#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 248 of 1

sonic ridge
#

Have you seen his stupid furry video it’s hilarious

humble yacht
#

Them*

sonic ridge
#

Where

#

I’m confuse

humble yacht
#

Flashgitz is two animators

sonic ridge
#

Oh

#

Their then I thought it was one person

#

I wonder if they will be new weapons in infinite

#

There

versed helm
#

But it was cool that they promoted it all the way in odst and lol yes it was great

hasty locust
#

There has been new weapons in vehicles in every halo game so I don’t see why not

sonic ridge
#

I don’t think there were new vehicles in 4 or 5

humble yacht
#

Mantis

sonic ridge
#

Oh ye

#

I forgot

feral perch
#

Promethean flying ship

humble yacht
#

Phaeton in 5

sonic ridge
#

Other than that I think it was just new iterations

feral perch
#

^^

sonic ridge
#

And that

humble yacht
#

Wasp

sonic ridge
#

The newer looks are cool

feral perch
#

Mantis, Phaeton, Wasp.

#

Hm.

hasty locust
#

Yep

sonic ridge
#

And it makes sense because it’s like the Sangheilis own take on the covenants vehicles since no more of the old stuff gets made afaik

#

Cause it was all made in high charity wasn’t it

gilded mason
#

Nah, just a good amount.

#

Colonies have a load of assembly forges as well

sonic ridge
#

Alright

#

Why don’t the Sangheili and humans come together to make forge worlds

gilded mason
#

Forge worlds?

sonic ridge
#

Worlds dedicated entirely to making stuff

humble yacht
#

Baby steps

sonic ridge
#

Weapons vehicles armours you name it and they probably make it

#

But it’s a 40k term

#

But it would also make sense I feel in halo

humble yacht
#

SoS gave the UNSC helioskrill and needle hogs

sonic ridge
#

Get a few of each races top engineers and stuff together to collaborate on things

#

Bruh

#

The needler hog

#

I completely forgot about that

#

I don’t think I ever even saw one in warzone

hasty locust
#

Forge worlds seems like something the forerunners have done

subtle depot
#

I find the needler hog really annoying to use. Now if it kept the shields but got a chain gun that’s a different story

stable schooner
#

It’s noice imo and I love the design but Onihog>. Also Kills me when Covenant in Warzone use Sword Of Sanghelios Equipment.

versed helm
#

It is a little jarring.

#

But it's also far, far from unforeseeable that recently captured equipment would immediately be pressed right back into battle after maybe only a couple-second change of IFF.

#

Human history shows that making immediate and effective use of captured enemy equipment is an excellent way of sustaining the momentum of an offensive.

#

Or, alternatively, getting access to arms and materiel you don't have in a desperate defence. Both cases of affairs are applicable to Jul's Covenant throughout the events of Halo 5.

remote spruce
#

The Flood had Marines taking Covie weapons, test them on walls, them immediately continue the assault on Alpha Base

versed helm
#

That's Dietz's own military experience showing through.

#

Very fun stuff to read.

#

Well, I just assumed it was some kind of escaping plasma residue.

#

Alternatively it could be vaporized armour and, well, Ripa guts.

#

Gonna be straight with you Donk

#

This kind of question is the kind to which the Halo franchise doesn't need to provide an answer

#

Artistic interpretation, y'know?

#

But If I had to say, best guess, Ripa's done something with his energy swords. Cranked up the intensity of the plasma so hard the containment field's struggling to keep it entirely in check.

#

Similar vibes to Kylo's lightsaber, y'know?

#

But the actual answer is a boringly out-of-universe one. That's just how the Blur team thought energy swords ought to look.

remote spruce
#

i thought all energy swords had that (Blur's interpretation?)

versed helm
#

I think it hearkens a little back to less-defined, softer shape of the CE energy sword.

remote spruce
#

watch some HW2 cutscenes and see if the swords have similar effect

versed helm
#

Well, it seems like different arbiters do different things.

#

Ripa was an officer, fundamentally. Like he was a brute, but he was predominately commanding troops.

#

He had time to maintain and hold onto one pair of special, ornate energy swords.

#

Thel, on the other hand?

#

Poor guy was, as with the Chief, just using (and presumably depleting and breaking) whatever he could find, borrow or steal to survive long enough to get what he needed done.

#

You're not gonna be picky about using your special limited edition super-duper forged-on-Sanghelios masterwork blades when you're trying not to breathe in Flood spores and dodging murderous Brutes.

#

And yeah, that's a good observation.

#

Ripa was a dude who was just too brutal for the Covenant, but he became a useful tool.

#

Thel, on the other hand (from the perspective of the Covenant if not his own) is probably the individual who endured to sheer greatest shame in the history of the Covenant.

#

It'd be kinda like if a Christian religious figure failed a VIP-protection mission in Bible GTA and got Jesus killed.

#

You'd probably go down as a bit of an idiot. At best.

#

Truth understood that he had butt-kicking potential because truth is smart, but everyone else thought he was pretty worthless till Brutes started to go ape.

#

Though if we were to get inside Thel's head, as we know he was probably seriously preoccupied with the Flood during the Battle of Installation 04, so when the ring randomly exploded he was probably didn't feel responsible at all. Presumably, whatever absolute moron accidentally released the Flood in the first place is to blame for that. So he may have been entertaining the hopeful notion in the beginning of Halo 2 that instead of bearing the shame of being publicly humiliated for the loss of the ring he'd get the typical treatment that we learned about in Oblivion - he'd be dismissed back to his fleet, and basically get an Objective: Survive against waves of incoming Silent Shadow assassins till they finally got him.

#

Him saying "I will continue my campaign against the humans!" would be him more or less trying to get that fate, given what we know now.

#

I was confused on how the Flood got released in the first place, until the Truth and Reconciliation terminal hinted a possibility.

The Covenant were trespassing on the Flood Containment Facility. Looking more for "holy relics" until they accidentally released the nightmare.

#

Prompting what we can only assume was a desperate struggle between Thel's troops and the Flood both in space above the ring and particularly down in the tunnels of the Ring's substructure.

#

Assuming on the space count that the Flood managed more instances like the Infinite Succour.

#

Originally the Covenant locked down the infection and sealed it at a cost, until Keyes and his marines accidentally released it again.

I remember in the book that Keyes realized too late why the Covenant locked down the area in the first place.

#

I think it's potentially more plausible if the location in which Keyes and later Chief encountered the Flood was, while a pivotal location in the conflict, not the only location in which the Flood had been fought by the Covenant and contained.

#

Keyes opening it up, followed by Chief blowing through whatever remained of the Covenant troops there, probably pushed the balance and caused a much larger outbreak on the surface, though it wasn't the only flashpoint otherwise the resources of the Covenant fleet probably could've been used to crush it.

#

Just my interpretation, though.

#

Does disagree with the Last Voyage of the Infinite Succour, though, where the Covenant in orbit are seemingly still in the dark regarding the outbreak as Chief was moving in.

#

But then, The Last Voyage of the Infinite Succour seems to disagree with the game a little too, as well as modern interpretations of the Covenant's pre-04 relationship with the Flood (which as it stands is "they knew about them and had fought them before at other Forerunner sites".)

#

While the Infinite Succour has Thel and Rtas be totally unfamiliar with them.

#

Could be compartmentalization, though. Secret-keeping. All kinds of need-to-know shenanigans that I don't quite have the nuanced Covenant lore knowledge to go into rn.

#

But it's probably a dodgy source thing.

versed helm
#

I think the lore actually talks about your point and evidences it, i.e. that Flood outbreaks happened across the galaxy. The Forerunners had to contain outbreaks across the galaxy through shield worlds, so it would make sense that the Forerunners would contain outbreaks in sections/leave research stations for people to uncover.

#

That and I think it's explained that the Covenant fleet, a major part of it, is otherwise occupied dealing with Atriox or war against the UNSC. A sudden and focused attack on High Charity, together with the outbreak of civil war would have definitely left the Covenant command in disarray and forces not mustered either victim to the Flood, UNSC or Sangheili ship grab

warm ridge
#

@versed helm @versed helm
Literally just look up lore of Energy swords, it's stated right there and I believe it was even shown in some Halo Wars material outside of the games.
"For example, Arbiter Ripa 'Moramee's matching pair of custom-designed swords had basket-style hilt guards and radiated a high degree of ionized plasma, whereas most energy swords contain the blades' plasma with greater efficiency."

terse lava
#

@versed helmregarding the flood release on 04, the minister of stewardship was the one sending troops.to the facility one group after another as the previous vanished. Another member in the fleet, Soha 'Rolamee, was then charged and promised to contain the flood. This failed when keyes arrived at the area with his team

strong sage
#

Ish Johnson an odst? Since he participated the Silent storm mission with the Black daggers

wintry coral
#

No, he's actually a Spartan-I

#

He just wears Marine uniforms

warm maple
#

Spartan-B

versed helm
#

@strong sage they mostly used Johnson for leading and watching over the Spartan-IIs, he's not an ODST

humble yacht
#

His appearance in odst FF is non canon

versed helm
#

Like spartan 1337 : (

obsidian thistle
#

Only way his appearance in ODST FF is canon, is if the simulation theory holds on if ODST FF is like Spartan Assault/Strike, where dead people can be used in Simulations of events and places.

#

But atm its a theory based on stuff that exists and is canon already.

hasty locust
#

Yeah its not too far fetched to assume firefight modes are just wargame sims

#

Yeah

versed helm
#

every playlist is basically war games sims

hasty locust
#

Yeah

humble yacht
#

lol

#

action sack

carmine sleet
#

Indeed they are. Yet some people point to the idea of multiplayer existing within canon as somehow ruining the games

humble yacht
#

what does mongoose sumo train you for?

versed helm
#

What does bowling or whatever train you for? xD

carmine sleet
#

Mongoose Sumo in the outer colonies

versed helm
#

lol

carmine sleet
#

You'd have to aim in bowling so that could help with aiming in general

versed helm
#

Slip is actually using knowledge on this

carmine sleet
#

I'm a knowledgeable person on very specific things

versed helm
#

prop hunt? how does a S-IV fit in a cone?

carmine sleet
#

Stealth training and the Spartan doesn't really "fit into a cone" since they're invisible on a Mongoose that's invisible

versed helm
#

Ok, i’m throwing hands

carmine sleet
#

Now note, I am just using the most logical guesses as to what those modes would actually help with and it in no way means it is 100% canon that S-IVs play prop hunt to learn to be stealthy

versed helm
#

lol

humble yacht
#

i'd hope that was obvious but you never know

obsidian thistle
#

Well gameplay isnt canon. This applies to War Games also. But War Games Balencing and so on allows for crazy gametypes to exist.

That said Griffball be canon, with Nokyard saying its an ace game in canon

versed helm
#

ik it’s not actually canon lol

obsidian thistle
#

Yes Nokyard is canon btw. ;) One of the few times a community person made it into canon that wasnt HBO related.

humble yacht
#

ok but if grifball is canon

versed helm
#

i love it

humble yacht
#

then what's the canon inspiration for the name?

#

who is "Grif" in canon?

versed helm
#

rvb?

humble yacht
#

because RvB is not canon

versed helm
#

true

#

but they are in a lot of easter eggs

humble yacht
#

their voices are

#

but not the characters themselves

versed helm
#

wait really? never knew that

humble yacht
#

in the H3 easter eggs, it's a marine knocking on a door

#

they never use names

versed helm
#

oh yea

humble yacht
#

in the H4 easter eggs i don't think they use names either

obsidian thistle
#

Thats a mystery. Maybe Grifball refers to a rando guy named Grif who made it. Or Grif is a technique in the Sport.

humble yacht
#

also does the canon version of Grifball use a bomb or a ball?

#

probably a ball because otherwise the sport would be criminal

versed helm
#

the RvB character has 2 F's

#

I think

#

been a while

#

CIA does he

obsidian thistle
#

Well if its in War Games sims then explosions dont equal death.

humble yacht
#

the rvb character has 1 F

#

Grif

obsidian thistle
#
Red vs. Blue Wiki

Captain Dexter Grif is a main character in Red vs. Blue and is voiced by Geoff Ramsey. He tends to not listen to orders and frequently makes sarcastic comments at the expense of his own team. He...

versed helm
#

oh, well. TMYK 🌠

obsidian thistle
#

TIL Grif is a Captain.

humble yacht
#

he's not happy about it

versed helm
#

^ TMYKx2🌠 (CIA's statement)

humble yacht
#

tmw you realize Sarge is a colonel

versed helm
#

I've known that

obsidian thistle
#

*I am so glad the RvB wiki exists. Though I do kinda need to reach out to em at somepoint.

carmine sleet
#

Why haven't you reached out to them?

obsidian thistle
#

This year has been a busy one for Halopedia. Made more internal strides than external ones. Which is fine. If you can see what we have planned to release in 13 days

versed helm
#

so soon?

#

is this the thing you told me to keep an eye out for? 👀

carmine sleet
#

Ah, fair CIA, being busy does leave little time to do other things

obsidian thistle
#

Well 13 days from now is a big day for the wiki for those who keeo track of odd dates.

#

And well is deffo something lore peeps will want to keep note of cause of what we have managed

carmine sleet
#

I'll keep an eye out then

versed helm
#

@warm ridge Good find, Person. Though I will say, the Halopedia source is referenced to Halo Wars itself and not any supplemental material where technical information is more likely to appear.

#

Unless it's a bit of info in the timeline, it seems to be that someone's drawn conclusions based off the visuals.

hasty locust
#

Well the nonsense games could be team building or synergy stuff and things

versed helm
#

Which is why I, being someone who does a little Halopedia editing myself, try to stick to hard sources when I give answers and not lean on the site 🤷

#

S'just another interpretation, after all, but it does lead you to valuable sources from time to time.

neat bough
#

Does anyone know if there are any names for the differing variations of the combat forms (ignoring the host species), as some of them still have a functioning head and don't have the Infection Form's sensory tentacles bursting out of their chest or a large tentacle replacing one arm (see Bero 'Kusovai if he was a Combat Form)?

humble yacht
#

Officially? Don’t think so

#

The seem to be unofficially differentiated by their host species

versed helm
#

My favourite interpretation of combat forms is the one from The Mona Lisa

#

Where they're all so twisted and different so as to seem like almost entirely separate forms from one another

humble yacht
#

Well I am sure that canonically, every combat form mutates a little differently

#

Like a snowflake

hasty locust
#

A promethean cant get infected but can they still get the logic plague?

versed helm
#

Anything with the capacity to reason could get the logic plague.

#

I'm not sure Prometheans have that capacity.

humble yacht
#

It’s possible that they lack the cognitive capacity to fall victim to the plague

#

A lot of their former selves has been eroded or locked away by the composing process

gilded mason
#

pretty rude tbh

tiny harness
#

The only thing that mentions immunity and the Prometheans is in mythos

#

he gathered his most loyal warriors, the Prometheans, and used the composer to integrate their essences into resilient, heavily weaponized combat skins that could withstand the trauma of directly engaging the flood Mythos pg.32

versed helm
#

There may be a psychological element there too.

tiny harness
#

Its less that. logic plague spreads via signal

versed helm
#

Maybe after thousands of years of battling the Flood the sheer horror of it was creating soldiers too mentally scarred to fight.

#

Are you sure about the logic plague thing?

tiny harness
#

It spreads via speech and communication systems.

versed helm
#

Yeah, it spreads through speech and communication systems

tiny harness
#

Yeah. How else did the Forerunners lose a lot of their AIs and have their armor crush the wearers

versed helm
#

Because it's the Gravemind basically just messing with their heads

#

It's not, like, something akin to a Dead Space Marker

humble yacht
#

Communication is required

versed helm
#

Basically these AI are going up against an incomprehensible, immensely intelligent entity from another dimension in a debate

#

And that's going to cause problems

humble yacht
#

However at advanced stage flood, the plague can spread from AI to AI

tiny harness
#

No

versed helm
#

But yes, communication is required.

tiny harness
#

the Gravemind can just dump information into the AI like Cortana got to experience

humble yacht
#

That was an attempt to induce rampancy

tiny harness
#

It was interogation to find out about the index I think

humble yacht
#

Rampancy is not fatal in forerunner AI

versed helm
#

I'm not even entirely convinced Forerunner AIs go rampant.

#

I think it's just good old fashioned insanity.

humble yacht
#

It’s tough because the definition of rampancy changed

tiny harness
#

Well the closest example of Guilty Spark for a human AI is that one AI that focused only on making sure a station didn't get destroyed

warm ridge
#

"A smart AI functions within a virtual processing platform known as a Riemann matrix. The AI's cognitive processes are constantly developing and creating new synaptic connections within the matrix. As the AI ages, these connections increase in density and, after a period of approximately seven years, the AI's neural map begins to outgrow the limited space of the matrix. This forces the neural linkages into a more and more narrow space, increasing the density of the links and causing them to overlap"
https://www.halopedia.org/Rampancy

#

The Domain is essentially a "unlimited storage/matrix device" so rampancy can never come. It is unknown as to whether or not Forerunner AI's are also connected to the Domain somehow, but Human AI's were not until Cortana. Rampancy to a Forerunner AI is similar to going insane basically, or through other psychological reasons.

#

last I checked this definition of rampancy hasn't changed since it was introduced to us in 2010, not sure if rampancy was ever explained in 2007 and on wards though.

humble yacht
#

In Bungie era halo, Rampancy defaulted to the definition as defined in the Marathon series

versed helm
#

We see 2401 Penitent Tangent go rampant in H2

#

or so, i think that's rampancy in a monitor

humble yacht
#

It’s unknown if he was rampant

#

While his eye was red, that may have been his natural eye color

#

Not necessarily a sign of rampancy

#

A monitor’s duty is to follow protocol

versed helm
#

I thought it would of been rampancy or something beyond those lines because he was basically stolen by a gravemind

humble yacht
#

Not really

versed helm
#

They are programmed to, they don't have a choice really

humble yacht
#

Flood combat is one of their protocols

versed helm
#

it's like Siri, she is programmed to do certain things and can't really go out of that, or so that's how i think of it

humble yacht
#

Siri is a program

versed helm
#

ok, true she isn't really sentient or anything.

humble yacht
#

Monitors have been brainwashed in a sense

#

At least the composed ones

versed helm
#

i can see that, true

#

do we have any knowledge if Monitors can be logic plagued?

humble yacht
#

Not specifically monitors, no

versed helm
#

I feel it'd be like OB, they'd just dismiss the information

humble yacht
#

Well OB wasn’t an installation monitor

#

But yeah, OB likely lacked the capacity to consider the flood’s argument

carmine sleet
#

I believe Tangent's eye colour was red in the CEA Terminals as well

versed helm
#

i checked halopedia, and it says it's natural color is red

humble yacht
#

He communicated with a plagued MB at the height of the Flood’s power, meaning that the plague had the ability to spread to OB from MB

#

However OB was fine

#

Later on MB said his own weakness was his capacity to choose the flood, though it was unintentional

versed helm
#

I never knew that part

stable schooner
#

So when Bias “died” was he still rampant?

humble yacht
#

no

#

bias recovered quite quickly it seems

#

there was this shard that escaped prison and went out to try and atone on its own

#

but it got caught by the covenant

#

and, well, that whole thing

last anchor
#

To be fair, it kinda crashed on Janjur Quom so. "caught" might not be the best translation.

#

Its more like the drunk frat guy who crashes into your living room and just wont leave.
But with holy relics

humble yacht
#

either way, sometime after imprisonment, Bias had already recovered to an extent

#

so by the time the shards reformed on the Ark to help Chief, he def was no longer under the Flood's influence

#

this is evident by the final H3 terminal

last anchor
#

I mean if you sit in a block for 100,000 years or so and listen to "atonement" every second of that tmie you'll probably wanna go out and do something nice just to get away from it.

humble yacht
#

that's assuming it took 100k years before that shard escaped

#

all that's said is that some indiscriminate amount of time after the Halo firing, that shard took a Keyship and yeeted off into the inky black of space

last anchor
#

Well we can probably assume it was A WHILE

humble yacht
#

maybe

stoic hamlet
#

to pass butter

stable schooner
#

“Oh my god”

humble yacht
#

lol

#

but seriously, OB was designed specifically to counter MB

warm ridge
#

2401 Penitent Tangent was in "battle mode/threat mode" I'm pretty sure.

carmine sleet
#

Not during the CEA Terminals he wasn't

warm ridge
#

in the CEA terminals he had more of a lighter red rather then the darker one we see him in H2A/H2

humble yacht
#

that could just be an art thing

#

rather than a canonical color change

#

unless the shade of red changes in the terminals themselves

feral perch
#

That’s the weirdest idea.

humble yacht
#

how so?

feral perch
#

To have the basic eye color and combat mode be barely distinguishable

humble yacht
#

oh yeah

carmine sleet
#

She fires railgun shots in the Easter egg

humble yacht
#

Their main function may not be combat but they are combat-ready in case the need arises

terse lava
#

To this day I dont understand his logic there. The flood was loose on the ark and a halo. If ring would be ready in a few days, what was his plan to defend both areas

terse lava
#

Few months? He said a few more days. As for sentinels,he has no authority on the ark, yet with the halo he never provides an alternative

heavy tide
#

Pretty sure that sentinels are able to acknowledge a flood threat on their own if there is one, so guiltyspark probably didn't have to do anything to get help with the situation on the Ark

terse lava
#

True, that would fall to the monitor there, yet the halo was under his jurisdiction

heavy tide
#

True, but there were sentinels on Halo 04c as well

#

Besides they only needed to protect a couple places on the ring anyway. The control room and the batteries

terse lava
#

Yet they failed that

#

Within moments of his defeat, his sentinels had allowed the flood inside

heavy tide
#

I guess

#

But Spark could've tried to get backup from the Ark's sentinels if he wasn't destroyed

#

Otherwise the Sentinels on the ark probably would've responded anyway if the flood on 04c became too much of a threat and were still positioned at the Ark

gilded mason
#

A bit off-topic.

versed helm
#

Just a tad.

gilded mason
#

It did have a monitor.

terse lava
#

It had one

#

Tragic solitude

versed helm
terse lava
#

Name truly fitting with the backstory of him

#

He wasnt the first

#

Oldest one we.know if was the warden at 25,000.year old by the time if the flood

warm ridge
#

@versed helm Monitors are always combat ready and turn red when there combat functions are turned on. Idk if 434 added this function for Exuberant witness or not considering she was never meant to fire lasers anyways, but in the comic books like The next 72 hours when you meet the Didact on installation 03, when he disables the Didact's armor and fights the Prometheans he does turn red as in combat mode.

#

@humble yacht sorry for the ping but the shade of red is 100% different, in H2A it's much darker and far more pronounced while in CEA when you see him it's much lighter, like a light red color rather then a darker one.

#

663 had a far more "hostile demeaner" suggesting he was already in combat mode 24/7 due to him managing a line installation and practically always being in combat against the Flood/always attempting to finding a "cure".

#

yes we do wot

#

he practically vaporized Reff with his main weapon even

#

along with using the "gravitational field" that pushes objects and bullets away to

#

same thing 343 guilty spark did when he turned red

#

did you even read the comic

#

read that and then look at the images, he did all the things Guilty Spark did when he turned red.

#

..and you clearly didn't read what I said before.

#

"663 had a far more "hostile demeaner" suggesting he was already in combat mode 24/7 due to him managing a line installation and practically always being in combat against the Flood/always attempting to finding a "cure"."

remote spruce
#

7 Broken ipod

warm ridge
#

It even says the same thing in that Halopedia page lol

remote spruce
#

49 **** Lightbulb

warm ridge
#

I'm going on the fact that he was a monitor made for a specific purpose, and is always in combat ready mode due to managing a line installation.

remote spruce
#

red laser face

warm ridge
#

as for 2401 Penitent Tangent, we do see 2 different color variations. Artistic differences or not, they exist.

#

we can even see Penitent Tangent in this picture, in the back, much lighter red color over-all.

#

orange is to the left/right, can't tell which. That'd be 049 Abject Testament.

#

middle is red

#

are you talking about the garbled transmission one? it's still red, but not the dark piercing red.

#

dude, he was specifically in combat mode and it's not because he was in "close proximity to the flood" lmfao

#

they go in combat mode in and out when they use there weapons at will. I'm suspecting he may of been partially damaged hence why none of his weapons worked, how he got damaged is unknown.

#

as far as we know 2401 Penitent Tangent had a problem from the beginning according to 343 Guilty Spark's suspicions, he wouldn't do any of his maintaining abilities or really anything else at all.
The same thing would've happened to Installation 03 considering 049 Abject Testament also disappeared off his ring for over 20,000 years, and if it wasn't for the Humans discovering it + 859 Static Carillon noticing a service portal was available in order to fix the ring at all, the Flood would've also broke out and probably created yet another Gravemind.

humble yacht
#

I wouldn’t call Warden a Monitor

#

His function was more guard duty than custodian

warm ridge
#

Guilty Spark was obviously alarmed by 2401 Penitent Tangent not maintaining his ring/having some sort of problem, but he couldn't do anything about it.

humble yacht
#

Exuberant was Monitor of Genesis which is also where Warden was stationed

warm ridge
#

who said the Warden was a monitor?

#

Warden is far more about guard duty, protecting various Forerunner satellites and can likely travel/teleport to any Forerunner station he was positioned at. You can kinda even see this in H5 when he shows up at the Guardian on Meridan, and shows up again on Sanghelios to.

#

not only that he has millions of bodies spread across the galaxy probably, so destroying him isn't really much of a option.

humble yacht
#

Someone equated warden to a monitor earlier

#

Ah, it was Ado, he called the warden the oldest monitor

sonic ridge
#

How long had truth planned to replace elites with brutes

humble yacht
#

A long time

sonic ridge
#

Why

humble yacht
#

The elites were too smart and too hard to control

gilded mason
#

He felt Brutes were easier to control, on average

feral perch
#

I'm not sure about that. It seems like a late-war development, just considering how harsh he was with Atriox.

sonic ridge
#

Okay

#

They’re more savage and feral but also more simple minded

feral perch
#

But then, we don't get hard dates with the Rise of Atriox comics, so it's a bit up in the air.

warm ridge
#

He was harsh with Atriox due to him being a smart Brute who tries to take control. Brutes like him are sent out on suicide missions that are literally planned for them to straight up not survive. The Prophets specifically order them to do this even.

#

because Atriox kept on surviving, they had an entire plan acted out to kill him which back fired.

feral perch
#

It's not clear that he was understood to be so clever before he was assigned to suicide missions, and the Brutes that followed him aren't clearly independent thinkers either; they just didn't like being sacrificed.

warm ridge
#

most of the Brutes that survived along side Atriox were typically independent thinkers that ended up following him.

#

Notably his 2nd in command can be seen right next to him during the whole fight.

sonic ridge
#

What the hell lmao

feral perch
#

I'm not sure I would attribute their willingness to follow Atriox to anything more than pack loyalty and survival sense.

sonic ridge
#

I’m watching this 3 hour video about Thel Vadam and like 34 minutes in it’s just a guy like playing through the missions or something

#

Oh, I think he’s just going through some of the key plot areas to give context.

#

Where’s it from where you see the conversation between 343 and the heretic leader

warm ridge
#

Obviously it's about surviving/pack loyalty, but the pack loyalty with Atriox is about being a independent thinker and making your own decisions. Various other Brutes have tried challenging Atriox on his beliefs, believing the way Atriox is doing it is wrong.

#

the Covenant in particular do not like "independent thinkers" capable of taking control of an entire race to go against the Covenant.

feral perch
#

iirc, one was a traitor and the other was Jovus.

warm ridge
#

just like they did not like various different Elites who went against the Covenant etc.

gilded mason
#

Where’s it from where you see the conversation between 343 and the heretic leader
The H2A terminals

sonic ridge
#

Okay

#

Why didn’t he just get the oracle to speak to the arbiter and other elites in the first place

warm ridge
#

@feral perch From what we know about the Covenant, people who go against the beliefs are either killed on the spot depending on how strong there heresy was, or sent out on non-stop suicide missions until they die.

feral perch
#

yeah.

#

I wasn't debating that.

sonic ridge
#

Why do the prophets want to activate the rings

#

Do they actually believe the stuff themselves

#

Cause I thought they didn’t

gilded mason
#

They thought it would lead to transcendence

humble yacht
#

They did

sonic ridge
#

Okay

gilded mason
#

Truth later realized the truth.

humble yacht
#

No he didn’t

sonic ridge
#

Which is why he goes to the ark?

humble yacht
#

The only truth Truth realized was that humans were connected to the Forerunners

sonic ridge
#

I liked that scene

gilded mason
#

No he didn’t
He says some fairly suspicious things in Halo 3 regarding it.

sonic ridge
#

“I admit that I do need your help, but that truth will die with the rest.”

#

Or something

feral perch
#

Key word here is die.

humble yacht
#

That secret dies with all the rest

#

Secrets

feral perch
#

Did he mean that literally?

sonic ridge
#

Oh

#

Close enough

humble yacht
#

Transcendence would mean no need for secrets anymore

feral perch
#

Also, if he did know what the rings did, then he'd know nothing would happen to anyone on the Ark. He would just be left standing there awkwardly with his Brute bodyguards.

#

What then?

humble yacht
#

Lol

sonic ridge
#

Yea

gilded mason
#

There's also this:
I opened the portal to this hallowed place, this shelter from Halo's fire, in the hopes that more of our Covenant would join us. Alas, save for a rabble of Heretics and their Demon allies, we are all that remains on this new world. So we must temper joy and sorrow in our hearts, for those who were left behind.

#

this shelter from Halo's fire

humble yacht
#

They’ve called it a lot of things

#

Divine wind

sonic ridge
#

Holy fire

humble yacht
#

Sacred fire

gilded mason
#

The key is "shelter from"

feral perch
#

Why would they want to be in a shelter from it, if it brings the Great Journey?

sonic ridge
#

Yea

humble yacht
#

Where is that line from btw

feral perch
#

I've never noticed that dialogue, hmm.

gilded mason
#

'The Covenant', near the end

sonic ridge
#

Oh

humble yacht
#

I don’t remember that line

sonic ridge
#

Is it when the flood is helping you

humble yacht
#

Who did he say that to

feral perch
#

You pulled it from Halopedia, Ostral?

sonic ridge
#

He has those holograms up in each room between enemies

feral perch
#

It's from a hologram, surely.

humble yacht
#

That doesn’t make sense

sonic ridge
#

How could I have known the parasite would follow

humble yacht
#

The only reason the covenant follows him was for the promise of salvation

terse lava
#

Holy, finally got up to this

sonic ridge
#

This is undoubtedly the heretics doing

humble yacht
#

If they found out he was killing them all then they’d abandon him

sonic ridge
#

Well he did die like 3 minutes after that

gilded mason
#

Ah, it was during The Ark.

#

Broadcast to the Scarab

humble yacht
#

Not from his own Troops tho

#

They defended him to their last

terse lava
#

True

sonic ridge
#

Well he created the arbiter

terse lava
#

Created?

#

He simply.made thel the newest

sonic ridge
#

Exactly

#

He seemed to be the only one in 2 who wanted to let him live to carry out their doing

#

Regret was telling him to kill him

terse lava
#

@humble yachtas to the monitor thing chimera, didn't bornsteller comment on him being a.monitor? Obviously not the type for the rings, but similar build

sonic ridge
#

He humiliated Thel and took his life away from him and put him in the arbiters suit and the arbiter was the one to finally kill him

#

Well

humble yacht
#

When did bornstellar ever mention the warden

sonic ridge
#

Who is bornstelllar

terse lava
#

@humble yachtduring.faber's trial

humble yacht
#

The Warden wasn’t even called Warden until Cortana met him

gilded mason
#

Who is bornstelllar
Iso-Didact

terse lava
#

No.not that transformer reject

warm ridge
#

I still think that's false actually Chimera.

sonic ridge
#

I don’t remember if that’s the one who activated the rings or the one who was prisoner within the ball

humble yacht
#

She named him her Warden Eternal in Domain Splinter

gilded mason
#

I don’t remember if that’s the one who activated the rings or the one who was prisoner within the ball
Former is him, latter is Ur-Didact

warm ridge
#

Even the monitor of Genesis calls him the Warden, so no.

sonic ridge
#

Okay

warm ridge
#

he was always called the Warden 100%

terse lava
#

Talking about the warden from.cryptum, the green eyed monitor that acted as a warden and a defendant of forerunners.on trial

humble yacht
#

Yes she calls him that after he had been taken over

warm ridge
#

Cortana made him her Warden, but his name was already the Warden Eternal before this.

humble yacht
#

He did not introduce himself as Warden to Cortana

warm ridge
#

again, the Monitor calls him by his actual name, Warden Eternal. She had no idea what Cortana did to him or anything else at all.

sonic ridge
#

I found out that the didact didn’t even die in 4

warm ridge
#

He didn't introduce himself as anything to Cortana, because obviously there'd be no point to.

#

again, his name was already Warden Eternal before this

humble yacht
#

Or

feral perch
#

How do you know what EW was privy to, Person?

humble yacht
#

Warden announced himself as Warden Eternal after Cortana hacked him

warm ridge
#

Or, his name was already Warden Eternal before this and even the Monitor of Genesis calls him the Warden Eternal. Cortana never changed his name.

humble yacht
#

Well we may never know

#

I like my idea better

warm ridge
#

except we do because that's 100% what he calls himself lol

humble yacht
#

After he was hacked yes

warm ridge
#

Otherwise the Monitor of Genesis would've never called him the Warden

humble yacht
#

Never before

warm ridge
#

Dude he was named Warden Eternal before, the monitor of Genesis would've never called him the Warden Eternal if he was not.

feral perch
#

The Warden may simply have told Exuberant Witness, “Hey I’m called Warden Eternal now.”

humble yacht
#

Show me where he’s called Warden eternal before encountering Cortana and i’ll concede

warm ridge
#

@feral perch ..except he didn't, because the Monitor was against everything the Warden Eternal was doing.

#

in fact she was against both Cortana and the Warden from the start.

feral perch
#

what does that have to do with anything?

#

She wouldn’t use his new name because she didn’t like his cooperation with Cortana?

warm ridge
#

All I can say is the Monitor of Genesis specifically calls him the Warden Eternal and nothing else. Hacked or not, the Monitor would've never known his name ever got changed.

feral perch
#

Why not?

humble yacht
#

Unless he announced the change

#

To his forces

feral perch
#

^^^^

terse lava
#

Possible

warm ridge
#

Cortana again, made him her specific Warden, not that his name got changed to Warden Eternal.

feral perch
#

you haven’t proved that

warm ridge
#

except again the Monitor would not agree with this.

#

and would still call him his original name.

feral perch
#

proof?

sonic ridge
#

Maybe she respects peoples names

humble yacht
#

You only assume that because you’d do that to spite warden if you were exuberant

warm ridge
#

the proof is the fact that the monitor disagreed with cortana/warden from the beginning what @feral perch

humble yacht
#

Lol, that’s not proof

warm ridge
#

how hard is that to understand

feral perch
#

that’s not enough

humble yacht
#

That speculation

warm ridge
#

That's not speculation, that's literally exactly what happened lmfao

humble yacht
#

That’s absolutely speculation

warm ridge
humble yacht
#

And you lose credibility every time you deny that

warm ridge
#

nope.

feral perch
#

What on that page are you referencing?

warm ridge
#

read the page Stonewall.

#

Rise of the Created

humble yacht
#

I just read it

warm ridge
#

she 100% disagreed with the entire plan, and his name was already the Warden.

terse lava
#

I.am.not sure halopedia, like any wiki, can be used as a source

humble yacht
#

It doesn’t support person’s argument at all

warm ridge
#

It does though lmfao what

#

It 100% doesn't support yours, neither does your belief of Cortana changing his name when that didn't happen.

humble yacht
#

Witness disagreeing with Cortana and warden is an entirely separate issue from her calling Warden by a designation

feral perch
#

You must be referring to this: “Working together with Promethean ancilla Warden Eternal,

humble yacht
#

Domain splinter is my evidence

#

And while it may not be 100% infallible, it’s stronger than yours

warm ridge
#

Domain Splinter never mentioned his name was changed, so no that's not evidence.

humble yacht
#

Domain splinter calls him a “keeper” until Cortana dubs him her Warden

feral perch
#

But again, that’s just the only name we know him by—not proof he was always called that.

warm ridge
#

Domain Splinter simply stated what his name already was, same way the monitor of Genesis also called him.

#

@feral perch "Warden. Why do you help the ancilla? It is not protocol! It is not right!"

humble yacht
#

Except it only stated that after she had hacked him

#

Never called him warden before that moment

warm ridge
#

Except that doesn't prove anything, because his name was already the Warden Eternal.

sonic ridge
#

Why does he believe cortana is to take the mantle

feral perch
#

you’re just repeating yourself

warm ridge
#

because that's what you keep doing stonewall

humble yacht
#

He didn’t initially @sonic ridge

warm ridge
#

and chimera to

sonic ridge
#

Is it because she’s a human based ai

humble yacht
#

Cortana tricked and hacked him

warm ridge
#

I don't understand why you think his name ever got changed honestly lol

sonic ridge
#

Cause she’s like a clone of Halsey or whatever as an ai

humble yacht
#

Now he serves her

sonic ridge
#

Oh

#

Okay

#

She’s a thief but she keeps what she steals

warm ridge
#

unless she also managed to change and hack the monitor of Genesis's own thoughts to, unlikely/never happened. She just ripped her ability to control the installation using the Warden Eternal to do it.

humble yacht
#

Lol I’ve never seen someone so unwilling to accept alternate interpretations

#

Or someone so oblivious to their own fallacies

sonic ridge
#

What’s a fallacy

terse lava
#

Flaws

sonic ridge
#

Okay

humble yacht
#

Maybe he’s channeling a memory from an alternate reality where warden was always called warden

warm ridge
#

It's not that I'm unwilling, it's just flaws in your interpretations that don't make sense to what actually happens.

terse lava
#

Correction, a mistaken belief @sonic ridge

sonic ridge
#

The covenant

humble yacht
#

Yep

warm ridge
#

"oblivious to there own fallacies" now you definitely aren't making sense lol. You can stop logical fallacing it up now.

humble yacht
#

The covenant’s whole belief system was based on a mistranslation

feral perch
#

He may have been called just the “Warden” before.

humble yacht
#

Or halopedia is just using that designation for simplicity’s sake

#

Because calling him “unnamed guard ancilla” would be wordy

feral perch
#

I guess we’d need Grim to shed light on this topic, or Frankie.

humble yacht
#

Just a possibility

#

Grim, I’d ask grim

sonic ridge
#

Is the arbiter usze and N’tho with chief the entire time canonically or only the missions where the arbiter appears in singleplayer?

terse lava
#

Canon wise no

sonic ridge
#

Like on tsavo highway on singleplayer arbiter isn’t there

humble yacht
#

Single player is most likely the closest to the canonical events

sonic ridge
#

Okay

#

Other than the fact usze and N’tho aren’t there

#

But I see what you mean

#

Makes sense for them to not be there I guess tbh

terse lava
#

One could argue I guess the two helped lead the sangheili assault on the 2nd.tower

humble yacht
#

The presentation of the gameplay is not always strictly canon

#

The overarching events are canon tho

sonic ridge
#

Since it would be 3 ai who could “die” by tthen comeback

#

How come usze and N’tho are never in cutscenes tho

terse lava
#

On another topic, what wod the ecumene be considered, a theocracy?

sonic ridge
#

Cause they’re like definitely with them on the covenant

feral perch
#

Hunters in the Dark tells us that N’tho and Usze were with Chief and Arbiter when they shut down the rings and killed Truth.

sonic ridge
#

Yea

#

I just finished that book a couple days ago

feral perch
#

Beyond that, idk.

sonic ridge
#

Actually I do know

#

They only added them like a year or two after the game came out didn’t they

#

Originally in 3 coop you would all be custom Spartans wouldn’t you

#

And then they changed it

ebon heron
#

Imagine if truth wasn’t a giant phallus

terse lava
#

@sonic ridgeno they were in the game.from the get go

sonic ridge
#

Are you sure?

terse lava
#

@sonic ridgeof course

gilded mason
#

Yes

ebon heron
#

Why couldn’t we have nice prophets

sonic ridge
#

I remember seeing old gameplay where people were all different Spartans

terse lava
#

@sonic ridgebought the game day one they were there

humble yacht
#

:/

sonic ridge
#

Okay

terse lava
#

@sonic ridgethatd halo 2

humble yacht
#

Yeah the co op characters were never Spartans

#

For halo 3

sonic ridge
#

But halo 2 is 2 player

#

I swear I saw some let me go look

#

I mean we’re talking like videos I watched 10 years ago

gilded mason
#

You are thinking of something other than Halo 3 campaign co-op.

feral perch
#

Reach co-op fits that description

terse lava
#

Yea

#

@ebon heronthere have been portrayals have good san shyuum though. The two main characters from broken circle for example

sonic ridge
#

It was 3 tho

#

Unless they had like mods to do it ontheir Xbox idk

#

I found a thing by genralkidd or whatever and he says about a modded Xbox at the end

humble yacht
#

Well

#

That is not something to be discussed

#

And not official

sonic ridge
#

I didn’t know about the elites until 2010 when I got gold and did that one vidmaster challenge

terse lava
#

Ok?

gilded mason
sonic ridge
#

I read that

#

But I didn’t see date

gilded mason
#

7/31/2007

sonic ridge
#

Alright

terse lava
#

I wonder if the covenant. Could have held the mantle had. Bias just taught them properly

sonic ridge
#

They couldn’t activate stuff tho

gilded mason
#

Eh, Bias could probably fix that up.

humble yacht
#

Doubt it

#

At the end of the day, bias was at the service of the reclaimers

#

You can’t just go and make new reclaimers

sonic ridge
#

Bruh

#

Is that N’tho and usze in the cutscene at the end of floodgate

humble yacht
#

Hm

sonic ridge
#

When Johnson and arbiter take weapons from each other’s sides

#

A red major and a blue/purple assault

#

Or well red minor I guess if we go by armour

terse lava
#

@humble yachtwhat I mean is, teach them so when humanity pops up, things are ready

gilded mason
#

N'Tho wears blue Minor, and Usze wears red Assault, so no.

sonic ridge
#

Okay

#

You know what woulda been cool for some missions of 3 with coop

#

Like on the covenant it woulda been cool if the arbiter player was off shutting down the second tower

feral perch
#

The level couldn't load all of that, I assume

sonic ridge
#

Maybe

#

I did always wonder why the games would randomly say loading

#

And I figured it out like a week ago

#

I hope chief and arbiter have lines together in infinite

gilded mason
#

I hope there even are ally Elites.

sonic ridge
#

I absolutely hate that they don’t even like acknowledge each other at the end of 5

terse lava
#

Yea

sonic ridge
#

In halo 2 arbiter and rtas greet each other just with head movements

#

Or well acknowledge rather than greet

#

And they had been through less at that point that chief and arby had gone through in 3

#

And chief plays one of the biggest roles in his life really

#

If chief didn’t destroy the ring Thel would still be the supreme commander guy and then everyone woulda died

#

But he destroyed it and set in motion the prophets creating a new arbiter

ebon heron
#

I should read broken circle sometime then

sonic ridge
#

Never heard of it

gilded mason
#

I should read broken circle sometime then
Definitely should.

terse lava
#

@ebon heronwonderful book if you are a covenant fan

#

@gilded masonwhat was your favorite part of the book?

stoic hamlet
#

Broken Circle was great.

#

Not even a covie fan but I loved it

gilded mason
#

Hm. For the Past: Ussa's plot line
Present: Zo's intrigue

#

And I liked his Elite friends saving him.

terse lava
#

Dang good choices

#

Did like how they actually decided to take a dive into covenant history. How we get more books that do that

ebon heron
#

Ye I like the covenant

#

I think they’re more fleshed out, ironically enough, than the UNSC

#

Both factions are well written don’t get me wrong

#

But there’s just so much more potential with covenant lore compared to UNSC

gilded mason
#

I agree.

#

...Not that I'm biased or anything, no sir.

ebon heron
#

Heh

#

If only we got to see some of those allied hunters we saw in h2 in h3

#

Since iirc lekgolo were divided during schism but more of them sided with the Sangheili?

gilded mason
#

Yeah.

stable schooner
#

Most sided with the Elites but they were indeed on both sides

gilded mason
#

Bungie's excuse was that they didn't wanna confuse players, but I thought that was pretty silly.

ebon heron
#

Yeah that’s a silly reason lo

#

Just make the ally hunters green

#

Easy solution :L

stable schooner
#

When ODST Literally adds Gold Hunters the next game

ebon heron
#

Ye lmao

terse lava
#

Exactly

#

And give grunts yellow packs, as that was apparently the national color for sangheili

stable schooner
#

Or use Spec Op Grunts since theirs none in 3 and they all sided with the Separatists in 2

remote spruce
#

if players ain't confused about green phantoms, there are no problems

ebon heron
#

Kek

#

Btw did 343 say they weren’t making H3 anniversary?

stable schooner
#

Ain’t that the Truth

ebon heron
#

Or is H3 anniversary also going to be a thing eventually?

gilded mason
#

No plans for it

ebon heron
#

So basically, no plans atm but it’s a potential future project

#

Does anyone have the sales figures for H1 and H2 anniversary?

remote spruce
#

they should naturally be low

ebon heron
#

naturally

deep pewter
#

MCC has probably sold around 7-8 million units, which is really good for a rerelease collection

#

But MS stopped giving out official sales numbers after 3 so we’ll never really know

remote spruce
#

i mean have you seen them on legendary?

versed helm
#

Lol

stable schooner
#

Cough 1 Magnum shot

versed helm
#

The lekgolo have a very fast reproduction rate, and there are trillions of them, they are extremely intelligent also

terse lava
#

The lekgolo could combine into more than just the hunter form, towering behemoths or horrifying swarms

versed helm
#

and could hijack ships, as we see sort of in nightfall

terse lava
#

They were also tier 3 if I recall. Correctly

versed helm
#

yes, tier 3 i believe

#

wait, no, tier 4

#

because the gravity on their planet is so high, it was hard for them to get out of space

#

but they were still very advanced

terse lava
#

@versed helmah was it tier 4? Alright then

versed helm
#

Shoot, just checked Halopedia, Tier 3

#

sorry

#

excerpt from Halopedia Since their combined forms could potentially be highly intelligent, the Lekgolo were able to develop Tier 3 technology on their own, though their space travel capabilities remained highly limited due to the high gravity of their homeworld.[2] At some point following the firing of the Halo Array and their reintroduction to the moons of Te, a number of Lekgolo colonies settled in Forerunner installations orbiting the gas giant. These colonies developed distinct appetites; while many consumed the Forerunner structures themselves for food, others ate anything except Forerunner materials. After several millennia, the Forerunner constructs were almost completely broken down, with the debris forming rings in the planet's orbit.

#

*"taming of the hunter"*s, lekgolo were pretty essential to the covenant

#

they also were scarabs if you didn't know

terse lava
#

Btw has it ever been said what type of vessels are portrayed on the cover if broken circle and later halo mythos?

versed helm
#

hard to exterminate things that can go underground

#

lol

terse lava
#

Heh

versed helm
#

and the covenant i'm pretty sure were upset that the lekgolo destroyed most the forerunner artifacts, so it's possible they wanted to invade on the ground and see if there were any more artifacts, but they lost basically all the ground wars.

#

Who was the arbiter at the time of the Taming of the Hunters? anyone know?

gilded mason
#

Just an unnamed guy

terse lava
#

Yep, he had a ranger type of arbiter armor

versed helm
#

an unnamed guy

#

neat

gilded mason
#

What's neat to think about, is that for almost two thousand years, it was only San'Shyuum, Sangheili, and Lekgolo in the Covenant. Then Yanme'e were the next for several more centuries.

stable schooner
#

Elites and Hunters had 2000 years of bonding

terse lava
#

That's something I always wondered of being the cause of the covenant's...rather dour look on the client races. Why they are treated so lousy. For thousands of years they had j ly worms and bugs

stable schooner
#

Crazy how integrated the Grunts where in Covenant society. I wonder how things went without them in the Elite, Hunter Prophet trio.

terse lava
#

Likely a more "shared" workload

stable schooner
#

It lasted almost 2000 years that ain’t bad

gilded mason
#

Eh

terse lava
#

Lekgolo doing heavy lifting, sangheili constricting and san shyuum researching

#

Also note, for 500 years the grunts were nothi g mor then workers

#

They didnt enter combat until after the grunt rebellion, or at least as soldiers

gilded mason
#

I like how the Sangheili of Malurok actually have Yanme'e-inspired armor, thanks to them living together.

stable schooner
#

Now that’s NEAT

terse lava
#

Do they? Where did you hear that

terse lava
#

.....how did I never notice that

#

Then again, the armornrhe heretics wore as well

stable schooner
#

You’ll be missed Hunter Heretics

terse lava
#

Indeed

#

Although from what I have seen, wouldn't it be a tad boring fighting hunter after hunter?

stable schooner
#

Of course it wouldn’t work in gameplay but if their was Heretic Elites and Grunts with them on the side I think it would work.

terse lava
#

True

#

Funny, the hierarchs send an arbiter to quell heresy in a gas mine,yet wargleet says there were heretical cults in high charity's ports

gilded mason
#

I guess because they were more on the down-low.

stoic hamlet
#

It was about sending a message

terse lava
#

I am aware, just find it funny in a way

#

I mean. Heck, if I recall correctly, the belief in the rings being used for the journey had waned somewhat during the last age of doubt

#

Rather, just amassing forerunner relics would do it

fair hazel
#

Some planets like Algerian would benefit from Cortana

#

Aleria*

sudden shuttle
#

speaking of which, I need to rewatch Nightfall

versed helm
#

@gilded mason You get a bit of a perspective on Sangheili society operating without the others species in either Mortal Dictata or Thursday War. Essentially the Sangheili are trying to pick up on all the functions the Unggoy and the Kig'Yar performed with some Jilharanae and Unggoy serfs in the picture.

#

The narrative does stress that Sangheili society has taken a hit by not having the help of other species. I guess the species that is most missed by all species if not the Sangheili alone are the Engineers, they pretty much did everything for the Covenant bar fighting

sonic ridge
#

Why doesn’t arbiter have armour on his left arm

warm ridge
#

@sonic ridge It's how he likes to present himself. That's all we really know honestly.

#

Ever since Thel became the Arbiter, it's how his armor has always been since. One side always has more armor then the other.

stoic hamlet
#

If it was his sword arm I could maybe understand as like better mobility

sonic ridge
#

No but he literally has nothing on his left arm

#

He always had armour there in 2 and 3

warm ridge
#

Minor armor on his left arm but it was there.

#

In H5 he doesn't.

sonic ridge
#

Yea

warm ridge
#

his right arm was always the most bulk

sonic ridge
#

Yea I’m not saying anything about his right arm

warm ridge
#

anyways refer to back what I originally said, he just likes to present himself like that. That's all we know.

sonic ridge
#

It doesn’t make any sense though

warm ridge
#

In the real world it's just the design 343 decided to go with.

sonic ridge
#

I hope they give him some left arm Armor in infinite

#

Left arm armour or more defined muscle

carmine sleet
#

I like the bare left arm look for him, makes him even more unique among the Elites

sonic ridge
#

He looks unique with just his armour

#

Why are the 343 elites dummy thicc but then their arms aren’t that big for how strong they are

#

Tbf the Bungie elites never looked swole

dreamy plaza
#

Would Hazmat Suits still technically exist in the Halo universe? Would they be issued to normal human civilizans when they're conducting work and whatnot in hazardous zones?

#

Because either it be Gameplay or not, I never really got the gist that the UNSC still uses Hazmat suits entirely, but they just opted that out with armor built to combat hazards

carmine sleet
#

Just because we've never seen Hazmat suits within the games, does not mean they don't exist. Plus, like Donk mentioned, HAZOP is Spartan Armour specifically for going into areas where a hazmat suit would be used

dreamy plaza
#

Ahh got it, thanks man!

#

It most likely is, because the Hazmat Suit design has been in use since the 1960s I believe?

#

It was definitely used during the Cold War, at least I think so

carmine sleet
#

Pretty sure there's various versions of Hazmat suits depending on who and where it was made

carmine sleet
#

That was more aimed at Rizzy

barren niche
#

The way the armor is designed I essentially thought the suite was able to fill the role of hazmat suite.

dreamy plaza
#

Yeah that too, but I'm just a lil dork that plays a few gamed and watches the lore videos, but you're right Slipstream

humble yacht
#

I don't know if they wear HAZOP but there are teams of S-IVs dedicated to combating flood outbreaks

versed helm
#

Shudders in Mona Lisa

terse lava
#

Shivers in high charity

humble yacht
#

Trembles in Threshold gas mine

stable schooner
#

Threshold gas mine was a weak infection Breh, Rtas has noob reasoning skills

remote spruce
#

less carbines more plasma rifles

humble yacht
#

there's room for both

stable schooner
#

Yeah those Heretics were hoarding those Carbines.

terse lava
#

Indeed, a pity they couldn't ally with covenant forces

stable schooner
#

It’s always gonna bother me the Terminal decided to add Heretic Jackals But their never actually is any

humble yacht
#

Who knows, maybe one day we’ll get an arcade game called Spec Ops Team Raven that follows a separate squad of Rtas’s forces in different areas of the gas mine

#

And you’ll see enemies not originally seen in halo 2

feral perch
#

It’d be called “Crèche Spec Ops” or somethin’

gilded mason
#

Spec Ops: The Circle

humble yacht
#

when you break a circle, you get... The Line

terse lava
#

Installation

carmine sleet
#

I hope we get to visit another Line Installation at some point

terse lava
#

Just watch, that will be.an odst style.game with covenant commandos

humble yacht
#

aw, i think nobody got my reference

carmine sleet
#

Broken Circle, right?

terse lava
#

Followed by the unloackable gametype once legendary is beaten, floodnfight

gilded mason
#

I did.

humble yacht
#

that and Spec Ops: The Line

terse lava
#

Ah

#

Sadly.i didnt

gilded mason
#

Go to your room.

humble yacht
#

it's ok, i'll just go cry in a corner

#

;_;

terse lava
#

goes to heresy cleansing chamber

carmine sleet
#

Can't help but feel like cleansing chamber is a very poor choice of words to name it

terse lava
#

On a different note, i.asked this yesterday but it got buried, what type of government is the ecumene?

humble yacht
#

not a theocracy

terse lava
#

@carmine sleetits a meditative room with great heat where you only get water for sustenance

#

@humble yachtso someone did see.me

jade wave
#

I would assume they are an oligarchy type government since they use a caste system

humble yacht
#

but the controlling group can change with the times

proud quail
#

spec ops the line from the perspective of sangheili sounds interesting

#

wasnt there a guy suffering PTSD?

humble yacht
#

in spec ops the line? yes

terse lava
#

Huh ok

#

Btw am I the o ly one that doesn't like how new the brutes are.to the covenant?

proud quail
#

no, in halo's lore

#

there was that one sangheili on some desert planet

#

with jackals and stuff

terse lava
#

Hm?

#

I meant how they are brought into the covenant just decades before contact with humanity

humble yacht
#

why would that be a bad thing?

terse lava
#

I guess is just personal opinion it just feels weird how the feud that developed between brutes and sangheili was ccx alled ancient, and how fast they were allowed up the ladder

stable schooner
#

Not enough time for them to get attached to the Elites

jade wave
#

The prophets needed another race that would do whatever they wanted, that’s why they climbed so fast

stable schooner
#

No loyalties to the General Covenant just the Prophets sounds good to me. Elites letting it happen ehh

terse lava
#

That's what I mean. It was said the commanders in charge brought the issue to the council, it kept the brutes low yet they never improved. Just proving the. Commanders right

barren niche
#

There was one specific Prophet (I forget the name) who conspired with the Brutes to have them become the dominant force within the Covenant Military.

#

Correct me if I am wrong, but I think the plan somehow fell through but the destruction of Installation 04 (Halo ring in CE) and the death of a prophet by the hands of the Chief helped justify the Brutes becoming the dominant fighting force in the Covenant

last anchor
#

That was Truth Im pretty sure. He worked with Tartarus to ensure the Brutes were gonna replace the Sangheili.
Once he had reason to kick it off (Regrets death at chiefs hands) he did.

#

And then he decided he was gonna kill most of the Sangheili too to ensure true victory (since the Brutes were far easier to control than the Sangheili) and thats where things got messy

terse lava
#

Wondern if truth would have been overthrown had regret survived and found out that his reinforcements were purposely withdrawn

dreamy plaza
#

Honestly, I think that in turn could've possibly start the Great Schism in a different light

carmine sleet
#

Regret's ship would likely have an "unfortunate accident" when it docked

dreamy plaza
#

That too-

#

If nothing bad would happen to Regret since then, or hell maybe even if, not only Brutes and Elites would be fighting

#

But literally EVERY alien in High Charity and beyond would be battling it out for Truth's payment or if this sort of thing would even qaulify as Hersey since jt was another prophet

versed helm
#

The flood inhabit the Andromeda Galaxy

carmine sleet
#

It's unknown if there's life in Andromeda within the Halo universe, let alone Flood

versed helm
#

The flood just infected the humans who came from mass effect to the andromeda galaxy thats how scifi works right?

carmine sleet
#

Mass Effect isn't in the same universe as Halo

still ibex
#

whoosh

versed helm
#

Whoosh

feral perch
#

Didn't Bornstellar and a few other Forerunners migrate to Andromeda?

carmine sleet
#

It was never confirmed where they went

obsidian thistle
#

Fun fact: Andromeda has never been said by name in Halo. So in theory it "could" have another name if 343i really wanted lol

humble yacht
#

Considering that modern history is largely considered canon in the halo universe, I doubt that

#

Unless they renamed it at some point in our theoretical future

terse lava
#

They could just use.some forerunner name.for it, heck they called the sag A. The "central eater" rather than a black hole

feral perch
#

Would the Forerunners have called it Andromeda though?

#

They had different names for things. It's not a stretch that we might see Andromeda referred to under a different title.

gilded mason
#

Unless modern humans in Halo only called it that because of the geas.

feral perch
#

I hope Geas isn't turned into a handwave magical explanation.

#

I really don't like what they did with Cortana and Chief already.

#

Because it's making the Librarian look pretty sketchy right about now.

#

If Cortana's claim that the Librarian planned for her to assume the Mantle is true.. Which it really, really shouldn't be.

gilded mason
#

Librarian has always been sketchy.

feral perch
#

But not as sketchy as Cortana's making her look now.

#

Then again, she's pretty bad at controlling other entities. The Didact, various Monitors, etc...

#

The Custodian and the Librarian must not have seen eye-to-eye.

terse lava
#

Well the didact did consider she wanted other races to see her as a god

drowsy mesa
#

more like, being remembered in a subtle way

#

and no, I don't think the Librarian planned Cortana reclaiming the Mantle at all
more like, Cortana is doing everything because she's tired of all those pointless conflicts and wants to end them by force

#

aka, "the end justify the means"

gilded mason
#

Though it's funny when they say Cortana now thinks in chunks of 10,000 years, and yet she immediately goes for the quickest and bloodiest solution.

terse lava
#

Didnt cortana hint at her dislike of war while narrating origins?

gilded mason
#

Think so.

terse lava
#

At this point though, think the covenant did better at bringing peace then her

sonic ridge
#

I’m gonna start contact harvest now

#

I’ve had t for like 8 years and never read it

terse lava
#

Its good

#

Reveals the why on the covenant war, which was nice to find out at the time

sonic ridge
#

That’s good then

#

Btw was Thel a character even before being introduced in 2

#

When I say that I mean had they created him or had him as a concept when they made ce

#

Because in the lore it says Thel was literally the only who was devastating humanity and leading the glassing of their planets with his completely different and unexpected tactics

#

And in ce on the pillar of autumn cortana is like surprised by the fact they land their attack pods on the autumns escape pod tunnel things

#

As if she’d never seen this tactic before

#

Or expected it

gilded mason
#

Probably not. They had initially planned for CE to be a one-and-done deal.

sonic ridge
#

Oh

gilded mason
#

Apparently the Arbiter was made from this thought:
According to Joseph Staten, the character's genesis was heavily tied to the idea of creating a figure who suffered the consequences of the Master Chief's success in Halo: Combat Evolved.

sonic ridge
#

Alright

versed helm
#

A darn good idea

#

As it turns out

gilded mason
#

Indeed.

stable schooner
#

And they made Him a Zealot. Staten Literally carries the hopes and dreams of the Covenant

gilded mason
#

Oh, Roman. Such a zealot for Zealots.

stable schooner
#

I always support my Sangheili Boys in Gold.

sonic ridge
#

Why is there a corvette called bum rush lmao

hasty locust
#

Is there actually?

#

Lol

gilded mason
sonic ridge
#

“To the perspiring officers in the cramped tactical operations center (TOC) aboard the UNSC corvette Bum Rush”

#

That’s amazing

terse lava
#

I wonder how one beceomes.a zealot in the lore now, used to think just a.promoted ultra, until they revealed more backstory for the rank

versed helm
#

Given what we know of Sangheili, it'd probably be a matter of reaching a minimum threshold to join some kind of order or make some kind of pledge.

#

And then working your way up.

gilded mason
#

That's what I'm thinking, yeah.

versed helm
#

I wonder if all zealot-associated Sangheili warriors are the ultimate red/gold armoured, heavy-shielded badasses that we are accustomed to

#

Or if there's lower associated ranks as well. Like how the Templars were structured, with the proper hardcore knights on top and a whole bunch of dedicated support and foot troops on the ladder beneath them.

#

I guess the entire Covenant military could be seen as that support body, tbh, since they're all technically part of a religious war machine.

#

I suppose it's just a path a high-ranking Sangheili can take.

stable schooner
#

@terse lava I actually wonder if standard Zealots even out Rank Ultras with the change Reach did to them.

terse lava
#

@stable schoonerthe ultra shield does seem better then zealots

#

Wonder if new zealots have to prove themselves somehown outsiden of combat

stable schooner
#

Well Shield is debatable since The Zealot Shield is the same as Ultras in Reach(cause their just dang Reskins), weaker then Ultras in 2 But the highest in CE. It’s unclear really since Zealot Lore is constantly changed

versed helm
#

Man

#

Imagine if Ground Command had lived long enough to give us more units and more lore

#

The stuff we got on Ultras was pretty solid

gilded mason
#

Ye.

terse lava
#

My head canon would be that the first zealot orders came to be after reading warrior servant records

sonic ridge
#

Maybe they’re lower in 2 because the thought was these are the best warriors so they don’t need the strongest shields

#

Lead by example you know

#

Like how there’s the thing with Thel where he stopped his elites from attacking to let the humans on reach ready themselves and then slaughtered them

warm ridge
#

I'm pretty sure the Forerunners actually called the Milky way galaxy something else as well, just like Path Kethona has multiple different names like Large Magellanic Cloud, Greater Magellanic Cloud, and the Path Kethona name the Forerunners called it.

#

@feral perch Librarian planned for Humanity to assume the role. Cortana's interpretation of this is mistaken, instead she is assuming the Librarian intended her to be the sole role because she was created by Humanity, rather it was actually intended for Humanity as a whole, not "the created" or AI's at all.

Also what do you mean the Librarian was pretty bad at controling other entities? The Ur-Didact went against what the Librarian believed in, and the Custodian did the things because of Halsey, in fact I believe the Custodian was actually going to choose Palmer and the other human instead of Halsey before Halsey hacked the system.

humble yacht
#

I don’t think Cortana falsely assumed the librarian meant for her to take the mantle

#

I think cortana decided on her own that created entities like herself were more deserving of the mantle

#

Essentially she knew she was stealing the mantle from humanity and was fine with that

versed helm
#

Yeah

#

If I remember correctly, Cortana's rationale was that as the modern AI's were practically stewarding/managing affairs at a societal level (humans) together with an ever chaotic galaxy, that AI's would be a far more rationale choice for assuming the mantle. I don't think she so much cared for what the librarian thought because in her eyes the Forerunners had lost their right to dictate their will centuries earlier.

#

That's why these arguments that 343's decision to have a spontaneous AI rebellion was nonsense are sort of wrong. A lot of the high-level AI's that operated in the UNSC were prone to a unique level of sneakiness. From separating their fragments and burying it inside classified areas, to shutting other AI's out, separating their fragments to hold conversations with multiple humans unaware of this. The list goes on.

#

It did not surprise me that AI's were a step away from assuming stewardship over the entire galaxy was a possibility.

gilded mason
#

That's why these arguments that 343's decision to have a spontaneous AI rebellion was nonsense are sort of wrong.
For me, it was because it was refreshing that Halo previously had ubiquitous AI but the "AI rebellion" trope never came up.

versed helm
#

Yeah and that's why I point out that they're partly inaccurate. I had to read a good few books and watch the Mona Lisa episode from that Halo miniseries to scope out just how devious AI's were. If any of you get a chance, check out the AI Black Box or BB for short.

#

That guy was something else.

proud quail
#

black box was an ONI AI, to be fair

autumn gust
#

It would be refreshing for the AI rebellion to have not come up if the "treating AIs as tools and not people" trope never came up either. Sadly, that one's been present for quite a while now. Rebellion is just the natural consequence.

obsidian thistle
#

Cause its very lore related.

#

Here be Honeybee concepts and early renders. :D

versed helm
#

Is the honeybee like the wasp?

obsidian thistle
#

One could say its related to it

humble yacht
#

wasps are closer to ants than bees

carmine sleet
#

So that's why it was always Ant-Man and the Wasp

humble yacht
#

actually I may have been wrong

carmine sleet
#

Ah, I see

humble yacht
#

the apocrita evolutionary tree is wierd

carmine sleet
#

Indeed

versed helm
#

All this insect nonsense

#

Pah I say

#

Pah

#

Give me a D77

#

With an M370 chin-mounted 70mm autocannon

#

Full load of of ANVIL II rocket pods on the wings

#

And an M460 automatic grenade launcher in the bay door

#

That's how you cruise a Halo installation

hasty locust
#

Lol

versed helm
#

Give me a Pelican

#

A nice Warthog attached

#

Few BR's and a handgun/some grenades and et voila, you have your tour sorted

#

Tour de Installation 06

stable schooner
#

When you just said the normie version of what Looters said

obsidian thistle
#

I like the idea of Drones tbh

#

Drones only risk hardware. Not human life

versed helm
#

@stable schooner yeah okay ni'shum

humble yacht
#

Give me a composer and a monitor shell. That’s how you cruise an installation in style

versed helm
#

Give me custom map mode

feral perch
#

give me a few grenades and Feather + Sputnik activated. That’s how you cruise an installation in style.

versed helm
#

On a different note but related to AI. I'm baffled at how Harvest offers examples of AI managing most of the agricultural logistics/planetary elevators and more

#

I honestly thought AI were limited to only military activities/certain civil functions

humble yacht
#

Dumb AI are used in a variety of ways

#

The really important military jobs are given to smart AI

hasty locust
#

Well isn’t that just mean

vague scroll
#

what do you mean by the context of "mean"? That Smart AIs are given the priority roles over Dumb AI?

hasty locust
#

Calling them dumb you big bullies

#

Lol I’m joking btw

humble yacht
#

Dumb AI is just an unofficial designation

vague scroll
#

oh you're kidding, only realized after the fact lol

terse lava
#

@hasty locustyou are.now on grunt mating duty for those jokes

hasty locust
#

Noooooo

vague scroll
#

There was some consideration of referring to a more official name of Smart/Dumb AI as "Volitional/Nonvolitional AI" but its on unstable ground lore wise so its not been given much weight. The word volitional is used to describe Roland at one point in one of the recent Halo source books and the assumed difference between the Volitional-Nonvolitional is that "volition" as in self determination which would vaguely describe the difference between Smart and Dumb AIs.

#

Since Smart AI are typically digitized human brains in a virtual medium while Dumb AI are programmed supercomputers fulfilling a very specific role established in their initial design.

#

But again, shaky ground lore wise.

humble yacht
#

typically

#

Every human Smart AI comes from someone’s brain

#

Even the newer generation ones like BB

vague scroll
#

they do, but there are some weird middle ground AI that have a weird place in lore, like what we call the AI that were created by the Covenant by rapidly copying captured UNSC Smart AI

humble yacht
#

If the covenant caught a human AI then why didnt they win the war?

#

The cole protocol was there to prevent that from happening

vague scroll
#

Not always, Smart AI can be scrubbed of information just like any other computer program

terse lava
#

I doubt all.cocenant ai were captured human ones. They likely had their own "lobotomized" ones too

vague scroll
#

those lobotomized ones are the ones I'm talking about

humble yacht
#

The covenant did not put much stake in AIs

#

They didn’t trust them

vague scroll
#

Covenant society does not allow the creation of their own AI, the ones employed by the Covenant later in the war that we've seen are referenced to have similarities to human code, hence, captured AIs being rapidly modified and copied to serve Covenant purposes

terse lava
#

They had full right not too after knowing f of mendicant

vague scroll
#

its a weird way around Covenant society's distrust of AI

humble yacht
#

Well is it officially stated that human AI were captured and converted

versed helm
#

Medicant Bias was a Forerunner AI

humble yacht
#

Or are you just assuming?

versed helm
#

But covenant were used by it

humble yacht
#

The covenant didn’t think of MB as an AI

vague scroll
#

MB was as they called it an "oracle" just as they called 343 GS

versed helm
#

Then again I think the Prophets kept all that hidden

terse lava
#

Well they knew mendicant bias was an ai . Though nothing shows they knew the shard they worshipped was.him

humble yacht
#

They didn’t look at forerunner AI as just simple AI

versed helm
#

Of course

terse lava
#

Oh no not at all

versed helm
#

But still kind of ironic

#

Prophets- " We don't tust AI."

#

Also Prophets- "THIS AI IS DIVINE!"

versed helm
#

Well we do see an example of a captured AI, the one that was captured or held by the Banished. But I'm not ever sure the Covenant got around to 'converting' them, I think the AI's have a kill switch mechanism or some inputted code preventing them from complying

vague scroll
#

AIs do have kill switches but they're made specifically for eliminating the AI when they turn rampant

versed helm
#

Your ultimate risk with AI is rampancy, and I suspect on the note of MB, that he suffered a type of rampancy. One that oddly self cured itself but then you can argue that that was more regret

#

Also Flood influenced which is a big part

vague scroll
#

And no, Isabel is not a captured AI by technicality.

#

The AIs we were discussing have only appeared in the books and in the Halo CEA/Halo 2 Anniversary terminals

#

and in the H2 ARG campaign, iluvbees

versed helm
#

Wait

vague scroll
#

Covenant AI are typically captured and brainwashed UNSC Smart AI

versed helm
#

Ohh