#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 143 of 1

versed helm
#

IT also works as a good way to rally troops. Spartans are iconic for their size and armor. Youw ant them to stand out amongst the battlefield. inspire hope on the battlefield

woeful sierra
#

Right. In a campaign just look at regular humans and how far down you have to aim to look them in the eye. Only people that really challenge Spartans in height are NBA players

#

To be fair only four current players match or surpass Master Chief’s height in armor

orchid kettle
#

@woeful sierra The thing is, Spartan-IVs are only as large as they are because their limbs have been lengthened

#

As opposed to undergoing a sort of super puberty

#

And if their muscles are enhanced thanks to the polymuscle material thats grafted onto them

#

Then they dont need to be large to be strong

#

Thorne is downright skeletal when you compare his weight to Chief’s

pearl raven
#

does anyone even like the Spartan IVs?

#

all they can do is point a gun and shoot

orchid kettle
#

I like the idea of them

pearl raven
#

(exaggeration)

orchid kettle
#

But problem is, Brian Reed being in charge of big projects like Spartan Ops and Halo 5

#

Certainly doesnt do them any favors

pearl raven
#

yeah

orchid kettle
#

Like, people are totally fine with Crimson for the most part

#

Because the second you say that that character is them, players get plenty attached

#

But my issue with the IVs is that their augs are a lil TOO silly

versed helm
#

Let’s not target brain reed please.

orchid kettle
#

Its one thing to just be “an olympian with a super suit” as Frankie once described them

#

But the Field Manual makes it sound like IVs are too perfect to die

versed helm
#

You can criticize decisions, not the decision makers

orchid kettle
#

They dont age, they barely have to eat or sleep, they cant be poisoned

#

It sounds horrifying in a way

pearl raven
#

yeah

#

like theyre more alien than the aliens theyre fighting

orchid kettle
#

I just kinda wish that Frankie kept to the idea that IVs are 90% their super suit

versed helm
#

I’d love to never have to eat

orchid kettle
#

Because at least a supersuit can be disabled or lost

pearl raven
#

@versed helm really?

versed helm
#

Only eat when I feel like it.

pearl raven
#

food is my life

versed helm
#

I like eating

pearl raven
#

right next to Halo

versed helm
#

But I don’t like having to eat

pearl raven
#

ok...

#

welp

#

the homework is a-callin

orchid kettle
#

Not to mention the idea that IVs are expected to be in their prime for at least a century

#

Imagine signing yourself over to the military for the next 100 years.

pearl raven
#

oof

#

yeah

orchid kettle
#

If you even survive that long

pearl raven
#

that would suck

orchid kettle
#

I think the reason why the IVs kinda bother me in a way is because each generation of Spuds had their own identity

#

ORION was a failed attempt, and the candidates are otherwise indistinguishable from the rest of the defense force

#

IIs are the few, proper supersoldiers

#

IIIs are the mass produced suicide troopers

#

And IVs are kinda just Spartan-II-2

#

Because being huge and in MJOlNIR was kinda the II’s whole gimmick

#

Or rather, ORION-2

#

It makes ODSTs seem even less important

versed helm
#

I have a thought..would the NOVA Bomb violate the Geneva Convention?..assuming the UEG/UNSC still use it in the 26th Century

carmine sleet
#

It would violate the Geneva Convention if it existed today

pearl raven
#

oof

#

uuh

#

i feel dumb

#

what is the geneva Convention?

unique rune
versed helm
#

im fairly certain they still follow them

#

considered halsey's considered a war criminal for her acts of the spartan 2 program

orchid kettle
#

No one can punish you for violating anything if you blow up the entire planet

#

Ya know, the Rebel Council or whatever in Silent Storm still really bothers me

#

Aside from the previous idea that the Insurrectionist elements were hardly related to each other outside of seeking independence

#

I kinda dont like the decision to reintroduce Cole’s wife

#

The appeal of that character, at least as I understood it, was how mysterious she was, and how she doesnt resurface until way later in the timeline

#

Some people also pointed to her faction as the “correct” way to rebel, because as far as we saw, she only attacked proper military targets

#

But in Silent Storm, she’s associating with a faction that blew up a civilian cruise liner

last anchor
#

Probably out of neccecity because the other option is to do their own thing on their own and get absolutely smoked by the Covenant for their trouble

#

They've got the titanium-hard rock of the Spartans on one side and the fanatical plasma-spewing hard place of the Covenant on the other

#

Hence Nyeto's attempts to kill the IIs

fair hazel
#

i was glad she came back

#

i like the Spartan-IVs and like that the notion that theyre mostly armour is dispelled

versed helm
#

Tbf, Spartan IIs are already pretty light in the weight department

#

And when I mentioned size to strength I was mostly talking about the IIs. They didn't have their muscles reconstructed. They were introduced chemicals that made the bulkier and denser.

#

Seriously, Master Chief's strength to weight ratio is ridiculous. He's only 290lbs at 6'10"

#

But his muscles despite having less mass than most strongman lifts far more

#

Also, the augs the IVs were given are far more intrusive than the IIs. IIs augs when it came to muscles were to introduce chemicals and hope the body does the right thing with them.

#

IVs had things replaced, lengthened, and reconstructed

versed helm
#

@versed helm "only 290lbs at 6'10"

#

only

#

sure his muscle density is extremely high

#

but 290lbs at 6'10 with that physique is extraordinary

#

Give me a bit. I'm still unpacking

versed helm
#

For a guy with really dense muscles. Being only 290lbs for his height is pretty light. That would mean Chief would have to have a wiry body to be this weight

#

Though, I might be including body fat in there. Spartans are sure to have a ve5ry low body fat

stable drum
#

^

#

I agree

versed helm
#

Also, gene therapy on the IVs making them live longer makes sense and is not too far in the realm of science fiction. We already know how aging can be stopped

#

We just don't have the tech to do it

#

The fact the IIs didn't have this same gene therapy is kind of surprising, but I do guess Fall of Reach was written like 17 years ago

#

Tech was way far behind and we don't know as much as we did before

#

Titanium covered bones makes sense. Titanium is the only known industrial metal the human body won't ever reject. I had titanium screw3s placed in my femur after I broke it.

#

Hmm, after abit of research I now realize ceramic carbide is literally just Titanium

#

Titanium carbide to be exact

pearl raven
#

how

#

HOW

#

did you break your femur

#

ive never heard of anyone break that one before

carmine sleet
#

Any bone can be broken, I know someone who broke their upper jaw from falling off a bike

pearl raven
#

well yeah

#

why couldnt it?

#

but the femur...

#

geez

versed helm
#

Lol

#

What a coincidence

#

I broke my femur falling off a bike

#

It's the end of the femur though and not the long part

#

The part connected to the knee

feral perch
#

The knee bone's connected to the - thigh bone, the thigh bone's connected to the...

full forge
#

hip bone... the hip bone's connected to the...

versed helm
#

Stomach bone

main frost
woeful sierra
#

Here I thought SIVs had less intrusive and intense augmentations because Gen2 Mjolnir was better than the Mk IV that SIIs were designed to use

feral perch
#

the stomach bone's connected to the... thicc bone

last anchor
#

THICC

obsidian thistle
#

I know enough about Biology to know some stuff not labelled is not normal in the body.

#

Lets say its very intrusive and some stuff I would not want in my body.

fair hazel
#

However those tactical roles

#

Defensive ones.

#

They mention structural hard light shield emitters and constructor beams as equipment defensive Spartans use

#

I am very curious on their nature.

limpid meadow
#

lol, I hear "tactical roles" and can only think of rolling dice 😛

fair hazel
#

Hah.

limpid meadow
#

But yeah, I love defined Spartan combat roles

#

Halo 4 gave us some detail, specifically with Specialization, but it's nice to have more

fair hazel
#

The one that has me the most interested is that one I talk about right now.

obsidian thistle
#

Note to self when I finished phase one of my image rename scheme on Halopedia, roles and rank roles will be getting pages.

fair hazel
#

I sort of almost imagine fortnite style Spartans. From the image of structural hard light emitters and constructor beams

limpid meadow
#

Well, there's still only 1 rank in the Spartan Branch

#

But different titles/roles

#

Though that can get confusing with the combat roles too, now

obsidian thistle
#

That why I said "rank roles"

#

And not ranks xD

fair hazel
#

Well there’s spécialisations and tactical roles now

limpid meadow
#

Ah, okay

#

Misread

fair hazel
#

There’s tactical packages and support upgrades as well. So not to confuse tactical roles and tactical packages. And not to confuse tactical roles with the rank roles

#

The two , or three? Biggest things about the spartan field manual for me where. Knowing the infinity did have factorie(s), tactical roles. And rank roles

#

Tactical roles, especially the defensive one

obsidian thistle
#

Yea there is a few pages I need to make on Halopedia. I plan to start with normal ranks and expand to Specialisations and roles

brittle gorge
#

Hey, just out of curiousity, would ONI ever transfer a researcher to the marines, even if the researcher is better suited as a marine rather than a researcher?

pearl raven
#

yeah prolly

#

low key death sentence?

limpid meadow
#

I imagine it would heavily depend on the context.

#

Essentially, why is this researching being transferred?

#

And what kind of clearance did they have?

#

Lot of questions

pearl raven
#

well

brittle gorge
#

The researcher is getting transferred to the marines to serve as a marine

limpid meadow
#

How come?

brittle gorge
#

"Due to her unusual skills for a researcher she was reasigned from an ONI researcher to the marine ranks where she could put her skills in use"

limpid meadow
#

What kind of clearance did she have before?

brittle gorge
#

Those skills being "Highly trained in Infiltration, intelligence, research missions, she is an excellent Sharp shooter / sniper. Trained to survive in the harshest of environments"

#

That i do not know

limpid meadow
#

How high was she in the ONI chain?

#

Because that would be a major factor, I imagine

brittle gorge
#

The character is 25, how high would she reasonably be?

limpid meadow
#

Depends on her knowledge

humble yacht
#

Is this an existing character or an OC?

brittle gorge
#

OC

#

And not mine

#

The info i gave is all the info i have currently

limpid meadow
#

I'll be honest, it feels odd that a researcher would be transferred at all in that manner.

#

I think it more likely she would be attached to a secret or black-ops unit where her skill could be used and her knowledge would be useful

brittle gorge
#

It just feels wrong to me that oni would transfer someone to the unsc who was a researcher in oni

#

And transfer them into the marines

limpid meadow
#

Same

humble yacht
#

It'd be more plausible that they would just turn that person into a Sec 3 operative like Locke

limpid meadow
#

^^^

#

Like, I could maybe see them planting an operative in a standard marine group for some reason

brittle gorge
#

That's kinda what i was thinking would likely happen too

limpid meadow
#

But an operative, not a researcher

#

A researcher, I think, would be more likely to get attached to a squad, likely a secret ops squad of some kind, rather than transferred

humble yacht
#

I'd wonder why'd they be in a research position when their apparent forte was militant activity

brittle gorge
#

Alright. Thanks for the help!

limpid meadow
#

Well, if they were more valuable as a researcher, I could see that happening

brittle gorge
#

Honestly, i question half the stuff i read there every day

humble yacht
brittle gorge
#

No

#

Small reddit roleplay

#

By small, i mean at most 40 active membets

#

I'm one of the mods in charge there, so i wanted to know if that would fit lore

brisk cape
#

??? is curious

last anchor
#

Oh boy don't open it up too much, all of the self-insert OCs would get absolutely MAULED

low idol
#

any more theories on what GRD in the morse code from the infinite trailer could be?

brittle gorge
#

Yeah no, unless i approached the mods about advertising the server here, i won't really mention it much, except to ask for lore advice like i did earlier

#

And, unless we lost nearly all of our members, i really wouldn't bother

brisk cape
#

The GRD helmet is teased again lol

obsidian thistle
#

Funny thing about that GRD helmet, its that GRD isnt actually the helmets name. Its the name given by a guy who spent 1 post detailing his efforts to unlock the helmet via the GRD textures in Halo Reach

versed helm
#

Alright, I'm just gonna say it

#

Spartan Field Manual is great

#

Also, I didn't notice the detail of telomeres lengthening

#

That's why they'll stay in their prime for a long time. As long as they keep getting their telomeres lengthened they're nearly immortal

humble yacht
#

Oof. that eventually leads to cancer, though

versed helm
#

Yeah

#

I was about to mentiont he cancer

#

Though, I'm pretty sure they already have the cure to cancer

#

If they have the tech to lengthen telomeres than it is almost certaint they have the tech to cure cancer

humble yacht
#

Accumulation of senescent cells (i.e. cells that stop dividing because telomeres are too short) is but one aspect of aging

#

there are many others that would prevent spartans from being immortal

#

Long-lived? sure

versed helm
#

Curious, what else plays into aging that could kill them?

#

Other than cancer

humble yacht
#

plenty of age-related diseases

#

aging is the greatest risk factor for many diseases

versed helm
#

I just realized

#

Did they move the IV's heart higher up into the rib cage?

humble yacht
#

At the cellular/molecular level, you also see mitochondrial and proteomic deficiencies in aged organisms

versed helm
#

At least I'm pretty sure that's their heart

#

It's far higher than normal. The center of the heart is level with the nipples

#

Also, it's been moved more to the right

#

I wonder if they did this so the thickest part of the chest plate would now protect the heart.

brisk cape
#

Wouldn’t surprise me if they did.

last anchor
#

I mean it makes sense to me. Probably helps increase blood flow efficency too

night tulip
#

It would make sense

#

Tho, I was under the impression the IV’s procedures were FAR less invasive than the IIs or IIIs

#

Maybe it was just an artistic mistake or liberty taken idk

versed helm
#

They were indeed less intensive overall.

versed helm
#

You know...would the Spartan programs also violate the Geneva Convention..especially the Spartan IIs and IIIs?

#

this was already asked

#

@versed helm (just answer)

#

はいはい。 @versed helm technically yes, while I'm unsure if they still follow them, don't forget that Halsey is labeled as a War Criminal for her role in the S-II program. so it's safe to assume that they do, and they are

fair hazel
#

they are unethical

fair hazel
#

i thought of something

#

not shown in gameplay but the pulse grenade produces an attentuation pulse

#

i wonder if the guardian is similar

carmine sleet
#

They do produce attenuation pulses according to Halopedia

orchid kettle
#

They produce tickle pulses

#

as evident by how effective they are in Halo 4

#

So, whats this about a "Halo Omnibus"?

versed helm
#

It’s the bus that drops all the Spartans off in battle royale

feral perch
#

XLR8....

#

Heck

reef plank
#

Kacau

rotund pewter
#

One message removed from a suspended account.

thick cape
#

I have a question. Is there a book or comic that explains how the covanent was formed?

severe elbow
#

The book Broke Circle shows it a bit.

thick cape
#

kool, thanks

radiant sphinx
#

CE Anniversary terminals shed quite a bit of light on it as well (that, or was it Halo 2’s terminals?)

unique rune
#

Halo 2's, I think. The CEA terminals are mostly about Spark's service on Installation 04.

fair hazel
#

I also recommend halo mythos @thick cape

thick cape
#

neato

last anchor
#

Halo Omnibus. I hope thats a real thing

obtuse void
#

Omnibus?

versed helm
#

Omnibus is Latin

#

It means “for all”

#

In print media it refers to a single publication containing all volumes/chapters of a previously split media

#

Basically. It would be as if The Fall of Reach, The Flood, First Strike, and Ghosts of Onyx we’re all in a single book bit could be referred to as an omnibus volume

last anchor
#

Hence my hopes such a thing is real

obsidian thistle
#

Minor lore request time in hope to get a tiny piece of lore. Does anyone here have the reach console?

#

I am in need of what the decals on the console say.

#

Cause lore dictates that its a oddity in-universe.

limpid kernel
#

Question

#

In Halo 2 why were they doing promotions in a mac station?

#

And more importantly was chief gonna get something

carmine sleet
#

The promotions were for boosting morale of the troops, Chief was there for the reason Johnson said "Folks need heroes"

limpid kernel
#

So where does lord hood go usually

carmine sleet
#

He's busy with meetings of the higher ups of the UEG and UNSC normally

obsidian thistle
#

The Reach Console is essentially a in-universe item called a "Archive Reader T4"

carmine sleet
#

That's cool

obsidian thistle
#

There is a lot to understand and dig with this.

last anchor
#

Considering that the Legendary edition of Reach indicated the game was an "archive of noble team", this makes sense.
The archive disc goes in the reader

obsidian thistle
#

Limited edition does that. The Legendary edition does other cool stuff.

#

That said I do love how most of Halo Reach's physical stuff has in-universe reasons for stuff.

last anchor
#

Agreed.
To be fair the Limited came with the Legendary, it just had the statue to boot

#

Cause the limited was just Halsey's journal and the evidence bag

#

Dear 343; can we get another Halsey's Journal style thing? PLZ

obsidian thistle
#

The Legendary Edition did come with a crate full of lore.

#

Like almost the whole crate was canon.

#

15 January 2610

last anchor
#

The crate itself was canon

obsidian thistle
#

Yep

last anchor
#

Which was super dope.
I still have mine in my closet right now

obsidian thistle
#

It was the shipping container of the in-universe statue we are meant to give to Ms. Bjarne. Shame she will never get it 😉

#

The weirdest one however is the reach controller... I have no idea what a "Type: M70" is. And it would be hard to make a page over it on Halopedia lol

versed helm
#

Perhaps it’s the classification of the controller, given that the console is technically an archive reader

night tulip
#

@limpid kernel Usually Lord Hood would be in Australia at ONI and HIGHCOM headquarters overseeing UEG and UNSC activities and strategy

limpid kernel
#

what would have happened if lord hood died

radiant sphinx
#

Could compromise Chief's mission regarding the strictness of jurisdiction of whoever succeeds Hood, even then I wouldn't intervene in whatever Chief has planned lol

#

Even considering the fact that Hood didn't want the mission in Halo 3 to proceed because of it's risk, I'm assuming not much would have changed

night tulip
#

@limpid kernel Lord hood would be replaced by someone promoted to his role. Yes he is an integral part of the military, but ultimatly he'd be repalced

severe bone
#

Replacements? This many years in the war, who isnt?

last anchor
#

Thats how the military works

clever fable
#

It'd be cool if we ever got revised details on how good/bad ships are at accelerating. It always seems so generalized. UNSC and Covenant ships are only ever just fast enough, or just not fast enough. Forerunner ships have a few scenes in their trilogy where they move at low relativistic speeds, but it's never given an explicit number.

obsidian thistle
#

Soooo we have a possible way Jun got off Reach now. Interesting.

versed helm
#

Well now

last anchor
#

If its from Frank then its as close to solid canon as we can get

versed helm
#

that "how did he get into orbit" comment
the million dollar question

last anchor
#

My money's on stolen Phantom/Spirit/Banshee. Heck he probably didnt even have to sneak, just found one that had been left behind by a dead pilot

dusty pilot
#

Joshua's Banshee

last anchor
#

As cool as that would be, Im pretty sure it was obliterated by the nuke he carried

carmine sleet
#

It was destroyed, no way it would've survived a nuke

pearl raven
#

in the Halo universe, give me an example of something that would survive a nuke

last anchor
#

Forerunner facilities, for the most part

#

Certain Covenant ships

#

Remember the UNSC has various levels of nuclear ordinance, ranging from the "football" Fenris we were just talking about all the way up to the NOVA

#

With everything in between.
Havoks, Shivas, I think Howlers might be nuclear tipped in certain cases

obsidian thistle
#

And thats ignoring all the Forerunner integrated advances

last anchor
#

Indeed. Naquida-style ordinance, anyone?

#

I kinda wanna see an event in-game that the Daybreak visor was made for. Accidental viewing of orbital nuclear detonations? NICE

feral perch
#

Sounds like SILENT STORM might have inspired the Daybreak visor actually

last anchor
#

That was my thoughts honestly

night tulip
#

I doubt anyone would survive a NOVA

#

Any structure any ship

#

Maybe the greater ark or forerunner capital maythrillian

limpid kernel
#

does master chief hate elites

modest marsh
#

He hates what they have done to humanity, but I don’t think he’s xenophobic so much as he is practical

last anchor
#

He sees the foe. He kills the foe. He moves on. Thats it.
No personal attachment, no emotional drive. The mission, finishing it. Done.

fair hazel
#

he has felt stuff though

#

but hes very focused

last anchor
#

Hes not emotionless, he just doesnt let it get in the way of his operations.

#

Thats part of why an S-II is so effective; they can lock their emotions away and stay completely tactical, whereas other soldiers can let it bleed over and loose their cool (see; Hoya on Requiem)

limpid kernel
#

i just though, why is halsey call chief one of the best if hes not the best?

last anchor
#

Because hes not the best at anything.

#

Kelly is faster. Lindas a better shot. Fred is a better tactical commander and at stabbing.
Kurt was kinder and had a sort of sixth sense for trouble. Jorge and Sam were both stronger

limpid kernel
#

yeah, so why is chief labaled one of the best?

#

i cant remember what it was said exactly but it was him and noble six

last anchor
#

Oh, thats just Reach's stupid "hyper lethal vector" crap.
Means he killed a lotta dudes

night tulip
#

Lucky

#

He has the forerunner geas

#

He has plot armour built Into his character

#

Six was hyper lethal among other SIII

#

But chief is lucky, has forerunner DNA and all that stuff

#

Literally anyone on blue team could outdo him in one thing or the other

#

And even then, blue team used to lose a lot to green team during training

limpid kernel
#

chief's pretty lucky that he gets to keep that title

fair hazel
#

...

#

forerunner dna?

#

no

last anchor
#

Geas is different than DNA

brisk cape
#

His luck and ‘drive’ separate him from the other Spartan-IIs. But it’s specifically stated that other Spartans were better at different things as others stated above. Kurt-051 had a sort of ‘sixth sense’ or a very refined intuition which allowed him to get a better ‘feel’ of the situation than other Spartans. Iirc, Chief himself says/thinks that Kurt would have made a better leader than himself in one of the books.

modest marsh
#

I mean, in a practical sense, Master Chief is the best because he’s had more opportunity than anyone to show that he’s the best

#

Being the main character and all

versed helm
#

Lucky green boi

modest marsh
#

Constantly doing things that would most likely get anyone else killed

brisk cape
#

In game yes, but in the lore the other Spartans were just as capable of amazing feats just as he is.

modest marsh
#

Nothing really compares to the absurdity of what happens in the games

night tulip
#

Such as Linda upside down sniping elites out of banshees with a rope tied around her leg

brisk cape
#

Exactly.

night tulip
#

One handed anti material rifle

#

Like

modest marsh
#

Yeah, I mean, that’s fantastic within her skill set, but like, Linda also died

night tulip
#

Kinda.

#

Linda.

#

Chief is an all round spartan, master of none, jack of all trades

#

Luck and opportunity are on his side

brisk cape
#

Basically.

night tulip
#

The “absurdity” of the games doesn’t really compare to some of the absurdity in the books

#

Saying someone died isn’t a valid proof of feats

#

Circumstance and mission parameters and something nobody can predict are huge factors in who dies and who lives in the field

modest marsh
#

Alright, let me rephrase then

#

Chief has never been critically wounded from being shot on a mission before

night tulip
#

False

#

First mission to capture colonel watts

#

Shot in the chest

#

Bleeding out

modest marsh
#

That wasn’t a critical injury

night tulip
#

Without bio foam

modest marsh
#

And the bleeding was stabilized

night tulip
#

It would’ve been

modest marsh
#

That’s completely irrelevant?

night tulip
#

It’s really not

#

Linda didn’t get biofiam treatment

modest marsh
#

Because she was already clinically dead

night tulip
#

Chief was never the most skilled spartan, or the last. Only the luckiest

#

John would’ve been dead too without biofoam treatment

#

Also as I’ve said before, getting shot or not is not a proof of a feat

modest marsh
#

Chief was still operational for the preceding moments of the mission, no amount of field resuscitation would’ve made Linda ready to finish the mission

night tulip
#

That doesn’t mean chief is better than Linda in skill, marksmanship, strength or speed

modest marsh
#

Well, the circumstances were also different, Chief was walking into a choke point from an enemy already aware of their assault

static trench
#

If a Grave Mind has memories from previous grave minds, can't they just evolve themselves to achieve their prior abilities they had as Precursors?

#

iirc, one of the didacts that was being talked to by a grave mind had felt that he talked to it before

#

when it was really the precursor he talked to before

fair hazel
#

the only medal he hasnt gotten is the prisoner of war one

night tulip
#

In terms of pure skill, everyone on blue team is better than chief

#

In terms of strength, Sam

modest marsh
#

I really doubt that honestly

night tulip
#

In terms of speed Kelly

#

In terms of marksmanship, Linda

#

CQB? Fred

#

Why do you doubt that when the proof is in universe

static trench
#

also, to be fair, all spartans have biofoam

#

and im sure lots of them get hurt

night tulip
#

Chief himself said so

static trench
#

"John would’ve been dead too without biofoam treatment" so would have lots of other spartans, lol

#

yeah but you get what i mean

#

all spartans have it

modest marsh
#

You’re picking specific specializations they have as if that encompasses the entirety of combat skills and aptitudes

night tulip
#

Chief is master of none

#

Linda would snipe him from miles out

fair hazel
#

John has had the purple heart

modest marsh
#

That’s not really stated anywhere, it’s just inferred?

#

Master of none I mean

night tulip
#

Kelly would move too fast for chief to react

#

It is

fair hazel
#

Johns the good leader though. and hes well rounded

night tulip
#

^

fair hazel
#

Even if it was propaganda

#

In hunt the truth

night tulip
#

He also said Fred and Kurt would be better leaders

static trench
#

isnt that a matter of opinion though?

modest marsh
#

There’s no statement in the Halo canon that Chief is average in any capacity

#

That’s an assumption made

fair hazel
#

The guy says it, he was always the guy to make the right call

night tulip
#

He’s admitting his own faults the only reason Fred was never shown to be the better leader was because he hated the spotlight

modest marsh
#

We don’t have any reason to believe it one way or another

#

Fred is explicitly flawed in his leadership skills himself

fair hazel
#

John talked about himself and others

#

but um...

#

These are spartans we are talking about

#

average?

#

That`s like, an average chess master

night tulip
#

No one said John was average mag

modest marsh
#

They have pros and cons individually speaking that they might not consider

fair hazel
#

what are they called?

#

Master Pros? Master grand? Chess grand masters

night tulip
#

Chess grand masters is the term ur looking for

#

John was anything but an average spartan

modest marsh
#

“Jack of all trades” is a descriptor applies to Chief, yes?

night tulip
#

Yes it is

modest marsh
#

I’m suggesting this is fallacious to ascribe it as fact

night tulip
#

He is adept at all things, but not master of any particular thing

#

False

#

Jack of all trades is relative

#

If we excluded blue team from the spartan ranking I have no doubt John would be on top. He’s anything but average

static trench
#

I'd go with someone well rounded in each field but not perfect, rather than rely on someone who is good at one specific thing and not much anything else any day

night tulip
#

I’d go with a team of specialized people thank you

#

Which is why they are in teams

static trench
#

im speaking on 1 person, not a whole team

night tulip
#

Ah I see

static trench
#

but yeah, by all means, make a team

#

nothing like having pros in your corner xD

night tulip
#

But the reason they are specialized is because they are meant to work in teams

#

Wel

#

Except Linda and grey team but

#

They are kinda outliers

static trench
#

When I saw that Halo 4 cutscene where red team ran down the mountain, that was the absolute biggest let down

#

that should have been chief's moment

night tulip
#

Wait what

feral perch
#

um

static trench
#

iirc, it was red team

night tulip
#

When did red team run down a mountain in halo 4?

feral perch
#

wrong team and game there chief

static trench
#

Locke and co right?

night tulip
#

-__-

modest marsh
#

Osiris

static trench
#

and i meant halo 5

night tulip
#

That’s Osiris in halo 5

static trench
#

lol, my bad

modest marsh
#

Not red team

static trench
#

Ah

night tulip
#

Colours are spartan II teams

static trench
#

Welp, i pictured them right but got names confused

#

my bad

#

but yeah

#

that should have been Blue Team

night tulip
#

Mmm maybe

static trench
#

but then again, i did hear that 343 thought that fans got tired or bored with MC

night tulip
#

Honestly that cutscene looked like something out of RVB freelancers

static trench
#

I hope we see MC pull off some badassery in the next game

night tulip
#

Spartans are supposed to move like that yeah but it’s awkward when chief has never done that in previous games

static trench
#

that poor excuse of a spartan fight was disappointing 😦

night tulip
#

Oh you mean the two drunk men punching each other

#

It was like the slowest hand to hand scene ever

#

Even for normal humans

#

Forget genetically enhanced

static trench
#

if the floor wasn't made of forerunner materials, i'd say it should have dented more

#

and doesn't MC had way more experience under his belt than Locke?

limpid kernel
#

chief didnt want to kill locke

static trench
#

i know but still

night tulip
#

You can disarm someone a lot faster than that

static trench
#

MC seemed to have been lacking in reaction and defense in that fight

night tulip
#

Without killing them

static trench
#

^

#

and they are enhanced too

night tulip
#

With state of the art nuclear powered armour

#

And exoskeletons

#

Like

#

Neural implants as well which made reaction time and faster by sending the electrical signals from the brain straight to the armour

static trench
#

Cortana made a hard light shield to protect MC, imagine the other insane stuff she could pull off if she had of enhanced MC directly?

#

probably the only AI the humans had that could do such a feat

night tulip
#

Well she was unique

static trench
#

true

#

so much potential

night tulip
#

She was beyond a smart Ai

static trench
#

#BringCortanaBackToTheLight2019

night tulip
#

She might be manipulated by the composed digital didact rn

static trench
#

i was thinking the LP

#

but i never thought about it that way

night tulip
#

LP?

static trench
#

Logic Plague

night tulip
#

Ah

#

Well according to H5 she cured rampancy, I thought the domain also helped cure the logic plague

#

I know the forerunners has trouble with the logic plague

#

But since the domain is precursor, I thought it would have an answer to that

static trench
#

hmm, i see

#

makes sense

#

i wonder what made her get like she is now

#

something went wrong

limpid kernel
#

i remember someone had a theory that one of her emotion fragments were the one that got caught in slipspace

night tulip
#

Or the real cortana is dead and this is simply one of the broken fragments that she cut off when trying to overload the didacts shield

static trench
#

Slip space?

limpid kernel
#

yeah

night tulip
#

Yes

#

Because the didact fell into a slipspace portal

#

H4

static trench
#

ah

night tulip
#

And what is the reclamation gonna look like?

#

Will all of humanity evolve rapidly to have the abilities of spartans?

#

Will humanity ascend to the milky ways dominant species and hold the mantle?

#

Idk

#

The definition of reclaimer and mantle has never been clear

limpid kernel
#

humanity will evolve into spartans that can turn into forge monitors

#

that is backstory of custom games in halo 5

night tulip
#

XD

#

And that’s why throughout all the halos we had forge mode lol

#

Well

#

Not all but

limpid kernel
#

cortana: chief when you get to earth good luck
chief: after im through with truth
cortana: dont make a girl a promise you know you cant keep.
big ship leaves with chief
cortana: the reclamation has begun

night tulip
#

Interesting

stable drum
#

What’s the best halo novel In your guys opinion

severe elbow
#

First Strike.

stable drum
#

True

#

Ghost of onyx is good

feral perch
#

Hrrnnggg

#

I can't decide between The Fall of Reach, First Strike, and Envoy.

remote spruce
#

First Strike or Evolutions

versed helm
#

Hm...Contact Harvest

#

Or the Forerunner Trilogy

stable drum
#

Silent storm isint bad

#

It’s actually decent

#

However there something’s i find off about it

#

Most Spartans like Solomon and naiomi barley had any lines and idk Solomon had any lol

night tulip
#

Lol lot of different answers

versed helm
#

Barley

brisk cape
#

I liked Silent Storm, they just threw too many names around, almost like a fan service. “Here’s a name, there’s a name, ALL THE NAMES!!”

versed helm
#

Silent storm was my least favourite book honestly

versed helm
#

to each their own

feral perch
#

So when exactly does Halsey say the things she says in Halo 5's intro to Locke?

humble yacht
#

Maybe that voice over occurs off screen during their downtime

last anchor
#

Could be on Sangheilios

#

When Osiris and Blue get back

limpid kernel
#

Halo reach was not the first time covenant attacked reach right?

versed helm
#

it was

#

it was the first time the covenant found reach, hence why humanity was desperate to save it

last anchor
#

Winter Contingency

versed helm
#

reach was a major stronghold and footing for humanity

limpid kernel
#

What about Thom?

last anchor
#

Different planet

limpid kernel
#

I read on the wiki it was some months before

carmine sleet
#

Some months before on a different planet

humble yacht
#

Yep

limpid kernel
#

Huh

versed helm
night tulip
#

@versed helm Reach was THE major fortress world of humanity. The headquarters of fleet operations, birth place of the spartans, its shipyards, the 20 ODPs, the epsilon eridani fleet, experimental programs like sabre project.

last anchor
#

To be fair the Saber was also on other planets, there just happened to be one on Reach for various reasons
Most notibly because macguffin to get into space without getting shot down

night tulip
#

I think we can forgive that if we can forgive the UNSC letting a 30km CSO Under it’s defense grid without so much as a whisper

#

Like

#

How

#

Did that thing

#

Go undetected by the hundreds of reach sensors and satellites

last anchor
#

Stealth.

#

A smaller Covenant fleet arrived, fully stealthed, and started setting up a cloaking network via the spires

#

Thats why the Long Night of Solace showed up when the spire went down; its cloaking field dropped

night tulip
#

How did they arrive in the first place without being detected

last anchor
#

Direct slipspace via data retrieved from the probe on the Iriquois following the battle of Sigma Octanus IV

#

They jumped into the system as close as they could, ship stealthed, and landed troops on the surface.

night tulip
#

No one detected a huge as slipspace rupture the size of 30km?

last anchor
#

Not if it happened far outside the system and the ship coasted the rest of the way

#

Remember Covenant ships are faster in normal space too

#

Gravitic boosting and Forerunner-tech based engines

night tulip
#

That doesn’t matter when there’s literal hundreds of surveillance equipment above reach and not one detected a single Anamoly

carmine sleet
#

Camo systems of Covie ships are very effective, not just for hiding from visual sensors but also other types of sensors

last anchor
#

UNSC tech at the time wasn't as advanced as it is now.
And the CSO had Forerunner "god cores" aboard it.

night tulip
#

And if they could just do that everytime then why not do it on every single other human planet

#

“God cores”

#

BS cores

last anchor
#

Is it really?

night tulip
#

Yes

last anchor
#

As for why they didnt do it every time; they couldn't. Nor was it needed.

night tulip
#

Why couldn’t they?

last anchor
#

Because they dont have an endless number of CSOs. Its also far more complicated, risky, and resource intense than their usual "get in and brawl" style of combat.

#

Also Im pretty sure most Sangheili ship masters would disdane a sneaky approach, prefering to get in blades flashing, so to speak

#

The reason it happened on Reach was because Reach is loaded with Forerunner relics

#

The original fleet that arrived was smaller and lead by the CSO under the command of a religious zealot who wanted to take them all for himself if I remember right.

night tulip
#

Your telling me not one reach sensor picked up a warp in imaging because of CSO stealth tech?

last anchor
#

Not a one.
Forerunner baffler tech if I had to guess.

#

We know their camoflauge was far superior to anything either race has

#

Also, the spire was helping too

#

It blocked out ALL UNSC sensors, period.

#

Hence the reason for "Nightfall"

#

Noble probed in to find out what the hell was going on

night tulip
#

They had to have deployed the spire on planet before using it

fair hazel
#

The long night of solace was commanded by Rho 'barutamee

#

He did not care as much about the war against the humans

#

his ship had cloaking tech itself

night tulip
#

Yes we know that

fair hazel
#

his primary motive was finding the location of maethrillian

night tulip
#

But not a single reach sensor went off

fair hazel
#

ok?

last anchor
#

Again, they had nothing to detect

#

Remember, the spires were covering the whole area in instrument blocking tech

#

Jun and Kat even say it in the opening of Nigthfall.
"Covenant can block our instruments?"
"So it would seem."

night tulip
#

By 2552 I’d expect them to have at least be able to sense a 30km mass moving towards you

#

No we are not talking about the mission nightfall

#

Not the spires

#

How the fleet got their in the first place

last anchor
#

The spire was in place by the time it arrived.

feral perch
#

Placed there by whom?

last anchor
#

If the LNOS transitioned into the system out of the range of UNSC sensors (which didnt extend far beyond Reach's orbit), and coasted the rest of the way there under its own cloak till it arrived at the shielding of the spire then it wouldnt know.

#

The original team that arrived, the one lead by the zealots we see in Winter Contingency

fair hazel
#

they can obviously cloak that mass

feral perch
#

How though?

last anchor
#

I dont think Yamato really understands the true capabilities of either the Covenant or the Forerunners.

#

I dont think Yamato really understands the true capabilities of either the Covenant or the Forerunners.

#

I dont think Yamato really understands the true capabilities of either the Covenant or the Forerunners.

night tulip
#

Why not do that for earth then?

#

If there were 300 ODPs and even more forerunner artifacts

last anchor
#

Because the guy who lead the assault on Reach was spagetiified along with Jorge and about 1/3 of his crew

#

Remember, the stealthy guy was there to find data leading to Maethrillian

#

And he died for his trouble.

night tulip
#

Why didn’t regret do it

carmine sleet
#

Also Regret was a big fan of just invading planets, not stealthing in

last anchor
#

Because Regret was there to BURN THE HERETICS

#

^

#

And he didnt have the same stuff that the Reach fleet master did. 2 assault carriers, far smaller than a CSO, and a bunch of various other ships.

#

PLUS he had no clue humanity was there.

fair hazel
#

we dont know for sure if he died

#

Also you do realize regret didn'T expect any human presence on Erde-Tyrene?

last anchor
#

Well, his fleet command was busted, half of it went into slipspace and the rest hit reach so...

feral perch
#

How did the Covies set up a massive spire on the most important human colony without being noticed?

night tulip
#

Wouldn’t a CAS be easier to cloak than a CSO?

last anchor
#

No. Again, the cloaking for the CSO was forerunner tech.

fair hazel
#

CSO has the technology

last anchor
#

@feral perch They set up the smaller jamming towers we see in Nightfall first. A ring of them blocked out a huge section of Reach's mountain range from the UNSC.
Hence Nightfall.

#

Noble probed in to see "what the covenant were hiding".

#

Found the Spire.

fair hazel
#

they did end up getting discovered in the end

last anchor
#

And thats when the CSO got involved and everything went to hell

obsidian thistle
#

The CSO however was not a combat ship.

#

Size may be decieving xD

last anchor
#

Against the underprepared UNSC though...

night tulip
#

Can someone give me a source as to where you got the info that it coasted in after leaving sigma Octanus IV and cloaked past the orbital defence grid?

#

It’s never explicitly stated in reach

last anchor
#

There's none, thats just what I've put together from talking with various other lore fans

night tulip
#

Ah

last anchor
#

@obsidian thistle Thoughts?

obsidian thistle
#

I need to dig again I am afraid. Reach lore I am not the best in as I used to be. To much of a mess xD

night tulip
#

Well it can work with TFOR if you try

fair hazel
#

it does work with it

obsidian thistle
#

It does work xD

last anchor
#

Its been done before.

#

Fortunatly, Reach has a longer than 24 hour day

obsidian thistle
#

So we cant trust the times shown in the game in relation to TFoR

night tulip
#

I wish you could explain that it works canonically to some certain other people who don’t believe me

last anchor
#

It annoys me they didnt just keep it zulu time
Or, you know, make the game fit with the freaking book

feral perch
#

Bungie too cool for that

night tulip
#

Think we’ll see red team in halo infinite?

carmine sleet
#

As in HW2 Red Team? Because I'd love to see them make an appearance in an FPS Halo game

night tulip
#

I mean they’re kind of stuck on the arc but it created a portal for Anders and the new halo to go through

#

Yes the HW2 red team

carmine sleet
#

It's not impossible for the story to lead Chief and Infinity to the Ark, like, the end of Halo 5 teased a Halo, for all we know, that's the same one we see at the end of Halo Wars 2

night tulip
#

*surviving Spartan II reunion

#

But I doubt Naomi will show up

#

Or grey team

carmine sleet
#

I'd say they should avoid throwing in too many Spartans

night tulip
#

They had a lot in halo 5 already with Osiris, Palmer, and chiefs blue team

radiant sphinx
#

Send Locke out like Mdama in the first mission lol

night tulip
#

Lol

#

ONI spook goes out like the target he was sent to assassinate

last anchor
#

Unlikely

night tulip
#

It’s a pipe dream

fair hazel
#

No.

#

It’s just that they didn’t do the best job with characters overall.

#

Not the number

night tulip
#

I agree, tho... the number of spartans didn’t help because you don’t get time to develop them when halo 5 is so short

fair hazel
#

You can have a big cast and do an excellent job

night tulip
#

You’re right, the avengers is like the prime example of that, but I’m saying halo 5’s campaign didn’t develop the characters as much as they should’ve been, and it was a very short game

fair hazel
#

standard length

low idol
#

pretty standard, gotta start on legendary

feral perch
#

15 levels. That's longer than Halo 3, Halo 4, and even CE.

versed helm
#

2 was 15

feral perch
#

Yep

tough elk
#

But you have to take in the fact that some of the missions on 5 were very short, your looking at how many missions, yes 5 had the same amount of missions as 2 but they weren’t nearly as long as most of 2s mission were. And I think that’s worth noting in this conversation

versed helm
#

H2 was also 2 campaigns basically

remote spruce
#

Both didn't play well

tough elk
#

Wait wait wait did you really just say that halo 2 didn’t play well?

versed helm
#

Oof

tough elk
#

Halo 2 was an amazing and very innovative game for its time

#

@versed helm also I just realized you could say h5 was kinda 2 campaigns

versed helm
#

More like 3/16ths and 13/16ths

tough elk
#

True

#

Lol

#

Cause what there’s only like 3-5 missions that your chief but still the game was pretty short compared to it predecessors

lilac prism
#

What's the in lore reason for the grunts (and latter in the universe other species of the covenant too) speaking English?

obsidian thistle
#

Either autotranslated stuff via armor, or they learnt it. Thats the two accepted reasons

Mostly its just ease of the viewer cause sometimes English makes no sense in terms of the scenario xD Halo 2s Thel levels for example

carmine sleet
#

Aye, it would be pretty annoying trying to play through the Arbiter levels if we had no idea what was being said

brisk cape
#

Iirc a good bit of Elites learned English by decree of the Prophets so that they could mock humans as they lay dying /before a battle. The rest I’d guess are more or less the same thing. As well as the gameplay reasons.

last anchor
#

Yeah. Obviously, all of the Sangheili aren't speaking English to EACH OTHER.
Luckily for us the Covenant ALL speak Sangheili so

night tulip
#

Halo 5 is significantly shorter in terms of length than halo 2

#

Yeah sure it had the same amount of missions

#

But 3 of those were just walking around and talking to people

#

So 12 actual missions that were all shorter than halo 2

#

And 3 of them were chief, 9 were Locke

tough elk
#

^^^^^

feral perch
#

I don't think every Halo 5 level is shorter than the shortest Halo 2 level

#

Swords of Sanghelios was fairly long, and Cairo Station and Outskirts were rather short. So is "The Arbiter." I'll bet Reunion is longer than that one.

night tulip
#

It took me the same amount of time to beat swords of sangheilios as cairo

feral perch
#

On what difficulty?

night tulip
#

Legendary

#

Well

#

I had a partner who kept running in and dying for H2

feral perch
#

Cairo Station is significantly harder than Swords

#

Halo 5 wasn't hard, just cheap

night tulip
#

I mean you have a squad to revive you in H5

feral perch
#

They're awful, they usually die before they can revive you

#

And their pathfinding is dumb too

night tulip
#

Yeah... I feel like a better squad system is republic commando

#

Didn’t they take inspiration from that game?

carmine sleet
#

Funny you bring up Republic Commando, Tim Longo, who worked on that, worked on Halo 5 as well

night tulip
#

Yeah that

feral perch
#

Some of the same developers-yeah

night tulip
#

🤔

white idol
#

Hey guys

#

I don't actually play Halo

#

But I've spent a day or two looking over the lore

#

And plot of the games

#

It's really really good

last anchor
#

There are few games with as deep lore as Halo and for that, we are thankful

white idol
#

Honestly though

#

I've been looking through a lot of flood lore

#

So apparently the flood are the "mutated" and "corrupted" remnants of the Precursors

#

But on the other hand

#

Why are they portrayed to be so strictly bad?

#

I went over the conversations between Mendicant Bias and the ancient flood/precursor being

#

It does kind of have a point

#

Is the flood, in a way, not just a hyper-advanced type of civilization just like any other?

last anchor
#

Yes. As far as we can tell.

#

The main issue is that they dont listen to reason and dont try to work with others

white idol
#

It's purpose is to "consume", perhaps, but it does so in a way that's very different from the "zombie apocalypse" type thing we see

last anchor
#

They just consume.

white idol
#

Fair enough

#

But they consume because they just do things better

last anchor
#

Techincally. But that violates the Mantle

white idol
#

I mean apparently near the end of the Forerunner-Flood war the keymind could control star roads

#

Precursor structures

last anchor
#

Yes

#

Thats how they mashed the Greater Ark

white idol
#

Yah

#

Like jesus CHRIST

#

Precursor technology

#

And they figured it out in what

#

A couple years?

#

And the mantle of responsibility is such a vague idea regardless

#

It's not like the forerunners followed it properly

last anchor
#

True, hence why they were to be replaced by humans (hopefully).

#

And considering they knew how to use Star Roads before, it was less learning how and more relearning

white idol
#

Oh yeah that's true

#

Since the flood is still basically the precursors

#

But caveman-y

last anchor
#

Yes

white idol
#

On the other hand

#

Is it not reasonable to assume that the whole Halo story is told from a very limited and somewhat biased perspective

#

Of the forerunners/humans/e.g.

#

The precursors afaik was VERY different from all the bipedal humanoid civilizations we see

#

I have this weird headcanon that although the flood is a somewhat warped version of the original precursors it still was following the mantle of responsiblity

#

In a twisted way

#

But that only applies to the stuff that happened long before our halo in the dealings with forerunners and prehistoric humans and such

#

Because it was implied that whatever was in the mids of whoever the flood "infected" was added to the gravemind

#

That could be interpreted almost like "preserving" life, no?

last anchor
#

Yes.
Considering that the "cure" the Forerunners searched for so valiently was, literally, the Flood saying "nah fam we done" and wililngly retreating...

white idol
#

Wait really?

#

I did not know that

last anchor
#

The Flood was the Precursor's route of vengance

white idol
#

Which part is that

last anchor
#

Yeah

#

Its first mentioned in Cryptum, but then gets expanded on in Primordium I think.

white idol
#

huh ok

last anchor
#

Basically the Humans found the Flood first and fought it back. They spoke to the Primordial, locked in its time-cage, about what to do. It told them a monsterious thing...and they did it.
They turned fully a third of their population into bioweapons and let the flood infect them.

#

It seemed that the Flood retreated...

#

In reality, it pulled back willingly, as Humanity was not due to be tested for the Mantle just yet

#

Then Humanity got devolved by the Forerunners for fighting them.

white idol
#

Ohhhh

#

Yeah

last anchor
#

And they searched for the cure, which did not exist...and then the Forerunner-flood war came

#

And it went downhill from there

white idol
#

I did see the part where the flood infected lots of humans and then just ignored the rest of the humans??

#

Not sure how that worked

last anchor
#

Pretty much. It turned back, vanished

#

As if humanity had beaten it

white idol
#

Oh but they actually just left

last anchor
#

Exactly.

#

There was no cure.

#

And when the Flood came back full force, it drove the Forerunners into extinction

#

Broke everything they had made. Turned them against themselves. And made them fire the Array.

#

A completely and utterly phyrric victory

white idol
#

Ohhh

#

So it can be interpreted as the flood being really angry precursors

#

They still liked humanity

#

But they were mad at the forerunners

#

How come that seemed to all go out of the window when it gets to the "current" Halo?

#

Then the flood just kinda

#

Eats everything

last anchor
#

It hasnt reached the coordinated stage

white idol
#

Or maybe that's because there was no proper grave

#

Ahh yeah

last anchor
#

No outbreak has gotten large enough

white idol
#

It was still in it's "KILL KILL KILL" stage?

last anchor
#

For the most part.

white idol
#

I liked the way that snek gravemind talked actually

last anchor
#

Once it reaches a secondary criticla mass thats when it really remembers its the Precursors

white idol
#

Sick prose

last anchor
#

Indeed.
I am a monument to all your sins is SUCH a power line

white idol
#

Also

#

I think a lot of the flood’s antagonistic nature to the player comes from how disgusting and repulsive it’s appearance is.

#

I mean

#

I read a sci fi short a while back

#

Independent of halo

#

And this IMMEDIATELY reminded me of it

#

Basically 20 thousand years later humanity is hyper advanced and has inegrated itself into massive supercomputers basically

#

Inside each individual can do whatever they want

#

Create universes

#

Play god, etc.

#

But the "final step"

#

Was when individuals began fusing

#

Personalities, knowledge

#

They merged together to make a new being

last anchor
#

The flood

white idol
#

YEAH

last anchor
#

Basically

white idol
#

DUDE

#

Imagine if the flood was less ugly

#

And "infected" in another way

last anchor
#

And less aggressively commanding

#

Yes

white idol
#

Maybe cool energy effects

#

They wouldn't even be the bad guys

last anchor
#

Give the host a bonus instead of turning them into a meatpuppet might be a good thing too

#

Symbiosis, rather than parasitism

white idol
#

Yup

#

Exactly

#

I always wondered what the "extragalactic" stage of the flood would actually look like

last anchor
#

What we see now, but entire planets moving is my guess

#

Some sort of horrific Bretheren Moon style thing.

white idol
#

Ahh

#

The Brethren Moons on the other hand

#

Is kinda ew

#

They don't really have the depth of graveminds/precursors/stuff

#

They're just kinda

#

"We are coming and we'll eat you"

#

"Ha-ha"

#

The big difference is that the flood takes the memories of new hosts and integrates them into itself imo

#

Necromorphs are

#

Just glorified zombies

#

Is there anyone else usually hanging around this channel?

last anchor
#

Im just using them as an example
Giant fully Flood-made planetoids

#

Capable of crossing the massive distances between galaxies

#

Theres a few people, you just came at a rather quiet time

#

It is saterday afternoon, a lot of people are out doing stuff

white idol
#

Oh yeah I get that

#

Also cool!

#

I just went off on a tangent myself

#

I might hang here more often

#

Halo universe is crazy

last anchor
#

This is the best place for ti

#

it

white idol
#

You know

#

There's another thing

#

The Gravemind/Keyminds is/are essentially just an incredibly powerful supercomputer with all the information ever gathered by the flood right

last anchor
#

Yes. More or less.

#

They are basically Flood Precursors at that point

white idol
#

Then what if they DID take over the entire galaxy?

#

What if the gravemind had

#

Hundreds of millenia

#

To just sit there and think

#

Would it still be so violent

#

Would it decide to change the way the flood looked out of boredom or try his hand at creating life himself the way precursors did?

#

Or is the whole aggressively consume thing genetically rooted in the flood

night tulip
#

jaysus well then

#

lotta messages of just you two

#

welcome to the fandom squirrel

white idol
#

Thank you

last anchor
#

Im not sure anyone really knows.
And yeah, Yamato, this is what happens when nerds get together XD

white idol
#

I'll probably never play Halo because FPS shooters are not my thing

#

But this is cool

last anchor
#

Its certainly possible the Flood could "chill".

night tulip
#

Are RTS's your thing?

last anchor
#

But we dont really know for sure and for the most part living beings prefer not to be consumed and repurposesd

white idol
#

What's the difference? (FPS and RTS)

#

You're right there

#

But that's what the primordial one said wasn't it

#

A collective consciousness is the "final" step of evolution that we know of

#

And the forerunners just weren't at that step to be willing to accept it yet

#

So it's argument was that the flood was an accelerant of evolution

severe elbow
#

No, the Flood's purpose at the time was to get revenge on the Forerunners for wiping out the Precursors, and to test humanity for the Mantle.

night tulip
#

forerunners were classified tech 1 and precursors were tech zero

white idol
#

It brought about the next step of transsentience maybe millions of years before the life would develop to that stage by itself?

#

@severe elbow Ohh

#

I've never read of the "test humanity" part

#

What did I miss?

night tulip
#

you know the precursors deemed humanity more worthy than the forerunners, and because of that, further testing was needed in order to see if humanity was worthy

last anchor
#

That was Silentium I think

#

Yeah.

#

The Flood was the test

white idol
#

Huh

#

Guess I don't have all the context then

night tulip
#

thats also the reason the forerunners felt betrayed and revolted...

severe elbow
#

Precursors created both Forerunners and humans, and decided humans would inherit the Mantle of Responsibility. The Forerunners wanted it for themselves, so they rose up against the Precursors and wiped most of them out.

night tulip
#

well

white idol
#

Ohhh

#

I always thought the flood was because the precursors tried to save themselves with the whole "turn to dust" shenanigans

severe elbow
#

Some Forerunenrs also insisted that the Precurosrs planned to wipe out the Forerunners, so there's a some doubt as to the truth behind the cause of the conflict.

white idol
#

But it messed up in transit

last anchor
#

They did, sorta.

#

And it did

white idol
#

So they ended up all weird

last anchor
#

But even twisted, they still remembered

#

And they went about doing it in a harsher, groaty way

night tulip
#

im of the opinion that the precursors are creatures from slipspace and that they kinda just left the milky way back to their own universe or somethiing

#

but

#

i could be completly wrong

white idol
#

I've never seen anything related to that

night tulip
#

just me theorizing

white idol
#

But yeah I really wish there was some way to find out what would've happened millions of years after if the flood did win

#

The gravemind is, in a way, a hyper-AI after all

#

Or maybe not and I'm high

night tulip
#

mmm not entirely wrong

white idol
#

Could he not achieve metastability from a state of rampancy (KILL EVERYTHING INFECT EVERYTHING) much like mendicant bias did?

#

Like I mean he's gotta get bored if he has nothing to consume

severe elbow
#

The surviving Precurosors planned to change themselves into dust, and reconstitute themselves at a later date. But something went wrong, and they never reformed from the dust. The dust was found by ancient humans who couldn't find anything wrong with it in their studies. But they found it useful for domesticating an animal species called the Pheru, so they used it for that. Over generations, that became the Flood. This was considered by the Primordial, possibly the last surviving Precursor to not be intentional, but was considered to be appropriate for getting revenge on the Forerunners and testing humanity.

white idol
#

What's he going to do just sit there?

#

Ohh da mn

#

I'd like to read that

#

Is that a book or something

#

(Why am I not allowed to say da m n)

severe elbow
#

Yes, the Forerunner Saga, Cryptum, Primordium, and Silentium.

white idol
#

Alright I gotta look into that

#

On the other hand and from another perspective

#

Why the f would the forerunners keep flood specimens

#

Like DUDE

severe elbow
#

The Gravemind also has the memories of the Primordial, hence it referencing the Flood War.

white idol
#

The Gravemind in current Halo?

severe elbow
#

Because they knew the Flood would eventually return, and finding a cure was the only hope for a permanent solution.

#

Yes.

radiant sphinx
#

@white idol Probably because they still have means of containing them (the rings)

white idol
#

Oh yeah

#

The flood was still outside the galaxy right

radiant sphinx
#

^^as well as above

white idol
#

So they wanted the cure?

#

When did the flood leave the galaxy anyways?

radiant sphinx
#

Depending on era-wise, the flood made it to Earth by hitching a ride on High charity

#

Unless we’re talking pre-Halo games lore

white idol
#

Oh yeah

#

We're talking pre halo

radiant sphinx
#

Ah

severe elbow
#

High Charity never made it to Earth. The Flood got there on a Covenant ship called the Indulgence of Conviction.

#

Which did come from the High Charity infection, granted.

white idol
#

And then the Sangheili melted all of the flood

radiant sphinx
#

Yeah that’s what I meant

white idol
#

Are there more original non-flood precursors out there

#

I got the impression that they were extragalactic

severe elbow
#

Not known.

white idol
#

But did all the precursors end up coming to our galaxy?

severe elbow
#

Precursors had the capability to be extragalactic.

white idol
#

Or is there like this massive precursor civilization spanning multiple galaxies

radiant sphinx
#

Isn’t there an unknown potentially precursor specimen on the Halo 4 map “Abandoned”

white idol
#

Ah

severe elbow
#

But it's likely they originated in the Milky Way.

#

Since that's where the Domain is located.

night tulip
#

it doesnt mean all of them are dead though

severe elbow
#

No, but we have no leads on any others.

white idol
#

Ah

night tulip
#

I thought the domain was located on a planet suspended in slipspace or something?

white idol
#

Don't think

#

Not sure

severe elbow
#

Most of the Precurosors not killed by the Forerunners fled to Path Kethona, aka the Large Magenellic Cloud, where they were eliminated. Some became the dust. At least one, the Primordial, was in a high-tech cell.

#

They haven't said where the Domain is specifically located. Abaddon, the Precursor AI that helped the Forerunners connect to the Domain, was located on the Forerunner Capital, Maethrillian.

#

Granted, from Maethrillian, they were able to "reset" the Domain after the Halo Array was fired.

night tulip
#

I just idk I have a feeling the precursors are somewhere in slipspace, I mean halsey sent an AI there and it came back bad mouthing the forerunners or something...

#

granted she was too freaked out to do anything further and had lapses in memory after that

severe elbow
#

No, the AI came back far more powerful. It just has to do with Slipspace basically hyoercharging an AI to where it's ridiculously powerful. Kind of the same thing the Domain is doing for Cortana and the Created.

#

I don't recall it talking about the Forerunners.

white idol
#

On that note

#

Didn't the gravemind say the domain would be destroyed by the halos firing?

severe elbow
#

Yes. Seems as though it was simply damaged, though.

#

It was "reset" when a Forerunner, Growth-Through-Trial-of-Change, sacrificed herself to serve as the "template" for the "new" Domain.

#

Though the Halo Array's ability to destroy Precursor tech doesn't seem to be 100%, as Abaddon sruvived, even though it was damaged.

white idol
#

1 sec ima google

#

Dang what the no results

night tulip
#

Def guru, what do you think Cortana's ultimate objective is with the domain and halo array at her command?

#

i mean upholding the mantle is

#

vague

white idol
#

Didn't that go out the window when she killed millions awakening the guardians

#

Btw how did the guardians awakening kill that many anyways