What if Neuro could write her own songs?

[distant geyser]

I have an idea for Neuro. what if neuro could design her own music on stream? choose her own lyrics and beat, design it mostly all herself. The viewers could give her feedback on whether they like it by sending checkmarks or X's which would allow neuro to adapt her music to the viewer preference.

also i do know there is a forum for song suggestion already but i figured this deserves its own post for the suggestion due to the fact im proposing the ability for neuro to make her own songs.

just imagine the crazy songs that neuro could make. i could see her making a song called "You will never guess what this mosquito did today" just to troll Vedal more lol

[limpid schooner]

VIVY REFERENCE NOWAY

[latent thistle]

idk if taking viewer input is the best way for her songwriting ai to learn, all neuro fans are yesmen who say neuro is always right (she is)

[cyan urchin]

Vivy

[hasty tapir]

Sounds funny but I imagine he wants the song to actually sound decent

Plus trusting chat they’d make it sound bad on purpose

[distant geyser]

true. but an approve and dissaprove system would be useful for the development of the songs so that neuro could learn what her audience likes. it could be limited to subs if neccesary

i think neuro could handle the lyric generation pretty easily. its just the beat and rythm and stuff that she'd need extra vedalopment to do

see what i did there? vedalopment? yeah i have a great sense of humor as you can see

no but seriously it would be really cool to see neuro write her own songs

[latent thistle]

I think ai generated lyrics could work but an ai generated beat idk about

I looked up ai generated music yeah ais arent ready to create their own tunes yet.

the only way I see it working is hiring a musician to work with ai generated lyrics and they make it into music, then convert the human song back into neuro like she does with karaoke streams

or maybe vedal will revolutionize the ai music creating field and actually create the first ever good music generating ai

[hasty tapir]

He could do one for fun sure but i think an actual song writer would be better for her first original song what neuro says is pretty much word soup and wouldn’t make much sense

[latent thistle]

I figure even if the lyrics dont make sense it doesnt matter, as long as it has a good tune. ai generated lyrics could totally work. I mean many people like japanese songs even though they can’t understand the lyrics at all

its just the tune itself would probably need a human to design based off of the syllable count

🎙️
1111 3
1111 3
one thousand
one hundred and eleven
heart heart heart heart

[hasty tapir]

There’s been songs that already exist that’s proven to not be the case

Plus if he’s gonna be spending money on this might as well pay people who know how to make songs so it sounds good neuro should just sing the song

if it’s gonna be AI generated why set the goal that high in the first place yk?

[latent thistle]

im just entertaining the idea that OP suggested without shooting it down altogether, neuro can string together coherent conversations sometimes so if you give it a few tries i dont think the lyrics would actually be that bad

the tune part will have to wait for a new gen of ai tech but i think the lyrics could work, especially if its supposed to be neuros song

[hasty tapir]

Vedal also doesn’t want neuro to do AI generated art so I don’t see him doing this, someone asked if neuro could help with his game a while ago too it just doesn’t seem like a thing he would do

[latent thistle]

its not ai art its ai music, yes "music is art" but nobodys gotten fussed over ai music, otherwise hatsune miku would be canceled and neuro would never sing. i could see vedal not doing it because its too much effort for what its worth which is a fair judgement tho

as for the coding ai thing, as far as i can tell he just doesnt do coding stuff anymore on stream. why make neuro content that wont be seen

if he needs an ai to help him out he asks chatgpt (hes admitted to it in past streams) so he doesnt need it for the functionality either

[mellow coyote]

If Vocaloids are okay, I think Neuro taking up song writing should be just fine. Thoughts?

[latent thistle]

I don’t see any ethical issues with it.

[hasty tapir]

People write vocaloid songs though, and she might end up stealing lyrics

[latent thistle]

just check the lyrics first to make sure she didnt. its a bit different from image ais because she can use her internal memory to write about her “life experiences” (love song to harrison temple but a mosquito keeps getting in the way)

[distant geyser]

exactlyyyy this guy gets it

and maybe if she cant make her own beat, she could make paradies to songs in the free domain

[hasty tapir]

There’s too many songs that exist for that to be possible imo I already stated why I don’t think it’s a good idea so I’m dropping this topic

[hasty tapir]

I just got reminded of an AI singer on twitter that attempted what you are suggesting, everything as AI generated and it did not end up sounding good it goods like a good idea on paper but it wouldn’t work in practice imo

[hardy wind]

LOL