#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 282 of 1

terse lava
#

All of them get to have a chance to kick the hierarchs' butts

gilded mason
#

No no...you had it right the first time

inner basin
#

Are we grammar checking now, Ostral?

terse lava
#

Always imagines truth waking up, surrounded by furious covenant and humans

gilded mason
#

No, it’s not about grammar. 😋

terse lava
#

It's about the humor

hasty locust
#

I’m lost

inner basin
#

What humour.... This chat never makes me laugh... It’s always dull and full of big nerds talking about VERY SERIOUS lore. This thing you call humour is heresy of the highest kind.

keen canopy
#

...Really?

inner basin
#

No, it’s called sarcasm

terse lava
#

take care beast, what you say is heresy

hasty locust
#

I have been diagnosed with nerd

keen canopy
#

Oh I must have lagged or something

#

I said "...Really?" after Ado said there's a bright side to being flooded 😄

#

Well I guess it is eternal life of some sort

terse lava
#

Let's be honest, if this chat room was a building, it would be a comedy club

inner basin
#

Oh no. Not the lag.... I’m laaaaagggg...... innnnnggggg.....

terse lava
#

Great, too much flood talk. The logic plague has set in

inner basin
#

Ado, do you not mean fight club, instead of comedy club?

terse lava
#

@inner basin why not both?

inner basin
#

Touché

hasty locust
#

Hmm

terse lava
#

Wonder if the covenant knew the fate of the infected

#

Vadimee clearly didnt, thinking his underlings were going on the great journey despite their flood fate

keen canopy
#

Ok here's one guys, what Flood direction would you prefer future Halo media takes:

The one where the Flood are Precursor-level powerful, and have been holding back in order to test Humanity for the mantle/some similar prank tactics that they pulled on the ancient humans and Forerunners?

Or the one where the flood are a shadow of the Precursors driven by revenge and want to kill all life they created, and they've been trying their very hardest to accomplish that post-Array Firing.

gilded mason
#

The latter, for me

inner basin
#

^ I second that

terse lava
#

Ditto

#

The idea of the precursors doing all this for humanity to gain the mantle.....yea

hasty locust
#

Both

terse lava
#

I...I don't think the other races would be happy knowing that

keen canopy
#

Me too, I think they've been trying their hardest, and attribute their failures to their extreme arrogance, a legacy of the Precursors.

terse lava
#

They never showed arrogance though

inner basin
#

The former doesn’t seem plausible firstly, and secondly they are a corrupted version of what they used to be (could be a good explanation for why they can’t either)

terse lava
#

That we k ow of

hasty locust
#

Who else would want another collection of halo short stories, like on explaining what happened to James-005 or his thought while he was just floating, maybe one of What buck did on reach during new Alexandria or hell even a chips Dubbo short story

terse lava
#

Ur didact when thought the precursors o ly wanted to create

#

Eh..expand it out a bit more

#

I don't think watching james become a popsicle would make for great enterainment

keen canopy
#

I definitely think many of their actions have been made in arrogance, the Flood wanted the Forerunners to suffer.

#

Instead of just systematically infecting them.

terse lava
#

@keen canopythe flood yes, not the precursors they once were though

hasty locust
#

Well they did that one short comic story about that ship dead in the water

keen canopy
#

Oh you're saying the Precursors didn't show arrogance?

terse lava
#

@hasty locusthm?

#

Correct

hasty locust
#

Lemme get the name

keen canopy
#

They're The Precursors they're on such a different level

#

There is no way they consider themselves equals with the life they created

terse lava
#

Well yea

keen canopy
#

The same way humans are arrogant when considering animal life

terse lava
#

Black white vs green and brown morality

keen canopy
#

Indeed, that's what I meant by arrogance

#

Just pure, inbuilt "we are gods"

terse lava
#

Will give you that

#

Idk about the gods part

#

They thought the universe itself was.a living being beyond their level

hasty locust
#

Undefeated (tales from slipspace)

terse lava
#

@hasty locusthuh, ok?

keen canopy
#

You know what I mean lol

terse lava
#

Yea

keen canopy
#

Look at this absolute bitter anger here:

Our urge to create is immutable; we must create. But the beings we create shall never again reach out in strength against us. All that is created will suffer. All will be born in suffering, endless grayness shall be their lot. All creation will tailor to failure and pain, that never again shall the offspring of the eternal Fount rise up against their creators. Listen to the silence. Ten million years of deep silence. And now, whimpers and cries; not of birth. That is what we bring: a great crushing weight to press down youth and hope. No more will. No more freedom. Nothing new but agonizing death and never good shall come of it. We are the last of those who gave you breath and form, millions of years ago. We are the last of those your kind defied and ruthlessly destroyed. We are the last Precursors. And now we are legion."

terse lava
#

Every time I read that I can taste it on my tongue

hasty locust
#

Taste?

terse lava
#

Which boggles my mind

#

They are these uber powerful beings, and throw a hissy fit

#

The bitterness settle

inner basin
#

I’d say that’s a bit more that bitter anger, eezy

hasty locust
#

Hey if I was sooooo powerful and got driven to extinction by some angry forerunner boys I would be pretty pissed too

terse lava
#

Its...just madness

#

That's the thing

#

Toys

#

It's like a human being pissed at a germ

hasty locust
#

Toys?

keen canopy
#

Well compare it to the bible for example, where the god comes to earth and experiences suffering and death and forgives everyone yada yada

inner basin
#

Every living being is like a toy to the Precursors, is what Ado was trying to say, I think, settling

hasty locust
#

Well if a disease or “germ” brought us to near extinction, I would hate said germ

terse lava
#

The point being normal mortal life is so far, far below these guys, who have seeded galaxies for billions of years.

keen canopy
#

if Jesus was a precursor he'd get back to heaven and then decide to turn everything to hell

#

It feels petty of the Precursors to get in their feelings

terse lava
#

I dont think that matches perfectly, but I get the gist

keen canopy
#

You created life, live with the consequences

terse lava
#

Exactly

#

And somehow, the forerunners are the ONLY ones to ever rebel?

hasty locust
#

The only ones to rebel.....

terse lava
#

No other race that was told by the precursors that they would not inherent a mantle just what shrug their shoulders

hasty locust
#

and suceed

inner basin
#

They must’ve had a real distaste for humanity to rebel against the Precursors for the sole reason of humanity being given the Mantle

terse lava
#

True, others were likely erased before

#

Mythos says the forerunners found that out by accident

#

And that started theirs

inner basin
#

Imagine. Had that never gotten out Halo as we know it, would’ve never happened. All the civilisations would be completely different

terse lava
#

Yep, well maybe

inner basin
#

More specifically the main thing about Halo, the Installations themselves would’ve never happened, more than likely

terse lava
#

Everyone would still be here. Just not in our current civilizations.

inner basin
#

Well unless the Forerunners did go on a rampage after humanity was given the Mantle

terse lava
#

Although you would have humanity in charge of the galaxy with the mantle

inner basin
#

^ Which could also be dangerous in itself

terse lava
#

Well no, forerunners would have be erased

inner basin
#

Oh yeah, I keep forgetting about that because it wasn’t done when they did go on a murderous rampage (against the Precursors)

terse lava
#

Yep

inland matrix
#

The precursors didn’t fight back at all

#

They were amazed by what their creations were doing

#

But the turned to anger obviously

#

And they decided to hibernate for billions of years

#

And in their hibernation, they became corrupted into the Flood

terse lava
#

Millions @inland matrix

keen canopy
#

Indeed, everything would've been fine if Ancient Humanity hadn't accidently brought them back from the dead.

terse lava
#

Eh someone would have goofed somewhere down the line

#

...likely humanity still

#

Bit they were just fine before

#

Kinda

#

Just noticed something interesting on the Halo war 2 DLC

#

They entire time voridus and his brutes were fighting the flood, that scarab was active the whole time

#

Used to think it had been forced to shut down or killed the colony inside it

inner basin
#

Hmm... why not just fire at the enemies below, even if some of it is friendly fire. Would’ve saved them trouble in the long run

#

The Brute forces down by the entrance clearly couldn’t handle the flood forces flowing out of High Charity

keen canopy
#

Probably because their commander was down there no?

terse lava
#

Likely worth the loss

#

He was the idiot who opened it, after his chieftain told him not too, and his brother told hin not too multiple times

#

Domt see him returning in any future.material

inner basin
#

He may now appear in future material, but if he was to be killed off then, I doubt anyone would’ve REALLY cared. I mean at that point he was a nobody

remote spruce
#

It's implied a crew is recommended but like a lot of Halo vehicles, it can still be solo crew

#

The Banished one that is

random fable
#

Aren’t Scarabs made up of the same thing as Hunters? Or am I wrong? Because if that is the thing then could it technically pilot itself?

gilded mason
#

Aren’t Scarabs made up of the same thing as Hunters?
Ye

sleek star
stoic hamlet
#

I don’t remember Xperia being so clickbaity

remote spruce
#

It's been like that for a long time

#

I assume the videos are good

versed helm
#

I mean... The video does explain both of those things...

stoic hamlet
#

What sources does he give?

versed helm
#

Fistful of arrows

stoic hamlet
#

Not canon

versed helm
#

True, but ive heard 343 was planning on publishing it.

stoic hamlet
#

....I don’t think they can?

versed helm
#

They did contact the writer about it

keen canopy
#

It's still not Canon however

indigo thorn
#

are there any explorer vessel or dedicated people discovering the universe like in trek?

keen canopy
#

There are salvagers

#

You might like Smoke and Shadow, and Renegades

versed helm
#

true, though both 343 and bungie have acknowledged it over the years as if it were canon, all 343 has to do is say its canon at this point.

terse lava
#

Pretty much

feral perch
#

I don’t think it’s quite that simple.

#

If it were, why not canonize it already?

terse lava
#

Maybe the creator wants credit? Who knows

#

Btw, have we been a covenant shotgun yet? Not counting the mauler as that's brute tech

true shadow
#

imo the energy sword and gravity hammer fill that category. A short range weapon that does devastating damage vs players.

#

That and vice versa can be applied to the shotgun coz it fills the role of melee weapons on the side of the UNSC

terse lava
#

I just find it kind of absurd that the sangheili could have gotten all the way to making plasma weaponry, but s shotgun never appears

true shadow
#

Maybe it has something to do with honour and culture i.e. if you’re that close to your opponent then use your physical strength against theirs

terse lava
#

Maybe

true shadow
#

Which would give some nice added lore to the energy sword imo

terse lava
#

They did t have the energy sword though before the covenant was made, they had curve bladed

#

And burn blades

obsidian thistle
#

This reminds me of a Shotgun in a sense https://www.halopedia.org/Type-50_concussion_rifle

Halopedia

The Type-50 Directed Energy Rifle/Heavy (T50 DER/H), commonly known as the Concussion Rifle, is a Covenant infantry weapon. The general design of the Concussion Rifle was engineered by a group of Sangheili merchants from Qikost long before the signing of the Writ of Union; wh...

true shadow
#

ik, what I meant by that is that in a way they’ve managed to preserve their old honour and culture through newer methods

terse lava
#

Always saw the concussion rifle as a clearing weapon sure, but it doesnt fill an area like a shotgun

true shadow
#

You’d be more likely to hurt yourself if you were to use it like a shotgun

terse lava
#

Yea

#

Must have been something though unless they never hunted flying fowl

stoic hamlet
#

I mean, tbf, they don’t really need a shotgun

#

Plasma is absurdly good in the lore

terse lava
#

True

#

One pretty much a grenade .launcher with plasma

#

The repeater...bungie did day it's the assautlt rifle of the covenant

#

@versed helmconcussion too

#

I wouldn't put the storm in the same page

#

Its only good at very close range

#

And yes, to me the plasma rifle will ialways be that. That's what. Bungie said thoufh

#

The plasma launcher?

#

Welcome

#

It is

#

It was. Nice

#

Indeed it did

versed helm
#

Does anyone have an explanation for the promethean soldiers? I know the knights are organics turned robot, but what are the soldiers?

gilded mason
#

AI

carmine sleet
#

Specifically Armiegers (Please tell if I spelt that right)

gilded mason
#

Armiger, I think

carmine sleet
#

Ah, thanks

versed helm
#

Well if the forerunners had ai robots to fight the flood, then why did they need knights?

terse lava
#

Logic plagie

#

It turns ai the flood cause

humble yacht
#

well for one thing, the Promethean knights weren't exactly an effective way of combating the Flood

#

at the macro level

carmine sleet
#

The Forerunners were losing and the Ur-Didact didn't like the idea of using Halos, so he created the Promethean constructs

humble yacht
#

yeah

versed helm
#

I forgot about the logic plague

terse lava
#

Wonder if the covenant ever encountered the logic plague or a gravemind before
Or if f they learned if them purely from forerunner records

humble yacht
#

records

#

Logic plague requires a Gravemind and as far as we know, the I05 Gravemind is the first the covenant have come into contact with

terse lava
#

Guess so until we know if the covenant ever faced a gravemind level outbreak before

humble yacht
#

they can disassemble and reassemble in new places

#

dunno

versed helm
#

Dark Magic

agile tangle
#

Yo, I’ve been getting back into Halo recently due to Reach being added into MCC and wanted to know if Halo Legends was cannon?

gilded mason
#

The events, but not the visuals

#

And Odd One Out is completely non-canon.

agile tangle
#

Ok thanks

obsidian thistle
#

Visuals at times can be debated.

#

So take it as you will

terse lava
#

I still say the duel was visually canon as well
Just for the sheer awesomeness of it

gilded mason
#
I still say the duel was visually canon as well```
No thanks
#

Actually especially no thanks on that one. 😋

terse lava
#

Ok correction, the action, visual action

gilded mason
#

That's acceptable

terse lava
#

Should have clarified

#

Not the Japanese buildings or....her

gilded mason
#

I won't have you branded for heresy yet

terse lava
#

I thank you my liege

versed helm
#

Since Los Angeles still exists in the Halo universe,does that mean Hollywood still exists?

terse lava
#

If it does, the halo movie still will not have been made yet

feral perch
#

gg

glacial dock
#

@versed helm Is spartan 1337 from the anime parody lol?

fair hazel
#

odd one out halo legends

glacial dock
#

Aww yea the dbz parody was so stupid

fair hazel
#

it was fun

glacial dock
#

I liked the mech one more

fair hazel
#

the prototype?

glacial dock
#

@fair hazel I think dont remember the epidsode name since it was so long ago. All I remember was that it was the epidsode where one marine goes on a rampage against the covenant to avenge a fallen marine

#

With a mech of course

fair hazel
#

more depth than that but, The Prototype

half apex
#

wait who is 1337

#

imma look it up 😄

#

oh there isn't much on him

#

._.

#

anyways i have a question. does the unsc have a version of the energy sword?

versed helm
#

On CE the energy sword was gonna have a counterpart

#

The M13 Machete

fair hazel
#

Spartan 1337 is the non-canon character from odd one out.

#

There's the energy bayonet.

terse lava
#

Wasnt that also in the halo mmo

versed helm
#

Halo Titan was it?

terse lava
#

Yes

#

That thing had promise

#

I think, dont think sangheili were playable -_-

versed helm
#

Wonder how it would've been like if it had been released.

terse lava
#

No clue

versed helm
#

Forerunners were gonna be playable though

#

Spartans marines and other aliens

#

But no Sangheili...

terse lava
#

They might have, but never hard. Saw they were enemies though

versed helm
#

Yeah I saw concept art of a guy in active Camo about to kill a zealot

fair hazel
#

This is a halo 5 thing

versed helm
#

Yeah it is

#

The bayonet

#

Also not having slow mode is such a relief in This channel lol

terse lava
#

@fair hazeljuat reminded me of the titan one

tacit stump
#

‪Just a little theory, what if mendicant bias was using Cortanas form to get close with the master chief to manipulate him into fighting for him, he is known across the universe as the greatest fighter after all and the librarian sort of planned for his existence, it would restore some of the damage halo 5 made to cortanas death as she’d now be considered dead

#

Plus mendicant bias could finally be introduced properly in a main line halo game!

obsidian thistle
#

https://www.halopedia.org/Energy_Bayonet @fair hazel may help to provide context friend 😉 Not everyone looks at uploaded file names.

Halopedia

An Energy bayonet is a UNSC Weapon attachment that is used to counter personnel in close quarters combat. It generally takes the form of a barrel attachment with a blade similar to that of an Energy Sword.

#

Wish we had more lore on it however.

#

It just exists...

fair hazel
#

Me too, and pictures

#

and places where its used in the story

obsidian thistle
#

Well I can probs get more images of the weapons its on.

fair hazel
#

Maybe an image where we see all the bayonet weapons at once would be nice.

#

The bayonet is one of my favourite attachments lore/story wise

#

Honestly it'd be interesting to me if they somehow made kinetic bolts + energy bayonet and hard light shield the default master chief equipment, or something like that

obsidian thistle
#

Well

#

Ya know

#

Kinetic bolts are on a shotgun that has seen use.

fair hazel
#

which is also my favourite boomco weapon..

obsidian thistle
#

Nice looking Shotgun I wont lie

#

OOHH Discord fixed the ) issue.

fair hazel
#

I honestly think the hard light shield is pretty cool too.

hasty locust
#

I remember it as one solid thing in h4

#

Probably wrong

fair hazel
#

I really want to see more armour abilities and attachments in various halo media

hasty locust
#

Again

fair hazel
#

What do you mean

hasty locust
#

All the little floaty bits on the corners and such

fair hazel
#

That's the concept art I posted

hasty locust
#

Yeah I prefer that over the ingame one

fair hazel
#

I like halo escalation making use of the armour abilities.

obsidian thistle
#

There is floaty bits. But not as much as the in-game one.

fair hazel
#

Sure it looks nicer but, it sorta leaves gaps in the concept art

hasty locust
#

In game just looks like a tiny floaty bit at the top and bottom

fair hazel
hasty locust
#

That Palmer?

fair hazel
#

Yes.

hasty locust
#

I would like to see in game elites wielding a sword with some kind of shield wether it be a round jackal one or like the h4 hard light one I think it would look coolios

fair hazel
#

Like this?

hasty locust
#

Exactly

#

That’s that comic (forgot its name) where Rtas loses his mandible right

#

Takes place during Ce with the Like garden ship and the prophet and the flood

fair hazel
#

Last Voyage of the infinite succor

hasty locust
#

Yes

obsidian thistle
#

Its in the "Halo Graphic Novel".

#

Original name i know xD

hasty locust
#

Lol

fair hazel
#

Good thing the first halo comic wasn't named. Halo Comic.

hasty locust
#

Ha

fair hazel
#

I really like the DSC-class

hasty locust
#

Was that the type os ship the garden ship is?

fair hazel
#

It's a support ship

#

Provides food, armament, repair rest/hunting grounds, to a fleet

hasty locust
#

Ah

#

Aren’t those two domes big farms

fair hazel
#

Two hunting domes which serve as training areas, recreational zones, cloisters of worship, and animal paddocks.

hasty locust
#

Hmm interesting

#

Probably the best ship to live on then

terse lava
#

Do I hear talk of covenant things?

fair hazel
#

the san'shyuum did really keep those ships exclusive though

#

honestly it'd be nice to see one of these pop up and sorta serve as the center piece of operational power of a post-war faction

hasty locust
#

Play in one in a game

#

Be fun

terse lava
#

Would be nice, some ex covenant group that ends up like the red cross, going from system to system to help old covenant worlds

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

That seems like a. Missed opportunity To have something like that. H5

terse lava
#

Mhm

tame crystal
#

you know how the halo multiplayer is supposedly a 'war games' simulation?

#

i like to think the campaigns are also simulations too, where they're like a retelling of what happened

#

that explains the different difficulties and the differences between each playthrough, and also explains some continuity issues (like CE vs The Flood, CE having very few weapons and halo 2 having no assault rifle)

stoic hamlet
#

The campaigns are literally just gameplay.

I suppose it kind of works, seeing as we have Spartan Assault and Spartan Strike as actual examples of past missions simulated, but stuff that’s there because of gameplay is literally just gameplay.

terse lava
#

Think only halo 2A was what could count as that

#

As it appears to be a re telling from thel

agile tangle
#

How strong is Atriox by himself? Could he be comparable to Chief or the Arbiter (Thel), below, or above?

gilded mason
#

He's probably a lot stronger physically than them

agile tangle
#

I wouldn’t be surprised if Atriox mopped the floor with Chief and Thel, he looks so intimidating compared to a lot of past enemies that Chief has gone against

terse lava
#

Idk, in cut content, thel took on the brutes holding johnson in halo 2 solo

#

Truthfully though would depend on the situation

#

well, it got far enough to be animated

#

If you want a better example, a commando sangheili took on chief after the alpha halo battle

#

Johnson shot his rifle full auto into the commander's back while the guy sawed through chief's armor with a sword

#

The sangheili only grunted and kept going

#

Not anymore

agile tangle
#

Where the brutes more efficient than the elites when they took over?

#

Or did it stay the same?

gilded mason
#

No no, Atriox is dumb muscle as well. 😏

terse lava
#

@gilded mason👍

#

Let's put it this way

agile tangle
#

When Chief first encountered a brute, it was stated that it moved as fast as him while also implying that it was faster than an elite, does that mean brutes are not only stronger than elites but faster as well?

terse lava
#

The covenant survived 3400 years with sangheili

agile tangle
#

My bad

terse lava
#

It survived a month with brutes

agile tangle
#

I got a lot of questions

gilded mason
#

I think Broken Circle has an Elite that's faster than his Brute opponent

#

So it varies

terse lava
#

True

#

And of course, fal 'chavamee

gilded mason
#

Also, we know Elites can move faster than Spartans

#

Or at least, some amount can

terse lava
#

Yep, use carried vale like a blur

#

Uzse

gilded mason
#

And they jumped the gap without having to use thrusters like the SIVs

terse lava
#

happy worting

gilded mason
#

With one SIV noting that the Elites were like bullets compared to himself

#

But are any faster than K?
Maybe some

#

Somewhere

lunar condor
#

Elites have their own K somewhere

#

Man imagine having an entire race as strong as spartans and still losing lmao

agile tangle
#

The covenant were technologically advanced yet they never made their own versions of the spartans, I know they had a group (or groups) that would ambush them and kill them

terse lava
#

Prelates

#

San shyuum

gilded mason
#

Man imagine having an entire race as strong as spartans and still losing lmao
Lose what?

lunar condor
#

Hmm i guess the covenant managed to not win long enough that they lost

terse lava
#

@gilded masoneveryone thinks the covenant/sangheili lost the war

gilded mason
#

And the Elites kinda beat the Covenant for the humans.

agile tangle
#

Ah

lunar condor
#

The Sangheili technically won the war with the humans against the covenant

terse lava
#

@lunar condoryou do know humans didnt win either right?

agile tangle
#

Ok that also answered another question I had

lunar condor
#

I mean humans and sangheili are still around cant say the same about the covenant as a whole that counts as a win for me

agile tangle
#

Humans, elites, and the flood basically ended the covenant lol

terse lava
#

Mostly the sangheili

gilded mason
#

Indeed

terse lava
#

Flood? High charity and the ark

#

Humanity? Same

#

Sangheili? Literally everywhere

agile tangle
#

The elites look so intimidating yet they get beat badly by Spartans

#

It irritates me

gilded mason
#

The Inverse Ninja rule

agile tangle
#

Some elites could definitely hold their own against Spartans tho

terse lava
#

Makes me lament the old lore, that had sangheili as the best navy/army after the war while humanity was busy recovering

#

Honor

gilded mason
#

Also: gameplay

terse lava
#

Why did knights and samurai get swords but not Joe the peasent?

#

Exactly

#

Shame on joe

gilded mason
#

Well, nobles can only get energy swords in civilian settings

#

In the military, it's all fine

#

I dunno. Ask France, Spain, Rome, etc

terse lava
#

Well minors cant wield them...though seems lore forgot that

#

Too young and lack of experience

#

You going to give the sword to the trained commander, or the eager minor?

#

Majors can apparently wield them

#

Major on up

gilded mason
#

Gameplay.

terse lava
#

For the very reason they are for higher ups

#

And that

#

Not horribly often, when they do appear usually by high ranks

#

The commando who fought john, major Thel 'Lodamee, fleetmaster Voro Nar 'Mantakree, characters from modern day broken circle, to name a few

#

Oh, thel's minors did too

sleek star
lunar condor
#

Afaik if thats from the kilo-five trilogy it wasnt even a heartbreaking ending

#

Maybe bittersweet

obsidian thistle
#

Anyone want a weird piece of trivia? 😄

#

The Halo 3 M6G (and I am referring about the Halo 3 version) is more a modification package to the latest revision than a actual M6G itself.

#

This would in theory allow the M6C branding to be on it. Via either the og weapon being a M6C or the modification package using M6C parts.

obsidian sapphire
#

does anyone know how big the post war unsc navy is

#

like 5 years after the end of the war

solid fox
#

@obsidian sapphire It did expand rapidly with the adaption of Forerunner tech.... I would assume maybe the size of the peak war fleet before harvest

#

The addition of Autumn class ship and The Infinity bolstered the UNSC navy immensly

carmine sleet
#

@versed helm That one they linked is HaloFollower

gleaming mauve
#

Just out of interest - does High Altitude Low Opening have anything to do with halo?

carmine sleet
#

HALO jumps are sometimes performed by Spartans or ODSTs

sleek star
#

casue i like to share Halo new and im big Halo fan @versed helm

#

that one was HALO FOLLOWER video

wicked pasture
#

english isnt your first language is it @sleek star

vast mortar
#

hello

#

echo echo echo

sleek star
#

english is MY ONLY language @wicked pasture

vast mortar
#

me no englac

carmine sleet
#

HaloFollower is known to get facts wrong in his video, which isn't great when its news or you're trying to introduce the lore to someone new

unique rune
#

To this day I still haven’t gotten over the fact that he consistently pronounced Emile-A239’s name like “Emily”.

humble yacht
#

Ew

vast mortar
#

how do you mess that up

feral perch
#

I don't mean to bash, but his channel is the only place I have heard "recession" pronounced "rekession"

fair hazel
#

Oh no. Emile is a French name.

versed helm
#

On a scale of 1-10

#

Probably 4

#

He isnt a psycho

#

Imagine Emile as the Halo equivalent the Punisher

#

He's just very angry his family died

#

And uses that as a catalyst in war

carmine sleet
#

I don't think they have a scale on how much of a psychopath someone is

vast mortar
#

I agree

#

are you sure about that

versed helm
#

Well he asked "how high" so I put on a scale

#

Otherwise no, there really isnt a scale for how psychopathic someone is

humble yacht
#

A psychopath is someone with a complete lack of empathy

#

Emile doesn’t completely lack empathy

#

At least not with other Spartans

stoic hamlet
#

He lacks empathy towards his enemies/covenant and insurgents, which isn’t necessarily unexpected. Most of not all III’s would lack empathy towards Covenant, seeing as how they lost everything because of them.

inner basin
#

The Spartan-IIIs are unable to humanise their enemies due to how much they’ve lost. Most if not all were described as vengeful orphans.

hollow meadow
#

He also butt heads with Jorge who is basically Emile's polar opposite. Rather than being a vengeful spirit hellbent on leaving his opponents drowning in a pool of their own blood, Jorge is more of the gentle giant with his motivation to fight being to protect his fellow humans.

terse lava
#

Jun too

inner basin
#

He still doesn’t like the Covenant though. If we were to go off a Fistful of Arrows as canon (which is all but confirmed as canon with some 343 employees seeing it as canon I believe), Emile and Jorge just bantered back and forth a bit more than being antagonistic to each other.

That section in Winter Contingency was however a genuine clash as Jorge was a bit more sensitive about the girl losing her father but Emile didn’t view it as such. At least that’s my interpretation of the bigger picture

terse lava
#

True

fair hazel
#

A fistful of arrows is definitely not canon

inner basin
#

Not saying it is canon as of this point. But there were plans to make it canon years ago (which unfortunately fell through), but some people in the 343 office consider it canon, Bungie said it years ago too, and it fits in the canon perfectly.

inner basin
#

And again, I’m not saying it is canon, like I said above. But even so, it sounds like an accurate depiction of the two Spartans in that book. I just wish 343 would make it canon in the future

humble yacht
#

Heard of the sequel? For A Few Arrows More

inner basin
#

I have heard of it, but not read it

humble yacht
#

And then the other sequel, The Good, The Bad, and The Dinos

inner basin
#

Which is why he isn’t

hasty locust
#

Who is spartan 1337

#

Do Spartan 4’s even have numbers anymore

humble yacht
#

Don’t think so

#

But then spartan IVs aren’t leaving their identities behind to become Spartans

hasty locust
#

So I wonder what the highest spartan number is 🤔 there were 300 Spartans in beta and alpha companies so that’s up to 450, so how many were in gamma?

#

In gamma alone?

#

Dang

#

So highest spartan would be G770

#

Whoops G780

humble yacht
#

Wouldn’t the numbers reset with the new class

hasty locust
#

Well Emile was A2 something, something

#

A239

#

And I think they had 150 in alpha

#

And 150 in beta

inner basin
#

No, 300 in Alpha and Beta

humble yacht
#

300 in alpha nd 300 in beta

#

Like there is a B004

#

So the numbers had to reset

inner basin
#

I’m pretty confident they did

hasty locust
#

Ah

#

Ok

humble yacht
#

Training companies were larger than 300 tho

hasty locust
#

Thanks for clearing that up for me

humble yacht
#

And numbers were based on training company size, not final company size

inner basin
#

If you go to Gammas, they have 001-330 in their tags instead of 601-930

hasty locust
#

Okey dokey

stoic hamlet
#

The numbers reset

inner basin
#

Donk, it’s a good read imo, but that’s because I love S-III lore

hasty locust
#

I’m re-reading everything this year before infinite

stoic hamlet
#

The highest Spartan III would actually be from Alpha Company

hasty locust
#

I’m on first strike (started at fall of reach)

stoic hamlet
#

At least potentially, as they had 497 candidates.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

inner basin
#

Crazy how they had to relegate over 197 candidates

humble yacht
#

In before they reveal the secret “omega company” that’s been hidden all this time

stoic hamlet
#

Most of them became DI’s/the companies seemingly had more than 300 assigned to them

inner basin
#

Yeah I am aware of that, Canadian, but it’s still crazy

stoic hamlet
#

I think a rough estimate of how many were augmented from Alpha and Beta was 350 or so, each.

Maybe 325.

hasty locust
#

Wouldn’t the resetting cause confusing cause in the reach game they are sometimes mentioned as s-???

stoic hamlet
#

No

hasty locust
#

I guess they are all dead though

stoic hamlet
#

In cases like that you’d use their letter prefix

humble yacht
#

Spartan 3s used they’re full designation

inner basin
#

They had the letters in after the Sierra, settling

humble yacht
#

Including letter prefix

#

Noble six never called himself 312

#

It was b312

inner basin
#

^ It would be S-B312

humble yacht
#

Sure

inner basin
#

If you included the “Spartan” in front

humble yacht
#

Point is, he wouldn’t forget the B

hasty locust
#

Carter is mentioned as Sierra-259 but more then likely G-259 and B-259 are dead

#

At one point

humble yacht
#

Who calls carter simply 259?

#

And when

hasty locust
#

One moment please

stoic hamlet
#

Colonel Holland

inner basin
#

He’s referring to Dot in the PoA opening cutscene too

stoic hamlet
#

Also Dot

#

G-259 likely isn’t dead

humble yacht
#

I’d chalk that up to production error

stoic hamlet
#

B-259 I definitely think is

inner basin
#

Or due to their being no other S-259’s in the operational area

stoic hamlet
#

Well, technically Kat and Six might have appeared in Ghosts of Onyx, just unnamed.

All of Noble bar Jorge did, actually

#

Well.....yeah

inner basin
#

Yes, that is Noble Six

hasty locust
#

Back, can’t find where but I swear it says it

#

Some parts do, some parts don’t

inner basin
#

Yes, it does Donk, I didn’t say it doesn’t

stoic hamlet
#

Likely during that training exercise where Tom and Lucy and the rest of Beta ambush the DI’s. Unless he was knocked out beforehand.

inner basin
#

No, I just call him 6 for short

stoic hamlet
#

He’s simply saying Spartan B-312 is Noble Six, the player character.

#

But yeah, all of Noble appeared during Ghosts, they were just unnamed.

#

He has to have, yes.

#

When Kurt first addressed all of Alpha

#

He’d be there

inner basin
#

He would be, considering he was training in Alpha. He died in April, 2552 (the same year as the event TFoR)

hasty locust
#

I wonder how many spartan 3’s are left

stoic hamlet
#

Every Alpha Spartan we know of, Hazel and Carter and their BS ages ncluded

#

I’ve gotten the count to about 331 @hasty locust

#

As of 2553

hasty locust
#

331, mostly gamma right

stoic hamlet
#

Yes

#

323 Gamma, 4 Alpha, 4 Beta

#

That are known about

#

There could be more

hasty locust
#

I wonder if those other fireteams mentioned at the end of new Alexandria survived

inner basin
#

There are also Spartan-III Headhunters active post-war, but we don’t have a count, just know there are some

humble yacht
#

may be fairer to say that all of noble team was present during events of GoO, rather than actually in the book

stoic hamlet
#

Well, we know one member did @hasty locust Kevin A-282.

inner basin
#

Except Jorge, Chimera

stoic hamlet
#

Which team he was with we don’t know.

hasty locust
#

Interesting

humble yacht
#

sure, except jorge

hasty locust
#

Rest in pepperonis

inner basin
#

Didn’t Owen deploy with a team on Meridian, Canadian?

stoic hamlet
#

I don’t know

#

He may have been lying

inner basin
#

I believe he mentions it briefly, but yeah the above could be plausible

hasty locust
#

Outpost discovery Owen?

stoic hamlet
#

Well, he said it alongside answering how long the Covenant had been there, which we later learn was a lie.

inner basin
#

Yes, settling

stoic hamlet
#

Yes

hasty locust
#

Cool, he’s an official lore character

#

What book is he in

inner basin
#

Halo: Battle Born

stoic hamlet
#

Battle Born and Meridian Divide @hasty locust

inner basin
#

(Meridian Divide following Battle Born)

stoic hamlet
#

Everything at Outpost is canon.

#

Well, mostly.

#

All the exhibits and stuff

hasty locust
#

K, I’ll look into it thanks

inner basin
#

Fireteam Raven is canon, Donk, except for the Chief cameo

stoic hamlet
#

^^^

hasty locust
#

How is the chief cameo not canon

#

The one at the end of the first mission?

inner basin
#

He was elsewhere at that time

stoic hamlet
#

Because he wouldn’t have been there at the time

#

Same with the Ring Experience in Outpost

#

The Spartan at the end is a random IV or III

hasty locust
#

Could be a 2

#

Mayhaps

inner basin
#

With the one at the end, judging from the PoA ship schematics, where Raven came from wasn’t actually a place you could come from, it was a wall

stoic hamlet
#

No

hasty locust
#

Brain form as the flood calls it

#

I thought it was a proto gravemind

stoic hamlet
#

A Proto-Gravemind was beginning to form

hasty locust
#

Shh

stoic hamlet
#

Well

hasty locust
#

Be happy we got them

stoic hamlet
#

In the terminal “Keyes” the Gravemind actually speaks, meaning the Proto-Gravemind has connected to the wider collective.

unique rune
#

food juggernauts
delicious

inner basin
#

Yeah considering there a flood pureform, they shouldn’t be able to be a thing until a Gravemind is formed

hasty locust
#

A couple of Gutas latched onto the side of the PoA, survived slipspace, then got onto alpha halo and got infected into juggernauts. Duh

humble yacht
#

the gravemind on I05 had been around for centuries

#

maybe more

#

it just wasn't anywhere near the events of CE

inner basin
#

That’s the main issue

hasty locust
#

Couldn’t a juggernaut be kind of like a carrier, not a pure form but still not resembling any species we know of

#

Yes

#

Works

#

And they decided to keep it cause, why not

#

Could be a flood mobile base

#

Like an elephant

#

So it’s just a hive with legs

inner basin
#

Okay I found out that apparently Flood Juggernauts don’t need a Gravemind, but rather only a Proto considering how one was in the Mona Lisa (which I forgot about), unless that’s another misstep

hasty locust
#

So it could just be like a carrier form

inner basin
#

The aforementioned one I said is derived from a Sanghelli

#

Potentially, settling

hasty locust
#

Glue a couple of humans and covenant together

inner basin
#

Just the way carrier forms are specialised, the Juggernauts are too, a specialised combat form to be exact

hasty locust
#

Yeah it says on halopedia it’s a bunch of people glued together by infection forms

#

Juggernauts are highly specialized combat forms directed by a seething mass of infection forms linked to multiple hosts. The creature harnesses the hosts' minds to analyze enemy activity and adjust the local Flood strategy accordingly. They have some of the traits associated with full-fledged key minds, including the abilities to synchronize nearby parasites and relay information between distant Flood hordes.

#

So they are mobile voltron flood bases

humble yacht
#

🤦‍♂️

#

reading that makes me hate ATN more and more

hasty locust
#

However, whereas the Juggernaut was to be controlled by infection forms, pure forms are created entirely from Flood biomass.

#

It says that^ also

fair hazel
#

I like ATN

#

But yeah, people at 343 wanting to make it canon doesnt mean they consider it canon [being canon]

inner basin
#

Still makes a good discussion point about a FFoA, but yeah I am aware that argument isn’t the best justification, erick

hasty locust
#

What is ATN?

#

Or what does it stand for I should say

humble yacht
#

awakening the nightmare

hasty locust
#

Ah, ok thanks

inner basin
#

Can I just ask if we have any material coming out expanding into the Spartan-II program’s candidates, particularly Spartan-116?

I ask this because someone on Waypoint was saying that this Spartan is their favourite Spartan in the universe (in a reply to one of my polls) and I was wondering if I am missing something. I couldn’t find anything on Halopedia either.

gilded mason
#

All I found on 116 on Halopedia is this:
The status of candidates 116, 118, 119, 121, 123, and 124 after September 10, 2517 is unknown

inner basin
#

That’s all I saw too so I had to ask in case Halopedia hadn’t updated on any material. Thanks for the clarification Ostral. Hmm... I assume his response will be... interesting.

gilded mason
#

lol

tame crystal
#

wait, were the vehicle crosshairs always centered in the halo games?

inner basin
#

Don’t know what that has to do with the lore unless a topic relating to the HUD was going to come in as a follow up.

terse lava
#

Human or sangheili hud? Chief and others seem to have a canon hud based off things like the package

stoic hamlet
#

The motion tracker, shield, at the very least.

But the in-game HUD lacks stuff the EU has.

hasty locust
#

Like, status lights

#

Which would be interesting to have

terse lava
#

Yea, dont think those have ever appeared oddly enough

hasty locust
#

Like being able to look at the top right and see who’s alive, or if they are fighting etc

stoic hamlet
#

TEAMBIO as well

hasty locust
#

Or top left

stoic hamlet
#

That’s canon

#

Also canon

#

Those are probably not canon

#

But the human ones would be. By the time of the games so would the Covenant.

hasty locust
#

I just don’t think it’s very practical though, like what’s the point

#

Unless it was some kind of system to show the diagnostic of said weapon, like if it would turn red as it heats, etc

inner basin
#

Maybe Mjolnir scans the weapon being held by the user to give the weapon outline a canonical reason. I doubt that’s the case, but food for thought?

versed helm
#

So Jackals can speak English in Halo 5?

#

I'm not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing?

gilded mason
#

It’d make sense. Every other race can.

inner basin
#

Jackals have been able to speak English prior to 2558. I’m pretty sure they were able to speak English in 2535 since they were trading with humans on the Rubble in that year. Ofc this was a covert plan by Truth to get the humans to reveal humanity’s home planet to him I believe.

terse lava
#

Though jackals were always weird

inner basin
#

That they were

terse lava
#

Although, a jackal version of treasure island would be funny

simple locust
#

What weapons did the San'Shyuum use during the War of Wills and the War of Beginnings? Did they alter the Sentinel Aggressors during their war with the elites? What weapons did members below the Hiearchs have?

versed helm
#

I wanna see a picture of a burnblade

terse lava
#

@simple locustduring the war of wills, its implied they used basaltic weaponry like humanity. Against sangheili, pulse rifle weaponry and sentinels. Far as we know, these sentinels were not altered outside of being able to communicate with san shyuum "eye" probes. Normal san shyuum had gravity cannon weapons in their chairs, but far weaker then the hierarchs.

#

@versed helmbelive thr best we have are curve blades, only difference being one was capable of generating heat while the other was just a normal blade

hasty locust
#

The jackal goonies

terse lava
#

@hasty locust jackal sparrow

hasty locust
#

Lol

tame crystal
#

oh whoops i accidentally posted the hud question in here

simple locust
#

@terse lava Is there a description for how the Pulse Rifle looked or handled? Also I'm an unfamiliar with basaltic weapons, are the stone weapons or similar to swords? Also are the normal San Shyuum chairs based on other covenant weapons such as the canons regret has are similar to those of the hunters so is there a weapon equivalent to their chair weapon?

inner basin
#

Maybe he means ballistic weaponry, but typo’d?

terse lava
#

Yep typo

#

Just normal bullet weapons. As for the chairs, I am unsure. Mgalekgolo cannons fire a gel, where the chair's weapons are only called "gravity cannons."

simple locust
#

@terse lava OK thank you. Also is there info on how the pulse rifle looked or handled? Also in Halo Wars 1 the prophet starts off with plasma rifles before his cannons. Also do you know what weapons Stewards had?

terse lava
#

No pictures? Regret does start off with plasma weaponry and later fuel, but no gravity cannon there. None could say though lesser san shyuum may have that plasma weapon though. As for the final one, pulse rifles

#

We know English was used when talking with Johnson

#

As for chief, and after defeating tartarus, who knows?

simple locust
#

@terse lava I assumed he had the rifles just on his chair since they have the same sound but it is neat. Also what weapons did the elites use in their early wars before joining the covenant and their war with the Prophets?

terse lava
#

Sangheili used plasma

#

They had developed it long before the war of beginnings

versed helm
#

So who or what was this "prisoner" that taught the Ussans a form of meditation?

simple locust
#

@terse lava Also were you intending original to say more about the Pulse Rifles or is there no information about how the look and function? It seems in you end mid sentence in "As for the final one, pulse rifles
" unless I missed something.

terse lava
#

@versed helmno one knows

#

@simple locustnothing else, no clue what they looked like. My last comment was answering you on what weaponry they used

#

Depleted uranium rounds

simple locust
#

@terse lava Also what were the combat difference between the reformists and the stoics?

terse lava
#

Think the only thing we know there was that their technolgy was similar at the time

obsidian sapphire
#

does anyone know what the covenant thougt of the humans

#

i know some elite's respected the humans but what about the rest of the covenant

obsidian sapphire
#

yeah but like post war

terse lava
#

Opinions varied, some liked, some tolerated, some hated

true shadow
#

I read somewhere on one of the wikis that some elites migrated to earth to seek political asylum

versed helm
#

some even suggested the humans into the covenant

versed helm
#

Would you believe me if I said that Halo is a multiverse?

#

Ik it's not canon, but what if it was?

#

Then every alternate form of Halo would be canon

#

And it would explain many plot holes in the Halo universe

#

It would honestly seem legit to be canon

#

What do you think bout this, peeps?

feral perch
#

Keep the multiverse stuff in DC. I don’t want alternate timeline anything in Halo

versed helm
#

and ben 10 lol

full forge
#

How fast could a spartan bike in full armor, on a bicycle designed to support their weight?

#

Asking the real questions today.

stoic hamlet
#

As fast as the bike can move. They’d be restricted by the bikes top speed.

full forge
#

And is that top speed anywhere near a Spartan's running top speed?

wicked pasture
#

This is hard to calculate because there isn't a consistent relationship between run speed and cycling speed.

carmine sleet
#

Using the multiverse to explain plot holes isn't the right way of using the multiverse @versed helm

#

Multiverse stories are used to give alternate takes on events we've already seen where things happen differently due to one or more factors

terse lava
#

Besides, all those other universes are drained before life develops

versed helm
#

Speaking of bicycles,do motorcycles still exist in the Halo universe?

unique rune
#

...Why wouldn’t they?

carmine sleet
#

It would be odd if they suddenly forgot what motorbikes were in universe

#

Like, the Mongoose is a quadbike so it would be logical that motorbikes exist as well

stoic hamlet
#

Obviously we need to take the casual approach.

If we don’t see it it doesn’t exist anymore.

wicked pasture
#

we would have seen the grackle in the mmo but they canceled it

unique rune
#

HW2 also had the Jackrabbit, which is... basically a motorcycle.

Plus Ruwan Ackerson was still running around in an old Pontiac GTO in the 26th century so even if motorcycles were outmoded by something, there’s bound to be some niche group that still swears by them.

fair hazel
#

tricycle

hasty locust
#

Hell yeah, UNSC iguana tactical 3 wheeled peddled reconnaissance vehicle

versed helm
#

So what is average San'Shyuum lifespan?

indigo thorn
#

is the unsc capable of time travel?

terse lava
#

No

obsidian thistle
#

Short answer "No".

terse lava
#

@versed helm few hundred years. Ancient ones though were far longer, a leader among them managed to live for 10,000 years

obsidian thistle
#

Long answer: The only case of time travel sent fragments of a broken AI (and other data related stuff) back to 2004. This however was an accident and a fluke

#

And the only explaination of what type of Timetravel it is, is an annoyingly vague tweet from frankie that doesnt explain it. Bar "it happened".

versed helm
#

Wasn't that the whole I Love Bees thing?

terse lava
#

Yea pretty sure

obsidian thistle
#

Yep. It be canon. But this is the closest we have to any explation on its timetravel.

https://twitter.com/franklez/status/1213565956535902208?s=19

@cia391 Well I suppose even in loose framing it depends if you believe that each (per wave function collapse? Or non trivial event?) outcome branches a new reality or not. Or whether you consider the fiction of ILB, this reality, and the game fiction to be branches/outcome...

#

That was in response to me trying to work out what sorta timetravel it was. In short it has no answer atm.

#

Either its closed loop (aka the Timetravel always happened)

Or its open and new timelines are created.

versed helm
#

How old was Mercy when he died?

gilded mason
#

About 220

versed helm
#

Sucks that he died

terse lava
#

Well he was certainly no saint

versed helm
#

True

vast mortar
#

hello

terse lava
#

Heck, 3400 years of covenant history, and mercy was still part of a group that thought it was wrong to decommission the keyship

#

Greetings @vast mortar

vast mortar
#

what we talking about

terse lava
#

San shyuum

vast mortar
#

alright

versed helm
#

Speaking of San'Shyuum...is Janjur Qom still around or what?

gilded mason
#

Unknown, but possibly

versed helm
#

Iirc,didn't it say that the Reformists lied about its destruction?

terse lava
#

Implied

#

Oh yea..filter

gilded mason
#

Eyup

terse lava
#

San shyuum who studied the plasma ball warming their home had concluded the thing was near the end

versed helm
#

what ever happened to the prophet of rhyme 👀

#

If Janjur Qom is around and that is a big if,would that mean that the Stoics are still around?

#

And what about the Prophet of Swag?

terse lava
#

Lost a rap battle to the sangheili fieldmaster of swag @versed helm

gilded mason
#

would that mean that the Stoics are still around?
They might, but 3000 years is a long time for culture to change.

terse lava
#

Indeed

versed helm
#

indeed rhyme didnt even know how to rhyme, ironic.

terse lava
#

Maybe they are tier 2 now... but who knowa

versed helm
#

Where in the galaxy is the San'Shyuum home system?

obsidian thistle
#

We actually dont know

#

Even if we used our own (which isnt canon to Halos) we dont know

versed helm
#

It did say that their home system is somewhat similar to the Sol System

carmine sleet
#

That doesn't mean it would be close to ours though

versed helm
#

Is Chips Dubbo still alive?

hasty locust
#

Yes

#

No

#

Maybe so

unique rune
#

the real question you should be asking is Did he ever really exist in the first place

inner basin
#

Well his canonical status is up in the air so to speak

versed helm
#

Well

#

Maybe he'll make an appearance in infinite

inner basin
#

I think 343 should address which events he did canonically take part in, as well as which ones his voice can be heard in, but it wasn’t actually his character. The main issues for this is the Battle of Installation-04 and the Battle of Installation-05, respectively.

This issue follows suit for Stacker too. Is he an ODST or a regular Marine? He keeps switching the BDU he is wearing. He also has made an appearance in the battles listed above, but how did he and Chips escape both? People speculate there was another craft that escaped 04, and that the Elites brought the humans back on 05, but eh, idk...

versed helm
#

Wasn't Chips in ODST too?

inner basin
#

Don’t think so. We’ve never seen him as an ODST in any game. We only know Stacker as an ODST due to “A Day at the Beach” cinematic cutscene.

#

This was made by Bungie back in the day I believe, but was remastered by 343 along with H2A

keen canopy
#

ooooo a Marcus Stacker mention

#

my favourite thing ever

#

We’ve never seen him as an ODST in any game. We only know Stacker as an IDST due to “A Day at the Beach” cinematic cutscene.

@inner basin He appears as an ODST Sergeant twice in the games. In Delta Halo alongside John, and also on the Ark in the generator assault.

#

We know ODST's can suit up as regular Marines.

#

Also there's no definitive evidence Stacker was actually ever on Installation 04 at all.

Since we have an almost concrete placing of him in New Alexandria as Kilo 40, he would have had only a week to make his way to another continent, and somehow end up aboard the Pillar of Autumn during it's extremely brief touchdown on the planet.

100% of his Scripted dialogue in Halo CE belongs to other characters canonically, and he's not listed in the game's credits as a character, while Chips Dubbo is.

inner basin
#

That’s why his canonical status can be dubious at best

keen canopy
#

It's not dubious at all

#

He is named in Halo 4

inner basin
#

For some events it most certainly is

keen canopy
#

He's named in Another Day at the Beach. The vidoc showed internal documentation of each character's in-universe names.

#

And his is "Stacker"

inner basin
#

Installation-05? We gonna just forget that he was supposedly present there?

keen canopy
#

He was, who does Arbiter rescue at the end of Great Journey?

#

Three people, the same people, every time. The three sergeants from Halo 2: Johnson, Banks and Stacker.

inner basin
#

Well no, Johnson was the only Marine in the Scarab, Arbiter was in the Banshee and Miranda was with Tartarus in the control room. We don’t see the other Marines leave

keen canopy
#

How do you know Johnson was the only Marine in the Scarab?

Stacker and Banks are standing right there, the cutscene happens, and after the cutscene they're not there.

inner basin
#

Well that’s just assuming they are in there.

keen canopy
#

You're right that we can't assuming they're in the Scarab

#

But we can't assume they're not either.

inner basin
#

Which is why it can be dubious at times

keen canopy
#

Not every little thing needs to be explained haha

#

We still don't know how Jun escaped Reach

inner basin
#

Well we do

keen canopy
#

Or how Thomas Chang escaped Installation-04

inner basin
#

We don’t know that

#

But we also don’t know how Chips escaped

keen canopy
#

We don't know that he did escape.

inner basin
#

Well he supposedly did

#

There’s speculation of him escaping on a different craft of sorts, maybe a stolen Phantom?

keen canopy
#

I haven't been talking about speculation

hasty locust
#

What about stacker

#

He probably got out with him

inner basin
#

Stacker wasn’t at Installation-04, at least if we’re going off what eezy said

keen canopy
#

Dubious @hasty locust

#

Anyhow beast, a better example is how stacker survived the quarantine zone

hasty locust
#

343 should bring him back just for some dialogue with buck, so he can say something like “brings you back to delta, eh chief” and buck objects saying he saw him in Mombasa

keen canopy
#

Because once he's saved with Johnson, getting back to earth from I-05 is smooth sailing.

inner basin
#

It is smooth sailing cause the other events are pretty clearly outlined. The UNSC troops weren’t massacred at I-00, but were at I-05 because of the Flood (same with I-04 but Melissa did some damage to the forces there too)

keen canopy
#

We know he wasn't captured with Miranda and Johnson, but we also know from those Marines John broke out that the Covenant took other prisoners to High Charity

hasty locust
#

Maybe we shouldn’t stereotype and every Aussie isn’t the same person

#

Or chip’s is a top secret ONI cloning program in the Australian city of Dubbo

inner basin
#

We aren’t talking about Chips

#

It’s Stacker we’re discussing

keen canopy
#

The presence of Banks & Stacker make me speculate that Truth kept the leaders together for extra questioning/to reduce risk of escape

hasty locust
#

Ah, okey

inner basin
#

I always thought Banks was killed by the Scarab on Earth before IAC follows Regret to I-05

#

But I know he actually isn’t dead, it just gives that impression

#

As for your theory, it’s plausible

#

We knew Truth did a lot of covert activities behind the other Hierarchs back’s

keen canopy
#

Keeping the leaders separate from the prisoners seems logical anyway

inner basin
#

Maybe...

#

But it is a BIG grey area rn

#

The canonical status of people and the surrounding events happening on I-05 aren’t crystal clear per say, but it can be explained through speculation for now

keen canopy
#

You wanna hear a possible explanation?

#

I've thought about this long ago, I just can't put it on the wiki obviously

hasty locust
#

Didn’t the covenant not use to take prisoners? What changed their minds?

keen canopy
#

Truth needing reclaimers to fire the rings.

hasty locust
#

Ah

#

Awsome

inner basin
#

Never thought you were a Wiki writer even though anyone can be one

keen canopy
#

everyone should be one 😛

hasty locust
#

Misinformed people shouldn’t, that’s when you get “shrek was a world war hero, fighting in both wars with a KD of 1000.739 due to his Mountain Dew obsession”

#

But that’s sick, that you’re a wiki writer

keen canopy
#

The position outside the Library had machine gun turrets set up, and dozens of marine combat forms. This means that Johnson and Miranda actually arrived to the Library with a significant force. As Arbiter, we hear Stacker on radio, so we know that he's present in the Quarantine Zone. Seeing as he's alive the most obvious explanation would be that he linked up with other forces and made it to the Library.

There were a bunch of flood around the Library, and Arbiter's platform was only seconds behind the Humans'. It's far too much Flood for Johnson, Miranda, Mkenzie and Perez to handle alone. So it's probable there were many more marines aboard the humans' platform. As it leaves only moments before the Arbiter witnesses no human survivors at the encampment, that means Stacker was likely aboard the platform.

Johnson entered the Library with Miranda, took two marines to cover the door, and left everyone else to guard the platform for their escape. The platform was overrun quickly so the surviving marines abandoned the platform and retreated inside the Library. Stacker, Banks, and the marines John rescues in Gravemind were possibly this bunch, captured by Tartarus and his brutes, at Truth's orders.

hasty locust
#

That’s a good analysis

keen canopy
#

Anyhow I think Halo 2 would make an amazing movie

hollow meadow
#

It would. I mean H2A's cutscenes work wonderfully for a CGI Halo film

keen canopy
#

Imagine if we got to know the Marines a bit better, then have to watch them die to flood, then a few seconds later watch the Arbiter and Rtas' show up and slice them all to pieces

hasty locust
#

Halo 2 would make a sick movie, or ce’s novilisation

#

I don’t call it the flood as often cause people get confused

terse lava
#

@keen canopythat makes a whole lot of sense.

keen canopy
#

Piecing things together from limited information is half the fun of being a lore fan am I right

hasty locust
#

Yes and the speculation

terse lava
#

Correct

#

Come to think of it

#

How did thel, Johnson, and miranda get to earth?

#

Used to think just some random sangheili vessel, yet we never hear of it helping the battle

hasty locust
#

Well in awakening the nightmare cutscenes they are punching and squishing the infection forms but in the flood they are being pierced by assault rifle rounds, som have that’s it, like stomp on a balloon, then shoot it with a BB gun

#

Sure the stomped one gets poppped still, but there are fluids inside an infection form

#

True

fair hazel
#

Sometimes they pop sometimes they dont pop I guess

terse lava
#

Going with gameplay, as halo war 1, halo 2A, And halo war 2 they dont "pop" like in game

terse lava
#

I know, I have the book

#

Both original and new😊

#

But remember though, there was nothing else for Dietz to do off of anyway

versed helm
#

Regarding Jun's escape from Reach,i was thinking that ONI must've extracted him at some point after the Fleet of Particular Justice started chasing after the POA

#

That's my best guess,what do you think?

stoic hamlet
#

We know other ships escaped

#

Kevin-A282 escaped on a UNSC cargo ship, IIRC.

wraith dragon
#

Pretty sure Jun just wasn’t even on the planet

fair hazel
#

they're not small

#

im going to guess Jun climbed a space elevator to get off the planet

terse lava
#

I wonder how much intelligence an infection form even has. Obviously not very much but must be something

#

Ant level maybe?

agile tangle
#

Are the Arbiter and Chief even when it comes to combat?

versed helm
#

Or would Chief consider Thel to be an ally?

stoic hamlet
#

He’s an Ally, definitely.

#

But not a friend

#

Just an ally

terse lava
#

Only thel considers chief a friend

versed helm
#

It'd be something that's for sure. But considering how both Arbiter and Master Chief fought alongside each other during the events of Halo 3, there's something that they both understand.

War brings people common ground.

feral perch
#

I would say the opening of Bad Blood indicates Arbiter and Chief have a bond very similar to friendship.

terse lava
#

I wonder how classy/lousy covenant restaurants were

inner basin
#

I am aware I’m very late to this conversation but I believe Frank said on Twitter that Jun climbed a broken space elevator, where at the top he could probably find like a Pelican or something that is space-capable

#

Maybe a Longsword, but all we do know is that he did climb a space elevator to physically get off the planet

keen canopy
#

He wrote a Twitter short story yea but he said it obviously wasn't real.

#

He was just illustrating that his escape isn't really a mystery, there are plausible explanations.

storm fjord
#

Are golf balls considered lore XD

keen canopy
#

No

#

no one ever invented Golf in the Halo Universe 😄

storm fjord
#

Well you can in forge so if master chief went into forge and created golf wouldnt that be considered lore

#

So yeah

keen canopy
#

I was kidding, golf exists in Halo

#

The giant golf balls in forge aren't canon however lol

#

There's one in Halo 2 campaign iirc however it's an Easter Egg.

#

Forge in general isn't Canon, as I'm sure you know

storm fjord
#

Yes but what if we make it canon

#

WHAT IF WE CAN

keen canopy
storm fjord
#

Ok fine

indigo thorn
#

wait wait golf is halo cannon

terse lava
#

"Golf"? You must mean grifball. Playing anything else the with clubs is high heresy

maiden crest
#

Hey guys

terse lava
#

Hi

inner basin
#

Hello

stoic hamlet
#

Hewwos

pale quest
#

A sport where you stab people with swords, smash them with hammers and blow up a bomb to score?
Probably not

carmine sleet
#

@keen canopy Forge is canon, just not in the exact way it's presented to us. I believe it's the tool used to create War Games maps for Spartans to train on in lore

true shadow
#

It’d be pretty hard to try and find a way to make forge canon without making the monitors out to be some sort of matter creating super machines

#

The route of war games simulations is much more easier to digest imo

carmine sleet
#

That's why I said "Forge is canon, just not in the exact way it's presented to us"

true shadow
#

Yeah

#

Anyone remember that terminal from CEA I think that showed Guilty Spark ejecting a section of his installation out into the vacuum of space?

carmine sleet
#

Yes, Anders does the same thing in Halo Wars 2 with the Banished forces on Installation 09

true shadow
#

If he has that amount of control over the ring (I mean why wouldn’t he, he was the monitor assigned to it) then in theory could he shape the landscape to however he pleased?

#

I dunno why but I feel like if that holds any truth that there could be some sort of obscure explanation for forge being canon

#

I dunno why I connected that scene in particular to forge it sorta just interested me

inner basin
#

It begs the question of why he didn’t jettison the part that the PoA was on? Was he unable? Would’ve it made no difference? Anyone got answers for me as I really don’t know

versed helm
#

Probably not, since Cortana explained to chief in H2 that she could detonate the In Amber Clad's fusion reactors, and the explosion would also destroy the ring, but idk i may be mistaken myself if it would've made a difference.

terse lava
#

Willing to bet he couldnt sue to damage by the flood

clever fable
#

I think a lot of inconsistencies or near-inconsistencies regarding Spark can be swept under the rug of insanity, though maybe that's a bit lazy.

deep pewter
#

It’s what has to be done with a lot of stuff regarding Bungie’s story, they never cared for consistency

versed helm
#

Especially with Reach

fair hazel
#

cortana still had the index

humble yacht
#

Installation 03’s monitor required Reclaimer support to eject a portion of the ring

inner basin
#

But wasn’t Spark able to do it for Installation-04 by himself? As for your Installation-03 point, wasn’t that because the Didact was there, and he can command Monitors what to do? I could be totally wrong, but isn’t that what more or less what happened, or make sense for it to happen?

carmine sleet
#

Spark did do it on his own, as it was at least a good hundred years before any humans arrived on the ring when he ejected a portion

inner basin
#

I thought so. It’d just been a while since I watched it (as it’s part of the CEA terminals iirc)

carmine sleet
#

It is

terse lava
#

Belive it had been 40,000 years since the array fired when he did that

versed helm
#

Earlier someone said something about the Banished on "Installation 09". Doesn't HW2 take place on the ark? Or is that another name on Installation 09

clever fable
#

The Ark keeps a ring ready, I09 in that instance.

versed helm
#

My halo dudes Im almost finished with Oblivion and Ive read silent strike and up to ghost of onyx but which one should i read next ? Glasslands ? I know thats the kilo 5 trilogy but does it continue after Onyx?

carmine sleet
#

Indeed, Trad, during HW2, the Ark launches I09 during the story

#

The Kilo 5 Trilogy does continue after Onyx

versed helm
#

Gracias

spiral jewel
#

So I09 was heading to Threshold when a Guardian appears out of nowhere?

feral perch
#

Seems like it

inner basin
#

From what we can gather, yes. We don’t know if it remained where it was intercepted, or if it was moved

terse lava
#

Likely as it was replacing alpha halo

spiral jewel
#

As far as I know, where the guardian came from exactly is a bit of a mystery since there is a 6 month gap between October 28-30 2558 (Created Subjugation of Earth), and April 2, 2559 ( I09 being intercepted by a Guardian)

versed helm
#

God the narrator for the kilo 5 trilogy audiobooks is terrible

inner basin
#

@spiral jewel You are aware that Cortana has a number of Guardians, so it could’ve been patrolling anywhere

versed helm
#

Also,how did that Guardian even pull Installation 09 out of Slipspace?

inner basin
#

Probably because it is physically able to pull anything out of slipspace perhaps? We really don’t know an awful lot about it’s capabilities except for the EMP-like effect that isn’t permanent (as it can be repaired), and the fact that they cause a lot of damage upon their first activation

versed helm
#

And one of their weaknesses involves the Huragok

inner basin
#

Which is why the EMP-like effect isn’t permanent

#

But it requires a Huragok to solve the problem, as seen in Bad Blood I believe

versed helm
#

It'll probably take a whole lot of Huragoks to fix Earth's infrastructure and electric grid

inner basin
#

Well I believe ONI has a number of them on Luna, but do correct me if I’m wrong

feral drum
#

I have a question

#

Do female Sangheili look like the males or are there differences?

inner basin
#

I’ll leave that one for Ostral or Ado to answer. They are our resident Sanghelli experts more or less

gilded mason
#

They look just like males

#

Some might be smaller or maybe smell slightly different.

versed helm
#

Or what about Fal Chavamee's wife?

gilded mason
#

Same reason Halsey looks like a young blonde women when she was in her mid-50s in The Package

versed helm
#

I seriously need to watch The Duel again

#

I'm still gonna say,Halo 5 did Jul Mdama dirty

gilded mason
#

Indeed

#

It actually made me greatly dislike Locke

versed helm
#

That whole game was pathetic

#

I was expecting a epic boss battle against Jul,but Locke stabbing him in the neck,that was it?

gilded mason
#

I didn't even need a boss battle, just something other than...that

inner basin
#

I think that whole cutscene did a great injustice for Elites. I mean when do you see a Spec Ops Elite drop their weapon and clumsily make their way towards their enemy (the one Vale killed first)?

gilded mason
#

Heck, have him live, with the storyline thought up by Haruspis way back when

#

@inner basin
I felt Halo 5 cutscenes made Elites act kinda drunk, movement-wise.

inner basin
#

Oh what about that one at the start of Blue Team. The way the high ranking Elite walks, ahhhh, that’s fun to make fun of

versed helm
#

That game ruined Blue Team

gilded mason
#

What's weird is that during gameplay, they seemed to move well-enough. (from what I remember, at least)

inner basin
#

Yeah gameplay is fine, but it’d be hard to mess that up

#

It’s the cutscenes that they made, ruined them. Then acting drunk does seem like a fair observation

versed helm
#

Then there's the Chief vs Locke fight

hasty locust
#

Yeah they bulked up elites too much

#

To the point they had to waddle

versed helm
#

Also,where the hell was Fireteam Majestic?,we never see them or get a mention of them,i think

gilded mason
#

Doin' other stuff

inner basin
#

We don’t hear of them at all in 5. Throne was supposed to be in Osiris, but they scratched that and put Buck in that place instead

gilded mason
#

Yup

hasty locust
#

I don’t like new blood or whatever it’s called

#

The one where ||rookie buys it||

versed helm
#

Bad Blood

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

Stupid

#

He should’ve gotten a better death

gilded mason
#

Bad Blood
It was New Blood

#

Bad Blood's the sequel

hasty locust
#

Ok

inner basin
#

Yeah New Blood was where J.D met his end, but I don’t think it was bad. I enjoyed it. The author clearly put in the time to nail the characters

#

It also wasn’t a throw away death like Jul either

hasty locust
#

I wish he at least got fleshed out a bit more

#

Then he buys it

versed helm
#

Bad Blood was the one where Buck and Dare got married right?

gilded mason
#

Ye

inner basin
#

Also where Alpha-9 were reformed as Spartans

#

Which was nice to see

versed helm
#

What happened to Mickey at the end of Bad Blood?

hasty locust
#

I know most people probably think this is dumb but something inside me wishes the leader of Osiris was rookie and he got to be fleshed out as a character and such

gilded mason
#

Yeah, my main thing about Rookie's death was the lost potential for fleshing out.

versed helm
#

We do know that the Rookie was from Luna

inner basin
#

But he has history that can be fleshed out instead. I think that engagement with Gage Yevgenny was nice

#

I feel that the short story Dirt is highly underrated

versed helm
#

What's everyone's opinion on the Fall of Reach animated series?

gilded mason
#

Doesn't even show the fall of Reach lol

#

And turns John into a monster

inner basin
#

Doesn’t accurately depict the events that occurred in it either

hasty locust
#

Yeah isn’t it just his training

#

Welp I’ve gtg, cya

inner basin
#

Later, settling

versed helm
#

Anyone else besides me thinks that Blue Team in the series look way too young

gilded mason
#

What do you mean?

#

Oh, yeah, their "present day" selves

#

Yeah, they look...odd.

versed helm
#

They look baby faced

gilded mason
#

Yeah, it's an odd juxtaposition.

versed helm
#

And the gym fight scene,what the hell was that?

gilded mason
#

It was creepy

versed helm
#

John nearly hit one of the ODSTs with a weight bar

celest palm
#

Where he 1v3 a squad of ODSTs?