#general-feedback-discussion
1 messages · Page 529 of 1
eggs should be a rare thing that arn't an important part of the diet but give a lot of food on the rare occaision they're found.
ovi should get most of its food from fruits/berries and small animals.
Agreed
@barren zephyr maybe but the only change would be few animations, an an defence position, an heavy attack and transformation to normal standing. They fixed the alt-turn and even improved it. Potential is there 🙏
The ovi would be one of the omnivores
And I am for it
It would eat gores, maybe some fruits, the bushes have little berries, if you look closely, hatchlings, small dinosaurs and eggs
Mmhmm, the devs just need to get the recode and base game done. Than hopefully omnivores
notmuch of a hopefully. its just "Then omnivores"
Just setting my expectations low so I can get impressed
Good idea. But I'd really like to have these feather bois in the game
will we still have our dinos after recode???
Unfortunately but worth it
@south beacon Thats not a suggestion
I didn’t know where else do ask don’t be rude.
you can ask in #401464048610312195 and he wasn't being rude
he was just telling you that's not where it goes
if they consider that msg rude then i hate to see their reaction to ppl being actually rude lmao. idk about spawning as a hatchling all the time considering you could just be nested in if you really want to be a hatchling
just cause something is realistic doesnt mean it will work out well ingame
takes long enough to grow, let me start as a juvie
this isnt saurian where you've got a chance because the ai isnt all that bright and theres no one else around. spawning as a baby would fuck people over with no chance for getting anywhere
Yeah that’d be a rip
Aren't all growth rates gonna be 1? Also seamless growth
Don't get me wrong, playing compy would probably be fun. But it would end up just like velo, where nobody ever plays it even though you can play it. I think taking time to make it a playable,(if it is an ai, which I have a feeling it is) would be a waste. Taco, Oro, and velo are all playable but even in sandbox people only play them for the memes
@barren zephyr I'm sorry but a logout timer not working when you've been hit in the last five minutes is terrible. What if I've won a fight and am healing but I have to go two minutes after the fight? I have to leave my dinosaur there? Also if youre having issues with a dinosaur not dying in a minute or taking sufficient damage that it has to get up and fight you off perhaps you just shouldn't be fighing it. Also, i'm pretty sure anything other than safelogging does make your dinosaur stay in the server for an extended time but until they starve is just too much. Things happen and you can't always wait for the timer or some players just don't know or need to quit the game early for some reason.
@agile zinc i see your point, but that would make revenge killing mighty easy
yeah thats what im afraid of too. Kinda like in WoW etc when u were lvling ur alt, some twink just killed u, u got angry, logged on ur main and hunted for the guy :D. And rule like "no revenge hunting" might not rly help aswell. Tho there could be some kind mechanic to avoid it. Like maybe, u can logg to diffrent dino only after certain time, like 30min between switches. And if u chosen a dino, got killed in it, the cooldown is still on, so u gotta create a new one. Might also kinda force it to spawn on some diffrent spawn. Tho thats kinda bad idea aswell.. hmm
eventuallly, make just like 2 spots on one u can pick only Carni and on another only Herbi dino. might kinda work, like if u got ur apex killed u wont probably be able to revenge kill someone as a maia :D.
Meh, idk, dont have an opinion
@burnt fern from what we know, dimporphism is purely visual.
so one gender being larger and more powerful
i know, i never claimed it wasn't purely for aesthetics, i would just prefer some variety in male/female dimorphism
like yeah one gender looks bigger and scarier, but i dont think there will be a stat difference
nor would i want stat differences tbh
If there would be stat diffrences there would be purely of that gender, so there would be barely any nests and breeding pairs, i guess.
sorry i don't quite understand what u said lol
Players would mostly pick the stronger one if there would be stat differences so there wouldn't be any hatchlings
oh ok
yeah, i agree
I saw your reaction under my suggestion @winter sage so I would like to know in what you don't agree.
I like when people explain why they disagree, thing than I do.
I like to talk with people about this kind of stuff
I like to talk ajout what I don't like in a suggestion, except if it is unbalanced or really dumb like Giga buff.
And same for @mighty girder.
It shouldn't change things that are used to deal dmg, as that would require different hitboxes
And the hitboxes should remain the same
That don't change damage
I said at the beginning "only cosmetic"
So nothing change for the damages and hitbox
Triceratops : Horns could change between male and female as like Horridus and Porosus but as we know there is a project of customizable horns for him (like allo).
- Diabloceratops : Same as Trike but for the horns over the head, like female has smaller one than male and they're pointing up to the sky, male could like now or a bit larger.
How would you do that
without changing the hitbox
to match
hm?
It stay the same
But it can't
That only model changement
If the female has smaller horns, it can't hit you with just open air. Its hitbox would have to be changed to match
there doesnt have to be a huge difference or hell they could just change the point of the horns instead of the size
Which I'm 100% against, male and female should have same hitboxes
I agree
I'd be fine if it was like, Crest size (I think the full idea of it is stupid tbh but it is what it is) But crest instead of horns would be better
Why on earth would you make them different species
And for the Dibble I talked about the upper horns, not the facial ones
Just as sexual dimorphism
No hitbox or damage changement
That's dumb
I against things like female weaker than male.
Thing needs to be balanced
But if you change the horns you have to change the hitbox to match the model change
thats what you arent getting
so instead just shrink the crest I guess
because crest doesnt do dmg
After I said than horns probably will be customizable
But yeah it could be the crest that change
Or/with the little horns
Is there scientific proof that those changes are accurate though?
We don't really care in The Isle about scientific accuracy. But these species, with their looking, could have a sexual dimorphism in The Isle.
Like Cerato for example with his horns
Not to mention it isn't always the case that females are smaller. Take black widows, hyenas, elephants, etc
honestly as long as the stats arent different at all it should be fine with different sizes between genders, which I think a dev said their stats dont change right?
Stats shouldn't change and I think devs already said that.
god dammit my other msg didnt send PepeHands. I think Crest patterns being different between genders for trikes would be better than changing the size of their horns, but we will see what the devs have done
I fought for some month and already did a suggestion that colors shouldn't be the only sexual dimorphism. I think trike should get one with the little hors on the nose and for the crest like male as a larger one (but not super large).
Daggum- that pic of the trikes makes me wish we had better looking trikes lol
Anyway- id enjoy purely aesthetic sexual dimorphism
No stat changes- this is a game and we all gotta be equal, this ain’t real life
Different sizes are different stats.
A smaller model will have a smaller hitbox, which will make it better in combat.
If it uses the same animations it will also be slower, and the animations would need to be redone to keep it the same speed. (Or you could speed up the animations which just looks wrong).
Saying changing the size doesn't change the stats is just wrong.
Nah other people have said about size changes not being stat changes. Wasn't aimed at you.
I like things like different crests and colours.
@still needle i think it might be kinda fixed with like, getting "invincible" for few mins/seconds upon logging to the game. Where u cant be killed untill u move or "buff " fades out.
@covert birch not sure if compy will be playable but thats a very interesting niche idea tbh. play as a swarm of small dinos instead of just one; though that would likely need some advanced ai for the swarm as you would ultimately be controlling just 1 and the others mimick you
Thats actually really neat, I like that
The Isle future will have hybird dinos?
Not hybrid, mutants
raptor pounce and body dragging will be defo added
anky bb will be added if anky gets added
@barren zephyr that's what I like to hear
@pulsar lake Will the mutants to obtainable to the general player base? Or is it only select players like the devs and youtubers?
@copper gorge if you mean strains, they are rn only in development aka dev only, but everyone will be able to obtain them
aww ok
They'll be available to players in the future
epic
@wintry cipher while idk how well the AI will be with recode but a good way to be able to fix/control that is by limiting the amount of AI per player. So like every player can have up to 4 ai following him. The biggest issue imo for this suggestion tho is how grouping would work and whether you would be able to combine swarms
probably wouldnt be able to combine swarms with multiple players. I would say that kind of dino would actually not need or benefit really from grouping
youd already be handling a swarm of hungry mouths. why rely on others and struggle to ensure all of your swarmlings stay full?
So are u saying they shouldnt group at all or that it would just be non-beneficial
people forgetting that this is the channel for suggestion discussion?
pachyrhino would be a perfectly good playable imo, but I don't think another ceratopsian is likley
Just gotta hope for the best
should the maiasaurus be replaced by iguanodon?
benefits are that it could do bleed damage with its thumbs
A: Iggy isn't much like maia at all.
B: Why would you delete a dino to add a new one? Deleting a dino doesn't get back the amount of time and money spent on it.
If iggy got added, it could easily be alongside maia.
@granite cedar you realize suggestions isnt a discussion channel right
And mouth grapple is already confirmed.
Allo is 2 shot by a rex, not 1 shot
well, it's kind of a one shot, so....
I'd probably delete the clutter if I were you.
@blazing charm only my suggesiton description is left now
my argue for the bite catch is that, it would add interaction instead of just smashing left click...
U can try a high risk / high reward catch, that would need like a small duration cast and small cooldown (like half a second to a second), and if u succeed to it, it catched the target. He's not dead, he still can escape, but with heavy blood. A teammate could rescue him by attacking the attacker.
That would add importance to play in group, to protect eachother, and would make u feel even more scaredand oppressed of being lonely.
With why not a - small - random chance to escape fast or not fast... just to make the game more credible, cuz I really DONT THINK a rex would one shot an allo if this had to happen in real life. The fight should get more than just CLICK oh he's dead, looked like a headbut lol !
Okay first off
I don't know if I'm alone to think this way, but every ppl I play with and I talk about would think this feature cool
It is already confirmed that you will be able to bite and hold onto prey.
OH I did not know that !
I've only heared about the feature, I'm still a new player
I play since 5 or 6 days
Second, Rex is a terrible example to use for that, that is an animal that depending where it grabs you, you're uber fucked.
I mean I've just heared, didnt read anything official
and never watched official dev stream or whatever
It's fine, you know now.
Any place I can know EVERYTHING we know so far about next update ?
i'll compile a list
Well, first off it's not necessarily an "update", they are rebuilding the entire game.
Oh, thanks Nines.
they've rebuilt the game and are delivering it as an update
its a rather large update
Well, I know it'd technically count as an update when it arrives, but I emphasizing that it's not just a simple-old update
that's why I've gifted the game to friends for christmas, u guys make a huge work so far
and deluver all of this for no more penny
that's quite huge, ty
@brittle fossil rex doesnt really need more money spent on another remodel. It looks just fine. Giga will be getting a remodel though, an entire remake in general really
youre welcome
@thorny lynx the screenshot ingame is on an angle, and the skull you have overlain is facing flat towards the camera. theres no way for that overlay to work out? the eye seems to be far back enough in the head to be in the correct cavity, but due to its angle it can seem closer towards the snout than it really is
I am not the one who made the screenshots.
They came from somebody who knew what they were doing. I'm sure they can take another image of the spino facing completely to the side and add the skull on top. I shall not discuss this further.
The screenshot is Spino facing to the side but tilting his head downwards. Simply placing the skull over the model works.
oh i dont mean an up-down tilt, i mean a forwards-backwards tilt. its still rotated away from the camera, the 2d skull wont match up unless you get a 3d rotation of it
yes, down and away. these thoughts can coexist
He is not facing away from the camera.
This is how the skull should look. Spino's snout is too short and the nostrils are incorrectly-placed.
No amount of angle adjustment will fix Spino's skull shape and length. It dips instead of being flat on the top and it is too short and the nostril is too low on the snout.
That's your opinion.
lol the last one was pretty mush asking for old spino
the new one looks beast dude
I don’t really care about the tiny details like small bits of angle and whatever but yeah having it properly long at least would be nice
All I would like to see is a longer snout and larger crest. That's it.
I do not mind the angry brows. I do not mind the robustness of the skull and the teeth any more. I actually have come to accept and enjoy those aspects. I just want my long snout boi.
I don’t expect them to actually change this and I know it’s an unpopular opinion but spinos super short legs, long face, and dumb cormorant stance where it looks like it’s about to fall on its face is what makes it really unique and cool. 
I love my duck boi, yes.
Jake made a scientifically-accurate spino sometime ago and I would love to see it as an alternate spinosaurus that is mainly aquatic.
I'm really surprised that people are upset with the spinos head and not it's sail. Not that I have issues with it myself
I narked on the sail, but someone mentioned it would not look proportional since our Spino has a chonky midsection. Then I dropped it.
Also for the camouflage.
as someone who has hunted in this game as a spino, im very happy the sail is small even if it's not accurate
Yeah, I don't mind the sail anymore. I do mind how short the snout and crest are, though.
I just want it to be as long as our old Spino but still be thicc and robust.
Hey guys,with my pachyrhino suggestion is there anything you didn’t like or I could improve on ?
@agile zinc Was gonna agree with your suggestion until you mentioned a nerf/debuff.
@reef thorn
from pinned messages; For everyone posting suggestions, from now on suggestions containing 'nerf x/buff x' are not permissive as they add nothing of value for the development team. Please propose a possible fix or weigh balance changes.
what?
I don't understand
oh
so like say
ava should get 6k health
I can't process it
Why buff the Ava? you need a reason basically why it should be buffed.
id suggest editing your suggestion adding your reasoning why it should be buffed.
thats i mean
its AI
not a playable
Make it hostile to juvi apex carnis
bruh
Id say a good reasoning for it to be buffed it being aggressive towards same sized and under sizeed dinos. basically juvis and everything close to it ; so AI isnt just an easy meal.
I hope spino doesn’t have some bird like stance or anything- I wanna feel like a heavy Titan, not some lame ass duck
Also, buff Ava to make hunting them more of a challenge
I defo agree about the ava buff. 100N damage and 15 bleed.
I should be risky and terrifying for juvies and fresh adult utahs/dilos to attack. Would be great if they defended themselves rather than just sat being bitten until they died.
@quartz remnant I'd rather giga got more bleed and less bite force. It's meant to be a bleeder dino and it one shots most things it faces due to bite force alone.
Nerfing its bleed and making it rely on bite force more makes it just rex mk2.
@valid flower yeah it does not have to be included, might not rly work properly and be just annyoing.
@quartz remnant butthurt rex fanboy thinking rex should be able to 1 shot trikes and gigas
Its sad when someone makes a huge suggestion that would have to be such a big update to the game it would be like 3.0. The only suggestions the devs probably will listen to are small ones that are easy to add
sounds to me like someone was just a bad rex player and died to a giga lol. giga is suppose to be a bleeder not a biter
if a suggestion is actually good the devs would listen to it and potentially add it or parts of it, regardless of length. It's actually a thing that your suggestion needs a bit of content instead of "add this thing"
- I wish spino had more smooth skin (texture) on some places, it somehow looks too dry for me.
- Guess its pretty impossible to want a bigger sail because of those chonky arms and weight. The right color choice could fix this maybe.
- Now the tail... is it just me or is it a tad bit short?
... - lol, yes I agree on doing some head changes similar to what Ultimate Fluff #CherryTrain 🍒🚆 suggested.
Ok so these are probably the only persoanlly issues im having with spino.
/
@stoic crow I think the bb system will get a rework aswell, I'm sure they'll think of something to make it much better than it is now
imo it would be better to have patterns unlocked from the start for everyone
It would be cool if dinosaurs could just roll/rag doll down hills
You mean when they're alive?
they would probly break every bone in their body
They wouldnt be very alive by the end of it
Agsgfb
imagine a cama rolling down a hill

Watching live dinos flail down a mountain and die would be golden tho
poor cama
Would make ledge baiting apexes all the more entertaining
If the bodies could also hit other dinos on the way and knock them over too
Imagine a herd of shants traveling down a steep slope and one falls and makes a domino effect of flailing shants crashing down the hill
Yes
We need this in the game
hmm, seems dangerous tho
Danger is hot
it's new, it's risky, but it's fresh and I love it
anky rolling down a hill smashing into some rexes insta killing them
I see no problem with that
I wanna be walking on a hill and then suddenly fall from nothing
I think Anky and pachyrhino would be the best BB herbies
Honestly I hugely want first person for the dinosaurs exclusively so you can peek out of a bush without having to walk 10 feet into the open
then how can you see things behind you?
Make it switchable with a button
Think how gta works
Imagine tall grass with current POV lmao
i think first person would make things worse in tall grass
It’d let you peek out at least, for running around it’d suck though
I kinda dont agree with the first person idea
Itd make it so youd only have to poke your head out of foliage to take a peek as opposed to adjusting your entire body and risk exposing yourself more so why not have it as an option
I'd love first person, it would make the game way scarier imo
@valid flower do you suffer with Mental Illness? please provide evidance i have said Rex should 1 shot Trikes and Gigas? i have no complaints in Trikes killing Rexes and Gigas killing Rexes with there bleed, but please provide evidance i claimed otherwise
i'm not about to agree with Jerry and never will but I have never heard of giga winning easily against a rex unless it got lucky and the rex didnt get bb on the first bite
i killed Rexes with Giga, its hard but can be done
so if it's hard then why is the rex bleeding to death in 2-3 bites?
doesnt sound hard to me
Rexs bb makes it hard, take bb away then it becomes easy
bb isnt going away though
so not much of a point
i agree giga should be nerfed but not in bleed
i agree, its bite force needs to be nerfed
getting rid of the bleed just makes it rex without bb and a slightly lower biteforce. lower the biteforce if anything, and let it keep the bleed since it's a bleed and endurance hunter
dunno why you said to nerf the bleed then
just like Giga cry babies want bb to be nerfed
what
what kind of disease? what mechanic affects would it have? how would dinos get them? i don't think thats a very clear suggestion
i have no issues with Giga bleed at 50 just like i have no problem with Rexs BB at 70%, but you get lot of Giga players crying its too high, i play Giga and Rex
bone break isnt even gonna work the same and neither is bleed
we have no clue how these things will work
well
actually we've got an idea
its just a vague idea on how it'll work
exactly
that sounds kinda abusable, dinos could eat a rotten corpse and make themselves sick as a way to food deny if eating them makes others sick in turn @barren zephyr
what the fuck is this conversation i feel like i've been dragged in circles
@paper oriole Maybe just temp sickness, like 5 mins or 10
@paper oriole To be honest, I was thinking of some dental infections and something else to counter it. But I just left it in "Diseases?" just to know if everyone would like to add such thing. I don't think it is something you would need to spread and will affect all dinosaurs, if we talk about dental infections.
And I wouldn't quite say it's abusable if in turn on getting sick, It would give your dino's a bit of debuff
maybe rotten gore would make dinos sick, and they could shorten the duration by drinking a lot of fresh water. certain dinos (scavengers) would be immune to this like cerato and troodon. i dont think eating a sick dino should be punished though, maybe it'd just give less food
if anything
or the body would decay faster
I was thinking of something not so normal. Probably have a chance of getting a dental diseas after eating and drinking from dirty swamp water.
Just to don't make it happen so frequently.
Well it does sound realistic, seeing animals in real life knows to stay away from sick animals
cerato could benefit from toxic water and bodies and gain a septic bite too
I wouldn't like to add something that could be toxic or that could be spreaded, since it will be just chaos.
People spreading diseases to kill other players, not cool man
game mechanic wise though it'd be used to food deny if making yourself sick made others sick
Well you got a point. I do think getting sick of rotten meat could be cool and a way to make people hunt for fresh food
there could be visible toxic algae that'd appear in certain waters that would make dinos sick except cerato and troodon and possible others. it wouldn't be common though, and rotten corpses which would obviously be a lot more common
So hypothetically, maybe a less dangerous disease that will only have an effect on minor stats.
That's why I thought about a dental disease.
Will probably affect all carnivores and some hervibores.
Maybe corpses rottening in water would spoil the water and make it undrinkable
a disease that put a cap on the amount of food your dino can eat maybe, so you aren't able to get as full, a disease that makes your hunger and/or drain faster, a disease that makes you less resistant to bleed
ehh thats abusable
The dental disease will worse your teeth over time and your bleed will decrease, not your bite force tho.
imagine dryo players bath bombing water to poison it
Ew
yes
hahaaHAHA
more like, just a small area around the corpse in the water, not the entire LAKE ;P
Drinking stagnant water could fill your water bar half as quickly and make your screen blur. Not the awful nausea wobbly shit though
Diseases sound decent on paper, until you realise nobody actually likes dying from sickness when, spoiler alert-
animals have very little way to actually treat such illnesses.
You could argue you could seek out medicinal plants, but there would eventually come a point where a demmand for these herbs would be high and thus you're forced to reset because of something you had no control over and now, no way to counter. Plus the concept of seeking out special plants could be given much more intuitive uses, like Affinity boosting or even temporary stat buffs.
could go with good old drink fuck tons of water to speed up getting rid of the disease lol
diseases really arent needed but it'd be sort of neat to have certain dinos who could take advantage of rotten corpses that others would have reason to avoid.
@blazing charm It doesn't need to be a toxic disease or a frequent one
I mean, monster plants are a thing. Or that's what dondi said.
Why not have a single or two diseases.
diseases is kind of like lightning striking dinosaurs it sounds cool/funny when you are saying it but then it happens to your 8 hour growth dinosaur and you cant do much about it
The best way to really implement diseases, in my opinion, is by using diseases as a mechanic to encourage players to make choices accurate to their dinosaur and give different dinosaurs niches. Though yeah, having diseases out right kill your dino imo is a horrible idea, with instead simply having diseases cause various debuffs such as slower stamina regeneration, faster thirst drain, decreased hunger pool, etc, being a better option. In addition, having rotted meat potentially carry diseases that scavenger-niche dinosaurs would be immune to is definitely a interesting concept, since it would give those niches an actual mechanic to benefit them.
Also since high stress is connected to lowered immune systems, it would make sense for diseases to be a punishment for having low affinity for a prolonged period of time, if affinity is implemented that is.
@sturdy ingot body dragging is planned to be implemented, likely with the recode as it was shown a bit in the past few months
ah, awesome!!
it would be cool, since a dead animal being dragged, due to punctures or a missing limb or something, a blood trail would be left in it's wake as the predator drags it off.
I was thinking you mean the blood trail for carrying a baby lmao
for a body would be cool but i was so confused
oh no!! for prey! for dead prey!, though it would also be cool to carry living prey, small prey so that you can 'teach your juvies how to hunt' by letting them chase down a dryo or some kind of injured animal for them. Like, if/when humans are introduced, I could see that being done by rexes or gigas, just take a broken human back to the nest, drop them and let the juvies 'hunt' them lol.
maybe too realistic?
@stuck chasm if you want to play something in a single session that cant last even 2 hours id recommend dryo or just growing over multiple sessions.
Currently, growing a dino is too easy, so we see a lot of apexes when they should be rare. I'm pretty sure once recode hits doung things your dino likes will make it grow faster but for now the only reason we aren't completely and utterly overrun with rexes and gigas and trikes is because of the long grow times
as if we are not overrun by them anyway...
I don't see why not upgrade Apex growth, in my opinion, it way to to easy ._.
I wouldnt say trike is the most feared thing for apexes
When you dont get spoonfed and cant sit around it'll be different
That’s not how it’ll be later, you’ll have to look for the food
I'm not a cocky rex
Plus if their is one trike, their are more horned babies hiding
Aight, regardless, growing an apex wont be easy when you've got to actively search for food
Mhm but I still want it even harder
I suppose i wont be upset with apexes being rarer but longer growth times wont make it harder
Making growth actually harder will make it harder
I give ya a point on that
People will just keep bush sittin and shit no matter how long it takes
that should be adressed
But things like what's planned, offering shorter growth times for playing the game instead of bushsitting, those will do a better job
make growing an apex require more player interaction somehow
would make it harder whilst not just lengthening growth times
Levi thats sort of planned already. People have to move to get shorter growth times and people would likely rather take the shorter growth
So moving around, exploring, looking for food, etc, will make ya grow easier?
I do reckon once scent gets fully implemented bush sitting will become less viable
Yes
If I understood that rightly
It comes with making yourself more vulnerable since youre not hiding
hmm
Even with that being planned, I do want growth time being alittle bit longer
I do hope they add a mechanic where if you're full you grow faster with Deinosuchus. since iirc that's what happends with crocodillians
Yeah i could see longer growth times working with that pushing people to take the shorter route. Just on its own longer growth doesnt make the game any harder
We dont know
Isn't deino take 45 hours to grow into adult?
Thats old information and likely changed
I'm gonna write a suggestion about basking
And its not 45 hours to adult
It can get to adult before that. The 48 hours was getting to the 2.0 legendary deinosuchus
Oh alrighty
But its probably not true anymore, that info was 2 years old
Dondi says a lot of shit and forgets about it immediately after
Mhm
aight, made a suggestion abt basking
the spino should also have basking cause.....the sail
Huh?
the sail is for big dick energy reasons
@brittle merlin juvis are planned to be made into something actually fun
will be able to keep up with adults for exemple
and will we not spawn on beaches in the middle of knowhere?
i know that, but they gave very little info on what thay intales... which is what my suggestion is for
that*
like the learning mechanic
thats fair
i personally really like the idea of in the beginning u can only tell the shape of the footprint, but as you see the dinos that produce the footprints you eventually gain the ability to smell which specific dino created said footprint
@wintry cipher
I feel like playing for 6 hours straight shouldn't be considered easy.
Some of us have lives. Thanks for the suggestion tho.
It is. Because that 6 hours isn't actually impacting how difficult it is to get to apex or adult dryo. If someone knows to keep quiet and to listen, they'll get adult every time no risk regardless of what they are or how long it takes; and it doesn't take skill to do that. If you want to be an adult Apex I'd reccomend a sandbox server as well if you don't like growth at least until the remake hits. But that's the only real coping mechanisms for a good long while yet.
@harsh rose Use this channel for any comments.
I think they should make the isle on console
After seeing @ Ultimate Fluff #CherryTrain 🍒🚆's suggestion, I went into Paint3D and made a few slight alterations to the spino in the preview video. I moved the nostril up a bit more as well as the crest and tried to put and end to the whole double-face meme that spino has had by smoothing out a part above the tooth in the middle. I didn't lengthen the snout or increase the crest size. This, to me, looks perfect. Thoughts?
Suggestion: npc #1. MEGAPIRAHNA 🐟🐟-
I honestly think megapirahna would be a good fish species to put in the isle. So basically I just imagined it being a scavenger "compsognathus" of the swamps, lakes, rivers of the island ...mainly feasting on dead corpses that happen to be in the water but also being prey to animals like spino, sucho, maybe even juv/adult deinosuchus....now im not sure of this other idea but i also thought maybe make them a little aggressive towards smaller creatures that are bleeding that may have a wound and stay in the waters too long...but fearing the larger dinosaurs...not sure if this would mess up gameplay...I also added a pic of their size compared to other dinosaurs and their skulls....also here's a vid I linked of pirahna's feasting : https://youtu.be/JQIo9r8ZcjM
You'll be amazed at how voracious these red-bellied piranhas become when a mackerel is lowered into their tank. At first they seem timid. But after the first piranha goes in for a bite, the rest of the school attacks in a full force feeding frenzy. Watch as this fish is strip...
Any opinions , ideas, critique ^
i think it would work well as the water clean up crews, that is only spawning around bodies, scattering when a bigger predator comes to claim the body
Yeah that's pretty much how I imagined it tbh..i think it would be a decent sized meal for any of the semi aquatic dinosaurs or deino..not sure if megapirahna would be better as a passive scavenger or a little aggressive towards other things. 🐟
Huh surprising amount of people want males to have their detail colour at all ages. I didn't expect that.
Currently only adults and subs have male detail colours.
thats because the want to be eaten sooner rather than later
better to die as a young beauty than as a old beauty
@zinc fern. That is a fantastic idea! Do you mind if I include a detailed concept for that in my revised second version of Diseases and Parasites?
I don’t mind at all <33
Thank you :)
how was my idea?
Do you mind if I add something to it?
@little tendon
sure
@orchid light That was a mod, nothing more
oh ok...
I dunno why someone put a gun under my suggestion
Just tag me and say why you dislike it, maybe we could converse and change it
@barren zephyr except maybe the people seriously want Beezle in game and banning them for wanting an animal in the game is retarded
They already said any suggestion about adding this or that dino will be removed anyway so that was unnecessary anyway
Nix one anyway
@barren zephyr Careful with what you post. You're lucky I show mercy otherwise another mod would've happily given you a second Strike. Post something more constructive next time and something you'd like to see in the game, not in this Discord.
why would you need emotes if you can just type in a group chat? if you are solo then it doesnt matter since there is no one around to see you use them
as I've said, for immersion and roleplay. just like how in fps games you can have emotes for "hold back" or "i'm hurt" to communicate with the team, I guess?
plus as I recall, back in 2016 the devs said "more emotes other than the calls wheel are planned", so I figured it would be a good tip
I dont think they care much about roleplay
I do not know what they care about.
Well the official servers are how the game is meant to be played and there's like, no rp whatsoever unless you count the utahs who sit at docks. Private servers can mod in whatever animations or calls they want when the dev kit is back for their roleplay endeavors
Wait let me correct that
That's how the game is intended to be played
And private servers can do whatever they want so they make their own version of how the game is played
really? please tell me how >_<
@tawny kettle Hold the walk button, continue to hold while activating the steam overlay (Default should be Shift + Tab), turn off overlay while still holding the walk key before turning Overplay back on, then letting go of the walk key and turning off the overlay again.
I have scleroderma and it's killing me to hold W for so long
alright, I'll try that. thanks so much
No problem.
@tawny kettle Also in regards to that Sauropod suggestion, Puertasaurus won't be a thing anymore, since Brachiosaurus is replacing it, and I don't think the posture is gonna change since brachi is meant to closely resemble the one from Jurassic Park.
Scientific Accuracy isn't entirely the biggest priority, plus I don't even think Brachi is supposed to be playable, so the whole eating thing isn't that big of a deal.
Even then demi Up right(not vertical tho) neck is accurate for some sauropods, including brachi and cama
@quasi stream To be brutally honest, the introduction of Primal Carnage has been a long, and painful endeavour for everyone, and I can't help but feel that shoehorning more of that into the game's title or logo is just going to create more opposition.
Well, to be honest the title doesn't have to do anything with Primal Carnage
I wasn't referring to it when I put the suggestion
I just liked the idea of a new title. Primal Carnage and The Isle are 2 different games
"Carnage Comes Home"
That is literally, the oldest tie to this god forsaken tie-in. That slogan is from 2 years ago for gods sake.
2 and a half if you count that time it was accidentaliy said out loud.
I wasn't aware of that
Not to mention.
The end of the trailer, has the Primal Rex roar
Please don't tell me you thought that roar was something else-
No bro, I know the ties with Primal Carnage, I was just saying the title would be cool, not the story behind it
There's alot of people, like myself that kinda prefer the Isle as it's own thing, I just feel like changing the title would kinda be a bit "in your face" with the whole PC thing.
Alright, I get what you're saying.
Personally I would find it a shame if Brachiosaurus was AI only
What were some of the reasons Brachi was gonna be ai?
If the reasons were it being too slow that’s not really a thing
Sauropods could move at a decent pace
15 kp/h for walking and 20-30 at full speed
its huge, clipping through everything or getting stuck on everything, nigh unkillable and able to do some serious damage
if anything, cama will be the test bed
cama isnt too big, so its just perfect
We’ll have to see
Personally I’d love to play the shit out of Brachiosaurus
They’d be hard to play in survival I reckon
Having it be like a tier 6, so itll take maybe 10-12 hours to grow to full will make it less op
Like a tier above apex
Its only when you get to near adulthood that you become this monstrously powerful creature
thing is, once you are adult, now what? you'd need a fucking hyper to kill that thing
or a dude with a sniper
I mean, its size would restrict it to more open areas
large sauros are pretty much on the level of hypers
And hear me out here, what if you make it beneficial for smaller herbivores to hang around sauropods and thus in the more open areas
thats what cama will be a test for
if they can make it work, as in: its hard to grow and can be hunted (also fun)
then they might move for larger ones
Have the health maybe twice or 1.5 a rexes, super slow, really long growing times, still killable if you got a group, and it would give so much food that it would be a glowing target. Probably itd get killed as a sub since itd still give tons of food and it isnt super buff yet
why would something so big have 2 times a rexes health?
2 times rex health would make it useless
Doesn’t trike have like 1.5 times rex’s health
I dont think it would work. cama is perfect, but anything bigger would be AI
at least for now
Well it's a fine balance between so much health and damage its op and so little that its useless
Actually bringing up hypers, that could very well be a good reason TO implement them, something you can stick around to make sure a hyper spotting you isn’t an instant death sentence
It wouldnt match the size but if you need 2 or 3 rexes to kill it its a good fight
.....hypers already have a purpose tho. Server reset without a reset button.
They will also be very rare
they are biological reset buttons
Like, once in a blue moon rare
You should not have a regular dino in the game with the excuse "oh hypers will hunt it" because then its just another hyper
That’s not what I said, its something that can possibly stand up to them on the herbivore’s side, since iirc herbivores are not getting strains
Imagine brachi being huntable by smaller things just like rexes are huntable by dilos, i know is hard to imagine
Nothing can stand up to a hyper. Not even on the carnivore side.
hypers are not ''carnivore team''
Again; its a biological reset button
Carnivores arent even a team in first place
You're much better off as something small that can hide. As carni and herbi
If you are so afraid of the one hyper that will show up once in 3 months
and, if we are honest, in a hyper and brachi fight, if the brachi is balanced to not be unkillable, it will be anihilated, if it can stand up againt a hyper, its absolutely broken
Cama will serve its role well enough as playable sauropod. The only diff between it and brachi gameplay wise would just be the pain in the ass that is its camera position prob.
Honestly my worry about hypers isn't really the hyper itself. I worry that even if they are near impossible to get, everyone will still play carni as they want to be one. Making the map pure carnis and very few herbis.
It's bad enough at the moment, without giving an extra incentive to go carni.
Thats a fair argument now
Yeah
solution, give herbis elders that are easier to get
but not nearly as strong as hypers
make carnis live difficult, only the best survive
If herbs get elders so should carnivores tbh.
Well. Do herbis need elders if carni life will be difficult already?
Strains are overrated as an end-game goal.
It's why i'm meh on the elders idea.
What’s gonna be the way to get magna strains btw? Is it just the same as hypo but slightly easier?
Herbs get elders, allo cerato sucho and dilo are left without strains nor elders gg
We know nothing about magnas atm.
I just want hunts to be hard. I like difficulty 
I can see some Dino's growing slightly bigger with age to show "oh shit this one survived a long time" like 1.2 but no further
Superadult carnivores and herbivore would imo be more interesting than hypos and such
Zubu. Play Utah in a legit fashion without assriding like I do. Shit takes hours to kill
it hurts
I've wondered about the idea of hybrid herbis.
But not sure how popular that idea is.
Super adult/ Elder are just the new full grown
Inb4 ankyloceratops
Makes no sense that rex wouldn't get elder too.
True. If the game is difficult enough what if full adult becomes a big deal?
RN it isnt
Tapwing has some amazing JP hybrid dinos as concepts.
Tapwing’s art just rocks
If I were to pick one hyper I would love having from tapwing’s collection it would be the hyper anky
That thing is gorgeous
Having some complex set of goals/objects which then allows two apex herbis to mix would be an interesting strain alternative.
Aka the ankyloceratops
Personally, I’d dislike that
Wouldn't be nearly as op as strains, but would off up an interesting incentive to play herbis too.
I know a lot of people hate the idea.
Hyper herbs would kill just herbis due to starvation oof
I mean, personally I would make hunting almost 100% focussed on grappling, latching on, pouncing and the like
And all the new Dino's are herbs besides one i thought
But herbis arn't getting strains.
Elders just becomes the new adult, and makes no sense why strain dinos can't grow to elder too.
Hybrids is just another potential idea.
....unless you hit it at the right angle
Latching onto stego’s side puts you in range of its tail
Exactly
Herbs will have stuff to counter. Thats a given
So if trike turns its head to look at your friend, you might get an opportunity to grab its neck
just let me maul maias for a bit of payback with pounce and we good
It's not countering the carnis/strains which is the issue. It's that everyone and their mother will leap to play carni just for the tiny chance they will reach hyper.
Leaving like 5 people on herbi and 70 people on carni.
What if herbs get a lot of immunities vs things like poisons and other such things?
Hmm
And carnis have to eat a certain herbi to get a temp buff against that
I would honestly have herbis just have baseline higher stats than carnivores
No, no better stats for any faction just because "lets give x faction better stats"
That isnt a reason to play herb
Fair point
Herbs could be made easier to play as in general. Combat wise
Galli for example focuses on running and escaping very well
Or, or, herbis just survive easier as their food is everywhere and dont run away
@peak wedge Maybe they could have one eye open when they sleep as some animals do
Trike is focused on punishing close combat
I'd rather herbi stats were not better than carnis, as that just encourages toxic KoS deathherds.
^ maia
Just balance animals ignoring their diet
Imo herbis should be able to defend themselves, but not be able to use those abilities to hunt shit down.
Aka the reason I want para/maia to have nerfed front attacks and have a back kick instead.
You want to encourage interaction with other Dino's for beneficial purposes. That makes gameplay interesting
Means they can flee while fighting, but can't hit forward very hard.
Yes
Trike is fine with a forward attack just cause it's so slow. If a trike runs you down it's 100% your own fault.
I like the idea of herbis being either stronger but slower than carnis (aka trike and stego) while others are weaker but faster than carnis (aka galli)
Carnis being in the middle
Stego is still controversial. Some people want it mid tier matching allo, some people want it full large tier and matching trike.
It will probably be large tier with a vulnerable head.
So if Allo grapples that
The stego is done
Stego mid tier would just be a walking borger for any apex which sees it.
Mhm
I also think the hybrids could work as we all know how much the devs love JP, and hybrid herbis are part of the JP lore.
I'm very tentative an that one as yes while they love JP i don't think that would be a good idea for this game mostly due to copyright and other things. I enjoy seeing the more unique stuff the devs offer
I'm just looking for something (anything really) which could offer an alternate long term alternate goal.
One that could draw as many people as the potential to play as a massive rex kaiju and wipe the entire map like hypers are.
Official servers are already 50% rex. Giving people more incentive to play it isn't going to help things.
Even a 1% chance to get to this from adult rex is going to make people flock to it.
@burnt obsidian Yeah, good idea
@haughty cliff I do believe it was mentioned that the footstep sounds are being revised.
That would be sweet, I hope so thanks!
If anything you could take the recent preview as some indication, since the footsteps weren't deafingly loud.
But, time will tell I suppose.
@valid zephyr I agree with your stance on herbivores. Although they shouldn't be able to hunt down other dinosaurs, they also shouldn't be walking meat snacks. Making them either fast with rear attacks or slow with frontal attacks makes sense. And yeah, if Stego is made a slow mid tier it will literally be an easy meal for apex carnivores because it won't be able to run away or fight back.
Not to mention that most servers have large amounts of carnivore players, predominately because of the lackluster herbivore gameplay. Herbivores are usually fun because of herds, but when there aren't other herbivores around to herd with it becomes sort of meaningless gameplay.
@fathom harness not to mention many herbivores are worthless when they are solo
I mean 1v1 most herbis are fine stat wise at the moment.
Trouble is it's always 1 herbi vs an entire pack of carnis.
Cause no one plays them.
exept trike vs rex 1v1 
If the rex doesn't get bb on the first bite the trike can win. Stomp on the first attack, walk turn around, and assride it spamming gore.
If it gets bb first bite then it's won.
sadly it seems that if the rex just stays still and bites it nonstop the trike dies
I've tested it, was hella sad. I had just killed a rex that tried hit and run on death match
Hopefully with locational, trike will have an advantage in a pure facetank.
yeah, nothing should be able to go face tank with a trike and win
cama maybe.
Brachi too
cama is a god that is not to be even questioned
I have killed camas as a rex, ez.
rex probably should focus on things it can kill in under 30 seconds at most, at least in my opinion. Giga would be the bastard that does long and slow hunts, fucking up larger prey, like cama
"Just a channel where we can talk" sooo offtopic?
@jolly finch Inglês apenas, e adiciona substância nessa suggestão, um porque, digamos assim.
Blz
@lone kite what do you mean?
quite sure there's already resting 3 call animations
hi all, any suggestions on cheap USB PC Wired Controller
wrong channel to ask about that
what channel would you recommend
#401470471750811669 . This channel is for discussing suggestions
@lone kite considering that it will be a very long time until elders will even be considered to be implemented you know with the recode and everything, it's probably something that would be decided on :D
@night mountain I expanded on your suggestion.
@supple pivot Here for discussing suggestions, and yes, it is, and I am shamelessly stealing inspiring myself on it
Dondi
@high hemlock it says there that paralyzis is permanent
ohh
The paralysis idea is cool, but there's no incentive to keep playing if you're the one paralyzed. Everyone would just hit respawn and the troodon loses the advantages from having a paralyzed prey item. Might be better with a chance that they'll recover from it, so some players will actually stay in the hopes that they'll be able to keep their dino.
well, yeah, the idea is that you are effectively dead. you could stay for the ''oh god wtf'' factor, but in reality its over, you can stay just because.
maybe they could recover, but the idea is that paralizing a target is hard and time consuming, taking longer than simply killing it, so allowing it to just get up and walk away kind of defeats the purpose
idk, I see the point
i'd just altf4 if there's no way to recover tbh
had enough of sitting doing nothing in this game, i agree w sparrow
Or you respawn? Cuz you lost the fight and "died"
It's there for flair. Cuz Jurassic park troodon is cool
Also, the ideia is that the target isnt dead, the eggs would die If the body rotted
I don't see how waiting for nothing could be fun. Paralysis seems like such an unfun idea
besides, I don't think anyone will be fazed by watching your dinosaur be eaten. We already hear or sometimes see our characters be eaten once we've been hunted
it could be fun for Youtubers to stream though
but I'm talking about the waiting time. If you have no choice but to lie down and wait for death... then might as well just leave the game
best if you can heal paralysis after a minute
What about the eggs tho?
Paralysis is death with a twist
You can respawn, the body stays as AI
sure then...
I just think poison should be something that temporary disables the victim for a short period of time
Like hinder vision, or make you bleed longer
Thats already there. It makes you weaker, easier to kill
Also added that If you respawn the body becomes AI
Ah @copper gorge, i think i understood what you where saying, changed It so sitting down stops spread of venom
Completely forgot about that, my bad
@stiff nova the Papo Acro does not have good proportions
But that being said, current Acro doesn’t look too great as well
Could gladly see some changes to him, iirc Jake expressed interest in working on him?
ai body after respawning makes it much better imo. that way the player can leave but the troodon family still gets the benefits of having a "live" host there, until it dies for other reasons
Ohh I get the concept now, so basically for example, if im a Diablo and I get bit by a pack of troodons, and depending where i got bit i experience the symptoms that was listed, now if it gets worse and I don't sit down, then the paralysis state takes over eventually then im basically just on the ground, but still have the ability to see whats happening to sum certain extent (in which any damage could be done to my body as Im in this stage..so basically dying)...then when I'm tired of watching just respawn..meanwhile there making my body into a nest. (Im here for it 🙌)
👍
Bronto tail attack should slap small and lower mid tiers into orbit and flay skin off large tiers like a whip too
lol that'd a funny execute. If T-Rex can swallow things whole, sauropods should be able to launch smols like projectiles with their tails haha.
Oh! I didn't bring this up in my suggestion but I was pretty happy to see collision working so well on tails as shown in Dondi's corpse dragging tests with the Utahs. I can't find the clip, but at one point the Utah's tail bends to avoid clipping into the slope.
Clipping should be less of an issue now for longer dinosaurs. 
is brontosaurus an actual dinosaur now? in 2015 some guys made a proposal that it is, cant find anything confirming it was accepted as a separate species
You mean besides the original paper establishing it as a separate genus? Not exactly, but there has not been any rebuttals stating it isn't either. As far as I know it's valid and most prominent paleo-figures (Mark Witton, Mike Taylor, Darren Naish, etc...) seem to accept it. There's even a whole paleo-meme named after it called Bronto Smash which sprung up a short time after it was announced.
https://svpow.files.wordpress.com/2015/10/apatosaurinae_sp_scene.jpg
Though I care less about the name than the dinosaur itself. Given Troodon, I don't think name validity matter much to the team anyway. Only reason I'm not suggesting Apato instead is because it tends to be bigger than Bronto, which would be harder to balance.
@ashen elm pretty sure the brontosaurus was a mash up of other dinosaur bones, not its own species, but correct me if I'm wrong
@plush meadow It had mistakenly had Cama's head for awhile, since they did not have the skull, but was renamed Apatosaurus for different reasons.
It was re-established as it's own genus about five years ago though. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-brontosaurus-is-back1/
No problem paleontology changes a lot and unless you are super on top of it, it can be hard to keep up with.
a study published in 2015 found A. excelsus, formerly known as Brontosaurus to be distinct enough from other species of apatosaurus to be labeled its own genus. thus Brontosaurus excelsus was revived as valid
@opal vigil hadros are fully terrestrial as far as i know.
Allos are confirmed to get a grapple
Utahs will get a pounce and probably use their claw
@last heath cheers, yeah not aquatic but like most dinos of today with duck bills...eating plants that grow near or in water. They have always being depicted as such.
@tulip dock dondi said in his latest stream that multiple animals wouldnt be able to drag the same corpse at the same time
- due to server constraints, not cuz 'i dont wanna!'
@icy tangle joke suggestions arent allowed if you weren't aware. But if thats not a joke, then fuckin gross
It's not a joke, I meant it. And what?! Dinos did poop and fart. So why not? Don't @ Me. @indigo sun
It's gross and would make this game a joke and no one would take it seriously. There's no actual reason to add it.
Do you poop and fart ?
No i'm clearly a robot with no biological function
I knew it. No human bein would say it will be gross.
@icy tangle give a reason to waste time and money to add that
mechanics
interactions
Again though, no one would take this game seriously if they added that and I would hate to make poor Richard do that.
Don't make richard's life hell

This game isnt suppose to be as real as it gets ? No more reason.
What?
I'm sorry could you explain your first sentence a bit i didnt quite understand what you meant
Dondi said they have enough money now. So no waste if it is to be a real thing
but why?!
Because it's real ?
It'd be a waste for it to be done when money could go towards other things
This game isnt going for realism woohoo no point in that then
fun>realism
We don't need to add stuff like that for fart fetishists to get off to
I'd honestly quit if The isle adds that to be funny, even if its realistic.
Please stop with the shit suggestions oh my god
@azure laurel shitting would only help predators track you more. It's easier to smell and track shit than the remnants of skin and oils from a footprint. Also please get your fuckin scat fetish out of here, this is a game that wants to be taken seriously. Literally no one would take that seriously if they added it.
Mhm
Even full realism games like saurian dont plan on having shit stop this
Honestly
Well yes its easier to smell so it can be used as distraction
It wouldnt be a distraction

How do you know
It would be "oh something was here and look there's footprints leading to it!"
People are smart enough to use it to their advantage
The only distraction would be people actually throwing up on their keyboards
It's useless
I mean if the other guy is puking on his keyboard, its a win for you
You still got rid of them
Plus the scent will be orbs
Someone puking is not a valid reason to waste time on shit, the animations and modelling for shitting, or anything else
We seriously need a rule against shit and mating suggestions
I thought there was a rule at some point
"Anything that can be very obviously used for fetishists to get off, such as scat, mating animations, and piss, are not allowed to be suggested"
I want that as a rule
I legitimately want a poop button for flying species
I really need this to be a fuckinrule
You are you, doesnt count
Tentacle is the exception
But wouldnt that block off useful suggestions that could be connected to fetishes then?
Theres fetish for everything
please delete this suggestion
The rule should be more specific:" shit, pee and mating suggestions not allowed"
Theres 3 things that should never be suggestions
Piss, shit, and fucking
Those things should be completelt off limits
I dont give a fuck about anything else
We dont need poop, we dont need farting, and we dont need mating animations. Its a waste of money and would do nothing helpful ingame other than be funny and ""Realistic""
Luckily this game is in no way trying to be realistic but if people who jack off to a dino shitting really want that, they can mod it in themselves and not waste the devs' time
Imagine tall riding an Rex, and he farts at your face.. 😄
You make me want to throw myself out of my window
Or the rex could just turn around and we wont have to have farting
No dont do it! Who is gonna talk on this channel anymore ?
You do realise these are ironic suggestions right?
It doesnt seem like they are
And even if It was ironic is not needed
Better not be ironic
You guys are bad with irony
The funniest part is we’re actually gonna get this stuff once devkit is out
these two are ironic lmfao
I would like to see Nines face when it does come out.
Yeah but some ppl always dive in the trolls
we all just ignored the stego guy in the middle
Idk you never know in this community lmao
If theyre suggested and they arent serious suggestions then theyre breaking the rules
I had a serious rock suggestion that was taken down but these "ironic" suggestions get to stay up?
Are you an admin right now Nines ? To judge who is breaking rules who is not ? Please stay at your place!
If they arent ironic they are gross
If they are ironic they are just shitposting in a serious channel
True gab
''shitposting''
hehe
Lmao
are mods asleep today?
So why even allow them?
Poops not inherently a bad thing but we don’t need it like hd and lovingly animated
They have fun this way
Legit want a poop button for pela and the pterosaurs
tentacle, no. youll die again
Hence my suggestion for a rule against these types of suggestions
If its just ironic then it should be deleted. Joke suggestions arent allowed iirc
They can have their fun somewhere else not in the fucking suggestion channel
They can go jack off to shit in some other game
But like why make rule against legitimate suggestions
thats just censoring the community

oh no! The horror of censoring that
Cus they’re shit suggestions adding nothing useful
shit suggestions
Because its disgusting, and you can get your poop and farting for your dinos with mods instead of wasting developer time
Hehe
But how do you know shit wont be useful
am sure people would find a way to use it to their advantage
ok, I guess we aint going anywhere. wake up mods and lets move on
Explain how it will be useful
I Thought there was a cockroach on my phone when i looked at ur pfp nines
like any suggestions nowadays add anything 
Hey man you can ask dondi himself to add shit and see what he says about it
It wouldn’t be awful from a tracking perspective to tell you what hangs out there
Wouldnt reccomend it though
Can you come up with a use for it?
''I get it, you want shit, piss and fucking''
-Dondi, some other time
If is a suggestion about something devs are against to add they dont need to exist, like i could suggest to add Jedis to the game but devs would yeet that suggestion because they know they dont want it
Explain how shit will be a usefull mechanic
So know u become dondi's best friend ? Nines ?
I never said i was
U know so much
I just said you could ask him but i didnt reccomend doing so
Never said i knew anything
Atleast nines didn’t suggest farting
Can this be dropped? Ain't getting anywhere
we still forgot about the poor stego guy 
Yeah no problem, i just suggested to make things real.
Doesnt need to be real though
This game isnt trying to be real
In fact that's why suggestions for "realism" have a lower chance of being added
This is not a fucking documentary, and not even saurian the hyper realistic Dino Game has shit
I just want to see someone give me a reason why shit or farts could possibly be a useful mechanic
Its a science fiction dinosaur horror game
Tracking
Thats the thing Aleey, theres no actual reason
Wait, why isn’t farting in cs go? It’s something humans do so it should definitely be added!
Footprints and other things do just fine
But they said it would be optional, so why would you ever do it if its making it easier to track you?
The only Game with shit i know is fucking insaniquarium and in that Game It was useful because shit was literally money 
Saurian has cloacas in their models and mating is planned
To be fair, planet zoo has poop animations and it’s not weird
Not that we need it
Planet zoo is also about cleaning and maintaining animal enclosures and stuff
Planet zoo shit has a purpose and also the shit isnt close to the camera
Rex eats bad food
Rex gets explosive diarrhea
Rex uses explosive diarrhea against assriding utahs
You guys are debating so much over a troll in a unironic way, it's feeding at a whole new level
Humans make me want to swallow a whole bottle of excedrin
Mm
How is it exactly troll tho Gab?
Y’all need to stay away from inappropriate suggestions. Period. Don’t let me see it again.
@tulip dock
I read your suggestion of 2 carnivores dragging on the same body for contesting it
As Dondi said, making 2 or more dinosaurs drag one body will be VERY difficult to make and it will cause a lot of lag.
The server would go bananas
That was 1.
And 2. Dinosaurs are not puppies. When they contest, they either harm the other to the point where it can't hunt anymore or even kill the opponent. That would give him more food plus the body it contested
but the gore... :c
@thorny lynx I don't think either the Dilo or Troodon were actually venomous
this game isn't realistic
@thorny lynx Pretty sure the Dilo's venom delivery as it is now is based on lizard bites such as Komodo Dragons or Gila Monsters. i.e. the venomous compounds come from modified saliva glands rather than a large venom gland like a pit viper. So the dilo model is probably fine as is.
True.
what about troodons
However, do you believe venom should be a depleted resource for dinosaurs or no? I believe so.
yeh
venom CAN be used for griefing, but if it's depletable then the problems just gone
A single troodon should not be able to sit there and stack on enough venom to topple down a rex. A small creature simply cannot produce that much venom.
I mean smaller creatures with concentrated venom, yeah, but
The larger the creature with venom, the slower the toxin kills
Rule of thumb.
Botulinum toxin, wandering spider, snek...
maybe make troodon have to chew the venom into its target like some snakes,
as in only really affects if you're latched on
Hm, I rather do not care about the delivery method, but more of whether the venom is depletable.
Troodon literally weighs around 50kg. It has no business even being around a t rex.
Or anything larger than a ton. It's simply too much for a pack of troodons to eat.
It annoys me there are people here that thing a creature that weighs less than 200 pounds should be able to kill a t rex. It's just not possible.
If a rex is wounded and sick and dying, yeah. A healthy one, no.
Larger dinosaurs should be more resistant to venom, period.
I agree
but where do you put the cap
lets say 50 KG
a dryo is like 200
would that be ok?
where do you put the cap for venom effectiveness
Anything over a ton should only have minimal effects
From one bite
Like "fuck I feel kinda like shit" but not "well time to lay down and die"
A troodon bites a t rex, rex probably won't even feel it.
hmm
what about this
venom doesn't really affect movement
it affects control
fucking with player control over the dinosaur would be something that would make venom feel more realistic
I thought something like sluggish controls
Well, Troodon venom slows you down, since they hunt fast and small creatures
kinda like artificial sticky keys
Dilo venom reduces natural bleed resistance, I believe.
You mean anticoagulant, which prevents clotting.
Antiseptic means it doesn't allow bacteria to seep into the wound
Venom sometimes kills by coagulating the blood and forming blood clots
Or it just disrupts the heart rhythm
depends which type you want, the coagulating venom would work with slowing down, destroying muscle fibers would make controlling your dinosaur harder
Or travels to the brain and inhibits neuron receptors from firing.
Paralysis isn't fun.
Coagulating venom would basically drop you dead from a heart attack.
A paralyzing venom would be more practical for smaller and faster creatures, as sneks do for rats. One bite and the rat is down within a few seconds.
what if they make troodon like allo sized?
that would be a small brain moment
Dondi said dinosaurs would be tbeir accurate sizes.
... it is.
oh
its nonem dubium
ye
ye
I mean, I can see that
I mean, that could be a interesting way to differentiate dilo and troodon
things like wolves eat berries and roots from time to time
Galli should be omnivorous in a way thst it eats very small insects and lizards and frogs
I mean, it is a big paleomeme
I mean, it has a high metabolism that demands food all the time.
It probably did peck at bugs and lizards at times.
I think a few ideas to differentiate them would be to have Troodons venom have a different effect.
honestly, I'm not sure this thing will be able to compete with dilo and the like at all
Probably be a carnivorous equivalent of a dryo
Troodon shmol
dryo aint that small
like they can just make it larger
Smol, but speedy and annoying with fast grow
troodon isn't really a valid genus so they don't have to stick to any specific size
I imagine they'll make it similar to the JP troodon
Achillpbator looks badass
Actually like it.
I would take this over Utah any day.
To be fair dinosaurs wouldn’t actually need a venom meter since they don’t inject in one payload like a viper or something does
I mean cherrytrain
But there has to be a limit for how many times a bite can deliver venom
Utah is a really interesting animal
I mean, accurate utahraptor is awesome
Speroraptor is just a meme now.
Getting eaten usually stops venom output lol
raptor bear
Utah’s like a wannabe allosaur isle Utah has almost nothing in common with it

