#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 281 of 1

keen canopy
#

@dense falcon Humanity expanded very quickly and ended up being in a position where the Inner Colonies were almost completely dependent on the Outer Colonies for food and resources. Yet they lived in relative luxury, while the Outer Colonies lived in harsher conditions. Many in the Outer Colonies got sick of providing for the Inner Colonies and wanted independence, and the UNSC wouldn't give it to them, seeing as that would be disastrous for the Inner Colonies.

versed helm
#

Yes, which is probably why the armor has those safeties when sprinting.

keen canopy
#

@versed helm Fred also tore his Achilles sprinting in First Strike IIRC

versed helm
#

So uhh I guess my theory holds up

#

Hmm

#

That is true

#

Well she isnt exactly using all of her armors power for that

keen canopy
#

If she really went for it, she'd probably be able to tear an Achilles

versed helm
#

She was very fast even from a Young age

#

Yes thats gen 2

#

Indeed

#

Now how fast is she in gen 3

#

She's always been the fastest

#

Even from a very Young age

#

So she probably doesnt have to use as much of her armors horse power when sprinting

#

Now

#

That may sound a little dumb

#

But that might explain it

#

If I could phrase This properly

keen canopy
#

I think it's not speed that matters here

versed helm
#

K or 087 so the filter doesnt turn on you

keen canopy
#

K is faster than the other Spartans at all levels of exertion

#

Perhaps Mjolnir limits the duration that a Spartan can maintain their top speed

#

Rather than trying to stop them from running too fast

versed helm
#

That does work

#

Imma go with that

#

If they make him interesting definitely

#

But I wonder

#

Who is the slowest spartan?

tame crystal
#

question: can the sabre also be used in-atmosphere?

versed helm
#

Is Enduring Bias a Contender class A.I?

keen canopy
#

@tame crystal Most likely not. You can in Forge though :D

#

@versed helm most likely not, which is annoying as hell. I guess there's still a possibility he is one though.

versed helm
#

Mendicant and Offensive Bias are Contender class A.Is so i'm betting that Enduring Bias could be one as well

keen canopy
#

All information we have points to him not being one, which is why the name is annoying

#

We also have Custodian, a Contender-Class whose name does not end with Bias.

half fulcrum
#

I wanna see Kalmiya in a game, but I suppose Reach was their shot to explore that and they didn't :/

maiden crest
#

Hey guys

#

Where is mendicant bias now

obsidian thistle
#

Uncertain.

#

Last seen on I08.

#

Either dead or missing atm

dense falcon
#

@keen canopy so basically the outer colonies are like rural zones?

hollow meadow
#

More like the Outer Rim in Wtar Sars

fair hazel
#

@obsidian thistle the spirit of fire crew complement lists a commander Theo , in the marine section

obsidian thistle
#
Halopedia

Commander Theo Figueroa is a Senior Officer in the UNSC Navy. He was the commanding officer of Epsilon Base during the Harvest Campaign on February 4, 2531. He expressed some concern to Captain Cutter over the base's ability to meet its operational schedule, but Cutter stated...

#

That guy.

#

HW1 Launch Site

#

During the Harvest campaign he was at Epsilon Base.

#

@fair hazel

#

What else do ya need to know?

fair hazel
#

The rank structure as displayed on halopedia @obsidian thistle

terse lava
#

I miss that interactive game...

obsidian thistle
#

Oh that

fair hazel
#

Yep. Commander. Marine.

#

Unicom

obsidian thistle
#

That was a layover. Was meant to fix that

#

Fixed

#

🙂

fair hazel
#

Yay

obsidian thistle
#

Actually I have an idea. xD

#

Thanks I am in a rabbit hole now

versed helm
#

does the A in CIA stand for alice

obsidian thistle
#

No.

fair hazel
#

Rabbit hole time

obsidian thistle
#

So my idea is this. (had it for awhile but may push it after my archive task)

#

Each human rank gets a page

#

Now

#

Why is this interesting

#

I can then proceed to track who had what rank and when they had it.

inner basin
#

That’d be pretty cool. Would you also keep former ranks that people had in their political and military info box though like it is now?

obsidian thistle
#

Well yes of course. Easier to track that way

fair hazel
#

Yes. I’ve wanted that

terse lava
#

That's a pretty good idea, rather then looking up pvt (name). Will the covenant be getting the same treatment too?

obsidian thistle
#

Where possible... but thats a way harder task sadly as very few have been "named" with "ranks".

dim roost
#

So, was Outpost Discovery a retcon?

unique rune
#

A retcon for...?

dim roost
#

Infinite.

feral perch
#

no

unique rune
#

How would it retcon anything relating to Infinite?

dim roost
#

Well, that's what Halo haters would ask.

#

I wanted to play Devil's Advocate to elicit a response.

unique rune
feral perch
#

wut

#

Halo haters wouldn't ask that

#

is the name of a popular shooter oft compared to Halo censored?

versed helm
#

So will the Ussans make a return?

gilded mason
#

I can always hope.

versed helm
#

Also,what is the protein mash that's described in Broken Circle?,is it like Mashed Potatoes?

gilded mason
#

A meat substitute. Though it probably has the consistency of mashed taters considering its name.

terse lava
#

Imagined it being similar to corn beef hash

full forge
#

so do the ussans eat a lot of beans then?

terse lava
#

Why do you ask that?

full forge
#

Protein.

terse lava
#

Meat would provide it too. The mash would pretty much be meat, just not from an animal

full forge
#

I don't think so, since the broken circle was supposed to be a shield world for the forerunners wasn't it? The forerunners aren't big on meat. The mantle 'Forbade consuming the flesh of the less fortunate' While the forerunners could easily create synthetic meats that don't originate from other species, I don't see them doing that. Their culture seems to focus heavily on vegetables.

#

Probably just those gray cubes the warrior-servants ate for sustenance I'd think.

but honestly it's like, a space magic forerunner food machine so who really cares

gilded mason
#

The Sangheili brought their own protein fabricator from Sanghelios

#

It wasn't Forerunner

full forge
#

Ooooh really now?

gilded mason
#

Yeah

#

The food was mostly the local and quite edible vegetable matter and some artificial meat — the latter from the protein fabricator they had brought with them from Sanghelios. The protein mash was unappealing, but Tersa was young and his appetite was strong.

full forge
#

Wait. Hol' up

#

So would the covenant floatillas have no need of support ships for carrying food supplies then in that case?

gilded mason
#

No big need, perhaps. Probably mainly for actually tasty food.

terse lava
#

Fresh food is still better then Relying on the synthesizer this would be

full forge
#

Of course, of course. But I thought that's why the Sangheili bring the unggoy along @gilded mason?

gilded mason
#

Hm?

full forge
#

unggoy
weak, tasty crabs

sangheili
strong, live on a world with lots of ocean

gilded mason
#

lol

#

Anyway, they also use assembly forges to create food as well, so it might be just a "cover your bases" thing?

full forge
#

You ever cook an Unggoy over an open fire? What, no-one? Is that frowned on, or somethin'?"

gilded mason
#

That was a Halo 5 IWBYD line, right?

full forge
#

Yee

gilded mason
#

Nice

#

Love those kinds of lines

terse lava
#

I could see that being a halo 3 line between s brute pack too

full forge
#

In my playthrough I encountered that line on the mission Reunion, when you reach the downed phantom.

terse lava
#

interesting

full forge
#

What happened to the buggers after the collapse of the Covenant?

gilded mason
#

They continue to do whatever.

versed helm
#

They went back to their home planet

#

Some were a part of that elites fleet from halo spartan assault

gilded mason
#

Don't buy that one

versed helm
#

Forgot his name

#

Merk vol was it?

#

Idk

unique rune
#

Merg 'Vol presumably had Yanme'e within his Covenant faction, yeah.

Though with Spartan Assault being a training simulator in-universe it's possible some details of the Battle of Draetheus V were mucked with.

terse lava
#

Was reading over Halo evolutions Today and had long forgotten a one the scariest things in Halo. Brute brothels

sudden hinge
#

that's a lot of meat being tossed around jeez

terse lava
#

Never noticed reading before, but appears the brothels was only on one of the moons

#

Rather odd

stoic hamlet
#

Wait, what?

terse lava
#

@stoic hamletwhat?

gilded mason
#

Probably the Brute brothels

terse lava
#

I feel deeply sorry for the local covenant officers. You know they had to check those at some point.

stoic hamlet
#

Yeah, the brothels

#

I don’t recall that ever coming up

#

I feel like I’d remember it, anyways

gilded mason
#

Brother Golubus had come really close to making the fatter ones taste like Thorn Beast, and he missed that delicacy as much as he missed the brothels back on Teash.

#

From Stomping on the Heels of a Fuss

terse lava
#

A tale from Halo: Evolutions back in...2008 or 2009

#

Wonder if native brutes would be more akin to vikings...or pirates

versed helm
#

Would nukes work against the Flood?

terse lava
#

In what regard?

#

Small outbreak? Planet-wide infection?

stoic hamlet
#

I think they would, Probably.

terse lava
#

@stoic hamletonly a small one really, like voi

versed helm
#

Planet wide infection

#

Remind me,aren't Key Minds technically the result of an entire planet succumbing to the Flood?

gilded mason
#

No, Keyminds are any coordinated Flood intelligence, or something

versed helm
#

Oh

gilded mason
#

And Gravemind would be the highest tier of this.

versed helm
#

Speaking of the Flood,how will the Flood return?

terse lava
#

@versed helmno one knows

#

A massive fleet of millions could chug on to the galaxy

versed helm
#

Is it possible that some distant galaxies might've fallen to the Flood?,given their extragalactic origins

#

Also,did the Forerunners ever have a name for the Small Magellanic Cloud?

terse lava
#

Think it was claimed the flood had consumed one galaxy. Not for sure and yes the forerunner called it "path keotha"

versed helm
#

Path Kethona was the Large Magellanic Cloud

terse lava
#

Ah misread your question

#

Likely then "path (name)"

#

You know I wonder what wrong with karan's books. Human weakness was utterly wonderful, but then years later with the kilo 5 trilogy just horrible

midnight loom
#

nah

#

the kilo 5 gave more missing info

terse lava
#

People hold kilo in very low regard

stoic hamlet
#

Speaking of Kilo

#

Does anyone else remember if there’s a passage in either Thursday War or Mortal Dictata mentioning that Vaz and Mal were given like, low level enhancements?

gilded mason
#

Been searching for a while, but no luck

stoic hamlet
#

Guess it is a case if misremembering.

#

Thanks for double checking.

gilded mason
#

Yup. Though it might be there, and I'm simply not searching the right word

stoic hamlet
#

Idk what words specifically you could search.

#

Enhancements, augmentations. Augments.

Maybe?

gilded mason
#

Yeah, I tried low, enhance, augment

stoic hamlet
#

Upgrades?

gilded mason
#

Hm. I'll try that real quick

stoic hamlet
#

Reaching wth that one but it’s worth a shot

gilded mason
#

Nope, no luck there

stoic hamlet
#

I really must be misremembering then.

IIRC the passage was like “after some convincing, Osman had managed to get the ODST’s on-board for low level enhancements/augments/etc.”

gilded mason
#

And it's not in Glasslands, right?

stoic hamlet
#

Or at least that’s what my memory said it was.

#

I don’t think so.

gilded mason
#

Mhm

stoic hamlet
#

It would have been after/during Phillips was on Sangheilios. Like, it was either a BB chapter or an Osman chapter, mentioned on the Port Stanley bridge.

#

I think I am just misremembering.

#

Meh

#

Thanks again.

gilded mason
#

👍

terse lava
#

Hate it when that happens, never was able to find that quote in broken circle on very elder sangheili growing whisks of hairs

gilded mason
#

I found it, if you're still looking, Ado

terse lava
#

You did?!

gilded mason
#

Yeah, a long while back. Posted it here

#

I'll paste it

#

Tup’Quk, a Sangheili bent with age, bristling with the odd hairs the very old sometimes sprouted from various crevices, came shuffling slowly, the ceremonial jewelry jingling from his pierced mandibles.

terse lava
#

Blood....where was that

gilded mason
#

Part 2

noble fjord
#

"Local Sangheili literally too old and stubborn to die"

terse lava
#

Well thank you ostral, truly you are an Oracle master

gilded mason
#

😎

#

I prefer the term "Sangheili Archivist." 😉

terse lava
#

Works for me

noble fjord
#

He is the "Elite Elite Archivist"

terse lava
#

You said it was ch2?

gilded mason
#

Part 2, An Invitation to the Dance of Chaos.

#

Or whatever it's called

terse lava
#

BLOOD! I truly thought it was the elder ussa met

#

I was 3400 years off XD

gilded mason
#

lol

#

Very start of chapter 17

terse lava
#

Well glad that was solved

#

I wonder if there's any reason to have a covenant that old to begin with. They could have had the covenant as a younger civilization like this pseudo race from mass effect. Or they could have had it Even older

#

Or just rounded it up to 4000 years

vivid rover
#

why did the humans go to war with the covenant?

gilded mason
#

It was a prank

vivid rover
#

?

gilded mason
#

The humans were being recorded the whole time. Super embarrassing.

vivid rover
#

give me the real answer lol

gilded mason
#

But seriously. The Hierarchs "found out" that humans were left behind after the Forerunner's first Great Journey, and realized if everyone else in the Covenant learned that ascendance wasn't a for-sure thing, things will get very bad.

unique rune
#

because a Grunt did a dumb thing upon first contact

vivid rover
#

oh

gilded mason
#

So they decided exterminating the humans would prevent other members of the Covenant from learning the "truth"

vivid rover
#

who were the forrunners?

gilded mason
#

Ancient aliens

vivid rover
#

oh

#

humans went to war with them?

gilded mason
#

How much of Halo have you played?

unique rune
#

Ancient humanity did.

gilded mason
#

And yes, Ancient humans

vivid rover
#

forerunners created the rings right

gilded mason
#

Yes

vivid rover
#

to destroy the flood

gilded mason
#

Yes

vivid rover
#

and humans survived

#

and covenant didnt like that so they went to war with them?

gilded mason
#

Yes, along with all other species that the Forerunners indexed

#
and covenant didnt like that so they went to war with them?

Not exactly

vivid rover
#

oh

unique rune
#

Covenant leaders learned that the entire “Great Journey” was based around a mistranslation

gilded mason
#

And thought humans were Forerunners that were left behind

unique rune
#

Given that the whole thing was central to the Covenant, the fact that it wasn’t what they believed it to be threatened to effectively tear the Covenant apart

empty canyon
#

My fiancee and I started a Halo saga playthrough, and are playing through in chronological order, so naturally we played Reach first. This led to a question from my fiancee that I don't really know the answer to... ||Near the end of Reach when Halsey entrusts Six to carry Cortana, we are led to assume that this is the first time that Cortana had been out of Sword Base (at least by my fiancee and I understanding), however at the very beginning of CE, when Chief gets to the bridge of the Autumn, Cortana and Chief joke around like they knew each other before. My fiancee asked the question of, if Cortana is a new AI, how do they know each other? Is there anywhere I can find some sort of info on their history prior to the start of CE?||

unique rune
#

which also meant the High Prophets would have lost their hold on power

gilded mason
#

Cortana is a new AI, how do they know each other? Is there anywhere I can find some sort of info on their history prior to the start of CE?
The Fall of Reach.

#

Though it's not much, just a day of knowing each other

vivid rover
#

oh, so the covenant thought the humans were the forerunners who survived?

terse lava
#

Yes, the cortana in Halo reach was simply a shard of her

gilded mason
#
oh, so the covenant thought the humans were the forerunners who survived?

Just the three hierarchs

#

Everyone else had no idea about anything

vivid rover
#

but they commanded their whole army to destroy the humans lol

gilded mason
#

Yes.

vivid rover
#

cause they had the power

gilded mason
#

Yes

terse lava
#

Yes

vivid rover
#

but forerunners look very different to humans

#

how could they mess that up

gilded mason
#

They had no idea what the Forerunners looked like

vivid rover
#

oh

#

and some people told me the war started because a brute pissed someone off, which one was it?

terse lava
#

At best they knew the forerunners were once mortals

vivid rover
#

oh

#

arent forerunners like 3600 feet tall

gilded mason
#

...No

vivid rover
#

oh

#

and some people told me the war started because a brute pissed someone off, which one was it?

#

anyone have an answer to that?

terse lava
#

It's started because mendicant bias claim the humans were Forerunners

#

He said this right in front of the prophets who would become the hierarchs

#

They misunderstood that as humans being literally Left Behind forerunners Something their religion said was impossible

vivid rover
#

oh

gilded mason
#

and some people told me the war started because a brute pissed someone off, which one was it?
The meeting went sour prematurely when an overeager Unggoy attacked and killed Osmo. Pederson was shot and killed with a Type-25 Spiker by Vorenus after the latter had heard Osmo firing his rifle.
This caused the initial battle

vivid rover
#

o

#

yeah, the only one I played so far was reach

#

on the mcc

#

still waiting for the other ones to release

gilded mason
#

But it probably would have eventually led to second diplomatic talks if it wasn't for the Hierarches

vivid rover
#

will I be able to learn everything from all the games dropping on the mcc over the next few months?

terse lava
#

@gilded masonhonestly sangheili should have been sent

unique rune
#

Not everything.

vivid rover
#

or they dont say enough

terse lava
#

The games themselves don't really say this

#

It's shown in the novel contact harvest

unique rune
#

The games mostly only cover some basic late-war stuff

vivid rover
#

oh

prisma oasis
#

When does another book focusing on the Flood gets made?

terse lava
#

Who knows

#

Then again none really focused in the flood per say

prisma oasis
#

What if they were to make a book on a Flood event that happened in 2531?

vivid rover
#

the flood was just a parasites that wanted to eat all living things?

terse lava
#

@prisma oasisso a novel of halo war?

vivid rover
#

and whos hyped to get deployed

gilded mason
#

the flood was just a parasites that wanted to eat all living things?
They want to join everyone in misery.

vivid rover
#

oh

#

and halo red vs blue

#

did that go on before the human covenant war?

#

was it a civil war

terse lava
#

That's non canon

gilded mason
#

Red vs Blue is a fanmade thing

vivid rover
#

oh

unique rune
#

RvB’s own universe makes minor connections to the official Halo universe, but in general it just isn’t compatible with it.

vivid rover
#

so before the great war there was a civil war

terse lava
#

Yes

vivid rover
#

what was the cause of it?

unique rune
#

Oh bugger. Can’t say war plural.

terse lava
#

Nope

unique rune
#

Stupid filter.

vivid rover
#

and I assume all the humans reunited to fend off the covenant forces after the covenant tried to invade

terse lava
#

@vivid rovernope

#

Still fought each other too

#

Some tried allying with the covenant

vivid rover
#

oh

#

did Arbiter respect master chief as a soldier?

unique rune
#

Insurrectionist forces in general laid low to avoid Covenant attention, though.

gilded mason
#

Though to their credit, they didn't know it was a war of extermination at the time.

#
did Arbiter respect master chief as a soldier?

Yeah, later on

terse lava
#

Whole thing was a mess really

vivid rover
#

I thought the covenant tried to make the humans go extinct

unique rune
#

They did.

#

Though it was mostly just because they were being told to.

vivid rover
#

oh

prisma oasis
#

Perhaps there could be more details added to a Flood event that happened in 2537.

vivid rover
#

were covenant soldiers trained like spartans in any kinda way?

gilded mason
#

Kinda

terse lava
#

Sort of?

gilded mason
#

Nothing like Spartan augmentation though

terse lava
#

Sangheili(elites) were trained.from childhood to fight

unique rune
#

Other than San ‘Shyuum Prelates

gilded mason
#

Yes

terse lava
#

Yea but prelates never fought in the war that we.know of yet

vivid rover
#

what happened to planet reach after the covenant took it over?

gilded mason
#

Glassed

vivid rover
#

they turend it to glass?

terse lava
#

Yep

gilded mason
#

They were only interested in any Forerunner artifacts on it.

vivid rover
#

oh, whyd they want them?

gilded mason
#

Because Forerunners artifacts are cool

terse lava
#

Because they worshipped the forerunners

unique rune
#

Glassing is just a colloquial term for the process of razing the planet with shipboard energy projectors

#

nothing was exactly turned to glass

vivid rover
#

They did worship them? I thought they hated them cause the forerunners tried to wipe out the galaxy

terse lava
#

I miss old " glass the entire planet "lore

#

...what? No

unique rune
#

but the surface of the planet would be left uninhabitable and turned into a glass-like substance
anyway

gilded mason
#
They did worship them? I thought they hated them cause the forerunners tried to wipe out the galaxy```
They have incomplete records of Forerunners.
terse lava
#

The covenant thought the forerunners, when activating the Halo rings, sent them on a great journey into a divine beyond. The covenants entire goal is to replicate this

gilded mason
#

And what they had painted them as mortals-turned-gods

unique rune
#

The Forerunners wiped the galaxy to stop the Flood.

The Covenant misinterpreted the Forerunners’ Halo firing as their Great Journey and ascendance to godhood

vivid rover
#

oh

#

I gtg to bed gn guys

#

school tom

prisma oasis
#

If another book about the Forerunner-Flood war gets added, then I can expect more details on that war like the Flood Juggernaut getting involved and fighting along with the Flood Tanks.

terse lava
#

Well, we have hints to that from halo 4 and 5 forerunner weapons

#

Their...forgot the name, hardlight beam rifles were used to take out large flood pure forms at a safe range

unique rune
#

I think that description matches the Binary Rifle

terse lava
#

And the larger incineration cannons were used by promethean forces to clear out developing graveminds, flood hives, and flood mountains

#

@unique runebinary rifle, thank you

#

Crawlers were created as a way to swarm into food hives and take the brunt of any attack before forerunners moved in

#

And the suppressor was used by Warrior servants to take out in clean flood infected ships

#

Truth be told we haven't seen much in the way of ground combat during the forerunner flood war

#

An interesting question, could the covenant have survived with the brutes as the military caste rather then the sangheili?

noble patrol
#

How much destruction does a single glassing cannon cause?

terse lava
#

@noble patrolthe energy projector? It was calculated by human ai that in 15 seconds it could glass one acre of land

noble patrol
#

Oh not super op but still strong

supple zenith
#

Do you think the flood could infect a hunter

#

being made up of a bunch of individual worms with separate nervous systems

terse lava
#

@supple zeniththey can't infect hunters for that very reason. They could kill one and use the biomass though

#

@noble patrolwell older lore had the covenant glassing every sq centimeter of a planet

noble patrol
#

Oohhhh

#

Ok

terse lava
#

Yep

#

You have any questions on the covenant/sangheili, myself or ostral can likely answer them

sharp adder
#

i think the covat glassed plants which had flood even apparentyl the covernat found unsc plantes with flood or a least dected flood so they glasses

unique rune
#

Uh.

Come again?

terse lava
#

Blob thinks the covenant glassed planets due to flood corruption. If they found such a thing they would, but besides voi, no known human worlds had flood on then

#

@unique rune

unique rune
#

I... guess that makes sense.

terse lava
#

Yea, I do know the fieldmaster on harvest commented to ripa 'moramee his concern that flood may be present in the relic from halo war 1

sharp adder
#

still the flood could bee dormny blew the plantes and not discoverd

terse lava
#

Forerunner relics on human world were quite rare. Any planet that had flood housed in relics even more rare. Out of the 800 worlds humanity had, maybe 1 or 2 would have bad a flood facility in it.

gilded mason
#

800 worlds
ado pls

stoic hamlet
#

Isn’t it more like 400 worlds

#

The rest are stations and stuff

#

Even that’s high balling if.

terse lava
#

@gilded masoncolonies, worlds, stations

gilded mason
#

That's better. 😉

terse lava
#

My mind was in old canon at the time

gilded mason
#

Isn’t it more like 400 worlds
No idea. Was the 400 ballpark mentioned anywhere?

terse lava
#

Actually wondering @gilded mason, I have heard that the halo choir theme was canon as a song sung by san shyuum priests at the begging of a new age. Would you know when this was stated?

gilded mason
#

That's news to me.

terse lava
#

It's what I have heard since contact harvest came out

#

The song those priests sing apparently supposed to be the halo choir theme

#

Figured I missed a lore tid bit somewhere

gilded mason
#

Maybe I missed it as well

terse lava
#

@versed helmyes

#

It was taken by forerunners most likely

#

They have

gilded mason
#

They did

#

Hellcat is based on ancient armor

terse lava
#

Armor on a derelict vessrl

#

Nope

#

Thats prelate from h4

gilded mason
#

Prefect

terse lava
#

Thank you @gilded mason

gilded mason
#

👍

terse lava
#

Getting tired

#

Easy man

#

If you mean human tech, nothing shows humans were capable of world building

#

As for the rest...dont think forerunners could put something in a black hole

#

Chakas pointed this out to his ancestor, lord of admirals when they were on halo

#

Fortcheno boasted of hyper trains and the like, being silent when chakas pointed out humans had never built anything like a halo

gilded mason
#

lol

terse lava
#

So I would say humanity was low tier

noble fjord
#

Something I always found odd about Halo Ship combat is how it's more akin to old naval dreadnoughts fighting as opposed to more modern aircraft focused carrier combat.

terse lava
#

@versed helmaccording to a civilian

#

The didact saw them as the latest challenge to forerunner kind.

gilded mason
#

It said the librarian said it
Where at?

terse lava
#

She did

gilded mason
#

Ah

terse lava
#

But, shes not a warrior servant

#

Yes

#

Lifeworker

#

As for combat warlock, they get close due to the Covenant just plowing on through

#

No no Tier 1

#

Just...low tier 1

#

Unless something comes up shown h humanity with mega engineering

#

No clue, we have not been shown. We saw humans who had been at war for over 1000 years

#

Centuries against the flood, then 1000 fighting the forerunners

#

Pre flood....maybe they did

#

For all we know, pre flood humans took apart shield worlds they had for war material to fight the flood

#

Well clearly, human edict said they put the paint on or get the hose again

#

Sure

#

Forerunners did that, combat monitors fought with forerunners

#

No just floated Alongside their forerunner masters

#

How well do you guys think humanity would have been had a pre covenant sangheili civilization found them?

glacial dock
#

@terse lava So if I remember correctly, the elites , before their conflict with the San Shyuum, didnt really want to touch forerunner technology because they thought it was sacred. Also, most of covenant tech is just reverse engineered forerunner tech.

Ez clap for the humans if them pre covenant elites wanted to fight us.

#

Also the Fall of Reach stated that the orbital macs were even effective against covenant ships as long as they hhad enough time to fire their volley and their fusion generators were intact.

#

So pre covenant elites would be decimated with our MAC'aroni and cheese cannons

keen canopy
#

@glacial dock Much of that isn't true. Pre-Covenant Sangheili developed the Plasma Rifle, Needler and Energy Sword. And without any Forerunner tech.

#

As well as Starships.

#

All while Humanity was in the Bronze Age.

versed helm
#

So if I'm correct the forerunners made the human race and covenant race yes?

keen canopy
#

No, the Precursors created all life

#

Including the Forerunners

#

You were probably thinking of them

versed helm
#

Ahh

#

Than forerunners killed off all of the precursors yes?

keen canopy
#

Indeed, except for a few who tried to convert themselves into dust, to be revived at a later date.

still ibex
#

which got corrupted and turned into the flood

clever fable
#

Verdict on them being gone always seemed fuzzy to me. You jump from one excerpt in a novel saying "Oh yeah, we all died except me." to a summary in warfleet saying they're just bouncing off to middle-of-nowhere space (something about unreachable depths?), then back again to Mythos saying "oh no yeah, that dude was totally the last one."

sharp adder
#

But remember humans when they were seded had nothing other species and civilisation had some stuff to go back to

terse lava
#

@glacial dock @keen canopy was thinking more on modern humans meeting sangheili, here the covenant never forming

maiden crest
#

Hey guys

terse lava
#

Wort

maiden crest
#

Bornstellar becomes didact

terse lava
#

@sharp adderdidnt affect the sangheili as they left forerunner relics alone

#

Yes?

maiden crest
#

So is the real bornstellar still in his mind

carmine sleet
#

Bornstellar is the Iso-Didact

maiden crest
#

Are there 2 distinguished characters in one body..?

carmine sleet
#

The original Didact, the Ur-Didact is a different person

terse lava
#

@carmine sleetthink he means dirind the 2nd novel

#

The whole "only born now in.my dreams"

maiden crest
#

Are there 2 distinguished characters in one body..?

terse lava
#

Well was at first

maiden crest
#

Now what?

#

Is he bornstellar or didact.?

terse lava
#

Later, born managed to integrate the didact's imprint fully, this feeling he was more thevdidact now then born

#

Finally at the end of the books, the imprint "releases" him and he was back to being born, just with the didact's knowledge

maiden crest
#

Oh

#

And how did the ur didact die

terse lava
#

He didnt

maiden crest
#

His body..

terse lava
#

Was composed

maiden crest
#

How

terse lava
#

Mind intact still

#

Multiple composers hit him at once

maiden crest
#

What happens when humans get composed

terse lava
#

He was only immune to one

carmine sleet
#

We see what happens when humans are composed in Halo 4

terse lava
#

Bodies turned to ash, mind transferred to a place called the "composer forge"

carmine sleet
#

And the Forerunner trilogy as well

maiden crest
#

Oh

#

So can didact get new body

terse lava
#

Think fire and brimstone hell

maiden crest
#

Mechanical promethian

terse lava
#

Possibly I guess

maiden crest
#

So is he immortal

carmine sleet
#

No. Prometheans can still be killed

terse lava
#

Yep

#

No forerunner is immortal

maiden crest
#

So mechanical promethians are human

terse lava
#

Some

#

Others are promethans

maiden crest
#

Do they have same mind as when they were composed

terse lava
#

Not really

carmine sleet
#

There's ancient humans, everyone on Ivanoff Station and the people who lived in New Phoenix that were composed during Halo 4 to become Promethean Knights

maiden crest
#

their minds got destroyed

#

When they were converted to promethians

terse lava
#

More....I would say lobotomized

carmine sleet
#

Enslaved would be a better way of putting it I feel

maiden crest
#

They no longer control their on mind

#

Right?

terse lava
#

@carmine sleetbut do we know the mind was fully intact?

maiden crest
#

How can their mind be destroyed

terse lava
#

@maiden crestwell if their mind is fully intact, are stuck along for the ride

maiden crest
#

When a mecg prom dies

#

What happens then

#

?

carmine sleet
#

If the data that lingers around for a few minutes isn't used to bring it back by a Watcher, it will die permanently

maiden crest
#

Oh

#

So didact can also

#

Die

carmine sleet
#

Yes, like we said earlier

maiden crest
#

If he emerges as a peomethian

#

And is eternal warden also composed being

carmine sleet
#

In the case of the Ur-Didact's Promethean Knights, the extracted neural map was used as the basis for artificial intelligence constructs in a manner similar to the creation of human smart AIs. These intelligences contain many of their original memories and sometimes even portions of their personality, but otherwise behave within the limits of the duties assigned to them
@terse lava This is what it states about the Knights on Halopedia

#

Warden Eternal not known to be a composed being, MaNn

terse lava
#

Thought so, for the most part the mind was not fully intact like begore

maiden crest
#

Ooops

#

U got filtered

terse lava
#

Indeed

#

Hm

#

Thought so

maiden crest
#

Eternal has one mind

#

But many bodies

#

So do composed promethians also have many bodies..?

terse lava
#

A body can be rebuilt by watchers

#

As shown in halo 4

maiden crest
#

If their mind remains intact

#

.?

#

Right

carmine sleet
#

Promethean Knights only have the single body but a Watcher can bring them back. Warden isn't a Promethean construct and we know very little about him

maiden crest
#

Oh

#

Are the promethians controlled by cortana now?

carmine sleet
#

Currently they are

terse lava
#

Yea

maiden crest
#

All

#

Of em

terse lava
#

Far as we know

maiden crest
#

So their minds can be controlled

#

They can be put to favor humanity

#

Like they did with covenant

#

??

terse lava
#

If the controller favors humanity they can

maiden crest
#

They can i guess

#

After all we are reclaimers

carmine sleet
#

Cortana kinda favours her own plans right now though

maiden crest
#

Ye

#

And what happend to janus key

#

Humanity has one part

#

And jul had other one

terse lava
#

They dont anymore

carmine sleet
#

It got deleted

maiden crest
#

How

#

Is it gone

carmine sleet
#

Deleted means its gone

maiden crest
#

Where?

#

Both parts

carmine sleet
#

Yes, both parts

maiden crest
#

Oh

#

And last one

terse lava
#

Taken by a contender ai guarding the absolute record

maiden crest
#

Where is mendicant bias now

terse lava
#

Tricky question, far as we know, dead

maiden crest
#

It contacted john

#

Right

terse lava
#

Yes

#

Through the halo 3 terminals

maiden crest
#

Can it be killed

#

Or erased

terse lava
#

Ai can be yes

maiden crest
#

Which book should i read after cryptum

terse lava
#

Happened to an ai who worked for ackerson

#

Primordium

maiden crest
#

Oh

terse lava
#

2nd book in the forerunner trilogy

maiden crest
#

And alsp infinity s ai was killed by cortana

#

Also

carmine sleet
#

AI is basically sentient software, a very basic and slightly incorrect description but still works for the sake of not explaining AI in detail as I'm not an expert, meaning it can be killed

#

Roland is still alive

maiden crest
#

It had one ai before roland

terse lava
#

The one before roland

carmine sleet
#

The AI before Roland wasn't killed by Cortana

terse lava
#

Some female

maiden crest
#

Yep

#

It was killed

#

She was crippled when infinity gell into requiem

#

And cortana killed her

carmine sleet
#

Cortana didn't kill her

#

Wait no, she did. I did not know that

maiden crest
#

She killed her when she was denied access to ship

#

Bcz of her rampancy

sharp adder
#

Because cortana was angry

maiden crest
#

Yep

sharp adder
#

And her forerunner heritage made her stronger than any human ai

maiden crest
#

It made her now

terse lava
#

There's no forerunner heritage

maiden crest
#

Is she immortal now

#

Cortana

terse lava
#

Shes just an advanced human ai

maiden crest
#

How can cortana be killed now

terse lava
#

That's what we will find out in halo infinite

maiden crest
#

Oh

carmine sleet
#

We'll find out how they'll stop Cor- Ado, you beat me to it

maiden crest
#

What is hellcat armor

carmine sleet
#

A set of Mjolnir armour

terse lava
#

Human armor developed from ancient human armor

ivory umbra
#

Quick question. Does the M6C SOCOM Magnum use Caseless ammunition?

terse lava
#

Halopedia may be able to answer tgat6

ivory umbra
#

ok thx

terse lava
#

Welcome

carmine sleet
#

Doesn't say anything about it using caseless ammo

terse lava
#

Well there we go

versed helm
#

Will we ever go back to Heian?

carmine sleet
#

Unknown. Only 343i know the answer to that

versed helm
#

It seems like we know very little of that planet other than the architecture of those ruins were Greco-Roman,East Asian,and Middle Eastern with subtle Forerunner themes

#

What else could be on that planet?

#

And iirc,didn't the Lord of Admirals say he visited numerous worlds with ancient human ruins on them?

terse lava
#

He did, and thanks to dark ages throughout time humanity's homeworld wasny earth

versed helm
#

Where in the galaxy is Heian?

carmine sleet
#

Unknown

versed helm
#

I also wonder how the hell the Covenant even found that planet

terse lava
#

Likely by luminary

carmine sleet
#

Or just stumbled upon it

terse lava
#

Equally possible

#

Hm, I wonder if precursor artifacts can interact with a black hole

versed helm
#

So are the Precursors gods or what?

#

Man,what is with this filter?

carmine sleet
#

Ok, seems like it's delayed again but basically, there's a filter in place relating to a big film from last month

versed helm
#

Did the Forerunners ever visit the Andromeda Galaxy?

carmine sleet
#

Unknown

terse lava
#

As for the precursors no, they are not gods

#

Just hyper advanced

carmine sleet
#

They're god-like to most people though, given that they're able to do so much

terse lava
#

Yes, even the librarian says as much, "closest thing to a god we have seen". Doesnt make them gods

versed helm
#

So,are the Precursors truly gone?

terse lava
#

No

#

They traveled galaxies, only one group was wiped out in the milky way and even then there were survivors

versed helm
#

And some of them transformed themselves into a powder that became the Flood

#

While the others,no idea

terse lava
#

Fled

versed helm
#

Imagine if the Andromeda Galaxy fell to the Flood

carmine sleet
#

I don't know if its a good idea to say that, Donk, given how people disliked MEA

versed helm
#

What was the name of that Elite that chased John around Installation 04?

feral perch
#

Zuka 'Zamamee.

terse lava
#

Zuka was an odd one

wicked pasture
#

You're an odd one, Mr. 'Zamamee

versed helm
#

You know,what would a Flood infected Elcor look like?

terse lava
#

Those large 4 legged creatures from ME? Likly like the thrasher forms from halo war 1

versed helm
#

Is there a lore explanation as to why cheif’s armor changed while he was taking a relaxing nap in the forward unto dawn beetween halo 3and 4

feral perch
#

Nanobots.

#

That's it. Nanobots.

#

It's dumb, and people shouldn't have asked for a lore explanation tbh.

versed helm
#

Bruh

#

Then 343 should have at least not have changed the armor so dramatically

#

I understand the reasons to do it

feral perch
#

They wanted to make their mark.

versed helm
#

Bruh they literally undid this mark with infinite

#

Also a dumb one but do the sangheili have problems eating

feral perch
#

Nah.

versed helm
#

THEIR MOUTH IS MOSTLY A GAPING HOLE

#

Why is this not a problem

gilded mason
#

Because

left depot
#

Teeth grip

versed helm
#

Makes a bit more sense

left depot
#

And they can move mandibles independently, so not all 4 have to be open to chew

terse lava
#

Yep, eating would be no problem

feral perch
#

They also might eat exclusively noodle-shaped food

terse lava
#

@feral perchsilence heretic! Do not tell them our weaknesses!

full forge
#

How tall is Atriox?

terse lava
#

8 ft

obsidian thistle
#

If I recall there is a lil mouth flap on some Sangheili models.

#

That would close the hole.

terse lava
#

@obsidian thistletrue, reach ones only I belive

#

Would be safe to assume all have it though

noble fjord
#

I always found it somewhat interesting how ODSTs spoke to Noble 6 in Reach.

terse lava
#

How so

noble fjord
#

"Try to keep up Spartan" idk sounds like there's a little bit of resentment behind their tones of voice

obsidian thistle
#

Well do note that there was a one sided rivalry between ODST and Spartans.

#

Spartans didnt really take it on.

terse lava
#

Putting it in that contact's, almost makes them sound like they are whiny about the Spartans existence

#

Odst just wernt the best anymore

noble fjord
#

I mean I know that there's reported incidents of Spartans getting into fights with ODSTs namely John beating a few up

obsidian thistle
#

Well some of that origins were more traced back to John accidently killing some after his augs. And rumors of that getting out there.

terse lava
#

Think that was the only time they fought

obsidian thistle
#

You can even read about 1 who was directly impacted by that in "Halo: The Flood".

terse lava
#

I did not care for him

noble fjord
#

But yeah I don't think ODSTs like Spartans at all...

Which is funny since a lot of ODSTs become Spartan IVs

terse lava
#

Bit of a jerk

obsidian thistle
#
Halopedia

Major Antonio Silva (service number 73809-39884-AS) was a Field Grade officer and an Orbital Drop Shock Trooper in the UNSC Marine Corps. He was the Commanding Officer of the ODST forces during the Battle of Installation 04 in September 2552.

terse lava
#

Oh....they gave him a face

carmine sleet
#

Aye, that's from Fireteam Raven

obsidian thistle
#

Tbf how would you feel if your soldiers were wasted on a training exercise for Spartans.

#

And yea Fireteam Raven was ace for providing us so many visuals. Shame we cant get many high rez stuff unless 343i give us them directly

terse lava
#

True, admittedly not how I imagined him

#

Looks more like solid snake

obsidian thistle
#

Well we even got visuals for Wellsley 😉

#
Halopedia

Wellsley was a 4th generation, Class-C Military dumb AI who was assigned to the ODST battalion on the UNSC Pillar of Autumn. He helped Major Antonio Silva and First Lieutenant Melissa McKay set up and operate the Alpha Base on Installation 04. Wellsley was ultimately consumed...

terse lava
#

I did see his before, once again off

obsidian thistle
#

Which fits the book description too well lol

terse lava
#

Yeah although for me I imagined his uniform would be more regal looking

#

Accurate though now that I see it properly. Last time I saw it I thought they literally threw him in a officer like uniform rather then one of his own time period

#

A bit

keen canopy
#

@clever fable

Verdict on them being gone always seemed fuzzy to me. You jump from one excerpt in a novel saying "Oh yeah, we all died except me." to a summary in warfleet saying they're just bouncing off to middle-of-nowhere space (something about unreachable depths?), then back again to Mythos saying "oh no yeah, that dude was totally the last one."

I'm sure now that the unreachable depths quote is just referring to the Flood. So that's 3/3 saying they're all gone.

stoic hamlet
#

Super annoyed we never got to see bestODST McKay in Fireteam Raven.

terse lava
#

That was kind of odd we didnt get to see her

stoic hamlet
#

She was too much of a BA for Fireteam Raven I guess.

inner basin
#

Wasn’t she the one who severed the fibre-optics connection on the Truth and Reconciliation?

terse lava
#

Yep

#

The only one concerned on the flood threat

#

Silva was too busy drowning in ego

feral perch
#

@keen canopy Why would it be? Awakening the Nightmare is a thing. The Warfleet depths quote is clearly referring to uncorrupted Precursors. The Primordial was the last being to retain a form like uncorrupted Precursors.

keen canopy
#

Precursors:
Eldest of the sapient minds in the Milky Way. They had infinite forms, many voices, and singular purpose. The realms they grew and the life they crafted continue on, though they themselves have sunk to unreachable depths.

#

This just implies the Flood to me, not uncorrupted Precursors.

feral perch
#

wut. How?

#

The Flood are still around. It’s saying the Precursors are in dimensions so far below our plane of existence that nothing can reach them.

keen canopy
#

Sounds similar to another source which calls the Flood something along the lines of "a fallen and corrupted remainder of their former greatness"

#

I did think the same thing as you do now initially

feral perch
#

That’s also true. The Flood are Precursors.

#

But not all Precursors are Flood.

keen canopy
#

I know that, what I meant was

#

It makes me think that "sunk to unreachable depths" is figurative rather than literal

terse lava
#

@keen canopywheres that quote from

keen canopy
#

And is simply referring tothem becoming the Flood

feral perch
#

Somebody get Grim and ask him which it is

keen canopy
#

It's not a quote, I'll try find what I'm thinking of though

terse lava
#

It's clearly normal precursors

keen canopy
#

Oh I think you just reminded me Stone

terse lava
#

?

feral perch
#

Eh?

gilded mason
#

That quote 2EEZY posted most definitely is talking about the Flood

terse lava
#

That one yes

#

But not the " unknowable depths" one

gilded mason
#

It certainly is

feral perch
#

No!

keen canopy
#

I can't find the one about the Flood being merely a "fallen" version of the Precursors, with only a fraction of their power and intellect.

#

But I did find this:

We are the last of those who gave you breath and form, millions of years ago. We are the last of those your kind defied and ruthlessly destroyed. We are the last Precursors.

feral perch
#

I think the Warfleet quote is a soft retcon of that.

keen canopy
#

Yeah I understand your stance perfectly

gilded mason
#

I think the Warfleet quote is a soft retcon of that.
It really isn't

feral perch
#

Saying the Flood are actually the last Precursors is like saying John was the last Spartan, at this point

terse lava
#

Its just talking about those who mvangef to flee. That one there from silentium was of those who became powder

#

Two different groups

feral perch
#

Or that, yeah

keen canopy
#

What turned me, Stone and Ado, is the similar quote about the Flood being not the true Precursors, merely fallen

terse lava
#

One and managed to flee the Galaxy, the other became a pet hair care product

keen canopy
#

It makes me lean towards thinking the sunken quote was talking about the same idea

terse lava
#

@keen canopy The quote I believe you're thinking of was infected copy of the Lord of add most. He was sent by the prime grave mind till librarian to mock her in her final moments. This copy Told her that even the knowledge of the precursors was denied to the grave mind, it done not know the fall might at once had

keen canopy
#

Like two writers looked at the same story bible or something 😛

feral perch
#

That’s quite possible

keen canopy
#

Indeed, as is the other interpretation that some Precursors are alive yet fled to dimensions unreachable.

#

I just have my money on the simpler explanation, that it's just talking about the Flood.

terse lava
#

But that passage was talking of the civilizations of the Galaxy. The flood are not a civilization, they are a disease

keen canopy
#

@terse lava That sounds like exactly it, thanks. We should get the exact quote though to be sure

terse lava
#

Give me a minute I'll get the book

feral perch
#

If the introduction of Spartans that ought to be dead is any indicator, I’d bet 343i wants to keep their options open. Same with AtN

keen canopy
#

We're not at that point yet with S-IIs

feral perch
#

Thankfully

terse lava
#

This we were told by the grave mind, the greatest of them, who has consumed 10000 planets and Broughtt entire galaxys to an end this we were told…

#

The grave mind no more understands the whole truth then we do. It is past all our understanding, from the greatest to the smallest. This reserve was wrapped in precursor architecture protected from many billions of years.

#

Done

keen canopy
#

anything along the lines of: "even the knowledge of the precursors was denied to the grave mind, it done not know the fall might at once had" ?

humble yacht
#

that goes against the actual events of the story though

#

because the last Precursor literally transferred its consciousness into the Flood after it was destroyed

feral perch
#

AtN also goes against the ending of Halo 3. Who knows what anything means at this point?

keen canopy
#

AtN?

#

oh hw2 dlc

#

Well it doesn't really

#

go against the ending of Halo 3

feral perch
#

Dead, not dead, it’s just a matter of time. Yeah it does, the Flood on the Ark were supposed to be destroyed totally

keen canopy
#

That's what we all assumed

humble yacht
#

it doesn't technically go against H3, it just invalidates the impact H3 had on the franchise

keen canopy
#

But should we have? The ring was literally falling to pieces as it fired.

#

Now that I agree with Chimera.

humble yacht
#

it would have been nice if the flood had been gone for longer than 4-5 years

feral perch
#

The Ark was also supposedly destroyed, until that got retconned. I think by Hunters in the Dark. Also Chimera, it was six or seven years

humble yacht
#

if another 1000 years passed and then the flood managed to regrow on the Ark, that would have been ok

#

same difference

#

my point being barely any time passed before they reached the point of being a major threat again

gilded mason
#

The Ark was also supposedly destroyed
Though Cortana only said that the ring's destruction "did a number on the Ark" in the end of Halo 3.

keen canopy
#

The Sentinels fixed the hell out of the Ark though, there's literally an entire planet of raw materials at it's center.

#

And yea it was implied to be damaged not destroyed.

feral perch
#

@gilded mason The Essential Visual Guide published by 343i prior to Halo 4 states that the Ark was indeed destroyed.

#

They’ve since ignored that.

gilded mason
#

Huh. Never read that one

humble yacht
#

maybe they just chose to be loose with the definition of destroyed

random cradle
#

Dang that’s a small detail

humble yacht
#

it certainly wasn't making rings before repair

feral perch
#

I’ll quote you the exact wording

#

“... the UNSC followed their enemies to this remote construct, prevented them from firing Halo, and used a newly formed replacement ring of Installation 04 to obliterate the extant Flood population and the Ark itself.”

terse lava
#

To be fair? The flood were wiped out on the ark, only infection forma would have lived. However yes, hunters in the dark clearly show the flood as pretty much gone as one of the characters looks on high charity. No barrier

feral perch
#

obliterate

keen canopy
#

That is pretty strong wording

feral perch
#

yikes

gilded mason
#

Well, that is pretty funny, to be honest

humble yacht
#

oh well

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

gilded mason
#

First 343 makes it so that the Ark is actually destroyed, and then backtracks a couple years later.

keen canopy
#

the high charity thing is even worse IMO

#

it being just chilling in HiTD

feral perch
#

The Flood and the Ark were gone until 343i decided they would make interesting future stories to make money from. I mean, c’mon.

keen canopy
#

well it was a good decision

#

they just should have had their ideas in line earlier

humble yacht
#

the ark coming back, sure, that place could be useful

keen canopy
#

to prevent small annoyances like these

humble yacht
#

that particular flood infestation surviving tho, pure fanservice

gilded mason
#

Yeah

humble yacht
#

they could have had the flood return any number of ways

keen canopy
#

but if we get an FPS Halo playing as Jerome set on the Ark with Banished, Sentinel and Flood enemies

feral perch
#

We still don’t know the fate of Anodyne Spirit. I wanna know, dangit

keen canopy
#

all will be worth

humble yacht
#

but it didn't make sense that an infestation of that size had managed to emerge in post H3 events

terse lava
#

It was likely either go with Flood or prometheans for the DLC

feral perch
#

I wanted the Promethean DLC 😦

#

It would’ve been cooler IMO

#

The Ark at least had Armigers we know

humble yacht
#

but robots bad, zombies gud

terse lava
#

But likely badd plot

keen canopy
#

Hey Prometheans as a concept, are probably way better suited for an RTS

gilded mason
#

but robots bad, zombies gud
Mainly because of gameplay.

feral perch
#

My thoughts exactly!

terse lava
#

I was thinking more along the lines of you'd be giving cortana the Ark.

feral perch
#

That’s true. That would be a problem

keen canopy
#

How about the Didact

#

instead

terse lava
#

There's a reason plot wise the Ark. Portal shut down and all access to its went caput

feral perch
#

Hey, why not. You can’t treat him worse than he’s already been treated. @keen canopy

terse lava
#

Touche

keen canopy
#

I think him escaping to the Ark somehow and being relegated to a side villain would've been preferable

humble yacht
#

maybe a small army of Prometheans could have shown up at the ark in order to turn back on the portal and thereby grant Cortana access, and the Banished would have to stop them before they could reactivate the portal

#

would've been less a throwaway story then

keen canopy
#

There'd also be nice contrast to what Jul did when his faction met the Didact, and what Atriox would do if the Didact tried to lord over him lol.

terse lava
#

Perhaps, But you'd have to explain why they got there and cortana did not

humble yacht
#

cortana is in the domain, if the Ark is cut off from the domain then that would explain why she can't appear there

#

on the other hand, Promethean forces would just need a ship and some coordinates

#

which cortana would already have, probably

terse lava
#

Fair point

#

I think however people might then complain of why were the prometheans not playable. We've dealt with people want in the flood Playable sense Halo war one

humble yacht
#

people will always complain

terse lava
#

True

humble yacht
#

i don't see what that has to do with anything

#

what we got in ATN was throw away story about the flood coming back. the state of the galaxy is the same before and after the DLC

terse lava
#

In hindsight you are correct, that was a rather invalid point of me

humble yacht
#

if it had been prometheans then it would have established that Cortana was interested in the Ark and would be continuing to try and claim it

terse lava
#

Well I stand corrected then

#

Maybe the problem of gone with prometheans over.flood, may have been the overpowered Forerunner vehicles

humble yacht
#

I don't doubt it was a fun DLC with high production value, but I can't help but look at it as purely fanservice

#

if anything it prevents use of the Banished outside the HW series since now if the Banished were to leave the Ark, they'd be abandoning maintaining the quarantine

terse lava
#

Are they really maintaining a quarantine at this point? Seems more the sentinels alone are doing that

humble yacht
#

last we saw, the energy wall was still broken, unless the sentinels were shown repairing it

terse lava
#

I don't think we were ever told that the banished returned to that Breach

humble yacht
#

well the last thing Atriox said to that brute was to clean up his mess

#

i doubt he was talking about wiping the flood gunk off his face

terse lava
#

I assumed that was taking care of the remaining flood outside the breach, not the breach it self. I assumed the sentinels were going there to repair it

humble yacht
#

He said "Secure the breach, clean up your mess"

#

so we don't know how long that will take

#

funny enough, the halopedia entry on AtN seems to get that bit wrong

keen canopy
#

how so?

humble yacht
#

Once again, he scolds the two brothers before ordering them back to base to clean up

#

atriox did not order them back to base to clean up

#

whoever wrote the entry on halopedia misinterpreted the phrase "clean up your mess" as 'clean yourselves up'

terse lava
#

Heh

keen canopy
#

fixed

gilded mason
#

gud job 👍

keen canopy
#

here's an a few examples of just how dangerous making assumptions on Halopedia can be lol (was just discussing it)

terse lava
#

You have earned your journey

keen canopy
#

It has also been noted that a number of descriptions in the book are ostensibly based upon, even quoted from, those of Halopedia. This has also resulted in several errors. Examples of such content include:

#

The Encyclopedia splits the Battle of Earth into a "First" and "Second" battle, a decision originating from Halopedia, until newer information from Halo: Ghosts of Onyx and Halo 3: ODST established that the battle was in fact one continuous engagement.

#

Another error has even had impact on the series canon outside of the Encyclopedia itself: the book mentions a faction of Insurrectionists named the "United Rebel Front" or "URF"; this name originated from Halopedia, which had mistakenly interpreted the descriptive term "united rebel front", mentioned in Ghosts of Onyx, as a proper name.

terse lava
#

I remember some of this stuff, sheesh

keen canopy
#

The Secessionist Union and the People's Occupation Government are stated to be the same organization, a claim clearly originating from Halopedia, as the original source for the two groups does not indicate they are synonymous.
Shield World 006 is referred to as "the Sharpened Shield", which was a short-lived fan-given name for the installation on Halopedia.

terse lava
#

Proves how good halopedia is I guess

noble fjord
#

Ok so played through Halo 5 again

In the end we see Locke tank multiple hits from a Guardian. This brings up the question... what does the Guardian actually do aside from send out an EMP pulse

keen canopy
#

flap their wings and look majestic

noble fjord
#

like Osiris is in Physical strain after getting hit by the guardian

terse lava
#

Likely messing with their nervous system

stoic hamlet
#

It takes. Long time for Spores to change the atmosphere and infect someone.

terse lava
#

That was pavium and a fair point. Bero kusavai became a combat form through them rather then an infection form on the infinite succor

#

Does raise that question of " flood can choose to infect" thing

humble yacht
#

Not really

#

We know they can choose but in this case that mist was likely just special effects

#

An artistic oversight. I doubt they intended for that to be a scenario where the brute could be infected.

terse lava
#

Maybe, just looking back on various examples

#

Forerunner era, can choose to infect, johnson? Left alone, 1 marine from the red horse? Becomes a combat form from a tiny flood cut. Crazy marine? Played dead. Arbiter? Left alone

gilded mason
#

Arbiter? Left alone
Maybe he was good enough in canon to never let his shield drop.

humble yacht
#

Johnson wasn’t left alone

terse lava
#

@gilded masonyet Vadumee never fell on the infinite

gilded mason
#

Did his shield drop?

terse lava
#

@humble yachtunert flood DNA in him sure

gilded mason
#

Wait, yeah, I guess so, since Rtas got sliced at the end

humble yacht
#

That may have been retconned

terse lava
#

But he never became truly infected like that female marine

humble yacht
#

Staten retconned Johnson’s “immunity”

gilded mason
#

That may have been retconned
Yeah

terse lava
#

Wasnt thinking the immunity part. More the "flood choice" with johnson

humble yacht
#

Flood doesn’t always have a choice

#

Sometimes it just messes up

#

Like with private Jenkins

terse lava
#

I still say that would be the norm, in the regard that the victim would be fully aware like jenkins, then get transferred to the proto or gravemind when the combat form dies

#

Allowing Jenkins control though? Yea the infection form goofed

humble yacht
#

It was an old or comprimised infection form

terse lava
#

Yep

humble yacht
#

If it’s still canon that Johnson has insert flood dna in him, then that too could be compromised dna that has lost its virulence

terse lava
#

A fair point

#

Come to think of it

#

Didnt halo war 2 make it canon that all flood victims would be trapped in their bodies like jenkins?

humble yacht
#

No? Where did you get that from?

noble fjord
#

I read through Tales of Slipspace again and wow I find Serina rather entertaining in some points.

humble yacht
#

That would reverse everything Greg bear wrote about the flood

noble fjord
#

namely when Jerome is throwing grenades at infection forms and she goes "What did I say about no more explosives! The chambers are not built to handle shrapnel"

terse lava
#

@humble yachtone of the phoenix logs on the flood, which comments that while the flood are incapable of feeling pain, the host is

noble fjord
#

also while Jerome is clinging to the side of Spirit of Fire after being launched out of the airlock, Serina just goes "You seem preoccupied"

humble yacht
#

Yes the conversion process is extremely painful

#

Hence the pained expressions the combat forms exhibit

terse lava
#

@humble yachtit was talking post infection I believe

humble yacht
#

Like I said, that would go against everything greg bear added to flood lore

terse lava
#

Well serina was loosing her mind by that point too

gilded mason
#

Though their bodies are bent to the Flood's will, occasionally the victim can still whisper for mercy or cry out in pain from ruined lips and half-consumed throats. Or worse, the parasite will speak on their behalf, using stolen thoughts and memories as a psychological weapon.

terse lava
#

@humble yachtcurious on how? His series added that the hosts live on in the gravemind being tortured. Either way the host doesnt die

humble yacht
#

Greg bear expanded on the hive mind nature of the flood

terse lava
#

@gilded masonalso another which comments death may not save them in time

gilded mason
#

There is no cure or treatment that can save these victims, and even death may not save their consciousness from being absorbed into the Flood collective for later use.
This one?

noble fjord
#

How does a Gravemind choose a personality < _ <

terse lava
#

@humble yachtdid I miss something then?

humble yacht
#

All those consumed by the flood are added to the compound intelligence, a writhing mass of endless pain and torment suffered together

terse lava
#

@gilded masonyep 👌

gilded mason
#

How does a Gravemind choose a personality
What do you mean?

terse lava
#

@humble yachtyes, how does that change what I was saying?

noble fjord
#

Well our lovely commonly known Gravemind clearly loves his poets based on how he speaks

humble yacht
#

You were suggesting that combat form hosts don’t get added to the flood

terse lava
#

@gilded masonassuming he means Male-likw

humble yacht
#

Just their bodies get taken

terse lava
#

@humble yachtoh no no

humble yacht
#

Also the tagging is starting to get cumbersome

terse lava
#

Apologies

gilded mason
#
Well our lovely commonly known Gravemind clearly loves his poets based on how he speaks```
He felt like it for a while.
terse lava
#

Was only saying that while their knowledge is transferred into the hive mind, I have been ression that the hosts consciousness/soul will still reside in their host bodies until it is destroyed. Then they're fully transferred to the hive mind

stoic hamlet
#

I don’t recall if those inside the gravemind were being tortured?

Their consciousnesses still existed, but wasn’t it more like they were just “there”. They felt nothing.

humble yacht
#

The gravemind or the primordial mentioned that the minds were not having fun time

terse lava
#

Makes me wonder if the minds are fully aware of everyone else. Or for each of them, they are alone

humble yacht
#

Infection was designed to be punishment to get back at the forerunners

#

Like a perversion of the mantle they loved so much

stoic hamlet
#

I wonder if that changed by the time of “Human Weakness”?

IIRC Cortana was subjected to both good and bad memories.

She was in a long dead alien’s memories of home, and then when she interacted with the Marine from the IAC he was still fighting, or at least didn’t seem in pain necessarily.

But it’s been a while since I’ve read it.

terse lava
#

Quite fitting for the forerunners, not so much everyone else

#

I just read that again last night, you are right. Though it seemed to jump from the marine being a actual mind, and just a memory

humble yacht
#

Did human weakness come before or after forerunner trilogy?

terse lava
#

Before

gilded mason
#

It was written before

stoic hamlet
#

It could be the Gravemind was just screwing with her.

terse lava
#

Possible too

stoic hamlet
#

If they wanted to retcon the two to make sense

#

But idk

humble yacht
#

It was definitely screwing with her

terse lava
#

It never clarified Yates's nature to cortana

humble yacht
#

Whether it was totally lying is unknown

stoic hamlet
#

I like the idea of the Flood not being painful after you’re fully converted. You don’t feel pain, or sadness, or joy or happiness.

You’re just there.

terse lava
#

Well the story did say others were trying to find a voice too

humble yacht
#

For pre bear flood I would have agreed

terse lava
#

But what state of "there"

gilded mason
#

Also, that Phoenix Log on Proto-Graveminds...
The Proto-Gravemind within High Charity is the shadow of a far greater threat, one that will unleash damnation upon the stars should it grow unchecked.
😕

stoic hamlet
#

I think the two could be reconciled.

#

Maybe initially it was torturous

gilded mason
#

Goes into what Chimera said before, about this making the end of Halo 3 just a bit less impactful

stoic hamlet
#

But it’s now become “peaceful” or something.

Or yeah, Gravy was screwing with Cortana.

terse lava
#

I find that odd, if the proto grave mind was in high charity, yet another one formed miles away

humble yacht
#

Or it moved

gilded mason
#

Why would it move outside of the safety of High Charity?

humble yacht
#

Less room inside?

#

Also HC was still in the sentinel wall

terse lava
#

But high charity was massive

humble yacht
#

It was also mostly broken

fair hazel
#

and trying to expand into this new area

hasty locust
#

The novelization of Ce (the flood I think it was called) doesn’t make infection seem peacefully painless, however it would be neat if it was making it like “a cure” to life’s problems and such, but then again maybe it is cause the only examples we get is poor Jenkins and stubborn Keyes

terse lava
#

Sad to think that keys would still be alive within the flood

hasty locust
#

Yeah, but since chief killed him wouldn’t his conscious be dead or whatnot

#

Like after you kill a combat form whoever’s consciousness it is is like of the died right?

gilded mason
#

Nah, pretty sure once you’re infected, that’s it: you’re now forever a part of the Flood, even if your original body is destroyed.

hasty locust
#

I see

inner basin
#

Once you’re infected your memories and knowledge are basically part of the Flood hive forever more or less. At least I think so, unless it’s just owned by one singular Gravemind and if it dies the knowledge dies with it, but that doesn’t really make sense if it were so

hasty locust
#

Rip Jenkins

#

Yeah your memories but your actual consciousness

inner basin
#

Well if you’re fully infected then no, Jenkins was in so much pain because he wasn’t fully transformed I believe

gilded mason
#

Things like the Phoenix Logs certainly implied it, I think, if other things like the Forerunner books didn’t already

inner basin
#

Hmm.... Maybe I need to read the Phoenix Logs. There is a lot of knowledge in those that would’ve proved useful for the conversation we had yesterday about whatever it was that I can’t remember, and now today

hasty locust
#

Lol

terse lava
#

Man I did not even think about Jenkins

#

Poor guy

gilded mason
#

Forever a private, and then he’s Flood. What a life.

terse lava
#

Well now he truly will be forever a pvt

gilded mason
#

lol

inner basin
#

He should’ve fired his weapon...

terse lava
#

Forever cleaning those flood lavatories with the I fected grunts

inner basin
#

It’s all Johnson asked of him

terse lava
#

Johnson failed them all. He didnt glare at the flood hard enough

#

Although, there is one bright side for those infected by the flood

inner basin
#

Yeah? What’s that?