#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 155 of 1

versed helm
#

Along with The Fall of Reach,First Strike,and The Flood

#

I got all 3 books of the Forerunner Trilogy and i read Broken Circle a few times

#

Who else besides me read Broken Circle?

gilded mason
#

Right here.

#

One of the best Halo books.

versed helm
#

Agreed

gilded mason
#

Made all the sweeter there being no humans.

versed helm
#

How good is Halo:Last Light

gilded mason
#

I liked it quite a bit.

versed helm
#

Or how good is Bad Blood?

gilded mason
#

Never read it.

versed helm
#

Oh

#

But back to Broken Circle..remember the part where Crecka mentioned being attacked by unidentified assailants in the System of Miasmic Giants?

gilded mason
#

Ye

versed helm
#

Here is the obvious question,what was the species that attacked Crecka's ship?

gilded mason
#

Don't believe it was ever said.

versed helm
#

Personally i believe that these "unidentified assailants" are basically an unknown race that inhabits the Halo galaxy

#

It could be possible that they could be the same race that crash landed on Alpha Halo as shown in the CE:A Terminals

remote spruce
#

Space Bears

versed helm
#

I know i've said it before but overall,why don't we see any more alien races outside of the ones we already have?,How many races survived the Great Purification and the subsequent reseeding outside of the ones we already have

vague scroll
#

We know that 123 sapient species were cataloged and redistributed to their home worlds after the Halo array fired. Any of them could be those unknowns.

versed helm
#

Well it would depend on how many of those 123 races successfully survived into the modern era

gilded mason
#

And the series mostly takes place in the Orion Arm. A lot of galaxy yet unexplored by the various factions.

vague scroll
#

True. Nonetheless, its reason enough to believe any of them could be it. Extragalactic forces on the other hand seem to be too slim of odds.

last anchor
#

I dont think we'll know until we have reason to do so

remote spruce
#

Space Bears, 343i said so

versed helm
#

Yeah..makes you wonder who or what lives outside of the Orion Arm

vague scroll
#

I'd personally prefer 343i not introduce any extragalactic factions since most of the explored galaxy is only the Orion Spur, it would be a shame to not use all that avaliable unexplored space rather than try to up the stakes.

Halo like a lot of franchises suffer from situations like that, where the threat has to be significantly bigger than previous because authors worry their stories will be boring.

remote spruce
#

Hopefully something not humanoid, do Hunters count as that?

last anchor
#

IMO the rest of the galaxy is the Star Wars one.
The Orion Arm is the Unknown Regions.
XD

#

The UNSC is gonna have a FIELD day when it hits the First Order

remote spruce
#

Nah it's Gundam

#

MECHS

vague scroll
#

For example, the Didact was easily the weakest pillar in Halo 4 narratively. Take him out of the game and just let it be about Chief and Cortana trying to escape a hostile shield world and race against the clock to reach Halsey to save Cortana would have been just as good or better in terms of storytelling.

last anchor
#

Not wrong

gilded mason
#

@vague scroll
Agreed.

versed helm
#

^

remote spruce
#

Get rid of the covenant

vague scroll
#

By just redoubling the focus on the game's strongest qualities you can get a much more enjoyable product. Of course though, hindsight is 20/20.

#

The Created are the symptom of a similar issue.

#

By setting up the UNSC as a galactic superpower, the sense of the impending doom the Covenant set it self up to be is no longer present.

#

And thus, we needed a new big bad for fear the story wouldn't be as enjoyable.

last anchor
#

Sorta what happened to Star Wars

vague scroll
#

The Halo 5 marketing tied with the game we got shows that 343i likely wanted to do a lot with Halo 5 but couldn't fit everything in at the same time and make it work.

A combination of overambition and too many interesting ideas suffering from poor execution. They put too many eggs in one basket.

#

Calling back to that one interview where a 343i employee was bragging about how cool their engine for Halo 5 was that they threw one of the maps together and populated with fully animated, fully destructible cactus. Turned out it crashed the Xbox One hardware.

remote spruce
#

That is slightly more hilarious than Bungie stating how much AI they could fit on one screen then the actual game showing Tip of the Spear's intro as the only use of that

last anchor
#

Thats not even fully active AI either

vague scroll
#

Yeah Star Wars suffers to a degree of the super-massive threat syndrome but its a veteran to that issue rather being a new concept.

Rather, Disney failed to learn from the Star Wars EU they killed off and turned into Legends. And put several different contradictory visions at the helm of their new project.

The First Order wasn't given much to work with in terms of levity. It seems to be more powerful than the Empire and yet...not so.

The Yuzh Vong or however the group was pronounced from the New Jedi Order series is an example of needing to up the difficulty because the New Republic was too powerful a group.

A fully organic, non-Force involved super society with a pension for Borg-like assimulation and Mongol-like raid tactics is a cool concept on paper but a boring enemy in execution. They're just a big bad that was created for the Star Wars novels to have some threat to the Jedi who might as well be gods at the point in Luke Skywalker's career. He technically beat a god in the form of the Mother.

last anchor
#

The Vong. Ahh. THE VONG

vague scroll
#

Sorry its been a while since I checked on those New Jedi Order novels.

remote spruce
#

Forget The Created, Infinite is got to raise the stakes with The Rebooted

last anchor
#

Hehe

versed helm
#

Lol

vague scroll
#

Lmao, that was pretty good.

versed helm
#

Well it would depend on if Halo Infinite takes place after Halo 5

vague scroll
#

Its hinted at.

#

Halo Infinite's teaser had a time stamp of 2560.

#

You can find it on the dashboard computer of the crashed Pelican gunship.

remote spruce
#

I know Infinity is the most hated ship in Halo since the Phantom guns in Halo 2 legendary, but I hope it just doesn't blown up

vague scroll
#

Got to turn your video graphic setting way up to properly read it though.

gilded mason
#

but I hope it just doesn't blown up
Let that rust bucket fry!

vague scroll
#

I think it deserves to crash to keep up with the Halo motif that CE set up.

#

Every main Halo game is required to have a crashing starship as a set piece... apparently.

remote spruce
#

Yeah at least something that doesn't feel like another reset for the sake of resets

vague scroll
#

Or to escape from an exploding alien or human installation/ship

#

The Infinity I think deserves to crash but like Halo 4, just let it get back up at the point where the momentum of the game starts to shift.

last anchor
#

Commencing Warthog run

vague scroll
#

You know...the Infinity would probably be good for that.

#

Its going to get blown up isn't it?

gilded mason
#

Its going to get blown up isn't it?
Hell yeah.

remote spruce
#

Chief is the last Spartan because we gotta make players feel special

unique rune
#

That will make me upset.

vague scroll
#

Man. I've seen so much discussion and complaints about Halo 4 and 5, we really are banking on Infinite to be just decent...

remote spruce
#

I'm hoping it isn't just a complaint addresser

vague scroll
#

It's going to be very difficult to be great but at least be hopeful it puts people's faith in 343i to keep the series going.

#

Complaint addresser it shouldn't be but building on what didn't work before is a must.

remote spruce
#

Yes, but don't do a Jul is what I'm saying

vague scroll
#

Kill off one of their most interesting characters...yeah, please don't.

versed helm
#

Tbh,it would've been better if the Arbiter killed Jul

vague scroll
#

It would have been better that he not die at all.

gilded mason
#

It would have been better that he not die at all.
Indeed. I was always partial to Haru's imagining of it.

remote spruce
#

So at this point I'm expecting ICONIC and not much else

#

No wait, space deer

#

Yes space deer

last anchor
#

Yes

vague scroll
#

Halo 4 set up his story, Spartan Ops was intended to last several seasons but poor reception forced the narrative to get sidelined as Escalation. Then the Created plot was birthed and Reed came back and realized he had to kill off the ideas he put up in Halo 4 in the first place.

last anchor
#

Which is dume

#

And annoying

#

did Reed work on Halo 4?

gilded mason
#

did Reed work on Halo 4?

#

Spartan Ops

vague scroll
#

I'm still uncertain what his mindset or feeling about his story ideas were. I wonder if he had a lot of good ideas that just didn't work in translation. I definitely don't like how they turned out.

remote spruce
#

Spartan Ops

#

Spartan Dalton for Infinite

vague scroll
#

I honestly feel bad for him, with how everything turned out. Even if I don't like his work.

remote spruce
#

Actually what was with Infinity finding some ships that belonged to Spirit of Fire?

vague scroll
#

Since my anger against him evaporated, I've been feeling more just questioning how he's doing now and whether he had good intentions just dished out a poor hand.

last anchor
#

Pilgrims Pride had the Spirit's ID number I think

#

That might be it

vague scroll
#

Halo 4 and 5 were certainly his biggest projects to date and now he's out.

#

His last piece of work for the Halo franchise was the short Rossubach's World I believe.

remote spruce
#

Hood drinking alcohol part 1

vague scroll
#

Yeah, that was bad.

#

But he also gave us the Maya Sincar AI.

last anchor
#

You can tell he didnt really feel it

#

To be fair Hunt The Truth did but he gave us confirmation

vague scroll
#

True. That said, Rossbach's World is not a bad story. It's a rather decent short even and asks some very interesting questions.

#

Or at least explored some ideas.

remote spruce
#

Hunt The Truth is great
A cumulation of 343i's UNSC lore that adds further context

#

Like the idea that S-IIs were purposly selected from outer colonies

vague scroll
#

I've heard people despise it as well but its one of my favorite Halo lore pieces. I don't think there is a single Halo medium that has explored civilian life better than HTT.

#

They weren't by the way. That was sloppily put together data.

remote spruce
#

Oh

#

That explains Randall

vague scroll
#

Several Spartans were from inner colonies. Randall-037 is from Earth even.

#

Yeah.

#

If anything Mushak was simply wrong with his data.

remote spruce
#

Too much Unggoy Farmer

vague scroll
#

As a human character, he's biased. And by breaking Halo's own internal lore, it actually made the story better.

#

Or rather it omitted since it was never a proper retcon.

#

But I really want to just see more focus on the Halo universe from civilian eyes.

#

I don't care much for the Created plot. I care about Earth, Humanity, and the post-Covenant rump states that popped up.

versed helm
#

^

remote spruce
#

I like that part in season 2 where it talks about synthetic food

#

It's so random, but it's good

vague scroll
#

Jungle, Orca I believe you guys have heard me talk about some of my ideas for my fanfic writing but that's generally what I've been so badly aching to see anywhere in the Halo franchise, anywhere. Because I don't or I only see hints.

#

I don't mind seeing more romance in Halo, or more stories about children. But I want more grounded stories and I don't need to see more military or Spartan action, this series' universe is honestly too big to just be centered around that.

#

After reading Legacy of Onyx's first 4 chapters, I thought back to the prologue from PS4's The Last of Us and realized Halo could pump out some small scale story games. The idea that came into my head was like Joel's daughter but another child character dropped into the Halo universe over the course of days and weeks listening and watching news reports or hearing rumors at school or from neighbors while living a normal life at school or home just as the reports about the Guardian Custode's waking up across the galaxy. That in it self I feel could make for a decent short game demo not unlike Life is Strange or the Telltale games but significantly shorter.

cunning pawn
#

Nice job Tide

vague scroll
#

Im sorry

versed helm
#

Am I the only one that thinks it's kinda cool how Thel has a similar height and body size to Sun Mingming?

last anchor
#

It was cool

versed helm
#

Yeah.. Then they had to make him a Shadow of the Colossus boss battle

#

Elites are just way too big in Halo 5. Imposing stature is cool and all, but you want them to be small enough to resonate emotionally with human characters easily.

#

H2A Arbiter looked right

severe bone
#

In that sunaion level, the arbiter actually hunched to the smaller height when addressing Locke

#

After that he stood up and became big again

versed helm
#

He's still not supposed to be that tall. H2 Thel is tall enough that he would have to duck his head against my doorway, but he's not kissing the roof or anything like that

vivid dust
#

I feel like everything’s ridiculously bigger since Halo 4

#

Except the Marines who got smaller

narrow wadi
#

I am now a proud owner of Halo: New Blood!

obsidian thistle
#

Great :)

narrow wadi
#

I’m gonna finish First Strike and then I read that!

obsidian thistle
#

May I recommend Playing ODST again?

vivid dust
#

I need to start New Blood too

narrow wadi
#

I’ve literally been planning a Heroic ODST playthrough to start as my next Halo thing, actually

#

Continue the trend of playing through Halo games with the difficulty upped

versed helm
#

How good is Halo:Hunters In The Dark?

carmine sleet
#

I enjoyed reading it

remote spruce
#

uhhhhhhhhhhh

#

it's ok at best

fair hazel
#

Fun read

#

is there a halo book that I hated? Not realy so yeah

feral perch
#

It's one of the weakest books IMO

#

but it has information that other lore references

vague scroll
#

Particularly Halo Wars 2

remote spruce
#

it references how many times i lose in HW2

obsidian thistle
#

The only Halo books I am always frustrated by is the Halo Encyclopedia versions.

last anchor
#

With good reason.

#

Seriously, they made the United Rebel Front a THING because someone wrote that in Halopedia?

#

Come on guys.

vague scroll
#

That said, now that its been made a thing, its nice to have multiple Innie groups in the lore.

#

Reflects the reality of how messy a rebellion movement spread across an interstellar empire can be..

versed helm
#

True

last anchor
#

I like the Successionist Union. Kinda sounds like Rebel Alliance in a way, which I find amusing

charred flower
#

Seeing the above conversation about fanfiction, I've had a few ideas to write one that is one of a few concepts: a survival piece, one with hope in some form, a political and social story akin to a story you found in Fractures, or take a different genre and merge it with Halo's military sci fi

warm ingot
#

I always wanted to make a story similar to Halo ever since I first played it.

narrow wadi
#

I’ve been contemplating writing a story myself, I’ve been bouncing around the idea of a mixed ODST/Sangheli squad, but haven’t done anything with it

charred flower
#

IVe had a few ideas for over three years and just recently got the idea to try them again. Im busy with other writing right now; a HAlo story will have to wait

narrow wadi
#

Yeah, I’m similar, except my writing is crap

charred flower
#

Im developing my writing as well. Ijust got part of my degree in it; need to get it better anyhow

narrow wadi
#

Whoo! I’m happy for you.

charred flower
#

thanks!

versed helm
#

I'm also working on my own space fantasy universe

charred flower
#

Cool
I have a science fiction/futuristic single player game concept Ive worked on for over a year and a half

versed helm
#

I also have or had something of a fantasy or high fantasy concept as well

charred flower
#

cool deal

versed helm
#

I did some measurements for the heights of characters in H2A just for fun

#

From comparing Chief and Arbiter to Johnson, Chief measured around 2.15 meters, and Arbiter ~2.35 meters

#

which stacks up pretty well with the numbers given

#

but, when comparing Tartarus to Miranda with the same method, he only comes as ~2.5 meters tall - barely any larger than Thel

#

The official numbers, however, put Tartarus's height at another foot taller than that. thinkingchief

civic plank
#

I've always found Halo lore to be incredibly interesting

versed helm
#

Why?

unique rune
#

it tastes good

narrow wadi
#

Cuz it’s insanely interesting with loads to read and dissect, at least for me.

brisk cape
#

^^ that.

feral perch
#

Is there any indication of what the CPV-class actually stands for?

#

It's a heavy destroyer seen in Halo Wars and several graphic novels

#

but other than Covenant, I'm not sure what the abbreviation is.

feral perch
#

Hm. The one in Halo Wars is named the Proclamation's Tithe.

#

I wonder...

versed helm
#

I wonder if Lisbon Station has been compromised by the created

vague scroll
#

It's possible. The proximity to I05 makes it a priority target.

versed helm
#

How much of the galaxy does the Created control as of right now?

gilded mason
#

I guess a majority of the Orion Arm at least.

#

Unknown status for everywhere else.

versed helm
#

Now that i think about it...why would ONI betray Chief?

#

Like that whole Biko incident

severe elbow
#

My theory is that it was part of ONI's overall plan to discredit Ben Giraud. They likely filled the Master Chief in on it, and I doubt he minded. He likely doesn't really care about his public perception.

versed helm
#

Seems kind of disturbing..considering what eventually became of Ben Giraud

gilded mason
#

A bit, yeah

severe elbow
#

I doubt they told him specifically about Ben.

#

They would likely go "Hey, we need to paint you in this light for a tactical advantage over a bad element, OK?"

gilded mason
#

Though I like how in Kilo-5, Parang or Osman talked about how they would declassify the SII project, and then nothing ever came of it.

vague scroll
#

I believe she said she would eventually do it. Given how Hunt the Truth Season 1 ended with perpetual all-out civil war in the Outer Colonies, you have to admit that the unspoken truth is they simply decided to not go through with it.

Talking to focus groups and performing AI-run simulations likely proved to them that revealing it was impossible without the threat of civil war. Best then, to discredit the dirty laundry through Ben because the truth is crazier than the lie.

ONI is better set to manage a fringe element that propogates a truth the majority of the population already accepted as fake.

#

While it was ultimately someone of Michael Sullivan's pay grade or higher that concocted the Giraud false-flag operation, that might have beem Parangosky's legacy to Halsey to hang her dirty laundry out to dry. It was a half-truth when you look at how HTT played the plot out, ONI knew that someone like Mashak was going to put the pieces together eventually, so, they controlled the story instead.

remote spruce
#

Big Maggie didn't get her wish

#

That or she lied

vague scroll
#

White lie but still a lie. She owes Halsey nothing. She didn't need to tell her she would leak the S-IIs' stories. She did it for her conscience, at the end of the day. Some ego-stroking.

remote spruce
#

Big Maggie why

#

Can you imagine her reaction to the Created?
"Damnit another galaxy threat"

gilded mason
#

"I kinda caused this!"

remote spruce
#

"I'm going back to cryo sleep, wake me when you need someone to yell at you"

severe bone
#

Politics..how tiresome

vague scroll
#

Ruth Charet 2552!

versed helm
#

Is she still alive?

severe elbow
#

As of 2558.

dusk flint
#

oh god not the helmet footage

versed helm
#

Regarding the ending for Halo Wars 2,how is a Guardian Custode able to pull objects out of slipspace?

last anchor
#

Forerunner slipspace capabilities.

#

They knew how to use it way better than we do.

#

Its the Halo equivilent of the Star Wars universe's Interdicter

versed helm
#

It's also got me thinking about the Line Installations,how are they able to shoot down ships in slipspace

last anchor
#

Giant slipspace-tearing guns. We saw one in Bloodline and we saw one on Wreckage in 4

versed helm
#

Speaking of Wreckage..iirc..didn't the description for that map say that whatever planet that it's set on contains the remains of UNSC and Covenant ships,but also ships belonging to undiscovered species

last anchor
#

Yes.

carmine sleet
#

It did but it's not likely we'll learn who the unknown ships belonged to any time soon

versed helm
#

Seriously..i would love to see more alien races outside of the ones we already have,we know that other alien races inhabit the galaxy since all of the Halo media released within the last 7 years or so have mentioned the existence of other,unknown races that inhabit the Halo galaxy,most notably the unknown alien spacecraft that crash landed on Installation 04 as shown in the CE:A terminals...and i know i asked this before but it still bothers me

last anchor
#

First Order when

versed helm
#

But still,and i apologize if keep bringing it up but is there a reason as to why we don't see any other alien races outside of the ones we already have

last anchor
#

Series limitations. If you start throwing in new races willy-nilly, you start to dilute the core of the seires

#

See; the issues that the series had with the Brutes and Drones being introduced in Halo 2, and the Skirmishers in Reach.

#

Even Star Wars has problems with it to a certain extent. And the fact that for the most part the seires is human-centers

gilded mason
#

And the fact that for the most part the seires is human-centers
😔

versed helm
#

True..couple with the fact that most of the series takes place within the Orion Arm,the rest of the Milky Way Galaxy is unexplored

#

Which brings up another thought...how large was the Covenant's sphere of influence prior to the Great Schism?,did they control territories outside the Orion Arm?

last anchor
#

Probably not

versed helm
#

Remind me,wasn't there something that mentioned the reason as to why the Covenant never deployed their full military might against humanity

last anchor
#

Several. The Banished, for one reason. The Prophets wanting the war to drag on for as long as possible to ensure their rule. Religous dogma. The simple displacement of the Covenant's fleet and the requirement of keeping their existing empire intact

gilded mason
#

The Banished, for one reason.
Eh, the Banished were only a hit-and-run type of deal and only popped up during the very late years of the war.

versed helm
#

Makes me wonder,were they at war with other interstellar civilizations besides humanity

gilded mason
#

There were implications of it. Like Regret's dialogue in Halo Wars.

#

How too much of the Covenant focusing on humans would leave the Covenant defenceless.

versed helm
#

And something about Truth stating that "No enemy has ever withstood our might"

gilded mason
#

Though with Truth, you could say he means every other Covenant species before they got offered the chance to join up.

last anchor
#

They fought the Empire. THRAWN XD

versed helm
#

Remind me,didn't the Drones get inducted into the Covenant via a treaty

last anchor
#

I believe so

versed helm
#

And the Kig-Yar joined the Covenant only for monetary reasons

severe elbow
#

And they would be glassed if they didn't.

vague scroll
#

Welcome to the wider galaxy hingeheads. It only gets more crowded everyday!

versed helm
#

I wonder what the rest of Africa is like in the 26th Century,since they usually focus on Eastern Africa

fair hazel
#

lots of cities probably

dusk flint
#

arent they repopulating where the flood hit? after it was cheaply covered up by ONI?

last anchor
#

Nope. That whole area is a mile-deep glassland

#

Except around the Excission

fair hazel
#

The amount of glassage is exaggerated

#

Half a continent wasn’t literally glassed.

#

The area yes

versed helm
#

Hood exaggerates a lot

last anchor
#

Its still a lot of area thats glassed.

#

Even if it isnt half a continent its still several hundred kilometers at least

charred flower
#

new years means new Halo lore aye

versed helm
#

Does anyone remember how Blue Team held on to one another during Silent Storm's slingshot manoeuvre?

#

They were all grabbing on to each other to form a column during the 30 gee acceleration. For the Spartan behind John, they were holding fast with 35 metric tonnes of weight on their back, plus their own ~18 tonnes tugging on John's thruster pack. This is an insanely good feat; both for Spartan strength as well as the armour's tensile strength.

feral perch
#

Because science fiction

narrow wadi
#

Weird question cuz I’m talking with a friend

#

Spartan-IIIs were made from stolen kids, weren’t they?

#

I know IIs were, but my memory on III lore is fairly lacking

feral perch
#

IIIs were made from orphans of the Covenant War.

#

Their induction into the program was more consensual than the IIs.

narrow wadi
#

I gotcha.

#

I’m reading first strike now

#

I have never been so overjoyed to see Johnson before

versed helm
#

Jonny Jonny

#

Yes pa pa

#

Killing covenant

#

No pa pa

#

Telling lies?

last anchor
#

All the time

modest marsh
#

@obsidian thistle you know, after 3 years you'd think i would've noticed by now, but i just realized that the M820 Scorpion has a coaxial machine gun

craggy creek
#

I want to get nerdy about halo

#

I'm looking for all games/books/etc just for master chief era

#

Not sure where to start can anyone help a noob out

obsidian thistle
#

Thats a list of all Halo lore

#

I have plans to try and make that list more accessible somehow

versed helm
#

Done

craggy creek
#

@obsidian thistle you the best thank you

obsidian thistle
#

I aint the best. Just one fan giving you something you wanted :)

dusk flint
#

more flood to deal with for me

#

how ironic that a combat form was carrying a sentinel beam

obsidian thistle
#

You talking Halo 2? Halo 3?

dusk flint
#

2

dusk flint
#

time to go lower the containment shield at the sentinel wall

versed helm
#

I still wonder..what happened to 049 Abject Testament?

#

Seems kind of strange that a Forerunner monitor,especially one that's the caretaker of a Halo installation would just vanish like that

torpid sonnet
#

he went for a pizza

swift igloo
#

He could've just ordered the pizza though

lilac palm
#

the area glassed became known as the exclusion zone. Alpha Nine was deployed to make sure the flood were no longer there. They weren't.

#

Maybe testament was in hibernation? 343 guilty spark would do it at times as seen in the Halo CE terminals

#

Maybe the area glassed was terraformed

#

or at least ONI is planning to.

narrow wadi
#

I was musing on this, and I wanna check if my logic here is false

#

I was thinking about how Truth was likely the biggest factor in the Covenant losing the Human/Covenant war in the end

#

Specifically because of the Great Schism, and his alienation of the Covenant’s warrior class being something that they just couldn’t recover from

onyx vigil
#

You are not wrong I think that he believed that since his goals where close the sanghelli would not matter because there would be no long game… how wrong he was

narrow wadi
#

Here’s his greatest issue as far as canon goes

#

Was assuming that the Brutes would work as front-line troops

#

Cuz the Brutes just aren’t good for that. They’re good as heavies and as a last resort, as well as for defence, but if you’re forcing them to adhere to tactics, and plans, it’s deminishing their effectiveness

#

There’s a reason why in Halo 3, the most terrifying Brutes are ones with Hammers. They play to their strength, others often do not

vague scroll
#

Gameplay wise, they're limited in their weaponry and tactics, however, Brutes are terrifying and would make great combat troops as shown by Halo: Landfall and the dioramas from Halo 3: Believe.

vivid dust
#

the fact that you could see them destroy Marines with a single punch or throw them against walls helps too

narrow wadi
#

That’s the thing

#

Brutes are best when they’re, well, being brutish

#

Conforming to strategies and tactics just isn’t their MO

vague scroll
#

They're an intelligent species, they can do more than be a checklist on alien stereotypes.

narrow wadi
#

SOME obviously do this, Tartarus and Atriox both come to mind, but by and large, giving the average brute armour and telling him to do the tasks of an elite isn’t going to be as efficient as having elites do it

#

The issue is that Truth just isn’t using them effectively

#

Elites are trained in military doctrine and combat, to a far greater extent. They’re more tactical and it shows through technology like Active Camoflage.

Brutes trained in tactics can do the jobs of elites, but the way Truth did it, just swapping them out, isn’t going to be as effective, and even if he did train them, some of the benefits that they bring would be wasted because of the simple fact that they’re so large that stealth and recon is a great challenge.

vague scroll
#

size doesn't determine if someone can be quiet.

narrow wadi
#

No but it does mean they’d stick out

vague scroll
#

Active camo negates any issues of that matter

narrow wadi
#

And while we know certain brutes are very good at stealth, it’s harder to be so than the Sangheli

vague scroll
#

As a counter argument, Elites don't make good ground troops because they're too honor-bound to take the necessary actions in a fight.

#

Either way, they're stereotypes, if you want to look at lore - all species should be looked on as a different flavor of human in a different body form and different culture. For the most case, aliens and humans should be able to adapt to most situations.

narrow wadi
#

My point here is effectively “when Truth tried to switch the Elites with the brutes, he did so poorly since the Brutes weren’t expected to handle these tasks prior”

#

Brutes of higher ranks stood better in the change, and as such were more dangerous, but your standard brutes were less so, because they were trained instead in using overwhelming force to take down targets, and not things like strategies

#

That’s why Brutes were dropped into New Alexandria during Reach, for example

#

The entire reason being “they’re more effective at killing, but less trained in things like strategies and objectives, where Elites are overall more effective@

vague scroll
#

I find it hard to agree with you when gameplay doesn't account for lore.

#

There were Elite and Brute units prevalent through the entirety of New Alexandria.

#

Brutes were heavily present in Exodus but that was more for the sake of enemy diversity.

#

Can't spend your entire game fighting Elites all day.

narrow wadi
#

But at the same time, my point here still applies

#

They dropped Brutes into heavily populated areas cuz they’re better at killing in high numbers

#

Whereas in the next mission, they largely had elites guarding the jammers, cuz Elites are better in that role

vague scroll
#

They only had one variant of the objectives in New Alexandria that was guarded by Elites

narrow wadi
#

Still, my opinion is basically just “Truth messed up by replacing the elites with brutes that didn’t have the same training and therefore lacked the skills needed.”

vague scroll
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

I consider it more Covenant politics than anything else. The lack of experience of Brutes in starship officer positions and their actual lack of experience regarding technology and maintainence is really what I consider to have done them in. Especially since the Brutes lost the ensuing Blooding Years against the Sangheili after the San'Shyuum disappeared and the Jiralhanae started fighting among themselves.

narrow wadi
#

That’s what I mean, tbh.
The Brutes were thrown into roles they had little to no experience in and were expected to operate with the same efficiency as the Sangheli, and while on the ground, they could adapt, their lack of skill in space combat was their true downfall

vague scroll
#

Yeah but I fail to see that their downfall can be accounted to their status as a species.

narrow wadi
#

Rtas basically summed it up as “3 brute ships vs 1 elite ship is an even fight” and that’s fairly accurate, given the Sangheli had decades of training in theses areas, and at most the Brutes has a few months

#

And I’ll agree that I was a little too harsh

#

Sorry

vague scroll
#

nah, not harsh at all, just an opinion I didn't agree with because it looked like you were using gameplay as an explanation.

#

so no problem, no need to apologize

narrow wadi
#

Yeah, I was using gameplay as well

#

I’ll still stand by the fact that the covenant would have been way more effective in combat if they used Brutes as heavies rather than just keeping them largely as defence

#

Using a bunch of Sangheli and light troops like grunts and jackals to keep them back and then using a Brute with a hammer to break their lines would be very effective for a strategy

vague scroll
#

I'll take that opinion, that's a valid concern, not sure if I agree with it but I can see that being a decent explanation

narrow wadi
#

Mhm, it’s just an idea I was musing on with the Beutes

#

*Brutes

#

In a side note, Johnson was in his seventies when he died

#

That’s fairly ridiculous

vague scroll
#

SPARTAN-1/Orion augs, also gene therapy extending the human lifespan

narrow wadi
#

I’m aware, but I’m still allowed to be like “can I look that good when I’m his age”

vague scroll
#

I wish too...

elder mica
#

You know why he looks that good?

#

Cos he knows what the ladies like.

versed helm
#

Brutes would be very low on my list of Covenant species to fight.

#

Probably only above Hunters. Brutes sheer size, man you'd be dead if you didn't get the jump on them. Same with Elites I suppose though.

#

That's one of the things that makes the UNSC so heroic to me. Regardless of role, or task, they very rarely ever had the upper hand. The average UNSC Marine has to be absurdly brave to go up against a Brute or Elite.

#

Silent Storm really highlighted that to me.

modest marsh
#

Engaging any Covenant species in direct combat is substantial risk

#

Their ability to kill you significantly outweighs the feasibility of you killing them

tropic ginkgo
#

Fighting to keep your species from going extinct is probably a good motivation

narrow wadi
#

Yep.
And I will say, there’s one race where you could fight them in Direct Combat and win, and that’s Engineers

feral perch
#

that's cruel

narrow wadi
#

One on one, you win every time, but the Engineer is more likely to fix your gear than even try to fight

#

So just have a heart, make a friend, and win

feral perch
#

I say you could win a fight with a drone

narrow wadi
#

Are you armed?

#

Oh, and is this fight one v one?

feral perch
#

unarmed 1v1

severe elbow
#

The Drone just needs to grab you, lift you up, and drop you.

narrow wadi
#

The San’Shyuum, then

feral perch
#

So kick it first

#

Unless it's a Prelate

narrow wadi
#

Given their current state, you could beat a San’Shyuum down without really even having to try

severe elbow
#

I feel like I could beat up a Yonhet.

narrow wadi
#

I could beat up a Lekgolo

gilded mason
#

I feel like I could beat up a Yonhet.
They are made to be bullied.

narrow wadi
#

Seriously anyone could kill a Lekgolo

#

Just stamp on it

tropic ginkgo
#

Egnineers are so adorable, save them 😦

narrow wadi
#

That’s why I commented on it cuz I had to, but then explained the best way to win against them is to make a friend

carmine sleet
#

Engineers are definitely a nice addition to the franchise, being a passive enemy that you can ignore without any repercussion for doing so. Hoping they show up again in future FPS Halo games

severe elbow
#

Well, the repurcussion is that they give the enemy more shields.

carmine sleet
#

True

#

Forgot about that bit

#

Then again, if all the other enemies are dead... thinkingchief

severe elbow
#

And if we're talking Halo Wars, their healing basically necessitates taking them out first.

carmine sleet
#

Also true

narrow wadi
#

I need to play more Wars

#

I’m only up to Arcadia Outskirts (I just beat that level, I dunno what’s next)

severe elbow
#

Next is Dome of Light.

#

I still haven't played the Definitive Edition I got with Halo Wars 2. I feel shame.

narrow wadi
#

Do you get it when you install it, or is that an extra thing you get only with certain editions?

#

If it’s an install, I’m downloading Wars 2 now, so I can play without needing the disk in my machine

severe elbow
#

You get it if you got the Ultimate Edition of Halo Wars 2 (different from the Complete Edition).

#

Otherwise it's a standalone digital purchase.

narrow wadi
#

Ah, I was wondering about that

#

I nearly got the ultimate edition

#

But it costs 70!

#

For context, I got my copy of the standard edition of Wars 2 for £15

severe elbow
#

Where are you seeing that price? The Xbox Store?

narrow wadi
#

In the shop where I bought my copy of Wars 2

carmine sleet
#

CEX by any chance Minny?

narrow wadi
#

Like the copy they sold of Wars 2 with Wars 1 and Awakening the Nightmare was £70, the pre-owned copy was £15

#

No, Game

#

CeX is actually decent as far as pricing goes

carmine sleet
#

Ah, I see

severe elbow
#

The Ultimate Edition doesn't have Awakening the Nightmare. It has HWDE and the Season Pass.

#

The Complete Edition has the Season Pass and Awakening the Nightmare, no HWDE.

#

I'm not sure if the Ultimate Edition is sold physically anymore. That may be why the price was higher.

feral perch
#

I got a physical copy of the Ultimate Edition. It was fun, going through the season pass, waiting to see what the new leaders would be.

carmine sleet
#

Shame there aren't going to be any more added

modest marsh
#

@feral perch Drones are 200lbs on average and have natural armor + weapons with their spikes and claws

severe elbow
#

Yeah but the game got a lot of DLC, especially compared to the first game.

modest marsh
#

You’d lose every time without a weapon

severe elbow
#

But I bring the gun show with me wherever I go.

#

flexes

modest marsh
#

Chitinous exoskeletons don’t care how hard you punch them

versed helm
#

Are we talking about Skyrim

modest marsh
#

Also the advantage of flight can’t be understated

#

When your opponent is tougher, at least as strong, is anatomically weaponized, and completely trounces your mobility, trying to beat one down with your barehands is hopeless

#

Maybe someone with decent H2H skills could manage a grapple hold to subdue one, but the viability of that is minuscule to say the least

#

@narrow wadi Engineers significantly outmuscle humans and would easily protect themselves from a physical assault

#

Plus they can

#

You know

#

Fly

versed helm
#

Halo Wars is definitely worth playing/completing.

#

Saying that as someone who didn't play the original Halo Wars till this past fall.

narrow wadi
#

I love Forge

versed helm
#

He's a solid character.

versed helm
#

I understand the irony and potential redundancy of asking this in a Halo discord...but are the comics worth the dosh? I've been eye-balling Escalation for a while and figure I should go ahead and pick em up. Never gotten a Halo comic before.

gilded mason
#

Escalation, not so much.

versed helm
#

Why? Just low quality?

gilded mason
#

Basically.

severe elbow
#

The first seven issues are good.

gilded mason
#

Those are with Thel, right?

severe elbow
#

And the later ones have at least some cool moments.

#

First three are with Thel, yeah.

gilded mason
#

Then I agree

feral perch
#

Rise of Atriox is your best bet @versed helm

#

It's solid pretty much all the way through

gilded mason
#

Though one other nice thing to come of Escalation is the Sangheili Ayit ‘Sevi.

feral perch
#

Though issue 4 was a tad confusing

versed helm
#

Gotcha.

#

I've heard overwhelmingly positive things on Rise of Atriox, so no suprise there.

gilded mason
#

I kinda just felt like rolling my eyes throughout Rise of Atriox. Not so much the comic itself (kinda) but because how hypocritical Atriox is compared to the comic and game.

versed helm
#

Atriox was criminally under utilized in HW2 IMO.

gilded mason
#

Everyone was

#

Let Volir got three lines of dialogue and one brief appearance

versed helm
#

He's basically just the stereotypical "angry brute dude" until the last mission.

feral perch
#

He kinda just treats humans as lowly fodder

severe elbow
#

The Shipmaster is 2's Brute Chieftan, except he actually gets to participate in the story.

feral perch
#

un what

#

*um

narrow wadi
#

Do you mean Tartarus?

versed helm
#

@versed helm check the pinned messages in this channel for a full list of halo media while your interest is high :) it’s the first link to halo waypoint

severe elbow
#

No, as in Halo Wars 1, the three Covenant Leaders were the Arbiter, the Prophet of Regret, and the Brute Chieftan, who didn't participate in the story. In Halo Wars 2, the three Banished Leaders are Atriox, Decimus, and the Shipmaster, who has a small role in the story, only slightly better than the Brute Chieftan in the first game.

gilded mason
#

Though I don’t know why they call him “Shipmaster” when he actually has a name.

feral perch
#

for people who don't bother to know what anything is beyond the simplest terms

#

some people still call the Banished the Covenant

#

just

#

pls

severe elbow
#

shrug

versed helm
#

Oh yeah

#

Oooooh yeah

#

I just recently started playing HW2 with some friends who have had it for a long time, and I literally had to shove it down their throats that the banished are not convenant and to stop calling them that

obsidian thistle
#

Kinda a shame about the Chieftain in the og Halo Wars. External media for him made him out to be somewhat interesting only for him to be made bonus material only pretty much.

versed helm
#

@versed helm Thanks. Unfortunately I've already worked my way through almost all of the books, games and shows/media. All I've got left is the comics.

#

Only books I haven't read are Legacy of Onyx and Battle Born(which just came out yesterday) lol.

narrow wadi
#

I’ve got to read a tonne of the lore now, and I’m currently chipping my way through First Strike

#

It’s a bloody good read

versed helm
#

Nylunds books are the best.

#

Enjoy them.

versed helm
#

Speaking of the Brute Chieftain from HW1..whatever became of him

remote spruce
#

unknown, maybe he's leading a faction

fair hazel
#

I read out battle born already @versed helm

versed helm
#

Cool.

#

Did you enjoy it?

fair hazel
#

Yeah

versed helm
#

What's the general consensus on Silent Storm? I finished it earlier this week and it might be my favorite Halo novel since Ghosts of Onyx and Nylunds other masterpieces.

gilded mason
#

I liked the Covenant parts quite a bit, though I think it was a mistake to have them suffer a defeat like that so early in the war. Also, Nizat is great and I hope we see more of him.

versed helm
#

Why do you think it was a mistake?

gilded mason
#

Eh, just think it was too big a blow to them after such a small amount of time had passed.

versed helm
#

Can't say I hold the same opinion, but each to their own.

maiden mica
#

Does the Flood show up on Thermal scans/scopes/visors?

versed helm
#

I'd imagine so considering they're bio-mass and probably put off heat.

versed helm
#

How old is ONI?

#

@versed helm it was founded in 2178

#

I wonder if they are descended from the CIA and FBI

#

Likely

unique rune
#

Probably more descended from the real life Office of Naval Intelligence.

charred flower
#

does that actually exist?

unique rune
#

yes

#

US Navy has its own Office of Naval Intelligence

#

been around since like WWII

#

er no
scratch that
been around since the 1880s

charred flower
#

ahh

vivid dust
#

hide your six-year olds

versed helm
#

I wonder if it's possible to create something similar to the Spartan programs in real life

clear wren
#

Most probably... but we're far off it.

versed helm
#

And it might break like God knows how many international and ethics laws

carmine sleet
#

Powered assault armour is being developed I believe

unique rune
#

Powered exoskeletons are in the works...

clear wren
#

Wonder what'll happen when theres masive war and people have those...

versed helm
#

How would a Silent Shadow elite fare against a Zealot?

#

Or an Ultra

narrow wadi
#

From everything I’ve seen, they’d win

#

Fairly handily

versed helm
#

Command Zealot

#

Not the fat and slow ones from Halo 4 and 5

narrow wadi
#

The Silent Shadow are noted as being able to kill Spartan-IIs fairly capably

#

They’d win

carmine sleet
#

@versed helm You say they're fat and slow yet they do move like Elites from previous games during gameplay

narrow wadi
#

^^^^%

versed helm
#

I've never seen them dive or evade at all, what are you talking about?

#

@carmine sleet

#

Not once has there ever been an instance when I'm playing H4 and 5 and thought "whoa, that elite is pretty quick!"

#

Though Rtas and the Elites from Hunters in the Dark, now those guys are fast for sure

vivid dust
#

since Reach their movements just look dumb imo

#

also the feet

versed helm
#

Reach Elites weren't exactly the greatest, either. At least they still had some nimble animations with their Evade ability, though - as well as how strong they felt being a plus.

vague scroll
#

You heard it here first folks: 343i is recommended to move forward with Elite character designs to have a dodge-roll that moves at the speed of sound.

torn comet
#

plz make elite awesome like halo 3. plz 343i

narrow wadi
#

So they aren’t there at all as enemies?

#

Interesting tactic

vivid dust
#

Lmao

vague scroll
#

Stealth Elites just evolved into something greater.

torpid sonnet
#

if the Halo2a armor elites return in infinite i am gonna be so pshyced

vivid dust
#

I don't mind the Halo 4 armors honestly

severe elbow
#

I like 4's Zealot design a lot.

torpid sonnet
#

they have grown on me too

#

but i love the halo2a armors

#

since banished used them are they still canon

narrow wadi
#

I like the Halo 4 and 5 armours a lot

torpid sonnet
#

they seem more realistic for that elite type

#

imagien then in h2a armors

#

lols

vivid dust
#

I don't like the Elites beneath it but I hope the armors make it into Infinite

narrow wadi
#

I was looking at the H3 armour designs and they really reminded me as to the fact that they don’t really look as good as we remember them to be

vivid dust
#

eh I like them too

#

but the Elites also had hecking big feet

versed helm
#

Hello

severe elbow
#

Hey.

vivid dust
#

hi

cyan kraken
#

Hi.

clever fable
#

It'd be neat if we could get more frequent tidbits of world building in the vein of map descriptions without the 3+ year delay between games. Small bite sized, maybe even novella-esque types of things released once a month alongside one of 343i's weekly/monthly posts on waypoint.

#

I think they got close to that with the idea behind the stuff found in the loot crate idea, but I feel like that might be restricted to too small a part of the audience, and inevitably doesn't attract as many people as the idea should.

#

It's a big galaxy full of possible stories, so why not make it feel that way, eh?

severe elbow
#

Well, we get around three books most years.

obsidian thistle
#

And a referece book

severe elbow
#

2018, three years after Halo 5, we got the physical release of Smoke and Shadow, an issue of Rise of Atriox, Collateral Damage, Bad Blood, Silent Storm, Fireteam Raven, and the Spartan Field Manual.

clever fable
#

Although true, in retrospect that didn't really stack up for me as big as it looks as a list.

#

Raven worked well as a game for friends, but ironically it's the kind of story that I'd like to see short descriptions of in those types of posts. I don't know how things work behind the scenes, but if there's any other offshoot narratives like that, that don't pan out for sellable products, I'd like to see them salvaged for this instead of possibly being buried and forgotten.

#

It'd mean no loss of money, and more material for the fans to appreciate.

feral perch
#

Silent Storm and the hardcover collection of Rise of Atriox were probably the best items from 2018 as far as Halo lore goes.

severe elbow
#

I think I'd put Bad Blood and Smoke and Shadow before Rise of Atriox, but yeah, Atriox was pretty good.

feral perch
#

Bad Blood was good but

#

It had a ridiculous number of typos and/or printing errors

#

Quality control got really lazy

severe elbow
#

I do remember it having two different names for the planet the Hole in the Wall was on, and the time Buck spent in Spartan-IV training was wrong.

#

But it's rare that kind of thing affects my overall enjoyment of something.

obsidian thistle
#

Ah that wrong name thing

feral perch
#

No, it was way more pervasive than that. It was distracting to me.

obsidian thistle
#

Where I had a whole idea of the planet orbiting two suns

#

No one has killed that idea yet lol

versed helm
#

They should make a novelization of fireteam raven

severe elbow
#

They pretty much summed it up in that Canon Fodder.

versed helm
#

I’d prefer a more in-depth version though

#

Not just a little summary

obsidian thistle
#

Well

#

You have Halo: The Flood

#

And Halo CE/CEA

#

With that two things you already have 90% of the story Raven gives us

#

The other 10% is original which the game gives us

grave swift
#

I think Raven would probably make for a better comic series than a novel tbh

severe elbow
#

I just want it on Xbox. 🙏

grave swift
#

That's fair. I'd kill for a good light gun game on the Xbox.

obsidian thistle
#

I'd prefer Spartan Strike

#

I love that game and want more to experience it

tropic ginkgo
#

Never did get to play it, is there any good story meat to it?

obsidian thistle
#

Its a great companion story to Halo 2 and Halo 4. Explaining stuff from those games kinda.

For Halo 2 is explains 1 possible reason Regret fled earth.
For Halo 4 it explains where the Covies went during the final mission in the game.

vivid dust
#

Where did they go?

obsidian thistle
#

They went to gamma Halo

vivid dust
#

huh

remote spruce
#

Infinity was there too
Somehow

severe elbow
#

What?

obsidian thistle
#

Infinity was not there

#

Infact we never actually learnt how one of the Headhunters got to New Phoenix from Gamma Halo so fast

gilded mason
#

Neural physics.

remote spruce
#

Wait so if Infinity is not there....

carmine sleet
#

Infinity has been to Gamma Halo, just not during the events of Halo 4

obsidian thistle
#

Yea I believe you are confusing stuff.

Infinity was at I03 prior to Halo 4. Its one reason they found John.

But it didnt return to Gamma Halio prior to it vanishing

#

If you are refering about one of SSs final cutscenes. Either its archive footage from one visit to Gamma Halo, a stylised look at Delta or Zeta, or a creation of Roland to prove a point.

versed helm
#

The gravemind In halo 2, he’s the highest form of flood intelligence????

narrow wadi
#

No

#

There’s a form greater, called a Keymond

#

*Keymind

#

Phone keyboard

versed helm
#

But he is the highest we’ve seen in game?

narrow wadi
#

Yes

gilded mason
#

You were correct the first time. The Gravemind is the ultimate form.

#

The Gravemind is a type of Keymind, the highest one.

narrow wadi
#

I read that a Keymind was a Gravemind that consumed an entire planet’s ecosystem?

#

And basically became the last step

gilded mason
#

Heard that as well, but it was either changed or expanded on in HW2.

versed helm
#

Okay, can there be two graveminds? Per say one on one side of the galaxy and the other on another

gilded mason
#

Yeah.

#

They'd be the same person, though.

versed helm
#

Do flood have some kind of telepathic communication that allows them to be one over large quantities of space??

gilded mason
#

Yeah

narrow wadi
#

Yes, through Precursor tech

vague scroll
#

Neural physics

narrow wadi
#

That’s how the Flood Gravemind the Chief and Arbiter meets shares the memories of the Gravemind from the Forerunner-Flood war

versed helm
#

Hmmmmmm so all graveminds keyminds, they’ve alway ever been just the same “person”

narrow wadi
#

Pretty much.

dusk flint
#

you could say that

versed helm
#

Yeah not the most accurate assessment but a laymen’s explanation, soooooooo the origin of the flood? Can be tracked down to one precursor? Because I saw something the other day that said the gravemind is a kind of reincarnation of a precursor who knew what the flood was capable of

severe elbow
#

More than one Precursor.

versed helm
#

So they all turned into the flood, or the dust did

severe elbow
#

The origin of the Gravemind is a single Precursor known as the Primordial.

versed helm
#

Okay that’s what I was getting at

dusk flint
#

the dust got corrupted

versed helm
#

I thought he was executed

gilded mason
#

He got better

severe elbow
#

The dust was used by ancient humans to domesticate an animal known as a Pheru. Over generations, it corrupted and became the Flood.

versed helm
#

Got better from death?

severe elbow
#

The Primordial's body was destroyed, but Graveminds inherit its memories.

gilded mason
#

Yes.

dusk flint
#

idk how corrupted dust can create the flood

gilded mason
#

Neural physics.

severe elbow
#

Corrupted dust of godlike beings.

versed helm
#

Okay so all that escaped turned into this star dust, do you think there’s any chance there’s any still alive? Maybe even trapped?

gilded mason
#

Possibly.

dusk flint
#

so gods became this never ending death machine known as the flood

#

if the primordial was released from zeta halos test fire then there might be others

versed helm
#

And was the cure the humans developed real? Did the activation of the rings really destroy it?

gilded mason
#

No real cure was found

#

It was a ruse

dusk flint
#

it was the closest

severe elbow
#

The cure was a lie. What humans thought worked was just the Flood retreating of its own accord to trick them into thinking there was a cure.

dusk flint
#

the primordial was known to lie

versed helm
#

Wait released?

dusk flint
#

?

versed helm
#

The forerunners fired the ring as a last resort right? Ending them and everyone else but your telling me that the primordial survived ? What did he do??

#

He still turned himself into star dust?

dusk flint
#

they fired the entire array i think not just the one

gilded mason
#

@versed helm
Primordial was already a Gravemind when they fired the rings

versed helm
#

Mmmmmmm

#

Okay thanks for clearing that up

#

Thanks for the help guys! Much appreciated

gilded mason
#

Got any other questions?

versed helm
#

Hmmm I don’t think so, maybe after i watch another video

dusk flint
#

the primordial was a cross between a gravemind and the other thing

versed helm
#

Wait I got one, had the humans not been fighting a war on both fronts could they have beaten the forerunners ??

severe elbow
#

They would have stood more of a chance.

gilded mason
#

Probably not

versed helm
#

That’s probably more of an opinion based question though

severe elbow
#

Forerunners and ancient humans were on approximately the same tech tier at the time.

dusk flint
#

im welling to bet the Forerunners would still win

versed helm
#

Right, though the precursors redacted and chose the humans over them

gilded mason
#

They only chose humans to be the next to be tested, right?

dusk flint
#

Faber tested on humans

versed helm
#

Ohhhhh I thought they were just outright chosen to be holders of the mantle

dusk flint
#

they were I belive

#

Faber tested on humans during the Forerunner flood war

#

first for a cure then for pleasure

#

cause the Gravemind/Primordial gave him something that was similar to the logic plague

severe elbow
#

The Master Builder wasn't affected by any sort of logic plague.

dusk flint
#

something similar

gilded mason
#

Ah, found it:
Primordial: “Through long study. The decision is final. Humans will replace you. Humans will be tested next.”

dusk flint
#

not the logic plague

gilded mason
#

The last part in particular.

severe elbow
#

No, he wasn't. The Master Builder wasn't affected by the Primordial in any way.

dusk flint
#

then why did he experiment on humans for mendican bias and the precurser for pleasure?

severe elbow
#

If you're talking about the experiments on Zeta Halo, those were done by Mendicant Bias after he defected.

#

Wait.

dusk flint
#

Bias determined if the humans were fit enough

severe elbow
#

OK, he ordered the experiments, but it wasn't because of the Primordial. It was to see if a cure could be found. Any pleasure he took in it is because he's not a good person.

dusk flint
#

and Bias continued to do this after he got infected with the logic plague

severe elbow
#

Bias got infected from the logic plague from communicating with the Primordial.

dusk flint
#

after the 40 year conversation

versed helm
#

Is there a theory that the flood are the test the precursors set for the humans?

dusk flint
#

not from what i know

#

and the flood originated from the precursors

#

cause the dust got corrupted remember

unique rune
#

I think I've heard that thrown around a couple of times... on Waypoint, at least, when I used Waypoint on a regular basis.

dusk flint
#

why give the humans a test that they could not complete

versed helm
#

Yes I remember lol
But we’re talking about godlike beings who were able to create all life in the universe, maybe they could manipulate all facets of the universe at will

dusk flint
#

what

#

who said what to me

versed helm
#

What?

gilded mason
#

I tried to say something about the Flood to you, but apparently it was a bad word.

dusk flint
#

what were you going to say

#

they really are

#

im welling to bet the Keymind looks like a beefier gravemind

severe elbow
#

@gilded mason Please don't try to bypass the filter.

gilded mason
#

Uh, okay.
Oh, never realized that was profanity until now. Huh. That makes more sense now.

severe elbow
#

We know what at least one type of Keymind looks like with the Abomination in Halo Wars 2.

#

Juggernauts are one step down from Keyminds, to and have some similar abilities.

dusk flint
#

whats the keymind from halo wars 2

#

as in what does it look like

severe elbow
versed helm
#

I've always wanted to fight inside an assault carrier

gilded mason
#

I've always wanted to travel inside one.

#

Though I wonder how much of a pain it would be to get from place to place.

versed helm
#

Sounds like fun to me, certainly not painful

#

Imagine using a Banshee inside one

gilded mason
#

"Minor, what have I told you about using military equipment for recreation?"

versed helm
#

At least they aren't as bad as the humans. I've heard that some of those guys like to flip their vehicles with their own landmines on occasion

gilded mason
#

How awful!

versed helm
#

largest deployment of Spartans in battle???

#

Would that be on requiem???

severe elbow
#

It would be Operations: TOREDO and PROMETHEUS.

versed helm
#

How many we talkin, what program if ya don’t mind me asking

severe elbow
#

Requiem would be close, but the Spartan-III Operations deployed the near-entirety of the Companies.

#

Around 300 each.

versed helm
#

Sheeesh

#

Do we win those battles

severe elbow
#

There are about 300 or more Spartan-IVs on the Infinity, but they were probably not all deployed.

#

They were pyrrhic victories. All but two Spartan-IIIs died.

gilded mason
#

Do we win those battles
The UNSC lives through Requiem, but they do not accomplish what they set out to do.

versed helm
#

Nice, I saw something like 400 ones Time but that seems close enough

#

Wasn’t asking about requiem ... was asking about the two he mentioned

gilded mason
#

Ah.

versed helm
#

And Jesus did they perform bad or were they stacked against the odds???

#

Wouldn't MJONLIR's integrated thrusters be a form of nuclear propulsion, since their energy source comes from tue fusion reactor on their back?

#

You don’t have to completely break it down

#

If ya don’t want too

severe elbow
#

Stacked odds. They were suicide missions.

versed helm
#

Damn, we’re they deployed as the main fighting force or were they aided? Marines? ODSTs?

severe elbow
#

No Marines or ODSTs.

versed helm
#

I’ll look up the nature of the operations

#

Thanks again!

versed helm
#

What became of the Pheru after the Forerunner era?..did they go extinct?

grizzled marsh
#

I would assume they would, either through the Flood or through the firing of the Halo array.

versed helm
#

I also wonder what the Pheru even looked like

grizzled marsh
#

Wasn't there a description of them in Cryptum?

versed helm
#

shrugs

versed helm
#

How deep does glassing go?
Does the ground actually turn to glass?
How does a planet get deglassed?

vivid dust
#

nanobots

versed helm
#

@vivid dust 😂😂😂

plush jetty
#

So can someone explain the time anomaly in First Strike? From my understanding, the crystal on Reach altered time to seem fast right? Going to Installation 04 seemed like it was 3 weeks but was really only a few days? Or was there teleportation of some sort involved?

#

I've read the books years ago and am now coming back to reading them again

vivid dust
safe siren
#

That could have speed-up their passage, and we don't know it's interaction with human technology, so the 'time travel' could be a side effect

versed helm
#

Reading first strike the first time hurt my head

versed helm
#

Why?

vague scroll
#

Probably the time dilation thing.

versed helm
#

^

last anchor
#

Ahh yes

upper star
#

Happy New year guys and gals

#

Don't know if I am late or not, has a battle born discussion already happened?

unique rune
versed helm
#

If the UNSC and SOS end up finding Charum Hakkor,could they find anything useful that they can use to fight the Created?

#

Anything that somehow survived both the final battle of the Human-Forerunner wars and the test firing of Installation 07

vague scroll
#

Maybe, I was considering a fanfic with that idea being the crux of the narrative but I ultimately ditched it because it was too close to the main plot of Halo in terms of significance, and on the other hand, seemed too much like an out-of-nowhere plot macguffin.

versed helm
#

Is it possible that Chips Dubbo and/or Stacker are part of the ORION project?

#

Maybe Durvall from Reach could also be

last anchor
#

Stacker most likely. Also Byrne from Contact Harvest is mentioned to possibly be part too

obsidian thistle
#

Best not to assume. We dont know how much of their backstories are canon.

vague scroll
#

The only that matters is that everyone understands that Chips Dubbo is the hero we deserve.

versed helm
#

Chips dubbo

#

Where is he now

grizzled marsh
#

Hmmm, well we don't have any direct confirmation from any of the games. It's possible that he was at Requiem if he's still apart of the Corps, due to the scale of operations there.

obsidian thistle
#

Its also possible he died in Halo 3

#

Or CE

#

Or at New Mombasa

#

Or its possible he was never canon at all

narrow wadi
#

Chips Dunno is Schrodinger’s Marine

obsidian thistle
#

A lot of marines are like that lol

narrow wadi
#

But Chips is the one everyone knows

obsidian thistle
#

That said a soldier seperate from Chiefs Alpha Halo survivors did survive Alpha Halo somehow

#

So its possible Chipps actually was a Alpha Halo survivor

narrow wadi
#

I’m just imagining that scene in First Strike

#

Johnson, an ODST, a Pilot, an ONI spook... and Chips

grave swift
#

Chips lives on in our hearts and shows up when we need him most.

obsidian thistle
#

Well we have no idea how Thomas Chang survived Alpha Halo. But how I am almost betting it included Stacker and Chips.

versed helm
#

I believe wholeheartedly that Byrne was part of ORION, beyond a shadow of a doubt.

#

There's no way that he isn't. He freaking threw Johnson across half a room, splintered wood, and was just giving Avery an unrealistic amount of trouble had he been unaugmented. Unless he's just coincidentally the 26th century's strongest man alive.

haughty bridge
#

Anyone here read the cryptum books?

#

Cause i know everything bout the forerunners now

#

I think

#

Ask me anything

#

Bout them

obsidian thistle
#

Okie dokie then. You asked for it. If I were to show you a "blue" symbol. What sorta thing is that color associated with?

haughty bridge
#

Emmm

#

I said i think

#

Also thats kinda vague

versed helm
#

@obsidian thistle the sky

haughty bridge
#

Lol

versed helm
#

😃

versed helm
#

What was the ancient name for Earth

#

Like what did they call it in the Forerunner Trilogy books

safe siren
#

Erda or Erde-Tyrene

versed helm
#

Chipps will show up at your most needed hour.

limpid kernel
#

Speaking of blue skies there was a beautiful blue sky yesterday when I was taking photos

subtle depot
#

Chips deserves a Medal of Honor

haughty bridge
#

I was gonna say that

carmine sleet
#

Sure you were

haughty bridge
#

Erde Tyrene was where Bornstellar met Chakas And Riser

#

See

#

Also the flood are made from god remains

#

Just saying

spiral jewel
#

Apparently Star Wars has a version of the Stalwart class , however theirs is a Star Destroyer class while the UNSC Stalwart class is a light frigate

tropic mural
#

question about spartans

#

ok so like we have 1-4 gen

#

are 4's weaker than 2's because they were made spartans as adults or that its more based on the suits than biological augmentations

haughty bridge
#

I said forerunner

carmine sleet
#

They weren't asking you that question specifically Demon

#

The S-IVs are weaker out of armour compared to the previous two generations of Spartans but the Gen 2 Mjolnir makes up for that @tropic mural

haughty bridge
#

U know the people listed under 343 industries

#

Are they people that actually made the games?

#

Wait

#

Teh Spearhead is here

#

Holy crap

narrow wadi
#

I’m reading First Strike, as noted

#

The line “There’s a spartan in here” immediately made me happy cuz I know that has to be Linda

#

Is that weird?

gilded mason
#

Not weird if you like Linda.

carmine sleet
#

@haughty bridge What's wrong with Spearhead?

haughty bridge
#

Isnt he the youtuber?

carmine sleet
#

He is

gilded mason
#

Yes. A lot of youtubers and others like them are mods for some reason.

haughty bridge
#

Cooiol

#

Cool i mean

boreal bane
#

@haughty bridge Yes, yellow folk are 343 employees. Please don't tag them though

haughty bridge
#

Ik

#

Thats kinda dumb

#

To tag em

boreal bane
#

Not really

haughty bridge
#

I mean

boreal bane
#

oh

#

yeah

versed helm
#

I wonder if we'll find out more about the unknown bipeds that lived on the Planet of Blue and Red?

last anchor
#

Perhaps, perhaps not

haughty bridge
#

Bipeds?

vague scroll
#

Two legged organisms.

versed helm
#

I'm betting that the unknown bipeds were wiped out by the Sangheili

haughty bridge
#

By the forerunners prob

#

Oh wait nvm

#

They have the mantle and all that crap

limpid kernel
#

are powerups canon in the campaign of halo 1 and 3?

versed helm
#

Yeah, they were in the Halo Encyclopedia if I recall correctly @limpid kernel

remote spruce
#

powerups are canon but not how brutes deploy bubble shields in a moving scarab

grizzled marsh
#

I don't believe the ones from Halo 1 are canon, but the abilities from 3, Reach and 4 are.

limpid kernel
#

halo 3 makes sense, but halo 1 didnt to me. though i do wish the powerups were in all the campaigns

versed helm
#

I bet 343 would try to make as many gameplay mechanics reasonably canonical

remote spruce
#

never forget how reach explained sprint

versed helm
#

Lol, some memes came out of that

limpid kernel
#

how did they explain sprint?

versed helm
#

But like 2010 memes, when they had them 99 percent comic strips

remote spruce
#

Kat made a hack to the armor that reduced movement limitations but it couldn't be used too much due to overheating the user

#

why

versed helm
#

Makes no sense

#

Especially for such a little speed boost

fair hazel
#

In canon it would probably be like, they can already srint about at fast speeds but they can go faster without those limits

#

like instead of going 50 kilometers per hour, to go 55

remote spruce
#

sort of makes sense, since it's an armor ability and not default

#

but still lol

versed helm
#

They can barely clock 44 miles per hour for a few seconds, yet when Chief disables his safeties, he can go nearly 68 over a third of a mile

#

And the fact that they're SIIIs doesn't explain it, since category IIIs are just as good as IIs

#

@fair hazel 55 was already an established base for unarmored IIs

#

Chief managed 72 in Palace Hotel, and they can run at 60km/hr for half a kilometer

#

Admittedly, Kelly has been stated as running a comparatively measly 65 as her running speed, but that was explicitly over extended periods of time. If that's a marathon run, that would make her more than 3x faster than peak athletes

modest marsh
#

Trying to pin down a given speed as a hard number is a useless endeavor

#

Spartans always need to be slow enough that driving a vehicle is more viable but also fast enough that they seem impressive in terms of athleticism

#

You’re gonna end up with conflicting ideas based on what the story requires

#

A big reason why we’ll probably never see especially fast Spartans in the games is that it’s important not to completely shatter the relationship the player has with the characters by having them perform completely differently between gameplay and cutscenes

#

Meanwhile, no such consideration exists in a book, so they can do whatever without hurting the readers suspension of disbelief

versed helm
#

@modest marsh then again, contraction forces in running are a little more complex than just lifting x amount of weight and moving at y speed. There are core concepts that are ubiquitous such as concentric and eccentric muscle tensions, but it could be justified as MJOLNIR being less oriented towards elastic contraction.

remote spruce
#

I mean they go fast in all Halo games so the requirement for "feeling like a super soldier" has been met since CE

modest marsh
#

I don’t think anyone is concerned with the physics of it from a narrative perspective

versed helm
#

Denning and Nylund seem to be interested in explaining certain elements of the fiction in that way

vague scroll
#

That not so much. War is more their forte.

fair hazel
#

i was just throwing numbers as an example...

versed helm
#

For example, Denning's emphasis on how nuclear explosions have a less volatile airbust on Seoba, and how they use vacuum-rated nonnuclear Octas as an alternative

modest marsh
#

Yeah but they didn’t pull out a calculator to make sure they used the precise number of foot-pounds for their scenes to make sense

fair hazel
#

except cortana would have disabled safety limitations during that run

vague scroll
#

Ultimately, its about the fun rather than accurate data.

#

Or NOVAs would not be a thing

remote spruce
#

Cortana is why Chief sprints in 4 /s

versed helm
#

Denning actually does do that occasionally

modest marsh
#

The safety limiter stuff is a load of bull hockey

fair hazel
#

basically, they can go fast but without limitations to prevent injury or strian, they can go faster

#

they can already sprint....

modest marsh
#

There’s really nothing that suggests Spartans risk self injury from running

#

It’s just a gameplay thing shoved in

fair hazel
#

John did get injured while running that fast

remote spruce
#

Waiting for the Halo game that explains why Alpha-9 is called Alpha-9

fair hazel
#

He tore his tendon

modest marsh
#

He was blown up by a missile first

versed helm
#

He was just hit by a near-proximity Scorpion missile

fair hazel
#

his injury was probably from the run however

#

thats how a bunch of people interpret it

versed helm
#

Either way, that's definitely not a good condition to be in beforehand

modest marsh
#

You can’t really say that in a vacuum he’d receive a similar injury when he was almost dead moments ago

remote spruce
#

No Chief didn't strech well the moral of the story is that you gotta stretch before you exercise

vague scroll
#

You guys expect too much from this series.

modest marsh
#

This

#

Lol

versed helm
#

This is an odd expression of how I have fun

vague scroll
#

Odd flex but fair

modest marsh
#

How dare you

#

Don’t you know that’s the wrong way to enjoy fiction

remote spruce
#

Alpha-9
So like
Alpha company....9th Fireteam?

vague scroll
#

You're better off accepting it as hockery.

feral perch
#

it sounds cool

fair hazel
#

overstrain does seem quite plausible for spartans too

vague scroll
#

If you aren't writing fanfiction with the intention of trying to fill the holes, head canons are kind of pointless.

feral perch
#

Bungie cared about the cool factor a bit more than other things

vague scroll
#

^

remote spruce
#

Y'all need to theorize why Evade is a thing

versed helm
#

Hey physics is cool

#

Sometimes

remote spruce
#

The heck does "dummy plugin" mean?

feral perch
#

you plug a dummy in there

fair hazel
#

the evade armour ability could be explained as the shields are modified on the go to allow for more fluent movement

#

there's explainations you can make on how these things go

modest marsh
#

It’s plausible but it seems tedious to say that Spartans need a disabled safety limiter to run 2-3 times faster because Chief tore his tendon when running 4 times faster than normal

feral perch
#

Evade is just natural thrusterpack

fair hazel
#

canon-wise

versed helm
#

It could be some rapid cocktail lol

fair hazel
#

i want armour abilities to be featured in the books more and comics

#

like seriously

#

They're useful pieces of kit

remote spruce
#

Evade reduces shield friction making you slide
Which explains why the evade animation is non-existent when there's lag

modest marsh
#

There’s no reason they don’t, it just doesn’t service the core franchise

feral perch
#

Reach seems to be semi-ignored by 343i as far as lore goes

#

It's that awkward middle child

fair hazel
#

Uh... how?

feral perch
#

.. that everyone loves anyway

modest marsh
#

Armor abilities were and are unpopular

feral perch
#

Not explaining Jun's escape from Reach, or any of the lore behind Noble Team really.

versed helm
#

I mean, they did the whole "memories of reach" thing, as well as this lootcrate campaign focused on noble team

fair hazel
#

that isn't quite, ignoring reach stuff

feral perch
#

It's not as much as I'd like so, I did say semi cone

versed helm
#

I still want to see Jun climb that space elevator

fair hazel
#

But seriously useful

#

we saw them in halo escalation

#

Linda should have active camo module

feral perch
#

I think Hologram is the most underutilized and potentially best AA

versed helm
#

Hard Light shield-Promethean Vision-Sentry Drone thing combo

fair hazel
#

well stuff was mentioned in the spartan field manual

remote spruce
#

sentry turret is the best armor ability

modest marsh
#

She uses a bubble shield in Tales From Slipspace

fair hazel
#

I don't remember Linda using a bubble shield

versed helm
#

Who?

feral perch
#

Actually no, Drop Shield is the best AA

modest marsh
#

Linda

fair hazel
#

Why drop shield and not Bubble shield armour ability

feral perch
#

Portable cover and health regen? Yes please!

versed helm
#

When did she do that? What was it against?

modest marsh
#

I’ll get it

versed helm
#

Okay

#

I love how the UNSC have hundred kiloton, nonnuclear shaped charges lmao.

remote spruce
#

Tfw Halo 4 campaign didn't have regen field

versed helm
#

Overkill much?

fair hazel
#

the spartan field manual does mention stuff

#

so at least

feral perch
#

Bubble Shield was one-use only, like all Equipment. Not an AA.

fair hazel
#

bubble shield is also an armour ability

remote spruce
#

Who thought flare was a good idea

modest marsh
feral perch
#

Since when?

fair hazel
#

spartan strike and maybe assault

feral perch
#

Oh.

#

Never played Strike

modest marsh
#

Halo 5 technically gives all Spartans a regen field

remote spruce
#

How so?

modest marsh
#

And overshield

fair hazel
#

revive?

modest marsh
#

The revive mechanic

#

Yeah

feral perch
#

Flare is just a flashbang that has no effect on the AI.

fair hazel
#

imagine promethean vision + active camo for linda

versed helm
#

@modest marsh jeez, that's easy to miss

remote spruce
#

Bring back flashlights

fair hazel
#

they were in halo 5

versed helm
#

Toggleable flashlights

modest marsh
#

Briefly lol

feral perch
#

Only in the level Blue Team

fair hazel
#

teleport armour ability would be cool to see more too

feral perch
#

Or on Shotguns

versed helm
#

Halo 5 had three missions

modest marsh
#

Tbh flashlights should blind enemies

remote spruce
#

Why do they have flashlights when they could have night vision lol

versed helm
#

Like in battlefield?