Players can make their own custom derivative breaths and pass them around

[raven ore]

The idea is really simple and easily done: players who mastered their breathings to a certain lvl can make derivative breathings from their own for a certain amount of robux, the moves will deliver the same dmg as the players derived from breathing does, the player can name the moves as he likes, the particles will have a few options to choose from, you will be able to recolor existing breathing styles (for example water) to different colors, and the animations? you will get to choose from the other breathings except the particles will be replaced with your custom one, OR the devs could add a few animations for the players to use, for example:

i am a water user, i decide to make my own derivative breath called swamp breathing, i will then buy the gamepass and recolor the blue water breathing particles to green and reuse a mix of some flame breathing, serpent breathing, and water breathing for the moves then i will have my custom breathing which (like sun and moon) can be taught to other players, this will remove a ton of pressure from the devs to add new noncannon breathings for variety like they did for the BDA's and would create this fad among the community who will pass around their custom breathings

as i said earlier, this SHOULD be a gamepass imo+

[ashen pawn]

having derivative breaths sounds like more work for us

but if you just want reskins you're probably gonna have less immersion

especially with how we're making the game

[raven ore]

well... unless the breathings are gonna be unbalanced

all breathings are reskins in a way

[raven ore]

how so? instead of making entire new animations and breathing styles, you guys can focus on the cannon ones

and we will make our own stuff

from the cannon ones\

[ancient sequoia]

Ts seems lowk useless and way more work for the devs 😭

[raven ore]

how?!

how is it more work?

[ancient sequoia]

How is it not

[raven ore]

adding new animations for like 4 other custom breathings per update

OR

letting the community use the anime breaths to make their own

the only hard (kinda) part will be the customization tab for this featire

*feature

[ancient sequoia]

It seems so complicated and so useless and so much work for the devs making your combinations of breathing u want 😭

[raven ore]

the devs wont make them

[ancient sequoia]

Broski

[raven ore]

the devs will just allow us to customize them thru a tab

[ancient sequoia]

U want sun breathing and moon breathing and serpent mixed? 😭

[raven ore]

sun and moon shouldnt have derivatives

seeing as every breath is derived from sun

and moon has no derivative

[ancient sequoia]

Ts seems so useless

[raven ore]

but yes, a custome fire and serpent breathing mix would be awesome

[raven ore]

then character customization is useless too

[ancient sequoia]

If your gonna customize it through a tab they will have to make the options of customization yes?

[raven ore]

yes, which will be the hard part, but its not that hard of a concept, just recolors of the old breaths

even if we do get that feature, i wouldnt expect it on release really

[ancient sequoia]

It's lowk a bad idea I'ma leave it at that

[raven ore]

HY

WHY\

u dont trash on my idea and refuse to elaborate, i shared this for criticism

if u gave a valid reason i would drop this willingly, its not a core feature, more of a fun idea

i wouldnt even care if they didnt put it in tbh

[ancient sequoia]

K it's a bad idea bcz it's so much work for them to make all of your guys breathing combinations all for what? You to have a cool color of fire and serpent combined? It would completely ruin the immersion of the game

[raven ore]

you are acting like they will animate them, make the particles, make the colors, and release them upon request, these will be 100% made by the player with no intereference from the devs outside adding the customization feature, i do agree that making it blend in could be hard

but i think that could have a fix

[ancient sequoia]

You want a normal player that has no modeling experience to make their own?

How

Will they have access to the studio of the game?

[raven ore]

you are clearly misinterpreting the idea

i will make a ui illustration when i come back from school

[ancient sequoia]

"these will br 100% made by the player"

[raven ore]

because you guys dont understand what i mean

[raven ore]

in the customization tab, as i said above, the player himself will reuse stuff from other breathingds]

the devs wont have a hand in it

[ancient sequoia]

So you mean like

They can use skills from other breathings

In one breathing

[raven ore]

yes, and recolor them and rename the moves

but the damage will be based on the original derivative move

*breath

[ancient sequoia]

That's wayy too op and pay to win

[raven ore]

how is that OP? they do the same damage as the derivative breath

its retextured water breathing, just like the derivative breathings in the anime which are more or less that (Except sound)

[ancient sequoia]

They could just add the best skills in the game (from different breathings) and be op

[raven ore]

are you not understanding me?
\

that wont matter because theyre not adding the damage those skills have

with the skills

theyre adding the damage from the water breath moves, maybe moves could be categorized into ranged and close combat

[ancient sequoia]

They could find a inf combo with the skills

[raven ore]

with the user choosing one of the two to pick from

[raven ore]

how so?

they work just like a normal breathing

[ancient sequoia]

If u can pick any skill from different breathings you can prob find an inf combo

[raven ore]

u forget about stamina like in project slayers

the combos could also be added from the derivative breath

[ancient sequoia]

Never know if any skills have a stun ability (where u can recharge your breath)

And continue the combo

3am and arguing with Shrek over a stupid topic 😔

[raven ore]

its 11 am here

[desert loom]

ownm3z0 You’ve Reached Level 7

[ancient sequoia]

That's you

It's 3 am for me

[raven ore]

yeah i agree it might not be TOO practical

there will always be some issues to fix with it, which is why its not expected on my end

but i do think it will be easy to fix those issues

[ancient sequoia]

If this gets added tho I'ma quit the game 😭

Unless they make it like 5k brobux

[signal ember]

too much detailed scripting and will take a really long time, dunno if its even possible too if its a game like this

and its also ridiculously hard to well, make it balance with the other breaths, there will also be cases where some ppl just pass an op breath on to bilions of people

[fallow otter]

I imagine like that someone will try to make the breathing Look like sun breathing 💀

[signal ember]

i can already guess the youtube caption. "NEW CUSTOM BREATH FOR YORIICHI/TANJIRO COSPLAYERS #HINOKAMI #DSRPG3 #ROBLOX"

[fallow otter]

xd

Good idea but i think there are more cons than pros

[ancient sequoia]

Wht I'm saying

[stuck robin]

Custom breathing shouldn’t be a thing

Let’s just stick to the anime for now

[primal mountain]

fr

[desert loom]

szu.lmb You’ve Reached Level 3

[raven ore]

for now i agree

[sour cypress]

i think custom breathing styles is a great idea.

One reason why i think so: Players would probably get bored once they master all breathing styles. Players would most likely have more fun with it and, it would be a great way to motivate players to try and master their breathing styles. Also instead of devs making new animations maybe they can start us off with 5 animations and we could probably make our own animations and sending it to a dev which would show the creator and ask if it would be alright to put in the game for that player and other players. It would capture even more players because of the abillty to add diffrent breathing styles.

[normal ginkgo]

so basically a spec

not happening

[sour cypress]

the devs can do what they want cause it their game but i think it would be a great idea for derivative breathing styles.

[normal ginkgo]

cause it's a ton of work to add a breathing just for it to be used by one person

[sour cypress]

not only for one person for other players too to use

[normal ginkgo]

it also adds difficulties in pvp with players not knowing how to respond to someone that plays that breathing

[normal ginkgo]

isn't that just a regular breathing then

[sour cypress]

kind of just diffrent animations and effects

but same idea

[normal ginkgo]

so a reskin?

[sour cypress]

ye kind of

[normal ginkgo]

eh

[sour cypress]

and the devs dont gotta make it

just add it

instead

diff particles and animations that players can add

[desert loom]

iilovezeno You’ve Reached Level 1

[normal ginkgo]

i mean

that'd cause issues

with players not being able to recognize stuff

[sour cypress]

ye that would be a problem

i didnt think of that.

[normal ginkgo]

and it'd probably be controversial since a ton of people would complain about the game not sticking to the series

also would kinda toy around with the originality of breathings

[sour cypress]

maybe people can do a poll to see?

[normal ginkgo]

i mean

it's not upto player's preference

[sour cypress]

ok

[normal ginkgo]

it's just a bad mechanic

[sour cypress]

alr

i just thought it'd be good cause people would not get bored at all.

[normal ginkgo]

that wouldn't change anything

u cant help if a player gets bored or not

[sour cypress]

i mean bored of a breathing style

[normal ginkgo]

u could make the best game of all time and people would still get bored cause that depends from player to player

[normal ginkgo]

i mean u can always switch in that case

[sour cypress]

alr it was just a thought

[spiral sandal]

no, you basically add moves to the game and customise them, just be a developer and end it all, this is a stupid idea because now you will see everyplayer the game using nature breathing or even rainbow breathing, just keep it as it is, maybe a different animation or color could be ok but to add moves to your breathing style just no

[primal mountain]

Should just keep it as is

[acoustic badger]

nuh uh