#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 244 of 1

stable schooner
#

In the closed Hangars with a stockpile of ammo though?

remote spruce
#

oh yea the ammo peeps

#

also some dead ones near the place where the fireteam hold position

#

and cells

terse lava
#

I just shrug that off seen as somehow a human made it on to high charity to study brutes

remote spruce
#

heck, outside the ship

#

My guess is some other force was sent and they banzai charged into the ship

#

the remaining 3 were captured and placed in cells next to Keyes

#

Because there are also Elite corpses in the level

proud quail
#

oh yeah, T&R had a dead spec ops elite in the first area

#

lol

#

all for that cloak babyyyy

stable schooner
#

That’s not a Spec Op

remote spruce
#

accidentally has flashlight on

terse lava
#

Dont re all any in ce intol the Keyes level

proud quail
#

wasnt it a silver elite

remote spruce
#

spec ops are black armored in CE

proud quail
#

what's silver, then?

stable schooner
#

Theirs dead Untextured Elites that are minors in Anniversary

remote spruce
#

uh
wait what is silver?

stable schooner
#

Stealth Elites

proud quail
#

either way there's a dead one who's just

#

right there

#

being dead

#

and a free invisibility poweru p

stable schooner
#

Yeah no The dead White Elites on the ground are just Elites with no Rank assigned in the files

remote spruce
#

there's one in the ship too
i guess those were the only casualties prior lol

stable schooner
#

Their Corrected Minors in Anniversary graphics

#

Though Minors being by Camo also makes no sense but ah well

remote spruce
#

did any of the Anniversary games miss some unique graphics for enemies? Like the curlback Grunts

stable schooner
#

I mean Anniversary Covenant is just reskined Reach Covenant

terse lava
#

Yea nothing new

stable schooner
#

The Minor is a Reach Minor. The Major is a red and white Reach Elite Officer. The Stealth Elites are Silver Reach Spec Ops. The Spec Ops are Black Reach Spec Ops and the Zealots is a weird yellow Reach Zealot

remote spruce
#

weren't there weirdly colored Grunts in 2 Betrayals or something

stable schooner
#

Nah all the Grunts on Two Betrayals are Majors with a single Spec Op grunt for some reason at one of the Covenant camps

#

That’s present in classic to though

remote spruce
#

in Anniversary graphics, all Unggoy Majors in this level who wield fuel rod guns wear red-colored Special Operations Unggoy masks.

#

spooky if true

stable schooner
#

Time to check myself

#

Man poor Zealots though they got massacred in Anniversary Graphics, the Armor isn’t even gold

#

The har har har just ain’t the same

#

@remote spruce you were right. The Fuel Rod Grunts wear Red Spec Op masks

terse lava
#

Maybe a sub rank of major like the officers

stable schooner
#

Nah the actual reason I 100% bet you is the Fuel Rod Grunts are Spec Op Grunts with the major Skin. Since Majors don’t actually spawn with Fuel Rods. But since Spec Op Grunts wear different armor in Anniversary the Fuel Rods Grunts got it to

terse lava
#

But they were regular majors in the original too

stable schooner
#

Which is why you didn’t notice since Spec Ops and Majors Wear the same armor in Classic

#

Same principle as the Ultra Spec Op grunt glitch in 2 who appears as a normal Ultra in Classic but an Ultra Spec Op in Anniversary cause of new armor introduced

#

Like little did you know Tartarus Bodyguards on Great Journey aren’t actually Captains but Brutes with the Captain Skin

unique rune
#

Yeah, they're still around.

#

Small handful of known Spartan-IVs have turned to the Insurrection.

#

Vladimir Scruggs (Escalation), Rudolf Schein (New Blood), and Michael "Mickey" Crespo are the few I remember off the top of my head.
Not sure if there's any others.

#

Same one.

#

And then there was also Ilsa Zane, the lone survivor of the prototype Spartan-IV program.

#

Risky enough to kill 9 of 10 volunteers.

#

Super effective, though.

#

She was able to take on Palmer who was wearing GEN2 armor at the time, if I remember correctly.

drowsy mesa
#

S-IV = ORION recruitment + S-III enhancements

#

why? many of the S-IVs enhancements came from Project CRYSANTHEMUM

versed helm
#

IVs are stronger, too

drowsy mesa
#

Sometimes, "biological augmentations" is used as synonym to "chemical and surgical augmentations"

#

I think

#

but, in summary, S-IV HAVE chemical and surgical augmentations, just as their predecessors (S-IIs and S-IIIs)

versed helm
#

IV actually aren't anything to scoff at when it comes to the augs themselves - it's just their training and sheer combat ability that's kinda.. weird

#

Going off later novels, the numbers are described more directly

drowsy mesa
#

Without armor: S-IIs > S-IIIs > S-IVs > ORION

#

but with armor, everything is reduced to experience and combat abilities

proud quail
#

i mean, if we're going by realistic values and if IVs recruit more from ODSTs than they do randos,

drowsy mesa
#

no, S-IVs are stronger than ORIONs

versed helm
#

Not sure. Later novels have had John trapped under a vehicle said to be 1.5x the size of a warthog, yet he managed to wiggle around under it despite poor leverage

proud quail
#

they'd have training and experience close to an SII

#

like, IVs should be veterans

#

and not every Spartan II got the privilege of fighting daily during the HCW

drowsy mesa
#

several of them are veterans from the HCW

terse lava
#

I would think 4s might be a little bit better as they are.full grown.adults where the 3s are teens

proud quail
#

in every conflict

drowsy mesa
#

some from a few years, others from the beginning, I think

proud quail
#

i dont think we have beginner veterans

#

nobody's that old

#

oh wait

versed helm
#

Baseline IVs are said to be able to lift warthogs. John, on the other hand, managed to stand under 12 thousand kilos of force @drowsy mesa

proud quail
#

chief is like

#

40, aint he?

#

uh, yeah, i can see a 50 something SIV veteran, but atm we have none

#

HCW is a 27 year conflict

drowsy mesa
#

@proud quail 47 by the events of Halo 5

proud quail
#

2525 straight onto 2552

#

huh

#

30-40 years are totally plausible, yeah

#

but atm we have none

drowsy mesa
#

and Buck is 48

proud quail
#

...huh

#

so i stand corrected

#

davis?

#

the dude with the messed up ears?

#

yellow recruit armour?

#

now a forerunner memory?

#

he doesnt have an age

drowsy mesa
#

or Dutch, who is 39 years old by the time of Halo 5

proud quail
#

dutch is younger than buck?

#

that's

#

weird

#

i'd be, too

#

they have the bodies of 16 year olds

#

or 20 somethings

drowsy mesa
#

well, in Forward Unto Dawn, Blue Team was just barely 14-15 years old

proud quail
#

that's incredibly uncanny when you remember they've fought early in the war

versed helm
#

I'm happy that Dutch is a Spartan now

proud quail
#

remember when dutch retired

drowsy mesa
#

yeah? after Rookie was killed

proud quail
#

all of them

#

except one

drowsy mesa
#

except for Rookie and Dare, all of them

versed helm
#

@versed helm All sans rookie, also Gretchen

drowsy mesa
#

with a new addition: Gretchen Ketola, Dutch's wife

versed helm
#

yea

proud quail
#

rookie became a spartan, they just genderbent him and made her dutch's wife

#

and gave him a background that isnt just listening to a dying man

versed helm
#

Lol

drowsy mesa
#

I can see Halo Follower publishing a video with that AU xD

proud quail
#

wew

versed helm
#

Yeah, Dirt was pretty underwhelming

#

Even just down to the name

proud quail
#

it was dirty, that's for sure

#

ayyyy lmao

versed helm
#

LOL

terse lava
#

Throws tomato

proud quail
#

jokes on you, i frickin' love tomatoes

terse lava
#

...

proud quail
#

locke may be the strongest spartan

#

but can he ever flip like vale does

terse lava
#

glasses planet

proud quail
#

also WOW speaking of that cutscene

#

isnt it just awfully convenient that elites had no shields

#

so they all got wiped off the face of the sunaion or whatever the planet was called

versed helm
#

Spartan strength is pretty inconsistent, really. It ranges from cracking concrete a bit (TFoR animated series), to smashing through boulders and warping the hull of a seraph fighter with body-slams

proud quail
#

because chief is the main character

#

and nobody liked osiris

#

that's all there is to it

#

buck shouldn't even be there

#

but thorne's voice actor was standing up for his rights

#

god bless him

#

foreal, gabriel thorne was gonna be the fourth member to osiris

#

there was a poster and everything

#

gimme a sec to find it

#

correction, it was concept art, ill DM you

drowsy mesa
#

that concept art became the cover of the Art book of Halo 5

proud quail
#

OH WAIT NO I FOUND IT

#

yeah

#

but back then voice actors in the gaming industry were on strike

#

something to do with pay

#

and nathan fillion was fresh out of his cayde-6 DLCs in Destiny 1, iirc

#

so that's how we got him in halo 5, being a funny man

remote spruce
#

big yawn moment right there

proud quail
#

am i wrong though

remote spruce
#

I think the strike was after Halo 5

proud quail
#

wasnt it during?

nocturne quest
#

you are right, denmark, in fact, is additionally not a real country

remote spruce
#

I know Halo Wars 2 was affected by it

proud quail
#

it went on for a couple years

#

like, i think a verdict came out last year or 2017

proud quail
#

but the explanation for a lack of thorne was because voice actor strikes

remote spruce
#

I thought it was schedule conflicts

proud quail
#

errr

drowsy mesa
#

yeah, it was for schedule conflicts

proud quail
#

that's also a likely thing but i always assumed it was the strikes

#

bleh whatever

remote spruce
#

I recall how strange it was that Fillion was free to do Halo 5 but not Thorne's VA

proud quail
#

hm

terse lava
#

Guess they cared about the fans more?

proud quail
#

if they didnt they'd give us the whole alpha nine experience, or any other recognizable fireteam

#

like majestic

terse lava
#

Perhaps

terse lava
#

You know I wonder what the covenant plan was had chief failed to destroy alpha halo with that flood outbreak

proud quail
#

to just die

#

there were no signs of any other ship outside the T&R iirc

#

and we all saw how that was going

terse lava
#

Their was a whole fleet on orbit....

proud quail
#

and none of them did anything? what?

#

what lmao

#

oh

#

right

#

halo 2

#

they really did do nothing

#

lmao

terse lava
#

What makes you say that? They sent strike teams to clean the ship, they blasted 2 of their fellow ships to prevent the flood leaving

proud quail
#

was this in the books or something? i distinctly remember the T&R still floating and the flood still being a threat

terse lava
#

Books, the graphic novel, map bios in halo 5

proud quail
#

that explains why i dont know what you're talking about

versed helm
#

What was the other ship?

#

Infinite Succour and

terse lava
#

One was the fleet's food ship the infinite succor

#

I can't remember the other one, was a galo 5 map bio

versed helm
#

Oh, interesting

#

Regret?

terse lava
#

Yea

versed helm
#

amusing

#

Does anyone else find it kinda funny how Troy Denning's work displays UNSC ergonomics with actually solid intelligence

#

all while contradicting itself with things like the design of their own vehicles that break said concepts? Lol

feral perch
#

examples?

versed helm
#

Details such as John describing how performing a strafing run beyond 30 degrees from the target simply makes the pilot equally as vulnerable - all while jumping into a Scorpion tank with an usually raised neck

feral perch
#

Chief never uses a Scorpion in any of Denning’s works.

versed helm
#

Lol, but it's still in the same setting where things like that are so prominent

feral perch
#

Oh well.

stable schooner
#

You know I’ve been too hard on Penitent Tangent. He did contain the flood for Thousands of years. 343 Guilty Spark let them spread all over the ring in no time

young glen
#

Fair point

#

Which track is better Impend or Heretic, Hero

gilded mason
#

Heretic, Hero

young glen
#

In Amber Clad or The Movement of The 1st Odyssey

sonic ridge
#

What rank was Thel m before he was made arbiter

gilded mason
#

Supreme Commander

sonic ridge
#

And what was his ships name

young glen
#

Seeker of Truth

versed helm
#

@feral perch lmao perfect response

sonic ridge
#

Okay to both

#

What is in amber clad

young glen
#

A track from Halo 2

sonic ridge
#

But cortana says it in halo 2

gilded mason
#

What

stable schooner
#

Heretic Hero, impend has a good opening but Heretic maintains the feels all track

sonic ridge
#

She’s says something about in amber clad in halo 2 on gravemind

gilded mason
#

Anyway, my vote goes to In Amber Clad

young glen
pulsar horizon
#

Isn't it the name of a ship?

sonic ridge
#

Idk

gilded mason
#

She’s says something about in amber clad in halo 2 on gravemind
Yes. It's Miranda's ship and a track

sonic ridge
#

It might be

young glen
#

Yes, its also a track name

sonic ridge
#

Oh

#

It’s the unsc ship

gilded mason
#

Yes

young glen
#

yes

#

Some of martys best work

versed helm
#

Is it explained how Thel is at the bleeding edge of aristocracy in terms of naval tactics while also remaining as being among the greatest infantry? I mean, he's close to Rtas' tier without even being as dedicated to close combat

gilded mason
#

Because he's talented.

versed helm
#

Lol fair enough

gilded mason
#

And tries his best

sonic ridge
#

Were 👏 it 👏 so 👏 easy 👏

versed helm
#

I guess. Just after reading a few other novels with supreme commanders and fleetmasters, they seem to have trouble keeping up with Special Operations

young glen
#

Halo 3 had the weakest campaign story wise out of the original trilogy, Change my mind

gilded mason
#

Nope, I agree

young glen
#

Good man

gilded mason
#

H2 > CE > H3

pulsar horizon
#

What about ODST?

sonic ridge
#

original trilogy

versed helm
#

I dunno, maybe very slightly in CE and 2's favour with the narrative - but 3 isn't far off from them IMHO

stable schooner
#

I mean Thels a Zealot and is shown stomping 3 elites at once. I put him above Rtas. Amber clad stomps that contest

gilded mason
#

Ah, but Rtas has Jedi speeds!

sonic ridge
#

Wait who is the leader of the Sangheili the sos are fighting in 5

young glen
#

I overcame my nostalgia for H3 a few years back. Its campaign is stretched, a rehash of CE, and left out the Arbiter as a main character.

#

Arbiter

versed helm
#

@stable schooner It's pretty funny how drastic the variety can be. You have elites with comparatively normal speed and reflexes, to ones who dance around bullet-dodgers - Sangheili that go down to a couple of marines, then Arbiters who take on entire armies

stable schooner
#

But yeah I agree 2>CE>3

sonic ridge
#

The Sangheili the sos are fighting

gilded mason
#

Wait who is the leader of the Sangheili the sos are fighting in 5
It was Jul 'Mdama (may he rest in peace)

sonic ridge
#

But he’s dead so why are they still fighting

gilded mason
#

Second in command continuing on, I assume

sonic ridge
#

Also they didn’t get rid of the arbiter as a main character

young glen
#

Yes they did

sonic ridge
#

How did they do that

pulsar horizon
#

He felt much more like a side character.

gilded mason
#

Sadly

sonic ridge
#

I disagree

young glen
#

He went from a playable character for the majority of Halo 2 to a guy with little to no dialogue and could no longer be played a s on single player

gilded mason
#

they done him dirty

pulsar horizon
#

A guess because more people played the game co-op they didn't bother giving him his own story.

sonic ridge
#

He has quite a lot of dialogue in 3

young glen
#

Not when compared to Halo 2

gilded mason
#

It's pretty surface level for the most part.

stable schooner
#

Yeah Arbiter hasn’t been a main character since 3 if you play it Co-op

sonic ridge
#

He only talks in cutscenes in 2

gilded mason
#

Besides that one scene with Truth.

sonic ridge
#

He talks throughout missions he’s in in 3

stable schooner
#

Arbiter talks a lot in 3 but it has little meaning compared to 2

gilded mason
#

👆

sonic ridge
#

Because in 2 it was only cutscenes

young glen
#

Personally, unpopular opinion, Arbiter is a better character then Chief. Idk i got a thing for underdog anti heros

gilded mason
#

Ain't unpopular.

#

I absolutely agree, and many others do as well

sonic ridge
#

That’s like saying the chief had more meaningful dialogue in 2 than 4 since he only talks in cutscenes in 2 and says some meh stuff while playing him in 4

pulsar horizon
#

Arbiter actually has depth, all chief's lore is in books.

gilded mason
#

and says some meh stuff while playing him in 4
Didn't seem that way to me

stable schooner
#

No cause 2S Arbiter Cutscenes > 3s.

young glen
#

Dont get me wrong i love Chief, but if you look at Chief from the original trilogy hes kinda just a silent action hero who says one liners, not very complex. If anything hes emotion less

gilded mason
#

I liked him in CE. Has some nice sass.

sonic ridge
#

He’s supposed to be emotionless

#

I literally said chief

pulsar horizon
#

Nvm, I can't read

sonic ridge
#

Boi

stable schooner
#

No thanks to your driving

pulsar horizon
#

We'll make it

gilded mason
#

And he was very physically expressive.

stable schooner
#

Tosses grenade in his hand

gilded mason
#

And his control room scenes.

young glen
#

Anyone else think Halo Infintes Chief armor is a little too bulky? I wish they had just reused Chiefs armor from Halo 2 remaster, crap why not everything from Halo 2 remaster everything in that game is the best Halo has ever looked.

sonic ridge
#

Except for the elite minor armour

pulsar horizon
#

I mean he has some flair when he melee with the magnum, he like flips it around. Thats some personality.

stable schooner
#

From CE to 3 I’d say Chief talked less with every game

gilded mason
#

I wish they had just reused Chiefs armor from Halo 2 remaster
Mark V 4 lyfe

young glen
#

Preach

versed helm
#

14 year-old chief is kinda weird, but in a goodish way

sonic ridge
#

Halo 3 had the best chief armour

young glen
#

Got a poster of that Halo 2 remaster armor in my room

#

I liked the darker green from Halo2 over 3's light green

sonic ridge
#

Halo 3s isn’t light tho

#

It’s pickle

gilded mason
#

To clarify, Mark V is his armor from CE. (just in case that wasn't clear)

young glen
#

when compared to Halo 2 its a lighter tone

sonic ridge
#

Caboose armour

trail wyvern
#

@versed helm

What do you mean by weird? I haven't read the books themselves, just whatever is online.

stable schooner
#

“Commander Human Vehicle” as I jam out To Blowing up Enforcers with Genesong

versed helm
#

@trail wyvern Just in contrast to what he says, how he obeys certain people and his voice. It's odd, he seems more Captain America-like, which is kinda cool in a way

pulsar horizon
#

Chief in "Fall of Reach" show sounds like that.

young glen
#

Mark V was a little awkward, i prefer Mark 4 from Halo Wars

trail wyvern
#

@versed helm

Idk, I still need to get all the books. I've only got The Fall Of Reach, The Flood and Contact Harvest

versed helm
#

Yeah. I prefer how he sounds in the FuD film myself

trail wyvern
#

Need to find the rest yet.

pulsar horizon
#

FuD is great.

#

Is he only 14 in that?

versed helm
#

@trail wyvern I recommend reading Contact Harvest, Silent Storm and Oblivion after Tfor in that order

young glen
#

A moment of silence for the cancelled Peter Jackson Halo Film.

pulsar horizon
#

F

trail wyvern
#

@versed helm

Guessing they go in that order?

stable schooner
#

Man I just Hate Breaking the Covenant. Gravemind just isn’t the same

versed helm
#

@trail wyvern Yeah

young glen
#

Chiefs really lucky that he got in contact with Lord Hood at the end of Halo 2 before they shot him out of the sky.

pulsar horizon
#

Q: How does the plasma sword have enough density to lift people. Given it's just gas?

versed helm
#

@stable schooner I know what you mean. I still really like Follow in Flight, though

stable schooner
#

That imo was actually better then the original

gilded mason
#

Chiefs really lucky that he got in contact with Lord Hood at the end of Halo 2 before they shot him out of the sky.
I don't think it would have really mattered

stoic hamlet
#

Honestly they should have fired anyways

young glen
#

You saying the crumbling Earth defenses couldnt have shot the ancient super ship out of the sky?

versed helm
#

@pulsar horizon Likely by using the same "anti-gravity rods" that hold the blade in place. Maybe they can be tuned in density and focus

stoic hamlet
#

One Spartan isn’t much compared to that high value of a target

#

Not to mention there were other Spartans in theatre anyways.

pulsar horizon
#

I thought it was just ionised gas held by a magnetic field.

gilded mason
#

Yeah, exchange one spartan for the leader of the Covenant. It'd make sense.

stable schooner
#

Dang Hood should have did it

stoic hamlet
#

I mean it likely wouldn’t do anything, but that’s a trade I’d be more than willing to make, tbh

gilded mason
#

It wouldn't have worked anyway, I imagine

pulsar horizon
#

Why didn't they just shoot it down after he jumped?

gilded mason
#

Because it was too powerful

young glen
#

Why did Chief jump?

stoic hamlet
#

It wouldn’t have done anything

#

It’s a Forerunner ship

#

The thing is basically impenetrable to UNSC arms

terse lava
#

Waste of ammo really

stoic hamlet
#

It’s also completely unarmed so it can’t fight back, but it can’t be destroyed, so yeah, waste of ammo.

stable schooner
#

Sniper Jackal Fives

young glen
#

Chief should've died at some point by now

#

Like one lucky shot

gilded mason
#

It’s also completely unarmed so it can’t fight back
Hm? As far as I know, it does have weapons

stoic hamlet
#

Weren’t those removed?

gilded mason
#

Oh, were they?

pulsar horizon
#

Why?

gilded mason
#

Ah, you're right

#

The two races then penned the Writ of Union, which formally established the Covenant, and decommissioned the Forerunner warship, removing all known weapons

stoic hamlet
#

I mean it’s possible Truth had the dreadnought re-weaponized but not with its original armament

young glen
#

Was anyone on the planet happy Cortana became a villain?

stoic hamlet
#

Probably not

gilded mason
#

Yeah, it was a bit out of left field

terse lava
#

A bit?

gilded mason
#

Just a teensy-tiny bit

young glen
#

Halo 4: Heres Cortana emotional perfect send off. Halo 5: Ima end this mans whole career

feral perch
#

Who likes Mark V[B]?

stoic hamlet
#

raises hand

pulsar horizon
#

Eh its alright

stoic hamlet
#

Also it’s just Mark IV but with shields.....

young glen
#

Mark 4 from Halo Wars was better

feral perch
#

I like it with the forehead attachment.

young glen
#

For its time Mark V was okay

stoic hamlet
#

I stand by the idea that it became “late War” Mark IV armour.

stable schooner
#

Mark IV fan myself

stoic hamlet
#

While the HW armour is “Early War”

gilded mason
#

Mark V is always the best Spartan armor. ❤
So sleek and smooth.

feral perch
#

Mark IV Halo Wars is perfect IMO.

stoic hamlet
#

They can both coexist IMO

feral perch
#

Aesthetically, of course.

stoic hamlet
#

I like them both for different reasons

young glen
#

Sleek and Smooth halo 5 wants to know your location

gilded mason
#

o no

feral perch
#

It seems that Mjolnir variants were a dime a dozen throughout the Covenant War... hmm

young glen
#

Reachs armor was some of the best. All looked lived in

pulsar horizon
#

And died in

gilded mason
#

eyy

young glen
#

Too soon

stoic hamlet
#

Reminder the only different armour pieces were the helmet, shoulders and knee guards

young glen
#

Remember Reach

feral perch
#

Am I the only one who feels like Reach’s armor weathering made some parts look more like cardboard than metal?

gilded mason
#

Good times.

young glen
#

You are the only one

stoic hamlet
#

Everything else was added onto the base suit, and I liked that a lot

stable schooner
#

You can change the chest in Reach to can’t you?

unique rune
#

Something about Reach's weathering always looked off to me, but I dunno if I'd describe it as cardboard-like.

stoic hamlet
#

Nope

feral perch
#

Especially the forearm armor.

pulsar horizon
#

Just the plating on it

young glen
#

There all attachments to the same armor

unique rune
#

Reach's chest armor could be changed, but it was just add-ons to the same base chest plating.

stable schooner
#

Ah it’s been a while totally forgot

stoic hamlet
#

It doesn’t change, you just add gear/playing to the base chest.

and it was wonderful

feral perch
#

I mean, I would say Grenadier with the huge collar might count as a different chest piece

stoic hamlet
#

Yeah, fair

young glen
#

Robot arm too

stoic hamlet
#

But everything else

unique rune
#

Eh. More just additional armor with more plates bolted on, really.

gilded mason
#

Robot arm too
Robot arms are neato. 👍

stoic hamlet
#

At any rate, I felt that was the best way to show unique Spartans while still keeping to the same “everyone wore the same armour” from the original books.

feral perch
#

If only the player could have two robot arms...

gilded mason
#

At any rate, I felt that was the best way to show unique Spartans while still keeping to the same “everyone wore the same armour” from the original books.
Ye

young glen
#

One thing that always made me angry was that you couldn't recreate any member of Noble Team exact. There was always one thing they had that you couldn't get

feral perch
#

I bet that’ll be... let’s say “grafted in” to the PC release

stoic hamlet
#

Mhm

young glen
#

Jorges Red visor still burns a hole in my heart

pulsar horizon
#

You can get close with Carter

feral perch
#

You can’t ever have Chief’s exact appearance either, in any Halo.

stoic hamlet
#

You can do Carter exactly I think

young glen
#

Halo Ce. hold my beer

stable schooner
#

Gotta keep em unique

stoic hamlet
#

Emile as well, just the visor colour is off.

#

I think

feral perch
#

Carter has a butt pouch that’s not accessible to players

stoic hamlet
#

It is though

feral perch
#

At least not with the commando chest piece

pulsar horizon
#

Na sholders are on the wrong side for Emile unfortunately

stoic hamlet
#

Isn’t it there on the piece?

young glen
#

Jun had a special shoulder piece

pulsar horizon
#

Emile's left handed and the player is right

feral perch
#

Oh, if it’s not that, then Carter has white stripes on his armor

young glen
#

Its like they were taunting us. Heres Emiles helmet.....but you'll never be him

stoic hamlet
#

I swear Emile has Operator left and (Security?) right?

#

You can get very, very close at any rate

feral perch
#

Emile has true black primary color, a red shoulder pad, and silver secondary

stoic hamlet
#

Ah right

young glen
#

Jorge dies Emile: Big man was always pretty sentimental.

#

loved Emile

feral perch
#

Jun has a copper visor and a knife on his right shoulder. I really want that knife.

pulsar horizon
#

Ah yea it's his arm band with the shells thats on the wrong side i think

young glen
#

Kat is no where close, wrong chestplate

stoic hamlet
#

Yeah, well, I suppose that’s the thing about it being a game, a Spartan wouldn’t be limited to two colours in the same specific pattern.

#

It’s the standard chest plate with the robot arm

#

But everything else you can get, to my knowledge, though her paint scheme isn’t available.

young glen
#

yall remember "Deliver Hope"?

#

still gives me chills

stoic hamlet
#

Side note

feral perch
#

You can replicate the exact appearance of one Spartan in Reach’s multi, Noble Six! hah.. hah hah...

stoic hamlet
#

I really wish book covers would show armour as they’re described in the books

pulsar horizon
#

Man Halo had the best by far promo material

stoic hamlet
#

I.E, SPI being a base gray, or in Silent Storm, all the Spartan Armour was black, but on the cover John has his usual green.

young glen
#

Along with the ODST ones and that figurine display one

pulsar horizon
#

We are ODST, Believe, Deliver Hope.

feral perch
#

To be fair, SPI should’ve blended in with the background in GoO’s cover

stoic hamlet
#

True, but Kurt might not have had the panels active

#

Thus, it should have been gray

young glen
#

Sad part Halo 5 had some of the best promo too, until... to quote Spongebob they SOILED IT SOILED IT

feral perch
#

Is that confirmed to be Kurt?

#

I haven’t been sure.

pulsar horizon
#

Eh I remember the trailer with Chief's heart beating, not much else.

stoic hamlet
#

I don’t know who else it could be, seeing as the team in that book was usually Fred, Kelly and Kurt.

Fred is in the Mark VI, Kelly in Mark V, and then Kurt would be in the SPI

#

Mind Fred wouldn’t be in that Mark VI anymore

feral perch
#

That was Will in the Mark VI

stoic hamlet
#

As in Canon he was wearing GEN1 Centuerion

#

Originally though it was Fred

#

Before his armour changed

feral perch
#

Probably, but Will isn’t a major character, so not much chance that his armor gets a retcon too

stoic hamlet
#

Aye

young glen
#

They removed them from Yotube due to backlash, but basically they released two trailer both live action one with chief dying and locke walking over through rubble asking chief if it was all worth it and points the gun at chief before it ends, same thing for the second trailer except locke is on the ground now and chief has the gun

feral perch
#

I liked those.

stoic hamlet
#

I do wish Ghosts got an updated cover like TFoR, Flood, First Strike

young glen
#

was brillaint

feral perch
#

Too bad they caved to the displeasure of the masses.

young glen
#

till they SOILED IT SOILED IT

stoic hamlet
#

Mind it’s perfect as is, IMO

pulsar horizon
#

Oh wait I was thinking about halo 4, I completely forgot that halo 5 trailer.

stoic hamlet
#

But it would be cool to see if it actually does need a change

feral perch
#

How about Kurt standing against a legion of III’s in SPI, and Onyx and Voro ‘Mantakree in the background?

#

Something busy.

stoic hamlet
#

There was one fan art someone did of like, Ackerson inspecting Alpha Company in the rain, looked awesome, lemme go find it

young glen
#

cant post pictures in this chat sadly

feral perch
#

I would also settle for finally seeing an official drawing of an Onyx Sentinel, and just having that as the cover

stoic hamlet
#

That would also be cool

gilded mason
#

Lookin' edgy there.

stoic hamlet
#

Yeah, but it’s still a cool visual

pulsar horizon
#

Getting some 40k vibes

gilded mason
#

Yeah, a commissar.

stoic hamlet
#

I feel like the III’s are like the UNSC’s version of the Sisters of Battle

#

Utterly devoted

#

And ABSOLUTELY ANGRY

pulsar horizon
#

Wouldn't Death Corps be more appropriate?

stoic hamlet
#

Ehh, in the sense that their lives are often given for a higher cause maybe

pulsar horizon
#

"Did someone say die for the UNSC?"

stoic hamlet
#

But not in the sense that they specifically seek martyrdom, and they’re not used like Kreigers. They’re more like Tempestus Scions or Drop Troops. Sent behind the lines to cause chaos and havoc and force the enemy to waste valuable frontline units chasing ghosts.

pulsar horizon
#

Oh so are all III's like the head-hunters?

stoic hamlet
#

Essentially yeah

#

Head-Hunters were split from the companies, but the Companies all were sent behind the Covenant lines. Alpha to destroy a ship-building hard and staging point, and Beta to destroy a Factory (Which has things gone to plan likely wouldn’t have seen Beta lose more than maybe 1-2 Spartans purely from the drop.)

#

IIRC the Spartan III’s were more valuable than the II’s from a strategic standpoint, because they could be sent on tougher, more higher risk missions but with drastic rewards for success (Alpha basically giving the UNSC another decade, for example), whereas the II’s were so few, and so well known, the UNSC couldn’t risk them on the missions/they wouldn’t be able to complete them, so they were kept back for morale.

scenic summit
#

I believe I heard that the III’s were picked out by well their reasons. Why they would want to kill, plus their childhoods being scarred from the war. Sort of messed up tbh, which is why they are considered more unstable then the II’s.

versed helm
#

Well I don't know if it's fair to say that Spartan IIIs generally were considered more unstable than the IIs.

#

At least, not from a military perspective. Maybe from the perspective of just being human beings.

#

The unstable ones were specifically Gamma-company Spartan IIIs, and that was on account a lovely little illegal mutagen by the designation "009762-OO".

#

But as human beings, given how laser-focused on the art of war their childhoods and educations were (with the Spartan IIs at least having some more general education), they're likely a little more eccentric.

#

Though the funny thing is, if anything the portrayals of Spartan IIIs are less aloof and more personable than the IIs. Looking at Owen and the members of NOBLE.

#

Same for Roland and Jonah in Headhunters.

#

Even in GoO the SIIIs came across (to me at least) as less chosen one-like and more scrappy.

strong sage
#

What are SII equalvalents for headhunters?

versed helm
#

They don't really have one. Though Black or Grey teams might conceivably be sent on similar missions. Then again, so could all Spartans.

#

In the postwar environment a SII could end up as part of the Headhunter initiative, though, seeing as how it's a fixture of the whole Spartan branch and not just one generation.

#

There's SIV headhunters, so conceivably there could be SII headhunters.

#

Provided the brass aren't too protective of their legendary heroes.

past olive
#

It's possible they were more unstable emotionally, but the S-lll program had much less casualties from augmentation allowing S-lll training facilities such as Onyx to produce hundreds of them without much fail. Most of them died in the battle of Onyx though.

#

But unlike the ll's, the S-lll's were volunteer children who were orphaned from the human covenant war

#

They became S-lll's with the promise that they could kill covenant for revenge

#

And many of them died young, in fact Noble 6 in Halo Reach is only supposed to be 19 years old

#

So while there wasn't much instability augmentation wise, emotionally they could be very unstable

versed helm
#

Has anyone else though about how UNSC using "primitive" technology such as rifles 500 years in the future sounds quite feasible? Given it's expansion of the human species grossing a population in the trillions among several hundred inhabited worlds, wouldn't that significantly stagnate the rate of development in favour of expanded logistics firms among the colonies?

#

And it's not like the UNSC don't have technology expected from a society grown in this period, anyway - from planet-scattering NOVA bombs, to artificial gravity, partial control of higher-dimensional slip-space, inertia buffers, and hard-sound rifles. If expansion is their main focus, then it's expected that anything not revolved around such would be hampered a little

lunar condor
#

I mean the rifles clearly work

#

And do their job pretty good

#

Makes sense that they havent focused on developing energy weaponry

wintry coral
#

They could start making energy weapons using Covenant/Forerunner technology

#

But that will probably never happen

lunar condor
#

With the amount of access they have to forerunner tech they will eventually learn to use it more and more

#

But its a long road ahead

#

Instead of energy weapons they need to make super macs into infantry weapons

#

That be pretty badass

wintry coral
#

There's so much more Forerunner stuff that humanity hasn't found. Well, they've found most of the major ones. They've already found Forerunner weaponry, shield worlds, The Ark, Halos 4, 5, 3, and possibly 7, and the Janus Key. Humanity still needs to find Maethrillian and Halos 1, 2, and 6.

#

Didn't Dr. Halsey find the Absolute Record and Mendicant Bias in a comic while captured by Jul 'Mdama?

humble yacht
#

She found the absolute record but not MB

hasty locust
#

Hmm

#

They know the true origins of humanity and such, right?

wintry coral
#

Then who was that Contender-class AI in that comic?

hasty locust
#

I haven’t read it but couldn’t be like uhh whats his name? Offensive bias? (Probably got that wrong) but the other one who fought mendicant

fair hazel
#

I personally am not even sure if it’s a contender class even if it has that shell.

#

Unless they talked about it in the library edition

warm ridge
#

@wintry coral It was confirmed that was a different contender class AI in the comic and not MB, nor Offensive Bias.

#

tl;dr We have no idea. @hasty locust

#

It's name is the Custodian, that's all we know.

fair hazel
#

Was it said to actually be a contender class?

#

That’s the thing

warm ridge
#

yes

fair hazel
#

Library edition?

hasty locust
#

I got the name right!

#

Yee

warm ridge
#

actually think it was specifically said in the Halo Escalation series that it was, not Library edition.

fair hazel
#

In the normal comics it doesn’t say

#

I’d still like to have a loot eventually.

versed helm
#

@versed helm Bit late here (and sorry for interrupting the current discussion) but I'm in agreement with you. I mean, I think there's potentially interesting lore still to be had regarding the subtle ways in which firearms have evolved in the Halo universe (relating to ammunition and smart link and such), but between the pretty extended period of peace humanity went through, the fact that a gun is a gun and will never be fun to get shot with, and cost-efficiency, there's more than ample justification for the UNSC's use of conventional firearms.

#

It is worth noting that generally speaking, UNSC equipment ranges of the heavier side compared to what you expect today. .50 HE rounds for pistols, 7.62x51 and fictional 9.5 cartridges for rifles, 8-gauge shells, 102mm rockets, mixed in with a few coilguns here and there - all overkill by modern standards.

#

But all presumably necessary to countermand more advanced ballistic protection.

warm ridge
#

If I'm being honest, the absolute record never really sounded like it was a specific planet with a ton of Forerunner tech on it, rather it sounds like it's an entire map of every single Forerunner device/location ever, worlds and all. I imagine it had wide scale use when the Forerunners were at there all time high before the Flood eventually attacked, making information like this secret/hard to find altogether.
I like to think of it as a sort of book that only a select few individuals ever had access to, and in order to gain this information you had to have ample reason to do so.

humble yacht
#

Halo Escalation, Issue 21, page 15

#

The Custodian says

#

"A hundred thousand years ago, a fellow Contender made a fatal decision when deciding with whom to ally himself."

#

That's the closest we get to labeling the Custodian as a contender class AI

past olive
#

Halo 5 introduced UNSC Foreunner firearm and UNSC Covenant firearm hybrids

#

unless it's not canon to the lore, which would be kinda dumb

versed helm
#

Well, they're just kinda attachments.

#

Not entirely unreasonable to stick a Covenant optic on a UNSC weapon. We've known for a while that the software of UNSC and Covenant weapon systems is not entirely alien to one another.

#

The kinetic bolts are an odd case, though.

hasty locust
#

Mhm

versed helm
#

Presumably they do what they do by coating the projectile fired by the weapon in hardlight.

hasty locust
#

Don’t forget the needler warthog too

versed helm
#

Well, that's not so bad.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

Just the merging of tech

versed helm
#

Take a .50 cal LAAG cartridge and make the projectile the same way needler rounds are made.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

It has shields too right?

humble yacht
#

yep

hasty locust
#

I don’t think they are canon because they are in a “simulation” correct

#

So maybe new prototypes in production

unique rune
#

They’re still canon.

#

Maybe not full production but testing phase.

hasty locust
#

Yeah they exist but what im saying is maybe not in the physical world yet

versed helm
#

Everything in warzone is simulated but hypothetically possible in reality.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

I'm always happy when the lore talk shifts back from whacky Forerunner ancient history to the good stuff

#

Shooty-shoot guns

#

👍

hasty locust
#

Its not whacky

#

But yeah i like the “modern” lore if you can call it that

versed helm
#

Well, y'know. I'm old school.

#

I'm all about the Combat Evolved in Halo: Combat Evolved, y'know?

hasty locust
#

Ha

#

“Back in my day we had two sticks and a rock for a whole platoon!”

versed helm
#

Doesn't matter if it's 100,000 BC or 2552, I just like getting into the nitty gritty of the militaries, soldiers and guns of Halo.

#

Even when they're a little silly.

hasty locust
#

YES

versed helm
#

When they're silly they're silly in good ways

hasty locust
#

Thats why i want a super gritty, super desperate game as a marine during the human covenant war

versed helm
#

I can get behind that.

hasty locust
#

Like we’re so used to being able to mow the covenant down but when you start seeing your allies being mowed down around you knowing you could be next

#

Now I’m sad it doesn’t exist

versed helm
#

Creating compelling gameplay for that which isn't just Spartan-lite like ODST would be a bit of a challenge.

#

I think AI would be exceedingly important, both friendly and enemy.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

And so would be giving the player tools to avoid damage and scramble out of bad situations

#

Instead of just tanking them like Chief would

hasty locust
#

Yeah maybe also have a more dynamic vehicle damage system

#

Like maybe a scorpion could detread or the engine of a hog could stall and fail

versed helm
#

If you were doing that you'd naturally want to make them predictable outcomes though, right?

#

Like a result of the tracks or the engine being shot up

#

Not just like a random thing

hasty locust
#

Yeah exactly

#

Random would just peeve me off

versed helm
#

I mean honestly that kind of thing is just a kinda obvious continuation of what Halo 2 started with its vehicle damage system.

#

I'm surprised stuff like it hasn't been more heavily explored already.

hasty locust
#

They said they were gonna do more spin offs after infinite so...

#

Lets just hope

versed helm
#

Then again, I've always been in favour of expanding Halo's gameplay by adding more subtlety and interactions to the existing gameplay loop rather than giving players more abilities.

hasty locust
#

Yeah i feel they should add different NEW gameplay mechanics instead of making “call of halo”

versed helm
#

Not that I don't see the merits of the direction it's gone in, but little touches that flesh out the world and sandbox are just so nice.

#

Like y'know how AI allies in Halo like to shoot corpses?

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

Yeah ive seen that

versed helm
#

Wouldn't it be cool if "dead" enemies sometimes twitch or crawl away to make it more immersive?

hasty locust
#

I feel like the marines in 4 seemed to crouch and slump more to try and reduce their “hitbox” if you will

versed helm
#

Hard to do with the ragdoll stuff I guess

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

Like an injury mechanic maybe

#

Also known as blow off a grunts legs and arms and send them flying

#

Poor grunts

versed helm
#

I've also always felt that the tools to make a player feel like a super soldier, as Halo 5 tried to do, have sort of always been there but just haven't be used to their fullest potential.

proud quail
#

that doesnt sound like a T-rated game

versed helm
#

Like imagine if melee attacks had a way more intense physics effect?

hasty locust
#

Yeah also make halo M agaib

versed helm
#

So you can like Jerome, smacking Elites across the Enduring Conviction's hangar

hasty locust
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

The blood in Halo CE is so beautiful

proud quail
#

the only reason halo was an M game to begin with was the flood

versed helm
#

Especially on snow

proud quail
#

and maybe the blood

hasty locust
#

Mhm

#

On the autumn too

#

Those hallways looked like a piece of modern art

versed helm
#

Honestly I was playing through Halo CE a while ago and after that battle on Assault on the Control Room after you go down into the ice-bottomed canyon and through the cave, then come out on that ridge with the shades, wraiths and banshees.

#

And honestly it was kinda mesmerising just wandering around afterwards admiring the carnage.

hasty locust
#

I feel like 5 makes you feel too much like a power ranger, like someone overlaid the theme song over the opening cut scene and i cant unhear it whenever i boot it up

versed helm
#

In a way that it just kinda isn't in the newer games, I dunno.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

Like I remember walking past a shade that'd be knocked over by a shot-down banshee and just seeing an MA5 lying on the ground with no human corpses nearby

hasty locust
#

I made it my mission to try to bring the marines back alive

versed helm
#

And I was like

#

I wonder what happened here

#

And it's moments like that which make me really hopeful for Infinite's supposed recapturing of CE vibes

hasty locust
#

It felt epic the first time playing jumping over a ghost spinning mid air and headshoting the driver when i landed

#

Never was able to do taht again

versed helm
#

Also

#

Is it just me or did the blood effects in Halo CE do a really good job of emulating gore

#

Without getting too confronting

hasty locust
#

Yeah they kind of exploded with blood though

versed helm
#

Like if an Elite got killed by an explosion everything around him would be painted purple and you'd get that visceral satisfaction

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

Then when i shoot the bodies it just pools and pools

#

Excellent

#

Thats what they get for killing johnson and chips and stacker for the 30th time

versed helm
#

RIP lads

#

See you next level

hasty locust
#

#ChipsInInfinite

#

Please

#

They could have a funny interaction with buck like after chief finds him he can say something like “brings you back to delta, eh” then buck can object saying he saw him in mombasa

#

I think it would be a fun nod

versed helm
#

I wouldn't be opposed to it

#

Though just to limit contrivances I do tend to look at those Marine "characters" as just stand-ins for other Marines most of the time.

#

From a canonical perspective anyways

hasty locust
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

Especially ones that were on 04 and pop up later

hasty locust
#

I have really really high hopes for infinite

versed helm
#

Same.

#

But I'm trying not to stack my expectations unfairly either.

hasty locust
#

Yeah i feel like the characters on 04 weren’t actually those characters till halo 2

#

Like to me the only time you see johnson in CE is in the cutscene the rest are just african american officers

versed helm
#

Once again, same.

#

Here's a question, though.

#

Got a favourite design of UNSC infantry body armour?

#

Non-Spartan, non-ODST.

#

Basically, what are the coolest Marines/Troopers.

hasty locust
#

Most say reach my personal favourite is 3

#

But until the post war ones i have never disliked a marine armor

versed helm
#

I used to kinda not like 3 very much.

#

But over the last few days I'm really coming round to it.

hasty locust
#

The marines or the game?

versed helm
#

The Marines in 3, I mean xD

#

Halo 3's great, as they all are.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

I think when it comes to classic Marine designs, I like them all equally.

hasty locust
#

Three has the most marines though and you get the big skirmishes with them

versed helm
#

Though I find the HW/H2A to be a bit of an odd departure

hasty locust
#

Same idk i like them but something just seemed odd

versed helm
#

As in the Marines

hasty locust
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

Like they're really heavily armoured everywhere but their stomachs

#

It just seems incongruous

hasty locust
#

I usually play classic unless in cut scenes

versed helm
#

Yeah

#

H2 classic Marines are 👌

hasty locust
#

Their faces seem really young too but that may just be me

versed helm
#

When it comes to the postwar dudes there's certain variations from Halo 4 that work for me.

#

When they're in bright colours or when they have the goofy big helmets I don't like them, but otherwise they're decent.

hasty locust
#

I liked the green close faced ones

versed helm
#

Obviously that leads me to find the Halo 5 ones very offputting.

hasty locust
#

And the black ones on that station that i cant remember the name of

versed helm
#

Ivanoff, I think.

#

The ONI security troops.

hasty locust
#

Yeah

#

They all got composed

versed helm
#

RIP boys

#

So you in Spartan Ops as Promethean Knights I suppose

hasty locust
#

Ha

#

Wonder how many marines chief has killed

versed helm
#

Not a huge amount.

#

I can think of two.

#

From TFoR.

#

Oh wait, you mean as Prometheans lmao xD

#

But they're not really living in the conventional sense anymore. Like they may be sentient, but who they were is gone.

#

So in a technical sense you probably can't call them Marines, or even the people they used to be. Just beings possessed of that consciousness.

humble yacht
#

Was new Phoenix a military site?

#

Why would the prometheans generated from the new Phoenix incident be from marines?

versed helm
#

Well, the assumption I made was that if those from New Pheonix could be Prometheans by the time of Spartan Ops by whatever means

#

So too could the security personnel of Ivanoff

#

Well, technically they were ONI security personnel, if you wanna be real technical.

#

But they came from the ranks of the Marine Corps and Army.

#

So I guess it depends how you look at it.

humble yacht
#

How many were even left by the time the Didact fires the composer that first time

#

Couldn’t have been many

versed helm
#

I think Chimera meant how many were there to be composed

#

And if I'm not mistaken evacuations were occurring

#

So there were probably a few of them flying off in close vicinity of defending hangars

#

Sorry, I was confused as to how the composer's range factors in to your statement there Donk.

humble yacht
#

Especially after didact ripped off the roof to get the composer, a lot of people must have been flung into space

versed helm
#

Since it's not a matter of the composer's capabilities but the timing of its firing and the combat beforehand.

#

I would assume that a station like Ivanoff would not have been totally depressurized from a single "compartment" being breached

#

But frankly I don't care enough to argue the point

humble yacht
#

Not the whole thing

#

After all, Tilson was fine

#

But the area that held the composer was big and the covenant and UNSC were in the middle of fighting over it

hasty locust
#

Well ima head out take care guys

#

Good talk

versed helm
#

Take care yourself

#

Aaaanyway.

#

You guys make anything of the scale issue discussions that've been going through the community after Installation 00's video?

#

Imagine the Autumn being 3 klicks long.

#

I can see a few scale adjustments putting my mind at ease too

#

y'all have probably seen the fits I frequently have about ammo and such

obsidian thistle
#

Oh the scale issue. Essentially the "only" scales we can really take are the ones officially given.

Gameplay sizes only give is a general idea of stuff smol and big. But are never exact.

versed helm
#

It is a little jarring as a consumer of Halo content to be faced with the prospect of pretty iconic visuals not being canon.

#

But I'm lore-savvy enough to live with it.

#

As-is, though, it's kinda a matter of the games (which should probably be seen as a relatively high form of visual canon at least) bowing to arbitrary numbers from the EU

#

When it should probably be the inverse, y'know?

#

I don't have a hard and fast stance, but it's interesting to watch it play out

obsidian thistle
#

And yes I noted as of late people do take gameplay sizes as fact. Even though each weapon has like 2-4 sizes per game.

  1. The First person model.
  2. The Third person model.
  3. The rare scale change when you/AIs pick up stuff.
  4. The active model. (Sometimes they change and cant work without clipping)
versed helm
#

Well, that's a fair point.

#

Slight difference between a weapon and a hangar, though.

#

Well, actually, probably not.

obsidian thistle
#

1 and 2 are indeed the most common. 3 and 4 are uber rare. 4 really only seen with odd stuff.

#

The Wraith actually has the most clipping with the Reach model.

#

Even though you'd never notice it.

versed helm
#

Like here's an example that's really central to my personal experience

#

Take the MA5B

#

I'm really attached to how the weapon plays in-game. The 60-round mag in combination with how it feels and the aesthetic is just 👌

#

But then logically, it can't really hold 60 rounds. Problem as old as time, no need to go into it again.

#

But if they messed with some supplemental lore and changed a few numbers, maybe they could make its scale more convincing without me having to pretend the magazine looks entirely different or something.

#

I assume it'd be a similar deal for some people with, say, just making the Autumn bigger

obsidian thistle
#

I'll need to see if the MA5B even has canon sizes again.

#

Gosh Halopedia has no source for that size...

versed helm
#

With the MA5B ammo issue it's more a matter of the ammunition.

#

Unless the weapon is so cartoonishly large it makes what would be a huge magazine look tiny.

obsidian thistle
#

I wonder if thats one of the Loftus scale things I am an avocate on removing cause they were never said to be canon.

versed helm
#

Well, like a 20-round magazine for 7.62.

#

Not tiny necessarily

#

But not the glorious 60

#

I dunno. It'd just be more immersion-friendly if the surrounding lore was that it fired some kind of compact, special futuristic ammunition.

#

Or even just if the cartridge was redesigned.

#

And from that basis I can empathize with how people feel about scale.

#

Like if the canon isn't what we're seeing, is it just whatever we make up in our heads? How could that ever be canon?

#

This is one of the factors that leads me to be a little nihilistic when it comes to canon in general.

obsidian thistle
#

Well if the "Length: 34.9 inches (89 cm)" info is inaccurate

#

Well guess what

#

We have all the leeway we want

#

;)

versed helm
#

It's fairly consistent with canonical lengths that we can source, though.

#

The MA5C, MA37 and MA5D are all 90-100cm

#

And in this instance it's not a matter of the weapon's size so much as the design of the magazine specifically, and the presumed dimensions of what lies inside.

#

Based on the representations of the ammunition they use that are normally seen as canon (the Halo 3 art/Encyclopedia ones)

#

Though y'know

obsidian thistle
#

Infact I actually legit think the number is wrong now.

versed helm
#

Oh, how do you think?

obsidian thistle
#

No source at all. And the only other number was from an anon who gave zero source

versed helm
#

Well, it's unsourced.

#

Probably wouldn't be far off though

obsidian thistle
#

So ultimately if a source exists one will pop up.

terse lava
#

I would assume if it does it.would be one of the older novels

feral perch
#

The MA5B magazine clearly fits 60 rounds in its compact frame through the use of neural physics : p

versed helm
#

No wait

#

I actually found something that's made me content

#

Props from Halo Nightfall

#

It's a reasonable assumption that given that it's actually a real-life representation of something from the Halo universe (and that there's no newer interpretation save from the Halo 5 beta that did not make it into the final game and the Halo 4 MA5D was seen at Outpost Discovery), it's probably the most canonically acceptable representation of 7.62 UNSC round, and a 32-round MA5 compatible magazine.

#

Now I don't even know how to begin actually measuring that, but I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that round does have a less pronounced shoulder/rim width than a 7.62 NATO cartridge. And I'm fairly confident that you could stuff 32 of them in that magazine, assuming a double-stack single-feed configuration.

feral perch
#

I’d love to see an MA5 with a drum magazine

versed helm
#

Id love to have every halo novel and game ever

#

So basically the conclusion is

#

The MA5B and its magazine as we know it can't really be canon

#

Which is honestly fair enough since the MA5D's design is just absolutely gorgeous

carmine sleet
#

Aye, I especially like the Halo 5 iteration of the MA5D with all the little details they added, plus the white stripe on the base skin helps separate it from other versions of the AR

#

Also, I wish I could've seen those pictures of the props from Nightfall for when I was modelling my BR model too because those would be great to use as reference

versed helm
#

I dont remembdr what the ma5D looks like is that the one in halo 5

carmine sleet
#

MA5D is the Halo 4 and Halo 5 AR

versed helm
#

It is beautiful but the look of the MA5B have a special place in my heaet

#

I mean, the MA5D basically is that look.

#

But less stubby and more actually usable.

#

Instead of just having a chunk for the handgrip it's got this lovely ergonomic curved surface, and the trigger has a trigger guard.

#

Tonnes of lovely details.

carmine sleet
#

Aye, the basic shapes have remained the same but the detail has increased and the design has been made more ergonomic

#

Plus, it's not like some weapons in Destiny where it's impossible for the bullets to get from the mag to the barrel as there's just a giant hole in the way

versed helm
#

The MA5D from Halo 5 is even nicer with the details, too. Pop up ironsights? 👌

carmine sleet
#

Indeed

versed helm
#

Brass deflector? 😩 💦

carmine sleet
#

Silenced AR? Oh how I love that version of the weapon

versed helm
#

Anyway

#

At the end of the day this is actually good for the MA5B

proud quail
#

lol destiny guns

versed helm
#

Because if my eyes aren't deceiving me and what we're seeing truly is a slimmed-down, taller 7.62x51 cartridge, then that means the idea of some kind of 60-round casket magazine based on that ammunition is actually feasible.

proud quail
#

i used to laugh at destiny guns but then i played warframe and wowie are they all freakishly hideous

versed helm
#

As in, like, in a capacity that could actually fit in the weapon

#

Ew destiny

#

Also same ^

proud quail
#

still fun to use but man

#

also those are some really nice props

#

i wonder where they're sitting now

carmine sleet
#

In the Halo Museum maybe? I know they have a couple props there

versed helm
#

Anyway

#

I've gotta blast

#

I have a sudden inescapable compulsion to play Halo 4

#

Halseys journal is so cool, it shows spartans and their whole chart, some spartans we don’t know much about

#

and how we don’t even understand covenant weaponry

versed helm
#

does anyone have the high charity cross section?

#

the what

#

there's some x ray of high charity I've seen before

#

showing the interior

stoic hamlet
#

It’s from either Mythos or Fleet Battles

gilded mason
#

Warfleet.

stoic hamlet
#

Ah yes. Thank you, I said Fleet Battles but meant Warfleet

gilded mason
#

Are images of that allowed to even be posted here, or must it be kept a secret from all who do not physically have it?

stoic hamlet
#

I don’t see why they can’t be posted

gilded mason
#

Same, but you never know what the ruling might be sometimes, y'know?

stoic hamlet
#

Mhm, fair

#

It’s easy to get around the channel “no images” thing though

midnight gale
#

I could not even find an image above 300x300 pixels for the HC Cross section, so im not sure it matters in this case lol

versed helm
#

darn well thanks anyway

#

I'm developing a map for it and I need all the layout info I can get

gilded mason
#

I could not even find an image above 300x300 pixels for the HC Cross section, so im not sure it matters in this case lol
Ya just searched in the wrong spot.

midnight gale
#

I have the book and could copy it, but my printer's scanner is broken

versed helm
#

rip

#

i found someone's photo of it

gilded mason
#

I'll see about helping you out, Stan.

#

Oh

#

Legible resolution?

versed helm
#

Yeah, just had to scroll down a bit

gilded mason
#

Alrighty.

#

👍

versed helm
#

thanks anyway!

gilded mason
#

Yuppo

terse lava
#

You know I wonder why the warfleet cross section wasnt a.full cross section of all the vessels they had

#

Think only high charity, the autumn, and infinity were full cross sections

carmine sleet
#

Likely due to the amount it would cost to print cross sections of every ship being too high so they just went with those for full ones. Not to mention page number also can increase the cost

terse lava
#

Fair point, just felt a bit cheated on ones like truth and reconciliation

#

It deserved a full cross.more then infinity imo. We have only seen a tiny section of it from t&t and keyes

swift plover
#

Which is the strongest infantry unit of the covenant?

#

I'd put my bet on Hunters. Elite close second.

terse lava
#

Scarab

#

It is considered by the covenant as ultra heavy infantry

versed helm
#

Jiralhanae are also pretty strong. They can take a done of bullet damage. Macabeus got hit hard with a wathog and still fought on on Harvest

#

RIP HARVEST BTW F TO PAY RESPECTS

terse lava
#

I chuckle at how in warfleet in the population section. Harvest is the only planet with 0 population

versed helm
#

Warfleet and population section? Wheres that is it a book or game?

carmine sleet
#

Warfleet is a book

versed helm
#

I gotta check it out

swift plover
#

@terse lava Oh you're right. The scarab is a living thing.

terse lava
#

@swift ploveryep

versed helm
#

Oh yeah it is alive

swift plover
#

I forgot about that actually.

#

That's still really cool.

#

Imagine an army of those things.

#

Terrifying.

#

Y'all ever read the forerunner saga?

#

Cryptum - Primordium - Selentium.

versed helm
#

I seriously hope for more enemy types in infinite

#

Nah but im close to finishing ghost of onyx

swift plover
#

I honestly wish the didact returns in infinite.

#

Halo 5 really crapped on the story imo

#

Or I hope they introduce something really interesting to do with the plot.

#

It's gotta be a banger.

terse lava
#

Agreed, makemor break game

deep pewter
#

5s story is underrated

gilded mason
#

Nah.

sudden shuttle
#

not really.

deep pewter
#

Yah

sudden shuttle
#

how so.

deep pewter
#

People are overly critical

terse lava
#

How is it underrated though

#

You have the touching halo 4 ending, then out of no where Cortana returns...despite us bring told she was dead

#

Over and over

gilded mason
#

Like, even in Halo5 marketing, they kept calling the Cortana we see in Blue Team "The ghost of Cortana."

deep pewter
#

Cortana is dead

gilded mason
#

Not to mention Jul just flopping over dead at the very beginning of the game after all the build up and backstory.

deep pewter
#

That part is the fault of the community

gilded mason
#

And who can forget ''The Brass wants nothing to do with the Arbiter's war."

sudden shuttle
#

????

gilded mason
#

That part is the fault of the community
343 chose to do it

deep pewter
#

Because of the overreaction to SpOps

terse lava
#

Whether the real cortana was dead or not doesn't relly.matter when nothing in halo 5 tells us nothing of that and treats her as THE cortana

deep pewter
#

She acts nothing like Cortana

#

Even Chief explicitly points this out

#

But a title not giving the full story is far from new to the series, but again it’s something people hyper focus on in 5 and ignore in other titles

gilded mason
#

They're around

#

Doin' stuff

stable schooner
#

Their hanging out with Drones and Engineers

deep pewter
#

Jorge personally genocided the species

stable schooner
#

Though Engineers tend to get spotlight in the books so just hanging with the Drones

versed helm
#

Halo 5 is the last jedi equivalent of halo. A story that doesn't evolve from its predecessor and leaves no one questioning and curious about the future of the series its climax and premise were confounding and its marketing was extremely flawed and misleadinc

deep pewter
#

no questioning

#

It literally ends on the biggest change the series has seen

terse lava
#

I am holding my breath on that

deep pewter
#

I don’t know how someone could play 5 and end up thinking it leaves no one questioning thinkingchief

stoic hamlet
#

Exubaeant Witness, you mean

gilded mason
stable schooner
#

Nah it just left me unexcited

terse lava
#

Well cortana has forerunner tech, emp everyone's fleets

deep pewter
#

Then that’s a you problem

stable schooner
#

I know one a majority of people share so I can live with it

deep pewter
#

You hype up your own opinions a lot

#

It’s more of a vocal minority with a problem

terse lava
#

I did like however we.got.to check out sangheilios

#

But...that's for me the only positive

stable schooner
#

lol vocal minority ok. If the people who like it were the majority where are they?

gilded mason
#

Seeing Sanghelios was the one thing I didn't dislike about the game.

deep pewter
#

If the people that didn’t like it are a majority where are they?

terse lava
#

@gilded masonthe ancient murals were a.wonderdul touch too

versed helm
#

Sanghelios was tight and Arby was great loved the new armor

terse lava
#

@deep pewter

stable schooner
#

On this forum every day, on Reddit, every YouTube video involving Halo 5 or represented in Halo 5s Lower scores

terse lava
#

@deep pewterthey are loek ppl y plenty, there's a reason you see old setstyle coming back

gilded mason
#

Yeah, like, I barely see anyone ever say positive things about the game's story.

terse lava
#

Old artstyle

deep pewter
#

So in total not even 1/10th of the people that bought the title?

#

People happy are much less likely to go to forums and talk about it

stable schooner
#

Barely 1/10 of the people who bought it still own it so sure

terse lava
#

@deep pewterok, could you explain then why the designs have returned to a mor classic.look?

deep pewter
#

So 10% disliked it, making it a minority

#

Art design and story are two very different things, and art design has been a complaint since 2012

stable schooner
#

No the math would equal 90%. If 10% are those still playing it, that’s 90% who sold it and weren’t pleased

deep pewter
#

Lol what

stable schooner
#

Anyways though this isn’t lore and not the place to defend or hate Halo 5

deep pewter
#

It’s a discussion centered around 5s story, it’s relevant until others tried to move the discussion from that to the community’s opinion on it

versed helm
#

Halo 5 is considered 343s greatest dissapointmrnt my hype for infinite isnt cause of halo 5 its cause of the trailer for halo infinite and the fact that halo wars 2 was so great showing a return to form

deep pewter
#

Halo 4 was by far their greatest disappointment, 5 was much better and the reason why I’m hyped for Infinite

humble yacht
#

This is sounding like not lore

hasty locust
#

Mhm

versed helm
#

People also hate it since 343 shat on the player base and fans by removing key multiplayer features and bringing them back as dlc. Instituting horrible microtransaction tactics and telling fans to literally get over it if you watch the trailer. Also removing split screen is just a huge no no

terse lava
#

Agreed. How about this

hasty locust
#

What i wanna know in lore is why did the elites randomly “evolve”

terse lava
#

Had it been confirmed or not that h5 Cortana is the original?

versed helm
#

They ebolved

gilded mason
#

What i wanna know in lore is why did the elites randomly “evolve”
What?

deep pewter
#

It is confirmed that Cortana is a rampant fragment

stable schooner
#

Oh gosh Settling we all know where this is going.

versed helm
#

Yep^

terse lava
#

Alright, good enough for me

versed helm
#

I do like that fact a lil mendicant bias type bettayso

hasty locust
#

Im talking about the 4 and 5 elites is there a reason in lore they changed or is it creative libertys

versed helm
#

Betrayal*

humble yacht
#

Yes and yes

stable schooner
#

Yeah both is the answer

gilded mason
#

Yup

humble yacht
#

H4 and H5 elites canonically are from hesduros

gilded mason
#

Nope

hasty locust
#

Ah

#

But the arbiter

humble yacht
#

But in all likelihood the changes elite design was artistic license

hasty locust
#

Yeah, figured

gilded mason
#

It's just a phenotype found anywhere, according to lore.

terse lava
#

Yep

humble yacht
#

343 was probably not married to a particular elite design like some elite afficionados are

hasty locust
#

I dislike it but not to the point where im gonna go on like a crusade about it

humble yacht
#

There’s been enough crusading on it

gilded mason
#

Yup

hasty locust
#

Mhm

stoic hamlet
#

sad Deus Vult noises

hasty locust
#

I wonder how 343 wouldve done sentinels with their art style 🤔

stable schooner
#

Theirs Sentinels in Halo 4

humble yacht
#

Yep

hasty locust
#

Constructors were the same i think

#

Oh there were

carmine sleet
#

They appear on the second level

hasty locust
#

I gotta replay those sometime i supose

#

Give it another chance