Based on the structure of the sentence, i don't think ''appearing'' is a right word and instead should be replaced with ''appeared''.
red venture
Based on the structure of the sentence, i don't think ''appearing'' is a right word and instead should be replaced with ''appeared''.
red venture
Edit: or alternatively there should be ''was'' after ''appearing'' to make it more sense.
bleak rain
It could be The Earliest Known Sharks Appeared