#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 319 of 1

humble yacht
#

It is

warm ridge
#

I wonder how long a trip to the Ark could take with the Infinity, directly from Earth in slipspace. Not using the Ark portal at all.

inner basin
#

It’s hard to tell. Maybe we’ll get to see a demonstration in the future

humble yacht
#

Probably around the same time it took high Charity

warm ridge
#

Wasn't Chief + Truth etc already traveling to the Ark by the time High Charity arrived at Mars?

humble yacht
#

Yes

warm ridge
#

that's pretty impressive considering the Gravemind supposedly didn't even use the Ark portal, which supposedly speeds up slipspace travel by a lot.

limpid meadow
#

Infinity would likely still take 8-ish months

humble yacht
#

8 months? With forerunner engine?

warm ridge
#

wot

limpid meadow
#

The only reason High Charity took a mere month was because of the Gravemind's Precursor know-how.

humble yacht
#

It upgraded HC’s engines

#

At the cost of the station’s integrity

warm ridge
#

He quite clearly was working off what limited power High Charities reactors, and other sorts of things that were still on High Charity at all + with how destroyed it likely got due to the constant plasma bombardments from the Elites.

#

tl;dr
precursor know how mostly sure, but the Infinity by comparison I'd imagine would reach the same time frame considering it wasn't destroyed or any of the sort at all.
The Ur-Didact arrived at Earth from Requiem incredibly quickly to, using just Forerunner engines.

limpid meadow
#

I doubt it would only take a month for Infinity.

#

Maybe not 8 months, but only 1? I can't believe that.

humble yacht
#

Has the efficiency of the infinity’s engines ever been compared quantitatively to standard human slipspace engine?

#

Also how much time passes between Hunters in the Dark and HW2?

warm ridge
#

didn't the Forerunners more or less use the Ark portals as a form of "instant travel across huge distances" when used in combination with Forerunner engines?

limpid meadow
#

Hunters in the Dark is 2555, HW2 is 2559

humble yacht
#

So plenty of time either way for banished to get there

#

Manually

limpid meadow
#

The Banished took about 8 months

warm ridge
#

Banished used the Ark portals supposedly, and once the Ark portals shut down, they got trapped. One of the reasons Atriox was so obsessed with getting on the Halo ring/waiting for it.

humble yacht
#

Ah so you were comparing Infinity to Covenant tech

carmine sleet
#

Pretty sure the Banished didn't use any portal relating to the Ark

humble yacht
#

If the banished used the portal then Earth would have flipped out

limpid meadow
#

Covie and Human. The Rubicon took about 8 months as well, but we unfortunately have almost no information on that ship.

#

But yeah, I was looking as the Banished trip. Sorry, I need to make my reasoning more clear 😛

humble yacht
#

But the Covenant ships has always been faster. 😉

warm ridge
#

More then one portal leading to Earth exist, you know that right?

limpid meadow
#

If the Banished used a portal, the trip to the Ark wouldn't have taken 8 months

humble yacht
#

How you gonna activate a portal without a key ship

carmine sleet
#

A Huragok

limpid meadow
#

The Huragok was a special case

warm ridge
#

Huragok definitely did it on Earth apparently, so did Tragic Solitude at the Ark.

limpid meadow
#

It has previously worked on the Keyship in High Charity.

humble yacht
#

Tragic Solitude activated the portal from the other end

limpid meadow
#

using a Human

carmine sleet
#

The Ark side of the portal does not require a Keyship

humble yacht
#

And the forerunners got rid of most of their key ships to keep the flood away from the ark

#

We only know of the one leftover

warm ridge
#

We don't really know how many Keyships survived the Forerunner-Flood war as it is, so who knows.

humble yacht
#

If the banished had a key ship, we’d know

carmine sleet
#

Aye, and it would've been a major plot point too

limpid meadow
#

The Keyship from Halo 3 is still on the Ark.

humble yacht
#

Too many plot holes to assume the banished used a portal to get to the ark

warm ridge
#

Apparently a ton of them definitely survived as the Librarian's plan used them greatly in order to reseed life in the Milky Way, that's all we know. Lots of Keyships survived, more then 1 definitely. We just know of 1 that was still "technically" in operation.

limpid meadow
#

If I recall, the Hunter pair Colony was studying it, or the Keyship launch site on the Ark.

#

But yeah, they don't have a Keyship otherwise

warm ridge
#

Ace of Spades, aka Rion Forge also came across a design seed which would've built a Keyship if activated at a Builder Facility in 2557.

last anchor
#

I mean the UNSC managed it using a Huragok

#

Also, lore states the Banished took the "long way". Thing is, the trip to the Ark once you know where it is is actually fairly smooth since theres...more or less nothing in the way once you pass the boundary of the milky way. Its extra-galactic

terse lava
#

What in the world have I missed?

inner basin
#

A LOT

#

That’s how I feel for the most part lol. Darn time zones

terse lava
#

And always when I am at work too

#

As for the earlier topic, truth was clearly only infected as you make your way towards him, and by spores. As for how fast they can infect, it is slower then an infection form.but not by much. We see Bero 'Kusovai become infected by spores and it didnt take a terribly long time

cloud trellis
#

you know what would be cool, a spartan siding with the ionsurrectionists and huinting other spartans

humble yacht
#

so, Ilsa Zane, pretty much

cloud trellis
#

i jsut didn't know that

#

not far enough in the books

gilded mason
#

She's from a comic mini-series

humble yacht
#

she's in the Initiation comics and the Hunt The Truth audio drama

cloud trellis
#

aw no

#

material outside books

versed helm
#

its still lore

cloud trellis
#

i only jsut finished the flood

inner basin
#

Hey Paciono, haven’t seen your face around here for a while

cloud trellis
#

where do i go next

gilded mason
#

Release order

inner basin
#

I think First Strike is next

versed helm
#

hey @cloud trellis

#

i had exams

#

yeah

#

first strike is next

cloud trellis
#

got it!

#

already in my hands

versed helm
#

then contact harvest, i think

inner basin
#

I assume that you tagged Rioom by accident, Pacino lol

versed helm
#

OH HECK

#

I DID

cloud trellis
#

after first strike is ghost of onyx

inner basin
#

Rioom use the link Ostral posted

versed helm
#

SORRY

cloud trellis
#

your welsome pacino

inner basin
#

No need to keep asking people

versed helm
#

no, ghost of onyx is last in that series

cloud trellis
#

ok Beastsprayz

#

i get it

#

you don't like me 😢

#

@pacino what?

versed helm
#

yeah

#

ghost of onyx leads to the kilo five trilogy

#

its last in that specific part of the lore

inner basin
#

Rioom is now that we don’t like you, but Ostral has posted something that answers all your questions

cloud trellis
#

i was being sarcastic

#

but i got the memo

#

no worries

versed helm
#

so, how's the new virus treating y'all?

cloud trellis
#

i am already dead

#

wait i am confused by the link, the list is release order

versed helm
#

this is my......what? third month of house arrest?
yeah. third month of house arrest

#

its all the lore

terse lava
#

Oh, it has been a while since we have seen you Forthebcho

inner basin
#

If you click the drop down box “List of Novels” that’s the release order of books, Rioom

versed helm
#

@terse lava I had exams. which are now over

#

and i am stuck inside AGAIN due to china not knowing how to contain a virus

cloud trellis
#

ah i get it

#

the author made ghost of onyx right after first strike

#

but lore/story wise contact harvest comes way before fall of reach

versed helm
#

yup.its the beginning

#

OF EVERYTHING

cloud trellis
#

hmmmn

#

well i have first strike and ghost in front of me in person

#

i might read it in release roder

versed helm
#

yer choice

inner basin
#

It’s best to read it in release order. That way you’re not confused when characters first introduced in older books appear in newer ones

stoic hamlet
#

Release order is always best, yeah

#

Chronological is super hard

#

Because books jump all over the place

versed helm
#

true that

cloud trellis
#

wait how old is chief in the flood

#

hes like in his forties right

gilded mason
#

Yeah

#

Chronologically

cloud trellis
#

in foR we jumped between 12 year old and 40

versed helm
#

A lotta fightin

#

and a lot of covie blood spilling

#

With a sprinkle of Innie blood

#

so i just got the fall of reach a bit ago

#

might read it soon

#

NOICE

cloud trellis
#

huh

#

that also means chief pretty much has matured

#

and we don't get to see the development

#

besides FoR

#

until the later books which are prequels

#

i don't knwo if i like that\

feral perch
#

Bruh TFoR was made in a six-week timeframe when Bungie didn’t even want it, to provide backstory for CE

#

be grateful it exists at all

versed helm
#

aye. you wanna see chief mature, read silent storm and oblivion

cloud trellis
#

@feral perch i am grateful, but this is me being a critic to writing as any other person will be. FOR was pretty good and the changing of chief was the best moments in the book imo

feral perch
#

Oh I see

versed helm
#

if you really wanna see chief mature, you should read silent storm

#

tbh i dont want a certain thing from the books i just want them to be good

#

they are.

#

ye

cloud trellis
#

i like the cover of silent storm

versed helm
#

ok now im so glad i didnt watch the fall of reach before because i hear its mediocre and probably would have made me not want to read the book

cloud trellis
#

fall of reach was a movie?

versed helm
#

it was adapted into one

#

the book came out like 15 years before the movie

gilded mason
#

Though it really wasn't that good

versed helm
#

yeah im really glad i didnt watch it

cloud trellis
#

shame by the developer

versed helm
#

although i want to get to watching the halo movies someday

#

its the animated film, right?

#

there were two animated ones

#

the fall of reach was a 3d animated one

#

the 2d animated one was a mini series called halo legends

stoic hamlet
#

@gilded mason @terse lava you’re the Covie lovers here, what are your thoughts on this?

#

I think he has some good points, but is missing the point overall.

inner basin
#

“Covie lovers” 😂

cloud trellis
#

whose he?

inner basin
#

It’s a they

versed helm
#

forget the Covie lovers and UNSC people, Flood all the way

inner basin
#

Both Ado and Ostral are as Eternal described, “Covie lovers”

gilded mason
#

❤️

versed helm
#

Hinge-head kissers

#

Split-jaw snoggers

gilded mason
#

Squidhead, gawd

#

Also, I'll take a look in a bit

inner basin
#

@cloud trellis If you have any questions based on Covenant lore, Ado and Ostral are probably your best chance

versed helm
#

And if you want to see someone have a mental breakdown at the keyboard and cover the channel in a wall of text

#

Ask me anything about guns

gilded mason
#

@versed helm
What's a bullet

inner basin
#

^ Yeah, he knows a lot about guns

versed helm
#

Your mum

gilded mason
#

😮

inner basin
#

Don’t start him Ostral

versed helm
#

Anyway

#

I'm actually... suddenly kinda hopeful some inkling of projection sights returns in Infinite.

#

I suddenly feel as if they kinda need to be retconned as having always been a thing.

#

They were probably one of 343's greatest additions to the world, if one of their more random additions to gameplay.

stoic hamlet
#

I mean....aren’t they? Or, haven’t they?

terse lava
#

Ok what have I missed now

stoic hamlet
#

Are they not what’s projected by a HUD?

#

I wanted your opinion on a rant. @terse lava

versed helm
#

Well, what I was referring specifically to were weapons like the MA5 having in-built holographic projectors.

#

As they do in Halo 5.

#

Because, when you think about it, there's... 2 main things a soldier uses a HUD for. Navigation and targeting.

#

If he had something else to handle navigation, a projection sight does everything a regular soldier's HUD is responsible for.

terse lava
#

@stoic hamletalright give me a few minutes

versed helm
#

I suppose IFF might be another function.

#

Keeping track of the positions of your team mates.

#

I suppose that's the one thing someone without a HUD really forgoes if projection sights are a thing. As well as other on-the-fly visual representations, but I assume a datapad could handle that.

cloud trellis
#

we have alien experts

stoic hamlet
#

We have several experts on various things, yis

versed helm
#

And - hol up - who are the individuals who you often see forgoing HUDs?

#

legends

#

Individuals like one Sergeant Zhao Heng Lopez. Or one Sergeant Major Avery Johnson. Or Sergeant John Forge.

#

Experienced jarheads.

#

you mean GODLY jarheads

#

Guys and gals who don't need some machine to tell 'em where their marines are at a given time, because they're likely where they told em to be.

#

I feel a conceptualization coming on

#

Eeeeeeep!

#

not really

#

they're just heckin amazing

stoic hamlet
#

Wasn’t Lopez given a tactical piece on a headband? In the Motion comic I believe she was, anyways.

Johnson uses Shooter Glasses often enough.

#

Forge I’ve got nothing

terse lava
#

Hm, quite certain I have read that rant before

versed helm
#

forge had an enhanced shotgun, i think

terse lava
#

Think he posted it on waypoint as well

stoic hamlet
#

He posted it to /r/Halo before.

versed helm
#

Anyway, projection sights fix everything

#

They're now my favourite thing about Halo 5

terse lava
#

Oh I see, literally 3 hours ago, interesting

versed helm
#

And you know what?

#

The AR also looks the best it ever has in Halo 5

#

Fight me

#

God, I feel a sudden need to play Halo 5

stoic hamlet
#

MA5K is best AR.

But the MA37’s also really nice.

#

I can’t wait to see what the MA40 looks like up close with the ammo counter and stuff

versed helm
#

First off, I win on a technicality because the MA5K is an assault carbine.

#

Second off, I concur.

#

If there's no indication of it having a projection sight (or workable alternative) I will be a bit sad tbh

stoic hamlet
#

Fair.

And I will also be sad. But I wonder how it will work for that sort of design.

terse lava
#

@stoic hamlet I would agree with him I thr sense that the covenant have. Even portrayed rather badly when one compares lore and games. Yes you are usually a super soldier but even when you are not the enemy falls somewhat easily. Its sadly the reality of making a game and expanding on the lore

stoic hamlet
#

Mhm. My thoughts as well. He’s not wrong, but I think he’s taking it a little bit too far.

gilded mason
#

Ye

terse lava
#

Too far yea I do agree too

versed helm
#

meanwhile, the MAR is the better AR

inner basin
#

Shame Looters left, he loves to talk about guns

terse lava
#

But realistically, if you want to face the covenant as shown in the books, the game would be unplayable

versed helm
#

U WOT

#

that is true

#

Riddle me this

#

Is the MAR designed for accurate, controllable, automatic fire with .308 at between 600-900 RPM out to 300m?

#

Does the MAR break the very laws of physics to somehow be a bullpup that also has a fully adjustable shoulder stock?

#

does the MAR have recoil?

#

Are we talking about the Galil derivative here?

#

we're taking about the basic MAR

#

I

#

Don't know which in particular you're referring to

#

But it's probably chambered in 5.56

#

And ergo

#

Wimpy

#

a stock, factory fresh MAR vs a stock factory fresh bullpup gun of yours

#

What MAR tho

#

There are multiple weapon systems throughout history that bear the name MAR, none of them being particularly widespread

#

Maybe the acronym refers to something else I'm not aware of

inner basin
#

Maybe a bad question but what’s the M stand for in MAR

#

Is it modern?

versed helm
#

magnetic assault rifle

inner basin
#

Ahh I see

versed helm
#

Oh so you mean like

#

a Gauss/rail-rifle

#

Hypothetically

#

yeah

#

I mean sure, if you've got a lot of fancy batteries

#

But the MA5 gets the job done

#

it does

#

that it does

inner basin
#

But we aren’t using the MA5 in Infinite ;P

versed helm
#

Well

#

so what all weapons are there? hs the list been released already?

#

I mean, we've seen what we're tentatively calling the MA40 based off the nerf gun

abstract venture
#

What's the MAR?

versed helm
#

That's the slick MA37 redux (Not the MAR, the MA40)

#

We've seen a magnum that... looks like the Reach one, dunnit?

#

On toys, this is.

#

We've seen a BR55 and an M7

#

And a SPNKR

#

And what looks to be a redesigned hydra

#

and the ARC?

stoic hamlet
#

You want the name of the acronym or are you asking if we’ve seen it?

#

Its the railgun

#

Asymmetrical Rail Carbine, IIRC.

#

Or maybe not

versed helm
#

No, in fact.

#

i know its the railgun.

stoic hamlet
#

It’s been a bit since I’ve looked

versed helm
#

Asymmetric Recoilless Carbine.

stoic hamlet
#

Ah, thank

versed helm
#

because 343 are out of their minds.

#

It's a railgun that's

#

Arc Reactor Cannon

#

Actually a coilgun

#

Or maybe not

#

That is recoilless

#

But not by any mechanism related to it actually being a rail or coilgun

#

Because as we all know, railguns and coilguns have an awful lot of recoil.

obsidian thistle
#

Thats a running gag on the ARC Looters. XD

#

To fans that is

versed helm
#

well......it does use mag fields to project projectiles

#

Mhm.

#

For every action

#

at mach speeds

#

There is an equal and opposite reaction

#

the action being the fields, the reaction being the ejection of the slug

#

there's no explosive force propelling it forward to cause a recoil

#

...

#

no gun powder in the back explosive force, i mean

#

See, the way an ordinary gun works

#

Is that the explosive force of the deflagrating propellant transfers its energy into the the slug

obsidian thistle
#

Well its kinda weird in its fiction. I actually dont think we "seen" outside books and descriptions. All we have is gameplay to rely on.

versed helm
#

And as the slug leaves the barrel, it uses the density of the expanding gases to push energy back into the bolt of the weapon

#

but there's no expanding gases here

#

And the reciprocating bolt is the recoil you feel

#

no solid propellant

#

Yes - instead of expanding gasses, what you have is the force of magnetism.

#

That would work the same way.

#

You know how I know it?

#

tried and tested?

#

Because the experimental railguns of the modern day have recoil, yes.

#

Honestly, I don't explain it that well.

#

But anything that pushes something else gets the energy it put into the thing blasted back at it.

#

but magnetism itself causes no recoil

#

Yes it does

#

You know that feeling when you try to push two magnets together and they push apart?

#

repulsion, yeah

#

That's your recoil, basically.

#

dude what no

#

magnetic repulsion is proximity based

gaunt oakBOT
#

@severe iris has been auto muted.

terse lava
#

What in the world?

gilded mason
#

Cripes

inner basin
#

Oof

gilded mason
#

=/

terse lava
#

How, why?

inner basin
#

Man was just talking about recoil

terse lava
#

Accidental bad word I bet

inner basin
#

That’s a safe bet

obsidian thistle
#

Lets not joke about that here please

versed helm
#

Sorry

obsidian thistle
#

Regardless what Looters said is right. That would be your recoil. Its one reason why the ARC is joked. Granted suspension of disbelief is to be had cause the ARC is far from the only thing impossible in Halo.

terse lava
#

Neural...

gilded mason
#

👍

terse lava
#

Wonder how long it takes the covenant to terraform a world

versed helm
#

aye

#

bad words are bad juju here

terse lava
#

Even though it's almost always a typo

versed helm
#

typo once twice or thrice
yer gonna be maybe fine
but typo a fourth time
and you'll have an ARC shoved up your behind

terse lava
#

Chuckled more thrn I should have at that

versed helm
#

bows
i aim to please

#

the ARC will do that for some guys too

inner basin
#

Let’s not get ahead of ourselves here. Maybe stop before it goes too far?

versed helm
#

yeah. sorry

inner basin
#

Typos are unreal today. Jeez...

versed helm
#

depends on the autocorrect

inner basin
#

Well typos are first then autocorrect makes it worse

versed helm
#

aye. they do
welp, i gtg. might be on later
have fun mi amigos

inner basin
#

Later

obsidian thistle
#

Well in other news. Have you heard about the best character ever? Spock the space Cat

gilded mason
#

Good ol' Spock

obsidian thistle
#

A cat so cool she was allowed on the Spirit of Fire Bridge.

keen canopy
#

Wasn't there a cat on PoA as well?

gilded mason
#

Yeah, I think a reference to Alien?

keen canopy
#

Ah, chuck it on the pile loool

gilded mason
#

lol

keen canopy
#

I wonder if we have a "list of alien references page"

#

Yes we do

terse lava
#

Heh

#

Ce is pretty much one big alien reference

warm ridge
#

@keen canopy The cat on the POA is just a easter egg and isn't considered canon, it's a joke at best. That entire board you see at the beginning of POA isn't really considered cannon by anyone.

keen canopy
#

I wish Staten was around for Halo 3 also

#

We could've gotten a more competent and threatening Truth, a more involved Arbiter, much more Separatist action, and a Johnson that wasn't done absolutely dirty by Halo 3.

inner basin
#

Still his lines at the start of Halo 3 are comedy gold, but some did feel a little out of place

gilded mason
#

Would have been great to have him, yeah

terse lava
#

Yea

pulsar pendant
#

so, i just find the terminal where 343 GS talk about a ship having crash on the ring, do we ever got id on what was on the ship?

bright briar
#

As far as I'm aware, it's still a mystery.

unique rune
#

Yep. Still no info as to whatever or whoever was on that ship.

Probably won't ever get any.

terse lava
#

Closest we ever got was 343 joking about it being a bear like race

stoic hamlet
#

I’m imagining like, the cutest possible bears.

#

Like some cute children’s cartoon stuff

gilded mason
#

The bears from We Bare Bears

stoic hamlet
#

Yup, exactly

terse lava
#

It will be care bears who shoot plasma

stoic hamlet
#

Turns out that’s where the Sangheili get their plasma designs from

#

The bears

#

Not the forerunners

#

They’re a member of the Covenant Fringe who accidentally revealed themselves to humanity, but the Ministries covered it up.

terse lava
#

Heh

versed helm
#

covenant fringe?

#

more like

#

covenant cringe

terse lava
#

throws tomato

unique rune
#

That was... an attempt.

versed helm
#

Sorry I hate the Star Trek reject aliens which were in the Locke movie

#

did you just call the covenant star trek rejects

#

anger noises

unique rune
#

The Yonhet design wasn’t... especially good.

versed helm
#

i agree with that one but most of the covenant is designed great in the pre 343 era

#

elites, grunts, hunters, jackals

#

etc

unique rune
#

I mean, I’m not gonna disagree with that, but considering he was talking about Covenant fringe just a couple messages ago... and the only fringe species we know of are the Yonhet... which appeared in Nightfall...

versed helm
#

oh the fringe

#

yeah the fringe is eh

versed helm
#

Arent the Sharqoui/Drinoll fringe as well? Or would I be mistaken?

terse lava
#

Ehh...sort of kind of? They were more living weapons then a race

versed helm
#

True

versed helm
#

yeah the xenos in the games are great <3

fair hazel
#

Before they were enslaved though. Probably some life worker project

sand iris
#

do u think there is a planet that is made of egg white and one big yolk in the middle

turbid ether
#

If the planet is the size of an egg than yes

#

Imagine just a random boiled egg floating through space

versed helm
#

Well... There's a planet thats shaped like an egg in real Life called Wasp 12b, though its color isnt white, buuuut it has the color of an Easter Egg kinda.

#

Actually theres another one called haumea thats white, no yolk in the Middle tho

fair hazel
#

@sand iris this is lore chat...

versed helm
#

It counts tho

#

Imagine having a giant egg planet orbit a Halo ring

carmine sleet
#

Why am I getting sudden Dr Who flashbacks with the whole planet that's and egg discussion?

versed helm
#

cause thats stuff we generally see in dottore who

versed helm
#

it'd be pretty cool if the regulars here got some rank like lore master or something

gilded mason
#

It'd make me feel all warm and fuzzy

versed helm
#

hehe

#

it'd be nice to see that

#

like, hardcore fans being appreciated for knowing this stuff

obsidian thistle
#

All equal here yo

gilded mason
#

Says the moderator. 😉

obsidian thistle
#

Pfft. Not that it changes my statement ;)

versed helm
#

the more active ppl here do know WAAY more about the haloverse than the avg player

obsidian thistle
#

A lotta the folks be Halopedians ;)

#

I'd sure hope the ones I keep seeing know their stuff lol. If they edit wikis and so on lol

versed helm
#

thats why we're here
cause we know

obsidian thistle
#

Its always fun to see folks talk here though xD Keeps me on my toes at times lol

#

(And I say that from a lore pov)

abstract venture
#

You guys think infinite will probably have playable Elites? I'm pretty sure that's the reason they introduced the anvil initiative in the lore

gilded mason
#

Well, I can always hope.

humble yacht
#

I don’t think the two concepts are related

obsidian thistle
#

Anvil was used to explain stuff in the original Halo Online. But 343i has at least kept it around.

gilded mason
#

I'm hoping the fact that 24 SoS agents are aboard the Infinity will actually come into play

terse lava
#

I would truly.hope infinite has playable sangheili, been waiting since 2010

feral perch
#

*2014

terse lava
#

I didnt count that due to it being an already existing game

feral perch
#

H2A was technically brand new

terse lava
#

Yea, but they just used h4 models...rather badly

feral perch
#

Can’t discount it just cuz you don’t like it /shrug

inner basin
#

Stone makes a good point. I don’t really like H5’s FF but it’s still FF

terse lava
#

Wasnt discounting it for that

#

But I concede yes I guess it would count as a new game with the newer maps

iron lotus
#

if your a true fan what was the reason MC was able to get of the exploding ring in Halo 3. And there is a very specific reason

#

plz answer

gilded mason
#

Are you asking because you don't know, or is this some purity test thing?

inner basin
#

^ Yeah... I can see it both ways and need some clarity

terse lava
#

The fact Johnson left his hog there?

inner basin
#

Or about the FUD?

#

Maybe even the portal and how it collapsed as the FUD went through?

gilded mason
#

Nah, that last one isn't part of "getting off" the ring

umbral swan
#

Hey, I dabble in constructed languages (dothraki, klingon, etc). Been thinking about trying to make a fleshed out Sangheili language inspired by what's on the halopedia page but also with my own linguistic interpretation of it

terse lava
#

Well I would still say the hog as that was needed to get to the frigate

umbral swan
#

Are there any sources beyond thaat wiki page or has 343/bungie said anything on it?

#

bc if there's already a proper sangheili language with grammar and whatnot out there i wouldn't want to step on any toes

unique rune
#

If I recall correctly there's a couple fan attempts at constructing one, but nothing official.

umbral swan
#

Okay! I may tackle it as a summer project then

gilded mason
#

There is a language made by Bungie and then later 343, yes. But the full extent of it is not known to the public

unique rune
#

Just bits and pieces assembled from the little we know

inner basin
#

Nah, that last one isn't part of "getting off" the ring
Well the FUD was still needed but the portal but I added just for further elaboration

umbral swan
#

I don't mean to be rude, but by language do you mean a handful of words or something with fleshed out grammar, like something you could make intelligble sentences out of?

gilded mason
#

The latter

umbral swan
#

Okay, neat

inner basin
#

I personally only know “Wort” lol

#

Don’t know if that’s even a word but... it’s what I know

umbral swan
#

imo the sangheili are one of the coolest parts of the lore and I love anything that further fleshes them out as a species and culture

terse lava
#

Yea, closest we have was from halo 2 promo stuff with covenant symbols for each letter of the alpabet

gilded mason
#

It is

inner basin
#

Okay so I know one Sanghelli word lol. What does it mean?

gilded mason
#

As expected, it means something like "Move urgently" or something along those lines

inner basin
#

Ahh I see

unique rune
#

The only bit of Sangheili language I consistently remember is like, nishum.

terse lava
#

Filthy nishum

iron lotus
#

no I know but Im asking

gilded mason
#

no I know
So it was a purity test?

unique rune
#

if your a true fan
Thinly veiled gatekeeping, more like.

terse lava
#

Cant really be a purity test seeing as the way off the ring technically varies

gilded mason
#

Same thing, really

iron lotus
#

Nope your all wrong those were not the answers I was looking for.

terse lava
#

.....

inner basin
#

Well that’s how Chief gets off the ring though thinkingchief

unique rune
#

The real way off the ring was the friends we made along the way

inner basin
#

He takes Johnson’s Hog with Arby, they drive to the FUD and then leave...

umbral swan
#

Let me get this straight, because you didn't like the answers, they were wrong?

terse lava
#

@unique rune👍

#

I am just waiting for he considers the answer

inner basin
#

@unique rune Metaphorically speaking I would agree, but literally is what I said

iron lotus
#

It was because of Mendicate Bias. If you check the terminal in the last mission, Mendicate says he will help him and does so. The path to the frigate was literally the only parts standing and they got desimated right after the player drives over them

gilded mason
#

🙄

inner basin
#

🤦‍♂️

unique rune
#

I mean.
Technically sure.

terse lava
#

Like I said, answer varies

iron lotus
#

I mean technically they are all correct answers but not the exact answer I was thinking of srry for being rude

gilded mason
#

Also, we have no idea if MB actually altered the way that the ring's scaffolding was exploding

inner basin
#

Yeah there is no proof. He said it, yes, but it doesn’t mean he did it...

iron lotus
#

I guess i'm wrong then srry if I wasted your time. I am only a kid

gilded mason
#

He said it, yes, but it doesn’t mean he did it...
I meant more MB could've simply been referring to the portal destination

iron lotus
#

eh all the asnwers could be taken as correct

inner basin
#

Well it is up to interpretation Ostral. (P.S I’m not saying I disagree with you, just playing Devil’s Advocate).

carmine sleet
#

I doubt Mendicant was "keeping the ring together" as Chief and Arby were driving the hog to the Forward Unto Dawn

inner basin
#

Until?

terse lava
#

The frigate

carmine sleet
#

Typo

iron lotus
#

it unto dawn

#

oh

inner basin
#

I figured lol. Just wanted to point it out ;P

carmine sleet
#

No worries, Beast

terse lava
#

Either way all good, and you are fine chief

iron lotus
#

thx

keen canopy
#

"The path ahead is fraught with peril. But I will do all I can to keep it stable - keep you safe."

I do like to think that MB somehow contributed to John and Thel making it to the Dawn despite all the chaos.

jolly furnace
#

I think all MB did was direct the MC to Requiem

versed helm
#

can someone remind me what MB stands for?

#

OOOHHHHHHH

#

medicant bias

#

my bad

gleaming thicket
#

Did the Insurgents and the UNSC work together during the later years of the Covenant war or did they just keep going at each other's throats?

versed helm
#

they kinda did

gleaming thicket
#

They kind of did which one?

versed helm
#

i dont remember the name of the book

#

but it happens

#

a spartan team is undercover on an asteroid colony

#

but a unsc ship lands there a bit damaged

#

it features thel vadame

#

both the innies and unsc work to rek the invading covies

#

and they do work together after the war

gleaming thicket
#

Interesting.

#

I figured the tensions are still kind of there even by Halo 5?

#

I need to consult the wiki tbh

gilded mason
#

Yes.

versed helm
#

they are, but between zealous sects

gleaming thicket
#

I wouldn't know much about Circumstances within Halo 5 btw since I myself haven't played it but have seen gameplay and cutscenes.

versed helm
#

the swords of sanghelios ask for the unsc's help to take back sanghelion

gleaming thicket
#

Yeah i know that. For my understanding the last of the Covenant remnants gets destroyed in Halo 5

#

at least the most powerful remnant that remains

gilded mason
#

Yes, Jul's Covenant was destroyed

versed helm
#

technically, Jul leads the Didact's groupies

gleaming thicket
#

Im a bit perplexed that Sangheili of all species still believe in the Covenant

gilded mason
#

Some Sangheili want power.

gleaming thicket
#

even after the events of the Great Schism and how the great journey is revealed to be nothing but bs

gilded mason
#

And want to consolidate that power into a faction they lead

humble yacht
#

There are an undefined number of remnants so the covenant can come back in some form as many times as the writers require

gleaming thicket
#

Yeah but probably never as they were prior to Halo 3

humble yacht
#

Doesn’t need to be like they used to be

#

Just needs to be an excuse to have the UNSC fight elites and grunts

gleaming thicket
#

The whole key to the Covenant is the Great Journey, if the Covenant abandon that they're no longer the covenant.

#

IMO

versed helm
#

but they find out that the journey is just mass suicide

humble yacht
#

Jul’s covenant still believed that forerunners were gods, even if they didn’t believe in the Journey

versed helm
#

some sects stopped believing, though, right?

gilded mason
#

Yes

humble yacht
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

Banished seems pretty secular

versed helm
#

oh, they know that the great journey is nothing but bamboozlement of the highest order

gleaming thicket
#

If the Forerunners were gods than why did they get defeated by space zombies.

#

Checkmate Covies.

versed helm
#

cause the space zombies had neural physics

humble yacht
#

Because the space zombies were devils

versed helm
#

magic devils

gleaming thicket
#

Not even space zombies

#

just dust

versed helm
#

but its quite interesting that the flood saw itself as a catalyst

gleaming thicket
#

dust that turns you into cronenbergs

#

Its more interesting to me how in Halo Legends Cortana reflects back to the Forerunners are a noble and peace loving people who were forced into this war with the Floods all while ignoring it was the Forerunners who decimated ancient humanity which was actively fighting the Flood and thus doomed the entire Galaxy.

humble yacht
#

Well that story came out before Greg bear contributed to the lore, so

#

Blame timing

gleaming thicket
#

My headcanon is that by the time of Halo Legends Cortana is going rampant, I think that's what its called.

#

So maybe her facts are not all there.

versed helm
#

she goes nuts in H4

#

thinkin herself to death

versed helm
#

almost to death,
then requiem happened

tender ginkgo
#

Well yeah Halo Legends Cortana is rampant since she has humanity and the Covenant have a truce to fight the Flood when the reality was much different

fair hazel
#

Halo legends ties into a lot of halo stuff

versed helm
#

It does.

#

But it goes a little bit off track in places

fair hazel
#

Even in 2020. It ties into blue team for infinite / new book.

#

The prototype. Ties into halo wars 2 dlc too.

#

Rise of atriox.

versed helm
#

That I did not realize

fair hazel
#

It’s interesting how certain pieces of media become very influential

#

Kilo five trilogy certainly being one of them.

#

See there’s some you might expect. Like Greg besr trilogy because those are obvious. Or the games.

versed helm
#

K5 is pretty important to connect stuff now

fair hazel
#

But then you’ve got stuff like kill five trilogy which introduced Venezia which really became this central place in the halo life

#

Lore

#

Legends. The stories connect in many ways. Thematically. Visually etc.

#

Halo nightfall.

#

It introduced so many things which were used forward more. Condor. Kil Silas. etc.

stoic hamlet
#

Venezia

Important

I think you mean Gao, silly.

versed helm
#

Venezia became quite important.
like, the whole pious inquisitor debacle happened there

tender ginkgo
#

Yeah legends have Fal Chavame who was made canon by the halo 2 terminals anniversary.

carmine sleet
#

He was always canon

#

The only part of Halo Legends that isn't canon is Odd One Out

obsidian thistle
#

Yep. Halo Legends was always canon sans Odd One Out.

gleaming thicket
#

1337 is still a memorable character. Makes me wish he was canon.

versed helm
#

Yeah. Him v Pluton was fun

versed helm
#

Dragon Ball Z + Halo = Odd One Out

#

Whats not to love?

#

Halo Ball Z

#

CE 🏀 🇿

versed helm
#

spits out coffee

#

THIS NEEDS TO BE AN ANIME

carmine sleet
#

Well, Halo Legends is the Halo Anime

versed helm
#

nononono

#

HALO BALL Z

carmine sleet
#

Also, please, try not to get coffee everywhere, I like having clean clothes

versed helm
#

instead of the dragon balls we have the skulls

#

and the saiyans are spartans

#

and instead of going super saiyan with longer hair, the armor version upgrades to give better combat ability

#

with the final form being didact-ian armour

#

which'll be like ultra instinct in the DBS saga

inner basin
#

I think we should stick with Halo: Legends...

versed helm
#

So... would Chief = Xeno Goku? Since he’s the most serious goku there is?

terse lava
#

Does this make Truth Freeza and Thel Vegeta?

#

Would the gravemind be the new Cell?

spiral jewel
#

dumb question: is there any connection between the opening for the animated "The Fall Of Reach" where Blue Team is looking for something on Reach and the upcoming novel Shadows of Reach? or would this question enter spoiler territory?

feral perch
#

Given that, in the prologue and epilogue for TFOR-AS, Blue Team is wearing their GEN2 Mjolnir armor, one could say that their appearance in TFOR-AS is distinct form their Shadows of Reach visit.

#

However, the prologue and epilogue could also be retconned to being one and the same with Shadows of Reach. Perhaps their GEN2 armor will become non-canon, and their GEN3 armor is what they actually wore in that moment.

#

Correct armor appearance is one of the things that gets pretty poor treatment in the Halo franchise, usually.

spiral jewel
#

or perhaps they receive their Gen3 at some point afterwards. im not sure. im sure things will get explained in Shadows of Reach

feral perch
#

Probably.

spiral jewel
#

i should pick up Shadows of reach when it either hits retail or arrives at Half Price Books

carmine sleet
#

When it hits retail

vagrant dagger
#

Imo that sort of stuff isnt necessary to the overall story ao its understandable their appearance is off

#

The story doesnt change based on how they look

stoic hamlet
#

It doesn’t, but it helps with timeline and consistency.

#

That’s why so many people threw a fit when the cover for Silent Storm was revealed.

vagrant dagger
#

I feel theyre just going to retcon a lot of stuff by the end of it regardless.

stoic hamlet
#

Well.......one of the reasons.

#

Highly possible

#

I just hope they give reasons for it. 343 don’t really do that.

#

And it really aggravates me, lol

feral perch
#

"mUh maRKetiNG"

#

"brand recognizability"

#

just make everything consistent dangit

#

If I had my way, Mark IV basic would have been used by every Spartan except Gray Team and Black Team, up until 2551 at least.

#

not counting IIIs of course

stoic hamlet
#

Same.

#

I don’t mind the attachments though

#

That’s how you show individuality.

carmine sleet
#

Give them different colours too, or at least different colours as markings on the armour

feral perch
#

That I don't want, unless it's very slight shading differences

stoic hamlet
#

Like a secondary colour or something. Like how Jun has some blue markings, but is very distinctly green.

feral perch
#

secondary color is okay I guess

humble yacht
#

Sounds kind of boring after an expansive color palette

feral perch
#

Multiplayer can have all the colors of the rainbow.

#

But for canon wartime activities, I think shades of olive drab, gray, and black, are appropriate.

humble yacht
#

White has its uses

feral perch
#

Ah yes, snow environments.

humble yacht
#

Or role distinction

#

Like medic

feral perch
#

Bad idea. Spartans don't need that.

#

Everything would be distinguished from within their HUD.

stoic hamlet
#

^^^

humble yacht
#

What if it’s for marines or ODSTs

stoic hamlet
#

It would likely also be in their HUDS.

feral perch
#

Marking a Spartan as distinct above the others would make it a priority target for Covies.

humble yacht
#

They already are

stoic hamlet
#

There’s a reason you don’t see Soldiers/Officers looking really distinct in the modern day.

feral perch
#

No need to make the problem worse, Chimera.

humble yacht
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

feral perch
#

If Netherop had been an extended wartime theater, then I could see orange Mjolnir.

#

Or maybe for Carrow, if that had been a planet worth defending.

carmine sleet
#

I'm honestly with Chimera, let the Spartans have different colours

stoic hamlet
#

I’ve head cannoned that ONI ordered them to look different once they realized people knew about them.

#

It’s the only way I can buy it.

feral perch
#

It's so much more exciting when the colors have a purpose and they're not merely difference for the sake of difference.

stoic hamlet
#

They’re not Space Marines

feral perch
#

ONI are a bunch of weirdos, that much is true.

stoic hamlet
#

They’re soldiers, they have no real reason to differentiate, and I don’t think personal preference would factor in.

IIRC Grim (or a canon fodder?) mentioned that the differences happened “slightly” over time but the lore doesn’t show this.

#

It should show this

feral perch
#

If they let Emile chip away at a ridiculously expensive piece of equipment, I could see personalized paint jobs happening. But Spartans like John saw Mjolnir as merely a tool, if an essential one.

stoic hamlet
#

Arguably all of them did.

I could also see personal customizations occur but we’ve never seen Spartans described as wanting these things.

#

So it seems out of place

inner basin
#

@feral perch Well if we are to use a Fistful of Arrows, Emile chipped away at his helmet because it was damaged so he decided to add an intimidation factor to it. In this instance we are assuming a Fistful of Arrows is canon, but it currently is not

feral perch
#

There is an alternate explanation that is canon though.

inner basin
#

What is that?

humble yacht
#

Wouldn’t that be he added a scratch for every kill?

feral perch
#

The skull is the result of thousands of individual scratchmarks from Covenant soldiers that Emile has killed.

#

yep

inner basin
#

Hmm, that is interesting how it has evolved over time. From a regular EVA helmet, to one with over a thousand or so scratches (with a Kukri ofc)

humble yacht
#

I wonder if he had in mind the skull design from the first scratch, of if he noticed that potential design after getting into it

feral perch
#

oh wait, it's only hundreds of marks

humble yacht
#

It’s gotta be approaching a thousand, at the minimum

stoic hamlet
#

Does he count explosives, or only those he’s killed with a knife?

#

Because that would effect it.

last anchor
#

Probably only those he killed "man to alien" if I had to guess. So shotgun and knife most likely

inner basin
#

Or maybe just kills he’s confirmed?

last anchor
#

Thats basically the same thing more or less. If you're close enough to see them die, thats a confirmed kill

feral perch
#

Interesting that confirmed kills are in abundance for Emile, whereas in modern warfare in the real world, they're not easy to obtain.

#

I wonder what about ground warfare with the Covenant lends itself to getting kill confirmation fairly easily, gameplay aside.

#

Maybe the fact that civilians and political boundaries are a much smaller factor?

last anchor
#

And because Elites tend to scream and shoot the air when they fall over dead...

versed helm
#

and grunt methane cylinders go skadoosh

stoic hamlet
#

I mean, most battles were killing zones where covenant threw bodies on a position until it drowned in blood.

#

Plenty of ways to get kills and confirm them there.

feral perch
#

Mm.

last anchor
#

MJLONIR probably helps. If that suit cant track where the bullet went and also confirm a hit...

#

I mean GEN 2 has hitmarkers for example

versed helm
#

You'd only need the markers with humans.
A battle with covies ALWAYS has confirmed dead.
they literally have suicide grunts

last anchor
#

Also its probably a case of;
"You still standing? Then you probably killed at least one. You dead? Not your problem anymore."

#

Also confirming kills is more important in chaotic, urban enviroments with civilians and stuff that can get in your way, since an insurgent who got away can cause trouble.
Wheras with the Covenant, well...for the most part, they dont ambush you (mostly, anyway).
They come at you screaming in heathen tounges looking to boil your flesh off your bones with plasma.

keen canopy
#

Potentially the PoA's ODSTs wearing black-colored Marine BDU with an ODST insignia. Fireteam Raven casts doubt on that somewhat

#

But I don't think there's anything confirmed to be non Canon in the book @versed helm , why do you ask?

terse lava
#

Dont recall anything either, one could easily argue Raven as happening to have different gear on when the
Autumn left Reach

keen canopy
#

Well the PoA was outfitted and ready for RED FLAG, it only touched down on Reach briefly to make some quick repairs at Azsod and pick up the Cortana fragment

#

But yea it could just have be that ODST's don't always deploy in heavy armor, and the Black marine BDU is something they might use at times as well

#

Of course the real-world explanation is just that ODST armor didn't exist yet when The Flood was written haha

last anchor
#

Same as how it describes the SOIEV's exterior burning off and opening to the air as it falls, wheras in Halo 2 we see it come down fully intact until landing

honest rune
#

How come in halo wars two they can deploy odst pods literally right next to each other? in reality they would smash on top of each other.

gleaming thicket
#

Operation Red Flag: would it have worked? Whats your opinion.

honest rune
#

Hmmmm most likely the other prophets would just let the other one rot away I mean we what truth did to mercy when they were attacked by the flood so no.

gilded mason
#
Operation Red Flag: would it have worked?```
Nooooope
feral perch
#

Yeah there’s no chance that 🚩 would have succeeded

honest rune
#

why didn't the covies just try to ally with humans first encounter? I mean humans obviously are connected to forerunners why wouldn't they manipulate instead of war?

humble yacht
#

because humans very existence invalidated the core Covenant beliefs

#

and the prophets were not about to have their gospel questioned

terse lava
#

We saw how that turned out

#

Should have just kept them as a fringe race

humble yacht
#

i don't think humanity would have accepted being a part of the covenant, anyway

#

some alien group comes in trying to push their religion on all of humanity? hell, humans can't agree on a single religion amongst themselves

honest rune
#

true

#

BUT

gilded mason
#
i don't think humanity would have accepted being a part of the covenant, anyway```
They'd kinda have to
#

There's only one real choice when choosing whether or not to accept being part of the Covenant

honest rune
#

the covies could ally themselves with humanity asking for tech and knowledge

#

then later betray humanity and know their weaknesses

unique rune
#

What would humanity have to offer that the Covenant didn't already possess...?

honest rune
#

yea we saw how the unggoy rebellion went

terse lava
#

Oe just keep them as a fringe away from main covenant society

gilded mason
#
What would humanity have to offer that the Covenant didn't already...?```
Forerunner cheat codes, if they ever find out about that
honest rune
#

EXACTALY

gilded mason
#

Otherwise, humanity being part of the Fringe is always on the table

terse lava
#

Mhm

#

Makes more sense

honest rune
#

covies didn't have those

terse lava
#

Have a few tag along with san shyuum and huragok teams

#

No no on the AI

#

The covenant known what mendicant bias did

unique rune
#

The Covenant would definitely be opposed to using AI

honest rune
#

oh?

terse lava
#

Yep

unique rune
#

Yeah.
It's not that they didn't have AI, they just heavily limited their usage after learning about the whole thing with Mendicant Bias being corrupted by the logic plague.

honest rune
#

I didn't know that I just assumed they were too egotistical to ask for a fake robot persons help

terse lava
#

The covenant had AI, but refused.to craft smart ai to avoid a repeat

honest rune
#

QUick question whats mendicant Bias?

gilded mason
#

lol

unique rune
#

Super powerful Forerunner AI
talked to the Gravemind too long and went loopy and turned against the Forerunners

gilded mason
#

He's a Forerunner AI that betrayed them for the Flood.

terse lava
#

The forerunner AI who was built by the forerunners.to fight the flood. He was sent out and was interrogated by a gravemind/last precursor and defectd to the flood

honest rune
#

ok

#

but did the covenant find him or someything?

gilded mason
#

Yes

humble yacht
#

i think humanity is too uppity and pro-freedom to submit to the covenant at threat of annihilation

gilded mason
#

And they know of his actions

terse lava
gilded mason
#

i think humanity is too uppity and pro-freedom to submit to the covenant at threat of annihilation
Nah, I don't think so.

humble yacht
#

i do

honest rune
#

Covies could always lie

terse lava
#

I would say as.long as they are.kept as a fringe they would be fine.

gilded mason
#

If they had to choose between extinction and being part of the Covenant, they'd be dumb not to choose the latter

humble yacht
#

humanity isn't the wisest species

#

"give me liberty or give me death"

gilded mason
#

Eh

honest rune
#

looks back at WW2 and bascially all wars yeah

humble yacht
#

plenty of humans have died for freedom

terse lava
#

It really depends on how much the covenant lean on humanity

#

If they ask for tithes in the form of resources, dont see a problem

humble yacht
#

it's ironic that the two arguing that humanity would be amenable to serving the covenant have covie avatars

terse lava
#

Not like they would put them in mainline military service here.knowing the danger

#

Are you really that shocked Chimera?

humble yacht
#

i didn't say shocked

terse lava
#

Well look at Britain and America.

#

Everyone was fine being a colonists until taxes.and other problems became too much

honest rune
#

Soooo do forerunners have tombs? cause that seems like they would have those

humble yacht
#

tombs? sort of

terse lava
#

All I am saying is if the covenant left humanity alone for the most part things would not be horrible

honest rune
#

and if so why has neither side tried cloning

humble yacht
#

humanity doesn't clone because of ethics

honest rune
#

besides the whole halo kills everything part

humble yacht
#

also technical limits

honest rune
#

Then why wouldn't covies try it for forerunners ?

#

also don't act like ONI doesn't exist

humble yacht
#

nobody said they didn't exist

#

Halsey is the premier scientist on all things forerunner and biological

honest rune
#

I mean the part of human ethnics

humble yacht
#

and even she couldn't make perfect clones

terse lava
#

Wait are you asking why the covenant didnt try to clone forerunners? They never found forerunner remains for starters

gilded mason
#
Then why wouldn't covies try it for forerunners ?```
They'd kinda need Forerunner genetic material to clone Forerunners
humble yacht
#

we don't even know if the covenant had cloning technology

#

it may not have been of interest to them

terse lava
#

Belive broken circle implies they do

honest rune
#

oh I thought they were still like remains of forerunners somewhere thats why I brought up tombs

terse lava
#

When the prophet of inner conviction and his wife were chatting on the young San shyuum women brought, she figured the hierarch would have been happily trying something distasteful like cloning

#

Well there.are forerunner remains here and there

humble yacht
#

the only "remains" of forerunners ever uncovered was the Didact himself

terse lava
#

Incorrect

#

Fossilized ones count

honest rune
#

yea

terse lava
#

Nothing fresh for cloning obviously

humble yacht
#

there isn't viable dna in fossils

honest rune
#

Jeez I just thought of something terrifying

terse lava
#

I never said there was, was only pointing out the covenant found no forerunner remains what so ever

honest rune
#

what if either side had found some way of controlling the flood and if not then brokering a deal with the gravemind

humble yacht
#

not a very realistic "what if" question

honest rune
#

I know thats why its a what if!

versed helm
#

They tried that in The Mona Lisa, didnt work out too well.

humble yacht
#

lol

unique rune
#

Remember the end of Halo 3, when the Flood temporarily helped Chief and the Arbiter?

And then promptly turned on them?

honest rune
#

oh yeah

terse lava
#

Funny enough such an attempt was considered by a group of human ai called the Assembly. They changed their minds later

humble yacht
#

this is where Boromir comes in like "One does not simply control the Flood..."

honest rune
#

brih

#

thats Aragorn

humble yacht
#

:/

honest rune
#

boromir comes like two chapters later lol

humble yacht
#

you're so wrong

honest rune
#

in the tavern

humble yacht
#

i'm obviously referring to the film

honest rune
#

Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

#

Its aragorn in the book

humble yacht
#

where the meme comes from

honest rune
#

sorry

#

wait so

#

we're both right and wrong?

#

nvm

versed helm
honest rune
#

So is the halo movie cannon orr naw since it says Legends?

#

im sorry halo movie Halo Legends

humble yacht
#

Every short in Legends is canon except Odd One Out

honest rune
#

b-but thats the best one

humble yacht
#

or rather, the events are canon, not necessarily the depiction

honest rune
#

So I never knew g=how the covenant got the Jiralhanae to join them.

humble yacht
#

they conquered them

honest rune
#

ah

#

Makes sense

humble yacht
#

it was join or die for the brutes

spiral jewel
#

Dumb question... Was the M392 DMR ever used during Alpha Halo (even though it's not present in CE or CEA)

terse lava
#

Better question is why did they bother with the jiralhanae

humble yacht
#

they were dumb and strong

terse lava
#

Likely were not any on the autumn

honest rune
#

well I mean the nickname brute kind of answers your question

humble yacht
#

plenty of uses for a race of dumb and strong beings

honest rune
#

Take humans for example!

humble yacht
#

well Thel wasn't a fan of the brutes so its not a stretch to think he didn't utilize them often

terse lava
#

I doubt many sangheili did unless forced too

honest rune
#

So when did exactly the covies recruit the brutes? cause it would sense during alpha halo conflict thel was the commander sor no brutes but were they part of the covenant then is the question?

humble yacht
#

like 50 years before the start of the war, or something like that

honest rune
#

ok

#

So kind of a weird question but were there any other factions like the banished? Like ones who turned from the covenant but not like Thel if you get what I mean like still bad guy factions.

humble yacht
#

there are essentially a limitless number of convenant splinter factions

#

and by extension a limitless number of reasons why those factions exist

honest rune
#

ok

#

So another weird one but how were covenant young teached? like on their home or on high charity and were they split or together?

humble yacht
#

very likely split by race

#

i doubt you'd see a classroom with elite young and grunt young learing together

honest rune
#

true

deep pewter
#

Elites seem to train the very young at home, at least

honest rune
#

But why the whole secret father for sangheili?

gilded mason
#

Meritocracy

honest rune
#

hol up while I look up that word

gilded mason
#

They want all young to start on an even playing field without any advantages

honest rune
#

Why not?

#

Wait

#

im dumb

#

but still I find it weird does anyone know if Thel is planning on changing that law?

gilded mason
#

It's not really a law per say

#

Just a tradition

#

One that's not even practiced everywhere

honest rune
#

oh

#

So did humans not think of a safeguard on A.I if they went rampart or rouge?

deep pewter
#

That’s what decommissioning is for

humble yacht
#

they did

terse lava
#

They delete then after 7years of service

humble yacht
#

smart AI have kill codes and manual override codes

#

except Cortana, who managed to remove hers somehow soon after birth

stoic hamlet
#

And Halsey knew but didn’t report her, I think.

#

Could be wrong though.

humble yacht
#

she was more fascinated than anything

honest rune
#

During the early years of most A.I were named after historical figures or mythological gods how come?

humble yacht
#

AI chose their own names and looks

honest rune
#

Oh

#

So how did Chiefs armour get upgraded while in cryo?

humble yacht
#

between 3 and 4? nanobots

gilded mason
#

Eurgh

honest rune
#

huh

humble yacht
#

yep. it's just something we have to deal with

honest rune
#

That doesn't help explain why elites went from lvl 99 mob boss to lvl 1 thug

#

design wise

deep pewter
#

Juls covenant isn’t as well funded as the regular one

stoic hamlet
#

@gilded mason don’t fret, it was neural physics, not Nanobots!

gilded mason
#

Ah, okay! I'm happy now

honest rune
#

No I meant their entire skeletal structure

#

it went from

gilded mason
#

Phenotype differences in the current explanation

honest rune
#

blarg

#

to gra;b

#

Man I miss red vs blue

deep pewter
#

A lot of soldiers in Juls forces are from a colony of Elites separate from Sanghelios

honest rune
#

ok

#

so you're telling me all the covie in halo 4 and 5 are just subspecies?

humble yacht
#

no

gilded mason
#

Subspecies is a bit more extreme

vagrant dagger
#

The covenant is a collection of different species to begin with

gilded mason
#

Phenotype is just all physical differences bewteen individuals

vagrant dagger
#

They have their own home planets

honest rune
#

true

vagrant dagger
#

Like Drones and Brutes are different species

honest rune
#

ok

stoic hamlet
#

It’s like an Asian man versus an African man, kinda.

#

Same species.

#

Just look different

humble yacht
#

... what

gaunt oakBOT
#

@honest rune has been muted for 3 days.
Reason: inappropriate

stoic hamlet
#

Wow

#

Dude

#

Wtf

humble yacht
#

it's been handled

stoic hamlet
#

👍

vagrant dagger
#

Nah. Unless it got retconned, they are different species I'm 90% sure

deep pewter
#

They aren’t

humble yacht
#

Brutes and drones are different species, yes

deep pewter
#

Oh, thought we were still talking about Elites

humble yacht
#

i hope not

#

so tired of that topic

terse lava
#

Agreed

stoic hamlet
#

Thirded

humble yacht
#

that's refreshing

#

🙂

cold roost
#

Who wants to talk about Halsey.

#

Or Locke?

#

Let’s get controversial

light igloo
#

what does 343 consider canon, the fall of reach animations or the books

#

seeing how different they are

cold roost
#

The game

#

They are all so different

keen canopy
#

Both Halo Reach and Halo: The Fall of Reach are canon. the 2019 edition of TFoR is the definitive version of TFoR, including it's comic and animated adaptations @light igloo

cold roost
#

Bungie kind of altered the whole cannon of halo with the Reach game, and from then on, went with it.

keen canopy
#

Bungie did change a lot with Halo Reach but they at least let Nylund write Halsey's Journal to smooth things over with TFoR. Then 343i made them work even better together with things like data drops.

cold roost
#

That is very true.

#

But who else is mad about how on the wrath and wrath anhur armor in h5 the kukri isn’t on the shoulder. And how Noble is symetrical.

#

Cuz I’m mad

#

It don’t look good.

stoic hamlet
#

I just don’t like the armour to begin with. It makes no sense as a variant.

#

None of Noble’s gear does, really.

cold roost
#

Yeah, other than to get people to buy that. Because nostalgia

#

I think the only good armor is Indomitable Eröd.

#

A good armor set personally is Mako Cthonic or any of the Recon or Hellcat sets

#

Just forget Seeker even exists

#

Cuz it sucks

stoic hamlet
#

Certain H5 Sets are good, IMO the more garish and “out there” sets don’t fit (aka most of them), and Halo would do better without that sort of style.

#

IMO anyways

cold roost
#

Agreed

versed helm
#

I personally like Helioskrill and Helljumper

cold roost
#

Same

stoic hamlet
#

Those are some of the good ones.

cold roost
#

What variant tho

versed helm
#

Indeed

#

I guess all of their variants

cold roost
#

Feetfirst or normal

versed helm
#

Prob the normal one actually

cold roost
#

I like the normal helm and feetfirst armor

versed helm
#

All normal for me

stoic hamlet
#

The only two “out there sets I like in H5/4 is RECLUSE (for the lore) and IDK, I think PIONEER is kinda cool, it makes me think of like, what Spartans could be if they weren’t warriors but more explorers.

cold roost
#

Cool

versed helm
#

I loved Prefect from H4

cold roost
#

Pioneer is cool, but let’s acknowledge that any of the Foehammer sets exist.

stoic hamlet
#

PREFECT was cool, but it didn’t seem a good MJOLNIR variant, IMO.

cold roost
#

Cuz the suck

stoic hamlet
#

Lorewise it was awesome

#

But it departed a bit from the established style for me. (PREFECT, I mean)

versed helm
#

Yeah but out of most of the H4 armor I think Prefect is my favorite

cold roost
#

PREFECT-class Mjolnir is a variant of the MJOLNIR [GEN2] manufactured by the Watershed Division. It is reverse-engineered from the personal armor worn by Forerunner Prefects.[1]

#

Straight from the wiki

#

Which made this armor cool

#

I’ve seen Fotus get a lot of hate, opinions?

#

Anyone

terse lava
#

It's just a silly unicorn helmet, woo...

warm ridge
#

Oh wait you're talking about the Fotus helmet, ok.

inner basin
#

I would love to see the FOTUS Helmet be used to kill someone, either because it was thrown as if it were a knife, or they headbutted an enemy with it

versed helm
#

charging headfirst into battle a la FOTUS

inner basin
#

Hell jumpers are feet-first, FOTUS wearers are head-first

versed helm
#

what if a hell jumper wore a FOTUS?

carmine sleet
#

They'd still be an ODST

#

Just one with a horn on their head

versed helm
#

but would they jump feet first to stomp, or head first to impale?

bright briar
#

They'd stand in the drop pod upside down, with a little hole in the bottom for the horn to poke through.

tulip pivot
#

please write your favorite character and why

#

Catherine Halsey

#

she is in between good and evil

#

she is like the stereotype of the kidnaper that falls in love with his kidnaper but it's like a mother to children relationship

#

with the person he kidnaps sorry

carmine sleet
#

she is in between good and evil
she is like the stereotype of the kidnaper that falls in love with his kidnaper but it's like a mother to children relationship
with the person he kidnaps sorry
I wouldn't say she's a stereotype at all. I don't recall her behaviour to be that of a stereotypical kidnapper at all. Plus, she is clearly on the side of good, even if her methods are ones I cannot condone. Morally, she is very much in the wrong, given that kidnapping and raising children to be soldiers is horrible

tulip pivot
#

i said you could compare it to a kidnapper

#

and she is only good at the end of her life

carmine sleet
#

She's not dead