#Ms. Bumbleflower: Communal Brewing
1 messages Ā· Page 4 of 1
isnt [[delney streetwise lookout]] really good here?
Legendary Creature ā Human Scout
Creatures you control with power 2 or less can't be blocked by creatures with power 3 or greater.
If an ability of a creature you control with power 2 or less triggers, that ability triggers an additional time.
"It's not a matter of what I know. It's a matter of making it worth my while to tell you."
2/2
might be slightly non-booy tho
This is neat
2/2 lifelinker that can also shift the counters you put on it š
I'm not sure if it makes the cut as a 2 drop, buuuut it might be better than a 3 drop because you can "throw it out" and itll probably get value
Delney seems bad, but the other guy is interesting, yeah
[[Kianne, corrupted memory]] This card seems pretty rad
No card found for āKianne, corrupted memoryā
damn duskmourne is big on math
Math is scary
Same. I have to make 2 slots for that and the survivor now 
I should just ditch my alt wincons like you mentioned
Maybe all but the draw out ones
Getting more and more difficult to see packing a token theme in. Maybe I'll just make a [[Volo, Guide to Monsters]] deck
Legendary Creature ā Human Wizard
Whenever you cast a creature spell that doesn't share a creature type with a creature you control or a creature card in your graveyard, copy that spell. (A copy of a creature spell becomes a token.)
"The beholder told me I had a good eye for details. Who was I to argue?"
3/2
I would like to play vs that with my precon
vs what?
bumbleflower
?
or that card
Bumbleflower
shes pretty overwhelming to go against, just a heads up
K
these guys decks have lot of work put into em
Hmmm what do you mean by this?
shes very strong
at least your itterations
the base precon i dont think is very fine tuned
Base precons usually aren't. Since they hamfist too many themes in
I think it's comparable to the other BLB precons though
I think the [[Bello, bard of the brambles]] deck is the most powerful ootb and when upgraded
Legendary Creature ā Raccoon Bard
During your turn, each non-Equipment artifact and non-Aura enchantment you control with mana value 4 or greater is a 4/4 Elemental creature in addition to its other types and has indestructible, haste, and "Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, draw a card."
3/3
Made a couple changes to my list.
-Smuggler's Share -Valley Floodcaller
+Fathom Mage +Kami of Whispered Hopes
https://www.archidekt.com/decks/8612729/ms_b_stirs_the_pot
Ms. Bumbleflower - Commander / EDH deck
+1/+1 Counters ⢠Casual ⢠Aikido ⢠Politics
(1) Commander ⢠(1) +1/+1 Counters ⢠(15) Aikido/Politics Package ⢠(10) Draw ⢠(4) Enablers ⢠(16) Interaction ⢠(35) Land ⢠(2) Pillow ⢠(14) Ramp ⢠(2) Recursion
Aikido without Deflecting Palm? How is that possible?! I guess we'll find out...
Smugglers Share seemed alright on paper but it's been so mid and I barely get the treasures off of my playgroup.
Valley floodcaller I just don't have enough noncreatures to abuse it. Making my 2 cmc ramp instant speed is pretty nice but with that new duskmourne card coming out I don't see a place for Valley floodcaller
Leylines of anticipation when
I haven't played fathom mage yet, but it seems good, yeah
I should probably make room for leyline yeah
Someone wanna help me with a cut for leyline actually?
I love the ones that get counters on draw
Fan of [[chasm skulker]] staying in then?
Creature ā Squid Horror
Whenever you draw a card, put a +1/+1 counter on Chasm Skulker.
When Chasm Skulker dies, create X 1/1 blue Squid creature tokens with islandwalk, where X is the number of +1/+1 counters on Chasm Skulker. (They can't be blocked as long as defending player controls an Island.)
1/1
On a hike, but I'll take a look when I get back.
Alright thanks
Oof, it's pretty tough replacing things
How much use have you gotten out of Into the Flood Maw?
Haven't drawn it yet actually
I also ditched my mana dorks
How wise would it be to cut on interaction though 
Oh? How's that been working for you
It's like they never left
I think they are mostly useful with a commander you want to get out a turn early
Which I guess can be ms B sometimes, but that makes it more likely to be removed early
Mm. I do feel like my games go better when I cast her early typically
May want to keep them in then
Do you feel you need a lot of recursion?
I'd typically just run Skullwinder and ditch ewit
Oh nvm, thought that was the other ewit. I like evo wit for the theme.
Hmmm
I think Evo wit potentially grabbing skullwinder is a nice bonus. And Evo wit is cracked
Ahh
I mean... I guess all it leaves is dipping into one of my aikido cards š Which idk if I want to do
Not a fan, but flash enabler is a good tool
I won that āturnā
Yeah mockingbird is insane
Eh, I tried making her as high power as I can
I won next turn
Thoughts on [[morska]]? It's felt pretty alright so far.
Legendary Creature ā Vedalken Fish Detective
You have no maximum hand size.
At the beginning of your upkeep, investigate. (Create a Clue token. It's an artifact with "
, Sacrifice this artifact: Draw a card.")
Whenever you draw your second card each turn, put two +1/+1 counters on Morska, Undersea Sleuth.
2/3
If you want the counters, youād run squid man or the new flash dude. If you wanted draw, well, youāre in blue
Doing both is not helpful if itās a clue
Yeah, the clue is pretty useless. I've mostly been running it for max hand size redundancy, and it gets pretty big from counters.
I want my beatsticks to be more like John
I wish everyone could be more like John
š So true
if I got the precon and 50⬠how would I spend it
[[nadu winged wisdom]]
[[dreamtide whale]]
[[mangara the diplomat]]
[[jace beleren]]
[[evolution witness]]
[[gluntch the bestower]]
[[kami of whispered hopes]]
[[smothering tithe]] or [[pollywog prodigy]]
[[freestrider lookout]]
ok bot doesnt like that, but basically those cards or all of them if you can fit them in
cant remember if mangara is already in the precon
disclaimer: nadu may or may not be too strong depending on your goals.
well for now I don't have the money to upgrade it to a higher powerlevel
oh and [[shabraz]]
shabraz is huge
frequently gets to be above a 15/15 i nmy games
and that life gain is incredibly good if you arent in a combo meta
Iād also suggest, if some of the items above are pricey (smothering tithe etc), going for [[Psychic Possession]]
Enchantment ā Aura
Enchant opponent
Skip your draw step.
Whenever enchanted opponent draws a card, you may draw a card.
"You will do the thinking for the both of us!"
[[$psychic possession]]
$11.30 ⢠ā¬5.11 ⢠0.02 TIX
5.11 isnt too bad. Might pick up a copy myself
[[Heliod, the radiant dawn]] felt pretty good the other day
Legendary Enchantment Creature ā God
When Heliod, the Radiant Dawn enters, return target enchantment card that isn't a God from your graveyard to your hand.

: Transform Heliod, the Radiant Dawn. Activate only as a sorcery. (
can be paid with either
or 2 life.)
"Compleat the faith, compleat the god." āAjani Goldmane
4/4
Heliod, the Warped Eclipse
Legendary Enchantment Creature ā Phyrexian God
You may cast spells as though they had flash.
Spells you cast cost
less to cast for each card your opponents have drawn this turn.
"Compleat the god, compleat the plane." āAjani Goldmane
4/6
Yep. Card allows your storm turns to pop off that much harder
Now I just need to stop running colorless mana š
Ezpz, land ramp
Huh, never thought of that
Freestrider is Nadu #2
On the trail is mental
Honestly freestrider and on the trail together when Ms B is double triggering per turn leads to more mana than I actually need.
I find I can frequently make all my creatures indestructible and hexproof then cast a board wipe, just because I have the mana up and it'll trigger Ms. B twice.
smugglers share is a little more of a "budget" enchantment so expected
I think this card is insane if left alone, because it basically gives you a boardstate if its a destroy wip
smugglers is pretty bad tbh, ive been considering cutting it for about a week or two.
Was thinking about being a villain and just playing rhystic instead
yeah all these are real hits, probably apart from managara and jace beleren, I think you could do a bit better
im only running smugglers because I dont have a cut yet for it
its to help trigger the double draws more tbh
and they asked for pretty budget suggestions
[[jace beleren]]
Like $50 doesnt go too far tbh.
Legendary Planeswalker ā Teferi
Whenever you draw a card, put a loyalty counter on Teferi, Temporal Pilgrim.
0: Draw a card.
ā2: Create a 2/2 blue Spirit creature token with vigilance and "Whenever you draw a card, put a +1/+1 counter on this creature."
ā12: Target opponent chooses a permanent they control and returns it to its owner's hand. Then they shuffle each nonland permanent they control into its owner's library.
Loyalty: 4
is better than that one
ngl I gotta make sure I have a riskars expertise in my deck
my plan is basically do the rampys by drawing from other peoples draws
then do [[innkeepers talent]] stuffs with planewalkers
Enchantment ā Class
(Gain the next level as a sorcery to add its ability.)
At the beginning of combat on your turn, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.
: Level 2
Permanents you control with counters on them have ward
.

: Level 3
If you would put one or more counters on a permanent or player, put twice that many of each of those kinds of counters on that permanent or player instead.
[[nissa who shakes the world]]
Legendary Planeswalker ā Nissa
Whenever you tap a Forest for mana, add an additional
.
+1: Put three +1/+1 counters on up to one target noncreature land you control. Untap it. It becomes a 0/0 Elemental creature with vigilance and haste that's still a land.
ā8: You get an emblem with "Lands you control have indestructible." Search your library for any number of Forest cards, put them onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle.
Loyalty: 5
Yeah that tef is decent but the ultimate makes people pretty mad
im never gonna get there tho
and also if I do get there, thats a wincon, people cant complain
Coz I often use it to just reset someone and then leave them until they are a problem or the last one standing
Never gonna get there? I draw like 7-8 cards easily in a turn cycle usually. I can ult that tef every other turn
Then add in the proliferate stuff I play and yeah.
am I meant to be putting fetchlands into ms bumbleflowers
[[[Roaming throne]] naming bunny or citizen?
That's an additional bumble trigger
I think it's not needed
Roaming throne might be interesting anyways
You could also name Faerie or something. I've been thinking of running Faerie Artisans in my list and I also have Faerie Mastermind
Here's a thought someone has mentioned before though. Maybe running [[Delney]] and not buffing the bunny would get you more mileage than roaming throne?
Legendary Creature ā Human Scout
Creatures you control with power 2 or less can't be blocked by creatures with power 3 or greater.
If an ability of a creature you control with power 2 or less triggers, that ability triggers an additional time.
"It's not a matter of what I know. It's a matter of making it worth my while to tell you."
2/2
My deck runs a ton of triggered abilities.
I may try slotting in a package of Delney, Octomancer, Bramble Sovereign, Faerie Artisans, See Double, & Fractured Identity for some token shenanigans.
yeah I mentioned it but I dont think its worth it
you want 4-6 creatures at any given point
and you want most of them buffed
so having something that limits buffs to get the bonus is bad really
Yeah for the beatdown plan for sure. But something cool you could also do is cast a bunch of instant spells with Delney and an unbuffed bunny while holding priority and I believe you double up on all of them and can suddenly make the bunny huge
I'll experiment with Delney and get back to yall it might be sweet
Notable things Delney currently doubles in my list:
Unbuffed Ms. B triggers
Selfless Squire's first instance of +1/+1 counters
The Second Doctor
Faerie Mastermind
Fathom Mage's first 2 draw triggers
Generous Patron
Ledger Shredder
Loran
Unbuffed John Benton (also makes him unblockable)
Kros Upkeep Trigger
Witch Enchanter
Kinda sold on it tbh even without any further adds lol
They would essentially let me buff up my opponents creatures for the aikido gameplan even harder. I think I'll also run Storm Seeker too š
Two copies of the precon. Then upgrade one with cards you have on hand.
lol
LGS didn't have Delney š¬
https://www.archidekt.com/decks/9155176/ms_b_stirs_the_pot_token_package_variant
The shenanigans probably take too much to get going but I'd love to make it work somehow
Yeah, the tokens probably aren't consistent enough for the effort they take. I'm just going to make a volo deck with that same package instead. Fractured Identity is just good enough to run without the package imo.
Yeah, kind of what I'm thinking. Though I think individual pieces of them on their own are actually quite good š¤
I'm really sacrificing a couple of fogs and Willbreaker
Those fogs seem real important since it's basically a turbofog deck lol
Until you're able to kill with the reflecting fog or big bumble
Oh, I added a few cards from your list since our last discussion. Looking forward to playing with them 
Sweet, which ones?
Meh... I usually only cast one or two. Never even casted Arachnogenesis yet. The goad stuff helps a lot
Like Selfless Squire alone has won me a game
Comeuppance, Selfish Squire, bloodthirsty blade, redemption arc
And I don't recall if you use these, but we were chatting about oversimplify, rewind, unwind
Oh I see you use unwind
One thing I've been thinking about is running an infect package and [[radstorm]]
Probably would attract too much hate though
Still might slip Oversimplify in at some point
It seems so good when I have maze of ith and Socrates
Socrates one of my favorite cards tbh
Just saw [[Stormseeker]] in your deck
Sigh, looks like I have to get another card
I sure love green Sudden Impact
So yeah my best friend has a Ms. Bumbleflower deck and it's extremely formidable X3
Ah dangit he hasn't updated it yet.
But yeah it's strong and the Commander is a really champion in her own right.
Believe me when we say this one, we know.
My deck is surprisingly strong and I donāt even have all the really good cards in it. I went a similar theme to Umaru with planeswalkers (as I donāt have anywhere else to play them) and PWs in edh are shocking. If I wanted to optimise those would be the first to go. But with that said, using PW as my theme and my deck still feels strong should tell you everything you need to know.
im going to be updating mine soon, but need to work out how im cutting by looking at other planeswalker decks
What are your planeswalker versions?
I feel like you need some more interaction in that
bunny can't go draw stuff if bunny is dead to someone else's board state though lol
It's ultimately up to you and if your playgroup is generally this low on interaction it's most likely fine, but if you wanted to cut some cards you have a couple cards that don't synergize with your planesewalkers/counters theme you have going on
yeah she doesn't make too much sense here but I also understand the urge to just jam every Planeswalker you have
Iām guessing itās alandra, johreal, smugglers share, illusionist gambit,
I knew I needed more interaction and she does destroy artifact or enchant and also acts as a damage effect for lategame so thought sheād be ok
alandra and jolrael are definitely two that pop out right away
I cut jolrael out of my deck but I leaned heavier into a grouphug theme
I was considering minn as an option to replace johreal but not sure
illusionists Gambit I think actually is good here because often I see counters decks just need one more turn and it buys you exactly that much time
š
Iām adding in the teferis I wanna add
I have him in my list of considering cards, but I tried to keep the upgrades to mostly cards I had already
my magic collection grows exponentially
Thereās also the issue of ramp
I donāt think I got enough
And thought vessel could be a ramp spell instead for safer ramp package
I think you have enough
If my goal is innkeepers talent into planeswalker ultimates, is that something I should be running idyllic tutor for? Or maybe an academy rector?
You could
If you want to up the consistency add some more draw and a couple tutors
My other issue is if tutoring for a 2 cmc enchantment might not be worth
But I have to consider that that enchantment gives ward 1 to everything with counters for 3 cmc
I mean surely you have other hits for them right
You don't necessarily need to tutor for it if you dont need it

+1 more John
I'd ditch your 3 mana ramp for 2 mana ramp yoo
If the plan is to ramp on turn 2, then play bumble on 3
Mana dorks also don't really make sense there either
I saw his EA Surge Foil in a card-store and read his effect and thought how hilarious he would be in the deck, so I picked him up, and I'm never not happy to play him. Always looking at my opponents and asking them "You wanna draw some cards?"
I dont own one, so I dont play one.
gives me serious Xyris vibes though
Anyone tried out [[Teferi Who Slows]]?
Legendary Planeswalker ā Teferi
+1: Choose up to one target artifact, up to one target creature, and up to one target land. Untap the chosen permanents you control. Tap the chosen permanents you don't control. You gain 2 life.
ā2: Look at the top three cards of your library. Put one of them into your hand and the rest on the bottom of your library in any order.
ā7: You get an emblem with "Untap all permanents you control during each opponent's untap step" and "You draw a card during each opponent's draw step."
Loyalty: 4
seems like a 4 mana do not a whole lot. You got many activated abilities you like to use to make the emblem worth it?
coz otherwise there are better walkers to be using for sure
I think the tamiyo for 4 mana is better
would really depend on what kind of artifacts/lands you are running
I can see why it could be a good
Fair, it's only the big mana guys on activated ability duty. And I'm already playing Seedborn Muse as a better impression of the ult. Well, not better necessarily, but less work
cant look at a card and say you get to ult it sadly š
so ama gonna review my card list and see how many catagories it fits in out of:
+1 counters
draw
value
ramp
as well as looking at the CMC value of each, aiming for around 3-5 cmc most
If you are playing PWs you should be proliferating and ulting at least one PW in the games duration
Otherwise just play something that gives you that effect (seedborn) without hoops to jump through
still think I should put this in
You planning to do anything with the illusions? Coz this is just a token generator and thats it.
Like you playing a phyrexian altar or anything? Coz they are only X/1 tokens meaning they get blocked by any random junk.
its more of the effect of putting stuff into play
it gets around counterspells that way too
so you're paying 3 mana in the hopes that someone just lets you amass an army and put stuff into play?
Like I play minn a lot, unless you are actively using the tokens to do something else. its a bit of a do nothing card
if you have some way of utilising them and it synergises, go for it, but dont just blindly hope it'll work out
id argue [[jolrael mwonvuli recluse]] is better
Legendary Creature ā Human Druid
Whenever you draw your second card each turn, create a 2/2 green Cat creature token.


: Until end of turn, creatures you control have base power and toughness X/X, where X is the number of cards in your hand.
"Humans bring nothing but suffering and deceit. They are not welcome in my forest."
1/2
less mana, guaranteed 2/2s and later on you get a semi overrun effect
Nope they are illusions
"Whenever you draw your second card each turn, create a 1/1 blue Illusion creature token with "This creature gets +1/+0 for each other Illusion you control." "
oh right
how do you feel like harrow and harrow clones in the deck
are they good to get lands out of the deck?
I am biased, I love harrow effects
since if we are already on evolution witness to recurr things, it can be ramp
its also instant speed
like I could take out cultivate and kodamas and insta swap it for both harrows
[[entish restoration]] isnt bad either
Instant
Sacrifice a land. Search your library for up to two basic land cards, put them onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle. If you control a creature with power 4 or greater, instead search your library for up to three basic land cards, put them onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle.
"Welcome to the Treegarth of Orthanc!"
we can get to 4 power pretty quick
Oh i thought you meant [[roiling regrowth]]
or [[springbloom druid]]
not with [[evolution witness]]
Creature ā Elf Shaman Mutant

: Adapt 2. (If this creature has no +1/+1 counters on it, put two +1/+1 counters on it.)
Whenever one or more +1/+1 counters are put on Evolution Witness, return target permanent card from your graveyard to your hand.
She remembers every breakthrough, from the gene's mutation to the new life's propagation.
2/1
all of these are on theme with scaling with counters, would be a big sad to lose one
[[narsets reversal?]]
I love narsets as a big gotcha card
does it copy overloaded rft?
someone casts [[time stretch]] yeah try again man
yup
oki me add
itcopies the spell on the stack
I personally like it because its like: "no you cant have that spell, but you can potentially have 2 others and I get to replace my card I used"
it plays into the politics of commander well imo
but it would be way better as a counterspell/mana drain
There is something to be said about token gen to use as fodder if you're going against go wide. Go wide would be tough for my deck to deal with for example, and I definitely see merit to running Jolarel or minn
Super good if you're running the parasitic draw engines (which u should be imo)
They either elect to not even draw or you go up cards off it lol
I think jolrael is better, the built in overrun with it also being 2MV vs 3MV
you can also use it defensively to block peoples stuff and they'll be shocked that its not a sorcery speed only thing
Not sure. I'm not gonna rely on my opponents being dumb, they're both generally removal targets but one illusion dying at least ramps you if you have a land in hand right
Yeah
Though my list has operated just fine without them I'll note. I still considered them
At least for me, jol rael has never survived to use the overrun and has never felt particularly good to play
Thatās great it was removal bait.
Perhaps, she's also only good after you've gotten your engine online
So like half of the cards were playing then?
Thing is though the engine is so easy to get online
Itās just ms b and a payoff card with a way to cantrip a little
I guess then why not play Minn if you're gonna play one of the two? If they're both removal bait and you're almost never going to be able to activate the overrun, Minn's bodies let you rebuild and make really favorable blocks/attacks as well. Plus board wipe security if it's not an exile wipe
yeah I think for this exact reason, alandra is bad
if your removal bait costs 4 mana, thats significant, when it could be 2 or 3 mana instead for the same "threat" to other players
alandra has always felt bad to draw because it puts a target on my back I think
when ive played it
people scared
[[alandra]]
Legendary Creature ā Merfolk Wizard
Whenever you draw your second card each turn, create a 2/2 blue Drake creature token with flying.
Whenever you draw your fifth card each turn, Alandra, Sky Dreamer and Drakes you control each get +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the number of cards in your hand.
2/4
Thinking I'd rather rogues passage a single creature than try to overrun
Can't wait for [[kianne, corrupted memory]]
I dont think its worthwhile, but if you have untap effects, it probably is
Yeah if you can save your spells for other players turns so you can proc her second trigger per turn, youāll be extremely far ahead by the end of that
Iāve casted a [[flawless maneuver]] for no reason other than to trigger Bumbleflower a second time many a time
I think Kianne is FANTASTIC personally
Definitely better than draw squid
And yes, I call it draw squid because I can never remember itās damn name for some reason
It's Chasm Skulker!
lmfao that is so good
oki doki
so
I made v2
please critquey

I wouldn't really run lotus petal unless you are :b
Yea if you're using it for that I'd just run a cantrip or Shrieking Drake/Whitemane Lion I think
Thoughts on running [[chromatic lantern]] or the like?
I haven't yet
oki doki
I have gone through the decklist and tagged everything
I have:
25 +1 counters cards
11 planeswalker suite
19 ramp
16 interaction
17 draw faciliation
12 protection
with a total of 36 lands but no MDFCs (yet)
one thing im wondering about is what kind of lands are the best ones to actually use
Like in general or the utility lands?
I certainly don't go under 36 in any of my decks. I have 37 in my Ms. B list including MDFCs and I like running the MH3 MDFCs a ton
MDFCs are great, yeah
I also really like bouncelands, especially with snap, unwind, rewind, etc.
[[maze of ith]] has become my favorite land too
this seems omega cringe
but
:))))
I think there is only about 10 decks on EDHrec that are similar to my deck š
also potential techg
[[unnatural restro]]
No card found for āunnatural restroā
[[unnatural rest]]
Sorcery
Return target permanent card from your graveyard to your hand. Proliferate. (Choose any number of permanents and/or players, then give each another counter of each kind already there.)
"If you don't reassemble me immediately, the Mother of Machines will notice my absence, and this entire layer will face her wrath!"
WELP
my sideboard has 37 cards I'm thinking could fit into the deck
fuck my life

Light work I have two dragonshield boxes full of options š
I just accept I'll always have too many ideas and slot cards in from time to time
Just need to separate them into packages and replace packages when you get bored of one
True
That's pretty interesting. Going an infect route might be cool.
I'd add in [[Radstorm]]
As a regrowth effect that also proliferates I think is useful
This might be very very good in planeswalers
Oh yeah forgot you can proliferate planeswalkers
Not that literally anyone cares, but you could proliferate someone's Battle too kek
Reason I think this is good is because ms b makes your attacking creature evasive and this buffs everything even more
Maybe as an alternative to something pricey like vornivex
This walker allows you to recast cantrips
The perch protection gift a turn has been surprisingly good
Yeah, I really like it too
Yeah Iāve only just caught up on this
I really want a Spanish ms bumbleflower now
Thatās hilarious
Saaaaame
@pastel agate how does your deck come to do the actual win?
I think ill use mutational advantage s a budget heroic intervention for now
considering some proliferate support in the spell section
in answer the chromatic lanturn question, i think youd run [[wrenn realmbreaker]] before that
Legendary Planeswalker ā Wrenn
Lands you control have "
: Add one mana of any color."
+1: Up to one target land you control becomes a 3/3 Elemental creature with vigilance, hexproof, and haste until your next turn. It's still a land.
ā2: Mill three cards. You may put a permanent card from among the milled cards into your hand.
ā7: You get an emblem with "You may play lands and cast permanent spells from your graveyard."
Loyalty: 4
my current deck doesnt have room for lotus petal, so taking it out the draft
replacing it with entish restoration
i run enough fetch effects to make use out of evoution witness, and entish is instant so good for other peoples turns
im at the stage of "do I cut a land from 36" or "do I cut a creature for a spell"
how good is austere command compared to damning verdict?
I guess theres the angle of austere commander + heroic intervention-like, is 8 mana wipe the board
getting a sea gate restoration, so swapping our wizard class and an island for damning verdict
thats 9 cuts/swaps
v3 of the deck after multiple run throughs of upgrades im willing to put in
current potential further change is swapping [[chasm shulker]] for [[generous patron]] because the floor is so much better with patron and has bonuses with ms b + proliferate strategy
Creature ā Squid Horror
Whenever you draw a card, put a +1/+1 counter on Chasm Skulker.
When Chasm Skulker dies, create X 1/1 blue Squid creature tokens with islandwalk, where X is the number of +1/+1 counters on Chasm Skulker. (They can't be blocked as long as defending player controls an Island.)
1/1
Generous patron is interesting with kros too
ive been on patron for years but only got one copy and its in obuun right now, but im dismantleing it now
I think im swapping it
patron is also a 1/4 opposed to 1/1 so I think that is also massive
Chasm and generous Patron do serve totally different purposes
im more about setting up and then randomly doing the thing at some point
so I think patron is far less threatening for that purpose
are you on both?
No, just Patron. However my list isn't entirely conventional as I'm trying to completely minimize how threatening I am on board for most of the game.
I don't have much counter synergies and my Bumbleflower counters often go on opponents creatures
My list aims to win the game through things like [[Reins of power]] and [[willbreaker]]
Storm into a voltron finish, grinding with Nadu and eventually taking a few extra turns and killing that way
has you looked at my updated decky yet

I have not, but remind me in a couple hours and Iāll be more than happy to taoe a look
You think throwing consecrated sphinx into a modified precon is still about precon level?
If you draw it itās a pretty big power spike
ooh [[glen elendra archmage]] seems absurd in bumbleflower.
Yeah I added it, but haven't seen it yet
Straight fucking devious yes
not sure if its a consideration, but this is something I have played before to good effect
this guy is great, or he used to be
probably in a similar boat to skyshroud claim, 4 mana fetch two
Thing is though, do we need ramp from turn 4 onwards?
Like I have no doubt that thing goes crazy with Ms. B and a Kami of whispered hopes
but how do we kill it ourselves to cash in on the ramp and do we need that?
And how many basics are you running where you'll get full value out of it
Iām running like 13 basics I think
So I could definitely get the value out of it. But I donāt feel that I need to play it.
Ah, that is a lot of basics
Ah, that's fair
narset parter of veils just seems mean here
[[narset, parter of veils]]
Oh, meh. You kinda want your opponents to draw cards though
it would be good in a group hug shell
I think for other builds it puts a target on your back more than you want
Most of my list is based on making people draw and then I draw for theirs
You would want to benefit off of your group hug cards with these kinds of effects
So narset would negatively impact me.
^^ parasitic card draw is the name of the game
you want narset when youre being super fun and are playing [[wheel of fortune]] and co.
Me myself and I. I'm the whole family. š¤£
[[me the immortal]]
An interesting choice for wheels but i wont knock it.
Legendary Creature ā Human Rogue
At the beginning of combat on your turn, put your choice of a +1/+1, first strike, vigilance, or menace counter on Me, the Immortal.
Counters remain on Me as it moves to any zone other than a player's hand or library.
You may cast Me from your graveyard by discarding two cards in addition to paying its other costs.
3/3
Power creeping squee the immortal smh
I really want Sra. Margarita š
just played my new deck online
I had generous patron and the whale
played shabaz, shabaz almost saved me
but I drew like 12 cards
and died

[[shabaz]]
No card found for āshabazā
[[Shabraz the skyshark]] probably
I think im sold on him now
anyone found lifetotals to be a problem, and if so, what other ways to get it back again have you looked at?
I haven't really found life to be a problem. (Other than dying I guess). He seems a little spendy for the counters though.
Shabraz is crazy good
It becomes absolutely massive
Either they have to remove it or they just die
sadly this game we had three decks based on combat
so no counterspells would work
I think riskhars expertise has a good home here
it makes any 5 drop a +4-8 draw spell
Yeah, at leasst it has flying.
So some sort of built in evasion
Not having trample really sucks if you don't find rogue's passage though
"but I drew loads of cards and died" could be the tagline for Ms B. No shade, I absolutely love it XD
so real
When you only get through half your deck 
Is this the mythical "doing the thing" people talk about?
Iāve been brewing a 7ish list thatās more of a midrange deck that keeps the group hug theme. It has a solid game plan (1/1 counters with doublers for finishers) while still keeping the essence of a group hug deck, you just benefit more than the other people in the pod. I only tested one game with pretty good results lemmie know what you think.
A weakness that keeps it from being stronger is the reliance on bumble for generating counters, theirs a few ways besides it but if they remove bumble then your plan kinda crumbles. Luckily you have a ton of access to a lot of mana while also keeping the theme of 1/1 counters
My deck is also a 7 š
What kinda brew did you cook up?
Oh I like that list
Thank you! Something I noticed in a lot of bumble decks is the inability to actually finish out/win games
I tried to solve this by including a handful of token doublers that can make a few bumble triggers into a critical mass midgame and actually kill people but without a degenerate way
Theirs a few infinites mostly caused by shrieking drake
You can cut the card but if I do notice I have an infinite I just wonāt play it out because I think that goes against the spirit of the deck
Court of Garenbrig seems good
Yeah, itās super good plus I love the monarch bc it encourages interactive games
And concord turns on all your mana dorks when you play it
While also being in the theme of group hug
Glunch is one of the only other reoccurring source of 1/1 counters and has been performing super good! People also tend to not remove him because of the group hug aspect
This deck really exploits using the group hug aspect as a way to politick to get an advantage that accumulates by turn 5-6 into oneshotting someone
Which is always hilarious
In theory she seems super good but it was a more recent add I havenāt tested, huge mana, draw, everything bumble kinda wants
I dunno if I need more ramp in mine
but also the game I tested, I did ramp because of evolution witness.. so im not sure
I notice your list does not have evolution witness despite having fetchlands
I had just added them to the deck to help fix the mana a bit, and was considering it
But Iām not sure if this would swing the deck into a higher power level if I included grave recursion at that level
Something I was considering because I donāt want it to be higher than a 7
I prefer more casual games because theyāre more interesting
Evo witness won't push ur deck much higher. Its just nice to have
Yeah I just added it, cut shrieking drake
I was really thinking about cutting it for a while bc of its smothering tithe interaction

If you guys have suggestions for mana sinks Iāve been thinking about adding one or two
Since the deck late game generates so much mana
Iāve been considering akromas memorial
sea gate restrotation
Doppelgang
I also run rishkars expertise because it fits my gameplan
doppelgang is probably very good, but its so much mana and I just dont think my tables would let me get that much mana on board without killing me
I think I'd run spark double over it in my list, due to being able to copy legends and walkers
I think avenger of zendikar fits my deck the most
Doppelgang just sounds like fun
I find that non targeted group hug is usually a downside in the deck. Group hug you can 100% control is an extremely powerful tool.
Welcome to the cabal of bnuuy enjoyers!
[[faerie mastermind]]
yeah I was also gonig to suggst that
Also based Cavetown enjoyer
Iām running it already
I donāt like massive draw bc we have massive draw built in
A mana sink for my deck needs to end the game
Which avenger accomplishes
True
if you draw lots and ramp a lot
if you boardwipe and protect yourself and protect the spells, you win, or should win
Itās also very efficient to make yourself scary, someone board wipes and you protect from it
It rockets you ahead
Iāve been finding jace/labman more and more necessary for the deck, just because of how quickly you fly through the deck
if I ever pop off with planeswalkers I think I should win
the theory is there
the emblems from each of them are crazy enough
Is this based off the precon or from scratch?
Boy, drawing out your deck feels so good. My friend started running orcish bowmasters and notion thief though. 
And if you want to do specifically counters, thereās a TON of good options
[[luminarch aspirant]] effects are peak
From scratch
Gotcha. Have you considered [[communal brewing]]?
Enchantment
When Communal Brewing enters, any number of target opponents each draw a card. Put an ingredient counter on Communal Brewing, then put an ingredient counter on it for each card drawn this way.
Whenever you cast a creature spell, that creature enters with X additional +1/+1 counters on it, where X is the number of ingredient counters on Communal Brewing.
Oh Iām aware, I left the counter generation sparse as a way to balance the deck and force you to rely on bumble; which puts a target on the back of bumble rather than being a pure 1/1 deck
Thatās why the density of cheap cards in my list
Youāre gameplan is to double the bumble counters rather than rely on other sources or countrrs
3* if you are in a 4 player game
It enters with one already
Yeah kinda, the gameplan is to make a few giant creatures
And most of the small creatures benefit from having counters on them
Thatās mostly what my list does. Storms off and makes bunny huge
https://www.moxfield.com/decks/B8zzpDQtNkGBPXpSWrXH8w
Iām trying to skyrocket the power on this one so itās pricy
But eventually I do want to go more into the 1/1 counters route with a new brew
I just added a finale + avenger package in my list as a lategame finisher

Just looking for a cut
I just added it, and yeah itās mostly for the mana
So I havenāt tested it in a live game
Vorel seems pretty slow, howās it done for you?
Heās amazing, you can combo kill people out of nowhere with the concord
True
My list: very much still a WIP, based on the precon. https://archidekt.com/decks/8498400/bumbleflower
You mainly only drop him if you have protection or concord bc heās taking someone out if he taps
You only draw from your opponents on their turn
Itās not
Itās really fun tho
I love marrying ppl
It would be a prime candidate for cuts, but the meme factor is a thing
Oh it's during their turn. Oops
Yes
Yup, thatās why itās not great
Itās a 100% mainstay
It's okay. It's good with my forced fruition.
Bc of the memes
I'm playing a mill plan
As funny as it is Iām not certainLong Riverās Pull is any good
If you notice a theme
A lot of my deck runs suboptimal cards on purpose
Just for the funny
Yes I could add a mana drain
But I want long rivers pull
Could just do a regular olā counterspell
It can trigger second card draw a turn effects like trouble in pairs or smuggler's though
I could cut wedding ring but I want to ask people to marry me š„ŗ
I played Ondu Inversion, and my ex husband started murdering me because of it though
Oh fuck I forgot to add trouble in pairs
How relevant is concordant crossroads?
Very with my build
Like haste could be good but I donāt think itās that relevant
White card draw is seriously insane
Man, this is the problem with bumbleflower
Itās a group hug thing + it makes my dorks curve even faster
Too many cards work really well with her

There is a lot of overlap with some of the best cards in her decks
My plan is to double counters from bumble and make a few creatures big
Surprised at no [[forgotten ancient]] then
Like I said I purposefully limited the amount of token generation
To balance the deck and keep the theme
My deck isnāt about giving a ton of creatures 1/1 counters from different sources, itās about using bumble to give 1/1 counters and doubling them
I think this puts too much of a target on your back
add in a +1 counters subtheme and you are going to die 100%
that mana could be spent double spelling or on a protection spell that they wont see
I think its a great card, but for Ms B, I think you gotta lie a little low
Last game I played, I had a 21/21 chasm skulker, and no evasion for it. It was real sads
So I don't like I like those type of passive +1s without trample
Thatās why [[shabraz]] the goat
I think you really want a low curve with bumble
I think anything higher than 3 is really hard to spend
Thatās been my experience
Agreed
I only have 12 cards with a cmc higher than 4
That's where I'm at, tough to tap out for something like that lol
Preferably you want to be playing many things on your opponents' turns. So hyped for that new flash enabler.
Heliod has felt so good to me already
High curve just needs more ramp to supplement.
My curve is higher in my deck but Iām consistently double spelling because you get to ~ten mana ASAP
Cut some cards, tamiyo and selfless squire was dead more often than it was alive
We REALLY donāt like 4 mana cmc unless we can and want to drop it after bumble
And tami tapping effect felt mediocre a lot of the time where Iād rather just a cheaper removal spell
Selfless squire maybe saved me once out of 5 games and felt super low impact
Hard bristle bandit is super good
Incubation Druid super good
Fanatic of Rhonas seems good in theory but often was too slow, and 4 green mana felt hard to spend a lot of the time
Still on the fence about out selv but sheās more of a group hug aspect anyway
Avenger of zendikar is so satisfying
ngl im considering cutting selvela
Also walking ballista has felt sooooo good
Yeah sheās a fine cut
I wanted to in general keep the theme of group hug
So I like effects that benefit everyone
I think cutting it for harrow would be a thing
Do you want to be pinging though?
If you want ramp deep gnome is good
It can be super beneficial playing vs burn
Or any aggressive strategy
To keep them in check
It being an instant ping can help vs black creatures to kill them before sac effects
- since Iām running doublers I can boardwipe
Fair. It kills Norin too. 
And planeswalkers lol
It's only creature or player though eh?
Yeah, how many planeswalkers do you need to worry about?
Only time I've seen a planeswalker ultimate is with doubling season. (Though I've had my Koth ultimate before.)
I'm also very new though
Much better more towards a lower end casual meta do that's understandable
I run a little goad package to provoke people and I focus on putting counters on other people's creatures like a Kros deck
*"creature or player" is updated to "any target" in (almost?) all cases, Ballista can hit PWs
[[walking ballista]]
Appears so
Yeah, I can see it. Itās a little slow for the gameplan of my deck and the playgroups Iām in with itās power level
Thatās what I thought
Updated list
I was proud of the title š»
+2 points for the alliteration
I was trying to figure out how to make a primer but Iām a dumb baby
My list feels pretty weak in 8 environments but it can survive
Itās a strong 7 for sure
Like every other deck, yeah
I have my old bumble list which was just an upgraded precon
It was def a 6
It didnāt have a real plan or way to win
It kinda just gave everyone cards and maybe beat someone to death if they took 3 hits
To survive at 8 better prob need Grand Abolisher/Kutzil to protect your storming off
I don't think numerical scoring makes much sense to me. But also having no way to win wouldn't sound like a 6 at all, but lower.
That would be full on battle cruiser :b which the precon unupgraded is probably better than battlecruiser
I at first theorycrafted a 8 list. You can actually do a fair bit of infinites with fast mana and tutors since bumble lets you draw the card from tutors, but combo wins donāt really feel that good for me
If you focus the deck on abusing the draw 2 for searching for combo pieces and play a control style with the free mana spells itās quite easy to make a 8 power bumble deck but theyāre never that fun
Yeah
In those kind of environments Iād rather play stuff like chatterfang or xyris
He's one of my favorite things to cast in Bumbleflower
Popping him down then a couple turns later equipping him with Sword of War and peace was hilariously effective
He does what I āwantā selv to do
Added benefit of being more targeted hug than group
I think
Shadowspear is better than war and peace
But yes it seems fun
3 cmc is rly high
Yeah John Benton is always my favorite card whenever I see him
Definitely
I want to make a commander version of him sometime too
Also
I also really like Socrates, but it's not as good

You could acc deck someone out
Add in psychic possession too. So you draw 30
I donāt remember if I cut windfall or not
[[windfall]]
Ya I need to add it back
I should add that too
Itās rly fun
milling out might actually be a plan then
I mean
Itās a fringe option lol
Itās not the goal of the deck
But I like the Jank combo potential
Why would you not?!
Since i run [[fruitful fruition]] with [[fractured identity]] anyways
*pulls out [[storm seeker]]
Sorry, [[forced fruition]]
Wasnāt storm seeker in the precon
No
I need to find something to cut for windfall
OOH
I need windfall now too
I love that card so much, because it's so weird that it's green
YAeah definitely seems like a color break
Seeing as it's just [[Sudden Impact]]
I cut sink into stupor
That's the bounce eh?
Ya 3 mana bounce
It was mainly to get to 34 lands
People in this server have so few lands in their decks
I run a ton of dorks
To compensate
I wouldnāt ever go under 33 in bimble
But I liked 34
Iāll test it out
I added an extra ram
In hard bristle
So it should be comparable
I count bolt mdfc lands as one full
Same
Since my curve is so low I can get away with 4-5 lands and dorks
Idk if bala ged is a better cut over sink into stupor
Probably
I like to have some recursion
I have finale, the counter dude that recovers and noxious
And bala ged
Brainstorm noxious brainstorm is still one of my favorite plays
Bumble and mimeo are my fav decks rn
And xyris when I wanna play high power
[[mimeo]]
Multiple cards match āmimeoā, can you be more specific?
I never go below 34, but i stay at 36 for bumble
[[the mimeoplasm]]
probably
My curve for bumble is so low I can get away with it
Ya thatās it
Fair
Like I have 12 cards above 4 cmc
There was this guy chatting yesterday with like 26 in his deck 
why is there not a thread for all the bloomburrow commanders
This is it?
this is for bumble specificly
Thatās wild
wdym all the bumbleflower commanders then?
The other ones arenāt cute
bloomburrow
Oh, I can't read
zinnia makes babies
Which alwasy bites me in MTG
babies are cute
If you make them, that means you can sac them though Mia
And idek the other one
Wait youāre so right
[[bello bard of brambles]]
Legendary Creature ā Raccoon Bard
During your turn, each non-Equipment artifact and non-Aura enchantment you control with mana value 4 or greater is a 4/4 Elemental creature in addition to its other types and has indestructible, haste, and "Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, draw a card."
3/3
the funny racoon
Bello is very strong
stronk
My group got all 4 precons and played them together
One could say he's the thickest in the thicket
I only own bumble
My Walmart has all three
Besides haz
Bc hazel is 120$
For whatever reason
I rly wanted hazel
if i could get all of them i would
And settled on bumble
The new commander decks look so mid
Miracle worker is the only one thatās kinda cool
- simic land deck number 59
The simic alt commander is great in bumble though
- rakdos everybody hate you deck
[[kianne, corrupted memory]]

None of my creatures benefit from flash
Besides bumble procs
It makes me think about when to give it counters
And I hate cards that make me think
is this the biggest thread yet
No, but we're getting close
https://discord.com/channels/675113113934364683/1092547804079063191 this one has around 1000 more messages
then there is general deckbuilding one with 9000
Everyone loves bunnies 
I love Senorita Margarita
Calm down shadow
This is a community created thing, a bunch of us were brewing bumbleflower so we did a group thread
Yeah Iāve been around for a hot minute
in the future i might potentially get this precon
I think alt art bumble being over 300$ is a crime
The precon is rly easily tuned out of the box
Yes. Not to mention the artist isnāt selling their Proofs, which wouldāve been a far cheaper option
Even if they do end up selling them itāll likely be only within Japan
I don't care about alt art bubmle, I'm just looking for a spanish bumble now
I bought a proxy one
Fair
not getting this one at least until my bello precon comes in the mail
Fuck wotc thinking imma spend over 20$ on one piece of cardboard
it was a birthday gift and my birthday was the first of this month
Happy birthday
STILL HAS NOT ARRIVED
Ya happy late bday
why does mail take such a long time to arrive
I spent 200$ upgrading my baylen deck, ordering proxies and buying a proxy version of my mimeo deck to test with my friends
baylen looks fun
He is
personally im brewing [[kitsa otterball elite]]
Legendary Creature ā Otter Wizard
Vigilance
Prowess (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, this creature gets +1/+1 until end of turn.)
: Draw a card, then discard a card.
,
: Copy target instant or sorcery spell you control. You may choose new targets for the copy. Activate only if Kitsa's power is 3 or greater.
1/3
i pulled the showcase one
Sick
I got hyped for the mimeo secret lair and spent a week brewing a list
Itās coming in before Halloween too
i dont think its necesarily gonna be a storm deck but just coppying big spells and winning
: Target Human gains flying until end of turn.


