#lore-and-universe
1 messages · Page 317 of 1
And agreed. Denning has been doing great with his stories for Halo
I think part of it is just that Fred and Kelly's VAs have much more memorable voices to me
Granted, Fred is played by Travis Willingham so he's kinda hard to forget
For some reason I always expected Fred to have a Latino accent
No basis for it. Just did.
This is up till Legends, I mean.
I see
Honestly though, when it came to Fred, I kinda always had what Travis' Fred voice sounds like in mind. Really hope he's back to voice him again in the future
Well, the mostly likely situation is that none of the VO changes.
And truth be told, I suddenly find myself a little worried at the prospect of H5's squads going away.
I hope there are still opportunities to fight alongside Blue.
I was re-reading parts of Oblivion and I found a line of dialogue where Linda DOES use a contraction
Oh, where?
so it’s not even entirely consistent
If Blue don't show up, I hope there's a good reason
In one of the chapters where they’re interacting with the Castoffs, early on I think @versed helm
What word was it?
And I hope that reason isn't that they were killed. Because Blue Team should be there in Infinite
Let me check
I think I might not be upset if Blue dies in Shadows of Reach for some reason.
I think you might be a psycho
Possible
StoneWall, don't tell me you also have a heart of stone (Sorry, couldn't resist)
Now that I finished Hunters in the Dark I feel so bad for Tragic Solitude.
Splendid Dust had a bad end
page 154 hardcover, “I’m” @versed helm
Hm.
Why not just trap the Huragok and Vale and kill the rest of the group.
He was interested in Vale for some reason.
Why not swarm Earth with an army of Sentinels, then start mining?
The Retrievers were ok.
He died because of the team on the Ark.
Because he didn't kill them.
Which is stupid.
Or why not fire the Halos and not even use the portal.
Just use slipspace.
Go to Earth and fix the portal.
@hot tartan you need to change your name in accordance to the rules and guidelines
Per the #471730170768654352, usernames and avatars must be appropriate for this server (no unusual unicode characters, slurs, offensive material, etc). We do not set nicknames for users.
Ooooo small preview for the book. Music!

I can definitely imagine a Spartan listening to Queen.
I would be unhappy if blue team died
I can definitely imagine Kelly listening to Killer Queen.
It just works for some reason.
It would be poetic for Blue to die on Reach.
Well if there was gonna be a place
And yes, I have seen RvB
And as soon as I hear those voices
If Cortana somehow causes their deaths, it would fuel Chief to defeat her in Infinite
My mind disassociates them from Spartans
What about freelancers.
I think he already has motivation enough.
VO isn't professional enough xD
If Cortana somehow causes their deaths, it would fuel Chief to defeat her in Infinite
@feral perch I don't think Chief needs any more reason to fight her
What about them? Desolate?
Also freelancers in general are pretty cringe.
Hey, it’s just an idea.
They are far more related to spartans than the reds and blues.
Hey, don't say that. The Freelancers are great
Besides I think the way they look is based on halo infinite look.
I don’t want Blue Team to die in Shadows of Reach. But right now, I think I wouldn’t riot if they do. That may change.
Also freelancers in general are pretty cringe.
@versed helm
They’re not related because they’re not part of the halo universe
Different universe
Doesn't matter.
It does.
It's something both of them share.
Yes, they can fight and that is a similarity, but the Knights of the Round Table can fight as well. Does that mean King Arthur is now related to the Master Chief because of that similarity?
Do they? How do we know the armor they wear is actually Mjolnir?
I don't remember King Arthur wearing Mjolnir
Oh, you were referring to RvB. That armour is not Mjolnir
I don't remember King Arthur wearing Mjolnir
@carmine sleet lmao. freelancers.
I guess you're right. They don't seem to have shields.
I was just trying to say that if you have a hard time thinking of the reds and blues as Spartans, it could be easier with freelancers.
Obviously none of them are spartans.
The Reds and Blues were never meant to be Spartans
Nobody was having a hard time seeing them as Spartans either
My mind disassociates them from Spartans
@versed helm this.
It will be far easier to imagine Spartans doing all sorts of things.
@wet pollen and this.
Freelancers are so over the top they're basically just as goofy
I feel like I should be hiding my profile picture from you now, Looters
If I recall correctly, it's because of one of the principles of animation.
I feel like I should be hiding my profile picture from you now, Looters
@carmine sleet lmao
Freelancers are so over the top they're basically just as goofy
@versed helm well, Spartans are described far more agile in the books than what they seem able to do in the games.
There's a difference between agile and over the top
Do vinyl records still exist in the 26th century?
Presumably
Like, we're not going to see a Spartan jumping off of a building, skydiving a large box into the back of a Pelican and then somehow managing to catch the back of a Warthog before carrying on a chase their teammates weren't apart of down a busy highway
I wouldn’t want to see RTs style of choreography anywhere near an official game
They should have been blurs.
Chief never should have missed a punch tbh
The comparison I like to make with Spartan speed is... y'all ever played Dead Space?
Yep
Nope :c
Stasis, right?
Aah, Twitchers
Fighting a Spartan would be a bit like that
Unnerving to a similar extent too
But they'd have very efficient movements
None of these huge haymakers you see in Halo 5
Imagine fighting a [CORRUPTER]
There's a bit from Palace Hotel where Chief kills a jackal by stabbing it in the brain, using his fingers as like a stabbing implement
Basically what he did to Keyes
That's pure Spartan
Sick
I thought he just punched through Keyes' skull?
Yeah he punched it
In The Flood it describes him sorta
Shovelling
It's pretty full-on
Anyway, another thing I think is pretty characteristic of Spartans fighting
That bit from Fireteam Raven where Chief just like, tosses a grunt into the ceiling offhandedly while engaging other enemies
That's what I like to see.
I think Spartans can run at like 60 kmph.
The Flood isn’t as bad as many fans say it is
I wouldn’t skip it in a series read-through.
The Flood was the first Halo book I read, actually.
The gritty military-ness and ultra-violence really shaped the way I look at Halo.
Honestly, the biggest issue with it is just that it's outdated.
And also the bits where Dietz just recanted gameplay
But everything he added was kinda brilliant.
Oh.
Then why are they populated.
What's the point of saving a species if they are going to die when the Halos fire.
I think the rings were re-populated... after the firing?
For... aesthetic purposes?
Maybe I'm wrong
You are
Yeah, that'd make the Forerunners a bit too extra.
Lifeforms on a halo are safe from the blast
We see that in the 2nd forerunner novel where the halo tested at charrum Hakkor and later the capital battle. Primitive humans had been put in that ring decades earlier and witnessed both blasts
A halo ring is capable of putting areas as well into stasis
Wonder where I got my wrong notion from.
I dont know
Thanks.
and
How fast is the blast?
The beam energy of the installations cannot travel slower than light, and ultimately, will propagate at near-infinite velocities.
Halo Silentium.
It doesn't say how fast tho.
Fast enough for some seriously screwy relativistic effects.
I think that for the blast to cover the whole galaxy it takes something like...
3 days?
Worth bearing in mind that it's 7 separate rings covering their own area.
As if it could be forgotten xD
Sometimes I see some stuff in reddit and it annoys me because its wrong. Like thinking that John's presence on the life pod killed the marines and pilot.
"Heroic difficulty is canon difficulty."
The one thing that annoys me the most is when people claim that Master Chief has the Didact's geas
CE?
Oh wth.
Discord bad.
I sometimes think forerunners are shown less powerful than they really are.
How could possibly a human destroy something made by these gods.
They're not gods. The covenant believed them to be gods because the Forerunner tech they found was far superior to their own, making them seem like gods in the Covey's vision
The forerunners are just extinct aliens who were eons ahead of 2500's humanity
Their technology was far more advanced than what the Covenant has
And yet some 10000 years old species can destroy their machines.
Being more advanced does not mean their technology will be indestructible
It should.
Plus, pretty sure all the races in Halo are older than 10000 years old
Humans.
I was thinking about the Retrievers from Hunters in the Dark.
I thought armor was pretty standard across forerunner ships.
Or sentinels.
Weak.
Their shields are a joke.
Their main weapon too.
You could easily fit a Spartan Laser inside a sentinel.
Well, it's not like the Forerunners had time to build a perfect Sentinel, but yes they are jokes compared to other Forerunner tech
Maybe it's because of gameplay.
If one sentinel could kill you in one second Halo CE would be unbeatable.
Wait? You were going off of gameplay for how strong stuff is in lore?
No no no.
Lore and gameplay.
I think forerunners should be more powerful.
Because that's what they want to make you think. Forerunners are powerful.
I mean, just throw John to a shield world and bam, no more shield world.
Gone.
Reduced to atoms.
Why isn't the standard forerunner weapon something like a Spartan Laser but with no need of cooldown? You could replace those weak Halo 4 turrets with a bunch of them and no intruder will get in.
That little forerunner pistol is... a joke. I actually laughed when I first used it. There is no need for it to exist if it can't deal more damage than a plasma pistol. Forerunners are big, why make a pistol so tiny and weak?
Crawlers use Boltshots.
As do Manipulars.
I might even say that they're intentionally small and weak because Forerunners were an extremely class-based society.
Crawlers use Boltshots.
@feral perch that explains the size.
But... Idk I still feel like forerunners should be intelligent and advanced enough to make something powerful and small. After all, the whole point of crawlers is to defeat enemies, right?
Maybe the Covenant didn't give every grunt a Fuel Rod gun because they don't have enough.
The only depiction of Crawlers during the Forerunner era that I've seen is of Abaddon's Crawlers in Promises to Keep.
I have no idea what they were used for during the height of the Flood war.
I mean.
You still have to remember that the BoltShot's power in-game relative to other things isn't fully representative of canon.
Wut.
I've only seen Knights fighting the Flood, not other Prometheans.
There is no need for it to exist if it can't deal more damage than a plasma pistol. Forerunners are big, why make a pistol so tiny and weak?
Presumably it'd do more damage than a Plasma Pistol, just like how Plasma Pistols are super deadly in-universe compared to their dinky in-game counterparts...
They nerfed it for gameplay purposes?
Uh.
Yeah.
Pretty much everything is, otherwise Halo really wouldn't be any fun to play.
Ok then the Boltshot isn't actually that bad...
I was expecting something like Spartan Laser damage.
Lmao.
Maybe I'm insane.
The Boltshot does not blow up tanks like a Splaser does in lore
Nah, youre fine.
The ones from Halo 4 were closer to the overall destructiveness.
The Incin and the Binary anyway
That's what troubles me.
Actually to be entirely fair Slip, the Splaser causes anything it hits to explode.
See the Package, where Fred literally detonates an entire platform of Covenant.
I would expect any kind of forerunner weapon to absolutely destroy me in an instant.
Huh?
Game?
Needless to say gameplay does NOT equal lore XD
Case in point and a favorite of mine;
The wraith mortar? In canon each shot excavates a 25 foot wide glowing hole in the ground.
Actually to be entirely fair Slip, the Splaser causes anything it hits to explode.
See the Package, where Fred literally detonates an entire platform of Covenant.
@last anchor that's the kind of damage I was looking for.
Yeah thats what it can do in canon.
Theoretically Selene's Lance could do even MORE since its overclocked...
Third Spartan Laser variant in Halo 5.
You have the base Spartan Laser
Then the Endgame which is anti-infantry use (less damage, faster charge and fire time)
And the Selenes Lance, which is the opposite (longer charge, targeting laser damages, hits like a truck)
Ohh.
I think the Lance actually has a reduced charge time compared to the base M6/E.
What's the name of that forerunner weapon that is like a fuel rod gun?
Actually I think it deals more damage.
Incineration Cannon
The Scattershot is like a shotgun.
The Incineration Cannon is like a rocket launcher.
Naa it a rocket launcher
That divide when they explode.
Incineration Cannon
It shoots a singular shot which splits into 3
It's got same principle of a cluster grenade
Theres only like, five forerunner weapons, we'll get em XD
Just very close together.
I think it is 4
Its 4 Im pretty sure yeah.
It's not like a shotgun
A cluster type rocket launcher
No this shoots 1 shot that splits into 4
Hm.
Shotgun short range
Also they tend to be more spread out, whereas the reason the Incin is so nasty is its cluster charge has RANGE.
Shotgun shoot bullet that shoot littler bullet.
xd
Then you could make a smaller weapon that fires only one of the explosive thingys.
Something like a grenade launcher.
Just an Incineration Cannon but four times less powerful.
That weapon would be smaller and could be carried by Crawlers.
Instead of those stupid pistols.
Yeah the Crawler Snipers from 4 were bad enough jeez...
Also they have loads.
Honestly the sandbox is getting almost cluttered at this point with how many weapons they got
There's tons of weapons in 5
Good to hear.
But what about the SPNKr?
It's in multiplayer.
Nah. The campaign only has the M57 Pilum.
The Pilum makes more sense than the SPNKr
I honestly don't care.
I think the ridiculousness of the SPNKr is overstated.
I didn't say the SPNKr was ridiculous.
🙄
How could you possibly decide to erase the SPNKr from existence?
It's the same.
... no
ye
that except the opposite
The SPNKr is in Halo 5
Some guy said it does not appear in the campaign.
It does not appear in the campaign.
in*
That is correct, but that doesn't mean it's not in the game
It was added after launch when a lot of people had the same reaction as you.
That is a pretty good question.
I'm now serious.
You don't encounter AA Wraiths in the campaign of Halo 5 either, doesn't mean there isn't any in the game
I consider it to be a good design that has no reason to exist.
Exactly.
Im jujst wondering what made the UNSC decide ot have a launcher like that.
The SPNKr is so beautiful.
Seriously the weight on that thing must be astronomical.
Generally speaking a theme with Halo 5 is that all the weapons are kinda, made more realistic.
The Pilum is fine.
Or rather they're made more tacticool.
Wonderful word.
Which Im fine with tbh.
Why cant the UNSC have multiple kinds of rocket launchers even.
Unpopular opinion, I prefer the Pilum over the SPNKr
Perhaps someone at 343 thought the SPNKr didn't fit in with that more operator aesthetic.
I mean it doesnt really, its kinda...bulky and weird looking.
It looks like a hammer rather than a scalple
Perhaps someone at 343 thought the SPNKr didn't fit in with that more operator aesthetic.
@versed helm that is probably what happened but... how.
Why
What
Who could do that.
Maybe a noob.
New employee?
no
New to Halo.
If 343 wanted to be operator they should have probably paid more attention to the obvious glaring inconsistencies I bring up fairly frequently.
Instead they just stepped in doodoo for no reason.
Why would they let someone without tried-and-true decision making skills change something like that?
I don't know.
Obviously someone with some experience was responsible.
I mean to be fair the Pilum's animation and reload is pretty cool.
Like
The SPNKr isn't the be-all end-all of Halo.
It's attitudes like yours, Desolate, that are probably why we don't know anything about Halo Infinite yet.
Let's not be immature about this.
I'm serious.
Seriously tho.
I meant to Desolate
ah
If Halo fans were fair, we might have gotten a few screenshots or something at this point.
I can't be the only one who thinks like this.
You're not. There are lots of people who agree with you.
:/
Part of why we're not engaging in such a spirited discussion is that this conversation has happened about 30 trillion times since Halo 5 released.
It's like
Just beginning to die off.
Clearly 343 has gotten the message if the Infinite toys are anything to go by.
Wasn't the SPNKr held by one of the figures?
I believe so.
That's good news.
Why would anyone want toys anyway.
Lmao
Idk maybe I would buy one.
I'd like it if they call it the Jackhammer in Halo Infinite.
What?
That's the colloquial term UNSC soldiers use for SPNKr-compatible rocket tubes.
They call them jackhammers.
The missile?
The tubes.
The tube is the launcher.
I'm sorry it's just that english isn't my first language.
The twin M19 SSM tube unifies with a fire control module to become the M41 MAV/AW
I mean. It's not like the SPNKr was ever really called anything other than "the rocket launcher" in the other games. Calling it the Jackhammer just gives it another nickname.
It would be nice to hear the term used.
I am now depressed.
Well I certainly missed a bit again
Someone may have called it that in ODST
Honestly, give me the Pilum as a purely ground to ground rocket launcher for ground based targets. Then give me the SPNKr as a surface to air rocket launcher or something like that and I'd be fine
Agreed.
I'd like to see multiple Assault Rifle variants in-game too. MA5B and MA40 side-by-side please.
That would be awesome.
What they cannot do
I just want the Stanchion as a usable weapon
Is have the MA5B fire its majestic 60 rounds
And the MA40 fire a 32-36 round magazine
60 plastic rounds.
And keep pretending that they're firing the same round
Give the MA5B caseless ammunition.
But then you don't get the tumbling brass
I think just give it like, a visibly extended mag
hmmmmm
Honestly if it was up to me I'd go all-in MW-style customization
That would mess with the design.
Yeah, who cares
Lmao
like this
"Hey guys, we just wanted to announce for Infinite that we're gonna have the MA5B and MA40 side by side. And to piss off one guy in particular, they're still gonna be firing the same ammo!"
Give the MA5B a drum mag
The design in CE cannot exist alongside other designs and retain the ammo count
oh nvm
KAJXKAKDNAKDK
Absurd
LOL @unique rune
To the extent that people will have their immersion broken. You would have your immersion broken
You don't need to be a gun nerd for this to be blindingly obvious
It's like
Preschool stuff
How many things can fit in this thing
Clearly not this many
They're 7.62x51mm FMJ rounds.
Whoops.
They have a cartridge neck size of 12mm.
Big ants.
The overall cartridge is about 70mm.
Introducing the Slipspace™ magazine
I've done the quick maths
welcome to tonight's piece of Looter Theater
Looters knows what he's talking about, Desolate
He does
I'm pretty new to this server.
"We at Misriah Armory are proud to announce new Slipspace ammunition, so now you can fire more bullet per bullet"
Please don't kill me.
Dont worry we wont kill you
Thanks.
Brand you with bthe mark of shame maybe
"Parade you through the city by your entrails" still hasn't been ruled out
Anyway basically how I'd do it
Is you get the CE-style MA5B
But it only has the same ammo count as the other MA5s/MA40s which have the same magazine
What if 7.62x51 in the future is made out of a ~titanium alloy~ that compresses like rubber to fit in the mag XD
And then there'd be some kind of extended mag variant or weapon customization thing
And when it fires it turns hard as... bullets.
But truth be told it'd probably just be best if 343 retconned all MA5s into firing different ammo.
Since you could only fit about 24 rounds of 7.62x51 in the magazines seen anyway
I just realized there's probably going to be some people who hear the term "MA40" and think that it's "MA4D"
._.
ye
hopefully it's spelled out in the HUD then
It's a bit of a non-issue
Why not just use the plasma pistol.
It's so good.
And you don't worry about ammo making sense.
I guess.
Unless you're some kind of plasma nerd.
Covenant weapons best
Plasma based weapons use batteries
Battery nerd*
Batteries don't have the same storage issues as a weapon's magazine
But you can figure out if a battery has enough power to fire certain amount of shots.
If you are given the specs.
Yeah, but the specs can change if it's sci fi.
ye
Indeed
You just claim it's a battery that uses tech we don't have today.
We could say it is battery powered by vacuum energy
Vacuum energy?
And only goes dead due to the battery unable to keep going
I've never heard that term.
It's the energy used to power vacuum cleaners /s
It's freaky quantum stuff
Dark energy?
Too advanced for the Covenant. Probably.
Yes, in the halo verse, it applies to energy that forerunners used for their technolgy
It’s when you use the power of other universes’ Big Bangs as an energy source, or something like that
Yes, infinite power
That's precursor stuff.
No
Nope
It’s Forerunner stuff
If it involves other universes...
Precursor is neural physics
It involves other universes in the form of consuming the energy of an infinite baby universes, wiping them out
That's vacuum en8
Energy
It should be unlimited then.
It is
No recharging then?
shrug
Set invulnerability.
To some extent
Not fully everything but most major stuff
Heat would still be an issue, at some point, the shields would shut off due to overheating
Just put a fan.
lol
Use that heat to generate more energy.
Refrigerators should generate energy.
Ok?
The government is stealing our hot banana energy.
Desolate, I don't think you quite understand how energy works
Jskdjsjksk
You can't generate energy, you can only change the state the energy is in
Hot banana has energy.
You put hot banana into refrigerator. Government steals hot banana energy.
.....
Why don't you try that Desolate, tell us how much energy you get
When you plug in your refrigerator it's actually generating energy and sending it to power plants.
LMAO
Tomorrow I'm like guys turn on the TV.
Hm, anyway, anyone think the covenant could have unlocked vacuum energy?
I sure missed some... nonsense.
Yea...
Why is that censored
anyways
Can someone explain to me about this Neuro metaphysics or whatever.
(Lore noob)
One moment
It's a concept which is meant to be relatively enigmatic.
Ahh i see
In short it's the science of sentience.
What do they use it for, what are it's applications
Well, if you do it right, you can manipulate reality in some pretty esoteric ways.
It's kinda hard to speculate about how it works
Since neural physics seems to relate heavily to consciousness
And the nature of consciousness is probably the greatest philosophical mystery of the modern age.
Could it be used as a weapon?
Basically, it's what you can achieve once you can understand what makes us not just alive but aware.
legend has it that the Precursors could make a mean apple pie
No wonder the forerunner rebelled. They must have preferred chocolate silk pie
Why didn't the precursors defend themselves?
Whiny buggers
As for why they didn't defend, they likely wanted to experience it as apparently no creation of theirs had rebelled before
Interesting.
Honestly
We know nothing about that went down
All we've heard are the ramblings of a manipulative, vengeful entity
It's probably best not to speculate too much unless we get something solid
Is the Domain working?
.... Yes?
It's not what it used to be
The firing of the Halo array is harmful to neural physics... stuff
And the Domain is neural physics stuff
So it was damaged
But Cortana seems to be making use of it
Apparently he was incorrect.
Or lied.
Very likely.
In an attempt to stop the forerunners from firing.
Why did I even explain it.
Nowait.
He could of ment simply the data and everything in the domain be wiped out
When the gravemind told the Librarian about the Domain, that it would be destroyed, the Halos had already fired.
"You don't understand me, Librarian. The effects of Halo radiation are already felt."
What does that mean.
They were preparing to fire?
Huh
Alpha Halo had detected pre echoes of the entire Halo array firing before they were
Think of me as a 2 years old kid.
.............ok?
Now try to explain that again.
....the halo from the first game, alpha halo, made a report to bornsteller. It said that an echo of the full array blast happened
an echo
Yes, a pre echo
like when you shout in a big room?
In other words the blast went so fast at infinite velocity That it was detected through space and time
Good
Thanks!
Welcome
Then why would the gravemind lie about the Domain?
If there was nothing they could do.
Just to make the forerunners suffer?
Or maybe the Domain was located outside the galaxy.
Maybe a part of it was safe, like a backup.
That would explain why the didact couldn't access it.
It wanted to give them pain, to know even their final victory was an utter defeat
They beat the flood, but lost their entire culture, history, knowledge, and all the minds of countless forerunners who were in the domain(on death, forerunners' minds apparently were uploaded into the domain)
All gone, nothing left
Except it somehow survived.
In a way, I would say like a box
The box contained all forerunner stuff. The array wiped out everything in it
And damaged it
It was fixed, but nothing there
Either way anything about the precursors wasn't going to be recovered.
So that's
good?
I mean, they didn't destroy the information about precursors.
That's gone too, everythingbthe precursors put in the domain
It was long gone before the Halos fired.
It was there still, just not usable by forerunners
It was one of the forerunner books. Information was distorted with the passage of time until
yes
that
It was "locked" in a sense
Do you think Halo 5's story is bad?
I am not fond of it
People are, I think, overly harsh on it.
I would describe it as serviceable.
I'm actually quite fond of the ending, or rather, the endpoint.
What is fond?
I feel so stupid.
Aficionado.
Right.
I don't understand why people hate it so much.
I mean the chief hunt part was stupid imo.
But after reading the forerunner trilogy I started to like Halo 5.
Well the elephant in the room would be usually Cortana coming back, alongbwith the Warden
Still an awful decision imo. Like I still don’t understand how Brian Reed even came up with that idea instead of literally anything that makes a bit more sense
Yea, and for me personally, no playable sangheili. Visit the homeworld, get their items in forge, but no sangheili themselves. Anyway though had high charity survived the war, could it have been useful?
If cleared of the Flood, maybe?
Though without the Anodyne Spirit present powering it might be a bit of an issue...
Looks like I missed... something..
Yes in this case had the flood failed at getting the city or at least, contained
Unsc dog
Yo what if there is a plot twist where you find out Johnson turned into a promethean and teamed up with 343 guilty sparks and you have to fight them
.......what?
Yo what if there is a plot twist where you find out Johnson turned into a promethean and teamed up with 343 guilty sparks and you have to fight them
@versed helm That wouldn't be a plot twist, that would be a very bad retcon that makes no sense
unsc use doggos
I saw something that said th unsc use dogs in the conflict might be wrong
Like sgt.laddie a dog
I doubt they did
maybe he means dog tags
I don’t think he does. It sounds like he’s talking about the animal
He means did humanity use dogs against the covenant
That would probably be animal cruelty
If that’s a thing in the Halo universe
But they didn’t (use dogs) so it’s all good
Waste of time too
I mean besides from lore standpoints, it probably wouldn’t sit well with audiences and could have some real world implications
Well yeah but not as bad as reading about dogs dying to superhot plasma
Well there is also the point that dogs would have been useless When facing the covenant.
You know now that I think about it, the covenant did not use any domesticated creatures either
they had plans to use the guta be creatures ridden by the covenatn
the covenant did have creatures
I have seen that art of kig-yar riding them but ultimately the closest we had in canon was the shariqoui I think
Some fun stuff. Me and some of the guys on Halopedia have been figuring out where Farkas Lake is, and we're pretty sure we found a match - south-west of Alexandria https://i.gyazo.com/39a365991fec6521ab46435959bf1593.mp4
Remind me, Farkas Lake?
👍
So does ONI only concern itself with things that involve the Navy and Marines? Or does it also cover all the other branches?
Do you mean do they use other operatives? or what
Is their jurisdiction only with things concerning the Navy or Marine Corps. So if the Army had a secret program would ONI still be overseeing it? Would the Army have it's own Intelligence department?
Yeah.
Colonel Ackerson, who was responsible for the Spartan III program, was a member of the Army.
ONI worked alongside him.
Same thing with NOBLE. NOBLE were technically part of the Army as of The Fall of Reach, and ONI was able to use them to achieve its goals.
Why was the main intelligence ONI? In real life, The United States Office of Naval Intelligence exists, but isn't as functioning as the CIA
Because the UNSC is the United Nations Space Command. Their ONI is vastly different and more authoritative than the USN ONI.
Have to keep in mind that the events surrounding Halo are roughly 400-500 years in the future and a lot changes.
It could have been. But this is how Bungie wrote the lore 😆
aight, I guess ONI is more interesting in a way
We should see FORECON, and as a small easter egg, make an NCO called, Sergeant Castle
When they are referring to Office of Naval Intelligence they are treating the UNSC rank structure similar to how the US Navy operates. I suppose it's because Space is like the Ocean and Space Ships are like, well, "Ships"... as though they are sailing through the ocean of space.
Like Space Marines too lol
I like how a lieutenant addresses Johnson as a, "Sir."
According to my understanding, the UNSC is a conglomerate of countries on Earth like the modern day United Nations. Except, the UNSC has WAY more power. And during the events of the Halo universe they have established and operate their own versions of Army, Navy, Marines, and Air Force. Each with their own established jurisdiction and all falling under the UNSC umbrella. However, differences that come to mind would be how the Navy of the UNSC operates as the largest branch and in many cases overseeing the other 3. Hence why ONI overseas various operations from other branches. Not to mention that ONI is a shady group in its own right. They don't really follow established rules and operate in a shadow kind of environment. Similar to how the CIA of modern day operates, or like the KGB. They have almost too much governmental power because of the Emergency powers given to them to quell the insurrectionists. This in turn just carries over after First Contact at Harvest and the rest is history so to speak.
What happened to Arbiter after Halo 3?
If my memory serves me correctly he went back to the remnants of the Covenant to rebuild the Covenant, however, this time with a different ideology. I think it is touched upon in Halo4 but this is why you are still fighting Covenant. Because they splintered into different factions all fighting for control. Essentially, the multi-headed hydra of the Covenant was slain, however the heads now fighting against each other to determine who should lead.
Halo 4 was my first Halo game
When I first seen the Elites, I was scared, my sister was scared too after seeing an Elite.
I highly recommend playing through the Trilogy. Although Halo 1 and 2 show their age, they are great games. Halo 3 holds up surprisingly well. Halo 3 ODST is sort of a bonus side story built into the events of Halo 3. It's optional, but still a fan acclaimed game that was beloved at the time.
I also play Halo 1 and 2
Halo 3 is the Finale so of the first 3 games, so you should definitely give it a playthrough. It answers a lot of unanswered questions that you may have from Halo 4.
I finished Halo 4 after 1 year
I'm planning to buy Halo MCC
My mom introduced me to Halo
Halo MCC currently only has Halo Reach and Halo 1. The others will be releasing later.
Halo Reach is another great game for learning more about the Halo Universe and it's beginning.
What happened to the Flood after Halo 3?
It’s not as coordinated since the Gravemind was heavily injuried. The flood still had a presence aboard the High Charity wreckage and attempted to make a new Gravemind during the events of HW2’s dlc
Awakening the Nightmare
There are still pockets of flood research facilities left across galactic space as well with flood samples stored within
I think on the Ark, when High Charity invaded during halo 3. However the explosion wasn’t enough to destroy all of high charity. So a lot of flood still live within high charity. But is sealed off.
Essentially that
@unique hornet You asked about how Marcus Stacker survived the Battle of I04... long story short he probably didn't because he was never there in the first place. The Stacker CE model only has one scripted appearance in Halo CE, and that was taken by Waller in The Flood.
He ended up in Halo 2 as a generic, unnamed Sergeant, who Bungie internally called "Sergeant Gruff". And then the crew who worked on ADatB decided to canonize him as "Sergeant Stacker" (the first time that was ever stated as his in-universe name, rather than just Bungie calling him Sergeant insert voice actor here). Then again he was never named externally, the only place you can see his name is in the Making of ADatB ViDoc where each of the ODST's in-universe names are displayed.
He ended up in Halo 3 again as a generic sergeant, and was never named. Bungie later canonized Halo 3 Stacker in Halo Reach's Armory. They also decided to put Stacker in the Battle of Reach in a place that makes it incredibly dubious for him to somehow get aboard the PoA.
And then Halo 4 came along and 343i again canonized Halo 2/Halo 3/Halo Reach Stacker. But to this day there's actually nothing connecting the Halo CE marine Sergeant to the Marcus Stacker character. At the end of the day we have Gunnery Sergeant Marcus Stacker, an in-universe character across Halo 2-4, and "Sergeant Stacker" a Marine Sergeant model in Halo CE voiced by Pete Stacker, who represents a number of in-universe characters, including Waller.
I'm of the opinion nobody else survived the Ring's Destruction. We know both 343i and Bungie consider/considered Chips Dubbo a joke character. And we know Bungie put marketing material lowest on the Canon Hierarchy, and 343i consider Believe "non-core canon". Grim even recently wrote off the entirety of Deliver Hope as just "a commercial" and told us to not take much stock in it. So that writes off Thomas Chang as well.
I am the polar opposite. I believe Chips Dubbo is a canon character, and while his appearance in CE is the only dubious part of the canon (same with Stacker), their appearances thereafter to me are canonical
One can make the argument they escaped the ring via other means, maybe using Covenant air craft (perhaps a Phantom). Maybe other ODSTs on the PoA joined them as Stacker is known to be an ODST too
His appearance in CE isn't the only dubious part. Dubbo has a scripted line on Regret's temple looking up at High Charity's fleet arriving. No way out of that situation alive either.
And ONI didn't mention finding any survivors in Nightfall.
They didn’t mention it, or they said they didn’t find any survivors
It’s been a while since I’ve watched Nightfall
Me too, but I don't think they mentioned survivors at all.
Either way, There's still exactly zero evidence connecting the CE Sergeant to actual Stacker.
Well it could be due to it being classified as Johnson mentions how he escaped was classified to the Master Gunnery Sergeant in the armoury.
As for the Sergeant and Stacker that is just an assumption
Even if you go on the assumption that M. Stacker was on I04, there's exactly zero places he can appear canonically in CE. His only scripted appearance is taken by Waller.
The rest are all randomized appearances and have no scriped dialogue, thus they can't be taken as canon.
Well at least now I know he wasn’t canonically there during CE’s events
Makes sense with how we know Johnson and John returned to Earth without breaking the Cole Protocol
Even if others survived, and got picked up later on by ONI, they'd be back to earth too late to participate in Halo 2.
It still upsets me how many ODSTs could have survived CE, but because Silva decided to take the T&R (carrying Flood in the hold) to Earth, Melissa made a brave decision to sever the Cruiser's fiber-optics connection to the reactor's bridge, blowing it up. It’s a shame that Silva became delusional as this may have been able to have been avoided
Yep that always gets to me too. I wish Melissa just knocked him out, took command, brought the ship a safe distance from the ring, and then focused on clearing it of Flood
She was okay with giving up her life, why not just take a courtmartial on the chin.
I get it though, the Flood are literally a nightmare come to life and she didn't want it spreading
Yeah she made a split decision so that’s what she did. But she could’ve at least attempted to stop Silva first, it’s not like they were near Earth or anything
Was for the best anyway
Had they taken the Vessel into orbit, they would have trouble making sure no flood were in the hull of the Truth and Reconciliation
Also, could the flood have seen the co-ordinates entered into the ship and figured out where Earth was? Assuming they didn't know if the Flood already knew or not.
Well the flood needs the proto gravemind to get that info. Although curiously the infection form that took Keyes never got it either
Well the Flood can’t just see the co-ordinates they entered even if they had a Proto-Gravemind. They would have to be in the ship’s systems to find those co-ordinates entered
@terse lava Farkas Lake is where you launch the Sabre from in Long Night of Solace
Ah ok thank you @scarlet hinge
👌
Oh.
Umm.
I can't find Broken Circle on my Kindle.
For some reason it's only available in German.
One would think it would be there somewhere
Weird.
I like to think so.
Though his history with ORION and his time in cryo as a marine are also often mentioned.
Also, aren't there rumours about him being part of the Spartan I program?
I think so but weren't they dismissed with him having a made up disease by ONI?
I might be wrong tho
He is a Spartan 1, yes
That's why he is immune to the Flood?
He is not immune to the Flood
He’s harder for the Flood to infect so the Flood tend to go for the more easily infected people first. It’s the same with the Chief and all the other Spartans
His nervous system was scrambled by the radiation from having used an entire crate of plasma grenades iirc
That was a fake reason
That was made up was it not? It’s supposedly how he contracted “Boren’s Syndrome”
they dont have hearts or souls but they know what we want and they know what we need 8ut they dont love us how can you love without a heart or soul?
Yeah Boren’s Syndrome was made up to hide his association with Project Orion
Ok, good to know
Wasn’t it for all Project Orion candidates?
However, Joe Staten retconned any resistance Spartan Is had to the flood
Or at least, Johnson having the syndrome
Right
Indeed
Plus everything you guys said.
retconned as in adding or removing any resistance they had?
IIRC Borden’s Syndrome was real, but ONI embellished the symptoms to fit ORION
Yeah
Removed resistance
bleh
It was either the author of first strike or the flood who tried to give Johnson flood immunity. Staten was like “nope”
Lol
First Strike
Well, if the Forerunners couldn't figure it out, what are the odds that 1 random human gets immunity?
Exactly
IIRC it wasn’t confirmed he had immunity, just that it was a theory.
-4%
Well generally, immunity is accidental
Exactly
Can someone explain who Chips Dubbo is? Been playing Halo for years and barely heard of him.
x2
Chips Dubbo really just relates to the voice of a marine that’s present in CE-3
I think it gained meme status and Bungie made him an actual character
He survived that much?
It’s not that surprising
Personally, I regard him as dubiously canon.
At the very least, if he is to be canon, he can't have been on 04.
There's... almost no way that can work, imo.
Makes me wonder what became of that commando John fought on the Ascendant Justice
The only certainly canon chips dubbo is the CE one, as he's named in the credits.
Staten said in the H2 dev commantary "The aussie! He's a survivor!" Which was clearly a joke IMO. Idk man both Bungie and 343 have memed the hell out of Chips Dubbo, it's best to think of him as a purely gameplay character post-CE.
i like to think of him as all of them
i thought the problem was with 2 and odst
the magical two places at once
I just assume by default that he was not in New Mombasa
The problem is how he made it off 04
i may be being stupid about this but in mcc you get an achievment for fighting alonside chips dubbo in ce, 2, and 3
just felt like saying that
There is another possible option, in a sense
Twins
One brother could have been on reach/alpha halo, and the other on earth
except that twins don't share the same first name
because what parents are that stupid?
The odds are pretty cartoonish that that would happen even ignoring the name thing.
Remember, there are plenty of parents who will give their kids dumb names. Look at the creators of skyrim, promising lifetime merch to anyone who named their kid "Dragonborn"
sure but naming twins the same thing is just confusing for them
you call one, you get both
I never said its smart
Could also be one actually does have a different name and took on his brother's on learning of his death on reach/halo
I mean, it's not like we have a ton of options.
Maybe it was just a bad idea to make him canon
May. Be.
It's almost as if over-eager Halo fans have a track record of influencing canon in ways that later end up being annoying.
Almost.
That said if you take the Halo 3 Diorama as fact (outside it touting the Spartan was John) then there must of been a second survivor group from Alpha Halo
How.
Truthfully there could have been others. I mean, we only know John and Cortana's POV from after alpha halo went down.
And we saw how quick cortana was wrong on the "Dust and echos" being all that's left.
At least one pelican of survivors and the rest of the fleet of particular justice
Yo
So in H4 terminals the Didact says he's immune tot he composer
And at the end of the game he's standing inside the beam when he's firing on the earth
Due to his most recent mutation yes
So how does he get composed in Escalation?
Poor didact.
He was going to be in H5, but they killed him off and cancelled him
Concept art looked awesome tho
Either only CE, or only 2 and 3.
@versed helm
He also dies in 2, there's no way off of Regret's temple for him
He has mission dialogue cussing out Regret's Hologram, and then more staring up at High Charity and it's fleet arriving.
@obsidian thistle surely Thomas Chang is non-core canon until proven otherwise. We know that's how 343i look at marketing material right?
didact isnt dead
They see it as stuff that they can bring in and make canon if they want
people always tell me the UR-Didact is composed, but idk man, that guy seems to lose his temper a lot
I'd debate that its more akin to semi-canon. So less important than core canon. But deffo not non-canon yet.
Stuff that 343i can choose to keep and will try to. But will lose no sleep over retconning/removing.
@keen canopy
Makes sense, it's still reason enough to not take much stock in the "well people could've survived I04" thing I reckon. CE, The Flood, First Strike, Nightfall, they all paint an incredibly bleak picture for any potential I04 survivors
I'm not sure if it was ever stated, but for the Created... Was it ever stated how they would deal with the flood if it ever returned... Or was it something the Cortana fragment didn't think of at the time?
nothing ever stated
however, given the Prometheans are the main enforcers of the Created, and they were created explicitly to combat flood, they probably have some idea of what to do
like, built-in subroutines
And adaptable weapons
I was simply curious and all, CIA and Chimera.
Perhaps the idea of The Created Dealing with the Flood could be explored at some point... Either in a future game or novel.
Like what we see in Halo 4 is close to how they would be against the Flood.
Interesting
What we see in Halo 5 is the weapons adapted for use against Humans/Covenant
And no worries @spiral jewel :) Ask away. We dont mind answering stuff we can.
says the poor guy with 800 discord PMs 😉
Kinda curious on something. When the jiralhanae joined the Covenant, loyal chieftains were given vessels to operate as a "gift". Along with this they were given a san shyuum prelate to help operate it. Wondering while Maccabeus was given a covenant vessel for his decision to the journey, he never got a prelate
how fast was slipspace travel between Earth and the Lesser Ark
One hundred millennia passed since the primordial virus spread a vast
This plague lies deep within my keep, so why have you come, Reclaimer?
@torpid flare
Using the Voi Portal? 22 days.
When Gravemind used Precursor Neural Physics-based Slipspace methods on High Charity? 21 days
What Oz? @wheat saddle
The speed of the slip space with Voi Portal is around .12475669 Ly per second.
I subtracted the the distance of Ark from the center by the distance of Earth to the center of Milky Way
Then I divided 237144 by 22 to get around 10779 Ly per day
Then I divided the 10779 Ly by 86400 seconds of a day to get around .125 Ly per second
Correct me if I am wrong
Unfortunately, distances aren't the same in physical space and slipspace
You're using the physical space distance
For example, there are UNSC colonies that are quite close to Earth in physical space, however take several months to get to, due to being quite far away in Slipspace.
Darn
I guess I bit the bullet
And what is the actual speed of the slipspace between earth and ark
we don't know, 343i usually avoid providing specific details about things like this, incase it limits them later on.
Yeah we cant have the lore restricting Infinite’s epic slipspace battle between Chief and YapYap 🙄
I guess my calculations are semi accurate
@terse lava lyrics from a song about Halo lmao.
Ah ok
When the prophet of regret was with the Gravemind in Halo 2. Was he brought back to life after the chief killed him?
Yea, the flood can bring people back after they're dead.
You see it a lot in 3, dead humans and elites will struggle and scream if they get reanimated by infection forms
Wouldn't call it screaming, more grunts and moans.
They don't always but they can fully scream haha, I always do it the dead ultras in Floodgate
I admit, was.never certain they were returning to life
Flood super cell has incredible regenerative properties, if First Strike is to be believed
Which would explain Regret being able to form words despite having his skull caved in a few hours earlier
As you mentioned Regret it made me think of when I was fighting Regret for the first time. I couldn’t help but laugh at how Chief just kept punching him in the face
More curious why Regret even bothered fighting. He could have just floated to the roof
Hold on, when I looked up unggoy in Halopedia, they were also known as “Lobster” “Pig” and “Monkey”
Is this a joke or is that a thing
It could be what humans referred to them as, but I didn’t know that personally
I know that Brutes are referee to as Apes, and Elites are referred to as Gators some times
If the Halo ring were fired, would anyone on that ring survive or also die?
They would live
Glad Cortana prevented chief from firing the ring
Those on a halo when its fired are safe due to it blanketing the surface in a stasis field
I think it’s a similar situation with the Ark, but if the rings were fired, it’s outside of the Galaxy anyways
@terse lava in the Greg bear forerunner Sierra dident the forerunners die during the rings though??? It’s been soo long since I’ve read that though.. maybe it was severely damaged ring or somthing and it had to do with the fact that the 7 halo ring was smaller cause it was apart of a different set of rings er somthing
The forerunner died due to thebringa activating yes. When they fired though there were no forerunners on any of the rings

