Make it so you should go through a difficult quest to get your slayer mark
For example:
10 demon kills(players)
Boss
ect.
Now for the red blades you can make it so u can obtain it after ur slayer mark and to obtain it you should have to kill like 200 demons or something like that
#Slayer Marks & red blades
tiny igloo
tiny igloo
Slayer Marks & red blades
stone island
Bandit beating suggestion 
wooden cove
Slayer mark will be cosmetic only
stone island
Slayer mark will be cosmetic only
Fr?
wooden cove
Yep
stone island
I didn’t know that wow 🤩
wooden cove
tiny igloo
Bandit beating suggestion <:Hollow:663380689290264595>
Bro it's not like progression bandit beating it's a quest chill
stone island
Bro it's not like progression bandit beating it's a quest chill
Kill 10 demons kill 200 demons
Sounds bandit beat to me
tiny igloo
It's both pvp and pve quest
tiny igloo
No💀
tiny igloo
Blox fruit bandit beat is for lvl
stone island
Blox fruit bandit beat is for lvl
Bandit beat for money so you can buy the skills
It’s literally how you get haki in that game buddy
tiny igloo
No
stone island
And how you get fruits
tiny igloo
I mean I'm max lvl
stone island
Ever heard of a trainer?
tiny igloo
It's more of a type soul
stone island
Let me speak
I asked you proof twice and you have none
tiny igloo
Quest
stone island
It's more of a type soul
Trash bandit beat pvp sweat
tiny igloo
Bro what do u even what in a game
lusty plank
extreme.nick You’ve Reached Level 1
stone island
Just go play deepwoken even though deepwoken isn’t even a bandit beater
stone island
Bro what do u even what in a game
I had a stroke reading that
stone island
Imagine sitting there and killing 200 of something for a move
That’s literal bandit beating
tiny igloo
It's more of like a buff
stone island
I’d rather fight a boss for it tbh
tiny igloo
I said and boss
stone island
It's more of like a buff
Doesn’t matter what you get and slayer mark is cosmetic
stone island
I said and boss
No you didn’t
tiny igloo
Idk it's just a suggestion
tiny igloo
Red blade is also a buff
stone island
Nobody wants to kill 200 demons
tiny igloo
It's easy after u max out
stone island
Red blade is also a buff
Don’t care about what red blade is I’m saying it’s a bandit beater
stone island
It's easy after u max out
You haven’t even played the game yet
What if npc spawns are quest based
tiny igloo
Ik I'm just saying normal demons should be easy kills
stone island
Or you have to search for them
stone island
Ik I'm just saying normal demons should be easy kills
That’s too easy then
Horrible game design
tiny igloo
Then no problem
stone island
A new player could do that
tiny igloo
It would be for max players
stone island
It would be for max players
Trash
tiny igloo
It wouldn't make sense
stone island
There is no point in getting a buff when you are already strong
stone island
Can't u accept any opinion
I’m only staying the facts
Having to kill 200 or something is bandit beating and repetitive
Lazy quest design that isn’t even a quest at all
tiny igloo
It's relatively easy
stone island
It's relatively easy
That’s also horrible
tiny igloo
But 10 kills
stone island
No challenge means no real reward
stone island
But 10 kills
Too easy
tiny igloo
It's a cosmetic
tiny igloo
Don’t care
Then why would u even act like there's a better option
stone island
What matters is the obtainment method you suggested
stone island
Then why would u even act like there's a better option
There is
tiny igloo
Find an npc it's not a better idea
stone island
There are a plethora of better things
tiny igloo
Finding *
stone island
Find an npc it's not a better idea
When did I say that? That is also trash
Your mind is so inside of the box that it shows how many Roblox games you exclusively play
tiny igloo
Bro I have played many other games it was just an idea
stone island
Bro I have played many other games it was just an idea
Bandit beating idea
tiny igloo
What do u suggest
stone island
Easy
Rather than fighting 200 demons you fight 3 of them
Each one has to be summoned with a quest drop
That comes from your respective trainer
And it has to be done in order
tiny igloo
That would also be easy
stone island
That would also be easy
No it would be a challenge
I didn’t even tell you if the drop was chanced or if the boss was hard
tiny igloo
Then it's different
tiny igloo
Then it would be like gpo and would make the game die
stone island
It’s like you project your own interpretation on how something is
stone island
Then it would be like gpo and would make the game die
That was an example of that making it hard
tiny igloo
The drops
stone island
Besides the drop doesn’t even have to be chanced for it to be hard
The bosses should be hard
tiny igloo
In that perspective the mark should give smth
stone island
In that perspective the mark should give smth
Why?
What is wrong with just getting a cosmetic
tiny igloo
It's unreasonable to do smth hard for no reason
lusty plank
extreme.nick You’ve Reached Level 2
stone island
It's unreasonable to do smth hard for no reason
But it’s a cosmetic
And if you don’t want it then don’t get it
It’s something for max level players to get if they run out of content to play
And it rewards them with something that doesn’t cause imbalance in pvp or pve
The obtainment method is all that matters
tiny igloo
The item matters more
stone island
No it doesn’t
tiny igloo
It would make demons op
stone island
No it wouldn’t
tiny igloo
If slayers haven't anything to help them
stone island
If slayers haven't anything to help them
Slayers don’t need that because it’s a cosmetic
That means the devs already have it balanced and not based on power ups for max levels
A lower level player should be able to somewhat stand against a higher level one if they are more skilled
That is what good game design is
tiny igloo
No
stone island
You shouldn’t need to rely heavily on abilities to play a game with pvp or pve in it
tiny igloo
That makes no sence
stone island
That makes no sence
Proof?
tiny igloo
If a new player can kill a max lvl
stone island
If a new player can kill a max lvl
That’s not gonna be for every new player obviously
It’s going to be for the ones who are skilled
tiny igloo
Makes the game not fun cause you wouldn't reward urself with ur progress
stone island
Makes the game not fun cause you wouldn't reward urself with ur progress
So you want the game to be blox fruits?
Where higher level players always have advantage over new ones
tiny igloo
No Blox fruit is ass
stone island
Even though there is a combat system
stone island
No Blox fruit is ass
Then stop trying to project it onto this game
Games like Elden ring have people fight at very different levels
tiny igloo
Never did that
stone island
But a level 1 can beat a max level
tiny igloo
No
stone island
As long as they are more skilled
tiny igloo
No Stat and weapon upgrade
stone island
No Stat and weapon upgrade
They can beat the entire game without them
tiny igloo
Yes
stone island
And they can pvp without them
tiny igloo
I have beat elden ring with lvl 1 wrench
stone island
They just have to be skilled
stone island
I have beat elden ring with lvl 1 wrench
Then why do you want the game to be a power fantasy
Where you kill 200 demons for a buff?
tiny igloo
Bc it's roblox not dark souls
stone island
Bc it's roblox not dark souls
That is an excuse for poor game design
tiny igloo
Look I'm not a dev
stone island
Nothing is stopping a Roblox game from not being a bandit beater
tiny igloo
I just suggested what I think would be cool
stone island
Look I'm not a dev
Quit making excuses and own up to whatever you are trying to say
stone island
I just suggested what I think would be cool
Then why are you so adamant on wanting a buff or having that obtainment method
tiny igloo
Cause it would be good cause every good game does things like that
stone island
The suggestion is the definition of bandit beating
tiny igloo
No it's both pvp pve
stone island
Gpo peroxide type soul
Trash trash and trash
Peroxide is alright
But since when did peroxide have a bandit beater quest?
tiny igloo
Well have u played the game
stone island
Yes I’ve played those 3
tiny igloo
To lvl u have to kill npc
stone island
And I’m max level in all of them
stone island
To lvl u have to kill npc
That is to level up
tiny igloo
And to get Horn of salvation
stone island
It isn’t linear where you have to kill things
stone island
And to get Horn of salvation
Not everyone is a soul reaper in that game
That is a biased example
stone island
It sounds like you just want slayers to be overpowered
tiny igloo
Example volt standing
stone island
And quincy
Hollows and Quincy can’t use the horn
stone island
Example volt standing
That’s a bad example
tiny igloo
It sounds like you just want slayers to be overpowered
They should be equal
stone island
A good example would be how Quincy have cybernetics
stone island
They should be equal
They already are
tiny igloo
That's drops that help u with abilities
stone island
The games combat system makes sure of that
tiny igloo
Like gatling and blue canon
stone island
That's drops that help u with abilities
No the Quincy cybernetics are part of that specific race
No other race has them
tiny igloo
Ik but the other races have other things
stone island
Same goes for horn of salvation and vasto lorde
stone island
Ik but the other races have other things
That is exactly my point
Each race has its own gimmick
But the gimmick can still be unbalanced
tiny igloo
I want slayers have their mark and red blade
stone island
Peroxide is unbalanced
tiny igloo
And demons smth else
stone island
I want slayers have their mark and red blade
Then just say that
That is what you want but that doesn’t mean it’s what the game should have
Fact of the matter is that demons don’t have a slayer mark equivalent or a red blade equivalent
tiny igloo
Ik but most people want that (I believe)
stone island
Therefore slayer mark is cosmetic
And red blade isn’t even planned yet
But nobody even asked about those two
I’m talking about the quest itself
tiny igloo
They should put smth non Canon for demons
lusty plank
extreme.nick You’ve Reached Level 3
stone island
You keep talking about buffs and what you get from it
But I’m talking about how the quest is a bandit beater
wooden cove
stone island
Not that the reward for it is bad or good
stone island
They should put smth non Canon for demons
Then they should do the same for slayers
tiny igloo
No slayers get mark + red blade
stone island
Demons won’t even burn in the sun for this game
tiny igloo
While demons smth
stone island
No slayers get mark + red blade
Cosmetic
You are just talking about stuff that doesn’t even matter
You aren’t even talking about the bandit beat quest anymore
stone island
You just care about the rewards and drops instead of the actual gameplay
stone island
And add smth to the demon faction
You keep yapping about rewards and not the quest
tiny igloo
You aren’t even talking about the bandit beat quest anymore
Well I can't change ur opinion I believe it's a good quest but I could recommend more
stone island
Well I can't change ur opinion I believe it's a good quest but I could recommend...
I gave you an example of a good quest
And you refused to acknowledge it
tiny igloo
I can suggest smth better in my opinion
stone island
The buso haki quest for gpo is literally the same bandit beat
You kill 100 or 200 yetis for buso haki
That is trash and a trash quest
tiny igloo
Well it's 80 yeti that are strong for the low level ur suppose to get haki
stone island
Regardless of what you get out of it the quest is bad
stone island
Well it's 80 yeti that are strong for the low level ur suppose to get haki
That is a trash quest
tiny igloo
Ik
tiny igloo
I'm not pushing the Idea of bandit beating
stone island
It’s literally the same thing if not worse
stone island
I'm not pushing the Idea of bandit beating
You literally already did
tiny igloo
I'm pushing both PVP & PVE
stone island
You stated killing 200 demons for it
stone island
I'm pushing both PVP & PVE
That doesn’t matter
tiny igloo
And 10 kills and a boss
tiny igloo
That doesn’t matter
It does
stone island
Killing players is even worse than bandit beating
tiny igloo
Demon players
stone island
Because chances are the quest will be much harder and you’d have to team
tiny igloo
Makes more sense
stone island
Demon players
That’s lazy
That isn’t an actual quest
That’s just a hitman contract
stone island
The game hitman makes that much more interesting
stone island
That's fun
That is lazy and boring
Nobody wants to fight 200 ranked matches for a cosmetic or move
The game is a pve and pvp game
tiny igloo
Who said 200 ranked
stone island
It’s not solely pvp
stone island
Who said 200 ranked
That is what you will get when you need to fight players
For a “quest”
That isn’t even a quest
That’s a bandit beater reskinned
tiny igloo
U could kill a boss then do a npc quest about saving other npc and bringing them back to there home town while other demons trying to kill u
stone island
Especially if everyone else is doing the quest
stone island
U could kill a boss then do a npc quest about saving other npc and bringing them...
That is a good idea
But saving other npcs could get repetitive
stone island
I'm saying a simple idea I don't know what the device want
That is a blank suggestion
tiny igloo
Well I can't write my whole idea cause it would take ages
stone island
That’s like saying “we should cure this disease” without actually saying how or giving any ideas
tiny igloo
And go against game rules
stone island
Well I can't write my whole idea cause it would take ages
It isn’t that hard to do
stone island
And go against game rules
The devs can still take parts of suggestions
And put them into their game
If you give them something as nonspecific as it gets then chances are they won’t understand what you are trying to suggest
Or they will forget it easily
tiny igloo
If I said a dev should activate the mark infront of someone and will go like a disease ,do you think that is a better idea?
stone island
Saying “make a quest for slayer mark and red nichirin” has been said 1000 times before
And the devs already thought of that
stone island
If I said a dev should activate the mark infront of someone and will go like a d...
That idea makes no sense
And has nothing to do with demon slayer
tiny igloo
Ik
stone island
That is a horrible suggestion
tiny igloo
But in the anime this is how you get it
stone island
But that is for derivatives of the sun breathing
And sun breathing is not for the public
tiny igloo
Ik
tiny igloo
I'm just asking if you think is better
stone island
That’s basically just meeting a dev and getting a cosmetic
tiny igloo
Ik
stone island
I'm just asking if you think is better
Obviously not but I would say it’s a little better than bandit beating
tiny igloo
Not saying this is how u should obtain it
stone island
Then what were you saying?
tiny igloo
My official idea is that u should kill a couple of demons and some demon players + a boss
(The boss should be hard)
stone island
My official idea is that u should kill a couple of demons and some demon players...
That is bandit beating
That isn’t an actual quest
tiny igloo
If you kill 10 demons?
tiny igloo
Then I said the other quest to protect the npc u said it is reused
stone island
Then I said the other quest to protect the npc u said it is reused
No I said it would be a good idea
But it could be repetitive
If anything the quest should be to save a village
Or doing a dungeon
tiny igloo
+killing bosses
stone island
Something where you are placed into another part of the map
stone island
+killing bosses
Killing a boss isn’t a real quest
tiny igloo
Well dungeons have demon npc
stone island
At the very least look up the definition of the word quest
tiny igloo
So u are saying bandit beating
tiny igloo
Killing a boss isn’t a real quest
It depends
stone island
Bandit beating is making a “quest” linear due to its requirement of you having to kill something multiple times
And bandit beating is looked down upon because it has been done thousands of times and is easy to do
tiny igloo
You don't have to kill the same npc
stone island
You don't have to kill the same npc
That doesn’t matter
If the quest doesn’t give you the option to make your own choices
Then you are playing a linear game
stone island
You could go on a dungeon and kill all super moons like the inf castle
That has already been done before
stone island
It’s not a good idea if it’s just reused
tiny igloo
So it's not a big problem
tiny igloo
It’s not a good idea if it’s just reused
Well it's Canon based so it's not that bad
stone island
Well it's Canon based so it's not that bad
That should be part of a story mode not a quest
tiny igloo
Demonfall has already done that too
Story mode would take ages to finish
stone island
It’s lazy and overused if it’s an obtainment quest
stone island
Story mode would take ages to finish
That’s why the idea doesn’t work
tiny igloo
Not for obtainment
stone island
Then for what?
tiny igloo
Just a part of a quest
stone island
That makes no sense and is a waste of the players time
tiny igloo
For like end game
stone island
That is horrible end game and it would die quickly
tiny igloo
That makes no sense and is a waste of the players time
If it gives good drops?
lusty plank
extreme.nick You’ve Reached Level 4
stone island
Project slayers had the same thing
stone island
If it gives good drops?
Literally project slayers copy paste
You are just reusing the same stuff from games that have already been made
stone island
Project slayers is wasted potential
tiny igloo
Yes I can agree
stone island
And it really isn’t a good game for quests
It has great abilities and moves and stuff
But it’s quests are bad
tiny igloo
Like what quests
stone island
Becoming a demon quest
tiny igloo
The wagon one or the other rice one
stone island
The wagon one or the other rice one
Those are lousy examples
tiny igloo
Becoming a demon quest
That's easy tbh they should have make it more difficult
stone island
That's easy tbh they should have make it more difficult
No it shouldn’t
If anything the quest was too confusing when the game first came out
And it had a multitude of bugs attached to it
Even today the quest is still a drag
They even made a game pass just to do the quest
So people who paid money can find muzan easier than a person without it
That is bad game design
Having to look for something, fetch something, and kill something have been done millions of times
At that point you might as well be asking the dev to make the same exact game
But reskinned so it looks like it’s different or new
tiny igloo
No the game should be different
Have different gameplay
Not same it would make it boring
stone island
Then it shouldn’t have the same quests
Or the same obtainment methods
At the very least the game should take stuff from things like Batman elden ring devil may cry
Games that have their own niche and know how to use it
tiny igloo
Well yes and no the game should put good stuff from those games but also put smth on there own like a different kind of obtainment for the breathings
stone island
Well yes and no the game should put good stuff from those games but also put smt...
The obtainment for something should always be a new form of content
You shouldn’t be doing “kill 10 demons for your slayer exam” to still doing “kill # of demons for your slayer mark”
tiny igloo
Yes but they should add something not like bandit beating but something to make u kill demons
stone island
There should be more complexity
tiny igloo
Yes
stone island
Yes but they should add something not like bandit beating but something to make ...
Killing demons should be a side thing
A way to level up
tiny igloo
Something the game it self never mentions
stone island
Take holy war x or rell seas for example
You can fish in those games
Games like those could give you a quest to fish for something and maybe it spawns a giant shark boss
Something that requires you to use the system and get something new out of it
It gives the player freedom to choose how they want to play
Rather than always needing to fight or kill for something
The closest any of these games have gotten to the “fishing” example are trading systems
Except all trading does is allow players to skip out on the bandit beating or drop chances because they don’t want to waste any time
Or playing that content is a drag
Slayer mark could honestly have similar obtainment to things like conquerors haki
Maybe you start off with the cosmetic or maybe you get it from any quest in the game at a random chance
Of course if it were to give you a power up that shouldn’t be the case because it would be unbalanced
tiny igloo
Nothing would make demon slayers more powerful
The buff the sword or the mark can give its like
Regen
While the demons have something else
stone island
That is just begging for a buff that wouldn’t happen
tiny igloo
Like enhanced m1s like a buff
stone island
The developers don’t want to see suggestions for things that are already confirmed
Slayer mark will not have any buffs
tiny igloo
That is just begging for a buff that wouldn’t happen
It's just a good idea that would reward the players for their time and grind
Then red sword
stone island
That is just forcing an idea that the devs will NOT accept
Because the devs already said slayer mark will NOT have any buffs
And that it IS a cosmetic
Why do you think they want it to be cosmetic?
Because of it being BALANCED
Developers don’t want to play the buff and nerf game every single update
stone island
It's just a good idea that would reward the players for their time and grind
And it’s been stated multiple times that cosmetics are the rewards for many things
When you really look at games especially online games
The endgame are cosmetics
Sure you will see thousands of kids trying to be tanjiro
But on the other hand you could see cool things like people using their stuff to be rurouni kenshin
Or someone like idk
Arima from tg
Maybe even itachi
That is why the developers are so adamant on things being cosmetic
Even their game passes are cosmetics
People who boost the server will get monthly cosmetics
tiny igloo
Then the mark should be different for everyone and should be changed however you want
Like you could have your mark at your leg
stone island
Then the mark should be different for everyone and should be changed however you...
That is how it is going to be
I’m pretty sure they have already made custom and non canon marks
tiny igloo
Ok
stone island
At the very least look at their #❓│faq and sneaks
#🉐│hinokami and #👀│previews already display what they are adding
Or what’s already added
tiny igloo
Only read the faq
stone island
The only suggestions they would really want or need are things like obtainment methods or cosmetic ideas
tiny igloo
Oh ok
stone island
Even without slayer marks they are going to let you choose different face markings
tiny igloo
Ok
wooden cove
Nah
copper osprey
yes
wooden cove
tell higoshi to change that
He's not gonna change it
copper osprey
if hes doing it for balancing reasons then he should just give demons a form like what uppermoon 1 and muzan did during the fight against hashiras
or just make demons base stronger then humans
wooden cove
Someone literally made a suggestion about it and they said slayer marks would be cosmetic only
Maybe they'll do something in the future who knows
But rn it's js cosmetic
copper osprey
sad
wooden cove
Go whine to him about it not me 😂
analog badger
Make it so you should go through a difficult quest to get your slayer mark
For e...
No
analog badger
Slayer mark is purely cosmetic if it ever does get added, red nichiran would be a buff mode causing pvp balance to be thrown off and other shit needing ti be buffed
tiny igloo
Is that really bad or hard to make like make base demons a bit more overpowered or add some other buff for them and add red nichirin that gives a small buff like 2% more damage