e giant

[untold current]

Remove e gians from the game.

[outer nova]

👍

[narrow sierra]

so true

[karmic raptor]

no they were in sw2 so no and its giants not gians

[dreamy vale]

nerf both the egiants and this idea

[outer steeple]

Why

[untold current]

long range.
high damage.
high health.

53 damage 900 health

[sinful bear]

Lol no

They're only good if they're spammed bro

If they're by themselves, then they aren't as good anymore

[dreamy vale]

UC

[round yacht]

instead of nerfing/removing e giants buff normal ones to make them just as good

this will make saving for expensive units some part of profitable strategy

also buff ripriders

because they succ dicc

heavy units arent supposed to serve just as a cover to archidons

also making expensive units actually powerful would end light units spams

[drowsy flame]

SWL kid Idea

[untold current]

I don't think Egians fit the balance of the current game. archers are very weak. Those who want to use archers must use rip. rip and archer are purchased with gold. This dual economy will be very difficult.

[warm moth]

No

1 riprider can solo normal and e giant

[round yacht]

then at least reduce their population to 7

[warm moth]

Yea

[untold current]

I'm sure e giants will be nerf. the sooner the better.

[round yacht]

Nah

This would be cring

[untold current]

It would be a good idea to remove e giants from the game until the game balance is adjusted.

[round yacht]

The thing that needs to be done is increasion of castle archidons range

In 2v2

In 1v1 too probably

To make it impossible for the opponent to just stand in front of your base and haunt your miners

And any other troops

But this will also require increasing length of battlefield

And about giants chaos giant needs a buff

What I keep repeating under every post about giants

[untold current]

You want to win the game without doing anything. We are making an effort. With a tower turtle you want to wait until you max out the army and get guaranteed points. This is very selfish.

[round yacht]

I just see it as a problem when someone puts enslaved giants in from of your base and doesn't allow you to even mine

But enslaved giants can't be removed and surely won't be

[sinful bear]

Hell no! The game will NEVER be perfectly balanced, there will ALWAYS be someone who doesn't like it.

[round yacht]

BUFF CHAOS GIANTS

[stable furnace]

[dusk kelp]

Don't end my career of making maid clothes for them

[untold current]

?

[round yacht]

[outer nova]

👍

[inner moat]

I think he deserve the Nerf After all he deal too much splash damange and normal damange and even if you buff the chaos gigant the e gigant Will be Always on top.

[haughty rain]

It is strange to me that e giant is better because in a 1v1 giant wins

But it seems like the range is just such a big advantage especially in bigger fights

[round yacht]

In 1v1 chaos giant wins only if enslaved giant is not in catapult

[haughty rain]

I forgot about that

Lol

[round yacht]

Expensive units need to be powerful to make saving for them profitable

We just lack any other expensive units that would be able to face enslaved giants

[haughty rain]

Yes facts

Honestly the giant needs a buff

Like even just a movement speed buff

[inner moat]

Yea iknow but After all the e gigant Is Just broken for his splash damage and even the riprieder get a buff that dont change so much are some deck that are anti gigant bug i think i deserve a splash damage Nerf

[haughty rain]

Or increase the amount of units dmged by it's aoe

[inner moat]

Btw Wat mean aoe?

[haughty rain]

Area of effect

[inner moat]

A ok thansk

[haughty rain]

Np

[round yacht]

Because (at least in my opinion) the game should start with light units scuffles and end with clash of powerful heavies

Making the game only about light units spam makes it pretty cringe and tacticless

Enslaved giant finally helped us escape archidons monopoly because before most of the pro decks based on archidons spam

[inner moat]

Idk Wat to Say i simply dont like the e gigant get delete but unless a rework that change a lot of things or a good Nerf to balance him

[haughty rain]

Yes

[inner moat]

Yea but are so many varients with riprieder and project block for spammer decks

[round yacht]

To fix the game creators need to:

• buff other expensive units such us ripriders and chaos giants, maybe add some more of them (I have several ideas)
• increase range of castle archers/deads to make sure base is well protected from enemy units standing in front of the base (archidons and enslaved giants)
• following the point above the battlefield length needs to be increased

[inner moat]

Yea maybe but After all if you buff the other exepsive unit even if you do for a good reason the main problem still remain, or the worst option Is more the anti gigant decks with this buff now you can't even play with gigant becouse for the riprieder buff and for the Shadow raft.

No One Is in right or wronge we only needed that the developer do some rework to the game.

[inner moat]

To balance It

[round yacht]

If what I'm proposing was made then a standard deck would likely consist of one light, one heavy and one very heavy unit

And the battle would be about first lights struggling for the middle (as it is right now), then heavies coming with help to establish beginning dominance and then epic clash of very heavy units

Supported by standard heavies

It would add some wider range of strategy and fun I guess

Instead of starting with archidons, haunting enemy with archidons and ending the battle with archidons

[inner moat]

Well we don't know how Stick War 3 Will be in the future but we can Hope that the developer Nerf the tower and idk rework some units ect

[round yacht]

From what surely requires a nerf is center tower boosting training speed

Because it's impossible to fight enemy who trains their troops 40% faster

[inner moat]

Becouse After all alot of player Simply hate the centrale tower to bee broken and no skill

[inner moat]

Yeap but Will be cool

[round yacht]

Not even mentioning tower damaging your statue, tesla, spirit units support and free resources

[inner moat]

Yea sucks

[round yacht]

What needs to be done about center tower (in my opinion):

• no training boost
• tower can damage statues but can't destroy them
• tesla in 2v2 not possible to be constantly active (give it splash but reduce its time)
• spirit units not being able to hold the tower for you as if they weren't fully your troops

[inner moat]

I agree to be honest but not for the tower can't destroy your tower becouse the tower damage was created to be a penalty for camper decks like magi gant or gigant spam

[round yacht]

From what I think would be a good reward for center tower holder are bonus gold ores around it

[inner moat]

Yea maybe Will be intristings.

[round yacht]

From the other side you can't win a battle just from holding center

[inner moat]

Sure but the main problem why you can't conquer the tower when you apponent Is holding Is becouse for the training time

But with out the training time bonus Is balace to me

[round yacht]

Many times I had a situation in which I was having a long battle with someone but the center tower finished it prematurely

Even though we were fighting

[inner moat]

Yea sure in fact can be good the centrale tower damage but with training bonus ect Is very dificult to deal that.

But with out the training bonus can be very chanlleing if you know how to do a come back 🙂

[round yacht]

Also I think that free support appearing when you are in a bad situation (like in stick war legacy) would be a very good idea

[haughty rain]

No that sounds bad

But it would be good as an upgrade

It think

[narrow sierra]

https://tenor.com/view/my-honest-reaction-honest-reaction-robert-pattinson-luxury-meme-batman-honest-reaction-gif-27703605

I'm Suddenly Interested In This Fan Idea.

For No Peculiar Reasons.

[keen moth]

jonsnow you have fallen from grace

[round yacht]

💀

[untold current]

OK

[outer nova]

(no)

(he has a point)

[untold current]

Time will show that I am right. e giants will be nerfed

[narrow sierra]

SW3 dating sim

[hardy lynx]

Impossible

SW2 units were promised for SW3

[sharp smelt]

catapult damage 53 and e giants take even more damage in catapult mode

I guess a rebalance will do

[untold current]

E giants' health and area damage should be reduced.

I still think it's a broken unit. e gians may be removed from the game until they are balanced.

[untold current]

The catapult ability is nice but very powerful.

[dreamy vale]

remove splash

[mystic pier]

Egiants not the problem

There just aren't many counters

One isn't a big problem

However it only becomes annoying when the opponent spamms them

[inner moat]

Yes

[sharp smelt]

its a rock

if rock hits the ground it creats more rocks

so splash makes sense

just nerf

or a splash damage rebalance

[wintry forum]

I think deleting them is still the better choice

[sharp smelt]

lol

well my idea is prob bad

its called Juggerknight upgrade

I have no stats or name for it

[inner moat]

Yea kinda but you know the funny part?
Is the fact that the e gigant Is broken and even if you Nerf the splash Is Just too broken to be a gigant if they remove the splash Will be really balance the e gigant.

[inner moat]

Or Just Nerf the damage and the splash damage a lot.

[robust echo]

clash royal players :

[untold current]

?

[sonic palm]

i think they need to nerf it like without the capult it does 20 damage and with the catapult it does 30 damage and health i think it's good

[untold current]

Even a 10 year old baby can reach grandmaster level with e giants. There shouldn't be such a broken unit or it should be fixed.

[summer torrent]

id say that the "games still in beta, broken things are meant to be expected argument" but everyone just dismisses it anyways

[untold current]

Yes I know. That's why I express my ideas for the development of the beta version.

e giants are very strong, they should be fixed

[summer torrent]

well any change to them is gonna be a while

[weak onyx]

The range of the enslaved giant should be reduced

they have same range as archidons

By the way, a 10year old child or a child who does not know the game cannot reach to the grandmaster with e giant. magikill and e giant turtle spammers can only go so far. and they can do this already before with normal giants

[dreamy vale]

heavy agree

[mystic pier]

Egiants range ain't a big problem

It makes sense

And it can only do so much before it gets demolished early game

[keen cosmos]

Maybe remove their catapult ability and add it as an upgrade?

[mystic pier]

Nah

Their catapult ability ain't that op

Unless you're spamming em

[weak onyx]

without catapult ability their ai is too bad

[mystic pier]

Egiant's range doesn't need change

The chaos giant just needs a buff

[dreamy vale]

eh, Egiant is such a big block in the meta, its not fun how it takes that much spotlight

[narrow sierra]

SW3 should get deleted , reworked , revamped , and rebalance everything at this point.

[dreamy vale]

✨beta✨

[drowsy flame]

✨Uncompleted✨

[sharp smelt]

✨ rebalance✨

[inner moat]

✨Centrall Tower war 3✨

[weak onyx]

tower buff made the game worse

it needs rework

[inner moat]

Ngl i Agree

[round yacht]

People claiming enslaved giant is overpowered when they find out about center tower:

[wary epoch]

add a 4th upgrade to monstrosity that gave player catapult mode instead of having it normally

and this can also could add ground slamp to chao giant

cost 500 gold and 500 mana while taking 90 s

cgiant ground slamp: dealt 60 damage(no bonus damage), with 4 aoe in a big circle with it's old kb before getting kb buff, took 30 sec

[stray stratus]

This is literally same post but riprider lol

[inner moat]

In fact turtell deck was the reason to the tower buff.
If i dont miss.

[round yacht]

ye but imagine Ur trying to fight invader that trains his troops almost 2 times faster + sends on U spirit units

• tesla

• free resources

[inner moat]

Yeap but in fact the dev sholudn't buff soo much the tower but Simply Nerf the cost of the magikill or the explosion radius.

And you want ear the fun fact? Now a days turtell deck are more popupalr than normal rush deck with spearton and swordraft.
In fact now the Avenger skill in Stick War 3 Is getting more lower not becouse for the turtell strategy but for the centrale tower buff.
And becouse you Need only 3 minuts to conquer the tower and Is a free win if the apponent dont have acid rain
And you have zero answer to the acid rain

[round yacht]

1. then why do i keep getting rushed by swordwraths on 1v1?
2. the game shouldnt base on rushing either, otherwise VoP, miner upgrade, and giants would be useless while they are a part of certain strategies

[inner moat]

Way Wat mean vop?

[round yacht]

vault of prudence

[inner moat]

Ahh ok

[inner moat]

1 they are Simply variant with e gigant and eclipsor
In some cenario have only swordraft and spearton Is a bit triky becouse One e gigant can Easy took them off or magikill and normal gigant, if the apponent dont rush in early game.

2 miner upgrade and vop was usefull in the early day of Stick War but with the curent meta of the centrale tower and with deck like shodow rip that are created to Simply take down gigant ect.

And becouse now we now that Stick War 3 Will never be balance like Stick War 2

Or Stick War empires

[round yacht]

U need to gather money for these first while swordwraths destory statue in moment

eclipsor needs a price and population reduction in my opinion

for example 350 gold and 50 crystal

and 4 population

because hes just slightly better than an archidon

[inner moat]

Btw i hate too the centrale tower but a more balance update Will be to effects only unit like magikill ect other than destroy the concept of the game to create deck and test your Skill.

[round yacht]

while being slower, costing a kidney and having too big pop

[round yacht]

if anone just stays in base then wait for the tower to end him

i do so

and with resources boost and spirit units he wont have it easy to defeat U

[inner moat]

I think a price and a population reduce Will be a lit bit broken but only a population reduce Will be much Better 🙂

[inner moat]

Yea i agree

[round yacht]

the only actual power of eclipsor is the fact he flies so he is useless against projectile units which occur in 90% of decks

[round yacht]

also not being able to fight back a full scale invasion of turtle deck means your army is only good against weak enemies and needs to be fixed

if you for example put enslaved giant in fron of his base and bombed his economy it would be over for him

[inner moat]

Nah in realty eclipsor are very good against arcidon plus they are a Chaos unit so they Simply have a huge adventeg against acid rain or poison in general

[inner moat]

Yeap and heres why e gigant should be Nerf or rework

Due for his higer splash and normal damage

[round yacht]

assuming 1 crystal = 2 gold then eclipsor is worth 2 archidons while having similar population to 2 of them so he should be just as good

while an eclipsor gets totally massacred by two archidons

and toxic dead that also massacres an eclipsor while costing much less

[inner moat]

Kinda

[round yacht]

maybe not much but still less

[inner moat]

If you are assuming that two arcidon can take off an eclipsor thats right but two eclipsor and two arcidon are very dif imo

[round yacht]

nah its just that we need more powerful and expensive units not to make the game just about lights

boost chaos giants and ripriders instead

to make it profitable to save for expensive ones

[inner moat]

Plus the same things cannot replay to tdead and two arcidon

Nahh i Simply dont agree with 🙂

Thats all

[round yacht]

ofc because eclipsor is slightly better than an archidon while costing both of Ur kidneys

[outer nova]

someone tell him how skilled jon is

(he has beaten countless egiant users)

[outer nova]

thats exactly how we got here

instead of nerfing units everything just kept getting buffs

[outer nova]

tdeads get massacred by like, 2 or 3 swordwrath

still more viable in endgame

sometimes its not always about the 1v1s 💀

[round yacht]

exacly

[outer nova]

tbh

eclipsor + projectile barrier decks are

somewhat good

[round yacht]

while 3 swordwraths are much cheaper than an eclipsor

[round yacht]

its usually that eclipsors cant kill even heavy covers such as speartons and giants and when the bubble ends they get massacred by more numerous archidons

as ive said the only actual power of eclipsor is the fact he flies

and so hes useless against units with projectiles

[outer nova]

most cases, eclipsors end up targetting the archidons

[round yacht]

not really

[outer nova]

as the archers move forward

when they detect the eclipsors

ofc if your enemy is attacking thenconsider it ggs

[round yacht]

if they do then maybe but usually if the player has more than 1 iq he protects archidons

[outer nova]

causing him to lose all dps and making his frontline take unnecessary damage

eclip spam is also surprisingly good at turtling ive beat a double giant rush with it before while the dude had tower+maxpop

(with some tanks)

but yeah

eclipsors arent meant to be spammed

meanwhile egiants

they arent meant to be spammed

but theyre fucking- op when spammed anyway

huge hp + splash damage + already high base damage is just

and them having heavy bonus means death to all tanks

then yu ave catapult

sniping reborn

kytchu sniping from old vers but worse

just make the egiant like SE

single target, still shreds armored units

but nonspammable

due to no aoe

meaning any egiant army dies against most decent armies

[round yacht]

egiants are weak agaisnt shadows

cuz shadows have insalnely huge dps which also gets doubled with time

and they can parry enemy attacks

[outer nova]

then you have other decks capable of countering shadows

the biggest flaw of sw3 is it's deck system

there arent enough slots to make an all around deck

you can only make a deck which is either

great at attacking with sucky defense

great at defense with sucky attack

balanced with attack and defense that gets crumbled by any deck that isn't also balanced (in other words high likelihood of losing)

[dark sierra]

you basically just dump your entire existence into one strategy

and then resign if they have the counter

if i had just two more slots

this game would be so much easier

if they have e giants, I can switch to giant archer

instead of spearton spamming

[stray stratus]

egirl

[dreamy vale]

okay, what is everyone’s deck

[dreamy vale]

this

[dreamy vale]

or this