID make it in - as the Imperium.

storm jungle
#

Also remember

#

adepts have literal civil wars in their halls over the most mundane office tasks.

#

and shoveling through paper files with actual shovels lol

vagrant osprey
#

Yes.

verbal nest
#

Tfw your civilisation hates technology so you basically live in a sorting office made of paper from 10k years ago

crisp heath
#

I don't get why people are trying to bring in female space marines. In a faction already so ultra inflated with nonsense, just scratching over all the lore and presidence it's had since the start just seems like a stupid idea.

#

Sisters of Battle are absolutely fine as the alternative and is actually a pretty interesting faction, instead of just slapping something absolutely left-field out of nowhere and cram and force in something that'll probably just look lame because of how they've had to cram it in.

odd sparrow
#

nobody is trying to bring in fem space marines

#

it's a dumb talking point brought in by some non 40k fans for easy clicks, which then perpetuates 40k fans getting mad about it as if it was ever an issue

#

totally in support for more fem models though. We've had female IG in trailers but still has to be a sausage party on the tabletop

odd tulip
#

I will literally murder a man for female IG models

vagrant osprey
#

IG is explicitly mixed gender.

#

Nobody looks too closely at the meat shoved into the grinder ¯_(ツ)_/¯

crisp heath
#

They should add female IG models more often. It does give the Guard more character. Femboy Death Korps of Krieg when?

odd sparrow
#

all they have to do is just release very slightly changed sculpts???? i don't understand it

#

change the figure and the face a little bit, congrats u have female cadians now

#

they sell like shit

#

uh, good shit i mean not bad shit

devout marlin
#

Question is would they randomly mix in the female models among the male ones or would they need to be bought separately

#

I think that’s why GW hesitate to do it, if they mix people will complain about it and if they separate them people will complain about it

vagrant osprey
#

Dude, 's not hard. Split the difference.

#

Sell individual models, and add them to mixed packs. Same as they do other stuff.

#

If people want specific variants, they either buy them or trade for 'em.

#

If people complain, ask them why they would dissect sausage :V

crisp heath
#

Lootcrate Imperial guards when?

vagrant osprey
#

I'm pretty sure GW has had packs since the 70s.

#

Granted, the number of variants has gone way up over time since manufacturing has gotten so much cheaper.

nova pumice
#

I have a lore question if anyone can answer as I’m kind of new to 40k... Can Ork Spores grow/spread in the warp? I would imagine both the Orks and Chaos Factions would desperately want the spores to grow there because that basically means infinity fighting which benefits both sides? Is there anything that points to Orks propagating in the warp?

verbal nest
#

Female IG models will quickly devolve into another coom model for 4chan lmfao

crisp heath
#

@nova pumice The Warp is a an eldritch dimension without rules. It exists and doesn't exist, like the inside of a wormhole. I don't really think something being able to grow there and sort of nurse itself is really something that can happen, it's like saying can a flower grow in nothing.

But. Like I said it's an eldritch dimension, so nothing is really finite, or makes sense. Orks probably exist and dont exist there at the same time. When it comes to the Warp, I don't think it has any particular rules, or sense to it. It's why it's 'Gods' are concepts.

verbal nest
#

Why orks

crisp heath
#

I guess because if Orks exist in the Immaterium does that mean orks can ever actually be defeated.

#

Gork and Mork are a thing, but if Orks function and can use the Warp wouldn't that make them by definition a concept of pure war. And thus, be undefeatable?

verbal nest
#

Uhh

#

Uhhhh

#

Sure whatever

vast frigate
#

Let me point out the fact why female marines didnt happen and why changing "a few features" isnt as easy as it seems

#

Plastic molds are made out of steel,steel master molds are VERY expensive

#

Now, a soldier builds up muscle and especially a space marine.
There used to be female marines with a slightly alterred breastplate and female styled heads in metal.
These didnt sell well. So gw discontineud them.

#

As for soldiers in the 41st millenium, the guard has male and female yes, often they are seperated to prevent men and women giving in to urges they shouldn't etcetera. As for more femme models. Theyd wear the same armor, thats why its called standard equipment

odd sparrow
#

the current cadian models, which tbh should probably be updated in their entirety anyways, have super broad shoulders and v distinctly masc faces. Though i'm not totally sure you even need to change the torso, you could probs just get away with changing the heads

#

also haven't they not even updated the catachan squad yet

vast frigate
#

Theyre old yeah, uypdating models happens once ina blue moon for non space marines

storm jungle
#

Firstly

#

Stop with this nonsense of "Guard shoved into grinder"

#

its the most stupid meme ever and it grinds my poor gears

#

Secondly

#

Female space marines are fiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiine, I get that people want them in the lore but we should still be satisfied theres companies that at the very least actually make heads and other stuff for them to put on your marines.

#

I'd say its a lot better than having nothing.

#

Probably one of the rarer instances of orks/chaos together

barren tapir
#

Dudes, sergeant "ripper" look at you from the jungle

storm jungle
#

I was almost about to say "are those plants pineapple grenades"

#

but i wouldnt be surprised, its Catachan

barren tapir
#

Also adding on female chars there is this one also

#

A blank investigator of necmonunda enforcers

analog ginkgo
#

I think one element of Warhammer more is pretty much left out.

Utility crew of space marine installations and spacecrafts.

Ships don't maintain themselves and since there are only up to 1000 space marines per chapter available, they can't do all the work by themselves.

We know that those troops and service personel exists but it's rarely topic of discussions.

storm jungle
#

Again dont ever follow that rule

#

Its stupid and almost everyone on the community agrees "1000 per chapter" is ridiculous and makes so many plot holes.

#

also Black Templars exist sooo

analog ginkgo
#

Off course it is ridiculous but even if there are more than 1000 battlebrothers in a chapter, they can't keep the ships running all by themselves.

And the BT are a totally different subject.

Especially the BT would rely on masses of support staff to keep their fleets running.

storm jungle
#

Oh no i totally agree

mellow depot
#

Are we talking about like

storm jungle
#

Its pretty much implied they got actual crews

#

its as you say just never referenced

mellow depot
#

The maintenance guys

#

In the ships

#

That actually fix steam lines and shit

#

Because I thought I'd heard it's to the point that like there are even weird little sewer villages and junk like that on a lot of them

storm jungle
#

Oh my god really

#

thats as funny as the older lore where every macro-cannon shell was hauled into loaders by ropes like its ancient egypt

#

but yeah i think thats what KaLeu is referencing

mellow depot
#

Yeah I mean just due to the ridiculous and outright silly size of these frigates

#

There are lile

#

Thousands of people

#

Making shit work

#

And so like

analog ginkgo
#

We still.have to differentiate between the imperial navy and the Adeptus Astartes.

The navy has tons of crew and that part is actually pretty well documented.

On the space marine side however. .

mellow depot
#

You have like miniature villages

#

Well I mean there strictly has to be like

#

A navigator and maintenance men

#

Space marines aren't gonna be turning wrenches and wiring things

#

They're too big lmao

storm jungle
#

Yeah the thing with the "crew" is unless you're a higher up no narrative will ever mention you

mellow depot
#

Yeah

storm jungle
#

Thats why the lower crew are so unheard of since nobody covers them

mellow depot
#

It's not that they don't exist

#

They're just like

#

The wind

storm jungle
#

Yep perfectly put

mellow depot
#

Imagine being the 6th generation in your family line to be on this ship without touching an actual fucking planet

#

And having to shoot giant rats

#

With a lasgun

#

Deep in the bowels of this ship

storm jungle
#

Thats why I love it tbh, its so fucking bizarrely morbid

#

and thats just a NORMAL ship

#

You got hulking continental ships like Big E's flagship for example. The examples are endless

#

god knows what people get up to down in its bowels

mellow depot
#

It's pretty nuts

#

It's a fucking miracle these shits run at all

storm jungle
#

Exactly lol

#

also works with plot tape but shhhhh

#

but yeah in the end the purpose of a lower crew in any 40k book is to:
**- Die to invaders on the ship and be mentioned in a single sentence as having been killed in drows

  • Complain about conditions and get sh**ot
#

otherwise I dont think any book covers them beyond these two examples

mellow depot
#

You could basically have almost-necromunda on one of these ships

#

Bunch of ragged tweakers that inherited servitude from their great grandfathers and have no idea what's going on outside the few decks they've been to

storm jungle
#

Perfectly put again

mellow depot
#

I'm pretty good if I'm being honest

#

😏

storm jungle
mellow depot
#

Jk

storm jungle
#

I always want to learn more about imperial ships but the 40k wiki is a goddamn nightmare to go through

#

repeating the same crap in every paragraph because they probably have no editors

analog ginkgo
#

I found the first Astartes video pretty nice in that regard.

Tight spaces and lots of crew doing their tasks.

storm jungle
#

Dangit

#

I was avoiding referencing that lol

#

but yeah its pretty adorable how the crew just hug the walls as they pass through

analog ginkgo
#

It is off course only a fan made video but imho, it was perfect regarding the atmosphere.

storm jungle
#

Yeah you can tell every short shot was planned and done over a few hours

cerulean wagon
#

I think i touched it before but outside of the immunity of the SM its a perfect set of animations

mellow depot
#

I think Astartes was way more time intensive than that

#

Lol

storm jungle
#

I think the aspect of them being almost invincible was to subvert the last part.

#

Where we are like "oh yeah they are kicking ass"

#

then whoops ELDRITCH TIME

mellow depot
#

Right, they put them over

cerulean wagon
#

i know but like they flat just

#

take autocannon and multilas fire

#

and shrug it off

storm jungle
#

To be fair

#

at least they take cover lol

#

but i totally get your point

cerulean wagon
#

they dont for the first one lol

#

it just bounces off his shoulder

#

and they keep walking

#

but ye im in agreement thatt he lower end imperial stuff is super interesting

#

the nobodies living the every day

#

and depending on what world thats from, your everyday could just be modern life

#

or it could be a shelled hellhole in the jaws of chaos but still kicking

#

i should run a demon world campaign at some point

storm jungle
#

Yeah the thing is

#

40k handles other worlds really poorly

#

its literally just "x-faction destroyed x-world"

#

then poof

#

Its the same as a giant planet having a single biome

cerulean wagon
#

i think 40k sufferd the same issue anything with a canon storyline does

#

theres specific races and ideas that are popular

#

so those take the forefront and are what drive it

storm jungle
#

Yep its the greatest strength of the setting and its weakness for me

#

i feel like its the reason why we'll never get stuff like Xenology anymore

cerulean wagon
#

the thing that keeps 40k rolling though id the writers

storm jungle
#

and artwork!

cerulean wagon
#

theres enough high quality booke that dont follow that principle

#

like sure irl there are full desert worlds and ice worlds n stuff

analog ginkgo
#

I mean... you have to hug the walls. Not because the space marines deserve it, but because they cant squeeze in.
Albeit, they do their very best to make space.

It shows a certain amount of mutual respect.

cerulean wagon
#

but i like the books covering cool concepts

#

like a ring world

#

where half the planet is 24/7 sunlight

#

the other half night time

#

and theres a ring of comfortably habitable land along the equator

#

because rotation n stuff

storm jungle
#

It makes me wish they consulted experts on stuff like that tbh

cerulean wagon
#

like its there and covered that worlds can be earth like, and people are people and a placr can have more depth than "hur hur sm shoot csm"

storm jungle
#

it would make it a lot cooler to get some plausible yet haunting worlds ya know

#

also more depth than "hur hur sm shoot csm"

#

if only

cerulean wagon
#

there are a few tbf

#

but at the same time

#

what takes centre stage is UM and their crusade

#

cause primaris being meta brings in the big dolla

storm jungle
#

Yeah, its the reason 40k has gotten so stale for me tbh

#

Im just here for the artwork/ lore lol

cerulean wagon
#

same

storm jungle
#

not (insert-role)cessors

cerulean wagon
#

lore, artwork, side content

storm jungle
#

^^^^

cerulean wagon
#

and running rpgs

#

running some Only War campaigns

vernal belfry
#

and memes ?

cerulean wagon
#

sfun

#

some memes

#

most of the memes annoy me now because people forget they are memes and that it doesnt work like that

storm jungle
#

SO TRUE

cerulean wagon
#

ye im still hung up on people not knowing IG use plasma

storm jungle
#

or you know

cerulean wagon
#

hur hur flashlights

storm jungle
#

they die in billions lolololol

#

commisars shoot everyone BLAM

#

it gets tiring

cerulean wagon
#

mhmm

storm jungle
#

not as bad as the Alpha Legion memes at least

#

it makes me wish the chapter didnt exist lol

cerulean wagon
#

lol

#

its why i semi dread DT tbh

#

Cause lore wise IG are super interesting

storm jungle
#

Its why I really love their books too!

cerulean wagon
#

massivley diverse with a whole host of tactics and equipment

#

Ye they definetly have the best books imo

#

but most people ignore that so a bit spooked

storm jungle
#

too true

vernal belfry
#

Considering the work that has been done in VT, I'm rather confident they can pull off an interesting back story for whatever grunts we will be playing as

storm jungle
#

Heres hoping

#

the cast of VT was great so i got my fingers crossed

cerulean wagon
#

my concern isnt even backstory n stuff, im sure thatll be amazing

#

my concern is equipment

#

Las is amazing tech, real cool and very effective

#

most people would say otherwise tho

storm jungle
#

🔦

vernal belfry
#

Oh that would be dramatic if they failed that yeah. Considering all that is available to the IG, it would be a shame to have too little options

cerulean wagon
vernal belfry
#

Well lasgun are effective but not universally effective, as with most IG weapons. So I reaaaaally hope we'll be able to mix up our arsenal to combat most threats

cerulean wagon
#

Lasguns are very well rounded for infantry targets

vernal belfry
#

Because I expect there will be at least some kind of armoured monstrosity at some point and lasgun wouldn't be so nice to have against that

cerulean wagon
#

its just a standard infantry rifle

#

ofc for armour n stuff we would want meltas/launchers n the like

vernal belfry
#

Oh I would love me some melta guns

#

Would be a lot of fun to play with

#

Or some heavy laser

#

bigger pew = better pew

#

it is known

cerulean wagon
#

i can see us getting hellguns

#

maybe hotshot volley even

storm jungle
#

Yeah i think the more "famous" weapons will be in the game

#

its just a situation of when to use them, you can already imagine people writing steam guides of STOP WASTING AMMO

vernal belfry
#

Hotshot would be dope albeit a bit.... risky ?

cerulean wagon
#

hotshots are fine

#

proper hotshots anyway

vernal belfry
#

For ammo it would be neat to be able to use the old IG trick to just drop the pack in some heatsources to "recharge" them 😄

cerulean wagon
#

lol

vernal belfry
#

I recall reading something like that at some point

cerulean wagon
#

yes they can be charged in fire or even direct sunlight

vernal belfry
#

Well I would like this option

#

Like, you get less max charges

#

But better than none

storm jungle
#

God this would be so cool

cerulean wagon
#

Honestly as long as they give las its 2 key features

#

fire rates

#

and charge modes

storm jungle
#

and seeing that red glow down a hall you fire

#

👌

cerulean wagon
#

yes

vernal belfry
#

yes please

#

So, what about plasma ? Do you think they should have a failure rate ?

cerulean wagon
#

prob just an overheat system like sienna

vernal belfry
#

Hmmm, yeah that would be better

cerulean wagon
#

and if you slap it on overcharged a single shot puts you in the danger zone

vernal belfry
#

Oh ! I also know at least ONE feature I would love to have

#

The same thing bardin got with his grudgeraker

#

The ability to bash faces with your gun

cerulean wagon
#

forget bashing

#

if theres no bayonet im not buying

vernal belfry
#

Or bayonetts, yeah

#

ha ha

cerulean wagon
#

lol

storm jungle
#

MINDLINK

#

also i almost hope you can overcharge and throw your plasma

vernal belfry
#

lol

storm jungle
#

its at the cost of your secondary/primary but it maybe does massive dmg

vernal belfry
#

Sounds like a neat idea

cerulean wagon
#

that or just let u explode at people like sienna lol

storm jungle
#

lmao

vernal belfry
#

Either they die by plasma fire or everyone does

storm jungle
#

^

#

In the end someone is getting 9th degree burns

cerulean wagon
#

another cool thing to do would be to make autoguns useful via stealth options

#

since you know

#

ionizing air las weaponry cant really be silenced

storm jungle
#

Thats actually one thing i also didnt get in vermintide

#

theres a tip that says enemies hear noises you make

#

yet it makes no difference when you get a horde trigger in like a minute or two anyway

#

wonder how they'd do it in DK as you say with the gun choices

cerulean wagon
#

guess its there for easy diff players

storm jungle
vernal belfry
#

The thing is, stealth would be nice but impossible to achieve in QP

#

Hell, I can barely have any QP in cata where DORF won't dive head in a Chaos Patrol

vast frigate
#

Theres a piece of lore somewhere where a priest puts a set of lasgun packs under a big parabole window to charge them

barren tapir
#

It all depend on which pattern the lasgun and its batteries are

#

Has anyone ever wondered if there is a leman russ tank pattern with a kettle to make some tea-equivalent in the grim darkness of the far future? I know about tanna from valhalla, but was thinking about something more general

cerulean wagon
#

i nean ye

#

valhallans n a few others just have kettles in their tanks

celest dome
#

Preatorian must have them since they are based on the British Colonial Force

analog ginkgo
#

I believe even their lasguns have their own kettles.

barren tapir
#

valhallans n a few others just have kettles in their tanks
Wut
How the warp i didn't find out that they made Tanna in their tanks? I always tought that they used campfire

#

I believe even their lasguns have their own kettles.
I want one thanks

cerulean wagon
#

idk

#

its brought up in the ciaphas cain books

#

n some other places

crisp heath
#

Soo the astronomicon is Used to triangulate once position in warp and space. But to triangulate U need more then one Point. What whould be the Other Points to use for that?

Also In the dark age of Technologie, before the astronomicon was build, they Used necron devices called Pharaos that where much weaker but spread Out across the Galaxie, with necrons Entering hibernation all of them but one shut down, anyone knows why that one was still running?

barren tapir
#

The Astronomican is a lighthouse, you see it, you know where Terra is, from that you know where you should point to go where you want

#

During the Age of Tech we could assume that the warp wasn't fucked up as it is in the 41st millennium, since slaneesh wasn't yet born and probably it was a lot quieter

#

IIRC the Pharaos throne was similar to what would became the golden throne, so it is possible that they are similar, after all the Pharaos was powered by a psyker too

#

I think that during the Age of Tech. warp jump were shorter and made with computers

kind dove
#

I thought Necrons essentially have nothing to do with the warp

#

But have insanely advanced tech

barren tapir
#

I thought Necrons essentially have nothing to do with the warp
Well, they know how to suppress the warp, so they have something to do with it, they simply don't use it

#

They also can enter the webway for short periods of time

crisp heath
#

Yes it gives U the point of Terra, but If u whould Go somewhere Else then Terra u need more fixpoint to get the right vectors.
Or U Always need to know Ur exact Position and alignment what Not possible by the way Warp works.

That they Most likly Just did short jumps and the Warp wasnt that rough is a good Point, didnt thought abbout that before.

vast frigate
#

basically the astronomicon gives them all needed info

#

see it like an uneven pillar

#

You can see points of referance on it from every side

vagrant osprey
#

Necrons are extremely anti-warp.

#

They don't use it, and can't use it.

#

DAoT humanity could make jumps as long as they wanted. The warp was placid outside of the very deep warp, so warp travel was extremely consistent and predictable.

#

Imagine a paddleboat on a still lake. You go in one direction, you go at a fixed speed, you get to your destination in a fixed amount of time. That was the warp before the birth of Slaanesh.

#

Now imagine a paddleboat in a hurricane.

#

It's easy to lose your references and wind up off-course, and there's no telling when or if you'll arrive.

#

The Astronomicon doesn't just act like a lighthouse, it also somewhat acts like a floodlamp. It makes the shape and movement of the warp knowable, which makes it so it can be navigated.

#

(And yeah, there was a Pharos active in the DAoT)

frigid mesa
#

what DAoT means

#

sorry lol

storm jungle
#

Dark Age of Technology

#

aka a period that existed in 40k where humanity was basically your run of the mill advanced sci-fi civilization.

#

It just exists so humans in the current timeline can pull out mcguffins out of nowhere and use OP tech from those times.

verbal nest
#

Which every fucking sci fi (apart from star wars) likes to do

#

And it pisses me the fuck off

#

"ancient tech from a golden age"
Lads why can we not be in the golden age rn

#

Destiny (the game) does this way too much

#

Everything you do is about golden age tech yet you get nowhere with it

primal tide
#

The tau are in their golden age 😂

rotund siren
#

You're not wrong

primal tide
#

Honestly, you could argue that so are chaos, tyranids (assuming they aren't running from sth else), and definitely orks too

odd tulip
#

I'd argue that the ancient tech thing is usually someone elses tech, EG the protheans or the forrunners. Warhammer is unique in that it's our own tech, we just lost it when the men of iron decided they didn't like us any more.

#

Though I haven't played destiny, so I don't know about that setting

rotund siren
#

Honestly, you could argue that so are chaos, tyranids (assuming they aren't running from sth else), and definitely orks too
@primal tide Nay for the ork bit. Orks are in their golden age culturally, in that they are having a great time, but technologically and in terms of overall galactic control, they suck when compared to the krorks of old.

#

Chaos you can never really tell, since they're always in flux and didn't have any presence in the DAoT, and Tyranids are permanently in their Golden Age

devout marlin
#

Tyranids are in their warm-up stretches

#

They haven’t even started throwing punches yet

odd tulip
#

There's some pretty decent evidence that all of the tyranid fleets that have entered the galaxy so far have been what is effectively just a forward scouting unit, and the real army is yet to come

#

Even more distressing is that they've come from all angles, suggesting the area outside of the galaxy is just one giant tyranid fustercluck

devout marlin
#

Existential terror is neat I guess

primal tide
#

To be fair, I did say orks, not krorks 😎

devout marlin
#

Even if Orks are taken as their own separate thing, which is somewhat valid I guess, their golden age was the war of the beast

primal tide
#

And chaos is living their best life now that they've got all those tasty marines and demon primarchs

devout marlin
#

The one time that actually managed to do something beyond be the generic enemy fodder for whenever chaos or tyranids isn’t around

verbal nest
#

@odd tulip destiny's golden age was basically
"The big glowy orb" showed up and (without explanation btw) humanity entered a golden age for many centuries, expanding across the solar system and building mega powerful shit, weapons, vehicles, any sort of tech. Then the Darkness (yeah, thrilling ikr) showed up to attack the traveller, it basically sacrificed itself (again, there's no fucking explanation at all) and gave humanity Ghosts, little flying robot fuckers who are chosen to retrieve a chosen person and turn them into a Guardian, which is what you play as in the games

#

The only problem here is that there's zero explanation and nothing quite adds up in Destiny

odd tulip
#

Dude, what happened to Bungie?

verbal nest
#

Idk man

#

I fucking hate Destiny 2 with a passion, it ruined anything Destiny 1 had for itself

#

The theme, the story, the whole thing

#

And this Beyond Light thing is basically,
Destiny 2, for its entire life, has been hinting at guardians and the Darkness getting interacted. And Beyond Light is this thing where Guardians go to Europa (Moon of Jupiter) and apparently get to use the Darkness

#

The problem I have is that it's gonna be one of those "ah well we have to 50 50 the light and darkness" instead of just fucking committing

#

There's so much shit that's never explained for so many years

#

Apparently the character you play as is very special, but so is basically everyone else who plays the game, but also specifically you as the player (?)

#

The main vanilla story Destiny 2 launched with, is now basically thrown to the side and the Devs actually list it along side all the dlc in the game

#

Despite it being the main story, if you installed a fresh account of destiny 2, they don't even force you to play anything,

odd tulip
#

"You're very special and so is everyone else" is a problem very unique to MMO's

verbal nest
#

Yeah it's fuckin awful

odd tulip
#

WoW and final fantasy struggle with it a lot

verbal nest
#

There's only one Mmo I like that does it but sadly this mmo sucks shit, Warframe

#

In Warframe you're supposed to be one of many people just like you doing many missions to do stuff

#

The only story breaking thing is when you repeat story missions

#

Something I also hate is that there's this Warmind, which is basically an AI built to do War stuff, that was basically revived and apparently this dude had control of every single automated weaponry in the entire solar system, fucker could wipe the human race in a second if he decided. But no this high and might Warmind just sits in the back of the game, speaking russian and doing jack shit

#

Like, there's a whole dlc based around reviving the dude and accessing his insanely powerful weaponry, but nothing actually comes from it in any sense

#

Oh yeah this Warmind was from the golden age too

#

This Warmind is literally an STC just waiting to be asked the question "bro can you make some....overpowered weapons or something"

#

But nope

#

Fucker just gon sit back and be all emo about being dead for a thousand years or something

frigid mesa
#

shit, sorry, wrong discord

vagrant lava
#

Does anyone know a place that has a good summary of everything that went on during the Horus Heresy?

  • Preferably just a few pages long.

Any details on how the Emperor started up everything is a bonus.

  • I'm trying to get a friend into the hobby and need to bring him up to speed.

(please @ me in the reply)

cerulean wagon
#

Uhhhhh

#

nothing that short no @vagrant lava the horus heresy is a fucking massive info dump

#

but 1d4 chan as usualy is like 80% shitpost

mellow depot
#

ye

#

unfortunately

#

concise information is hard to find in 40k

#

because like that one meme you need to constantly interrupt yourself

#

it's pretty cumbersome

cerulean wagon
#

Its less that its comersome and more that theres so much interwebbed shit

#

some of it is definetly fucking aweful to explain

#

but like, explaining why tech priests are they way they are only takes ages cause its something like 15k years of history or something

frigid mesa
#

SO anyway, are the emperor children gonna get their own set of news minis like the death guard or not

mint hill
#

Horus Hesery Summery: Horus fell to chaos and split the imperium in two, then died.

devout marlin
#

But who is Horus? What is chaos? How is chaos? Why is chaos? Why is Horus? Why?

#

This is the trap of talking about 40k lore

storm jungle
#

Honestly 40k 4chan is the best

#

But lexicanum might be the undisputed "short version" site.

#

I fucking hate 40kwiki with a passion since all they do is copy paste shit straight from the codices with ZERO editing and even fail at giving proper references to the said fluff.

lunar wren
#

@devout marlin its the issue with any non-historical based lore; at some point, you have to just accept it and move on. Or, demand they go back to the origin of the universe and explain the last 40k yrs...which I dont got time for

odd sparrow
#

Yeah Lexicanium is the wiki for serious 40k stuff with actual references and citations, 1d4chan is the fun memey one

#

don't bother with any others

#

But yeah that's like, a crazy amount to the horus heresy. Super short version is: The Emperor founds the Imperium and goes on a conquest of the galaxy. He entrusts this conquest to his 20 primarchs (his sons), each of which at the head of their respective space marine legion. During this time the emperor himself basically goes AWOL to work on his own projects, leaving his primarchs to do his dirty work.

Chaos, the extradimensional corrupting influence on reality, is able to manipulate about half of these legions, including the legion of Horus Lupercal (the most influential primarch at the time who was serving as the head of the imperiums military), into betraying the emperor for a variety of reasons ranging from personal grudges to lofty ideologies about chaos etc. The other half stays loyal to the emperor.

The civil war begins with a massacre of loyalist forces by the traitors. The civil war, e.g. the horus heresy, then goes on for nearly a decade and ends with the Emperor himself boarding the flagship of Horus and killing him, with big E being mortally wounded and put on life support in the process. A bunch of other primarchs are also dead, the miltiary of the imperium is a shadow of its former self, the adeptus mechanicus never fully recovers and the remaining chaos space marines from the heresy retreat and regroup under a new leader.

#

but yeah i can't really go any further into it without going on a 30 minute ramble about way too much stuff to be concise

crisp heath
#

Good summary, has all the Important pointsgoodjob

devout marlin
#

It’s maybe worth mentioning the Pharos just because of its implications regarding the Tyranids but that would open up a whole other can of worms, as is so often the case in 40k

odd sparrow
#

gotta know how to simplify stuff with 40k lore. A universe in existence since the 80s with hundreds of novels published about it is inevitably convoluted af

vagrant osprey
#

Also: The entire thing happened because the Emperor is not human, doesn't understand how humans think, and routinely underestimates them. He's also a raging egoist who is incapable of comprehending that he makes mistakes.

mellow depot
#

he doesn't tho Smug

#

jk

devout marlin
#

Lowkey Magnus did do nothing wrong and it’s all the emperor’s fault

vagrant osprey
#

No. Magnus did ONE thing wrong.

devout marlin
#

He could’ve just told Lorgar to hurry up instead of nuking his entire worldview and then the heresy never would’ve happened

vagrant osprey
#

He got three words after his Folly. He said "Father! Father? Father!" and then booked it.

#

If he said "Horus betrayed you" that would have done the thing he set out to do, and it would have been worth it

devout marlin
#

It’s not like the emperor would believe him at that point anyway

#

Horus as far as the emperor knows is his best son, Magnus as far as the emperor knows is the most likely to do something he’s not supposed to, and even showing up proves that

#

There’s no reason to believe the guy who just annihilated your life’s work, especially when he’s accusing the favorite son

vagrant osprey
#

Except he would have believed him enough to have the Solar Auxilia come to full muster.

#

And he DIDN'T annihilate the Emperor's life's work.

devout marlin
#

He kinda did though

vagrant osprey
#

It's literally just a single primarch-sized portal inside the generator room of the Human Webway Project.

devout marlin
#

Which is enough for a horde of daemons to pour through and keep the custodes tied up for the entire duration of the war

vagrant osprey
#

Believe it or not, that'd be an annoyance if Magnus and/or the Emperor could take the time to go patch the hole.

devout marlin
#

From the emperor’s perspective Magnus just used his power to start a daemon invasion in the imperial palace, anything he says and any accusations he makes are null because there is no evidence that anyone is a traitor except Magnus

vagrant osprey
#

You say that, except the Emperor then sent for Magnus to come to Terra and explain his actions.

devout marlin
#

Yeah because even when his son looks like a traitor he doesn’t want to believe it

#

Think about that

#

If Magnus is literally caught red handed and still is only summoned to stand trial, why would the emperor bat an eye towards Horus

#

The emperor isn’t even the one go order Horus’s destruction at Isstvan iirc, Dorn is

vagrant osprey
#

Because the Emperor knows Magnus is a massive book nerd and wouldn't start punching holes in reality unless he was panicking.

#

Magnus, if left to his own devices, will sit around and study the secrets of sorcery.

#

Being a traitor requires he actually do something, which is against his nature.

devout marlin
#

And Horus has been the emperor’s most loyal and favorite sun, and has been at his side far longer than any of the others

#

Magnus is much less believable than Horus

#

By the time Magnus gets off anything about Horus, he’s already proved that he’s willing to disobey the emperor’s will

#

Horus has done nothing of the sort

vagrant osprey
#

Except you already said the Emperor was reluctant to believe any of his sons was a traitor.

#

The logical conclusion would be that somebody pretending to be Horus was acting against him.

#

Naturally, the end result is the same: Muster the Solar Auxillia and call his sons together to sort things out.

#

Horus being unable to get off his initial sneak-attack would have crippled his war effort.

#

Of course, the real problem is that the Emperor created the whole damn problem in the first place.

#

All he had to do was explain his long-term plans at some point.

#

The Astartes turned because they helped wipe out the surviving Thunder Warriors, and knew what happened to a tool when the Emperor no longer needed it.

#

And the Great Crusade had an end point in sight.

frigid mesa
#

He is Human after all

vagrant osprey
#

He didn't even tell the Primarchs what his plan was for the Astartes after the Great Crusade. Each one of them tried to set their Sons up to do something different.

#

He's really not.

#

If he ever was human, he stopped being human when he entered that Warp gate and made a pact to cut his humanity out of him to keep it from getting in his way.

#

Star Child is still canon.

frigid mesa
#

yeah, but thats a good daft punk song tho

storm jungle
#

Will people

#

SHUT UP ABOUT MAGNUS

devout marlin
#

No

#

Because he is a good boy who did nothing wrong

storm jungle
#

I hate that meme so much

#

eurgh

devout marlin
#

It’s not a meme

#

It’s the truth

storm jungle
#

I mean

#

it is a meme

#

everybody on r/grimdank says it daily

vagrant osprey
#

It's a meme

green sedge
#

What's this about people thinking Big E is, like... human? Plz explain. He seems extremely not human.

#

Like, sure, he's one of my favorite characters but I can't see any argument for him being human still.

#

Not with what he becomes, and what he can do.

#

He's... seriously beyond human. He may have always been.

#

He's just kinda human shaped.

verbal nest
#

I always assumed he was the god of humans, the same way khorne is the god of being angry as shit, nurgle being the god of dirty shower cubicles, and slannesh being the god of kinky times

#

So it's the embodiment of all humanity

#

Although seemingly a lot of the bad human stuff

devout marlin
#

The gods can’t exist in the materium

#

Big E cannot be a god in the same sense as the chaos gods unless he physically dies

rotund siren
#

He's just super psychic

#

and is worshipped

#

a lot

devout marlin
#

Correction, they can exist in the materium but if they did they’d tear reality apart around them

rotund siren
#

oh and is fed souls

#

yes

verbal nest
#

My idea of Big E was that he is human
But he's so psyker that like, he big brain mfer

devout marlin
#

The emperor by the time of 40k is dead enough that he’s probably damn close to being a god if he’s not one already but he definitely was not a god while he still walked among the humans

verbal nest
#

Didn't he have godlike power? I've read the wiki for him and apparently he could manipulate space and do all sorts of wacky shit

#

He may not have been a god but damn he was close

devout marlin
#

Godlike

#

He was very powerful but he was not a god

verbal nest
#

Who would win between 1 million grail Knights and Big E

rotund siren
#

at his prime or on the throne?

verbal nest
#

Lol on the throne lmfao are you joking

At his prime ofc

rotund siren
#

Probably him. He did wreck an entire planet of mek orks

verbal nest
#

Sigmar Vs Big E¿

rotund siren
#

idk about that one

devout marlin
#

Sigmar before or after becoming a god

#

Same question for the emperor

verbal nest
#

Both in their prime

#

Wait so sigmar became a full blown god?
Ok both in their physical prime

devout marlin
#

Emperor

verbal nest
#

Ok what about Sigmar (physical prime) Vs like...a thousand Grey Knights

devout marlin
#

How many of the Grey knights are named

#

Fight like that comes down to how much plot armor is in play and Sigmar has a load of plot armor

#

Depends how many grey knights are named and, more importantly, if one of them is Kaldor Draigo

storm jungle
#

Big E would basically mindrape sigmar and make his head explode.

#

But in reality they'd bro-team up for the betterment of humanity because fuck yeah!

verbal nest
#

"betterment"
I mean i subscribe to the idea that Big E was eventually going to turn humanity into the religious shitstorm it turned into eventually

#

He just had to get everyone's attention first

storm jungle
#

Not really

verbal nest
#

Shush

storm jungle
#

He'd most likely disappear and let humanity develop.

#

The great crusade wasnt even a part of his plan.

#

Theres a reason he stayed hidden for so long.

verbal nest
#

K

storm jungle
verbal nest
#

Oh what do you guys think that funny paper thing is that only one grey knight knows about

#

Apparently it's supposed to be used as a last resort

storm jungle
#

Terminus Decree you mean?

verbal nest
#

I forgot the name

storm jungle
#

Yeah thats it

#

but theres pretty much nothing about it but I do love the memes around it

verbal nest
#

It would be interesting if it turned out to be an intact STC of the best kind

#

But authors can do what they want

storm jungle
#

Well thats the whole purpose of STCs and the DAoT in general.

#

aka be mcguffins.

#

So yeah it would be interesting.

verbal nest
#

Yeah and it sucks shit

storm jungle
#

Hm?

verbal nest
#

I already went over this yesterday

storm jungle
#

The golden age thing?

verbal nest
#

Yes

storm jungle
#

40k pretty much copied the Butlerian Jihad from Dune. It wasnt that common of a trope back in the day.

verbal nest
#

These days it's in everything

#

And has been for a while now

storm jungle
#

Thats the fate of most trope sadly

verbal nest
#

It's not even pulled off well

storm jungle
#

I mean its not suppose to be

#

theres a reason its left incredibly obscure.

verbal nest
#

Yeah but it's possible to pull it off well

storm jungle
#

Hows that exactly?

verbal nest
#

Don't leave it so obscure
For example, in destiny they could easily find golden age stuff and get it working again, but also have it explained and go in-depth about the how's and whys instead of just leaving it obscure so they can invent more OP golden age mcguffins out of nowhere

storm jungle
#

Then that doesnt leave much to the meaning of "Dark" in Dark age of Technology though.

#

It goes too well with the 40k narrative in general.

verbal nest
#

That's the inherent issue with 40k storytelling imo, there's too much that's hidden for the sole purpose of the attraction of mystery

storm jungle
#

also 40k golden age tech is far FAR more devastating than most people would have you believe.

verbal nest
#

I know

storm jungle
#

well to be fair i agree there but this is like a 30 year old franchise

#

the lore itself is a "dark age" of its own lol

verbal nest
#

The other problem I have is how awkward the content of finding golden age stuff is
In Destiny you're walking around with some top tier golden age weaponry and AI, but the story or gameplay doesn't drastically change despite these discoveries

#

The rest of the franchise doesn't adapt to the sudden discovery of some really cool shit

storm jungle
#

Thats just a case of bad writing

#

destiny is a really cool franchise obviously but half of it just left "blank"

#

BECAUSE GOTTA MAKE THAT DLC BOI

verbal nest
#

Lol yeah

lunar wren
#

D2 is a FPS with a skeleton of a story...if they had writers and opened it up, it'd flesh out really nicely

#

Strange Traveler...never forget

verbal nest
#

The stranger is in beyond light

lunar wren
#

But 40k does a good job by putting everything behind fanatiscism; which is pretty authentic

barren tapir
#

Ah yes, the terminus decree the thing that have a symbol that is found only in another place... The golden throne... Which is also the place where a "talisam" has been placed that the greatest blacksmith of the primarchs made without even remembering doing...

lunar wren
#

yes...like 8 years after first/last contact

verbal nest
#

Yeah basically

#

And 6*

#

Destiny 1 launched in 2014

lunar wren
#

still, long as time for your guide in the first game to come back and say whats up

verbal nest
#

I didnt quite catch what you meant there

lunar wren
#

Bungie is just now getting around to filling in some of the major plot holes; largely because they fly from shiny object to shiny object

verbal nest
#

Oh there's a lot of issues yeah

lunar wren
#

and rely on grimoires to add depth...when they could do so much more in game if they had a semi-coherent story arc

verbal nest
#

The taken king was the last time I ever liked the franchise, coz it really opened up on the lore for a hot minute

lunar wren
#

40k allowed writers to flesh out its world while they still curated it, enabling so many opportunities to engage with the lore

verbal nest
#

It's hard to keep a straight face while we literal God killers are just normal ass human with a flying Amazon Echo near us

lunar wren
#

Very true; it went very deep on Oryx as well as started to explain the Cabal

storm jungle
#

To be fair Guardians are pretty OP

#

practically immortal as long as your Alexa doesnt get pew'd

lunar wren
#

lol, yep

storm jungle
verbal nest
#

Yes but the way the franchise shows it is awful

storm jungle
#

oh god yeah

verbal nest
#

"you're immortal and are powerful enough to kill whole dang gods"
"....k?"

lunar wren
#

I dont think they had enough writers...or maybe they cut costs there...its got lots of good things to work with, but they are all half-assed

verbal nest
#

Like if that's the case then why hasn't Light been harvested to make another golden age

storm jungle
#

I feel like destiny would work perfectly as a tabletop game too tbh. You practically hear nothing of the common stuff

#

aka literally forgetting humans are down to a single city

#

or how the people live there

#

etc etc

verbal nest
#

Destiny is the only franchise where the fan fiction was actually decent (this was back in 2016 so it's probably shit now)

lunar wren
#

I love how you go out and conduct strikes on Mars, Mercury, etc, but right outside the last city of humanity you still got enemy at the gates...like wtf?

verbal nest
#

I love how Mercury and the Moon is literally inside and out covered and terraformed with alien shit somehow

#

Also Rasputin

#

Just why

storm jungle
#

Rasputin is fineeee

lunar wren
#

Crota killed hundreds of guardians, dies to 3

#

6*

#

Loved how they changed the Rasputin lore between 1 and 2

verbal nest
#

Crota can die to 1 guardian with the correct loadout

#

Same with oryx

lunar wren
#

I skate, so I dont have time nor the hops to solo oryx, lol

verbal nest
#

What did they change about Rasputin lore in 1 and 2? All I've noticed is that they gave Rasputin way more power than I remembered

lunar wren
#

In 1, there were multiple warminds; in 2, they are satellites of Rasputin. So in 1 you had the Jove warmind that you interacted with while Rasputin was stuck on Earth

verbal nest
#

Oh yeah I remember that

#

Maybe that's the power jump I'm on about

#

Rasputin has way more power over the entire solar system somehow (and still does jack shit despite being fully awake in the current events of destiny2)

#

Rasputin is fucking alive and breathing rn, and yet

Oh dear the darkness

lunar wren
#

exactly; he wasnt all powerful

#

he was only responsible for the Earth defense grid

verbal nest
#

If he's so powerful why doesn't he just say some wacky shit like "lol the main character is actually like...god or something"

#

Just twist up the lore even more

lunar wren
#

lol

verbal nest
#

The whole beyond light is just dumb as shit

#

It's gonna be troped the fuck out, I will bet that

vagrant osprey
#

@verbal nest The C'Tan are referred to as "The Gods of the Materrium".

exotic chasm
#

Has any heretic force kicked down the doors to the emperor’s throne room at all ever

#

Besides the Horus Heresy

#

I keep getting this image in my head of all the major champions of the chaos gods under the banner of Chaos Undivided and deciding to visit Terra

storm jungle
#

It will happen one day when 40k stops making money

exotic chasm
#

yeah probably

storm jungle
#

but sadly no, because terra is fortified up the ASS

exotic chasm
#

It’s such a cool idea though

storm jungle
#

Yeah im pretty sure when GW decides to do End Times someone is gonna reach the throne room and stab Big E

exotic chasm
#

Idk I was just thinking to myself, who would win in an immaterium battle? The four Chaos gods or the emperor

#

Like who’s stronger psyker wise

storm jungle
#

Honestly this is the big problem with 40k

#

literally anyone can win as long as the plot demands or pulls somethings out of its ass

exotic chasm
#

Ultramarines stay mad

storm jungle
#

They got their sweet plot armor

#

but realistically id guess the 4 chaos gods

#

unless Big E orgasms into existence like slaanesh

exotic chasm
#

Hot Take: Ultramarines are only successful because orks think Blue is lucky color

storm jungle
#

LOL

exotic chasm
#

Bet

#

Actually bet

storm jungle
#

im pretty sure i saw that on r/grimdank somewhere, if not then it must be made as a joke

exotic chasm
#

I am fortunate enough to not peruse Reddit

#

But honestly it wouldn’t surprise me

storm jungle
#

give it a shot trust me

#

r/40klore and r/grimdank are great

exotic chasm
#

Is it all just “haha mechanicus fuck toasters” And “Ultramarines stinky” and “looky ‘ere, new meme for da boyz”

#

Because that’s what I think it would be

storm jungle
#

Actually thats a common misconception

#

The comment section makes those jokes sometimes but theres actually really fucking funny memes produced daily

exotic chasm
#

Well shid might as well

storm jungle
#

Its a good hit and miss

#

meanwhile I recommend r/40k lore for reading sessions, people post some nice popular threads there once in awhile

devout marlin
#

literally anyone can win as long as the plot demands or pulls somethings out of its ass
I mean yes but also the Tyranids have an astronomical advantage over virtually every other faction and it’s ultimately a countdown until they or the Necrons decide it’s time to kill everyone

#

Chaos can’t and doesn’t want to actually win over the imperium, everyone else is too weak to pull out a dominant win before the Tyranids or Necrons start throwing down

#

Except maybe the Orks but they like stabbing each other too much to put a concentrated effort into stabbing exclusively everyone else

primal tide
#

r/40k lore
A big +1 on this, there are great threads on there
There was a thread a few weeks ago with lots of examples of grumpy dreadnoughts being total bros and it was great

storm jungle
#

@devout marlin Still proves my point.

#

The setting would be destroyed long ago by any one of these factions if it wasnt for the plot armor tape holding it all together.

#

And these "advantages" they have over the imperium doesnt matter when a named character can just slap any special character from an opposing faction to the next dimension.

#

Like the swarmlord lol

barren tapir
#

Chaos tried and failed to assault the imperial palace after the creation of the cicatrix maledictum... To note that it was just khorne armies... Another force of harlequins made it to the eternity gate IIRC during the war of the beast... Orks had the entire Terra at gunpoint during that event too... And there are also tyranids that are attracted by the astronomican... Terra is the most defended world in the imperium, after it there was only cadia and the latter sadly get dostroyed...

#

At the moment the greatest threats are nocrons and tyranids, mostly becasue super tech and huge numbers respectively... Then Orks, because they are starting to become more united thanks to ghazkul...

cerulean wagon
#

na the ork threats gone

#

the new Space wolf stuff meant they fucked gaz waaaagh

#

which was fuckin dumb

vagrant osprey
#

Necrons seem unlikely to attack Terra, since they wouldn't really get anything out of it.

mellow depot
#

i thought necrons just wanted to destroy all organic life

primal tide
#

Some want pets

mellow depot
#

hahaha

primal tide
#

It's true

barren tapir
#

the new Space wolf stuff meant they fucked gaz waaaagh
Ragnar managed to behead Ghazghkull, but his head has bee recovered and now ghaz is back, bigger and stronger

#

He seems to be attracting orks from all over the galaxy

#

Necrons seem unlikely to attack Terra, since they wouldn't really get anything out of it.
They may be more interested in Mars, but the imperium hardly will let them even enter the solar system without a fight, so Terra is just on the way

#

Just wait until the silent king hear about a possibile shard of the void dragon on mars, he seem to like those shards, and he can muster theoretically all the necrons

#

Some want pets
Others just want to study souls... And where are some of the weirdest souls in the imperium??

storm jungle
#

now ghaz is back, bigger and stronger

#

@barren tapir Not unless Space Marines have to win for a bigger sale

crisp heath
#

I like to pretend nothing after primaris marines were introduced happened

#

the primaris marine design is ugly and the concept is dumb

#

plus I dont like alot of the new designs in generap

#

heavily disappointed by the necromunda ganger factions and the enforcers

odd sparrow
#

some of the more recent primaris stuff has been a lot better imo. More gothic stuff

devout marlin
#

I don’t really have a problem with the primaris anymore

#

They don’t really change much except design and I like their design

odd tulip
#

Primaris designs are pretty sleek imo.

thick shadow
#

I still HATE the design of thinner version of their calf protection.

#

It should've just like a Stormcast's

#

The usual irl lookin one

primal tide
#

calves too pointy, 2/10 would not paint

thick shadow
rotund siren
#

why those legs so thin

thick shadow
#

That's the problem

rotund siren
#

YES

#

thicc is best

primal tide
#

Don't be rude to my booty boys

rotund siren
#

Well that's the thing; how can they be expected to have fine booties, if they have the legs of chickens?

primal tide
#

Chicken leg, he calls the 8 foot tall transhuman

devout marlin
#

They look fine to me

primal tide
#

I think they all look good, middle doesn't look like he's got the same range of motion as the left tho

#

Imagine having to curb stomp xenos without being able to rotate your ankle to the sides

devout marlin
#

Probably just does the cartoon thing where metal bends as if it were cloth

#

Dude in a suit of armor bends over, the armor bends with him

primal tide
#

Yeah

#

Just aesthetically I see the left and say hey neat that looks a little more agile

#

Wonder if that was their goal or if it was purely for the boot look

devout marlin
#

I feel like at this point it’s entirely rule of cool

#

The pauldron are horrible from a realistic standpoint but they look damn sexy so they stay, I assume it’s kind of the same for the legs

#

Although I will say the Primaris pauldrons look a lot less intrusive than the old astartes ones

#

So maybe they are trying to make it more realistic

barren tapir
#

With the primaris GW tried to solve the problems with proportions... New primaris have right proportions, and they armor are "thinner" than the firstborn SM because are more modualr and made for mobility not bulkiness... All the SM power armors followed a path which would lead to "thinner" armors with some exceptions... And primaris could have "thick" armors too

devout marlin
#

As long as terminators stay thicc I don’t mind

barren tapir
#

Now that i think of... I still haven't seen a primaris terminator

devout marlin
#

I think I remember seeing them but I’ve forgotten what they look like

storm jungle
#

Nah thats a custodian terminator armor

#

you can tell from the eagle sigils on the boots

devout marlin
#

I just looked up Primaris terminator and that was the first result

storm jungle
#

Yep i know

#

I got the same result

#

This is the armor im talking about

devout marlin
#

The Primaris still look mostly the same as the old terminators from what I’m seeing

#

Ah yeah fair enough

storm jungle
#

Yeah dont worry, i dont blame the confusion since primaris got a lot of dudes in heavy suits

devout marlin
#

Are there even Primaris terminators

#

Most of the google results are speculation on them

#

Nothing concrete

storm jungle
#

Yeah i think then thats a no

#

GW are still on the rush to upgrade all old marine units to primaris ones so terminators must be next

devout marlin
#

I find it hard to believe they went through all of 8th edition without introducing Primaris terminators

storm jungle
#

Saaaame

#

its like the most iconic unit

devout marlin
#

Space marines are badass but terminators are badass

barren tapir
#

No primaris terminators, gravis armor is similar

#

Used by commanders and aggressor squads

storm jungle
#

@devout marlin its why i hope they dont upgrade its iconic features

storm jungle
#

aka stuff like the snout'ish helmet

devout marlin
#

Yeah that’s what I saw a lot of when I looked

barren tapir
#

Gravis armour doesn't reach terminator armor as protection, but it is really close

devout marlin
#

Thought it was terminators but I guess not

storm jungle
#

so its diet-terminator

#

gotcha

pastel pebble
#

As far as 40k literature is concerned, what are some of the best novels to read?

primal tide
#

im a big fan of the eisenhorn series, like a lot of folks. i see it recommended fairly often for people looking for some 40k books to read

odd sparrow
#

Ciaphas cain is also a good one

meager narwhal
#

I 200% also recommend Eisenhorn and Ravenor series. Get the Omnibus versions if possible so to include all the short stories also

devout marlin
#

I really loved the night lords omnibus

vagrant osprey
#

Master of Mankind is basically essential to understanding the Emperor.

#

Gaunt's Ghost is an excellent series.

#

Also, it looks like the new lore is making Mechanicum more and more relevant.

#

Prospero Burns is also fantastic. (Anything by Dan Abnet, really)

#

Whatever you do, avoid anything that focuses on Space Marines or the nameless Imperial Guard regiments. The writing is terrible in both cases; the first because it's insipid wankery, the second because it's basically always a first-person view of somebody watching everybody they know be fed feet-fist into a woodchipper before getting shoved in themselves.

unreal grail
#

I would recommend anything by Aaron Dembski-Bowden, such a great author

#

you are going to get your fair share of pointless bolter porn in any W40K novel, but the good authors manage so much more when it comes to the setting and characters

#

a couple of titles (by various authors): Legion, The First Heretic, Prospero Burns, Angel Exterminatus, Helsreach, the Night Lords trilogy

pastel pebble
#

Awesome, looks like I have enough recommendations to get started. Thank you.

vagrant osprey
#

Also: If you see anything by CS Goto, just run.

kind dove
#

Just finished all the Caiphas Cain Omnibuses and they were amazing. Just started the Eisenhorn omnibuses

cerulean wagon
#

caiphas is the best

#

so gud

crisp heath
#

Oh yes. Cain, Eisenhorn, gaunts ghosts, and ahriman. All my Favorit book series

#

And ofc. Farseer because it gives a nice View from a "normal" Person in the univers

#

Spacewolfes from King was also nice. Featuring ragnars Transformation to a spacemarine

kind dove
#

Spacewolfes from King was also nice. Featuring ragnars Transformation to a spacemarine
@crisp heath

#

I ur get a b*ner, we’re killing ye