#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 330 of 1

fair hazel
#

Why would it not be?

obsidian thistle
#

With any deviations from "Halo: CE" its easier to view the book at the canon version. Gameplay be odd at times from a canon perspective, where if you are uber lucky with rng, 90% of stuff Chief does in the book can be done in CE.

#

Seriously some stuff that happen in the Flood require absolute luck to even happen in-game its really funny tbh

#

Get X enemy rank to spawn, kill X in a very arbitrary way.

versed helm
#

So, does Cortana improve Chief's physical performance?

violet notch
#

She can help his reaction time by using his suit's systems to increase his movements.

reef estuary
#

supposedly his suit is linked to him via a neural interface thus she does it directly,

versed helm
#

RIP Keith.

spiral jewel
#

I feel like there is still much to learn about the Forerunner/Human/Flood wars, even though there's the trilogy of books, the in game terminals, and various ancillary media covering the topic...

terse lava
#

Well we only know a little bit of that time. We don't know how humanity was before the war, how they really gave names, we dont even know what they called their civilization

spiral jewel
#

I hope new information is made in the future

last anchor
#

Who knows.

obsidian thistle
#

IRIS is great!

versed helm
#

I love bees was pretty cool too

#

So i'm listening to the Halo Primordium audiobook and i'm not gonna lie,i felt sad when Gamelpar died

terse lava
#

Misread that as the IRS for taxes😝

versed helm
#

So are the Moa birds we see in Halo Reach related to the now extinct Moa on Earth?

humble yacht
#

no

versed helm
#

Oh

#

I do wonder what a Reach Moa even tastes like

#

Since they have freaking restaurants serving Moa meat

terse lava
#

I imagine something like ostrich. A venison flavor similar to prime rib

fair hazel
#

Didnt Tim Dadabo read Halo Primirdium Audiobook?

obsidian thistle
#

Yep

#

To many thats the definitive way to experience the book

fair hazel
#

honestly him reading that passage of renegades was absolutely delighful

versed helm
#

yeah. he has a nice voice

#

like, it gets the feels flowing

#

i cant phrase the thing im trying to convey any better

#

Is there any canonical reason as to why Chief can suddenly use the energy sword in 2?

carmine sleet
#

No

versed helm
#

I guess he just did from observation.

carmine sleet
#

There is a canonical reason for why swords can't be used in CE, however. Being that the swords seen in CE disable themselves completely when their user dies to prevent someone else from using them

versed helm
#

I thought so, that weapon is a gas field encased by electrons, right?

carmine sleet
#

The blade is superheated plasma shaped by magnetic fields

versed helm
#

its like a thinner version of a lightsaber if im not wrong

#

I see.

#

Thanks.

carmine sleet
#

A better version of the lightsaber

versed helm
#

But I thought it would lose in a duel against a lightsabre?

#

im pretty sure there needs to be some switch or something on the hilt, but the tech was improved by the covies during H2

carmine sleet
#

Who said that it would lose in a dual against a lightsaber?

versed helm
#

I remember a breakdown showing the big weaknesses of the sword.

#

Particularly the gap in the middle.

#

thats the strength

#

you trap other swords in it and twist em outta the opponent's hand

#

I see but the energy is also limited.

#

lightsabers also have limited energy

#

Really?

#

its not like they're powered by the force

carmine sleet
#

Energy being as limited as it is in the games is a gameplay mechanic. While yes, it would still have a limited amount, it wouldn't be anywhere near as bad as it is in gameplay

versed helm
#

the movies dont show it

#

No but by a kyber crystal, no?

#

The crystals are very powerful.

#

that gives the colour and refraction

#

But they have more properties than that from what I remember.

#

It also depends on the lightsabre itself too, there are multiple variants.

#

those are the two main ones: they give the colour, and they focus the beam

#

Some do it more powerfully right?

#

depends on the how pure the crystal is, i guess

#

i dont think that colour and strength are related, though

#

im pretty sure im wrong, since crystal structure and purity decides the colour

carmine sleet
#

The explanation of the colour depends on the continuity I believe

versed helm
#

not my place to comment, since i havent touched SW lore for some time

carmine sleet
#

Give me a few minutes

#

Ok, in the current canon, a kyber crystal gains its colour by bonding with a force user or by being bled to make it red (Or reverse bled for white in one case)

#

In legends, the crystal was just whatever colour you found it, such as blue, green or yellow

#

Red crystals were the most rare and more often than not, weren't real kyber crystals if they were red, instead being a synthetic one

versed helm
#

ahhhh

fair hazel
#

i do want more non-standard energy swords

#

i liked vorpal talon and ravening sliver

carmine sleet
#

That would be nice to see more of

versed helm
#

so, most of the red sabers are fakes

carmine sleet
#

Well, the crystals were, but the sabers were very much real

fair hazel
#

it is annoying how people think energy swords only have ten hits or something

carmine sleet
#

Tell me about it. I still remember the Game Theory where he brought it up despite the fact he was using lore info for other parts of the video

versed helm
#

aye. that was dumb

#

the vanguard version of vorpal talon would look legit

#

How do they change the colour of the sword? Different temperatures of plasma?

#

most probably

gusty star
#

Hard to say. Although blue generally indicates a hotter temperature than red, Bloodblades have been said to burn hotter than the average energy sword.

versed helm
#

Why do Brute plasma rifles deal more damage than the regular ones then?

carmine sleet
#

Because they were modified

gusty star
#

They simply have a faster rate of fire.

versed helm
#

Yeah that makes sense.

#

and i guess they'd be a bit bigger, cause they're the brute version

#

Is there a reason as to why they are issued with different plasma rifles to Elites?

carmine sleet
#

Because Truth wanted to outfit the Brutes with weapons that the Brutes preferred

versed helm
#

I can't see the preference with the other variant though.

carmine sleet
#

The blue Plasma Rifle was the standard Plasma Rifle used by the Covenant, it was less preference that most Covies used them and more just the simple fact that it was the only version of it they could use without being executed for modifying it, with a couple exceptions

versed helm
#

he wanted to keep the brutes and elites separate, to ensure that NO kind of buddy buddy feels developed between them

#

Truth was one paranoid san shyum

#

Did he plan the Schism significantly earlier or something?

gilded mason
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

im pretty sure the schism happened after thel rekt him

#

isnt the schism the breaking up of the covenant?

#

Well the Elites being exiled mainly.

#

or are we talking about the great journey here?

#

ahhh

gilded mason
#

Think Redacted is asking more about Truth using Brutes to stage a coup

versed helm
#

yeah

#

Yeah, is that not relevant for the Schism?

gilded mason
#

It is

versed helm
#

Just checking.

#

he did that after he saw signs of disbelief in the elites, didnt he?

#

I'm a bit moronic.

#

Well I'm pretty sure that he was afraid of the Elites if anything.

#

honestly, who wouldnt be?

gilded mason
#

👋

carmine sleet
#

He was afraid of the Elites turning on him if they learnt that the Covenant was founded based upon a mistranslation of the Forerunner symbol for Reclaimer

versed helm
#

yeah

#

funny how one mistranslastion caused so much malarkey

#

Yeah because they already requested for the humans to join before and some were suspicious.

#

The Elites also showed a lot of hesitation when commanded by the Prophets, no?

#

And Thel was feared the most for how quickly he rose in the ranks.

#

they did. primarily it was because of how the prophets were using the forerunner tech that the sangheili considered holy

#

and the great war that happened between them

#

Right.

#

I don't blame the Prophets for being afraid though.

high pendant
#

Hi

terse lava
#

Greetings

versed helm
#

wort up

slim thorn
#

Why Truth still want to replace Elite with Brutes while he should be aware that if that succeds then he will play right into Atriox's hands. Considering the Covenant can't even touch the Banished, it's quite shameful.

gilded mason
#

that if that succeds then he will play right into Atriox's hands.
?

carmine sleet
#

Atriox wasn't trying to take over the Covenant, Valkyrious

past olive
#

he was trying to destroy it

carmine sleet
#

It honestly seems like Valkyrious thinks all the Brutes were loyal to Atriox, which we know isn't true

versed helm
#

aye. some brutes side with the elites, don't they?

loud gorge
#

I question myself sometimes if the elites in the banished are mercs or joined him for actual loyalty

carmine sleet
#

Some Elites are mercs, others joined him because they saw Atriox's cause as something to follow over others

versed helm
#

Think Atriox would have helped the humans and Elites destroy the Covenant in H3?

radiant sphinx
#

I think they would have tried to massacre everyone

past olive
#

Atriox hates the humans as much as the covenant iirc

versed helm
#

Really?

#

I thought he was willing to accept humans who were worthy.

humble yacht
#

I don’t think Atriox would have helped. He probably would have used the opening to rob earth or covenant worlds

terse lava
#

Also the Covenant could have easily dealt with Atriox had they tried. He was a small time pirate pretty much. Not worth any proper effort

humble yacht
#

I dunno, Ill give him credit for his tactics

#

I don’t think Atriox could have taken on the covenant in open battle but I also don’t think he’d would have let himself get caught if they ever got serious

terse lava
#

Well he's certainly not this uber guy that people have taken away from Isabel

humble yacht
#

He might be

#

He took on 3 Spartans solo

#

I don’t want him to be Uber powerful but some people do

versed helm
#

Did Red Team ever fight against Brutes?

#

Before HW2?

stoic hamlet
#

In gameplay they fought against Brutes on the shield world

#

But IMO that cutscene is iffy, I don’t think that’s how the fight went down.

Atriox was acting really dumb, as were Red Team, and if I’m supposed to think “standing there and bashing three brain-dead Spartans” is a show of some insane skill then that’s a problem.

versed helm
#

Lmao.

last anchor
#

To be fair, he does have a giant energy mace, so that probably helped

versed helm
#

It's not a mace, right?

carmine sleet
#

It is a mace, he made it out of a Gravity Hammer and an Energy Sword if I recall

versed helm
#

Yeah you're right, I just checked.

#

The spikes are activated like the sword.

simple locust
#

What happens if the flood infect a cyborg?

gilded mason
#

The cyborg will be infected

simple locust
#

Without the logic plaque.

versed helm
#

I wonder if it is worthy of the planet being nuked.

#

Like with a Spartan.

carmine sleet
#

The cyborg still has organic parts, no need for logic plague

#

Would likely depend on how dangerous the cyborg is, Redacted

versed helm
#

Would it not need to use the logic plague on the cybernetic components?

simple locust
#

So what if mechanisms exist for the cyborg parts to detach,separate, or stop communicating from the biological components?

carmine sleet
#

What kind of cyborg are we thinking of? Like someone with a robot arm? Or something more along the lines of the Cybermen from Dr Who when they first returned where they were basically brains in metal bodies?

versed helm
#

He's probably thinking of someone like Kano from MK.

carmine sleet
#

Kano's only cybernetic is his eye I believe

humble yacht
#

Kano controls his cyber parts with his organic brain

#

They don’t run by themselves

carmine sleet
#

Which means that if he was infected by the Flood, he'd likely just become a standard combat form

humble yacht
#

A standard combat form with a Robo eye

carmine sleet
#

Basically

versed helm
#

Now what about sentient guns in Destiny? Like DARCI or Whisper of The Worm?

humble yacht
#

Depends

versed helm
#

DARCI is controlled by an AI while the Whisper is sentient through spirit.

humble yacht
#

Destiny has magic so that’s different rules

versed helm
#

I doubt that an AI driven gun is powered by space magic.

#

Maybe the Whisper.

#

But not DARCI.

carmine sleet
#

I don't think a logic plagued AI inside a rifle would be all that useful to the Flood

#

And as Chimera has said, Destiny's got magic and stuff

versed helm
#

Well considering how Guardians have a lot of weapons, using them against themselves would be pretty useful.

#

Making less weapons viable too.

simple locust
#

Or if the technology only works with unaltered genetics. Either or would work. A Cybus Industry Cyberman can remove it's brain and still function?

versed helm
#

I don't think that's true, don't they have a failsafe for that?

#

Also, Cybermen have a program that disables emotion to prevent the mind from being overwhelmed with pain.

#

When disabled the host pretty much dies.

carmine sleet
#

With the Cybermen it really depends on which ones you're dealing with. Like some are like the Cybus Industry ones where the brain is the only organic thing left, while others are people with the Cyberman parts added onto them

simple locust
#

In the Pandorica opens it removes it's human head. It's works on it's own or at least partially.

versed helm
#

Considering how the Flood is supposed to be the apex predator of life itself, it would probably win regardless.

carmine sleet
#

Look, honestly, the Cybermen are way to complicated for this former Whovian who kinda just drifted away from the show five years ago to really explain properly

versed helm
#

I used to love that show.

#

Anyway, can you imagine the amount of power the Flood could possess from corrupting the Doctor?

carmine sleet
#

Infinite

versed helm
#

Corrupting the Tardis could prove to be more useful, imagine Flood time travelling to re-arrange the past.

feral perch
#

nah

#

They’d just screw everything up

versed helm
#

That's what they're designed to do.

simple locust
#

Not sure how the Mondas Cybermen would fare though. Also if they could time travel would they go back and infect the precursors to cause a paradox?

versed helm
#

Highly likely.

simple locust
#

What would happen after that?

versed helm
#

End credits to the franchise.

simple locust
#

In lore.

versed helm
#

Either end the universe through a time paradox or end the universe through corruption.

simple locust
#

Did the Precursors create the universe?

versed helm
#

Unsure.

#

I've never cared for that aspect of Halo.

simple locust
#

I guess if time travel if ever used that could make the flood more threatening by stopping the universe from existing in the first place, which would stop the Forerunners from destroying the micro universes they get their energy from. Actually thinking about that makes sense from a precursors view, if there is more life in them than the universe in regard to the Mantle.

#

Also what if the flood fight the Krynoids or some other infectious creatures?

versed helm
#

Time travel has already been used

#

In the halo universe

#

Halo: First Strike

near tide
#

well that was time distortion

last anchor
#

And even then we arent sure if its really there or not since the dates are assumed

terse lava
#

I would say on the subject that the Precursors did not create the universe. We only.know they seeded life in various galaxies. As for time travel, would say truthfully the closest we have is Alpha halo picking g up and reporting an echo of the entire array firing before Bornsteller had activated them. Though this was more due to the blast traveling at infinite velocity and timely whimsy etc

last anchor
#

Also neural physics are weird.

#

Especially when operating on THAT scale

terse lava
#

Yea, would hate it if they try to make it to where the precursors did shape the universe somehow. Have that remain nebulous

last anchor
#

I doubt they will. Honestly I dont think we'll hear more of the precursors until this whole Created thing is over

terse lava
#

Because the Created are soooooo interesting đŸ€”

humble yacht
#

I like them more than the precursors

terse lava
#

I guess I am on the fence there

#

On one hand the Created appear to be a cliche AI rebellion. On the other, infinite advanced aliens

humble yacht
#

The created at least have clear origins and motivations

sturdy ice
#

d

limpid meadow
#

Is AI taking over for the betterment of mankind really that cliche? Isn't the cliche usually AI trying to destroy Humanity or organic life or whatever?

carmine sleet
#

Aye, it is normally to wipe out life but given how often AI are seen rebelling, it's a cliche

humble yacht
#

The idea of robots being antagonistic towards humans in some fashion is pretty common. But some of the more popular examples do take it to the level of lethality (matrix)

limpid meadow
#

This isn't really antagonism though.

#

Or it's a different kind of antagonism

humble yacht
#

The created’s ultimate goal isn’t antagonism, but they’re not afraid to use force to get what they want

limpid meadow
#

I don't know, the Created thing just never felt that cliché to me.

humble yacht
#

Tho cortana does have some prejudice against humans, specifically

limpid meadow
#

I have my issues with it mainly because of execution and how sudden it was, but not with the core idea of it.

spiral jewel
#

I feel like it was being built up to since at least Halo 3, but I don't have any evidence to support my claim. Outside those pauses in the game with Gravemind and Cortana's dialogue.

carmine sleet
#

I wouldn't have said the Cortana moments were teasing her leading an AI uprising

terse lava
#

Yea usually the niche is hostility but what Cortana did may as well be the same thing

humble yacht
#

I feel like cortana left the particulars of the combat to warden. I don’t think cortana reveled in the deaths caused by the raising of e guardians; rather, I think she was apathetic towards it

terse lava
#

Which is a concern, not even a tiny hint of regret or anything. If she has control over every chunk of forerunner tech she could have easily sent other forerunner devices to assist in a cleaner excavation of the guardians or evac the dig sites

last anchor
#

My issues with the Created are the same ones I have with new Star Wars's First Order.
Namely that they seemingly came out of nowhere and have incredible power but we dont see exactly how.

However, when it comes to the Created, I can EASILY believe they are as powerful as they are because they have access to Forerunner tech and we KNOW that stuff is absolutely BONKERS.

Wheras the First Order...(sucks teeth)

terse lava
#

Good point Orca, hated that on the FO seeing as they are supposed to be this tiny remnant yet uber powered

carmine sleet
#

I honestly wish they were less afraid of exploring the origins of the First Order

last anchor
#

Technically they aren't, we got some stuff in the comics.
But it really just boiled down too "Palpatine puppeted them through Snoke with the intention of using them to draw Rey to him so he could steal her body."

#

Which has its OWN issues but I wont touch on that here because thats Star Wars.

terse lava
#

But we dont really find that out till the 3rd act

last anchor
#

Wheras with the Created we know their origins, we know what they want more or less (Mantle of Responsability with a little side of "not dying to rampancy") and it makes sense.

terse lava
#

The OT hinted at palpatine'd existence before the reveal

#

I would agree that there are better ways the created could have been executed

last anchor
#

Im just more curious as to what a Created controlled planet looks like.

terse lava
#

I would assume some type of paradise world where the same time it's like 1984

last anchor
#

Bad Blood helped but I wanna see "Created controlled Earth" that got mentioned in the helmets.

#

Thats probably accurate honestly

terse lava
#

It's the only logical idea. If it was truly a paradise world with no problems there being no reason to fight the created

last anchor
#

Auto correct again?

terse lava
#

Fiddledticks, yep

#

I assume a Created planet would be similar to the Justice Lords episodes of Justice League. A planet on the surface peaceful and happy, but under the thumb of the Justice League-turned rulers

#

They had a guy arrested for complaining about his dinner check

#

The unggoy likely wouldn't mind as they really know no better life in over 100,000 years.

humble yacht
#

He wasn’t arrested for complaining. He was arrested for making a scene, or “disturbing the peace”

#

But yeah, justice lords is an apt comparison. Weighting safety and peace against freedom

last anchor
#

Well that doesnt really sound so bad.

#

Maybe if they rule over the greater Seattle area they'll give us proper freaking wifi

#

Another bonus of a Guardian; 6G, no matter where you are XD

#

Its a 1600 meter floating router

humble yacht
#

Yeah but the domain is like Wikipedia that’s allowed to change its own entries

last anchor
#

So Wikipedia but even easier to mess with.

#

Or...self aware wikipedia?

spiral jewel
#

Is there any humans from the UNSC that are on some of "Do not kill" list the Created might have (meaning that the rogue AI's have some trust in x person or group of people). From what I know, Cortana still has trust in Blue Team.

humble yacht
#

John

spiral jewel
#

But I'm not sure if that's the case as of post Halo 5

humble yacht
#

Though whether warden listens to that is up in the air

spiral jewel
#

Good point

humble yacht
#

Warden was hacked by cortana and listens to her, that much is true

#

But I don’t think she has 100% control over his actions. I think it’s more like she tells him to do something and he takes liberties with how he does it

last anchor
#

Something that old and that complex? No way she controls him directly.

humble yacht
#

C: raise the guardian on Meridian?
W: ok, I’ll kill all the humans there

#

C: bring John to me
W: ok, I’ll throw a few tests his way to make sure he’s worthy

#

(And by tests, I mean try to kill him a little)

last anchor
#

Thats...basically what the Breaking is, is it not?

#

W: Time to make him earn his waifu. (THROWS ALL THE PROMETHEANS AT BLUE TEAM)

humble yacht
#

Cortana does interfere when the odds are really stacked against blue team

last anchor
#

Yeah, she yanks like...five of the Wardens?
Man that boss fights bad enough as it is, I dont wanna think about fighting that many. Eugh.

#

And then finally when they get to her she just dismisses him

humble yacht
#

She turns 5 wardens into 3

last anchor
#

Is it 3? I cant remember, been way too long

humble yacht
#

Well the highest number of wardens you ever fight at once is 3

last anchor
#

End of the Breaking, right.

humble yacht
#

I think James Spader would have made a better warden

#

Read warden’s lines in Ultron’s voice and tell me it doesn’t fit

last anchor
#

Him or possibly one of the dudes from the Transformers movies. Maybe Megatrons VA?

#

Warden doesnt really have the bite I expected him to have

humble yacht
#

Frank Welker? Maybe

#

I can’t imagine megatron’s voice ever saying they’re in service to someone else

spiral jewel
humble yacht
#

For a beast, that megatron had a suave voice

fair hazel
#

I like wardens voice

humble yacht
#

Why do forerunners all have British accents?

#

Even warden

#

Yet lord hood, an English nobleman, sounds distinctly not British

last anchor
#

I like to think that the Warden isn't actually speaking, hes just emmiting some kind of open source noise that a sentient brain picks up as something they understand

#

for whatever reason, that gets coded to Spartans as British

fair hazel
#

Canadian? Hood

#

I don’t register didact as so called “British”

last anchor
#

Possibly.
Or its that hes blood-related to the royal British family but he's spent so much time in space he lost his accent.

fair hazel
#

Or librarian

full forge
#

I like the warden's VA.

jolly furnace
#

How we all doing?

#

Any topics being discussed lately?

carmine sleet
#

I know we were talking about Flood infected cyborgs last night

jolly furnace
#

Oh. They could do that

#

Infect cyborgs

carmine sleet
#

Aye, it was an interesting discussion

simple locust
#

So could the Precursors have come from another universe?

carmine sleet
#

Unknown. Don't think we need to know

fair hazel
#

i dont discount that possibility

simple locust
#

If so I would like to see it but have it be really weird. Show how they attained the Mantle.

#

Also what happens if the flood fights another kind of infection? Like a plant infection.

gilded mason
#

Show how they attained the Mantle.
Attained? It's just a philosophy.

simple locust
#

Yes, show how they came to believe their beliefs.

carmine sleet
#

An extremely flawed philosophy

humble yacht
#

those with power will inevitably assume control over those without

#

the precursors' philosophy was related to their power. their transient nature, their ability to seed life

simple locust
#

Is it essentially internationalism but for galaxies or is it more of a non-interventionist stance.

humble yacht
#

they were kids with ant farms, and that's how they ran the galaxy

#

they set it up and let it prosper or die on its own, and then moved on to the next experiment

#

i guess when they made the forerunners and ancient humans, they figured they finally got it right, right enough to intend for humans to take their place

simple locust
#

So why did they not just promise it to humans in the first place or just make humans first then give them the Mantle?

#

So if their creations asked them to leave peacefully what would they do?

gilded mason
#

Break everything like a whiny child

simple locust
#

Also why did they create the other races that were not intended to inherit the mantle of responsibility?

humble yacht
#

they probably made a bunch of races and let them grow and then picked their favorite

simple locust
#

So what does the Mantle grant one species over the others?

humble yacht
#

nothing

#

the mantle isn't an actual thing

#

it's the metaphorical throne of the galaxy

simple locust
#

So are they more valued or view themselves as superior to those others?

humble yacht
#

well, what do you think?

#

look at the races who have held the mantle before

#

Forerunners: prideful, arrogant, superiority complex

#

Created: also superiority complex

simple locust
#

So why even create the philosophy?

humble yacht
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

the universe needs order

simple locust
#

So is it intended to be handle like some such as Human Rights Watch or something else?

#

Or the UN?

humble yacht
#

i don't understand what you are trying to say

simple locust
#

Is it intended to allow sovereignty or take it away?

gilded mason
#

The latter

humble yacht
#

it's up to the holder of the mantle how they enforce their rule

simple locust
#

So can they take away peoples' stuff?

#

Like their resources and other things?

humble yacht
#

if they have the military strength to claim the mantle, then they probably could take whatever they want from people

simple locust
#

So could the Covenant take over the Mantle?

gilded mason
#

Yes. They actually knew of it

#

And thought they were enacting it, kinda

humble yacht
#

the covenant had the strength to claim the mantle but they were more concerned with transcending rather than ruling over the galaxy as they were

simple locust
#

What did the Covenant think of ancient human ruins?

humble yacht
#

i doubt they recognized them

gilded mason
#

If they ever found any (would there even be many left?), I imagine it'd just be "Oh, ancient ruins. Wonder what species built them."

simple locust
#

Halo Legends on the Babysitter.

#

They had human statues.

#

Also were the San'Shyuum intended to help humanity? Were they once considered for the Mantle?

eternal oriole
#

where was Warden Eternal before Halo 5, or was he created by cortana in halo 5

gilded mason
#

He was in the Domain beforehand

eternal oriole
#

Oh

#

By why introduce him then

#

Why not earlier

gilded mason
#

Because 343 didn't think of him before that

eternal oriole
#

I feel like its wierd they just made this new character to poof into existence

#

Well, thanks

simple locust
#

Did he ever fight before Halo 5?

#

Warden Eternal that is.

gilded mason
#

Unknown

humble yacht
#

every character is new

#

at some point

simple locust
#

Were Promethean Warrior Servants better at fighting than the regular Warrior Servants? The Promethean ones float and the regular ones do not or are not seen floating.

humble yacht
#

prometheans were the top of the warrior servants

#

the didact's personal force

simple locust
#

So was it just a height advantage, since they have the higher ground or the high ground to allow for more accurate shooting?

humble yacht
#

i don't know what you mean

simple locust
#

When someone shoots are a higher height it is easier to see their targets which makes shooting easier than if they were lower.

#

Also can the Didact be infected by the flood?

humble yacht
#

yes

#

well, not anymore

simple locust
#

So before he was composed he could be infected by an infection form or spores?

humble yacht
#

yep

simple locust
#

Also how large are the universes the Forerunners use for their energy?

gilded mason
#

They literally just began

near tide
#

Can spartan 2's be infected by the flood?

gilded mason
#

Yes

near tide
#

Really?

gilded mason
#

Really.

simple locust
#

Does Halo have a multiverse, for things like Odd One Out?

gilded mason
#

No

simple locust
#

One thing I found interesting is how the creature in it was genetically modified. Also do we know how the AI in that became a mother?

humble yacht
#

odd one out isn't meant to be analyzed that deeply

gilded mason
#

Yeah

simple locust
#

Well yeah I know it's not cannon but still, how does an AI have children?

humble yacht
#

it doesn't

near tide
#

Cant

simple locust
#

I mean in Odd One Out, not main canon.

humble yacht
#

odd one out is a joke, so make something up yourself

gilded mason
simple locust
#

Also is the species for Pluto canon?

gilded mason
#

Jiralhanae...?

simple locust
#

Is it a brute?

gilded mason
#

Yes...

simple locust
#

It looks pretty different but still somewhat similar.

#

1337 needs a crossover with YapYap.

gilded mason
#

No thanks

simple locust
#

Are there any other non-canon Halo stories besides that one?

gilded mason
#

I don't think so, off the top of my head.

humble yacht
#

potentially some trailers/marketing material, maybe parts of iluvbees or iris

obsidian thistle
#

Hellspartans are non-canon

simple locust
#

Also what is it like living in the Domain?

obsidian thistle
#

Thats two big questions you are asking back to back. XD

#

But we dont really know a full real answer to that one

simple locust
#

Is it just like Hell in the domain or do they have more freedoms?

humble yacht
#

the domain is just a network

#

it's like the internet

simple locust
#

I mean the Composer.

humble yacht
#

that's very different

quiet umbra
#

domain is closest conceptually to The Force from star wars tbh

humble yacht
#

yes, the people composed live in a bad place called the Abyss

quiet umbra
#

it's not actually digital, it's woven into existence itself

humble yacht
#

it doesn't look fun

simple locust
#

Can they fight each other in there?

quiet umbra
#

we have virtually no lore on what the inside of the domain is like, sorry

simple locust
#

Ever seen that show Upload?

quiet umbra
#

until futher notice just equate it with the afterlife or "the spirit plane"

simple locust
#

It's a show on Hulu I I think. People upload their minds to a computer.

humble yacht
#

people in the Composer's Abyss don't have room to fight

#

they're kind of jam packed and just screaming

quiet umbra
#

Doom Eternal did something pretty cool where heaven's immortality is premedicated by creating worlds only to sacrifice them to Hell for argent energy

#

in laymans terms heaven and hell are codependant

obsidian thistle
#

@sly field please push the toy lore discussion here. :D Thankies

simple locust
#

So what do we know of the Meddlers?

gilded mason
#

Which ones.

simple locust
#

All of them.

humble yacht
#

oh boy

gilded mason
#

...

humble yacht
#

maybe halopedia would be helpful to you

obsidian thistle
#

Its "meddlers" not Meddlers.

gilded mason
#

I think that term really just confuses people

obsidian thistle
#

Difference being one is being used as a descriptor. The other implies a name which it is not.

simple locust
#

OK. So did the Precursors become the flood on purpose or by mistake?

gilded mason
#

Yes

obsidian thistle
#

That is a list of all mystery aliens in Halo. Not properly wikified yet. Its still in the early stages of being made into a page.

gilded mason
#

Oh, there's another potential mystery alien in Broken Circle, CIA.

obsidian thistle
#

Yes thats in the list? Unless its one I aint considering?

gilded mason
#

Doesn't seem to be in your list

#

One moment

#

The method was said to have come from a prisoner from a far planet who had stumbled on their colony long ago. The meditation had been handed down for numerous generations and taught to Bal’Tol by his uncle, N’Zursa ‘Xellus, the previous kaidon.

obsidian thistle
#

Oh that. Totally forgot to add that. :D

#

What chapter?

gilded mason
#

I'll check real quick

#

Chapter 15

obsidian thistle
#

Woot

#

Thankies

gilded mason
#

👍

simple locust
#

What creatures cannot be infected by the flood, besides Engineers and Prometheans?

humble yacht
#

everything organic is suscpetible

simple locust
#

What about drones?

gilded mason
#

Yes

humble yacht
#

are they organic?

feral perch
#

Yes, Yanme’e are organic

humble yacht
#

i was asking a rhetorical question to arrow

feral perch
#

it wasn’t obvious

simple locust
#

I heard they lacked calcium which causes them incapable of being infected. I think HiddenExperia noted that.

humble yacht
#

that's unlikely, given calcium is a common component of exoskeletons

#

also, even plants can be turned into flood biomass

feral perch
#

I would suggest Halopedia

#

as your go-to lore source

simple locust
#

So could Silicon based life be infected?

humble yacht
#

Good question

feral perch
#

Is there silicon-based life in Halo?

humble yacht
#

Not that we know of

simple locust
#

It is usually something noted as being a potential material for life.

humble yacht
#

Throw it in the maybe pile

simple locust
#

What kind of robots can the logic plaque not infect?

humble yacht
#

AI lacking the capacity for choice are Likely immune

simple locust
#

Are there any suit that maintain high internal temperatures to destroy any potential infection while keeping the host alive?

humble yacht
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

simple locust
#

Have you ever seen the YouTube called Altehros who does Halo AI battles between AIs from different Halo games from each other? He can have Halo CE, Halo 2, Halo 3 and so on grunts all fight each other at once.

#

He made YayYap who has fire on his body and when the flood try to infect him the fire kills the infection forms.

humble yacht
#

Modding games isn’t canon

simple locust
#

Yes but I was wondering if there was anything that could function in a similar way, like maybe the gel in Halo Wars 2.

humble yacht
#

Probably not

simple locust
#

Also can the Yonhet breath underwater as adults?

obsidian thistle
#

We dont know enough about them to know that

versed helm
#

So the race that lived on the Planet of Blue and Red was described as being bipedal and that they apparently had knowledge on the Forerunners,what else do we know about this species?

gilded mason
#

That's it.

versed helm
#

I want to know more about this race

#

How did they die out?

#

There's also the race that lived on Netherop

obsidian thistle
#

Ah the Spider mechs. XD

near tide
#

No one knows

terse lava
#

The race from Red and Blue were likely one of those who perished in the Dark Times following re-seeding

#

We see they apparently never got beyond tier 7 based on the fact they used stone carvings and showing the fact they had knowledge of the forerunners one could conclude it would be shortly after reintroduction

versed helm
#

What about the race from Netherop?

#

From what i read on this planet..it did say that it was once inhabited by an intelligent race that died out before they achieved spaceflight due to the excessive heat caused by greenhouse gasses...i'm wondering..were these greenhouses gasses naturally occurring or was it caused by this unknown species over industrializing their world to the point were it triggered a runaway greenhouse effect?

terse lava
#

What was shown for their tech level?

last anchor
#

They had a city

terse lava
#

Wasnt it just stone?

last anchor
#

Mostly I think, but they also had coal powered spider walkers with radiation guns

#

I doubt there’s much else on Netherop but stone

#

It’s kind of a hell hole

terse lava
#

True

near tide
#

Yeah

bright iris
#

I wish the Cut covenant and Flood creatures were never cut

#

some from Halo CE

carmine sleet
#

That's the nature of game development, some stuff just has to be cut

jolly furnace
#

@humble yacht U can't imagine Frank Welker's Megatron saying he is in service to someone? He tried to do exactly that in Transformers Prime early on with Unicron. Unicron couldn't have cared less. Granted Megs did have ulterior motives.

violet notch
#

Sometimes content is cut for good reasons.

jolly furnace
#

Some Flood can and have come back into canon.

#

Like Juggernaught

#

Also Sharqoui came back

carmine sleet
#

The Sharquoi were part of the canon thanks to some Halo 2 limited edition material, we just didn't know too much about them until Envoy

jolly furnace
#

YEAH

versed helm
#

And there's also the race that attacked Crecka in the System of Miasmic Giants

#

I still wonder what race that was

terse lava
#

Just some alien race, I am more curious as when said race was able to develop space ships seeing as warfleet said the san shyuum and sangheili were the first races to obtain it in the Orion. Arm

unique rune
#

I am confused. It depends what game is this. For the CAS and CSO,
Where is the glassing beam? For some games it's at the front, for others it's at the back.
For the Halo 3, Reach and Wars, it's at the back, but for Halo 2 it's at the front and back
Presumably both. CASes and CSOs are large enough that they can support multiple energy projectors.
Not to mention variations between patterns may also cause differences in location.

near tide
#

Glassing beams aren't energy projectors @unique rune

unique rune
#

An energy projector, also known as a cleansing beam,[5][6] plasma lance,[1] or ventral beam due to its most common placement on warships,[7] is a Covenant weapon used exclusively by large capital ships. It fires a thin beam of the energized matter known as plasma,[1] capable of destroying ships effortlessly at long range[4] and "glassing" planets, systematically rendering them sterile and incapable of sustaining life.

#

Sure they aren't.

versed helm
#

@terse lava Consider the ship that crash landed on Alpha Halo as seen in the CEA terminals,that ship crash landed on Alpha Halo in 40,000 BC,57,445 years after the Great Purification and subsequent reseeding of all the lifeforms that the Librarian and Lifeworkers managed to save.So what race could've went from being reseeded on their home world to being space-faring within that 57,445 year time frame?

terse lava
#

It was never said that race was from the Orion arm, could easily be from another who had a bounty of forerunner tech and wasnt reduced as badly as others

versed helm
#

That's what i was thinking tbh,it's possible that this unknown race was from a planet that either had a yoink ton of Forerunner tech or might've found a nearby planet that had Forerunner tech

#

Like we have no idea who or what inhabits the rest of the galaxy or what the rest of the Milky Way is like

terse lava
#

I would think it's also likely their homeworld likely had ample technology and they managed to re actuvatenit on re seeding. The idea of every single sentient civilization being crossed right back to tier7 has always sounded dumb to me.

#

Besides is it really that shocking that a civilization jumps up in tech like that? Look at how far we have come in 200 years

versed helm
#

Yep

#

I also wonder how many races died out during the Dark Times

terse lava
#

Likely many seeing as only a few survived into modern times and betting plenty became Covenant fringe

versed helm
#

That sucks

terse lava
#

And others were simply wiped out by the Covenant

#

Must have done something pretty serious too to get that result

last anchor
#

Maybe they didnt join the Covenant. They were originally planning on executing the Lekgolo till the Taming happened after all.

versed helm
#

Weren't there augmented Elites in the Covenant?

carmine sleet
#

Elites? Not as far as we know. Prophets, however, yes

spiral jewel
#

Stupid question

where/are there any S-2's aside from Blue Team operating on the Infinity?

carmine sleet
#

Not as far as I know, but it is possible

terse lava
#

Unless it was for some holy mission I dont see sangheili allowing themselves to be augmented

versed helm
#

It would've been awesome to fight a Prelate

#

And iirc,didn't it say that the reason as to why the Covenant never used their full military might against humanity was because they were waging war against The Banished and possibly other interstellar empires

gusty star
#

I doubt the Banished posed much of a threat during the time of the Covenant.

versed helm
#

True

#

So it's possible that the Covenant was waging war against other interstellar empires,but i'm still not sure

terse lava
#

I would think it's possible the Covenant were dealing with other civilizations.

#

Would make more sense anyway

versed helm
#

Agreed

#

There was that Halo 4 map named Wreckage

gusty star
#

As an empire, the Covenant needed to dedicate large portions of their military to ensuring submission among their colonies and territories. This could very well be why they couldn't use their full military might against humanity.

#

You must also take into account the bureaucracies that ran the Covenant. They constantly squabbled with each other to gain power and influence. Many of these ministries had their own dedicated fleets that were appointed to whatever mission that ministry took upon itself.

#

They could focus on Forerunner artifact retrieval for example.

clever fable
#

Since Balaho is hecka cold, do grunts not bathe

versed helm
#

It's probably different since Cortana took over

carmine sleet
#

Just because some place is cold, doesn't mean that the people who live there don't wash

clever fable
#

Imagine needing a galactic takeover to get showers to Balaho

versed helm
#

How fast do Grunts reproduce?

#

Don't they reproduce like rabbits?

gusty star
#

Not quite as fast as Lekgolo or Yanme'e, but they seem to be combat capable very quickly, which is why they are the primary canon fodder of the Covenant and its remnants.

simple locust
#

" coal powered spider walkers with radiation guns" were they ever used in the story?

clever fable
#

wut

versed helm
#

And i wonder how many worlds they might take over since Cortana gave them a yoink ton of weapons and technology

clever fable
#

I'd imagine she wants them to be peaceful about it though, yeah?

#

Though she isn't particularly peaceful herself.

versed helm
#

Considering she killed probably millions when she awakened the Guardians

#

I still wonder,when the time does come,will John kill Cortana or find a way to cure her?

gusty star
#

I hope to God he kills her.

versed helm
#

Same

clever fable
#

bet some weird stuff goes down in the domain, or something. We get a AI/Cortana fragment of some kind, Cortana throws down with it, she comes out having fused with it and "cured".

#

I don't like that, but it's what I'm betting on happening.

#

It's weird, most people won't expect it, and there's enough gray area in the Domain's operations for them to just do whatever they want I guess.

carmine sleet
#

Allot of people are worried about and don't want a Cortana redemption

clever fable
#

Same, I just don't think they'll have the guts to finally do her in.

versed helm
#

Speaking of the Domain,wasn't it described as having some form of sentience?

terse lava
#

Yes

queen otter
#

Allot of people are worried about and don't want a Cortana redemption
@carmine sleet a lot of people want a lot of different things

terse lava
#

Question is would a Cortana redemption be good or bad for the story

humble yacht
#

Bad for me

#

I think it could be bad for the story, as it would feel like moving backwards rather than forwards

gusty star
#

I don't recall any energy projectors at the stern. I remember them having a ventral energy projector at the bow and amidships as well as a dorsal energy projector amidships.

runic inlet
#

Who or what pulled the SoF into a portal to the Ark in HW2?

gusty star
#

@balmy gulch That's not the back (stern). That's the middle (amidships). Unless by back you are referring to the underside (ventral)?

#

As for the ODST beam at the front (bow), it just so happens that carriers have energy projectors at both areas of the ship.

#

Yes but once again that's not the back, that's the middle of the ship.

#

Oh by the back are you referring to the fact that the ship can separate into two parts?

#

I see

#

Then in that context, yes, that would be the back

#

I wouldn't refer to that as the back of the ship though

#

It is more accurately the aft section

#

The back is the very back of the aft section

#

Indeed

#

You are most welcome

unique rune
#

Who or what pulled the SoF into a portal to the Ark in HW2?
@runic inlet We, uh. We dunno. Nothing official has stated or even hinted at it, to my knowledge.
There's some theories floating around involving Mendicant Bias, if I remember correctly, but it's all just speculation.

fair hazel
#

i think its Orion forge..

last anchor
#

There is a time gap between when we last see her and when HW2 takes place

#

She does have the tech access

versed helm
#

where does Halo Wars and Halo Wars 2 take place?

#

are they before Halo CE?

last anchor
#

HW is. HW2 is about a decade later

#

2530, 2552, 2559

gusty star
#

Halo Wars takes place in 2531.

terse lava
#

Yea

muted blaze
#

How old are grunts that are on the battlefield?

versed helm
#

They reach adulthood between 5 and 8, so most likely they're sent to battle at 4- 5 human years

muted blaze
#

Thanks

versed helm
#

I understand that extremely honorable/high ranking Elites are allowed to mate at will/with any female partner

So has the Thel (Arbiter) been a milkman or a honorable virgin samurai?
I'm pretty sure its a no or the games and lore just doesn't want us to know what he's done but I'm just curious if he has children

gilded mason
#

He does have children

versed helm
#

How many?

gilded mason
#

No idea

versed helm
#

Oh lol

terse lava
#

We know he planned on sireing more after his mission in 2536

versed helm
#

Well that's one way to ask that question.

near tide
#

Does anyone actually think Noble Six is alive?

carmine sleet
#

Some people genuinely do

#

I don't, since it wouldn't make much sense for him to still be alive

near tide
#

Yep

#

Plus the planet was glassed

#

And he was swarmed by elites

carmine sleet
#

Indeed. Not to mention that it wouldn't make sense from a narrative standpoint

near tide
#

It wouls kind of defeat the purpose of the level lone wolf

last anchor
#

Some thought he was alive to sooth the pain of th eend of Reach. then it turned into a meme by 12 year olds because thats what they do.
Then the lore community turned them inside out, Composed them, reconstitued them, and then turned their hardlight reconstiuted forms inside out, and they stopped

#

And then just for good measure the lore community put their essensces into monitors and had them guard the most boring jobs in the Encumine

near tide
#

Always the people in the comment section of a halo video somewhat related to reach, "6 is hiding out in a cave somewhere"

carmine sleet
#

Is it bad I kinda hope they release an official image of Six's skeleton in a cave just to make it even more clearer that he's dead?

gilded mason
#

"Ha, he made it to a cave! Take that, non-believers!"

jolly furnace
#

To add to the discussion about the aliens who crashed on Ring 07 above, those aliens could have had Forerunner tech on their homeworld and figured it out and reverse-engineered it or simply re-evolved and advanced technologically much quicker than most other species and then found or didn't find Forerunner tech later. I assume they find some eventually given how widespread Forerunners were.

#

Also the Domain either is self-aware and sapient itself or its the Precursor entity Abaddon inside it. Or both.

cobalt quiver
#

Do the halo rings have timezones?

versed helm
#

He's just sitting in a cave with his bonfire.

#

It would be more logical if he found a bunker or something.

#

But no, cave.

fervent pond
#

if blue team goes to reach in the new book, they can visit 6 in his/hers cave

#

oh boy

versed helm
#

I hope they find his resting place.

#

That would be glorious if written correctly.

#

If Chief and the team make a memorial for him.

fervent pond
#

i saw an idea for an achievement (if you can go to reach in infinite) for finding noble team's helmets

versed helm
#

That would be so cool!

fervent pond
#

i highly doubt it will happen, though

versed helm
#

Yeah...

#

I just want Elite comrades with their H2A design.

fervent pond
#

playable elites 343pls

versed helm
#

Highly likely.

#

But still, I just them to fight alongside them on the Halo Ring.

fervent pond
#

it's not confirmed, so idk

versed helm
#

Anyway, do members of the Covenant have an equivalent to alcohol?

fervent pond
#

there is the food nipple...

versed helm
#

Oh God.

#

Spare me.

versed helm
#

It's pretty sly of Truth to quickly stop the footage of Sesa before he explains himself.

#

When showing him to Thel.

jolly furnace
#

Yes Covies have alcohol

#

SanShyuum were famous for it even in forerunner days

blazing cypress
lament hornet
#

Fractures: Untitled Story?

blazing cypress
#

yea

lament hornet
#

That's the name

blazing cypress
#

well how do i read it lmao

#

or can u just tell me what happened to born stellar

#

@lament hornet

carmine sleet
#

You read it by reading Halo Fractures

lament hornet
#

Here's the amazon listing for Fractures

#

It's a collection of short stories, Untitled being the last one in it

blazing cypress
#

yyea i have fractures

lament hornet
#

haha then you can just read it in the book

#

Easy 😄

blazing cypress
#

the last story in the book is end credits lol

versed helm
#

ohhhhh. thats a nice one.

spiral jewel
#

While unlikely, I feel like something is going to happen with the Created to where a large handful of Promethean knights and soldiers will end up leaving the organization, due to either infighting or reasons yet unknown.

runic inlet
#

@runic inlet We, uh. We dunno. Nothing official has stated or even hinted at it, to my knowledge.
There's some theories floating around involving Mendicant Bias, if I remember correctly, but it's all just speculation.
@unique rune Ahh ok thanks

versed helm
#

Do elites have tongues?

gilded mason
#

Yes.

versed helm
#

Hot

limpid meadow
#

I like to think their tongues are heavily used in speech, as their mandibles can't play much of a role in speech

gilded mason
#

Would make sense.

fair hazel
#

halo 5 gives is a close look at elite's mouths

jolly furnace
#

I mean tongues are used in speech so...

zealous jolt
#

Yeye

limpid meadow
#

Like I said, heavily. As in they used in place of lips and such

#

Since, again, the way Sangheili mandibles are built just can't really figure directly into speech all that much.

obsidian thistle
#

"Science is still uncertain why Elites can pronounce the letter M."

main siren
#

When I was a kid, I thought the legendary difficulty logo was a midget with four legs.

gilded mason
#

The answer is quite simple.

#

Neural physics

obsidian thistle
#

Dont you mean Nanobots son.

gilded mason
#

Neuralbots.

obsidian thistle
#

Let me quickly add that to Halopedia. /s

gilded mason
#

based

main siren
#

So Neural Physics is the answer to all the problems in the Halo universe? thinkingchief

feral perch
#

Evan Philliss

obsidian thistle
#

If its weird alien related. Yes.

If its Human related Nanobots.

Its its space related Slipspace be weird.

If its ILBs related Butterfly effect.

gilded mason
#

lol

obsidian thistle
#

And Covies have a lack of lore in many areas so anything can be added and cause lil issues

jolly furnace
#

Neural Physics is basically just magic without saying its magic. Its Clarke's Third Law to a tee.
It will likely be the writers way of handwaving away more fantastical concepts in Halo.

zealous jolt
#

👀 more fantastical than pretty much any of the forerunner covie machines we’ve seen

jolly furnace
#

Yeah

#

I mean Precursor tech outright breaks physics in Halo verse

zealous jolt
#

Like the domain or the needler even

jolly furnace
#

Ah the Needler... how I love that weapon

#

Needler works via Halo verse laws of physics. What those are I have no clue

fair hazel
#

well, i think the thing is, it obeys physics but, we just dont know physics well enough

#

principe

terse lava
#

Yea dont forget this is a universe where the precursors themselves said the universes is itself alive

limpid meadow
#

Not quite. The Precursors recognize the universe as "alive" but not in the way we typically think of life.

humble yacht
#

(â•ŻÂ°â–ĄÂ°ïŒ‰â•Żïž” ┻━┻

#

Precursors

feral perch
#

their true form

jolly furnace
#

The universe in Halo is an animate entity it seems

terse lava
#

I think I would have preferred the precursors as just hyper advanced. But not as far as they have gone

limpid meadow
#

The Forerunners were already hyper-advanced.

terse lava
#

What I mean is

limpid meadow
#

The direction they went with the Precursors is kind of the only logical direction.

terse lava
#

How they were portrayed, physical beings with the showing we have. Not the extra dimensional physical avatar stuff

limpid meadow
#

They are physical beings

humble yacht
#

They don’t have to be, though

#

That’s one of the things I don’t like about them

terse lava
#

I agree there. I am fine with them changing form, going from advanced to primitive. Moving galaxies, planets, and stars. Maybe have them just beginning to do the whole spirit thing as the forerunner rebellion happens. Yet having them have that ability the whole time makes their anger and the flood pointless

versed helm
#

Wait they have tongues?

terse lava
#

"How dare you kill our physical bodies which we can bring back. We will now make life suffer for all eternity"

limpid meadow
#

They do have to be physical, though.

#

They aren't tied to a single form, their minds are transcendent, but they still require physical bodies

humble yacht
#

when you can shed your physical form at will and build a new one out of thought, it's not the same

terse lava
#

Yea

limpid meadow
#

Who says they can build a new body out of thought?

versed helm
#

I thought they don't need a physical body though, can't they corrupt AI with the logic plague?

jolly furnace
#

Its akin to deities taking on avatars to interact with the mortal plane

terse lava
#

Them apparently

humble yacht
#

the forerunner trilogy said that

limpid meadow
#

When?

humble yacht
#

i dunno, i only read summaries

jolly furnace
#

They are likely higher dimensional beings in nature

limpid meadow
#

I don't think it says that

terse lava
#

I dont mind the idea of them going to spirits, but should have had it where it was just barely been discovered before the rebellion

jolly furnace
#

Their physical forms just vessels to interact with our universe

limpid meadow
#

They're physical forms are rather important.

main rivet
#

The Halo universe can be summed up as the more advanced your civilization, the bigger jerks you were.

limpid meadow
#

If not, the Flood would never have been a thing

main rivet
#

The Precursors are merely the Ur-Jerks of the universe 😛

jolly furnace
#

Unless the Flood locked them into those forms

#

Or they just went insane and decided screw everything else

#

and lets just use this new form to corrupt all creation

humble yacht
#

The Precursors were not tied to any particular physical form, assuming any shape as they saw fit; they would allow themselves to die away and be evolved anew over and over again, taking on numerous incarnations both physical and immaterial.

jolly furnace
#

We know not all Precursors became Flood

#

But we don't know what became of them

humble yacht
#

Silentium says the could be material or immaterial, physical or spiritual, depending on how they felt at the time

main rivet
#

And the Flood wasn't necessarily the intent of those Precursors too.

jolly furnace
#

Precursors are lovecraftian-inspired

terse lava
#

" flesh and spirit, primitive and advanced. Spacefaring and locked to their worlds. Evolved over and over again. Died away, were reborn.

jolly furnace
#

As per Greg bears words

limpid meadow
#

Fair enough then

main rivet
#

Really, given how everything in the Forerunner Saga is secondhand info, it's best to think of it as a possibility rather than the ironclad truth.

limpid meadow
#

That's true

terse lava
#

Sure it doesnt say how long it takes between death and rebirth

jolly furnace
#

Ultimately I don't expect Precursors or any of this to show up in the main games

tired saffron
#

I don't get how because the Precursors died, they became the flood

terse lava
#

Only some did

limpid meadow
#

I remember there's also subtle implecation that "Precursor" doesn't necessarily describe a single species, but a title that's passed along.

jolly furnace
#

Cos this kind of eldritch stuff is magnitudes above modern Halo races

#

Librarian speculated Precursors could have had their own

#

and so and so on

terse lava
#

That was a fan theory Toa. Same thing with forerunner

jolly furnace
#

but that was before we got the revelation at the end of Silentium from Forthencho

main rivet
#

Yeah, I can see the Precursors coming back in some form, but not in the way they were presented in the saga.

jolly furnace
#

I dont see them coming back at all

#

Other than as Flood

humble yacht
#

i personally don't want that

limpid meadow
#

Yeah, the Precursors shouldn't return in the games. They should stay in the background as much as possible

#

Beyond involvement of the Flood, of course

main rivet
#

In general there's a pretty big gulf in what they bring up from the Forerunner Saga and what we see in games, and that's for the best. Greg Bear's stuff is amazing but I can't see it really working on the context of the 26th century stories.

jolly furnace
#

True non-Flood Precusors using Slentium level power leaves no hope in hell for modern Halo races to beat

main rivet
#

People freaked out enough with the stuff they introduced in Halo 4.

humble yacht
#

at least with the forerunners, we knew they were fallible

jolly furnace
#

Given the scale and scope of their power, you'd have to wonder what hope in heaven the modern races would have against them

#

Precursors were fallible

#

Just more alien in their thinking

terse lava
#

Go on the Great Journey and fight them in equal ground😛

humble yacht
#

if they killed and rebirthed themselves for fun, who's to say they're really dead?

jolly furnace
#

I mean its possible they didn't really die

terse lava
#

Warfleet implied surviving precursors sank many levels below reality out of reach

humble yacht
#

exactly. that's what i don't like

jolly furnace
#

They kinda literally came back from death as the Floood

main rivet
#

can't really call that living 😛

limpid meadow
#

See, I love that kind of stuff

jolly furnace
#

@terse lava Yeah but is that a metaphor for becoming FLood or an actual plane above or below our plane of existence

humble yacht
#

some of them did, sure. and then the Primordial was like "i'll just pop my consciousness over into this dead mass and keep on living"

#

it's too powerful

jolly furnace
#

Primy pulled an essence transfer

terse lava
#

Doubt it was a meaphore

#

You know in a way, would have found it funny if the Great journey had been real. Rather then peaceful paradise though, you are thrown into a eternal war against the precursors

versed helm
#

Sounds like the opposite to the Promised Land lmao.

#

Fight God, the raid boss.

terse lava
#

Makes me think of Doom or 40k

humble yacht
#

This ain’t Supernatural

jolly furnace
#

Well Halo basically went to 40K and Lovecraft with Silentium

terse lava
#

Supernatural never even crossed my mind

versed helm
#

By the way, I have a question about Sangheili tongues since I saw it being mentioned earlier.

terse lava
#

Yes?

versed helm
#

Do they just tuck them away in combat?

terse lava
#

They are down in the throat

versed helm
#

Woah that's weird.

humble yacht
#

Most of our tongues are down in our throats

terse lava
#

Yep

versed helm
#

As in they tuck them down there? Or they are positioned ALL the way down?

terse lava
#

Same as ours, as Chim said our tongues are mostly in our throat. Ours just comes up a bit into out mouth. With the sangheili, not so much

versed helm
#

So it just sticks out a bit?

#

Unnoticed?

terse lava
#

It doesnt stick up at all unless needed

versed helm
#

Or behind the mandibles and just at the entrance of the mouth?

#

Sorry I just want to know it accurately you see since I never knew this.

terse lava
#

I would say the back of their throats are likenoue mouths. Our tongue does not come out unless we need it too. Same with them, it is further down the we can see

versed helm
#

Yeah I was thinking along those lines.

#

Makes their digestive system look more like an assembly line now lol.

terse lava
#

Pretty much what every digestive system is already

versed helm
#

Yeah but more so in this case.

#

Because it has more stages.

#

Are their salivary glands closer to their mandibles?

#

That's assuming that they even produce enzymes like amylase.

midnight loom
#

oh

terse lava
#

I would say they likely have them at the back eith their tongue seeing as we never see drool ornspittle come off the mandibles but likely some on the mandibles too to prevent drying out

midnight loom
#

no clue lol

versed helm
#

Yeah I'd say they would have some to coat the mandibles with some enzymes but have the majority in the mouth itself.

midnight loom
#

when they roar spittle comes out

versed helm
#

I've never seen that before.

#

Are you referring to the books or comics?

#

I bet they would hate ice cream.

#

If they had sensitive teeth anyway.

terse lava
#

Dont see why they would

midnight loom
#

hmm

versed helm
#

It would probably be difficult to eat.

midnight loom
#

why are we talking about this?

sick python
#

Hi

#

Can I join clan?

main siren
#

Wrong channel to ask, bud

midnight loom
#

hmm

sick python
#

How do I join 1

#

It say clan recruitment

midnight loom
#

u dont

versed helm
#

Since it would just melt when they try to chew it and seep through the mandibles lol.

Dont see why they would

jolly furnace
#

One thing I find odd is why the Precursors didn't expect violence from Forerunners. They would have to know of the concept given they spent billions of years changing forms and in some cases being locked to planets and going extinct on them before reincarnating over and over and living through every form or sociological and technological state imaginable. They would no doubt have made war among themselves as a result for the same reasons we have and do.

#

Like none of their creations seriously rose up against them or attacked them prior to the Forerunners?

sick python
#

Wat happened to Jun in halo reach?

versed helm
#

He left it with Halsey.

sick python
#

Y

versed helm
#

But it'z been left ambiguous.

#

And Carter ordered him to.

sick python
#

Ok

humble yacht
#

Technically he got Halsey to where she would later escape reach

#

How Jun left is unknown

sick python
#

Is it possible to beat lone wolf?

midnight loom
#

o

versed helm
#

Well from what I remember, Chief and Johnson hijack a Cruiser and meet with Halsey (?) Then they return to Earth.

gilded mason
#
Is it possible to beat lone wolf?```
Do you think there *would* be a way?
sick python
#

Idk

#

Yed

#

Yes

versed helm
#

I'm pretty sure it cuts to the scene of Six dying after 1 hour of survival.

gilded mason
#

Then the answer is no.

sick python
#

Ok

#

Thx

versed helm
#

General Kidd did a video on it.

sick python
#

Okk

humble yacht
#

Well from what I remember, Chief and Johnsone hijack a Cruiser and meet with Halsey (?) Then they return to Earth.
Naw son. Halsey was on Onyx at that time

versed helm
#

My bad.

#

That's why I included the question mark.

sick python
#

Y did he go to the lone wolf anyway

versed helm
#

Because he had nothing left to defend for.

#

He was abandoned on Reach.

sick python
#

Halsey

#

Ok

#

Gtg night

versed helm
#

Goodbye.

#

But I do remember Chief and Johnson meeting with survivors on Reach as a checkpoint.

#

Before returning to Earth.

#

when would that have happened?

gilded mason
#
I'm pretty sure it cuts to the scene of Six dying after 1 hour of survival.```
Doesn't General Heed have a video of him surviving for about 20 hours?
midnight loom
#

eh....

versed helm
#

I remember there being a timer.

gilded mason
versed helm
#

And I do believe it is 1 hour.

gilded mason
#

Here's the video, for reference

versed helm
#

Thanks.

#

That's weird because I remember something being mentioned about a timer.

midnight loom
#

hmm

#

dunno

jolly furnace
#

I also still wonder why the Precursors would ever want to give up their role as the rulers and protectors of the cosmos and all life within and their position as the gods and rulers of reality.

versed helm
#

Arrogance.

#

How long does a day and night cycle last on an Installation? Or are they all different?

jolly furnace
#

Arrogance what?

versed helm
#

I was just saying maybe they didn't see the issues in their work because of their arrogance?

green steppe
#

@versed helm @jolly furnace The Precursors were highly philosophical beings, coming in part from their knowledge of neural physics. So, if you look at human philosophers till date,most of them were pretty giving in nature. Maybe the same rule applies to them?

#

Also @versed helm in Halo:Nightfall, Alpha Shard had a day/night cycle of 16hrs (commented upon as being sped up), so I think most had around a 20-24 hr day/night cycle to manage the gravity generation on the ring, varying per Installation.

humble yacht
#

Precursors weren’t concerned about ruling

#

They were like kids with ant farms

#

Galaxies were experiments to them. They’d just set it up and watch it play out. And then move on to a new galaxy if they got bored

bronze bane
#

how did sgt. johnson get off the halo in halo:ce

humble yacht
#

In a pelican

bronze bane
#

how did people find out

gilded mason
#

First Strike

humble yacht
#

Chief found his pelican in the rubble of the halo

gilded mason
#

A book that came out a little bit after CE released

bronze bane
#

oh

#

in halo 2, who was the red monitor that the gravemind was holding

bright briar
#

2401 Penitent Tangent.

humble yacht
#

2401 Penitent Tangent

gilded mason
#

2401 Pen-aww

bright briar
#

Monitor of Installation 05.

humble yacht
#

He was the monitor of I05

gilded mason
#

😏

bronze bane
#

which one is that

gilded mason
#

...Delta Halo

humble yacht
#

The one from Halo 2

bronze bane
#

oh that makes sense

frank sedge
#

How did Srgt. Johnson survive again?

humble yacht
#

Pelican

gilded mason
#

We just went over this

last anchor
#

Picked up by Chief and cortana, stole a Covenant ship.

#

First Strike happened

frank sedge
#

What happened to the elite he was hugging tho

bronze bane
#

something that doesn't make sense to me is how the humans didn't know that the ark was on earth

gilded mason
#
What happened to the elite he was hugging tho```
He teleported away after giving Johnson his number
frank sedge
#

Lol

empty vapor
#

bro what happened to best boy The Cowardly Grunt?

gilded mason
#

It was deep under ground

#

You'd never know it was there unless you already knew about it

humble yacht
#

That elite hugging scene is non canon. That’s the real answer

bronze bane
#

yeah but its like 500 years from now

gilded mason
#

And?

bronze bane
#

im pretty sure they would have advanced tools to dig that far

frank sedge
#

Wait fr? It's not cannon?

gilded mason
#

Perhaps, but you'd actually need to use them on that spot after using sensors to detect something in that area.

#
Wait fr? It's not cannon?```
...Yes. Johnson and an Elite hugging while they die from an explosion is not canon.
bronze bane
#

i guess its just a coincidence that they didnt dig there

frank sedge
#

I mean it's from the official game so I always assumed it was

last anchor
#

Why would they dig that far?
They built a city on top of it. They only went as deep as they needed too.

gilded mason
#

Indeed

bronze bane
#

i mean digging for materials

last anchor
#

WHY?
There's nothing THERE

gilded mason
#

There's no need for that

last anchor
#

No reason to mine, no reason to shore things up...

bronze bane
#

after all, its 500 years later, you'd think they would start running out of materials

gilded mason
#

Actually no

last anchor
#

...
800 colonies bro

#

Including Reach and its 60 km deep titanium mines

bronze bane
#

but then, there's other worlds, i guess

gilded mason
#

And, y'know, asteroids and other bodies

last anchor
#

Plus asteroids. The moon. Mars.

#

SUNS

bronze bane
#

didnt thinl of that when i said that

last anchor
#

Also gas mining on Jupiter, Saturn and Neptune

#

they literally built the space elevator on New Mombasa cause they needed to get shiments UP and out to the colonies existing, and to get new materials back IN

#

Also most of the Ark was under basically just dead land. Any mining wouldnt go more than 1-2 miles deep.

#

Hold on

#

Yeah deepest mine on earth is barely 4 klicks

bronze bane
#

the ark was in africa, right?

frank sedge
#

The film Forwards onto dawn is cannon correct?

gilded mason
#

Yes. To both questions

last anchor
#

Beat me to it

gilded mason
#

Ark portal, rather

last anchor
#

The actual ark is in interstellar space

bronze bane
#

where is the actual ark

gilded mason
#

In space

last anchor
#

2 to the 18th lightyears from the center of the mikly way

#

To be precie

#

So...2000000000000000000 light years

bronze bane
#

how did 343 get to the ark from the original halo

#

or, how did he get off

gilded mason
#

...The portal?

last anchor
#

Rode with Chief aboard Forward Unto Dawn.

frank sedge
#

Oh yeah, also do u guys have any idea of who are the dead Spartans on the last mission on Reach?

humble yacht
#

Guilty spark was flying around space after his ring exploded

#

Then he found the heretics

last anchor
#

Via a trip to Threshold, getting captured by the Covenant, then allying with Miranda, Johnson and Thel.

gilded mason
#

Just randos

bronze bane
#

why? didn't send sentinels to kill the Chief

gilded mason
#

?

humble yacht
#

Did you play halo 3?

bronze bane
#

*didnt he

gilded mason
#

Or Halo 2

bronze bane
#

343 sent sentinels to kill Chief after Cortana took the Index

humble yacht
#

That was all the way back in halo 1

gilded mason
#

This is all covered in H2/3

bronze bane
#

must have missed it

humble yacht
#

😩

gilded mason
#

đŸ€”

last anchor
#

So it would seem...

#

Also missed First Strike from the sounds of it

bronze bane
#

yes

#

i played the games

#

didnt read the books

#

how were the flood made

frank sedge
#

I only have halo legends on disc. That's the only other piece of lore I have besides games

bronze bane
#

how were the flood created

humble yacht
#

For that sort of question, halopedia may be better