Java players cant join with regular ip but can join with dynamic ip

[novel remnant]

Java players cant join with regular ip but can join with dynamic ip

But sometimes java players can join with regular ip its always random

Bedrock players can normally join no issue there

[oak acorn]

Geyser does not modify server behaviour, if this happens to a java player then it won't be the fault of Geyser

[novel remnant]

it only happens when i install geyser plugin it works fine when i remove the geyser plugin

[oak acorn]

This is not possible, Geyser simply does not interfere with java traffic

at least not in this sense

[oak acorn]

This shows that the server didn't respond at all which Geyser definitely can't cause

it's a translation layer and so doesn't need to touch java's networking side as much, just emulating it

Which host are you using?

[novel remnant]

sorry i forgot to mention, its aternos

[oak acorn]

Are you trying to join on PojavLauncher by any chance?

[novel remnant]

no no, i'm using the orginal minecraft

on pc

[oak acorn]

alr just checking, since android networking is a bit odd and I've seen similar behaviour

does the issue persist if you put StaticIP:Port?

[novel remnant]

yes it rarely lets you join but when i put dynamic ip it always works

but on bedrock you can join normally with static ip

[oak acorn]

Also, I do believe this is on Aternos' side, sounds like their static IP isn't setup correctly for TCP on your server

[novel remnant]

I see, so using dynamic ip is the only solution

[oak acorn]

for now, you could contact Aternos and describe the issue, they're pretty cool in my experience and will probably be able to help

[novel remnant]

i did, they told me to use dynamic ip or change the dns to google dns which is fine by me but my friends don't want to use google dns

changing dns seems to work normally

[oak acorn]

There isn't much more you can do then, if Google DNS works then it's definitely some weird obscure networking issue, likely on the default DNS that you and your friends use

[novel remnant]

I see thanks for the help nova