#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 303 of 1

humble yacht
#

Really they’re just bipedal

static trench
#

Why would they look like anything not humanoid?

humble yacht
#

Beyond that, nothing really human

static trench
#

and yeah @humble yacht

versed helm
#

Not really, so should Monitors be humanoid omega?

#

Why couldn't you take a human essence

#

And stick it in something that could fly

static trench
#

i dont design the stuff

versed helm
#

I'd say an apc-like design would be alot more effective as a war based machine

terse lava
#

Because they are now robots and can be.molfed however one wants,

static trench
#

im just taking note of what i see

#

i dont design them

versed helm
#

Omega, you've basically blundered in here and made every lore mistake in the book

#

I’m not against the humanoid design, but the fact they were humanoids doesn’t explain their design.

#

You've come in with a very silly explanation

static trench
#

i didnt do anything

versed helm
#

And you're waiving off discussion by going

#

Waaah, don't come at me

static trench
#

The Didact converted them into bipedal entities

versed helm
#

Just chill out for a second

static trench
#

that look human

versed helm
#

Eh, Omega was just pointing out his point of view, and bringing up a possible explaination. Nothing wrong with that dude.

static trench
#

one of the prometheans unmasked at MC, and it showed a digital HUMANOID Skull

versed helm
#

Yeah, repeatedly, and kinda ignoring what people were saying

#

What looters said

static trench
#

youre ignoring the cutscene then @versed helm

versed helm
#

I'm not!

#

That's the thing

static trench
#

you are

versed helm
#

But what you're saying is correlative, not causative

terse lava
#

The point here, is why craft them with a humanoid look when one doesnt need too

versed helm
#

Exactly

#

We're not asking if things are the way they are

static trench
#

i could care less for the big words

versed helm
#

We're asking why take that route

static trench
#

like i said, im just taking note of what i see

humble yacht
#

You could ask that about any alien species on two legs

static trench
#

idk, ask someone at Bungie

hasty locust
#

Cause fighting humanoids would be more familiar and satisfying in combat

static trench
#

oops

#

343*

jolly furnace
#

The Knights are bipedal.

terse lava
#

I mean from the didact's viewpoint Chimera

versed helm
#

There's a difference between an evolutionary trend when it comes to biologically evolved alien life and the sort of design you'd want to inhabit with what are essential feralized smart AI

jolly furnace
#

A twisted reflection of forerunners and humans

humble yacht
#

Human art of nonhuman things often retains elements of what we are familiar with

static trench
#

i just feel like they took that route because the Forerunners are Bipedal and look humanoid, and the Didact converted humans into Prometheans, so that is my reasoning. I could be wrong. I dont know why 343 decided to go that route.

versed helm
#

I guess if we explore what Omega's saying more deeply, a bipedal construct is more suitable for a human essence on some instinctual level?

#

Perhaps, though he was bringing up a point. Though, counter argument, there's still no reason for them to look humanoid just because they were humanoid before. Lore-wise it would be better to have a better armored body with as few grabbable points as possible fighting the flood. Gameplay wise, it would make their designs more varied and unique, instead of having each knight rank have a few extra spikes

static trench
#

speaking of lore, they are supposed to be a lot dangerous, yet they are defeated so easily

terse lava
#

Gameplay

static trench
#

i mean in various cutscenes too

versed helm
#

Yeah, that's gameplay sacrafices, though.

#

Hm

static trench
#

i didnt mean actual gameplay

versed helm
#

You actually do make a point there though.

static trench
#

of course thats for balance purposes

humble yacht
#

They should have just been formless entities that opened portals to shoot at you through

versed helm
#

Eh, not really, i don't think that would work either

terse lava
#

Heck, the reason forerunner weapons are so underwhelming is because they can't reach their full power with knights

humble yacht
#

If they look like nothing, can’t Complain about the design

static trench
#

the Monitor in H3 said what he wouldn't do for a group of Prometheans iirc

versed helm
#

And now you're being childish...

#

Well, there was the one Palmer killed. Just bonked it on the head and blasted it point-blank with a .50 HE round.

#

I guess you could say

hasty locust
#

You thought jackal snipers were bad? Introducing the floating gun a forerunner construct

versed helm
#

The Marines with her had hammered it with their MA5s?

#

Course Lasky managed to totally take one down with an M45D

#

But they were being careful cuz they wanted Halsey

static trench
#

Also, im not sure if you all agree or not

terse lava
#

Whose being childish?

humble yacht
#

The monitor in H3 never mentioned prometheans

versed helm
#

Chimera, with the "Can't compain about the design if there is no design"

static trench
#

But with the cutscene of Locke and his team entering the atmosphere and battling the Covanent, that should have went to MC and his team

terse lava
#

Think they mean the monitor from the comic

humble yacht
#

Because prometheans hadn’t existed design wise at the time of halo 3

static trench
#

I feel like it would have made him look a lot more BA and live up to his lore

versed helm
#

🙄

humble yacht
#

Oh the monitor of installation 03

hasty locust
#

Spark only mention Prometheans in HCEA terminals

terse lava
#

Yep

versed helm
#

That monitor isn’t from H3 Ado

hasty locust
#

Nvm

humble yacht
#

You can’t call gamma halo “halo 3”

#

That’s too confusing

versed helm
#

Exactly

#

You can't just go "oh, hey, this was a cool cutscene but it should have been these other Spartans I like"

terse lava
#

@versed helmi never said it was

versed helm
#

There's no reason for Blue to be on Kamchatka without like, heavily rearranging the entire narrative

humble yacht
#

And look how that went last time

#

(I was fine with it but)

versed helm
#

Yeah but it doesn’t make sense for him to say “that monitor from H3” when he’s talking about a completely different monitor Ado.

terse lava
#

That's why I said I figured he was talking of the one from the comic who made.a deal with the didact

#

And just getting it mixed up with halo 3

static trench
#

and yeah i was mistaken about the monitor iirc

versed helm
#

Those forerunner ball turrets, they're actually exactly what i'm talking about. Make the promethians a bit more designed like that, it feels distinctly forerunner and having something like that move around would be a bit better. Maybe give them very nocticibly different patterns of floaty bits and different colors of glow to them for the ranks, as well as different weapons other than the beam the turrets have, obviously. That would make it seem a bit more like a force specifically designed to kill the flood

static trench
#

wasn't it from Halo 2?

terse lava
#

No

#

A post halo 4 comic

versed helm
#

No it was not

#

Hm

humble yacht
#

Halo 2 had 2 monitors

versed helm
#

Had 2 monitors

humble yacht
#

Penitent tangent and guilty spark

versed helm
#

IIRC the only monitor we saw in the OT was spark

static trench
#

and yes, i can say that. Master Chief deserved a great cutscene like Locke and his team got

versed helm
#

Wait you're right

#

Penitent tangent

static trench
#

Not that horror show that was Locke vs Chief

versed helm
#

But he was only in one cutscene

#

The red monitor and the blue monitor CSGOMister

#

Yeah

humble yacht
#

Blue team got their own epic intro

versed helm
#

Yeah they smashed through that window

hasty locust
#

Yeah when they hopped through dat window

humble yacht
#

No wasted moves

#

Very precise

static trench
#

you got a link?

hasty locust
#

I liked their intro

humble yacht
#

YouTube

hasty locust
#

Then I only got to see them for two more levels and i was like ahhhh man

static trench
#

i mean the game and such

versed helm
#

Tbh, i still think it was an insane decision to make halo 5 squad based, and then make that the game where you removed splitscreen

terse lava
#

A link for what Omega? You can find it on youtibe

humble yacht
#

Well that’s not really a lore topic

static trench
#

what game did they show said cutscene, lol

versed helm
#

If i remember right, it was supposed to be a spinoff at first, which is why it's so different and why blue team were in like, 2 missions

humble yacht
#

But it’s also not something they’ll repeat

terse lava
#

Halo 5 Omega

versed helm
#

Aye

static trench
#

thanks

terse lava
#

Welcome

static trench
#

Halo Legends was pretty cool. I wish they'd give us more animations like that expanding on the lore and various ONI and weapon facilities

versed helm
#

Ooh yeah

terse lava
#

Would be nice

versed helm
#

There was a guy uh, installation 00 on youtube

#

He does in depth looks at various weapons and other things in the lore

#

Poorly

humble yacht
#

Oof

static trench
#

yep, I watch his videos

humble yacht
#

Can taste the salt

static trench
#

He does a better job than the other youtubers that attempt to explore the series

#

imo anyway

versed helm
#

Eh, I like him. I'm a bit of a nerd for firearms myself, so I like the explainations of how the guns n stuff work.

gilded mason
#

Didn't he say that Halsey has the Librarian's geas.

humble yacht
#

I don’t watch any of them but Toa seems to be a level headed person so they get my vote

static trench
#

But wasn't that a theory?

humble yacht
#

A bad theory

versed helm
#

A game theory

static trench
#

"Lore and Theory" xD

versed helm
#

Yeah it's a pretty awful theory though

static trench
#

i didnt take that video too seriously, but in a way, it make a bit of sense

versed helm
#

Still, his other stuff is pretty decent.

humble yacht
#

Not a fan of the geas in general

gilded mason
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

His video on human artificial gravity is pretty cringe

#

Doesn't make any sense

#

Artificial gravity is something that's theoretically possible. I'll have to check that vid though.

static trench
#

He didn't go with the classical graviton argument?

#

can't get any better than that really

versed helm
#

The way he conceptualized it as like, deck plating

#

Is not canonically acceptable

#

Ah yeah no

#

Warfleet talks about "gravity fields"

humble yacht
#

The only tron I’ll accept is megatron

static trench
#

well, didn't deadspace do something like that?

versed helm
#

And Halo 4 and CH mention gravity generators

#

So clearly, you have generators which sustain an even gravitic field within the hull

#

Not this random gradient idea he came up with

static trench
#

i figured it was gravity generators built into metal plates that could line the floor of a ship

versed helm
#

Also his MA5B video is pretty whack to me but that's just because I've spent far too much time obsessing over the MA5

#

Current models of gravity generation involve centrifugal force, spinning to push you towards the ground. Maybe they have those magnetic boots, though. Although that wouldn't explain everything else having gravity as well, unless they're also magnetized, but that would create a lot more problems than it solves.

#

It's real simple

#

Gravity generators turn on, things fall to the ground. You can observe it in the first level of Halo 4

cosmic wedge
#

guys do you know him?

versed helm
#

Later on, Cortana informs Chief that "all but one of the grav generators just went dark!"

#

In CH

terse lava
#

Him?

versed helm
#

Him?

cosmic wedge
#

yes

versed helm
#

An "anti-grav unit" is damaged

#

And that causes a ship to lose gravity

terse lava
#

Who are you talking of

versed helm
#

Yeah but that doesn't explain what it is, only disproves the magnetic boots theory, which already debunks itself

frozen spire
woven halo
versed helm
#

I would say it explains what it is perfectly

#

Centralized field-generating units

static trench
#

my headcanon is that the gravity generator uses gravitons to set gravity at a given direction and G, and range/field

versed helm
#

But not, of course, how it works

#

Since we don't even have a complete understanding in the modern day of what gravity is

#

That's what we're talking about.

#

🤷‍♂️ I'll reserve speculation on the particle mechanics of the situation until RL eggheads actually find the graviton.

#

All I know is

#

Grav generators ain't deck plating

#

Yeah they're def not.

#

And also

cosmic wedge
#

pls do you know him?

versed helm
#

Who is him?

#

MA5s do not have a canonical range of 150m

static trench
#

lol

versed helm
#

Or like

#

Didn't he say 30m is one of his videos even

gaunt hazel
#

BOOOOOOOOOOAS

versed helm
#

The thing pushes 7.62x51 down like a 20-inch barrel

#

Possibly closer to 30-inch

#

The effective range of that weapon on semi-automatic will be considerable

#

Especially with futuristic targeting systems

#

This is one of those "gameplay is an abstraction" situations

twin geyser
#

how come humanity weren't able to join the covenant?

gilded mason
#

Because the Hierarchs didn't want the "truth" to come out

twin geyser
#

what exactly is the "truth"

gilded mason
#

That being the Great Journey not being a for-sure thing for everyone

twin geyser
#

oh

terse lava
#

Yep the hierarchs thought humans were left behind forerunners

versed helm
#

Truth did

#

Because in the original canon, ancient humans were the forerunners, which is revealed by spark at the end of 3 with the quote "You ARE forerunner", but they retconned it in reach. There was a forerunner AI in high charity, and the 3 prophets learned that their faith was a lie from it and that humans were the forerunners, so they declared war on humanity to prevent that truth from coming out.

#

Maybe

#

The "you are forerunner" quote was CE

#

By Halo 3

terse lava
#

Reach didnt retcon it

versed helm
#

The forerunners were a different species

gilded mason
#
The "you are forerunner" quote was CE```
No? That quote is at the end of 3.
versed helm
#

Revealed in the terminals I believe

terse lava
#

We know looter

versed helm
#

Hold on

gilded mason
#

But yeah, Humans and Forerunners being separate was in the terminals and Halo 3 tie-in comics

versed helm
#

Here

#

Does this mean 3 contradicts itself?

gilded mason
#

Yes

#

Kinda-ish?

versed helm
#

Scrumptious

gilded mason
#

I guess one could simply have it be Spark being Spark

versed helm
#

@humble yacht

#

Boi

#

Yeah, the old lore wasn't really as deep as it is now. For all the criticism the community has for 343, they sure did add a LOT of lore to it.

terse lava
#

It does in the sense Guilty was crazy and thought humans were forerunners

versed helm
#

Probably an oversimplification

#

Perhaps, though i don't think they'd put something so blatantly easy to misunderstand like that in

#

"You are the child of my makers, inheritors of all they left behind"

#

In my eyes, that line maintains a certain separation between humanity and the forerunners

#

While of course, blurring that separation because of the forerunner's very philosophical outlook on reality

gilded mason
#

Yeah, Librarian considered humans her children later on. Though that "You are Forerunner" part was a bit more egregious.

twin geyser
#

what happened to the forerunners?

versed helm
#

They died when they activated the halo rings to kill the flood

gilded mason
#

A large amount, at least

twin geyser
#

the flood are that old huh

gilded mason
#

Others went into exile

versed helm
#

The Flood are, depending on how you look at it, the oldest living beings in the galaxy.

#

The flood are what remains of the species that created humanity and the forerunners, called the precursors. The forerunners got mad that the precursors favored ancient humanity over them so they killed most of them, and the last of the precursors went into hiding and turned themselves into a powder for stasis so that they would reform eventually. This powder corrupted, and long story short created the flood

#

^ To be fair, that is second-hand knowledge.

twin geyser
#

I never knew halo has this much lore

versed helm
#

From the Primordial, isn't it?

twin geyser
#

very interesting

versed helm
#

Bit of a manipulative fella that one

#

True and the primordial is certainly a liar

twin geyser
#

thank you all for filling me in

versed helm
#

It's likely a half-truth

#

But, well, it's closest we got to the story

#

And np mate

#

Indeed

#

Halo has like, a TON of lore.

terse lava
#

Dont forget it was also said the precursors planned on wiping out the forerunners as

#

A problem

versed helm
#

Really? Where did it say that? I'm curious.

humble yacht
#

Nothing about the H3 terminals explicitly identified humans and forerunners as different. I read the transcripts last week

terse lava
#

2nd forerunner book and halo mythos. Nothing concrete thougu

versed helm
#

Ah, well, i'll have to go through that. I aint read much of the books, but i been meanin to.

humble yacht
#

At most there was one terminal where librarian wrote about being on a world where the earth was lush and the natives primitive, but that was “earth” as in dirt, not the planet

#

It wasnt until the forerunner trilogy that librarian was confirmed to have died on Earth the planet

gilded mason
#


L: My work is done. The portal is 
inactive, and I've begun the burial 
measures. Soon there'll be nothing 
but sand and rock and normal ferrite 
signatures.
versed helm
#

Odd that they would use earth as a term, Makes you wonder if it's like, chief's translation software or something saying that (Assuming the terminals arent already in english which would add even more interest to the idea) or if it means something more

gilded mason
#

She's talking about the Ark portal

#

@humble yacht

#

So, the earth she's talking about is on Earth

versed helm
#

Yeah

humble yacht
#

If you assume it’s the same portal, I suppose

terse lava
#

Of course it is, seeing as we only ever see one portal

humble yacht
#

We know by this time Bungie had decided internally that forerunners were different, but the ambiguity was still quite prominent in the game

#

Aside from essentially one line in one terminal

gilded mason
#

We literally also have the Halo 3 comic Cradle of Life showing past humans watching the Ark portal being built

humble yacht
#

Yeah but that’s outside of the game

#

I didn’t start looking at outside media for halo until after halo 4

#

When you just play the OG trilogy, that ambiguity on the identity of the forerunners is there and it was something i really liked

terse lava
#

Fair, but in regards to the portL and that terminal, it's very hard to see it anywhere else but earth

#

Even from only the games

humble yacht
#

Realistically speaking, sure, but humans hold out false hope all the time

#

And perception is reality, as they say

versed helm
#

If the MA5 series existed irl, it wouldn't really be used by any military because it's far too bulky. If humanity is still using bullets in the 2500s, the small arms are gonna be not that dissimilar to modern weapons, which are smaller and easily stored. The MA5 is like holding a plank of wood with a hold for a grip, an AR irl is like a tube with a handle and is much smaller.

terse lava
#

Wheres Looter when you need him

versed helm
#

Looting, presumably

terse lava
#

Just saying, he's into the gunn talk

static trench
#

It would be nice to see the Flood advanced in capabilities, since they possesses the knowledge of previous graveminds when they acquire enough mass and intelligence

#

they didn't do that enough in previous games and game lore

terse lava
#

They were decently advanced for the outbreak

versed helm
#

Well, they did use that ccs cruiser to crash into voi in 3

static trench
#

I wish we could see Neural Physics and Star Roads in action, even if said action is a flashback

#

the Domain survived, so we can have hope that some Star Roads survived

terse lava
#

You can see them tearing apart the greater ark in mythos

static trench
#

i saw one picture of it, but nothing like animation 😛

versed helm
#

That'd be pretty cool

static trench
#

that picture was pretty cool though

#

and spooky but in good way

torpid flare
#

why were the flood so effective?

versed helm
#

Because they used their enemies strengths against them. The more people they turned into flood the smarter they got, which means they could then take your weapons, vehicles, ships, and even your own AIs against you in a FAR more coordinated and effective manner than you ever could.

humble yacht
#

There is no race in the galaxy that could hold off that advanced of a flood outbreak the way the forerunners did

#

Seeing the return of advanced flood abilities would simply spell the end for everyone else

#

Either the halos get fired again or the flood wins

#

But they win much faster than in the forerunner flood war

static trench
#

true

#

At their prime, they could infect life and AIs instantly

#

not to mention space too

noble fjord
#

You know I still find it hard to believe that ONI could keep the glassing of Africa and the flood outbreak a secret from EVERYONE on Earth...

#

Also did Rtas need to get authorization from ONI and Lord Hood to glass Africa? Or did he just go and say "this is going to happen regardless"

gilded mason
#

Or did he just go and say "this is going to happen regardless"
That one

#

Who was gonna stop him?

noble fjord
#

True...

versed helm
#

I think lord hood was there when he gave the order and was just a little pissed

noble fjord
#

"A little" he seemed rather frustrated

half apex
#

hmm

#

so

gilded mason
#

You know I still find it hard to believe that ONI could keep the glassing of Africa and the flood outbreak a secret from EVERYONE on Earth...
I could see it. After all, they were already glassing the area to uncover the portal.

half apex
#

about yapyap....

noble fjord
#

Yapyap is funny

He isn't Cannon (I think)

versed helm
#

He was only slightly agitated about losing an entire continent

half apex
#

other than grunts were there some unsc forces who actually took him seriously

#

oh

#

Bruh Africa got too much in the history of Halo

#

In the end it got a glassy ending

#

and had minimal water

versed helm
#

UNSC re-terraformed that shizz lickety-split

half apex
#

oof

gilded mason
#

Though remember, only a small area was glassed

versed helm
#

But he didn't really seem that mad

half apex
#

wait so if they could do that why can't they do the same for reach?

#

and all the other colonies that got glassed?

versed helm
#

It's not an easy process

#

But they put in the extra effort for Earth

half apex
#

does it take a large amount of time?

versed helm
#

You gotta like, remove all the glass

noble fjord
#

Is glassed material even usable for anything...

half apex
#

._.

#

yes

static trench
#

ONI is scum

noble fjord
#

Windows

half apex
#

the unsc will now have plenty of glass to last for centuries

versed helm
#

Draco III was still glassy when it was recolonized

half apex
#

look on the bright side

#

more windows

static trench
#

I wouldn't mind seeing a halo game where they become the villains and must be taken down

#

Also, how did they get away with framing Chief?

versed helm
#

On draco III you could see still the chemical soup that was buck's home

static trench
#

xD

deep pewter
#

The UNSC already are the villains :^)

gilded mason
#

based nathan

hasty locust
#

You starting to sound like an insurgent

abstract venture
#

Do we have any confirt that a small portion of Africa was glassed?

versed helm
#

I smell insurrectionists

abstract venture
#

Lord Hood doesn't really have a reason to lie and half jaw made it pretty clear he was going to glass the entire planet but settled for 'half the planet', also we know the Covenant easily have the capabilities

terse lava
#

Because the memorial area was intact

gilded mason
#

Do we have any confirt that a small portion of Africa was glassed?
Only a couple months later, we have the memorial service near Voi and no glassed areas in sight

versed helm
#

"Half a continent" was Hood's words.

abstract venture
#

Maybe that area had it easy

versed helm
#

Just so everyone's on the same page.

#

He may have been exaggerating

terse lava
#

You don't have it easy from glassing

gilded mason
#

Maybe that area had it easy
That was right next to the Flood outbreak

terse lava
#

Yes hood used hyperbole

noble fjord
#

I still can't imagine how a marine would react, just in the middle of an outbreak on their coms "This is the Carrier Shadow of Intent. Clear this sector while we deal with the Flood"

abstract venture
#

Maybe the flood Didnt go that way so they didn't have a reason to Glas there

#

Considering its next to the ocean

terse lava
#

Rememebr the " the fleet that attacked reach was fifty times this size"

abstract venture
#

That's different though

#

As half jaw backs up the statement saying he was goit to Glas the planet instead

terse lava
#

It is another example of him using hyperbole

abstract venture
#

This is more credible

terse lava
#

No it isn't

noble fjord
#

Who did take command of the fleet of particular justice after Thel?

terse lava
#

Had hood been literal, half of Africa would be molten rock

abstract venture
#

Why would half jaw be gout along with his hyperbole

terse lava
#

@noble fjordThel 'Vadamee

gilded mason
#
Why would half jaw be gout along with his hyperbole```
Because he doesn't care a bit about correcting him
abstract venture
#

And why would he mention he was going to Glas the entire planet but settled for half of Africa

versed helm
#

Do squidheads even know What hyperbole is?

abstract venture
#

The difference is we know the covenant ships easily had the capabilities though

terse lava
#

Because the arbiter talked him down

versed helm
#

I did indeed

gilded mason
#

And why would he mention he was going to Glas the entire planet but settled for half of Africa
He didn't say that exactly. It was more:
"You glassed half a continent."
"I was gonna glass Earth if Arbiter wasn't here."

abstract venture
#

Yeah

terse lava
#

"If it were not for the aribter's council, I would have glassed your entire PLANET"

gilded mason
#

He just sidestepped the "half a continent" thing

abstract venture
#

No

gilded mason
#

I imagine because he knew the sentiment Hood was going for, which was "I can't believe you had the gall to glass Earth"

humble yacht
#

Rtas is very serious about getting rid of that stench

#

Someone should introduce him to Febreeze

abstract venture
#

His response was to the half a continent thing

#

"you glassed half a continent"

#

"I would have glassed the entire planet if I wanted"

versed helm
#

What was ado 'ulamee responsible for?

terse lava
#

The flood consumed Febreeze with logic plague, who knows how

#

Pardon?

versed helm
#

He was the first Sangheili to be infected in CE

gilded mason
#

Pardon?
He thinks your character is canon.

terse lava
#

Oh..

gilded mason
#

I think

versed helm
#

Or might be joking ye know?...

terse lava
#

No, it's my own personal thing

#

@versed helmits been an long day

gilded mason
#
Or might be joking ye know?...```
Sometimes ya can't tell, y'know? 😋
versed helm
#

I was

#

He's the elite with the messed up guts the Marines and Keyes find

gilded mason
#

Ah

terse lava
#

Well yea, Vadamee is canon

versed helm
#

I find it easy to tell when someone is joking FOR THE MOST PART atleast.

humble yacht
#

You think they still have Saturday morning cartoons in the 26th century?

versed helm
#

Pfffft

#

Lucky you

#

I'm still sure half the time that people retroactively decide they were joking when they get called out

terse lava
#

Likely, 1337 mini series

torpid flare
#

hey elites

versed helm
#

I'm always getting into spicy arguments on the internet only to find that someone was joking all along

#

It's triggering

gilded mason
#

lol

versed helm
#

Legit

#

I mean if it was clearly a joke then thats on you.

torpid flare
#

you allowed the glassing of half of africa, you split lip

versed helm
#

The other day I said "well maybe people ought to take things more seriously!"

#

I went grumpy old man

#

Full grumpy old man

humble yacht
#

The funnybot paradox

versed helm
#

you allowed the glassing of half of africa, you split lip
@torpid flare. But I did kill a prophet

terse lava
#

As for covenant cartoons..."Thunder Brutes hooo!"

static trench
#

you never go full grumpy old man

#

xD

versed helm
#

U dont go grumpy over someone calling Thel thicc

torpid flare
#

@versed helm good arby's

versed helm
#

The Arbiter liked BBQ

#

He even has his own restaurant called Arbies

humble yacht
#

@versed helm just would like to mention now rather than later that role playing isn’t for this server

torpid flare
#

this turned into a crapshow

versed helm
#

Unless u go to Clan Chat and clan recruitment where UNSC and Sangheili role players can rarely be found

#

But ive seen them 👀

torpid flare
#

what is the best rp you saw

versed helm
#

A Merc asking to be hired

#

To Assasinate some clan leader

#

I think he was "Insurrectionist" or something, or just some Merc rp boi

torpid flare
#

did he like the sangheili

versed helm
#

Ive also seen a Sangheili role player get triggered by UNSC role players

#

Its rare

#

But ive seen it 👀

torpid flare
#

what is the best sangheili rper

versed helm
#

Depends on What you mean by best

torpid flare
#

the funniest

#

and the worst

versed helm
#

Funny in terms of actual comedy or cringe?

torpid flare
#

cringe

versed helm
#

Ah

#

Thats a though one

#

But Ive seen some in H5

#

Who put on Hellioskrill and cell themselves Sangheili

#

And One time

gilded mason
#
Who put on Hellioskrill and cell themselves Sangheili```
It's all people have. =(
versed helm
#

I found This person calling himself, "I am The Princess of the Blood line and my father is the Prince"

#

I know Ostral 😢

torpid flare
#

what the hell, this is worse than the royal family inbreeding

versed helm
#

Its not the worst ive seen

#

I saw a Sangheili Couple role playing a wedding

terse lava
#

Odd

torpid flare
#

this is way too cursed

versed helm
#

Atleast the UNSC arent as cringy

#

They act like an actual Military for the most part but still cringy

gilded mason
#

Hmmmmm

versed helm
#

Ok maybe ive over stepped that statement

#

But its not as bad for the most part

#

But still pretty bad

terse lava
#

HMMMMM

torpid flare
#

thanks, i now hate sangheilis

versed helm
#

RP is cringe tbh

#

Just write instead

#

Ok its equally as bad

torpid flare
#

expect for rtas and arby

#

they are cool with homo sapiens

terse lava
#

I can imagine that spongebob episode with the baby clam fitting this moment well

versed helm
#

It does

torpid flare
#

oh wait

#

i found even worse video of sangheili wedding

versed helm
#

I think ive seen it

terse lava
#

Lovely

versed helm
#

Is it the reach one?

torpid flare
#

yeah

versed helm
#

Or the H5

#

Ah

torpid flare
#

god is dead and we killed him

versed helm
#

Nah he just abandoned hope on us

#

And proceded to leave us

torpid flare
#

makes more sense

versed helm
#

The sad part is

#

I dont think that kind of cringe is exclusive to Sangheili 👀

torpid flare
#

i thought it would mostly little kids or young teens

versed helm
#

Nope

#

Adults do dis 2

#

Sad but true

torpid flare
#

so they are fully grown adults marrying with the sangheili

#

weird

versed helm
#

Yes

#

I think ive heard of UNSC spartan marriages too 🤧

torpid flare
#

this is a suffer worthy level of ∞ out of 10

versed helm
#

I think This suffering goes beyond being infinite as impossible as it sounds

torpid flare
#

i would freak out until i die if i see another halo wedding

versed helm
#

Once custom browser comes to MCC you might see Sangheili breeding camps

torpid flare
#

we would infiltrate them, but our suffering levels have a limit

versed helm
#

We would sabotage them

torpid flare
#

yes

terse lava
#

The heck?

versed helm
#

Look up Sangheili wedding on YouTube Ado

torpid flare
#

@terse lava yeah, we are suffering over halo weddings

versed helm
#

So I dont suffer alone

torpid flare
#

there is even worse than even weddings

versed helm
#

Oh God not the fanfics

#

Anything but the fanfics

torpid flare
#

yeah, i am just in constant pain typing each word.

#

i had the combination of tv static and dial-up sound in my head

static trench
#

becomes the first Spartan to marry a Sangheili female

torpid flare
#

my soul is ripping up each milisecond

static trench
#

but in all seriousness, it would be nice to see female Sangheili in combat

#

LOL @torpid flare

torpid flare
#

i am dying mentally

versed helm
#

U dont want to inspire people to do such thing Omega

torpid flare
#

@versed helm we would like to be blessed

versed helm
#

Look up Dorime and your wishes shall be fulfilled

torpid flare
#

dorime finally cleansed us of the sangheili

abstract venture
#

Lmao covenant rpers are basically alien furrys

torpid flare
#

@abstract venture IKR

abstract venture
#

they're disgusting

noble fjord
#

What is the currently known status of Shadow of Intent?

abstract venture
#

No offense to anyone here

gilded mason
#

No offense to anyone here
Hm

versed helm
#

Lol

terse lava
#

Searching for the san shyuum exile fleet

gilded mason
#
What is the currently known status of Shadow of Intent?```
Last we know, it was helping the UNSC in policing the joint-occupation zone, or something
abstract venture
#

There was a catalog post where it mentioned ONI sent Prowlers to spy on it

#

Which they blew up

gilded mason
#

Yeah

terse lava
#

Mhm

abstract venture
#

And I think it was time-stamped the most recent

lucid fiber
#

master chief dies in end gane

gilded mason
#
And I think it was time-stamped the most recent```
Ye
terse lava
#

Fun

#

....

torpid flare
#

.....

noble fjord
#

Promethean Knights use Hardlight Weapons yes? how effective is Hardlight against the Flood?

versed helm
#

One can presume pretty effective.

#

It'd be nice to get the chance to find out in-game.

noble fjord
#

Well I take in game weapon effectiveness with a spoonful of salt... Plasma is the most nerfed thing in the game

versed helm
#

Plasma is very nerfed, at least against unshielded targets.

vestal ermine
#

Is Jun dead?

gilded mason
#

No

abstract venture
#

What's Juns rank again?

#

Isn't he the Spartan equivalent of a brigadier general or something?

#

I think he's the highest ranking 'active' spartan

terse lava
#

Chief of staff

abstract venture
#

You're right

#

It doesn't have a stated rank equivalent but it's above a Spartan Commander which is the equivalent of a Colonel

terse lava
#

I find it funny, looking over the halopedia page, that ancient humanity sounds.like 40k humanity

noble fjord
#

"Clear this sector, while we deal with the flood" Call me Captain Obvious, but something tells me Rtas ensures his Elites know how to deal with the Flood...

terse lava
#

Well yea

#

Besides 1 major, the rest were commandos

torpid flare
#

ran over sangheili with my 2001 honda civic, i did.

versed helm
#

How did it not self combust?

torpid flare
#

i upgraded my civic to a warhog

#

them elites ain't got nothing with my business of elite bashing

versed helm
#

It better be the ugly ones

torpid flare
#

it is

versed helm
#

Good

torpid flare
#

the classic ones run my business

terse lava
#

How canon would you say the other ranks in reach invasion is

torpid flare
#

do you want a 2001 honda civic

terse lava
#

...no

torpid flare
#

why not

obsidian thistle
#

Ranks? What cha mean? @terse lava

terse lava
#

@obsidian thistlethe covenant readout ranks like "royal zealot." I am curious if that would be possibly a higher rank zealot title in perhaps a chapter house or if maybe a sign if an "aristocrat" type

obsidian thistle
#

Oh

#

That

#

I'd say at most War Games canon.

#

But very likely just non-canon for the loadouts.

terse lava
#

Hm pity

solemn jay
#

Like I love halo and all but why does the flood betray u after killing truth

#

Like that’s the only thing I never understood

gilded mason
#

Because the Flood doesn't like you

solemn jay
#

Lol

gilded mason
#

It only wanted Truth out of the way so he wouldn't activate the rings

#

They still want to infect everyone and bring misery

terse lava
#

Yep, good going precursors

solemn jay
#

Lmfao they failed miserably though when master chief activated halo at the end of the mission halo in halo 3

#

Goes to show nothing can stop master chief and the arbiter 😂

terse lava
#

Wasnt much of a setback with ATN

#

Or in general, gravemind knew one day he would return

gilded mason
#

Gravemind has all the time in the world to eventually reform

terse lava
#

Hm I wonder

#

Would the governors of Contrition treat the gravemind as aa god?

gilded mason
#

Yeah

terse lava
#

Well that's ys the thing, they still appeared to hold reverence to forerunners, because they thought the forerunners created the flood

gilded mason
#

Ah

terse lava
#

Yea, would a gravemind overrule the forerunner or....?

gilded mason
#

I guess it may depend on how much they learn of the Gravemind's origins

terse lava
#

Maybe, we are never even told how they came across the idea anyway. One would assume the mendicant shard but as far as we know, he only taught theban shyuum and covenant anti-flood things

lost lintel
#

Guys I found a easter egg in the halo infinite trailer

gilded mason
#

Yeah?

versed helm
#

👀

carmine sleet
#

@lost lintel Are you gonna tell us about the Easter egg you found?

jolly furnace
#

Maybe those prophet cultists found forerunner records about AH's pheru flood origin and mistranslated it as forerunners creating the flood.

#

Or they were just completely nuts

#

Something i think likely given they revered the bloody Flood

#

Also really server? I can't use "d*mn" in here

terse lava
#

I think it may be more likly the shard in a moment of rempwncy told them

noble fjord
#

Bringing up a question that was left unanswered yesterday.

If the Didact was freed, could he regain control of his Prometheans from Cortana?

versed helm
#

I would assume so.

agile dragon
#

I wonder which would be "smarter" Cortana as an ai vs the Didact...

versed helm
#

Didact would probably be "smarter" Cortana as an AI is a joke compared to what they've made

agile dragon
#

And if she's got all the data from the forerunners / "upgraded" herself? =o
I remember in one of the earlier books, she ran some unknown code on herself when she was unable to tell exactly what it would do to her. There may be software "upgrades" she might be able to run in the future

terse lava
#

She took apart a covenant ai, as for the question, dissect likely could take control from her as they are ultimately his. And for smater..tough call. Cortansn can think of things billion to trillions times faster then a human. Meanwhile the didact could view thousands of warrior servant at once, and recall from memory a ten thousand long code

versed helm
#

I was meaning how, almost for certain the Forerunner had stronger AI

terse lava
#

Well of course

spiral jewel
#

I'm not sure if there was any spare Mjolnir on Installation 00, but would it be safe to assume that Red Team was upgraded to Gen 2 at some point between 2559 and 2561 , or at least had some sort of upgrades to their Mjolnir,?

feral perch
#

There were spare Mjolnir GEN2 components on the Ark.

#

Douglas used those to refit his armor after Atriox crushed his helmet and shoulder pad.

#

Of course he didn't personally fix his Mjolnir; Spirit of Fire technicians did.

versed helm
#

isabel also helped.

humble yacht
#

When were spartan iv’s ever on the ark?

#

I know vale was on the ark at one point but that was before her augmentation

carmine sleet
#

It's possible a few were stationed there between Hunters in the Dark and before the events of Halo 5

#

Maybe temporarily and they just happened to leave some stuff behind

obsidian thistle
#

If I recall Apollo was once there

humble yacht
#

Ew, Fireteam Apollo

obsidian thistle
#

Whats wrong with Apollo? :S

humble yacht
#

A spartan team created expressly to promote the loot crate service?

#

They’re basically an ad

obsidian thistle
#

Well thankfully they appear in other media. :)

quiet umbra
#

Apollo boooooo

spiral jewel
#

Thankfully I've never heard of Fireteam Apollo

quiet umbra
#

Infinite's microtransaction model worries me because we know it's going to be there

humble yacht
#

That’s not lore

feral perch
#

Spartan IVs don't have to be stationed on the Ark for Mjolnir GEN2 components to be there.

#

It could just be in case they do show up.

terse lava
#

Do you guys think the hierarchs would have been good rulers had they not been worried about the whole reclaimer thing?

feral perch
#

No.

gilded mason
#

I don't know enough about their not-human-related policy-making skills to give a good answer.

jolly furnace
#

Did the Covies know of humans before first contac? Cos i think HW logs have something to effect Covies could understand human language before first contact. Am i wrong?

gilded mason
#

I guess they were being monitored for a little while.

jolly furnace
#

Yeah that was what was speculated in the log i think

#

As for Reclaimer thing - that would inevitably become an issue for prphet rule

gilded mason
#

To paraphrase from last time:
Haha, yes. Thanks to recent scripture that has been uncovered, we discovered this species seems to have been left by the Forerunners as a gift to us to better utilize their wonders.

jolly furnace
#

I think many elites would question that

gilded mason
#

Can't argue with results.

jolly furnace
#

Questions like why this species

#

who arent very advanced

#

not have much knowledge of these gifts they are meant to help utilise

#

ultimately its gonna end the same way as canon

#

war

gilded mason
#

I disagree there.

humble yacht
#

That quote is why, in my mind, the human girl in the covenant for the tv show is not that outlandish of an idea. She could just be a secret skeleton key for forerunner stuff who serves the prophets. Or maybe just one prophet

carmine sleet
#

My guess is that Truth would most likely have orchestrated her kidnapping

#

Regret seems too focused on wiping out humanity and Mercy isn't really the schemer

jolly furnace
#

Ultimately the elites will wonder why humans are the Reclaimers and not them or the prophets like they believe

humble yacht
#

I could see truth keeping her a secret from the other prophets

jolly furnace
#

And f a monitor chats with them, well thats the end of that

humble yacht
#

And that she’s only ever taken out under escort by a specific team of truth loyalists and is disguised at all times lest other covenant notice she’s human

jolly furnace
#

Hard not notice she's human

#

body structure height etc

#

she'll stick out like mad

terse lava
#

They could day she was a fringe, or just a human who they absolved

#

Not the first time that was done, look at the lekgolo

#

Only some were let in, everyone else wipeout

carmine sleet
#

Likely kept confined to a specific part of High Charity or some hidden facility that only Truth and a few others know about opposed to being a human they just accepted into the Covenant

jolly furnace
#

I just cant buy a human in the covenant

terse lava
#

Look on the. Bright side

#

We will finally get more deep covie lore

#

Hated the idea of her until that thought came up

gilded mason
#

I just hope they don't use her in place of Covenant antagonists.

carmine sleet
#

I honestly have a feeling that things are likely not quite as literal as they are in what the article said

jolly furnace
#

I think thats what they are doing

carmine sleet
#

Also, it's already been confirmed that's not what's happening, Ostral

jolly furnace
#

Covies need CGI

carmine sleet
#

Or practical effects, like animatronics, like those seen in the Landfall and ODST live action trailers

terse lava
#

So what? Give the thing enough budget

jolly furnace
#

higher budget means more money needed to make profit when it comes out

gilded mason
#
Also, it's already been confirmed that's not what's happening, Ostral```
Ah good
humble yacht
#

So what? Give the thing enough budget
That’s what every show or movie maker would say if it was a realistic option

#

But how do you convince producers to just give you more funding? That’s how projects get canceled

terse lava
#

I know, I'm an optimistic 😔

#

Just feels cheap to have it be a pure human covie enemy, even if I have warmed to the idea

quiet umbra
#

turning rebellious elite figures into arbiters predates finding humanity by a longshot

#

so no the SanShyuum were always engaged in political skullduggery to maintain the covenant caste system

#

with them at the top

carmine sleet
#

Who said anything about that, X?

quiet umbra
#

earlier question about Prophets bec=ing good leaders

#

being*

#

I mean maybe that makes them good leaders but definately not aspirational or moral ones

carmine sleet
#

Right... But nobody said anything about Arbiters

quiet umbra
#

ik just an example of their political gamesmanship

#

when elites question the prohets too much they get declared heretics

#

and are often turned into arbiters

terse lava
#

That question.i was thinking more along the lines of say truth, he wanted to give out forerunner relics more efficiently and was the only one who supported the unggoy before their rebellion

#

As a minister he appeared to have a rather level head

quiet umbra
#

Truth in Halo 3 by comparison just sounds like he OD'd on his own koolaid

terse lava
#

Yea

quiet umbra
#

What a bizarre writing blunder 😦

terse lava
#

Could argue he lost it when he knew high charity could fall

gilded mason
#

If only they had Staten. 😔

terse lava
#

Indeed

quiet umbra
#

Did Staten not write 3

gilded mason
#

Yeah. He was busy with other projects at the time

terse lava
#

He did write contact harvest though

#

And I think a Fractures tale

quiet umbra
#

I know Halo 3 deliberately has a more straightforward, approachable story but Truth just seems like he went crazy

terse lava
#

My head canon was that maybe he truly thought high chairty wouldn't fall. On seeing it did, in part thanks to himself. Seeing the loss of the city, along with most of his own kind sent him over the edge

#

I mean look how that prelate reacted on realizing he could have saved his family and didn't

quiet umbra
#

Even right at the end he's babbling like a mad king which was just bizarre

#

he did get infected by the flood tho

terse lava
#

Yea

#

He knew his fate

quiet umbra
#

chad gravemind basically un-infecting Truth because Arby wanted to kill the real Truth

#

nice 👌

#

I like that the Gravemind is big on irony and poeticism,, he'll hinder his own agenda for the sake of theatricality

terse lava
#

He did also admit as the primordial that suffering was "sweetness." Truth at that point was one large piece of candy literally and figuratively

jolly furnace
#

Maybe GM subtley implanted him with logic plague while still in High charithy

#

Since GM can do that just by talking

#

GMs very words are evil and corruption

gilded mason
#

I don't really see when he would have the time or chance

jolly furnace
#

Its will and malice and desire to corrupt absolute

quiet umbra
#

uhh I'm not sure it can logic plague organic life before it reaches Key Mind status

#

y'know when it can logic plague remotely and command star roads

jolly furnace
#

He was talking though HC's speaker system

#

while MC was running through it

humble yacht
#

That doesn’t mean anything

jolly furnace
#

and truth was reassuring the covies in countering GM's threats

#

Its a half serious suggestion

quiet umbra
#

I don't think it works with that much of a seperation

jolly furnace
#

GM may not need Key Mind status

gilded mason
#

uhh I'm not sure it can logic plague organic life before it reaches Key Mind status
Keymind is any level of Flood coordinated intellect

humble yacht
#

The only known living organism to get plagued was the Didact

quiet umbra
#

at that point GM wasnt even on HC

jolly furnace
#

we may end with cortana logic plagued

humble yacht
#

And that took direct communication over a period of time

jolly furnace
#

GM doesn't eed to be

humble yacht
#

Like, face to face communication

jolly furnace
#

Again its a half joking suggestion

humble yacht
#

Well I’m fully rejecting it

jolly furnace
#

I dont expect a sufficient answer to thruths persona change in 3

#

He just lost the plot in the weeks between 2 and 3

humble yacht
#

we may end with cortana logic plagued
Hopefully not. I want to keep that theory far far away

gilded mason
#

Indeed

jolly furnace
#

the fact 343i have a work in canon suggesting makes me think they will do it

quiet umbra
#

absolutely plausible theories not entertained in a lore channel?

humble yacht
#

They don’t really

quiet umbra
#

😩

gilded mason
#
the fact 343i have a work in canon suggesting makes me think they will do it```
They had a character suggest it, but that was part of a whole series of different suggestions for why she's acting the way she is
humble yacht
#

That loot drop hardly suggested that Cortana herself had the plague

rigid sundial
#

she is just on space drugs and is having a bad trip

humble yacht
#

Subject Denver mentioned the plague merely as a reason that the covenant didn’t give too much ability/authority to AI

jolly furnace
#

I know but the fact the idea was entertained makes me think they could go with it

gilded mason
#

A bunch of different things were entertained, though

obsidian thistle
#

Well the series 2 Loot Drops were mainly this in a nutshell...

#

"Cortana has numerous reasons to turn out the way she did."

#

Thats it lol

gilded mason
#

Yup

quiet umbra
#

We already have precedent that Cortana was logic plagued in the past

obsidian thistle
#

It funnily enough added very lil to the narrative bar minor stuff.

quiet umbra
#

think of it like a backdoor for hacking

obsidian thistle
#

Which to be fair if the only place of said lore was "that" I dont disagree with 343i not putting major stuff into them

quiet umbra
#

mfw lore in loot boxes >_<

terse lava
#

With that lootbox I am more shocked that 1. The San shyuum lived that long and 2. No covenant picked him up

obsidian thistle
#

Great schism yo

#

Havok all around

#

Displaced so many people

#

And ships can only handle so many people.

#

I almost bet you that no matter how many both sides saved. Many had to be left behind or fight for themselves.

terse lava
#

Oh yea, billions died just around high charity

humble yacht
#

We already have precedent that Cortana was logic plagued in the past
I don’t think we do. We just have knowledge that the gravemind tried to convert her, but she was saved just before that could happen. Considering that next action she took was the one thing that could actually hurt the flood, evidence suggests that she wasn’t full blow logic plagued

terse lava
#

Do find that amusing though that 7 billion lived in high chairty

humble yacht
#

Hm

#

Well when you consider that most of the surface area of the earth is uninhabited by humans, I guess it’s not that surprising that so many organisms could be packed into such a small space

terse lava
#

True it's just the first time I have seen that idea put into practice in fiction

humble yacht
#

Though HC also seemed to have a lot of unused space

#

The area surrounding the key ship was so open and vast

#

Think about how many residential levels that space could have been used for

gilded mason
#

Man, the scale for in-game H2A High Charity is a bit screwy

obsidian thistle
#

I somehow get Midgar (FFVII) vibes from it xD I wont lie.

gilded mason
#

Those buildings look way too thick and tall for me, makes the place look really small

obsidian thistle
#

Where the old version was more flat

torpid flare
#

which one is better

terse lava
#

I love the new one; that is the one from the h2A cutscenes. If in-game, halo 2 classic as the buuildings.looked alien

gilded mason
#

Yeah, H2A terminals have a good scale for High Charity

obsidian thistle
#

I'd say the H2A one is "better" in a narrative point of view. But the H2C one flows better.

terse lava
#

Well H2A clips really put the proper scale in. You can barely make out the buildings compared to the key ship

#

Btw if I recall, wasnt the entire city floating over a massive methane field?

bright briar
#

Why is that unfortunate?

terse lava
#

I think he just does that to try to get a reaction out of the sangheili fans here

torpid flare
terse lava
#

Btw, anyone else think the jiralhanae were only allowed into the Covenant as a way to free up the control the sangheili had over the military

torpid flare
#

yeah, it is certain

abstract venture
#

It's worth noting though that the city is an extremely tiny portion of the actual station

#

In the Warfleet cross section it's shown to only be the very tip, with the rest being the stations different systems, defenses, docks and manufacturies

terse lava
#

True, the outer shell does have "city stations" that each hold tens of millions

#

Found it a tad interesting though that warfleet points out that the inner areas of the docks became inactive 1000 years ago

abstract venture
#

When I first read that I thought there could still be some time of underworld there, like the underhive of a hive city for 40k

#

Could make a cool story in halo

terse lava
#

Could, though that idea seemed to be implied in the further down docks

#

The "shadow" ports

abstract venture
#

Yeah, they could also be an explanation for the UNSC sneaking into high charity in the past

feral perch
#

That story is wack

terse lava
#

I hated that idea

abstract venture
#

it do be like dat sometimes

terse lava
#

A station whose fleet of hundreds wiped out anything larger then a cm... somehow fails to detect a single human

abstract venture
#

Prowlers op

terse lava
#

Chief gets the excuse of being teleported on. The flood get a break due to civil war kept the covenant from wiping the frigate on impact

gilded mason
#

Yeah, I don't buy it either

terse lava
#

It's never even said HOW he gets on ed either

#

AND got off

abstract venture
#

Imo ONI filled a prowler with Spartans wearing Ranger armor, with that doctor aboard and got on somehow

#

Maybe even used help from criminal elements in the Covenant, like the ones who ran the 'shadow ports'

terse lava
#

....the 2nd idea has just barley more merit then the first

abstract venture
#

The first part actually has merit, the second one is just a theory

#

The visual guide states it was rumored to sneak Spartans aboard, and we know a random doctor got aboard somehow so we can put two and two together

terse lava
#

My point is though...they could have done it elsewhere. A border colony, a cargo vessel. I could belive he got on the jiralhanae homeworld as it was new and primitive. But they go with high charity?

#

The most heavily known guarded place in the galaxy?

abstract venture
#

Also Silent Storm establishes that Prowlers stealth tech is much more powerful than the Covenants

feral perch
#

For how long into the war, though?

terse lava
#

That was mere months into the war

abstract venture
#

At the very start atleast, but if the Covenant never retrieved an intact prowler than its likely they couldn't develop effective countermeasures

#

Since they all self destruct usually

terse lava
#

They cleary developed something looks at Long Night

feral perch
#

CSO gang

abstract venture
#

gang gang

feral perch
#

we have massive hangars and Windows

abstract venture
#

Oh yeah btw

#

There's some newish alleged lore for the CSO

terse lava
#

At least the Long Night has the excuse of forerunner tech running it. Mr brute professor has nothing

#

Hm?

#

What would that be

abstract venture
#

https://youtu.be/0ARQmgR5pHg?t=8m23s

The guy who runs the sins of the prophet mod reached out to 343 writers who stated that the ship was pretty garbage, and more of a mobile battle station than a warship

#

Not clear canon but it's something new atleast 🤷🏾‍♂️

feral perch
#

And yet, Halo Oblivion establishes that there were at least twenty CSOs at the start of the war

abstract venture
#

I don't think those points oppose eachother though

feral perch
#

If they wanted to move away from the CSO, why introduce more?

abstract venture
#

I mean if you look at it, the CSOs each had a fleet of ~200 with them, which falls with the mention of them needing entire fleets to protect them since their too unwieldy

#

And they could just be battle stations for the entire fleet, coordinating everything and resupplying them

#

Also providing ground forces if they ever found forerunner relics and needed to invade a planet

feral perch
#

Sure

terse lava
#

I have seen that before

#

I have wondered though, ifbthry dont like it, why not just creatr.a new one? We know other vessels looked different then their fellow class

abstract venture
#

I agree

terse lava
#

Look at a regular destroyer, which if I recall was called shark-like, to the larger one used as a glorified penance vessel, to the largest type which has a large bulbous feature to it

versed helm
#

@feral perch Didn't Oblivion say there were like, twenty ships bigger than a CAS?

#

There may be classes of Covenant vessel between CAS and CSO

feral perch
#

Yes, but we don’t know of any.

#

Process of elimination says CSO

#

And gathering entire fleets around a single type of ship?

#

Sounds like a CSO

versed helm
#

I prefer not to count my chickens 'till they hatch

#

20 CSOs does seem excessive to me, given their advanced cloaking technology with logically ought to be of Forerunner origin given their title.

feral perch
#

It does seem excessive. Somebody ask Troy Denning on Twitter?

gilded mason
#

I guess I will.

versed helm
#

I would suggest the reason he didn't outright state "20 CSOs"

#

Is exactly because he wanted many of them to be not CSOs

#

Or 343 did, anyway

gilded mason
#

I'll note something similar in my question

feral perch
#

That’s entirely possible

abstract venture
#

We know that CAS are on the upper end of size/resources put into a ship for the covenant

#

So I doubt there would be many models larger considering the CAS already does its job extremely well

#

Odds are they were CSOs

versed helm
#

I don't follow the logic.

#

The CSO's mere existence indicates the feasibility of ships larger in scale than a CAS which aren't the CSO.

#

Of course, given that the CSO is basically (at least externally) an upscaled CAS, they do all probably share the distinctive CAS layout.

gilded mason
#

Sent the question to Troy.

feral perch
#

Thanks!

gilded mason
#

aaa I made a spelling mistake

#

o no 😥

feral perch
#

Oh. Time to commit seppuku I guess

versed helm
#

Or whatever Elites do instead

#

Successfully fire the Halo array, I guess

#

Or get Arbiter-ized

gilded mason
#

rip me

terse lava
#

"There was only one typo.."
"One..are you certain?"
"Yes..it was[typo]"
"Why was it not correct with the rest of the sentence??"

feral perch
#

Mark of shame

solemn jay
#

U kno reach could have been saved and not glassed if the humans just had better defenses

#

It’s just really gets to me

gilded mason
#

They really could've lived if they didn't die

terse lava
#

Reach was doomed regardless

solemn jay
#

I mean if they had better defenses

gilded mason
#

That sounds tautologous

solemn jay
#

I mean the covenant had better technology

terse lava
#

Yes...?

gilded mason
#

Quite the fast reply

#

Since it wasn't specified in the text, I shouldn't specify it here. No good comes of sealing the continuity for anyone who might want to touch on it in the future.

terse lava
#

Wait..he responded to that but not the Xytan one? Pity

#

But yea..that reply makes sense

solemn jay
#

Lol

gilded mason
#

Ye

#
Wait..he responded to that but not the Xytan one? Pity```
I asked Grim that, not Denning.
terse lava
#

Oh

#

Cleard that then

versed helm
#

So uh

#

Yeah, on that basis, best not assume 20 CSOs

gilded mason
#

Yeah

terse lava
#

Truth be told...we have never been told the CSO was the largest vessel the covenant had

#

Look at the forerunners, itnqas claimed while the Mantle's Approach was advanced, it was not the largest

versed helm
#

For the sake of sanity it's probably best not to try and push things further than the CSO

#

At the very least, do away with the upscaled CAS design

terse lava
#

I know, I am only saying, 3400 years is a long time. They could have built something more

#

Agreed on the 2nd part

#

I can tolerate a few being around, as a jump board, a prototype to show the thing can be done

gilded mason
#

Yeah, make it look a bit more unique

versed helm
#

Let's not forget how already massive ships are in the Halo universe, though.

#

If we're trying to keep realistic feasibility in mind.

terse lava
#

Correction, how massive covenant and forerunner ones are

versed helm
#

Well, put it this way.

#

The biggest ships in The Expanse (in the TV show as-yet) measure out at about the same as a UNSC light frigate. Aside from the Belter monstrosity which isn't much of a warship.

#

Go figure.

#

If we're looking at things in a realistic capacity, much greater than 5km really is straining believability.

#

The raw materials alone are ridiculous, and this is all hardened meta-material battleplate stuff.

terse lava
#

Well forerunners had the golden ticket that won them infinite energy for such things

#

I would say at beast, outside of what we have seen, the covenant could have put Dyson swarms around stars

versed helm
#

I think that's a bit of an overestimation.

#

What's your basis?

terse lava
#

I am literally only assuming, we know they terraform a world for plasma, and apparently can cover an entire world in plasma torpedo drones, though of course a star would be far far far more massive

versed helm
#

🤷‍♂️

#

Remember, for the universe to work, they still need to get their butts beat by humanity sometimes.

#

They ain't Godlike yet.

terse lava
#

The closest I have for basis I would say is this, they can pump out massive vessels decently enough and have been around for 3400 years

#

I would think at some point, someone would consider turning to those big balls of gas burning in the void

#

Also, dont forget the entire covenant was not focused on the war

abstract venture
#

Yeah the covenant mined out decent sized moons hollow

#

And terraformed entire planets to mass produce plasma

#

Early covenant was able to build High Charity over 140 years with only a few dozen colonies and it weighed 100 trillion metric tons

#

That amount of material is roughly 1 CAS carrier per day (more accurately 0.725 CAS's) or 21.6 CCS Cruisers daily produced by early covenant with a fraction of manpower or resources they had at their peak

#

quick maths

terse lava
#

The covenant will never cease to impress me

torpid flare
#

covenant during their peak era is like about 1000 times the production of America during WW2.

sacred dew
#

Could a sangeli live to see high charity finished within its lifetime

abstract venture
#

Yeah

#

It was built over 140 years and we know some Elites over 200 years old are fit to serve in the military still

terse lava
#

Well actually we dont know if early covenant sangheili lived as long as nizat

abstract venture
#

True

terse lava
#

3400 year difference, and the san shyuum only sought life extension in the 1550s

torpid flare
#

did your elite fingers mess up your typing? lol

abstract venture
#

I don't think the Elites would alter themselves though to increase lifespan

#

Since it probably required medical procedures which we know how they feel about

sacred dew
#

Heresy!!!

terse lava
#

We only know how some feel on that

#

Those on sangheilios

#

And even then, one keep

abstract venture
#

Pretty sure its stated several times

#

That blood spilled outside combat is shameful and elites avoid it

#

It's mentioned in Envoy also where the elites ain't from sanghelios

terse lava
#

Ok fair, there are many other colonies though

gilded mason
#

I don’t buy that stuff as being all-encompassing

terse lava
#

It cant be

abstract venture
#

Yeah

terse lava
#

A colony would have a hard time setting shop if everyone who gets hurt avoids treatment

gilded mason
#

Any Sangheili that tries to speak for everyone regarding that kinda stuff is just some hick that thinks everyone is like them.

sacred dew
#

Maybe it's exclusive only for warrior classes

terse lava
#

Doubtful

gilded mason
#

It’d make even less sense

terse lava
#

They would need treatment at some ppont

half apex
#

i don't think it makes sense that only the high end elite warriors are the only ones getting treatment

abstract venture
#

Also Covie warships had some pretty advanced automated surgery suites

half apex
#

it's not like they are tasked with the important stuff concerning building a colony

#

like building shelter

gilded mason
#

Hunters in the Dark and Silent Storm note that they receive medical attention.

terse lava
#

And can use it easily enough

gilded mason
#

And The Flood, for an earlier example

torpid flare
#

try some Irukan

#

it is good

half apex
#

your Irukan im pretty sure might get poisoned by ONI

#

no chance haha

#

wait Irukan was the food the elites ate right?

gilded mason
#

A grain that is part of their diet, yes

half apex
#

hmm

torpid flare
#

i tried ONI's Irukan, the elites loved their grain

remote spruce
#

what human food would elites like

terse lava
#

Likely any

torpid flare
#

but not chocolate

half apex
#

hamburgers

#

i don't care what species you are

#

you absolutely cannot resist hamburgers

#

did spartans play sports?

#

in down time

reef cobalt
#

Boxing probably

torpid flare
#

grifball? but it could be simulated

half apex
#

well any unsc troop really

#

in halo it seems like all war and shooting and stress but no fun?

subtle depot
#

Probably after the human covenant war ended they would have more time for leisure. As for the sports though probably just basketball and soccer in free time. Spartans especially probably weren’t on organized sports teams