#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 251 of 1

jade wave
#

That is not how the logic plague works tho

versed helm
#

But psychology doesn't wooork liiiike thaaaat Chimera

#

It's not just insta-flip

#

It's not mind control

#

Like did the Didact align himself with the Flood?

#

As I keep saying

#

It's the psychological trauma, long-term confusion and shaken beliefs that come from matching wits with an entity that is potentially trillions of times smarter than you

humble yacht
#

Ok, instead of align

#

Rephrase to “perform acts that serve the flood’s interests”

versed helm
#

And what's she already done?

#

Bring back a philosophy of galaxy-managing that weakened it the last time the Flood rocked up?

humble yacht
#

Only works in favor of the flood if they’re already ready to respond

versed helm
#

Hm

#

They could be

#

Ya never know

humble yacht
#

If they were it would be a dues ex machine and would lessen the story in my eyes

#

I sincerely hope they don’t go in that direction

versed helm
#

Well

#

That's fair enough

jade wave
#

What direction do you hope they go in then?

humble yacht
#

I prefer to think it’s all of Cortana’s worst, corrupted elements given healthy form

#

And that her current self lacks the good elements that kept her in check

#

Like someone who lost their frontal cortex to an accident

#

But lived

jade wave
#

So you would prefer that Cortana is the end series threat?

humble yacht
#

No

#

But I like threats to be mostly be contained to their own arcs

#

We can defeat Cortana and then introduce a new big bad later

agile lotus
#

How do you stick an energy sword into the ground and not have it just start ever so slowly digging? Furthermore, how does it know that you strike flesh and not, say, dirt or concrete?

humble yacht
#

I think the latter question is answered by “because gameplay”

#

In lore I’d expect energy swords to cut everything

jade wave
#

Why would it need to differentiate between what kind of surface it is striking?

#

And it probably doesn’t constantly sink into the ground just due to the amount of pressure needed or somethin like that

humble yacht
#

Doesn’t an energy sword need to be grasped in order to be active?

#

Once you let go, doesn’t it shut off

jade wave
#

Pretty sure

humble yacht
#

Eh, actually maybe not

#

Kill a sword elite and it just falls next to them still active

proud quail
#

gameplay though

jade wave
#

In all cutscenes that I’ve seen the energy sword turns off

fair hazel
#

Attention, we can now discuss halo meridian divide here.

versed helm
#

@fair hazel Midnight in the Heart of Midlothian?

fair hazel
#

No?

versed helm
#

@fair hazel Mona Lisa?

fair hazel
#

Meridian divide

versed helm
#

@fair hazel Savannah? Grafton?

fair hazel
#

What are you trying to do?

carmine sleet
#

I think they're listing ships

versed helm
#

@fair hazel Do You Feel Lucky?

#

Wow

#

What a quirky, fun way of being an absolute pain in the butt for no reason

#

Also, EVA or EMA class helmet?

#

I'm scratching my head trying to remember the classification.

fair hazel
#

You can stop now, otherwise you might need a break.

versed helm
#

No, no break needed. Besides, I'm entirely unsure how quoting UNSC ship names in a lore thread can be classed as griefing.

#

It's just that there's no context for what you're saying

#

My guess is that you're responding to something from a while ago

carmine sleet
#

It isn't contributing to a discussion to just list them

versed helm
#

And it's disrupting the flow and being kinda rude to people out of the loop

#

Which seems to include, speaking of people out of the loop, the person you're messaging at

#

There is context, if you would ask instead of charging in to accuse.

#

Ericky said Meridian Divide

#

If you watch the webisode carefully, Meridian is listed as a visited location by the Midlothian.

#

And from there sprung my decision to just throw UNSC ship names out of jest.

#

Hilarious.

#

Welcome to the Halo lore thread folks.

#

Where even the 40k nerds are bettet behaved.

#

Well, 40k nerds don't usually just randomly start listing off ship names as a "joke" with literally zero context.

#

I guess just expecting everyone also in the chat to immediately recognize this really obscure category of ships that visited a place and was brought up without any kind of prompting.

humble yacht
#

Ok let’s all chill and switch back to discussing halo

#

Rather than each other

#

Oh and a little context in your posts never hurt anyone. Also tagging mods unnecessarily is annoying

versed helm
#

@versed helm Can tell you that 40k nerds not only engage in those types of discussion and do so without setting subjective and toxic parameters for what is considered appropriate. I understand this is a more strict and content appropriate server.

#

But even when I jest with Ericky, he acts like I've just handed a Shipmaster my navigation charts and spat on Preston Cole's command chair.

#

Anyway

#

Meridian, is it a good book?

#

I enjoyed it.

#

My niche is normally the relatively gritty military sci-fi stuff, so I did go into this book as I did with the original BB with a certain leniency.

#

It can be a little jarring but also a little endearing how Cassandra Rose Clarke handles concepts from the universe in a way that's almost more true to gameplay than the other extended fiction.

#

And it also continues the trend of carrying out serious recontextualizations of the Halo Universe's "secrets".

#

Specifically relating to how much humanity as a whole or the general human public knew about the Covenant and the Forerunners.

#

As a narrative it's... decent, I suppose. Fairly standard Halo tropes facilitating a fair amount of decently compelling characters. Teen angles always detract a little from the gravitas of a scenario, though. That said it's really quite funny sometimes how grim the content gets pushed.

#

The original Battle Born is a novel I see as more dark than Legacy of Onyx, for instance.

#

The UNSC's propensity for child soldiers is now officially getting a little worrisome, though.

main rivet
#

Desperation generally leads to child soldiers 🙂

carmine sleet
#

Doesn't mean it's not worrisome because they were desperate

feral perch
#

It’s okay, just double the amount of guilt and Halsey-hating in the post-war era to compensate 👌

main rivet
#

I think with both Denning and Clarke, their first books in the series were much better IMO. battle born > Meridian Divide, Silent Storm > Oblivion.

versed helm
#

The UNSC doesn't generally seem short of troops imo - more like short of ships and planets.

#

And I gotta disagree with you on Oblivion.

feral perch
#

Silent Storm is almost perfect, I think.

versed helm
#

Silent Storm was great, and Oblivion was equally great for different reasons.

feral perch
#

Oblivion leaves somewhat to be desired.

versed helm
#

At the end though Oblivion's narrative just was kinda more memorable to me.

#

There were so many entertaining moments.

main rivet
#

To me Oblivion just juggles too many plot threads it doesn’t resolve, and there’s a middle part of the book where the perspective changing just makes it really hard for the reader to figure out what the hell is going on since there’s so many factions.

feral perch
#

I didn’t like the shift from warfare to mystery in Oblivion. I like the fighting scenes in Silent Storm.

versed helm
#

It was good having some regular leathernecks get some play instead of constant helljumpers. And honestly, Oblivion is just like the definitive handbook of Blue Team for me.

#

Like, there were many moments that just defined Blue Team as people.

feral perch
#

Linda was just... off because of the way he wrote her dialogue.

versed helm
#

Chief rallying and immediately slipping into that reassuring leadership role as the drop falls apart around him.

#

Linda' little zen speech was 👌

main rivet
#

Yeah she seemed more snippy than usual.

versed helm
#

On point, Denning. Just on point.

feral perch
#

She never uses contractions in Oblivion, and yet she does use contractions in Silent Storm.

main rivet
#

But it was nice to have Blue Team as a team more.

feral perch
#

And every other book she’s featured in

versed helm
#

Well, that was a little odd I'll admit.

#

But text never really does justice to the nuances of human speaking patterns.

feral perch
#

It’s like Denning didn’t know how to distinguish her enough

versed helm
#

I just interpreted everything more or less in her Halo 5 VO

#

And it didn't bother me

feral perch
#

I also felt like the quippiness was excessive at times

versed helm
#

Y'all are being too pedantic imo.

feral perch
#

Ah, I kept switching between Steve Downes and whoever voiced young Chief in the FoR animated movie, when I read Chief’s lines

versed helm
#

But it's not like it matters.

feral perch
#

Hbu?

main rivet
#

I think he’s done a pretty good job on young Chief, which we never really got before.

feral perch
#

Agreed.

main rivet
#

Like in Forward Unto Dawn Chief is basically just Chief.

versed helm
#

That's really interesting, cuz Young Chief has been a pretty solid character since TFoR if you ask me.

#

And Denning kinda just... kept it going for him.

#

While spicing up the rest of Blue a bit.

main rivet
#

And Nylund’s Chief I think is pretty different from the character as represented in most else, but we barely see much of him as a “full” soldier.

feral perch
#

The best UNSC part of Oblivion is the battle on Mesra imo

versed helm
#

Well, that's fair.

#

It was pretty sick.

feral perch
#

But otherwise the book is basically about Nizat.

main rivet
#

Yeah I totally forgot that was even part of the book for a second, since the rest of it is so focused on Netherop.

versed helm
#

Aww c'mon you totally can't say it's basically about Nizat

feral perch
#

Oh, and there’s some rude marooned people /s

versed helm
#

It was 100% Blue Team's book still

main rivet
#

I do appreciate that Denning has the Spartans regularly losing, which again flies in the face of Nylund but provides a welcome change of pace to the traditional format.

versed helm
#

So much of it was occupied with exploring their interactions, viewing them through different spotlights, situation and perspectives.

#

I just felt really fulfilled as far as Spartan action went.

#

And you probably know I don't have a terrible amount of time in my day for aliens usually 🤷

feral perch
#

And the censor ate my message

versed helm
#

As in fixating on UNSC characters and tech and such is always greatly preferred by me.

#

I'm the boi who keeps the MA5B in CE despite the plasma rifle being loads better in like every way

feral perch
#

What do you mean, @main rivet? Nylund wrote relatively fragile Spartans. Denning makes them look almost too capable IMO.

versed helm
#

Accepting and working around losses was kinda a theme of Oblivion tho

feral perch
#

MA5B firing sound from OG or Anniversary?

versed helm
#

OG my man who do you take me for

feral perch
#

Yessss

#

Gimme a high-five

versed helm
#

🖐

feral perch
#

🤚

versed helm
#

Though y'know

#

Realtalk

#

I kinda need the MA5-series to sound like the SCAR-17 in MW

feral perch
#

I want to see a little novella where Nizat nom nom noms Petrov

main rivet
#

@feral perch I talked about this in our recent TFOR retrospective, but insofar as Chief has an arc in that book, the main lesson Chief learns is losing. Throughout the book we mostly see and hear about their successes, and then you hit Reach and it all falls apart for him. It’s the transition from the kid he was who just wanted to win everything to the leader who loses everything.

#

In general the early thrust of the fiction was that Spartans almost always succeeded, it was just that wasn’t enough to counter the overwhelming Covenant tech superiority.

#

So you had lots of “we succeed in destroying the Forerunner macguffin and wiping out a fleet”-style stories.

#

Oblivion, meanwhile, has total failures even at an operational level.

feral perch
#

Collateral Damage and Oblivion broke that, then.

versed helm
#

Spartans win on the ground but it doesn't matter if the fleet can't win in space, is the trend.

main rivet
#

Yep.

versed helm
#

But Denning's books and Nylund's books have so far covered different kinds of battles.

main rivet
#

The opening to TFOR is the Spartans wiping the floor with thousands of Grunts.

versed helm
#

Nylund had the Spartans fighting on home turf to disrupt Covenant invasions, and like in Silent Storm they almost always succeeded.

#

But Oblivion is a rare, surreal oddity of a mission where things get out of hand at moment one and never really stop.

feral perch
#

The Spartans themselves don’t fail in Oblivion

versed helm
#

Well they don't achieve the objective that they landed on Netherop to accomplish.

#

They dropped in, everything went to hell, and they managed to get outta dodge, take down someone who was out for their blood (for now at least), and save some kids.

#

Also Petrov doesn't deserve to be eaten.

main rivet
#

It’s annoying to me that the plot thread of the trackers doesn’t get resolved in part because this is a prequel, so we already know the plan doesn’t work.

#

So it’s weird to withhold any part of how that factors into Nizat’s arc.

versed helm
#

Well

#

I was under the impression there was gonna be another book

#

Or am I just plucking that out of thin air

main rivet
#

(Also: did people interpret the end as petrov making food for the Elites or there were others marooned with her?)

#

I’m assuming there is another book.

#

But I’m not a fan of assuming another book will solve the issues I have with this one, especially given how different Oblivion is from Silent Dtorm in many ways.

versed helm
#

I think you're probably overstating the differences.

#

They're still clearly part of a coherent narrative, focusing on Blue Team and tied together by Nizat.

#

They share tonal DNA.

feral perch
#

We need more Johnson lol

versed helm
#

Also from what I remember it seemed like Petrov was there with other humans who were left behind.

#

But I am a little hazy on the ending.

feral perch
#

Nizat and Tam deduced from her amount of supplies that other people must have been in her camp

versed helm
#

Nice

stoic hamlet
#

I really do wish that was brought up more/given more gravitas.

feral perch
#

This ^

barren niche
#

Has 343 confirmed Noble 6’s is dead? I’m in an argument with a buddy of mine and I’m certain his death is cannon.

feral perch
#

Yes.

carmine sleet
#

Many times

feral perch
#

He’s dead and your buddy is wrong

obsidian thistle
#

Plenty times. How many sources do you want. :)

carmine sleet
#

At this point, I wouldn't be surprised if they give us a story of someone tripping over his body many years after Reach

feral perch
#

Make the Haunted helmet canon!

#

That’d be a great excuse

obsidian thistle
#

Might be in Wargames

#

I mean if Timmy is Wargames exclusive

#

So "could" in Haunted and Armor effects in theory.

main rivet
#

Noble Six is dead dead dead. Jorge, meanwhile, is chilling on some alien beach 😎

barren niche
#

@obsidian thistle three sources please.

obsidian thistle
#

Halo: The Essential Visual Guide, p. 130 (Noble Six) - This gives his date of death "August 30, 2552" and says "Six fell"

https://twitter.com/GrimBrotherOne/status/827954872087506944?s=19

https://twitter.com/Halo/status/1035311842833260545?s=19

@HaruspexOfHell Ded.

#TodayInHalo, 2552 – Noble Six gives his life in defense of Reach, the culmination of a desperate attempt to aid humanity's efforts in the war against the Covenant. https://t.co/OsZyaidYL2

Retweets

1771

Likes

6618

▶ Play video
#

@barren niche I can get like 1 more really easy before I need to start digging.

#

So Noble Six be dead.

#

Zero sources point to his survival.

fervent mica
#

Plus, the last mission in Reach, when you die by the Elites swarming you, the mission ends

obsidian thistle
#

That said, only thing recent lore has done beyond say he is dead is confirm Noble Six never got the Recon helmet he ordered, as a Replica of his Mark V(B) helmet was made for Outpost Discovery.

fair hazel
#

Dead dead dead.

sacred dew
#

I like how oblivion constantly mentions that Spartan armor has an onboard computer that helps them with targeting and dodging fire

proud quail
#

lol what

#

predictive targetting systems is a thing now?

sacred dew
#

Yep they were getting bombarded by wraiths and told them the most safest paths and stuff

proud quail
#

whack

fair hazel
#

I liked that

sacred dew
#

Elites also have heavy energy shields
Linda snipes a ranger and he tanks it after the other got one shotted earlier and then a grenade sends Him flying he gets up and Linda emptys her clip killing him
But he was a distraction or was it bait

stable schooner
#

Now Rangers with heavy shields is just blasphemy

gilded mason
#

What makes you say that?

stable schooner
#

Weak Shields and Enhanced mobility is the entire thing for Rangers.

gilded mason
#

Mobility, sure. Why weak shields?

remote spruce
#

game balance?

gilded mason
#

Even in Fall of Reach, we had that ranger with the great shielding.

stable schooner
#
  1. Ranger isn’t a high rank. 2. Energy from their suits could be diverting to the jet packs. It’s like a Stealth Elite with Good Shields it’s just thematically not right.
gilded mason
#

lol

sacred dew
#

He was a special case a distraction to lure them out pretty sure he was getting cold feet and nizat had keep telling him about honor and stuff

stable schooner
#

A heavy Shielded Ranger is like a Minor with Ultra Shields the blasphemy of such a thing.

#

Breh

gilded mason
#

Hm. Filter why.

carmine sleet
#

Maybe it's a high ranking Ranger?

gilded mason
#

Okay. Wasn't a fluke.

#

Hm.

sacred dew
#

I just explained why

stable schooner
#

Oh no it’s the Rank bloat since Rangers have always been one Rank. Also Oof again Ostral. Did the other Elites boost his shields somehow then?

#

Lol

gilded mason
#

...What is getting hit by the filters.

#

Nothing in the paragraph is a bad word

carmine sleet
#

What about Ranger Commanders? They're a different rank than normal Rangers

remote spruce
#

Rangers but gold

carmine sleet
#

They're still a higher rank than normal rangers

stable schooner
#

Breh they Canonized the Bobs

humble yacht
#

@gilded mason no guarantee but it's probably anti-spoiler measures for the upcoming SW movie

gilded mason
#

Uh, do you know which word is getting flagged?

humble yacht
#

I think I do

#

mass * acceleration =

gilded mason
#

Cripes

#

Okay:
I do enjoy this description given to Rangers in Shadow of Intent:
Rangers were an elite [faction], trained in the demanding art of Zero-G combat. The humans had called them "ship killers", and for good reason: many human vessels had perished when Covenant rangers breached their hulls and tore them apart from the inside out.

#

Finally.

obsidian thistle
#

Ah I remember when Grim made Bobs canon. Used my image also ;)

stable schooner
#

Welp I guess Ranger Commander is like Spec Ops Commander cause I just checked the Bobs stats and he’s the Strongest Elite in Reach Lol

sacred dew
#

Bobs are those the gold boys from reach the Easter egg

carmine sleet
#

They are, but they're now a canonical rank, like what was just discussed

#

That said, I believe the Bob on Sword Base is still an unknown, given that their armour is white instead of orange and it can be any one of the armour sets used by Elites in the game

fair hazel
#

Rangers aren’t your minor elite

#

They’re, a bit elite

stable schooner
#

Truly the key to stopping the Covenant at Reach wasn’t killing the Field Marshall’s but the Bobs. They were the real masterminds of Reach. Stealths are Elite to But their not Elite Elite.

gilded mason
#

Correct.

sacred dew
#

Imagine that conversation
We are the elite of the elite

remote spruce
#

wort wort

stable schooner
#

You mean every conversation between a Spec Op and Stealth Elite Wort

obsidian thistle
#

I do love how Rangers are volunteers in the og covenant.

sacred dew
#

Really?

gilded mason
#

Look at the cute boi's description.

stable schooner
#

Dang I underestimated the Bobs. Rangers have always just been Minors with wings but the Bob is a God among Elites

gilded mason
#

The answer has been with us all along. They're called Bobs; know who else is called Bob? Mr. Incredible.

stable schooner
#

No way that White Elite on Oni sword base is getting the Canon Treatment Though he’s Literally random.

#

That will be the day when Honor Guard Councilor is a real Rank

clever fable
#

Don't take my dreams away from me.

stable schooner
#

I really hope that doesn’t ever happen though lol. Being a Honor Guard and a Councilor makes no sense.

humble yacht
#

it really doesn't

#

unless he's like the air marshall of honor guards

#

disguised as a general council member until something bad happens, then he springs into action

sacred dew
#

That sounds pretty awesome

barren niche
#

Is there a halo version of WarHammer?

fair hazel
#

Whatdoes that mean

hasty locust
#

Like a tabletop game?

barren niche
#

Yes

fair hazel
#

That’s more fitting for general than lore , but there’s no current active production table top. There used to be fleet battles and ground command

barren niche
#

Thanks

barren niche
#

I think they were general team, but what generation of spartans are you asking about?

proud quail
#

besides grey and black team, spartan IIs were trained for everything

#

SIIIs were the same minus the Mjolnir and Headhunters.

#

cant say much about SIVs though

versed helm
#

The Spartan Corps

#

shudders

stoic hamlet
#

All Spartans are trained as jack of all trades, II’s and III’s anyways. Some specialized, but usually they’re were still extremely proficient in the things they didn’t specialize in. As an example, Mark G-313 was Team Sabers sharpshooter, but he was incredibly skilled in CQC.

proud quail
#

It's Spartan Operations, not Corps

stoic hamlet
#

Mhm

sacred dew
#

Question Whats masterchief best strength feat because in oblivion he holds up ten tons

stoic hamlet
#

Do you have a source for that?

It’s the second time I’ve heard it but I can’t remember that actually occurring.

proud quail
#

He can flip a tank.

stoic hamlet
#

No he can’t. No Spartan can

proud quail
#

Tell that to my gameplay features

stoic hamlet
#

Heh

sacred dew
#

No only gameplay and Conners word says Spartans lifts tanks

stoic hamlet
#

Who?

gilded mason
#

Though Frankie is Frankie.

stoic hamlet
#

Oh, yeah

#

Don’t, don’t take his word on anything

#

Or take it with a massive grain of salt

#

Anyways, do you have a page or chapter number for that lifting feat @sacred dew?

feral perch
#

Halo: The Flood has Chief flopping a tank, doesn’t it?

#

Or am I misremembering?

stoic hamlet
#

I don’t remember that. I think he flipped a hog, but it took a lot of effort and he needed against something. It was already mostly righted.

sacred dew
#

Eternal Canadian when chiefs in the prowler at the end he's lifting something the gees start to make the object weight 4,000kg then the prowler decelerates causing it to weigh 12,000kg which is 10 ton chief was at his limit though

stoic hamlet
#

He wasn’t in a Prowler at the end of the book?

sacred dew
#

No it was a warthog

stoic hamlet
#

He also wasn’t in a hog

#

I have the book right here.

proud quail
#

he lifted a prowler and it decelerated?

#

so it was moving?

stoic hamlet
#

I’d really like a chapter or page number.

#

I don’t want to have to search like three or four chapters

sacred dew
#

A reading the text but page number isn't there sorry and no it's not fake

stoic hamlet
#

Do you have an Ebook version?

#

What’s the chapter then? Those would be consistent

gilded mason
#

Or give a small quote so I can search for it real quick.

humble yacht
#

Lol when people willing to find proof for you and you can’t provide the location

sacred dew
#

The prowler lurched as if she had backed into stone wall and John felt his legs taking four thousand kilograms of weight under the vessel's nine-g deceleration

#

Type that

stoic hamlet
#

@gilded mason

#

I definitely don’t recall that in the end

#

He didn’t regroup in a Prowler

gilded mason
#

Chapter 6

#

So going to the planet

sacred dew
#

It might not be the end sorry

stoic hamlet
#

He wasn’t lifting anything though?

gilded mason
#

The prowler lurched as if she had backed into a stone wall, and John felt his legs taking four thousand kilograms of weight under the vessel’s nine-g deceleration. The marines bulged toward him in their safety slings, their eyes bugging and their skin pouching toward their faceplates, their gear pulling little cones into their pressure suits.

stoic hamlet
#

It was the force of the deceleration.

#

He wasn’t actually lifting anything

humble yacht
#

Chief himself felt like he weighed 4000 kilos

stoic hamlet
#

It’s not an accurate measurement

sacred dew
#

Eh at least I wasn't lieing about the feat

stoic hamlet
#

It’s just he felt like it. It’s used as description

gilded mason
#

And the marines were undergoing the same experience

humble yacht
#

Not lying but not accurate

stoic hamlet
#

I mean, you were wrong

#

But not necessarily fully wrong

humble yacht
#

Wrong but well intentioned

stoic hamlet
#

Mis-reads and minsinformation happens all the time

#

Yeah

#

No harm done

sacred dew
#

Ok

versed helm
#

how long have the flood been around

#

i know they are like the guardians or something

#

or some sorta god

humble yacht
#

Not really

#

The flood have been around for millennia

rain token
#

100,000+ years right?

barren niche
#

give or take.

humble yacht
#

well there was their first appearance, after which they retreated out of the galaxy for >3000 years, then there was the Forerunner-Flood War which lasted ~300, then about 100,000 years passed between that war and current Halo events

versed helm
#

theres also how long have the covenant been around

#

including the brutes

gilded mason
#

It was formed 852 BC

versed helm
#

so really i say that when the brutes left the covenant it collapsed

gilded mason
#

so really i say that when the brutes left the covenant it collapsed
Do you mean the Elites?

versed helm
#

like i love halos lore

#

no im sure the brutes left

#

and then it was the elites,grunts and like everything else

sacred dew
#

When there religion was shattered it collapsed

versed helm
#

well yeah

stoic hamlet
#

The Covenant as an empire collapsed

#

But the religion lives on

gilded mason
#

no im sure the brutes left
Because the empire itself was no more.

versed helm
#

they left after the events of halo 3 did they not

#

and were never seen again

gilded mason
#

Elites (and individuals of other species) left before it collapsed.

versed helm
#

well yeah then they set up like small factions

#

or small groups

gilded mason
#

and were never seen again
They've been seen many times in other media.

stoic hamlet
#

It’s important to note an empire doesn’t collapse overnight.

Individual warlords oftentimes declare themselves the true heirs to the empire, or the entire empire adapts to evolve, a la Rome.

versed helm
#

well they didnt exactly attack earth very much after did they

#

or ever

stable schooner
#

They didn’t leave the Covenant it was dissolved

stoic hamlet
#

^^^

versed helm
#

so lets say that the prophets were killed then what

sacred dew
#

There are still brutes that believe the great journey like caster and the one from envoy

stoic hamlet
#

The Keepers of the One Freedom

#

@sacred dew

#

That’s the group name

sacred dew
#

Yep

versed helm
#

when i say never seen again i mean they are still alive im just saying they didnt do much after

stoic hamlet
#

They did

sacred dew
#

Read the books

versed helm
#

Hold up

#

which ones

#

This channel is supposedly about educating and discussing lore

#

So let's clarify

#

Is Stuie talking about the Sangheili?

stable schooner
#

Are you talking about Brutes or Prophets(San Shyuum)?

versed helm
#

the brutes

#

and how they left

stable schooner
#

They haven’t left at all

gilded mason
#

We've got the Keepers, Hekabe, The Banished, Lydus, and others I am forgetting.

versed helm
#

I don't think the Brutes had any centralised form of government after the war.

#

If I'm not mistaken.

obsidian thistle
#

And presumably many more off-screen.

versed helm
#

they did leave

#

The Brute elements of the Covenant broke off and formed what @gilded mason said

stable schooner
#

Theirs even Halo Wars 2 for visual brute Media Lol

sacred dew
#

Last light,retribution,envoy

versed helm
#

because you dont seem them after halo 3?

obsidian thistle
#

Actually we do 😉

versed helm
#

its just the elites,grunts

gilded mason
#

They are in other media.

versed helm
#

And they are referenced in books and comics

sacred dew
#

Hw2,

versed helm
#

but you dont really fight them

gilded mason
#

And HW2, yes.

stable schooner
#

Halo Wars 2 man

obsidian thistle
#

Halo Spartan Assault has them in a faction. And Spartan Strike has them in Juls Covenant. 😄

versed helm
#

so they left the covenant and didnt attack earth

#

and i didnt play those small off branch games

gilded mason
#

Basically nobody attacked Earth after the war, besides the Didact, I think?

stable schooner
#

Jul having Brutes is weird to me I gotta say

versed helm
#

so i dont know the whole lore

sacred dew
#

Were fighting the elites

carmine sleet
#

A species as divided and scattered as the Brutes in the post war galaxy wouldn't be able to launch an attack on Earth

versed helm
#

well they could it would just be a bloodbath so they didnt

sacred dew
#

They nuked themselves for crying out loud
Twice and didn't learn a thing

versed helm
#

Wait

#

That's not true

stable schooner
#

That was pre Covenant Richard

versed helm
#

@gilded mason

gilded mason
#

Hm?

carmine sleet
#

Stuie, no, they really can't, they would fight one another before they could even start an invasion of Earth

versed helm
#

Didn't Naomi's dad plan an attack on Earth after he recovered

#

Pious Inquisitor?

gilded mason
#

Think so? Though he never got around to it

versed helm
#

ugh this lore is way to complicated im out

carmine sleet
#

He wasn't planning an invasion though, he was just planning a terrorist attack

gilded mason
#

Uh

sacred dew
#

It was there description in the bestrium book for halo 3 I think

stable schooner
#

Lol

versed helm
#

Man

gilded mason
#

It ain't that complex.

versed helm
#

I love the neat references to Pious Inquisitor

#

no it really is

#

Especially the map

#

Is it, in the game Reach?

#

like i dont understand any of this

#

Or Halo 3?

carmine sleet
#

It's not hard to understand that a species would be divided by a conflict like the Human-Covenant War

gilded mason
#

What don'tcha understand at the moment?

versed helm
#

well my boi Pious Inquisitor

gilded mason
#

What about it?

stable schooner
#

Even just playing the games you show know Brutes still exist. When do we see Brutes go exotic

versed helm
#

whom is he/she?

obsidian thistle
gilded mason
#

It's a ship

versed helm
#

It's a ship

#

ah

#

wait

#

this is what i mean

#

i dont get any of it

#

You asked if there were any attacks on Earth by Brutes

#

Yeah I get the impression what you know of Halo is limited to the games

#

well

gilded mason
#

i dont get any of it
What don't you get about the ship?

versed helm
#

A lot of the context of this lore can be sourced from the games

stable schooner
#

Yeah I’m confused on how your confused

versed helm
#

But expanded on a lot more by the books/other media

#

im just saying on a whole

#

i dont get it

stable schooner
#

What do you not understand?

gilded mason
#

Pick one thing you're confused about, and I'll try to answer it

obsidian thistle
#

If in any doubt or mystery wiki it 😉 Hopefully you'll find something. Even I admit the amount of stuff on Halopedia amazes me and I admin there.

versed helm
#

Stuie

#

just the lore in total

#

Maybe if you threw any questions our way

stable schooner
#

CIA391 be self advertising Breh

versed helm
#

We could answer them

#

Just fire away

#

well i wouldnt know anyway

#

Anything you want to know about

#

Like for example

gilded mason
#

Yep, pick any one thing you want to know more about

versed helm
#

just with people talking about this that and other

#

made me confuzzled

carmine sleet
#

Then ask questions, be curious. People here are more than happy to ask and answer questions

versed helm
#

You know what makes me unconfused?

#

A Sweet Williams cigar

#

i didnt know what a ship was

sacred dew
#

Example the origins of the flood
Like this

stable schooner
#

Let’s be real Stuie the outside lore is not vital to understanding 90% of the games. You know don’t need to understand everything at once

versed helm
#

eh

#

just eh

gilded mason
versed helm
#

well imma just stick with the shooting side

#

For example

#

not lore im good at fallout for lore

#

not halo

#

This current article on an unidentified cigar found in Halo 2 @versed helm

stable schooner
#

Booo Bethesda Retcons.

versed helm
#

making me confuzzled

#

and i only play nv and 3

carmine sleet
#

I was not an expert on Halo lore when I first delved into it, we're not expecting you to be an expert either Stuie. Just ask questions and we're more than happy to answer them

versed helm
#

jeez

obsidian thistle
#

Dont worry about it 😄 @versed helm We all begin somewhere with lore! I began as a egg hunter before I became really interested in Halo lore. xD Oh how a change that was in 2010.

versed helm
#

i just know some of the lore

#

still dont actually get the guardians

#

well

fair hazel
#

Wait, I wasn’t born an expert halo lore master?

sacred dew
#

There basically the space police

stable schooner
#

Don’t feel bad I don’t even want to get the guardians lol

versed helm
#

and what formed the halo ring

gilded mason
#

They're constructs designed to police lesser systems for the Forerunners.

fair hazel
#

Thé forerunners built the halo rings

sacred dew
#

The forerunners made them

versed helm
#

for what

gilded mason
#

and what formed the halo ring
The Forerunners created the Ark, which assembles the Halos.

carmine sleet
#

The Halos are used to combat the Flood by killing their food, which we are told in CE

fair hazel
#

The arks*

sacred dew
#

To stop the flood by killing there food and any advance flood form

versed helm
#

so then what do the humans want with the halo rings

#

which made them go there and find the flood

sacred dew
#

Nothing

versed helm
#

which then had to make chief blow one of em

stable schooner
#

To study and deactivate them. Cortana’s coordinates in CE

fair hazel
#

They found a halo ring. Landed on it. Found what it was. Blew it up before it was activated

gilded mason
#

Humans found the first Halo by happenstance thanks to coordinated Cortana found. She didn't know where it'd lead.

carmine sleet
#

Humanity wasn't on the ring to find the Flood in CE

stable schooner
#

Have you even beaten the games? You should know why Chief blew up the ring

sacred dew
#

They wanted super weapons to fight the covenant but found the flood which is worse

carmine sleet
#

They were there because they crash landed

versed helm
#

no i have just not in a long time

#

and i played them just to pass time

#

never actually listened

stable schooner
#

I recommend replaying them before getting into the advanced lore

versed helm
#

its a shooter and im like 9 do u expect me to listen

carmine sleet
#

Like currently you're nine?

versed helm
#

aka im like 15 now so i still dk

stable schooner
#

Oh geez lol

gilded mason
#

You're nine years old?

#

Oh.

versed helm
#

no im saying when i first played them

#

jeez

carmine sleet
#

Right, you weren't clear

versed helm
#

no i get that

stable schooner
#

Woosh Close one

versed helm
#

wait what would you have done if i was 9

#

theres the real question

stoic hamlet
#

Been really surprised and felt really old.

versed helm
#

heh

fair hazel
#

You should go replay the campaigns

stable schooner
#

Gotta be 13 right? so probably get muted until you were 13 lol

stoic hamlet
#

I still feel old

versed helm
#

no im 15 and just play reach most of the time

#

em

#

i play them but the campaigns just feel a bit stale

stable schooner
#

I know right the Halo Discord makes me feel old and I’m a young in

versed helm
#

soory if i just offended people

obsidian thistle
#

Lets move on shall we. Perhaps lets discuss Spock the Space cat. 😄

stoic hamlet
#

You’re good dude

#

We were all there once

versed helm
#

i just like to play the mp on reach

#

cause nothing else is as fun imo

stoic hamlet
#

several people here would disagree 😛

proud quail
#

BF2142 MP was more fun but that aint halo

versed helm
#

well

stable schooner
#

Well that’s general or Reach channel stuff so let’s try and keep it Lore now

stoic hamlet
#

^^

versed helm
#

yeah

obsidian thistle
stoic hamlet
#

Yey kitty :3

versed helm
#

wait why was the UNSC ship (forgot the name) chief is on at the start of halo 4 ripped in 2 anyway?

obsidian thistle
#

Halo 3 happened 🙂

stable schooner
#

Ending of Halo 3 the slipspace portal closed

sacred dew
#

Halo 3 ending

versed helm
#

i remember that ending

#

but thats unclear

gilded mason
#

It was shown explicitly in Halo3 that it was cut in half.

stable schooner
sacred dew
#

Perfect

obsidian thistle
#

Halo 3 ended with the Forward Unto Dawn slicing in half. With the front end going to earth, and the back end going to a mystery planet.

versed helm
#

which is requiem?

obsidian thistle
#

Yep

sacred dew
#

Wait the forward onto dawn killed the dawn

stable schooner
#

Man Sentinels are great am I right people

obsidian thistle
#

*I fixed that

versed helm
#

cause the only campaign apart from reach i remember is 4

#

some how

obsidian thistle
#

I love the Stewards from Outpost Discovery

#

😄

sacred dew
#

Not as great as engineers

versed helm
#

what is that

obsidian thistle
#

Hey now they have that robotic... jellyfish look

#

Steward Sentinel

versed helm
#

my brain is fried

obsidian thistle
#

A variant of the Strato-sentinel.

versed helm
#

i havent properly played halo since today

#

so its kinda jogging my memory

stoic hamlet
#

CIA you’re confusing him, lol

obsidian thistle
#

Stratos in turn are big huge sentinels that do a lotta the heavily lifting in the Halo rings.

versed helm
#

anything after halo 4 and idk

#

yeah my brain is defo blowing a fuse

obsidian thistle
#

Actually I have an idea 😄

#

Have you read a Halo book before?

versed helm
#

not really

#

i dont do much reading

obsidian thistle
#

Hmmm then I have the next best idea.

#

Do you have Netflix?

versed helm
#

yeah

obsidian thistle
#

Cause if so you can give Halo: Legends a watch.

#

😄 Has a ace short in it called Origins.

#

That gives you the tldr of the Halo universe. 😄

#

Plus it has other cool stuff in it I recommend.

versed helm
#

i shall try it

sacred dew
#

No tell him about 1337

versed helm
#

hmm

#

its the fact your saying no tell him

#

instead of just saying

#

why dont you watch 1337 after

obsidian thistle
#

Lets not get confusing richard. xD

versed helm
#

or before

sacred dew
#

It will make it funny if u don't know

stable schooner
#

I won’t even lie I like the look of Prometheans more then that New Sentinel. Looks nothing like the other Sentinels to me imo

sacred dew
#

OK sorry

versed helm
#

well ill watch it later or something

sacred dew
#

That's how the original retriever sentinel would have looked

obsidian thistle
#

Halo Legends: Origins used to be my main recommendation for someone getting into the universe as it very broadly went over everything.

#

Halo Mythos took its place. But Origins is still the best option for those after a quick recap

versed helm
#

well im just gonna go to sleep

stable schooner
#

Yeah I recommend Origins to watch Forerunners look cool and then get stomped

versed helm
#

Origins just like

#

Redeems Halo Legends for me

#

Legends is like this balancing act of really cool and really lame stuff

#

And the really cool just kinda edges it out

#

But I s'pose that's anime in a nutshell, right?

proud quail
#

i mean

#

that's quality in a nutshell

versed helm
#

I feel like most things don't have such extreme thresholds for stuff, though.

#

Like your average Marvel movie is filled with kinda cool and kinda lame stuff

#

But anime, because of its characteristic lack of subtlety, tends to push traits to extremes

#

But that's just a theory

#

An off-the-cuff entirely shallow media theory

obsidian thistle
#

Origins was like 343is very suttle roadmap of Halo lore for the then 10 years of Halo 343i had planned.

#

Mixed with stuff we already knew. And Cortanas imagination

manic tinsel
#

What would a ODST training consist of?

past olive
#

jumping out of an aeroplane without a parachute

#

correction, out of a plane with a mattress instead of a parachute

severe lodge
#

Hi. I know that may have been discussed a million times but I still have a few questions dealiong with Reach events. I have read fall of Reach, First strike, played Halo Reach and read Halsey's journal from limited edition. I have checked many timelines based on unsc military calendar. On the 23th of July how could Covenant forces land near Visegrad ? With orbital defense and everything it was hard to land on 30th Aug and it was the Fleat of particular justice. How could convenant land near visegrad and not be noticed before landing ?

past olive
#

yeah they conflict

#

Fall of Reach was written before Halo Reach

#

and Bungie didn't make Halo Reach to tie into The Fall of Reach cause they wanted to do what they wanted to do and not what was in the book

#

as for which is canon, the game is canon because to Bungie the games are priority over the books

carmine sleet
#

Halo Canon recently released a video that details all the events surrounding Reach and how they all fit together

severe lodge
#

yeah that's too bad. FoR was actually a nice prequel to halo CE at the time but I hoped everything would fit in the end

carmine sleet
#

Both Reach and The Fall of Reach are canon

past olive
#

gonna have to watch that vid

carmine sleet
#

343i have confirmed so multiple times

severe lodge
#

probably countless times yes I have checked everything I could before asking here

#

will watch that video

carmine sleet
#

That's the one

severe lodge
#

Thanks @carmine sleet

stoic hamlet
#

It’s very good. (I helped edit it :D.)

humble yacht
#

The covenant that invaded Visegrad were not part of the Fleet of Particular Justice. That fleet (Thel’s fleet) did not come to Reach until the end of battle

feral perch
#

somehow the UNSC kept the fighting quiet for a month

stoic hamlet
#

I can kind of buy that

#

If there was an attack in China right now, in some remote locale, I could maybe see them keeping it quiet

feral perch
#

But with interstellar travel?

#

Surely somebody would see the Corvettes, and other larger ships post-LNoS

versed helm
#

Planets are pretty big.

#

ONI is pretty smart.

#

I visualize the conflict of Halo Reach taking place primarily within a "safe zone" where the ODPs were neutralized following the attack on Sword Base by the Covenant troops out of the Szurdok staging area (as mentioned by Auntie Dot)

#

Think of it like an expanding planetary ring which kept the Covenant highly constrained till the final fleet battle.

feral perch
#

Up until Silent Storm's publication, it was difficult to give the UNSC that much credit.

versed helm
#

I don't know what you're trying to imply by that

#

But I used to be in the same boat as you regarding the secrecy element of Covenant invasions

#

343 have kinda impressed me by using newer media to retroactively make it the norm

#

They're turning a pretty poor bit of Reach EU-desynchronization into a somewhat universe-characterizing plot point with a decent logical basis

#

And I'm all for that

feral perch
#

I find it difficult to think that the UNSC could really contain a Covenant invasion like that, considering how easily Earth was breached by a fleet that didn't even come knowing that humans lived on Earth.

#

And how disadvantaged the UNSC were during the war, when it came to space battles.

versed helm
#

I think you're mistaken in conceptualizing the conflict we see in Halo Reach (or the majority of it) as an invasion.

#

Like there are certainly areas where it appeared that way (ahem New Alexandria)

#

But it was primarily groundwork

feral perch
#

Earth's initial conflict with the Covies wasn't an invasion, either, it was similar to Reach.

#

Covies wanted Forerunner artifacts.

versed helm
#

That said, Halo Reach's story would've been immensely improved by a ticking clock counting down to the full invasion

#

And a representation of the huge-scale naval fight

#

And the difference, Stonewall, is that the Covenant during the First Battle of Earth more or less went all-in and hit hard with decent tactics

#

During the early stages of the Battle of Reach, they were playing the subterfuge game

#

It's not really equivalent at all

feral perch
#

My biggest issue is probably with the Pillar of Autumn, though. How it got through the thick of battle to land, and then got past the other ships in orbit when it left.

versed helm
#

Well, Halo Canon has a spicy timeline up these days.

feral perch
#

I just watched it.

versed helm
#

A revamped one.

#

I don't entirely take it as 100% gospel - I tend to lean on TFoR being a dubious source wherever things get tight

#

But it's a good basis

feral perch
#

He doesn't explain how it got through the Covenant's main invasion force to land, because afaik there isn't an explanation

#

I wouldn't be opposed to them re-hiring Nylund to actually go back and rewrite the segments with the battle of Reach to fit everything together perfectly. But of course, that won't happen.

versed helm
#

Sneeki Breeki

#

I assume it involved probably covert landing teams constructing the spires first

feral perch
#

I meant the Pillar of Autumn.

versed helm
#

Ah, sorry, skimmed over.

#

Well as I said pre-emptively

#

I just don't take TFoR to be 100% gospel, especially as far as times go

sinful quartz
#

Why did Nylund stop writing halo novels?

#

He was so good at them

versed helm
#

I know it can be a slightly difficult pill to swallow but the sooner everyone comes to term with the notion that the OG trilogy of Halo novels is just kinda outdated at this point the better

#

And I guess because he wanted to move on to different creative pastures

sinful quartz
#

I think the OG trilogy of Halo Novels are very good to base a Mindset on

versed helm
#

I would argue that First Strike is a little bit of a low point in places

sinful quartz
#

They're solid competent books that give a very nice view of the time period in question, and get you in a right mindset.

#

I agree there

#

First strike is the weakest of the trilogy imo

#

Onyx > Fall of Reach> First Strike

#

I actually read Onyx recently, and it doesnt actually feel very outdated.

versed helm
#

Onyx is pretty timeless

sinful quartz
#

There is only one really outdated bit

#

Halsey uses a laptop

#

Not a tablet 😛

versed helm
#

Well y'know

#

Maybe she needed some real beefy power for something

sinful quartz
#

Even Fall of Reach is pretty timeless after the 2010 rewrite imo

#

it removed the inconsistencies and smoothed things out

versed helm
#

I'm sorta formulating a guide for people getting into the EU as is, and honestly I'm at the point of just leaving TFoR out

#

Well not an official guide or anything

#

Just what I recommend people

sinful quartz
#

The only issue is the continuity snarl with Reach

#

IMO, Onyx is an excellent introduction

versed helm
#

And as-is it goes Contact Harvest, and then the TFoR animated show.

sinful quartz
#

I go

#

Contact Harvest > Cole Protocol > Onyx

#

Thats imo what you need to fully get into all the bits of Halo.

versed helm
#

I feel Onyx would be more than a little confusing if you don't have the basic story of the SII program down

sinful quartz
#

Eh. not sure actually. Seeing as so much is told by Kurt

#

and explained quite well

#

All you need to know is he is an augmented former child soldier'

versed helm
#

Still, it's nice to experience the narrative of the SIIs as it happens instead of through exposition.

#

It is kinda a cornerstone of the universe

sinful quartz
#

Oh yeah. But Fall of Reach is just kinda confusing to get into with the game being so different

#

Its why I suggest skipping it

versed helm
#

And aside from a few bits which are odd to the true pedant TFoR animated is a pretty gravitas-filled introduction to the SIIs

#

Lots of swelling music

#

And it sorta re-arranges elements of the story so there's more familiar characters

sinful quartz
#

Contact Harvest, Cole Protocol, and Onyx all tell largely self-contained stories, that still give you a nice introduction to the series as a whole.

#

@versed helm The comic is better IMO

#

Fall of Reach comic series is great and doesnt clash as crazily with the game

versed helm
#

Well I just figure that if you go for the TFoR without the FoR you minimize any potential for confusion

#

And I also think that Silent Storm and Oblivion do a great job of getting some info across that TFoR gives you

sinful quartz
#

Well, the comic shows all the important parts of the book.

versed helm
#

Relating to the HCW and the Spartans

sinful quartz
#

Oh agree

#

but as a pure introduction to everything?

versed helm
#

I'd recommend it as a follow-up to CH and TFoR-A

#

And also Collateral Damage

sinful quartz
#

Contact Harvest > Fall of Reach comic > Cole Protocol > Ghosts of Onyx

#

In that order if you wanna get someone ino the whole series and its inner workings

#

Collateral and the animated series lose their impact if you dont know a lot of the backstory

#

And cant recognize stuff from the books. Reduces the fun factor

versed helm
#

But TFoR-A covers that tho

sinful quartz
#

yeah, but its easier to get someone to read three short comics than a two hour animated movie

versed helm
#

And if you only watch TFoR-A before reading CD and SS you don't get put out by the timeskip

#

Going forwards then back again

#

You get a nice chronology

sinful quartz
#

Silent Storm should be read LATE

#

Because half the fun of the novel is all the easter eggs and references

#

Here is a reference to cole's wife from Halo Evolutions.
Look, a reference to Contact Harvest.
Hey, these are the sniper rifles Johnson used in Contact Harvest.

#

That is so good, i'd call it criminal to not lot someone experience that

versed helm
#

They're easter eggs and references to us, maybe, but to the un-initiated they'll seem like really neat universe groundwork. And as I keep saying, I'd recommend CH before anything else and TFoR-A immediately after.

#

So you get connections from behind and you also get to see characters come back later on

sinful quartz
#

Oh I agree with you on that

#

I just think its either CH > Comic , or CH > animated

versed helm
#

Well yea

sinful quartz
#

It should depend on that person in question

#

Comics guy > the comics
otherwise > animated

#

Then Cole Protocol to give you both an insight into the UNSC, their mindset, the lives of civilians, and some stuff on the Elites

versed helm
#

Surely you'd go SS and Oblivion first tho

#

Muh chronology

sinful quartz
#

SS and Oblivion should be read until after someone has read Onyx

#

Just so you got a good chain of events worked out in your head

versed helm
#

But they come before Onyx

#

And Denning worked in a lot of character stuff for the members of Blue and the Spartan ethos in general which would be pretty beneficial going into anything in the 2550s

#

I just am really interested in the potential of these awesome new sources to anchor the universe in a kind of slice-of-life way as well as helping to build a really strong understanding of the HCW's early days

#

But I guess it's a moot point, people'll read what they read I guess.

#

Nothing's truly terrible to start off with except like maybe The Flood

#

Which you kinda need to be pretty discerning to handle cuz it's got some real doozies

#

I do love that book though - tonally it's just 👌

sacred dew
#

Read the fall of reach until Sam dies then collateral damage the silent Storm and then oblivion thats the chronological order actually contact harvest first

versed helm
#

Well that would probably be optimal, actually.

#

But it's kinda oof to tell someone to get a book and then not read half of it till down the line

#

But yeah, that'd be the best way to do it 100%

#

Still CH first tho

#

CH is really undervalued as just a lore cornerpiece

#

That book like single-handedly made sense of the universe when it came out

stoic hamlet
#

The AI love story still hurts to read (in a good way)

#

Because it’s just so sad.

sacred dew
#

No am just saying that's how it is canonically not to read them like that
That would be weird

versed helm
#

I'm just gonna take a second to just address all the ways CH is just awesome

#

First off, despite its like one canonical issue being colony numbers, it gives possibly the best interpretation of the insurrection and the UNSC pre-Covenant or even just in general

sacred dew
#

The sniper scene nuff said

versed helm
#

One of the first things it does is ground the Covenant and then the story build motivation for why they're fighting in a way the games never quite do

#

It's got a mature and relatable tone and doesn't really require any prior knowledge, making it less just a bit of Halo EU and more a striking sci-fi story in its own right

#

AND it gives really valuable information going into the continuation of the Created's storyline by getting inside the head of an AI

#

It's just perfection and if there's one book every Halo fan needs to read it's CH

stoic hamlet
#

See, I disagree with the idea of it helping the created storyline

#

But everything else 100% yes

sacred dew
#

Also the war started because a grunt accidentally fired his gun

stoic hamlet
#

It was going to start anyways

#

And it was a militia trooper

#

But he was disembowelled like right after so we don’t necessarily know who attacked first.

versed helm
#

Well I mean

#

I'd say the war started cuz the Covenant more or less just went "give us your planet"

#

Incident or not that was gonna cause issues

stoic hamlet
#

Yeah

#

Like War was a certainty

#

How it started might have been slightly different though.

sacred dew
#

That almost sounds like space British

stoic hamlet
#

Britain isn’t the only nation to do that

sinful quartz
#

I think the quality of halo writing is often shown when the Covenant writing is good too

stoic hamlet
#

Every nation on earth has technically done that at some point

sinful quartz
#

The best halo games also had good Covenent/Elite stuff

carmine sleet
#

Aye, we may have been one of the most notable, but Britain was not the only one to do that in history

sinful quartz
#

One reason I have hopes for Infinite's story is because that hack Brian Reed is gone.

#

Him and his obsession with Locke and Palmer

stoic hamlet
#

Spain, Portugal, the Dutch, France......

sacred dew
#

It was a joke about the meme not to offend anyone am sorry

stoic hamlet
#

All good. In future though maybe say “space imperialism, or “space colonialism”

#

Or something

sacred dew
#

Alright thanks

versed helm
#

Tbh

#

There's nothing offensive about it

#

Everyone's being smarty-pantses

#

Not triggered

#

It was a totally valid comparison

sinful quartz
#

I like the lore that shows the inner workings of the Covenant

#

And that the whole war wasnt even something most of them wanted, or heck, even knew about

#

Most Sangheili live their lives on isolated worlds and only know stories about off-world places

#

If they're rich, they visited High Charity once on a pilgrimate.

#

Maybe saw a Tithe fleet

versed helm
#

I'm a big fan of when Halo humanizes aliens.

sinful quartz
#

Or well. Rationalized them

versed helm
#

I tend to be very UNSC-centric but war stories are better when they're not simplistic.

feral perch
#

I started reading with The Fall of Reach, and went TFoR > The Flood > First Strike > GoO

sinful quartz
#

Like. The bit of The Cole Protocol that I liked the most was when the Kig Yar were starting to hesitate betraying the rebels.

feral perch
#

I hadn't played a Halo game until after finishing at least First Strike iirc

versed helm
#

War's not about good or bad guys. It tends to be about misunderstandings and higher-ups telling grunts to do things they don't understand the brutality of.

sinful quartz
#

I would love to see some human Kig-yar cooperation.

versed helm
#

Reading CH and just, like, having an alien start their part in the book by picking up a prescription is 👌

#

Love that kind of stuff

sinful quartz
#

Its why Venezia is such a nice setting idea.

feral perch
#

I thought you didn't have much time for aliens, Looters ske7ch

sinful quartz
#

Humans and Jackals setting up this industrial hub.

stoic hamlet
#

I definitely like the idea

sinful quartz
#

And becomign rich selling to both sides

#

ALSO

stoic hamlet
#

But I feel it’s often a little too overdone.

versed helm
#

Oh yikes

sinful quartz
#

The Helioskrill Armor!

stoic hamlet
#

Especially in Halo considering what happened.

sinful quartz
#

The backstory of it is amazing.'

sacred dew
#

The only halo games i have played are reach and 4 and the lore just interested me from there no regrets

versed helm
#

Well that's surely a first

feral perch
#

I would honestly have to recommend starting with Mythos if you want a solid overview of everything.

stoic hamlet
#

People are a little to friendly towards the aliens, and vice versa for my tastes.

versed helm
#

That's the coward's route xD

sinful quartz
#

@stoic hamlet I like it when its done well in the line with the setting.

feral perch
#

And then start reading the novels, either with The Fall of Reach, or CH

stoic hamlet
#

It’s tough to suspend disbelief at times.

sinful quartz
#

Rid you read the books with Venezia, Eternal?

stoic hamlet
#

Yeah

feral perch
#

Although I would always recommend TFoR novel

#

always

sinful quartz
#

I like how it was done there.

versed helm
#

StoneWall no

stoic hamlet
#

I’ve read every book released so far.

versed helm
#

Ppl will get confused

feral perch
#

yes

versed helm
#

It'll be terrible

feral perch
#

lies, deception

sinful quartz
#

Rebels Pirates and Smugglers of both races coming together to make money, makes so much sense

versed helm
#

You don't want anyone new to the universe to try and wrap their head around the Battle of Reach

#

If it was me I'd just go "this is..."

#

And leave

sinful quartz
#

While the UNSC and Swords of Sangheilios having an uneasy peace, works too.

feral perch
#

Let's assume that they haven't played Reach

versed helm
#

But then if they do it'll be the same as us

feral perch
#

or, also plausible, that they don't care much for timelines and stuff

versed helm
#

And for us it was years of just screaming at Bungie

sinful quartz
#

Altho i wish we got to see more of the Sangheilios part of the truce.

versed helm
#

Well 343 I guess

#

Just going

#

Whyyyyyyyyyyy

feral perch
#

why 343?

sinful quartz
#

How the elites feel of the fighting ending.

versed helm
#

Oh yeah good point

#

I just said 343 cuz they took over after Reach

#

But Bungo's still responsible

stoic hamlet
#

I agree, but I feel people (in-universe) should be way more hostile or untrusting of aliens.

Look at Draco III, Sigma Octanus, Jericho VII, Beta Gabriel.

You don’t really become fast friends after that.

versed helm
#

Whyyyyyyyyy Bungo

#

Y u do dis to my boi Nyyyyylllluuuund

#

He was the chosen one

#

And you betrayed him

sinful quartz
#

@stoic hamlet Well it should be done when it makes sense. And if they offer something.

#

The fact that the UNSC was letting Covenant laborers take refugee status on some human worlds to use them as skilled labor.

#

Makes sense.

feral perch
#

guys, let's organize a lore protest over Halo: Reach and storm Bungie HQ!!11! The look their on faces will be 👌

sinful quartz
#

I can defintely see the UNSC snatching up some elite artisans and armorers.

versed helm
#

Talk about a blast from the past

sinful quartz
#

And hiring their services

stoic hamlet
#

Man remember when Nylund had applied for a narrative position in 343 but they already hired and so he didn’t get the job

#

Oh man, that was a sad day

feral perch
#

wait

#

What

sinful quartz
#

Waitwhat

versed helm
#

I'm aghast

#

Genuinely

feral perch
#

Holy crap bad mistake

deep pewter
#

Gonna need a source

sinful quartz
#

They could have gotten Eric-Freaking-Nyland, and they got Brian "I think having a generic unlikeable black guy replace the Master Chief is a great idea." Reed?

versed helm
#

Oi

feral perch
#

also I looked up Nylund's other books. Turns out he writes mostly YA fantasy magic books. Weird, right?

versed helm
#

Let's have a little nuance and decorum

stoic hamlet
#

It was a few years ago now but I remember the post. Gonna search for it now.

deep pewter
#

Reed didn’t replace Chief

sinful quartz
#

Sorry, added a bit

#

Locke was just boring

versed helm
#

I kinda like him

stoic hamlet
#

He’s a compelling character

versed helm
#

I kinda like all of Osiris really

sinful quartz
#

And felt like a cheap attempt to make,. A New Chief

stoic hamlet
#

But under-utilized.

sinful quartz
#

Locke should have had buildup

stoic hamlet
#

Like all of the characters in Halo 5

sinful quartz
#

And not taken most of the time

versed helm
#

I had a freakin' movie tbh

#

Even if it was a little

sinful quartz
#

A bad movie

versed helm
#

lmao

#

I mean bad

#

🤷

#

I enjoyed my rewatch the other day

#

Wasn't what I'd want from a Halo movie though

#

Not enough shooty-shooty bang-bang really

#

And I'm man enough to admit that

#

But some of it's quite tense

feral perch
#

It's like if you took all the guilt and anguish from Kilo-5, and condensed it into a miniseries

versed helm
#

Good thing I'm a sucker for anguish 👍

#

Anguish me up baby

feral perch
#

ew

versed helm
#

You know you want to

versed helm
#

Alright look I'm gonna run down some elements of Nightfall here

#

And we can decide if they're good or bad

#

Okay first thing - the AWOL Spartan

#

I can't remember his name

#

But it's a solid performance and he's an uplifting character

#

Agree?

feral perch
#

Imagine Nylund, who's otherwise known for young-adult fantasy, creating one of the most compelling grounded sci-fi backstories

proud quail
#

Randy?

#

Randall

versed helm
#

Randy Pitchford

proud quail
#

whatever it was

versed helm
#

Rogue Spartan

proud quail
#

He wasn't AWOL or Rogue

versed helm
#

He was chickened out

#

We can agree on that

feral perch
#

He was depressed because "muh daughter"

proud quail
#

He didn't want to be a conscript, he was allowed leave

versed helm
#

Yeah but the bit at the end where he tricked the others to sacrifice himself

deep pewter
#

That sounds more like there was more going on than just the narrative position being filled

feral perch
#

we didn't get to know him

versed helm
#

That was a heroic moment

proud quail
#

Oh

versed helm
#

I liked that moment

proud quail
#

The straws moment

versed helm
#

Draw ballz

feral perch
#

I didn't care about any of the characters tbh

versed helm
#

Here's another thing I see as pretty good

proud quail
#

Yeah it's a nice reflection on his character and tbh it helped gave some emphasis to the kind of people Spartans were

versed helm
#

The creepy dude on Locke's team who tried to buddy up with him to backstab the others

#

That performance was pretty menacing

proud quail
#

Randall was pretty much Jorge in the moment

versed helm
#

And it was uplifting and entertaining seeing Locke just kinda nope him

humble yacht
#

Except Randall actually saved people

#

Rip

sinful quartz
#

Randall was a cool idea.

#

For sure

proud quail
#

eh

#

"Make it count"

#

people didnt make it count

#

their fault

sinful quartz
#

The whole "ONI RIPPED OUT HIS AUGMENTATION" just seemed kinda Grimderp.

humble yacht
#

Some of the augmentations

proud quail
#

i think it's less "ripping" and more "pump these drugs backwards"

versed helm
#

Yeah nah there are certainly technical elements of Nightfall that come apart under scrutiny tho

#

Universe-scanning intensifies

sinful quartz
#

@proud quail Spartan 3's had drugs

versed helm
#

Tho it was a database

sinful quartz
#

Spartan 2's had full on bone and nerve replacements

humble yacht
#

It’s more likely they reversed the surgical elements of his augmentations

feral perch
#

That article talks about how Nylund would be too late to "redeem the narrative of Halo 6"

#

pessimism much?

humble yacht
#

The chemical elements probably couldn’t be reversed

sinful quartz
#

So they stripped out his entire nervous sysem? 😛