#general-feedback-discussion

1 messages · Page 502 of 1

brittle bough
#

i used to prefer no alt to alt, but after playing in dm for a while ive come to appreciate the presence of alt turn on survival dinosaurs much more, and favor the combat more since it makes combat more involved than "run in a circle or brake check and nothing else"

umbral prairie
#

defending is more difficult without alt turn, except it is so difficult it becomes incredibly unbalanced unless you introduce more rules

barren zephyr
#

the option to remove alt turn from servers is gay and is getting removed soon

random knoll
#

without alt turn anyone can kill anyhting thing by just staying on its butty

#

so you like ass ridisng?

barren zephyr
#

dinosaurs walking backwards looks dumb

random knoll
#

ass ridding is the easiest thing in the game

#

is that skill?

mossy sapphire
#

Who is talking about ass riding

random knoll
#

you are

brittle bough
#

thats all no alt fighting is

umbral prairie
#

alt turn is realistic though, not the speed which some dinos do it with but turning on the spot is probably more realistic than walking back

dim ore
#

Slate, i know combat is getting reworked, it needs to be and i am all for it, hopefully it gets rid of alt turn while they are at it, as alt turn is unrealistic and looks stupid to see rexes swiveling around on the spot like a death tornado.. i dont like alt turn, nor to i like that people can currently butt ride, a solution needs to be made, and hopefully the devs are coming up with one, i simply suggested backing up as one option to help in a future that will most likely see alt turn removed entirely.

random knoll
#

in no alt turn servers thats all you do

#

ass ride

#

and you can kill bassicly anyhting

mossy sapphire
#

I nevver mentioned ass riding

random knoll
#

but without alt tunr tahst what happens

brittle bough
#

smoothie.. what is no alt fighting to you?

umbral prairie
#

alt turn is not unrealistic dapper

indigo sun
#

"looks stupid" so is your issue also with the lack of animations that is actually going to get fixed?

barren zephyr
#

"no alt" is so fucking cringe omg

umbral prairie
#

large animals turning on the spot is more realistic than large animals walking backwards

#

again, some dinos do it too fast

barren zephyr
#

enjoy having that removed >:)

umbral prairie
#

but the idea behind the mechanic is not unrealistic

dim ore
#

alt turn is very unrealistic, the solution is simply to give all creatures a very tight turn radius or give the utah a wider one.. alt turn is ridiculous to imagine any creature performing such a feat.

brittle bough
#

how is alt turn unrealistic. elaborate.

indigo sun
#

my guy....

umbral prairie
#

what is unrealistic about an animal turning in place

#

explain to me

#

why a rex would not be able to turn in place, but walk back

indigo sun
#

please stand up, then turn around without walking in a giant circle. you'll find it's very easy

brittle bough
random knoll
#

dont say that

#

give us a repsone

brittle bough
#

we are calm, stop derailing.

dim ore
#

name one creature of a comparable size to a rex that can stand on one leg and perform a ballerina dance like alt turn is.

random knoll
#

give a reason

umbral prairie
#

nobody is angry here

#

stop with ballerina

indigo sun
#

so your issue is the lack of animations, which isnt actually a reason and it getting fixed

brittle bough
#

@dim ore dont bring the animations into it. mechanics, not aesthetics. weve already said the animations are unfinished and will be fixed.

umbral prairie
#

that is the worst argument to bring against alt turn

brittle bough
#

elaborate on how the mechanic is unrealistic.

umbral prairie
#

because that has nothing to do with the mechanic

#

but only with the animation

barren zephyr
#

think about this.
u want the devs to spend time making animations for walking backwards and tail attacks even tho they could give alt turn an animation

random knoll
#

we need reasons not just "calm down" or "it dosent look nice"

barren zephyr
#

in pretty sure theropods cant walk backwards

dim ore
#

Slate if you had read my earlier post you would see that i already acknowledged the fact that the devs are working on it, i already agreed that it is a good thing they are doing, and i know its still unfinished, my suggestion is just a suggestion.

umbral prairie
#

I have never seen a bird walk backwards, but I have seen birds turn in place (ok, most birds just hop and turn but they still turn in place)

brittle bough
#

dapper, we asked you to elaborate on why the mechanic is unrealistic. you said "ballerina turn looks stupid."

umbral prairie
#

which has nothing to do with the mechanic itself

brittle bough
dim ore
#

alt turn is turning on the spot without actually having any turn radius, its unatural in the extream, very few creatures can do it like alt turn does.

random knoll
#

no

#

give a real reason

umbral prairie
#

it is not unnatural

random knoll
#

not " it looks stupid"

umbral prairie
#

it just lacks an animation

#

turning on the spot is not unnatural

dim ore
#

you show me a large creature that can alt turn in nature, you will have a hard time finding one

barren zephyr
#

the thought of 9 ton rex doing is funny @brittle bough

umbral prairie
#

look at elephants

indigo sun
#

wasnt there a video of an elephant doing that posted like two minutes ago in here?

random knoll
#

we did

#

scroll up

umbral prairie
#

do they need a turn radius?

lament thorn
#

Honestly the only animal that I know that can't irl alt turn is a kangaroo?

umbral prairie
#

no they don't

#

or snakes

mossy sapphire
#

Isnt this a dinosaur game eyes

lament thorn
#

Snakes aren't even real creatures

jovial skiff
#

wat

brittle bough
#

i literally just linked an elephant turning in place dude

indigo sun
#

i'm sorry do you got a time machine where you can get us footage of dinosaurs? nah. all we got is the current large animals

brittle bough
umbral prairie
#

'show me a big animal' shows big animal 'that's not a dinosaur though'

lament thorn
#

You know your point can be made against you?

brittle bough
#

i can look for an emu or something i guess lmao

mossy sapphire
#

Show me a real dinosaur alt turning to prove me wrong

lament thorn
#

We don't have a time machine so we can literally do what we want

random knoll
#

wat

mossy sapphire
jovial skiff
#

alt turn was made to counter ass riding

random knoll
#

there are no dinosaurs left what do you want us to do? go back in time and take a video

jovial skiff
#

doesn't matter if its realistic or not

#

@random knoll Show him a bird lol

barren zephyr
#

it's okay i will use my time machine to go back in time to harass a tyrannosaurus to force it to move in place

lament thorn
#

This game isn't even realistic so as long as a mechanic is plausible why does it matter?

random knoll
#

i feel pain

dim ore
#

the elephant shown is not doing what alt turn enables players to do, the elephant is in fact simply using his natural turn radius, this would be an acceptable thing in game as his hind legs remain fairly stationary and he pivots around in a circle. alt turn however has the creatures spinning at a remarkable speed often on one leg .

umbral prairie
#

that is not a turn radius

#

it is not walking forward

random knoll
#

go find a video of a Elpahnt doing a full on turn

umbral prairie
#

it turns

jovial skiff
#

U do notice alt turn animation is not complete right guys so it doesn't look realistic...

umbral prairie
#

on the spot

#

yes, it doesn't float like TI dinos do

#

but it still turns in place

brittle bough
#

@dim ore i swear to god if you bring up the animations one more time.

#

make a point against alt turn WITHOUT mentioning the ballerina part.

jovial skiff
#

guys

#

think of it

#

a utah

indigo sun
#

still your main argument remains it doesnt look nice, and we've stated MULTIPLE TIMES that it wont always be spinning

jovial skiff
#

up a trikes ass for 20 minutes

indigo sun
#

christ on a bike cycling to mass on a friday you still have a lack of argument here

viral creek
#

Actual animations for alt turn are planned, so your arguement is out the window.

dim ore
#

@jovial skiff indeed i agree stego, this is mostly my point, however they are attacking me rather extremely now...and taking my suggestion far beyond a decent conversation.

brittle bough
#

you can make a point that maybe they turn too fast for what they are, but animations may change that.

#

dapper.

viral creek
#

Nobody's attacking you

umbral prairie
#

who is attacking here

viral creek
#

They are explaining to you

brittle bough
#

literally all we have asked for is your reason for why alt turn is unrealistic other than the animations, and you have exclusively replied with "the turning on one foot is dumb." literally all we want is a mechanical reason for why its bad.

valid zephyr
#

How many times do we have to explain alt turn simply lacks animations.

dim ore
#

@brittle bough the ballerina part is the point..it doesnt look good at all right now, and i dont honestly believe the devs are planning on keeping it in the long run.

viral creek
#

🤦

random knoll
#

bruh

north hemlock
brittle bough
#

....dapper.
the devs. are going. to give. alt turn. proper animations.

lament thorn
#

Dude

umbral prairie
#

people are getting unfriendly because you just repeat your already proven invalid point

viral creek
#

Alt turn is getting animations.

umbral prairie
#

but nobody is attacking

indigo sun
#

they have stated alt turn will be getting proper animations if you would open your eyes and read peoples' messages for once JESUS

brittle bough
#

so they will actually put their feet on the ground. realistically. to turn.

viral creek
#

If you keep making that statement then people will attack you dondiTroll

umbral prairie
#

wait your point is that because it looks dumb, it should be removed

indigo sun
#

just read dude

umbral prairie
#

I'm out

#

this kinda feels like you want to provoke us

jovial skiff
#

so um

#

TL DR: Alt turn is getting new anims to look better

barren zephyr
#

waste time adding unnecessary shit cause i dont like how a certain feature looks ingame even tho its getting changed to look better in the future...

brittle bough
valid zephyr
#

alt turn will be given the correct animations one day. It will involve shuffling the feet round rather than pivoting on one leg.

viral creek
#

That could be a good reference for the new alt turn anims actually

cyan flame
#

Just look at the cerato for animations, it actually does step, even while alt turning

#

Granted, it's not perfect, but at least the cerato is sort of moving, not just spinning

brittle bough
#

playing cerato
dondiLUL

sacred wyvern
#

alt turn is coming 0w0

brittle bough
#

ive never seen ceratos alt turn actually, ill give it a peep sometime

jovial skiff
#

pivoting feet for alt turn sounds pretty cool tbh

sacred wyvern
#

i wonder what gigas alt turn animation be like 0w0

brittle bough
barren zephyr
#

it will be lightning quick @sacred wyvern

lament thorn
#

So anyone got any other suggestion they want to discuss?

pulsar lake
#

But dinosaurs don't walk like that

brittle bough
#

it was a jest.

pulsar lake
#

They need to do like the austrich not like an human

brittle bough
#

it was. a fucking joke.

pulsar lake
#

Oh ok

north hemlock
mighty girder
#

Imagine complaining about not having an alt turn feature and then continuing to play on servers that have it disabled

brittle bough
#

"if only there was a way to get away from this cliff," cried the lad to the official discord

north hemlock
#

lmao

#

servers with alt turn disabled suck

#

👏

brittle bough
#

i did actually catch staff saying why they were disabled on nublar, its because of rex's bb being op
so maybe once combat is better, that pocket of people wont be so hostile to alt turn

mossy sapphire
#

proof or fake news

brittle bough
#

? proof of what the nublar staff said?

mighty girder
#

I'd rather take my chances with rex bb being op then have a utah eat my ass apart just because I can't turn as quick as it

#

or get stuck because I cant turn around from a cliff or a tree

brittle bough
#

to be fair if you look behind you or straight down you can bite with your ass on rex lmao

umbral prairie
#

that would make sense, but disabling it because of rex makes everything else unbalanced, so I personally would keep it enabled, even if it makes rex stronger

#

but it is at least a reason

#

that is not 'dinos aren't ballerinas'

mighty girder
#

But anyways, point is if you choose to play on a server with alt turn disabled, you really lose your right to complain about not having it because your CHOOSING to not have it. Make the suggestion in that server to turn it back on or play somewhere else

pulsar lake
#

I'm in many server without alt turn and I prefer that when ass riding is not alowedd

north hemlock
#

yea but rules are dumb

brittle bough
#

ive never been on a server with no alt that didnt permit assriding, wonder what thats like

pulsar lake
#

I like rules

#

Clear and simple

north hemlock
#

how are you supposed to fight in a server like that

#

hit and run can be a pain in the ass

#

sometimes

brittle bough
#

i like nublar's contesting rules, thats namely why i play it

lament thorn
#

Rules keep us safe from the crazy people

north hemlock
#

some rules make sense but alot of them dont

pulsar lake
#

I make that. As allo I killed rex on biting them one time, go away and restart the operation.

umbral prairie
#

rules are really the worst solution, a games mechanics should make you do things, not some rules. That is why the rules on officials will go away as soon as possible, they're only there until there are mechanics to replace them

pulsar lake
#

Same with all dinosaurs

north hemlock
#

thats good to know

#

bc rules on official servers made no sense to me

brittle bough
#

yeah, the game's ultimate goal is to not need external rules other than "dont hack/cheat/exploit", but missing or broken mechanics prevent that

umbral prairie
#

imagine rules in other games, a shooter that allows you to choose a super OP weapon but then people report you if you do

#

what kind of game design would that be

north hemlock
#

terrible

#

👊 😔

pulsar lake
#

So we need a system like in JWE for population in your group, new alt turn mechanic, disagrement of your dinosaurs about kos, except youn of your species as carnivore, and a lot of other mechanics

brittle bough
#

still, TI and shooters are quite different; TI has the added issue of somehow enforcing somewhat natural behavior upon a bunch of rowdy kids lmao

north hemlock
#

"disagrement of your dinos about kos"

#

the fuck does that mean

pulsar lake
#

Animals don't kill for nothing

north hemlock
#

lol no

brittle bough
#

i mean, they do

north hemlock
#

kosing is fun

lament thorn
#

I mean some do

brittle bough
#

wolves surplus kill, i know those off the top of my head

mossy sapphire
#

whales kill for fun

brittle bough
#

probably others lol

north hemlock
#

cats kill for fun

#

too

lament thorn
#

Dolphins too

pulsar lake
#

The only animals who kos are cats, orca and human. After other kill young and other of their species because it's concurrence.

lament thorn
#

If you let a pack of wolves into a sheep pen they will kill them all

north hemlock
#

false

pulsar lake
#

A lion won't kill 4 wild beasts

north hemlock
#

if they could they would

brittle bough
#

but yeah, this is a game in the end, not nature; fun is the priority, not realism. all this is pretty irrelevant

north hemlock
#

^

lament thorn
#

Because a lion struggles to kill 4 wilder beast

#

Even a pride would

mossy sapphire
#

If you put a chihuahua in a pin of humans it would kill them all

brittle bough
#

people also tend to go down after a bullet or two but that doesnt stop most shooters lol

pulsar lake
#

They focus on one and will try to kill another one later if they can.

lament thorn
#

But yeh it's a game so realism needs to come after balance

brittle bough
#

fun > balance > realism, basically

north hemlock
#

i just want the game to have fun and not have stupid mechanics/rules

#

be fun*

#

fuc

lament thorn
#

An allo pack shouldn't mascara a herd even if they can or want to simply because they would be screwing themselves over in the long run

mossy sapphire
#

didnt they take out sandbox awhile back think fun > balance >realism ?

brittle bough
#

..wut

mighty girder
#

no?

lament thorn
#

Which is why AI really needs to be changed to stop spoon feeding them

mighty girder
#

sandbox is still there

brittle bough
#

sandbox is.. still readily accessible. whatre you on about?

mossy sapphire
#

I didnt say it was still gone lol

mighty girder
#

they never got rid of it

brittle bough
#

isnt the only mode they removed at any point prog?

pulsar lake
#

After animals can kill another for defend themselves, for eat or eliminated concurence as carnivore or herbivore, not for nothing except intelligent animals.
You won't see a buffalo kill a young lion who was a the other side of the river or lake, only if he is close (like 150 meters around) and on the same side.

mossy sapphire
#

@mighty girder They did a long time ago, a lot of people were complaining

north hemlock
#

bruh moment

pulsar lake
#

After kos don't disagree me on officials servers

#

Idc in official

north hemlock
#

i literally cant understand you lol

brittle bough
#

tbh a buffalo wouldnt have any reason not to kill a young lion who's anywhere nearby. that young lion being allowed to live and grow is just another predator who will come for them or their children lol

pulsar lake
#

Many people don't like you x)

lament thorn
#

Also can we stop using Kos when talking about killing for sport?

#

There's nothing wrong with seeing something and killing it

north hemlock
#

lmao bro

#

dont be a cuck now

brittle bough
#

is that at blue or levi lol

south flower
#

Don’t get off topic with insults.

mossy sapphire
#

Isnt kosing for sandbox servers thoguh

north hemlock
#

no

pulsar lake
#

Yeah I say Kos but it's mor Kfs than I talk

#

Sorry for that xD

#

Yeah it's Kfs

lament thorn
#

Also buffalo go on hunting parties to kill lion cubs

#

So people complaining about a Maia or dibble killing their Juvie allo need to stop using realism

pulsar lake
#

If the babies is alone and in a close range like 150 meters around or a little bit more

lament thorn
#

Even if the cub is with its mother

#

A lone lioness isn't taking on a herd

brittle bough
#

in nature, a herbivore literally has no reason at all to politely let it's predator live if it has the opportunity to kill it. letting that predator live will only allow it to hunt it later.
but again, this is a game, not real life and nature. fun must be prioritized, and to prioritize and permit fun for both herbivores and carnivores, limits must be placed on kfsing, namely by things like affinity.

lament thorn
#

Also a update to AI

#

Current system drives me crazy

pulsar lake
#

How did we come to Kfs from Alt turn ?

brittle bough
#

uhhh

lament thorn
#

Magic

brittle bough
#

probably alt turning making killing easier or something like that, i dont know lmao

lament thorn
#

Speaking of killing and alt turn

#

What's your thoughts on herbis having some sort of defence for their behind?

#

Think I saw a suggestion for hip/tail shoving

brittle bough
#

humm, im not totally sure about that. i generally dont make suggestions for combat because i only ever really play on nublar with occasional trips to dm, so most of my experience is with no alt lol. i've not a good grasp on combat outside of "yeah nah no alt isnt that great if youre the one being ridden"
a hip shove that maybe very briefly staggers carnivores but does low damage could work for herbis who dont have flexible enough tails to whip them?

lament thorn
#

Yeh since we are getting collision and a combat system I wasn't sure if they would be needed? But I feel like for some situations (like getting mobbed by a pack) it might be useful to just try and get them off you

mental sleet
#

Trample them.

lament thorn
#

That works too

mental sleet
#

also depends a lot on how high the damage you can take on the legs post-locational works.

#

all a Maia herd would need to do to kill a pack of utahs would be to just stampede in their general direction

brittle bough
#

can confirm i played a dinosaur game where everything had trample and i spawned in as a juvi in the path of a mass full speed maia migration

#

felt like god damn mufasa

mental sleet
#

a dinosaur game

#

which dinosaur game ?

brittle bough
#

era of terror lmao, 's roblox's version of the isle essentially

mental sleet
#

lul

brittle bough
#

kinda shit but i had 2gb of ram to work with

mental sleet
#

huh... Levi

#

That second phrase makes no sense

lament thorn
#

Please clarify what you just said

brittle bough
#

i think levis saying herbis should have lowered affinity from loitering around corpses to discourage corpse guarding

pulsar lake
#

It's herbivore stressed by a body

mental sleet
#

But he used Cannibalism

#

and then carni to herb

valid zephyr
#

what i don't get is all these people obsessed with making sure 3 maia don't kill a random dilo walking by, but 15 strong allo packs wiping all they see and not even eating it is just fine.

brittle bough
#

uhhh

mental sleet
#

It isn't fine, but comrade

valid zephyr
#

carnis KoSing is a problem too

mental sleet
#

the fix to that is much easier

#

if they have 15 allosaurus it's because they can sustain 15 allosaurus

pulsar lake
#

I will rewrite that.

mental sleet
#

just make them not be able to sustain 15 allosaurus

#

Woosh

pulsar lake
#

That hwo it will be unfortunaly :- /

#

Cannibalism will punnish some species

lament thorn
#

All I think

brittle bough
#

thing is, a large part of why giant packs of carnivores are so sustainable is the busted ai
once ai is fixed, big packs will have to be more skilled, and will be more prone to starving out

pulsar lake
#

The only one who will be able to eat other of his species will be Cerato

wintry cipher
#

it should not punish apexes so as to encourage them to be openly competetive of one another and keep the numbers down

lament thorn
#

When did you hear this?

mental sleet
#

we don't know Levi.

pulsar lake
#

It was said in a dev stream

brittle bough
#

i do have the vague memory of cannibalism being discouraged, but im not entirely sure about it's details

mental sleet
#

Ah.

#

affinity hit when eating bodies from your own kind

#

probably as simple as this

pulsar lake
#

And only dinosaurs who will be able to eat rotten ribs will be cerato too

brittle bough
#

aye, and cerato is meant to be the scavenger of all things, regardless of quality or nature, so it would probably be able to eat other ceratos

lament thorn
#

It's gonna eat bones too?

#

(Still on the cannibal thing I wish for apexes to still be able to do it no problem to help encourage fights)

grave karma
#

or atleast a smaller hit to affinity

pulsar lake
#

So, for stop corps guarding herbs, we can have a system with affinity than a corps make them stress quickly and for regain their confort and affinity they need to go out of the place.
More body are here more the stress will be intensified.

north hemlock
#

i dont really see a point in punishing cannibalistic behavior

#

🤔

#

its just another thing that happens

brittle bough
#

me neither tbh but if it's the devs vision, ehh

lament thorn
#

I guess cause a lot of animals don't do it that often?

brittle bough
#

i guess that could be the way to discourage pack-killing?

pulsar lake
#

Yes it is

brittle bough
#

thats why then lol

north hemlock
#

hmm

#

but it still shouldnt punish all animals for it

brittle bough
#

again the goal is to enforce 'rules' without needing external rules and moderation, unless youve got a better idea to prevent pack-killing

pulsar lake
#

The only know as he won't be punish is cerato

valid zephyr
#

how do you prevent random troll utahs suiciding into trike nests and ruining all their affinity?

lament thorn
#

I guess animals not cannibalising will make more opportunities for scavengers

pulsar lake
#

After probably rex and giga will be able too

north hemlock
#

how to prevent pack killing : dont pack with assholes/idiots

#

problem solved

pulsar lake
#

Trike will move of this place

north hemlock
#

😔

lament thorn
#

I don't really have an issue with pack killing tbh

pulsar lake
#

Yes but we don't know who is an ass holes and who is not

lament thorn
#

Don't play with random people that you don't trust?

north hemlock
#

its easy to tell if you pay attention

#

lol

#

dont be an idiot and you survive

pulsar lake
#

I do @lament thorn

brittle bough
#

"have friends" isnt a viable solution for gameplay lmao

north hemlock
#

thats not what i said

#

bru

brittle bough
#

yes but thats what blue said.

lament thorn
#

I said that you don't trust

brittle bough
#

so how do you determine on the spot whether you can trust random people

pulsar lake
#

After if you don't have any friends on the isle who play on official it will be hard

north hemlock
#

its easy to tell when someone is blood thirsty in chat or othewise

lament thorn
#

Some people instantly give off 'let's not' vibes

north hemlock
#

^

lament thorn
#

If the other person doesn't talk or respond I take that as a hint

#

And if we somehow end up starving I make sure to turn on them first

fathom harness
#

@willow zealot 🇾 🇪 🇸 🇵 🇱 🇪 🇦 🇸 🇪

subtle adder
#

Lmao

viral creek
#

is it bad that a judge wether i do or do not want to group with a person based on their skins

#

i only want to group with good lookng dinos. unless i actually know them lol

thorny lynx
#

I'm that person who wears camo in survival and in sandbox.

brittle bough
#

im terrible at stealth anyway so i just like to have a laugh and be solid white sometimes lel, i might try to take it more seriously after the recode tho, at least for a bit

#

i also dont often play with groups so at least my vanilla ass isnt bogging anyone down except for my friend who yells at me

oak shale
#

@dense wagon allosaurus couldn’t actually do that

#

the bite it has now is fine

#

Imo

blazing charm
#

Can someone give me a tl;dr of that paper

jovial skiff
#

I think his trying to say that the "Axe" biting technique wasn't what allosaurus probably hunted like

unborn quail
#

@blazing charm Allosaurus adopted a bite style more reminiscent of monitor lizards then an actual axe bite

blazing charm
#

Oh yeah, I remember you told me this.

unborn quail
fathom harness
#

@barren zephyr Great idea! Especially with how little sexual dimorphism there is between Male and Female dinosaurs. It can be hard to tell if they are female or male, which will make nesting so much harder once you need both to nest.

pure copper
#

The axe motion is within its capacity to do technically but its unlikely given it doesn’t make sense in terms of being efficient and could result in needless tooth loss if it strikes back bone. Just plain biting and ripping is better.

south flower
#

I’m actually curious about something - why are so many against allowing herbivores to sniff while trotting or walking? Would that not be more helpful to herbivore players? Almost every time I see someone make a suggestion for it, there’s people who are against it.

lament thorn
#

A main reason I've seen people against it so to limit them in being able to track

south flower
#

Huh, I suppose I never considered herbivores actively tracking down carnis.

valid zephyr
#

yeah it sucks, but you've always got to consider how will people abuse this 😦

pale kite
#

yeah, its not as bad as shants in the isle when prog wasa thing but, shants, trikes, you name it. they will actively track carnis sometimes
@south flower

grand brook
#

but i feel like it's unnecesary to have to stop, sniff, then move again, which takes a short while to find food because a couple of idiots decide to fuck with others. It's the same with people who say nerf this herbie or whatever, the problem is not the stats or the dinosaur itself, it's the fact that the base game as of now has no way to counter cunty behaviour.

#

just remove the ability to smell footprints while moving then

#

problem solved

brittle bough
#

different levels of sniff depending on movement could be an interesting concept, like
idle - all (water, food, footprints, blood) stays longer (assuming scent can be manually turned off at this point if it's still visually invasive like current water)
walking - all (shorter duration than idle)
trotting - water, food, footprints (if carni)
running - maybe exclusively blood by carnis? very short duration. ive always found it a little silly that a carnivore can't smell blood while it's running something down and presumably breathing heavily, but it may make it too hard to get away, so eh. all else fails, maybe smelling blood while running could just be a thing for bleeders like dilo/giga

ionic comet
#

Would become a bit confusing and tedious

azure arch
#

Running could be you can only sniff for blood and tracks

#

but also agreed, ooof.

grand brook
#

i would just keep it simple, if you are a herbivore you can sniff while walking but not trotting, and when you do you can only smell food and water, but no blood or footprints

sick crescent
#

Yeah

#

Herbivores should need to stand still to sniff blood and footprints

#

Footprints are mostly important for anything

#

Not even to chase down

#

You can go up to a corpse and sniff for footprints next to it, it can help identify the carnivore/killer and if it’s been there recently.

barren zephyr
#

Nice suggestion @azure arch it would be nice to be able to tell what's in the area by sniffing tracks. It would also be a good pass time during the long boring nights.

sick crescent
#

Seems too

#

helpfully easy

#

@azure arch

paper oriole
#

"scavenger like tyrannosaurus" lol

oak shale
valid flower
#

Well what ever the fuck it is

#

It's broken

#

I got killed by its tail

#

Infact, i wasnt even near its tail

blazing charm
#

That's already going to be resolved in the recode.

#

Pretty sure you've already posted something like this in suggestions, multiple times.

valid flower
#

I hope so

valid zephyr
#

@native vault You have to be more specific. Simple 'buff' or 'nerf' posts are not allowed.

oak shale
#

Kinda want to know what people think about my suggestion

#

seeing as no one’s reacted to it

#

so that I could probably improve it later

fading shadow
#

if no one reacts they dont care

oak shale
fading shadow
#

i like it

oak shale
fathom harness
#

@oak shale You said only for Alberto, right? Sort of limits the idea unless if there is a specific reason for JUST Alberto be capable of doing it. Also, this would imply that there would be some sort of armor mechanic too. And, would there be a seperate bar to show it? Why not have this attack take stamina instead? Would it be primarily for pack hunting or lone hunters in design? I would assume pack hunting since it seems difficult to perform and could give an opportunity to the opponent to kill them. Also, what would the debuff be called? Armor negation maybe, sort of like how there is bone break? It's an interesting idea but needs to be a bit more fleshed out, but that's just my opinion. 😃

#

Would it be a bite or a different animated attack?

oak shale
#

I mean

#

most people want Alberto as a glass cannon crusher

#

so I was mainly thinking of mechanics that could help it fit that role

#

As a crusher I thought being able to take out stuff like armour more effectively than say allo or carno would fit @fathom harness

#

As for the animation it’s self

#

it would be a bite animation

#

but different to a regular one

#

a lot more telegraphed as I had stated

#

Like rearing up to slam it’s jaws down on its victim

#

face plant dondiUhh

#

The name of the mechanic was in bold

#

plate strike

#

because

#

you know.

#

Plates as in bone plates

#

Osteoderms

#

and such

umbral prairie
#

I don't really like the idea of alberto being a glass cannon

fathom harness
#

Ah I see.

#

Also, Cerato could have it.

#

Since it's sort of a worse version of Allo.

oak shale
#

@umbral prairie eh it’s what most people seem to want

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

umbral prairie
#

yeah I know

#

I just don't see why alberto would be a glass cannon

#

maybe it is an idea to make it more different from allo, but it's not a good one imo

fading shadow
#

alberto is a glass cannon bc unlike trex most tyrannosaurs are skinn bitches that bite hard

#

that including alberto

#

so it could have high speed low health with an impressive bite but unable to take the hits a sucho or sub rex could

#

@umbral prairie

oak shale
#

@fathom harness Didnt really think about cerato, because supposedly it’s getting the scavenger niche

#

And so wouldn’t really need mechanics involving crushing and being able too tear through thick hide

shell garnet
#

guys im kinda new on the game. is there a way to play as spino or quetzal?

indigo sun
#

Spino yes, in sandbox servers
Quetz, not anymore

lilac swallow
#

@formal vine even ignoring real Life from a balance stand point a creature that needs to wait to prey to come needs a slow hunger drain

formal vine
#

Yeah

#

Thats what I meant

pulsar lake
#

Deino should have a slow hunger drain because he will not have many occasion to hunt so he need to survive.

barren zephyr
#

@left storm

#

Herbis should be the one to have elders

#

Carnis have strains

valid elk
#

Anyone wanna discuss my Deinosuchus ideas?

mental sleet
#

for the first portion of your suggestion

#

wouldn't making certain water sources murky do the trick ?

random knoll
#

I don’t think it would as deinos head sticks out

valid elk
#

Well, it won't matter if a Deinosuchus' head pokes out

random knoll
#

Unless you can get colours that match perfectly to the water

valid elk
#

The logs and rocks would provide a lot of cover for any crocodilian animals

mental sleet
#

Hm.

random knoll
#

I would assume you would be able to get into an ambush like position if you press crtl that would make your head dip under water ready to ambush

mental sleet
#

This depends a lot

#

on whether or not they let us see from underwater

random knoll
#

I would assume you would be able to maybe slightly blurred

mental sleet
#

If you can see from underwater

#

You do not need cover on the water's surface, making it murky will do.

#

Otherwise, cover may be needed.

random knoll
#

You would if your head was popping out

#

But I’m guessing they’ll have a way for you to dip your head under

valid elk
#

I assume the swampy areas would provide good cover, but places like lakes will be harder. Maybe if the water was muddy or something?

mental sleet
#

Rivers would be troublesome

#

moving water = barely any cover

random knoll
#

Dead trees that have fallen into the river and are sticking up could help

#

As well as being places for juiv deinos to hide in

mental sleet
#

Could work.

blazing charm
#

@versed olive Out of curiosity, what would this new name be?

versed olive
#

@blazing charm daspletosaurus.

random knoll
#

Dead trees and logs that are in the water would make for some nice hiding spots if were able to go inside them

blazing charm
#

Now, while this is kind of a #paleotalk talk thing, but I genuinely can't seem to find any evidence for this. Plus scientific accuracy isn't really a major priority for this game, last I checked.

versed olive
#

Seen at the Field Museum in Chicago.

#

I know scientific accuracy is not the primary objective, but thought I share.

blazing charm
#

Is it entirely possible that said Mueseum exhibit is just outdated?

#

Like, i'm no expert on the subject but I can't find anything claiming Alberto isn't a thing anymore.

indigo sun
#

I cant find anything about alberto getting renamed completely. I did find something about an immature specimen of alberto thought to be a part of a third specimen of daspleto but this wasnt universally accepted

#

It says "this skeleton"

lilac swallow
#

Strike you are Nines right? Just to know

indigo sun
#

That skeleton in the field museum used to be called albertosaurus, but was re-examined

#

Yeah im nines

blazing charm
#

Also, no point in changing anything about Alberto until it's implemented in Survival.

lilac swallow
#

Ok ty

indigo sun
#

@versed olive i believe you might have gotten confused with the wording. The specimen in particular that's in the field museum was renamed, not albertosaurus itself.

versed olive
#

@indigo sun ok, that makes sense. 😬

#

I live in the US since 4 years, but English isn't my native language after all.

valid elk
#

I mean like, the problem as a crocodile is that your prey has to mistake you for a log or you hide under

random knoll
#

Hmm

valid elk
#

I assume the newer map coming out will have plenty of them

brittle bough
#

they have emphasized how hope will definitely accommodate water bois, so i would imagine more water debris and foliage would be a part of that

random knoll
#

Need me some logs to hide in

valid elk
#

Need me some banks to rest in

#

Which reminds me, how does everyone feel about the standing Deino?

fading shadow
#

@versed olive fucc them scientists

indigo sun
#

That was cleared up, CC. It wasnt actually renamed, the specimen frank had seen was re-examined and renamed

versed olive
#

@indigo sun would have loved if they used different wording, like "formerly identified as" or something. Sorry for the confusion, but I appreciate the quick and plentiful feedback. 👍

teal grotto
#

@left storm elder stage would be a thing and my guess it would be used to face the hypos and other elders..

#

My guess Ancient

barren zephyr
#

@versed olive

#

Albertosaurus was not renamed.

indigo sun
#

ALREADY TAKEN CARE OF

barren zephyr
#

Gorgosaurus is still a different genus

indigo sun
#

jesus

#

it was already talked about and the misunderstanding was cleared up

barren zephyr
#

Oh okay

brittle bough
#

i think packmates having the same color footprint as your own (based on the previous suggestion of having your footprints be a different color) would suffice well enough. a 'youre all together, you should smell fairly similar' sort of thing

indigo sun
#

uh wrong channel i think fluff

paper oriole
#

doesnt need to be any easier to survive as juv rex than it currently is

half mist
#

Aren't apexes already supposed to be incredibly hard because the apexes are so strong?

paper oriole
#

yeah, which currently isnt the case

half mist
#

#10HourApexes

barren zephyr
#

yes but making their food/water drain fast as a juvi seconds after you spawn is a bit over kill

paper oriole
#

not really

#

juv rex drain isnt that terrible

brittle bough
#

considering ai spawns in your mouth, i think youll be able to manage it one way or another
after ai is changed we can talk about hunger drain lul
in general though i do think the water/thirst drains should be swapped, hunger always seems to drain like vastly faster than thirst, which Displeases Me

paper oriole
#

ive always made it to water in time when ive played one, and i suck

#

and juv rex is fully capable of hunting ai

#

ai literally runs towards you

barren zephyr
#

ai doesn’t always spawn @brittle bough

brittle bough
#

ai will spawn at about 75% hunger or less, if you stay in one area

#

if you travel constantly youll outwalk it's spawning

barren zephyr
#

you gotta travel to find stuff

brittle bough
#

like what? find some water and just sit in a tree nearby, ai will spawn around you eventually

barren zephyr
#

Certain spawns aren’t close to water, that’s the problem

paper oriole
#

you SHOULD have to travel tbh, but right now it's an afk game to grow an apex

#

basically any place will spawn AI, there are a few exceptions like inside swamp and canyon on thenyaw

brittle bough
#

wym certain spawns, its based on you, they arent preset locations
ive noticed that sometimes if youre sitting all the way in water then ai is a little more reluctant to spawn, but other than that its pretty consistent in just about all areas
if you wanna test it, get a utah over to gulf pond, sit on that rock you can jump up next to the waterfall, and just wait there. AI will spawn without fail, go down, eat it, go back up, enjoy your life as a rocktah. same applies for other carnis

half mist
#

It'd be nice if certain AI spawned in certain regions

#

But what I'd really like most is just more diversified AI

brittle bough
#

ai will be changed after the recode, so we can look forward to something that isnt this lol

half mist
#

Cause rn its just like

#

Taco, Oro and Ava

#

Gimme somethin big

#

That'll fight back

brittle bough
#

acro and possibly shant? not sure are going to be ai, so theres that

half mist
#

Shant would be a good target for apexes

#

Big Rex or Giga groups

#

While I can see Acro as the thing keeping apexes from growing

sick crescent
#

@tepid wing if you mean an Isle server, there’s a lfg section you can post it in on the steam forums.

cursive wind
#

@half mist take a look in suggestion ive got you covered bud

grand brook
#

@cursive wind but...diatrima is a herbivore

cursive wind
#

....uhhh no it istnt

#

oh shoot it looks like you might be right

indigo sun
#

Yup

cursive wind
#

ah but this was not true of all terror birds it seems

#

@grand brook i have edited my suggestion to use Phorusrhacos instead, a terror bird which was a carnivore

elfin oyster
#

Is the postosuchus a good Idea?

half mist
#

Well we’ve got Rauisuchus deep in the depths of The Isle’s past models

elfin oyster
#

Oh wow, but if its old and stuff its probs scrapped, which is a shame

half mist
#

Yea, that’s the shitty part

#

It would’ve made for an interesting early tier though

#

Certainly has all the qualities you’d expect of a low tier predator

#

It was pretty big and heavy

#

Just a bit lighter than Austroraptor

neat flicker
#

Replays will be fixed either with the recode, or sometime after the recode.

#

This is the discord for the official servers for The Isle, there is a LFG section on the forums for you to post and advertise your own server @tepid wing

indigo sun
#

Hey op. Did flytiger's suggestion get removed?

neat flicker
#

Which one was that

indigo sun
#

I think it was about giants in the isle but i'm not entirely sure

neat flicker
#

i'm pretty sure that wasn't the one, I did delete his suggestion though as it was a blanket statement and not one that followed the allowed format

indigo sun
#

Which one was that one? All i remember is giants

neat flicker
#

I can't remember exactly but it was one of the suggestions that said add x without explanation or substance

indigo sun
#

"Add giants to the isle like in skyrim i wanna hit a rex with a club" seems to fit with its lack of substance

neat flicker
#

Oh, Gar deleted that one

indigo sun
#

That was a weird one

barren zephyr
#

What do you all think about fish ai as extra food for aquatic creatures like the sucho or bary or spino?

indigo sun
#

Fish are already planned

barren zephyr
#

Ah okay

#

my bad then

paper oriole
#

LOL

#

trikes chasing gigas down? are you joking?

indigo sun
#

Is sub giga slow enough that you cant just run from a damn potato?

paper oriole
#

also, do your think your sub giga would have been better off against 3 trikes lol nah

indigo sun
#

And also how is changing trike limits gonna help them not murder you? Not like they'll suddenly be nice and not kill you before you get the chance do kill them

jovial moss
#

They're just salty they let themself get caught by the slowest thing in the universe

indigo sun
#

That situation is not changing because there's less trikes in a herd

jovial moss
#

clearly the only option is nerf trike to 1 km/h

paper oriole
#

shouldntve been sitting out in the open lol

#

i praise that herd, we got too many rexes and gigas slithering around on every active server

indigo sun
#

Honestly yeah good on those trikes

jovial moss
#

always kill sub rexes and gigas when you have the chance

paper oriole
#

doing the world a favour

jovial moss
#

There's nothing more satisfying then destroying a sub rex as a pachy

#

sweet sweet justice

paper oriole
#

one time i found an afk sub giga as a galli and kicked it to death while it sat there unawares

jovial moss
#

LOL

paper oriole
#

should galli be nerfed too

jovial moss
#

nerf galli to 1 kg

paper oriole
#

make galli break his leg each time he kicks

indigo sun
#

Yes clearly cmon have some common sense you killed one thing you clearly need a nerf

jovial moss
#

but give it 10000 damage so if it hits anything it 1 shots

paper oriole
#

swap galli and trike stats

jovial moss
#

lol imagine

#

seeing a slow galli as an allo and running up only to get smashed

paper oriole
#

perfect

valid zephyr
#

How do people get caught by trike?

grave karma
#

really dumb or alt turn off server and run into a wall

#

or low/ no stam

valid zephyr
#

Also imo you shouldn't be going for a full strength apex herbi herd. You should be looking for weaker herd or individuals.

#

Rex and giga can choose when to engage and when to leave. Trikes don't get that benefit.

grave karma
#

trike's only choice is to fight

#

even the slowest predator can outrun trike

#

adult predators that is

barren zephyr
#

Trike should beat apexes 1v1

#

head on i mean

#

60/40 Trike vs Rex

#

70/30 for trike vs giga

valid zephyr
#

As allos we managed to separate a sub trike from its two parents and bring it down. That's how carnis should be playing imo. Not seeing a max size herd of the strongest herbis in the game, walking in, and killing the lot.

brittle bough
#

yeah trike should beat everything in a facetank lol, thats its whole thing

valid zephyr
#

With locational trike should beat rex in facetank. Rex should try to get behind (or ambush from behind), and bite the neck.

barren zephyr
#

fucking disgusting. fuck rexes and gigasdondiREE

grave karma
#

@barren zephyr dino posted a sound file that toyed with progresively distorted calls, so it's a possibility

barren zephyr
#

when

barren zephyr
#

ah nice

cursive wind
#

can i get some feedback as to why adding this would be bad?
the Kelenken

valid zephyr
#

I think it just doesn't suit the theme. Terror birds are cool, but they're too recent to fit in game.

umbral prairie
#

it doesn't fit the there and idk what it would really do

#

what dilos and utahs wouldn't do

still temple
#

doesnt add anything new to the game

cursive wind
#

as an ai specifically

umbral prairie
#

it would play like a utah with maybe a tiny bit more damage and no pounce

cursive wind
#

it would make the world alittle more dangerous

umbral prairie
#

even as AI it wouldn't really fit the theme

still temple
#

why spend 7k+ on a new model just to have it as AI

#

when we already have plenty of candidates

cursive wind
#

well i feel that the ai for carnivores is woefully underfulfilled

#

we just have the velo essentially and they are only a threat to lone juvies for the most part

still temple
#

still doesnt justify the addition of Keleken

umbral prairie
#

there are other options that already have a model and that fit the theme more

cursive wind
#

such as?

umbral prairie
#

look at every carnivore we have in sandbox only, alberto might come into survival, austro or herrera aswell

#

and either austro or herrera could be AI too

slate nimbus
#

We have a game where trexes and stegosaurs can interact, which they could have never do in the past due to being millions of years away. Also humans and genetic engineering. A terrorbird does not sound weird to me at this point. But either way, I too agree that there isnt enough challenging carnivorous AI out there.

lament thorn
#

isnt terror bird just a worse utah?

slate nimbus
#

Idk but utahs are playable. Unless survival dinos get AI too, the utah cant take the spot people hope for terrorbirds/other dinosaurs to be an AI

lament thorn
#

pretty sure there the survival dinos will have ai too

slate nimbus
#

Really? I never heard of that before

lament thorn
#

since Don mentioned wanting people to not be able to know if they are ai

#

that doesnt work if they only non playables

slate nimbus
#

Ooooh that does sound promising

tender latch
#

@oak shale, you can go to the next line down by pressing Shift+Enter so you don't have to type multiple messages.

oak shale
#

Ik

tender latch
#

rip

oak shale
#

Lol

grave karma
#

im really hoping you mean the actual dinosaur

#

and the $100 donation would mean nothing to the thousands of dollars they have to spend to add a dinosaur in

indigo sun
#

It's gonna take a bit more than $100 to add in a creature in the isle @glossy flower

glossy flower
#

Starts gofundme*

#

Also I'm talking about the regular looking tyrannosaurid from the 1991 Godzilla va King Ghidorah

vestal rune
#

that's a property of toho

#

they literally can't add it

indigo sun
#

I highly doubt they'd legitimately add in a fake kaiju-dinosaur thing regardless of copyright
You could make an infinitely better case for gojirasaurus

glossy flower
#

Had to Google gojirasaurus

#

Lol

vestal rune
#

obviouslly there's a dino named after godzilla

#

don't see the reason in adding it though

glossy flower
#

Too bad it's not too interesting

pale prairie
pale tinsel
#

Is the corpse carrying clip recent?

#

@pale prairie

pale prairie
#

what? ehh if you found a random clip on dons twitch page, there should be a date.

pale tinsel
#

oh, ok

#

ty

barren zephyr
#

@barren zephyr pretty sure we already have that but i dont consider it a biome

hasty parcel
#

There are areas with birch trees

#

but they aren't exactly entire biomes

paper oriole
#

birch trees in isle are my worst enemy lol

outer nebula
#

@inner glen they are testing the aquatics with deino to see what they can and cant do with aquatic creatures

barren zephyr
#

@prisma bluff maybe a troodontid

glossy tangle
#

@native vault Trike already can kill rex

#

It has more then a 50% chance

lilac swallow
#

Yeah yeah

native vault
#

Not really.

#

You can facetank a Trike as a Rex and win.

#

Trike needs its old turn radius back

lilac swallow
#

Almost the whole isle community (which is very carni biased) agrees on trike being a joke, It has to be right

crystal minnow
#

@barren zephyr i like the suggestion but i see a problem with apex babies have a very easy time surviveing when being carried by adults.

native vault
#

@lilac swallow and that's just dumb. Herbis need to be able to defend themselves

#

Irl Trike would just stab a Rex

lilac swallow
#

I know

#

And as i say allways the slower the stronger

native vault
#

The Isle ain't focusing on realism

lilac swallow
#

And we know who the slower is

native vault
#

but

#

herbis need to defense themselves ;-;

#

atm trike is the only apex herbi

barren zephyr
#

@crystal minnow herbi juvies are actually very easy to kill even while being protected. I do it all the time with dilos and carnos

native vault
#

and the fact it cant defend itself against a rex is just dumb

lilac swallow
#

If It cant scape It should fight but trike cant really do neither

native vault
#

Agreed.

lilac swallow
#

You would like to hear that almost everyone agrees on trike needing to defend itself

native vault
#

So the isle is just carni biased as you've said before and I agree

#

I like to play as a Carni

lilac swallow
#

And even being carni biased the community stills agrees on trike

native vault
#

But Trike needs to be able to kill a Rex.

#

Anky also

crystal minnow
#

@barren zephyr yes and this is fine for an Apex carni

native vault
#

It's literally just useless rn

barren zephyr
#

I rarely play herbivores because there is no gameplay. But Trike takes far too long to grow just to be a free meal to the first rex to see you. I would never play trike.

lilac swallow
#

Yeah but anky isnt balanced currently as It isnt on survival devs dont really care about its balance

native vault
#

I love Trike and it would be amazing if it would be able to defend itself

lilac swallow
#

I do play both carni and herbi almost equally

native vault
#

It's kinda rare to see a Trike

lilac swallow
#

True

native vault
#

But Rexes are everywhere

#

Rex is overrated.

lilac swallow
#

You know why? Not just because Rex is more popular is just because It is viable solo while a solo trike is doomed to die

native vault
#

Smh.

barren zephyr
#

Or add Shant to protect the trikes

lilac swallow
#

Justake trike protect themselves

native vault
#

Yeah.

lilac swallow
#

Dont want to depende on another player

native vault
#

I hope it will be better after the recode is done.

lilac swallow
#

Colision and locational dmg is supposed to help trike a lot

barren zephyr
#

Once collision is added

native vault
#

Trike's stomp gives a lot of dmg but

lilac swallow
#

As no one will be able to run throught you and your head will be dmg resistant

native vault
#

It's hard to land

#

And Rex can just ass ride you

#

Or facetank

native vault
#

@barren zephyr The Isle doesn't even use hitboxes. It has been set up to use the psychical collision.

barren zephyr
#

@oak shale that’s a brilliant idea! Will also make it so players to not always stay hidden in water. They must come out and be exposed a little as well.

#

Anyways I meant that dino shouldnt be able to kill someone behind him etc

umbral prairie
#

will get probably fixed, or at least a lot better with the recode

#

I can't see why they wouldn't address one of the biggest problems of the game with it

neat flicker
#

The "hitboxes" or lack thereof will be fixed with the recode.

grave karma
#

shitboxes i think you mean

oak shale
#

@barren zephyr thanks

still temple
#

@native vault Microraptor is too small.
p. neimongoliensis is the smallest dino they'll ever add to the game, and it's still bigger than Micro

craggy scarab
#

@dim ore I believe looter addresses this to the best of his ability.

dim ore
#

neat, thanks trevor 😃 i didn't see that post lo

#

lol

craggy scarab
#

@dim ore I’ve learned to periodically search discord messages by devs to see if they posted anything I might have missed haha

dim ore
#

lol i am new to this discord, i have missed out on a lot of the news . i will have to read up on the old posts . 😃

vestal rune
#

tbh I kinda hope they rework the combat system or add new alt turning animations before mod support is added, as then removing the option to disable alt turn would be useless

barren zephyr
#

@oak shale I like the idea. But rather than adding adding another bar, couldn't they just make it so deino has to bask to refill stam? Similar to Rex

#

@thorny lynx please dont request a nerf for juvie Cerato. It is already trash once it reaches adult. Atleast let it be decent as a juvie.

thorny lynx
#

I ne er said to nerf juvie cerato

#

I compared

wintry zealot
#

Hello can i ask something? Can i install mods on the game?

odd idol
#

Currently no

blazing charm
#

@vital shadow That was the exact reason it was removed, because they were too cordinated, back in the day you just had these unhuntable herds roaming the server squashing anything that could ever possibly be a threat to them.

barren zephyr
#

I think trikes bleed resistance is good as it is. It’s not that it is bad, it’s just that Gigas have good bleed.

barren zephyr
#

@formal vine

#

But Tyrannosaurus is fine

#

Why "especially tyrannosaurus rex"?

#

Literally

#

stop nitpicking it

formal vine
#

Dondi is partial to tyrannosaurus

barren zephyr
#

Any developer whos partial to their favourite dinosaur would do alot of stuff for it

#

admit it yourself you would

#

The thing is that Tyrannosaurus does deserve its fame and reputation

#

its no joke its favourited.

valid zephyr
#

Yeah but game balance > all

formal vine
#

Yeah

barren zephyr
#

Indeed

#

then its fine

#

rex is especially fine ingame

#

Dont need to nitpick it

formal vine
#

How is it fine?

barren zephyr
#

Its balanced.

#

It just needs a BB rework

valid zephyr
#

Rex is fine.

#

Trike and Giga are not fine

formal vine
#

^

barren zephyr
#

Rex is A tier at most

#

Like middle A tier

#

By dinosaur viability

formal vine
#

I suggested to balance ALL the survival dinos

#

Not only rex

valid zephyr
#

Rexes only issues are bone break placeholder, and how easy all apxes are to grow due to low player density and spoon fed AI

barren zephyr
#

but they are balancing the other dinosaurs

#

not only the rex

#

exactly comrade

formal vine
#

Did Dondi state that the recode will include balancing dinos?

valid zephyr
#

I've heard mention from a lot of people of a stat redo and how the stats even work

#

not sure if true

formal vine
#

And thus my suggestions

oak shale
#

@barren zephyr yeah, whilst still getting the buffs and benefits of basking possibly

umbral prairie
#

there are new systems for health, stam, bleed and bb already done

#

so I'm pretty sure they need to give everything new stats anyway

#

so why not balance it while doing so? Ofc it would take some time but maybe the QA can help with that

grand brook
#

i think the rex is easily the most remodeled dino in the game if i'm not mistaken

#

it has had 4+ models since the game came out

night mountain
#

Hinky is right tbh, SO many people get in trouble for memes and admins literally constantly have to deal with warning people about them theres no reason to not have a channel for it

#

would straight up clean up general a ton, even as is

grave karma
#

just like no offensive memes

umbral prairie
#

rex had 4 models?

#

I thought it was only TSL, the one we have now and one in between

grave karma
#

didnt it only have 3 models

#

allo also had 3 different models

umbral prairie
#

stego is also on it's second model now and will get a third

grave karma
#

so not easily the most remodeled

umbral prairie
#

maybe I'm forgetting a rex model though

#

one directly after TSL, I got the game when the rex before the current one was in

#

so idk if there was one before that that wasn't TSL

grave karma
#

nope

#

there used to be just tsl, then tsl and second rex model as playable, then tsl rex was removed

#

unless tsl got a rex remodel at one point

umbral prairie
#

don't think so

#

I just thought trike had 2 remodels but I think I just remember it wrong

#

probably confusing it with animation sets

neat flicker
#

There used to be a meme channel before and it was removed for a reason. This is an official discord server, this isn’t your place to post memes or anything like that. Every channel has its specific rule sets and you keep to that. If you want a place to post memes then make your own discord and invite your friends to it

#

There’s too many kids on here that’ll post offensive dumb memes constantly and it’ll be a spam fest.

indigo sun
#

1.) Congratumotherfuckinlations man youre an admin thats awesome good job
2.) Isnt it more of a hassle to have to constantly delete stuff from all the channels than deal with a few bad eggs in a single channel where things can be easily dealt with? You could make it specifically isle or dinosaur memes only

umbral prairie
#

I think there would be more inappropriate memes if they were allowed to be posted

neat flicker
#

There's barely people that post memes now that they've gotten the memo that I actively look at the channels and won't allow it. I'm sorry but I'm kind of bias against memes, only children like to post things like that, but I'm an older guy. If you want to post memes for your friends, make your own discord and invite your friends there and spam out your own server with it.

If there was a meme channel, everyone would be spamming it constantly with stupid crap and it'd have be watched all of the time

#

There's just way too many kids/teens/immature people on the discord for a meme channel to be allowed otherwise people will constantly spam it, throw one offensive/disgusting thing in there and spam it more to hide it

barren zephyr
#

did you get promoted

neat flicker
#

You'd have to be watching it 24/7

#

Yeah, my names yellow instead of blue now gasp

umbral prairie
#

how many members does this discord have

neat flicker
#

btw thanks for the congratulations @indigo sun

umbral prairie
#

I joined at 18000 members

valid zephyr
#

Use the isle reddit for memes.

neat flicker
#

^

umbral prairie
#

but idk how to see the current members

neat flicker
#

I don't think discord has an option without a bot yet

barren zephyr
#

idk a meme channel would been neat cause of the content drought imo

umbral prairie
#

I'll just send an invite to the discord somewhere so I see the members

#

you don't see the members on invites anymore -.-

valid zephyr
#

I do suspect the current chat issues will reduce once content starts coming again. I think people are just restless as nothing new to discuss.

#

So it's go round in circles or post memes.

neat flicker
#

^

wintry cipher
#

@vital shadow You do realize that's exactly why they cant group now right? because herbivore death squads became even more effective than carnivore death squads. The devs have been removing the capabilities of both sides to do that.

valid zephyr
#

I dunno carnis still death squad just fine.

#

15 strong allo packs.

vital shadow
#

@wintry cipher That's why most servers have rules lol

wintry cipher
#

thats also why they have rules and changed the game itself rather than just put a rule of "dont group with species not your own"

umbral prairie
#

@thorny lynx pretty sure the recode will include new lighting

#

together with the new clouds

thorny lynx
#

But I want the old lighting back ;A,

umbral prairie
#

idk how similar it is to the old one, but it looks promising

#

also afaik a dev said the flickering shadows might get reduced a bit because of how the sun will work, but I'm not sure

blazing charm
#

New Lighting looks pretty fine to me from what we've seen on stream.

neat flicker
#

@thorny lynx The old lighting was a hamper on performance and they are redoing the lighting with the new map and more than likely might be included in the recode

spiral ravine
#

wonder if there is a plan to increase player cap on official servers after the recode?

bitter trench
#

If they fix the stabability on server caps, probably

spiral ravine
#

fingers crossed then

#

anywhere from 120 to 150 would be decent for v3 imo

bitter trench
#

I mean, server stabability can be a pretty big problem on big servers, so it's likely they will tweak it to work to a 500 cap max or more

#

Although official servers would probably have a cap of 300 if it were 500 max

spiral ravine
#

wait 500?

bitter trench
#

Eh, I don't know what max stable player cap they could make work for The Isle

#

It just needs to be higher than 200 and stable

#

200 is practically the max cap, anything above it is really hard to play on

#

Even then 200 has weird AI spawns and some lag

spiral ravine
#

yeah, so hopefully they're working on the network code

bitter trench
#

Yeah

#

If they're tweaking AI it should help too

spiral ravine
#

if hope is planned to be bigger than v3

bitter trench
#

I hope it isn't

spiral ravine
#

100 is definitely too little

#

but we'll see I guess

bitter trench
#

Hah, I play on a server that never has 100 people on

spiral ravine
#

At this point we're all just waiting for the recode

#

dam

bitter trench
#

It's highest player count is in the 70s

spiral ravine
#

how do u find anything to kill lol

bitter trench
#

And they switched over to V3

#

Well, most people just live near a certain area I guess 🤷

spiral ravine
#

Kk

bitter trench
#

We're hoping for something bigger than Thenyaw and smaller than V3

spiral ravine
#

hmm

#

could be

bitter trench
#

I've heard mixed things about Hope

#

I've heard it will be like 3 V3s, it will be small, it will be medium, it will be large

#

I don't know what to believe

#

We just have to wait and see 🤷

#

(I've also heard dondi is making more than one map)

spiral ravine
#

yeah, recode cannot come any sooner

bitter trench
#

Atleast when the recode comes we should get practically a brand new game

#

They're tweaking adding and removing a lot

#

I'm going to play on a deathmatch server now, bye

still temple
#

I just hope maps will be carefully crafted and thought out

#

with resources spread over the map so that there aren't massive deadzones where no one goes to like in V3

barren zephyr
#

@formal vine Lets not make bleed cripple players too

#

because thats literally BB

#

for bleeders

#

they are bleeders

#

not crushers

vestal rune
#

@azure arch what's the point of that?

hasty parcel
#

Seems like way too much information

paper oriole
#

i think bodies should just have different marks to roughly show their cause of death

#

like claw marks, small or large bites, puncture wounds, or dulled skin for starvation/dehydrtion

#

we're dinos not detectives

hasty parcel
#

at least with that you'd have to use your own knowledge

#

which is what the point should be

#

we shouldn't just be given all that info on a platter

paper oriole
#

yeah like if it was large clws marks you could assume theri, spino, allo

#

just be able to determine if the cause of death is something in your league or not, not looking at a body and (queue NCIS investigation music) this para was killed by a male rex sub adult at 60% growth

inner kindle
#

Hey admins, there is a big problem of people abusing gamma, maybe you could make night as a layer of dark and only N could remove this layer, so no one could abuse gamma ingame.

vestal rune
#

thenyaw nights are pitch black, only night vision can clear it

#

idk why v3 nights aren't

paper oriole
#

hopefully new map is gamma abuse proof

vestal rune
#

@barren zephyr I don't think you understand how hypers work, they're not gonna play like creatures with the ability to nest, instead they'll be more like bio weapons which come into existance to just wreak mayhem and kill alot of creatures, and then die of starvation

#

also the devs already have an idea for how to obtain hypers which they'll keep secret from the public

grave karma
#

do we even know how we'll get hypers?

vestal rune
#

nope, we won't even know how to get it when they're ingame

#

the first person to get it will get it completely by surprise

barren zephyr
#

You will get to play as hypo when you reach Anthomnia type youtube status

vestal rune
#

I doubt anthomnia has the skills to become a hyper lmao

barren zephyr
#

He already has, all he has to do is ask one of the devs lol

vestal rune
#

he fucking needs to cheat with admin commands in order to not die

#

but, hypers aren't ingame yet...

#

they're just husks of what they're gonna be

barren zephyr
#

Yea for us there not

vestal rune
#

no they're not

#

period

barren zephyr
#

Were just trash lol

vestal rune
#

they're not finished

barren zephyr
#

Finished or not.

vestal rune
#

yes it isn't finished, strains aren't ingame, just fancy models with big stats

#

they won't be ingame untill the mechanics for them are added and everyone has the capability to become one

#

the devs giving some famous people strains for fun does not count as obtaining one

barren zephyr
#

My point is, if your anthomnia status on youtube, you can actually have fun while waiting for the recode lol

vestal rune
#

so, you can only have fun if you have a strain?

#

wtf

#

stop being salty that anthomnia gets strains, it's good publicity for the isle and anthomnia, and having everyone be able to get it in the current state of the game would cause pure chaos

barren zephyr
#

Lol this guy

#

Btw that’s why the are crazy because imagine if more of these hyper creatures were being born most people would try to kill the source and because this killing machine is able to nest that means it will have more of its kind to kill other creatures

vestal rune
#

but that's bad

#

hypers aren't meant to be reproducing

#

the whole point is that a hyper appears, kills some things, and then dies

#

they're more like events then actual creatures

barren zephyr
#

Then there is no point at all

vestal rune
#

yes there is

barren zephyr
#

Just have a pack of gigas run around

vestal rune
#

hypers are literally designed to stop packs of apexes

barren zephyr
#

Or spinos

random knoll
#

what?

vestal rune
#

or huge groups of dinos

barren zephyr
#

But the apex packs would do the same thing

vestal rune
#

no it wouldn't?

#

your idea of them reproducing would be the same thin

barren zephyr
#

What if there was no reproduction

vestal rune
#

I mean ye, that's what I'm saying

barren zephyr
#

So would u like my idea if there was no reproduction

vestal rune
#

I mean idk

#

I'm not sure how much people would like getting swooped down by some random flying hyper, atleast with the other hypers you can avoid them

#

in fact it's excactly that, for hypers the main challenge is finding food, as everything will be hiding, with a flying hyper it would be significantly more easier to do this

#

it's possible they may have plans for flying hypers, but idk

barren zephyr
#

I know it’s just an idea and a dream

#

I can only hope

vestal rune
#

it doesn't really fit in with the idea of a hyper though

#

maybe it would be cool for some flying hunter, however making such a thing not incredibly frustrating for land dinosaurs would be hard

barren zephyr
#

I feel like that the trees should be made so flyers aren’t able to fly in them unless they are walking

#

Or have landed

vestal rune
#

well I imagine they'll have collision so a flyer would just crash into them

#

but there are still alot of open spaces

barren zephyr
#

Yeah but that way trees can be used as cover and if used properly it could eventually cause the hypo to starve

vestal rune
#

trees aren't a good enough fix, people are alot of the time forced to go into open spaces, especially apexes which give the most foods and are likely the easiest to kill for a flier

barren zephyr
#

And based on the reactions I’m getting u aren’t the only one who disagrees

vestal rune
#

ye, you simply didn't get the idea of hypers correct

lament thorn
#

they arent just a super powerful creature that co exists with everything else

vestal rune
#

ye I explained

#

it's annoying having multiple people rag on you about the excact same concept

lament thorn
#

I would love to see Tapwings designs come to life

vestal rune
#

tapwing's design can't fly lmao

#

well the quetz one, but I don't think she did a ptera one

lament thorn
#

ptera doesnt deserve strains

vestal rune
#

wow, way to roast ptera

lament thorn
#

its the velo of the skys

#

pathetic

vestal rune
#

more like the dryo

#

hera

#

austro

#

yes, it's the austro of the skies

#

dude imagine a hyper austro though

barren zephyr
#

meh ptera is supposed to be a chill flyer

vestal rune
#

chill flyer?

#

is that like, not attacking?

#

or not requiring much effort to grow?

#

I guess both are correct since it's small and fishes

lament thorn
#

I mean I assume it will be hard to grow unless it can fly straight away?

steady cosmos
#

@barren zephyr so this?

vestal rune
#

that's tiso dondiTroll

steady cosmos
#

yep

azure arch
#

@prisma bluff I'm with you, brother. I said that around a week before you did

valid zephyr
#

not a fan of the extra limbs

paper oriole
#

the extra set of wings makes it look like something out of avatar rather than a cool isle strain