#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 414 of 1

cedar surge
#

truth shouldnt have ordered the death of elites

jolly swift
#

it's annoying that it's a species wide thing, but that's Species of Hats for you

cedar surge
#

cause yknow

jolly swift
#

yeah that's where he messed up

cedar surge
#

civil war

jolly swift
#

he underestimated the Elites tbh

cedar surge
#

even after stipped of the royal guards the elites were still loyal

lilac hare
#

Interesting.....

vague scroll
#

Truth was a sucker for his own delusion of grandeur. While he denied the notion that humans were the Reclaimers as Mendicant Bias claimed, he still believed in the Great Journey enough to pursue it whole heartedly.

#

His goof with the Sangheili seems to be a matter of him getting sloppy - probably thought he was days away from igniting the rings

#

could care less who got left behind or not at that point

jolly swift
#

"I promise the Humans are the reclaimers I WAS THERE"

vague scroll
#

"haha Great Journey go brrr"

round comet
#

i wanna go to war

vague scroll
#

that's not a rally point

round comet
#

no i am badass i will speak badass dialogue people will love it

jolly swift
#

wheeze

round comet
#

take me to war

jolly swift
#

war

#

huh

#

what is it good for

#

a trilogy or more of games

round comet
cedar surge
#

"unsc high command trust me nuking two random covenant planets is a important strategy to winning the battle of earth"

round comet
#

a bad trilogy

vague scroll
#

two epic quotes from two unrelated franchises.

"War...war never changes."
"War has changed."

Guess which ones.

jolly swift
#

Fallout and MGS

round comet
#

yessir

vague scroll
#

ding ding ding we got a winner

jolly swift
#

or is War Has Changed also in Modern Warfare?

vague scroll
#

nah not Modern Warfare though that's not a bad point for that matter from Shepherd

round comet
#

i will inject myself with war

#

i am war

carmine sleet
#

Ok Ares

round comet
#
  • master chief
#

darn it slip you ruined my flow

vague scroll
#

don't worry, you can still kill war

#

you'll probably regret it after though

cedar surge
#

if spartans are hyper lethal what are odsts? or other troops

stiff creek
#

Lethal

#

Kek

vague scroll
#

^ this man is going places

#

"hyper lethal" is a cool marketing term that has no basis in the greater lore, you'd do yourself a favor by not giving it much thought

carmine sleet
#

Aye, it was a term invented by Bungie to try and hype up Noble Six back when Reach was being first made and has only appeared a few times since then, with the most recent being a retcon to make the term apply to all Spartans, regardless of that Spartan's skill level

jolly swift
#

I prefer having just the two hyper lethal vectors

cedar surge
#

but why?

jolly swift
#

I dunno

#

I like it being a special name I guess

cedar surge
#

it sounds like what kids on a playground would call their supersoldiers

jolly swift
#

kids think Vector is a funny man who dresses in orange pajamas

cedar surge
#

"nuh uh! my soldier beats yours cause hes hyper lethal!"

#

plus the name

#

why only chief and noble six have it when there are other spartans on their level

jolly swift
#

are there

willow pendant
#

hola soy nuvo

#

nuevo

cedar surge
#

every spartan 2 who survived the war until then

#

hi

willow pendant
#

i no ingles

jolly swift
#

I like to think that Spartans we play as are inherently the best because they're controlled by some paracausal force (us)

#

but that's an idea I've taken with me from Destiny

karmic hemlock
#

Listening to halo canon, just figured out what happened to Linda. She was on the Autumn. She was clinically dead. However, her cryo tube was ejected during the evacuation and later picked up after the ring was destroyed

cedar surge
#

that wouldn't make sense

#

why is something outside canon nvolved

#

also

#

that would mean you got your arm ripped off by a grunt

jolly swift
#

I just think it's a neat idea

#

it ain't canon, and shouldn't be, but I think it's cool to think about

cedar surge
#

maybe infinite will allow you to beat people with a mongoose

#

i wonde rwhat unsc vecile is the limit of what they can lift or at east flip over

jolly swift
#

dude

#

Spartans can flip Elephants

#

there just is none

bleak dome
#

Overlord has a point

cedar surge
#

thats game play overlord

jolly swift
#

if the game isn't canon what is

#

who knows

#

maybe Chief could flip High Charity

cedar surge
#

gameplay isnt canon,cutscenes and scipted dialauge is

bleak dome
#

so chief did not press all of those buttons

cedar surge
#

otherwise most weapons would shoot 40 meteres and a odst could beat a brute to death

lilac hare
#

@FELUCHO1909#2013 vas a Espanol

bleak dome
#

So Craig is not in cannon

#

if its in gameplay

jolly swift
#

what're you talking about Rookie can just Do That™️

snow halo
#

why's there a trademark symbol

bleak dome
#

idk

jolly swift
#

for the meme

cedar surge
#

they trademarked it in under a minute

vague scroll
#

@willow pendant #español

#

the words "gameplay isn't canon" is a statement used in the lore community to point out that nonsensical or unrealistic events, or even things that do not line up with the rest of lore in gameplay is thrown out

#

for example, conundrum of The Flood versus Halo CE gameplay

humble yacht
#

The conundrum of how Johnson can seemingly die multiple times in CE

vague scroll
#

exactamundo

inner basin
#

How nanomachines changed Chief’s armour... oh wait

cedar surge
#

like how chief should have been dead 10 to 15 times over

jolly swift
#

that's just luck

cedar surge
#

*plot amor

jolly swift
#

it is canonically luck

#

Chief is very lucky

#

because he's a leprechaun

#

hence why he's green

karmic hemlock
#

Plot armor = best armor

#

Add a touch of Applied Phlebotinum and boom! 117 is best spartan by way of player character puppeteering

jolly swift
#

THAT'S THE PHRASE I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR

karmic hemlock
#

Applied Phlebotinum?

cedar surge
#

no the last three words

karmic hemlock
#

Ah

#

No, chiefs superpower is to reload his last checkpoint.

#

He's not lucky, he just cheeses the ever living heck out of the system until he gets the best results

jolly swift
#

exactly

humble yacht
#

So Chief is Subaru?

karmic hemlock
#

Subaru?

jolly swift
#

that's how I think his luck actually works

zenith veldt
#

no, a corolla

humble yacht
#

Smh

cedar surge
#

Re:Zero

vague scroll
#

I don't think John got isekaied Chimera

#

well... maybe the player did

cedar surge
#

thats what you think tide

karmic hemlock
#

In other words: Master Chief Petty Officer John-117 is the Halo universe's ultimate munchkin

cedar surge
#

the galaxies chew toy?

karmic hemlock
#

Like the dnd bard

#

Abuses the system

last anchor
#

Chief gets Isekai'd. Wherever he goes instantly basically stops existing

#

Is this the beginning of the fabeled "strong grumbly man kills annoying screeching things" crossover we've wanted forever?
Chief, Goblin Slayer and Doomguy...

versed helm
#

goblin slayer? you mean guts from berserk?

humble yacht
#

I should make a meme were a grunt mech sees goblin slayer approaching and then flees

stiff creek
#

Anime characters are a lil hard to compare in coolery.

#

But I haven't watched Berserk or Goblin Slayer.
Actually I have watched some Berserk, Guts is kewl, I guess.

#

He reminded me of Artorias from Dark Souls when his arm was jacked up.

cedar surge
#

ghost in prototype suit vs johnson in prototype suit

stiff creek
#

Ghost would probably win, mainly because the Green Machine doesn't have much for armament.

#

But that gauss repeater might do some more consistent damage.

#

And Ghost wouldn't mind blowing himself up in the end anyway.

#

Ghost wins.

versed helm
#

When did Chief learn how to use an energy sword? Was this even established or no?

humble yacht
#

i don't think the moment he first picked up an energy sword is detailed

versed helm
#

Thanks.

last anchor
#

Spartans learn fast though. He probably just grabbed one and went swish swish stab.
Its a sword, not that hard to understand I'd think.

#

The first confirmed time we see him hold one is during The Package.

cedar surge
#

the unsc got energy bayonets now

#

so the unsc could make a energy knife for normal soldiers

#

or just for spartans

last anchor
#

They could. But the Spartan combat knifes already as good.

#

Without the need for energy.

humble yacht
#

energy knives overrated

#

gimme HF knives

cedar surge
#

helioskrill Fountain?

#

but marines and odsts taking energy knifes and shankng elites would be so cool!

gilded mason
#

Seems like a bad idea to try to get up close to an Elite.

cedar surge
#

what goes around comes around

#

well nearly every marine got close to a elite

humble yacht
#

Worked for Forge

#

and Locke

#

well locke was a spartan but still

cedar surge
#

and thorne

versed helm
#

Lmao.

humble yacht
#

oh, worked for Buck

cedar surge
#

and every spartan

versed helm
#

Don't forget Emile (partially).

cedar surge
#

energy machete

gilded mason
#

I'm talking about unaugmented humans, ya goofs.

humble yacht
#

eh, emile doesn't count because he didn't walk away from that fight

cedar surge
#

buck adn forge both shanked the covenant as non spartans

#

buck shanked a brute in odst

#

forge shanked ripa

gilded mason
#

(I was gonna mention Forge since his survival was pretty luck-based on him figuring Ripa wouldn't simply kill him without showboating)

last anchor
#

Buck had a combat knife though

cedar surge
#

so?

#

he still shanked a covenant meber

#

i wish odst had you use a knife to melee covenant

versed helm
#

A pretty important one too.

gilded mason
#

You mean the brute that the entire team had to pile onto?

cedar surge
#

well

#

buck carried

versed helm
#

No, I was talking about Forge.

gilded mason
#

Anyway, just sayin' - you shouldn't count on facing an Elite/Brute in melee to actually work in your favor. There would be a lot of survivorship bias there.

versed helm
#

I would if I was a Spartan.

jolly swift
#

punch that brute

gilded mason
#

I'm talking about unaugmented humans, ya goofs.

#

aaaa

versed helm
#

There are instances where you could defeat them, so you should not completely dismiss the option.

gilded mason
#

I know.

just sayin' - you shouldn't count on facing an Elite/Brute in melee to actually work in your favor. There would be a lot of survivorship bias there.

versed helm
#

Sounds like Covenant fear mongering to me (joking).

humble yacht
#

ostral would do that

gilded mason
#

lol

versed helm
#

I would be lying when saying that I was surprised.

astral pivot
#

So do we know what life on high charity was for normal citizen not in the military did they have like stores go shop at or holographic tv entertainment? Or they more under government gives you job and food kinda of deal

humble yacht
#

it was a theocracy so there was probably a lot of praying and attending sermons

faint stone
#

our destiny is to use the mantle

#

but the pesky banished and cortana keep getting in our way

humble yacht
#

the mantle isn't something you use

faint stone
#

reclaim

#

so sorry sir so sorry

#

very sorry yessir

craggy sierra
#

The mantle isn’t a thing

#

It’s a metaphorical concept for galactic dictatorship

humble yacht
#

it's a metaphorical throne

craggy sierra
#

And tbh if anything the universe is pointing towards humanity willingly rejecting the mantle.

vague scroll
#

it's a no-fun throne

humble yacht
#

i mean

#

the best kings are the ones who don't want to be

#

it's the ones who enjoy the power that ultimately become corrupt on it

craggy sierra
#

Also Halsey is the only human who even really has a concept of the mantle.

#

And I trust her with that as far as I can throw her.

humble yacht
#

the true test of the mantle is abolishing it

#

(at least I think that's how it should go)

craggy sierra
#

To be even more blunt about it. Why would we let a bunch of people who’ve been dead for 100,000 years tell us how to run our society?

humble yacht
#

well

#

tbf

#

humanity has always looked to the past when it comes to making decisions

carmine sleet
#

There's plenty of laws that people still follow to this day that have been round for hundreds of years as well

humble yacht
#

modern democracy is rooted in ancient greek idealogies

craggy sierra
#

Yeah but this is a history we don’t even have a record of

humble yacht
#

true

ashen scarab
#

just finished new blood, anyone else reed it?

#

*read

keen delta
#

Not to mention its a concept invented by eldrich horrors for their creations, which should immediately raise some eyebrows with their history

humble yacht
#

just because the primordial looked like cthulu doesn't mean all precursors looked like that

west silo
#

He was noted to just be a gravemind masquerading as what the precursors looked like

#

And to be honest the precursors could have looked like anything they wanted

humble yacht
#

no, it was originally described as a mutated precursor

#

how it was related to the flood before it was "killed" is not clear

#

perhaps a psychic link

west silo
#

It was kinda in command of the flood before turning into dust

faint stone
#

yeah

#

if the real test for us to reject the mantle and remove it

#

and end up creating something else like a galactic union

#

then that'd be great story wise

versed helm
#

how would a galactic union be formed, though?

humble yacht
#

each species/faction would elect or otherwise designate delegates who would convene and make decisions and compromises on behalf of their people

west silo
#

So basically the Republic?

#

Or the federation in some way?

humble yacht
#

sure

#

that's one way of doing things

west silo
#

Lets just hope the Senate isn't evil

cedar surge
#

Secretly truth had a child with neural physics powers while also somehow coming back from the dead

craggy sierra
#

if the real test for us to reject the mantle and remove it
You can’t remove a concept. And again, literally no human besides Halsey alive in the universe even has a concept of what the mantle is.

#

So honestly we’re pretty much doing that alreafy

cedar surge
#

Trusting halsey with that

#

I have a bad feeling about that

#

Oh wait

#

Ots just a ideology

#

So basically anybody could claim to hold the mantle

#

So cortana or the forerunners didn't really steal anything

humble yacht
#

well no

#

not anyone

#

you need the military might to actually enforce your rule

#

otherwise everyone would just laugh at you

west silo
#

Soo the if the covenant had known about the mantle would they have technically count as holding the mantle?

#

Since they kinda did rule the galaxy

gilded mason
#

They ruled a portion of the Orion Arm

versed helm
#

No. They were prejudiced against humans.

west silo
#

So we're the forerunner

gilded mason
#

Also, they did know about it. And thought they were enacting it, according to Wages of Sin. (I think)

west silo
#

Wait really?

gilded mason
#

Yeh

west silo
#

I thought they just wanted to go to heaven

gilded mason
#

Not really exclusive

west silo
#

Are u talking them assimilating other species into the covenant?

dusky brook
#

what happened with the covenant after halo 3

gilded mason
#

The organization dissolved

humble yacht
#

the mantle is about ruling but the covenant had no desire to watch over life in the galaxy as custodians

#

they wanted to leave their mortal coils behind

dusky brook
#

how come you fight them in halo games after 3 tho

gilded mason
#

Because those are other factions

humble yacht
#

because they split into a bunch of different leftover groups and we fight one of those leftovers in H4 and H5

#

the banished are another leftover group

#

technically the Swords of Sanghelios are also covenant leftovers

west silo
#

Well there not really covenant

humble yacht
#

covenant leftovers*

dusky brook
#

ok

west silo
#

So the planet in badblood is under created control now

humble yacht
#

that's how the cookie crumbles, sometimes

west silo
#

Man and I was thinking it would be some kinda safe haven

#

But nope guardian arrives and ruins everything

humble yacht
#

only if you resist

gilded mason
#

@west silo
Oh yeah. Here ya go:

We have seen inert control surfaces spring to life at their human touch. The Oracle itself calls them “Reclaimers.” But what do they reclaim? These machines? These cities? These worlds? Or, as I fear, are they to reclaim the mantle we so terribly squandered? The responsibility the Forerunners left us was a magnificent one, but perhaps beyond our means and character. We are a greedy, squabbling lot. We clamber over each other for rank and privilege, and kill, maim, or betray for power.

The Forerunner mantle was one of responsibility, it seems. Perhaps we were intended to nurture rather than conquer. If the Halo array is what it appears to be, then it is a monstrous thing, a necessary evil. Left intact to save us should the parasite return.

west silo
#

Is this from contact harvest?

gilded mason
#

Wages of Sin

west silo
#

What's that

gilded mason
#

A prophet hiding away in High Charity while the Flood consume it

west silo
#

Oh canon fodder

gilded mason
#

Hm?

astral pivot
#

Prophet of bailing in his office in the tower district

west silo
#

So what book?

#

Is it a short story?

humble yacht
#

canon fodder is a blog

#

posted on waypoint

gilded mason
#

Wages of Sin is a short story

#

From Evolutions

west silo
#

Ohhh

#

Wow so the mantle predates the forerunner trilogy

humble yacht
#

well yeah

gilded mason
#

We first hear of it in the H3 terminals, so...

humble yacht
#

^

#

those terminals really were a great thing

gilded mason
#

Funnily enough, it's the Librarian of all people that calls it a stupid concept in those.

west silo
#

So why do people act like it was something 343 just threw into the lore

gilded mason
#

They don't pay attention

humble yacht
#

too bad a certain someone named after ursidae ruined their legacy

#

shakes fist

vague scroll
#

even then it's tonally consistent with the 343i renditions going forward as well, the Librarian was a critic of the Mantle in the 343i era lore

west silo
#

You know Greg payed a lot of attention to the lore

#

The only things he added were ancient humans and neural physics

humble yacht
#

he added logic plague

#

he tied precursors to flood

#

he added geases

vague scroll
#

tbh, those were inspired choices as well - if they weren't already hinted at in the H3 terminals, they were concepts he developed from experience of writing grand scifi as far back in the 80s

humble yacht
#

and a whole nother didact

west silo
#

The didact thing was cool

humble yacht
#

well whatever inspired him, keep it far away from me, pls and thx

west silo
#

The book should have came out before the game though

humble yacht
#

hashtag not my muse

vague scroll
#

kek

#

np there

west silo
#

We all have our preferences

versed helm
#

That is true

vague scroll
#

but I'm not kidding there, his background is the silver age of science fiction (I think that's the right term?)

humble yacht
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

vague scroll
#

he collabed with Larry Niven on some Known Space stories

west silo
#

I have no idea who that is

vague scroll
#

author of Ringworld

west silo
#

Ohh

vague scroll
#

the thing that inspired Halo's premise

#

Known Space was Niven's sci fi universe

west silo
#

Heard about it but never read it

vague scroll
#

it's an okay read, not for everyone, it certainly shows it's era and the common tropes of it's decade

west silo
#

I would give it a read

#

What's the tone?

vague scroll
#

pulp fiction type sci fi, fairly grounded but certainly has some fantastical elements to it

#

it's more similar to say Mass Effect in tone than Halo

#

though it's scale is on par with the Forerunner Saga

west silo
#

Oh yeah isn't that how the got the physics of how the halo has gravity in the flood book

#

With the whole spinning ring

vague scroll
#

well it inspired Halo but Niven wasn't just making stuff up

west silo
#

though it's scale is on par with the Forerunner Saga
@vague scroll
So its a hard sci fi galactic war story

vague scroll
#

no

#

it's a pulp fiction sci fi romp about alien politics and ancient megastructures

#

not much in it about military sci fi

west silo
#

So kinda space comedy

vague scroll
#

comedy is the wrong word, maybe closer to an epic or classical adventure

west silo
#

Ohh so opera

#

Space opera

vague scroll
#

yeah that would be a better assessment

west silo
#

Okay ever heard a book called man after man or something

vague scroll
#

a quick google introduced me, not sure it's my speed

#

but I can see the appeal

west silo
#

It's body horror

#

It actually reminds me of a scene in the forerunner trilogy

versed helm
#

When Chakas stumbles upon a proto gravemind?

vague scroll
#

yeah more reason not for my pursuits, I'm more a military sci fi/cyberpunk reader

west silo
#

When Chakas stumbles upon a proto gravemind?
@versed helm
Naw when the librarian journeys to path ketina and finds the primitive forerunners

versed helm
#

Ohh

#

The most runes

keen delta
#

ok so someone else mentioned the great schism here, but my noggins been joggin on the subject.
what actually caused the great schism in the first place, because halo 2 doesnt really make it clear. we are shown the changing of the guard before the arbiters mission to recover the index, we (as in the audience) know about the brutes betraying the arbiter but nobody else was around to witness this. the next we see high charity is on the mission gravemind with the master chief in the council chambers and the schism is by this point in full swing with brute, elite, and even flood controlled ships destroying each other. And also on the mission uprising happening simultaneously where its shown the brutes and elites are already fighting. so I ask why did the fighting start? did tartarus simply order this to occur? did the elites take up arms against the changing of the guard? its not really well explained as during this time we were chatting it up with gravemind.

versed helm
#

The schism is caused by truth, when he gives the brutes more regard than the elites

gilded mason
#

Truth ordered all the Brutes under his command to begin killing any Elites they could find once many of the Elite Councilors arrived at Delta's control room.

keen delta
#

was this presented in game and I just missed it?

#

or something from a book?

gilded mason
#

Which would be either right before or at the start of Gravemind

#

And yeah, Broken Circle goes into it

keen delta
#

ok

#

because at the changing of the guard scene things seemed shaky but still stable within the covenant, and arbiters betrayal could have easily been swept under the rug

gilded mason
#

At that point, things were already set in motion. Though nobody except Truth knew at that time.

keen delta
#

so my next question is why would truth even order this in the first place? what benefit was there to killing off the elites?

gilded mason
#

He hated Elites and thought they were too smart.

#

He wanted patsies he could order around and not question anything

unique rune
#

too smart for barns

gilded mason
#

lol

keen delta
#

I getcha

#

just seems off though since he would jeopardize his schemes for something so petty when everyone was onboard for activating the rings

gilded mason
#

he's a very greedy boy

keen delta
#

I suppose but it seems out of character for someone whos made to be extremely manipulative

versed helm
#

Cause, at the end, he done goofed up good

gilded mason
#

^This goes into some of it

#

Under the subheader Along the Path

keen delta
#

alright ill give it a look

humble yacht
#

the thing about megalomaniacs is that they don't like to be challenged. at all

west silo
#

Truth in 3 seems entirely different from the one 2

keen delta
#

nodoubt because of the nature of halo 2s development

west silo
#

He seems more like an insane loon than a manipulative snake

keen delta
#

makes you wonder why he would go through the effort to head to earth on his dreadnaught when for all he knew delta halo would have been activated anyway

craggy sierra
#

Actually it was because Staten went on sabbatical for a lot of 3’s development and Marty decided to...”improve” the script.

#

By basically making it worse in every conceivable way

keen delta
#

I wouldnt 100% say its bad, truth was really the only character affected. also having both keyes and johnson die when they did was a good move that staten was against

craggy sierra
#

Miranda and the Arbiter

keen delta
#

i dont see it

#

how did miranda change?

craggy sierra
#

He basically axed all of Arbiter’s role in the story and made Miranda bafflingly stupid

west silo
#

Mirandas death is the most forced thing I have ever seen

craggy sierra
#

to war

keen delta
#

a dumb line to be sure but not against her character

west silo
#

And arbiter was basically made a side character

craggy sierra
#

No it is against her character

west silo
#

And johnson never really grew

craggy sierra
#

Cause Halo 2 Miranda is not that much of a dunce

west silo
#

As a character

keen delta
#

I dont know I seem to remember her grappling on a tentacle and nearly falling to her death in 2

west silo
#

Cause Halo 2 Miranda is not that much of a dunce
@craggy sierra
She did try to retrieve the index in enemy territory by herself

#

Without out back up

craggy sierra
#

Her and a full squad of marines with Johnson

keen delta
#

and going into the flood wall without your strongest asset

west silo
#

She didn't know the marines were there

craggy sierra
#

...she did

keen delta
#

chief should have went after the index

west silo
#

Its implied that Johnson just came out of nowhere

#

Why would she go in there alone

craggy sierra
#

Johnson literally calls out to the marines that were with them and it’s implied Arby killed them off screen before attacking Miranda and Johnson

#

It’s not implied like that at all

keen delta
#

as for arbiter I dont see how his character was affected at all infact it came to a conclusion with him killing the prophet of truth

craggy sierra
#

Miranda literally says in an earlier cutscene that she was taking Johnson and a group of marines to secure the icon

gilded mason
#

That was basically all he did.

west silo
#

The arbiter had no scene for himself or missions besides making one liners

craggy sierra
#

Yeah he was meant to have his own levels like in 2 but Marty was like “nah”

keen delta
#

he had perhaps the biggest scene for himself

west silo
#

Dude killing an old man?

#

That's his biggest scene?

#

The covenant was already dead at that point

keen delta
#

him getting revenge on the man who destroyed his reputation, dishonored and massacred his people is pretty significant

craggy sierra
#

His character feels like he has absolutely no emotional investment in Halo 3.

#

He doesn’t feel like he has any buildup to the conclusion of his story.

#

He just walks into the scene, stabs a guy, roars, and it’s off to light the ring

keen delta
#

thats because his build up was in the other game, and there are some little scenes sprinkled in around halo 3 commenting on truth

craggy sierra
#

That’s not how you write a game

keen delta
#

ok but he wasnt the star of the show of this game

humble yacht
#

Guys, it’s halo 3

#

It can’t be flawed uny

west silo
#

All hail 3

humble yacht
#

There is no reason to be upset craighearts

west silo
#

For it is perfection itself

craggy sierra
#

You don’t buildup a character conclusion in a previous game and then shove it off to the end of the next game and then have the entirety of the next game just not touch the character until it’s time to arbitrarily end their story.

#

It makes the conclusion to his story ring hollow

west silo
#

To be honest halo has never had the best development

craggy sierra
#

Cause Halo 3 just forgets that he’s meant to be invested for like 4/5s of its run time.

west silo
#

That's pretty much the true curse of halo

#

Poor development time

craggy sierra
#

Halo 3 wasn’t an issue of development time

#

It was the first Halo game to have a somewhat smooth development.

#

Marty just decided he didn’t like Staten’s story direction.

keen delta
#

yes and they had to pick up the pieces of the half finished previous game, and all with fan criticism of having a different main character than chief for half the game. and im by no means a halo 3 apologist as bungie themselves intended for halo to be a 2 game series. so they had to essentially stretch out the entire third act of their story into one full game.

west silo
#

So would you guys want equipment back in halo multiplayer

keen delta
#

yes please

west silo
#

Because to be honest I would like it if we got the mobility of halo 5

#

I honestly got into the halo thing around. Halo 4

keen delta
#

I would rather bring back equipment and abandon advanced movement altogether

#

it just doesnt feel like halo

west silo
#

No I pretty much want advanced mobility to stay

#

I cannot play the earlier games because I feel slow as hell

#

And I like most of the Spartan abilities

#

Though they do feel lackluster some times

keen delta
#

halo 3 could have used a higher base movement speed (which i think we got in reach) ill admit that, but part of the appeal is the marriage between moving and shooting, rather than the separation of them which is what advanced movement does.
for example being able to move at your top speed and having 360 degree awareness rather than being locked into a sprint animation, or using jumping techniques to scale obstacles rather than being locked into animations and reducing combat effectiveness. also it affects map scaling and cannot easily be removed or toned down post release as it means you need to completely redesign levels. personally I would love a game that goes back to the earlier design philosophy and improves upon it. because right now the best for the philosophy was halo 3 which IMO is far from perfect.

west silo
#

I get the locked in sprint thing but to be honest use that to get to where I want to be

#

And to honest the movement speed in 5 feels really fast

#

And a reason I don't like 3 is that most of the weapons in 3 feel useless in multiplayer

#

Its either BR or shotgun or sniper rifle

#

At least in 4 and 5 most of the weapons feel kinda good to use

keen delta
#

of course and I was actually getting to that, this is an issue that can be solved with good map making as opposed to introducing core mechanics. for example vehicles specifically like the mongoose whos only function is to go from point A to B fast (and delivering objectives) comes into play, things like gravity lifts, teleporters, man cannons are all made to get players into the areas with the most action faster so you arent just walking around aimlessly for 30+ seconds hoping to find someone.
also I do agree with your opinion of the weapons and it to is a criticism I share with 3s sandbox. however I think halo 4 and 5 had the opposite problem where the weapons were too effective. and with the halo sandbox a balance needs to be maintained.

west silo
#

Well to be honest in 3 the balance never really existed either

keen delta
#

thats what im saying

west silo
#

of course and I was actually getting to that, this is an issue that can be solved with good map making as opposed to introducing core mechanics. for example vehicles specifically like the mongoose whos only function is to go from point A to B fast (and delivering objectives) comes into play, things like gravity lifts, teleporters, man cannons are all made to get players into the areas with the most action faster so you arent just walking around aimlessly for 30+ seconds hoping to find someone.
also I do agree with your opinion of the weapons and it to is a criticism I share with 3s sandbox. however I think halo 4 and 5 had the opposite problem where the weapons were too effective. and with the halo sandbox a balance needs to be maintained.
@keen delta
This kinda sets up problems where it can make players create killzones and traps at these points which wouldn't make the game very fun

#

It's basically if someone knew where your teams spawn was

#

But this time its everyone knows where your going to go

keen delta
#

thats why you have multiple paths

#

for instance, take the map avalanche say its BTB flags or whatever. you have several means of gaining entrance to the enemy base, and on defense its hard to cover all of them without neglecting others. for instance any of the hornets, warthogs and mongeese can easily rush into the enemy base and even launch yourself in via the man cannon) but this frontal assault could be countered with power weapons or opposing vehicles and the enemy team falling back to defend since vehicles have to go around the entire map. alternatively you could attempt to gain control of the middle pathway and fight into the enemies 2nd floor path, but like a vehicle rush this can be countered if you dont have enough friendlies to make the push. or you could be cheeky and use the enemies teleporter at the rocket spawn (and potentially get said rocket launcher) and enter through the back door of their base and back out again with the flag to an awaiting vehicle

#

what you do really depends on what your team and the enemy team are doing at the time, they cant be everywhere at once

west silo
#

Isn't that being hard on the defenders like 7 different paths?

keen delta
#

halo maps tend to be more offensively based, also this is a multi objective map so they are trying to steal/bomb your flag too

west silo
#

so warzone but without Spartan abilities and sprint?

keen delta
#

I have limited experience with warzone

#

But from what I remember you could spawn in your own weapons and vehicles

#

Which is not the case for these games

west silo
#

Only at a certain point in game

#

And its not permanent as in if you lose it someone else can pick it up

keen delta
#

Of course

west silo
#

And the weapons suck if you don't know how to use them

keen delta
#

That's no different than any halo game, if you can't use the sniper well it doesn't matter if you know where they spawn on every map

lilac hare
#

Why are the banished "banished"?

#

Did they do something wrongthinkingchief thinkingchief

keen delta
#

They got banished craighearts

#

I dont know it's halo wars 2 lore

lilac hare
#

Ok

fair hazel
#

halo lore guys

lilac hare
#

In depth breakdown

west silo
#

Basically just named themselves that

stiff creek
#

The Banished aren't exactly "banished" so to speak.

#

The original group pretty much releaved themselves of Covenant authority, but many of it's newer members joined after the dissolution of the Covenant, so the reasons of joining are varied.

#

Some just get paid for being there, like Let Volir, and others joined so they could continue fighting, seeing as they wouldn't be good for anything else, and I'd like to think most Jiralhanae joined to bring pride back to their race.

dusty copper
#

Question why is the armor of the ODSTs different i mean it has a look in halo 2 then changes on 3 what’s the lore for this?

vague scroll
#

there are different in universe ODST armor sets

gilded mason
#

Just different equipment

dusty copper
#

K thanks

stiff creek
#

The one we see in 3 and ODST is the Mk. 117.

#

Don't remember the Halo 2 one.

cedar surge
#

All unsc armor is xanon

obsidian thistle
#

Actually

cedar surge
#

Yea the halo 2 one looks pretty different

obsidian thistle
#

The Mk. 117 may not refer to the model in ODST and H3

cedar surge
#

117?

obsidian thistle
#

It could just be a thing we dont know the meaning off on the chest piece

#

Regardless the cosplay guide doesnt even mention it

dusty copper
#

K

#

Another question

#

Why doesn’t the unsc just give everyone master chief armor

obsidian thistle
#

Augmentations yo

#

Cant do that to everyone

dusty copper
#

Is it too heavy or something?

obsidian thistle
#

Its expensive to do that

#

Mjolnir = Expensive
Augmentations = Expensive

dusty copper
#

Okay

obsidian thistle
#

Without augmentations the armor will kill the person.

dusty copper
#

Gotcha

#

Mjolnir is the armor?

gilded mason
#

Yeh

dusty copper
#

K

obsidian thistle
#

SPI atm is the closest we have to armor the public can wear

dusty copper
#

Okay

obsidian thistle
#

And that armor platform (despite a few disliking this) can use Mjolnir-like stuff

#

Even being able to use the Buccaneer helmet from Halo 5.

dusty copper
#

Okay

#

Thanks

keen delta
#

without augmentation mjolnir will turn the wearer into human spaghetti

dusty copper
#

Okay

#

Maybe last question

#

What are the previous suits of mjolnir I know five and six but what were the ones before

#

And I know 7

keen delta
#

IV looks similar to V however it lacks energy shields as it was made prior to the human covenant war

dusty copper
#

K

keen delta
#

I-III are prototypes that look more along the scale of mechs than the power armor we are used to

dusty copper
#

Okay

keen delta
#

the youtuber installation 00 has lore breakdowns of each of the suits

dusty copper
#

Can you link the video/channel

keen delta
#

thats his channel

dusty copper
#

K

obsidian thistle
#

Oh his breakdowns there... erm add a lotta accidental fanon... and irl stuff that isnt canon.

west silo
#

Can you name some?

#

Not doubting you just asking

faint stone
#

we know that there were odst before regrets slipspace jump in nb

#

but just after the scarab got yeeted alpha 9 and the other odsts were preparing to drop so there is probably different uniforms and equipment

stiff creek
#

There are. In Halo Wars 2 both styles coexist just fine.

cedar surge
#

Most halo styles are canon

#

They are just different armor

cedar surge
#

Maybe in imfimote we could actually see other classes in action Cept for the infinity and stridents

#

Why would they make these new shops and not use em

#

Actually in Spartan assault they did

#

Would have the elites rebelled anyway even if truth didn't order their deaths?

gilded mason
#

Eventually. There was growing support for humans among them

terse lava
#

I'm not sure on that

#

The sangheili were still greatly loyal

gilded mason
#

Well. "Rebelled" is a strong word

#

I imagine the councilors would've evntually just went "Okay, Hierarchs, we gotta talk..."

terse lava
#

Yea, at worst, i think Truth and co would be forced to step down

gilded mason
#

Yeah

terse lava
#

The sangheili as a people could likely tolerate the stain of losing Regret. It was being demoted from what the Writ itself assigned them that hit hard

#

Being replaced by jiralhanae was just salt

karmic hemlock
#

probably more than you think. an honor-bound warrior race, having served their religious leaders for a long d*m time, suddenly replaced by literal berserkers? i think of it like the clans from battletech - honor and loyalty defines them

terse lava
#

Yeah, their literal purpose was to be the escorts of the san shyuum

karmic hemlock
#

a slap in the face like that would be astounding

terse lava
#

I think, had they kept the honor guard role at least, things would be better. Perhaps a time of penance

#

Being temporary demoted

#

Because I mean, in 3400 years surely Regret wasnt the only one to perish

karmic hemlock
#

true. but we're also talking about the idiot prophets. i think that if humanity had been approached like another client race things might have gone different

#

or, maybe not

#

humans are stupid like that

terse lava
#

Sending jiralhanae to peace talks was a mistake too

cedar surge
#

I mean imagine the amount of prophets the unsc killed

terse lava
#

Not many

cedar surge
#

So they would have failed quite a few times

terse lava
#

There is also that old chestnut humans wouldn't tolerate being in the Covenant

karmic hemlock
#

they sent brutes to a peace talk?!

terse lava
#

Technically only Regret did. He claimed they were "other witnesses" when he originally told the Minister of Fortitude(pre-Truth) about thr supposed large forerunner relic cache on harvest.

#

Fortitude at first though sangheili had been sent, and showed shock and horror with that idea, as.he saw it creating a massive imbalance in power

karmic hemlock
#

...i really need more context about the whole schism. were the prophets trying to stir crap up?

west silo
#

Well only mercy and truth

karmic hemlock
#

well, yeah. they were also the kooks who decided to cancel humanity

terse lava
#

Ehh...not really no. As the war progressed Truth saw faults open up within sangheili society. Questioning the war mostly

karmic hemlock
#

as any being with common sense should

#

under different circumstances i imagine humans and sangheili would have been great allies

west silo
#

The elites were gaining more power and becoming questioning about the war with humanity
But mostly because San shyuum are power hungry freaks

karmic hemlock
#

this is true

terse lava
#

Truth assumed the sangheili would be too stunned to really fight back. He underestimated how fast they recovered from the betrayal and the staining of their leadership

#

Fun fact

karmic hemlock
#

HAH!

west silo
#

Remember the reason the war began is because they didn't want to lose there seats of power

terse lava
#

Ripa 'Moramee, the Halo Wars arbiter, was sent in a mission to take out a growing sangheili faction who disagreed with the new Hierarcha the time

cedar surge
#

The collapse of the religion yea

#

And he tried to start a rebellion right?

#

And failed

terse lava
#

He was trying to secure the Covenant

west silo
#

Especially since they had just finished backstabbing the ones who were in power before them

cedar surge
#

Where does the backstabbing end

terse lava
#

And yes Ripa was jailed for a failed coup against his kaidon

#

More so for the failure of it

karmic hemlock
#

absolute power corrupts absolutely is the adage im thinking of for the prophets

cedar surge
#

Your writing a story right?

karmic hemlock
#

trying to

terse lava
#

True, it was something a pre-Covenant hierarch pointed out himself

karmic hemlock
#

halo lore is

#

kooky

cedar surge
#

Confusing?

karmic hemlock
#

very

west silo
#

Eh San shyuum have been known to be good manipulators

terse lava
#

He saw the hierarchs as being corrupt, when they were suppose to lead the faithful to the Journey

cedar surge
#

Well that's what happens when half of its life the creators actively hated the EU

west silo
#

Even guilty spark pointed it out

cedar surge
#

Doesn't guilty spark know about the ancient Shan shyum?

terse lava
#

He does

karmic hemlock
#

eh

#

memories were locked away until after

#

i think

#

my knowledge is still spotty

west silo
#

Well he probably had a encyclopedia

cedar surge
#

Clicking through random halopedia articles helps

#

So how much did the hepatic leader actually know?

terse lava
#

Who?

#

Heretic?

cedar surge
#

Geratic leader

west silo
#

Its still funny that guilty spark could have saved the POA if he had just done something

terse lava
#

He knew the journey was a lie and then promise of salvation false

cedar surge
#

The elite in halo 2 at the gas station

karmic hemlock
#

guilty spark was also nuttier than a fruit cake

terse lava
#

True

harsh skiff
#

how does the ground pound work canonically speaking?

terse lava
#

Really though things would have gone bettering Mendicant bias had chosen his words better

pliant agate
#

Thruster pack boosts you into the ground maybe?

viral apex
#

what is the cheifs estimated kill count and how are there still grunts alaive

pliant agate
#

West I feel like that’s a YouTube video

harsh skiff
#

since the ground pound can one shot on a direct hit due to Newtons third law it should kill you if not break your arms

pliant agate
#

Well that can be explained by the Spartans augmentations

karmic hemlock
#

isaac newton is the deadliest son of a b**** in space

viral apex
#

ok simple question

terse lava
#

Unless you're a reaper

pliant agate
#

Lol yea

west silo
#

2 million on low end

harsh skiff
#

just count the enemies in every halo campaign and that is the kill count

pliant agate
#

Well there’s also the books

#

And whatever happens in between

west silo
#

since the ground pound can one shot on a direct hit due to Newtons third law it should kill you if not break your arms
@harsh skiff
Unbreakable bones son

harsh skiff
#

books arnt canon just like halo 5

viral apex
#

why do grunts kill themsleves in every game, you would think that with evolution their brains would grow to not suicide themselves

west silo
#

What

#

why do grunts kill themsleves in every game, you would think that with evolution their brains would grow to not suicide themselves
@viral apex
Better than being a slave I guess

viral apex
#

halo 5 was terrible

#

they had females in the main campagin

#

spartans should only be males

cedar surge
#

Oh

harsh skiff
#

i think halo 5 would have been better if locke killed chief in their fight scene

west silo
#

Halo always had female Spartans

viral apex
#

that fight scene was in real speed, fun fact

cedar surge
#

Yea female Spartans have been around before even CE

viral apex
#

but the cutsceen played it in slow motion

#

see but u have to read a book to know that

karmic hemlock
#

oh for gods sake you moderator bot

harsh skiff
#

cheif couldnt dodge lockes knee shots that were moving at 0.1mph

viral apex
#

people only want to play vidoe games

cedar surge
#

Why wouldn't he George?

viral apex
#

so keep female spartans out of vidoegames

cedar surge
#

Misogyny I see

versed helm
#

are you brain dead @viral apex

karmic hemlock
#

as i was trying to say before the stupid mod bot silenced me, gender doesnt matter for spartans since they are all effectively castrated, zero libido

harsh skiff
#

in the fight scene lock beats up chief with 2 knee shots to the stomach and he just sat there and took it like there was nothing he could do about it

cedar surge
#

Read a book? Heck we had female Spartans since reach in games

harsh skiff
#

as i was trying to say before the stupid mod bot silenced me, gender doesnt matter for spartans since they are all effectively castrated, zero libido
@karmic hemlock so cheif doesnt have a pee pee

cedar surge
#

Also George chief was in a super armor suit

#

Yes he does

pliant agate
#

I think it’s been established that the Halo 5 Locke vs Chief fight scene was not the greatest

viral apex
#

think about this the most stupid spartan death was Kat, a female

harsh skiff
#

remember when Kat got shot in the head lmao

terse lava
#

There have been worse deaths

harsh skiff
#

name one

ripe sage
#

You are fun at parties I bet, West

cedar surge
#

Carter

terse lava
#

Another was crushed between 2 cruisers

karmic hemlock
#

locke vs chief was a booze fueled nightmare and didnt happen

viral apex
#

he sacrificed himsewlf

echo nebula
#

Kat had not enabled her shields yet, having only just put on her helmet

cedar surge
#

Or the Spartan who got shot into space

west silo
#

James

terse lava
#

No he didnt

viral apex
#

how dare u say that

cedar surge
#

"Dare" lol

viral apex
#

geroge saved

#

the worlkd

ripe sage
#

spartans should only be males
@viral apex

Do elaborate. I must know.

karmic hemlock
#

spartans are supposed to be the pinnacle of humanity, if punches arent being thrown at the speed of sound i dont believe it

viral apex
#

@ripe sage let me guess ur a woman

#

man> woamn

ripe sage
#

Irrelevant.

pliant agate
#

Lmaooo

boreal bane
#

Oh dear

cedar surge
#

We eat Jorge actually didn't really have a impact.like a new fleet showed up seconds later

ripe sage
#

Ah alright

terse lava
#

Oh lovely

viral apex
#

thats just a fact

unique rune
#

It would appear I’ve picked a bad time to check in on this place

I really should get cracking on that copy of Mythos I borrowed.

ripe sage
#

Well. This woman is about to yeet you from the server

cedar surge
#

Man this guy really loves blaming women huh

fair hazel
#

Im literally eating popcorn watching this happen

terse lava
#

Pass some over please

pliant agate
#

Lol

cedar surge
#

Man that's got to be the worst troll I saw

#

He was so transparent

harsh skiff
#

but was he wrong

echo nebula
#

My guess, West has been harmed by a woman recently. Possible dumped or publicly embarassed

ripe sage
#

Back to normal lore

spiral jewel
#

Stupid question: Aside from the SoF, is there any Phoenix Class Colony Ships in active service in the 2550's/2560's...

I want to say that the flagship, the UNSC Phoenix is still roaming around, but I feel like it was turned into a city at some point.

(I can't find much information on The Phoenix)

karmic hemlock
#

jorge was the most pointless death ive encountered. kat was one thing, she got got by a sniper, but his sacrifice was made irrelevant literally five seconds later

pliant agate
#

Yes I agree

terse lava
#

I felt nothing for Jorge

fair hazel
#

We dont know of any others but it's a possibility autobotking

karmic hemlock
#

true

#

my only beef was that he was a S2

cedar surge
#

Auto I think there was a few others but the only one we know is the SoF

harsh skiff
#

I think Kat should have died first because i dont like her because she is girl

fair hazel
#

has the long night of solace not been blown up, it could have probably been hijacked by the spartan-IIs for operation redflag

karmic hemlock
#

oh jesus

cedar surge
#

Are we going round two on female Spartans already?

pliant agate
#

There was also that one book where like 200 spartan-IIIs died on the same mission

cedar surge
#

No

karmic hemlock
#

ghosts of onyx

ripe sage
#

@harsh skiff do you wanna join the other guy or?

cedar surge
#

There was only around 40 2s

karmic hemlock
#

read that one, at least

echo nebula
#

S-III's were purpose built for suicide missions

west silo
#

290 actually

cedar surge
#

You mean the Spartan 3s@pliant agate

harsh skiff
#

@harsh skiff do you wanna join the other guy or?
@ripe sage or what

pliant agate
#

Yes

terse lava
#

Ugh....

native coral
#

lata

pliant agate
#

Did I type 2s?

cedar surge
#

Yea

karmic hemlock
#

oh happy days! found a reach timeline made by Halo Canon!

jolly swift
#

Jorge's death was supposed to be pointless

pliant agate
#

Wops

jolly swift
#

that's the point

terse lava
#

Yeah

#

Pretty much

jolly swift
#

Reach shouldn't have had a happy ending

cedar surge
#

But that guy was saying that no other Spartan aside from cat who is a woman got a pointless death

karmic hemlock
#

-_-

cedar surge
#

Yknow

#

Lets move on from that

karmic hemlock
#

yes

#

post haste

terse lava
#

If we.are.going for pointless deaths, really Aruther had the worst

cedar surge
#

Who is he?

west silo
#

Solomon had the worst

jolly swift
#

died in the Package in Halo Legends

fair hazel
#

both of them hoenstly had terrible deaths

terse lava
#

Yep, crushed between 2 cruisers

karmic hemlock
#

even more since legends was made canon

fair hazel
#

what do you mean was made?

cedar surge
#

Most of legends

fair hazel
#

It wasn't ever non canon minus odd one out

terse lava
#

All of it was canon aside from Odd one Out

cedar surge
#

Visuals are Debateable but odd one e out aint

karmic hemlock
#

i refuse to think of legends as anything more than high budget fanfiction

terse lava
#

....

karmic hemlock
#

epseically package

pliant agate
#

Speaking of canon vs non canon, is the upcoming halo live action show going to be canon?

fair hazel
#

Another one of these.

cedar surge
#

Cabbage I think so

pliant agate
#

Ok...

cedar surge
#

But I also heard its going to be its own universe

fair hazel
#

maybe, we'll have to have a bit more info

terse lava
#

I...think? At worst an "elseworld" tale

karmic hemlock
#

just my opinion, i know that not the case, but... really should have had more time in the oven

fair hazel
#

we dont know for sure yes

west silo
#

Ehh halo legends was overall good

pliant agate
#

I haven’t seen it

karmic hemlock
#

the package really killed it for me, couldnt get past it

jolly swift
#

the short about the Forerunners and the Flood was really good

terse lava
#

The Duel was good

cedar surge
#

Prototype got the best visuals for me

#

Plus it lead into a evolutions story

west silo
#

But seriously changing keyes and Mirandas race because they thought it fit better doesn't really make sense

edgy plume
#

hmm

#

ok ok

karmic hemlock
#

havent tried watching it in years

cedar surge
#

Heart of the mothilodian

west silo
#

Baird

#

Best odst

karmic hemlock
#

should i give it another shot?

cedar surge
#

I think you should

terse lava
#

Yeah

jolly swift
#

never was big on the Duel, I'm not huge on samurai personally, but now that I've seen the Halo 2 terminals I like it more

west silo
#

The terminals made them more like Spartans

#

Than samurai

karmic hemlock
#

question - as a pleb who can never find the terminals, how important to canon are they, and should i just watch them on youtube?

jolly swift
#

with changing Miranda and Jacob's races, honestly I don't see any reason why not to, so I'm chill with it

#

they provide some nice backstory

terse lava
#

They just enrich the current story

jolly swift
#

Halo 2 Anniversary is mainly about the history of the Arbiter

#

Halo 4 mainly retells the story of the Didact in animated form

#

CE Anniversary shows what Spark was up to for 100,000 years

karmic hemlock
#

against a backdrop of shooting the ever loving heck out of forerunner goons

#

played 4 on xbone, cant wait for the pc release

west silo
#

with changing Miranda and Jacob's races, honestly I don't see any reason why not to, so I'm chill with it
@jolly swift
So they could just as easily change Johnson's race to make it fit better too right?

karmic hemlock
#

never picked up 5 since i heard it was a crapshoot

west silo
#

Or change john

jolly swift
#

so in ODST there's a poster that presumably shows a bunch of locations for one corporation, and one of the locations is a village in Vermont

#

what the heck is going on in Vermont in 2552

west silo
#

Or make halsey Asian

karmic hemlock
#

a village in vermont? what twisty turvey happened?

jolly swift
#

yeah I'm not gonna comment on that topic any further, too easy for it to go down a not so great path

west silo
#

Ehh true

#

Its just the reasoning was garbage

open falcon
#

Why is the queen the most powerful chess piece

#

Get out of here with that feminist stuff

terse lava
#

That is...utterly random

gilded mason
#

I can't tell if he's trying to joke or is being sincere with it.

terse lava
#

No clue

keen delta
#

i know im kinda late to the party but the spartan 3s main purpose seemed to me to be a gross misallocation of UNSC resources. the price for the training and augmentations and those stealth suits (which i understand are cheaper than mjolnir) are resources better spent elsewhere. though their targets were significant, I dont think wasting 2 full spartan companies on them was worth it.

#

our of prometheus and torpedo I think torpedo was the only significant strategic target

inner basin
#

Torpedo could’ve had more survivors but the UNSC was unaware of the lurking threat of 7 Covenant Naval assets in the sky. They are the main reason Beta was mostly wiped out (besides from the 2 survivors ofc)

keen delta
#

of course which is why i kinda give it a pass. Prometheus on the other hand seems like a waste of a target when the enemy already has an armada of 10s of thousands of ships

inner basin
#

Ehh. The main point of the S-III program was really to trade lives for time, so any target the UNSC/ONI thought was appropriate, the S-IIIs were sent on

#

Ultimately, I do think it was a waste of resources, but that’s just how things are

echo nebula
#

True, those 300 lives spent, and the resources spent to create them, probably did save thousands, if not tens of thousands of lives

versed helm
#

The S-IIIs were a kamikaze project, at the end of the day

versed helm
#

So is it cannon that halo 1 to reach's multiplayer is virtual training? or is that just Halo 4 and 5s multiplayer?

rain imp
#

Halo 4 onwards, isn't it? I thought it was once Infinity was built.

versed helm
#

I think it is

#

but I couldnt find anything about 1, 2, 3 and reach's

rain imp
#

I don't think there's lore behind those.

versed helm
#

was it ever explained how 4 and 5's virtual training works?

rain imp
#

It's a simulation room that the Spartans train in. Wargames.

versed helm
#

ah ok

rain imp
#

UNSC War Games, often shortened as War Games, is a form of UNSC combat training carried out in specialized locations. While frequently undertaken by Spartans, War Games events are also held for non-augmented personnel of the UNSC Armed Forces for inter-service training.

#

(from Halopedia)

#

War Games chambers use a combination of holographic projectors, millions of pneumatic risers, props, and simulated sensory information fed through a neural interface to generate realistic environments in which combat simulations are initiated.

Simulated training can be watched by via cameras or specialized areas spread out around the fields, and some facilities even have an AI, such as one that manages the War Games simulator on the UNSC Infinity and acts as the games' announcer. Sarah Palmer, the commander of the ship's Spartan contingent, has a low opinion of the AI.

On the UNSC Infinity, Spartans have to ensure optics are calibrated before they enter War Games simulations, using specialized Information cards.

War Games simulations sometimes introduce "balancing" to several weapons and AI units. A notable example is the M6/E Selene's Lance, where balancing adds extra recoil to the weapon.

#

I remember the E3 Halo 5 tour that Microsoft did using Hololens. I loved that.

#

That's where the lore of the InfoCards arrived.

versed helm
#

It never says it was newly introduced in the UNSC infinity so maybe it existed years before hand? so that could explain multiplayer for the other games

rain imp
#

It's never been confirmed.

versed helm
#

ik, Its just a theory of mine I guess

rain imp
#

I get that. But that's how lore gets broken. Go with what can be verified more than anything else. Otherwise we end up with lore ideas like John-117 being the IsoDidact. /shudders

#

I'll never forget that. :/

versed helm
#

Im not familiar lol, I never really kept up with halo after halo 4 (since I wasnt very fond of it)

rain imp
#

I actually love Halo 4. I (don't shoot me) think it's the best lore-wise out there.

versed helm
#

It was fun, but I didn't like the art style or level design that much

versed helm
#

@inner basin @echo nebula @versed helm Lucy my main gal from the og spartan-lll. One of 2 survivors. Spoiler * I love how she can’t talk cuz she s seen too much.

rain imp
#

She's since recovered, but only speaks under measured circumstance.

jolly swift
#

tbh I think the way they handled her recovery is lacking

#

maybe instead they had Halsey working with her the entire book (maybe as some form of penance because Halsey still feels guilty about the Spartan II's)

humble yacht
#

Somebody earlier complained about Jorge’s death being pointless because covenant fleet arrives seconds after....
Like, that’s the point? That’s what makes it tragic. The only silver lining is that he didn’t see his efforts go to waste in front of his eyes

#

(Unlike Daisy)

cedar surge
#

daisy saw all of the troops she saved shot down right?

terse lava
#

Daisy I actually felt bad for

cedar surge
#

was there any way she could have saved them?

#

there was still some space elevators around right

#

or were they all already shot down

#

actually how much damaage would a falling SE do?

#

the covenant have massive grav lifts to space right?

faint stone
#

yep

#

daisy escaped too

#

went back to her home

#

found her flash clone who was basically slowly dying hence her being in a wheelchair

#

and her clone gave her the old teddy bear charm which she kept

#

then all of a sudden meets one of her old friends whos the pelican pilot

#

but gets bombarded with fuel rods and she dies in vain

#

then chief finds her body and idk

jolly swift
#

Honestly the whole idea of Reach was that any death would be pointless

#

Jorge wasn't going to save Reach, we knew that going into it

#

Reach is a tragedy, it's not the same kind of story as the other games

humble yacht
#

Reach’s most impactful moments are when it gives you hope and then immediately takes it away

#

The end of Tip, the end of Long Night

#

Those are the moments that best encapsulate the tone of the game

jolly swift
#

Then at the end it gives you hope and doesn't take it away

terse lava
#

Would count Kat's death in a smaller way too. Taken out just feet from safety

faint stone
#

oh yeah

#

'take out the spire noble team'

#

'takes out sheild'

#

frigate just gets yeeted

#

kat could've survived

#

but nope got slapped by a needler rifle

cedar surge
#

well the frigate didn't need to be in punching range right next to the spire

#

but it would have eventually got yetted in the space battle anyway

#

so all three unsc ship classes were old right?

jolly swift
#

the UNSC wasn't producing a ton of new stuff near the end of the war I think

#

we were nearly extinct by that point

terse lava
#

More quantity over quality...though that tactic failed too

cedar surge
#

it worked sometimes

#

like how cole was ripping up covenant fleets in the outer colonies

jolly swift
#

the quality over quantity was the math with the Spartan II's

#

after that they switched for the Spartan III's

cedar surge
#

and with the Ivs they reach an equalibrium

jolly swift
#

that's kinda what I don't like about the IV's tbh

#

they're too... safe

cedar surge
#

i can see that

#

they also have the most innsurrectionists

jolly swift
#

with the II's there were only a few of them, and the III's were hopped up on drugs and made for suicide missions

cedar surge
#

well only really the gammas were on drugs

jolly swift
#

there's always an element of shadiness to the II's and III's

cedar surge
#

cause they can't feel pain

#

well the first class of spartan 4s is kinda that

jolly swift
#

honestly the II's and III's were almost like, soft body horror

cedar surge
#

they were suppossed to be as powerful as spartans in suits

#

it went poorly

jolly swift
#

imagine if Six was from Gamma

humble yacht
#

Imagine if Isla Zane got hold of mjolnir

jolly swift
#

"Forget Reach, smoothers I need"

#

"left me my wife has, game I must"

cedar surge
#

if she got mjolnir then everybody would be beat

#

she would have the power of a spartan x 2

#

would her body be adapted for the suit though

versed helm
#

i guess so

cedar surge
#

her boody was made to be as strong as the suit

versed helm
#

so, if she does get the suit, she'd be on par with chief, if not stronger, right?

cedar surge
#

but wouldn't she new crew and the machinery to keep the suit in shape?

humble yacht
#

one of the MJOLNIR variants in H5 is like DIY variant

#

bucaneer, i think

versed helm
#

Where does Halo 3 ODST fit in the timeline again?

cedar surge
#

between the two weeks between 2 and 3

#

the name makes it confusing yea

versed helm
#

Ok thanks

jolly swift
#

Y'know I just realized

#

Reach is basically a Greek tragedy in the way it's written

humble yacht
#

how so?

cedar surge
#

when you try your best but nothing will stop this monster?

versed helm
#

its like the siege of troy

#

and we follow a bunch of trojans trying to get stuff done

jolly swift
#

We know how it's going to end, we know they all have to die

humble yacht
#

the classic greek tragic hero is tragic because they have a personal flaw that brings about their downfall

#

I wouldn't say Noble Team had personal flaws

cedar surge
#

and the CSO would be the closest thing to the trojan horse

jolly swift
#

Maybe Greek isn't the one I'm thinking of

cedar surge
#

emile had anger

#

issues

humble yacht
#

yeah but emile's anger didn't directly contribute to Reach being destroyed or him dying

jolly swift
#

Whichever kind of tragedy REALLY liked using dramatic irony

cedar surge
#

the smartest got headshot

#

the quit one dissapeared

#

the tough guy died in a huge explosion

#

carter died in a fire

#

and the lone wolf died alone

humble yacht
#

Jorge's death wasn't ironic

#

neither was Carter's

jolly swift
#

Less with the characters and more with the story overall

humble yacht
#

Emile's maybe because he got killed by a blade

jolly swift
#

We go through the whole thing knowing how it ends

versed helm
#

Didn’t carter die by his choice

humble yacht
#

yes

cedar surge
#

he could have set the pelican on course and jumped out

#

or use biofoam

#

to heal himself

versed helm
#

Yeah but he was gonna die anyway

#

Reach was doomed

cedar surge
#

the unsc can kinda bring you back from the dead

versed helm
#

They can?

cedar surge
#

linda was cliinically dead at one point i think

#

she got shot multiple times by plasma and once in the neck

versed helm
#

I thought she was presumed dead but not actually

#

Oh

cedar surge
#

carter didn't have as bad wounds

versed helm
#

Well again

#

Reach was doomed

cedar surge
#

the suit comes equiped with biofoam

#

jun lived

#

blue team lived

versed helm
#

yeah.
also, halsey gave linda dermatological steriods, right?

humble yacht
#

Linda had flatlined but she was put on ice before brain damage set in

versed helm
#

Halo CE already established that Reach was destroyed. They had to kill them in some way to make an excuse why they weren’t mentioned

humble yacht
#

halsey repaired her and resuscitated her

versed helm
#

Prequels are always doomed to have some writing mistakes

cedar surge
#

actually a book came before CE

versed helm
#

Really?

cedar surge
#

the Fall of Reach

versed helm
#

and contact harvest

#

that came before all of em

#

Then that establishes my point even more

The team was doomed from the start

#

and so does cole protocol, if im not wrong

jolly swift
#

Lance means that Fall of Reach actually released like two weeks before CE

#

So technically CE is a sequel lmao

cedar surge
#

and 343 is trying to do the same with infinite

#

with next to no lore and a single book coming out

jolly swift
#

They're definitely doing the BotW approach

#

Try to invoke the original

snow halo
#

is there a lore reason as to why there weren't any ars in h2

jolly swift
#

I'm wondering that too

#

We even saw them in the same city on the same day in ODST

#

My money's on the trademark Parker 117 luck

cedar surge
#

chief felt like a new loo

dusty copper
#

ARs?

#

Wait dont the marines carry them?

humble yacht
#

assault rifle

#

in H2? no

#

they carry SMGs and BRs

dusty copper
#

Oh

snow halo
#

they should've removed the ar from odst to make it more consistent

dusty copper
#

Uh maybe the in amber clad didn't have any?

jolly swift
#

Maybe

#

But the AR was a big part of 3's sandbox

snow halo
#

but they were down on the surface and they still didn't have any

cedar surge
#

thats because it was for gameplay