#lore-and-universe
1 messages · Page 253 of 1
I wish
the whole "that should be already evident by each member's age" really doesn't help things
You can’t really tell their ages in-game anyways
If it wasn’t for the encyclopedia it’d be fine
We could hand-wave it/ infer like we do with Saber/G-059, or Roland and Jonah
Very interesting about the whole “moved to hitscan” thing
Read all the Halo 3 armor descriptions
So yea definitely didn't unlock all the armor whoops
Prototypes be a thing.
Who says the helmet "couldnt" exist in 2542. If only as the helmet and not the entire suit anyway.
Just like how CQB used the design of a early Mark IV helmet.
Or how Grenadier started off as a Mark IV prototype before becoming the "G" variant of Mark IV.
That said there is a belief by some the "Base" sets of each Mark have a name. We just never been told them, instead only getting what Mark they are on.
I feel like giving names to the base versions of the suits at this point might not go over too well with some people, given that we're so used to calling them the Mark IV, Mark V and Mark VI respectively
Yea thats the sad thing about it tbh.
However that said we do have helmets and parts appearing before their named Mark was a thing. The biggie is Owen (2548-ish) and Carter (after his augs) having Mark IV (b) but with a Mark V shoulder really makes one wonder.
https://www.halopedia.org/images/c/ce/Halo_Meridian_Divide_cover.jpg
My guess is that it's most likely modular pieces that existed before the Mark V. Like how you don't need to wear a full suit of Recon to use a Recon helmet
Thats the thought process. Leading to stuff like the Mark V helmet existing in August 2542 really easy.
That's what happens when you augment someone like her. I wouldn't be surprised if she would've gone on to be an athlete if she didn't get kidnapped and trained to be a Spartan
Arbiter would likely lose in a one on one against the Didact
In preparation for the next Halo game, I've started doing my own little "Halo Timeline Marathon" where I'm doing the entire Halo Universe in chronological order, not just games, but also books and everything in between 😄 Just got onto Silent Storm
@tawdry galleon This is Gold. Will you keep updating it?
@twin obsidian Thanks! Yes, I will be updating it whenever I have free time to spare in my days. 😄
Question: In the Halo lore, what is usually considered the turning point of the Human-Covenant War? The Battle of Installation 04 in CE or the Great Schism in Halo 2? I've heard people say that the GS is considered the turning point, but isn't the Covenant's loss at the Battle of Installation 04 a direct cause of said civil war?
Some people have even said the Fall of Reach since that whole thing is what set the Battle of Installation 04 in motion and all. Personally I don't consider Reach to be the turning point, I'd actually say that was when the UNSC realized the war was all but lost until the discovery of Alpha Halo.
The Battle of Installation 04 is what I'd consider to be the catalyst of the end of the war.
The Fall of Reach is like, the beginning of the end.
But 04 could've gone a lot of ways, that's for certain, and the way it did go led to the Great Schism and the final battles of the war.
But then again, maybe it's more complex than that.
Regret learned the location of Earth from Meridian, and that had nothing to do with 04
And Truth knew (very mysteriously) even earlier and was trying to seize Earth covertly for his own reasons
The battle of Earth was going to happen no matter what, basically
Really a lot of this hinges of Truth's motivations and knowledge, I'd say.
It's hard to point to an exact turning point without getting into his head.
But 04 is probably a safe answer.
since the slipspace jump from reach that landed them at Alpha Halo was random, I'd say the turning point was the Battle of Installation 04, not the Fall of Reach
blind
But I agree with the point
they didn't know where they were going is the point
Didn't Cortana kinda know?
On a hunch?
Based on the artefact retrieved from Sigma Octanus?
¯_(ツ)_/¯
Like she extrapolated coordinates from it and plugged them in cuz it may as well have been random
But they took em to 04
The jump wasn’t actually random though. It’s made clear in reach that they know the location of it. That’s why Cortana was so important. Cortana said it was random to classify data pretty much
like I said before, i corrected to "blind"
all they had were coordinates
She went there because just as Halsey said halo was humanities last hope. They knew about the ring too
Either way, if you wanna get real technical, you could make a case for the turning point being both Sigma Octanus and Meridian
Or failing Meridian
However Truth came to know of Earth (prior to First Strike)
But it was just kinda blind reactions from those flashpoints which butterfly effected everything
After 04 there was definitely a solidly connected cascade of cause and effect
I always liked the story of the Human-Covenant War. I just think it's a cool concept: Interstellar humanity is being brought to the brink of extinction by an alien empire with seemingly no motives but the complete eradication of the human race. Humanity is desperately clinging on to whatever worlds it has left in a war where the goal is to simply try and survive to the next day, rather than actually win. Cool stuff.
Mhm
That's why I'm here lmao
The story of humanity's struggle in the 26th century and the HCW is my Halo
I also like how human bullets still kill the aliens 😄 all these movies where our weapons and technology doesn't do squat against alien races is a load of baloney - bullets still kill doesn't matter what its being pointed at lol.
Ay, bullets hurt.
And the UNSC uses big ones.
The truth is that guns are pretty darn stronk
Though there is definitely a gulf in lethality between your typical rifle cartridge and a plasma bolt
Now like Halo shows, spaceships are another ball game when it comes to levelling the playing field. But when it comes to basic ground combat - yea, bullets still kill 😄
Bullets, tactics and liberal application of HE.
That's how UNSC infantry roll.
Other things too
Like badass NCOs
Combat stimulants
Uhhh
Even the Mythos book says that when it came to ground battles, the UNSC usually won when the odds were in their favor (unless they were being overwhelmed). It was in space battles that the UNSC was basically outgunned by the Covenant's vessels.
Which makes sense from a human standpoint. We're still pretty primitive in terms of spaceship technology in the real world. Who's to say there isn't aliens out there with advanced vessels far beyond our understanding?
Well you can't downplay the importance of the home-field advantage.
When you think about it, we've only been going to space for roughly 50 years. I don't doubt there's probably spacefaring races somewhere out there that have been doing that stuff for thousands of years.
But in a way I think one of the more uplifting elements of Halo is that it likes to portray humanity as fundamentally a bit of a warrior race
Like it gets into weird nature vs nurture territory
But look at how we were back in Forerunner times
Gotta watch anything that could be interpreted as rude my dude
The filter'll get ya
I also like how Halo portrays human spaceships in the future how they actually would look realistically speaking - big bulky hulks of metal. Not sleek looking starships like in Star Trek.
They're definitely the coolest ships in sci-fi imo
They're certainly held together on a lore basis by a lot of sci-fi mumbo jumbo under the hood - inertial compensators, gravity generators.
But that's part of the charm, really.
And the aesthetic is grounded.
HEY GUYS I thought I'd mention that today is Halo 2 day.
The means of their manoeuvring is a little dubious at times though
i like infinite warfare space ships designs they look pretty realistic and visually pleasing
Bah
Today, 533 years in the future, the Great Schism will begin 😄
Disgusting
Anyway, uh, UNSC ships (as with all Halo ships really) have huge stacks of thrusters coming out one direction
And not a lot of, like, manoeuvring thrusters
What seems to be the case
Is that there's some sophisticated application of magnetic fields which allows the direction of thrust to be significantly altered well after leaving the thrusters
funfact the reason why star trek ships look so sleek is because they have to fly in atmosphere or nebulas
In addition to typical thrust vectoring techniques
But I wouldn't be surprised if gravitic tech is also involved
On this day, November 3rd, 533 years from now, the Great Schism will be started, the Gravemind will send the Master Chief and Arbiter to High Charity and the Installation 05 control room while he starts putting in motion his plan to take over High Charity.
The old school books make heavy mention of manoeuvring thrusters of course but a lot of old school ship technical lore is kinda defunct now
See rotating sections
Though an interesting element is that it does seem like UNSC ships actually rotate 180 degrees when they need to rapidly decelerate
Or are known to
Happens in Oblivion
imagine there was no portal of voi on earth that would have ended humanity
The weird thing about needing to rotate 180 degrees to decelerate is that MACs are spinal
So that means if a UNSC ship wants to drastically decelerate it can't shoot ahead
Though it likely doesn't matter that much cuz in Preston Cole story from Evolutions space battles are described kinda like jousting matches
Fleets sorta orbiting a gravity well and charging at one another and passing until they come back around and do it again
Pretty awesome imo
Lmao look what you did
Triggered a random lore rant
ok
UNSC ships are just that cool
November 17th will mark 533 years 'till the start of Halo 3
Presumably the rear engines can use their sci-fi magnetic field thrust vectoring to manoeuvre horizontally real good
Hm
is the unsc infnity actually one of its kind or are there more to be build?
Eternity isn't finished though
But I believe it was scrapped (or set back) to help refit the Infinity prior to Halo 5
Infinity is one of the best-named ships in the UNSC Navy. I don't know where the UNSC comes up with the names for their ships, i. e. UNSC Bum Rush, UNSC Do You Feel Lucky? and, yes, even UNSC Pillar of Autumn. Seriously who comes up with these names?
Well, it’s the first of its class
Infinity is one of the best-named ships in the UNSC Navy.
Eh
So it needs the small name.
@gilded mason I meant in comparison to others like the aforementioned ones
Ship names likely come from multiple sources
Like how the first Halcyon was the UNSC Halcyon
Or the Halberd was the UNSC Halberd
Etc
The first Autumn class is presumed to be the UNSC Pillar of Autumn II tho
So it's not like a universal rule
Spirit of Fire is actually pretty cool
By that logic the first Halberd could've been
Like
The UNSC Halberd in yo Face Fool
lol
Then you get ships like Say My Name, which are likely named by someone who couldn't think up a good name
Also Halberds are the UNSC's workhorse combat vessel
Don't @ me
People think it's cruisers
It's not
@versed helm
It's destroyers
100% agreement
Darnit
i love it how ship names are more than 1 word like in e.g star trek
Then you get vessels like UNSC Pony Express, UNSC Weeping Willows, and UNSC Unto the Breach
Best ship name is In Amber Clad. ❤
UNSC Bad Moon Rising (based off the song)
I like all the ship names tbh
Also has a great song to go with it
Indeed
I'm looking at the ship names on the Halopedia and it looks like most of the Destroyers are named after famous battles, people, etc. - UNSC Iwo Jima, UNSC Agincourt, UNSC Bunker Hill, UNSC Thermopylae etc.
Frigates are named after well-known places it seems such as UNSC Grafton and UNSC Gettysburg
While we're on the topic of vessels - is the Covenant Supercarrier really that huge?
https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-3683556515e2e900930ef6e4619b0541.webp
I feel like the Covenant's compensating for something 😄
They're a space empire, of course they'd have big ships
Yeah, they're that big
I'm just saying I feel like for the Supercarrier to be twice as large as the SW Super Star Destroyer is a little too big.
28.960 kilometers long
Though I do wish the design wasn't simply the carrier scaled up.
Well your ship gets that big
You can make it look like whatever I guess
Since the tech holding it together is presumably so potent
Bungie c. 2009-10:
"Guys we have to make a new design for a Covenant Supercarrier"
"Let's just take a normal Carrier and blow it up on photoshop"
"YES GREAT IDEA" 😄
"Uh oh, it's BIGGER JAWS"
It definitely works for the Covenant, a thousand year empire, to have a ship that large.
The Galactic Empire was only in power for 20 years
It'd be pretty cool to explore one.
Darn straight
Perhaps as the setting for a smaller game. Or, y'know, something.
No way supercarriers don't make their way back into the universe at some point
They're the biggest fish really
Ye
It'd be cool to have a sorta Infinity vs CSO (it's CSO innit) in like a cat and mouse chase
CSO, yeah
I just don't see how you can maneuver a vessel that large. You'd have to have so much room just to turn a ship like that. It actually kind of reminds me of the historic Age of Sail, how all the big Colonial Empires would make Man O'Wars and just keep making them bigger and bigger to the point where they were practically moving slower than sloths on the water. That's how I imagine the Supercarrier: Don't get into range of its guns, but if you can maneuver around it and maybe hit key spots you're set.
And yeah, basically, whoever can get the first connected strike off wins.
Well Covenant manoeuvre drives are actually spicy gravitic memes
Or just super-nuke it 5 seconds before the rest of the fleet shows up cough
They don't work by just blasting out thrust
Warfleet goes into it
So that might account for the seeming ungainliness enough to make it practical
👍
I doubt the Covenant had many Supercarriers though. Even a massive interstellar empire can't afford to make an entire fleet of Supercarriers that they then have to maintain and all that, even if you make the Grunts, Engineers, and Drones do it on minimum wage 😄
Remeber, elites are also engineers!
Yeah, there'd be very few of them.
And we know at the very start of the war, they sent off 20 super carriers somewhere
Wait
It makes sense to have 1-5 Supercarriers only as armada flagships
Wat
lumo
There's definitely a CSO or two in HC's defence fleet tho
Someone worked that out
From bits n' pieces of lore
Yea I could see HC having a few that makes sense
Just from my observations in H: Reach, it seems that Supercarriers are mainly used as an invasion platform for massive armies to take on a strategic world or mission.
Well, Rho didn't really expect Reach to be what it was.
Well, that's definitely the one solid example we have of their employment
And it was a pretty effective one
If only they'd expected humans to pull their usual cheeki breeki tricks
Like Reach - the Covies probably knew that the UNSC would be bringing a lot of defense works on such a key world, so they probably brought in a Supercarrier for what would have been a quick and effective invasion landing.
'Barutamee was surprised to learn that the system boasted a massive human military presence in the form of the Epsilon Eridani Fleet,
Hmm...nvm then.
Still I think given enough time that CSO could've dismantled Reach
Of course
Maybe it was because they knew the Forerunner artifact was there and they wanted to set up a base of operations around it?
However, 'Barutamee had ulterior motives aside from glassing Reach. He secretly continued to pursue his objective of locating the Capital and believed that the Forerunner artifacts on Reach were the final piece to the puzzle that was the Capital's location.
Like the spires seemed like they were there more or less to elevator troops for the archaeological digging rather than an invasion as it turned out.
(Forerunner Capital, to clarify)
I dunno if that's accurate, Woody.
The spires at Szurdok were being used as staging areas to strike key points across a whole continent
I don't know I'm tired and throwing out baseless speculation ;D
And even orbital defences after Sword Base
I don't doubt that, as with all things, chasing after Forerunner stuff was top of the agenda
But there was absolutely an invasion going on
With the end goal of burning Reach
Remember Reach IS a huge planet.
It's at least 10 meters big.
I know, right
my god
No definitely more like 7 Grunts
Cuz it's 5 Palmers
Woah Loskay is also a tall boi
Like 6 Loskays
wow that supercarrier is really large
Looking into Halo Wars 2's ATN event, Does anyone know how much UNSC assets were lost to the Flood? (I think the amount of Flood Infected UNSC enemies varies by difficulty.)
Very hard to tell.
Probably relatively little though.
The gameplay shouldn’t be taken as canon.
I guess. There was only one UNSC base near High Charity that got destroyed, the entire area was under Banished Control when the Flood was unleashed.
I am still sad we never saw Morgan Kinsano in that DLC
Seeing as "Fire" + "Flood" = "Popcorn".
Does the unsc use cryoweapeons or was serina a one time thing
I can’t really imagine it’s widespread or would even actually be useful.
Well limited Cryo Weapons.
In the SoF pov.
This squad for example legit "can" exist.
The Phoenix Log also expands on it.
"Hellbringers are qualified to maintain, operate, and deploy a number of specialist weapon systems in the UNSC arsenal. This includes a range of incendiary, thermobaric, energetic, chemical, and biological weapons that most UNSC personnel are not even aware of. Serina reasoned their hazardous material qualifications and daredevil reputation made them well—suited for field testing experimental cryotech weaponry. Who better to strap on experimental and unstable power cells that tap strange energies than Marines who routinely wear volatile chemical packs into battle? She was probably right, if the spirited discussion about her cryotech weapon templates among the Spirit of Fire's Marines is any indication."
That said "Cryo-weaponry" seems to be... very in its infancy.
The ZAV-48 Frostraven is only a theoretical design https://www.halopedia.org/ZAV-48_Frostraven
And as the SoF has no "Bisons" the Tundra Bison cant exist.
Ah so the were made by serina
Anders then Serina. One could say Serina adopted the research, then Isabel to a small degree.
New question how widespread were the shields that the autumn used
I think Richard was referring to the Pillar of Autumn, not the Autumn class
No it was the autumn class warfleet said they had proximity shields or was it just the pillar of autumn
Since master Chief petty officer is a rank who else achieved the rank of master Chief besides Chief @ me if you have the answer
I think Kurt also has a higher rank
Don't think he's asking for higher ranks. Just equivalent ones.
Would Palmer have gotten masterchief rank before commander
OK
there's other master chief petty officers but they're called something differently out of respect for John
117 never dies
Which is dumb IMO
Agreed.
the calling other Master Chiefs something different
so you want him dead?
We're talking about the topic regarding rank titles.
Well it would be kinda weird having a bunch of masterchiefs
Aside from John-117 how many people currently have the rank of Master Chief Petty Officer as of 2560. Not just Spartans but actual navy personnel in the Halo Universe?
A lot.
Apologies for this but:
man, this really annoys me
Right
Yeah, there are a lot. John isn’t special, the rank isn’t special, it’s just a rank, no more, no less.
he us siecuaj
Gesundheit
Sierra 117 should probably have more impact and recognizability, do you agree Eternal?
I think halo 4 did a good job portraying that and the field manuel describing him as a legend or a god among men
Gross.
^^^^^
Come on the ending speech with every Spartan stopping to gaze at a living legend and the fact that every post war media that mentions him have everyone want to be like him or his mention in HW2 with juroeme being proud of his accomplishments
No thank you.
Why
Because it’s dumb
I like it, to an extent
Anyway, Jerome was -unknowingly- echoing a sentiment also voiced by Maria-062. It’s not like this regard for Chief is really new.
Where did Jerome echo a sentiment?
Saying he was glad to know John was still out there is in the same vein as Maria saying everyone would sleep better at night once he got Mark VI
I still don’t like it.
It’s still dumb
The worship
The idea that he has somehow made an entire rank special
Etc, etc
His call sign should get more fanfare than his rank, as I suggested earlier.
I’d agree with that. That would be a good compromise
the hero worship is just tickling the player ego and making the chief a more significant character to play
Doesn’t change the fact that it’s dumb
You don’t see games like Call of Duty, or Medal or Honour, or Battlefield etc, etc do that.
His callsign is special that is literally what they used for his name in the end of halo 3 not masterchief not Spartan not his name but 117
or Mount and Blade, or Titanfall, etc
Because there not that special jack Cooper was a rookie that was just lucky and skilled , prices team had a ship named after them and I don't know about medal if honor
Titanfall is not comparable
Because it’s only had two installments, and one had no proper campaign
The point I’m making is hero worship isn’t needed for a good protagonist, or to recognize their deeds.
You do see “anti-worship” in Portal. Heh.
and then hero worshipping in half life 2
I’m not saying hero worship doesn’t occur
Just that it’s not needed, especially in a more “Grounded” setting like Halo
yeah I get your point about how it isn't too realistic
but then again I'm not too cranky about small details like this either
oni bad, marine corps good
I suppose his legendary status in the original trilogy came from the fact that he was the "last spartan remaining"
Haaa hero worship has been in halo since 2 halo 3 entire campaign and marketing is that masterchief is the only hope left the last Spartan there's a cutscene where two Marines see masterchief coming and they lose their minds
Which wasn’t true even slightly.
Also it wasn’t that it was John, it’s that they saw “A Spartan”
And any Spartans a legend it's the entire reason they say Spartans never die
halo 3, second mission first cutscene
I don't know anything about halo 5+ but before that, s117 was the last known remaining spartan
That’s not true
yeah sorry, haven't read the books so my knowledge is strictly in-game
Though it could be argued during CE, since all the others were trapped on Reach as it was being invaded and the other one with him was clinically dead.
Thought this was about SIIs.
And Maria
And I meant at the time CE came out.
“The Last Spartan” I took to mean in general
Ah yeah fair.
But since First Strike we’ve known he never was
Sure, yeah.
During all Spartans aside from grey team and maybe black team were on onyx and by the end the planet was destroyed not that hard to imagine why they thought they were all dead
And the 3s were on onyx
So what happen to the 300
They were likely sent behind the lines, but by the time they arrived/were reassigned to defend Earth the war ended
They’re still in action post war
IIRC the last chronological story before H5 has a Gamma kill Avu’Med Telcam, from K-5.
She blows his brains out, if I recall.
”Wort”
Sup
-‘Telcam’s last word.
Ugh
Lol
Let's agree to disagree I like the heroism of halo and how they acknowledge them u like the realism of them being professional I think
What? It’s an iconic line
Go go
Just, y'know. Considering Telcam's importance and all that. And then his only line in his death comic is "Wort".
I agree with that
Yeah
I liked that story and not much else
The best story is hands down Something Has Happened IMO
but even then, the inclusion of a BR85 is.. painful
Oh I forgot that was in there
And then the one Blue Team comic... that’s not canon. It can’t be. 
Oh yeah that one lol
And undefeated is good too
Lol is his last words really Wort
Note we have no idea what wort means
curse word
Other than it has a meaning but when it was almost given it was taken away from us in Envoy
cries
wait really?
Yes really
“Wort wort wort!” the Sangheili shouted, feet thudding as they leapt for safety. She knew what that meant, but her brain was too fuzzy to translate after exerting the energy it took to steady herself and throw the grenade.
Dang it, Melody.
Though it matches the previously understood "Go go go."
Tobias you troll
Honestly
To me wort is probably a rough human approximation of a sound we can't really make (I mean, I can't really emulate how it originally sounded in-game)
And is one of those sorta weird words that translates to a concept that English doesn't encapsulate in one word
Like to me it could almost be the equivalent of something like "d a m n" but maybe it can also be used in the manner of urging someone forwards and can be be repeated in quick succession for emphasis.
Kind of a general purpose urgency/danger catch-all
Would make sense.
Try being a Sangheili and attempting to speak certain words
I.e
Evan Philisssssss
Man it'd be pretty sick to hear the oddities of Sangheili speech actually manifest in game
But I guess it'd ruin the Arbiter's gravitas, right? xD
It'd be cute.
I heard that before, but I could never find the passage talking about it
Know the quote?
I see.
Like a lizard with a beard 
8/10
I knew because there's a pub called the bearded dragon in the general vicinity of where I live
I'm not like a lizard expert or anything
The AI from Red Vs Blue? They're not canon to Halo
You know who is? MB
And t hank god for that
But yes, Wort is probably the Elite equivilent of "random panicked noise", doesnt really have a meaning
Or it’s like “Cree” in Stargate where it means a bunch of things depending on context.
Ye
Can someone replace every Wort with “random panicked noise” as a spoken sentence in MCC PC? Please?
Someone please do that
It’d be hilarious.
Actually
One small detail I find to be interesting is the observation by Dr Evan Phillips that the Sangheili and other species of the Covenant would be left feeling confused/offended when a human smiled at them.
The impetus being that when a human smiles, it is typically as a gesture of contentment or being satisfied at something, where Sangheili associated it with predators/animals baring their teeth in anticipation of fighting.
Question, just got Oblivion and noted a comment that the covenant lost a beacon 5000 cycles ago. Have we been given a proper cycle/ year conversion rate as the covenant was only 3400 years old? Or did I miss a retcon?
It's been said cycles can mean several different things and don't translate well to human calenders.
True, at first I thought it was referencing the luminary from broken circle until it clarified
Couldnt we get something from broken circle that says the reformists left their homeworld 1000 cycles ago?
Cycles may reset based on military campaigns, I heard.
What determines a new Age of Reclamation? Appointment of new High Prophets?
Figured new technology
The beginning of the Human-Covenant War was declared a new Age of Reclamation in Contact Harvest, if I recall correctly
The ninth age
So did y'all see the stuff Halopedia recovered? :)
Cause like I still totally love the Alpha-9 Interviews.
Btw was there different varieties of the helljumpers armor
Or just the one that's in all Halo games
Different varieties
Ok thanks
Two different ones could be seen at the same time in Fireteam Raven
i've played fireteam raven, ther'es one downtown montreal
speaking of, I should see where to go to have the list updated
the odst team from operation spearbreaker in halo wars also used different armors as well
@obsidian thistle I remember those, they were a nice touch to the game advertisements
I totally love that Live Action Website. Really was one of the best ways to introduce Alpha-9.
@humble yacht if I recall, before the whole human relevation, wasnt it commented that harvest was the largest concentration of forerunner relics found in a few ages?
@obsidian thistletrue, the odst "traning" trailer was another nice touch to those too.
It was the companion piece to that after all ;)
Indeed
The Life (We Are ODST) trailer release coincideded with the Pre-Mission Evaluation. With the trailer having a code in it for the Website.
Wasn't that because the luminary identified humans as relics or reclaimers
Yes, but at that time they were not aware of that.
Is nizat special like in age or something because in oblivion he says he's a hundred or so years old
He has served in the military for about 200 Earth years.
I imagine that's not near the limit considering how spry he still is.
The longer lifespan could be due to their size. Assuming they have a slower metabolism than humans, they probably age at a slower rate.
Man remember when we thought Thel was old
Is that his sidekick the one who killed the prophet in silent Storm to save him
Good cop bad cop
Elite literally gets his insides smashed like a boss
Hm?
@gilded mason200? The book only said he had served in the military for 100
Denning confirmed Nizat was thinking in Sanghelios years.
Which last twice as long as Earth years.
This is why I love sangheili
Wort
I wonder what the tale.though is behind the lost beacon. Vanished with a fleet "5000" cycles ago and the covenant only know the it ended up at the center of the galaxy
man, that's a long time between birthdays
Makes u wonder how long brute life spans are
Well there was that one chieftain from the atriox comics that been living since before the Covenant encountered the brutes
61 years
That could mean anything from they were born just before the Covenant brought them into the fold to them having been old enough to serve in the Covenant military when they first arrived
The madmax looking one
What?
Also don't forget that reptiles tend to live long as well.
That probably explains Sangheili age too.
Also yeah the Brutes were only in the Covenant for like 200 years or so I think
Not even that long.
So yeah its entirely possible for there to be Brutes alive in the Halo trilogy that remember the time before.
Considering it was basically them living in Atomicbombia...
They were probably pretty happy to join up
As of 2552, only 60 years.
Jeez...
They’re good bois
one of the more odd things on the brutes. Bungie commenting on them bring the "barbarians of Rome", and the feud between them and sangheili called "ancient" did make it sound like they were in the covenant for at least 200 years
I guess some of that early Halo oddness.
Not terribly odd, until their offucal intrigues to the covenant came
Thankfully statements are not as set in stone as "released" media and so on.
True dat
even though that sounds better than what we got
@obsidian thistlenot saying it was bad, just feels odd
Yea
Actually on the topic, had it been up to you, how long would each client race be in the covenant? @obsidian thistle
Tbh I dont know. And as the answers are already there, I'd rather work with what exists than re-write stuff.
Fair enough
Dang that statement sounds better then what we actually got
Hm?
About the Feud being ancient. The Brutes being apart of the Covenant for only half a century is crazy when the Covenant is over 3000 years old.
True
It’s like I don’t know how Truth expected to win against the Elites with such small amount of preparation. He couldn’t even fend off the Elites at the Ark
You know, I can't remember which exact lore stated Truth actually wanted to genocide the sangheili. Broken circle has that one underling of his comment that the sangheili were only to be demoted. Contact Harveatvhad Truth himself say that while a.grunt rebellion may unbalance the covenant for a.time, a sangheili revolt would shatter it.
Here's some lines from Broken Circle that certainly paint the "Genocide" picture.
“Noble Hierarch, are we now ready to take action?” demanded Tartarus. “The Jiralhanae in my confidence are hungry for it—and I am impatient to set our plans into motion.
“An Honor Guard made up of Elites, as you well know, was there to protect him. This regrettable death has opened the door for us all, however. Already the forces around the human world have been . . . changed; the Brutes now control those fleets, and the Elites suspect nothing at all.
“There’s more—I have gathered much information since we last met. Truth has apparently sent special orders to Brutes stationed around Earth. Why would he be giving such orders, from here? That task is below him. And orders only for the Jiralhanae? He’s also sent another fleet to Earth—again, not a job for his high station. Why? And according to data I’ve acquired from comptroller files, he has already placed a large order with the Sacred Promissory—the weapons armory here on High Charity—but he has kept this quiet even now. The order, as I understand it, is the mass production of traditional Brute weaponry. It appears to me at least that he is arming the Brutes to a perilous degree. I personally believe that he is setting a trap for your people—and reaching for full control of the Covenant.”
...
“What I mean to say is: if Truth takes such an action, it will most certainly lead to war. Civil war, Zo!”
“I suspect Truth may welcome a civil war with the Elites; that is likely his very trap. He can then eliminate them quickly—and consolidate his strength with the Brutes . . .”```
Wasn't truth the only one who wanted the brutes higher because he wanted more power and they were more obedient so they wouldn't ask questions about the war like the elites
Yeah.
Man that's like the halo version of order 66
Other then that last Paragraph I didn’t really detect genocide
Yeah, a bit more subtle in the earlier quotes.
Of course, we then have Truth ordering all the councilors in the Control Room murdered. Which would have definitely sparkeda civil war if one hadn't already begun.
Sounds more like weakening the elites to a level where they can't fight back
That allows for an easier genocide if they're unable to fight back
Yeah.
Yep
You know the polearm naginata kinda thing the Sangheilis have
Not the energy one the metal one
What metal is it made from
Polearm naginata?
That still doesn't answer my question, what is a naginata?
Ah, I see
Also, do you have a link to the Halo weapon you're talking about?
No
I just remember it from that one bit in halo legends and I’m pretty sure they have them in cutscenes in halo 2
It’s a glaive
A Naginata has a thinner blade
@gilded mason @carmine sleet I believe he’s referring to Energy Staves?
The ones used in HW1
you mean the energy staves?
I’m planning on using a Sangheili in a gurps and it’s fantasy so I’d be using the metal one
That’s.....what I said, yeah 😛
Stave
i always thought you can cut through a stave anyway
Do you know the material of the stave tho
F
How fast do grunts grow
Is it like ur fighting teenagers for how fast they grow
More like six year olds. They have the same mental capacity at least
How so?
I mean there is no "so".
Obviously Grunts aren't that dumb.
Like, the most cursory reading of any of the EU would make that abundantly clear.
Specifically The Flood, Contact Harvest or Legacy of Onyx.
And Stolt. ❤
Our boi
But yeah
This is part of the reason I kinda despise the overuse of grunt "humour".
Yap yap
It leads to certain uncomfortable misconceptions.
Dimkee Hotay was decent though
That was just sorta clever anecdotes with characteristic Grunt speech patterns tho
And that's another thing
I'm also not a fan of that humor's overabundance because of their species' overall hand in life being pretty...not good.
Grunts speaking simplistically and using strange combinations of words doesn't indicate low intelligence
Well my head canon is, that most grunts are indeed “dumb” at least the ones living on high charity, because generations and generations of being bred as canon fodder, I don’t think the hierarchs would fund grunt school
Feels like a weird disconnect
The Flood emphasizes that Grunt speech in particular was kinda difficult for translation
So the way they speak could, in-universe, just be attributed to that
Maybe.
Grunt school would be kind of hilarious
How would the write with their massive “claw like” hands?
But they did have grunt seminaries for those who would become deacons. Pretty much religious college
so whats is yalls opinion on halo infinite
My opinion is that I hope it is good. And has playable Elites.
im really confused on the emphasis of the game, the trailer showed the pilot in space and masterchief also... but then we see masterchief holding his helmet to his side and a group of injured marines droppping a signalling flare
I hope that it changes up the gameplay in a satisfying way and tells a good story that many enjoy
im really confused on the emphasis of the game, the trailer showed the pilot in space and masterchief also... but then we see masterchief holding his helmet to his side and a group of injured marines droppping a signalling flare
The first trailer isn't a story trailer
well i know that
but halo has never really showed us anything that hasnt had even a miniscule role in the story
or atleast the game in general
The teaser trailers rarely have much to do with the story
To use an example, sure, we saw a bubble shield in the Halo 3 Believe trailer, but it wasn't in the form that we know from the actual game
well i cant tell the difference between teaser trailer and a story cutscene, the art is the same beautiful work
fav game?
ODST for story, Halo 5 for multiplayer
Halo 2. Best story for me
Halo 4 is a close second for me as well
I don’t really have a fave for story
Honestly I feel Halo really doesn’t have a good story in the games
Shoot me
Well, if you insist!
But compared to several other games it really falls flat. Even Halo 4.
That’s not necessarily a negative.
But I’d be lying if I said Halo’s game story is appealing
It’s no Wolfenstein, or God of War, or Last of US, or Red Dead.
ok man I can see where your coming from and to me everone has a right to an opinion
I fell in love with the universe of Halo
Not exactly the preset stories
But when they’re together, it truly is appealing as a whole
I’d agree
The books are miles ahead of Halo’s games in terms of storytelling and emotional connection, IMO
its just that most of the people who love halo, and i think i speak for most everyone when i say this. The people who love this had a special connection with the game. my childhood was ok but what really lit it up was thinking that in this world of bad, i could read, or even visit a universe with a hero of the likes of masterchief. a world where i can feel safe since a total badass is out saving the world.
the halo world is much like our everyday life. We all play the hero and no matter what we do, we never get rest from evil, and most of us are the background marines, and the few rise to the top like chief did and help the world as a whole.
See, the games never appealed to me in that sense. I suppose it was because the books were my only real way to consume Halo for years (and they’ve since returned to that position) that John never really grew on me. He’s bland compared to other Spartans, like Kurt, and Fred, and Lucy and Tom. I love Halo because John is just “there” for a lot of the story, he’s just another soldier, not special.
But that’s sadly changing.
that is true
sometimes the background characters have a deeper story than the rest
thats why so many people love halo reach
noble 6 was an outlying character that had really no meaning to the halo story until his story was told
Chief wasn't really a background character given that he is the protagonist within the games
no im saying noble 6 was a background character until halo reach
in fact he was virtually unknown
He still is, lol
well yea lol
in the halo saga
but to the people who lived his story and watched him develop as a soldier, he is a bleeding legend
All we know about Six is that they're a man, they're a Spartan III from Beta and that they were pulled out of Beta before the mission that got the majority of Beta company killed
Not including what happens in Reach
^^^
yes, and he was an assassin who killed many a enemy
hold on
He was someone's personal assassin, right?
You don't need to be a trained assassin to assassinate someone
well halsey and im reading it noww
He wasn’t Halsey’s assassin
“He’s made entire Mikita groups disappear”
That trailer isn’t necessarily canon.
Actually it can’t be
halsey said that he was a hyper-lethal spartan and he shared that title with only one other spartan
Which has been retconned
aaaa
Disappear could mean anything given we have no idea what those kinds of ops would've been like
aaaa
Heh
hyperlethal as an official military term hurts me
it's the sort of thing you'd come up with trying to describe your _ the hedgehog OC
Yeah.
"Behold, project "Reaper," armor crafted from forerunner warrior servant combat skins. Includes duel wielded beam rifles, energy blade nails, fuel rod grade hand cannons and interplanetary travel. Truly it will make any soldier the most hyper lethal ever"
I feel unclean just typing that for laughs
lol
thank you for your sacrifice
Welcome
Truly it will earn me a place in the mausoleum of the overpowered
Come to think of it, I wonder when the mausoleum of the arbiter was built? Was it with the city, or perhaps met only for the first covenant arbiter as their own, and only later began use for all following arbiters
Grunts are cowardly and Obedient on average but I wouldn’t call them Dumb. Just a little hyper and lax.
High Council got most of their deaths from banzai charging the ape with the hammer
canonize this pls
If Tartarus didn’t have those Broken Shields those Elites would have stomped his Gorilla Butt.
Why was Six being hyperlethal retconned? That was a nifty tidbit about him?
When was that even retconned?
nifty
Eh...
Made him the SIII like how each generation has their standout
-Spartan 1: Johnson
-Spartan 2: John
-Spartan 3: Six
-Spartan 4: well either Locke or Palmer
No Spartan exclusively holds that designation now
All Spartans are hyper-lethal
As per the Spartan Field Manual, iirc
There really was nothing unique with 6, he only had hyper lethal due to being a.player character to make him neat
I always thought the shields came from the Fist of Rukt.
Maybe but if so, how and why only now?
Well we see the Hammers energy can be shot like a bolt like he does against Spark and Arbiter. Maybe he’s instead projecting that energy around him as some sort of Shield In the final battle
An idea yea
an SIV standout would've been Thorne, personally
But Six being a standout for IIIs is icky when you have actual characters like the Ferrets
hey can someone explain to me why Nobel team all died in one game but master chief was a lone wolf and managed to survive
the reason im asking is because shouldunt the armour for spartan 3 be better
?
Noble Team was written to die against an unstoppable force
wdym written
Chief not so much
Lore wise, Noble Team was vastly outgunned and outnumbered and Reach was a losing battle for the UNSC
but they were a whole team
written as in they're an expendable cast to emphasize on the fact reach for the UNSC sucked
they're a whole team, yeah, but six spartans can only do so much for an entire covenant fleet
as for whether or not their armour's better or not
also didnt reach already fall before spartan 3s
i dont even like the introduction of Mjolnir for III's instead of just SPI, but MKV[B] wasnt better
iirc it was either on par or worse
...
I know it used a lot of standard issued stuff modified
which explains why you had all the armour attachments
ok
but when reach came out that book was kinda ignored lol
No, SIIIs were developed before the fall of Reach
which came with it some lore inconsistencies but since then it's been revised? i think?
wait
SIIIs werent written in until after the fall of reach
which is what i think he meant
spartan 3 r younger or older then 2s
spartan 3 r younger or older then 2s
Younger.
then whats No, SIIIs were developed before the fall of Reach
SIIIs as a concept weren't written until after the fall of reach came out in ghosts of onyx
or am i just small brain and not getting it
As in, Spartan 3's were made before 2552
when they were written in, they were developed before the actual fall of reach event
oh but they werent part of it???
not until Halo:Reach the game came out, no
ohhhhhhhh
Alpha and Beta Companies were reported KIA, Gamma were deployed elsewhere
nah, it just means we invested too much time in halo's lore.
I like Maccabeus
rip
He’s the brute ship master guy in contact harvest
He was actually not bad. More formal and humble
That's Tartarus uncle right
Yup
yes ma'am
Had he won fighting tartarus I wonder how things would change
Not much I imagine. Maccabaeus was more devout, he wouldn’t have contested the Prophets’ moves.
Huh? He was more devoted but was questioning his final orders on wiping out the Humans
This is why I Love Brutes Good Complex Characters when they actually get some spotlight.
Would he actually have rebelled against the Prophets, especially when they started favoring the brutes? I highly doubt it.
His only compunction against destroying the humans was trying to get the relics, not that he really cared about exterminating them or not.
Timeline of the Human-Covenant War
https://www.halopedia.org/images/thumb/c/c4/Human-Covenant_War_composite.png/1188px-Human-Covenant_War_composite.png
Part I: The War Begins: 2525 - 2531
https://www.halodiehards.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/angraufharvest.jpg
February 11-22, 2525: First Battle of Harvest: The Colonial Militia on Harvest led by Captain Ponder and Staff Sergeants Johnson and Byrne resist the assaults by the Brute ship on select towns on the planet by shuttling as many civilians as possible to the planet’s capital city, Utgard. They then send these people safely aboard the Freighters on top of the seven space elevators present on Harvest, the Tiara.
February 23, 2525: First Battle of Harvest: The evacuation of civilians from Harvest begins. In the process, 22-23,000 civilians are killed by the invading Covenant forces.
2552
🤔
23rd Age of Doubt: Age of Reclamation: The scheming Prophets known as Ord Casto, Hod Rumnt, and Lod Mron, usurp the Hierarchs and become the new High Prophets of Truth (Casto), Mercy (Rumnt), and Regret (Mron). The High Prophets declare holy war on the humans in order to prevent any of the Covenant from discovering their true place as the Forerunner’s heirs. The Prophets recommission the Luminary as a means to locate human planets, and the Human-Covenant War officially begins. The Ninth Age of Reclamation begins in the Covenant.
@gilded mason whoops typo sorry
Also, why are you posting this.
They're the same dates so I get them mixed up sometimes 😄
I dunno I'm bored and I like writing lol
Seems sort of spammy.
Oh sorry I just thought people would be interested. Sorry 😦
I think we’re more interested in back-and-forth discussions and less about a presentation that we could find on the wiki
NVM sorry about that. I was just writing in my own details about said events so people could see when they took place and such and maybe talk about it; it's kinda dumb but i like lore history so sorry about that.
That’s fine, most people in this channel like lore
It’s just an unsolicited summary of the war is a bit much
Something like that would be better for a blog
Yup.
NVM
What do you guys think the 20 ships in oblivion were on one hand I want to say there cso class because there bigger than cas but humanity would have been royal stomped if they were
Humanity was royally stomped.
No there were 200cas and 20 larger classes
CSO seems more likely since I don't think we've seen any in-between ships yet.
Mhm. Until it’s been clarified better to assume that they’re CSO’s
Yes way.
That’s beyond overkill. Clustering so many in one spot is just negligent.
Actually, it was said they were all just about to leave to parts unknown
So they were probably all headed to separate places
No, they were originally at High Charity
Oh, okay then.
I thought he meant there were twenty CSOs in the battle above Netherop.
Nah
That would be a clusterfrag
More to the point there’s no way anyone else would have lasted long enough for the timespan of the book or the Spartans to be exfil’d.
One cso would have stomped the planet itself
Actually it was said they were heading off to go face humanity
May actually help explain the lack of surprise at the size of the long night of solace at Reach. Humanity Must have had reports of them before
The CSO is a glorified support ship. Its kinda funny
It needs the CAS and other ship types to be really effective
With their vast size, and now the lore addition of "luminal beacons," used for finding halos, thinking the now dubbed megacarriers were used for travel to otherv arms of the galaxy with that goal in mind
Otherwise, feels pointless to have such a large vessel when you have stations that are the same size and can service multiple vessels at once
Considering the one CSO we know of was knocked out by a Spartan team...yeah. You need proper screening support for em
two, technically
Wouldn't count the other that was an accident
Didn't The lnos only got destroyed because they used a slipspace bomb or they would have to call in almost all the remaining fleets and reach would have already been lost and that was without the invasion fleet
Say again?
Oh.
Maybe.
A bunch of other ships showed up immediately afterwards anyway, so one extra ship might not mean much, even if it was a CSO.
No they thought it was just the long night thats why it was such a gut punch when the fleet arrived
I mean the flight that arrived kinda sat around for over a week so I don’t think one more ship would’ve changed much
I do wonder why rho bothered going groundside
any of you remember the halo guy named Joe ?
I remember Joe Mama.
well played
@gilded masono met bringing the carrier groundside
Whos rho?
rho mama
@terse lava
Huh, don't remember that.
@gilded masonut was hoving above those spires
Wah
I think your messages keep getting cut off for me for some reason, Ado.
Hm.
Hm?
Has not shown them having any problems and to my knowledge have not said anything offensive
I mean, your messages keep looking like:
o met bringing the carrier groundside
ut was hoving above those spires
Probably auto fill issues
Ah.
Was wondering why rho bothered bringing his carrier groundside
Ah, I had thought you meant Rho himself personally went to the surface.
No no, though I guess he could have for all we know
Mass confusion going on here
@sacred dewno he was in charge of the long night of solace
Ado. ohh wait why was he groundside
What I am asking, why was his carrier in atmosphere rather then in orbit
Hey guys I'm working on a chronological order sheet for a massive Halo media marathon I've been running for a bit now where I watch / read / play every single piece of Halo content in chronological order starting with the Forerunners all the way till now. Question for anyone who knows: does Halo Oblivion take place in 2526? I haven't read that one yet.
Yes, 2526
Thanks. Any particular month? How long after the events of H4 Forward Unto Dawn? (That was in late April 2526)
June
He had his carrier covered by the stealth field and after he was discovered immediately went to orbit. This makes it likely he was close to the ground for rapid force deployment (shorter travel time between atmosphere and ground than space and ground). As soon as he was made vulnerable he assumed orbit where he had the most defensive position
It's unlikely
His wiki page says between 70 and 75
Halo 4 was 4 year, 7 months and 10 days after Halo 3, it wouldn't add a decade
About a year
Halo 3 was in late 2552, Halo Wars 2 is in early 2559
Not necessarily
It's quite possible that they're all retired or dead
Cryo allowed for some absurd life-sustaining feats
I wouldn’t be surprised if people could continue fighting well into their 100’s given enough time in Cryo
Well in those cases they wouldn’t really be 100
Chronologically, sure, but biologically they’d be much younger
On that subject though, I do reckon the UNSC could use their medical technology to reduce the effects of aging.
Keep useful personnel in the field longer.
"Your knee's permanently injured? Have a new one!"
In my little project I'm working on I'm toying with that whole idea
You could have some pretty hardcore NCOs, and hardcore NCOs are the lifeblood of any fighting force
I'm not talking like centenarians on the frontlines lmao
But these days as I understand it infantrymen have a pretty short half life
Only a matter of time before the physical strain catches up with you
UNSC troops might not have to worry about that - subsidized procedures to mitigate the effects of aging could incentivize soldiers with valuable experience to stick around for a long time.
A more grounded explanation than Spartan I stuff enhancing Johnson's lifetime, for instance. And I mean, look at Stacker
Still in the game in Halo 4
Stacker is like the one dude I accept is definitely a real person in the Halo universe out of all the Marine personalities
I wouldn’t be surprised if people could continue fighting well into their 100’s given enough time in Cryo
I can't see it being that extreme tho
Like transit time is, what, a few months typically?
And then they fight
I dunno, it'd be a very extreme case
And it wouldn't be biological age
Which I think is typically what matters
TIL the Halo 3 Diorama site calls its Scorpions the M808B. Which would be fine if it wasnt for the fact Halo 3 calls that design the M808C. https://archives.halopedia.org/halo3/believe/images/wallpaper/diorama/halo3_diorama_0290.jpg
Surely you gotta just allow that to be an error
It might even precede the M808C designation existing
Unless it's another instance of "superficial traits and even certain functional distinctions don't necessarily characterize certain variants".
Which is always quite annoying
Seeing as thats the "only" examples of the "Turret" point being sealed off on that design. Its likely is a M808B variant. Just without the "coaxial M231 medium machine gun"
I mean its very likely one of the "locally-produced variants and field upgrades over its nearly two centuries of use"
Regardless. Tis interesting to see that it exists.
*And is also interesting to see the Halo 3 Scorpion design actually also used under the M808B line.
Is the stanchion still production post war
Good question
The Spirit of Fire utilises a variant of it that uses heavy sabots instead of small projectiles
Which means they likely produce replacements and spare parts
But they're not the mainline UNSC
And the possibility exists that the Stanchion may have been somewhat upstaged by the ARC-920 railcoilgun
Or coilrailgun
The gun that uses coils which are formed with some kind of energy along a rail assembly and is often called a railgun but is technically a coilgun maybe
How the railgun is in game is also not completely accurate to how it is in the lore
How is it in the lore
Gameplay and Lore are not 1 to 1
I mean I generally assume that all weapons in the Halo universe function in a more realistic way
Which means damage isn't a linear TTK and is a result of, y'know. Real physics and random chance.
Range is a lot further
Etc
Which means the railgun would probably be somewhat sniper-esque in capability if you extrapolate from in-game functionality
If that's what @carmine sleet meant
That is what I meant
Hey so I'm currently in the process of a huge undertaking: to watch / read / play the ENTIRE Halo franchise in chronological order. I've divided the series into "stages" and am currently on Halo: Silent Storm in terms of where I'm at in the timeline. If anyone would be interested in helping me form this Google Doc I've been writing with the chronology on it, please feel free to leave comments. Or, if you're interested in doing a similar undertaking in preparation for Halo: Infinite, feel free to use my reference sheet. It's helped me so far 😄
Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xp-XsvqpuOa8GQJ2vo51dWEs0HPnZrd11X6T_9XFTfc/edit
So with the casting of Jacob and Miranda Keyes, we can take it that the show isn’t canon
Let's just call it an else world
Yeah
More pertinently: the whole thing of Miranda now being a doctor and a human being raised by the Covenant.
The covenant adopting a human child never thought I'd see the day
Rip
Wait so does this retcon halo 2 and 3 with miranda being a captain
Will be a fun little elseworld story, while our canon is still around
I don't like where it's going.
Yeah...
Tell me about it. Anything to save that CGI 💰 though
I mean, I think it could work
And like, that’s a hard maybe
But a lot would have to happen for it to work
It could be a halo legends type thing with the actors
and for the rest of the details, maybe they're pulling something clever, but i dont know if its how it is
The changing of Miranda into a Dr, and the covie are the big things
Here’s a comforting thought: Those are just the things we know about.
Savage and Tru
Her being a doctor COULD fit in some of the timeline
Oh, yeah. So there's likely a lot more changes we simply don't yet know about
Imagine what else they’re keeping from us 
still, it's all concerning, and better them know concerns beforehand.
Can it really be considered 'elseworld' when the creators state they 'wont do anything to violate canon'.
What have I come back too? Miranda raised by the covenant and else world movies?
And to be honest, this kinda muddles anything we learn about the characters within the show being able to be applied to their other counterparts.
@terse lava
Miranda's a doctor, and another human character was raised by the Covenant.
Elseworlds don’t violate canon
Because they’re elseworlds
Marvel zombies doesn’t violate main marvel canon
@gilded masonyou mean a remnant right?
but is it a different canon
It’s its own self contained thing
Why would you make a point of 'not violating canon' if the thing is an elseworld though, seems like a PR move.