#feedback-readonly
umbral tartan
The game includes catalan as a posible language to choose. However, in the discord we don't have a sub-channel for us. Can you add a catalan channel here? And there are some mistakes in the traslation in the catalan version.
compact briar
Teaming players(nonono+number)
They are annoying and we should auto ban the similar name players that in one game
distant forge
no, my brother and i have a similar name but we don't team
he is IAmNotTheHH ig
so yeah
and we do play together but we never ghost
pine sluice
@compact briar not a feedback and simular names dont mean people are teaming
sharp stone
Please remove seer from ranked game it gives no oppurtunities for wws and solos
instead aura det will be fun as they require deduction
thin dome
You should make it so that when you go onto the outfits section u can hold a click on the outfit for like 3 seconds and the grave to that outfit appears (if it has a grave (ik this one does))
runic dragon
@cold cypress mask is always on top of the hair. That’s a designing rule that everyone has to stick to
cold cypress
That's not good
rain crystal
I think cannibal should increase its amount of kills as triangular numbers(1,3,6), since right now there is no advantage in not killing at night
vernal dune
@sudden dock @cold cypress in some cases the mask looks better in front of the hair, and if you think of it it makes sense that the mask is over the hair 
@sharp stone when you get to the gold league, there is no more seer in game, and seer is in silver to help villagers get to gold. I know it can be frustrating as ww, but there are usually more villagers than evils, so it gives a boost.
@thin dome i'll add it to #feedback-devs, thanks for the suggestion!
@rain crystal at the start of the game, people can have forgotten there is cannibal ig, so it can be a good time to save hunger.
woeful mesa
hi, what does the last feedback means?
vernal dune
@woeful mesa it means cannibals hunger should increase faster 🤔
woeful mesa
the last feedback-devs sorry👀
vernal dune
When you tap and hold an outfit in your inventory, it should make the gravestone associated to the outfit appear
woeful mesa
like when we click on the outfits on the profile?
vernal dune
Yes but In the inventory
vernal dune
Np 
woeful mesa
feedback:
I saw that lately a lot of badges have been created for different achievements that mostly help the game, insta pics, designer... why not doing one for the active feedbackers? It would be a badge for people who made a lot of feedback that have been put in feedback-devs, and maybe got a certain number of upvotes. It will surely encourage (not sure if it exists in english, but means push the player) to write more feedbacks which will surely help a lot the game, and also help people visiting this discord page so that more players give their opinions^^
I have no idea about what would look like the badge though, and for the number of feedbacks and upvotes for them needed to get the badge sorry
thick relic
Ooooooooooooooooooooooooo
sweet barn
Add The ability to whisper to other players but make it noticeable so everyone in the server knows you're whispering but wont be able to tell what unless you guys add a spy type role that can read night time ww chat and whispers
warm helm
@thick relic please dont send too many emotes after eachother. Ty
safe python
@sweet barn that's a Town Of Salem feature right ?
Idk about whispering but the ToS roles won't be added probably
runic dragon
BEST NEW ROLES <3
latent saddle
You dont need this list so why you dont disable it in tutorial
cold cypress
Bc its also ig
thick horizon
pls do hebrew game
drowsy yarrow
can you add the full outfits of the quest we have not yet complete in the last category
runic dragon
If you have 16 roses you have a button to convert to roses for all pls do this
charred kiln
@vernal dune i suggested that first to but i got a countersuggestion that berserk shouldnt be remove so
Anyways u forgot to credit @craggy dagger
vernal dune
Its fixed
flint monolith
Gg
full falcon
Roses
We need a feature that enables us to trade more than 1 rose at a time, I watch a lot of ads and get a lot of roses too, I have 200 roses just lying around and trading all of them with someone will take hours to do.
Maybe add a feature that automatically sends roses in a fast way to a player but only if that player has the feature enabled to you too (fast automatic exchange, a flower for a flower at a time done by a bot or such) this would allow players to actually focus on the game.
And if that's impossible, add a button that sends 5 roses by 5 roses (the command is registered but is only executed if both players enable it for one another, aka if both players send 5 roses to one another, thus 5 roses are sent at the same time from both players to both players, which will prevent scams)
Both these features are a good solution and can prevent scams
Side idea: they can also be fused together.(the idea was probably already suggested, but the mechanics of it are probably unique to me)
drowsy yarrow
how about something were you can check all donations per week
quaint bramble
@woeful mesa feedback badges have been suggested before, but for now it seems like it;s not going to happen :(
I guess it would also be pretty hard to determine, how far back we would go to check if someone has earned this badge.
And it could lead to a big increase of spammy feedback ideas here.
@drowsy yarrow I think it wouldnt make sense to view outfits from your iinventory if you dont have them yet. You could see them completely in the preview function though. (The eye icon at the top)
@full falcon I know a certain new feature created a higher demand for rose trading and I think this system could be improved indeed. I like your idea of being able to send 5 or 10 at once.
I am not sure I fully understand your first idea about the fast system? You mean it auto-sends roses back to anyone who sends them to you? That sounds a little risky to me.
full falcon
@quaint bramble more like... Each player has a rose Bot that does the trading for them, for example, one player can send a small invitation for another chosen player (in a current running game, the invitation would be a colored message) to trade roses continuously and automatically, if player 2 agree to the invitation, the two bots will figure out who has more roses (and thus, who sends the First rose), after that the two bots would trade the roses automatically for both players, this goes on until, say 20 roses get traded(maximum), thus ends the trade, but it can still be reactivated. If one of the two players has less than 20 roses, they would all get traded with the other player, if both have less than 20 roses, the trade-able amout would be traded (if P1 has 8 and P2 has 9, 8 roses will be traded in total and P2 would have 1 rose remaining). In addition, every player can choose to have a "locked" rose number than the bots would subtract from the actual rose number (thus, a player can keep 5 roses with him at all times that bots aren't allowed to auto trade)
Hopefully this makes my first suggestion clearer, but it's way too complex than the 2ed suggestion and probably won't be added smh.
(I can develop the first idea more, if it's more doable)
quaint bramble
@full falcon That's a great explanation! But yeah i feel this wouldnt fit the game very well, and it brings more questions like what happens if one of them suicides etc.
I would like to post the idea for trading set amounts, instead if just single rose/16x single rose.
But if you still want expand on that idea I can wait and post it later.
full falcon
Alright hold on
Roses
We need a feature that enables us to trade more than 1 rose at a time, I watch a lot of ads and get a lot of roses too, I have 200 roses just lying around and trading all of them with someone will take hours to do.
Maybe add a button that sends 5 roses by 5 roses (or 10 roses by 10 roses): When a player chooses to click on that button to send 5 roses to another chosen player, the command is registered but is only executed if both players enable it for one another (do it for one another): aka if both players send 5 roses to one another (after deciding that they wanna trade "5s by 5s") thus 5 roses are sent at the same time from both players to both players. This mechanism will help to prevent scams because the 5 roses won't get sent from player 1 to player 2 if player 2 hasn't clicked to send 5 roses to player 1 as well (mutual action required for the command to be executed).
This feature/button can't work to people who have less that 5 roses (or 10) (because trading them doesn't take long and because they don't have enough roses to activate the button)
@quaint bramble should I add something else ?
safe python
Okay, i think Jailer should also have a few seconds of his ability locked. Because some jailers just shoot without waiting for questions. Anyone should be able to have their last words at least lol, and it can get annoying.
*for respones
rigid bronze
It doesn't change anything really... If jailer shoots instantly, I dont think he would change his mind in a few seconds
safe python
I mean mostly yeah. But sometimes village pays the price. Just a idea idk lol
pine sluice
Sometimes jailer needs to kill asap
Like when they need to kill ww in case arso Burn them first
quaint bramble
@drowsy yarrow That's what the ledger is for, it shows all recent donations ^^
sorry got distracted and forgot to answer this
magic smelt
Oops wrong place
quaint bramble
could you please remove it then...?
magic smelt
How
quaint bramble
hold press the message i believe, on phones
magic smelt
Lol
south moon
yep
quaint bramble
I will reply to a bug first and come back to your suggestion asap ^^
drowsy yarrow
the donation tab slows the total donations every player did and in the ledger there are many players that make to many small donations
like day 1 50g, day 2 35g, day 3 45 g
its little annoying because i have to count all the donations every time to see how much they donated and if everyone has donated
quaint bramble
@full falcon Alright I dont have high hopes that such a complicated feature will go very far, but it sounds good and well explained so im posting it anyway ^^
full falcon
It's not that complicated XD it's just that P2 has to send 5 flowers to you too for the trade to be completed
I just explained it too much
cobalt quartz
Add the villager/werewolf/solo team talisman;they will work exactly like the regular one,but on more roles and with lower effects.Can still be upgraded.
quaint bramble
@cobalt quartz I think having team talismans like that, would make the game unfair for anyone who does not have the coins to buy them. You would be a bad role more often and thats not fun
It could also help friends with teaming
cobalt quartz
The same could appean with the normal talisman too
And if the talisman doesn't cost much and the effects is just 1% more or 3% isn't a problem?
quaint bramble
I think it wouldn't really be that useful, if you wanna be ww you could equip diff ww talismans, and if you really wanna be a villager it helps if you put on the less-liked roles like doc and bh and paci
cobalt quartz
But putting like 10 villagers talisman is worse than 1 village team one
I think that you can reduce the amount of usable talisman per match to 3 and add those,so they will be more useful
undone quail
I think red lady should be changed so that when she dies that it should tell everyone who they visited
Cause when the medium dies the red lady’s ability is pointless
desert fossil
full falcon
Vague/team talismans
There should be a feature that adds werewolf/villager/solo team talisman, they work exactly as the regular talismans, but they add an additional chance to land on the team associated with your equipped talisman.
They wouldn't add as much chance percentage to the whole team as a regular talisman would add to a role otherwise they would be too overpowered.
This would be very useful, because it would make a shortcut as follows:
Instead of equipping a talisman for every villager role, one can simply equip a team village that would increase the odds for all of the village roles.
Same goes for werewolves.
This would still give the player a fairly randomed role in an exciting team so it doesn't strip away all the randomness/mystery of the match.
Also, these "vague" talismans would be more accurate that the regular one, because, in an exciting game, there is always three teams (solo, werewolves and villagers) so the vague talisman will always increase the odds of what it's meant to increase Wether in a regular talisman, you have to be lucky for the role that the talisman increases the odds to to be present in a given match, thus, it doesn't always serve it's purpose and it's too unpredictable.
By: @cobalt quartz
#whenwritinganessaycandetermineyourlife
cold cypress
Can we have the option to replace the Lootbox in the rose wheel with another coin field or maybe get 10 Roses instead?
rigid bronze
I don't think there would be an option for that, but I can add it to #feedback-devs @cold cypress
cold cypress
Hm.. Ok but yk getting 20 coins for 30 roses (maybe a talisman as well) isn't really enjoyable
runic dragon
why seer spirit is nor fixed?
quaint bramble
@runic dragon it should be working now. Could you describe what problem you still have with this role?
An example, if NO player dies from werewolves that night, the flames stay blue if you selected a ww. This is not a bug.
And some good roles like MM or jailer will be red if they kill someone, also not a bug
runic dragon
i just selected a ww and again blue flame...
i know i selected wolf seer and jww and he said blue flame
quaint bramble
did somebody die from ww attack that night?
runic dragon
yep he died rrv
quaint bramble
if this happens again, post a screenshot in #bugs-readonly please so we can try to help you better
runic dragon
ok
full falcon
Maybe make the ghost 👻 icon transparent so we can see the avatar behind it, makes the game more beautiful
soft pumice
Can y'all help me become a guardian in we online
full falcon
@soft pumice ask this in #questions
runic dragon
If they don't vote for the person that does it won't be red, not a bug
quaint bramble
@runic dragon it's been tested and confirmed that voting/not voting doesnt matter. if ww's kill,all of them would be red
safe python
I thought ww seer was an exception ?
desert dawn
Im like 99% sure that ww seer still counts as red spirit
desert dawn
Lol 😂
full falcon
That's the lonelinest thing I've seen
desert dawn
😂
When ur corrupter and u corrupted someone u can’t vote them, i feel like it would be better if u could vote them because it makes u look a bit suspicious
cold cypress
U can vote them
cinder ledge
Corrupters op
opaque pollen
Yeah you can still vote a glitched victim
If you can't please report it as a bug 👍
quaint bramble
I tried it earlier, didnt work, the glitched icon might have too much click-surface
opaque pollen
Urgh
runic dragon
Concerning Arsaud's recent feedback :
Yeah,maybe move it a little higher
plush mural
Flower child - German description.
First word is spelled correctly : "Schütze"
Zombie - German description
Second last sentence should be correctly : Du gewinnst, wenn alle lebenden Spieler Zombies sind.
Get rid of the ,,
meager gyro
Thanks a lot I'll fix it with my team 
plush mural
I was ghost seer. And I was converted the second night. I checked 15 and 16, they both appear blue but the message was only stating that 15 didn't kill. I dunno if it is a regular bug or if 16 was like nightmared. Dunno
Also playing in Sandbox mode is pretty much cancer to be honest and talk about it straight. Random kills everywhere and flaming. But the worst : LITERALLY EVERY GAME there are 1-2 players leaving cuz they have "an old and boring role". In like no sandbox mode of my last 10 there was a doc, since they suicide every time. This needs to be punished cuz it's a constant problem destroying game fun.
runic dragon
Can we adjust the skill lose rate in ranked games when a solo role wins? At the end game everyone let's ww win just because they lose less skill points and that's pretty annoying but I dont think you can really change this but eh here is my feedback
split briar
I have a problem if anyone can help?
runic dragon
Why new skins are so magestic special or celestial? You should make the skins they they were before simple but perfect that wpuld be very good because now I don't feel like buying them for they items.
opaque pollen
@jerome33#3651 Hello, what is your problem?
runic dragon
@runic dragon You could tell the designers this in #avatar-ideas and maybe give some ideas for other outfits you may have in mind.
iron girder
When editing your profile info, and exiting withour saving and reentering. It shows the edited parts. Unless you relog. This gets confusing as I had to relog to know that I actually didn't save my profile info.
foggy palm
Remove the sheriff role please it su cks it's so hard to find the exact person who will die and even then you are not sure
So many games I have seen so far with sheriff ig, that's the most useless role, even wws don't try to attack them
normal wyvern
Sheriff is a new role and will be tested at the moment. I don't believe he won't get removed because they still can buff him. And he's strong when you find the right target, tbh. Just try your best and don't complain after, maybe 5 tries
foggy palm
Ss was replaced with sheriff right, that's far much more better than sheriff, and it's not about me being incompetent in the game, you all can find out how much sheriff was of help in any game and find.
And btw, my removing I mean just add some other role instead of sheriff in sandbox and other games, not like completely remove it
runic dragon
I want shirt
normal wyvern
Sheriff is still in a testing phase. You can't remove him from Sandbox now 
@runic dragon write ?discord shirt and ?tester hat in #bot-commands
iron girder
Although I dislike the way Dr_daenerys is saying about the Sheriff role. I do personally think it needs a buff
How about changing it so the Sheriff can investigate 2 people at the same time. And incase of the 2 dying at the same time. There will be 4 suspects
grave pawn
I think sheriff needs a serious buff
runic dragon
Sherrif is too hard to play
runic dragon
Well those skins are made. But the community downvoted them a lot. So some designers don’t try even more.....
@mighty cypress how would you change it?
safe python
Tbf there isn't a honest way to change. Maybe just to spread awareness that not all skins with a ton of stuff attached to them mean good. I'm still mad that the graduation girl skin got downvoted
split briar
My problem is that an admin came into my game and shouted out my role and i don't think that is even fair for me or allowed to happen
I just need to know what to do about that?
safe python
@split briar which admin ?
split briar
There was no name just said admin.
I have a screenshot of it
Idk if im reading it wrong or if it was an actual admin
safe python
@split briar this happened in game or ?
split briar
Yes during one if the games i played today
safe python
If you have screenshots you can contact the guardians and report him. Impersonating staff is a serious offence and he will get banned
Just ask for someone at #questions to give you a list of guardians
Or wait here for someone to see from the staff
full falcon
Maybe his name was Admin
runic dragon
@mighty cypress they put in the outfit that the community likes the most. I agree with you, but this is what we got when we suggested it ourselves.
kind nebula
Telling your lovers role shouldnt be banned
Like when you're a useless villager, and your couple is bad, makes your team have advantage
for a cost of 1 villager
runic dragon
@kind nebula You're teamed with your couple though
kind nebula
Doesnt really matter until lategame
You arent in the same team tho, its just like a bond
A bond that can be broken at any time
with no penalty
kind nebula
.
vernal dune
@plush mural that is a bug, please report it in #bugs-readonly !
Secondly, suicide is already punishedby a temporary ban!
@runic dragon i agree this is a problem, and i will add it to #feedback-devs 
@runic dragon if that's what you think, i'll put that in #feedback-devs
@iron girder about editing your profile, how do you suggest to change that?
For the sheriff buff, i'll add it to #feedback-devs, but i don't think it'll be changed soon since it is still in testing
@kind nebula teaming against your couple is gamethrowing, because it doesnt give them a chance to play.
wet dock
about the rule of no pre-evaluated role allowed in the role tournament
well you could say that, but no role is perfect when it first comes out. Every role has some bugs or loopholes that im sure the creators havent thought of before. This channel, wc, they all exist to make sure the roles can be reviewed and made to be the best before coming out. If there is no evaluation allowed, then roles would be full of loopholes, and how do u suppose people can vote for a role that has flaws in every aspects, that has important interactions and mechanics not properly thought out? I understand that there might be the so called unfair factor of people helping, but to be honest, working alone and never asking for help is a foolish thing to do.
Of course, some people might have a really bad idea and improve it by a lot after getting help, but that is an exchange between the role creator and the person who helps them. If the person who helps know the consequences of them helping, I.e. well, a better idea is presented, and they still choose to help, I dont see a problem with that.
Copying is one thing, getting help from other people is one thing, I dont understand how that is a problem. If you say getting people that have good talent to help is unfair to people who don't, then maybe banning all "talented" people is what you should do instead?
Furthermore, you say that accepting help is unfair, then I ask you, how is cramming all roles into one channel fair? Yes, the voting system has been improved, but you cannot eliminate the discrimination and bias involved. To be honest, I don't see how that is any less of a problem than accepting help.
gahd how much did I type
If you say that having roles pre-evaluated is very unfair to those people who have their role presented for the first time, that is just absurd. Making a role idea, not getting help or evaluation, just going into the tournament without thinking if its viable, is that really a thing that should be encouraged? #role-ideas-readonly exist for a reason, that is for people to work for the common good and bring out good roles for the game. It is also a resource that people should use to improve their roles. Some people not utilizing that resource properly making the wise ones lose their resource is not a thing that should be done.
I'm not hating, but this rule seriously baffles me, but if I am completely wrong about why this rule is implemented, I do see reason w.
It is my most sincere advice to dispose of this rule and make another more specific rule that bans people from copying or stealing ideas in the coming role tournament.
iron girder
@vernal dune so the moment we leave the profile and reenter(not using app) it will revert to unsaved state
vale solar
i think the corr role has some problems?
maybe we shld make it as in like if a person is jailed then the corr shld not be able to jail the person
^ here’s the feedback
bcos if a person is jailed, what happens now is that the person is shown as corr but still can y’all
talk*
and it’s kinda unfair for the corr
dawn plume
Feedback for new roles: please take sheriff out of game. The role sucks and is basically absolutely useless while game except doc dies and you know seer will get killed. Or at least make it that sheriff sees who killed the observed person.
willow plover
MVP (Most Valuable Player) shown if:
-Win by first and most vote to lynch (Villager)
-Win by most revealed (Seer,Aura seer,Detective,Wolf seer,Pacifist,Spirit seer)
-Win by most elimination (Killer)
-Win by lynched (Headhunter,Fool)
-Win by first vote and most killing using werewolf (Team werewolf)
-Win by most killing using village attacking role[won't do if killed own team] (Gunner,Priest,Marksman,witch)
-Win by most protected player[from lynching or from evil attacks] (Doctor,Bodyguard,Jailer,Witch,Wolf guardian,flower child)
Either one of them got this may get more xp and skills.
dawn plume
Well doc has a huge advantage against the other protection roles you say ( bg {2 protections—> dies}, witch/flower child { can only protect once}, wolf guardian { two lynch protection} and jailer is not a pure protection role ( same problem with the killing for village usage)
charred kiln
Remove zombie and sl from random killers since they dont kill
And they are so annoying for custom games specially zombies
vernal dune
@iron girder sometimes people close the profile unintentionally, and that's why it currently keeps in memory the message you wrote, so unfortunately it won't be reverted
wild sinew
Hi
Is this sneak peak?
For like
The word
Illusionist?
I mean the new role for another update?
willow plover
@wild sinew #questions
wild sinew
Kk
maiden flame
heady trellis
Hey, can you make a tab for "my itens" on inventory?
runic dragon
@heady trellis there already is. You see that shirt with a dit in the left up corner? Click on that
heady trellis
Thx
wet dock
@maiden flame u do not ping whole roles
runic dragon
@vernal dune Thank you for uploading my idea to #feedback-devs I really apreciate it, Gracias bro.
vernal dune
No problem 
@maiden flame you just have bad luck, this is not a bug! Also, please do not try to ping roles 😄
runic dragon
When corruptor dies don’t reveal the roles of the corrupted players. Because ww can claim roles from corrupted players and when those roles are revealed the ww will be exposed as liers. This will also cause that villagers will have to think more.
charred kiln
Remove zombie and sl from random killers since they dont kill also zombies are annoying af when u want sth like all random killers
Dont ignore it this time ffs
plush badge
Make it so beserker only kills the doc/bg and not the role they're targeting. Mainly because of president
runic dragon
If you have 16 roses you can convert to roses for all pls do this
cold cypress
Maybe you should add the words "Nigger" and "nigga" to the autoreport list.
charred kiln
Nah
Autoreport for one word is already stupid
And some people say for fun nigger not to be rude
safe python
"for fun" ?
runic dragon
some people also shoot people random for fun but we still report them🤔
charred kiln
Autoreport is dumb anyways
Also some black people say to other black people “hey nigger”
Thats not offensive
safe python
Agree with @cold cypress
wind jewel
Up vote this if you like it
Devs should add a section in which you can see Your total skill gained and lost per day or per game.. this way we can easily keep track on our skill points.
charred kiln
Ofc everyone agrees with @cold cypress everyone who plays this game already cries when someone says fuck
wind jewel
Lol.. they do. They even go crying reporting
charred kiln
Or they cry becuz i said they cry
cold cypress
Sorry that I don't like being called a "Nigger" :)
charred kiln
Family friendly game already sounds rediculous
wet dock
"werewolf" is a family friendly game
charred kiln
Specially when 90% of the people who play this game are 7 year old stupid quick game players
wind jewel
Up vote this if you like it
Devs should add a section in which you can see Your total skill gained and lost per day or per game.. this way we can easily keep track on our skill points.
wet dock
just wait
wet dock
one thing, dont ping people for ur idea
wind jewel
Why?
wet dock
staff will check the channel regularly
wind jewel
It's a feedback
wet dock
be patient
safe python
@charred kiln there is a difference when someone says fuck and uses a racial slur tbf
mighty birch
Put the rules also in setting when you are in a game, then you can check them at all time while being in game.
There or in a button next to the others
vernal dune
@mighty birch already suggested, tho you can upvote the suggestion here 
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/617667245258047518
woeful mesa
Hi, I don t understand this feedback dev:
Why new skins are so magestic special or celestial? You should make the skins they they were before simple but perfect that wpuld be very good because now I don't feel like buying them for they items.
By: @ulonpo
runic dragon
It was that there aren’t that many simple skins anymore
Like there used to be
I told someone who agreed on the feedback after that that they just put stuff that the community likes in game so you can’t really change it
@woeful mesa ^^
woeful mesa
it means there re now too many payable skins compared to normal ones?
cedar crescent
This game i play this alot ps a beatiful letter is E
runic dragon
@woeful mesa currently there are a lot of detailed and complex skins going in game especially as special offers. They would like some more easier and simple designs. Though I don’t know why it got in feedback devs since it’s more for avatar ideas
woeful mesa
ooh okay, not a bad idea that's true^^
quaint bramble
@wet dock I have explained to you before, role-ideas and role-tournament are completely seperate things, they are 2 different paths to get a role-idea to the dev's attention.
The tournament is time-gated challenge and team effort to create something new and fresh, where everyone has the same fair chance to do so. It's a competition, so no you cant just send a role that already received feedback and that you could fix accordingly.
For tournament you choose your team and you evaluate and feedback the ideas with your team members.
The tournament has the advantage that devs might choose your idea even if you do not reach the top 10, but it will be one of many ideas they will see there. And you wont get any proper feedback on a tourney submission until after you submitted it.
While in role-ideas and writer's club you get one-on-one feedback and tips from fellow enthusiasts, to make your role the best it can be. And then you submit it straight to the staff to be put up into the vote-channel.
floral heath
I know how Cannibal works now, it’s a Serial Killer that can pick which nights it kills without being limited to 1 kill every night, the Cannibal can easily make up the 1 kill by saving up.
I’m requesting a buff and a nerf to the role. The first being that the kills stocked do not reset and the second being that the Cannibal has to cooldown for 1 night before killing again. That way it’s not just SK with instant make-up for not killing.
quaint bramble
@maiden flame Please dont ping random roles. You could buy talismans to get other roles, and if that doesnt help you might have a bug.. so report it in #bugs-readonly instead of this random complaining about it.
@wind jewel It already shows you how many you lose/win per game, but per day is a nice idea. Where should this section be in your opinion? And should it be visible for everyone else or not?
And yeah no need to post it every 5 minutes.. and you should not ask for votes on your ideas. That will happens once it's posted in the devs channel.
@mighty cypress I dont approve of you calling the designs 'for kids' thats a very strange and unnecesary argument. 🤔 The designers make the stuff they like to make, and the players vote for what they like as well.
Sadly thats not always the same thing and esp simpler designs get rejected.
Those special offers are paid for with real money so its not that strange that people would rather pay for an awesome looking armour with 10+ items, than a causal hoodie and sunglasses for example.
safe python
I agree on the simpler skined avatars
quaint bramble
@floral heath I havent seen cannibal in action a lot yet, but not resetting the kills sounds very powerful. But most games dont really last long enough to make that useful, I think
floral heath
The cooldown restricts the use of multiple kills every night. As of now, it’s SK that has instant make-up for nights where it doesn’t kill.
@quaint bramble By Make-up I mean if you don’t kill 1 night for example, you’ve “missed” a night of killing. Cannibal never misses any night of killing, it just gets stocked up to use on another night.
quaint bramble
Yeah thats the whole idea isnt it?
or you mean it does stock up as well, if the kill failed (protected) ?
floral heath
Ww/sk can “miss” nights of killing by not killing (on purpose)
Protected it’s kinda the same I think
@quaint bramble
Serial Killer:
N1: Dont kill (incase of ww)
N2: Kill 1 person
N3: Protected target
N4: Kill 1 person
N(n): Kill 1 person
Cannibal:
N1: Dont Kill
N2: Kill 2 people
N3: Protected target
N4: Kill 1 person
N(n): Kill x people where x is the number of nights waited.
See the difference?
quaint bramble
Yeah but I dont really get your point.. waiting to kill more at once, or just kill every night as a regular sk, is the whole idea of the role. it's supposed to be different.. I also dot rlly know any sk who would wait to kill someone since it doesnt rlly do much for them except wasting a turn
floral heath
It’s sk but they get to wait without the penalty of wasting a turn.
floral heath
Yes
quaint bramble
SK is built to kill every night, and Cannibal is built to choose waiting and killing more at once
i agree its like a buffed sk but thts the way it was designed..
full falcon
We want a special post apocalyptic background for the upcoming battle pass instead of the usual day/night one
Just like Christmas, it would make the game lovely, and it would help mark the presence of the battle pass
quaint bramble
@runic dragon This is a channel for ideas, for random talk you should go to #off-topic .
yeah it is, and saying youre bored is NOT feedback, so please move.
I'm not rude, Im just telling you to use the right channel.
please stop chatting here unless you have actual feedback to make
cold cypress
In my opinion flower child shouldnt be able to become hh target, because he can save himself from getting lynched.
charred kiln
In my opinion flower child should be removed
quaint bramble
@cold cypress Thats a very fair suggestion, I will add it to the devs channel
@charred kiln Would you like to give some arguments for that? we cant really remove something without explanation...
hexed zodiac
Imo that people's roles should be revealed after they get bit and the game ended so it would show their role but it also shows that they were bit
quaint bramble
@hexed zodiac Could you be a bit more specific, is this about zombies?
hexed zodiac
Yes
quaint bramble
seeing zombies original role after the game ended, is suggested before, if that what you mean
hexed zodiac
Yes
tidal carbon
Should put “she was protected” instead of “he was protected”bc 11 is a girl and it’s better if it’s depending on genre you chooses
quaint bramble
I believe the devs are already looking to change messages to a more gender neutral 'they' instead of him/her
wide creek
This is more of a suggestion, but I think you should have the feature to turn single roses 
into a rose for all by sacrificing 16 Roses. Just if you have a boatload of roses and want to give them out efficiency or smth like that. Idk really, just an idea I had.
quaint bramble
@wide creek Thats definately been suggested before, but it might be time for a repost :)
tidal carbon
Ah Nice
wide creek
Awesome
unique dragon
you should add it where you can pay gold to send a battle pass gift to someone
quaint bramble
thats already been denied, cause its indirectly trading gold and thats just not a good option, cause of gold farming etc
iron girder
@vernal dune Oh ok maybe add an x to a profile to close instead?
spiral grove
Why am i banned for random killing my friend is aura and he say the person evil so i shoot him/her
opaque pollen
If you feel you were unfairly banned please DM a Guardian
runic dragon
thorn yoke
Hey um
I feel like the serial killer is VERY underpowered, I've gotten it like 7 times today and each time just died eventually. Nor have I seen others winning with it.
Just thought I'd let you know
It's like a ww ... by itself
left bloom
so. Do you have any method for enhancing them?
thorn yoke
Ill think on it
wet dock
@quaint bramble It still doent change the fact that you are allowing ideas that have issues and and loopholes into a competition. How is receiving feedback and improving your idea not fair? Are you implying that the devs shouldn't be presented a properly thought out idea but an idea that is very rough and they have to work on it themselves to make it perfect? That is not efficient at all.
The tournament is on a team basis but how does that mean people cannot ask advice of other people beforehand? I'm not saying multiple teams are working on the same idea and sending it out, that would cause problems, but how Is receiving simple feedback from other people going to undermine the fairness of a competition?
thorn yoke
Woah um
wet dock
Frankly, unless it is a competition about knowledge or academic stuff, I dont see how a competition would ban people from getting help
thorn yoke
I'll just come back later
wet dock
You dont see sculpture competitions banning people from borrowing tools from their friends do u? Same for the tournament, this is simply not a problem of fairness at all.
vale solar
i think we shld change the sheriff role to sth else
i mean u won’t know who the sheriff is unless he reveal his role
which means that ww might hv a higher chance of killing the sheriff once he reveal his role
and the thing is the sheriff will only hv info when someone is attacked
which in this case, when doc is dead and the sheriff knows that ww are going to go after the seer next
just a feedback^ but the other new roles like flower girl and Guardian wolf are kinda good, except that the Guardian wolf is a very powerful role for a ww
thorn yoke
Ok can we talk about the current state of solos (quickplay)
SK and bomber to be specific
Every time I get sk or bb I just give up.
And I still haven't thought on a positive way to fix it yet though
vale solar
hi I was thinking that we add a coins feature? as in there’s a feature for u to buy roses with the coins, but there’s no feature for u to buy coins with roses
and the thing is I hv too many roses but very little coins
runic dragon
@vale solar there is a rose wheel which gives you coins when you pay a certain amount of roses
vernal dune
@vale solar for the sheriff, this also happens with every role, if they don't reveal themselves because they don't have good info.
@thorn yoke We know that these roles are hard to win, but the role of solo roles is to balance the game between wws and villagers, so when you suicide you technically create an unbalance 🤔
vernal dune
Well its the same, when you give up you forget your actual goal to balance the game
even that
thorn yoke
Sounds like a job rather than a role
thorn yoke
K
I have things to say but I don't want to be mean or get in trouble so I'll just agree
vernal dune
You can say them, we won't be angry at you 😄
thorn yoke
Ok
It's not fun being doomed to a role where you play and just lose or leave the game
Those dont sound like good options
You can check my account I've played about 200+ games and like 10 were suicides and those were when I had to do something irl
vernal dune
You're not doomed to lose with these roles, you need to play well (and actually pretend you are good to have a chance).
vernal dune
I once had an sk win, its not impossible
thorn yoke
I know it's hard to tell through text but I'm not upset rn I'm happy I can have this conversation
I got mad respect for 9/10ths of the peeps on this server
But anyway gn
charred kiln
Flower child should be removed acctually only becuz of noobs and friends teaming with each other. For example: if det says 8=10 and 8 dies and turns out to be med. However 10 is ww and 8 was shamaned. Later in the game 10 is suspisious af and also claiming rv bg on like day 4 everyone knows that hes fake af but the flower child is noob and saves him from getting lynched and village lost. And for teaming if 2 people are friends they save each other. U can also fix flower child by not protecting werewolfs and solo.
runic dragon
You can team with every role. That’s no point to remove a role. Also noobs protecting ww isn’t a reason to remove it. Because if you want to remove every role that noobs can mess up, then you would have to remove almost every role
Tlm. L4l. 4i.l4li.14.öi3q.iöqrö.iqrö4i.qq4i4iäq3
3qiö.4oä
4oä
Oäoä
Q.öq
Iö4q
Iö
Q.j4mi4m
6ubj
G
T
H
H
Ububjb
Jb
Vhvh
B
Bj
Jb
Jb
Bjb
Bhb
Bhv
H
Jv
@runic dragon don’t spam
Hv
Bj
Jb
Bb
Unban me
?
I got banned
Without any reason
fallen rock
You come in and you spam and then you want to be credible by saying what you're ban for nothing
@left bloom Look at this specimen.
left bloom
@fallen rock Thanks for report
fallen rock
😉
charred kiln
@runic dragon u have somehwere a point but with flower child the influence is a lot bigger and the its also the only funtion he has
runic dragon
Paci does the same. Only they reveal someone
runic dragon
Discord shirt
fierce birch
!discord paper mache
fierce birch
Thank
charred kiln
@runic dragon paci is not made to save someone up but to reveal someone and sometimes they can decide the same as flower child (acctually paci should be removed too but thats another point)
runic dragon
They won’t remove roles because teaming is possible
Because if you want to you can almost team with every role there is
white isle
i think the outfits should be more strict... there are a lot of outfits that dont meet the rules and there are eyes with mirrored highlights and eyes without mirrored highlights, its kinda messy and unprofessional 😅 so if it doesnt meet the rules, just ask the person who made it to make some adjustments before it gets in vote?
west wind
I think the Nightmare werewolf shouldn't be weaker than the Junior werewolf
runic dragon
@white isle do you have any other examples than mirrored and not mirrored eye highlights. Because this is a designer choice and there are no rules considering mirrored highlights.
white isle
for example the ears that are only one skin colour and i have seen a few hairs that go behind the back in vote (not in the actual game though) ^^
runic dragon
@white isle
white isle
okayy kshdjs doesn't really make sense to me but if its what they want🤷 🤷
its just feedback hehe
it was mostly about the mirrored eye highlights anyway bc it looks so weird hahah
charred kiln
Look if ur forkman u can make one vote different when ur teaming if ur flower child u can save the guy
Fix flower child so that he wont save werewolfs
rigid bronze
@charred kiln The flower child was made to prevent random reveal from pack since the people who can get revealed choose when or even if they want to be revealed, so I'm pretty sure it won't be removed mostly because of that
rigid bronze
Offering with gold was already suggested before (for battle pass for exemple) 
Thanks for reporting
Suggesting*
😅
runic dragon
@white isle I agree with you, but these are just the arguments given against it😂
fallen rock
It's been turned down?
rigid bronze
We don't know
runic dragon
@charred kiln Umm. That's not an ideal idea. It sounds pretty much like "Make jailer cannot kill villagers" 😅
west wind
The nightmare werewolf should be stronger than the junior werewolf when the beast hunter's trap is triggered
glacial warren
@west wind the junior ww is a baby and the nightmare is "older" so the Jr dies first ^^
Also it has been suggested before.
Even then thank you for suggesting this
west wind
That's what I mean, I was nightmare werewolf and the junior was alive but I got killed by the trap @glacial warren
glacial warren
Waiiiit...
Oh yeah.... 🤔 Has already been suggested too.... That's weird for me xD
west wind
@glacial warren Thank you for the help, I found it weird too, especially because Nightmare werewolf sounds like a strong and dreadful type of werewolf
runic dragon
@glacial warren I think it is because Nightmare Ww is a new role being tested? I heard that new WW roles usually be the weakest one.
glacial warren
It could be but I think it is because he doesn't kill ^^
runic dragon
@glacial warren Shaman Werewolf doesn't , too?
glacial warren
True
runic dragon
@glacial warren So....? 👀
glacial warren
Still suggested and I don't know why devs choose it like this
runic dragon
When only we seer and alpha are left, spirit seer should see alpha as the one who killed. Since seer checks and doesn’t vote
runic dragon
Heya all 👋
As you can see in #community-announcements we have some problems right now.
So if you have feedback contact one online helper or mini mod about it 
full falcon
Remember the rose system I suggested ? Well, it can be improved by adding an option to just send multiple roses to someone (and not trade), in case of a giveaway or just if you wanted to give someone lots of roses at once (10 at once) it will be a different option from the trade system already in #feedback-devs
pallid merlin
Hey 👋
Being able to send roses in a pack, and not at once has been suggested before, which you can upvote here: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/607138335407734784
Thanks for suggesting ^^
runic dragon
A few suggestions after a few games in sandbox.
-Change Sheriff to where instead of being like detect, he is like tg, BUT he can only scan every two nights as he needs a night to rest after staying up last night
-Flower Child and Guardian Werewolf abilities should be disabled upon death
-Werewolf Berserk should be 2nd ranking in Werewolves behind Alpha Werewolf.
And that is all I think about the new roles.
In case you don't understand what I meant by Sheriff being like Tough Guy, I mean as soon as the person he was watching was killed he knows who killed them but the killer doesn't know who he is.
The Sheriff change suggestion sounds weird. And I see odd night abilities or similar like that aren't loved. Also, sheriff's name obviously shows a relationship with Detective. Ok, by what you said, you are trying to NERF the sheriff which actually is so weak already.
I'm not nerfing detective if anything I'm buffing it.
pallid merlin
I think every other night seems to weak - and not quite needed
As for the gww and fc idea, I'm not sure to understand, if they are dead, they can't use it anymore, no?
For your 3rd idea, Wwb is already just behind aww in the list
runic dragon
@pallid merlin Its not. I just got overpowered by a nww in sandbox
He killed doc instead of seer when I had frenzy on.
And it was just the two of us.
runic dragon
I dont have any screenshots...
But im sure you could recreate it.
3 was doc 14 was wwb 11 was seer and 15 was nww
i dont know who he nightmared
I left after he successfully killed doc.
And wasted my frenzy
quaint bramble
I believe if 2 wolves vote different people, it pick one random. Or you got a fixed version of ww berserk that indeed only kills the protector, and not the protected as well.
runic dragon
I didn't stay to see if frenzy killed 3 or not, I'm sorry. Ww seer was afk and jww was useless. I was highly upset.
I remember my exact words when doc died. "Fuck this"
pallid merlin
As of now - only the protector should die, which has always been the intended version (both have been happening lately sadly)
Whether nww or Wwb died seems like another issue tough
runic dragon
No ww died Only doc. Did you mean who got the kill through?
quaint bramble
That might just be the intended working then
rain crystal
Why is "homo" censored but not "gay"
pallid merlin
Theorically, from the start, only doc should die, and seer should stay alive
Unfortunately, issues have happened and both were killed. This behavior was actually a bug
rain crystal
gay is more offensive than homo
pallid merlin
Wasn't it censored and people complained?
safe python
@rain crystal it isn't. Homosexual was used in the past as a clinic term. Implying homosexuals are somehow ill or diseased. Correct terms are gay/lesbian
rain crystal
Oh, okay then
safe python
No prob
safe python
quaint bramble
that doesnt really sound right to me either
sudden dock
Alright, get ready for A BUNCH of feedback
Feedback:
You shouldn't have to have everyone say that they want to skip the discussion. Half would be better.
There should be a new reward when servers are down, and not just
I don't know if this is just me but you should be able to hold down on a player you have viewed to see what they look like during the night they are viewed. (If that makes sense)
If the seer doesn't check at night they should be able to check during the day.
Photobooth option: a way to share all of your avatars in one photo
This would be an option to either add images that you want to keep, or automatically save the avatars that you have made to you camera role.
You should also be able to send roses after the game ends. Alot of people want to, but they aren't able to.
sorry about all of this helpers
autumn tangle
pallid merlin
1 - That has been suggested before and added to #feedback-devs, tough I think only half is too much
2 - You get 100 gold if you already have the hat
3 - You mean being able to "review" what you saw? The game is based on memory too and notes were denied so I don't think it's a really good idea 
4 - That's waaaaay too strong
5 - photoshoot is a very good idea, #feedback-devs ^^
6 - This was already suggested and added to #feedback-devs too ^^
7 - same as 6
@autumn tangle was suggested before and denied, as sb is English only ^^
Thanks for suggesting 
ornate sun
anal in analysis is being censored...
sudden dock
@pallid merlin thanks for the feedback! Sorry there was so much lol
pallid merlin
Np ^^ glad to get some nice suggestions
sudden dock
☺️
full falcon
It would be great if the time remaining for new quests showed the hours too
vernal dune
@full falcon that was already suggested ^^ I hope that they will implement that too 👍
safe python
That is what ? Like a man of the match thing or ?
runic dragon
why tf i cant find #general or #off-topic
faint violet
dreamy lion
@faint violet You have to add a 👍 to #rules-archived to see all the channels now ^^
full falcon
It would be great if we had a "Save" option alongside the "share" option, to automatically save the image in the gallery in a folder named "Werewolf Online"
charred kiln
We can talk again!
grave dagger
E
safe python
This was probably suggested but how about a weekend tournament things. Like making a bracket of let's say for example "favourite roles" and then the fan base votes and we see which role os the most favourited one, and vice versa. (Instagram or FB based feedback)
grave dagger
Rat
dreamy lion
@full falcon Uhm it has been suggested around a month ago, and there should already be an option when you click on "Share" to add the image to your gallery, but I really like the idea of a new folder, so guess a repost to #feedback-devs won't hurt ^^
full falcon
@dreamy lion it would be great if you do that, also because I don't have the option to add it to my gallery in the share menu, (I have to share it with another app and download the picture from there so it's quite a tiresome process)
full falcon
Can we have a green dot (or grey if they went off) next to players' names who are your friends ? To quickly know if you added them previously instead of going through each of their profiles individually.
dreamy lion
@safe python Indeed that could be funny having something like a scoreboard/ranking for the most liked roles of the week, but how would you introduce that to the game, example adding a survey at the end of every match? or maybe adding a vote section when you click on "Roles"? Any ideas about?
full falcon
Also some options that would show up when you long press on someone's name in your friend's list, including the option to remove them :p (instead of going through each of their profiles separately)
broken finch
Can it be added to the rules not to ask for roles in game? It is a loophole to help villagers to win in most cases as had med ask for rolecall and then left 4 wws as leaves a 50/50 chance to kill a ww now as it ruining the game.
Sorry for the language but it is becoming a fucking joke!
thin dome
Should not be male and female symbols as they r both females
Maybe could be angry and happy
full falcon
@dreamy lion can you review my suggestions please ?
runic dragon
The girl has more eyelashes and a bra like shirt things(don’t know how to explain)
And the boy doesn’t really have eyelashes and has a covered chest
normal wyvern
Well, I'm getting a little averse to sandboxing. Mainly because in 9 out of 10 games there is only Marksman left. Since it works well it would be possible to have Gunner again or at least someone who really kills. As Marksman you dare to shoot almost never, because the chance is too high to die...
dreamy lion
@full falcon Hey, honestly I can’t see the utility of the first one, you’re supposed to know who you added as a friend, I mean like how green/gray dots would help? It’s intended to be like this, people don’t just randomly add each others, I personally do that maybe cause I liked how they played in the game and maybe want to talk a bit more.
About the second one, what if it was -> possibility to select multiple players on your friend list (could turn out useful don’t you think?), to maybe send a broadcast message and/or remove them 
full falcon
I add people who send me requests cause otherwise I would feel bad if I decline them 😓
About the seccond idea, yeah, it would be great to be able to send a collective message and/or remove them.
About the first idea, highlighting a friend's name in green and keeping other players' names in grey (during a running game on the right menu) so we can know if we added/forgot to add (and not forgot about the friendship) that friend/player that we have been interacting with for sometime now. @dreamy lion
dreamy lion
@full falcon Uhm, feeling bad in declining friend requests isn’t really a good reason to get me post it to devs 😅 and underlining/changing name colors in game has already been suggested and got rejected so this won’t be an exception, still I think the second one could be useful, so I’ll add it later as soon as I’m home ^^
full falcon
Well, it wouldn't really change their name in the game, just in the running game menu on the right
But post the second idea if you think it's worth it 🙏
dreamy lion
Sure thing, as soon as I can ^^
full falcon
Also the green name for friends is a good idea for people who are forgetful, which is like.... Most of us :v
safe python
@dreamy lion tbf i asked over at Instagram ideas (i meant a social network type of survey) but they sent me here 🤷
dreamy lion
Oh, I thought it was based on instagram and fb but was supposed to be a game feature
safe python
Yeah i mean feedback is for the game idk why i got sent here lol
charred kiln
I think there should be like some option that counts only for the devs to give some people roses/gold/skillpoints for when people miss gold/roses/skillpoints/xp cuz of a bug or sth
rigid bronze
It already exists ^^
drowsy yarrow
remove all the extra talismans except 1 and give us gold for them, also make the talisman permanently upgradable with gold
like 200g to upgrade it to lvl 2, 300 for lvl 3 ....
solo,evil and weak roles should need less gold for the upgrade
hollow mortar
As much as it is fun to make and create role ideas, I feel like there needs to be a better way of keeping track of peoples work and getting rid of plagiarism. Apart from that I love how they continue to make new roles incorporated into the game.
charred kiln
@rigid bronze oh really i heard there wasnt a way to get my skillpoints back?
So or u misunderstanded it or hyde and arnaud lied to me
rigid bronze
@charred kiln skillpoints maybe not
full falcon
A minor suggestion :
Emojis make my game lag for 3 seconds
Maybe reduce their frames per second playback
But idk if that would help tho
fallen rock
Createa a badge for people that reports a lot of people (with a good reason obviously)
Doing a system of missions (daily or permanent), one could win rewards such as gold of outfits or roses.
Example of missions: play 5 times in sandbox, play 1 game with a friend, occupy the place 14 two times to sharpen
sand dome
I feel like creating a badge for people that report would inadvertently increase false reports since lots of people are unfamiliar with the rules and those same people would be encouraged to make reports
I like the daily missions thing
fallen rock
It would be banned for unjustified postponement
quaint bramble
@fallen rock heya please dont add voting options on your feedbacks, thats not really the purpose of this place.
I do agree with the message above. Reports are useful for the game but I thnk it's not the kind of thing we want to give out badges for, since it would lead to more false reports as well. And those mean more work for the guardians.
Challenges has been suggested in many different forms by now, and the devs currently dont seem to be looking for more things like this. You already have daily rewards and you can get them without doing anything after all.
fallen rock
I agree but as far as the guardian are concerned, nothing limits the number of guardians in the game☺️😉
unique dragon
i'm not sure if someone has said something before but you should be able as bh to place the trap on a ww and if that ww moves at night then it kills that ww
quaint bramble
that sounda a little OP... werewolves basically always move at night?
unique dragon
ok thabks anyway
silver ruin
let it do the reverse, wolf with bh trap is going to be villagerhunter wolf
Jk that's just a joke
hybrid scroll
Is this count as game throw? I was couple with 1 and we could’ve won ( she’s gunner ) but she purposely let village win!
left bloom
@hybrid scroll it is. And next time. Use #questions
golden wyvern
kinda sounds like u should get over it...better that an entire team win than 2 stuck up snobs
quaint bramble
@golden wyvern Following the rules is not being a stuck up snob, so please mind your attitude 🤔
Sect and zombies are solo killer roles, not your wolf finder friends.
golden wyvern
lol how kind of you to inform me of the reality of the subject
craggy dagger
Suggestion Make all other pacifists have their reveal disabled if another uses his ability.
Why? Multiple pacifists revealing day 1 is broken. If they can all use their ability the same day, the drawback of no lynch is effectively voided. If they have to use their ability on separate days the drawback is meaningful
golden wyvern
how will the village find 2 valid suspects in 1 day?
craggy dagger
If village plays optimally its usually easy to reveal a wolf or solo day 1
golden wyvern
a
craggy dagger
being unable to reveal twice/3x the same day makes the drawback more of a reason not to use the ability
golden wyvern
honestly this feels like something purposefully left in the game to add critical decision making
wait for info or don't let the drawback happen?
craggy dagger
3 pacifists in game with smart players is completely broken
I mean this the nicest way.. good players reveal wws/solo with their ability with 70% confidence
at least
golden wyvern
well there can also be 3 rl in game so rng is a big factor in ranked...
quaint bramble
If 3 pacis can reveal 3 ww's in one turn then some bad choices were made on the ww's team... if a. they left that many pacis alive and b. they were that easy to be detected
craggy dagger
@quaint bramble On day 1?
If this happens on the first day what does this mean for the game
quaint bramble
That should be nearly impossible, to reveal 3 wws/solo then
silver ruin
Actually, it's plausible. Since well, you have 3 Paci that can certainly self claim, a gunner, 2 seers(maybe 1 more but idk), and seer information. That's basically 4+4 = 8 people scouted basically
The chance are like 5, even 6/8 to find bad role
Unless seer check the same target which might happen, or checked pacis, which just probably going to be one less info
It's almost guretnee of 50% chance to reveal a bad role with that sense
(and the rest is probability)
Oh and 1 person killed
Well you get the idea
craggy dagger
I say to X "talk X, or I will reveal you"
this has greater than 50% success to find a wolf if you give them a reasonable timeframe
Good players know how inconsistent the population is when they are wolf/village
the differences are there.
Villagers will defend themselves differently to wolves when accused most of the time
golden wyvern
almost sounds like ur another one of those guys that says asking for role is op xD
silver ruin
Actually, there's probably a problem . Maybe rvs in rank specifically, cannot have roles of the same type 3 times
craggy dagger
Well, wolves actually dont answer the question
golden wyvern
Shady r u sure? I think I remember 3 bh we were so confused xD
silver ruin
Because you know, more role of the same kind actually gain exponential advantage unless you are called rl, villager (still being op)
I mean, in most situation
silver ruin
Rv doc basically make villager immunity to wolves👀
golden wyvern
rl is balanced imo, but maybe I'm dumb :v
silver ruin
I mean it's true, 3 rv of the same kind most often, will be op
craggy dagger
Not really, because docs dont know who each other are
silver ruin
Most situation
craggy dagger
so they tend to protect the same target
silver ruin
Most often
That thing you are saying is probably like rank point 1-100👀
yes, not even 1000
The suggestion here (for rank gameplay only) is that, most of the roles shouldn't exist in like 3 in a kind, like 3 rv paci and things (most of them. Some is situationally poor, but again, getting 3 rv of the same kind is still really lucky but bring problems).
**Reasoning**: 3 rv of the same role is actually quite insane to play against, especially those who know how to play in higher ranks. And the problem with same role repeating 3 times is the fact that most of the time, you probably getting screwed(Rv or not rv in decision making) , and secondly, roles stack exponentially. If you have only 1 protector , good, probably that protector won't do anything. But comparing that to 4 protector, well, wolves probably won't be able to do anything(unless berserk exist, but relying on only berserk to only be able to kill a person is like really extreme already). This is especially true for even killing(witch and marksmen), even role blocking(granny), and maybe even paci reveal in higher gameplay .
**Suggestion**: Maybe remove 3 of the same kind of rvs (unless you want specific role to be able to have 3 of a kind then I don't mind) from rank, so people will never get more than 3 of the same kind of roles from rv (does not include main role already in it)
opal rampart
Probably it has been suggested, but I think HH should not be in gold league in ranked mode. Most of the time HH would sell his target and then join the village. It makes the village team stronger than it already is, it gives them additional team member plus knowing hh target helps eliminating 1 more suspect. The way I see it, a solo role is supposed to be more on evil side to balance the village team power.
fallen rock
Put a mod under ranked and it would take 500 wins to unlock it
normal wyvern
Why a mod?
craggy dagger
"Put a mod (moderator?) under ranked and it would take 500 wins to unlock it."
500 wins to unlock ranked mode!?!? You can't be serious
lament frigate
waiting for ranked would literally take HOURS
and everyone would have to wait hours
lmao horrific idea
velvet thicket
i want to report someone but cannot do it in #ingame-reports-archieved
player 16 reveal his werewolf teammate
lethal storm
Mmod should be able to give rewards for YouTube and social media
Because, poor Lisa
@velvet thicket you can report this player in game, no need to send it here
vernal dune
@opal rampart this has kind of been suggested before, but I will still add that to #feedback-devs since it wasn't said specifically for ranked 🤔
velvet thicket
@lethal storm the report section is locked though
full falcon
@velvet thicket the report section is closed permanently, they aren't a report channel, if you wish to report a player you should do it in game, however if the player is really misbehaving and it's an urgent matter, you can contact one of the guardian here to tell them (with proof)
velvet thicket
@full falcon okay thanks
hybrid scroll
Quick game so unbalanced now. 3 seers 4 bullets and 2 protectors smh
pallid merlin
How would you balance it better? 🤔
@lethal storm
This would cause more confusion tough 😅
I assume there's a reason it is how it is atm, and mini-mods are supposed to moderate
pallid merlin
It's a pretty suggested and tense topic, but I'll post it, thanks for giving an in depth explanation ^^
fallen rock
@normal wyvern mod is Game mode
@craggy dagger Yes I'm serious when I say 500, so that I'm sure people its strong
Because 30 is really little
runic dragon
@mighty cypress I think it's suggested before. But I'm not very sure. Maybe wait for an actual helper to help you 👀
No problem. Though I actually did not do anything
full falcon
Badges
Badges should really have a customisable color (only the red part)
I know they're an image file but we can at least alter it, it only takes about 10 minutes of altering to change a badge's color (pixel by pixel, so it would be accurate too), so I think maybe designers can release new modified versions of these badges that a player can choose by long pressing on an already obtained badge. This will allow players to mach strict colored outfits with colorable badges.
The color that designers will work on and release should be chosen by a collective vote by those who wish for a specific new color to be added.
(A photoshopped image for demonstration, with contrast modified to allow the black ribbons to stand out)
willow plover
Champion League Mode
-Win as many as you can. 3 loses and out(reset to 0 wins and 0 loses instead).
-Cost 50 gold per participate
-Winning may get some stuff(eg. 1 win = 10 gold, 1 rose; 2 wins = 20 gold, 2 roses;etc)
lethal storm
@pallid merlin maybe @meager gyro would agree that she receives too many dms and that it would help her if the mmods could deal with the YouTube and social media rewards
runic dragon
She also agrees that she is pinged too much
pallid merlin
@full falcon https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/426721136701603840/491135242598350849/IMG_20180917_023109.png sorry that's not possible 😅
Thanks for suggesting
@willow plover it'd take too long for a game to start...
meager gyro
@lethal storm Actually no, there are reasons why I got more dms than normal the last days and also why it took a bit longer than normal to reply to them + why it's like that and we won't change it ^^ Thanks for the suggestion tho ^^
lethal storm
Oki ^^
runic dragon
I think a Moderator should be able to share the work with Mega Mod
Mega's job is damn tiring
lethal storm
I was just suggesting because well, the social media items have been added when there were 5 mods+
Now, there is only 1
lethal storm
@runic dragon but there are no moderators
lilac temple
You can always apply for Trial Helper
lethal storm
Ik
runic dragon
Moderator exists 🙂
lethal storm
But Currently
There are 5 mmod
0 mod
1 megamod
@runic dragon but nobody has this role Currently.
willow plover
Mod offline
lilac temple
Oof, thats unbalanced.
runic dragon
@lethal storm Lisa does
lethal storm
Gosh
I'm telling you there are none @willow plover
lilac temple
Lmao, yeah only Lisa.
runic dragon
lethal storm
@runic dragon she is MEGAmod
lethal storm
Not moderator
lilac temple
''Moderator.''
runic dragon
Don't ping me on every single mesage lol 😂
lethal storm
@runic dragon 😂
lilac temple
She's a Trial Helper with a megamod why-
lethal storm
Because she kept all roles
lethal storm
@runic dragon well there are a lot of helpers and mmod
glacial warren
@runic dragon heyo ^^ we are aware of some issues and first we have to fix things after this weekend. Yes since many of our loved members resigned we need to handle these things.
You can always apply for trial helper, but at the moment the application is closed. You can find it in #community-announcements 
runic dragon
Waiting for it to be opened again :cute-non-existent-emoji:
lethal storm
:cute-emoji-that-I-cant-use:
glacial warren
@runic dragon good luck 
lethal storm
Staff role (discord + guardian + mentor) should have sherif's perms so we don't have to wear this ugly role
pallid merlin
I'll redirect this idea, thanks for suggesting ^^
lethal storm
:)
charred kiln
I thought of an idea where u can see all messages of one person in game. Let me explain.
Well it works like this. When u send a message S1 (s=show) all messages of 1 will get another colour so u can see what 1 has sent. When u send U1 (u=unshow) it will be undone. Idk if other people can see to if u sent s/u 1/16. I think this would be a great way to show what a person has all said instead of searching ur death into the spammed chat.
This could be nice for example:
-all aura/det info.
-see if someone is suspisious he ever said sth
-see what someone has claimed
floral quail
maybe add a next button so we can play too the next game
charred kiln
Thats already ig
U should show that in #bugs-readonly y it doesnt work
Please dont ignore my suggestion
runic dragon
There is only helper online. Be patient
quaint bramble
@charred kiln That's an interesting feature and it sounds helpful.
Do keep in mind that after a while, the older messages in the game will be gone so it wont be flawless, but thats probably a good thing... I will add it to the devs channel 
@floral quail As arsonist said, that's already in-game. It should not look like this after the game, there should be an xp button and a play again button. If this is what you often see then maybe report it to #bugs-readonly indeed.
floral quail
@quaint bramble I was a spectator
quaint bramble
How was I supposed to know that 😛
quaint bramble
Alright a play again button after a spectator match is the idea then?
floral quail
yes
quaint bramble
Sounds good 👍
floral quail
okay!
wind jewel
Add a section in profile where we can see our last game lobby with skill points lost or won in that match.
For ranked only
floral quail
I highly agree with @wind jewel...
quaint bramble
It already shows you how many you lose/win at the end of the match
wind jewel
@quaint bramble only after the match
But with this it'll be permanent and you can see your previous matches and with whom you played with
quaint bramble
that sounds like something different, like a game log, but thn i wonder why that should only be for ranked games...
Try expanding on this idea a little and explain why you like to have this etc
wind jewel
Because ranked games are serious games... While others are simply fun
Won't it'll be difficult maintaining logs for all game modes
floral quail
I actually like cause sometimes, if you died early, you want to know if you won or lost in case you had to go. This way, you will. know if your team won or lost.
quaint bramble
Like I said, write it out in one solid feedback idea, describe what you want in it etc... These are all just random 5 sec thoughts and I am not gonna be the one to put them together for you.. you should explain it yourself
charred kiln
@runic dragon i am but sometimes it just get ignored
@quaint bramble no? My messages only dissapear when i go off. I can read whats said from day 1
quaint bramble
On very long games or very chatty days, it does remove the first days texts sometimes, i dont know the exact conditions for it.. but i certainly never go offline during the game
charred kiln
Maybe deveice?
Are u on phone?
Or maybe it was just a long time ago and its updated now
quaint bramble
I play on pc now so it shouldnt ever count e as offline nor have trouble loading it all up
But yeah it could be changed by now, i dont scroll back a lot
charred kiln
Hmm okay
I remember also very lightly days where i couldnt see everything but im not sure
normal wyvern
If you spin the wheel and leave the game, there should not be a message during the spin function that you still have to spin to get the gold. But you are already spinning the wheel, so why should this message come?
quaint bramble
Yep has been suggested before, and the devs are never very eager to seperate the game into different levels
I do believe Match making can be done without adding different servers but it would be a quite complicated project probably
alpine turret
Hi some idea To make the game player life better or not depend your vision
A gamepass we but it like 20-30$ month we get all new skin when they are release gold skin item token and more
And grade like stone odon gold diamond platinum rubis like other game advantage skin flachy nametag
I think that should be in the game for the player who pay not only skin
Event game each week with special role everyone can join for like 50 gold
Special music for grade cause the actually them music are boring
The top 3 winner of event win something skin item or whatever
normal jungle
Editing the TIE result
Well honestly if losing will make you lose less points than a tie then you probally should lose and throw the game right?
The idea is to make people who are about to tie earn points instead of losing
And the people who already lost nothing will change
For example:
Arso and jww left so it's either wolf win ( if arso didn't vote ) or arso win ( if jww didn't tag )
In both cases village lost thus they will lose the same amount of points they lose normally
For arso and wolf if they tie they lose 30 points!! Even tho a Tie is way better than Losing
Yet point system is messed up so, people like this jww let arso win so we lose less points which is reasonable but game throwing
The general point of this that people who participated in the tie should earn 10~20 points for their work not to lose points more than they lose in a lost game
quaint bramble
@alpine turret Nobody erased anything here,,, it probably was too long to send or got auto removed by disord. try to post it as one neat message please, instead of 20 different posts.
normal wyvern
Is it possible to check my feedback after the huge ones? Would be cool, thanks
alpine turret
Hi some idea To make the game player life better or not depend your vision A gamepass we but it like 20-30$ month we get all new skin when they are release gold skin item token and more
And grade like stone odon gold diamond platinum rubis like other game advantage skin flachy nametag I think that should be in the game for the player who pay not only skin Event game each week with special role everyone can join for like 50 gold Special music for grade cause the actually music are boring The top 3 winner of event win something skin item or whatever
Done
quaint bramble
@normal wyvern I dont really think its that weird, yes technically it means 'you should finish spinning to get your gold, so if thats what you want it to say then i can add it, but otherwise i dont realy see the point in changing it
normal wyvern
Then maybe change it into this sentence that you should wait until the spin is finished because now it sounds like you still can spin to get your rewards..
quaint bramble
@alpine turret Thats a very expensive thing, and I dont think many people will like to just have all the outfits that are released in a month.
I dont understand the grade stone thing or how that fits with the wwo-theme.
What does 'a flashy name tag' look like to you? In game or only on profile?
I dont understand the special role part either
Its kinda rude to call the current music boring, someone worked hard on those. And we already had a few suggestions to add more music on Battlepasses for example
Top 3 winner of what..? that has nothing to do with your paid subscription idea and you didnt explain what the event is. And we already get many ideas for events and the devs dont really like it because there is already daily rewards and battlepasses and clan quests.
alpine turret
Paid 20 month or 4.95 each 3 day? Skin
Grade more the grade is up more or expensive
Flashy name like:
I
Second pic is my nametag
First is non-payable nametag and mine during one season
Event game can be a game. Made by staff and everyone can spectate winner team fight other in a second fight like tournament
quaint bramble
I really meant how it should look like in wwo, its not really comparable...
quaint bramble
Ingame names wont be colour changed cause it makes the chat messy
quaint bramble
in wwo it is denied before
@normal jungle Ranked is a little outside of my knowledge so I will have to trust your word on this.... you're saying that during a tie, everyone loses skill points?
And how do you define 'participate in a tie' ?
quaint bramble
that kind of ruins the fun of having super cool graves, if you cant show them?
runic dragon
Some games u have tutorials for roles
What if u click on a role and get an option to see what the basics are. Just a few steps so u know how to play the role.
So that its easier for new players to understand the game
A little video or 4 photos to let see how u use youre ability and what to do in some situations
quaint bramble
The tutorial recently got updated and over time we might be seeing more for different roles ^^
runic dragon
I mean if u click on a role u can get an option to for example try to jail or with witch try to heal or try to kill. That kind of stuff
So you know what to do
normal jungle
@quaint bramble yes, we lose like 30 points for ww and villagers idk about solo roles
By Participate in tie I mean that the tie happen between 2 teams most of the time
For example wolfs and villagers
So just an idea to prevent people who lost in this example to try to get a tie so they dont points is to make villagers and ww (as in example) only get tie points while other teams like solo roles will lose
You can just imagine it as the last 2 teams in tie will only get the points
forest rover
I think that what @sudden dock means with the off gravestone is to make easier to know if the dead people are on or off.
This could be useful for med when he is going to rev.
And, @quaint bramble,about your point of cool graves,I want to know,would you care about everyone seeing your really cool gravestone if you are not in the game?Doesn’t makes sense.
opaque pollen
The game already warns when a Medium tries to revive an offline player
forest rover
Well then maybe just to have better way to see if the dead players still watching the game or not.The off message its a bit small and I think that with the off message in the gravestone and seeing it all grey makes easier to differentiate them.
At least add it to feedback-devs to see if people like or not the idea.
runic dragon
I disagree Just increase your brightness
and it shouldn't matter wether or not you can see if a dead player is still watching or not.
Dont spam the chat with the same thing too @forest rover
Anyways I'm here looking at what people have to say about updating ranked and expanding it into multiple gamemodes. The classic "wait for full" is boring and heavily overpowers village. I prefer a 10-12 player ranked game as thats when the game is balanced to the highest degree, (at least in my opinion)
Maybe adding 3 separate game modes like.
8-player game
12-player game
16-player game
and adjust the skill received for wins as the roles/teams.
I think it would be a nice change to be able to play 10-12 because as off the vote for start update. Out of at least 500 ranked games only 3 of them have been 10-12 or lower.
rigid bronze
@fallen rock 1. It wouldn't have "/7" for sure
2. It's not that useful, since that they have only a one time usage
3. It wouldn't be public for sure so a bit useless
But thanks for suggesting
@forest rover Just open the menu and you'll see a clear grey "Off" ^-^ thanks for suggesting
@runic dragon I think it's a pretty good idea, would it be like gamemoded inside a gamemode ? If yes, thinking about the small amount of players playing ranked heavily, don't you think dividing them in 3 gamemodes would make ranked even less played ?
runic dragon
@rigid bronze It's all going to be under ranked games and the players who play ranked will just m be divided. Majority of them who care about their skill level and look nice will stick to 16 players, a few players wanting a balanced challenge goes to 12 players, and those just wanting a quick game would go to 8 player.
rigid bronze
But look, right now in a casual English ranked game there is only 10 players
I mean it's a very good idea, but they aren't really enough ranked players to make it happen
rigid bronze
I know I know
runic dragon
We would never have 16 player games
runic dragon
Anyways I'll continue typing.
Even though the players would be split up, I know how sucky the community is and at least 50% of them would stay in 16 player games, there would be no problem starting 16 player games.
8 players is a small number needed to start anyways 10-25% of the original 100% would go there
The only gamemode I think would have a problem starting is 12 players. Not sure if that 40-25% is an accurate number and don't know if there would be enough online to start.
The number of players needed to start wouldn't be a problem.
And if any of the 8 player or 12 player rooms had trouble starting Everyone would just go back and flock 16 players again. And we'd be able to tell if it was a good idea or not based off of if its successful or not.
rigid bronze
Okay okay got me, I'll add it
And I'll add also the idea of only putting a 16 and 8 players gamemode
Since I'm pretty sure you're right when saying 12 wouldn't be used as much
runic dragon
@rigid bronze I still would like for you to add it (if possible) I think 10-12 player ranked games have the most balance.
rigid bronze
I will dont worry (if what I send in #feedback-devs doesn't suit your mind, just tell me I'll change it)
fallen rock
@rigid bronze It's still convenient to know and it can be put in more
quaint bramble
@runic dragon Hmm I think 8 is a too small amount for a balanced game, 12 sounds more likely to succeed
But new game modes AND splitting ranked is always denied... it also seems complicated to have different rank modes going on at the same time.
runic dragon
@quaint bramble Then feel free to tear it down. I'll just stick to custom or something
quaint bramble
I think you are underestimating how hard it is to add modes with less players, the devs would at the very least, have to design a bunch of new role setups and balance test them
runic dragon
@quaint bramble Isn't the game already set up to be balanced at whatever number of players there are?
Like below 10 Solo kill gets removed.
And so does 1 ww
quaint bramble
it's set up to remove roles in a specific order, i think
runic dragon
Yes, the lesser amount of players the more roles that are removed
full falcon
Apparently people get very creative at night
full falcon
We should add spectator mode to sandbox, when you die, everything goes as it's supposed to, but you get an option to "spectate game" doing that will disable your ability to talk, send roses, or emoting, but it will discover all the roles in the current match.
Side idea: make this spectator mode a thing before the game starts, so you can "watch a match" and learn from it, if this were to be added to quick game, people can learn from spectating matches.
quaint bramble
but... why?
forest rover
What about if the game sends us a message like:
In 30/10/5/2 minutes we are going to restart the server.
Then I will stop playing and I won’t have the problem of a game that we cannot do anything,and its even more frustrating in ranked.
It would be nice either if once the restart was warned,the game don’t let us to play until the restart finished.And also that the restart waits,at least,that all ranked games finished.
Idk if was suggested before but it could help players to know when they shouldn’t play because we cannot finish the game once it restarts.And that is annoying.
fallen rock
I agree that players should be prevented from launching games before maintenance
runic dragon
Lock #feedback-readonly , #bugs-readonly , #feedback-devs , #bugs-devs , #bot-commands , and only leave the #questions open for non-Sheriff members.
Set a cooldown in #questions , so even if there is a mass spamming there and other stuff, welp,... Maybe a 5s cooldown should fit it
quaint bramble
im pretty sure the feedback and bug channels are already locked behind the sheriff role
Only questions is open to to newcomers
runic dragon
OK.
Set the cooldown in #questions then
Add a command for Werewolf Online for Helpers, such as "?h sheriff", to help new-comers
jovial haven
Hello I hope u add a room with arabe flag in the game so we can talk in arabe
trail shuttle
...
gilded pilot
what if people has to complete a test about server rules in order to have access to other channels
runic dragon
Cheating 🙂
@gilded pilot They can just go to #rules-archived to find the needed answers. But I think at least, they read the rules, so I guess it's a good suggestion.
hybrid scroll
@full falcon You know you could play with a Friend and your friend could tell you the roles? Like it would be easier to hear
rigid bronze
@runic dragon I asked Lisa but I guess you know what will she answer 🤷🏻♂️
trail shuttle
?h
runic dragon
glacial warren
@trail shuttle hey may I help you?
lament frigate
@runic dragon lmao literally why would they need that perm
Its literally useless
Also why do YOU care about their perms lmao
full falcon
Uhmmm yeah can we not make the profile of a person close/disappear when you send them a friend request ?
full falcon
#questions not here
glacial warren
@sudden dock hey ^^ since it's always male/female, I think this will not happen, but I think the idea is good so I will add it to #feedback-devs
Thank you for the suggestion
white isle
sudden dock
😀thank you
white isle
i would like a way to organise your clothes yourself, like dragging it to the spot you like or being able to choose if the quest outfits show first or bp outfits, etc. because now i have to scroll all the way down most of the time :')
lethal storm
A ?h command about the sherif role and the locked channels
warm helm
@white isle heya! To which outfit set does this belong? Also, the clothing thing looks like a nice idea. Thanks for your suggestion
@lethal storm i will discuss it with the others, thanks for your feedback
solar dew
Because it's kinda rude that we can't get the items from the old battle passes I suggest following:
If you finished the actual battle pass you can buy the old ones for the prize it costs in the past and play it. If you don't finish it while actual battle pass is going it will be reseted and you have to buy it again and play it from tier 1 after you finished the actual battle pass.
You can also buy battle passes you already completed for example for the roses.
I hope I explained it clearly
vernal dune
@solar dew buying old battle passes has already been suggested and denied ^^
solar dew
Was the suggestion more like this or more like you can buy it all the time?
@vernal dune
vernal dune
both of these won't be added, previous battle pass will never be able to be bought again
solar dew
That's so rude
vernal dune
but its what makes the battle pass so original, that you absolutely need to finish to get the items
solar dew
But I didn't knew that this wonderful game exist when season 1 started😭
quaint bramble
@solar dew Rude really is not the right word for it... they are exclusive, limited items. Adding them to the game again could also be considered 'rude' to the people who have those items as they can proudly show how long they have been around on this game.
white isle
@warm helm the shirt is from this battle pass, the one with the brown hair and shield
solar dew
Yeah maybe it's the wrong word.
But I think it's not important when they started. I think it's more important if they play it seriously and often.
I would prefer it if the ones who play it seriously have the chance to get this.
And I think I used rude because I love the items from season 1 and 2 and have no change to get them just because I found this game so late
quaint bramble
I wasnt around for BP 1-4 and yeah there is some really nice items, and I would love to be able to get them. But that's generally not how those things work..
solar dew
Hm... I wanted to use the chance to ask for it... I'm very sad that I'll never have the chance to get these items...
wicked flume
@craggy dagger I propose a pacifist buff to allow voting to still happen after a reveal. The pacifist is often a liability to town since it gets rid of one vote which is crucial for town victories. Furthermore, there are 16 people in a game and 6 of them are bad so the odds of someone successfully revealing someone bad is similar to the chance of a gunner randomly shooting someone bad. Pacifist needs this buff to be as good as the other rv roles like beast hunter and forkman.
keen jewel
Make option to keep clan open but only Players from my Country would have option to join
I need that
full falcon
:v
wicked flume
I think werewolf berserk also needs a buff to kill all visitors to a person instead of just protectors. So if a det wants to check gunner with someone and gunner is attacked the detective should also die. This is just for consistency.
Nightmare werewolf counterplay is to say during the day "if im not nightmared i will emote". This is absurdly broken and very unfair. The nightmare werewolf should be able to control what emotes the nightmared player uses during the night.
quaint bramble
@wicked flume heya, before i read your ideas, could you please change your server-nickname to something more family friendly?
you can change it too, if you tap on the server name in the top left corner
quaint bramble
@wicked flume Pacifist isnt supposed to random reveal, its considered gamethrowing. If used correctly, it can be really useful to sort out confusion. And yeah it takes away one voting for the village, and that's the price to pay. This is what makes it a balanced role, it shouldnt be buffed Imo.
Frenzy killing visitors, I dont really understand why you call that consistency. Checking roles isnt really considered literal visiting, as far as I know. And it can already kill more than one person at once.
Personally I have never heard of emote codes being used for being nightmared, and I dont know why that would even be useful info to convey to the other players 🤔
And again, such a thing would be a reportable offense already.
wicked flume
Pacifist is easily one of the weakest rv roles in the game. It cannot kill or protect and also just wastes a day that could better be spent lynching. It is outclassed by mayor which can autoconfirm itself and double votes without wasting a day. I feel like pacifist should not have this major drawback.
quaint bramble
Not every villager needs to be able to kill or protect, there's already so many of those and the village is already considered overpowered.
It's not the role's fault that many people consider it boring and only use it to random-reveal. It's extremly un-tactical and definately not the only way to play the role.
wicked flume
I win more with forkman than i win with pacifist. I think that is legitimately a huge issue that needs to be addressed.
quaint bramble
I could give you an example of a good paci tactic if you want 🤔
wicked flume
I am open to suggestions
I have been lynched after revealing and also shot at @craggy dagger can confirm
I feel like a sensible nerf to town would be to replace the 3 rv slot with 3 pacifists because of how bad of a role it is.
quaint bramble
As I said earlier, its main function is sorting through the confusion and making sure the hh doesnt get his target lynched for example.
And I think rrv paci is best if you dont claim it early on, kinda similar to mayor. When there's someone wrongfully claiming rrv, you can reveal an evil role easily, which can then be gunned or jailkilled.
Someone literally posted a feedback a few days ago that 3 rrv paci in a game is too op 😅
wicked flume
I am sure he has no idea what he is talking about
quaint bramble
3 the same of any rrv, can be very overwhelming...
a sensible paci can reveal a wolf, and the others would use it in the same round so it doesnt block more lynches
And then bam, you got 2-3 evils revealed
wicked flume
But they cannot be lynched which makes the reveal pointless.
keen jewel
Ping me later if u read my idea
wicked flume
I feel like I should get the opinions of top 10 global players like Milli who liked my idea (see the thumbs up).
thin dome
Paci is already powerful enough
wicked flume
Incrediably underwhelming you mean.
I get depressed every time i see "pacifist" in the wheel.
quaint bramble
Should be pretty satisfying to lay low and wait your chance, and actually revealing a previously unconfirmed evil role imo
thin dome
Plus wws never usually kill pacis bcuz they assume that the paci is gonna gamethrow
solar dew
I like pacifist and I think it's good like it is. If you don't like it it's your thing. I don't like it to be seer but if I am I play the role and if I'm playing with friends it's also funny with roles you don't like
wicked flume
Last game as paci i type "hippity hoppity your role is my property" and then revealed med
Who then died the next day
quaint bramble
Yeah that souds like random revealing aka gamethrowing again though
Again just cause most people dont botther to play a role well, doesnt mean the role itself it to blame
solar dew
Is paci in quick game? If it is you can suggest to remove it from there because of the much game throws
flint charm
I have an opinion on zombies, i feel like they're kinda overpowered not gonna lie
quaint bramble
I'm not 100% sure but I think paci is never in quickgame.
@flint charm That;s absolutely true...
solar dew
@flint charm everyone think this😂 and there are many suggestions but all denied I think
flint charm
Ahh darn it
wicked flume
I can reveal people role as gunner too (but they die) and i did reveal med by accident too.
Why do they not die when i reveal bad.
Makes no sense.
flint charm
Tho i've only been zombie once and i tried to bite one person but he commit suicide and during the morning the seer had checked me
solar dew
Not long time ago all suggestions for zombies were post in #feedback-devs
quaint bramble
so you can actually make sure theyre bad, instead of shooting seer, i dont have to spell that out I hope
wicked flume
I'm being sarcastic but for the love of god can you guys nerf paci and ww berserk.
They actually ruin ranked.
You can talk to anyone top 200 and they'll agree.
Paci should die if they reveal someone good (like priest dies)
And gunner shouldnt die when jailed that is actually absurd
It is unwinnable if all 3 bullets die in fool game cuz wwb tapped one button.
WIthout like 3 pacifists or multple witches or another busted rv.
full falcon
So many people want at least one item from a previous battle pass because they didn't discover the game earlier, and that's a shame/a bit unfair.
How about making 1 redeem code of a desirable item obtainable through maybe tier 99 of the next battle pass (so new players can have a chance to obtain an item from BP1 for example) and so a player can choose what outfit item/emoji/player icon they want to have.
And this redeem code would only work on battle passes 1 through 5 maybe (or all of them up to the current one)
This feature will give everyone a fair chance (if they achive tier 99 of the next BP) to obtain something a player who dicovered the game earlier, and by chance has obtained.
quaint bramble
@wicked flume well they added their rofl emotes but I dont see anyone else actually sharing this opinion here yet...
wicked flume
wdym
quaint bramble
If those '200 top ranked players' agree with this suggestion, they can tell us that too.
wicked flume
OOHH so we can actually make a change?
Should i get all of PR, Hewwo, Chicken WIngs, Rebellion, etc to give feedback
quaint bramble
I dont think paci will be changed just for top 200 rankers no. But you can try to get wwb removed from ranked, theres been some attempts on that already.
quaint bramble
Make balanced suggestions with real arguments. Not just 'people dot use paci right so the role is bad'
quaint bramble
If you want to hear about a real riskless role, try flowerchild 👀
wicked flume
that role requires u to about to be lynched which no one randomly does in fool games
solar dew
Haha you wish
I saw so much voting random in a fool game
Please add an option to gift owned outfits to friends.
Reasons:
-if you are in a long holiday or something you can give your outfits to a friend who don't have them, but love them.
-if you have a clan quest a friend of you don't have you can give it to him if you don't like it But he love it. It's because sometimes you join a clan where all have this quest and you want the outfit but love the clan too.
-if you have a random pay skin or an old pay skin you don't like, but a friend love you can give it to him so you didn't put the money into the rubbish.
-if you quit the game but you have outfits a friend love you can give them to him as a last action in game
I'm sorry I'm not that good with words in English. Hope you understand my point
charred kiln
Paci and berserk indeed need a nerf
I agree with @wicked flume
And im from pr too
They just are to annoying and not making fun of the game
Also i just think paci should die when revealing a role but nerfing it in anyways would be fine destroying it too just make it a forkman also fine imo
U know why paci need a nerf? Becuz it ruins all werewolfs plan. In first case everyone random reveals and even its gamethrowing everyone does it also good players. This will make already the game cancer from the beginning since or one villager revealed and or one solo or ww is revealed and boom cancer game. If they dont gamethrow they will usually confirm an rv what will ruin the fake rv’s whole plan also other fake things like fake det fake aura paci has the power to ruin it. I want some real arguments why this is not overpowered and not things like “its just a role and u can always try to stop them” or sth
solar dew
that's why we have to nerf ranked. Every noob can join if he want
And I think the sense of the role is to make fake things clear👀
charred kiln
Thats not a real argument
Invalid
Yes the meaning of the role is to make fake things clear and THATS op
and i want an argument why that wouldnt be op and shouldnt be nerfed
runic dragon
make people join gold league from 3000 skills please
solar dew
Than maybe suggest to change pazi from rrv to rsv?
charred kiln
Hmm
lethal storm
@warm helm thx
charred kiln
Thats not even so bad
If it just get dissapeared or nerfed from ranked its fine by me
quaint bramble
You changed from buff paci to nerf paci 🤔
charred kiln
@quaint bramble i still want an argument
runic dragon
Fap stop
solar dew
This isn't the right channel to troll.. if there even is one... @wicked flume
wicked flume
but now im serious plz nerf paci and wwb
charred kiln
U have no arguments but still dont put it in #feedback-devs
quaint bramble
It's a balanced role, you reveal someone at the price of not being able to lynch them.
Sure if you have 3 rrv paci its a problem, but that's not the argument here
charred kiln
That price is horrible
wicked flume
day 1 no leads or 2 det claims or rv aura hmm suddenly paci busted
charred kiln
Nobody votes at all
solar dew
I think your suggestion isn't written out
charred kiln
Paci only reveals when no voting needed
wicked flume
exactly ppl dont lynch day 1
quaint bramble
Yeah it's best to use the role when there is no usable info for a lynch, thats how it works
charred kiln
Yeah
wicked flume
which is literally every single day 1
charred kiln
But the funtion of it is op
solar dew
For the thing with unbalanced by more than one paci just make it like Cupid,jailer,... That there only can be one in game
wicked flume
but how about wwb