[CLOSED] 10/16/25 Thursday Question Submissions

[brisk plinth]

Thursday Show Submissions!

🏈 Want to be featured on Underdog Fantasy with Josh & Hayden?
Now’s your shot 💥

🎤 Send us your best Fantasy Trade questions — via video or audio — and we might answer them on-air.

🔥 The better your question (and your recording), the better your chances of getting featured.

💰 If selected, we'll send you $10 in bonus funds on the Underdog App

Bring the heat. Let’s talk fantasy.

[fair spindle]

This is my home league, very weird settings. 12 team, half ppr. Must roster 2TQB, 4RB, 4 WR/TE, 2K, & 2D. Must start 2 RB, 2 WR/TE, 1 RB/WR/TE. The deal is I receive Jefferson & Vikings QB for Pickens & 49ers QB. Is this a lateral move, or am I capitalizing on Pickens value for JJettas (tiering up). Absolutely love the show & the work you guys put in! Thanks!

[fossil trail]

10 team full PPR. 2 flex.
Receive Jamar Chase and Devante Adams
Give Pickens Tet JCM
Have CeeDee lamb as well. RB dept is a worry but Chase and CeeDee together sound great

[limber fossil]

James cook or Pickens I need an answer !!

[little hornet]

I got offered Rome Skat and Brob for JSN

Hayden mentioning Skat as a top 10 RB makes me wanna do it! But JSN is a top 10 player!

[spark badge]

Hey guys. 0.5 PPR, Superflex 2RB 3WR 1 FLEX H2H league. Currently 3-3 with the 2nd most points for (schedule variance lol). I like my roster a lot but I'm concerned about the ceiling of my RB's going forward. My roster is
QB: Daniels, Stafford
RB: Kenneth Walker, Chase Brown, Stevenson, Dowdle, Allgeier
WR: Puka, Pickens, Worthy, QJ, Golden, Jennings, Coker(IR)
TE: McBride

I've been offered Bucky Irving for Jennings and Chase Brown from a team who's 1-5 and needs to win now. Would you pull the trigger?

Thanks and Up The Villa (except against Man City)

[opal jay]

What’s up yall. Big fan here, watch each show religiously. So, I am in a 10 man PPR league and got offered Lamar, BTJ, and Skatt for Jayden Daniels, MHJ, and Kyren. I am definitely upgrading at receiver and QB but don’t love losing Kyren for Skatt due to Cams tough schedule. However, I have Hampton on IR waiting for me. I am currently also lacking a true WR2. So should I make the trade? Any help would be great!

[honest star]

12 team ppr

giving dowdle and jeanty
getting henry and adams

[atomic crest]

Hi guys, big fan. Currently 3-3. In a 0.5 PPR, SF, 10-Team DYNASTY league. Trade 1 is I give up Worthy + Tuten for Rashee Rice + '28 third. Second trade is I give up Troy Franklin + '28 third for Chase Brown. I'm afraid I'm giving away too much future production and giving up on my young guys too soon to chase hypothetical immediate value. Let me know what you think

[night haven]

12-team half PPR, 4-2; I’m being offered Lamar/Javonte Williams for Pickens. Feels like a no brainer just wanted to hear your thoughts and maybe some ideas on who to flip Hurts for, appreciate all the content!

[uncut meteor]

So I hoped the most useful fantasy-podcast could help me. I’m playing in a super tight 12-team hppr league with two flex spot (WR/RB/TE) were it’s super hard to trade because people lack depth. I kinda like my team but always looking to improve and JSN sounds like the man this year but my RB-situation would be trash.

Also I would recommend everyone to add playing against the median score makes it more difficult and exciting

[somber bane]

10 person league with all my friends. I’m 1-5 and need some help please 🙏 full PPR.
My friend just said he’ll take my offer of Bo Nix, Ashton Jeanty, Quentin Johnston for Baker Mayfield and Saquon Barkley.
My team is deep but I need more realizable starters.
What do you think?

[somber bane]

Feel like since I’m losing it’s pointless to have such a deep bench

[uncut meteor]

Thank you for answering! Would be lovely if some took the bait on Mayer or Lamar though

[brisk plinth]

[CLOSED] 10/16/25 Thursday Question Submissions