#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 376 of 1

feral stirrup
#

and got pissed off at times

fair hazel
#

Yep emperor

terse lava
#

yeah he was humanized in the bungie era, flippin Fall of Reach shows it, as does The Flood(the CE novel) and First Strike

feral stirrup
#

but he still remained mostly as a silent protagonist and vessel for hte player to interpret through his eyes

#

which bungie understood

fair hazel
#

How lazy

cedar surge
#

Bungie intentionally made him a shell of a character

#

It was the books that humanized him

versed helm
#

Are you a bungie fanboy lol @feral stirrup

feral stirrup
#

not a recent bungie fanboy

vague scroll
#

It’s okay to have a silent protagonist for your audience to latch onto, claiming that humanizing a character is a bad thing is well... bad

fair hazel
#

The one time I’m okay with calling something lazy. And I don’t like using that word for game development often.

feral stirrup
#

i think bungie has made way too many mistakes lately.

#

with destiny. I played D2 and was no impressed

terse lava
#

they made mistakes in the past too with halo

cedar surge
#

You mean bungie era halo fanboy

vague scroll
#

Bungie made a lot of mistakes in their pre-halo days too

feral stirrup
#

of course they did. But many of those mistakes where accidentally awesome

terse lava
#

no one is perfect

vague scroll
#

Bungie was never perfect

feral stirrup
#

like the pistol

vague scroll
#

Far from it in fact

versed helm
#

XD @cedar surge

cedar surge
#

Pistol?

feral stirrup
#

yeah in CE

terse lava
#

the CE one

vague scroll
#

Their success was built on a pyramid of mistakes

cedar surge
#

That's a gameplay thing

feral stirrup
#

extremely Op

#

and their difficulty settings in CE where perfect to

fair hazel
#

Not very well balanced

feral stirrup
#

instead of lazily just bullet sponging the enemies and having them one shot you

vague scroll
#

Myth 2 they turned into malware for a joke

versed helm
#

You know the big hunk of metal in chief hand lol

feral stirrup
#

they simply just flooded you with more enemies

vague scroll
#

Cost the company 500 thousand dollars

feral stirrup
#

which is how higher difficulty should be

cedar surge
#

Doesn't the flood also do that @feral stirrup

feral stirrup
#

yeah

vague scroll
#

Halo CE only worked 5 weeks before launch

cedar surge
#

Flooding you with enemies

vague scroll
#

Halo 2 had to be remade from scratch

feral stirrup
#

i'm talking about the covies though

fair hazel
#

Except enemies take more damage and do more damage..

feral stirrup
#

that to but it wasn't only that

cedar surge
#

And wasn't in 2 brutes were bullet spomges

versed helm
#

Halo 2 development was hell for bungie

terse lava
#

yep

fair hazel
#

“Instead of “

feral stirrup
#

2 brutes where no joke

cedar surge
#

And that sniper jackals were awful

fair hazel
#

Kind of not consistent

vague scroll
#

I guess no one wants to hear the story of Bungie as a company run by humans

feral stirrup
#

halo 2 had brutes in their true form. which was being purely brutes and nothing else

vague scroll
#

“They were perfect”

cedar surge
#

Also to bring up a point earlier crunch time is not good

feral stirrup
#

complete a holes to kill in higher difficulty

fair hazel
#

Those games, perhaps amazing for their time, have a lot of flaws.

feral stirrup
#

the only thing i don't miss from the older days of gaming though where the terrible physics

#

and random deaths caused by it

fair hazel
#

In their true form..

versed helm
#

Plus console limits @fair hazel

cedar surge
#

Halo has good physics most of the time

vague scroll
#

Truly totally, Halo was never a hot mess that managed to pull off something because of luck and passion

feral stirrup
#

had a flash back for a minute and completely forgot how frustrating that was

unique rune
#

Having revisited the campaigns for CE and 2 recently, they’re... yeah, pretty flawed gameplay wise. I still generally think they’re fun but they get to be a right pain in the rear sometimes.

feral stirrup
#

coupled with the AI being terrible drivers lol

#

but it was very cutting edge for it's time

#

CE compared to today's standards had some pretty sluggish gameplay

fair hazel
#

Well none of that pertains to lore now

terse lava
#

I still say to this day halo 2 had the best ally AI, via the sangheili

cedar surge
#

You complain about 343's story but you are also not addrsssibg bungies story

feral stirrup
#

and awkward jumping mechanics

#

but i think i know the reason why

#

it wasn't even supposed to be a shooter originally

terse lava
#

yea started as an RTS

feral stirrup
#

so they had to modify what wasn't and make it into one

cedar surge
#

You were complaining that 343 had a terrible story but you never addressed the issues with bungies story

feral stirrup
#

kinda like taking a 1993 honda civic hatchback and dropping a 12 valve cummins in it

cedar surge
#

You just touched on their gameplay

feral stirrup
#

ok bungies problem story wise

#

why was there never a cure for the flood?

vague scroll
#

He wasn’t complaining that 343i has a terrible story, he was complaining that everything but maybe one little lore thing was terrible

terse lava
#

why would there be a cure

vague scroll
#

Why should there be a cure?

feral stirrup
#

why is the sky blue?

cedar surge
#

The flood doesn't have a cure

vague scroll
#

The flood’s a parasite, not a disease

unique rune
#

So... on the subject of lore...

Still making my way through Silent Storm. Enjoying it thus far.
Always had this weird nagging that Hector Nyeto sounded familiar and I’m almost a little surprised that I’d forgotten he was mentioned in the Denning’s other Halo novels.

versed helm
#

The cure are the halo rings

terse lava
#

well ok there is a cure

#

cleansing plasma

fair hazel
#

Because of Raleigh’s scattering effect. That’s why the sky is blue

vague scroll
#

Death is a cure then

terse lava
#

not really Tide

vague scroll
#

Shhh

#

Seemed to work for the ancient humans and forerunners

cedar surge
#

These sound like random things and not really story issues though

vague scroll
#

Well fine

feral stirrup
#

why do i always get contrarians in a box of cracker jacks?

vague scroll
#

I amend my statement to obliteration

terse lava
#

yeah, there was nothing in CE-3 that had anything to do with a flood cure

cedar surge
#

Ok your not going to talk about bungies story then huh

feral stirrup
#

halo 3's lore problem

vague scroll
#

Because you chose the flavor when looking at the aisle

#

You get what you paid for, or rather you chose your soapbox

feral stirrup
#

was cortanas only real solution just to fire the halo array? when she clearly lambasted cheif for trying to do the same in CE?

terse lava
#

one was in the galaxy

terse lava
#

and would set the others off

#

the other was far outside the galaxy

fair hazel
#

Except you’re wrong about your question?

cedar surge
#

That halo was outside the galaxy

#

And not complete

feral stirrup
#

what about the flood on earth?

fair hazel
#

You make the wrongful statement that she was trying to fire the halo array

terse lava
#

even if it was complete it wouldn't harm the galaxy

feral stirrup
#

you really think glassing that continent was enough to contain it?

terse lava
#

yes

cedar surge
#

The flood on earth was flassed

#

Yes

fair hazel
#

The content was not glsssed

versed helm
#

Who’s she XD

feral stirrup
#

what if one spore escaped?

terse lava
#

it didn't

fair hazel
#

And, dead flood.

vague scroll
#

Halo’s can be fine tuned to fire in only a single star system for the record

feral stirrup
#

in the atmosphere

#

and got carried away in a jetstream

fair hazel
#

Well the ancient halos.

cedar surge
#

Because the flood did not reach the airborne stage yet

terse lava
#

funny thing, flood turns in plasma

feral stirrup
#

i'm sure they already where when that cruiser crashed

vague scroll
#

That’s a fair distinction but I don’t think Hawaii guy knows that ericky

fair hazel
#

The scenecent halo array can

versed helm
#

2am I should be sleeping but this conversation is fun lol

cedar surge
#

@feral stirrup if the flood was airborne earth would be glassed

terse lava
#

we see flood spores floating around sure, but they weren't high enough in the atmosphere yet

feral stirrup
#

rtas had a good point

terse lava
#

everything was burned by the sangheili

orchid prism
#

25,000 light years the radius of the explosion from halo, right?

vague scroll
#

On default with the contemporary array yes

fair hazel
#

Not explosion but, of the firing. Activation

#

It’s effects can be felt through time

feral stirrup
#

oh and another thing. how the hell did cheif survive the halo firing in the forward unto dawn?

orchid prism
#

Oh

fair hazel
#

Oh and the range amplified as the waves overlap

terse lava
#

because he wasn't in the blast area

feral stirrup
#

when he didn't go through the portal

gilded mason
#

how the hell did cheif survive the halo firing in the forward unto dawn?
He got inside the portal in time

terse lava
#

he had gone through the portal before it closed

feral stirrup
#

ah that's right

terse lava
#

ah welcome to the heresy Ostral

feral stirrup
#

well shoot

#

i guess i can't find anything wrong with bungies lore guys

fair hazel
#

To war

#

Truth halo 3

cedar surge
#

Oh really you are gonna say that huh

fair hazel
#

Portal high charity

#

The whole mess of canon halo reach fall of reach

#

Too much to list. Don’t want to do it

terse lava
#

the dead bodies in High charity, the zero explaination of how johnson, thel, and miranda got to earth

cedar surge
#

How about the fact that most of bungies characters in halo 1 to 3 were static characters and the arbiter was the only one who grew

feral stirrup
#

oh there is one thing

terse lava
#

"one"

versed helm
#

Cortana said and I quite we went through the portal just in time

feral stirrup
#

mackenzy and prerez

#

WTf happened to them

terse lava
#

dead

vague scroll
#

Time between Johnson/arbiter/Keyes getting back to Earth before Chief

feral stirrup
#

and did thel kill them

terse lava
#

killed by thel

feral stirrup
#

we don't know that

gilded mason
#

They decided to go on a duo adventure

terse lava
#

with a pet infection form

feral stirrup
#

lol mckinzey and pereze's excellent adventure

terse lava
#

named bob

versed helm
#

With they good buddy Thel lol

feral stirrup
#

mckinzey and perez hot boxing it with thel

vague scroll
#

Sounds like a lot of lore problems to me if we have to get nit picky

#

Just like when people nit pick the 343i games

feral stirrup
#

"yo thel. this is the best sangheli weed i've ever had man"

vague scroll
#

Sounds like they suffer through similar problems

feral stirrup
#

to be fair. 343 has been on a stream of effups

vague scroll
#

Maybe Bungie and 343i games are just as good, just in different ways

orchid prism
#

Ah back again with 343

feral stirrup
#

i think the best thing they did with anniversary is not touch it at all and contract it out to that other studio

cedar surge
#

Which one

vague scroll
#

Maybe we shouldn’t judge people’s work as the worst thing ever when clearly people like it more than me

cedar surge
#

CE or 2

feral stirrup
#

2

cedar surge
#

Because they have done good things

vague scroll
#

Maybe other people’s opinions have merit

fair hazel
#

Other than halo 5’s overall narrative.. and some things in escalation, some, and initstion, I’d say all the stories have been great

terse lava
#

I like you Tide 😛

#

i couldn't resist

feral stirrup
#

the only thing i liked about 5 was the sangelios map

#

and exploring sangheli lore

vague scroll
#

No problem man, you my bro ado

terse lava
#

wort

orchid prism
#

Haha wholesome

gilded mason
#

A common sentiment

terse lava
#

also yes, I agree with him on that

fair hazel
#

You can do that in a few books which you probably should honestly. They’re very enjoyable

#

And they’ll widen your knowledge on sangheili

feral stirrup
#

locke is just a boring character

terse lava
#

so is chief, big whoop

cedar surge
#

So is miranda

orchid prism
#

So is johnson (kidding)

feral stirrup
#

i want to see more lore about elites arguing why humans aren't being allowed to be adopted into the covenant

fair hazel
#

As much as explaining to someone can be okay. It doesn’t been experiencing thing

#

Best

feral stirrup
#

and seeing some question it further and defecting

fair hazel
#

Beat

cedar surge
#

If you defected you would have been called a heretic amd killed

terse lava
#

it was never much of an issueenough to leave the Covenant

feral stirrup
#

yeah the elite on the gas giant was one of those

cedar surge
#

Yea they questioned the prophets but never left

feral stirrup
#

but i bet there where far more than just him

terse lava
#

but not thanks to humans, he just saw the Great Journey as a load of bunk

cedar surge
#

That's because he was convicted by guilty spark who had evidence

feral stirrup
#

and that you where being manipulated

terse lava
#

convinced*

cedar surge
#

Guilty spark could actually back his claims because he was a forerunner AI

#

He knew what the rings were for

fair hazel
#

Human forerunner ai

terse lava
#

well, it also helped the Covenant saw him as a mouthpiece for their gods

fair hazel
#

Funny thing that it was a human who told the truth

feral stirrup
#

it would be funny to see guilty spark meet glados

#

both of them have a itch but for a different reason

fair hazel
#

It would be funnier to me see spark meet didact again

#

Itch..?

feral stirrup
#

one has to do constant testing inorder to be satisfied

#

and the other has to convince a reclaimer in every possible way to activate his installation

cedar surge
#

That seems to be a bit of a stretch

feral stirrup
#

to get that programmed digital dopamine rush of satisfaction

cedar surge
#

He doesn't have to convince a reclaimer

feral stirrup
#

he must follow protocol

cedar surge
#

Just take the index

fair hazel
#

That’s a BIG stretch

terse lava
#

even stretch armstrong would question that

cedar surge
#

In CE guilty spark said to kill the chief so he could get the index to activate the ring. He doesn't need a reclaimer. It just helps

terse lava
#

well no

#

he does need one

cedar surge
#

At the ark yes

terse lava
#

but he can hold the index himself if need be, can't use it though

orchid prism
#

Ok guys one question for Buck, in 5 does he wear the odst helmet in honour of Rookie's death?

terse lava
#

had he managed to kill chief, he would have just went after another human

#

he outright says that

cedar surge
#

If he can't use it then for what reason does he need the index so badly

gilded mason
#

He wears it because he enjoyed wearing one back when he was an ODST

terse lava
#

pretty sure he wears it as he was an ODST

feral stirrup
#

yeah he has to manipulate the reclaimer into activating it

delicate ether
#

If it ain’t broke

cedar surge
#

Don't fix it?

fair hazel
#

Upgrade it?

cedar surge
#

Bop it

fair hazel
#

Twist it?

orchid prism
#

@gilded mason @terse lava i see

terse lava
#

I hate you both for getting that song in my head now

feral stirrup
#

hey UNSC why do you still use bullets instead of advanced plasma weaponry

cedar surge
#

Your welcome

#

Oh don't start that argument

delicate ether
#

I’m not complaining, love the ODST helmet

feral stirrup
#

unsc spokesperson "Because that's the way it's always been done sonny jim"

terse lava
#

"Nanomachines son"

#

or, you know

#

NEURAL

feral stirrup
#

this rifle you're holding is the same exact rifle your great great great great great great...great grandfather once held

gilded mason
#

PHYSICS

fair hazel
#

Except when they don’t.

feral stirrup
#

ironically everything is still chambered in 7.62 and 5.56

terse lava
#

excellent Ostral, was worried you'd leave me hanging for a moment there

gilded mason
#

lol

fair hazel
#

More than just that

terse lava
#

may just tag you from now on XD

fair hazel
#

And there’s advancements thsy can be made that are not just size wise

#

Unsc has used hard light and plasma stuff.

cedar surge
#

Plasma is worse at mid to long ranges and makes it easier to see where its being fired from. Plus it still can do much against shielding

#

Like the battle rifle

#

Probably the most powerful rifle

terse lava
#

the real reason though is two-fold. Bungie wanted something familar, and lore-wise, humanity had been at peace for a few centuries

feral stirrup
#

it's always funny to see lore in certain videogames get written and wrapped around gameplay mechanics.

fair hazel
#

I like post war tech they incorporated advances

cedar surge
#

Plus bullets would be cheaper than terraforming a whole planet to get ammo

fair hazel
#

I like when we see stuff change over time.

terse lava
#

misses plasma rifle

feral stirrup
#

of course the main reason why the unsc still uses traditional chemical projectile weapons was because of the 200 years of peace

fair hazel
#

I used the tier 3 brute plasma rifle in warzone recently. It’s fun to use that one

cedar surge
#

Well bullets are still effective

feral stirrup
#

weapons tech didn't advance for a long time because there was no driving force or reason

terse lava
#

not the same

feral stirrup
#

which makes sense when you look at our modern military

#

some things have literally not changed weapon wise for over 100 years because it never really needed to

fair hazel
#

It’s still a plasma rifle.

feral stirrup
#

a great example is the M2 browning

#

hell i bet the UNSC uses the M2

fair hazel
#

I hope we see the answer mentioned in a book or somewhere else one day

#

And a lot of the variants

#

Actually. I’d like a book to make up a new variant. Then have it come into halo infinite

cedar surge
#

Bullets would be cheaper to produce than making power for plasma weapons

#

Don't you have to go to a refill station to give plasma weapons back power?

feral stirrup
#

plasma weaponry would require a method for storing energy that would have a ton of energy density

#

literally more energy density than gasoline or diesel

cedar surge
#

And over heating problems

feral stirrup
#

so irl if you where to make a plasma weapon you'd basically need either a arc reactor

#

or mini fusion reactor powersource

#

that is able to harness almost all of the energy it gets

cedar surge
#

Yea I don't like it when people say that it should be easy for the unsc to reverse engineer plasma weapons

fair hazel
#

Or harness stuff from planets atmosphere with certain ships and use in pinch fusion rracgors too

orchid prism
#

It took years for reverse engineering covenant shields

gilded mason
#
```👍
fair hazel
#

Or terraform worlds to provide you with the materials and plasma

feral stirrup
#

yeah terraforming would require boat loads of energy

cedar surge
#

Because a person justified that energy shielding is advanced so replicating plasma weapons should be easy

gilded mason
#

lol

fair hazel
#

Comon guys. You guys should know whay I’m referencing

cedar surge
#

Stellaris?

fair hazel
#

Ealen IV and those collecting covenant ships insolent storm

feral stirrup
#

00 was talking about how shield technology in halo lore worked for spartains

cedar surge
#

Oh when they terraformed a planet to give ammo

feral stirrup
#

i thought it was really cool

orchid prism
#

What's ealen iv? A novel?

feral stirrup
#

he was mentioning that basically spartain shield tech works by manipulating things at a quantum level

cedar surge
#

Oh yea the guy who said that in referencing is gen tech

fair hazel
#

Theorizing

#

Theorizing.

feral stirrup
#

i thought it was a great theory

fair hazel
#

A theory does not mean it’s canon

feral stirrup
#

because something like that could exist in real life

#

energy shields might not be too far of in the distant future

fair hazel
#

Do not confound theory with canon.

feral stirrup
#

ok will do. I will not confound 343's story with bungies

#

got it

cedar surge
#

He actually said that energy shielding is so advanced so replicating plasma weapons should be easy that gen tech guy said. And he sounded so sure of himself

#

Your starting that again

terse lava
#

cute

fair hazel
cedar surge
#

Relatable

gilded mason
#

A bit big.

fair hazel
#

Perhaps not enough for the situation frankly

#

Too bright for the time though.

cedar surge
#

Havnt we put the 343 bad bungie good down years ago

terse lava
#

never heard of zombies?

#

it will always come back

fair hazel
#

I guess we just have to be ready for it so we don’t get, flooded. 😎

cedar surge
#

Good thing I have OD-OD-OD-ODSTs in position

fair hazel
#

Looks like we may need to rescue some of@them in infinite

terse lava
#

watches fully upgraded kig-yar sniper army get overwhelmed by ODST spam

cedar surge
#

That's the way jackals crumble

terse lava
#

closest thing to flood firefight at the time

cedar surge
#

The only 343 ships I really have a problem with is the vindication or anlace

fair hazel
#

Which I hope we get in infinite because I want to fight with promethean weapons

#

I like the ships but I just want to know more and see@more of@them in action and other

cedar surge
#

Vindication because even for the unsc it's a brick and antennas

delicate ether
#

The Flood, did they sneak onboard the Amber Clad? So confused when it suddenly appears in High Charity

fair hazel
#

We need more space battles in modern halo stories

cedar surge
#

Yea most post war ship battles are just the infinity

fair hazel
#

They probably just took a pelican backa snd infected everyone

gilded mason
#

Yes, they got aboard the ship through unknown means while Miranda was captured

cedar surge
#

I miss fleet battles between two factions and not just one ship

#

Yea who would expect flood to be on a pelican

#

Though Miranda should no there might be the possibility of flood also being on this ring so why did she land the frigate so close

fair hazel
#

Perhaps to keep the ship safe, but from@the covenant

delicate ether
#

Yeah, being in orbit seems like a death wish

#

Out in the open

fair hazel
#

You know what moment I enjoy from the battle of installation 04?

#

When the unsc forces raid the pillar of autumn

delicate ether
#

Oh

fair hazel
#

It’s fun to play it too

#

The sort of building up the resistance moment feels nice

#

I hope we get some similar stuff in infinite

terse lava
#

maybe

#

while I wasn't really fond of it in CE, could be better in infinite

delicate ether
#

Atleast in Aliens they kept the ship in orbit, that worked out 😂

fair hazel
#

We didn’t get to see it in CE

delicate ether
#

What happened to the truth and reconciliation after “Keyes”?

#

Or was that the ship in Halo 3

#

Flood infested one in floodgate

fair hazel
#

No.

delicate ether
#

Okay

gilded mason
#

UNSC forces took control of it, but McKay crashed it into the ring to prevent the Flood onboard from getting to Earth with them

fair hazel
#

The unsc boarded it. Flood infected. McKay made it crash and die and boom

#

What he said

delicate ether
#

Woah

#

Guess I should read more novels

#

Nice to know what happens to things off-screen, closure is good

fair hazel
#

Yes you should

#

They’re very great

#

Each book is an adventure.

terse lava
#

I met the novelization of CE @fair hazel

gilded mason
#

Wow, were they humble or arrogant, Ado?

#

😋

terse lava
#

eh at this point too tired to think

delicate ether
#

If most of them are also in Audiobook form then i’m game, mostly enjoy reading stuff on wikis

#

Never been one for physical books ☹️

plain sierra
#

who’s in blue team

gilded mason
#

At the moment: John, Fred, Kelly, and Linda

delicate ether
#

Hope Infinite keeps it that way

gilded mason
#

Ye

terse lava
#

I prefer books

delicate ether
#

Sue me, but i enjoyed them in Guardians

#

Probably watered down versions but still

terse lava
#

hm?

gilded mason
#
Probably watered down versions```
Yeh
delicate ether
#

I was even okay with Osiris

#

Might be the Fillion Factor

lethal comet
#

The only spartan 4 i like is buck

#

change my mind

delicate ether
#

Yep

feral stirrup
#

hard for me to change my mind on that one cause i agree with it

#

also you know what doesn't make sense at all. Censoring swear words on a channel about a videogame that has alot of swearing in it lol.

#

a long standing tradition even on -blam!-ing bungie.net

inner basin
#

I like Spartan Thorne. He felt like he was actually trying to live up to a Spartan’s expectations (which is commendable) but he also didn’t lose his personality. I think he was initially supposed to be in Halo 5 before 343 said “Nah, screw it” and replaced him with Buck instead

#

At least I think that’s what happened. I could misremembering as it’s early in the morning

#

a long standing tradition even on -blam!-ing bungie.net
On HaloWaypoint it’s -Yoink!-. Guess 343 are still keeping that tradition

slim thorn
#

I'm looking forward to see Alpha-Nine back in action again though

#

But, since they don't have someone to rant themselves on, I'm curious how it will work things out.

#

Two pairs of couples at a same team, could put Romeo an Mickey into bully

carmine sleet
#

What do you mean by "rant themselves on"?

cyan thunder
#

So I'm half way through primordium. I'm not too keen on the forerunner trilogy. The pace is a bit slow. It's's interesting, just not my favourite. What I'm curious about, is it explained why only humans can fire the halos? Or at least that's how the games portray it, needing Miranda Keyes to activate Delta Halo.

scarlet topaz
#

I do know that a human AI gets rampancy because of all the data he/she collects in 7 years if i am correct?

#

But why do forerunner AI's have rampancy?

#

Like guilty spark

orchid prism
#

Yeahh.... 343 guilty spark got bored which probably caused the rampancy in one of the halo cea terminals iirc.

#

But really, boredom?

scarlet topaz
#

I mean why is it even possible, couldn't they just make a counter to rampancy in there AI's

craggy sierra
#

That wasn’t really rampancy in the traditional sense

#

That was literally just normal psychosis brought on by 100,000 years if isolation

#

Because the forerunners thought that loneliness would be a good thing for the monitors to feel.

#

So they kinda just all got psychotically attached to their duties surrounding their rings in lieu of anything else.

lethal comet
#

Spark was so lonely that he couldn't even power down peacefully

terse lava
#

to be frank I don't think it's ever said why they didn't consider something like that happening, but guess would assume compartmenization,

craggy sierra
#

I'm pretty sure the entire forerunner schtick is extreme short sightedness

#

Everything they do can best be summarized by the Jurassic Park line "just because you could doesn't mean you should."

#

They're essentially a galactic boogeyman story of what happens when technology and hubris far out paces common sense

lethal comet
#

At least the librarian had some sens

#

planned out the future

craggy sierra
#

She has follies too. Doesn't she still want to up hold the concept of the mantle?

lethal comet
#

she wants to pass it on

craggy sierra
#

Yeah that's not a good thing

lethal comet
#

The janus key is proof of that

craggy sierra
#

The mantle was a thinly veiled metaphor of galactic dictatorship and the forerunners very much treated other races under them in a similar way to how Cortana wants to treat them now.

lethal comet
#

The precursors had the right idea

#

But they didn't factor in that when faced with extinction their creations would fight back

craggy sierra
#

There shouldn't be a single totalitarian leadership in the galaxy of a single race

lethal comet
#

The forerunner precursor war could have been averted

#

Was there really a need to tell forerunners that humanity is better and they are gonna be exterminated

#

Any species is gonna fight for survival

craggy sierra
#

All that matters with that is where the universe currently stands. And I think we'd be better off not having a bunch of dead people dictate the optimal way to run the universe.

#

Especially since it ended well for exactly zero of them

west silo
#

Well by all indications humanity wasn't any better they were basically a mini imperium of man

craggy sierra
#

idk much about Warhammer but from what little I know, any political ideologies from that franchise wouldn't exactly make for peaceful leadership

humble yacht
#

Screw politics, just live in The Warp

terse lava
#

I doubt the precursor-forerunner could be avoided as the precursors planned on wiping the forerunners out regardless

humble yacht
#

That’s what the forerunners assumed

west silo
#

Nurgle is love
Nurgle is life

terse lava
#

no reason to think otherwise

humble yacht
#

It’s not like the precursors attacked first

terse lava
#

not even gravemind corrected that idea, just said the rebellion was unprovoked

west silo
#

Warfleet does kinda leen towards the precursors planning to kill the forerunners

terse lava
#

Yeah

#

You can argue its biased being a forerunner record, but at this point I look at it like this

#

While will you believe? Hyper advanced mortal aliens who while imperfect, did try to help keep the galaxy safe?

Or hyper advanced aliens who, according themselves, let themselves be wiped out, and then sought to bring eternal suffering to all life in the universe as revenge

feral stirrup
#

The gods are flawed

#

Man I love halo trilogys cannon

#

Oh I forgot to ad this in yesterday's discussion about what bungie did wrong that 343 actually fixed and did right

#

Two words

#

Warthog suspension.

#

It makes 0 sense on bungies side. Especially the linkage system

terse lava
#

Well of course they were flawed, neither races were gods

west silo
#

The precursors were pretty much gods

feral stirrup
#

The precursors remind me of the xelnaga

#

Primordial being that hated their successors

#

Because the forerunners saw them as a threat

west silo
#

Going to universe and seeding them with life

feral stirrup
#

Yeah

terse lava
#

They seeded galaxies

#

Not the universe

feral stirrup
#

They are basically both the creators and destroyers of life

west silo
#

Same difference

terse lava
#

Not really

west silo
#

They are basically both the creators and destroyers of life
@feral stirrup
Well only amon is evil the others just dont care

feral stirrup
#

The primordial = nihilism embodied

west silo
#

The precursors are implied to be multiversal by there ftl

versed helm
#

YO

feral stirrup
#

Told humans a fate so bad that they simply committed suicide

terse lava
#

Well he told them how all life would suffer under the flood. That their creators now sought damnation for all life in the galaxy

feral perch
#

It makes 0 sense on bungies side. Especially the linkage system
@feral stirrup

I’ve seen it argued that the Bungie Warthog used futuristic suspension, and the 343i era Warthog using modern-looking suspension seems inferior to something more futuristic like Bungie’s hog.

light kiln
#

What does Veronica Dare even do?

feral stirrup
#

They mostly did that suspension type due to graphical limitations

#

Multilink suspension requires more animation work. Vs the lengthy but simple elongated torsion bar

sinful pollen
#

I mean, she made out with Buck in an elevator

feral stirrup
#

Technically a elongated torsion link suspension would be inferior to that of a front and rear independent suspension setup with double a arm due to it not handling horizontal loads as well. But its also ironic cause the warthawg in ce has a super bathtubby feel.

unique rune
#

What does Veronica Dare even do?
Classified ONI things

feral stirrup
#

Lol

jolly furnace
#

Regarding Precursor motive for genocide, the Domain in Mythos apparently says Precursors planned to exterminate forerunners

#

Acording to the UNSC Curator AI

sinful pollen
#

There were two sides to that story. There's a side that says that the Forerunners revolted against the Precursors when they learned that Humanity will inherit the mantle instead of them. Then there's the Forerunner story that said the Precursors were going to exterminate them b/c they didn't pass their test.

cedar surge
#

In going to be on the forerunner side theree

inner basin
#

What does Veronica Dare even do?
She was an ONI Supervisor for Alpha-9, a few times, but she’s an ONI Agent so most of her dealings are highly classified

cedar surge
#

It seems more believable than the entirety of the forerunners being selfish and killing the precursors

jolly furnace
#

three sides - the Curator account differs from both other accounts in ways

#

It says forerunners claimed Mantle and became prideful and arrogant, Precursors observed, didnt like it and decided to erase forerunners

#

and give mantle to another species

#

forerunners sent fleet to PK

#

to spy on Precursors

#

and learned the genocide plan

#

forerunners then struck first

#

Also this account says Precursors stayed in PK after seeding life in MWG

#

leaving only their architecture and tech behind

#

All acocunts contradict somewhere

versed helm
#

Who will inherit the mantle at the end of infinite

gilded mason
#

No one, probably.

carmine sleet
#

The Mantle is a flawed concept and should be disregarded

#

Plus, I wouldn't really say there's anything that indicates that someone new will inherit it in Infinite

versed helm
#

Ok

jolly furnace
#

Mantle will either be discarded or shared by all in the end.

#

Long term, it will fail regardless i think

#

Cos species will always fall into conflict

#

in the end

#

So says the cynical part of my mind

sly stream
#

why does halo 2 and odst have the best stories in halo games

versed helm
#

I mean reach was a good story

jolly furnace
#

4 is best story

deep pewter
#

2 > 4 > ODST

sly stream
#

reach would've benefitted from stronger character development for noble team

deep pewter
#

Reach is on the bottom regarding story

sly stream
#

halo 4 could have been a LOT better

versed helm
#

That’s true but reach story was setting up CE

sly stream
#

it looked pretty good with those in development storyboards

#

like, palmer and the spartan ivs were a lot better

deep pewter
#

4 could’ve been a lot better, but it was still really good

sly stream
#

i didn't enjoy it personally

#

maybe if i read the books

deep pewter
#

I hadn’t read any of 343is books at the time and still enjoyed it

#

It didn’t really rely that much on outside knowledge

sly stream
#

well then i just didn't enjoy it as it was then

feral stirrup
#

Halo 4s story made no sense besides the parts that where already pre existing in lore

#

Revealing forerunners as enemies wasnt a good approach. Forerunners are supposed to be all dead

sly stream
#

i dont even remember 4's plot, chief awakens the didact, the didact wants to so something evil, chief stops him, cortana goes rampant and dies

feral stirrup
#

It killed the mystery behind them .

jolly furnace
#

Lore prior to 4 revealed not all died

sly stream
#

Revealing forerunners as enemies wasnt a good approach. Forerunners are supposed to be all dead
@feral stirrup this, forerunners should be left unexplained

jolly furnace
#

were else was there to go?

#

Do covenant again?

feral stirrup
#

Yes

deep pewter
#

You can’t consistently leave something as a mystery

#

Especially as making the covenant the main baddie would step on the original trilogies story

feral stirrup
#

Or just have the balls to end it all right there after halo 3

deep pewter
#

And 3 ended with a reveal of a forerunner planet

jolly furnace
#

U think doing COvenant again would have been a good idea? No just no

deep pewter
#

3 ended on a cliffhanger

jolly furnace
#

We needed a new foe

#

Forerunners were the logical choice as they were ripe for exploring

feral stirrup
#

Always better to end something on good terms than continue to dilute plot armor

jolly furnace
#

and we didnt even get flesh and blood ones bu robots

feral stirrup
#

Starwars cough cough

jolly furnace
#

Cos Forerunners at height of power stomp on all modern races

deep pewter
#

Humanities inevitable rapid expansion post-war would lead to the demystifying of the forerunners either way

jolly furnace
#

Yes

feral stirrup
#

A contact harvest game however would be super interesting

deep pewter
#

343i never would’ve gotten the clear to make a non-John related Halo game as their first foray into the series

nimble crest
#

Start off like cod with killing people and stuffs

#

That’s how the book was

carmine sleet
#

Making a game out of Contact Harvest would mean they'd have to change allot about the original story to make it work

nimble crest
#

How so?

feral stirrup
#

You'd play as the legend himself

#

Johnson

feral perch
#

I cannot believe you compared The Fall of Reach's prologue to a Call of Duty title... just... what??

nimble crest
#

I’m talking about Harvest

feral stirrup
#

Yeah no more cod cookie cutters

nimble crest
#

Because of the inserrection

#

That’s how it would feel

carmine sleet
#

Well, they'd have to make it so Johnson encounters way more than just a couple Jackals when he boards his first ever Covenant ship and add in a whole load of new combat sequences that involve conflict that weren't in and likely take away from the original story

#

And that's just a few things

nimble crest
#

Well either the jackals would have to be tougher and inflict more damage or there would have to be some more aliens

feral stirrup
#

You'd definitely have to have scully do the voice work

nimble crest
#

It was just brutes that went down to talk with the humans right?

#

On harvest

feral stirrup
#

I think so

nimble crest
#

That’s so weird to me

terse lava
#

This is going again?

nimble crest
#

Brutes aren’t exactly talkers

terse lava
#

No but they still listen to orders

feral stirrup
#

The genocide pretty much started when the profits learned the humans to being the chosen successor to their gods

nimble crest
#

But I mean I would think that the prophets would send a more thinking species

terse lava
#

They didnt really learn that. They assumed humans were forerunners

nimble crest
#

Like the elites

terse lava
#

And that there's a chance you will be left behind in the journey

feral stirrup
#

Medicant bias told them

nimble crest
#

You think mendicant will be in infinite?

terse lava
#

He told them humans were his makers

feral stirrup
#

They had to keep it underwraps otherwise the covenant would be broken

nimble crest
#

If the covenant hadn’t met the humans and they found the rings, would they basically be harmless?

terse lava
#

No

feral perch
#

yes

#

Only humans can initiate the firing sequence.

feral stirrup
#

They need humans to activate it.

nimble crest
#

They need a reclaimer to activate them so they would’ve just been unable to do anything

feral perch
#

Halo rings do have defenses. If they managed to pilot the ring to another location, those defenses could be used on individual ships and whatnot... but that's very impractical.

terse lava
#

Well remember given enough time it's never been said the covenant couldnt figure it out

feral stirrup
#

This all boiled down to the profits trying to safeguard their power

terse lava
#

Prophets*

feral perch
#

There's no reason to think the imitative Covenant would ever figure it out, especially if 000 Tragic Solitude wasn't able to find a workaround.

#

If a Forerunner ancilla can't find a way, I doubt the Covenant ever would.

nimble crest
#

Who was the monitor of the ark?

jolly furnace
#

good point

feral perch
#

000 Tragic Solitude was the Ark's monitor.

nimble crest
#

Oh

#

Was he in any way different compared to the other monitors

jolly furnace
#

If Forerunners own ancillas cant get around the human-encoded feature of Halo activation, covies likely wouldn't

feral perch
#

No, he went crazy and tried to kill all life with the Halo array.

jolly furnace
#

Would Ur-Didact be able to fire a ring now

#

?/

#

Though i am expectin Cortana to figure out a way to fire a Halo without humans for some reasons

#

or merge a composer or sublimation device with a Halo firing mechanism

#

I feel like 343i will do that

nimble crest
#

Was the ark outside of our galaxy?

feral perch
#

Yes.

nimble crest
#

By how much ?

cedar surge
#

A lot

feral perch
#

Halopedia is your friend.

gilded mason
#

imitative Covenant
People seem to forget the very next part of that quote, where Halsey goes on to say that even if they seem imitative, the Covenant are still incredibly intelligent and are capable of great feats. And later media talks about how "imitative" is a bit of a misnomer.

nimble crest
#

Was the lesser ark outside of it too?

gilded mason
#

Yes

nimble crest
#

What was the difference between the two? Was the lesser one smaller or what

gilded mason
#

Yup

#

The Greater one was for the bigger, original array.

cedar surge
#

Lesser ark was the second ark after the first one got destroyed

nimble crest
#

It was built after the events of halo 3?

gilded mason
#

No

cedar surge
#

No the ark in halo 3 is the lesser ark

gilded mason
#

We went to the Lesser Ark i Halo 3

cedar surge
#

It just got repaird

gilded mason
#

The lesser Ark is what built the seven current Halos

nimble crest
#

How big was the original one?

cedar surge
#

The original ark got destroyed by the flood thousands of years aho

gilded mason
ashen storm
#

whats the biggest halo creature

feral perch
#

craig

ashen storm
#

ah yes

cedar surge
#

Precursors or gravemind

#

Wish we could see the new ships more in action

#

Like a autumn class leading a fleet to retake a colony

#

Or stridents and Posiden classes on patrol

nimble crest
#

Did the covenant attack mars ? Wasn’t there a colony there?

cedar surge
#

Yes the covenant attacked mars

#

The colony wasn't destroyed though

nimble crest
#

Is mars the only planet in the system they terraformed?

cedar surge
#

Just damaged after the covenant destroyed the defences there and moved on to earth

#

No they did it to nearly every planet in the system

#

Not gas giants though

#

Do you think the unsc managed to figure out how to live on gas giants?

nimble crest
#

Probably not but maybe use it’s resources or something idk

#

Maybe a ship building planet or a station

#

I learned only recently that it took 3 months in slip space to get to delta

feral perch
#

No, it didn't.

inner basin
#

Lance, there are only 4 non-gas giant planets in the Sol system. Funnily enough the 4 gas giants are the furthest from the Sun

gilded mason
#

About two weeks, actually.

inner basin
#

But he learnt it so it must undoubtedly be true /s

feral stirrup
#

i wonder if they will have the profits return

inner basin
#

I hope Infinite makes a profit

gilded mason
#

eyy

feral stirrup
#

maybe a couple of them

inner basin
#

As for Prophets, no. I don’t want Infinite to have any Prophets

feral stirrup
#

haha like your avatar

inner basin
#

Thanks. Del Rio’s face here as aged like a fine wine

gilded mason
#

👌

terse lava
#

You know, I wonder how the Covenant on Regret's ship passed the time to delta. Same with the IAC crew

craggy sierra
#

I mean the prophets kinda lost the most out of any race from the war. They no longer have a religious order to rally people under so if they do appear it wouldn’t be as prophets. Just San’Shyum

terse lava
#

Well they already were just san shyuum. 😝

west silo
#

Probably a prelet

terse lava
#

What about the prelates?

west silo
#

They could appear in infinite

terse lava
#

I doubt it seeing as most fell saving san shyuum citizens from high charity

west silo
#

And they are san shyuum

#

I doubt it seeing as most fell saving san shyuum citizens from high charity
@terse lava
Oh really

terse lava
#

Yeah

west silo
#

Fighting the flood?

terse lava
#

And sangheili yes

west silo
#

Man still they could be an interesting boss fight

#

Or fighting a goliath

nimble crest
#

I’m sorry 😭 them boys lied

fair hazel
#

aged much better than halo 3's faces

#

a few preates could still be around, few

inner basin
#

aged much better than halo 3's faces
Is this Del Rio you are referring to Erick?

cedar surge
#

So the Shan shyum are on the run to not answer to their crimes?

gilded mason
#

Ye

gusty whale
#

oh yeah werent the san shyum allies of humanity during ancient times?

fair hazel
#

Yep beast

gusty whale
#

interesting to think that they used to be friends now they want to wipe eachother off the face of the galaxy

gilded mason
#

Well, not anymore, I imagine.

cedar surge
#

When they do finally find the prophets who are they gonna make them answer too

#

There is no galactic council or anything

#

And who knows what ONI will do

#

So will they answer to the swords of sanghellios?

gilded mason
#

If it came to it, probably a joint council of people from the UEG and SoS

inner basin
#

And who knows what ONI will do
Repeatedly chants “Midnight Facility”

cedar surge
#

Like hood and the arbiter?

gilded mason
#

Yeah

gusty whale
#

wait didnt hood die in a comic or am i trippin

gilded mason
#

Nope

gusty whale
#

guess im trippin then

gilded mason
#

At the moment, he's drinking his days away on a secret planet

inner basin
#

With Serin Osman cause she’s also important and they have a S-IV as protection

gusty whale
#

yeah i thought he got impaled in a comic but i guess he survived

inner basin
#

I never recall him getting impaled personally

gilded mason
#

He did, yeah

#

But he Got Better™️

inner basin
#

Hmm. When?

gilded mason
#

When Cutter's son attacked the Infinity for revenge

#

Escalation

inner basin
#

Explains why I don’t remember now

cedar surge
#

He attacked the leader of the unsc for his dad going missing?

#

What

#

How is that hoods fault

#

It was cutters chive to chase after the covenant

#

If it wasn't for cutter humanity would have definitely lost

gilded mason
#

Then-Captain Terrence Hood (Cutter's former executive officer) blamed himself for allowing the ship to go missing, as he ignored orders to avoid contact with the Covenant; the ensuing engagement prevented Spirit of Fire's log buoy from being recovered, thus denying the UNSC any indication of the ship's whereabouts.

cedar surge
#

Oh

fair hazel
#

Hood is not 'the leader of the UNSC'

gilded mason
#

Close enough

cedar surge
#

Wasmt he in control of all of the forces of humanity at one point

#

Because the situation got that dire

humble yacht
#

he was during the H-C war

west silo
#

Yeah pretty much after Coles death

humble yacht
#

and the defacto leader of the UEG, since the UNSC took over during that tumultuous time

cedar surge
#

Psi sepentus best space battle

west silo
#

Battle of the greater ark baby!

cedar surge
#

What happened to battlegroup India after Cole told it to leave him?

west silo
#

Didn't they join up back with the fleet?

cedar surge
#

Which fleet

west silo
#

Cole's wasn't his a distraction?

#

To split the covenant fleet

cedar surge
#

Cole told battlegroup India to retreat while him in his flagship lured the covenant to destroy 300 covenant ships

#

At the end of the battle

west silo
#

The planet becoming a miniature star might have destroyed it or the got back to unsc space and reported his death

cedar surge
#

No battlegroup India retreated back to slipspace before the explosion

#

I think they joined up with the reach fleet

sonic mica
#

Imagine lore of halo

#

Jk jk

west silo
#

Then they proceeded to fight in the war and were probably destroyed

cedar surge
#

You think any many marines survived the full war? Johnson fought in the first and last years of the war

terse lava
#

perhaps, unless you are being fully literal in which only Johnson's squad would count

west silo
#

if we u the 27 billion number a lot of marines died

tame belfry
#

Johnson's squad got wiped like, 4 times

terse lava
#

come to think of it, wasn't the only survivor from his original squad that chick he later slept with?

cedar surge
#

I don't know

#

Heard context harvest had a lot of moments like those

nimble crest
#

Didn’t captain cutter get his stomach ripped up by a grunt and that’s what the shooting was

#

At the meeting

feral perch
#

... no

#

Captain Cutter was in cryosleep adrift in space.

nimble crest
#

Then who was it

feral perch
#

who was what?

nimble crest
#

There was a grunt that got frightened by a marine and started scratching and clawing at him and shot at it and spooked the covenant with the shots and the grunt survived

#

And got killed later by the covies

#

Not a marine but a militiaman

feral stirrup
#

why didn't we find out what happen to that guy that elite captured in halo waypoints : the return?

#

that was actually incredibly well done story telling wise. We need more stuff like that

#

i don't care if 343 doesn't make another game without elites being a playable character

#

i just want to see more side movies about elites

terse lava
#

I want both

next delta
#

how many humans lived before the war

#

wasnt it like 72 billion or something?

#

and 28 billion died

terse lava
#

23 billion or so

west silo
#

Wasn't it 23 billion that died in palace hotel

terse lava
#

23 billion had been killed at that point in the war

west silo
#

And it could be in the 50 billion if we go with halseys journal

terse lava
#

shrug

west silo
#

23 billion had been killed at that point in the war
@terse lava
Its kinda implied it was only military deaths

terse lava
#

If I recall Cortana simply said they (those who died to the scarab on the bridge) would ledt behind like the 23 billion previous humans

west silo
#

"They will be left behind like the 23 billion before them" as I said kinda implied

#

Anyways do a unsc cars u water as fuel

terse lava
#

Doesnt really imply military only, but meh

versed helm
#

How many arbiters were there

feral stirrup
#

the idea behind a one world government seems awful

#

at least the writers acknowledge how messed up the unsc and oni where

terse lava
#

182 Arbiters

versed helm
#

Ok

west silo
#

To be honest civilians life seems great in the ueg unless ur in the other colonies

feral stirrup
#

depends on the extend of how much the unsc effected things

knotty mesa
#

Which halo ledgends shorts are canon, is it all besides odd one out?

feral stirrup
#

if the unsc's only job was to provide global defense and leave the rest of the governing duty to civilians then yeah

#

local civilian govs

#

with autonomy

nimble crest
#

I don’t think the package is believeable

feral stirrup
#

which is probably the way it worked inorder to have a thriving society within the unsc's colonys

nimble crest
#

Halsey looked like she was a teenager

feral stirrup
#

they'd have to let people trade and respect civilians personal privacy

west silo
#

Just the art isnt canon for some like the package and the duel

feral stirrup
#

but what's weird and correct me if i'm wrong is that i don't remember any lore mentioning if humans during the time before the covenant war reached any point of having a zeitgeist economy

#

to where robots and stuff made almost everything they consumed for them

west silo
#

Are u talking about ancient humanity

#

Because no there was no lore about it and the were added in but there still pretty cool

feral stirrup
#

no

#

just the unsc time line with humans

cedar surge
#

@knotty mesa all of halo legends is canon except for odd one out

#

The visuals are not exactly canon though

knotty mesa
#

So the package having energy sheilding

#

?

cedar surge
#

The plot is canon but I don't think the visuals are

#

So if it pertains to the plot of the episode its canon

#

But if its purely visuals its not

knotty mesa
#

My point was in the package the mjolnir armor has sheilding but when the short should take place mjolnir shouldnt have sheilding yet (given its blue team and cheif)

cedar surge
#

Did it say when it took place? Havnt watched that yet

plain sierra
#

who killed decimus

cedar surge
#

The SoF and her marines

stable flower
#

Anyone interested in what that mysterious alien occupation in Shadows Of Reach is? My money is on the Banished.

terse lava
#

Going with either Banished or Nizat having made his own faction and going to the world

cedar surge
#

Eh those ships on the cover font don't have banished colors

knotty mesa
#

It doesnt say when it takes place iirc@cedar surge

cedar surge
#

It takes place after bad blood

#

2 months before infinite

feral perch
#

It’s not the Banished, that much is confirmed

knotty mesa
#

You sure the package takes place that late?@cedar surge

#

I know the gen 3 mark 6 takes inspiration from the design used in the short

feral perch
#

In a blog post, 343i said that Halo Infinite is the first time Chief has encountered the Banished.

knotty mesa
#

Im refering to the halo Ledgends short the package which afaik doesn't have the banished

feral perch
#

So Shadows of Reach has some other faction.

cedar surge
#

I never said when the package takes place,just if it said it did

feral perch
#

I think it’s 2544... don’t quote me on that.

knotty mesa
#

Yeah, im pretty sure its pre halo Reach

#

Since its really the only time that blue team is all together and can rescue ||halsey||

unique rune
#

Operation: WARM BLANKET and thus the events of The Package took place in 2544.

knotty mesa
#

Thats what 8 years before reach

unique rune
#

8 years, yeah. Pretty much everything in Bungie's entries in the franchise happened in 2552.

knotty mesa
#

I always expected reach to be in fall due to the color pallet of winter contingency

#

And halo 1 to be the winter of 2552

vague scroll
#

you got to remember that time is not constant across many planets and locations

#

Reach's autumn is not Earth' autumn

knotty mesa
#

Yeah true

vague scroll
#

and plus, places like the Halos aren't exactly "Earth-like" environments

#

they might be breathable and have similar climates and fauna

knotty mesa
#

Yeah they have certian biomes for certian things like cold for flood study

vague scroll
#

but it's an artificial, it has more in common with an air conditioned room than earth's biosphere

#

aye

#

in the Halo CEA terminals, they show Guilty Spark easily just lobbing entire sections of Alpha Halo into space because he could and he did it for research

knotty mesa
#

The only time we are on earth too is in new monbasa which is an equatorial city

vague scroll
#

if he wanted to as the monitor, he could make the entire ring eternal winter most likely

cedar surge
#

So would you guys say that the needles is the most painful covenant weapon?

#

Plasma should kill you quickly

#

But needles would stab you and explode leaving shards in the flesh

vague scroll
#

I’d say both are pretty nasty ways to die

#

And you won’t feel the needles, you’ll be paste spread across the walls by the time you realize you’ve been hit

#

In the lore, blamite generally explodes on contact with soft tissue

#

Very rarely does it maintain its structural integrity, for example with Chyler Silva in Halo 4 Forward Unto Dawn

terse lava
#

Always found it odd how some kig-yar use the needle as a cutlass. Great idea sure but you lose the blade in your first battle

flat swift
#

what happens if two spartens have children

pale zephyr
#

I doubt they could. Spartan-II augmentations practically left spartans with zero drive. Let alone the ability.

gilded mason
#

Nah, it only had a risk of lowering drive

flat swift
#

what genes would the child have

gilded mason
#

Normal ones, the augments wouldn't change the kid-making genes

pale zephyr
#

Well, technically...

#

There are several cases of Spartan-I soldiers having children after leaving service, said children did gho on to have some of the enhanced traits of their augmented parents.

#

As for S-II's, there's no records as far as I know?

flat swift
#

when was the s1 go into retirement

vague scroll
#

the only Spartan-II with known children was Randall-037 who was stranded on the colony of Sedra for a time. As part of a deal to retire from the Spartans, he agreed to be de-augmented by ONI. He had a kid on Sedra.

#

Except his child died during the bio weapon attack in Halo: Nightfall so we never got a chance to see whether she exhibited traits or not of Spartan augmentations

unique rune
#

The modifications to the -IIs are all physical, phenotypic modifications, not genetic, so there wouldn't be anything to pass down to offspring anyway.

#

It'd be like expecting the kids of people with hip implants to have hip implants from birth

flat swift
#

what about s4

vague scroll
#

some of it was chemical based so it's possible those could have been passed down but you are correct that it's very uplikely

#

Orion ran all the way into 2506 so S-1s weren't ever retired but information on what happened after for them is spotty

#

S-IV children are... plausible though the augmentations are fine-tuned to each person so changes made might necessarily be consistent across the generation

flat swift
#

s3

vague scroll
#

S-IIIs ironically have the most likelihood due to having chemical-based augmentations, mostly steroidal type injections but they too also lost their sexual drive, though by no means are they infertile

#

but they also have the highest attrition rates of the Spartan generations so seeing offsprings of S-IIIs is even more unlikely

#

Orions did have children that seemed to exhibit some kind of genetics passdown for the record

cedar surge
#

I don't get it. Wasn't the 1s and 2s surgical?

#

How do the kids get the genes from surgeries

vague scroll
#

because not all aspects of the augmentations are surgical in nature

rich aspen
#

Okay guys

#

Spartans still have the s x drive

#

It was a possible side affect

#

Fred clearly shows attraction to vets lopes butt during last light

#

Like it’s explicitly stated

vague scroll
#

The catalytic thyroid implant, and muscular enhancement injections were hormonal in nature - thus possible for continued effects later in life, or even an offspring - that doesn't necessarily mean augmented offsprings, that could be something as odd placed like a birth defect or latent health concerns for offsprings because of modifications made on a potential S-II who became a parent

#

@rich aspen it's more than that, Spartans can have children - Randall-037 had a daughter

rich aspen
#

@vague scroll oh yeah

#

dunno why the whole thing about Spartans not having kids really stems from then

vague scroll
#

people misread the wiki, have only ever picked up the Fall of Reach, or haven't bothered to watch Halo: Nightfall

cedar surge
#

So how strong are Spartans? Like are they capable of lifting up a warthog?

vague scroll
#

it's easy to forget that Halo lore is massive and that not everyone is in tune with it. For me, I've contributed to Halopedia and consider myself somewhat knowledgeable on Halo lore - I haven't read six or so of the novels. It's quite an investment to remember this kind of stuff.

Personally, I find the fascination of Spartans' capability for having an offspring something trivial but it seems to be one of those things people love to know more about.

#

Spartan strength is subjective to the author/storyteller but generally flipping a warthog is in their wheelhouse when wearing armor. Flipping a scorpion is a bit outlandish even for Spartans.

rich aspen
#

nah bro

#

press x to flip wait how did you do that?

main mountain
#

classic

lethal comet
#

Isn't it mentioned in Fall of Reach that the spartan IIs augmentations suppressed their sexual hormones

#

And Spartans CAN have kids

#

Randall was an example

gilded mason
#

Only that there was a risk of it happening

lethal comet
#

Haven't seen any spartans with those emotions except black team pre augs

#

or maybe randall

versed helm
#

What does it take for a spartan to become a headhunter

lethal comet
#

Skills and the ability to survive without human contact ig

versed helm
#

Ok

lethal comet
#

Not all headhunters work in pairs

#

Cat 2 would be a desired trait too i guess

versed helm
#

Ik jun lead a headhunter team

lethal comet
#

6 would have been headhunter too i presume due to him being a lone wolf

#

And "making entire armies disappear" sounds pretty headhunter to me

versed helm
#

I mean noble six was a hyper lethal like chief

gilded mason
#

Marketing term, later expanded by 343 to mean every Spartan

versed helm
#

I’m still surprised that we haven’t gotten more lore for noble six

gilded mason
#

Personally, I'd feel it a bit wasteful

lethal comet
#

They already canonised Six's gender

cedar surge
#

Yea but what's even the point

#

Six is the most soulless character in all of halo

lethal comet
#

Because he hasn't been expanded upon yet

cedar surge
#

No he is even more of a shell than chief in the main games

#

Six doesn't have any personality

lethal comet
#

Bungie did that on purpose

cedar surge
#

Chief during the trilogy at least had some oersonality

#

343 has nothing to work on

lethal comet
#

Six is supposed to be a reflection of the player

cedar surge
#

Them how are you supposed to make a character out of that

unique rune
#

Which is why trying to give him deeper character building would only lead to disappointment and outrage

lethal comet
#

Finally make canon stuff on him

cedar surge
#

Making a character that's a reflection of millions of people who all have different views on six

#

You can't make a character out of that

lethal comet
#

Fistful of arrows at least gave personality to rest of noble

unique rune
#

Yeah, and?

cedar surge
#

Yes because they had personalities

unique rune
#

The other members of Noble were written with the intent of being their own characters

cedar surge
#

They actually had souls

unique rune
#

not player self-inserts

lethal comet
#

What about the rookie

cedar surge
#

Rookie died

unique rune
#

I mean.
They killed off the Rookie.
Tells you enough about him.

cedar surge
#

And rookie was a actually character and not a self insert

#

As little as it was

lethal comet
#

At least wasn't as much of a self insert

west silo
#

Doomslayer is pretty much a player insert and he has more character than six

cedar surge
#

No he is not

#

Doom guy actually has a character

lethal comet
#

Slayer is literally a god in the lore

cedar surge
#

He refused to fire on civilians and had a pet bunny

west silo
#

Wow i did not know that

lethal comet
#

He refused to fire on civilians and had a pet bunny
@cedar surge that was the original slayer

west silo
#

He refused to fire on civilians and had a pet bunny
@cedar surge
He was also a little insane

cedar surge
#

Doom actually has lore

lethal comet
#

Og slayer was a marine

#

new slayer is a god

west silo
#

There the same eternal confirmed it

#

He was found by heaven after doom 64

lethal comet
#

The doom reboot and og doom are alternate universes

#

lets get back to halo now

west silo
#

When he stayed in hell

#

Alright

lethal comet
#

btw in the reboot the forces of hell succeeded in conquering earth unlike the og dooms

west silo
#

btw in the reboot the forces of hell succeeded in conquering earth unlike the og dooms
@lethal comet
The reboot takes place thousands of years later

#

Dude read the lore

lethal comet
#

Imagine the bfg in halo

#

Blow a hole in high charity

west silo
#

The incineration cannon

lethal comet
#

How effective would slayer be against flood I wonder

west silo
#

How large is the outbreak?

lethal comet
#

High charity in halo 3

cedar surge
#

Nothing can harm the doomslayer except the energy demons use in doom

lethal comet
#

The spartans sure as hell wouldnt survive the forces of hell

cedar surge
#

Anything mortal will not work on the doom slayer armor

west silo
#

Man am not even sure how chief survived fight inside a graveminds with billions of flood forms

lethal comet
#

The flood doesn't seem mortal to me

cedar surge
#

They are

#

They use mortal weapons

lethal comet
#

What would the definition of mortal be

west silo
#

Anything mortal will not work on the doom slayer armor
@cedar surge
Are u saying if the nova bomb blow up on Doomslayer he would survive?

cedar surge
#

Any thing not used by demons

west silo
#

Dude stop it

cedar surge
#

The energy demons use is the only thing that harms it

lethal comet
#

How many spartans do reckon could take down a marauder

cedar surge
#

Can we go back to halo stuff

#

And probably 5

#

For example

west silo
#

How many spartans do reckon could take down a marauder
@lethal comet
One with the right equipment

cedar surge
#

What were those marines dking on high charity during halo 2

#

Shouldn't have the covenant killed them

lethal comet
#

spartans don't have anywhere near as powerful regeneration as slayer @west silo

west silo
#

They were prisoners along with johnson

cedar surge
#

To be eaten?

west silo
#

spartans don't have anywhere near as powerful regeneration as slayer @west silo
@lethal comet
Have u any feats of slayer regeneration?

orchid prism
#

Well Slayer's blessed with the divinity machine

west silo
#

To be eaten?
@cedar surge
Maybe

lethal comet
#

They needed backups in case johnson and miranda wouldnt activate halo

cedar surge
#

Backups?

#

All you need to do is force their hand on it

lethal comet
#

suicide exists

#

Tho it never came to that

cedar surge
#

Cole protocol has taken a extreme turn

lethal comet
#

You know that the covenant taking you alive is worse than killing you

#

especially when its brutes

west silo
#

Dude this is what I hate about doom they take something thats obviously hiperbol and use it as gospel

#

The slayer was beaten by a building falling on him then they just took his armor

orchid prism
#

He wasnt killed

versed helm
#

Did you think black team was washouts or no

lethal comet
#

not washouts

#

Just segregated from others