#tank-balance-discussion

1 messages · Page 98 of 1

tired sorrel
#

mhm

quick lichen
#

Also t95 and e3 have 305

ember thunder
#

Hi
My name is Salt...
I love you

tired sorrel
#

i miss them sorry @quick lichen

quick lichen
#

263 isn’t as strong as you’d think

shy wren
#

Best tank in terms of armor is the Maus. If that’s what you want

ember thunder
#

XD

shy wren
#

It’s OP because it’s easy to play and not many people have it after the 2016 Halloween event.
A good player will know how to counter it tho.

ember thunder
#

.... its not easy to play
Have u driven a maus before?

dim field
#

I think they mean helsing

shy wren
#

Wrong phrasing.
The people who play them knew how to play the Helsing
Was referring to Russian Bias

ember thunder
#

Oh..ffs

shy wren
#

I’ve played a Superheavy before, the KV-4. It’s a tricky tank to ace actually.

#

Miss it actually, since selling it for the ST-I

#

No comeback from the one who says that Helsings HO are just blatantly OP? Ok then.

jovial kernel
#

tbf it is blatantly op

shy wren
#

From my experience, not really so

jovial kernel
#

Compare it to the IS and KV-13. It does both of their jobs, but better.

quaint beacon
#

@shy wren You want him to come back?

shy wren
#

Welp, he’s back guys
9 and counting

bold zephyr
#

Slow mode is stupid balance slow mode from 45s to 20 or 15 seconds

shy wren
#

Leave the 15s to the open communication

jade cargoBOT
#

dynoSuccess Russian Bias#3128 was banned

quick lichen
#

10 @shy wren

#

I banned the French one too

shy wren
#

Hmm, he really cannot wait

quick lichen
#

Nope

thick sandal
#

Helsing is perfect tank, 63%vr, over 1k battles... slow turret is only weakness...

proven helm
#

I dont think perfect is a good term to describe it.

thick sandal
#

For me, the best tank in tier7

compact sundial
#

Gravedigger would beat it out on armor...most tanks can't pen the front and sides ;-;

prime oracle
#

Gravedigger has a sht gun

compact sundial
#

Yep, to compesate for the NUKE-proof armor is my guess

prime oracle
#

But it's kinda balanced

open hedge
#

How many times have I found myself in the middle of opposition when they don’t even show? That’s not lag.

compact sundial
#

It's a good tank for survivability in, but it also puts a GIANT target on you as a player in battle.

indigo knot
#

Is update really on 13th

jovial kernel
#

most likely

unique scaffold
#

when it fake..

obtuse bay
#

When the matchmaking will be better?

#

The actual matchmaking is very bad

unique scaffold
#

Mm is fine.

obtuse bay
#

Lol it's a Joke bro the MM is the best sh1t 1ng mm of MMO

unique scaffold
#

English please

obtuse bay
#

Sorry I speak english rarly

#

It's verry wtf 2 afk in my team in one game

jovial kernel
#

MM is completely random, what do you expect? It just cobbles together whatever people are playing those tiers.

acoustic burrow
#

One time this happened to me .. like all my team was afk and when the first enemy tank come all wake d up and i won it

#

Random match

bold zephyr
#

Please buff FV215B 183 IT NEED BETTER ENGINE WITH 5000 horse power and have 80 kph top speed and lets not forget 5s shell reload

ember thunder
#

@bold zephyr XD
IN UR DREAMS

jovial kernel
#

you forgot the 82789327498325mm pen on HESH

unique scaffold
#

Don't you mean HEAT?

jovial kernel
#

no hesh

unique scaffold
#

Oh sorry about that, my mistake

bold zephyr
#

You guys are messing the point 5k alpha

hidden solstice
#

If the fv 183 needs that then the T110E3 need armor to match ×10 because it just does

bold zephyr
#

T110E3 needs RU-251 mobility pronto

jovial kernel
#

_ _

hidden solstice
#

@bold zephyr no it needs better mobility

bold zephyr
#

And get rid of that pimple on the top the T110E3 is under powered

hidden solstice
#

It also needs the gun from the t92 hmc with the same reload it has now (the gun before the damage nerf)

bold zephyr
#

Lol is that an artelary?

hidden solstice
#

Yes from woT PC

bold zephyr
#

Yeah I have it on there lol

hidden solstice
#

Then the E3 would be balanced

bold zephyr
#

Yeah it is way under powered just like the maus it need at least 640 alpha and 500mm turret

#

And 70 kph top speed

hidden solstice
#

Wtf it's not changing what I said I can't edit it

bold zephyr
#

Slow mode it sucks

hidden solstice
#

I'm trying to say of not or

bold zephyr
#

Lol what

hidden solstice
#

What i said about the t1 it won't let me change or to of

acoustic burrow
#

Perfect tank is : Maus armor , bulldog movement , ru top speeds, jagd e 100 penetration , fv 183 damage , keny reloads and bc 25 t range spot

tired sorrel
#

Vehicle with more HP?[HorsePower}

fierce rock
#

@acoustic burrow Fun fact: M60, m48 patton and stb-1 has better view range then bc 25t.

acoustic burrow
#

Sry my bad i am not rich to have this tanks xd

fierce rock
#

@acoustic burrow You dont need to be rich to learn this informations. You can check all tanks view range from in game stats.

acoustic burrow
#

Meh for me wot armor inspector dosen t work so i am not surprissed if the game stats dosen t work :))

#

Or you mean in the game ?

fierce rock
unique scaffold
#

Pls buff VK 45.02 A its not good enough to fight vs tier 8 and 9

jovial kernel
#

It's good enough to fight tier 8 mediums

glad creek
#

So is Hellcat and Jagpanzer E100. The jg is a HEAT magnet to the face and the other tank destroyers use AP with their high pen. Hellcat is very bad in armor. It needs at least a turret boost

jovial kernel
#

If you're spotted in the open and staying still in the Hellcat you're doing it wrong.

unique scaffold
#

Bingo

jovial kernel
#

Bad Hellcat drivers are a KV-2 driver's wet dream.

glad creek
#

And the driving on the hellcat is ugh

jovial kernel
#

Have you tried not being spotted and then getting out of there the moment that light bulb pops?

glad creek
#

Yes

acoustic burrow
#

The moment when you start a match in kv 2 and in like 5 second you are still in spawn and you get spotted .... another 5 second you are dead

glad creek
#

The hard turns are difficult when I see a KV2

unique scaffold
#

This is hilarious

worthy jasper
#

Don’t you think it is pretty fun when you have a team full of Heavy tanks that decide to camp behind the TANK DESTROYERS

#

Needless to say, my team got slaughtered quicker than the prisoners in gulags

small flame
#

Hey man jokes about people in gulags aren’t very funny

static gale
#

Prisoner talking about prisoners

toxic wren
#

Buff the ms1

#

Give it a 183 gun😃

cobalt quiver
#

What do you think about the IS 3 defender?

formal spear
#

Don't u hate when u get shot when the light bulb barely shows up

unique scaffold
#

I hate that i drove today with my k91 literally 100 m from a borsig and he was in sánd river in the corner right in the open

#

I wasnt able to spot him
We nearly Lost that
I got spoted
Could not figure out he was that close to me

dreamy trail
#

Oof

plush field
#

@formal spear the light bulb comes on 3 seconds after you have been spotted.

formal spear
#

Ik

versed lark
#

That a little late for a response on that topic

formal spear
#

Ik ik ik

formal spear
#

Ok ik

plucky acorn
#

VK 45.02 A is a good tank

dusky birch
#

How is it set the match making? I wonder because I always get morons as team mates..... and opposite team are usually pretty decent.....

#

Specially lately

jovial kernel
#

It's literally random

flat maple
#

The conqueror with the type b barrel is so bad

half veldt
#

What has kept the Ke-Ni Otsu from being nerfed all this time? IIRC, WG tried to take away the tank from players when they realized it was broken, but there was a lot of outrage, so they had to return them.

What stopped them from nerfing it immediately?

late hemlock
#

I’d rather have a gun handling buff

small flame
#

I would personally very much like them adding the XM-1 or the first variant of the Abrams as a tier X premium.

#

Feel free to @ me or dm to debate it

jovial kernel
#

Ah yes, because composite armor with the mobility of the Cromwell and armor of the E 100 would totally be fair.

burnt lava
#

What about the gun? Gun of the Grille 15?

static gale
#

Ye M829 depleted uranium shot is all we need at T10 not to mention ceramic armor

unique scaffold
#

Balance ? Or not balanced ?

icy merlin
#

I’ll take balanced for 700 slav(EU)

sharp burrow
#

Who is complaining about the vk 45 a?

hollow crescent
#

It's a reliable tank, maybe a bit lack of frontal armor

sharp burrow
#

Good reload decent pen not great armour but if you can angle it it’s pretty reliable, it’s my favourite tank, I aced it in 8 games

hollow crescent
#

I've played it too, i liked it, 45 b too and maus is OP i love it

#

But i prefer my batshit

sharp burrow
#

Vk 45 b is wonderful but I can’t play it because my teammates are always bots so it just ruins my stats

hearty marsh
#

I am really not looking forward to the new tech tree changes

void patrol
#

Same

atomic hound
#

@hollow crescent ok, never again will I call that tank the batchat... 😂

hollow crescent
#

:)

sage mauve
#

hello

void patrol
#

Would anyone play the Pz I C if:
-Tier X
-Credit coeff of 180%
-1500hp
-55km/h top speed
-7.92mm MG with 290mm of pen on AP(no apcr), HE with 3mm of pen.
-40 shots per clip, 10 damage per shot for AP, 12 for HE. Clip reload 7s
-30mm front armor

upper socket
#

I would 🤷

#

400 dmg every 7 sec seems quite nice

shy wren
#

That’s 3.4k dpm

void patrol
#

Too high or not high enough?

shy wren
#

That doesn’t count burst time
If burst time is accounted for, let’s say 2s; the DPM might be 2666.67dpm

wary holly
#

is this satan

shy wren
#

Probably

#

If the burst time is 3s, the DPM would be one of the lowest at tier X, at 2400dpm

late hemlock
#

What’s the point of the HE lol

void patrol
#

How about belt fed, so 200 per clip, 10s reload? And 10s to empty one clip? MG 13 has a fire rate of 600 rounds per min, and there are 2 MGs mounted. @shy wren

#

@late hemlock Anti-Grille ammunition. Or just pegging people very quickly for track/module damage.

shy wren
#

Too OP; that’s gonna give you 6000DPM

void patrol
#

Very nice. Clear a Jpz E-100 with one clip

hearty marsh
#

Yeah we need some More OP T10 tanks bro

shy wren
#

Make that 90 rounds instead; you’ll get 2700DPM with 900dmg burst

void patrol
#

Too low. 100?

shy wren
#

3000DPM
1000Dmg per burst, 300 rounds per minute

void patrol
#

Not too bad. Comparable to TDs and not as broken as Leo. And don’t forget it has 0 armor

shy wren
#

If it has 10 shots, it’ll fire 10 rounds per tap, like the AT 7

void patrol
#

Nah. MG, not autoloader.

late hemlock
#

What if it just did hella module damage

void patrol
#

Then it achieved its purpose

true crypt
#

SU 85 was OP at one point of time

void patrol
#

how?

fiery cairn
#

Emil speed buff

true crypt
#

@void patrol cause of the DPM,DPS and speed , but since the update where the provisions were changed , its now just eh

fallow spade
#

I feel that the Is8 is underpowered, it doesn’t have enough armor to be a true heavy, but it doesn’t have enough mobility to make up for the lack of that armor. It’s dpm is ok but nothing outstanding and the health pool is kinda bad as well. It’s almost like a strict downgrade from the ST-I

brave dragon
#

I struggled with the is8 as well, fwiw

fallow spade
#

Yeah, it’s a huge struggle for anyone to get the is7 which I think is quite popular

#

Also it would be cool if they changed the name to t-10

dapper osprey
#

Any tips to play leo1?

atomic hound
#

Use bushes, snipe from mid range, move to positions with shots that are at other angles to your allies, don't trade shots.

#

Your main advantage is your mobility, make sure you don't get trapped into a position as you'll die fast.

icy merlin
#

Anyone think the AMX 13 90 should be buffed? 2/3 of it are tier 7 not tier 8.

unique scaffold
#

I agree maybe penetration 175 struggles so much against sloped armor :/

craggy dust
#

Why buffed?

atomic hound
#

Use calibrated shells, it isn't that bad, will deal with meds, most TDs, and lights frontally with little issue, if you're shooting standard rounds into the front of heavies like the e75 you're doing it wrong.

craggy dust
#

That’s the whole point use your speed against heavies

unique scaffold
#

Pouvez vous changer les horaires des tournois

#

C'est trop tôt

wispy sigil
#

Any tips for AMX 13 90 ???

ivory fractal
#

@unique scaffold English only pls

flat maple
#

pleaseeeeeeee buff the conq

#

this 83mm is literally garbage

somber mauve
#

Conqueror? It's an excellent tank at tier 9 imo. It has the best heavy tank gun (120mm) on any given heavy tank

white haven
#

like 100k exp before u get it tho

somber mauve
#

@white haven that's a reason why you save up free exp 🙃

white haven
#

so true

acoustic burrow
#

save free xp for BLITZ "Unfair"

jovial kernel
#

Blitz (un)fair

soft rune
#

meaw...

unique scaffold
#

@ivory fractalno englich

#

Sorry

sharp mantle
#

Whens 5.4 out?

unique scaffold
#

@sharp mantle about a month ago.

sharp mantle
#

Oh

#

5.5 even

plush umbra
#

i think 13 november or something like that

sharp mantle
#

Thanks, now I know I can grind the vk

shut wigeon
#

@wispy sigil Free xp it.

#

Light tanks are mostly useless in current meta.

sharp mantle
#

Oh

lean forge
#

@shut wigeon say it to my RU 251 👀

unique scaffold
#

Hat wer Bock zu. Spielen??

wet quail
#

Buff 183 😁

unique scaffold
#

@shut wigeon. Light tanks are game changing if played right.

#

The problem is that players don't play their roles. They think they can brawl a heavy in a light tank or that yoloing is the right way to go... That isn't a light tank problem it's a player education problem.

magic prism
#

when the team dies too quickly it’s almost impossible to win in a light tank. But light tanks are fantastic support vehicles

unique scaffold
#

And lights can be game changers in the end game.

I tend to aggressively scout, lure the reds towards the greens, fall back through the greens, flank around the reds, engage the best targets while trying to split / distract the reds, then when possible race in and mop up.

Lights are team dependant but at the same time they are great at setting the terms of the engagement.

stuck umbra
#

How about adding APCR gun for IS5? Just like it is with IS6?

visual nimbus
#

Lights are an essential part of the team if played right.

sharp wind
#

IS-8 is op

sharp mantle
#

Damn right

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Heavies can be game changers in the end game. There is a reason why everyone spams heavy tanks in tier 8 tournaments.

unique scaffold
#

@shut wigeon I've killed 2 mediums and a heavy in under 15 seconds in a light. There aren't many heavies that can do that.

jovial kernel
#

I'm guessing this light was french

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Maybe because they are garbage players? As i told you there is a reason why everyone spamming heavh tanks. Its meta.

unique scaffold
#

A. Tournament ≠ public matches.
B. Nobody is saying heavies aren't relevant. I'm saying that lights are relevant.
C. A good player is going to be more flexible in a med or light then they will be in a heavy.

shut wigeon
#

Good player will still play good with a sturer emil. But that doesnt mean sturer emil is an amazing tank.

Also heavy tanks have much higher winrates then light tanks.

Who cares being flexable? You will be enough flexable in an is-spam tank with god level armor.

unique scaffold
#

Are you just here to argue?

More then one type of tank can be relevant. Lights are relevant. Heavies are relevant.

deep egret
#

Hello

shut wigeon
#

Lights are underpowered compared to heavy tanks.

Im not trying to argue anything here.You are saying light tanks are fine just because you can do something in random which enemy team can be full of noobs. You arent giving any reasonable explanation. All you saying is i killed meds with my light tank so they are fine.

They arent fine. Get over it.

Even tho tier 7 lights are utter garbage with some exceptions.

unique scaffold
#

The majority of the lights are acceptable. They play their role fine. If they were buffed so that the average 40%er could do well in them you'd have games where a 60%er would own any match they played in them.

dusky wolf
#

while seeing some bois playing speedies like TD and camps far behind

#

even there's 2-3 HT in squad, and all of them still acts like TD.

unique scaffold
#

lights aren't underpowered, its just harder to use it correctly than heavies

dusky wolf
#

TBH, why don't those bois buy a TD instead using non-TD tanks and acting like a true TD player.

unique scaffold
#

Im suprised that no one spoke about meds yet

dusky wolf
#

For me, meds are literally supersized LTs. but somewhat well balanced.

unique scaffold
#

The leopard (Tier V) is a fat light

dusky wolf
#

A LT secretly working out, same as VK 28.01.

unique scaffold
#

Some german meds are bigger than some heavies

shut wigeon
#

Most fair thing to do for tier 7 is buffing all light tanks hp to 1150 same as type62 and along with it amx 13 75,t71, spıc needs another buff to their gun or mobility. Also amx 13 57 needs its camo rating fixed its unusable now.

When it comes to tier 8 Ru251 could use some mobility buff(Dont tell me it has amazing mobility with 80 kmh top speed, it has garbage p/w ratio which leads takes forever to reach that speed.) and amx 13 90 could use some reload speed to magazine it takes so much time which leads crappy dpm.

@dusky wolf Mediums are not well balanced in tier 8. Some of them have the worst overall winrates.

unique scaffold
#

The IS-8 is a light tank
The maus is a medium

dusky wolf
#

i guess i went T-54/Type 59 went too far also tier 9 leopard prototype.

shut wigeon
#

T54 mod 1 and 59 are well performing meds. While panther 2 has awfull winrates compared to them.

unique scaffold
#

Players inability to play them does not necessarily mean they are bad tanks.

shut wigeon
#

If they were viable pros would use them in tournaments.

unique scaffold
#

If I put a 5 year old behind the wheel of a Infiniti Q50 that doesn't make it a bad car.

#

And once again ...

Tournaments ≠ Public matches

shut wigeon
#

Tournaments=Most viable tactics only=Heavy spam.

unique scaffold
#

Irrelevant to public matches

dusky wolf
#

A master knows how to use bad stuff to against/tilt the odds and conquer or creating more win oppotunity.

cyan vine
#

I think Some lower Glacis on some tanks need to be buffed

dusky wolf
#

Bad driver having good car, maybe it seems good. but still wasted most of it's best protential.

cyan vine
#

(Fv215B and E100 cough cough) AMX AC 48 needs a buff on top hatch

shut wigeon
#

It does. In randoms still heavy spam is the most efective tactic. If your team has more heavies then other team (especially when your team filled with is-spam tanks) you have higher chances to win that match.

dusky wolf
#

If you had deep pocket like spoiled kiddo that stole parents credits card, yea...

#

And panther 2 would be a sad MT since it's more like a mobile TD but low pen and not that fast also too tall to hide the body.

#

long 88 seems good, but it just makes panther like prone to snipe only.

shut wigeon
#

Panther 2 and panther 8.8 needs 8.8cm kwk l100 gun from e50m. With that buff both panthers can do their job with much more effiency.

unique scaffold
#

I've seen matches where the MM puts 4 lights against 4 heavies. This was in tier VIII and the lights tore the heavies apart. Superior view range and the ability hit, reposition, and hit again won the game with ease.

I've got other things to do. To say lights aren't relevant is ridiculous.

I haven't been playing much lately because I've been busy and I'm kind of burned out on the game but I'm sitting at a 74% average win-rate in my high tier lights right now.

Seems relevant to me.

jovial kernel
#

Here's a rule. If I can do well in a light tank, then that light tank is too good.

dusky wolf
#

Besides panthers overall armor just saying i am target pratice, pls hit me hard and end my suffering asap.

main vine
#

I’d much rather play a tier 7 light than a tier 7 heavy

lone warren
#

id rather not play tier 7. lol

main vine
#

^ that too

jovial kernel
#

the Aufklarungspanzer Panther would be a neat addition to the game

dusky wolf
#

i'd brings KV-2/SU-152 with 152 derps to send tier 7 lights to GULAG.

shy wren
#

Lights are fun to play; you’ll have to adapt to a steep learning curve to master them

lone warren
#

Ru is one of my most played such a good tank i love it

dusky wolf
#

While there's T-54 ltwt that got more T H I C C armor than most MTs in tier 8

shut wigeon
#

"I've seen matches where the MM puts 4 lights against 4 heavies. This was in tier VIII and the lights tore the heavies apart. Superior view range and the ability hit, reposition, and hit again won the game with ease."

Those doesnt work against skilled heavy drivers because they can easily predict which place you come. Also you need to aim very carefully to pen them while they dont even need to aim at all.

Even if this possible tier 8 tournaments would be filled with full of light tanks. Thats NOT possible thats why they dont use them. It seems working in theory but not works in action.

Also that list only have 5 battles with them. So its not proving anything.

main vine
#

But assuming both drivers are of equal skill, the light driver can use the mobility and camo to create a significant advantage over the heavy tank

unique scaffold
#

@main vine. Bingo. This guy has heavy blinders on🤣

dusky wolf
#

As long as not those RNG with IS series spaced armor

shy wren
#

5 battles? You must’ve forgotten that the ltwt is also tier VIII

unique scaffold
#

the guy must really have something agaisnt light/mt 🤣

dusky wolf
#

Which it's truly broken LT for me so far. i mean look at that turret armor, better than most MTs in tier 8

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Im not against the lights. Im against the damn HEAVY SPAM thats why i want buff for them.

unique scaffold
#

so you have something agaisnt mt?

main vine
#

what

unique scaffold
#

lights are perfectly fine IMO

fallow spade
#

Why would you buff something that’s spammed already

shut wigeon
#

@fallow spade Who spams light tanks?

dusky wolf
#

so... asking buffing heavies?

fallow spade
#

Oh wait, you meant buff the lights?

unique scaffold
#

he mean buff lights

#

If you noticeably buff the lights they are going to become massively over powered in the hands of a good player.

prisma dune
#

@unique scaffold The more experienced I get the more I prefer the flexibility of meds. Heavies can be too one trick pony sometimes. Meds just can make themselves relevant by getting to critical positions as critical times of battle. I’m still a heavy centric player.

shy wren
#

RU already have very good DPM
T49 has derp
AMX has 675 clip potential
ltwt has armor
Don’t think they really need a buff; they fill their niches quite well

shut wigeon
#

Thats why i want a slight buff. I dont want them to be overpowered either.

unique scaffold
#

it's already pretty good in the hands of good player, if you are saying it's bad then it's really the driver not the tank

dusky wolf
#

i guess MT truly needed buff according to those LT traits especially Panther 2. Heavies? maybe not those IS series

unique scaffold
#

he only want the buff for LT not MT somehow

"FordToday at 06:52
@B_Huff [FEAST] Im not against the lights. Im against the damn HEAVY SPAM thats why i want buff for them."

lone warren
#

imagine if ru gets buff pfft

prisma dune
#

@lone warren I’d still yolo in it. Lol

jovial kernel
#

RU gets HESH as well

shut wigeon
#

@shy wren Ru is extremely big target and its p/w ratio isnt very great.

T49 is fine.

675 clip potential doesnt back up its disadvantages.

Ltwt is fine.

lone warren
#

RU gets 100mm more of HE pen

jovial kernel
#

"RU" "extremely big" found the ELC driver

timid glen
#

shuddum and shoot somfin

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel Ru hep is mostly useless against is-spam tanks. Every game is filled with full of is-spam tanks.

lone warren
#

Ru isnt that big its kinda low profile turrets not that big just keep moving at 70-80

unique scaffold
#

that's not true ru is pretty good if you use it correctly like any other tanks

timid glen
#

wow this channel is insane. i had to disable my voice to lolz

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Being possible doesnt make it balanced.

jovial kernel
#

The RU's HE shells don't work on the sides of IS tanks because they have spaced armor. Try aiming through the tracks.

unique scaffold
#

you are obviously not using it correctly that why you think its not balanced?

lone warren
#

so many scrubs drive the ru though and die in 1 second flat a little piece of me dies everytime i see this

shy wren
#

If anything, the TT Mediums are the ones that are a bit underpowered

jovial kernel
#

And how is the RU "extremely large" u wat

dusky wolf
#

Mediums are not well balanced in tier 8. Some of them have the worst overall winrates. As Ford said.

lone warren
#

If the ru is massive then the Spic must be larger than a maus

shut wigeon
jovial kernel
#

If you think the RU is massive you have never driven any Centurion tank or the CDC.

unique scaffold
#

ru isn't balanced is seriously ridiculous imo

lone warren
#

ru251 is god

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Ru has garbage overall winrates. Explain this then if you think its petfectly balanced.

jovial kernel
#

The RU has bad win rates because noobs yolo and get blapped.

unique scaffold
#

just because players can't use it correctly doesn't mean the tank is not balanced?

#

@shut wigeon you aren't getting it. A good light driver relies on map knowledge, situational awareness, and a general knowledge of tactics to play well. There is no way to buff a light tank to make a 40%er have this knowledge and if you were to try you would make the tank an absolute beast in the hands of a good player.

shy wren
#

A good player knows how abuse it’s strengths
A bad player typically yolos

lone warren
#

^ exactly the ru is an op af tank in the right player

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Then explain m8 why good players doesnt use them?

jovial kernel
#

It's like saying autoloaders are bad because noobs don't know how to use them.

shy wren
#

I don’t have RU yet; got ltwt. It’s fun

dusky wolf
#

Except paper armor, speedy and firepowers speaks opposite. And i would say tier rushing skrubs keep farming exp from it.

unique scaffold
#

maybe they don't feel like it? maybe they are too lazy to grind it? there's so many reasons that people don't play a tank but the tank itself is balanced

lone warren
#

@shy wren u should get ru if ur not a bot its very fun and not that much grind

shy wren
#

Hating the SP 1c atm, rage sold it

dusky wolf
#

for me, i grind tier 8 premiums for extra creds more than using other tier 8 non prems

jovial kernel
#

If you want noobs to do well, give every single 40%er a WZ-120-1 FT. They simply won't do well in a light tank because they can't hold themselves back from over using their speed.

shut wigeon
#

@shy wren Spıc is utterly garbage.

lone warren
#

I’d take my ru over many tier 8 mediums or other lights

jovial kernel
#

I bet that if you gave the IS-3 the RU 251's speed, noobs would do worse because they would rush, be surrounded, and killed.

unique scaffold
#

Good players do use them.

Plenty are on here telling you that right now.

Either way I'm done. Don't ping me again.

shy wren
#

That was 9 months ago, haven’t bought it back, so Idk about now.

dusky wolf
#

or Giving AT-15/T28 that ru speed. prob ended up in ram only

lone warren
#

i think maus should get ru mobility

jovial kernel
#

It's entirely because noobs think speed=yolo

shut wigeon
#

They rather use is-5 or löwe over a ru251.

unique scaffold
#

I don't think you get the point

timid glen
#

use guys should get in a tank and fight about it

mossy cipher
#

i think the t43 needs at least a better gun

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Good players can make st emil work. Does that make st emil fine?

shy wren
#

You do forget that those are premium credit grinders, not a TT tank; the RU has one of the worst credit coefficient

lone warren
#

^

shy wren
#

Most LTs tend to have terrible credit coefficients at higher tiers

lone warren
#

smh why im always broke i drive three fvs and a fully equipped ru

shut wigeon
#

@shy wren Most of those players already have millions of credits so money grind isnt the explanation for it.

And yeah ru251 has one of the worst credit coefficent. Lets punish players more for using underperforming tanks.

unique scaffold
#

Irrelevant. And ru isn't even underperforming tank... it's one of the best tier 8 lol.. good player do use it as well for me as example and no I don't even have millions of credit when I play it

shy wren
#

That’s their choice of playing; people have different preferences; some like slow, lumbering heavies with tons of armor, some like the speedy demons

shut wigeon
#

@unique scaffold Thats why everyone spams is-spam tanks in tier 8 right?

jovial kernel
#

Also the T-54 ltwt is not fine. If you look at the average player stats, it beats the T-44 in everything but average survival %

shy wren
#

Also GD; T-44 has -7°

unique scaffold
#

it can still perform well even with is spam....

shut wigeon
#

It doesnt make it balanced just because it can.

shy wren
#

At tier VIII, all tech tree mediums loses out to DPM meds of tier VII and IX.

jovial kernel
#

I mean you claimed the T-54 ltwt is fine, but it's clearly not considering it's just outperforming the T-44 in everyone's hands.

lone warren
#

The ru is fine where it is.. if it gets buffed anymore you will suddenly see the ru dominating the mm because it will be op

dusky wolf
#

Most tier 8 LTs are between borderline OP and fine, and MTs are truly need some buff than other classes do.

shy wren
#

They do gain more alpha and armor, but their DPM is lackluster

jovial kernel
#

actually the T-54 ltwt has more alpha than most tier 8 mediums

shut wigeon
dusky wolf
#

T-54 ltwt 100mm gun which makes tier 8 mts like a joke.

unique scaffold
#

I actually like how he use blitzstar to claim that a tank is worse than another tank

jovial kernel
#

Stats from the last couple days actually matters more. It better reflects the tank in the current meta.

shy wren
#

The T-44 too
I was referring to the overall tier; at tier VII, medium tanks run guns ranging from the 7.5cm to the 100mm. At tier VIII, it ranges from the 84mm to the 122mm

unique scaffold
#

Players go to heavy tanks because they are dependable. Comparing a heavy to the ru is like comparing a Honda to a high end sports car.

Anyone can drive a Honda to nearly it's full potential. The same can't be said about the sports car.

jovial kernel
#

actually it ranges from an 84mm to a 122mm because the Centurion 1's 20 pdr is an 84mm gun

lone warren
#

I hated the cent I thank god i had the tier nine discount

jovial kernel
#

If you want to see decent tanks that people suck at driving, there's the Centurion 1 for you. A lot of good players say it's either great or average at least, but people including me suck at driving it.
You see the exact same effect in the Caernarvon.

shut wigeon
#

Players plays with heavy tanks because its meta.Even the most succesfull players i see were all using heavy tanks or tds. There is a reason why you cant see an %70 player using a ru251 because they know its not a good tank to play with.

@jovial kernel Cent is underpowered.

unique scaffold
#

I hated the Centurion... But ♥️ the 7/1.

jovial kernel
#

Fine then look at the Caernarvon

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel Caern, tiger 2 and vk 45 02p are currently the worst tier 8 heavies.

unique scaffold
#

I guess its depend on how you define succesfull player really

sharp wind
#

Caer and the VK452 are op

shy wren
#

The guns on the British tanks destroy Russian tanks, as they can pen IS tanks like a knife through hot butter

jovial kernel
#

The Caernarvon literally has armor, dpm, mobility, and penetration. People just suck in it because they get into situations where good IS-5 drivers force them into shot trades.

shy wren
#

Tiger II all depend on your ability to sidescrape and using that gun to good use
Vk 45.02 A can be a heavy flanker

dusky wolf
#

most of Caernarvon i know shows their bellys.

lone warren
#

90% of people i see driving the caer dont know wtf they are doing lmao goes for alot of british tanks tbh

sharp wind
#

Never sidescrape in VK452

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel Caern only has some armor on its upper plate and turret front. Anywhere apart from this has garbage armor.

jovial kernel
#

Have you considered that there's this thing called a "hull down position"

lone warren
#

whats the gun depression like on the caern again(

sharp wind
#

Caer requires use of map knowledge a concept I can see that you lack

late hemlock
#

-10

shy wren
#

British tanks tbf have pretty steep learning curves, that’s why people struggle with them; not recommended for newer players

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel Did you heard t-34? T-34 hulldowns much better then caern why even i should bother with caern?

lone warren
#

@shy wren tell me about it... first two lines i did were brit tds and heavies

unique scaffold
#

Guys, Ford knows what he knows and won't hear anything you say. Just let him be.

shy wren
#

F.
I started out with the Russian KV line @lone warren

sharp wind
#

A caer can pen a hull down T34, you are just proving your lack of knowledge. Because a T-34 is a Soviet tier 5 which definitely doesn’t go hull down well

lone warren
#

Tbh i think it was nice that i went for the british tanks first, it was harder for me but i learnt the game and became decent with the nation and only play their tier tens now pretty much

dusky wolf
#

Which T 34? T34 on tier 8? or T-34 on tier 5?

burnt lava
#

They mean the American Premium Heavy tank, the tier 8 T34. Caer would never be matched with a tier 5 tank....

#

Logic people....

shut wigeon
#

@sharp wind Wow. Im done with this.

@unique scaffold You didnt explained anything yet. Lights arent okay just because you killed another underpowered tank.

dusky wolf
#

I would like to see a T-34 user out smarted a caernarvron skrub.

unique scaffold
#

I agree, just let him be

shy wren
#

The guns on a British tank are accurate and have high penetration to compensate for their lack of alpha. They can easily demolish the hull of the T34 or hit the hatch reliably

shut wigeon
#

Hatch is not visiable when t34 is using its gun depression.
@shy wren

sharp wind
#

The apcr will pen the cheeks of a T34

jovial kernel
#

Lets not forget the Caern literally has the most health and dpm of tier 8 heavies at the same time, and is one of the most mobile too.

unique scaffold
#

What part of "don't ping me" is so hard to understand?

I posted my last 27 games in high tier lights over the past 30 days with a 74% win-rate. Let's see your high tier heavy stats for the past 30 days.

shut wigeon
jovial kernel
#

That's not a penetration map that's a normal armor map.

lone warren
#

lol

shy wren
#

Area just above the mantlet is pennable by a British gun

shut wigeon
sharp wind
#

Child don’t educate me on a tank that I’m at least top 100 in

lone warren
#

what kind of bot would try to challenge a hull down t34 anyway

shut wigeon
#

@lone warren @sharp wind saying caern can beat a hulldowning t34.

shy wren
#

Using a T29 as the hulldown tank (same armor profile like T34, minus the ears), pennable with APCR

jovial kernel
#

Actually the T34 has a 200mm plate on the turret bustle but that's besides the point

shy wren
sharp wind
#

Gun on the T34 is slightly higher and you can pen right under neath the gun as well

shy wren
#

That’s true; haven’t bought the IAP on Armor Inspector to prove that with a British gun, hence using the T29 as a placeholder

jovial kernel
#

Personally I would have used the T30 as the placeholder but 🤷
oh wait tier 9 and 10 are blocked off with premiums right

sharp wind
#

And I only played the Caer before it was buffed twice

shy wren
#

@jovial kernel rip

jovial kernel
#

I need to buy that bundle :/

lone warren
#

my ms1 can beat t34 hulldown

shy wren
#

Same; that app is quite useful

jovial kernel
#

Google opinion rewards gib more surveys thanks

late hemlock
shy wren
#

Yep, that’s it; the T29 has a pretty similar armor profile anyways

jovial kernel
#

Basically the same model other than the turret back and ears

shut wigeon
#

T29 doesnt have the same effective turret armor value as t34. Nice try.

jovial kernel
#

The T34's model was literally just posted by r4zerbl4de

shy wren
shut wigeon
#

@shy wren I tolf efective armor not the armor thickness.

jovial kernel
#

It's the same armor at the same angles dude lmao

dry thorn
#

Even tho I love the kv2, I think it needs a rebalance, just saying

late hemlock
#

A caern should not try to out hull-down a T34. It should rush it and utilize its DPM against the T34’s long reload

jovial kernel
#

Or just play the medium flank and just outbully those guys and push the T34 later

lone warren
#

@dry thorn yeah probably

shut wigeon
worthy jasper
#

Who still has a Gravedigger?

shy wren
jovial kernel
#

I was playing and it got down to a 1v1 between a full health IS-3 and a Caern who was having trouble connecting at the start, and he was trying to trade shots. Guess what, and props to this guy, I tell the Caern to push and use his dpm. The Caern moves up and just outright bloody shreds the IS-3 because it has almost 600 more dpm than the IS-3 and started the fight with 1600 hp and not 1500.

shy wren
#

Factor in normalization; that’s an easy pen

shut wigeon
#

@shy wren Lol the pictures that shows cheeks isnt even looking to us.

jovial kernel
#

He's trying to prove they have basically the same armor model, not prove the pens.

shy wren
shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel They dont have same efective armor. Caern can pen t29 cheeks but not t34.

late hemlock
#

Guys it really doesn’t matter lol. Don’t even know what you’re arguing about

lone warren
#

This discussion has lost all meaning

jovial kernel
#

Someone mentioned that it was possible to kill a hull down T34 with Caern prammo and Ford kept trying to say the T29 used as a placeholder turret was different compared to the T34's (It only is if you count the mantlet shape and turret rear plate) because he realized he can't prove that he's right.

shy wren
#

@lone warren from LTs to HTs to similar tanks

shut wigeon
#

They are saying caern is amazing hulldown tank. then i sad why would i bother witg caern when i can use t34. Some of them told caern can hulldowning t34 and here we are. @late hemlock

late hemlock
#

They both have different strengths? They have different play styles so you can’t compare them too well

lone warren
#

Bother with caern because any non-bot will just use the mobility and dpm and force the t34 to move

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel For gods sake t34 turret cheeks are way more angled then t29 turret cheeks. Caern cant pen a hulldowning t34.

jovial kernel
#

We never said the Caer was amazing at hull down, I said it was a good tank that people just can't drive, you said it was one of the 3 worst tier 8 heavies.
The T34 and T29 have the same cheek angles.

late hemlock
#

Any good caern player will just aim for the cupola, end of story. No need to aim at the cheeks

lone warren
#

honestly u guys are saying the same things over and over again lmao

shy wren
#

The turret on the Caernarvon is not the best, but it’s still pretty bouncy

shut wigeon
shy wren
#

Use armor inspector; we don’t know where you’re highlighting
You might be focusing on a different part of the tank

late hemlock
#

Alright I’m gonna leave, you guys have fun with your discussion

jovial kernel
#

Tap the spaced armor to get rid of those ears, most people wouldn't be able to tell them apart.

#

Fine, I'll prove this later, I'll take my Centurion 1 (which has the same penetration values as the Caer) and someone with a T34 and I'll record where you can pen that turret. Also the original argument was that APCR pens that, so I'll have that loaded.

shy wren
#

Make sure the T34 uses a contrasting camo to make it easier to see the pennable spot for your test

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel Apcr can pen t29 not t34.

jovial kernel
#

hmm I wonder what that forehead triangle is

shut wigeon
jovial kernel
#

Well a 20 pdr can tag those weaker spots with apcr ez

shy wren
#

Take a look at a sliver of orange just to the right of the T34 gun mantlet

shut wigeon
#

@shy wren Good luck hitting that part constantly from a range more then 50 meters.

sharp wind
#

You can hit it 6/10 times

jovial kernel
#

I mean the same can be said for the T29 turret

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel T29 was never in our comparision. Some guy put it just because he thinks they have same armor profile.

jovial kernel
#

They for the most part do

#

And besides if this is a 1v1 situation the Cearnarvon can always just rush and unload 2600 dpm into that big juicy hull

shut wigeon
#

@jovial kernel Yes caern can do that no doubt about that. However this arguement for the guy says "Caern can beat t34 on hulldown" arguement.

jovial kernel
#

I'm pretty sure he meant it's pennable not it does hull down better

shut wigeon
#

If im gonna hulldown i would use t34.Or at least t32. Why would i bother with caern?

jovial kernel
#

maybe you were forced to given the situation

shut wigeon
#

Not really. No one forces people to grind fv215b line.

shy wren
#

Unless if you’re grinding it; you’re forcing yourself if you hate the tank

#

What he meant was that he’s forced to be in a spot where you have to get hulldown. The upper glacis plate on the Caernarvon can bounce shots, unlike the Americans, the British turret is weaker, but still very bouncy.

drowsy plaza
#

The roof/cupola of the T34 is an easy pen for the Caern.

#

Even with AP.

#

The T32 turret is significantly tougher than the T34, if you want a great hull down tier 8 tank.

shy wren
#

The person above was trying to bash me because I was using the T29 as a template for the armor profile on Armor Inspector instead of the T34 (both have very similar turrets), which is due to me not having the pen IAP @drowsy plaza
Hence the arguments that ensued

drowsy plaza
#

Ah

unique scaffold
#

It all started with someone saying lights aren't relevant...

jovial kernel
#

And then it went to people saying that lights just get driven badly, which went to me mentioning the Caernarvon being a "misunderstood" tank, then going to someone saying the Caernarvon can pen the T34's turret cheeks with APCR, which then went to that being misread as "The Cearnarvon does hull down better than the T34" which then in the process of using the armor models becoming "The T34 has a stronger turret than the T29" which is wrong frontally because they're basically the same at the front, which then ended with this.

vocal verge
#

im wondering if they will ever put in the polish and Swedish tanks in

jovial kernel
#

Swedish is rumored to be next year, but I want the polish more tbh. I like big tickers

iron falcon
#

If they add the Japanese heavies imma die...

vocal verge
#

They should add rap heavies though but probably decrease penetration or increase reload so lights may live. I think the the polish heavies would be fun.

#

The czech tvp would be so fun

shy wren
#

Czechs might come next year

vocal verge
#

that would be awesome. they should add artillery but just convert them to massive derp tank destroyers with slow slow reload that ark a tiny bit so it can slightly lob over small ridges and stuns

shy wren
#

Stun? No
Derp TD? Possible. But they have to have a bit less HP than their counterparts

vocal verge
#

true they shouldn't one shot at least at low tiers but maybe at high tiers against lights and lightly armored med

#

The italian meds would make the game more variable though over the polish sweds or czechs because of their weird auto loaders

severe valve
#

can we buff clippers

#

what's the point if you can't even connect on target with half the damn shots. Forget penning them, how about connecting them?

vocal verge
#

@oak sandal spg are and integral part of the original game and they make the game more interesting. they dont do much damage but their stun helps a ton and @severe valve Clippers???

severe valve
#

yeah clippers. what is point having 3s intra when it misses anyway

vocal verge
#

you mean stun by spg?

#

because if you miss its your fault and splash damage by spg are significant if you are hitting a med or light or light sneaky td

vocal verge
#

Spgs are campers legitimately and sneaky tank destroyers should camp while lights med and heavys spot for it

formal spear
shy wren
#

F

wicked needle
#

You should turn on supremacy

deep pike
#

f

pseudo grail
#

F

flat bane
#

F

burnt lava
#

F

ember thunder
#

U

deep pike
#

C

dusky wolf
#

Is that some sort of sorcereh?

stray rock
#

F

tawny finch
#

the KV4 needs a buff

shy wren
#

It’s fine as it is, good AP pen, excellent APCR pen, great DPM, great gun handling on 107mm gun, heavy, slow and well armored

little crest
#

F

unique scaffold
#

Player ?

willow junco
#

What are you planning for "BLACK FRIDAY"

unique scaffold
#

Nothing

indigo knot
#

When is the "black friday"

lapis shadow
#

No idea

summer plume
#

23 Nov?

ember thunder
#

@tawny finch it needs a buff of armour on the top turret of the normal turret..the big weakspot
Rest is OP

severe flame
#

Katyusha sakai

tribal plume
#

23 of Nov black friday

shy wren
#

@ember thunder that has 180 on the front and side cheeks on the upper turret

ember thunder
#

No...any tier 8 and above can pen it easily

#

Its sometimes very irritating when players hit u there EVERYTIME AND U CANT DO ANYTHING

#

Hmm but...its ok if u wiggle it

unique scaffold
#

WG why are u killing MM

#

Mm is fine

#

not at all

#

Explain

ember thunder
#

Its not fine

unique scaffold
#

Your explanation is lacking. Explain what is "not fine" about it.

hybrid sage
#

Everything

unique scaffold
#

in ranking battles u always get like stupid teammates who doing always the opposite what u say

#

Why should a player listen to you?

#

I've said this before but here we go again.

A good player wins despite what mm throws at them.

A bad player loses and then blames mm.

modern rapids
#

Nothing wrong with MM

#

@unique scaffold what's wrong with it?

formal spear
#

@unique scaffold no it is not

#

It takes to dam long like the world wars combined.

dapper osprey
#

The FV 183 was behind a wall and I was in leo, wasn’t spotted until he shot

unique scaffold
#

Okay champ. I'm not the one whining about mm without giving any actual reasons.

shy wren
#

Hey, language @Im called Pepe#4402

remote valley
#

nt sure abt language but im guessing he got the boot

limpid elm
#

Lol.

glad creek
#

They should remove that way from VK 45 to Maus in 5.5 completely though

shy wren
#

Ah yes, didn’t realize that the tag wasn’t working

limpid elm
#

@glad creek You might wanna change your name.

shy wren
#

@glad creek they shouldn’t; people are still grinding the Maus through the Vk as of right now

glad creek
#

I know I was copying someone else's name

#

I have to wait until they allow me to change it

remote valley
#

@glad creek nah its better to replace the maus with pz 72.01k to ensure greater consistency in the line plus they still trying to follow suit to the content they have in WOT PC

unique scaffold
#

Can you stop copying my name lol

remote valley
#

go figures wondering whose name he was copying lol

limpid elm
#

No wonder it looks so familiar....

unique scaffold
#

I do have that symbol but in another server

soft flax
unique scaffold
#

Bot team

soft flax
#

I cry alone...

ember thunder
#

@unique scaffold now that statement is false
You must know this
"A leader is nothing without a team"

quick lichen
#

The only constant in every game you play, is you @ember thunder

#

There’s a reason for 30% and 70% players. Skill. Not mm

#

Take off the tin foil hats guys

brittle river
#

Cant expect everyone to be skillful. Thats why good matchmaking logic makes better gameplay experience.

limpid elm
#

@brittle river Not exactly, every small advantage over the opposing team comes from every decision you make from the get-go. From choosing to flank, escape and even which tank you are driving and supremacy mode.

brittle river
#

I agree that. Several factors indeed.

limpid elm
#

I actually don't really enjoy the new mm.

brittle river
#

Im gonna watch live stream. See you later @limpid elm :)

limpid elm
#

Advantage with tank types are at most 2. Not exactly good when you know it's disadvantaged in your team from numbers but your team decides to go your flank.

brittle river
#

Hmm

limpid elm
#

And then the heavies throw hate your way for dying in like 2 mins.

drowsy plaza
#

Good players see MM as a challenge, poor players blame MM. As @quick lichen mentioned, you are the only constant -- everyone gets the same teams over time, what you can do with those teams means the difference. Yes it can be frustrating when you draw a total lemon team, and the red team is not a bunch of potatoes -- but the randomness of the game is part of the draw, and challenge -- those games are where the aces, and the RAS, Pools etc come from -- rise to the challenge.

limpid elm
#

Well said.

quick lichen
#

If you ever thought your mm was bad, look here

unique scaffold
#

I like the one on the left.

plush trellis
#

XD

west zealot
#

I'm gonna miss my Pz IV shooting VK Leo with 400dmg per shoot in the next update

midnight tendon
#

I like the one on the right but the mm is great

spring pelican
#

@quick lichen you in that team?

quick lichen
#

@midnight tendon if only you knew 😂

spring pelican
#

the fact that all 3 are blond, that means WG wants to get more men players

quick lichen
#

Well that’s rather sexist

spring pelican
#

did you see that letter "S" they pronnounce like letter "Z"

quick lichen
#

Back to balance discussion

spring pelican
#

yea lets go, PLS BUFF 183

#

evile smile

wicked needle
#

Group A seems tough

balmy token
#

When's the gravedigger getting nerfed

sharp wind
#

When enough data is gathered and is determined whether or not a nerf/buff is needed.

sharp mantle
#

It does seem a bit OP

unique scaffold
#

Meh. Gravedigger is nothing special.

sharp mantle
#

Well the armours pretty good

unique scaffold
#

So shoot it where it's not.

atomic hound
#

I've found it needs to be played extremely aggressively to be effective, if you play it safe, you'll do no damage because the gun can't hit weakspots at anything but point blank, and the turret is a huge weak spot to tier 8s. I have got it over 70% over 70 games solo, so it certainly isn't bad

sharp mantle
#

Yeah, but it gets annoying when you fight it I'm a t6 and it pumps 400 dmg before you can react

jovial kernel
#

I bet the KV-1S is fun to play against then

atomic hound
#

If it pushes hard on a tier 6, that tier 6 is utterly screwed. The only tank in the tier that can reliably pen it is the arl44 (and they are annoying), but you can clear one in 2 clips

sharp mantle
#

Yeah, the ARL's 212 pen is epic

unique fulcrum
#

@quick lichen LOOOL you cant expect hot models when majority of the players are of shape unattractive nerds.

quick lichen
#

That wasn’t what I was saying or my point

unique fulcrum
#

LOOOOL ooops

elfin heath
#

That tourney tree looks rough.

stoic pebble
#

Does anyone think that the T-44-100 needs a gun depression buff, or a buff in general? I have heard many people on other servers say that it's one of the worst T8 premiums and I'd like to hear what everyone here thinks.

jovial kernel
#

It's balanced is the problem. The T-44-100 isn't bad, just all the other tier 8 prems are good.

stoic pebble
#

The T-44-100 is what a premium should be - worse than the tech tree counterpart in some way, but has a gimmick that makes it work. In the case for the 44-100, it gives up a large chunk of engine power and -2 degrees of gun depression to gain 8mm side skirts.

#

However, I would much rather play a T-54 proto because that thing is a T-44 with more armor and around T-44-100 mobility

jovial kernel
#

Mod 1 has bad dpm

stoic pebble
#

100 less DPM for 2 more degrees of depression is something I would give up.

severe valve
#

gravediffer is already overdue for an armor nerf

jovial kernel
#

I think the armor is fine, just remove the recoil so the lower plate doesn't keep moving up and down so you can't hit it.

#

Honestly I'm fine with fighting those tanks other than that issue

zealous citrus
#

can i get YOUTUBERS role because i m also a you tuber?

strong depot
warm flicker
#

Yes, also frustrating

strong depot
#

i want to rage, cry and trashtalk right now

#

this is balanc discussion so balance matchmaker

cloud wadi
#

Nope, it's reality 😂

strong depot
#

matchmaker is like: F.. u, u will not win this match

minor grail
#

T-44-100 I is average tank but need buff

quick lichen
#

@strong depot what is wrong with mm?

strong depot
#

everything

dry thorn
#

It alright

strong depot
#

they have 4 players > 60% wr and rest >50% while my team all under 50%

dry thorn
#

Hard to find games sometimes

strong depot
#

can still give me some players who actually know anything about the game

#

there was no way we/i could win that match

#

and this is not the first time

cloud wadi
#

And also not the last one, tbh. But I'm sure u don't check enemy stats same way when you win that battles. U know it's not always sooo bad, don't you?

stoic pebble
#

... When did they nerf the Pz. Sfl IVc's gun elevation? It's literally impossible to play the tank :^)

strong depot
#

i know

#

i'm allowed to check stats when all under 500 dmg and make conclusion no?

wind gust
#

Oof

tired sorrel
#

Im starting to hate this game cuz of unrealistic tanks

daring island
#

play in tier 8/9 and murder them with realistic tanks?

quick lichen
#

@strong depot so you’re telling me you’ve never been on the winning side of this?

#

It’s always your skill that wins every game?

strong depot
#

u know what i'm talking about

#

what is it, ur gonna blame me i get a little annoyed because i'm trying to win a battle ?

quick lichen
#

You’re the only constant in every game you’re in

#

There’s a reason why players are 30%ers and 70%ers

strong depot
#

so u mean u have absolutely no idea what i'm talking about

#

u know what, screw it. Matchmaker is perfectly fine every battle.

shut wigeon
#

Matchmaker uses rng. Thats why sometimes you get losing streaks or winning streaks. If it would use Prng you wouldnt get those streaks. Prng simply wont allow you to match with %70 unicum or %40 garbage player consecutively.

#

I have access to more then one accounts and i can clearly say i dont feel any mm difference between a wallet warrior account and a freemium account.

woeful tendon
#

Make kpfpz realistic, can not possibly go wrong g

#

Composite armor, gun velo, round types, speed... Kpfpz definitely needs to be realistic

shy wren
#

Please no

woeful tendon
#

Y not?? Its not like an MBT could possibly be OP in a game based mostly off WW2

#

but it does need a buff... The most modern of any tank in game and has lowest DPM of any t9 heavy... And drastically so

shy wren
#

It just needs a slightly better RoF. That tank has the highest alpha of all tier IX heavy tanks

woeful tendon
#

And still lowest DPM by far... E 75 is only tank that gets close

winged barn
#

It is not that different from a kv-1s
It just has an armored turret to go with it

solar river
#

Does anyone else think that the Predator could use a little depression buff?
I mean it's almost impossible to fight some tanks at even medium distance.

Not even an alpha or armor or pen buff, just a little bit of more depression.

west zealot
#

Huge tall tank with Russian depression is kinda sucks indeed. Grave also have awful depression for a tall and huge tank.

solar river
#

The main problem with predator is that it has its gun on the highest point possible.

That's like gravedigger having its gun on the literal roof of the turret

late hemlock
#

@winged barn except the kv1s doesn’t have issues penning most things it sees, while the kpfpz has pretty bad pen for its tier

solar river
#

the kampfpanzer hits like a truck tho.
It can 3 shot basically anything that isn't a maus.

#

That thing is obviously meant to bully meds and lights just like predator and grave and original is6

icy merlin
#

Pls tell me what the match maker is getting fixed in the update!!

robust haven
#

Matchmaking will never be fixed in any game

solar river
#

Tbh instead of wishing for the matchmaking to be fixed i just kinda started to let go of the obsession with winrate. God knows it's not easy, our very own little skinner box. It feels good to see the numbers rise but it matters little in the game and even less outside it.

The truth is that I've seen 45%ers pull ridiculous numbers in battle and carrying and I've seen pseudo unicums Yolo and die first and then spending the rest of the match cursing at everyone for not being able to follow his yolo in a goddamned light tank.

The truth is that mad games were a great success because people are having fun for the first time in a long while because they don't have the burden of numbers on their shoulders. They can have fun without concerning that their immaculate reroll accounts are getting stained by "bad numbers" that literally no one outside of the ga

limpid elm
#

@solar river Very nice. Well said.

heady acorn
#

Yup well said

deep pike
#

hm

dim field
#

Completely agree

unique scaffold
#

Well said

#

It's honestly annoying when you get called a 45%er and a noob when you're trying your hardest to help the team

deep pike
#

yep

dim field
#

Or when somebody makes a series of bad choices, blames you for the loss, gets their clan to harass you, and say they were right and send hate because they have a better wr than you.

unique scaffold
#

Yep

deep pike
#

yep

dim field
#

Can we get a buff to Vk 30.01H pls? Poor thing is basically a dw2 going against tier 6

remote valley
#

rather than a buff i think a rebalance shud be made to it. more on armour less on the gun to play it more like a heavy

#

cause the gun is exceptional on the tank and compensates for the lack of armour on the tank @dim field

dim field
#

I was just thinking maybe more hp and maybe more engine power (not speed but push power)

unique scaffold
#

One good example was when I was playing on an account given to me, I was playing the Super Pershing, and ended up tangoing with a CDC and 2 other meds that were trying to flank my teammates. I managed to hold them off long enough for my team to make short work of their teammates, getting called a noob by the CDC after I got killed even though he and his buddies had trouble trying to take me out. He then proceeded to message me and insult me and my clan. And this guy was from ARCHR.

remote valley
#

@unique scaffold be smart. post pic send to wg wait for them to impose karma on tht guy

unique scaffold
#

I'd rather save that for someone that went too far.
Insults to my clan and myself I can handle.

unique scaffold
#

No it doesnt you just bad 😂😂😂

shy wren
#

ASIA server player here; only saw Grave Digger twice.
It’s tough to pen the turret, but lower plate’s paper

solar river
#

Tbh gravedigger is a monster against tier 6 only
I mean not even the TOG stands a chance, and the TOG is another legendary monster with massive dpm, pen and health

remote valley
#

@solar river u do have to know the tog has no armour and notoriously slow lol (large amount of hp doesnt equate to having to survive longer than any other tier 6 tank. To many of us we just see it as fresh meat :3

dim field
#

When you bounce a kv-2 round while in a TOG

shy wren
#

HMS TOG II is too strong for your minute rounds, KV-2!

remote valley
#

Tog 2: bounce me? hah good try kv-2 pelts kv-2 to death

dim field
#

My dream is drive my TOG off a cliff and land on an enemy.

remote valley
#

@dim field time to grow up use a type 5 heavy XD

#

the meta points to the japanese heavies in squishing enemy abilities lolololol

dim field
#

But my beautiful chocolate covered banana or extended watermelon needs me

remote valley
#

nyeh throws in a wild O-I

shy wren
#

@dim field your dreams might come true with the Neptune map

dim field
#

My TOG is ready!

solar river
#

Big hp pooling might not be everything alone but combine it with the super high rof and pen and also its turn rate and basically you get a giant dalek

shy wren
#

It kinda looks like a HOT TOG

remote valley
#

Me in my KV-2: loads HE juicy also me in my su-152: omae wa mo shindeiru

dim field
#

NANI

grand raptor
#

nande?

shy wren
#

Nando’s

remote valley
#

Naan

grand raptor
#

nandos!!!!!!!!! 🐔

shy wren
#

Nunchucks

dim field
#

Balance the nunchucks

shy wren
#

Tightrope

dim field
#

@slender briar wr doesn't actually do what you think it does. It's misleading and overvauled. It's just an overall number but it doesn't carry much weight. It doesn't show how good you are, it doesn't show how much you contribute to winning either. If i do zero dmg, but my team pulls throgh with a win, my wr goes up even though i didn't do anything. People who are garbage at the game might one day have everything click and start getting much better, they'll still be stuck with a bad wr that doesn't represent their actual skill level. Plenty of good players can still lose even though they did beautifully all game. You've probably seen or experienced those times where people have pulled 5000 dmg and still lost with the rest of their team pulling out a combine 1000 dmg. Many things can cause winrate to be inaccurate it's only an average. Another possible and easy discrepancy could simply be a person works up to a 60% and then stops playing for a year. They come back and play like a 30%. It's possible. All of these things mean you can't reasonably tag wr alongside by itself. It doesn't tell the whole picture. Think of how many people make bad decisions and just happen to have 60% wr. I often will see a 60% wr sit back in the corner trying to snipe while they're in a light tank or a 60% td yolo into enemy lines and die 30 seconds in.

grand raptor
#

literally the story of my wot blitz life. I am making stupid mistakes all the time but I still manage to maintain a 60%+ wr

dim field
#

I just cannot see any real value coming from attaching a score to a persons name in battle that wouldn't have more downsides than upsides.

remote valley
#

what abt wn8? @dim field anything to say abt it?

#

but wn8 still doesnt eliminate sealclubbing tho u can have a super unicum wn8 just from sealclubbing ._.

grand raptor
#

it should be average damage and wn8

slender briar
#

Ok, we can use WR alongside an expected win rate metric, in a given tank, assuming a significant # of battles, say 10x tier.

eWR can be regression based, with the y value being WR, and independent variables being platoon rate, damage, damage ratio, survival rate, spot rate, and damage:kill ratio

dim field
#

Iirc wn8 is something blitstars adds up yes? I'm iffy on it tbh. I don't remember how it adds things up exactly or why it adds it up in such a way. I've had unicum stats when I had been doing crappy over 30 days.

grand raptor
#

actually a good idea would be to put the average damage/wn8 of the tank that person is playing.

slender briar
#

Platoon will probably need squared, not sure about the others.

remote valley
#

@dim field i believe they take into ur acc ur spots, avg dmg, hit rate, so on so forth. Even if u didnt win, as long as u spot a lot, made a lot accurate shots so on so forth im guessing thts the reason

solar river
#

As i said winrate is a skinner box
It's there to compulse you to play even if you don't want to in order to keep the streak or recoup lost wr

I'd be best if wg allowed us to hide stats like literally every time other game
But it's part of of the business, human psychology so it's better to if you train yourself to ig or it. I guide myself more with países because those are given, those are méritos other people hand over to you in acknowledge of your contribution or skill

dusky void
#

Guys when is the 5.5 update coming out

remote valley
#

@dusky void 13/14th nov

solar river
#

2018?

remote valley
#

@slender briar u r aware blitzstars.com shows u ur periodic winrate as well?

dusky void
#

Thx
Do any of you think BT7 needs an armour buff

slender briar
#

Yeah, it's nice, but it isn't in the game.

dim field
#

I go by praises aswell atleast to sorta gage my own involvement. But military honor has its flaws aswell.

remote valley
#

@slender briar its doesnt have to be cause the website is already endorsed by wg so its pretty unnecessary to stuff one into the game but i believe they shud publicise the website

slender briar
#

Like, the entire military honor system is completely flawed?

Uh, being available in game is the whole point of the entire discussion

remote valley
#

nah @dim field praises aint a good indicator some of them can be because ur platmate just praises u for the fun of it

dim field
#

I'd be alright with wg hiding stats, but i also know competitive people be competitive. I see stats more of a personal gage and maybe see how you and your friends compare. Since you will know more about your journey than a random and who doesn't like to brag to their friends how you have every stats in your isu higher than their isu

#

I value "worthy opponent" to an extent. Makes me feel good.

slender briar
#

I give everyone upvotes. Driving a 183? Here's a lucky upvote.I give worthy opponent to potatoes lol

remote valley
#

welp websites like blitzstars.com are ur side "products" tht competitive people can use to gauge their performance after all, its a game, its not intended to make everyone competitive its meant for people to have fun

grand raptor
#

if i am in a bad mood i give them all downvotes cuz I hate arty

slender briar
#

The point of a game is to win,. The purpose is to have fun. Games are inherently competitive

remote valley
#

@grand raptor excuze me theres no arty in wotb XD

dim field
#

They mean Bt-7 arty

grand raptor
#

183 arty

solar river
#

Also, why people take "lucky player" as an insult? I had once a triarii flipping on me when I gave him the lucky praise

remote valley
#

@solar river beats me

slender briar
#

If your good game was dismissed as lucky, I'd be salty too

limpid elm
#

@solar river Bushka does that to players who didn't do too well. Guess they are insulted because of that.

dim field
#

I'd wager it's more that people are inherently competitive, games just follow suit.
Tournaments are competitive in design.

remote valley
#

i wudnt bother tht just me XD

dim field
#

The only reason I care about stats the amount i do is

  1. I cannot let my little brother think he is better than me
  2. Defense against the "My wr is 1% higher than me insert unoriginal insult here therefore you have to play how i want you to play because I'm better and some how it's your fault that I died after i yoloed into all the enemies at once"
slender briar
#

That's why regression is used to get an accurate picture of performance, captured in a single metric, a second WR.

dim field
#

Still wouldn't provide any real benefit.

slender briar
#

Sure, helps me identify HVTs, and pinpoint more likely locations. More data means better predictions, and higher returns based on skill.

dim field
#

But it's a raw score, void of a way to know how it was formed.

Sure scores could have large gaps between them but you don't know what makes them so different.

slender briar
#

Soft skills- calling, picking out HVTs, better predictions, assistance damage, applying cap pressure.

#

You can disclose exact coefficients, so everyone knows exactly how it's formed. With a good model, is unlikely that there will be much deviation

remote valley
#

well @slender briar those factors wud be extremely hard to put into data unless ofc wg has in place some sort of deep learning software which allows the game to recognises these skills

slender briar
#

They're not in data, which is why WR would be different from the eWR regression.

dim field
#

I'll give an example. Tell me how the number is formed and who is "better". I'll give you a rough formula
Average tier x dmg x winrate = score
3500 vs 6000

remote valley
#

nope wudnt do tht

slender briar
#

Is WR a decimal or a whole value?

dim field
#

Decimal

slender briar
#

definitely the 6k player, but not at all what I'm looking at doing now

dim field
#

Ready for the math?

#

Actually can you tell me how the 6k player is better first?
What is their average tier, damage, and wintate?

slender briar
#

Uh, you're asking me to solve 3 variables without any constraints. Like an hour ago yeah. I moved to the regression of significant stats vs their aactual Wr

dim field
#

Yup, you wanted a score by their name

#

Average tier x dmg x winrate

71000.50 = 3500
81000.75 = 6000

3500 vs 6000

slender briar
#

So the 6k player has 1 higher avg tier same damage, and a . 25 higher wr? I'll take him any day

dim field
#

The 6k does have a higher wr and average tier, but they're not doing anymore damage than the other player. This could be a problem.

slender briar
#

Ok, still I'm looking at regression.

dim field
#

What about 2700 vs 2000?

Also what do you mean by regression?

limpid elm
#

Oh wow. Those numbers. Is this a math class? 🙃

slender briar
#

a measure of the relation between the mean value of one variable (e.g., output) and corresponding values of other variables (e.g., time and cost).

dim field
#

How would you put that into our example?

slender briar
#

In this case, the Y would be WR, and the other variables would be survival, damage, spots, etc etc.
It could be tank based, or on the individual. Due to the nature of regression as a prediction tool, it will be somewhat inaccurate. This inaccuracy helps identify the type of player that is being dealt with.

I don't have the ability to generate an example. I could make a sample model tomorrow.

dim field
#

Now, how is a player to dissect that number though?

We still have trouble weighing how much each stat actually means.
Each stat on it's own is unhelpful really. How do you combine them? How does a player know by looking at a number what it means or what the pieces were? It's like looking at the image for a puzzle, without knowing how big the pieces are.

#

Bigger number = statistically bigger threat I'd assume but you could still have similar numbers be worlds apart.

jovial kernel
#

Personally I run it by average damage times (10+average tier) multiplied by average spots multiplied by their winrate

slender briar
#

This would actually be able to weigh stats for us, with enough data, whether it's the stat itself, a square, a cube, or even a log.

Basically, if your eWR is lower, than you're doing something soft that is increasing your WR. If it's higher, you're not doing something right.

eWR= expected win rate = regression analyzed win rate

dim field
#

So basically it would be like
30% plays like a 60%, this dude has bad luck

60% plays like a 30%, this dude is luckiest man alive.

slender briar
#

Assuming there's a significant difference anyway. differences will probably be within a percent, if i had my guess.

jovial kernel
#

Yeah I made up a formula that kinda works decently for most players

slender briar
#

I'll try it out. Pull 5 different clans and run it to see if it's even significant.

jovial kernel
#

watch it suck horribly lmao

dim field
#

Assuming this all some how works out neat and tidy, it's going to open flood gates for toxicity and it might skew it's own reults.

Let's say you see 4 of your teammates are 40% players they go towards hill. Two are 50% they go towards town. The 50% players ditch their 40%ers. Who do you travel with? (Assume WR and eWR are close to each other)

slender briar
#

I'll be able to get it to predict WR correctly at least 90% of the time.

Depends on the map and tanks...

jovial kernel
#

I take hill because hill is more important and I get more support

dim field
#

I cannot throw in map and tank comps atm. The skew I was going to bring up was if people start judging eachother based on these scores before the battle even begins, do you not think there is the possibility that people will give up on the people they see as bad players? Typically people won't do well if they have to verse an opposing force larger than themselves. And people seen as bad players are probably going to be used as cannon fodder. This sould lead to them getting poorer stats which lower their score would it not?

remote valley
#

@dim field r u trying to make a mod?

dim field
#

Nope.
We've been having a discussion bout adding Wr (and now a secondary Wr) next to players names during or possibly just in pre-game loading screens.

We're talking about the pros and cons if WG started doing it.

#

I'm highly skeptical towards it and believe stats are often overvalued, missused and it could lead to more toxicity and problems.

Bootleg believes it would be a highly valuable tool to implement.

slender briar
#

I'll certainly be better able to formtactics and advice based on how bad players are.

I'll know for sure that Mr 40% has 70 + battles in his Tiger, and odds are he's going to lose it, because his wr is 40% and matches his eWR. I know I'm not going to listen anything he says about tactics.

jovial kernel
#

Even if you know a player is bad, if you're using them as cannon fodder in any way other than using their spotting to farm damage, you're worse than they are. But then you don't need stats to take advantage of spotting.

remote valley
#

i think they shud add 30 days performance rather than overall stats.. tht also over a certain group of tiers. At least people will kno how each player fares in a certain group of tiers

slender briar
#

Just tank performance will do.

dim field
#

Do you mean add 30day performance in the stats menu or during a game?

remote valley
#

@slender briar tht will do also :3 but like i said go for 30 days or so.. overall wud not give a very accurate representation of the players current performance

jovial kernel
#

I say it makes sense if it's 30 game performance in the tank they're in if that person has over 100 battles in the tank

remote valley
#

@dim field both and @jovial kernel exactly

#

but then again ill suggest to wg to have it as a side "product" for players to install into the game

jovial kernel
#

I care a lot more about how well a person is doing in their Tiger 1 that they're driving than what horrible things they're doing in their R35.

dim field
#

Maybe expanding the stats menu might be ok, adding in an option to hide stats would be appreciated though.

remote valley
#

@dim field u prob can do tht in post game results... it wudnt be viable during battle

dim field
#

I'd want to hide it period. Even if i had an 85% wr

remote valley
#

nani?!

bold dagger
#

wassup

remote valley
#

nani?! oh were going overboard over the issue of stats @bold dagger

jovial kernel
#

We're discussing if an XVM type thing would be a good idea in the base game and how calculating an expected win rate of people that didn't count seal clubbing and bad luck in the MM would work.

remote valley
#

welp not as a mod but as a part of the game

dim field
#

I don't like the toxicity stats like wr bring. People already bash eachother for it. I don't want to have to play peace keeper when the stats are visible mid game.

jovial kernel
#

And let's not forget all the prammo getting sent in the way of unicums and forcing their heavies into only hull down and sidescrape positions if the stats are visible.

dim field
#

Well.... I should probably go to bed. This was a pretty good discussion and I'd like to keep going but it's almost 6am and I've got to be up in a few hours. Y'all have a goodnight

remote valley
#

gdnite mate

balmy cipher
#

the shellthrower's pen (scavanger's gun) from 25 to 40

remote valley
#

huh?

unique scaffold
#

Hi

tawdry abyss
#

Hello

ember thunder
#

What will be avatars xD
I cant wait for those

unique scaffold
#

Whos the average player that just wants to play for fun and is not planning to train to become pro they just want to play for fun?

These people dont care about any status
They just want to play but the "unicums" kept bashing them making the average players/newbies think that this game have a bad community.

wary holly
#

^

warm kernel
#

32 Pounder gun for Caernarvon plz

winged barn
#

It does have a bad community

remote valley
#

@unique scaffold i believe the qn shud be more of who on earth thinks tht the game shud be solely played for competitive sake rather for the fun of it, which is basically the whole idea of playing the game

unique scaffold
#

Players who refuse to learn and for some reason thing that losing is fun are the problem.

I'll take a try hard super Unicum on my team over a turret spinning, team trolling, rock shooting, 40%er who plays for fun any day of the week.

whole veldt
#

i think VK 45.02 A need buff on the front armor. RN the thickness is 120mm in WOT it's 150. i'm using that tank to get Maus guys. Believe me it's terrible. side and back thickness is 80 so i hope the front armor have good thickness but it is 120mm. and i think like "well it's okay the armor is slope anyway" boi i was wrong even the 122mm D-25T can penetrate it sometimes. so i demand WG to buff VK 45.02 A front armor coz the only advantage of this is the tank faster a bit than any tank in tier 8

#

@lean forge @charred comet

winged barn
#

It is a slow medium and should avoid being hit

ember thunder
#

@whole veldt I agree fully

stoic pebble
#

I doubt the VK A needs a frontal armor buff of any amount. If the frontal armor is buffed, it will not only be faster than the Tiger 2, but also be more well armored.

quick lichen
#

@unique scaffold if you’re complaining about this game then you take the game seriously. If you play the game seriously then you’re not just “playing for fun”. It’s part of it but not everything. I play to win. Fun still happens though

unique scaffold
#

Well its kinda meh, but depends on a player

civic sorrel
#

Well idk why PRAMO talks bs all they play is for just doing battles bc they have all tanks on their garage they have got every singel tank from 1 to tier 10

Also not to metion that PRAMO

PAYS 100 DOLLARS FOR RNG AND WW BENEFITS I MEAN sik of this sht

sharp wind
#

🤔 my brain wave reader isn’t working on this one

unique scaffold
#

Ahahahahaha this shit sad...

#

Pays 100 $ for rng 😂😂😂😂

sharp wind
#

WG isn’t that nice, at least a couple grand must be paid to get rng perks

rancid flame
#

Bro, if $100 buys good RNG and MM, where the hell is mine!?

quick lichen
#

I got $300 to join xpd a few years ago

#

But we don’t pay for anything

#

We don’t have press accounts

#

Please take off the tin foil hat

jade cargoBOT
#

dynoSuccess Danirepgameplay[Nova6]#2912 was muted

unique scaffold
#

Well he isnulted his clan so it's justified

queen hemlock
#

I think people missed the R for good RNG

#

No need to pay, just pray. One letter makes a lot of difference

unique scaffold
#

On point.

tepid cipher
#

I use credits for equipment, consumables, provisions, and crew training. Those things reduce the effect that RNG has on my actions. Anyone can do this. Anyone can "pay for better RNG" in a way.

#

It's not unfair, it's just a part of the game.

queen hemlock
#

True. You do get those amazing penetrating shots in the one game and then the next everything misses or bounces. But it affects everybody so that's fair

quick lichen
#

@tepid cipher it’s a good thing we all got 500 million credits when we joined

tepid cipher
#

Yep. Didn't need to use any skill whatsoever playing premium tanks and tournaments to make those credits.

quick lichen
#

MBGA

wicked needle
#

Balance this mm

quick lichen
#

Plenty balanced

#

Awful game for everyone playing

unique scaffold
#

It´s not about the MM. Its about the players, who are just playing TD´s…

quick lichen
#

How are people still surprised by td spam?

#

It’s gone on for months

unique scaffold
#

FeelsCensoredMan…
I think, they are not surprised, but feel a little bit confused, because TD´s just laughing about armour…

#

Well if you dont like a lot of td's in a game, you could start from yourself and dont play them 🤔

#

I dont like TD´s. Doesn´t matters if I am playing them or get outplayed by them.

#

It is a problem for months now and i dont really see it fixed still

atomic hound
#

I want to ask wg something. When I shoot the flat side of a tank with no armour, amx light tank, t49, etc. and the shot is absorbed into the tracks (usually without even blowing them off) to the incredibly irritating tune of 'we got em', is this a bug with your game (after all, there is no way that these tanks have 200mm+ effective side armour flat on, tracks or not) or have you designed this in for some odd reason? Either way, please fix this, even if we all benefit from it at some stage, it makes games so much more frustrating...

unique scaffold
#

@atomic hound That´s not a bug. It´s irony. And much vodka.
Maybe you aimed to low.

#

If you hit an external module like tracks there is a chance of penetrating but not doing damage. Its not a bug its a game mechanic

atomic hound
#

Can anyone actually verify this isn't a bug? Just because it has been around forever doesn't mean it is intentional, when and where has wg said this is intentional? Id be grateful to find out

stoic pebble
#

@atomic hound I have had this problem as well. I'm waiting around the corner for a CDC to show up. He drives around the corner side on and I blast him with my IS-5. And for some absurd reason, the shell does no damage, not even damaging his tracks.

atomic hound
#

@lean forge I would very much appreciate it if you could clear this up for me

unique scaffold
#

@atomic hound It´s RNG.

#

Ivan got too drunk

atomic hound
#

Can't just say it is down to rng, there is no pen roll on any gun at tier 8 that will fail to pen the flat side of a light tank.

unique scaffold
#

Its tehnically a penetration, only thats it doesnt do damage. Its the thing with external modules as i already said

atomic hound
#

Again, where is your evidence that this is intentional? @unique scaffold

sharp mantle
#

What are you talking about?

dim field
#

I often will disable enemy crew members, but not do any damage.
Like kill their driver and gunner, but their tank will still have full hp.

wooden gazelle
#

No you don't.

atomic hound
#

@unique scaffold do you have any idea whether this is intentional on wg's part (my question was above)

unique scaffold
#

@dim field thats wrong. Its only for tracks and optics or such, but if you hit a crew member you are doing damage 100%

#

?

#

i dont know

dim field
#

Tell that to all those times it'll pop up a yellow steering wheel but the enemy keeps full hp

unique scaffold
#

never had that

atomic hound
#

Not that, the zero damage penning hits into the sides of light tanks

unique scaffold
#

that thay say we got them

#

they

#

thats just rng

#

hating you lol

#

@dim field thats a track...

dim field
#

It's happened a couple times. It's not a track. A damaged track shows as part of a track

atomic hound
#

As I said, there is no pen roll on any gun at tier 8 that won't pen the flat side of a light tank, so how is it rng?

unique scaffold
#

cause you only hit the tracks' hitbox

#

not the actual tank

wooden gazelle
#

I'm assuming you've got some sort of screenshot of this happening then?

atomic hound
#

Shouldn't the shell go through the tracks like it does if you hit the drivewheel? I'm not talking about when you shoot below the hull into the tracks

unique scaffold
#

ah

#

idk

atomic hound
#

Do I need a screenshot? This happens all the time, to everyone.

unique scaffold
#

if you have some

dim field
#

I'm sure it'll happen again, i'll try to remember to take a screenshot next time

atomic hound
#

As will I, I'm sure I'll get plenty next time I play for 15 minutes...

wooden gazelle
#

Not you Adam, the guy saying that he's killing drivers without dealing damage.

unique scaffold
#

Well hes mistaken

atomic hound
#

Yeah, dead drivers with zero damage is bs.

queen hemlock
#

@atomic hound it all depends on the shell and the thickness of the drive wheel

#

All modules have a certain thickness and HP pool too.

#

If the shell has sufficient pen left AFTER penetrating spaced armour or modules, then it will be the armour plate behind it

atomic hound
#

The shots I'm talking about don't hit the drivewheel, when I shoot the flat side of the CDC, above the bottom of the hull, and the shot is absorbed into the tracks, there is no way the effective thickness of the tracks is 180mm or whatever, so how is this possible?

unique scaffold
#

He just explained it to you....

queen hemlock
#

If you hit tracks at a 90 degree angle, most energy gets absorbed by them

atomic hound
#

Why?

queen hemlock
#

Because of the way the armour models are designed and calculated

#

What tanks are we talking about? CDC versus ...???

atomic hound
#

Is5, but it really isn't limited to that

stoic pebble
#

I specifically remember this happening with my IS-5, but I shrugged it off as bad rng.

atomic hound
#

It's even worse in TDs with 150mm+ guns that should overmatch the sides of these things...

wooden gazelle
#

Simple solution, stop shooting tracks.

stoic pebble
#

That's not simple

atomic hound
#

Exactly, if you shoot the side of a tank, there is a good chance it will hit the tracks.

stoic pebble
#

If I see the side of an IS-3 or IS-8, I'm going to shoot the tracks to avoid the stalinium that lines the sides of those bias tanks. Same applies for the IS-7.

queen hemlock
#

Spaced armour is annoying indeed

wooden gazelle
#

Fair, but not relevant to the CDC example.

quartz steeple
#

Stalinium 😂 😂

queen hemlock
#

And the IS series has loads of strange angles too.

#

@wooden gazelle my guess is he hit the tracks dead on, and the shots get absorbed by them.

atomic hound
#

Spaced armour is annoying, but I still don't see why the tracks on a tank alone (this happens to me in the borsig, and that has almost no side armour at all) should stop a high pen round.

unique scaffold
#

Get over it, it is how it is

stoic pebble
#

Bad RNG. Happens to the best of us.

atomic hound
#

If wg answered like that to every issue you had, I think you'd have some strong words for it... @unique scaffold

queen hemlock
#

But it is pretty much true @atomic hound . The game is designed as it is. Little we can do there

unique scaffold
#

I dont see it as an issue, as i said i think its a game mechanic

atomic hound
#

Isn't that the point of this discord server though? @queen hemlock

#

What I fail to understand is why wargaming would intentionally make this a game mechanic, spaced armour, yes, but tracks that absorb everything once in a while, no.

queen hemlock
#

I think it has more to do with limitations of the armour model than intentional programming

atomic hound
#

Meaning it is closer to a bug then...

queen hemlock
#

A bug is a fault in software. This is not a fault but a technical limitation

jovial kernel
#

There's also the chance that the shell went down and hit a road wheel which counts as hitting spaced armor, and left the bounce icon over the CDC making it look like you bounced

wooden gazelle
#

*roadwheel

jovial kernel
#

Thanks yeah

ivory swift
#

Bite

rustic remnant
#

Heh

#

Hey look its Dan

#

40 seconds in-between msg’s/comments....seriously...

quick lichen
#

.serverinfo

jade cargoBOT
#
WoT Blitz Official (ENG)
Owner

WoT Blitz#3977

Region

eu-central

Channel Categories

5

Text Channels

27

Voice Channels

24

Members

18241

Humans

18238

Bots

1

Online

1829

Roles

9

Role List

@everyone, Wargaming, Dyno, Moderators, Youtubers, Players, Muted, Community Helpers, DJ

quick lichen
#

@rustic remnant 18,238 people

true relic
#

how do you get DJ? Is it like a role you get for higher than player or what

quick lichen
#

65% get dj tag

#

(Jk no one has that tag)

wooden gazelle
#

you have that tag

quick lichen
#

I’m no one

inner comet
#

Is pramo on some performance enhancement pills or sumn

quick lichen
#

🤦🏼‍♂️

inner comet
#

Let raid win

quick lichen
#

Pramo runs twister so we can control that for you

#

🤦🏼‍♂️

inner comet
#

Hmmm

old basalt
#

Lol.. Nice one iraikkonen

shut wigeon
#

Raik what is your thoughts about vk100?

rustic remnant
#

I understand keeping it under control ... but there are only 1400 on this channel...interestingly enough ... i woulda thought they could do a channel by channel slowmode if needed..

cedar mist
#

I've spoken to WG about the slow mode and they will not be changing it from 45 seconds due to these channels being more important in the chat with devs section.

rustic remnant
#

Interesting...

limpid elm
#

Err... it is 45 seconds.

cedar mist
#

Yes

inner locust
#

It's too long tho

cedar mist
#

Like I said, I asked WG if they could reduce it, but they said the above.

deep egret
#

@cedar mist buddy please suggest to wg change server option again coz i face to lag in NA server and actually i live in india .. thats why i told u so please help me

lone hound
#

O

wicked needle
#

Only option is you shift to NA

quick lichen
#

@shut wigeon I think it’ll be very strong but nothing too broken

jovial kernel
#

I think the VK 100.01 (P) will either be extremely useless or extremely strong with no in between.

hollow wren
#

Um...I want to buff t54e1 penetration..

unique scaffold
#

No need

north rover
#

pls fix platoons in matchmaker becouse we wait for 20 mim to get into battle !!!!!!

#

that becouse no one play platoon

celest lance
#

lol 20 mins? Are you playing when no one is online?

unique scaffold
#

Exggergating

quick scroll
#

Hi idk if that a good idea but its possible to upgrade the ap penetration of the 150mm of the Rhm B Wt (215 -> 220 or 225)

jovial kernel
#

Use calibrated shells.

quick scroll
#

Yes but the reload was too slow 😂

jovial kernel
#

So you want it to be the OP monster it was on release? Good luck with that.

quick scroll
#

Its just a idea

coarse harness
#

The ISU is has more pen, dpm, armor, accuracy etc🙄

quick scroll
#

I dont like isu too slow

coarse harness
#

35 km/h with fast acceleration and good traverse speed

shy wren
#

Borsig has turret

serene falcon
#

Borsig has turret. That is the main appeal of it to players

tepid wadi
#

A buff for the engine of the AMX 13 90 is greatly needed

#

Its acceleration is too slow for its size

coarse yacht
#

But it’s a heavy

jovial kernel
#

what lol

hollow wren
#

Yes...I think AMX 13 90 needs to buff penetration.. it's too low...So AMX 13 90 can't penetrate 9 tier heavies by ap shell.

coarse yacht
#

An

jovial kernel
#

13 75 and 13 90 need buffs badly, the 13 75 is just a 12t that reloads faster and got thrown up a tier, and the 13 90 is just a bad tank overall.

coarse yacht
#

The kv2 needs to be buffed

hollow wren
#

Um...why?

coarse yacht
#

I was using my kv2 and there was a mt25 shot him then it bounced

limpid elm
#

@coarse yacht Buffed in what?

hollow wren
#

I think it is RNG..

jovial kernel
#

Also why would you be using any gun or ammunition that would be capable of not doing damage with the KV-2

coarse yacht
#

It needs more armor nope I was using the derp gun it one shot 2 other people

jovial kernel
#

how about no

limpid elm
#

🤣

wary holly
#

@jovial kernel tru

#

any buffs to kv2 is a nightmare tbh

shy wren
#

It already has the derp gun and a turret. Why a buff? It’s meant to face tier V-VII.

pallid pier
#

Nerf lepard !!

limpid elm
#

@pallid pier Which leopard? 🤣 Leopard (Tier 5) , Leopard PTA or Leopard 1?