variety of weapons

[stable raft]

add the choice of the weapon you want to have like genya for example he uses a gun and not necessarily a katana even if he has one.

[frosty aurora]

The question is

Would it Limit the choise of breathings?

Imagine using stone breathing with insect katana

[olive island]

canonically stone breathers don't use standard katana, so an insect katana wouldn't work either.

[frosty aurora]

so the question is now if it locks stone for example if u have a other weapon then flail and axe

[stable raft]

uh the only user of the stone shown in the work is gyomei, nothing says that the other users were not using a normal katana

[stable raft]

normally it's possible it just depends on if the user is comfortable with it

[frosty aurora]

nah thats cap like how you wanna use the other moves. These are literally just based on the flail and axe. Not a single move can be used as supposed to do with a katana

[stable raft]

uh is that written somewhere? that you can only use rock breath with a flail and an axe?

[stable raft]

I checked and it is not noted in the rock breath wiki

So, that can work

[frosty aurora]

Based on the only user in the series, Gyomei Himejima, it can be assumed that Stone Breathing can only be used with a flail and/or axe. However, in Kokushibo's flashback, the progenitor of Stone Breathing is seen wielding a giant Kusarigama-like weapon.
Coppied that from wiki

and do you know what a kusarigama looks like?

just type that in wiki

to say short. It doesn't have to be a flail and a axe but just smth that mimics it

Aint no insect katana can mimic flail and axe

[stable raft]

I reviewed the chapter and I see who you are talking about but nothing says that he was the pillar of the rock. However, even if it was really him the simple fact that he uses a weapon other than the flail and the ax proves that my idea is possible

[frosty aurora]

I mean i don't judge but kusarigama are literally 2 sickles connected with a chain🤦‍♂️

so it was only possible with this weapon bc it works the same way as a flail and a axe

a insect katana for example doesn't work like a flail and axe

[crystal iris]

Stone breathing is literally based off of the weapon, you can’t replicate the same moves with a sword

[frosty aurora]

that is what i tried to tell him the whole time🤷‍♂️

[crystal iris]

it doesn’t have to be written somewhere. it’s common sense

[stable raft]

we can't with a sword but with a weapon almost similar to that of Gyomei yes, for example the first user of the rock breath did not have the same weapon. And my suggestion is the possibility of choosing your type of weapon and not using breaths with a katana lol

[stable raft]

bro it's not the same weapon, it looks similar but it's not the same and my idea is to be able to choose your weapon when there are two weapons there is already a possibility of choice. Attempts to see in general and not just in a specific case

[stable raft]

no, a similar weapon may do the trick, no need to have Gyomei's weapon just one that allows the use of breath

after you have the example of the first user of the breath of rock guys, why don't you understand?

[undone wraith]

It's said somewhere in the manga that previous users of stone used a Flail and something else

the first user of stone used this thign

but a giant version lol

[crystal iris]

yeah, except earlier you said that it’d be possible for someone to use stone breathing with an insect breathing sword

that’s what i’m commenting on

[stable raft]

I said it ? Bruh, so idea was to be able to choose your weapon even if there are only two for a breath..