[🕒] Cancelling an Urban Transit contract can delete a train that is needed for another contract | Rail Route | Page 1

vernal oar · 2023-09-12T04:45:08.905Z

Game version: 1.15.10 OS: Linux Steps to reproduce: - (edit: map file and save file are not attached, so it's easier to just load those instead of rebuilding this from scratch) - use the editor to create a map with two stations connected with two tracks, and each station connected to a coach yard - add four contract templates: - 100 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : a#0#08:00:00#1 b#0#08:10:00#1 - 101 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : b#0#08:00:00#1 a#0#08:10:00#1 - 200 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : a#0#08:15:00#1 b#0#08:25:00#1 - 201 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : b#0#08:15:00#1 a#0#08:25:00#1 - save the map and start playing it - while playing, open the contracts and cancel one of the contracts Wrong behavior: - the train for the cancelled contract will be deleted, even though it was still needed for the other contract! - when the time for the next train departure arrives, it will ding at you to dispatch a train from the coach yard, but none of the coach yards have a train of the necessary type, so you can't dispatch one Expected behavior: - since the train is still needed for another contract, it shouldn't be deleted when the first contract is cancelled edit: added save/screenshot

vernal oar Sep 12, 2023, 4:45 AM

#

Game version: 1.15.10
OS: Linux

Steps to reproduce:

(edit: map file and save file are not attached, so it's easier to just load those instead of rebuilding this from scratch)
use the editor to create a map with two stations connected with two tracks, and each station connected to a coach yard
add four contract templates:
- 100 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : a#0#08:00:00#1 b#0#08:10:00#1
- 101 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : b#0#08:00:00#1 a#0#08:10:00#1
- 200 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : a#0#08:15:00#1 b#0#08:25:00#1
- 201 URBAN 100 LPPP X0 : b#0#08:15:00#1 a#0#08:25:00#1
save the map and start playing it
while playing, open the contracts and cancel one of the contracts

Wrong behavior:

the train for the cancelled contract will be deleted, even though it was still needed for the other contract!
when the time for the next train departure arrives, it will ding at you to dispatch a train from the coach yard, but none of the coach yards have a train of the necessary type, so you can't dispatch one

Expected behavior:

since the train is still needed for another contract, it shouldn't be deleted when the first contract is cancelled

edit: added save/screenshot

📎 0a339be7-b838-4e8a-a36a-8f5bea81b8c0.zip 📎 0a339be7-b838-4e8a-a36a-8f5bea81b8c0_Bug_report-_cancel_UT_contract_08-59-40_9e989.mp.lz4 📎 Player.log

vernal oar Sep 12, 2023, 9:41 PM

#

Added map/save/log/screenshot

steel silo Sep 14, 2023, 6:49 AM

#

Issue RR-2212 has been assigned to this thread.
https://bitrich.youtrack.cloud/issue/RR-2212

Mišo

Buy & sell train sets for Urban Trains instead of granting & removing them

Originally many bugs like

Urban traffic contracts of +58min don't have enough rolling stock Open Discord Thread
Train remains in CY after contract failure Open Discord Thread
Cancelling an Urban Transit contract can delete a train that is needed for another contract Open Discord Thread

Open Discord Thread

State

Open

Assignee

Unassigned

Priority

Normal

Created

Fri Aug 25 2023 20:39:01 GMT+0000 (GMT)

Updated

Thu Sep 14 2023 06:48:58 GMT+0000 (GMT)

hollow pond Sep 14, 2023, 6:49 AM

#

These problems tends to mount up so we plan to resolve them by game mechanic change mentioned above

#

It is planned to be implemented during autumn.

#

I acknowledge it is a bug but I would not hot-fix it as it could introduce more problems than it resolves. Let's wait for the proper solution.

#

[×] Cancelling an Urban Transit contract can delete a train that is needed for another contract

#[🕒] Cancelling an Urban Transit contract can delete a train that is needed for another contract