haughty junco
Thursday Show Submissions!
🏈 Want to be featured on Underdog Fantasy with Josh & Hayden?
Now’s your shot 💥
🎤 Send us your best Fantasy Trade questions — via video or audio — and we might answer them on-air.
🔥 The better your question (and your recording), the better your chances of getting featured.
9/25/25 Thursday Question Submissions
Hey everyone! Just to emphasize it, our Thursday show will be dedicated to your hypothetical fantasy trades! So dust off your trade machines and give us some hypothetical moves to ponder!
latent oak
Standard league. Out of the following players who would you get rid of to try and get a RB1 or WR1? Monty, Ladd, Kamara, Pearsall, Pickens. Looking for a 2for1 or 3for1
daring ermine
Just got offered Judkins & Olave for Pickens. 1/2 ppr, other RB- Achane, Irving, Brown, Tuten, & Pacheco- other WR- Nico, Egubka, T-Mac, Worthy, Mooney, Tillman. What you think?!
supple temple
broken bough
Hey Hayden and Josh! I’m in a 12 team full ppr league. Drafted heavy on the wr (I have puka, Rome, Allen, and leek) and could use a rb upgrade I was just offered Hubbard and Etienne for leek and JCM thoughts??? Just saw Giants may be starting Dart this week should I plan to hold onto leek for now?
haughty junco
Hey everyone! Keep in mind that if you want your trade featured on the show, the best chances of getting it on there would be to ask your questions over video!
We'd also love for you to submit some screenshots of your lineups with it!
bitter iris
turbid delta
Fellas, I know that the heart of a good trade is filling my opponents needs along with my own. I've got a stacked squad with deep RB resources, and Shmuck 1 + Shmuck 2 are vulnerable at RB. I'm considering:
Send: KW3, London, Skattebo
Get: Nabers, JSN
Send: KW3, Skattebo,
Get: Josh Jacobs, RJ Harvey
Send: KW3 (And Kraft?)
Get: McBride (and RJ Harvey?)
These 2 for 1 or 3 for 2-ish deals are usually smashes if you get the best players out of 'em, but I kinda feel like I should just stand pat and let Skat build more value. Though, could it be time to cash in on KW3? If I don't move though, someone else might (unlikely). Any comment on when it's time to just stand pat and relax a bit, given this roster? How do I leverage this strong position?
PS, Josh, I swear, I'm a fellow KW3 truther, and I promise I'm not in your mentions trying to shit on this guy.
latent oak
Standard league. I’ve been hurting at TE all year and I have deep WR depth. Would you trade away Ladd to get Rashee Rice and Jake Ferguson? My WRs are Egbuka, Odunze, Jameson Williams, Devonta Smith. My TEs are Fannin Jr & Loveland
green kiln
I just traded away Nico and Alvin for Gibbs. Thoughts?
true birch
Is Kamara + Pearsall for O. Hampton overpaying? I wanted to offer Marks, T. Franklin, Pearsall but initial talks hint at raising the price.
Rest of team
WRs - Brown, Nabers, BTJ, TMac, Ricky, TFrank.
RBs - Kamara, Marks, B. Allen, BRob, Ray Davis, Spears
dry sand
Before week 3 started I made a trade
14 Team - 3 WR - 2 RB - 1 Flex - Full PPR
My Emeka Egbuka, Isiah Pacheco, and Ollie Gordon for his Rhamondre Stevenson and TreVeyon Henderson
My RBs were CMC, Pacheco, Gordon, and Monangai so I was thin at the position. My WRs were McLaurin, Egbuka, JSN, Doubs, Mooney, Franklin, and Horton
Is this reasonable or did I exploit myself?
PS: I picked up Sterling Shepard
solemn crescent
0.5 PPR league. Trade Kittle and Hunter for BTJ? Other TE is J.Johnson and weak at WR.
shut lintel
Hey guys! I’ve been offered Christian McCaffrey and Daniel Jones for my Saquon Barkley and Bo Nix. Is this smash accept? 10 team half PPR. I have drake maye and Achane at the positions also
Appreciate if anyone else has advice on this
wanton moss
I get Kamara + Jennings for Garrett Wilson
My RBs are Hubbard, Chase Brown and Bill
My WRs: Chase , Embuka, Ted
Full PPR
distant osprey
Full PPR, 2 flex. Who wins? Appreciate the show thanks for all the time you put into it!
haughty junco
Hey everyone! Really appreciate all the questions coming in!
We're REALLY looking for primarily video questions! So if you want your questions to be answered (so that you can win your league) please record yourself and send us a screenshot of your team! Thank you!
fierce yacht
exotic spruce
Thoughts on chuba for Ladd in full ppr?
desert cedar
Reminder: We're looking for more VIDEO submissions. Also, please include your UD username along with your message 🙂
timid steeple
ELIMTZ14: just got offered James Cook and BTJ for Lamar and Olave. Thoughts?
shut lintel
verbal radish
Kluu - 12 Team PPR, 0-3. Hampton+G.Wilson for Saquon? 3WR 2RB 2FLEX. Quite deep @ WR
dense imp
Full PPR, was offered BTJ and RJ Harvey for my Judkins and Slick Rick Pearsall. Thoughts?
remote sphinx
Thanks guys!
fast bay
In a 2nd year 12 team dynasty SF TEP start 10, I lost Burrow. I decided to sell some of my older players. Through different trades I traded away Kyler, Jennings, Sutton, ASB, A.J Brown, Warren.
I flipped Harrison, received Rice, Penix, Kittle, Garrett Wilson, added 2026 picks, 3 1sts, 3 2nds and a third.
Have Henderson, Addison, Pearsall, McBride, Herbert.
Maybe trade Kittle when he’s healthy and Penix if he plays better. Thinking about Chase, he’s on the block. Not sure where to go from here. Thanks!!
UD username: Kristin
somber oxide
so I saw this video of David Montgomery saying no matter the situation he would try to score every time would you want a player like this on your fantasy 😂🔥🔥🔥
username: RICHMAJOR
hidden bane
Q.Johnston v Tre Henderson what do you guys think
Full PPR, 2 Flex
narrow valley
Nico for emeka and David Montgomery, 10 man pull ppr what do you guys think
unreal gyro
Chase trade? Chase panic?? Or am I just Chasing my tail!?
bleak river
How much is enough for Chase?
My team is 1-2. Looking to make the leap up.
I already got rejected in a Chase for Jacobs offer.
bleak river
Chase trade? Chase panic?? Or am I just Chasing my tail!?
I feel you!
I have a similar question
barren fjord
We start 3 WR’s in our .5 PPR league. Need helping choosing which 3 to start. I have Tae Adams, Tyreek, Egbuka, Pickens, and Keenan Allen. I’m worried about Quinyon Mitchell shadowing Egbuka, or is that an overreaction? Thanks
echo solar
Yes
daring bloom
What do we with Tony pollard after this week? Spears comes back and the offense is not holding up well. Do we hope and pray that Ward n the coaching staff get it right going forward or do we sell Tony now before spears comes in and takes work. Are we holding, selling or even buying Tony pollard/spears?
tame acorn
Full ppr league, got offered skattebo, olave and devonta smith for k9 and pickens. My receiver depth is a little spotty with shaheed and kirk as my wr4 and 5 and this is a 2 flex league. Seattle seems like they’re still going to heavily involve charbonnet for whatever reason so I do want to get off k9 but unsure if this is worth
green kiln
Thank you guys for everything you do!!
I traded away Nico Collins & Alvin Kamara for Jahmyr Gibbs. 12 man FULL PPR
also got offered BILL for Hunter Henry. Any feedback and help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you guys.
proud vigil
Which one of these RBs should be packaged with Metcalf to get WR help?
Mason, Judkins, or Chuba.
I still have Bucky.
Other teams struggling with RBs have some elite WR.
Would be shooting for the moon to start.
First hopes-Jefferson, Nico
Second hopes-AJ, Zay
Third hopes-Hill, Tee Higgins
12 team. PPR.
urban stream
Simple Josh and Hayden would you or would you not trade Jamar Chase ?
shut lintel
I’m in a bar and can’t hear the podcast. Did they answer saquon vs cmc?
urban roost
warped sequoia
wise zealot
slim sleet
