Correct me if i’m wrong, but i’m pretty sure the guest is the only neighbor with unique chase music, so heres a suggestion
What if every neighbor had their own chase music?
Scary - The default music he already has now.
Clown - Definitely something that sounds a bit like circus music.
Butcher - Hmmm… im not actually sure what his could be. perhaps just something similar to scarys chase music, but lower pitched and maybe slightly louder.
Ghost - His chase music could be a bit slower, and maybe a little higher pitched? to make it sound a little creepy. since hes a ghost and all.
I feel like all of them should be somewhat similar to each other, but still different enough to distinguish whos chasing you, like all of them have a different beat or something, i dunno, im not an expert on music.
(excluding the guest, because its a whole different entity, so it having different chase music makes sense.)