#thread
1 messages Ā· Page 1 of 1 (latest)
hu
hi
hello
hello
Salutations
this icon looks good

best icon ever
i prefer the first one but this one is nice
yh
my take, this doesn't fit the idea the original design has
too realistic
yeah
thought millers would win ngl
oof
the first one tbh fits
its a nice render/model but doesnt really fit it
i think people are just voting based on the looks, not the actual fitting idea š
same
its too realistic compared to the actual icon
this doesnt fit
exactly
too realistic
the actual logo is too small
itll probably transparency crop bad
the logo doesnt even fit in the punpkin it looks fat
I regret doing this
welp.
I legit thought miller would win by a landslide
me too ngl this one is kinda meh
uhm! time to use my powers to fix the votes
vote middle today
who said we hve to be democracy
show who the real ones in charge rae
removes all reactions
dont worry miller
fat pumpkn
u 2 will be winners
staff votes are 100x power
yes.
so real
what about we use this one for 20 minutes so everyone can see how awful it is
then host a revote
good idea

deal
the only thing abt the middle is the background
and the water mark
sigma
I dont understand why people put watermarks on them
is gonna use
nobodys stealing your shit
Rsc halloween logo

for their work ???
true š
literally that art has no use other than to be the logo for a month
bro thats a good question
haha i broke da 69
i love skibidi toilet
itd be funny if I used that
tho
with the backgroun n watermark
bleh
** You are now Level 6! **
@opal gorge get the non background non watermark version
of the middle
set the rsc logo to each and take a screenshot
then host a revote
most accurate
yes
people can actually see
I doubt anything would change
as a person voting for this pumpkin I can agree
this one is mid
wouldn't the logo need to be animated?
I feel like one of the digital ones like the bat thing would be easier since its probably not devised of a drawing, but thats my opinion I prefer this one but it seems a bit more difficult to set up if it were to be animated.
animated is optional
no way this is winning this looks so choppy
pretty sure this is 3d but animated is optional
Oh?
AI
AI
Prob ai ngl
true
** You are now Level 9! **
i would've liked this more if it were transparent
ehh
ask it to not include any text
the bat one is animated
I still got my one from last year lol
NO FUCKING SHOT THIS IS THE MOST VOTED LOGO š
Why are yall so picky it looks nice
The middle one literally just added a spider and a hat ontop
The first one's pumpkin is offcentered
why does that matter š
also itās just a tilt like the original logo
Why does the 3Dness matter then
doesnāt fit the original style
they're all halloween related
no shit bro šš
yeah??
they used the leafy part and actually changed that
there was 100% more effort put into this one
This one is alright, the roblox studio logo is just white though
AI.
im going to personally jump you
this is sad
okay buddy
Looks like AI did it š
i like this one the most
@pure wedge we need one with no background
Ill also show the blender file to prove that it is not ai generated. I mean this is community voted. Sorry if some of you think that it is "awful". I mean you guys can be a bit nicer š. But again ty for voting for it
@opal gorge I sent you the image without bg and the blender file too if you want to see it
don't worry dude, my one got hate for being 'just a hat and spider'
Some people are just pissed they didnt get top 3
ty man
no worries, congratulations on winning first by the way!
ty ^^
never said it was ai generated
not awful
its just weirdly llooking like AI
Ngl i smell favoritism here
Like Juli won legit
And Miller who got second place is also a winner?
Just because he is staff?
Im 100% sure if Juli got second place and Miller would win you wouldnt give him winner title for second place
Wich is kinda sad
Its kinda like: "Staff always should win. No matter how well other ppl do"
Like think about it
Or maybe you guys are jealous for how good of a designer he is
Especially w third
like dude, yeah they both got a shit load of score
but that's kinda unfair leaving me out LOL
nah
Just became staff so there's no bias imo, and submitted the logo before Miller became trainee
the community isnt happy that juli won
theyl just be shitting on the logo so only course of action
I don't want any party to be receiving hate
also juli will be getting a role too which the other 2 won't get
Once the banner is ready
They hate him or they are just jealous?
** You are now Level 1! **
no because it frankly dosen't match the rsc aesthetic
it looks like models downloaded online mashed together
but hey thats what the community thinks
This just shows how toxic the community is isn't it?
Ok. But now im curious. Why did it win the COMMUNITY VOTE when the COMMUNITY doesnt want it???
I dunno
its like half half
half love it the other half despise it
its a niche look sorta like bright and pale art
ya either hate it or love it
Maybe its time to try something new then
You cant always stick with the same kind of logos
I bet when rsc always had realistic logos and now a minimalistic 2d logo would win the reaction would be the same
I mean i got nothing against millers logo. I really like it too. I also thought that he was gonna win. I made that logo just for fun without expecting anything for it. But now im the bas guy because i made it and won which is kinda sad. Thats why i dont complain that it was said that there would be one logo which wasnt true and now there are 2. You guys can just accept it now and try out something new which a part of the community wants more than something (which looks also great) but has been done multiple times like it before. And if there is a lot of constructove feedback after the logo is the official logo now. Which is just negativ feedback and also a variety of peopƶe not just like 5 to 10 people of 70k. I would be ok to replace it with millers logo too as long as i get the role after some time and the negative constructiv feedback. I just dont want to be hated because of it š
It is kind of unfair that the person who didn't win gets their one up for the other half of october
And I'm not saying that just because I lost in general
Well I kind of am, considering they didn't win and still get theirs up LOL
but you could understand how I'd feel myself honestly
ok I'll revert it back but @stone aurora you are also getting a role
You and miller get event top
while juli gets winner
thank you honestly
usually people just dont give a shit and make some random excuse LOOL
thank you guys a lot
Shit looks ai generated
frfr
No, the community just isnāt happy such a shit logo design won. We arenāt bias over miller, people just need to accept his logo should have won.
Like itās wayyyy too choppy
As a GFX artist it hurts to look at⦠like a lot
rtx logo
I'm upset that his one is winning
you got the role