#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 423 of 1

inner basin
#

Covert Operations are typically used to cause a political effect

#

You could’ve just searched up “What are Covert Operations?” on Google and you would’ve got the answer

tough ocean
#

Oh, I thought they were different from actual Covert Operations.

midnight loom
#

😛

#

im confused as to WHY kilo 5 was employed in the first place

inner basin
#

To destabilise Sanghelios and have the Sanghelli interlocked into civil war so they would never be a threat to humanity. That was ONI’s thought process behind it anyways

gilded mason
#

Because ONI is stupid as 'heck'

inner basin
#

I personally think it isn’t smart to sabotage your only ally

midnight loom
#

yeah....

gilded mason
#

Yeah

flat bone
#

Mhm

midnight loom
#

oh hey ur the ostral guy! ur still here! wow!

#

wait holdon

#

but the arbiter

gilded mason
#

Hm?

midnight loom
#

was way stronger than other side

flat bone
#

Who would want rtas as an enemy, when he could be an ally

inner basin
#

His rousing speeches bring a tear to my eye

stable flower
#

Rtas is basically the Covenant version of Sgt. Johnson

midnight loom
#

oh lol i went inactive here like last year and now ur the only 1 that was around back then

gilded mason
#

Many of the others got banned.

flat bone
#

Oh

inner basin
#

I’m a long timer, although admittedly I did go MIA for a while

flat bone
#

I started here like a month ago

gilded mason
#

I've been having some spelling mistakes recently, so my time may be up soon as well.

flat bone
#

Rampancy

midnight loom
#

wait u git banned for spelling?

inner basin
#

A lot of my misspellings have thankfully been noticed by mods and admins and have been removed from the system :)) I also accidentally got banned once which reset my warnings

midnight loom
#

oh i get it.

#

why were they banned? they were smart...

humble yacht
#

This isn’t a lore topic

flat bone
#

Lol

midnight loom
#

ok ok

#

but why did they do that? the arbiters side was much stronger

flat bone
#

Why in halo 5 are they struggling against jul then?

inner basin
#

F, ONI are cold and calculating with every decision they make. A lot of those decisions are morally wrong, but they claim that it’s for the greater good of humanity

flat bone
#

I don’t think it was that much stronger

#

Great journey fanatics

#

That’s all the halo 2 covenant was

#

Also anti heretic

inner basin
#

The Great Journey fanatics weren’t really intriguing to me. I hope it’s similar to the dive into the politics of the Covenant and the inner workings/manipulation that we’ll be seeing

humble yacht
ocean ibex
#

Jenkin’s squad could’ve survived the flood encounter on the ring

flat bone
#

Wasn’t Johnson the squad leader

ocean ibex
#

Keyes was

flat bone
#

Keyes is a captain tho

ocean ibex
#

He’s the highest rank there

flat bone
#

I remember Johnson giving the orders

ocean ibex
#

Anyways if Jenkins shot his gun they would’ve killed all of the infection forms

flat bone
#

Idk

shut dew
#

And I hope we get something more than surface-level stuff H2 did. The Banished as of now...

  • Led by Atriox
  • Rogue splinter group that does hit-and-run attacks
  • Are on the Ark for some reason and released the flood
  • Deal with Human Criminal Organizations.

Like please have genuine non-combatant Banished characters that aren't immediately killed off or never mentioned again. And dive down DEEP into the Banished's internal workings so much more than the OT ever did for Covies.

flat bone
#

Why just Jenkins

#

Everyone else was shooting

#

His gun was not a Spartan laser with infinite ammo and a constant beam

ocean ibex
#

He had a fresh mag with 60 rounds in it

flat bone
#

Keyes did too

ocean ibex
#

He had a pistol

flat bone
#

He reloaded every 0.2 seconds

#

I don’t think it would’ve mattered

inner basin
#

Keyes never keeps it loaded ;P

flat bone
#

...

ocean ibex
#

The fact they survived more than 10 seconds is surprising

flat bone
#

Not really

inner basin
#

It’s a reference to the line he says when he hands you the Magnum in the first mission, oof. It’s not anything dirty-minded

flat bone
#

I know

#

But like

inner basin
#

3 dots would suggest otherwise

flat bone
#

Ik

#

I was just

#

Nvm

#

8 marines -ish Johnson and Keyes

#

If one marine could almost get through the library that fire team could definitely survive 10 seconds @ocean ibex

ocean ibex
#

Why did they only send 8 marines to a weapons cache

#

When they knew it was heavily guarded

inner basin
#

There was more than 8 marines

ocean ibex
#

Even then

flat bone
#

That’s why I said ish-

ocean ibex
#

It looked like a small swuad

inner basin
#

There was second squad if you recall them being in contact over the radio

#

For all we know, second squad could be where the numbers of Marines were

ocean ibex
#

They weren’t inside with them

inner basin
#

Yes they were

ocean ibex
#

Ohh the first marines that got killed

flat bone
#

Did you know that in Halo CE the captain of the pillar of autumns name is “hellomynamekeyes”

inner basin
#

No, second squad was also in the facility. If you recall, first squad were deep in the facility, right? Second squad were somewhere inside, but closer to the entrance. After Chief takes the elevator up to the entrance, he rendezvoused with some surviving Marines who were lost in the facility for hours (according to them)

ocean ibex
#

Don’t recall

inner basin
#

Sounds like someone needs to replay CE

ocean ibex
#

Was it ever confirmed how the marine in the library died

#

Oh yes I do

inner basin
#

It was confirmed in the book “The Flood”

ocean ibex
#

More books to read

flat bone
#

I dont read the books

inner basin
#

Bruv, if you want to ofc. I wouldn’t deem The Flood necessary

ocean ibex
#

Nah it’s good, would love to read it

flat bone
#

Are the books free?

#

Take it as a no

inner basin
#

No, they aren’t. But you can probably find some of the earlier books at not a bad price

ocean ibex
#

Barnes and nobles always has good value

#

If you have one

inner basin
#

I can’t say I’ve ever seen one in my country

ocean ibex
#

Where do you live lmao

inner basin
#

UK

#

And I should probably be getting to sleep, yet I’m on Discord talking to random people

ocean ibex
#

Yeah you probably should

faint stone
#

your choice not ours matey

stable flower
#

I dont read the books
@flat bone Me neither. I'd rather smooch Little Moe with the gimpy leg.

flat bone
#

What movie is that, home alone?

cedar surge
#

Is that the movie in home alone

flat bone
#

I think so

cedar surge
#

Movie producers in halo got a lot of material to work with now

#

Do you think the covenant got similar entertainment producers?

jolly swift
#

steamy human/sangheili romance movie

flat bone
#

No

#

Please

#

Saying Sangheli romance makes me want to puke

humble yacht
#

Covenant entertainment probably amounts to propaganda

cedar surge
#

I could see a heavily exaggerated movie about how chipped dunno became the greatest unsc marine

humble yacht
#

Seems like the covies got a kick out of public shaming

cedar surge
#

Maybe movie about past arbiter and all of their sins and shames to scare some covenant back into line?

flat bone
#

Or documentary’s on the great journey

cedar surge
#

Or covenant parading around with the bodies of Spartans as a trophy

flat bone
#

Why do some brutes/elites dibs on your body when you die in-game

#

Trophy?

cedar surge
#

Well yea

#

If you managed to kill one of humanities greatest warriors who likely killed thousands of covenant wouldn't you also call dibs on their body?

flat bone
#

Yeah probably

#

It’s 5 am

#

Ima head out

cedar surge
#

Cya

versed helm
#

@flat bone Sangheili romance

gilded mason
#

Based

versed helm
#

^

unique rune
#

based on what

gilded mason
#

Based on love

versed helm
#

Lmao

#

Jackals can’t be romantic because they have no eyebrows

gilded mason
#

rude

versed helm
#

They can’t scowl though

#

Just having those hungry eyes darting at you sitting at the table

#

“So uh, how’s the.. Armadillo, pate”

vague scroll
#

clearly you've never seen a Kig-Yar courting ritual

versed helm
#

The one Elite chick from that one book

#

I would

dense falcon
#

So we met the Proto-Gravemind on the level Keyes back in Halo CE, but when was it officially given that name?

versed helm
#

IIIRC, it was first named that in Halo 2, though “proto-gravemind” was something they called it in the studio for CE.

vernal badger
#

Jackals can’t be romantic because they have no eyebrows

Jackals are saying the same about our critical lack of coloured feathers, plumes or quills.

versed helm
#

We humans don’t condone peacocking

versed helm
#

you say while so many fashion shows are being held every hour

#

@versed helm Those are lizard people

flat bone
#

Lol

paper reef
#

lol

faint stone
#

david attenburgh prophet

versed helm
#

oh man

#

what if he did the narration for the Halo series?

#

it sounds stupid

#

but it'd be legit

flat bone
#

what if truth was voiced by morgan freeman, that would be funny

snow halo
#

is the flood juggernaut canon

craggy sierra
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

Pretty sure it’s just made out of raw biomass like the pure forms in 3 so no reason for it not to be.

flat bone
#

why do pure forms need spores to be created

#

i heard they are only created after/when flood spores start to be emitted

jolly swift
#

probably just when they have enough biomass to make pure forms, they also move to spores as a method of spreading

flat bone
#

makes sense

cedar surge
#

All flood forms canon

snow halo
#

why were they even removed from Halo 2

cedar surge
#

Purr forms?

snow halo
#

juggernauts

cedar surge
#

Oh

#

Don't know

#

Came back in Fireteam raven tho

jolly swift
#

a lot of stuff was cut from Halo 2

#

it had an infamously tumultuous development

flat bone
#

like the final level

#

i wish we had a warthog run

unique rune
#

Quite frankly
I'm glad Halo 2 didn't have a Warthog run

snow halo
#

I hope maybe we get to see the juggernaut in Infinite

cedar surge
#

If 2 also had a warthog run it would dilutes 3's

snow halo
#

but both CE and 3 had one

flat bone
#

infinite better have a warthog run

cedar surge
#

Yes

#

A warthog run in the first game and the "final" one

vernal badger
#

Imo juggernauts seem out of place now. Just a less interesting pure tank form. Between Hunters and Pure flood they don't have much reason to be in a game.

cedar surge
#

That what makes it special

#

You wouldn't want to eat cake every day would you

#

And well

#

Theet already got a successor

#

The juggernaught in HW2 ATN

vernal badger
#

Halo wars also had tentacle turrets and bases to shoot. Doesn't mean they go well in an fps. Different genre, different enemies.

unique rune
#

but both CE and 3 had one
Just because it's part of the same franchise doesn't mean it has to retread and regurgitate the same stuff over and over

cedar surge
#

Try saying that to die hard fans of any OT

flat bone
#

if its epic it deserves to be regurgitated every once and a while

cedar surge
#

You wouldn't want to eat cake every day would you
@flat bone

#

That takes away the magic of a warthog run if in every game you have one

flat bone
#

i didnt say every game

wispy wasp
#

How did the unsc /oni deal with marines that had survived encounters with the flood?

humble yacht
#

if there were any

#

they were probably debriefed and then given a hush order

wispy wasp
#

Not sure how many survived the ark, but i'm sure the few survivors of alpha halo encountered the flood, and chips dubbo

humble yacht
#

chips is not a canon character

wispy wasp
#

Oh

humble yacht
#

johnson survived the flood but his encounter with them was largely kept from ONI

wispy wasp
#

I guess that makes sense that chips wouldn't be canon

#

Was he always non canon or was that a 343 thing?

humble yacht
#

the idea of chips originates with bungie

jolly swift
#

Anyone else notice that the concept art of the Primordial looks a lot like the H4 Promethean Knights?

humble yacht
#

but he's never officially named

obsidian thistle
#

Well its debated on the wiki. They could've kept Stacker in that limbo but didnt for example

#

One hypothesis is. They are canon. But their depictions at locations may not be unless scripted or are impossible

#

Another hypothesis is they are not canon. And the Halo CE/TF approach is done where in-universe they are replaced by other people

#

Regardless its a fun topic. Can really stretch the limits of digging the realms of possibility in the games

last anchor
#

We can agree that Stacker's named apperance in H4 rollin with Infinity IS canon right?
It even says his name on the screen

#

Cause IM thats his best apperance in my book.

humble yacht
#

I think Stacker has more canon validity than Chips

stable flower
#

why were they even removed from Halo 2
@snow halo Time constraints

snow halo
#

but they were already there so why remove them

jolly swift
#

just because they were there in some capacity doesn't mean they were ready

humble yacht
#

they didn't have death animations

faint stone
#

halo 2 with a warthog run would feel, meh

junior compass
#

wouldn't really fit in with the cliffhanger

faint stone
#

there would've being explosions but last i checked high charity being destroyed in 2's ending would remove the its threat and cortana being left behind

jolly swift
#

Halo 2 at this point is so ubiquitous it's hard to imagine it any other way

faint stone
#

all you gotta know is 2 happened lol

junior compass
#

then again cliffhanger is just filler since they messed up the development

faint stone
#

but annoyed people because of the ending

#

sounds like a bungie move ngl

vernal badger
#

Miranda was supposed to strap a bomb to the Chief and somehow shove him into a shaft, we dodged a lot of bullets with those halo 2 time crunches, lol

#

she was mad about her dad dying on Halo and blaming the Chief for... reasons.

jolly swift
#

he did punch a hole in his skull...

#

at least she'd have motivation

vernal badger
#

He blew up the ring to get rid of any witnesses of that.

#

iirc

jolly swift
#

Cortana saw it, and gave Miranda everything she knew about the first Halo

#

everything

vernal badger
#

Miranda:
flips though 400 terabytes of desciptions of the flora on installation 04

jolly swift
#

all to get to the description of Chief's anime shower scene

limpid anchor
#

Hey do you guys know the various Mjolnir versions pretty well? I'm piss poor at recognizing them and I'm looking for somebody a bit more skilled.

jolly swift
#

the generations or the specific armors?

limpid anchor
#

The generations

cedar surge
#

Gen 1 is before and during HCW

#

Gen 2 is post war

#

And gen e is during and after infinite

#

Scratch that

limpid anchor
#

Sorry, I was hoping somebody could id a picture!

cedar surge
#

Some time after cortana

jolly swift
#

if you can post an imgur link then probably

gilded mason
#

What's the pic?

limpid anchor
#

Ah, wasn't sure if I could post links

gilded mason
#

Looks like Mark 6

vernal badger
#

the helmet can't be mistaken, that's for sure

gilded mason
#

But kinda in the style of Installation 01

jolly swift
#

yeah, but is it the Gen 1 version or the one used by Gen 2 spartans?

gilded mason
#

Nah, Gen2 Mark 6 is different

jolly swift
#

yeah, that's Mark 6 Mjolnir Gen 1

limpid anchor
#

I was thinking mark 6 with the helmet, but wasn't sure about the chest

jolly swift
#

just cross referenced some pictures

#

they're right, the chest is different

#

I'd say it's gen 1 mark 6 with artistic liberties

gilded mason
#

Oh, I'm right. It is Installation 01's Mark 6

jolly swift
#

oo that is crisp

limpid anchor
#

Ahhh nice!

gilded mason
#

Ye, it's my favorite version of Mark 6

limpid anchor
#

Really appreciate the ID. I wanted to make sure

gilded mason
#

👍

limpid anchor
#

Where can I find more information about the variant? I'm only finding Mark 6 GEN 2

jolly swift
#

halopedia

cedar surge
#

You can find most stuff there

#

Like how Shan shyum used to be handsome

gilded mason
#

used to
🤔

limpid anchor
#

Hah. I'll keep scrounging. Thanks again

jolly swift
#

the best Halo source is internet funnyman Brian David Gilbert

vernal badger
#

was pleasantly surprised to learn that the san'shyluum are actually nice to the women they invite to their genetic diversity breeding programs.

#

just because they are evil doesn't mean they gotta be evil i guess

limpid anchor
#

Good token of info

next fox
#

Is Emile as good of a spartan people make him out to be? Or is he a wanna be badass

vernal badger
#

What do you mean? A spartan is a spartan. He got recruited as a spartan III, and survived a suicide mission.
He got special look on life, and are temporarily removed from Noble when they have to fight Innies for... reasons.

humble yacht
#

Emile is certainly proficient as a soldier, moreso than a majority of Spartan IIIs since he got into Noble Team

#

that said, he tries harder than his teammates to be imposing

#

which could be seen as "wannabe" in some ways

jolly swift
#

he's an emo teen's spartan OC

vernal badger
#

my bad, he did not actually get deployed to the usual Spartan III suicide missions, due to being an emo liner - i mean having an aptitude that did not fit in with the other Spartan IIIs of his company, but him getting into Noble Team still speaks volumes of his skill.

cedar surge
#

So smile was being considered to be replaced because he was too violent?

vernal badger
#

Not considered to be replaced. It was just planned to swap him out for another Spartan if Noble were sendt on another mission against Insurrectionists, as his brutality made for bad PR.

#

Detail oriented and effective, and diciplined off the battlefield.
More than you can say about certain other members of Noble :p

humble yacht
#

effective
lol, sure

vernal badger
#

The only problem is that he uses that shotgun instead of taking full advantage of his 1337 pro pipe skills!

cinder sluice
#

😡

cedar surge
#

Maybe they were also planning on switching him out because he never looks at his motion tracker

jolly swift
#

Emile plays life like it's MLG

stable flower
#

I wonder why Spartan-IIIs were deployed against innies. Isn't that a job for Spartan-IIs?

jolly swift
#

I guess the II's had more pressing matters

deep pewter
#

Don’t ask questions about Reach’s story

stable flower
#

Don’t ask questions about Reach’s story
@deep pewter Oh right, I forgot.

deep pewter
#

None of the questions have answers

stable flower
#

Reach is the only game where Bungie even mentioned the innies.

craggy sierra
#

My only question for Reach is why is it like this? And that’s more so directed at the people who made it.

versed helm
#

I would’ve preferred to have actually fought the innies for a time. Then again, I think it was a smart move on Bungie’s part to immediately open you up to covenant conflict — I doubt insurrection from the get-go would be as presentable in letting the player feel like it’s a Halo game

cedar surge
#

Innies wouldn't have as much variety as the covenant would

versed helm
#

Maybe some stragglers on the 2nd or third mission before returning to more Covenant

cedar surge
#

They use repurposed unsc and a little covenant tech

versed helm
#

Would still be pretty interesting, in moderation

#

And in Firefight

deep pewter
#

If they weren’t going to be a meaningful idea, why even introduce them?

versed helm
#

Just a little spicing tool for the sandbox and narrative

#

Showing how widespread of an impact the invasion makes

deep pewter
#

But as soon as the invasion starts civilians are almost entirely ignored, there’s a bit later on in that mission but that’s about it

versed helm
#

Insurgents would be lagging around moreso than the average civilian; especially given their potential footholds over certain regions

#

If we were to come across one, it could have a meaningful effect

#

It would also be a great reference point for how competent Spartans are, by having an enemy more relatable

#

(If they were to make them canon fodder)

west silo
#

Question wasn't the slip space crystal in first strike destroyed?

jolly swift
#

playing through Halo 3 again, it's pretty obvious that Bungie intended the Forerunners to be ancient humans

gilded mason
#

Some of Bungie, at least.

carmine sleet
#

So glad that isn't what happened

jolly swift
#

I kinda like the idea

craggy sierra
#

What little we knew about the forerunners would’ve made them too far gone from being relatable for that to even really resonate.

lean karma
#

do we know the exact day Jorge joined and left UNICOM to join noble team?

#

Im working on writing an unofficial novel of marines in UNICOM who worked with Jorge while he was there in group 3

#

i couldent find a date anywhere

craggy sierra
#

Also there’s definitely a lot more leaning into the idea the forerunners made a sacrifice in making themselves extinct when firing the rings too.

#

And if we were actually forerunners, why wouldn’t we have left some manuals lying around to re-elevate ourselves back up to the same level of intergalactic society?

#

There’s a lot that doesn’t quite add up if you follow that thread.

ocean ibex
#

Wouldn’t we have discovered by now that we have part forerunner genes

versed helm
#

Why?

jolly furnace
#

What we chattn bout?

#

Humans don't have Forerunner genes

#

They have genetic commands and instructions/key that lets them activate and use Forerunner tech on instinct or as if they were Forerunners

#

Humans and Forerunners do have an extremely similar base genetic code however there is no confirmed genetic relation between the species.

#

Ultimately the origins of both lay with the Precursors

jolly swift
#

We're talking about how it seems like the original intent may have been for Forerunners to actually be ancient humans

jolly furnace
#

It was

#

It changed

#

That's it

jolly swift
#

Correct

gilded mason
#

If humans did have Forerunner genes, how would they know they're Forerunner ones? They don't have Forerunner genetic material onhand, so they'd just assume it's just human genes.

jolly furnace
#

Yah

west silo
#

Does geas count as forerunner genes

gilded mason
#

Nope

west silo
#

Why not

#

Or is it because its more space ghost than dna

cedar surge
#

Its instructions

west silo
#

Didn't chakas have some geas?

jolly furnace
#

Geas are genetic commands and instructions and brainwashing tool and genetic storage for essences of dead people. Its weird

#

Also they can control ur physical actions even if ur aware of the geas and don't want to do what the geas is making u do

#

As we see in Primordium

#

Resisting causes physical pain

west silo
#

Soo basically basically its a plot Swiss army knife

jolly furnace
#

Yah

#

And yes Chakas had a geas as did every other human on Earth once

#

Chakas' sisters may have passed those same geas onto any character we know

#

If their bloodline survived intact

#

Also Riser too

cedar surge
#

So at any point in the games it could have just been the geas in the pilot seat?

west silo
#

So geas can also move through bloodlines?

cedar surge
#

Well its generic

#

Genetic

west silo
#

Sounds kinda genetic to me

cedar surge
#

So I don't see why not

#

Plus it stayed around for thousands of years

#

So I think its safe to say yea it dies

#

Does

west silo
#

Man would it be likely to meet any durances on zeta

cedar surge
#

Durances?

#

Are those new

#

Setinals?

#

Oh hey

#

Maybe we will see onyx setinals in infinite

#

Maybe they havnt been forgotten

humble yacht
#

All bloodlines got erased when the halos fired

cedar surge
#

Werennt the geas installed after

humble yacht
#

The conservation measure included seeding the new humanity with genesongs

#

But it’s not like anything would have been passed down by Chakas or his line

west silo
#

Durances?
@cedar surge
There basically forerunner souls that are contained instead objects

jolly furnace
#

@humble yacht Chakas had many sisters, some could have survived the Array firing if taken to Ark and put back on Earth and had descendents. If so his bloodline may be intact through them

#

Meaning the geas in him and any AH essences could still exist in modern humans

humble yacht
#

Humans weren't taken to the ark

jolly furnace
#

Earth humans were

humble yacht
#

the only survivors on the ark were a small group of forerunners

jolly furnace
#

No

humble yacht
#

earth humans died on earth with the librarian

jolly furnace
#

Many were taken to Ark

#

that was the point of the conservation measure

west silo
#

The ones on the greater ark died

jolly furnace
#

The lesser ark

#

Its detailed in Rebirth

#

And Slentium

west silo
#

Oh

jolly furnace
#

Point is Chakas line could still be around.

#

But Im not expectin anything to come from that

west silo
#

Well he was going to find there geass

#

In rion

#

Or use her in some way

#

Wait am thinking of his friends

#

Not family

jolly furnace
#

He wanted to find Riser and Vennera's geas or essences or go into domain to be with them there

#

That was as Spark

#

His sisters are long dead

#

but his own bloodline could be intact if they have living descendants

west silo
#

Well weren't they said to have gone silent

jolly furnace
#

thus his geas could be in descendants of his sisters

west silo
#

If they were lucky enough to survive

jolly furnace
#

Yah

#

Its not impossible

humble yacht
#

Chakas wouldn't have been turned into a geas

jolly furnace
#

No but the geas in him could also have been in his sisters

humble yacht
#

only if the geas in Chakas came from his parents

#

but it didn't. chakas got those genesongs placed in him directly

jolly furnace
#

Its like this - I have a geas and many AH essences. That same geas could be passed into any children i have.

#

and so on and so on

humble yacht
#

sisters are not children

jolly furnace
#

Oh jeez

#

His parents could pass the same geas into all of their kids potentially

#

Chakas and his sisters

humble yacht
#

his parents didn't get geas

#

he did

jolly furnace
#

assuming they are not half-siblings

#

Then how did he get it?

#

He was born with it

humble yacht
#

didact and librarian put them in him

jolly furnace
#

Yah she did that with the AHs who were originally devolved

#

and they had descendants

#

CHakas is one of those descendants

humble yacht
#

as an infant, Chakas was implanted with a geas

#

he wasn't born with it

jolly furnace
#

I'll go back and re-read it

#

but im sure im correct

humble yacht
#

i'm looking at halopedia right now

jolly furnace
#

Also didact did nothing

#

He didnt even know of what she was doing

#

nor would he have approved

#

hence why she didn't tell him

humble yacht
#

ok sure, he wasn't involved

#

still doesn't change that it happened post birth

jolly furnace
#

Ok seems ur right bout imprint at birth thing

#

But is that the instructions to find and open the cryptum or the essences of god knows how many AHs

#

Or one of them only

humble yacht
#

well, it was Forthencho's genesong

#

and later it manifested as a voice in chakas' head

jolly furnace
#

Among many

west silo
#

Well didn't that happen because born arrived and it just kicked in

jolly furnace
#

She put 1000s of essences into the surviving AHs when the war ended

west silo
#

So was everything chief did
destined to happen?

humble yacht
#

sort of

#

humanity was destined to create beings like the spartans, to create AI, to go to space

#

humanity was not destined to go to war with the covenant

west silo
#

So the librarian was able to put all this in place

jolly furnace
#

Many things could have went wrong

#

She didn't have seer powers

humble yacht
#

so while a being like chief was destined to eventually come about, most of his actions (i.e. saving the galaxy) were not destined

jolly furnace
#

Natural disasters yada yada could have killed us al first

#

we could have killed ourselves

humble yacht
#

though ultimately, humanity was destined to find forerunner stuff and "reclaim" it

jolly furnace
#

Alien religious fanatics could have

#

would have

#

we got lucky there

west silo
#

No it was all part of the plan

#

She didn't have seer powers
@jolly furnace
Well they kinda did

humble yacht
#

the covenant was not part of the librarian's plan

west silo
#

It's just really vague and we only saw it in action once

jolly furnace
#

She had great ability to predict possibilities and eventualities. Not outright future sight. Now the Gravemind or Precursors on the other hand may have...

#

🤔

humble yacht
#

booooriiiiing

west silo
#

Oh am not talking her

#

I mean forerunners had future sight

#

With technology!!!

humble yacht
#

nope

west silo
#

Yep

humble yacht
#

nope

west silo
#

But as I said its vague

#

And the domain can kinda predict or warn about up coming future events

humble yacht
#

whut

#

where'd you get that idea?

west silo
#

Warfleet

#

And one line in slientium

humble yacht
#

the domain has been described as self aware, and as having the ability to choose what info it holds onto and how it represents that info

#

but it can't tell the future

west silo
#

It was showing the forerunners there descendants from the future trying to warn them

humble yacht
#

at most it can extrapolate the outcome of a major incident

jolly furnace
#

Show me the Warfleet qoute please. I don;t know this info

west silo
#

I don't have it right now

#

But its calledd the clench in the book

#

Clench tactics

humble yacht
#

i think you're talking about when the domain reached out to Bornstellar, telling him to preserve the history of his race

west silo
#

Its basically the forerunners using advanced maths along with slipspace to see into the future

humble yacht
#

that would be prediction, not visualization

#

predictions can be wrong, even with advanced math

west silo
#

Still seeing into the future

#

It just might not be perfect

humble yacht
#

seeing the future and making predictions based on math are totally different

#

besides, you said before that it was the domain that saw the future, now you're saying its the forerunners

west silo
#

Then again maybe they can use it to see the future

#

Slipspace is weird and all

humble yacht
#

i think you just have wishful thinking

jolly furnace
#

Oh yeah forerunners used math or advanced slipspace stuff to predict the probabilities of each outcome in battles

#

I imagine their contemporaries had similar capability if they were to contend with that

humble yacht
#

we do that today

west silo
#

I imagine their contemporaries had similar capability if they were to contend with that
@jolly furnace
Well its used against ancient humanity

#

But its not stated and its from the lord of admirals perspective who has no idea what's going on

jolly furnace
#

@humble yacht This is more advanced and remember Forerunner space battles happened so fast modern humans couldn't even perceive them properly and these battles could happen all over the galaxy at once and be over in minutes or less.

#

I imagine AH and the San'Shyuum had the ability to contend with and perceive that kind of speed and temporal screwery with their own tech or else they'd never have lasted 1000 years against the Forerunners.

west silo
#

So how do you think the forerunners would do against the tyranids

lapis jetty
#

Can someone briefly explain to me how the primordial was imprisoned and if it had anything to do with the ancient human's sacrificing 1/3 of their population? Are those two related? I keep seeing conflicting answers when I search myself

west silo
#

We don't really know

#

He was found in an asteroid then moved to the human capital

lapis jetty
#

So there's no official lore explanation how it was imprisoned?

west silo
#

He could have been imprisoned by the precursors or the forerunners

lapis jetty
#

I've seen some accounts say the AH sac'd 1/3 of their pop to imprison it, others that the forerunners did it during the forerunner-precursor war

west silo
#

No

#

They sacd 1/3 of there population to kill the flood

#

Forcing the flood to retreat

#

Its revealed that the flood only retreat because they had other plans

#

I've seen some accounts say the AH sac'd 1/3 of their pop to imprison it, others that the forerunners did it during the forerunner-precursor war
@lapis jetty
Not likely that was a war of extermination

#

The forerunners only felt bad after all the precursors either died or retreated from the galaxy

lapis jetty
#

the word "sacrificed" which is used in the forerunner trilogy in my mind implies an active decision to kill specifically 1/3 of their pop. Is that meant as in the AH happened to lose 1/3 of their people fighting the flood? Or that some deal was struck between AH and the flood? That the flood would let the other 2/3 live if 1/3 was sac'd? The wording just throws me off

west silo
#

They messed up. 1/3 of there population and sent them to die against the flood to get infected and mess the flood up

lapis jetty
#

Hm, interesting, thanks for the info. Halo lore is badass

west silo
#

Dang right it is

strange bay
#

Does anyone know if we are getting into on how cheif ended up in space and with older armour or are we gonna get that info in infinite?

west silo
#

Gotta wait till infinite

#

But most likely he was spaced when something happened to the ship he was abroad

strange bay
#

Maybe..

#

That would explain why he doesn't have a stasis cause if they didnt have time then he would just have to hope that he gets picked up

#

Or stasis pod

west silo
#

Well considering what we saw in the game reveal I doubt it was voluntarily

strange bay
#

If it was voluntary he would have been more prepared right?

west silo
#

Might have just took a pelican

#

Or just jump in the direction of the ring

strange bay
#

Just jumped and hoped for the best lol

#

Luckily that pilot found him

versed helm
#

I'm pretty sure his suit locked, like in the beginning of H3

west silo
#

Lucky indeed

#

Its almost like that's a trope with him

versed helm
#

The suit just...pauses

strange bay
#

Doesn't he have a differnt suit in h5 and h5?

versed helm
#

Like " hold on fam, imma need a breather"

strange bay
#

Meant h4

west silo
#

I'm pretty sure his suit locked, like in the beginning of H3
@versed helm
In infinite its said its in some kind of survival mode

strange bay
#

Huh

versed helm
#

It was the same in H3. Suit locked to ensure minimal damage due to movement

#

Gel lock and stuff

strange bay
#

His suit looks too old to be able to keep him alive though wouldn't a newer suit be better

west silo
#

And it drained his suit

versed helm
#

It IS a new suit

west silo
#

His suit looks too old to be able to keep him alive though wouldn't a newer suit be better
@strange bay
Believe me he has a lot of suits

versed helm
#

All suit powers probably went to life support and stasis

strange bay
#

Yeah he does doesnt he

versed helm
#

Hence no movement

strange bay
#

That also make sense seeing as normally his suit wouldn't be able to support it would it

west silo
#

All suit powers probably went to life support and stasis
@versed helm
I don't think miljor has stasis

versed helm
#

We don't know if this one does

#

The old ones didnt

#

This one could

#

New tech

west silo
#

Shadows of reach gives us nothing

#

On the specs

#

Other than its an improvement from the last one

versed helm
#

So, we don't know what all it can do

#

Besides a grapple

strange bay
#

I mean it has to be if hes just been floating around right

west silo
#

And removing thrusters for god knows why

#

Yep

#

Grapple hook cool

strange bay
#

Yeah all we know is that he has a grape now

versed helm
#

Like I said, all power most likely went to life support and stasis

#

Makes sense the thrusters wouldn't work

strange bay
#

I can already tell I'm gonna be to into melee combat because of this grappel

versed helm
#

No point carrying around a corpse

west silo
#

Its not like thrusters are better in every way

#

Weren't we already in melee combat most of the time?

versed helm
#

I can already tell I'm gonna be to into melee combat because of this grappel
@strange bay gonna blood punch the ever living heck outta them covies

strange bay
#

Yeah you have a point @versed helm but also being able to get to your destination and now being potential space junk is nice

#

@versed helm yes

#

Blood punches

versed helm
#

If you think about it, being still and in stasis offers a better chance of survival than the thrusters do, for a small thing like the suit

strange bay
#

Yeah it would give a better chance but if he was never found then that would be it for John

versed helm
#

Thrusters would shorten the time span a lot

#

Plus, if no ships are in range, he would legit get lost in space

strange bay
#

And not everything was life support cause he still had to have power for the beacon

west silo
#

Thrusters allow you to move in space

#

Plus it's not like there constantly on to drain the suits power

strange bay
#

A controlled burst every now and then is nice

#

Just so you dont lose your trajectory

versed helm
#

But only if you have a destination

west silo
#

The biggest to me is that gen3 the suit that is said to be the best of the best has worse active camouflage than SPI

versed helm
#

He didnt know where to go

strange bay
#

His destination was most likely the ring right?

west silo
#

Yep

#

Plus we don't know if the suit has stasis iys just a guess

versed helm
#

Oi. We still don't know how he got into stasis. He could've been hit mid jump, or blown out of a ship

#

Impact caused gel lock and stasis

west silo
#

How would the thrusters affect the suits stasis anyways

versed helm
#

Power

strange bay
#

Or it could have been a last minute addition to his suit

#

As he wa as being evacuated

versed helm
#

Lesser stasis duration

west silo
#

Ohhhhh I get it

#

You mean stasis as in gel lock

#

That doesn't require power from the suit

strange bay
#

Hell even a gun could provide propulsion

west silo
#

Its just hardens on impact

versed helm
#

And the suit has a survival protocol, right. Priority goes to safeguarding the guy inside. So, suit remains still still someone comes and helps

west silo
#

Wouldn't that just leave him super exposed?

versed helm
#

Any heavy impact could've caused gel lock

strange bay
#

Ahh so safe guard is a distress beacon and a hardened suit

versed helm
#

The same happened in H3. He legit froze

strange bay
#

Will life support or stasis

#

@versed helm I dont remember that?

west silo
#

When he entered orbit

versed helm
#

Then the suit reactivated on identifying friendlies

west silo
#

He wasn't in space

#

He was already in earths gravity

versed helm
#

The crash caused the gel lock

west silo
#

Then the suit reactivated on identifying friendlies
@versed helm
Didn't the marines unlock it

#

Pretty sure the one with the computer did

#

It happened to Fred as well in the books

#

And chief had to unlock it for him

versed helm
#

Heck. Forgot that. My bad

#

But you all get the idea, right

west silo
#

Yep

versed helm
#

Heavy impact causes gel lock

west silo
#

Just aim for the planet

versed helm
#

And hope you got a friend with a laptop on planetside

versed helm
#

otherwise, you're a new entry into the wax museum

midnight loom
#

haha. it does? i thought high pressure did.

#

or gravity.

#

like when general grave captured blue.

west silo
#

Well the shockwave from a nuke did cause Fred's armor to lock so yeah

midnight loom
#

hmm...

#

so the gel is supposed to protect?

humble yacht
#

The gel layer? Yes, it acts as a shock absorption layer

midnight loom
#

yeah but why does it llock up?

#

isnt that bad?

humble yacht
#

To prevent a Spartan’s body from twisting or breaking during impact

#

Of course

#

Well that dude is wrong

#

Gameplay does not equal canon

west silo
#

Some suits have a function though

stable flower
#

That dude must be a know-it-all who hates sprint.

gilded mason
#

Nope

humble yacht
#

The sprint mod from reach is a redirection of power to make the user achieve top speeds not normally possible

west silo
#

That was TFoR

humble yacht
#

Basically allowing a super sprint

west silo
#

He tore his tendon

humble yacht
#

He’s wrong

midnight loom
#

bruh those are supposed to make them FASTER

west silo
#

Come on

humble yacht
#

Just tell him he’s wrong and if he doesn’t accept it, move on

west silo
#

Just watch a trailer

#

Any trailer

midnight loom
#

yeah...

#

pretty dum that guy iz...

west silo
#

Isn't sprinting just running?

humble yacht
#

Just ignore it

#

Sprinting is a particular type of running

midnight loom
#

true, true.

west silo
#

Very fast running then

humble yacht
#

Sprinting is basically running at maximum effort

midnight loom
#

they can go down faster than that so they should be able to go sideways just as fast.

humble yacht
#

It’s the cardio equivalent of benching your max

midnight loom
#

lol all i see now is chief running and a fireball forming around him because of the cmopressed are

#

*air

west silo
#

So running at your fullest

midnight loom
#

yeah i think.

west silo
#

Well chief did hurt himself doing that

midnight loom
#

but on the other hand, sprinting for most sprtans is just jogging for kelly...

#

it says so in the buks

#

so what would kelly's sprint be called?

humble yacht
#

Kelly is the fastest spartan but she’s not that fast

west silo
#

But that was after a anti tank missile blew up 2 meters behind him

midnight loom
#

sonic: goes back in time kelly: lands in the future without slipspace

#

it said so in the lore.

#

she was super fast.

#

it said that jhon with mjolner only IMPRESSED kelly no mjolner

#

0.0.

#

i forgot if it was fall of reach or something.

#

i cant get to halopedia because its blocked but ill take ur word for it.

#

hasnt kelly been seen in comix running as fast as a truck on a highway?

jolly swift
#

so, why is the Mega Construx figure called SPARTAN Lang, when Ava Lang was an ODST, and is, by all accounts, dead? that's gotta be a misnomer, right?

radiant raft
#

🎃🎃🎃

stiff creek
#

It is a mistake, yes.

#

It says Spartan Lang on the box, while on the case, it says ODST Lang.

versed helm
#

accidents do happen

pearl oasis
#

I presume this question has alreadu been answered but

#

ODSTs still exist post Human-Covenant war right? (Not counting the Spirit of Fire's ODSTs)

humble yacht
#

Yes

pearl oasis
#

Makes me wondered what role would they be relagated to? Rapid insertion like before? Or do they have competition with Spartan IVs?

humble yacht
#

ODSTs always had “competition” with spartans

#

But ODSTs are still used like they used to be

#

After the war, buck and the rest of Alpha Nine were sent on a mission to defeat some innies

pearl oasis
#

mhm

#

that makes sense

versed helm
#

Clean up?

stiff creek
#

To take down some peeps.

#

Mission wasn't worth it.

#

sniff

cedar surge
#

Unsc should have used the sound rifle more

craggy sierra
#

There’s only a few hundred spartans.

#

ODSTs are far and away much more numerous still

carmine sleet
#

Spartans are also not meant as replacements for the ODSTs. Spartans, even in the post war era with the S-IVs, are meant for operations which are highly dangerous to most other operatives

pearl oasis
#

that would make sense

stiff creek
#

I wish ODST's weren't just Marine reskins in 2 and 3.

#

Neat how Ruby's Rebalanced Halo changed that.

craggy sierra
#

What do you expect them to be?

#

They’re just normal dudes

#

Except they sometimes drop from space

#

Not really anything to make them radically different if you stick then in the same spot as a marine

#

But also in Halo 3, ODSTs aren’t the same because they’re battery powered

#

I’m not even joking, a programming error makes it so they die via energy drain while normal marines are fine.

stiff creek
#

That's kinda funny.

#

They are just normal dudes, but they are highly trained normal dudes. Each of them specialists.
Most of em, anyway.

craggy sierra
#

Thing is you can’t exactly convey that in gameplay with a game like Halo.

carmine sleet
#

Ruby's mod making ODST specialist ranks is literally just something he did based off of the roles of the ODST squad in ODST. The colours he gave each of them have no grounding in canon in regards to what specialisation an ODST has

#

I could wear blue ODST armour but that wouldn't mean I am an ODST sniper

craggy sierra
#

Maybe if it was CoD and you had a super hand holdy campaign that has friendly AI scripted down to the pixel for every moment of its run time to take up co-ordinated positioning in every combat arena but that isn’t how Halo’s made at all.

carmine sleet
#

Plus, it's highly unlikely every ODST squad will always feature one sniper, one explosives expert, etc

#

There would more than likely be overlap as well

stiff creek
#

Just like...
give the ODST guys more health, or something.
I didn't really mean the exact same as Ruby's ODST's either, just wanted to bring that up.

craggy sierra
#

Well again, like I said, they are technically battery powered because of a bug

stiff creek
#

and that's funny

craggy sierra
#

But anyways I doubt anyone would even notice if they had extra health anyways

#

I barely notice when I have friendly AI with me in Halo.

inland axle
#

I have a doubt

#

If you use the green regenerator near them, they actually recover health?

#

Same question for the marines

craggy sierra
#

Yeah I think the regenerator affects health values

stiff creek
#

Everything.

#

If you throw down a regenerator on 04b it starts building itself faster guys try it I'm not joking this isn't a joke

humble yacht
#

Having better training than a standard marine doesn't make you more bullet resistant, tho

#

at most, I'd say ODST AI should have slightly higher accuracy or attack than standard Marine AI

craggy sierra
#

What do you mean? If you get shot enough you start building up a tolerance.

stiff creek
humble yacht
#

where's my bullet vaccine

stiff creek
#

sobbing

craggy sierra
#

It was in the works till covid hit. Then they diverted the resources.

#

But yeah, Halo 3 has a lot of...interesting choices in what it chooses to tell the player about health mechanics.

#

Not to hijack the lore channel but did you know that while your shields begin regenning after 4 seconds, your actual health doesn’t begin coming back until after like 10 seconds.

#

And that’s all I gotta say on that. It’s an interesting choice for the game to keep you in the dark on approximately 40% of your health value at all times.

cedar surge
#

Biofoam injectors

#

Also don't odsts have better armor

#

Than marines

craggy sierra
#

No

#

I mean they have fancier helmets

#

But that’s largely just cause they find themselves in outside situations more often in space.

humble yacht
#

ODST don't have onboard biofoam injectors

#

they need to get biofoam administered externally

stiff creek
#

cough Romeo cough

#

That probably left a nasty scar.

#

I wanna see it.

cedar surge
#

Its probavly all healed due to unsc hhealing stuff

sick surge
#

taking that as a yes, sorry mods

humble yacht
#

biofoam has tissue regen properties so that would probably help prevent scars

stiff creek
#

From something as damaging as what he had to endure?

humble yacht
#

maybe

cedar surge
#

Well he did had to feel what felt like fire ants in his woumd

humble yacht
#

just during the application

#

exposed nerve endings don't like touching stuff

sick surge
#

spicy boys

humble yacht
#

biofoam has pain relief medication in it so it would provide local anesthesia to the wounded area

sick surge
#

biofoam bath ☺️

humble yacht
#

yea that wouldn't work

#

you either wouldn't be able to enter the bath or you'd be trapped in it for hours, unable to move

stiff creek
#

^

#

Kek

sick surge
#

how lame, its probably expensive too

stiff creek
#

Then the tub would be all gross afterwards.

humble yacht
#

not sure if biofoam leaves residue after it breaks down

#

also not sure if its water soluble...

stiff creek
#

Ehhhhh..

#

ew.

acoustic dock
#

yeah so does halo 2

#

oh no

#

i was reading older messages

#

o_o

#

also no bio foam wouldnt work if it was water soluble

inner basin
#

Imagine needing to apply bio foam in raining conditions. Would kinda ruin the point of applying it if it was water soluble

stiff creek
#

Also depending on the quality of rain, the wound may get effed up.

fair hazel
#

Medigel bath

stiff creek
#

Bacta pool

#

Shantae

#

Hot spring

#

Healimg

humble yacht
#

hot springs heal Link in BOTW, too

stiff creek
#

Was gonna mention that.

echo ember
#

yes

flat bone
#

?

ocean ibex
#

Why is Halsey always rude to spartan IV’s lmao

west silo
#

She's rude to all Spartans not 2s

#

Its more she sees them as cheap knockoffs

ocean ibex
#

I can understand 4’s but come on, spartan 3’s deserve some credit

west silo
#

Well there case is kinda sad

#

They were basically suicide soldiers

ocean ibex
#

They did as much as the 2’s in ending the war

cedar surge
#

And technically a 3 is the only reason why master chief saved humanity

ocean ibex
#

Multiple

#

Jun just dipped

gilded mason
#

Once she got to know the 3s she was with, she became much more sympathetic to them, from what I remember.

west silo
#

I know

#

Halsey just sees them as such

ocean ibex
#

Most of the ones she knew are dead lmao

west silo
#

And to be honest the person who made them she wasn't really a fan of

#

Once she got to know the 3s she was with, she became much more sympathetic to them, from what I remember.
@gilded mason
Well the 3s are pretty tragic

#

And the 4s are basically navy seals with power armor

ocean ibex
#

The threes didn’t get any glory cuz most of their missions were known by few

west silo
#

So were the 2s till they were made public

cedar surge
#

Wait what

#

She was a fan of ackersan?

#

I thought they didn't like each other

gilded mason
#

I think he meant to say "wasn't really a fan of"

west silo
#

Yeah

nimble crest
#

She was pleasant towards Jun

#

In fistful of arrows tho

jolly swift
#

she didn't know Noble were Spartan 3's until long after

#

she just assumed somebody had made another class of 2's

nimble crest
#

She didn’t notice the fact they all had unique armor and not green Mjolnir Mk5?

gilded mason
#

She did. But as Kualsi said -

west silo
#

Well fist full of arrows isnt really canon

inner basin
#

Well fist full of arrows isnt really canon
Unfortunately. Personally, I really enjoyed it

fair hazel
#

that's a fan comic

inner basin
#

I am aware. There were discussions to make it canon at one point if I’m not mistaken because of the quality of the book, but those discussions fell through

west silo
#

Yeah it was alright

#

But it didn't really add anything

#

Wait a minute wasn't suppose to bring halsey to castle base?

humble yacht
#

He did

#

Or at least took her somewhere where she could head to castle base safely

west silo
#

How did he get separated from her

humble yacht
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

west silo
#

Because I remember that frankie wrote a little story of him climbing off reach

cedar surge
#

So after climbing up the elevator how did jun actually get off reach then

humble yacht
#

What elevator?

vagrant hawk
#

The space elevator?

west silo
#

The Frankie story

#

It was on Twitter

#

So after climbing up the elevator how did jun actually get off reach then
@cedar surge
Probably found a pelican

humble yacht
#

That might have been a joke story

west silo
#

I don't think frankies that much of a troll

#

And it doesn't contradict anything

#

Since jun only existed in the game reach and wasn't in first strike

humble yacht
#

But it’s not listed as an official source

#

And cia wouldn’t be likely to leave out something like that

west silo
#

Or would he?

humble yacht
#

He wouldn’t

west silo
#

Eh just file it in to the semi canon folder

humble yacht
#

Not when he listed the confirmed non canon “fistful of arrows” story

west silo
#

That's strange

#

Especially since that isn't canon

#

It just a really good fanfic

#

Maybe he isn't aware of it?

humble yacht
#

Unlikely

#

He’s one of the most knowledgeable lore aficionados around

west silo
#

Still weird to take fanfiction as canon

#

Instead of something that came from the head of 343 that might at least be canon

humble yacht
#

I didn’t say it’s listed as canon

#

It’s just mentioned on the wiki

west silo
#

So its just mentioned

#

That's better

humble yacht
#

Also Frankie is not the head of 343

#

That’s Bonnie

west silo
#

Oh

#

So is frankie like second in command?

humble yacht
#

I don’t think it works like that

#

His position is Franchise Director

west silo
#

Question do they list comments that confirm stuff as sources too?

terse lava
#

No I don't belive so

west silo
#

Uhh

#

Its because I remember the 200 year old elite thing now

cedar surge
#

How old do elites go

west silo
#

But we only assume it 200 in human years and it was confirmed by the author

#

On Twitter of course!!

#

The oldest we know is 200

#

And he was basically in his 50s

cedar surge
#

What do they mean 200 in human tears

west silo
#

Years

cedar surge
#

Like elites see time slower or faster?

west silo
#

Sanghelios has slower years than ours

cedar surge
#

Or that we think that's old

gilded mason
#

It takes more time for Sanghelios to revolve around its suns than Earth does its own

#

Yeah, what Spartan said

west silo
#

From our resident elite himself

cedar surge
#

So every colony works on earth time?

gilded mason
#

Both, I guess.

west silo
#

Yeah

#

It makes it more easier I guess

#

Imagine meeting a 5 year old who's 20 because of how fast his planet rotates

ocean ibex
#

Are ballistics really that ineffective against combat forms as shown in the Mona Lisa film?

west silo
#

Yep

#

Especially snipers

#

Only infection forms are really that vulnerable

ocean ibex
#

Why didn’t they just use incendiary or armor piercing rounds

cedar surge
#

Well wwould using incendiary rounds on a ship be a good idea

#

Or armor piercing rounds and potentially miss and hit your own hull

jolly swift
#

I should hope ship hulls are more durable than that

cedar surge
#

Inside out but yea

#

Well ain't the Mona Lisa a prison ship

#

Why would it need incendiary rounds

jolly swift
#

incendiary weapons are also... highly illegal

#

the flamethrower is even not meant as a weapon

#

it's for clearing brush

cedar surge
#

Well the hellbringers would disagree with you

ocean ibex
#

You think rules of engagement matter when fighting aliens and galaxy threatening zombies

west silo
#

That's kinda what the unsc said

ocean ibex
#

Wdym

west silo
#

Plus the mona Lisa was a prison ship that most likely wouldn't have access to incendiary weapons

#

Wdym
@ocean ibex
The whole its a war of genocide thing

#

Using Flame throwers against people is a war crime yet the unsc has entire troops dedicated to using them against the covenant

midnight loom
#

well this is centuries after now, who noes if they are still a war crime then...

cedar surge
#

Well every faction already commited a war crime by that point

#

The unsc probably equal to the covenant if not more

craggy sierra
#

Incendiary weapons aren’t illegal. It’s only napalm that is.

ocean ibex
#

Armor piercing would work too

#

Cuts through bio mass easier

#

Higher chance of killing the form inside

analog frigate
#

yo

versed helm
#

They'd have to be pretty strong AP rounds, then

midnight loom
#

well no, it would be better if the bullet stayed inside (those banned expanding bullets)

craggy sierra
#

Flechette rounds?

unique rune
#

Hollow-point, I would assume? As far as I’m aware, their legality is... contentious, depending on where in the world you are, and they’re specifically designed to expand upon impact to prevent overpenetration, which would be a problem with using AP on soft targets.

stable flower
#

Using Flame throwers against people is a war crime yet the unsc has entire troops dedicated to using them against the covenant
@west silo Well the Covenant kill innocent civilians in their genocide against the humans, so it's fair that the UNSC use Flamethrowers on them.

ocean ibex
#

Aren’t there armor piercing incendiary rounds

#

Now that would be very illegal

crimson moth
#

Yo who is worried about it being illegal when master chief is literally a kidnapped child

versed helm
#

ONI and UNSC is doing legal stuff, given that their enemies are non human

#

It would be a war crime if the covies were a human faction or something

#

But, since they isn't human

#

No war crimes

ocean ibex
#

I’m talking about the flood where anything is allowed

versed helm
#

But I'm pretty sure that the SoS can sue for war crimes now

ocean ibex
#

For how much lmao

versed helm
#

Idk

ocean ibex
#

Is there like a galactic currency

versed helm
#

 ̄\_(ツ)_/ ̄

ocean ibex
#

Anyways wouldn’t an AP-incendiary bullet be useful against combat forms and other pure forms?

#

Why not?

#

What about the armor piercing aspect?

#

It seemed like a good idea at first but you’re actually right

#

It’s only good for burning bodies

#

And or hives

barren pike
#

Imagine debating the morals and ethics of the unsc when we know they're down with kidnapping children and injecting them with bone augmenting juice to make them into super soldiers

ocean ibex
#

It’s fun to talk about

stable flower
#

Imagine debating the morals and ethics of the unsc when we know they're down with kidnapping children and injecting them with bone augmenting juice to make them into super soldiers
@barren pike And give them the task of fighting a bunch of rebels.

inner basin
#

Imagine debating the morals and ethics of the unsc when we know they're down with kidnapping children and injecting them with bone augmenting juice to make them into super soldiers
Well it was actually ONI. Not many UNSC personnel outside of ONI knew about the origins of the Spartan-II program at the time of its creation

#

Hell, some ONI operatives didn’t even know about the Spartan-II program at the time of its creation. It was highly classified (for obvious reasons)

faint stone
jolly geode
#

what would it be like living under cortanas rule

humble yacht
#

No more rated M games

jolly swift
#

cortana says we can't play Halo

versed helm
#

In Reach, for the forge world background, is the battle a major one, and is it even named?

humble yacht
#

probably not

#

forge world isn't a canon experience

winged venture
#

Cortana would ban the matrix and terminator movies 😦

cedar surge
#

Propbably master chief propaganda 24/7

west silo
#

Probably exposing stuff about oni

#

And not being able to have ais anymore

obsidian thistle
#

Forge World was later called a "Simulation" on the Halo Array lore stream

#

So is canon. Just not in a "normal" way

hard star
#

That's nice

midnight loom
#

cool

#

setting the flood on fire would mean if they set YOU on fire if they catch you.

humble yacht
#

the efficacy of fire against the flood wouldn't be the pain it caused them

#

but rather the amount damage it would do to the flood form's whole body in a short amount of time

#

the first few seconds would damage the outer skin but after that, the burns would start to go deeper

ember tusk
#

yeah
its also great in H3 when you set a combat form on fire and they just run at you
so many times have I lost speedruns and no-death runs to those enemys

versed helm
#

what if when you died to the flood, it showed Chief slowly getting infected

#

and becoming a combat form

flat bone
#

why do the halo 3 flood split into 5000 pieces when you punch them enough, is this canon or gameplay

humble yacht
#

gameplay

flat bone
#

k

versed helm
#

spooky

jolly swift
#

so, why not use the Composer on the Flood?

flat bone
#

how are you orange

jolly swift
#

because I'm Mr. Halloween

humble yacht
#

so, why not use the Composer on the Flood?
Because it's not effective on a large scale

#

and the composed beings retain the infection

midnight loom
#

well yes

#

but they become data

#

delete!

jolly swift
#

no more flood!

humble yacht
#

there are more effective ways to eliminate flood on a large scale than the composer

jolly swift
#

fire

midnight loom
#

but the composer means no deaths

#

and it means even the hiding infection forms go boomboom

humble yacht
#

but it's a thin beam that you have to aim manually and it takes time to compose large numbers

#

you'd get attacked while using it

flat bone
#

in Halo 5 (idk about 4) before prometheans spawn blue things appear. what are they

humble yacht
#

slipspace events

flat bone
#

k

midnight loom
#

hmm...

#

fair....

flat bone
#

for flood why not use the same thing the didact used to thanos dust the people on the composer research facility

midnight loom
#

but glassing can leaev them alive

#

better safe than sorry as the forerunners said

humble yacht
#

for flood why not use the same thing the didact used to thanos dust the people on the composer research facility
that was the composer

#

it's not effective on large areas

west silo
#

But when composed you now have the flood souls elsewhere

humble yacht
#

so?

#

you can't do anything with them

west silo
#

And could the flood get into a knight body