#h1-builds-and-combat
1 messages · Page 521 of 1
Y'all are awesome 
Only the guys? 
Duh
you're awesome too Nyaan 
She got Curse of Vengeance
Whom would I wreak havoc on?
@untold vortex kind words, but it's all meaningless now.
You had like 2 hours of sleep. Yikes. Did Hypnos abandon you?
My tag team partner has abandoned me, and I am stuck here in Elysium . . .
who sleeps anyways?
just pull a zag: look at your bed, press E, and walk away commenting on how wide awake you are
works for me every time
stuck here in Elysium
That's a weird way to spell Asphodel
Leave me be, strangers. Take these Death Defiances and be on your way. 
Aight thanks
Patty!
Patty saved my runs today
Wait. What's the leg one about. 
Have you even SEEN Patty's legs?
they're beautiful
like all the DD's and jerky he gives you
also I've watched Haelian stream too many times
I can't say I have paid attention to his legs.
look next time you walk through. You (probably) won't be disappointed.
He def waxes his legs
they're... shiny
What does that suppose to mean?
To me it looks like man legs are being categorically insulted
Patty is living proof that men can have nice legs
Maybe he just wants to feel like a dolphin
Oh but cutting in with an actual gameplay question rq, is poison damage scaled off of Hard labour or Heightened Security?
Because it can be applied by both, and I never let it tick long enough to find out. It occured to me I had no idea
That's a good question
But it's also caused by ground traps and thr puddles left behind by giant rats.
probably just scaled by whatever the cause is
Will test tomorrows if you don't get a definitive answer by then
Thanks, because it's something that I can't really test too often in standard gameplay (what with the immediate oh gross get it away reaction)
I enjoy being poisoned. Gives a bit of a rush, similar to that of TD and FO
I don't know if it's affected at all.
But just in case
To Do:
Poison self for @ Silvaria
If you are interested still, I'll test that in the next run. No bamboozle.
Lysol I appreciate you even if that made me wince
And thanks, FoxHope! It's just something I hadn't ever wondered if it IS affected by damage modifiers or not.
No I have my curiosity too
Curiosity killed the dog.
Like the vase with Hades is trap
wanna ping me with the results plz
But the damage from skulk is scaled with hard labor
And does proc acorn
Yeah probably in like and hour or so.
I'm watching a show xD
Better than me. I'm currently
💪 napping
Yes. I can tell you are napping.
And @dry ember, it means I care zero, zip, nada for how his legs look. 
Curiosity killed the dog.
That's rich coming from someone with Mewmew in their name
I'm rich. What are you gonna do about it?
What is this talk about legs?
Rich because my heart is filled with Lady Aphrodite's love. 
Yeah, her legs emanate too much love they can't be seen in her art
No, we're talking about Patty's legs
Oooh.... wait, what?
Who is best gril, for the record
They said I should look at Patroclus's legs.
I'm like he's a guy though.
¯_(ツ)_/¯
He was a warrior, his legs must look nice 
What does any of this have to do with game strats? 😂
Well, it all started with me being sad because you abandoned me.
Never~
Edited
And the best way I can tie this to actual gameplay is people trying to low-key bribe Patroclus to pop up in runs by complimenting him
And hey it probably works for Most NPCs.... right? I haven't just been talking about how cool Athena is for areason or anyhing >.>
If that'd be the case, he'd never show up for me because I rage at him too much for not appearing when I need him while appearing when I don't need him
I do that, too.
And he also does not appear when I need him.
So . . . maybe it does work like that.
When I need Patty's DDs and I don't get them, I don't mourn for the run
or the DDs
I mourn because I didn't get to see Patty
You're all weird.
It's so nice getting a run to that point, seeing him, and being able to take the jerky, though. Thesus just melts and iit's hilarious
Speaking of going off-topic so much, by the way, I've been curious for a while:
how the heck do you make a good rail build
bc mine suck
@naive tusk please do something about this slander. 
A lot of flat damage on hit effects, OR you go for the classic bread and butter of Artemis special and Aphro attack.
Why Heartbreak Strike?
@naive tusk thank you. 
Like, idk, you probably Could have somethnig else there that fits it better, but I've had better success wiith going for that combo personally.
It sounds like a good combo.
"Also testing poison now
Which weapon should I use?"
@dry ember doesn't matter, whatever gets you to styx with lots of health
Pick Aphrodite's Eternal Rose for Life Affirmation ❤️
Fare thee well, beautiful Hades players
I'm going to actually nap now
Yes, carrying the Eternal Rose close to my heart is Life Affirmation for me.
E
fawns
Enjoy the nap!
@magic dagger farewell, stranger. Until we meet again.
"Can't Sleep"
-Zag
Gnight, Lysol!
Why purse? Are you robbing him in his sleep? 
You can't do that. We're a face tag team. 
Another day another dawn
Iiiit's Hades the Guessing Game time! Where you get to guess what a purse has anything to do with sleep! 
AhemHypnosAhem
If it's a big purse, you can use it as a pillow.
If it is an even bigger purse, you can use it as a mattress.
If you order food between naps, you do not need to get up to get your money.
The day has only started and you're already going way off-topic. 
Need to stay on-topic, so @naive tusk doesn't get into trouble for not keeping us on-topic. 
Sooo who's like me and picks Cthonic Coin Purse in Tartarus 90% of the time?
You already know I pick Owl Pendant 90% of the time. 
Until recently I only took the Arrowhead || because Artemis refused to make any sense ||
How else am I supposed to get my crutch strategic dash or attack?
What's "regular" for you at this point?
Hard to say.
Best way to answer would probably be just working up the bounties until 20 heat has been reached
but I have also done some 32 heat runs like that.
Deep Pockets or Golden Touch?
Pro-talk here 
I always take 100 coins at the start.
Is somebody here getting paid for playing? 
I am a real big and impulsive spender, I never save my Obols for later if something good/interesting is for sale.
I see I see. I don't really save mine, either. But I still think I get more coins out of Golden Touch over a run, more often than not.
Technicly, the Developers are getting paid for playing.
Well or rather, pay themselves.
@earnest ravine @magic dagger so the Poison by the Satyrs scale by Hard Labor, which is 2 per tick per stack
2 per tic per stack, yes?
Poison created by Rats and Traps scales by Heightened Security, which is 4 per tick per stack
yes I was careful in makign sure only one stack is applied
So it actually is differentiated? Oh man, that's neat!
Thank you for testing that out!
yeah np.
I honestly did not know poison in Styx can stack.
I could have saved some screenshots
but rn i can't for some reasons
....
just take my words I guess, I checked it twice for each scenario
I think the big miniboss Satyr applies multiple stacks at once.
I will take you at face value here because it does not change my gameplay of "Not wanting to get poisoned" and "Immediatly going for the Anti-Dote everytime I am poisoned".
yeah non boss nobs
armored though
But shouldn't make a difference
I have no BP on anyway
Frostbitten Horn or Overflowing Cup in Tartarus for an Ice Wine build?
With Excalibur.
I almost never start a run knowing what I will or want to see.
I go through Tartarus, see what I can find, then build me up from there.
Hmm I see.
If I were to actively go for Iced Wine, I would start with Dionysus in order to get the Cast first asap.
Probably Dio, he’ll give you more value with the cast early.
That and you do not want to make things awkward by having Demete roffer you her cast.
I was thinking using the Horn first would make sure that later I get Trippy Shot instead of being offered something else and having to reroll.
Because I could fill some core boons before Asphodel.
I'm actually gonna try going with Chaos Egg, though. That sounds interesting.
Chaos Egg is amazing if you use Persuacion.
Ooh say hello to Cool Voice Fetus Cloud for me
Rerolling Wells into Chaos is a good thing. Being able to reroll Chaos for useful stuff is too.
Because you can see Chaos multiple times semi reliable like this, Chaos' Egg is actually the only god keepsake that is worth to keep for more than one floor if you really want to.
Wow, when it rains it pours. I got all the resources I needed to 1. Open up nyx's gate, 2. Help Dusa renovate the lounge, and 3. Void Orpheus's contact all in the same go.
Must be nice to get quests to proc instead of dialogue about random bits of lore lmao
Still haven't beat Hades tho
I keep thinking I'll trigger zag's bed another time somehow
i've discovered it's never too early to farm resources
since i'm still missing a lot of darkness and gem upgrades
so don't worry if you can't beat hades, you're still making progress
Hey you should get some mirror upgrade done before Nyx quest though. It's more efficient that way I think
i think it's too late if he has the gate open
@cunning urchin per your feedback, the first time I paid 3 diamonds for it, I had no ideadl what changed
Had to come here and ask
Some runs later, still don't use it lol
That "shortcut" is a waste of money
it's the loosest definition of shortcut if i've ever seen one
Shhh it saves you one dash
Another ploy from SSG to make people actually try Ruthless Reflex
Smh my head, can't fool me
Erm sure
puts em in an aquarium?
New PB too
wanted to like a super tank build with it
yeah and new pb it was gas
First run with that aspect
I always play tanks in MMOs so once I saw that I knew I had to try it
You did good!
hi guys, i vaguely remember reading about boon/god mechanics where you can only see up to 4 gods per run? is there a rundown text guide on this, or could somebody explain it to me. i.e. is it up to 4 gods per run, but they're only counted IF i pick up a boon, or is it counted if a room generates that offers a boon from a god?
there's no limit to the number of gods per run
no? so in one run i could in theory see all the gods?
yep
is there a system in place that nudges more of a god to show up the more i have boons from them then?
not as far as I'm aware
however, you can use keepsakes to force the next god to be one of your choice
neat, thankies
no problem
what about Theseus then? if all the gods can be in a run, that means some of them will help both him and Zag
And that never happened so far afaik
I am sure that you cannot meet all gods up until you meet Theseus.
It was possible to guarantee that you meet all the gods up until Styx, but that is no longer possible since they have introduced Demeter if memory serves me right.
Tartarus can offer up to four individual gods in total, 5 if you include hermes, 6 if you include Chaos
you can then bring one god keepsake to Asphodel, one to Elysium and one to Styx to force three more gods in
Making for a total of 7 (main) olympians.
We have 8 now though. Zeus/Pos Athena/Ares Demeter/Dio Artemis/Aphro
Those pairings are how I remember the gods being in this game.
The brothers, the rivals, the best gods, the cute ones
is guan yu even worth upgrading?
yeah it is
guan yu at its lowest stage kind of meh getting for
but once its fully upgraded it is a game changer
What in the name of hell is that run
It's about as good as you can make zeus without the duos what the hell, sans the levels
And you somehow got 400 hp as well
There is one Icon I do not recognize.
Second row from the left, second symbol from the top
i'm pretty sure that's chaos's DD
I actually do not know how that symbol looks like.
I kinda doubt that it is that because he has 4 total DDs but one of them is the Tooth
maybe, i couldn't remember the difference between skelly and chaos's DD symbol
Skellys is almost the last DD to use up (which is bad by the way and should be changed) and has a skull Icon.
Chaos' DD is always to the right and has a purple eye that would kinda remind you of Chaos' Shield.
i have no guesses left, now i'm curious
Skelly's is probably last because it triggers after SDs, and they're probably set up in the same order
Which is bad. He should be the first DD to use for a hundred reasons that would make it more usable.
It always resurrects you with 100 HP, making it, in a lot of cases, worse than a regular DD lategame but better than a regular early on, which means that it would be a much more attractive choice to use on earlier floors if it were the first DD to be used up instead of the last. This would also not take away any of its current usefulness as a lategame keepsake.
I'm not saying you're wrong—I'm just saying it would take a bit of reorganizing in the code. I only just started using DD (once I got enough Darkness to have more than 1) so I'm used to SD
@turbid arch it's the god mode damage reduction icon :)
Aah. That explains why I did not recognize it.
Yeah, I used to use God mode when I sucked at this game even more than I do now
And it's always in that slot
when a door has a skull on it, what do the red notches represent next to it ?
check pinned messages , theres a post that explains it
you need to scroll down a bit in the pinned messages
actually, to make things easier for you @surreal hound here you go ^_^
all good it happens, glad you found it 
didn't realize the boss room had a little star
if that damn little vermin had one, that would be great, so i don't touch that door with a 67m stick
would be a good idea to put that in feedback Sancre ^_^
i guess that's a no XD
i wasn't sure really
cause i just noticed about the little star
ahhhh I getcha
gonna post it nevertheless
might help save a future run
although i kinda get that if you go into elites, you're really desperate for a boon or you have a run winning build already
it would definitely help those who want to avoid lil vermin like yourself ^_^
it's probably a lot
i mean, only found it like 2 times and killed it both, but it wasn't an easy fight, that's for sure
mmhm, I enjoy the fight personally, but agree that it can definitely be challenging
I never
noticed
the red notches.
Remarkable.
Also, the screenshots that Raj posted in #hades-feedback
Disgusting
i feel witches are among the most delectable enemies to get benefits package boons
i got a room in asphodell with several witches with the tracking boon
room was often almost fully purple cause of the bullets
i had athene dash and still was taking damage left and right because i couldn't see magma or deflect all endless waves of tracking bullets XD
Witches are even more ridiculous because they do not only get the benefits of Benefits Package
but also gain Homing On top of it.
I am not sure if other enemies get similiar additional otherwise non-mentioned benefits aside from the witch-type enemies.
A lot of enemies gain extra benefits if they have armor on.
Shield Heroes have a charge attack, armored, they also do a spinning move afterwards.
Witches usually only get extra projectiles when they are armored, three of them, the spreaders shoot three waves
and because THAT was not enough, Steve decided that they also needed homing.
Have you ever seen a spreader shooting out 15 bullets out, all of them homing in on you super hard?
Have you ever seen 3-5 spreaders do that at the same time!
My god, my PTSD is kicking in....I need a restaurant
yep, exactly what happened to me XD
literally there were so many purple bullets in there going towards me that i couldn't see the magma
or stop dashing, because there wasn't any free space where zag could fit
I actually went to the restaurant.
Mountains of meat and a lot of fruit as dessert.
Feeling better now.
zag aspect sword with double edge, splash dash and drunken flourish is a good idea right?
Depends, what is "Splash dash"?
probably posi dash
I'd be careful with Poseidon Dash on the sword because it can make you knock your enemies out of attacking range
mmm, blizzard shot feels pretty nice, even in a build with only 1 stygian cast. I only lost 30 hp in hades fight because I was just throwing cast and sitting behind the shield
bonus cast damage affects shards damage, right?
poseidon dash is a bit of a wildcard with melees
also if you have poseidon dash dont recommend get aphro cast... for obvious reasons that i had to learn the hard way XD
knockback'd the very enemies i wanted to shotgun cast lmao
don't need to get in sword range if your dash already acts like a localized nuke
das true tho
my dash was a white but my cast was epic level 3 i think with about 240+ damage 😔
it was a little better with razor shoals so i could get privilege status but still a dumb learning curve on my part XD
You don't need to worry about knockback if you apply 3 stacks of dot before your enemies get away
461 health also helps tho
also, you can just chase your enemies if you're spamming dash-strikes anyways
How do you get greater recall?
thanks!
Needs to be said that Bad News feels remarkably rare.
I hardly hunt for Greater Recall in the first place because I do not have Infernal Soul most of the time
but yeah, that one is pretty rare too.
I feel like an issue with our boy Hermes is that he has a ton of boons but shows up much more rarely than the others.
I mean, that’s ‘cause he basically functions like a Daedalus hammer so you either get a legendary on the second boon or you have to try to buy it in Styx for a exorbitant amount of obol.
I just took 64 damage from asterius spin because I got stuck trying to dash along the wall👍
walls are the enemy
anyone have any tips for the dudes in elysium
they're so hard to hit with the spear
so thin
improving aim is paramount to improving with spear
and most weapons, tbh
aside from that, it depends on which elysium enemy you mean
all 4 warriors are to be handled a bit different
which one give you the most problems?
really, all of them
guess i'm just too used to the incredibly fat enemies in tartarus/asphodel
learn their attacks and plan your actions in anticipation of them. Hit shields from behind or with piercing stuff (artemis cast and some hammer upgrades afaik).
for swords keep your distance
and wait for them to stop spazzing out around the whole place with dashes
be ready to dash yourself if they throw the ground spike projectile
The spear’s dash strike is pretty easy to build around and has a much larger aoe, might make it easier to hit ‘em on the fly. Pattern recognition is also really important for Elysium enemies. I would routinely take like 50 damage from the Spear dude poking me x3 before I realized how that attack worked.
yeah, guess it's just frustrating when they get stuck in a corner and still attack and their hitbox seems so infinitely small
gotta work on that aim
oh, that might be cause of hitboxes
if there is a bit of a wall, between both, your hits won't register
unless you use excalibur, that has wonky hitboxes
Of course, you can also get the ||Achilles Aspect|| unlocked and do a cast build, eliminating the need for the spear’s attack hitbox almost entirely
yeah i'm still very bad and haven't finished elysium yet LOL
Oh cool! You’ll get it haha. It’s like bosses; wait for the enemy to tire themselves out with an attack or two and try to sneak in some damage. After a while you’ll get used to their movement and how to prod them with the spear and its special.
It’s special attack, not just that the spear itself is special lmao
it's excellent for those pesky shielders
and might be great if they decide to add at least 2 more of those
Also remember that the enemies with yellow armor health bars won’t stagger while they have those and their attack patterns are harder to dodge.
AND THE GAME DID IT AGAIN!
Just doing a 19 Heat run, not thanking anything mean, trying to get Blizzard Shot on my poseidon sword for a good time
And then Bruiser Teleporting Snakestones appear in my very first Styx Room
I was literally screaming "OH MY GOD I CAN FEEL MY PTSD KICKING IN AGAIN!" at my screen.
Literally on the very first run I play after not having touched the game for a week. Now I am not one for esoterics, but I feel like the game is trying to send me a hot message there.,
Bruiser Snakestones are your life? That the message?
oh wow, aspect of hera and posi cast feels great
Btw, isn't Blizz shot a bit wasted on the Poseidon sword? The cast doesn't lodge.
Or can you cancel it early with that?
50% extra damage
More damage than I've ever had on the bow
frequent crits of 595 damage, backstabs deal 619
619 when I miss the powershot, that is
bad player here again: any tips for || minotaur/theseus||
don't die
alternatively, learn to recognize when asterius is about to charge, either dashes or bullrushes can get through him when he's charging without taking damage
it's mostly a matter of learning to see the windows you can pull that off
right, you will get used to keeping an eye on them both, and with theseus you just mainly have to consider his predictable spear throw or the spin if you're up close
yeah
theseus is mostly a matter of keeping an eye on the reticle to see when you're about to get harpoon'd
I just realized yesterday that when u upgrade weapons with titan blood you get to choose ONE form so ive kinda wasted a bunch of titan blood feelsbadman
think i might just not be patient enough
also always go for asterius first since theseus in phase one is an annoyance at best
and then focus on theseus when asterius is down
don't wear them down at the same time because things can and will get messy if they enter their last phases together
yeah, for speed's sake, you might go for theseus with a build that has decent aoe since asterius follows you deliberately while theseus (mostly) tries to keep distance by walking away
but for learning the fight, would definitely recommend asterius first
'ppreciate it y'all
np
Alright, so I got three major weapon aspects left to level up: Nemesis sword, Hades spear and Hestia rail. Any recommendations which are the most fun?
imo nemesis
big numbers = fun, and you're also incorporating both special and attack into your playstyle
Alright, that sounds like a convincing argument.
Plus Hades spear is kinda... everytime I try to get a spin build going I get one of the two hammer boons, never both.
i don't like spear so i can't say much about hades, and hestia rail is also powerful but imo i just don't like the style it has
Spear is fine if you're going for an Achilles cast build or Guan Yu as a whole. Basic spear is kinda super meh.
For Sword, Excalibur and Poseidon are fun to me. They also change the regular gameplay style around a lot.
For Spear, Guan Yu and Achilles are pretty good. Also change around the basic playstyle somewhat fiercly.
The Shield, Chaos Aspect is the best but Zeus is by far the most exciting to play around with.
Bow, I think Hera wins overall here.
Fists, Talos probably offers the biggest shift from regular fist gameplay, but I would not say that this weapon really is outstanding in general.
For the Rail, all aspects are great.
Personally I haven't really found Zeus shield all that great, played around with it a bit but didn't like it much. What do you put on there?
Hera bow is very good, don't get me wrong, I just think the playstyle is not my thing, really. You have like a big boom every couple seconds and are relegated to plonking away in the meantime. I've personally much preferred Chiron up to this point.
Also Zagreus fists with Merciful end is dope.
On Zeus Aspect, Drunken Flourish and Lightning Flourish are high DPS options that also apply debuffs for Privileged Status.
Hummm...
That's actually a good argument, haven't really used my mate Dionysus for much outside either his cast or his call...
Dionysus is a good alternative to zeus for the rail and fists in terms of stacking hangover quickly
Hera Aspect is basically a cast build weapon that lets you much better aim certain casts like Trippy Shot or at a distance Slicing Shot.
I just this moment finished a Hera Ice Wine/Scintillating Feast run. With Lvl3 Epic Trippy Shot, +9% crits from pressure points and Lvl 3 Epic heartbreak strike
melted everything
Drunken Strike on Malphon has very poor single-target DPS unless you hit and run a lot. It shines on multiple targets, though, if you move on from targets fast and let the Hangover damage to the rest.
very poor single-target DPS unless you hit and run a lot
To clarify, for hit-and-run tactics, it's stronger than (most?) other options. When zerging, it's actually the weakest except for maybe Tempest Strike.
How about when terraning or protossing?
Well, actually I haven't attempted Tempest Strike on Malphon yet. Maybe the knockback doesn't ruin zerging too much—especially on bosses.
Tempest Flourish definitely sucks with Demeter Aspect.
No what?
from what i saw when i played it, what happens is that the specials all happen first, then the knockback of all specials applies
That's not been my experience. And it puts them out of range of follow-up attacks, anyway.
Might have poor interactions with some hammer upgrades but not others.
with 5 specials, you're gonna be deleting a good bit of hp anyways
ah, i used explosive upper when i did it
It's 7 hits for Uppercuts and 6 hits for Dash-Uppers.
Tempest strike on Malphon fists doesn’t actually do much knockback, you can still rush your enemies no problem
Altho your damage will suffer because lol tempest strike damage
No, that's just the base DPS from Tempest Strike that is poor. It opens up your path to Rupture etc. which give excellent DPS.
I just unlocked Arthur Aspect and noticed there's a new zero-heat bounty for beating the last boss. Is that just another titan blood or something special?
i swear ice wine and fully loaded RNG are so bad
wasted all of my fated persuasion and literally no luck
Fully loaded requires exit wound now
ugh
Yeah it’s rough
what about ice wine?
I had 5 or 6 demeter boons
got the frost special almost immediately
i have legendary/duo proc'd
Ice wine is just Festive Fog + a demeter boon in the main hotbar
used 4 or 5 re-rolls persuasion
That one was just unlucky
ughhhhh
^
it's okay if it's on separate rolls
but it just keeps re-rolling the exact same boons
just really really unlucky
that's just the persuasion experience
They patched it out so you get something different, but yeah
if it doesn't get buffed then i'm never using it again
Welcome to RNG when the amount of boons is actually kinda low
it's not because of the boon amount
lol, weren't you the guy that wanted to write an article about how good persuasion is?
yeah i'm a persuasion main
but i think it needs to be buffed for how little we have so i put that in feedback
why is that even worth laughing at? persuasion is good in theory but the RNG in the game seems broken
I've already argued all of my points in feedback.
because experience teaches that every option has nuances that make things good and things bad pending on situations
RNG will always seem broken, from what I’ve seen accross multiple games and genres
So yeah
Statistics also says that we are not being promised on what we are sold on.
There's just no way that a purely RNG boon roll can get the exact same Chaos boons 3 times
what statistics?
from experience...
yeah i can keep track of them from now on
some n values?
i can do the statistical analysis if you are so cynical
that's not a problem
i'm convinced
that
I will tell you that from MY experience with the Persuation rolls, that it’s actually fine, RNG wise
just my opinion anyway
i am, mostly cause that would be helpful as feedback and understanding just exactly what FP does
^
since lots of mechanic exploration is done with FA
would you be willing to help gather data?
but almost none on FP
i'll share a google sheet on this
pends on how often i use FP
i think the easiest way to test RNG assuming all re-roll mechanics are equivalent for boons
is Chaos
just write down all the curse/boon combos you get
Well that was kinda nice, did a low heat darkness farm run and carried almost 2k darkness out of there.
if you get repeated ones, then note that down
But in my experience, my re-roll are definitely not uniformly random.
I always get repeated boons, and a lot of times all 3 are repeated with different stats.
I don't fundamentally believe stat re-rolls capture the point of Persuasion.
That's just my opinion.
i'm not doubting that
... shouldn’t you just gather the results first THEN analyze it ? I don’t see the point of just gathering the repeats
i'm doubting the assertion that it's statistically wrong
because there's no evidence for it
only feelings
^
even my own
True. I haven't shared any data but I will start collecting it.
I'm just saying from my memory, if I took all that data, it would be statistically meaningful for me.
You're welcome to distrust that.
Yup.
Well they did patch in so that you can’t get the exact same result after a reroll, if that counts as RNG manipulation
See, I interpreted doubt as in the negative connotation. If you were just skeptical, it would be less about opinion and more objective. That's the only reason why I am arguing my opinion on the other side. Not because I'm being lazy on the data, which I just haven't tabulated.
But now it's clear you are just skeptical.
It's possible.
@turbid needle I think they define that as in the stats.
Like if you don't get the exact same stats.
You can definitely get the exact same boons.
(In some permutation, actually. They switch places...)
Different rarity and all, yeah I implied that
exact boons is tricky because boon pools can vary pending on what you've unlocked, taken, etc
I would never re-roll for stats. Just compatibility.
First room boon is pretty much 4 boons only so yeah
And I do reroll there for that extra rarity damage
rerolling also for something like legendary/duo has to also consider the chances of those appearing
which i'm not sure anyone knows what the base appearance of those are
They are lower than before for sure LOL
but there are certainly scenarios where you only have 3 available boons for offerring and your 2-3 rerolls hits the "no duo/legendary" every time
They just have to correct their algorithm, since it has conditional bias. Perhaps they aren't changing the RNG properly when including newly accessible boons.
It's not clear from the probability-adjusting stats in the mirror how it works either.
correct
+10% as in everything else loses 10% or relatively speaking
multiplicative or substitutive/additive
it's super confusing
They need to put more thought into that when the game is so heavily dependent on RNG.
It's basically undergraduate mathematics to make it balanced. Someone just has to do it for every new addition to the game.
On one hand they could be more clear on the numbers themselves, on the other hand the RNG so far hasn’t been far off or anything
Yeah, and I probably won't use Persuasion if they decide not to buff it in terms of boon-variance. It's just my opinion that RNG-balancing is a necessity.
And RNG is actually harder than simple maths when you need to take into account the user bias, which you don’t need to, but yeah
i would not be surprised if the number of times I get what i want from a FP reroll is similar to times I don't
User bias is always there though. The point of the game is educating yourself to improve your own bias and improve in the game.
Unless they are constantly fighting that to make the game harder.
it's just the number of times where i reroll into the same or nonideal boon offerings are just easier to remember and feel worse
I didn't mean observational bias. What I found significant were the times I got the same boons regardless of if at least one of the boons was what I wanted.
Usually I get one of my boons.
It's because I didn't get my good boons until there was about 3 min. left and I was less than halfway through
Though it's very confusing when the other two are almost duplicates.
There must be something fishy when that's happened around 15 times (where I get the exact same boons) over an extended period of runs. I've only used Persuasion around 100 times since playing the game.
I'm going to gather some data.
And when you consider the available options, it’s actually fine. Many of the boons are tier 2s, duos, and whatnot. When your hotbar is filled be prepared to see lots of dupes
you'd have to gather a lot of data
But either way, as it is, I think they should buff it or fix the variance, regardless of what exact distribution this corner case falls into.
what boons you have when you pick it up
what boons you are offered
what mirror upgrades you have
That's why some help would be nice, or else nobody would believe me anyway.
actually, i guess that's it
Due to low N
Rarity upgrades
Poisson convergence happens after around N = 200 if we just considering a binary case of bad randomness vs good randomness
mini boss vs not miniboss
And that’s like 15-20 runs worth of rolls st ‘least
And for Chaos that’s even more
i'm sure there's a mod out there that gives unlimited keys
and you can just reroll chaos
that's how FA tests were done
Oh
Who did the FA tests?
i don't remember, googled it on reddit
I don't have the modding experience to do this on mass. All I can do is collect my own data.
The time you will take to learn modding will be MUCH shorter than you gathering data over runs for significant results
here's the other thing, if it took you this long of using FP to notice it's faults and you thought it was great until then, then maybe it works just fine for 90% of the playerbase who may never play that much
not to say the data isn't good
i think it's great to know mechanics
but the need to change it, might be way lower on the priority list
I never thought it was that great. I'm saying that it's exhibiting signs that severely cripple it.
I fundamentally like it a lot.
we also know the game has rng manipulation
In the end, I care enough to try to show that there's something about the game that can be improved.
so somewhere, internally, there's something less than full rng
Yeah, of course. We'll never learn the distribution accurately anyway.
@naive tusk has said something like certain boons are more likely to show up or practically guaranteed to show one of a certain pool. So with Persuasion rerolls, that would likely still take effect. I don't know.
Chaos boons are odd because there's the curse part and the boon part. No idea how it interacts with those. I rarely have bad luck with those, though.
A second reroll is rarely worth it unless you really really want something or the first reroll is just terrible.
Like if it's not your first zone and you have a death, Athena will likely give you death defiances and whatnot
Chaos boon re-rolls are the reason I put that up in #hades-feedback
Also, Persuasion increases in value when you get only 1-2 choices because you can reroll and aren't forced to take something that ruins your build.
Practically duplicated after a roll, with maybe 1 curse changing.
At least 1 will always change.
Their stats/rarity change. I can guarantee that I have gotten the 3 exact curse/boon pairs.
The way Chaos' curses and blessings work is still a mystery to me 
Maybe permuted.
Since I haven't taken a look at the coding in that section lol
the way chaos' curses and blessings work is still a mystery to me
working as intended then
chaos is so eldritch even his spaghetti code is incomprehensible
Also, something more recent is I got the same Legendary Chaos boon after a re-roll, which considering the entire pool of combinations, already seems very unlikely.
If you can't show that you got the exact same 3 boons offered, I won't take your word for it. I've actually reported a bug once thinking that happened, but then I realized one was actually different.
Just 1 is already enough to throw a red flag, and 3 seems like the game is just flexing on you,.
Maybe one curse was changed.
I actually have stumbled into Chaos' Legendary twice after using Fated Persuasion 
nice
Either way, my complaint about the lack of variance is still relevant.
wait does he even have a legendary
It's not even close to uniform RNG.
i think the other wrinkle to put in it is you also have to be careful about how powerful you make FP
wait does he even have a legendary
@neon fiber Yes, their Defiance boon is the Legendary.
oooh
in a game of replayability, you need to have options
no wonder i've never seen the bloody thing then
And again, it's just my opinion that it's not balanced.
Balanced for variety and effectiveness compared to FA.
does it have requirements as the other leggy boons or is it just rng lmao
1-2 being the same should happen frequently enough to notice it if you use Persuasion a lot. That's expected.
hs is messed up how does that thing only count for 1 heat
The pool of possible boons can be pretty small.
Pretty sure you need at 'least 1 chaos boon before it's Defiance boon shows up
well dang
It's somewhat overkill to strictly define my sense of balance. IMO, re-roll dynamics should be more transparent to inform us whether we should take FA or FP depending on heat and etc.
time to grab the e g g then
Well there's already the advantage of you being able to reroll Hermes/Chaos boons which is huge by itself already
If you want a threshold, I would think @cunning urchin comment about how it's expected to get 1-2 of the same boons is not reasonable. I think it should be more random.
I agree that they should be more transparent.
^
but expecting 1-2 of the same boon is random
No, it's expected when it's random to see that often enough that it's noticeable.
I think if you compute the expectation, it would be closer to seeing 0.66 of the same boon.
Just an estimate.
There's a lot of choices for boons after you pass Tier 1.
Chaos is just even more combinations.
So no, in the colloquial sense, I would disagree that seeing 1-2 of the same boon after 1 reroll is (uniformly) random.
I have to say, FA is also not so random because I seem to bump into many Centaur Hearts-Obols-Poms instead of boons when spamming FA on a door 
Unless you are used to using a different canonical prob distribution.
So both FA & FP are kinda not so random.
i do agree chaos is a good tester cause he doesn't have trees to deal with
You have 10 FA's.
Aren't boon rooms rarer than the Hearths/Obols/Poms already tho ?
Or is it the same chance
It's about the same, from experience.
Altho what I DO notice is rerolls in Styx are super consistent
I don't know, but I feel like each golden laurel reward should have an equal chance at appearing after using FA.
I decided to stay with FP because at least I can reroll Chaos & Hermes' choices, sometimes giving me better options. I will change to FA if I'm seeking duo boons or specific builds though.
More of the same stuff that should be transparent, IMO
Hm... I guess a 50/50 chance for both 
FP works with duo boons quite well, again from experience.
The fact that we don't really know the base numbers to begin with is odd
Those kind of appear in appropriate timeframes if you have the mirror ability.
Though the mirror ability for legend/duo isn't that much of a buff.
depending if it's additive or multiplicative
I meant, seeking duo boons as if seeking 1 of the 2 gods I want (changing Poseidon's door into Artemis/Aphrodite for Heart Rend, for example).
it's probably additive as most % boosts in the game are
ahh i see
but that's only an assumption
ofc ofc
cause who wants to actually test that?
It's not clear cause if it's additive, then how do the other percentages change?
^
There's a lot of choices for boons after you pass Tier 1.
There really aren't that many choices, and core boons are quickly practically out of the pool with how rare exchanges are.
Do they take a ratio and then subtract ratio * that buff?
Maybe.
Either way, the cumulative probability is not clear.
according to game files, there is a base % chance of legendary and duo boons appearing
Speaking of exchanges
Dio is drunk https://gyazo.com/4ba0f7d30fa8196419f00a960ec47c87
I'm still going back to computing the expectation.
Probability of getting 2 of the same boons is much worse than getting 1 of the same boon too, even if we only have 2 - 6 intermediate boons to pick from after Tier 1.
"Dio is drunk" that seems like a redundant statement
The choice system should make things more variable but the results don't match.
Fair LOL
@turbid needle what aspect?
But it's like, he practicaly did nothing for me because It's the last styx room I wanted
Zagreus aspect for spear
I'm just screwing around in 32 heat at this point LOL
Ah lol.
@turbid needle Any tips for Zagreus Spear? I want to like it more 
It's Guan-Yu lite pretty much
Well, that's a bit disappointing 
Since you still get decent damage on spear throws
trying to figure out how to use spear as well
I'm going with aspect of achilles but didn't work out so well : \
But yeah, don't be afraid to build around the hammer upgrades
They are build defining for the most part
Guan Yu gets way better damage on Special due to Piercing.
^
achilles is pretty fun for nyooom memes
Plus not losing your weapon.
My first 32 heat win was with Achilles LMAO
but currently most of the spear aspects are fairly underwhelming when compared to other weapons
^
You need another source of damage that Achilles can support.
The spear itself has somewhat unimpressive DPS imo.
Athena cast would like to know your location
It's actually great with Achilles
And in general is an undervalued cast
You'll want to pair it with Artemis/Aphrodite duos to get the most out of it
Zeus isn't a bad option either depending on your weapon/aspect
Since the duo is actually decent
It's not GREAT but it's there
Zagreus Aspect Varatha, in my opinion, is about as good as you would expect an aspect to be that's focused on throwing away your weapon while hordes of enemies try to kill you.
if you can get explosive throw, it solves the clunky problem of having to retrieve your spear every throw
but again, if that's your solution, you might as well guan yu
I actually like Poseidon a lot because of the knockback actually working well for the "Yeet at thy foe" plan spear usually plays
Then there's spin and rapid jab thrown in there
i use spearyeet so sparse that i actually prefer running ares's doom
helps me clear off some fleeing enemies while making cheese off close enemies
ares's based on special
i get some other attack
when i do get anything, RNGjesus ain't kind sometimes
@naive tusk try a Tidal Dash build + either Tempest Flourish, Curse of Pain, or Drunken Flourish, and hope for Chain Skewer. I think that might be fun and effective. Yeeting your weapon away might actually work well with a dash build lol.
Just an idea, anyway.
I always felt like the charge attack for the spear should not have been that huge 360 strike but instead more like what Guan Yu Special is
A strong forward throw with good impact and decent width
Only problem there would be that that would be too close to bow and shield
I will be trying that out for sure 
the charge attack in itself ain't a bad idea, helps to clear in area, that is something the lance often lacks without some boons
I like getting new ideas from other people 
it is, way, way too slow
Drunken Flourish, actually. So you can get Rupture + Hangover for a longlasting Privileged Status.
@naive tusk Do add into what Nyan is saying, Rapid jab builds are actually super powerful, and that's something Guan-Yu can't use. It's another option to get from hammers
I mean, when I think of what Spear combat should be, my first associations are usually "Melee to midrange combat, focus on piercing movements forward, Final Fantasy Dragoon Jumps"
Guan-Yu is more specialized, but Zag spear is much more versatile
@naive tusk from a couple days ago; artemis and skewers is fun for zag aspect if you want to use it in particular!
Big Swinging Attacks usually not my first idea because I think that spears are not the best weapons for that.
Sure you COULD do it, but you would need to pull some levels of SSBM Marth Gameplay, as in, making sure to always hit an enemy with the spear tip.
they aren't, but i think that's why they picked a naginata like guan yu XD
@naive tusk Vicious Skewer is actually pretty good too for damage if you can get it https://gyazo.com/e2a0b22eb862ef8c53631e1351f8220f
Why can't Spear spin instead be a Jump à la Final Fantasy. That would be fun.
I suggested that many moons ago for the special.
I mean the spear dudes do that already
in Elysium
hell even the shield dudes do more spinning then them LOL
Yeah, it's a tragedy that spear heroes are better spear wielders than us
I think I would enjoy playing an Elysium Spear Hero more than I do playing with Varatha.
But maybe that is just me having too much respect for those scumbags.
What nice ideas! I actually tried Deadly Flourish + Chain Skewer along with Hunter's Mark. It was a janitor's dream 👌
I mean, we could then go and look at other spear wielders in the game.
Hades, who uses his spear more like a sword with his 3 hit swing combo and his 360 swing
He does have a stinging motion, but you can do those with a sword as well.
hades 360 no-scopes like a champ and he doesn't even use guns
And then there is Theseus who uses the same special as Zagreus, but with better aiming
And he also does a wild 360 spin
He does it twice though
Oh, idea
Theseus also cheats by dual-wielding tho
hades 360 no-scopes
I was going to say the same thing about Longspears lol.
Like he has a shield, who's to say he's spining because of the spear or because of the shield like the elysium shield dudes
From off-screen.
Good point.
Theseus is a new dark souls player
LMAO
we can also 360 no scope with the spear but our sweep sucks
😔
2H and iframes baybee
What you actually mean is Theseus cheats by dual wielding miniguns
Technicly, they could introduce Zagreus dual wielding pretty easily.
... second phase
And I guess a chariot
But yeah double miniguns too
Put a weapon into slot 1, put another weapon into slot 2. Weapon 1 uses its attack, weapon 2 uses it's special.
Would throw out the balance right out the window
That'd be neat, but also sorta confusing
but I'll be damned if that would not create hilarious runs
yeah
why can't we use malphon and another weapon
Say you go for Shield Main and Sword off hand
You know, I didn’t even think about the absurdity until now when I put it into words but....miniguns?
Sword can actually have a projectile !
You can Shield Charge Attack into your enemy and follow it up with a sword nova
haha macedonian go brrrrrrrrrrr
You could throw Bow Attacks out while throwing out Rail grenades.
shhhh, don't give them ideas
Sword does have a projectile though
i don't want thesseus to get adamant on his chariot, and then get down with malphon, varatha and aegis
Shield + Malphon would be amazing!
Shield Attack + Shield Charge + Dash Specials of Malphon.
small shields are used as knucke dusters sometimes
you would be the ultimate Brawler
so it wouldn't be that weird to have both
Melee Martial Artist + Shield wielder would be my personal favorite kind of fantasy character.
Shield Wielding Monk
monks already work more or less like that, but they themselves are the shields
Yoooo dawg
Actually, Shield attack + Bow special. Get those shotgun hits more easily
I heard you like shields so we put a shield on your human shield monk so you can shield while you shield.
XZibit approves.
i would like a proficent shield wearing class, but people don't have much creativity to get a good shield moveset going on 😦
I mean, Supergiant did a great job turning a shield into an offensive and defensive masterpiece.
Then there is Captain America who finds new and inventive ways to break the laws of physics with his vibranium shield
cap uses american magic to bring the shield back
Shield Attack + Shield Charge + Dash Specials of Malphon.
That's basically what I do in my Malphon builds with Divine Strike + Divine Dash + Explosive Upper lol.
And don't get me started on this gentleman https://gamepedia.cursecdn.com/smite_gamepedia/e/ea/SkinShot_Cabrakan_Default2.png
If you count card games, Reva from One Step From Eden too LOL
Oh yeah, Darksiders 2 had gauntlets that you could use for defense and offense.
All about reflects and stuff
Problem with that game was that you never really wanted to do that because of how OP his arcane spells were.
Crows + Zombie Army kept you alive for days while killing everyone and the scythes gave you OP wrath regeneration with the right passive.
But I digress.
yeah, but the possibility is there XD
gave a good old beating while being able to use an energy shield on the run
don't know if this will show a photo
let me see
it does, good
Yeah, the design on those were pretty nice. But then again, "style" was never one of Darksiders problems for the most part, especially in game 2. Death made everything work.
In terms of satisfying shield gameplay, Curse Of The Dead Gods also made a good job.
Shield bash with strong knockback, shield charge with a stun, shield combo finisher for decent damage and strong knock back.
it's not an easy gameplay to land, that's for sure
i'm i'm glad supergiant managed to land it
they even went ahead and added some special twist like zeus's special
I am waiting for what the shield aspect will be.
^
It will have to pack one hell of a punch
same
also really curious about the fists
I hope that the fist aspect will do for me what the Guan Yu Aspect did.
and currently wondering about what the hell are they going to do with exagryph
"Make me care for a weapon I otherwise could not care less for."
i still say that aspect of rambo is objectively the best choice
for a fourth exagryph aspect
With Arthur, they have proven that they are willing to go into past fiction.
With Rail, they might take it into SciFi and give Zagreus a laser gun.
Has anyone else been calling the Bone Hydra "Lernard"
What if the Shield Aspect will turn into Kung Laos head from MK11?
That'd be a hilarious twist.
depends on which shield they take
if they take El Cid's shield, with a dragon head, i would be all out for having a shield that can bite and carry enemies around, using them as shields
why not Svalinn?
it's a norse shield that stands between the earth and the sun to prevent it from being scorched
ozone layer shield confirmed
@turbid arch have you posted any feedback for changes you'd want to see for Malphon?
did any human get to carry svalinn?
Not a lot and some of it has already been implemented.
I do not play Malphon a lot and I would not know what kind of substancial changes I would like to make to it in order to make me like it more.
unsure but iirc fourth aspects don't necessarily require a future human wielder, i think supergiant just said they wanted fourth aspects to be an exotic aspect
A problem is that I have a hard time gauging how strong the weapon actually is because it is hard to get a solid idea on how strong my attacks are because of the counting system.
I do know that I dislike the weapon aspects a lot for a couple of reasons.
"shut up and eat the skull boy" -Hades
@dry ember Your wish comes true. Hades now hits for 160 damage.
I see I see.
I don't think it even needs EM4 for that.
he already hits for 80 base with 100% extra damage.
isnt 80 with hard labor?
Yeah.
i'm actually terrified about EM4
And then you eat a caststone.
also i have made a great discovery
some people think that EM3 is about ||busting out things from the armory for theseus and asterion but the real theme of EM3 is teaching the heroes to do circles:
asterius learns to spin2win and theseus does sick wheelies around the arena with his macedonian||
When you have a big ass chariot chasing you, it happens more often than you'd think LOL
Hades is just trying to be a good dad by playing catch with his son outside
... Yeah that'll happen LOL
"boy let's play catch
the rules say you have to catch the ball with your face" -Hades
LOL
It's not Hades fault his sense of love is skewed by his trauma with Kronos
Hasted Brimstones might be the best way to commit suicide
I don't like pressing the give up button
nah
Bruiser Puller Snakestones on melee weapons
I saw.
Now that's pain
How about Bruiser and Homing on the Witches when they do nothing but stand above lava
how about the entire map is lava
actually
it would be really crazy
if we have a mod that makes every tile in the game is some combination of traps and arrow traps
what is wrong with you
Heightened Security would like to know your location
chop chop modders
and you basically have a boss rush
make a nightmare biome
have you seen the stuff that the Hollow Knight community is coming up with?
Every tile on the ground is a trap
savior teleporting snakestones
but you use Excalibur
INB4 Secret Chaos room that is basically just that
they made some obscene mods
Skyrim screaming memes in the distance
are you saying obscene like skyrim mod obscene or obscene like i mario maker obscene?
mario maker obscene
oh ok
Skyrim is notorious to have some of the most memetastic mods
And is a meme game itself kinda
i don't play skyrim either
Never played Skyrim, I just learned that from the various memes surrounding it
lmao 3 people who never touched the game are now discussing it
Stay on-topic. 
you are not a mod, i ain't scared of you
But my tag team partner is. 
Stay on-topic.
this is on topic, i'm only using references to understand Hades modding
cause it's a christian server
Wait I thought this was a greek server
even the greeks were more obscene
If we go by the overall tone in here, definitivly more modern christianity than ancient greek.
... How is your god not Bouldy
just nectar sacrifice
tomato tomato
What about Tomatos?
Than tomato
Either way
Couldn't quite get the victory screen to work, but uh shotgun bow build is fun
is this your first 32 or ?
not even close at this point
ok lol
It's like my 20th at 'least